IIo3j e COBeTCKHe H eOJIOrH HalJanH CTapaTenbHO BbIHCKHBaTb B COqifHeHHHX MapKca H 3Hremca npOpO'leCTBa 0 PYCCKOH peBonw­ U1fH XOTH MapKC H 3HrenhC 0 B03MOj HOH POJIH noro Mpa'lHoro MUllaH fIIUMe'lKa Konocca uaPCKOH HMnepHH B nepeCTpoHKe MHpa H He 3aAYMbIBa­ JIHCh nonee Toro MapKca pa3 'paj aJI cpaHaTH3M 3AllA llHhlE DEBhIE H PYCCKMI PEBODIOUIDI H Henpe 'cKa3Y­ eMOCTb B nOBe eHHH PYCCKHX 3MllTpaHTOB HX HeTepnHMOCTb H KO­ BapCTBO TO BJIHHHHe KOTopoe OKa3bIBana Ha HHX MHCTHlJeCKaH CH­ COIl HaJIH3M TeopluI c03 u aHHaH 3ana l HOeBpOneHcKHMH RH­ TeJIJIeK'ryaJIaMH pe3YJIbTaT HX BOCmlTaHHH - Tpa HUHoHHoro H3Y­ 'leHHH 'peBHero MHpa xpHcTHaHcTBa pecpopMaIl HH COBpeMeHHoR CPHJIOCO CPHH eCTeCTBeHHblX HaYK OnblTa peBOJIlQUHR H T B JIa PO HHbI lbiTaH nHCbMa MapKca H 06paTHJI BHHMaHHe Ha TO KaK OH nHcan 0 naKYHHHe I nO YMaJI 'lro B 31'OM CKa3bIBaeTCH OKTPH­ HepCTBO MapKca ero npHBepj eHHoCTb K qifCTOTe KOMMYHHCTHlJe­ TO CKoro Y'leHHH Ho Kor u a H npoqifTaJI nOCJIaHHyw naK 'HHHbIM H3 j e BpeMH TeopHH cornmnH3Ma H KOMMYHH3Ma B onpe 'eneHHOH CTe­ IIeTponasnoBcKoii KpenOCTH HcnOBe h' KOTOPYw MapKC 3HaTh neHH H pe3ynhTaT IX BbICOKOMepHH 3ana Hble HHTenneKTyanbl He COMHeBaJIHCh B npeBOCXO CTBe 3ana u a Ha OKpYj aWllIHM MHpoM He Mor H 6hm nOTpHceH IIponacTh B KOropyw CKaTHJICH nOT Ha­ nyraHHblR 0 CMepm peBOnWIl HOHep OnaneHHhrn OrHHMH nO'lTH 'lTO nOAKpenJIHnOCb TeXHHlJeCKHM npeBOCXO CTBOM H KynhTypHhlM Bcex eBponeRCKHX BoccTaHHii OKa3anaCh fie3 ORHOM B pa3BHTHeM noro perHOHa TaK 'lTO cpOPMYnHpYH a6CTpaKTHble no­ H npoHCHeHHH HHTHH COUHaJIHCTH'leCKOH IX H KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKOR TeopHii aBTopbl Boo611Ie He npRHHMaJIH BO BHHMaHHe onblT HaKOnJIeHHblH BHe EBponbI OHH CqifTaJIH caMO C060R pa3YMewillHMCH 'lTO 3ana HaH EBpona - npao6pa3 pa3BHmH BceMHpHoR Il HBHJIH3aUHH H 'lTO npoHHKHoBeHHe ITOR Il HBHJIH3aUHH B caMble OT u aneHHble yronKH caMblX BapBapCKHX cTpaH - Bce He06xo HMOe AJIH PYCCKOii peBOnWIl HH BO BceM ee MHoro06pa3HH HcnOBe­ naKYHHH KaK 6bl onOJIH IUI JloCToeBcKoro H nocne 3HaKOMCTBa C HcnOBe hW CBH eTenhCKHe nOKa3aHHH nyxapHHa PbIKoBa Pa 'eKa H Pyrnx nO CY U MblX Ha MOCKOBCKHX npoueccax Yj e He Ka3aJIHCh MHe CTOJIb a6cYP HhIMH Bonpoc nHllIh BpeMeHH IIo3j e CTOPOH­ HHKH cOI J H llJIHCTHlJeCKHX OKTPHH nblTaHCh OKonaThCH 0 HX KOp­ CKOHUeHTpHpOBaJIOCh Kor a B POCCHH nOHBHJIHCh nepBble pa60qife Kpyj KH no He­ CKonhKY eCHTKOB 'leJIOBeK B 3ana HOH EBpone Yj e npoHCXO HJIH HeM BbIHyj eHbl 6hmH npocnej lfBaTh JIHHHW pa3BHTHH 3ana HOro nepBoMaHCKHe eMoHCTpaUHH pa60'lHX 6bIJIH MO HbI IIIHpoKono­ MblllmeHHH JIble coUHamiCTHlJeCKHe lIIJIHnhI a enYTaTbI OT COUHaJIHCTHlJeCKHX MapKC - THIIH'lHbrn npe CTaBHTenh 3ana HbIX HHTeJIJIeKTyanoB napmii 06JIa u aml napnaMeHTcKHM HMMYHHTeToM nYAYllIee cOUHa­ He 3Haw KaK npeno awT CKaj eM B CeBepHoM Kopee KYpC 0 Tpex nH3Ma Ka3aJIOCb onpe eneHHblM OCHOBHblX HCTO'lHHKaX MapKCH3Ma HO AYMaw 'lTO AaJIhHeBOCTO'l­ Kpam'leCKHe napTHH 3aBOWWT 6onhlIIHHcTBo B 3aKoHo u aTeJIhHbIX HOMY cnywaTeJIW OJIj HO 6blTh oCKop6HTeJIhHO nocToHHHoe CKno­ opraHax eBponeHCKHx cTpall H nyTb K COUHaJIH3MY 6y eT OTKphIT B HeHHe O HHX H Tex j e 3ana HOeBpOneMcKHx HMeH COUHaJIHCm'leCKHe BHj eHHH Ha eHCh Ha n06eAY CBH3hIBaJIH Mblcnb 0 HeR HCKJIWl IfTenhHO C 3ana HOR EBponoH o6pallIeH K DpaHIl HH K AHrnHH - nHoHepy npoMhllIIJIeHHOM peBonwUHH K fepMaHHH­ 0 CBOHX nOCJIe HHx nHChMax BOj HM COUHaJI- eMoKpaTHH fepMa­ HHH 3HrenbC C y oBJIeTBOpeHHeM nHcan 0 pacu seTe pa60'lero BHj e­ HHH 06 ero ycnexax Ha BbI60pax - H HH cnoBa 0 peBOnWUH f CTpaHe peBoJIWUHH H 6ecnOKoRHoro AYxa KOJIbl6enH opraHH30BaHHoro pa60'lero BHj eHHH K neJIhfHH I1x B3rnH 6hm B CKOPOM BpeMeHH cOUHaJI- eMO­ POCCHH HHKTO Bcephe3 H He YMaJI K fOJIJIaH HH TeXHH'leCKH OT­ Ho Ha ene Bce 6hInO He TaK npOCTO H 31'0 He TaK rrpOCTO cranaH C KpenOCTHblM npaBOM C MHJIJIHOHaMH HerpaMOTHhlX MY­ Ha KOTOPhlM nOKOJIeHHe 3a rrOKOJIeHHeM JIOMaJIH rOJIOBhI j HKOB MaJIOqifcneHHoM HHTeJIJIHreHIl HeR H caMo epj ueM BO rnaBe CPOpMHpOBaJIO 3arra HoeBporreRCKYW TeopHW KOTopaH TpaHC­ B CTpaHaX POCCHH He YKna blBaJIaCh B npe CTaBneHHH TeopeTHKOB COUHaJIH3­ CBoero npOHCXOj eHHH CBo60 Ho 06CYj anaCh B neqaTH H napJIa­ Ma 0 B03MOj HOM aBaHrap 'e HOBoro 0611IeCTBeHHoro nopH Ka MeHTaX B H 'eOJIOrHIJeCKHR reR3ep 6PhI3j YllInH Yj e 60JIee wecm­ 120 121 AeCHrn JIeT H OKPOIlHBWHH EBPOilY H MHp He 3aIlaAHOeBpoIleH­ CKHe COll 1aJIHCThI omymaBwHe Bce HlQaHChI COIl ¥ 3JIHCTH' eCKOH H KOMMYHHCTHllecKoH AOKTPHHhI Cq OPMYJIHpOBaHHoH