1I1OIJ HH oepHUITeHH KlIaCCOBOrO AeHCTBruI BepHO OIIHCbIBalI B03MOJKHOCTH YCIIeIIIHOrO r Ii03e jJ flOKUtTe jJ1l B MHpe KOTOPbIH CYUIeCTBOBalI AO IIepBOH MHPOBOH BOHHbI HO eMY IIPHllUIOCb fibI MHOroMY Y'illTbCH 3aHOBO EIIJ E PA3 0 IDlTE 'ITofibI He IIOTepHTbCH B IIOlIHTHKe OfimeCTBa Bceofimero filIarOCOCTO­ HHruI TIocne BBeAeHruI B TIolIbIIIe BoeHHoro IIOnO f eHruI B BbIcrynne­ OHO IIpeAIIOnaraeT 60nee UIHPOKHH Kpyr030p 'IeM TOT KOTOPbIH HruIX MHOrHX 3aIIaAHOeBpoIIeHCKHX nOlIHTHKOB H 0603peBaTeneH OfieCIIe'lHBanCH IIPOCPC0103HbIMH UIKonaMH B AHH oepHUITeHHa pa­ CHOBa cralIO MelIbKaTb CJIOBO Hnra TIolIHTH'IeCKHe KpyrH 3anaA­ 6o'lee ABH f eHHe AOnJKHO fibIIIO npHcnocafinHBaTbCH HOH EBponbI CCbIJIalIHCb Ha fury AJIH OfiOCHOBaHruI CBoeH fie3AeHCT­ K IIpeBpamo­ CTHM KanHTanHCTH'IeCKOrO pa3BHTruI CerOAHH 3KOHOMHKa AOnJKHa BeHHOCTH nepeA nHUOM HaCHnruI HaA BOlIeH nOlIbCKoro HapoIJ a H MO f eT cpopMHpoBaTbCH COOTBeTCTBeHHO KOHuenUIDIM COIl Hanb­ B npollUIOM Hmy BCnOMHHaJIH IIO TeM f e npH'lHHaM B CBH3H C Horo nnaHHpOBaHruI BeHrepCKHMH COfiblTHHMH KHH B flepeeoo E IIIpai UHa 1968 1956 rOAa H oKKynaIl HeH qeXOCJIOBa­ rOAY TIpH'IeM nOHHTHe Hma AOn f HO fibIIIO C03IJ aTb BneqarneHHe 'ITO y COBeTCKoro C0103a eCTb He TOlIbKO nOnHTH'leC­ Koe HO H lOpHAH'IeCKOe IIpaBO AeHCTBOBaTb COOTBeTCTBYlOmHM ofipa30M TOrIJ a KaK lOpHAH'leCKaH ofiH3aHHOCTb 3anaIJ a B 3TOM clIyqae - He IIpeAIIpHHHMaTb HH'Iero B Haqane HbIHeIIIHero rOAa B ra3eTe HbIO-MOPK TaHMc KaHII lep 3anaAHOR fepMaHHH femMYT IIlMHAT nHcan TIO'lTH 40 lIeT Ha3aA Ha KOHcpepeHIl HH B Hme peUIeHo fibIIIO pa3Aemnb EBpoIIY Ha ccpepbI BlIHHHHH MHorHe n03 f e paCKaHBaJIHCb B 3TOM HO HecMoTpH HH Ha 'ITO Y f e Ha IIpoTH f eHHH 40 lIeT npH3HaHHe 3aIIaAoM cpaKTa 'ITO CTpaHbl Ha BOCTOK OT 3mfibI He BXOIJ HT B ero ccpepy BlIHHHruI COBepUIeHHO O'leBJlAHO Cl paH 3cKHH IIpe3HAeHT MHTTepaH HCXOAHT H3 aHaJIOrH'IHOH npeAIIOCbInKH XOTH nOlIHTH'IeCKaH HanpaBneHHOCTb ero BbIBOAOB HeCKonbKO HHaR obIIIO fibI none3HO Bce 'ITO cnocofiCTBOBaJIO fibI aHHYlIHpoBaHHlO HnTbI rOIJ HeM BbICTynlIeHHH 3aHBHn npe3HAeHT l paHUHH B HOBO­ HO lIHIIIb B TOM cnyqae eClIH f eJIaeMOe He fiYAeT BbIAaBaTbCH 3a AeHCTBHTenbHOCTb K AHCKYCCHH 0 HnTHHCKOM cornaIIIeHHH nOIJ KnlO'lHnHCb H COBeT­ CKHe npeACTaBHTelIH B KOHue HHBapH TeKymero rOAa IIO MOCKOB­ CKOMY TeneBHAeHHlO BbICTYIIHn COTpYAHHK OTAena Me f IJ YHapoA­ HOR HHcpopMaIl HH UK KnCC B KofibIIII Ha BOIIPOC IIO'leMY Ha 3anaAe CTanH Bce 'lame BbIcrynaTb IIpOTHB HnTHHcKoro cornaIIIe­ HruI KofibIIII OTBeTHn ITpHHIl HnHaJIbHbIe IIOnHTH'leCKHe IIepeMe­ HbI B TIonbIIIe K KOTOPbIM OTKPblTO CTpeMHnaCb ConHAapHocTb OKa3anHCb fibI B npoTHBope'illH C cornaIIIeHHHMH AOCTHfHYTbIMH j t 160 B HnTe TI03TOMY BaUIHHfTOHCKHe npaBHTenH cTapalOTcH oCBo60­ J ITbCH OT aMepHKaHcKHx ofiH3aTenbcTB KOTOpbIe IIpHHHlI B HnTe 161 l Jl 11'3BenbT II03ToMY OHH H rOBOpHT 'ITO RJITa ce6H H3 f Hna H qrO ee 3aMeHHnH KaKHe-TO XenbCHHCKMe J OKYMeHTbI 06paT­ HbIM nepeBO l C '1eIllCKOrO - llepBoHa'laJIbHo 4ep'lHJIJIb nbITaJICH J oroBopHTbCH co CTanHHbIM BeCbMa '1eTKaH jl0pMynHpOBKa 110 K06bIWY BonpOC BHYTPH­ nOnHTH'leCKOrO ynopH lO'leHMH IIonbllIH nocne OKOH1 JaUHH BTOPOM MHPOBOM BoiiubI 6bIJI peIlleH Y f e B RnTe COnH llapHOCTb f e KaK OU YTBep f laeT CTpeMHnaCb MMeHHO K BHYTpIDIOnHTH'leCKHM nepeMeuaM 113 noro K06bIIll J enaeT BbIBO l 'ITO J eiiCTBHH ConH­ lapHOCTH 6bIJIH uapYIlleHHeM RnTMHCKoro cornaIlleUHH np06neMY HeCKonbKO HHa'ie B Ha'lane jleBpaJIH 1982 ro lla leHT­ paJIbHblii opraH KII4 3aHBJIHeT l1cTOpH'IeCKHe J OKYMeUTbI nOJI­ UOCTblO onpOBepralOT MH jlbI KOTopble nbITaeTCH BOCKpeCHTb npe3H leUT lpaUII lm MHTTepau 0 pa3 J ene MHpa ua c jlepbI BJIHHUHH B RnTe Bo06me He rOBOpHnOCb HHocTpaHHbIx ro lla B RJITe BO BpeMH neperoBo­ poB Me f J y Coe J HUeUUbIMM UhaTaMH H BenHK06pHTaHHeii C O J UOH CTOpOHbI H COBeTCKHM COlO30M - C lPyroM 6bIJIO J orOBopeuo o pa3 J eJIe EBponbI ua c jlepbI BJIHHHHH TO eCTb 0 TOM 'ITO Ha RnTHH­ CKOM Kou jlepeUUHH 6bIJIO lOCTMTHYTO comaIlleHHe KOTopoe YBa­ KanOCb CTopOHaMH Ha npOTH f eHHH J eCHTIUIeTHH H KOTopoe OCTa­ len BeJIHK06pHTaHMH nowy B nOH lOHe 5 MaH 1944 ro lla l1 J eH nepe llaJI MHHHCTP COBeTCKOMY ryceBY npoeKT coma IlleHI1H B COOTBeTCTBHH C KOTOPbIM 11'MbIIlHH lOmKHa CTaTb COBeTCKOH onepaUHOHHoii 30HOii a rpeUHH BOMTH B onepaUHOHHYIO 30HY BenHK06pHTa­ l COBeTCKoe npaBI1TenbCTBO COrJIaCHJIOCb C 3Tl1M npe l lO f eHl1eM O J HaKO C YCJIOBHeM 'ITO npoeKT BeJIHK06pHTaHHl1 nO J lep f HT H npaBI1TenbCTBO COe lI1HeHHbIX IIlTaTOB Coe J HHeHllbIe IIlTaTbI npe l lO f eHHe AUmHH OTBepmH Ho Hec­ KonbKO J eiiCTBI1H Ha nOT pa3 B BH J e HCKnlO'IeUHH 11' J e npaBO nHIlleT npaB J y 1945 o TaK Ha3bIBaeMbIX onepaUHoHHbIX 30Hax mm 4eXOCJIOBaUJ aH ra3eTa 11' J e npaBO OCBeIllaeT O J HaKO ny MH jl 0 TOM 'ITO B jleBpane BanKaHbI a 3Ha'lHT H fpelJ HlO B pe3YJIbTaTe '1ero COBeTCKoe BnHH­ HMe pacnpocTpaHHTcH l0 6eperoB Cpe J H3eMHoro MOpH n03 f e KOr lla cornaIlleHHH 4ep'IHnnb 06 npell IO f Hn OrpaHI1'IHTb CPOK oIIepaUHoHHbIX 30Hax TpeMH MeCH­ n aMH npe3H J eHT 11'3BenbT cornaCHnCH OTMeTHB IIpH nOM nonH­ TH'IeCKHH 11 IOpl1 lH'IeCKHH xapaKTep aHmO-COBeTcKoro COmaIlleHI1H MbI 06H3aHbI nO J '1epKHYTb CKa3an 11'3BenbT - 'ITO no corna­ IlleHHe HH B KoeM clIY'Iae He 03Ha'iaeT onpe J eneUHH nocneBoeHHbIX c jlep BnHHHHH 2 IIocne OKOH1 JaHHH TpeXMeCH1 JHOrO cpoKa J eiicTBHH comaIlleHHH 4epqH1lnb CHOBa noexan B MOCKBY IIpe3H J eHT COe J HHeHHbIX eTCH B CHne no ceH leHb r1IY60KO YKopeHH1ICH B C03HaHHH MHorHX IIlTaTOB KOTOPblii B TO BpeMH 6bIJI 3aHHT npe lBbI60PHoii KaMna­ IIopa3HTenbHo qrO 3TOii nereH J e BepHT H CCbIJIalOTCH Ha Hee CTonb HHeM onbITHble rocY lapCTBeHHbIe J eHTenH KaK KaHll Iep IIlMH llT H npe- nocna CIIlA B CCCP A rapPHMaua AMepHKaHCKoe npaBHTenbCTBO 3H lleHT MHTTepaH Ho 'ITO f e B J eMCTBHTeJIbHOCnf npOH30llIJIO Ha npH 3TOM 3aHBHno 'ITO cornaIlleHMH KOTopble 6Y lYT J OCTHrHYTbI RJITHHCKOH KOH