Letter from Chancellor Kohl to President Bush Bonn 28 November 1989 Dear George Thank you for your telephone request for information on the German situation for your upcoming meeting with General Secretary Gorbachev in Malta I welcome this This is a big sign of German-American friendship and partnership At the same time I would like to thank you for your friendly words in your Thanksgiving television address In order to take full advantage of your offer I ask that you understand that your meeting with General Secretary Gorbachev will likely deal with themes that touch on the interests of the Federal Republic of Germany and all Germans 1 Malta Philosophy I am much obliged to you George for the clarity with which you’ve rejected every parallel between Yalta and Malta I mention this point not as a German or a European status perspective My point is more that the historical reform process we are currently experiencing in East and Central Europe is not only proceeding in the direction of our western values—free self-determination democracy private enterprise—but is also being carried out by the people themselves Lech Walesa impressively underscored this recently in talks with you and before the Congress of the United States That is why attempts to steer these reform developments from above or to channel or limit the movement of the people fail to meet the demands of this historical epoch This is of course a consideration that applies to us and to our European neighbors In this sense the talks in Malta should avoid any appearance of a status quo summit 2 Stability of the Reform Process The issue that General Secretary Gorbachev will in all likelihood address—warding off of all destabilization increasing stability through reform—should be handled under this perspective Towards these goals I would like to recommend full and complete agreement—also in my name The same goes for your assurance that America greets these reforms—and not as an opponent looking for an advantage but rather as a people that offers support That is why it is important to establish with General Secretary Gorbachev the definition of both concepts --Contrary to what some eastern propaganda still claims destabilization does not come from western influence or an invasion from the West Its source is more from the awakening after many decades of violent oppressive conflicts for example ethnic conflict or the rejection of reforms and the subsequent reaction—or flight—of the people The GDR and the CSR are the latest examples of this and the fate of Romania is an occasion for much concern --Stability means stable development of reforms that guarantee the self-determination of the people—in the words of Gorbachev “freedom of choice ”—that allows the citizens a democratic share in the political developments in their country and opens to the people a concrete future outlook in their homeland In short like in 1776 it is about life liberty and the pursuit of happiness --Last but not least stability means a positive foreign policy environment especially dynamic progress in disarmament and arms control If these definitions are correct then the result will be that the most important decisions over stability or destabilization will be made by the countries in Central and Eastern Europe The duty of the west on the other hand must be to support the ongoing reform process from the outside Concrete forms and conditions of this support could be a main topic of discussion in your meetings with Secretary Gorbachev 3 Situation in the Soviet Union Based on our analysis you will face a General Secretary Gorbachev who wants to continue his policies resolutely consistently and dynamically but is meeting internal resistance and is dependent on external support The economic situation in the Soviet Union is based on the judgment of our analysts worse than when Gorbachev took office The already difficult supply situation could worsen this winter due to an energy crisis Our analysts say that General Secretary Gorbachev’s position currently is safe and his acceptance as number one even from government colleagues who are critical of the direction and tempo of perestroika is unchanged There is also no indication that his popularity among the people has decreased due to the absence of concrete results 4 Disarmament and Arms Control On top of that together with General Secretary Gorbachev we can work on advances in foreign policy The agenda that Secretary of State Baker and Foreign Minister Shevardnadze worked with in Wyoming has far-reaching meaning for American-Soviet relations I hope that your meeting with General Secretary Gorbachev will give a strong stimulus to the arms control negotiations even if no concrete agreement is concluded I would welcome it if the goals established in Wyoming for the START negotiations were further solidified This could strengthen the hope that in the next year an agreement could be reached or be very close to being reached in this important area that also has significant meaning for us Europeans An outstanding interest of the Federal Republic is speedy substantial results in the Vienna conference on conventional weapons in Europe—here I am also in agreement with our NATO partners especially with you This deals with a key issue of European security Given the strong Soviet armed forces in the countries of Central and Eastern Europe dynamic events in the Warsaw Pact states have given these negotiations