MEN mute-us DECLASSIFIED horityWD DEARA Date trout this wir'm-Mn For cnrcurrar For signature 1 H0lo a'n d return For actlon For Information i Li-ma ah'd 'IImltI W Thomas i EH itch Department INITIALS REIIMRKS Attached 1 a copy of an informal paper prepared in ABC cancer-1115 German participation in TO Nan-Ia and unlt Robert E Kaufman INITIALS REMARKS consideration of this problem E5 Pierrclatte gums diffusion plant which my _be of some interest to you in connection with your EUR DATE State Department I 3 3 TO Home and unItII mums REMARKS LI 1 I 2 DATE FROM Name and unit REMARKS 1136b ny W1 1' mm ELBJ ratzu CONTAINS CLASSIFIED 3 r'i mum PHONE Na DATE 5 21l63 USE OTHER SIDE FOR ADDITIONAL REMARKS U 5 GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFF IE r-r-vr' xd-I- 'mm It 19mm Emails mam mm these may U 39 q Copies sea- m 5 grass Marya-mama Thea-a haw bean mg of French to mm and palm Italian financial mad tecbuical participation in c me I of the an l 33 33am plant 12% estimated cash of this plant a5 Wt by the French is 1 2 b lian 1er anti its Lemma might men in full wins-him in to be ten m yms ya - daa' ad 111% 'mtmed Ill- 235 It 15 mm mum's tap Met will not heme available until 196 Based ea current Mina Shakes Mariana the Wed 121231 mat and its cast th csparammal Beat 3138 0333mm '11 is estimated that the cast at B a 15 um Emmi mm baa 338$ three times that to 1223 11 3 it its M mlh in W4 in light at Reach Jack amalgam WmmeWrth m waterma tu them-1mm ma a m mma bWWEmm amid through rm if me whim a water eutpufm an the baa-la or its nun-mala- caync rta'g lm mm mt make ta macaw Franc gr 8m aim Ear mm even 151435 i p i u entirely 63 3311 11 23ch Gm amine fw- range min-2x E5 a 6 235 9 25 mail cms p m dam rise mania them-Barber mums WOW the Pier-rath 1 101 12 by this time mam bet-mines than 30 900 magma at $235 - It its reward that ue Gama Mam- 51 in participatien is base on that ties-11m tn ham a am of 3-235 far civil moses inm- the Waited States It mat he mama Mm that am such Mnimtim wmrwult 53-135mm having a were or $235 wieh maid ha m withw aim er mm Wm P03311333 Emit fa Wm Intrarea t- in 11 SW of Sums of 13-235 r on the what other mum depend-pa a 3913 foreign 3mm of supply 16 a wit- W569 19 3 $235 dimmer polities hm mmam maimed to asmaa zeea an in the Minty a 136-235 Ema rm United Stamb Me the 12mm that ma gamma wo da for entering 3 11m 1mg - mam 5w the - 41 fe-235 mmw ing to We enema life is 143 meta-a to be 13133029 prime ham an east apply msticcm am am we have ham mdace aign 'im y aw - the last - We years 65 00 mm at 13-2235 hm hum it-mated t5 the This mammal 3' 22 35 71 3 the nit itggi t ffL 93mg the So a infirwginag laws Title 0 1 II 8 b I Marta 851011 or rqyda on Of Which in any ma _q is pa'ohihitgd by law person SEGREF a It 9' fill - - - - - DECLASSIFIED oritywo - 21 1 Frcsidaat for mix-i1 was W of whim 30 000 hen men ma a mil- abla to Watch Tha CWim has my Mamet de an increase the allacatioa far civil 12m abmad to 350 000 14310 was of 11-235 anti abject $9 mm of this Wmum and required warez-aim ammo-ml will increase the WW total ta magma of 21-235 Bespi te thaw actions and a m8 - of mm - related Mama-am 53 ms m1 aim-imam policies them are W1 Winding weas mmdpientm cns suchaa Emmamrerw am- am more li eral policies Sam 02 thaw amass as Mad 30m mm Ram attitudes at recipim ram are as follows 1 5 8 @235 is mpg-lad under the ma a that mam will be @1196 In the cm 3th meat mam Wm Mama mam 2 We $11 3 M35 mmtm m- examine far-th memaim tmml a Mean 1an $11586 Of 1 23 United 553365 1 The 11 5 angina wiz nad mum emu-mar