KCTarn Ha HX pOAHhIX H3hIKax a PyccKHe 60JIhweBHKH Ha npaKTHKe ocymecTBH­ JIH nycTh H pa3YMHoe HO Bce lKe naTeTH' eCKOe H HenpaKTH' HOe yqeHHe I1 ocymeCTBHJIH no co CMeJIOCThlQ H YBepeHHOCThlQ xa­ paKTepHoH AJIH AHJIeTaHTOB reM caMhIM yqeHHe HOCHBwee xapaK­ Tep JIaOOpaTopHOH mnOTe3hI CTaJIO CYAh60H orpoMHoro HapoAa 3ra HeOlKHAaHHaH IlonpaBKa K BOJIlOll HH KaK K II TeopHH Tpe60BaJIa oObHcHeHHH I1HTepHall HOHaJIa OTHecmfCb K PYCCKOH pe­ PaCCM XOTeJIa npOAeMOHCTpHpOBaTb KJIaCCOBhIH xapaKTep Bcex co­ BaJIHCh - raM Hall 10HaJIH3M KaK ObI 3aMeHHJI KJIaCCOBhll AeTepMH­ HH3M HCTOpHH llapHlK KOJIbI6eJIb peBOJIIQI HH HHTepeCOBaJICH JIHllIb IlpOJIHmeM Ha q pOHTe HeMeI KOH KpoBH a peBOJIlQll HOHHoe KpaCHoe HaA lleTporpaAOM B POCCHH lKe naTpHOTH3M ClaJI BeTOllIblQ TaM pOlKAaJIaCh MelKAYHapOAHaH COJIHAaPHOCTb Knac­ COB IlponerapCKHH HHTepHall 10Hamf3M Ha PYCCKOM q pOHTe opaTa­ JIHCh conAaTbI aocYPAHOH aHOMaJIHH APyme CIJHTaJIH PYCCKYIQ peBOJIIQlI 10 onyxOJIhlO Ha TeJIe oomecma KOTopaH BCKope pacco­ ceTCH Bce I HaJIhHbIX IlpomBopellHH Ha 3arraAe npOpOqeCTBa MapKca He CObl­ 3HaMH pa3BeBaJIOCh HaCeJIHlQmero wecTYIQ qaCTh TeppHTopHH 3eMHOrO wapa fuCTh TeopeTHKoB PaCCHHCKaH HMIlepHH pacnaJIaCb JIOnHYJIO cJIa60e 3BeHO HKOOhI YKJIaAhIBaJIOCb B TeOpeTHqeCKHe CxeMhI MapKCH3Ma 0YATO nalKe CTOPOHHHKH PYCCKOH peBOJIlQll HH omymaJIH Heooxo­ AHMOCTb OObHCHHTb 3TOT q eHoMeH WeHHIQ 3Toro Boupoca - J eHHH ObIJI IlOArOTOBJIeH K pe­ OH IlHcaJI 0 TeopHH HepaBHoMepHoro pa3­ BHTHH KaUHTaJIH3Ma KOTOpYIQ AOnOJIHHJI IlOJIOlKeHHeM 0 caMOM CJIa­ OOM 3BeHe OKOBbI KaUHTaJIH3Ma IlHcaJI OH PBYTCH B caMOM CJIa­ OOM 3BeHe a POCCHH H OhIJIa TaKHM 3BeHOM B ueIlH KarrHTaJIHCTH­ 3aIlaAHble IJHTaTeJIH J eHHHa CIJHTaJIH ero AOKTpHHepOM KOTOPbIH He MOlKeT OTopBaTbCH OT AaBHO OTopoweHHOH peBOJIlQll HOHHOH cymHOCTH MapKCH3Ma B EBpone Ho Te KTO 'lHran J eHHHa B POCCHH BepIDIH liTO J eHHH - COBpeMeHHbIH npopOK H lITO AeHCTBHTeJIh­ HOCTh AOKa3bIBaeT TO'lHOCTb ero IlpeACKa3aHHH I1 KOrAa BepHYB­ IIIHCh B POCCHIQ J eHHH 3aHBHJI 'ITO peBOJIIQI HH YBeHqaeTCH nooeAOH npOJIeTapHara BHMbIM no HeBepoHTHOe npopo'leCTBO Ka3aJIOCb ocymecT­ qeCKHX cTpaH B nOM HHKTO H He COMHeBaJICH 06bHCHeHHe J eHH­ Ha ObIJIO YAalJHbIM H BnOCJIeACTBHH OHO HeOAHOKpaTHO HCllOJIb30­ BaJIOCh llo KpaHHeH Mepe AO CHX IlOP HHoro OObHCHeHHH HeT llocJIe nepBOH MHPOBOH BOHHhI rnYOOKHH KpH3HC rrepelKHBaJIH H APyme rOCYAapCTBa fepMaHHH ohma B pa3BaJIHHaX H rrepcneKTH­ BhI ohmH AaJIeKO He P030BhIMH ABcTpo-BeHrepCKaH HMIlepHH BOOO­ me paCnaJIaCh llepeA PoCCHeH lKe pa3Bep3JIaCh 6e3AHa llaJIo caMO­ AeplKaBHe CBH3b1BaBwee BOeAHHO orpoMHYIQ MHOrOHall HOHaJIhHYIQ HMnepHIQ PacnaJIaCh apMHH OhIJIa pa3pyweHa 3KOHOMHKa B CTpa­ He He OKa3aJIOCh HH OAHoro aBTopHTeTHoro HHCTHTYTa KOTOPblH Mor OhI CBH3aTh Ae3HHTerpHpOBaHHhIC 3BCHhH OhIBweH HMIlepHH PYlliHJIHCh rrOJIHTHlleCKHe H COll 1aJIbHhIe I eHHOCTH npolliJloro B raKHe MOMeHThI AalKe caMhIe CKeIlTHqeCKHe YMbI IlOJ lI aIQTCH HJIJI103HHM liTO Obi HH npHlliJIO Ha CMeHY CTapOMY HOBoe oYAeT JIYlJIlle TOro liTO ObIJIO PbIH MHP qeM OCHOBaTeJIbHee oYAeT pa3pyweH CTa­ TeM JIerqe 0YAeT nOCTpoHTb HOBbIH rrycn npaBHT paOO­ lJHe H KpeCTbHHe flYCTh OHH YHHIITOlKaT IlpelKHHe npHBHJIerHH H 60­ raTCTBO POCCHH AOJIlKHa HCKynaTbcH B KpoBH cropen qTOObI KaK 1 eHHKc B03POAHTbCH CHOBa I1CTOPHH PoCCHH nepHOAa peBOJIIQI HH H rpalKAaHCKOH BOHHhI CO­ OTBeTCTBOBaJIa MapKCHCTCKHM cxeMaM H BOBce He yTBeplKAaIQ 60JIbweBHKH nOAIJHHHJIH HCTOPHlO MapKcHcTCKOH TeopHH - 'lTO WUI 3Toro OHH ohmH CJIHlliKOM HeMHOrOIJHCJIeHHbI npocTo caMa HCTO­ pHH Morna CJIYlKHTh HJIJIIQCTpaI HeH MapKCHCTCKoro Y'leHM MapKC B CBoeH TeopHH OnHpaJICH Ha OilbIT KJIaCCOBOH 6oPbOhI BO 1 paHI HH HO HCTOPM PaCCHH nOATBepAHJIa ero TeOpHIQ BOJIhWeBHKH pewH­ JIH ocymeCTBHTb npOJIeTapCKYlO peBOJIIQI H1Q B CTpaHe He 6hmo IlpOJIerapHara rAe nO'lm H nOOeAHJIH OHH npH3BaJIH COJIAaT cTpe­ JIHTb He B opaneB no Knaccy a B CBOHX KJIaCCOBbIX BparOB - COJIAaTbI OTKJIHKHYJIHCh Ha IlpH3hIB H Ha 3aIlaAe TaKHX arHraTOpOB paCCTpemmH ObI KaK H3MeHHHKOB BonbweBHKH nOlliJlH B HaCTY­ IlneHHe Ha 3HMHHH ABOpeI nOA aKKOMIlOHHMeHT JIHllIb OAHoro welJHoro ny_ 0pYAHH Ha CTOHmeM HenOAaJIeKY KpeHcepe H npaBluenh­ CTBO nano TaK KaK ero HHKTO He 3all Hll aJI llOACIJHThIBaH CKonhKO waHCOB Ha peBOJIIQI HIQ H 3aXBaT BJIa­ CTH ynYCTHJIH COI HaJIHCm'leCKHe nHAepbI 3anaAHblX CTpaH MhI He­ BOJIbHO IlOA03peBaeM qTO B AeHCTBHTeJIbHOCTH 3anaAHbie COI HaJI­ 122 123 tJ CMOKpaTbl Bo06lUC HC BCPIUU B MapKCIf3M lJU