home | about | documents | news | publications | FOIA | research | internships | search | donate | mailing list

Archive Sues State Department Over Kissinger Telcons

700 Transcripts Still Withheld, Eight Years after Appeal

Threat of suit in 2001 led to recovery of Kissinger documents

Digital National Security Archive has published 15,000 to date

National Security Archive Electronic Briefing Book No. 503

Edited by William Burr

Posted March 4, 2015

For more information contact:
William Burr - 202/994-7000, nsarchiv@gwu.edu

In the News

Somebody Else Is Suing the State Department—To Get Kissinger’s Phone Calls
By Asawin Suebsaeng, The Daily Beast, March 12, 2015

State Department hit with suit for Kissinger records
By Josh Gerstein, Politico, March 4, 2015

Indexed Trove of Kissinger Phone Transcripts Is Completed
By Scott Shane, The New York Times, December 23, 2008

 

Related Links

Declassified Documents Show Henry Kissinger's Major Role in the 1974 Initiative That Created the Nuclear Suppliers Group
April 24, 2014

Kissinger to Ford: "Smash" Rumsfeld
January 24, 2014

Kissinger and Chile: The Declassified Record
September 11, 2013

Kissinger Blocked Demarche on International Assassinations to Condor States
April 10, 2010

Cuba and the U.S.: Road Map on Efforts to Improve Relations Revealed in Declassified Documents
January 22, 2009

The Kissinger Telephone Conversation Transcripts
December 23, 2008

New Kissinger 'Telcons' Reveal Chile Plotting at Highest Levels of U.S. Government
September 10, 2009

Kissinger Conspired With Soviet Ambassador to Keep Secretary of State in the Dark
November 2, 2007


Sign Up for NSARCHIVE
Email Alerts!
Click here to receive email alerts on all the latest releases from the National Security Archive

Washington, DC, March 4, 2015 – The National Security Archive today filed suit against the State Department under the Freedom of Information Act to force release of the last 700 transcripts of former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger's telephone calls (telcons). The Archive's appeal of State's withholding dates back to 2007.

Kissinger had removed the telcons, along with his memcons and office files, from State when he left office at the end of 1976. A lawsuit by the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press to recover the documents failed in 1980 with a Supreme Court ruling that the plaintiffs lacked standing.


President Gerald R. Ford sitting between two bureaucratic rivals — Secretary of State Henry Kissinger and Secretary of Defense James R. Schlesinger — during a meeting with Congressional leaders on 29 April 1975 to discuss the collapse of Government of South Vietnam (Photo courtesy of Gerald R. Ford Library, photo number A4383-25A)

The National Security Archive in 2001 crafted a new legal complaint directed at the State Department and the National Archives for abdicating their duty under the Federal Records Act to recover the Kissinger documents, which were produced on government time with government resources. Remarkably, the State Department Legal Adviser William Howard Taft IV agreed with the Archive, asked us to hold off on our legal action, and formally notified Kissinger that he needed to return the documents or complete copies thereof.

When Kissinger did so, in August 2001, the Archive promptly filed a Freedom of Information request for the telcons, and has published 15,502 of the conversations in the Digital National Security Archive series through the online publisher ProQuest.

But the State Department withheld, starting in 2007, some 700 of the telcons, claiming they were "pre-decisional" or covered by executive privilege — claims that should long since have expired in the case of 40-year-old records. The Archive's formal appeal of the withholding, along with repeated queries by the Archive to State and the White House Counsel's Office about the status of the telcons, have been met only with years of delay, thus making the lawsuit necessary.

The Archive is represented by expert FOIA practitioner David Sobel, a winner of the James Madison Award from the American Library Association for his open government advocacy. Posted today on the Archive web site at www.nsarchive.org are the legal complaint, an overview of the issue by Archive senior analyst William Burr (author of the critically-praised book, The Kissinger Transcripts), and six of the most recently released Kissinger telcons as examples of what is at stake in the lawsuit.

* * *


Excerpt from conversation with White House Press Secretary Ron Ziegler who teased Kissinger about his dates with leading Hollywood actresses.

Today the National Security Archive filed a lawsuit against the Department of State insisting that it expedite declassification review and processing of a Freedom of Information Act appeal concerning hundreds of transcripts of Henry Kissinger's telephone conversations (telcons) produced when he was Secretary of State during 1973-1977. The Archive has waited nearly eight years since that appeal and nearly 700 telcons remain at issue. The initial FOIA request, filed in August 2001 yielded thousands of telcon transcripts, high quality records which brought greater openness and clarity to the turbulent foreign relations history of the Nixon-Ford years. As part of the FOIA processing hundreds of documents were coordinated with other agencies, including the White House. In June 2007, the State Department denied over 800 of the transcripts, many of them records of White House-level conversations, on executive privilege and "pre-decisional" (b) (5) grounds. There were rumors that Kissinger's influence at the George W. Bush White House was behind that decision, but whatever the facts are, the Archive challenged the exemptions in an appeal filed in July 2007.

