r l if HAUMOHAnhHAB rrpOBnEMA nHfiepaJIbHO HaCTpoeHHbIX nIDAeH KOTopbIe BblcrynaIDT npOTHB Hall HOHaJIH3Ma KaK npOTHB 6eccMblcneHHoro H orraCHoro 3a6ny K­ AeHHH lbtcopOJIC Yp6aH XblO CeToH-YoTCOH rrpaBbl OHH HJIH HeT MO KeT 6bITb B '1eM-TO H npaBbl HO MHp BOBce He TaKOB KaKHM fibl ero XOTenH BHneTb HeKoTopble HAUMOHAnM3M M Ero AcrrEKTbl finarOHaMepeHHbIe HHTenJIl1reHTbI MHp He TonbKO pall HOHaJIeH HO H Hppall HOHaJIeH a Hall HOHanH3M B Hallle BpeMH BOBce He 1 0 ocna6eBaeT 11 y K TeM fiaJIee He cofiHpaCTCH HClJ e3aTb Donee Hall HOHal1bHOM C03HaHHH H Hall HOHanH3Me Toro H nOn03peBaID 'ITO H B Ka KAOM H3 Hac rnyfioKo 3acen YPEAH KaK no HH OOHanbHO MO KeT np03BylJllTb H Bce Ke KaKOH-HHfiYAb H3 Hall HOHanH3MOB nycTb XOTH 6bl B rere­ pHCKHY 3aMCTHTb lJ TO BCID lJ e110BelJ eCKYID HCTOPHID HHlJ TO taK JIeBCKOM He TpeBO KIDlO nIDneH KaK Bonpoc 0 nOHCKax KaKoH-TO OfilllHOCTH 06mero H3bIKa KOJIJIeKTHBHOH CMblcne HX cymecTBoBa­ HHH 06 HX MeCTe H npeJ Ha3HalJ eHHH fOBOPH HHalle lJ enOBeK ­ 3TO cymecTBo CI1CTeMa CBOHX KOTOPOMY AHTpon0110rH HayK no-pa3HoMy nOKa3anH COll Honorl1 KaK MeTOAaMH penHrl1H YTonl1H H HAe0110fHH CIDlHTCH 06eCnelJ HTb nIDnHM qmnocQ pcKYID n03HlI HID KenaHI1H fibITb C Tefie nOA06HbIMH B 3amHTbI M HY KeH BblClllHH aBTOpI1TeT HY KHa nCI1XOnOrH CMbICJIe BOT MOH Kyl1btypHaH JIH B HeM Bonpoc B lleM nO-BallleMY nOnl1THlleCKaH H 3Ha'lHMOCTb XOTb 'ITO-TO COBpeMeHHoro cnocofiHoe Hall HOHaJIH3Ma ypaBHoBeCHTb ECTb npHcymHC CMY AeCTpYKTHBHble KalJ eCTBa rrpOAOn KaeT nH OH TpaiJ HlI HH B KH3HI1 H nOMOllb HM MeHbllle CTpalllHTbCH Henpe J BHAeHHblx no­ 1848 cnenCTBHH c06cTBeHHbix neHHHH KoropaH Bce MeHblllC BnHHCT Ha cOBpcMeHHYID KynbTYPY roJJ a MnH OKa3bIBaeTCH KaK 6bl cypporaToM penHfHH CeHlJllC MeHH HHTepecyeT B KaKOH Mepe 3Ty CPYHKlI HID ocy­ mCCTBnHeT Hall HOHaJIH3M HaCKonbKO OH npeAocTaBnHeT nIDnHM CETOH-YOTCOH y6e KACHHOCTb Hall HOHaJIH3M H Hall HOHaJIbHaH KynbTypa - B HX CPIDlOCOCPCKOH rrpaBoTe Hall HOHanH3M llnH Ha'lana H XOTen fibI nOAlJ CpKHYTb llTO HC OAHO H TO KC XX BeKa 3aMeTHO OTnHllaeTCH OT paHHero nHfiepaJIbHOrO Hall HO­ Hall HOHaJIH3M KoroPbIH H nOHHMaID KaK AOKTPHHY ofi OCOfiblX HanH3Ma BonHa KOToporo rrOJ HHl1aCb B EBporre rrocne DpaH­ npaBax UY3CKOH peBOnIDlI HH llTOfibl BbIl1HTbCH B BOCCtaHHH 1848-49 JJ aHHOH Hall HH HJIH KaK J BH KCHHe HMeIDmce ucnbID 3ty AOKTPHHY peanH30BaTb HC pa3 3a nOcneAHCC CTonCTHe PO K­ rOAOB CpeAH HbIHelllHHX 3arraJ HbIX nHfiepaJIOB 11 rrOKnOHHHKOB JJ an COUHllnl13Ma Hall HOHanH3M I1nl1 TOlJ Hee pa3HbIe Hall HOHanH3MbI nHCTH'IeCKHM 6enoro OTBpaTHTcnbHbIe npccrynnCHHH ilo3TOMY MHOrHC HC