HIfX OH 6bIn JfH­ cTByeT 0 COOTIlOlliCHHIf CHJl qeM CTOKHoBeHHH peryJlHpHblX apMUH CTPYMCHTOM npOBCtJ CHIUI COl UiaJlbHblX pe j J0pM HO HC PCBOJllOUlfOH­ If If X reHepanOB B OJIpeneneHHoii CTeJICHH IfCTOpJ qeCKYIO JlCrHTHM­ HOro npe06pa30BaHIUI Mlfpa Ua If clfTyaUlfH HC Ka3anaCb HM C03PCB­ HOCTb 60JlbllleBHKaM npH J aeT j JaKT 'lTO HapOn POCCHIf 6bIn BOOpy llIeM I1 m PCBOJllOUlfIf nOCTOHHHO OTCYTCTBOBanlf KaKHC-TO npe UlO­ f eH Ha npOTH f eHHH HeCKOJlbKIfX JleT JIOcne OKTH6pbCKOii peBOJlIO­ CblJlKH HC06xOtJ HMblC AJIH CC n06ctJ bI 3a no H 06BlfHHn IfX llcHHH U1fH nOJlY'lHTb OpY f HC CTpeJlHTb - TO B tJ OKTPIfHCPCTBC TO B PCBH3HOHH3MC Ho H 6eHbllleBHKH HC JIPOTHBHOH CTopOHe 06bl'IHO nOCJle JIepeBopoTa HOBaH SJlaCTb AJIH oqeHb-TO BCpIDIH B MapKCIf3M IlpoCTO pa3BlfTlfe C06bITHH B POC­ npcnOTBpalUeHlm HeO f IftJ aHHOCTCH Cpa3Y f e CTapaCTCH YCTaHOBHTb Mor KTO XOTen - Ha Toii HJ11f B pocClfiicKYIO f e HIITCpnpeTaUlfIO MapKCIf3Ma KOHTPOJlb Ha ll IfMelOlQHMCH Y HaCCJleHHH 0pY f lfeM B PoCCIfH 3TO' OT noro n03HaHIUI PYCCKlfe peBonlOUlfOHcpbl nbHHCJlIf OHO npHtJ a­ rO CncnaTb HC Y IlaJlOCb M 60JlblllCBHKH JI06e llHJlH S rpa f J aHCKoii CHH YKnatJ bIBanOCb MapKCH3­ BOHHC nOTOMY 'ITO JIpHBneKJlIf Ha CBOIO CTOPOHY 60JlblllC JlIO Ilcii Ma KOTOPblC HX ACHCTBHTcnblfOCTH He COOTBCTCTBOBanlf 3a n0 CB­ 'ICM 6eJlaH apMIfH a TaK f C nOTOMY 'ITO He BOCCTaHOSMJIIf JIPOTIfB ce­ BaJlO HM CMcnOCTb MCHHTb TC TeOpeTHqeCKHe nocrynaTbl poncHcKlfc COUlfanlfCTbl 06BlfHHJIIf lleHHHa B pCBH31f0HIf3Me nepc­ 6H 60JlbllllfHCTBO HciiTpanbHoro HaccneHHH XOTH B TY JIOPY Y 6oJlb­ qlfTblBaH CCHqaC noncMIfKY Me f JlY HHMH HCB03MO f HO HC YtJ HSnHTb­ llICBHKOB He 6bIllO Hlf Clm HH HHCTlfTYTOB KOHTponH H CYtJ bOO IfX CH CKonbKO 3HeprHlf 3aTpaTHJ1H 06c CTOPOHbl AJIH tJ OKa3aTcnbCTsa 3aSHcena OT Toro KaKYIO JI03HUlfIO 3aHMeT HaCeJlCHHe CTpaHbl scpHocm c80eii HHTcpnpcTaUHH yqCHHH MapKca BYtJ To caMa nCH' CTBHTenbHOCTb MeHce Sa f Ha qCM j JaKT ee coorseTcTBHH KHIf lKHOH TCOpHH Tpy J Ho onpeneJIlfTb B KaKoH CTcnCHH 60nblllcBHKIf 6bmlf HatJ e­ neHbl BnaCTblO H B KaKoii CTcneli1f OHIf ce6c ec npHcBolflIIf B nepBble nocneoKTH6pbCKHC J HH BlIaCTb KaK 6bI CBaJlHnaCb lIa HHX C Heoo M PYCCKHe peBolllOUlfoHepbl HC n03BonHlllf ny snaCTb Y HHX OTHHTb 3TO 6blJlO cnenCTBlfeM sepbI 60nbllleBHKoB B CBOIf CHJ1bI lleHIfH HC tJ on f CH 6bm CqlfTaTbCH C 3ana J HoH npaKTlfKOH j JOpMHpoBaHHH npa­ BHTenbCTB OH He nbITaJiCH COCTaBIfTb KOaJlHUlfIO 6onblllHHCTsa OH HC CTpeMHJ1CH tJ cnlfTb HH C KeM HH PIfCK HIf OTBCTCTBeHHOCTb KOMMYHHCTlfqeCKIfH MaHH j JeCT onpaBtJ blBaJI tJ HKTaTYPY nponCTa­ pHaTa aTa - B03MO f HO 601lblllCBHKH BcpHnH qrO nlfKTaTypa nponeTapH­ nepBblii llIar K uaPCTSY cBo60nbI H OTMHpaHHIO rocynapCTBa XOTH Ha nenc B03HHK KyJlbT HOBoro rOCY J apCTBa n03TOMY OHH HC XOTenH tJ CllHTb BJlaCTb KpoMC nCBblX 3cepos COlO3 C KOTOPblMH 6blJl HenpOtJ on f HTCnCH 60JlbllleBHKH C npyrHMH napTIUIMH HC CO­ MCTOpHqeCKaH HCKnlOlfiITcnbflOCTb nHX C06bITHii llICCTlfneCHTIf­ nCTHeii J aBHOCTIf 3aKnlOqaCTCH HC B npHXOtJ e 6oJlbllleBHKOB K Bna­ qTO HM Y J anOCb ynep f aTb ce B rpa f J aHCKOii BoiiHe KOTOpaH HC 3HaJIa cc6c paBHbIX BbmH ncpHOtJ bl Korna Ka3anOCb qTO COBeTCKaH BnaCTb TepnHT Kpax- nOTcpHHa CH6IfPb OTpC3aHO nOBOn f be 6enbIe HacTynalOT Ha neTporpatJ lOr CTpaHbI s pYKax UCHHKHHa 3ana J Hble npaBHTeJlbCTSa nOMep f HBaIOT aHTH6onbllle­ BHCTCKHC CHJlbl Ho rpa f J aHCKaH BoiiHa 60Jlee HarmI J HO CBH J eTeJlb­ 124 XX BeKa Kor J a H IleOnOrlfH CTaJla Bce­ ro JlHllIb HpKHM JIJlaTbeM CKpbIBalOlUlfM JIparMaTJ qeCKHC IlCiiCTBHH BnaCTH J a f C HC XO'IeTCH BCPIfTb 'ITO JI06e lla peBOJIIOUlfH B POCCHH 6bIJIa S 3Ha'lHTCnbHoii CTeneHIf JI06e lloii COUHaJlHCTlfqeCKHX H KOM­ MYHHCTIf'ICCKHX H Ileii Bonee TO'IHblMH Ka f YTcH 06bHcHenIUI peBo­ lllOUlfIf KaK H3 PH J a BOH BbIXOnHlUero HBneHIfH o6ycnOBJleHHOrO COBnaAeHHeM BO BpeMenH 06beKTHBHblX H cy6beKTHBHblX HCTOPH­ 'IeCKHX j JaKTopoB pa3nO f enHe TpatJ HU HoHHbIX UCHHOCTCii CTapoH POCCHIf nOCJIeBOeHHaH cna60cTb H lIepelllHTenbHocTb eBpoJIeHCKHX Ilep f aB M Bce f e JIOnHOCTblO JIOHHTb JIo6e llY PYCCKOH peBOJllOUlfH HeJIb3H eCllH HC YlfiITbIBaTb 'ITO B 3TOM rllOOOllbHOM COBna lleHHH CblrpaJIlf Ba f HYIO ponb HAelf cOUlfanlf3Ma H KOMM 'HIf3Ma nOnHm'IeCKaH JlIHeparypa TOro spCMcnH - TcopcTJ qeCKIfC pa­ 60Tbl JlcHJfHa nnexaHOBa TpOUKoro ByxapHHa H npymx PYCCKHX peBOJIIOUlfOHCPOB JIpOJIaraHtJ HCTCKHe 6POlliIOPhl nepBbIX JIOcncpe­ TpY J HHqanH crn a B TOM CeHqaC B nocne J HHe rO llbl BonlOUlfOHHblX