jlepeHUHH Me f J y 4ep'IIDlJIeM H CTanHHbIM He craUYT 06H3aTenbHbIMH ll IH ynonHOMO'lH1l Y'IaCTBOBaTb B MOCKOBCKHX neperOBopax COe J HHeHllbIX IIlTaTOB 1 0 Tex nop nOKa MX He 06CYMT H O jlOpMHT ua KOH jlepeUUHM npe l CTaBMTeneM Tpex J ep f aB 3 IIocne OKOUqaHHH MOCKOBCKHX neperoBopoB 6bIJIO KOBaHO COBMeCTHoe KOMMIOHHKe 3a O l HHM H3 ero npe l lO f lHHH 06CY f leHHe c jlep BJIHHHHH J eiiCTBHTeJIbHO HMeJIO MeCTo HO Ha COBemaHHH nO lp06HO 06cY J HnM pa3BHTHe C06bITHH B IOro­ c jlep BJII1HHHH He B UeHTpaJIbHOH a B IOro-BocTo'lHOM EBpone BOCT01 JHoii EBpone H He Ha RmHHCKOH KOH jlepeHUHM a Ha neperOBopax Me f J y CTa­ peroBopoB KOTopaH nerna B OCHOBY nereH J bI 0 pa3 J ene EBponbI JIHHbIM 11 4ep'lH1lJIeM KOTOpble COCTOHnHCb B MOCKBe B oKTH6pe 1944 rO J a C HHHUHaTHBOH C03 llaHHH c jlep BnMHHMH BbIcTynH1la BeJIHK06pM­ H CKpbIBaeTcH CO l ep f aHHe TOM qaCTH ne­ Ha c jlepbI BnI1HHHH KOTOPbIM pa3 J en Y f e Ha nepBoM 3aCe laUHH B UO'lb C 9 TaHl-fH TOr llaIIIHI1H npeMbep-MHHMCTP YMUCTOH 4ep'lH1lJIb onacancH npell Io f H1I pellIHTb BOIIPOC 0 KaK nHIlleT OH B CBOHX MeMyapax qrO COBeTCKMe BOMcKa 3aHMYT apMHH erOHT B 11'MbiHMH H BOnrapl1H - 162 HK06bI 6bIJI J oroBopeH Ha KOH jlepelllum B Rnre Ha 10 OKTH6pH 4ep'lHnnb BanKaHcKoM nonyocTpoBe BaIlla CKa3an 4epqH1lnb Y Hac 163 B 3TMX CTpaHaX CBOM MHTepeChI B HMX HaXO ll MTCH HalIDf MMCCMM Ho neperoBopbI Me l ll y qep'lIDIJIeM H CTaJIHHhIM KaK M RJITHH­ areHTbI He 6Y Il eM I e MbI TaM BhIcTynaTb Il pyr npornB Il pyra 4 CKYIO KOHtPepeHLl MIO MHorMe npO ll OJI I aIOT CBH3bIBaTb C onpe ll eJIeH­ qep'lIDIJIb COBeTCKMM npe ll CTaBHTeJIHM JIMCTOK 6YMarH HhIMH IOpM ll M'IeCKHMM 06H3aTeJIbCTBaMM He TOJIbKO BeJIHKHX Il ep­ npoeKT aB HO M CTpaH lleHTpaJIbHOH M IOro·BoCTO'IHOH EBponbI 06 Ha nepe ll aJI KOTOPOM 6bIJI pa3 1l eJIa naJIKaHcKoro nOJIYOCTpoBa Ha CtPepbI BJIMHHHH BhIrJIH Il eJI 3TOT npoeKT TaK 3TOM CBM Il eTeJIbCTByeT M 3aHBJIeHMe K06bIlIla 'ITO COJIH Il apHOCTb Il eHCTBOBaJIa B npOrnBOpeqMM C pelIleHMHMM RJlTHHCKOH KOHtPe­ CCCP anA -Bellu K06puTaHWl peHLl MM II03TOMY MbI nonbITaeMCH paCCMOTpeTb onMcaHHbIe C06bI­ TMH M TeKCThI Me l rOCY Il apCTBeHHbIX COrJIalIleHHH C TOqKM 3peHMH 90% 75% 50% 50% 10% 10% 25% 50% 50% 90% PyMblHUR EOllzapWl BeH zpWl lOZOCIlaBWl FpeijWl Me l ll YHapO ll HOro npaBa PaCCMaTpMBaH npaBOBYIO CTOPOHY COrJIalIleHHH Me l Il y CTaJlH­ OT'IepKHYB npM npoBepKe Ll MtPPbI raJIO'lKaMH CTaJIHH cpa3y HbIM H pq JIJIeM C yqeTOM HOpM Toro BpeMeHM 3TOT Il OKYMeHT I e COrJIaCIDICH C npoeKToM Ho qep'lHJIJIb HeO l M Il aHHO 3aKOJIe6aB­ MO I HO lIlHCb cnpoclm npaBHTeITbCTBaMH He nOKa l eTCH JIH tPPHBOJIbHbIM 'ITO MbI TaK JIerKoMbIcneHHo pelIlaeM BonpoCbI KOTopbIe KacaIOTCH MIDIJIHOHOB JIIO ll eH He JIy'llIle JIM C I e'lb 3TOT JIMCTOK HeT 11 CKa3aJI CTaJIMH oxapaKTepM30BaTb KaK cY ll e6 npaBHTeJIbCTBa HeT q cneHHbIx coxpaHMTe ero 5 HetPOPMaJIbHbIH Il OrOBOp Me l ll y BeJIMK06pHTaHHH H COBeTCKoro 06H3aJIMCb OcYmeCTBJIHTb CTpauax