Since it filed that appeal, the Archive has waited patiently. When the Obama administration came to power in January 2009, the Archive reminded the State Department's Appeals Panels of this unfinished business citing the President's 21 January 2009 memorandum which declared that agency heads should follow a "presumption of disclosure" when making decisions on FOIA requests. While the Archive argued that any legitimate executive privilege interest had long faded away and that the "pre-decisional" exemption could not reasonably apply to forty-year-old documents, the records have languished since 2007 at the State Department and the White House's Office of the General Counsel. In light of the unwarranted delay, the Archive saw little choice but to file a lawsuit to accelerate the release of the remaining telcons ensuring that they will be available to historians and social scientists without undue delay.

The record of Henry Kissinger's telephone conversations is a significant historical resource which illuminates the inner workings of the Nixon and Ford administrations. If Kissinger had his way, it is likely that the telcons would be under seal at the Library of Congress to this day. Nevertheless, they became available for declassification review and release after the National Security Archive threatened to sue the National Archives and the Department of State in 2001 for their failure to follow federal records laws by allowing Kissinger to keep under personal control records that were produced with U.S. government resources on U.S. government time. That Kissinger had taken the telcons (and other unique records) from the State Department and the White House, in violation of federal records laws, was a great vulnerability in his legal position, one that the Supreme Court had exposed in its 1980 ruling. Rather than dragging the issues through the courts, the Department of State and the National Archives requested Kissinger to return copies of the telcons so that they could become part of the open historical record. Apparently not wanting a fight with the Bush administration, Kissinger assented.


Excerpt from conversation where President Nixon exploded that Mexican President Echeverria had met "total enemies" of the administration, including I. F. Stone and Arthur Schlesinger Jr.

As part of its mission to obtain and disseminate valuable declassified records on U.S. foreign and military policies, the National Security Archive has published comprehensive collections of records involving Henry Kissinger's role in government during the Nixon and Ford administrations: The Kissinger Telephone Conversations (2008) and a collection of memoranda of conversations: The Kissinger Transcripts (2007). Last fall, the Archive updated both collections with new material: The Kissinger Conversations, Supplement, which includes over 280 new telcons from the Nixon and Ford administrations. A sampling of the documents appears below.

One of the telcons is from late June 1972, of a lengthy and wide ranging conversation with Nixon, after Kissinger had just returned from China. In two pages from the lengthy transcript that were declassified in response to a request by the National Security Archive, Kissinger said that the Chinese "need us," because of the threat posed by the Soviet Union. But the main reason for the previous classification was a discussion between an irate Kissinger and Nixon of Mexican President Luis Echeverría, who had recently visited Washington, D.C. for talks with Nixon. After two meetings at the White House, Echeverría visited New York City for a session with left-liberal actors and writers, including I.F. Stone, Arthur Schlesinger, Jr., and Shirley McLaine. According to a report in the New York Times, Echeverría criticized Nixon for lacking knowledge about the salinity of the Colorado River, a still important regional problem. Telling Nixon about the article, Kissinger said "that son-of-a-bitch has really not behaved too well." Exasperated with the State Department's schedulers, Nixon was angry that they had helped arrange a meeting with "total enemies."

 


The Documents

Document 1: Telephone conversation with Ron Ziegler, 1 June 1970, 9:35 a.m.

Source: mandatory declassification review release by Richard Nixon Presidential Library and Museum (NPL), National Security Council Files, Kissinger Telephone Conversation Transcripts, box 5, June 1-5, 1970

It took a declassification request to make this transcript available not because White House press secretary Ron Ziegler mentioned Kissinger's dates with actresses Jill St. John and Faye Dunaway but because of the discussion of the U.S. material support to Thai "volunteers" deployed for military operations in Cambodia after the recent U.S. invasion. Because of domestic opposition, Thailand could not send regular troops, but U.S. military assistance permitted irregular operations.[1] Despite press reports from Thailand about U.S. support, Kissinger explained that "we don't want to admit it." As for St. John and Dunaway, Kissinger said that the "publicity" about his personal life was "self-perpetuating. Once the thing has gotten started they're such publicity hounds it keeps itself going."

 

Document 2: Telephone conversation with President Nixon, 24 June 1972, 12:25 p.m.