nCT JIOKa3bIBaIOT KaK JIOHIfMaJIH Tor J a H IleH coUHa­ nH3Ma H KOMM 'HH3Ma HeCMOTpH Ha HCKa f eHHe 3THX TpaKTOBOK B H IleonorJ qeCKOH JIOneMHKe nOCne llYlOlUHX HeT B3rnHAbI nepBblx PYCCKHX pCBonlOUlfOHepOB ClletJ ycT ClfiITaTb neHHHH3MOM KaK ero nOHHMaCT 60nblllJfHCTBO CJICUlfanHCToB B TOM lfiIcne H COBeTCKHX B npHHUlfnc 3TO TeopHH MapKca BbIBe lleHHaH H3 COCTOHHHH paB­ HOBeclUI ncpeHccemleM UCHTpa TH f CCTH Ha peBonlOUHOHHOC pellle­ HHC COUlfaJIbHbIX npo6nCM Ha PYKOBO llHlQYIO ponb napTHH Ha IlHK­ 125 raTYPY npoJIeTapHaTa H Ha pewalOLUee 3uaqeHHe OnbiTa PYCCKOH pe­ neHmtH3M B nOBCe lI HeBHOH npaKTHKe peBOJIIOUHH n03Bomm or­ poMHOMY l IHCJIY npe lI CT3 BHTeJIeH peBOJIIOI HOHHOH BJIaCTH capaM H lI eJIeraTaM - C p°PMYJIHpOBaHHaH MapKCOM H lI eH u apcIBa CB060 lI hI BpH lI JIH MOrJIa npHBeCIH B lJ BH KeHHe PYCCKml Hapo lI a nOHHMaHHe KOM­ BOOIOUHH lUI lI pyrHX CTpaH KOMHC­ MYHH3Ma KaK CHIOMHHYTHOrO YCTaHOBJIeHHH cnpaBe lJ JIHBoro nOpH lI ­ Ka - CMOrJIO npHHHMaTb B CJIO KfleHWHX YCJIOBIDIX Toro HneH rocynapcTBa pa60l lHx H KpeCTbHH nOHHTHa H lIpHBJIeKaTeJIb­ BpeMeHH caMocTOHTeJIbHhIe peweHIDI nO lI l IHHHHCb npH 3TOM OCHOB­ Ha TaK KaK pa3pywaeT BeKOBble Tpa lJ Hn HH H C03naeT IDIJII03UIO lJ JIH HOMY HMnepaTHBY peBOJIIOl HH 3TO yqeHHe 06be lI mtHJlO peBOJIIOl H­ Macc OHHYIO aKTHBHOCTb Ha WHPOKHX npocTOpax PoCCHH TaK KaK ero He eCT 3TOT JI03YHr 1I0HHTeH 310 He rOJIOBOJIOMKa Bpo lI e TeopHH TaK Ke KaK H YTonHqeCKHH JI03YHr KTO He paOOTaeT TOT CTOPOHHHKH He TOJIbKO 3HaJIH a36YKY KOMMYHH3Ma HO H PYKOBO lI ­ lIPUOOBOllHOH CTOHMOCIH PyCCKaH peBOJIIOn HH He CKYlIIDIaCb Ha CIBOBaJlHCb elO B CBoeH npaKTHKe n03IOMY HeCMOTpH Ha Bce aBaH­ YTOnHt eCKHe JI03yurH - TlOpHble OTKJIOHeHHH H OWH6KH HeBHnaHHoro no pa3Maxy peBOJIIO­ 30Boe o6naKo 0 KOTOPOM nHweT P03a nIOKceM6ypr HallaJIH na­ I HOHHOro npou ecca PYKOBO lJ HTemIM peBOJIIOl HH ynanOCb Y lI ep­ pHTb Ha lI IIepe I HBaBWeH H lJ eH COl HanH3Ma H KOMMYHH3Ma KaK po_ TH KeJIeHWHe HClIbITaHHH CTpaHoH TaKoDa Karb ero B onpe lI eJIeHHbIX yqeHHeM paMKax HMeHHO BCne lI CTBHe ne­ Y K CY lI bOO peBOJIIOl HOHHbIX ylJeHml HHHCKoro nOHHMaHIDI peBOnlOl HOHHOH TeopHH PYCCKOH peBomOn HH qTO COU HaJIH3M H KOMMYHH3M 310 HaYlIHaH TeopHH KOTDPa a OIIHpa­ ynaJIOCb H36e l 3Tb cY lI b6b1 MHOrHX lI PYrHX peBOJIIOl HH - ee He pa3­ CKOJIbKO 6h1 HH YTBep KnaJIH eTCH Ha 06beKIHBHble 3aKOHbI pa3BHTHH 06meCTBa B npou ecce pe­ BOJIIOl HH COI HaJIHCTHqeCKHe H KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKHe H lI eH - JIO I HJIH HH BHYlpeHHHe cnopbI HH ppaKl HOHHaH OOPbOO HaMHoro CJIO Kflee pacn03Halb B KaKOM BH lI e H lJ eH COl HaJIH3Ma H KOMMYHH3Ma 6bIJIH YCBoeHbI Hapo lI OM BpH lI JIH OHH 3a pHKCHPO­ JIHWb yronIDI Bcero H TOJIbKO YTOlIHH pa3YKpaweHHaH OpHaMeHTOM Be­ KOBbIX qaHHml HapOna H3JIYlIaeT Te MarH'IeCKHe BOJIHbl KOTopble BaJIHCb B ero C03HaHHH KaK JIeHHHH3M 0 KOTOPOM lJ HCKYTHpoBaJIH cnoc06HbI npHBeCIH B lJ BH KeHHe MHJlJIHOHbI TOJIbKO YTonHH MO­ 60JIbweBHCTcKHe BO K lJ H H TeopeTHKH BPH lI JIH npeHMYLUeCTBeHHO KeT 3aCTaBHTb ConnaTa peBOnlOIJ HH He HMelOLUero HH Maneu wero KpeCTbHHCKOe H HerpaMOTHoe HaceJIeHHe POCCHH Momo YCBOHTb lIpe lI CTaBJIeHIDI 0 TeopHH COI HanH3Ma H KOMMYHH3Ma BOCKnHK­ YTOHqeHHYIO TeoPHIO COl HaJIH3Ma KOTOPOH npH lI ep I HBaJIHCb COl Ha­ HYTb nepe lI Ka3HblO JIHCmqeCKHe napTHH 3ana lI HbIX CTpaH Cpe lJ H PYCCKOH MaCChI 3TH KOMMYUH3M H lJ eH pacnpOCTpaHHl1HCb B KpaHHe ynpoLUeHHOH POpMe 3 lI paBcTByeT CO l HaJlH3M na 3 lI paBcIByeT KaK BhITe­ KaeT H3 JIHTepaTypbI Ioro BpeMeHH MapKC3HreJIbC 6bID KaKHM-TO lJ BymaBbIM CYLUeCTBOM a H3 Jla PypMaHOBCKoro l anaeBa Mbl Y3­ KaK paCTepHJICH CJIaBHbIH BOeHallaJIbHHK Korna eMY C0061UH­ PyCCKHe peBonlOl HOHepbI Ha npOTH KeUHH MHOrHX JIeT lIPOCTO JIH 0 cYLUecTBoBaHHH lJ Byx HHlepHal HOHaJIOB Korna Ke caMOH H lI eH He nyMaJIH 0 TOM qTO COl HaJIH3M H KOMMYHH3M lI OJI KeH BOClIPHHH­ HaeM CTaJIO He lI OCTaTOllHO ee nepCOHH pHl HpOBaJIH B PYKOBO lI HLUeH pOJIH MaTbCH KaK H lI eaJIbHbIH 06LUeCTBeHHbIH nOpH lI OK HaCYLUHble npo­ neHHHa H lI PYrHX H3BeCTHbIX lI eHTeJIeH peBOJIIOl HH 6neMbI peBOnlOl HH 3aHHMaJIH HX nonHOCTblO TaK qro Ha pa3Mblllll1e­ H lI eH COI HaJIH3Ma H KOMMYHH3Ma OCYLUeCTBJIHJIa CBOIO HCTOPU­ HHH 0 COl HaJIH3Me He OCTaBanOCb BpeMeHH EOPbOO 3a BnaCTb OTO­ qeCKYIO MHCCHIO He KaK HaYlIHaH TeopIDI XOTH MapKCY OqeHb XOTe­ lI BHrana TeOpeTH'IeCKHe pacCY I lJ eHIDI Ha oonee n03 lJ Hee BpeMH no­ JIOCb BepUTb B ee HaYlIHOCTb a KaK yronHH KaK BH lI eHHe HOB oro CJIe