DECLASSIFIED This document consist of 55 agesr Am xn y F30 a Number of copies Series ammwu SUBJECT 24 63 my -- EYES mm mm DEPARTMENT OF STATE Memoranclum of Conversation DATE July 23 km $230 p m g lay s Heat Kant rms Limitatian Prahm Saaurity Guarantee 7 9 Israel PARTICIPANTS The Yn ant FORM 3-5 3 Ball Kr Jah 3 Eg l y As istant acrataty Fhiliip Iaibat Amha sa ar Jana ta BAR Hr Jahn EmGone it etnr Kr fan Kitza saistant arntaty aw KcGearse Bun y 1 3 whita aa e Rabart Kamar the hite Eauam Hr Katmann Kilt Raferance Ehe Secrutary a xamaraa am ta the r i ent ated July 22 1963 The rasidanz thaught it best not ta taka any spaaial actiaa with reggae ta Israal right new 33 aha mament the ialague cauld be cantinued batween the mbasaa ar and The Iaraelis will attamgt ta bargain fa a sacnrity gmarantee In any says they have net been aiug vary much an nuclaar activity rece tly Kt nail yaintwd an tha suacassful aenclnaian af a_ ast ban agreament shaul Frnvide an appartuuity to tast Israeli intantians Yha Prasi ent aaka if same kind af inspactiaa perhaps canl be gptten 29m assarh Kr c lay raealled asser s atatemant af a setting a sar ka n9 thaught it thraugh aad neither a UK net an i aa ha ayyeaiad ta him 'Easser baa paintad an the Israalis hava a nuclaar patential while he aas mat Ha weu1d be glad t0 knaw ghat thay daing hut he had nathing tn inspect g had baan pattin larly sansitive an missilas and rafuae ta e apt ny varifieatinn His reasans ha bang-pelitieai an waa net a aecurity guarantae gag Hat wish any a brelia fr m aha Western pawers - accepta the resi ent s gned intentians but wisha to avai any suggestiaa af a p a e arata En mania ha wiliing-ga regly t a Eresidantiai letter an nuclear weapnns an at attacking Iaraal amba sa ar Eadeau WP 3mm ms mm mm GPO 965913 i r Authority BN9 mon 2 my swam Ems ambassa ar Badeau paiatad nut tha when ha ha ravi wad tha subjacc f his last amazing with Kassar Haasar had again mantianed the eolleetiv ghting and ka eita the d is Abaha Badaau had tal aaser ha might hava aam thing mare ag eifie ta anggea his ra urn Th3 Ambassa ar than nata tha asaar a July 22 had stated the has an 91am fag iiqui ating Israalg 2 wnuld nan attaek Intaal e thamght this signifi ant Eta Frasi ant suggaste that af ar be ma a ta giva Nasaur a atatammnt widnr disalminatiaa in aha miayrasa an elaawharu Ha an intarast in seeing Eanaar tamarks Qha yrasidanc than a te that sans innpa tian i ama k in bath Itraal an aha EAR If w gan gm saws sari af Ea taxpan ian wu W ni hawk ta giva leaa ea Israel n aska Mr a awaa whathar aha EAR wanid agacpt agmu innpaetian Th3 glue rauallad that whaa sauvw a EBBX ilia was h xt the Eranah baa 36mg ngarn ahaut Iaraali nuelaar intanti na Kn aaka if anything furthar had haen haard abaut this Mr Mane mm that ma been 311m a mi mac-gar by aha awiaza EAB had mat aguaad ta XAEA taxpa tiena 3% in as Inga ii aan eznad wa want b11$t ra1 iasga tiane h - ig1nal Franch Israali agrnament had givan 2 3 Fr neh sama a agaar a at imnna Tha glutonium pwa ne d was ta he rataina by aha quaeh Lace ha xptassed aangarn ahaat Israali intantians n had aet d that the I raelin art haying fat wiehmut a faguar s zl uiring Frenuh ta e sama yrnamgtivg buying Er Hacaat-sai ha is naw aatia iea in nu atha aemglex in Iaraul at the pvasant time Es theught aw might be ahla ta gut swag inapacaian 23m tag Ran In raayanaa ta tam trasi gnt'a inquiry am Mn ana anglaine that aban Qua year aft r Btaana gags tit1ga1 Iaraal will hm bi tn ak a anaiaar d$viea wharaa tar th y can build u ta tum ar thraa pat year an antimata ii that will 39 aritinal lat in 1963 at tariy 196k Inapeezian must ha hagnn $311 1a advanea nea th raactar in aritiaal mueh at it will ha radiaaetiva and glasa uf a lay suggasta that u gee agrammant an ralatt any afferts in Israai 9 it rashar than Eta residant 3mm 31% mm a DECLASSIFIED i Authority BNO Cathy's 4 we a k l f 5 ms om mm The raaidant shanght we shaul get aha Egyptians ta agraa ta inspacti n and-tha Esraalis ta hilataral inapaation as wandered what we might hava ta 51v uha Israalia ta gm it xx Talbat pointa nut that Israel has alraady agreed in prineipla t0 saws farm 9f inapeatien T ma far hawavwr yracedural an timing arrangamants hava haen inadequata Tha resid nt said Ha ahauld kaap up th cattusg ndanae-with Isranl aha this Parhaps Sanatnr Fullbright might alas be getaen ta mmka a atate meat 9a the snbjaat Whila Israal might $133 aema agrwemene en the ha wan erad haw egg euuid pravant Israel 33m manufacturing anglear weapana Ex MQCana gaiatad an that the irst inagaatian shanl revmal mn h ahaut Isra li'intanzinna wxampla xkaetar inalu s a hwmiaal a paratian giant this aggesta thay may have 13-m$nd making nu laat wmapana Tka Prasi ent ra arxad ta asser s snatamant that he wanl engage in ymataativu against Iarael 1 ha that Bimnna is manufaeturing nuclear wmapeas asked why Ragga and net statad this pabliely earliar Ambassg ar Ba gau sai cur past assurances ta aha Arabs tbs aha raactnr is mat pra ueing such waapans have helped An aquate prncass in part tha whal i dla East situatxan Ex Ball askad whather-Iaraal wauld maraly ha abla ta set a against or waa1d it be a wuapen Mr Mg ang painted ant that aha Iaraalia alxga y hava mapahility ta mate a nuelaar explasian with a napena syntam Mr Hitna eai the Eantagen haliavas UAR cannat maunt a suaeasaful atta k against Xaraal If asser maally had ta fight Israal he wuuld p aba 1y laak at the situatian onan again Ambasaa or Badman thaught wu ld meant an air raid ta wipa an Bimnna aa thar a tar wait intervantian ta atah iza the situatian The raaidant sai wu shaul at e anythiag far aha timm baing Evaatually hnwevar an ahnni ha ma a ta sat an agraamant imam Israel as wall as sama sat af intaraatienal insyectien-in EAR Amba sa nr sadeau suggestsd than 99mg tpinking kg ana an what might ha inwulva in a aall tiva arrangwmeat Ha thought an shnuld not natal rely an Egyytians ta gama up with sama i gas Th3 Preai a t askad haw many cauntrias with raactors hava uujactad inapentian Ha mundared i might wark an an inspectian syatem with thasa gauntrias where th raactar is net a gra t pxablwm Hr 333$ 10 DECLASSIFIED 7r f I 47 any mg Mr Hm lay that any-inquiry in staal be hal aff until Ha knaw whera an gamma with asapeat ta 3 aaeuvity guarantaa at Istaai If wa 3a a letear Exam asaar and than givu a aa ur ty gnaraataa ta 32331 this eauld ha a problmm Tha rasidant gaid aha a la tnr- gam Nasaur might ha menial in th 9 8 at thia kima mhassadarxn aau zhmught we might Flak up tn agpxapriatn quetatiuas fv m Nassar s July 22 apttah and ala say sama thing ahnut magi ar iaapactiaa tha rssident agid that a ta a taa ban treaty is aigped wu shaal attempt he gnu avsxy cauntry that gs nut yn agrged to inagaetian tn aeaepa 59mg farm af internatianai inspa tian Ea might gain an hang it is in th Arab interaat ta an an since this will alga put prasaura an the Iata lis Ambassadar Ba aau agrea but aautiene ighat aaxu ha t kan ta avaid any anggastian that tha in baing single ant Emu Emma that WE hava net ya wupliad ta Ban- urion s latter 9f and a half Maths as Fragment thaught his may a atatemant sheul be to thaw in thair saeurity I Rome paintad ant that Baav utien' a latt r ha spaei iaally in ieata thay wishgd a security guazantaa a d that Eskkal s regent Llatter ha refawrad 3a this waguaat Ex falbat thaught a lettax nhnul ha sank ta Enhkal but seeurity guarantaa questions shoul be keys gayarata Ball sai a prspaaed lettar an tha saaurity guarantna qu$stinn anammd 2a h m ta ha 39 argumantativa whg- raai znt thaught Ea ahauld wait an tha s aurity gaarantaa if quastion a ahauld yain ha tha that the ay 8 seatamant is as far as tha Fraai ant wan g9 withaut inviting aha Soviats inta the Mia ia East n ahauld alga paint at all tha raggans why this is tha hast ma a a daing it Mr all wwi aratad gha if lsraal in amang th firat Ev adhara ta has ban agteemaat this be evid nea of genitive intantionsa If thay hald bank thin extatas a aw situatian which w hall hava to at was mt by mum fhe raai ant thaaght that signing was nqg uaffieiant W3 mnat aisa have inspectian Hr Macena poingad an that innpaasian appliss anly ta taa ters It ees pravant tha impartatian f nu 1 ar matarials Tha Fr ai ant aakad if tha sacratary aaul write t9 and inquire abaut inagactian arrangamanta with waspaet ta Dimena Hr Ball aaid h thnught this aaui kg dang m saw-r we aim mm This document is from the holdings of The National Security Archive Suite 701 Gelman Library The George Washington University 2130 H Street NW Washington D C 20037 Phone 202 994-7000 Fax 202 994-7005 nsarchiv@gwu edu