j _ _ - - - · - ft- _CJblRcO - - ·- _ -SEGR TITT f 7ECA'fVl 10 -'df ' ' - ---5@_ _ r _1 IIIIFO SERVICE CENTER DDIEDIATE • ommz OCT 91 SECSTATE VASHDC DlllfIIIATE 9406 e£ T 3Prefi iE TIIJII 01 Of 03 MOSCOW 30544 EXDIS DECAPTIONEDI E 8 1me· DEEL IIAIII TASS PRCL NNUt PARM UR US SllaJECT IS WORRIED ABOUT UKRAINE BUT FEELS ___ mvotlll MIIY BACK OFF Amil THE REfERENDIRI O L 1 t IEiRR · UA IRE lfX1 • Z SIHIARY THE UlRAJNlAII PARLIAMENT'S otTO IER 22 DECISIDII TO CQIITINIIE DISCUSSION Of APlMI JO ESTABLISH A STAIIOING I CllAlllIAH ARMY SEPTEL AW POSSIBLE IMPLICATIONS FOR COlfTRDL OF NUCLEAR lft APONS BASED Iii UKRUIIE VAS THE MAJOR THEME Of POLICY PLAWIR STAFF HDIIER UlilllRN' S OCTOBER 23 MEETING mu lllU BE A MEMBER Of THE SOVIET DELESATIIII TD 11£ MID-EAST PEACE mtFERENCE SAYS THE UUAINf 'S ACTION JS ASPECIFIC VJOI ATlDII OF UIIERTAUtfGS MADE TO AIID RSFSR YJCE PRESIDENT RIITSIO't 111 KIEV JS WORRIED ABOIIT THE uwm IIUD ITS PllTOOlAI FOR NUCLEAR PROUFERATllltl BUT FEELS lRAVCIU JS GRAHDSTANDIJIG AND MAY BE SUSCEPTIBU TI REASOH AFTER THE DECEMBER 1 REFERDilllll • 3 PERSONALLY -FEELS THE UlRAINIAllS' ASPIRATIONS TO Bf MUVED 111 IIOCLfAR ISSUES axJI D BE llliESSED BY -MWURES SUCH AS ESTABLISIIJII A COIISULTATIVE -GROUP SOOLAR TI 'NATO'S NPG OF THE FOUR REPUBlltS 1111 WOSE TIRRITDRY ICIIM'S ARE STATllJIE OIi STM T CFE l ATIFICATION AND IF UlRAINIAN R£PRESENTATMS DO NOT JOIN THE SUPRENE SOVIET -RECGIIIEIIIS PROCEEDING m EAllllrST ONLY fTER DECEMBER 1 H SUGGESTS PIITTI fo THI IJltlS OIi THE lru AUUANS ntRDUGH U S AND IIEST E18JPEAII APPROACHES TO THEM WITH U S SENATE ACTIDfl PRECEDIU6 A PUBLIC INVITATlDll lO THE llRAIHIAHS TO PARTICIPATE IN TII CEIITTR'S R TJFJCATION OF Tit£ TP EATl£S EHD SIM ARY • •·· 4 UKRAINE'S COlfTRDL OF FORCES -SAID THE ------ ----- - - - - - UlRAINE'S ACTION EXPUCITLY VIOLATES tM1£RTWHGS l HICH HE All'D RIITSIOl' tfERE GIVEN IN UEV SPECIFICALLY THAT THE UlRAlftE AGREED TI REFRAIII FR II MY UNILATERAL ACT VITH IIIPLJCATlDNS FOR TII STRATEGIC SITIIATIOII SAID THE ACTUAL snumON REMAINS TO BE XLARlfJED BUT IT APPEARS THAT THE UtRAlHIARS AR£ IN PROCESS OF HAl lM UICAL ARMY HA ' ' AIR FDHCE AIIJ STRATEGIC ROCm a»IIIAIIDERS C IIE RAV£ N'J CO iflRKATlON THIS 15 IW'PEIIING -BELIEVE S TIIAT lRAYCllll 111 THE RUIIIIP TI DmMIIER 1 IS •001 r tt FDRJS it 'c ' 'la-s-si - fl --ca tf o-n Ext ' ' e 'nd e d o n - - REVIEtl Foti DlSTRIBUTllll TO CltlCS • 03 06 2014 - Class SECRET SUBMIT JCS·DSS FORM 30 If