OKOHlIaTenbHOu no6e lJ bl TaK 3TD 6bIDO lI 0 Ha'lana nOneMHKH 0 nOpH lJ Ka B Koropoe Ka K lJ bIH BKna lJ bIBaJI CBOH co6cIBeHHbIe Ha lI e K­ B03MO KHOCTH IIoCTpoeHIDI COl HaJIH3Ma B 0 lJ H0u CTpaHe lJ bI TeopHH KOMMYHH3Ma KaK H TeopHH 0 6eCKOHellHOCTH BCeJIeH­ B HaCTOHLUee BpeMH TeOpeTHqeCKml apceHan KOTOPbIH IIOCTaB­ HOH BbIXO lJ HT 3a paMKH C pePhl KOTOpylO MO KflO ce6e npe lI CTaBHlb nHn ooeilpHnaCbI lJ JIH 6ecnpeu e lI eHTHOrO aKa lI eMHt eCKOrO cnopa HamH lJ HO HO B TO Ke BpeMH H lI eH 31a nOMep KHBaeT CIHXHHHoe MeHee HHTepeceH qeM CMbIcn 310ro cnopa PeBOnlOn HH II06e lJ IDIa CTpeMJIeHHe K paBeHCTBY KynaelcH B TeMHbIX BOnax COU HaJIbHOH 33­ 1I0 lI 3HaMeHaMH YTonHH HO lITO lI enaTb C YTonHeH nocne II06e lJ bl BHCTH H 06eLUaeT CHIOMHHYTHOe Hhle 'lliCTH 06LUee HeCqaCTbe - nepepacnpe lI eJIeHHe 6nar Ha paB­ Be lJ b O KH lI aIOT lITO OHa BonnOTHTCH B l H3Hb nOJI6e lI bI 127 126 Ii TYT 06HapY fJlOCb IJ TO rr06ellHBlIIHe PYCCKHe peBOmOll HOHe­ peBOllIOUHH ee HMrrYJIhCOM H crana HAeollorHeH KOHKpeTHoH MOAe­ pbI TO f e He OlJ eHb-TO BepHJIH Y'leHHIO 0 COUHaJIH3Me H KOMMYHH3Me lIH 061lIeCTBeHHoro YCTpoHcTBa arrOlloreTOM nOllHTHlJ eCKOH H COll H­ OHH BCrrOMHHJJH BAPyr 'ITO MapKC HCXOIlHJI H3 OrrbITa 3anaAHOH EB­ allbHoH rrpaKTHKH a npaKTHKa KaK rOBopHT pHH ponbI H MHOrHe 06JIaAaIOIlIHe TeOpeTH'leCKHMH 3HaHlUIMH 6oJIbllIe­ BHKH CKJIOIDUIHCb K MHeHHIO 'ITO HeB03MO f HO rrOCTpoHTb COUHa­ JIH3M B OAHOH CTpaHe K TOMY f e TaKOH OTCTaJJOH KaK POCClUI 3TH 601lbIlIeBHKH BO maBe C TpOII KHM nponOBeAOBallH TeopHIO nepMa­ HeHTHOH peBOJIIOUHH H YTBep f AalIH 'ITO TOllbKO BOllIOUHH B pa3BHTbIX CTpaHax 3anaAa POCClUI 3eJIeHee cePOH Teo­ noclIe n06eAbI pe­ BHa'laJJe PYCCKaH HAeOllonm 3allIHIIIalla B OCHOBHOM He 'laCTHhre COBMeCTHO C HHMH MepbI rrpaKTH'leCKOH rrOllHTHKH COBeTCKoro npaBHTeJIhCTBa a 3aKOH­ HOCTb peBOllIOUHH Bo061lIe lIeHHH rrpeAOCTeperaJI APyrHe CTpaHbl OT CMO f eT npHCTynHTb K CTpOHTeJIbCTBY HOB oro 06IlIeCTBa II03HlI HH 3THX KOMMYHHCTOB 60JIbllIe COOTBeTCTBOBaJJa Y'leHHIO CJJerroro KonHpoBaHlUI POCCHHCKoro OnbITa rrpHHUHITbl - MapKca 'leM n03HlI HH HX npOTHBHHKOB KaK CTpoHTb COll HaJJH3M B POCCHH MapKC He yq HJI He 3aHHMaJI­ OH 3aIll HllIall lIHilih BlIaCTb rrapTHH IlHKTayYPY npOJIeTapHaTa COI03 pa60­ lJ ero KlIacca C KpeCThHHCTBOM H T A lIenfTHMHOCTh peBOJIIOlI HH lIe­ CH 3THM BonpocoM H lIeHHH lIeHHHcKoe onpeAelleHHe KOMMYHH3­ HHH 3allIHIlIaJI TBepAO C HaCTDH'IHBOCThIO J aHaTHKa Ma - HpKO rrpoHBlIHeTCH B KHHre fOCYAaPCTBO H peBOllIOlI HH rAe lIe­ coBeTCKaH BJIaCTb fIJIIOC meKTpI-lIpHKaUHH cTpaHbI npoCTo 3TO oco6eHHO 3aKOHHoe 1lH­ HaHBHaH YTonlUl a KpoMe noro B CO'lHHeHHHX lIeHHHa TO f e HeT HH­ HHH nhITaeTCH AOKa3aTh 'ITO PYCCKaH peBOllIOUHH 'lero 'lTD MO f HO 6bmo 6bI Ha3BaTb MOAellbIO COBeTCKoro COUHaJIH3­ TH MapKCH3Ma H eBporreHCKoro pa60'lero ABH f eHHH XOTH PYCCKaH Ma HanpoTHB BBeAeHHe H3IIa CBHAeTellbcTByeT 0 TOM 'ITO H lIe­ peBOJIIOUHH MHe AYMaeTCH MO f eT npeKpaCHO 060HTHCh 6e3 TaKOH HHH He BepHlI B npeo6pa30BaHHe PoCCHH COOTBeTCTBeHHO TeopeTH­ POAOClIOBHOH TaK KaK Ha ee CTOpOHe IlIerOCH J aKTa lJ eCKHM nOCTYlIaTaM Bec HCTOpH'leCKH CBepllIHB­ TBOPUOM COBeTCKOH MOAellH CTaJI CTaJIHH nOABeprl1 lHiicH MeHb­ Ho TaKOB Y f xapaKTep HAeOJIOnm Bce XpHCTHaHCKHe pe J op­ IlIe APYrux PYKOBOIlHTeJIeH BJIlUIHHIO TeopHH COUHallH3Ma IIpe3pe­ MHCTCKHe ABH f eHlUI YTBep' AaJIH 'ITO TOJIhKO OHH BepHO TOJIKYIOT HHe TpolI Koro K CTallHHY-TeOpeTHKY 6bmo OnpaBAaHHbIM IIHcaHHe a KaK H ero 3aMe'laHlUI 0 HeB03MO f HOCTH J UI CTaJIHHa npo'leCTb 'lTO-JIM60 rpa' AaHCKHe peBOJIIOUHH CChmaJIHCb Ha TpallHlI HH ApeB­ Hero MHpa H paUHOHanH3Ma OKTH6pbCKaH ' e peBOJIIOlI HH CTpeMH­ Ha HHOCTpaHHblX H3hIKax Ho CTaJIHH lIY'lIlIe 'leM TpoII KHH C03Ha­ JIaCh craTh 3aKOHHhIM npeeMHHKOM KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKOH TpallHII l fH BaJJ ' TO BbI f HAaHHe nory6HT PYCCKYIO peBOllIOUHlO 'lTD eCJJH yrac­ EBporrbl BYATO 6peMH HCTOpH'IeCKOH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 6hmo He HeT peBOJIIOlI HOHHaH aKTHBHOCTb peBOlllOUHH COHAeT Ha HeT CTa­ JIMH BHIlHMO OTIJ eTlIHBO npeACTaBlIHlI ce6e pa30'lapOBaHHe nOKOlle­ nOA CHlIY 601lhIlIeBHKaM H 'ITD6hI 0611er'lHTh ero OHH nepeKJIa 1 bI­ BallH ero Ha TeHH npeAKOB KOMY H3BeCTHO H3 KaKHX my6HH HC­ HlUI npolIHBaBiliero KpoBh 3a peBOllIOUHIO eClIH 6b1 POCCHH Aa f e He TOpHH BhlpaCTaeT HHyYHTHBHoe CTpeMlIeHHe HaHTH B npoIlIJlOM J YH­ nOnbITallaCh peallH30BaTh YTonHIO AaMeHT COBpeMeHHOCTH JIeHHHH3Ma IIepe'lHThIBaH CeH'laC