Source: mandatory declassification review release by NPL, National Security Council Files, Kissinger Telephone Conversation Transcripts, box 14, June 15-27, 1972

When the lengthy transcript of this wide-ranging conversation was originally declassified and released pages 13 and 14 were exempted and not declassified until 2009 after an Archive's MDR request. The withheld information included a continuation of the Nixon and Kissinger's discussion of China on page 12; Kissinger, who had just returned from talks with Premier Zhou Enlai in Beijing, declared that China was "our best ally right now except on Vietnam." Both agreed that China "need[s] us," apparently because its leadership feared the Soviet Union and saw the United States as a needed counterweight. Kissinger noted that the Chinese are "tough" and "fear [probably a mishearing of "share"] our assessment of the Soviet Union."

When speaking about sending a report on Kissinger's visit to China to select heads of state and prime ministers, Nixon mentioned the possibility of including Mexican president Luis Echeverría, but Kissinger objected by saying "that son-of-a-bitch has really not behaved too well." Kissinger was referring to a report of Echeverría's meeting in New York with left-leaning journalists, actors, and intellectuals, including Arthur Schlesinger Jr., Shirley McLaine, I.F. Stone and Michael Harrington, during which he criticized Nixon for not knowing about saline pollution in the Colorado River as it crossed into Mexico.[2] Nixon was indignant, not only about that statement (he claimed to know a lot about the issue) but that the State Department had included in Echeverría's schedule a meeting with "total enemies." He believed that Echeverría could have said "positive things" especially because he (Nixon) had taken the trouble to hold two meetings with him: "Good God, we built him up, we gave him that kind of treatment."

 

Document 3: Telcon Mr. Edward Littlefield/The Secretary, 26 August 1974, 7:00 p.m.

Source: FOIA request, released on appeal

As national security adviser and Secretary of State Kissinger was never entirely comfortable dealing with international economic issues. It was not part of his Harvard training and his expertise was in the intersection of political and military affairs. To get the help he needed with economic diplomacy, Kissinger tried to recruit Charles W. Robinson, a California-based businessman, to serve as job of Under Secretary of State for Economic Affairs. Part of the recruitment process involved a conversation with Edward Littlefield, one of Robinson's corporate colleagues at the Marcona Mining Company, during which Kissinger explained why Robinson was the right person for the job and why he needed to start very soon. Sharing his vision of the need to turn the State Department into a "disciplined political and economic unit," Kissinger needed help: "I am quite good in designing the foreign policy constructively. I have no idea how to relate economics here" and Robinson could fill the gap. Kissinger had high hopes about bringing Robinson into the government, believing that he would be suitable for a cabinet post, but he said he could "not wait six months." As it turned out, Kissinger had to wait; Robinson took the job, but did not begin work at State until early 1975. By the next year, he had been appointed Deputy Secretary of State, Kissinger's number two.

 

Documents 4A-C: Kissinger's Schlesinger Problem:

A. Telcon General Scowcroft/The Secretary, 12 September 1975, 6:15 p.m. Excised copy, released under appeal

B. Telcon Secretary Schlesinger/ Secretary Kissinger, 7 January 1976, 7:25 p.m.

C. Telcon Mr. Habib/Secretary Schlesinger, 24 August 1976, 8:34 p.m.

Source: FOIA request, released on appeal

When Kissinger was Secretary of State, his main bureaucratic rival was the late James R. Schlesinger, who was Secretary of Defense during 1973-1975. Their policy views were not that far apart, but as talented and highly competitive individuals they found it difficult to cooperate. As Walter Isaacson has noted, both found it difficult to treat colleagues as partners. Kissinger compounded the problem with secrecy and compartmentalization while Schlesinger's haughty personal style aggravated many, not least President Ford.[3] The tensions in the Kissinger-Schlesinger relationship are evident in a conversation that Kissinger had in September 1975 with his White House deputy, Brent Scowcroft: it began with Kissinger observing that an acquaintance, whose name is excised, had said that Schlesinger is on "an all out campaign to get me." According to Scowcroft, General John Wickham, Schlesinger's military aide, said that Kissinger was "talking about Schlesinger" but that Schlesinger was "saying nothing about you." Scowcroft did not think that was true: it "is the other way around." With respect to Schlesinger communicating to Kissinger, Kissinger complained that "every single initiative has to come from me." But then Scowcroft observed that if Kissinger called up Schlesinger, the latter would "leak" that Kissinger had "caved."

This was all moot because a few weeks later, as part of the October 1975 "Halloween Massacre," Ford fired Schlesinger and demoted Kissinger by removing him as national security adviser (Scowcroft got that post) but leaving him as secretary of state. A few months later, Schlesinger initiated a friendly conversation where they lamented over the Angolan situation and the "collapse of American responsibility." Discussing the new Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld's, efforts to get a budget approved, Schlesinger declared that "there will be some cutting up on Rummy on the Defense budget" and Kissinger observed acidly that "it is hard to cut someone up who yields on the first hill." After agreeing to meet for breakfast, Kissinger admitted that he "missed" Schlesinger: "Unbelievable that I long for a good row with someone who knows what he is talking about."