B COOTBeTCTBHH COI03a 000 CBoe BJIHHHHe B nepe­ C COrJIaCOBaHHOH cxeMoH MO l HO TaK I e KOHCTarnpoBaTb 'ITO TO COrJIaWeHHe OKTH6pH B nMCbMe Py3BeJIbTY qep'IIDIJIb nbITaJICH o60cHOBaTb Il OCrnrHYToe B MocKBe COrJIalIleHMe He06xo ll MMO 6bIJIO nMCaJI OH HaihM 06mHH 3HaMeHaTeJIb BocnpenHTCTBOBaTb nlOHa qep'IIDIJIb cornaCOBaHHOH Il JIH rpa l Il aHCKHM naJIKaHCKOro BOHHaM B nOJIYOCTpOBa H CTpaHax 3TOro pe­ BCH'IeCKM nbITaJICH npeYMeHblIlHTb 3Ha'lMMOCTb co CTaJIHHbIM Ta6JIM Il bI B MeMopaH Il YMe 0 MOC­ KOBCKMX neperOBopax KOTOPbIH qep'lHJlJIb nOCJIaJI CTaJIMHY 3Ta Ta6JIHUll Ha3bIBaJIaCb BeJIHK06pMTaHMM 0 lIlllapraJIKOH B OT'IeTe H e KacallOcb CfeXOCII08aKUU Ilollbwu r OP U All X1H UU 06R 3b18a1l0 TOllbKO BelluK06puTaHUIo U Co8eTcKuu COI03 HO H U 8 KoeM CIIYlflle CoeOUHeHHble lJITaTbl KOTopble tjJOPMallb­ 11 0 'JTO C021laWeH Ue H e YT8epOUIlU 7 U opY2ue 3anaOHble crpa­ Hbl He 06R 3b18aeT H U zocyaapcT8a H U H apoObl CTa8WUe 06'beKTOM npaBMTeJIbCTBY 'JT020 COZIlaWeH Wl TaK KaK no OeucT608a8weMY B Te 200bl Me neperOBopax B MOCKBe qep'lMJIJIb Ha3bIBaeT OYH aPOOH OMY npa6Y COZllaLUeHWl H e 06R 3bl8aIOT rpeTbe zocyaapcT­ ee BpeMeHHbIM PYKOBO ll CTBOM JIMlIlb Ha BpeMH BOHHbI KOTO­ 80 U He npeOoCTa81lR 1OT npaBa TpeTbeMY 20cyaapcrey 6e3 no H a poe Il OJI I HO 6bITb nepeCMOTpeHO BeJIMKMMM Il ep l aBaMH Ha nepe­ TO C02IlaCWl 8 rOBopax 0 nepeMMpMM IDIH Ha MMPHOH KOHtPepeHLl MM npM 06cy I · Il eHMH KOMnJIeKCHOro nOCJIeBOeHHoro ynopH Il O'leHMH EBponbI 6 - 6blll0 npuW TO H a 6pe MJl 80UH bl UIlU 00 3aKIlIO'IeHWl MUP­ HblX 002080P06 CM 06MCH eH Wl Cfep'IUIlIlR CJIe ll yeT nO ll qepKHYTl 'ITO Mbl nOJIHOCTbIO a6CTparHpyeMcH OT Bonpoca 6bIJIO JIH JaKJlIO'IeHHOe comaweHHe Boo6me npaBO­ MOq bIM TaK KaK B Te ro ll bI Y I e 6bIJIa npHHHTa IleKJIapaLI MH Om ­ TaKOBbI MCTOpM'IeCKHe tPaKTbI 0 npHHHTMH pelIleHMH no pa3 1l e­ JIY EBponbI 164 e ll MHeHHbIX HaLl M il ATJIaHTHqeCKaH XapTMH H IleKJIapaLI MH npaBH­ TeJIbCTBa CCCP OTHOCHTeJIbHO ATJIaHrnqeCKOH XaPTHH 9 165 r ' He Cne lyeT TaK I e 3aOblBaTb 'ITO ooe CTOPOHbI caMO rrOHJiTHe ''ImHlIHHe'' paCCMaTpHBanH pa3nwrno llnH COBeTCKoro COID3a BnHHHHe 03HaqaeT a o arrTau HID lTHMH CTpaHaMH COBeTCKoii Mo o enH OOlIIeCTBeHHoro YCTpoiicrna a qep nb KaK BbITeKaeT H3 ero MeMYapOB nOHHMan ero B qHCTO BHelllHerrOnHTHqeCKOM CMbIcne CJlOBa CM TaK I e BblcTynneHHe qepqlfMH B $YJlTOHe B H COBeTcKOO COlO3 - OOH3anHCb nOMO% HaPO o aM B OCBOOO l o eH­ HbIX CTpaHax HnH B ObIBllIHX rocy o apcTBaX-CaTenmuax OCH B EBPO­ ne C03 o aBaTb BpeMeHHbIe npaBHTenbCTBeHHbIe BnaCTH IIlHPOKO npe o CTaBnHIDlIIHe H 00H3aHHbIe Bce o eMOKpaTHqeCKHe B03MO I H0 lneMeHTbI HaceneHHH CKopee YCTaHOBHTb nYTeM CBOOO o HbIX BbI60pOB IIpaBHTemCTBa OTBeqalOlIIHe Bone Hapo o a H CIIoco6CT­ 1946 r flbITanCb OTBernTb Ha Borrpoc MO I HO nH CqHTaTb lTO cornallleHHe o eHcTBHTenbHbIM B Hallie BpeMH MbI paCCMOTpHM caMbIH KpIDi­ BOBaTb no r o e OKa l eTCH Heo6xo o HMbIM IIpoBe o eHHIO TaKHX BbIOOPOB