BonpOChI KHHrY rAe CTallHH BrrepBhle nonhITaJJCH BhlCTynHTb BOJIhIlIeBHKH 6hmH pacTepHHhl OHH OKa3aJIHCh Ha HenpOTopeH­ MhI BHAHM 'ITO maBHoe 3JIO CTaJIHH HOM rryTH IIo3TOMY OHH H CTapaJJHCh YBHlaTb CBOIO peBOJIIOUHIO C IIo6eAoH CTaJIHHa B nOlleMHKe 0 COll HallH3Me B OAHOH CTpaHe aHOMaJIHlO a KaK pe3YJIhTaT eBponeHCKHX TpallHuHH paCC'lHTbIBaH KaK TeOpeTHK MapKCH3Ma npoIlIJIhlM rrpeAcraBHTh ee pa60'leMY ABH f eHHIO EBponbl He KaK BHAell B naCCHBHOCTH OI OH'lRJIaCb HCTOPlUl peBollIOUHH H Ha'lallaCh HCTOpHH COUHanH3Ma npH nOM Ha rrOAAep f KY eBponeHCKoro pa60'lero ABH' eHHH lIeHHH H cOUHallHCTH'leCKOH HAeOllorHH 3ra HCTOPHH H3MeHHlIa JIHUO MHpa pa30IlIellCH C OPTO 1 OKcaJIhHbIMH COUHaJI- 1 eMOKparaMH H BBell f eCT­ pa3AeJIHJIa ero HaABOe H no ceH AeHh CTHMYlIHpyeT HanpH f eHHOCTb KHe YCJIOBlUI npHeMa Me f AY KOHTHHeHTaMH H HenpeKpallIaIOIlIHecH COll HallhHble nOTpHce­ eBporreHcKoro pa60'lero ABH' eHlUI nOAAep f aJJa III HHTepHaUHOHaJI 3Ha'IHTeJIbHaH er 'laCTb TaK KaK Ha HlUI IIoCJJe pa3pa6oTKH nepBoro rrHTHlIeTHero nllaHa H Ha'lalla KOll­ cTopoHe neKTHBH3aUHH MapKCHcTcKaH AOKTpHHa nepecTalla 6hITh TeopHeH npoJIeTapHara BJIaCTh 6hlJIa B PYKax napTHH H Ka3aJJOCb 'ITO C03Aa­ 128 lIeHHHa B 6hlJIa OCH3aeMaH 1 eHCTBHTeJIhHOCTh 1 HKTaTypbI 129 Hbl ycnOBHH WUI peanH3au HH J lBHHI1IHeH Me'ITbI Be l 'lUeH CHnOH CO­ u HanbHblX IIpeo6pa30BaHHH CTIlna PoCCHf£ CTpaCTHOH nlO6BH H npe J lHHOCTH H no CTaBHnO HHTenneKTyanoB EBpoilbI B HeJIerKOe nOnO l eHHe PyCCKaH H 'eonorHH o J ep ffiJ a IIepBYIO n06e J y lJaCTb eBponeH­ PyCCKaH H eOJIOrHH Tpe60Bana qT06bI Bce nanhI pa3BHTHH Co­ CKoro pa60'lero BIDKeHHH IIpH3Hana ee nerHTHMHblM 3aBepllleHHeM BeTCKOH PoCCHH BocnpHHHManHCh C TIlKHM l e BOCToprOM KaK H pe­ Tpa J Hu HH a 'laCTb - BonlOu HH HeOilpoBep l HMblM cpaKTOM Cne 'CTBHeM nOH BOKPyr CBHlUeHHoro HHM6a peBOJIIOu HH 3aCHIDlH HOBbIe no6e J b1 6bInO Bce06lUee IIpH3HaHHe HOBOH PoCCHH He TOnbKO ne­ ny'lH Bble HO IIO'lTH Bce BH J Hble HHTenneKTYaIIbl EBpOIIbl 3alUHlUaIIH pe­ nHTHneTKH BH3aHTH3M BMeCTO aBaHrap J HOro HCKyccma - BonlOu H1O H IIpaBo PyccKoro HapoAa pemaTb CBOH ena caMOCTOH­ nHCTHqeCKHH BMeCTO JIeHHHa - peanH3M CTIlJIHH a C HHM nnaH HH l 'CTpanH3all HH COu Ha­ 3aTeM MOCKoBCKHe cy e6HbIe IIpon eCCbI TenhHO IIO-CBoeMY He3aBHCHMO OT 3ana J HoH EBpoilbI Be J h KpoMe BOHHa C I HHnHH J HeH 3aXBaT npH6anTHHCKHX rOCY J lpCTB orOBOp nHTepaTypbl C'lHTIlnH OHH C fepMaHHeH H pa3 eJI ilonbIIIH BORHa C rHTJIepOBCKOR fepMaHHeii CTapaH PoCCHH HH'lerO He n ana Ho eno 6bWO He TonhKO B pau HOHanbHOM IIpH3HaHHH HCTOpH'leCKOrO cpaK­ nocneBoeHHaH 3KCnaHCHH C03 J lHHe BOCTO'lHOro 6JIOKa COBeTCKaH Ta PeBonlOu HH 3aTpoHyna Te ccpepbI C03HaHHH KOTophle B 60nbmeH aTOMHaH 6oM6a no aBneHHe BeHrepCKoii peBOJIIOUHH oKKynaUHH CTeneHH 'leM HaM XO'leTCH IIpH3HaTb BnHHIOT Ha IIOBe eHHe 'lenOBe­ qexocnoBaKHH H COBeTCKO-KHTaHCKHH KOHCPJIHKT 3TO 6bInO CJIHIII­ Ka PeaKu HH 6b1na 3MOUHOHanbHoii - KOM MHoro H peBonlOlI HH H3nyqana Bonllle6­ Hoe CH'IHHe H ee BOCTOp l eHHO npHBeTCTBOBanH KaK paCCBeT HOBoro J HH Ee Harpa l J lnH JIIHTeTIlMH OHa nepeCTIlna 6bITb npe J MeTOM cnOKOHHoro aHanH3a ilpOTHBHHKH npoKnHHanH peBonlOlI HlO KaK J eno PYK aHTHXpHCTa H pa3pylliHTenbHbIX CHn CTOPOHHHKH peBO­ WUI Tpex IIOKoneHHH COBeTCKHH COlO3 npeIIO J HOCHnCH KaK e J HHCTBeHHaH B03MO l ­ HOCTb peanH3aUHH BeKOBhIX 'laHHHH KaK BonnOlUeHHe COUHaJIHCTH­ qCKHX H 'eH KaK oa3HC nporpecca B 3arHHBalOlUeM MHpe npa06pa3 6Y l 'lUero J pyrHx CTpaH PO J HHa Bcero HOBoro H l H3HeCnoc06HO­ nlOu HH HCCTYIIneHHO KpH'lanH 06 HCKynnemlli 0 Haqane HOBOii HCTO­ ro - pHH 'lenOBeqeCTBa OHH J eKnaMHpoBanH BnoKa H MaHKoBCKoro YKe KYJIhTYpe HCKYCCTBe H T 3TIl nO l b H eOJIOrHH BbI I HBana TaK KaK OHa nOCTOHHHO CCbInanaCh Ha moxa 6hIna HeIIo J xO J HlUeii JIH Tpe3BoH On eHKH CPaKTOB B MarepHanbHOM npoH3BO 'CTBe opraHH3au HH 06lUeCTBa B Ha­ HeCMOTpH Ha Bce nepem6hI H TOIlhKo 'lTO OKOHlJHIIaCb CTpaI1IHaH BOHHa elUe pa3 J OKa3aBlllaH 06'heKTHBHhle 3aKOHbI pa3BHTHH 06lUeCTBa • llonYCKaIIOCh npaB­ HHTenneKTyanaM a 'lTO HeKOTopble qepTbI COBeTCKOR eHCTBHTeJIhHOCTH He COOT­ 6ecnoMolUHoCTb pa3YMa nepe ' nHn OM Horo CTpeMneHHH y6HBaTh l HBOT­ Ha 3TOM Mpa'lHOM cpoHe PyccKaH pe­ BeTCTBYIOT pacnpoCTpaHeHHbIM IIpe CTIlBneHHHM 0 nY'lllieH anhTep­ BonlOu HH BcenHna Ha J e l J y OHa 6hIna e J HHCmeHHhIM HMnynbCOM K HaTHBe HO npH nOM BCe-TIlKH npH3HaBanOCh 'lTO 06'heKTHBHO CO­ HCTOpHqeCKOMY M OnTHMH3MY eBponeHCKHe HHTenneKTyanbI KOTopble H3ronO J lnHCh no Ha J e l