REQUIRED uthortty DSCG 11-1 ACTilltl oeclassi on 10 24 2 016 INFO CJC i l i Jii 3- JS l SECDfF·N 1 • USD ' 13 USDA P l l USDA At l F I1 Al 2 USDP•CH i I USDP PD i Dl 1i PD ll PlOpl OO i-1 1 JIIM12 Dt -5110 • osc Cl l llr'SllJ DA-PA t D1 11 DlO l j 00B j D11 01 -tOCSII liASfflllGTOII DC tCNO IIASlllTIGTON DC REVIEW AUTHORITY -tNATS PENTA iDN IIASHllaOO DC M • M L S • NA S PENTASN VASfflllliTON DC artin C ean emor 4ll5M411 Sl1N'E BWSURV Y I _R_ev_l_ ewi -e_r_____ __ _ - ¥4¥ tt£ J 4 4 o o Oo ''- HERO fH AMEIIBASSY MOSCOII TO 1V EXCLUSIVE ZYIIV RUEIIIIOA0544 2971417 EVERYTHIM'i HE CAN Tv DEMONSTRATE -HE'S AJIATION L MCN 9125-7 057 46 TOR• 91297 1B102 7t LW1 5 EINHORN RMEVEb lHE il S MESSAGE TO All PARTIES CONCERNED THAT ANY SHARm RESPOHSIBILITY FOR Tlft DISPOSITIOII OF NIICLUR 'rlEAPOOS t 111 EVEll THEIR USE IS THE BUSINESS OF THE CENTER ANO RIPUBUCS TD IIORII' OUT AMl»iG THEMSELVES BIJT WE ARE DEEPLY COKERIIED ·111 T ND REPUBUC HAVE INDEPENDENT IXIIIIAND AI TIIORITY UR C WTROI THIS WIIUl MEAN WClEAR PROUffRATION AND HAVE DJSASTRDOS CIIISEQUEHCES FOR OVEIIAU STAIJJLID • ltl nt£ RE lOY AS tlf Ll AS FDR M REPUBLICS' ECON04IE5 SAm 11£ ARE NO LESS tolfCERBED • AND S 6fSTED 111 T ESTABLISHING RN AllVlSORY CMJTTEE OF THE FOOR REPIIBLICS AUllfG LINES OF NATI 'S ·NPG VOIILD BE lllE IIAY OF AtcatlllllATIIIG THE UKRAINIANS' COHCERNS IIITltOOT GlVlllG TlfEK SUCH JMIEPENOEHI OWIHDI Al r Q THE ll BAJNJNIS COP D PARTJCJPATI IN ASTAT CWICIL WRUNG GROUP ON NUCLEAR DEFENSE AS ·WELL AS IN THE DEFEJISE CalllTTEE Of THE UIIICfl PARUAMEHT ASKED IF Alff DISCUSSlOIIS REGARDJllG NUCLEAR ARWGElOrS WERE ALREADY OODIG OH AIION6 TH£ REPIJIIUCS AS UUAUIIA I FORlJ6N JIIHIST£ll ZLENf HAD IIITDIATED IN WASHIMiTflll ntEIE 'MlGlfT BE AfflRKED THERE ARE NO NEGarIATIUIS • EIJHlRII NOTED THAT RlflSIDY SAID 111 A RECENT lNTERVIEtl WITH DIE wm· THU GORBACHlY JII Y£L 'TSIN HAD AGREED TO PIIAL NI ClIAII CONTROi -SAID THIS JS CORRECT -GOIIBACHEV HAD ASSENIED THt DAY AFTER RETURIIING flllll TH£ CRDIEA -- BUT n WAS UHFORTIJl m lfiT RUTSlOY VAS TAUNG ABOOT IT IN PUBLIC THIS UNITEO BROADER BT 9 f C R E 1 SP Clff SECTION 02 OF 03 KOSC0lrl 3054 f From the Nunn-Lugar collection of the National Security Archive ' - _ -M 9511 BEGL1Q IIR TAGS PREL -MN IC PARM lift US SUBJECT IS VllllRlED AIIOOT UlRAIN£ BUT FEELS · •··-- l RAVCllll NAY BACl OFF AFTER THE REFEREMIUM C04PLICAT11WS lllfEII A PRIVATE AGREEMENT WIILD HAVE sumcm 6 UUAIHJAN HOTJVES ASIED TI COOl£RT ON