HOO BapHaHT a HMeHHO HMen nH COBeTCKHH COlO3 rrpaBO YCTaHO­ OTHocHTenbHo ITonbllul obmo o ocTHrHYTo cornalIIeHHe C03 o aTb BHTb B CTpaHax BOCTOqHOH EBponbl nOnHrnqeCKHH pe l HM COBeTCKO­ BpeMeHHoe IIpaBHTenbCTBo Hau HOHanbHoro eAHHCrna H nopYqlfTb ro THrra H 3alIIIlli1 aTb nOT pe l HM BceMH o OCTynHbIMH COBeTCKOMY eMY COlO3Y cpe o CTBaMH BbIOOPbI KaK MO l HO CKopee Ha OCHOBe BceoolIIero H30HpaTenb­ 3TO n paBO nO o TBep l o eHO COBeTcKOH Me l AYHapO o HOH H IOPH­ o HqeCKOH j pa3aMH 0 nOMOlIIH KOHll enUHeH KOTOPaH 3aByanHpoBaHa npHeBllIHMHcH COIIHanHCTHqeCKOM HHTepHall HOHanH3Me H O o HaKO l J1H onpoBep l eHHH COBeTcKoH OpaTCKOH KOHI errUHH IIpOBecTH cB060 o HbIe H HH'IeM He BocnpenHTcrnOBaHHble Horo npaaa IIpH TaiiHOM ronOCOBaHHH B lTHX BbiOOpaX Bce aHTH­ HallllCTCKHe H o eMOKpaTH'IeCKHe IIapTHH o OJ1 l HbI HMen rrpaBO IIpHHHMaTb yqaCTHe H BbiCTaBnHTb KaHAH o aTOB 10 Kor o a qepqHJ1Jlb BO BpeMH HnTHHCKOH KOH j epeHll HH rrpe l J10­ o BblOOPbI B ITonblIIe o omKHbI npoxo o HTb no o KOHTponeM o oCTaTO'lliO CpaBHlITb COBeTCKYIO TpaKToBKY C oonee n03 o HHMH I HJ1 o oroBopHblMH 00H3aTenbCTBaMH o ep l aB-IIOOeLUneneH OTHOCHTenb­ o ep l aB-no6e o HTeneH MHHHCTP HHOCTpaHHbIX o en CCCP OTBeTHn HO ynopH o OqeHHH EBPOIIbl H o OIIonHIUb lTO cpaBHeHHe aHanH30M 'ITO 3TO ObJJ10 ObI oCKop6neHHeM rop o OCTH H HapYlIIeHHeM He3a­ MOCKOBCKoro BHCHMOCTH CBooo o Horo Hapo o a Ho Kor o a B HHBape cornallleHllH Me l ly qepqunJleM H CTanHHbIM C TOqKH 3peHll1 IIPHHu HIIOB H HOpM Me l lyHapo o Horo IIpaBa B IIep­ BYIO Oqepe o b C TOqKH 3peHHH IIpaBa Hau HH Ha caMooIIpe o eneHHe COBepllleHHO IIapa o OKcanbHo o nepBbIM o oKYMeHTOM Me l ­ 1947 ro o a 3TH BbIOOPbI nocne l J1HTeJlbHbIX IIpoBOJlO'leK HaKoHeII-To COCTOHJlHCb OHH npOxO o HJ1ll BeTIllKoopHTaHHH B ycnOBHHx KOTopble CO'lJ1H HapYllIeHHeM IIpaBHTeJlbCTBa HnrnHcKHx CIUA H cornallleHHH o yHapO o HOro npaBa KOTOPbIH CBOAHT Ha HeT COBeTCKoe IIOHHMa­ B CBH3H C '1eM H 3aHBHJ1H no 3TOMY IIOBO o y npoTecT npaBHTenbCT­ HHe cornallleHHH Me l ly CTanHHbIM H qepqlfnneM - BaM COBeTCKoro COlO3a H ITOJIblllH 11 3TO OOH3a­ TenbcTBa BbITeKaIDlIIHe H3 caMoii HnTHHCKoH KOH j epeHUHH Ha B TaKHX l e ycnOBHHX npoxo o HJ10 Y'Ipe l J eHHe npaBHTeJIbCTBeH­ lTOH KOH j epeHUHH TpH BemiKHX o ep l aBbI IIpllHHnH He TonbKO HbIX opraHOB H B o pyrHx CTpaHax BOCro'lHOH EBponbl 3a HCKnID­ pellleHHe 0 IIocneBoeHHblX rpaHHIIax ITonblllH TO eCTb 0 IIepe o aqe '1eHHeM qexocnoBaKHH r o e KOMIIapTHH nonHOCTblO cKoHIIeHTpH­ COBeTCKOMY COlO3Y BOCTOqHbIX oonaCTeH ITonblllH B3aMeH 3a npll­ pOBana BnaCTb B CBOHX PYKax n03 1 e coe o HHeHHe K ITonbllle Ha ceBepe H 3aIIa o e HeMeIIKHX TeppHTopHH 3ana o HbIe o ep l aBbI B Ka l J OM cnyqae 3aHBnHnH npOTeCT Ha ITOTC­ ro o a 12 H BennKoopHTaHHH 3aHBHnH 'ITO C03 o aHHble no o COBeTCKHM Ha l H­ B MOM npaBHTenbCTBa crpaH BOCTO'lHOH Coe o HHeHHbIX mTaTOB o aMCKOH pOBaHHH IIpe o cTaBHTenbHblx rocy o apcTBeHHbIX opraHoB ITonblllH 00 OCBOOO