J e H l a l anH H36aBHTbCH OT BeTCKoe 06lUeCTBO pa3BHBaeTCH B HY l HOM HanpaBJIeHHH e­ KaK H BO BpeMeHa peBOJIlOlI HH H lJ eonomH TpaHccpopMHpOBana CTPYKTHBHOrO CKenTHu H3Ma OKYTanH PYCCKYIO peBonlOlI HlO CBoeH pau HOHanhHhIH aHaJIH3 B cpaHaTHqeCKYIO Bepy JII060Bb HeHaBHCTh H nlO60BhlO 3TO He 6hInO paCCY J O'lHbIM OTHOIIIeHHeM K 06lUeCTBeH­ Ha e l J y 3TIl l e H J eonorHH Tpe60Bana OT eBponeHCKHX HHTenneK­ HOMY IIpon eccy H TonbKO HMeHHO H eonorHH nepeHecna 'lenOBe­ TyanoB KOTOPbIe npHHIDlH peBonlOu HlO npHHHTh Bce 'ITO 6bInO C 'leCKOe OTHOIIIeHHe K peBonlOlI HH B ccpepy 3MOll HH H Bblpa l anOCb HeH CBH3aHO H 'ITO IIocne OBano 3a HeH Be J h eCJIH PYCCKaH peBOJIIO­ OHO cnOBaMH nlO60Bh HeHaBHCTb IIpe J lHHOCTb H3MeHa npOlUeHHe H To I I HH - 3aKOHHoe eTHlUe eBponeHCKOH I I HH TO COBeTCKaH J eHCTBHTenbHOCTb COu HanHCTHqeCKOH Tpa J H­ nerHTHMHoe npo J on l eHHe ee 3TIl H eonOrHqeCKaH aprYMeHTIlUHH YBeHlJaJIaCb ycneXOM fnH J H B IIpOIIIJIOe MO I HO CKa3a Th 'lTO neBhIe HHTenneKTyanhI 06POBOJIb­ PH J eBponeiicKHX HHTenneKTyanoB CBH3aIIH C lTOH Ha e l OH CBOIO l H3Hb ilO'lTH Ba nOKoneHHH nO J 'lHHIDlHCh YilpolUeHHoii cxeMe B coomeTCTBHH C KOTOPOH IIOnO l HTenhHoe OTHOIIIeHHe K HO IIPHHOCHnH l epTBY PYCCKOH H eonorHH H 06POBOIlhHO no 'lH­ HHnHCh ee HMnepaTHBY BhIna B3HTIl Ha BoopY I eHHe JIO l h 0 HeYCTOH'lHBOCTH HHTenneK­ Ho PYC­ TYaJIOB IIpH J yMaHHaH JIeHHHbIM 'IT06hI HeHTpanH30BaTb B03MYlUe­ CKaH peBOJIIOUHH He OBonbCTBOBanaCh CHMilaTHeH OHa Tpe60BaIIa HHe PYCCKHX HHrennHreHToB l eCTOKOCTHMH 6oJIbIIIeBHCTCKOH Bna­ PYCCKOH peBonlOu HH crano 3TanOHOM IIporpeCCHBHOCTH 130 131 cnf fIonb3YHcb nOM nO l blO PyccKaH H COJIOrHH YlufllTO l ana 06H­ 3aTcnbHbiC aTPHOYTbl pa3YMa H 3py I liUHH - CKcrrCHC c ep l aHHOCTb Hcnpe B3HToCTb TcprrHMocTb crroc06HoCTb K aHaJIH3Y H L B COOT­ AH 'pe Kn COBeplllJUl CBHTOTaTCTBO H3MCHHJl CBoeMY npolllJIOMY H K TOMY cmc OCKop6wI COBCTCKHH Hapo KOTOPblH TaK pa YllIHO H rOCTcnpHHMHO npHHH 1 3ana Horo rrHCaTCnH BCTCTBHH C PyccKoii H 'conomcii rrpe aHHocTb H rrocnyllIHocTb CTanH ncno Knm 6bIJIO nHlIlb nponorOM K TparC 'HH HCnblTaHHH pa3Y­ IlCHHTbCH BbllllC pa3yMa B rrpHMep HHTcnncKTyanaM CTaBJUlCH Ha­ Ma KaK C06CTBCHHO H CbC3 COBCTCKHX rrHC ITCJIeH Kor a Eyxa­ pO ero 3HTY3Ha3M H KnaCCOBoe C03HaHHe Ha y HBneHHc BceM H eonOrHH Ym noCb 06e30pY l HTb pa3YM OHa HaBH3aJla HlITeJlneK­ pHH H rOpbKHM paCTOllTaJIH Ha C I 'bl nHTCpaTypHoro aBaHrapm EB­ ponbi TyanaM qyBCTBO HerronHoueHHOCTH H MHorHC H3 HHX C03HaTeJlbHO CTpeMHJIHCb pa3 enHTb cpaJlblilMBblii BOCTopr Hapo a T H I CJIblH lIlOK nepC I WIH 3arra Hble HHTCJIneKTyaJIbI-rrorrYTlIHKH PYCCKOH pCBOJllOUHH BO BpCMH MOCKOBCKHX CY C6HbIX npOll eCCOB Torm PYCCKaH H conorHH nOTpc60Bana OT IIHX l epTBbl - caMOH 60JlblllOH rronpaHHH pa3YMa rro aBnCHHH COMHeHHH OTKa3a OT '1e­ nOBe'IHOCTH TICPC'IHTbIBaH nHTcpaTYPY Toro BpCMeHH HCJIb3H HC qeM m JlblllC B rrpollIJIoe YXO WIa peBonlOUHH TeM Tpy HCe CTa­ HOBHnOCb pa3YMY B HeKOTopble rrcpHO bl COBeTCKOM HCTOPHH pa­ 3yM eBporrCHCKHX HHTenneKTyanoB Bo06me OKa3blBanCH Ha fIpo­ KPYCTOBOM nO l e • H HMelO B BH Y He rono 1920-x rO OB He HH­ meTY KOTOpylO npHHecna Hapo y peBonlOUHH He COUHanblible rrpo­ oneMbl HOBoro OOmCCTBCHHoro rropH Ka BPO 'C KapTOliHOH CHCTC­ Mbl pOCTa lIHcnCHHOCTH 6ccnpH30pHbiX CTCM 61OpOKpaTHH H Lrr Bcc 3TO eCTCCTBCHHbIC TPY HOCTH H HC OliH 3aCTaBnHnH BonHOBaTb­ rrpHHTH B Y I ac MOCKOBCKHX npoll CCCOB a l c HC rrbITanHCb 6bITb y6e 'HTcnbHblMH HO nCBblC BbI rrpH3HaTb 'ITO 3TH Cy bI - KOTopaH nHpoBaTb K COBeTCKoii rop OCTH KOTopaH Y l C Torm rrcpClIJIeTa­ nacb C rop OCTblO BcnHKopOCCOB Ha rreperofHM rrJlaH CTaJIH BbmBH­ raTb ycncxH a 0 CJIO l HOCTHX Bo06me ncpcCTanH rOBopHTb PyCCKaH HLl eOnOrHH Bce ooncc 60ne3HcHHO pearHpOBaJla Ha KPHTHKY COBCT­ CKOH 'eMCTBHTcnbHOCTH fIOMHIO KaKOC BnetlaTnCHHe Ha MCHH rrpo­ H3BC IH KHHrH AH 'pe KH a • H rrpO'lHTan HX B 1950-c rO bl Kor a OHH Y I C OblJlH 3arrpcmCHbl Ho 0 JTOrO H rrpO'lHTan OT3bIBbi Ha HHX - oyplO ynpcKoB pyraTcnbCTB 06BHHCHHH B H3MeHe B a 'pec AH pc I lf a Y rrponOBC 'OBana CTpOHTcnbCTBO CrrpaBC JlHBoro 06mCCT­ BCKOBOH MClITbI '1eJlOBC'ICCTBa BC b COBCTCKYIO POCCHIO OCY l m JlH HX BparH - 6yP l fH TPOll ­ KHCTbI cpalllHCThI fIo HOliaM HX My'-lHJlH KOlllMapbl HC J aBaJla crraTb '1y OBHmHaH CPOPMYJIHpoBKa ABrycTa Ec6CJlH EcnH Te6H XBanHT Bpar 3Ha'lHT Tbl B '1CM-TO OlllH6cH 11 HeM HM rrpHXO HJIOCb CKpbIBaH COMHeHHH BO HMH m BHCH MClITbI 3amHmaTh paCCTpCJlbl B XOJlO HOH MOCKBe B H COJlO HlieCKHX cy