extra meaning I think it especially important that progress in the Vienna negotiations keeps step with the general political changes in this region of Europe I would welcome it if you could tell GS Gorbachev the western resolution at the NATO summit in May to outline a time frame for seeing the first results in Vienna I believe that the Soviet Union is striving towards this goal as well They should be strengthened in this interest which was expressed in GS Gorbachev’s proposal of a meeting of heads of state in the second half of 1990 to ward of the signing of an agreement on conventional weapons We welcome the agreements on chemical weapons reached by the USA and the Soviet Union because they give hope of the possibility of soon reaching in Geneva a global comprehensive and effectively verifiable ban on chemical weapons I would welcome it if you reengaged General Secretary Gorbachev on this and thereby could move towards campaigning for extensive involvement on his part For the overall plan for arms control and disarmament at the NATO summit we adopted a clear position with respect to the question of nuclear deterrence and land-based short-range nuclear systems We wrote down a precisely defined negotiations perspective for this area General Secretary Gorbachev should be constantly reminded that his unilateral dismantling of the large military superiority in the East should make later negotiations easier Let me be clear on this point I heard with joy and satisfaction your renewed assurances in your Thanksgiving television address that you will leave American forces in Europe so long as they are wanted and needed by your European friends I assure you as before we view the presence of your forces as vital to European security Developments in other Warsaw Pact states Regarding the reform process in Poland Hungary Bulgaria the CSR and not least the GDR we have General Secretary Gorbachev’s policies to thank His perestroika loosed made easier or accelerated these reforms He pushed governments unwilling to make reforms towards openness and towards acceptance of the people’s wishes and he accepted developments that in some instances far surpassed the Soviet Union’s own standards General Secretary Gorbachev more or less declared the Brezhnev Doctrine dead and instead sanctioned the right of every state and people to “freedom of choice” in their political and social systems in among other things the joint declaration he signed with me in June as well as the last communiqué of the Foreign Ministers of the Warsaw Pact Here it will depend on General Secretary Gorbachev committing to his own promises and in particular stressing that the ban on interference goes for everyone for the Soviet Union in particular where it has its own troops stationed With respect to the situation in Poland and Hungary my visit in Warsaw and a last-minute talk with Németh have firmly convinced me that with winter coming both countries are facing considerable problems in providing for their people due to a reduction of Soviet energy supplies and the liquidity crisis In both countries “social eruptions” are not excluded particularly as orthodox Party circles could be interested in that In the face of this critical situation I must emphasize that western help is coming much too slowly In particular neither the International Monetary Fund nor—in the case of the Poland—the Paris Club discussions have been completed nor is the Stability Fund in the amount of 1 billion dollars which you suggested in the beginning of the October secured With the exception of the United States of America and the Federal Republic of Germany no other western country has promised contributions I am going to use our alliance meeting on December 4 to push for a quick passage of a resolution by the international financial institutions and to plead for further contributions to the stabilization fund 6 Situation in the GDR What I said about the importance of respecting the “freedom of choice” is especially relevant for the GDR Based on our information and in particular after talks with the head of the Federal Chancellery in East Berlin Minister Seiters we have come to the assessment that the leadership situation is no longer stable and the people are restless In spite of the opening of the border and the Wall in spite of changes in the leadership and the prospect of proposed reforms the mass demonstrations continue and Germans are fleeing from the GDR to the Federal Republic of German in significant numbers The upcoming Party Congress in the middle of December will answer key questions --Is the Communist Party prepared to renounce its monopoly on power and to change the corresponding constitution --Is the Communist Party prepared to allow for free elections in the near future to allow new and non-socialist parties and unions and to initiate urgent economic reforms Positive answers to these questions depend on whether the Federal Republic of Germany can realize its offer to help the GDR in new financial dimensions Should General Secretary Gorbachev criticize this view of the Federal Republic as interference I would be indebted to you if you could clarify that for both us and west it cannot be about stabilizing a discredited leadership and an intolerable situation it must be about—respective of the wishes of the population—a far-reaching political economic and social change process supported from outside 7 German Reunification