l o eHHOH EBpOIIe o ep l aBbI-yqaCTHHIIbI IIpe o CTaBHTenH 1948 HO H B3HnH Ha ceoH 00H3aTenbcTBa OTHOCHTenbHO ycnoBllH j OpMH­ lleKnapaUHH KOH j epeHlllIH B j eBpane EBponbI He onHpalOTCH HnTHHcKoH KOH j epeHUHH oOH3anHcb IIpe o oCTaBHTb OCBOOO l o eH­ Ha llIHpoKoe npe o CTaBIuenbCTBO Bcex o eMOKpaTH'IeCKHX lneMeH­ HbIM Hapo o aM B03MO I HOCTb C03 o aTb o eMoKpaTHqeCKHe yqpe l J e­ TOB a nOTOMY He COOTBeTCTBYIOT HnTHHCKHM cornallleHHHM HHH no HX cOOCTBeHHOMY BbIOOpy O o HHM H3 IIPHHI OB ATnaH­ THqeCKOH XaPTHH rOBopHTCH TaK I e B lleKnapaUHH IIpaBo Bcex Hapo o oB H30HpaTb j opMY IIpaBHTenbcTBa IIpH KOTO­ POM OHH 0YAYT l lITb llanee BenHKHe o ep l aBbI - 166 JilCXOAH H3 CKa3aHHoro BbIllIe MO I HO c o enan ABa BblBO o a HBnHeTCH a TeM caMbIM MOCK08CKoe C02flalUeHue MeJiCOY lfep'IU lfleM U CTCl lUHblM TO eCTb npU6eOe1lllYIO 8bllUe m6flul Y lleflb3Jl C'IUTaTb npa80MO'lHblM 167 ' Ie IOpUOUlteCKUM OOKYMeHTOM 0 c¢epax 611W1HWI B alMOM KpaiiHeM C ly'ltle 3TO C0211aWeHUe MOJICHO CltUTaTb 6peMeHHb1M 6b16U1 UM 6 cUile 00 f IITUHCKOii KOH¢epeHijUU Ha KOTOpoii OepJK116bl 0020­ 60PUIIUCb 0 npo6eOeHUU OeMOKpaTUlteCKUX 6bl60p06 npa6UTellb­ CmeHHblX OpzaH06 e6poneiicKUX 20CYOapcm - Co103a - BHYTpeHHHH Ha ee OCHOBe HaIIHH HJIH Hapo J nOJIHTH'leCKOe JKOHOMH'leCKOe He pe3YllbTaT f IITUHCKUX C02l1aweHuii a UX 2py60e HapyweHue H 06IIIeCTBeHHoe YCT' poiiCTBO Ho TOJIbKO eOUHCT60 3THX 06eHX CTOPOH npe J CTaBnHeT co60ii nO J JIHHHOe cO J ep l aHHe npaBa Ha caMoonpe J eneHHe 06paTHblii llepeBO J C 'leIIICKoro - co30aHue 6 loKa CTpaH BOCTOltHOii E6pOnbi noo 2e2eMOIlUeii Co6eTCK020 popYMe a BTOpaH BbI6HpaeT 14 Pe J B paMKax OpraHH3aIJ HH 06'he J HHeHHbIX HaIIHii 6blJIH pa3pa60­ TaHbl Be pOPMYJlHPOBKH npaBa Ha caMoonpe J eneHHe I1epBaH H3 HHX npHBO J HTCH B Me l J YHapo l HOM I1aKTe 0 rpa l J aHCKHX H nOJIHTH'leCKHX llpaBax H B 60JIee nrnpoKoii POpMe CJIe J OBaTeJIbHO KaK JTO HH napa J OKCaJIbHO HY l HO CTpeMHTb­ CH He K aHHYJlHpOBaHHIO HJITHHCKOro COrJIaIIIeHHH a K ero nOCJIe­ J OBa TeJIbHOii peaJIH3alT lm B 3aKJIIO­ 'lHTeJIbHOM AKTe XeJIbCHHCKOro COBeIIIaHHH Bce HapO J bI rOBopHTCH B 3aKJIIO'lHTeJIbHOM AKTe - Bcer J a HMelOT npaBO B YCJlOBIDIX nOJIHOM CBo60 J b1 onpe J eJIHTb Kor J a H KaK OHH CTaTYC l eJIaIOT 003 caoii BHYTpeHHHH H BHeillHHH nOJIHTH'leCKHH BMeIIIaTeJIbCTBa yCMOTpeHHIO CBoe H3BHe nOJIHTH'leCKHe H OCYIIIeCTBJIHTb no JKOHOMH'leCKOe CBoeMY COUHaJIbHOe H KYJIbTypHoe pa3BHTHe Bo BpeMH MOCKOBCKoro COBeIIIaHHH Me l J Y CTaJIHHbIM H qep­ 'lH1UleM 0 npaBa Y I e c41epax BJIHHHIDI B IOro-BocTO'lHoii EBpone npHHIJ Hn Hamill Ha caMoonpe J eJIeHHe 6blJI nrnpOKO H3BeCTeH onepHpOBaJIH 14 BCnOMHHTb HM B MeX JJ YHapO l HbIX OTHOIIIeHIDIX locTaTO'lHO nyHKTOB nporpaMMbI npe3H J eHTa BHJIbCOHa le­ KpeTbl BpeMeH OKTH6pbCKOii peBOJIIOIIHH AmaHTH'leCKYIO XaPTHID H J PyrHe J OKYMeHTbI B TO BpeMH 3Ha'lHTeJIbHaH qaCTb HaceneHIDI 3eMHOrO mapa X HJIa B KOJIOHIDIX H J PyrHx a J MHHHCTpaTHBHbIX e J HHHIJ aX XapTHH y I e B co6CTBeHHoii JTO 06CTOHTeJIbCTBO 1941 C J eJIaHHOii 6Y J eT 003 B rOCY J apCTBeHHOCTH AmaHTH'leCKaH Y'lHTbIBaJIa a COBeTCKHH COlO3 ro J Y B TaK Ha3bIBaeMoii nOH J OHCKOii J eKJIapaJJ IDl nO J J epX KY 3aIIIHIIIaTb npaBO AmaHTH 'leCKOii Ka l J oro Hapo J a XaPTHH Ha 3aHBHJI 'lTO roCY J aPCTBeHHYIO caMocTOHTeJIbHOCTb H TeppHTOpHaJIbHYIO HenpHKOCHOBeHHOCTb ero npaBO Bbl6HpaTb TaKoe 06IIIeCTBeHHoe YCTpoiicTBO H TaKYIO POpMY npaBHTeJIbCTBa KaKYIO OH C'lHTaeT He06xo J HMoii J JIH 06eCne'leHHH 3KOHOMH'leCKOrO 13 Ba H KYJIbTypHoro pa3BHTHH CBoero rOCY J apCT­ 06 JTOM e J HHCTBe HaIIHOHaJIbHOrO H nOJIHTH'leCKOrO caMoonpe­ J eJIeHHH nHIIIeT coBeTcKHH CneIIHaJIHCT no MeX JJ YHapo J HoMY npaBY CTapYIIIeHKo Y npasa Ha caMoonpe J eJIeHHe Be CTOPOHbI O J IIa BHeillHHH H Ha ee OCHOBe HaII WI HJIH IIapo J onpe J eJIHIOT CBoii llOJIHTH'leCKHii 168 H JKOHOMH'leCKHii CTaTYC Ha Me l J yHapo l HOM BTopoe IOpH J H'leCKOe onpe J eJIeHHe JTOrO npHHIIHna CO J epX HTCH B leKJIapaIIHH npHHIJ HnOB MeX JJ YHapo J Horo npaBa OT B Heii KpoMe npHBe J eHHoro BbIIIIe onpe J eJIeHHH J pyroii npaBa pe J aKIJ HH Ha YKa3aHbI caMoonpe J eneHHe H pa3JlH'lHble KpoMe TOro 1970 rO J a B HeCKOJIbKO pOpMbl peaJIH3aIJ HH B J eKJIapaIJ HH JToii 3aHBJIHeTCH 'ITO nepexo J B HHOii nOJIHTH'leCKHH CTaTYC cB060 J ­ HO Bbl6paHHblii HaIJ Heft llpe J cTaBJIHeT co60ft O J HH H3 cnoc060B peaJIH3aIIHH npaaa Ha caMoonpe J eneHHe lanee roaopHTCH 06 06H3aHHOCTHX TpeTbHx rocY J apcTa C o l Hoii CTOPOHbI 06 06H3aH­ HOCTH 06IIIHMH YCHJlHHMH H YCHJIHHMH Ka l J oii CTpaHbI nOMep­ l HBaTb J OCTH I eHHe paBeHcTBa B npaBax H caMoollpe J eneHHe a C J Pyroii 06 06H3aHHOCTH a03 J epX aTbCH OT KaKHX 6bl TO HH 6blJIO HaCHJIbCTBeHHbIX J eiiCTaHH npomB npasa HaI I Hft Ha ca­ Moonpe J eneHHe 11 HaKOHeII a leKJIapaJJ IDI npHHIIHllOB MeX JJ Y­ Hapo J Horo npaaa rOBopHTCH 0 npaBe HaIJ Hii 6oplOIIIHXCH npoTHB nO J aBJIeHHH HX npaBa Ha caMoonpe J eneHHe 06paIIIaTbCH 3a no­ MOIIIblO H npHHHMaTb 3TY nOMOIIIb B COOTBeTCTBHH C IIenHMH H nOJIO l eHHHMH YCTaBa OH TaKHM 06pa30M C KaKHX 6bl acneKTOB HH paccMaTpHBaJIOCb npaBo HaIJ Hii Ha caMoonpe J eneHHe 'ITO 6bl HH rOBOpHJlOCb 0 c pe­ pax BJIHHHHH H KTO 6bl HH CCblJIaJICH Ha HIlTY - JTH H J eM B CBeTe J eiiCTBYIOIIIero a HaCTOHIIIee BpeMH MeX JJ YHapo l HOrO npaBa coBepIIIeHHO HeCOCTOHTenbHbl 169 npHMeqaHHH EC1Ut C 6Y lJ CT pa3pa60TaHa HOBa» OM3aTCJIbHa» HOpMa MC ­ lJ YHapO lJ Horo npaBa - rOBOplfTCH B CTaTbC 1969 UlCHHH 0 lJ OrOBOpHoM npaBc OT 64 rona - BeHcKoro corna­ TO npC HHH HopMa CCnH OHa OKa CTC» B npOTHBOpC'llfH C HOBOH nOTcpHCT CIDIY Cne lJ OBaTCnbHO nerCH lJ a 0 HnTC MIf J 06 2 onpe lJ encHHblx lJ OrOBOpaMH H B3alfMHO nplf3HaBacMblx c J cpax BJlHHHHH HC IfMCCT no lJ C060H HlfKaKoro OCHOBaHHH Bollee lIo lJ po6HO CM S1 G Xydis Anglo-Soviet Agreement CTp 248 Hlf B HCTOpH'leCKOM rmaHC HH CM W S Churchill Der zweite Weltkrieg T VI I CTp 98 3 TeKCT TenerpaMMhl CM R CTp 69 E