THE -· - - - - - - - - EVOLUTION OF ltlE UHAIHIAIIS' INTEREST Ill AIIUCUAR VEAPOlfS FREE ZOH£ AHD JOIHIMi NPT FOUDll D BY REfUSAL TD TRANSFER •THm• WEAPO lS TD «ussJA POSTPOIIEMDIT or AN llVFl AND INSISTENCE OIi A ml £ Itl THE DISPOSITIDII OF IIEAPalS AIISVER£D FULL·BOR£ -- THE UWIHE HAS NO TRADITIONS AS AN EsrABWIIEll STATE AND NEVER HAil Cl EAR BORDERS ITS CURRENT •ABSOUITELY ARTlflCJAL• IIOIIERS VERE MADE WJISE BY ADDITJDNS TO ITS TERRITORI' -IN lfflllSIICIIEV'S TIME - MOST Of TH CUIIA£11T UKRAIHJAf LEAllERSIIIP IS ABSOUITELV JGNORAIIT • TH£1R UNDERSTAWJNS Of THC INTERNATIONAL SlTtlATION IS LIKITTD • AIID THEYIIA f A LOVE Hm RELATIOflSHIP 111TH GREAT PCTIIERS • -- THEY CIWIGED THUR APPROACH IHN TH£Y Rf ALIZED THAT UKRAINE' S GREAT P lllERSTATUS WlllD DEPEND OIi NOCI EAR 11£APONS -- CR WCHl f MIO ZLElf ' AP ·mva · HMVrn BE REASOIIAliL£ AITTR 0£CEHBEP 1 Allr -7 ST RTtm R TJrlCl TJON SAJD IT li'JU ll 6£ 1----------------·---·ar o· -- FDR 115 1111 FOP YOU •• TO BEGIN T1I£ IIATlfICATJOII PROCESS VITllOUi UCRAllflAN PARTICIPATlllll Hf SUGGESTED A FAUBACC POSITJDrl TO ADIAL UIRAJNJAN D£LEGATJ0 'I JOIIIING lltE SUPREME SOVIET lHAT A SPEClAL UlRMNlAII DEL£Gi TIQII Clli TO MOSCOW PCRHAPS AS _ lAD•91297 1B162 SECRET SPE CAT 1'I- 'l t COSN MAU657 PAGE 1 OF 03 SECT MSG 2JI 1-4172 OCT 2 91 -SECRET SPECAT COPY NUMSER-------- JOINT STAFF INFO SERVlCE CENTER EXCLUSIVE 8 SUGGESTED lll IH6ING PRESSURE OH lHE U RAINIR IS THROUGH APPROACHES BY THE U S AMI WESTERN COONTRIES THEN MOVING TD A RIISSIAN·UltRAINIAll DIAI OOUE HE SUGGESTED AlliJTIIER StEHARIO FOR PUTTING THE mrus OIi THE UKRAINIA IS THE U S SENATE IIOULD mm' AFTER WHICH THE U S •• WESTERN COIIITRIES AND RUSSIA WULD APPEAL TD THE u RAllllAUS TD JOIN 1N SUPPORT FOR RATlflCATION IF THEY FAILED TO uo so THE CURREllT· SUPRDIE sovm KM UD PBOCEED VJIH R ilflCWDfi AUD THE UKIIAlNUNS COULD BE PIIBLIClY CRITICIZCD oso·a s b 6 From the Nunn-Lugar collection of the National Security Archive • OBSERVERS FOR THE SPECIFIC PURPOSE ·Of PARTIClPATlNG IN T1IE COIIHClL Of REPIJilLICS' VOTES ON START CFE • ASS ED ABOOT TIKING -SAID THE SPECIAL DELEGUJON WAS HIS OIIII IIIEA BUT THAT NDTHlN MUCH COULD BE DONE BEFORE THE DECEMBER 1 REFEBENOOM AITTR THAT START CFE RATIFICATION WIJUJ BE AN •mELL llT TEST me· Of UKRAINIAII POLlCY 9 IHTRA-REPIIBLltAN CONSIILTATIYE ARRANGEMENTS --------· --- ·------- -SAID BmER ARRANGEMENTS ARE CLEARLY NECESSARY HE ACOOIILEDGED TIIAT GORBACHEV HAD SPOlEH