oporax 6HJIHCb BCC KTO rrpHCHran rrporpcccy peBonlOUHH H COUHanH3MY PaCCTpeJlbl Hcnb­ 3H 6blJlO 06bHCHHTb pa3YMOM H '1T06bI HC OTKa3bIBaTbCH OT Ha e l ­ bl nCBbIe HHTcnncKTyanbI oTpcKnHCb OT pa3YMa YIIIJIH B TCMHYIO rremcpy HppaUHOHaJlbHOCTH OTKYJ a HCTOPHH BH HTCH KaK Il Crrb 3a­ rOBopOB H3MCH H rrOLl B0XOB MeHH cnO l HJIOCb BrrC'IaTnCHHe 'ITO Oll BblCTynHJI C rrpHH­ UHnHanbHOH rrOnHTH'ICCKOM KPHTHKOM COBCTCKOH CHCTeMbl K MO­ CMY rnYOO'laHlllCMY y I liBneHHIO H Halllcn y Hcro nHlIlb HCCKonbKO ynpcKoB no nOBO y MOHorronbHoro xapaKTepa COBCTCKOH rrpona­ y ep l aTh BH3Ma B BocnHTaHHH CTCH H T HHCTCH rro6e OH COBCPlllCHHO 6narOLl YlIlHaH KPH­ THKa Ho anOJIOreTbI PYCCKOH H eonorHH pcampOBanH TaK OY 'TO To liTO H B TOM H3BpameHHOM BH C pYCCKaH H conorHH CMOrJla raH b COKpbITHH HconarOBH HbiX cpaKTOB '1PC3MCpHoro KonneKTH­ 132 rrocne HHH aKT KpOBaBOH Tpare I liH 60Pb6bl 3a BJIaCTb KaK MOrJlH OC03HaTb TO Y3HHKH H conorHH Ba fIo MCpC TOro KaK YKpcrrnHnCH aBTopHTeT CTanHHa OH Ha'laJI ancn­ nHlIlb 6bI He CMOTPCTb rrpaB e B rna3a KaKHC TOJlbKO aprYMCHTbl OHH HH rrpHBO 'Hml OHH 6blJlH HC roTO­ cH TCM ooncc 'ITO B rrepBble rrocncpeBonlOUHOHlIblC rO b POCCHIO 3HaBana HanH'IHe rrpoonCM Tpc6YIOmHX B peMeHH J JIH pa3pClllcHHH HIITeJIJlCKryanbl EBporrbI rrpo cnbIBaJlH BCCB03MO I Hble nOrH'IeCKHe yrrpall HCHHH - paCCMaTpHBanH KaK 3anor ClIaCTJlHBOrO 6YLl Ymero a HC KaK Y l e ocymecTBnCHHblM H ean B Te BpeMeHa H COBCTCKaH MeonorHH rrpH­ OT KonnCKTHBHoro rrpHHTHH HaCHJIHH H COJIOrHH Ha pa3YMOM 0cpHUHaJIbllblC COBCTCKHC pa3bHCHCHHH rro rrOBO y B rrneHY MHorHX eBporrCHCKHX HHTenncKTyanoB 06'bHC­ cpalllH3Ma H HaUH3Ma B HCKOTOPblX CTpaHax EB­ porrbI Bbl6paTb MO l HO 6blJlO O HO H3 TpCX HarrpaB ICHHH KOMMyHH­ 133 CTWleCKoe Tpe6ylOllJ ee nOnHOH OTna 1H HaIJ HCTCKOe B KOpHe Bap­ ' BapCKOe IDlH aHmO ppaHI T Y3CKOe KOTOpOe HMeHHO B 3TH rOnbl 6yn­ CTH B COOTBeTCTBHe HneOrrOrHIJeCKYlO HOCTb neMoKpaTHH He cneilYeT ynHBnHTbCH 'ITO npH CTom CKPOM­ neHCTBHTenbHOCTH OTnaB CrarrHHY npeilllOllTeHHe nepen rHrrrepOM 3a no pYCCKaH HneorrorHH or6naronapIDla HX nononHHTenbHOH nopKOH pa3YMa COBerCKHH COlO3 3aKnlOIJHn norOBOp C HaIJ HCr­ CKOH repMaHHeH oKKynHpoBarr 3anailHYlO 'IaCrb IIonblllH H 06bHBIDl BOMHY I HHnHHilHH Pa3YM He Mor 06bHCHHrb 3TH lllarn nepBoro ro­ cynapCTBa pa60IJHx H KpeCIbHH Te KTO Bce ellJ e CIJHTarr BepCHlO COBeTCKOM neHCTBH­ TerrbHOCTH H l H3Hb npaBna 0 KOTOPOH ' aCTO Y3HaerCli C on03naHH­ HOM BbI60pe HHTenneKTyanbI EBponbI He BbICKa3bIBarrH Bcnyx CBO­ HeCOOTBeTCTBHH PYCCKOH HileonorHH PYCCKOH C Tex nop neBble HHrenrreKryanbI 3anana He 3HalOT KaK npl lBe­ TO 3ananOCb uenblO npOneMOHCTpHpOBaIb Cna60CIb H HepelllHTenb­ ux Ha6rrlOneHHH 0 f· ' r eM Benb B pe3YllbTaTe MHorOIJHCneHHbIX nOTpHceHHH npe l le MO­ HOllHTHbIH KocrHK PYCCKOH Hileononrn naBHO Y f e npeBpaTHJ1CH B P l aBbIH MeTaJ1J10nOM ' I 'ITO CO­ BeCTKHH COlO3 HrpaeT porrb aBaHrapna COll HamfCrH'IeCKOrO nBH I e­ HHH 'ITO COBerCKHH COlO3 peaJIH3yer BeKOBble llaHHHH 3Toro IlBH I e­ HHH 6bIJ1H B nonHOH paCTepHHHOCTH PyCCKaH HneonorHH BCH'IeCKH CTapaJIaCb KynbTHBHpOBaIb ltJ1J1lO­ 3HH 06 HCrOpH'IeCKOH MHCCHH COBeTcKoro COlO3a OHa nOll'lepKHBa­ na 'ITO CCCP - rocynapCTBO pa60IJHx H KpecTbHH Bcero MHpa pOilHHa YrHeTeHHblx a nOTOMY 3alllHTa H nonnep I Ka COBeTcKoro COlO3a CBHTaH 3analla 60Pb6bI 3THX KrraCCOB B npyrux cTpaHax Ha nerre l e COBeTcKHH COlO3 neHCTBOBaJI KaK nlO60e HHoe rocynap­ CTBO B3HB Ha BoopY l eme pa3pa60TaHHble PYCCKHM caMOnep l aBH­ eM KOHu enll HH CTpaTenm 3KOHOMHKH H nonHTHKH I1neorrorHH nbITanaCb n06HTbCH HeB03MO I HOrO 06bHCHHTb MHHMble H nOilllHHHbIe neHCTBHH COBeTCKoro COlO3a KaK npOHBne­ HHe nHaneKTH'IeCKOrO eilHHCTBa I1neonorHH BblTallJ IDla H3 apceHa­ na CTapoe opY l He MapKCH3Ma H nonbITanaCb TorrKOBaIb HaUHcrCKYlO arpeCCHlO KaK HMlIepHarrHCTH'IeCKYlO aBaHTlOpy C KOTOPOH pa60IJHH Krracc repMaHHH HH'IerO o6llJ ero He HMeeT l epTBaM HaIJ HCTCKOH arpeCCHH COBerCKHH COlO3 COBeTOBan He OKa3bIBaTb conpOTHBrreHHH Bpary HX CTpaHbI TaK KaK caMoe rrraB­ Hoe 'IT06bI COBeTCKHH COlO3 - Hane l na nponerapHaTa Bcex CTpaH OCTarrCH B cropcme OT HMllepHanHCTH'IeCKoro KOH pllHKTa K CIIa­ CTblO Y nOH HneOrrOm'leCKOH KOHcrpyKUHH He 6bIDO BpeMeHH pa3­ BHIbCH raK KaK repMaHHH Hanarra H Ha COBeTCKHH COlO3 Bce 6bI­ rro CMbITO peKaMH nporrHTOH HapOnaMH CCCP KPOBH HO B Bocno­ MHHaHHHX eBponeHCKHx KOMMyHHCTOB l HBII1HX rorna B MOCKOB­ CKOH rOCTHHHue RlOKC no CHX nop l HBbI OrIJagHHe H TpaBMbI HaHeceHHble B Te ronbl pa3YMY· 134 135