Schlesinger nevertheless got on Kissinger's nerves; months later, he found that the Chinese had invited the former Secretary of Defense for a visit. Kissinger was angry that Beijing had invited an ex-official whom the President had fired. With relations with China already at a low point, Kissinger believed that Beijing was using the invitation to Schlesinger against him. He also believed that Schlesinger would use the occasion to make statements critical of the administration. Accordingly, Kissinger asked Assistant Secretary of State Philip Habib to lodge what appears to have been a low-key unofficial protest with "our friends," by which he meant the Chinese liaison office in Washington, D.C. But the Chinese diplomat said that his government "had a right to invite the people they wanted" in the interests of a "good relationship."

Kissinger and Habib also discussed the repercussions of an incident in the North-South Korean Demilitarized Zone, where soldiers from the North had killed a U.S. Army sentry. With the South Koreans characterizing the U.S. response as a "backdown," Kissinger wanted U.S. Ambassador Richard Sneider to tell President Chung-hee Park, the military dictator, that "we are outraged."

 


Notes

[1] For the role of Thailand, see Kenton Clymer, Troubled Relations: The United States and Cambodia Since 1870 (DeKalb: Northern Illinois University Press, 2007), 113.

[2] "Echeverria Meets With N.Y. Leftists," New York Times, 18 June 1972.

[3] Walter Isaacson, Kissinger: A Biography (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1992), 622-624, 669

home | about | documents | news | publications | FOIA | research | internships | search | donate | mailing list

Contents of this website Copyright 1995-2016 National Security Archive. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditions for use of materials found on this website.

The State Department Kissinger Telcons: The Story of a FOIA Request

January 20, 1977 - Henry Kissinger's last day in office as Secretary of State. He had stored his telephone call transcripts at Vice President Nelson Rockefeller's estate in Westchester County, but on threat of a lawsuit Kissinger deposited them at the Library of Congress. There he had made arrangements to preserve copies of his White House and State Department office files, which would be closed to the public until five years after his death.

March 3, 1980 - The Supreme Court announced its decision on a FOIA lawsuit filed by the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press against Kissinger for copies of telcons created when he was National Security Adviser and Secretary of State. The Court ruled that the FOIA could not be used to recover records that were no longer under executive branch control. The Reporters Committee lacked standing to file the lawsuit and that under federal records laws only the U.S. Government could take legal action to recover the telcons. In his opinion on the case, Justice John Paul Stevens commented that the FOIA was relevant: "the fact that the documents had been removed by the head of the agency shortly before the expiration of his term of office raised an inference that the removal had been motivated by a desire to avoid FOIA disclosure."

January 25, 2001 - On behalf of the National Security Archive, pro bono counsel Lee Rubin and Craig Isenberg (of the Mayer Brown law firm) sent a draft complaint to the State Department and the National Archives arguing that they were in violation of federal records laws by allowing Kissinger to keep records that had been improperly removed from government agencies. During the following months, after meetings between the Archive's lawyers and agency representatives, including Legal Adviser of the State Department William Howard Taft IV, the Bush administration convinced Kissinger to return copies of all of the transcripts.

August 8, 2001: The Department of State announced that it had reached an agreement with Henry Kissinger to turn over copies of his telephone conversation transcripts to the National Archives and the Department of State.

August 10, 2001: The National Security Archive filed a FOIA request with the Department of State for declassification review and release of the Kissinger telcons from his Secretary of State years.

September 21, 2004: The State Department submitted its first substantive response to the Archive's FOIA request. Having broken up the case into sixteen segments, the Department released over 3500 documents in their entirety, excised over 340 and withheld in their entirety another 30. Hundreds of other documents were coordinated with other agencies (CIA, White House, etc.).

October-November 2004: The Archive filed appeals for the excised and exempted documents.

June 6, 2005: In response to the Archive's FOIA appeals, the State Department's Appeal Review Panel released 86 documents in whole or in part, including some of the previously exempted documents.

May 8, 2006: The State Department released 22 documents coordinated with other agencies, some of them excised.

June 11, 2007: The State Department released over 900 coordinated documents in full, excised over 200, and denied in their entirety over 870. Almost all of the denials and many of the excisions were on the basis of the "executive privilege" and/or "predecisional (b) (5) exemptions.

July 7, 2007: The Archive appealed the excisions and denials.

April 14, 2008: The State Department released 76 more coordinated documents, either in whole or in part.

April 24, 2008: The Archive appealed the latest excisions.

November 20, 2013: In response to the Archive's July 2007 appeal, the State Department released 76 documents, most in their entirety.

March 4, 2015: The National Security Archive filed a suit against the State Department challenging the unreasonable delay in processing the nearly 700 telcons denied since 2007.