Sherwood Roosevelt und Hopkins B llnaHe Me iJ YHapO lJ HOrO npaBa KOHl cnIJ J1H KOTOPYIO MO HO cpaBHlfTb C lJ OrOBOpcHHOH c J c­ POH BJlHHHHH cyrucCTBOBaJIa H lJ 0 BTOPOH MHPOBOH BOHHbl B CCpc lJ lfHe B npoCTpaHCTBa HaIJ J1CTCKOH ICOPHH - Y Ka J OH eCTb HMncpHH KOHl CnIJ J1CH rOBopIDIOCb CBoe 60JlbUlOe npOCTpalICTBO Ha KOTOPOM OHa pacnpOClpaHHeT CBOH H lJ eH If KOTopoe HC MO l eT CTaTb UlOM Hcro'lHHK CM lIpllMe'laHHe 2 CTp 269 5 TaM lKe CTp 270 30-x rO lJ OB cc pa3pa60TanH Haf HCTbl OHa OTHOCIDIaCb K EBpone If Ha3bIBanaCb Grossraum konzcption 6onbUloro 4 06beKIOM HHOCTpaHHOH HHTepBeHf HH OBOpH 0 60JIb­ npOCTpaHCTBC HeJICnO HCnOJIb30BaTb TaKHC nOHHTHH KaK cyBepcHHOc rocY lJ apCTBo rrO lJ lJ aHHble rpa l lJ aHe H TepPHTOpHaJIb­ HaH HCnpI1KOCHOBCHHOClb HaCCJIHIOrulfC 60JIbUlOC rrpOCTpaHCTBO Hapo lJ bI 06H3aHbI ocrdBaTbC» B cro paMKax B 3TOM CMbICJIC Me l lJ Y MC iJ YHapO lJ HbIM ynopH lJ OQCHHCM 60JIbUlOrO rrpOCTpaHCTBa ero BHYTpeHHCH CHCTCMOH CyruCCTBYCT B3al1MHaH CBH3b IS' KaKoe TporaTCJIbHOC CXO lJ CTBO If 6 TaM lKe CTp 277 llaHH3JIh EprHH Daniel Yergin B pa60Te Shattered Peace CTp 58-61 YTBCPlK lJ aCT ene lJ YlOmee Qep'lHJ1nh lIhlTaJICH HeCKOllhKO lIPHHH3HTh corllallleHHe co CTaJIHHhlM llHlllh J llH TOro 'lT06hI lIPHBllC'lh Ha CBOlO CTOP lHY Py mellhra KOroPhilt rrplIHIIHlIHanhHO 6hlll lIpomB o6pa30Ba­ HIIH l aKHX 6hl TO HH 6hIDO ctjlcp BllHHHHH A CTaJIHHY qcp'lHllllh HK06hl rOBopHll 'ITO HOT PaJ lJ Cll 6y lJ CT 06H3aTenCH H B lIOCllCBoeHHhlR lICPllOLl 7 B CBHlH C ilOTC I tMCKOti KOHtjlepcHIIHeR HOBhilt aMepHKaHCKHR rrpe3H J eHT r TpYM3H COBeplllCHHO oTBepr H lJ elO etjlep BllHHHHH B BhICTynlle­ HHH no paLl Ho 9 aBryera 1945 r npe3HLl cHT TpYM3H CKa3an 3aHBlleHHc o PyMh1HHH EOllrapHIl II BeHrpll1l 6hVlO nO lJ TBeplKLl cHO B EepnHHe 3TH rocy u apCTBa He CTaHYT ctjlepoll BllllHHIIH i aKoil'-llll60 Ll eplKaBhT Hx Ll ellaMII 6YLl eT 3aHlIMaThCH KOMHCCHH no KOHTPOlllO B KOTOPYlO BoR lJ YT npeLl CTa­ BHTenH Tpex COlO3HhlX roey u apCTB Archiv der Gegenwart 1945 CTp 361 8 CM BeHCKoe cornarneHlIe 0 lJ orOBopHoM npaBe Dokumenty ke stu­ diu mezinarodn ho prava Ill Praha 1970 CTp 20 9 B ArnaHm'leCKoti xapmll BellHK06pHraHlIH 06H3anaCh YBalKaTh npaBO Bcex HaIIHti 1I36l1paTh TY tjloPMY npaBlleHllH B KOTOpoR OHII XOTHT lITh B Tal Ha3hTBaeMOH ITOH lJ OHCKoR Ll eKnapaIIHII 1941 COBeTCKoe npaBHTellhCTBO 33RBHllO 0 CBoeM corllaClI1I COCHOBHhTMII lIpHHIIHnaMH ATllaH­ TH'leCKoti XaPTIIII CM W Churchill Der zweite Weltkrieg T 1 CTp 71 10 11 TaM lKC CTp 91-93 CM G Rhode Polen as Volksdemokratie CTp 235 12 06 rrOM HarIlIcaHO MHOro KHllr CM HanplIMep Z K Brzezinski So­ vietblock J K Hoensch Osteuropa-Politik I Deutscher Stalin H Seton­ Watson Revolution 13 170 14 HCTO'lHIIK i al B npllMe'laHHH 9 CrapyrneHKO ilPIlHIIHII caMoonpeLl eneHHH Hapo lJ OB HHaIIHti CTp 144 15 Carl Schmidt Volkerrechtliche Grossraumordnung cTp 69 R• Hohn Grossraumordnung und volkisches Rcchtsdenken CTp 23 33 171