VITH YEL'TSIN BEFORE RESPDNIIIMi TO THE PR£SIDEJIT' S NUnEAR IUITIATM BUT NOTED THAT YEL 'TSDI STILL •NEEDS EDUCATIJli• OIi THE l5Sll£S AND TIIAT REAL C IISULTATlO lS IIDUI D IIAYE TO lAtE PLACE H I MR LEVELS THERE REJCAW A PROBLEM IN GOIIIIACHEV'S WANTING TO DO THINGS WITHOUT KENlJNGFIJL COllSIILTATlONS AND YEL 'TSIH IS BEING PUBUCLY ' CRITlCllED FOi LACl OF ACONSULTATIVE MECIWIJSM • Office of the Secretary of Defense Chief ROD ESD WHS S' ltsn_ Date 7-'' Me -rt1 olb Authority EO 13S26 Declassify - - - Deny in Full Declassify in Part X --Reason 3 3 C t U MOR l ' -M- 3 ' 11 10 MIRV'S ElllHORN NOTED THAT Ill ASTATBIOO -------- ISSUED rDLUllflNS GORBACHEV' 5 RESl'OHSE • lO YREV IIAD SAID THE RSFSR VANml TO ·HUE DEEPER CllTS IN tlllCLEAll W£APOIIS DID THIS MEAN MIIMD ICBK'S7 -SllID 11£ PERSIINAI LY SUPPORTS ACTil 'lTY Itl SEEUNG MIRV REDIJCTIOKS lllm'ER THE U S SHOULD DO SIX4fTHING TO MAKE OOR POSJTJON IIIIIE FLEXIBLE YOU SHOULD DO SOlfTIWIG TOO • BT 5 E Ii II E I SP SECTION D3 Of 03 MOSCO' 30544 DECLASSIFIED IN PART Authorffy EO 13526 Chief RCICOtEla Atleclau Div WHS Dale MAR 2 3 2016 -aMS E 0 1235 · NCf BABftTAGS PREL MNUC PAIIM UR US SUBJECT JS liOIIRIED AllOlll' UKRAIHE BUT FEELS ···-·· IRAVClllt MAY BACI OFF AFTER THE R£fERDlll M 0 11 FUTllRE SECURID AGENDA TALKS THE TALKS __ I- - - - - - - - - - INIIHICHlS A PUTATM PARTI ill fi VERE A THREAD THDJ6l«llT THE CDNVERSATIOII -ENDOl S£D THEM AS AVEHICLE FOR JtlFLUEHCIHG THE UlRAINIANS MD IJTIIER REPUBUCS HE EXPRESSED CQ 'ICERI THltl Bl'El ORIJSSIA AUD WAKIISTAN 11001 D Bl OFFENDED If Oll ER REPIIIILJCS IIER IIIVITED AND THEY WIRE NOT ALTffllUGH HE M CEPTED THAT REPUBLICS NOT INVITED Tq THE FIRST SESSION COULD BE • lllVITED LATER HE EXPRES ED COOC£ml THAT SOVIET FIRST DEPUTY FORHlitl Mill tSTIR PETIIOVSUY WOUI D NOT INSPIRE COllflDENCE rn SEtURIHG GlXII REPUBLICAN REPRESENTATI ALTERHATIVEl Y -SAW MERIT Iff ilOT INVITIIIG UKRklNE TO JHE FIRST SESSIDII lilllCH YILL B£ HUD BEFORC THE pCCCKBtr 1 RCF£RE Rll ll Hf P ECIHiENDED NA1AllBll '£V' FRIEND SULEJMEJtOV IPIIOHI AS A PIITTNTIAL KAZAlH lHVIlIE BRDADLY EXPR£SS£D SCIIE COlr ERI TIViT HIS FPJEND YAt0 '1 £ ' MIGHT BC ttlFUSlHf •APPR IIP JATP R£PRES£ffTATil i AT THE TALES l ITH COOORT £' P EPIIESElfTATIOII Tff£ GOAL SHOIIU BE TO sm PRESENTATIVE ·REPRESENTATION • STIIAU ' n I i-- 1• N•81287 O5146 6 5 I 4 ¥ 1 - 1 ' I• 10 •91297 18102 TAD•91297 1816Z SECRET SPECAT COSNaMAU657 • PAGE 2 Dli 2 2-41417 OCll 9 03 SEC' MSG