Let me thank you in the name of all Germans for your clear statement that the USA welcomes German reunification and that it is an issue for the Germans or rather both states to decide General Secretary Gorbachev may speak of this question in the sense that we must continue to respect the post-War reality and that the reforms in the GDR may not go so far to change the borders between East and West and to reestablish the unity of Germany in whatever form I ask you explicitly—also in the sense of which I explained at the outset—not to agree with any commitments that could be displayed as restricting the policy “of working towards peace in Europe in which the German people recover their free self determination of their unity ” This goal was renewed by the NATO heads of state in their declaration of May 30 1989 and we demonstrated this to the Soviet Union already in the conclusion of the 1970 Moscow Treaty The crux of the matter is and remains the free self-determination of the Germans in the GDR The events of the past summer have proven that they do not feel or think as members of a separate nation Since the opening of the Wall and border more than half of the citizens of the GDR—as of today more than 9 million people —have visited the Federal Republic of Germany and were welcomed with warmth and solidarity With the mass demonstrations in the GDR the calls for freedom free elections and free unions were increasingly joined by the call for unity It will continue to grow if the promised reforms fall apart Naturally it is in the common interest of the West and East and all Germans that a “chaotic situation” doesn’t arise such as General Secretary Gorbachev feared in his message to you on the tenth of this month The Germans in the GDR really have shown considerable attention reason and levelheadedness in the sight of repression still carried out at the beginning of October The German government has in no way used the current situation in the GDR in order to single-handedly achieve its own goals On the contrary we have strengthened our unbreakable loyalty to the Alliance and our active cooperation with European integration This has been acknowledged by you and by our European friends and allies for which I at this point again thank you Even General Secretary Gorbachev in a telephone conversation with me spoke in favor of the German government’s practice of clever restraint I hope very much that he does not tell you anything different I assured him that the German government stood firmly by the Moscow Treaty and the CSCE obligations whereby self-determination must apply to everyone It is in accordance with the legitimate security interests of all Europeans and the entitled interests of the German people in particular the people of the GDR to harmonize a longterm perspective I summarized in 10 points in front of the German Parliament what the German government intends to do to move towards this goal First Immediate concrete help for the people of the GDR in humanitarian and medical areas and by financing their newly won freedom of travel Second Strengthened cooperation with the GDR in all areas that would be of immediate benefit to the people economy science and technology culture environment communications Third An expansion of our help and cooperation in new areas if there are fundamental changes to the political and economic system Fourth Picking up the concept of President Modrov regarding contractual association development of joint institutions such as for business traffic environmental protection technology health culture Full incorporation of Berlin Fifth As soon as the other side is available as a democratic and legitimate partner the development of confederate structures between the two states Sixth The embedding of the future structure of Germany within the pan-European process for which the West has paved the way with its concept of a lasting and just European order of peace Just as we described to the Soviet Union the building blocks of this structure unrestricted observance of the integrity and security of every state the right of every state to freely choose its own political and economic system observance of the principles and norms of international law in particular the right of self-determination of the people and—not least—the realization of human rights Seventh Openness and flexibility of the European Community with respect to all reformed countries in Central Eastern and Southeastern Europe naturally including the GDR speedy conclusion of trade and cooperation agreements in the long-term the development of associations to assist with dismantling the economic and social differences of the continent Eighth Energetic progress in the CSCE process using the forthcoming forms Ninth Far-reaching and speedy steps in disarmament and arms control compare with part 4 above Tenth Organic development toward a situation in which the German people through free selfdetermination regain their unity whereby the interests of all involved are taken into account and peaceful coexistence in Europe is guaranteed Dear George I would be especially indebted to you if when you meet with Gorbachev you could support the policies in these ten points and make clear to him that the best interests of his country do not lie in holding onto taboos that can be overcome but rather in this forward-looking course For this I thank you in advance With friendly greetings your Helmut Kohl