an a ham Basia mi 31% credit based m military 931119 for gnu-Mazes plum Iran-235 is Whated abroad an a 5319 Emma with no mm far I mica-$1111 be paid if any 12142391211123 is Them tween 629 151 and We ist mtim paid-alas would be am by pending hang Wit ng for private ml in tha 95 11 - 23mg cf plutm watg fuel mm bath here by Fromm- 6 at 39235 the limited stutta Mlma mental mama and Ma ea dams Tm when ma ic m W515 as am by Mimla y as it relates mbeequeni were bf WW mm 1 project ta a ax-Inna- 15 gamma 5 in a ceiling up per mt mW-m 3 235 mned by am $3 51 91 pm- ma a n63 mew mu H13 Has has 111mm 1m 1 Ir mini -F - ma a p'uu 'u a A tau-n5 n _u __415 km 8W n 5131 a n - m Wm um u 3 mm hill-H amt I I nail-hr ll-I Him - um mm WITFIIBI - 3mm 3225 xi-wi iu5 1- 2'12 J - I - n '5 a I EQLASSIFIED tymao 5%3 5 BM 12464 I gat af 31' In the final mantis has-mar 3 1 gem clam - that by the United 3mm or any other agplier auricth 111 um th strong 13 each madm- recipient mti for an E mg as satn'Lca' '3 m'T' dwastis me 33$ 0333' W per ha to magmas this dasiz'a would be $115 delivery in advance by a Unitnd States as a qunn ity of $235 We - to the recipimt This to usage 39mmqu 1m also as a commence a - ohfche gas method of imam aspen- an 1111950 ana- reaul-t or 11 5 imitative the German WEB weed to My its gas centrifugam'ngm Thiswoul hamtha Mimi ng ens-me Germans lawns-ed this comi ment mm the mortality of - mom-tins gas wW ge saparabim mm which Gan-nan mamm- clearly baa antimatedu as 3 caan 42 e lniaai c'auua them appar-I ently has bees mm mm The aimsman classify hex-savercomm level altarmtewwafaupp arm-255 Aswauldt-mirparticumum anthePimela-t a moragas in Gamay mum the Germans with gamma of $435 which IIL lmm- Aspmt pf Meow-WM Coopex atzmq meinthemeh gaseous MManplant-mul 1thba ctho-a 1mm of Wt o u interests anach- j ectiveb first it stand a mama 91 mag for military paw-0355 to a Velma into we W- mans field amid 113053511313 sex-1W impair mama mm mm or anal e ort- an Eha gas- are 17mm in any am mmhbamd inrelmxon to thei m that amid mmimwy at my ma mam mt e embrols an have the 39mm mm 2pr 11m in this ma aili hm mims mien 1 51 16 ma m a force @3363 Thirdya Barman financial and technical umtrim m mm probably awalmte 353 conceivably night even determine the Warm 1 rInH 1_ I hemtm faint-e of tha mm gasems diffusion punt 59mm By bringing resmm ta bear it alma- mull - blyleaa-m mm enlargemazt at the plati- t a 61543 larger than it might be meted ta 11 it renamed solely a French Fon'th 113 cmm m I'm WEE-613 have as we i s-almm the amnicatim a all Ranch 9 mg g fmgurim to H he mmcuon Wmmammofm m inrthe mam-him - amm mgmaIMthseowmaw - MW 1% am Ea madam W some at ma Wand ch Mob with Wuhan ii xii mag tojha mm swag4m fag-2 timing mm 9 rm are ma 1 man I 2 11f which its United We could own - gimmick name Wouaf ihwotth par asagh - ram the desirability a praceeding with tha Winn 9m 1 11 10 31 8 Uu 5 in Hi 11m 31'7- Wald Wl m Eu rzrmi alimarm m tannin lass attmtimmamow c9 - lm Hi Im- an areeipim mtien an mather meeai' m1 afa- H- -1 and-rm 111 a- can-hm of the party that the mtarial maid bade for purposes mm mu 1 made available to awn-mm - L i i 1Em9 r i mauni a air Eli if nil 1m 153 a $1 321 le i' - Jini-l 1 a immil - FEET 2352 We stay nial is cum-mt 1mm mamam make- ma attractiw the we of 13 5 - 3-235 abroad is thawm adcgtim 6f an alley at to iffa imW w Ei m na x Mop hio a 9 an mnMdwatic mums uke 11 tank i lI-i-J mug We mutt-91 W3 and warms We Wm t Elm the po syw dmba ectinam i pammn q gamma wreak planm A richad 11 Mad not wax-arm ham a ma a affect in - managing Gm WW8 far alternata 9mm 31' supplya i WW ller-them s eps mam taken eiwmemgm-dm all recipient War specifically if favor nf 68 92 33 It seems aware-m hm that am 131 13f German- far WW periodcf was he Wane aims mama for'nniiam treatnm 3101' all Mahala means in this WNW aims mam-eat and mm 33 5th we wow our policy in mm area has been to mom'nnii nm mman 121 an cooperating nations Further it saw equally mam-1m tha am of thaw We have madm- 633mm and ma Man- 13 other impar'bw ts bj i've Ep a L- HE Finally and mun-r 3i 153 5 in I H h ml 1w 31'3 u' r'c calf - htF- L' I i it a r5 ai' tim- s t k 1 m' i ma uth 113 additianal mammal by ick the United Shams might affect that Wm mum 13 01 53 armaments with the Frank Gammantm max-mm their incentive tamels mama technical assistants mimhly an minim- 1 $235 to W m- aim and - unitary mom The French detan uatim to have an in amth melee We in such amt 3 5 af 3515138111336 cf- this mama is to 613311sz than from Wading with plation or the pm Emma 1 airs mm mm not ma-eils' a mum tn wake ma cialimiaa but the stems Jam-35' mm cf 3 w ty of 13 235 corresponding 4m a nmnbar GE years out-pert o the WW plant it is Madam that France mam the praiact Eastman - mm we gamma rate- at magma-Ewes far its _-coastructim Alternatively a 11 23 affw 151 MW in mam the pram-ms which hm - teen ea by lm in emmabiun of the plant might be mlem 3 13 19 1116 French Eras Beehixis anti acceyt ng am outside assi mam The 31 95 13 of any technical wmmce of mm 3011113 inth 1 51151 W m or Resmcted mm which is arm-dad as high Sensiti'm 1111 3133103315 1 91 ch be the we of am tam ax Msw'w to new which 13mm satmi y Germany's 6382113 for an jade I d-235 production mummy and thereby ramcma the Gen-am incentive far canme with Eramm Tm moat emicua methad tam achieving this walla take me farm 9f technical citapamtian with the Gamma mains to at ma a-Mm by them ci a gas Wifqu aspara ma SESEEF in I 5-miit hmq4 1 I - -- I NARA Data I u plat As indicated earlier in this mmdm a Gamma effort in this area has long bean underway- and this affort may lead to their 43$ 8 plant with or without 6 8 cooperatim The posaiw bmtiea of 13 5 cooperation with dam in the gas centrifuge area hm bean 9W fax-Manna cat'ng mm technical mamas in this field in vimr or the sigrd ctmce and high plenty at 631mm program This consi erauon indicated that cm the one hand of 51 3 restrictions on cornmea aim cf metric- ed Data and on the other hand of the restrictions of the mm Treaty cm any new Were caopera an by mmbara er the cmity with third partiem -- A air-Q rmer amen- 11 1mm $0 to channel the Gamma manna th other uropean Wty m ms' de Irma 5 the - u uiun and him i' a - 318 21 -2 - as u l an 3 5 In ch 635 Erhanexpana an ake he Ema gas has a 11313 mm 2 1 mm fz amw term a source of 3-235 for its civil Frog-m this We might have at twantion far than As a possibility the United States might take'mms ta nmmrag i a oin c coati'm in the of M3 employing the 71 um of those facilities This alarga mesa-rem a a problem associated with the Wea m or Esau-1mg Bata man would me under 1 ms man of 1 90ch t9 the in 17115 5 field aim 111333 132 113 3 v 5 Restricted Data Bf Gama In gm di uaion plant data 3 3 mame by we Um 1n aces - with the cm classificatioa guide and the matter 91 the New at Iii-each Witty pmde far the an the waiver 1m the mold have to be 3 1 1 75'31                     National Security Archive    Suite 701  Gelman Library  The George Washington University    2130 H Street  NW  Washington  D C  20037    Phone  202 994‐7000  Fax  202 994‐7005  nsarchiv@gwu edu