KoncfinHCb lJ enOBeKa Bbl3bIBaIDT ecnH He pe3Koe oTtanKHBaHHe TO B nYllllleM cnyqae rrpHCKopfiHe H Ha caMOM Aene ecnH CTpalllHeHlllHe MC KAYHapoJ HbIe cpnarOM TBopHnHCb KPH3HCbl H nOA Hall HOHa­ npoAOn KaIDT TBOPHTbCH cpaBHHBaIDT cro C paKOBOH onyxonbID OJ HaKO Hall HOHanbHOC MHI u eBHlJ HanbHOR KynbType B KOTOPOH CPOpMHpOBanHCb HX pOAHTcnH Hall HeH XpHCTa B03pO KAeHHeM BeplllaTCH BOHHbI B xpHCTHaHCKOM MHpC KC BCKe rrpOB03rnaCIDlH 0 KOTOPOH 3a­ lJ ro pYCCKHe B TOM CBoeH OC060H MHCCHH Ha 3eMlle npe J Ha3HalleHHoH J l1H HHXDorOM llro HTanbHHUbI TorJJ a Ke BblCKa3aJIH CBOH Hall HOHanbHbIe rrpHTH3aHHH BeCbMa HarrOMHHa­ IDmHe pYCCKHe 'ITO HeMUbI Y KC B HallleM BeKe rrOrrblTaJIHCb YTBCPAHTb CBOe rrpaBO Ha MHpOBOe rocrrOACTBO 3aHBJIHH cefiH HaCnen I HKaMH TeBTOHOB - y'ITH Bce no MO KHO nOHHTb npHHa J l1C KHOCTb HHiJ HBHAYYMOB K JJ aHHOH HaUHO­ BcrrOMHHTb llTO rrOnHKH B AeBHTHaAQaTOM BeKe OfibHBIDlI1 ce6H C03HaHHC H OHH caMH BnonHC CCTeCTBeHHbI H HCBI1HHbl Hall HOHaJIbHOe C03HaHHe 06ccnCllHBaCT AYXOBHOR KH3HH nIDnHM onpcAcneHHbIH KOHTCKCT HX H 3TO qyBCTBO npHHa J JIC KHOCTH HCKnIDllH­ TcnbHO Ba KHO J l1H 60nblllHHcTBa H3 HHX OnaCHOCTb B03HHKaeT TorJJ a KorAa nID60Bb K CBOCR Hall HH HnH BCpHOCTb eii nOAMCHHCT pcnHrHID KorJJ a Hall HID npHHHMa­ IDTCH OfiO KCCTBnHTb HMCHHO C lToro MOMeHta Hall HOHanbHOC c03HaHHC BbIPO KJJ aCTCH B onaCHeHlllYID MaHHID Hall HOHanbHoe 172 173 C03HaHile HeMIl eB Ha'lana nllOIlInOrO BeKa 6b1J10 'ocTolmo yBa­ eHlUl JTO 6bITI naTpllOT1l3M OCHOBaHHbIH Ha Q YH aMeHTe HeMeIl KOH KYJIbTypbl Ho 113BpaIlleHlieM OKa3aJICH TpeTllH peHX Kor a HeMeIl KllH Cl oJIK Hapo 3amw MeCTO Bora B YIlIax JIIO CH ropa3 0 rllOMlIC ero C YTBep J CHuH 0 paBCHCT­ Be H 06 06I U eH 06f13aHHOCrn HaIJ Hii pa3BHBaTb lUfBllJ1H3aIl IlIO H cnoc06cTBoBarb POCTY 'lCJIOBC'lCCKOrO BeJIll'lllll H He 6y y CeHqaC nO 'l106HO rOBopMTb 0 TOM KaK Y'lCHMe H BO HMH 3Toro l1 ona npliHHnlicb BepIlIHTb HH C 'leM He cpaB­ fep epa 6b1J10 M3BpaI U eHO naHrepMaHCKIiMIl H naHCJIaBMCTCKM­ HliMbIe 3JIo eHHHH Mil HaIJ HOHaJIHCTaMM JTO M3BeCTHO BOT OTPbIBOK M3 BCCOB 4TO e KacaeTCll COBpeMeHHOCTH TO MO HO Ha eflTbCH 'ITO llocToeBCKoro CKa3aHHoc B HeM He TOJIbKO OTpa l aeT npeBpa­ HaIJ Hll KOTopble OCTllfJIll BbICOKoro ypOBHll KYJIbTypbI II 06­ I U eHlle rep epOBCKMX H J eH B CJIaBHHCKuH MCCCHaHIl3M HO H pcnH KaK 6bI npe BOCXHI U aer CTaHOBJIeHHe HCMeIl KOrO HaIl llOHaJIM3Ma onpe 'cnliBIlIllHCll CTaTYC OKa YT CBOIO COTpY HH'laTb pyr C PyrOM 0pl1Mep TOMY - cnoc06HOCTb EBponCHCKoe 3KOHOMI1'leCKOe co06IlleCTBO XOTll OHO 11 HeCOBepIlICHHO OOKa eIlle npe eBpeMeHHO nOllO HT TaKoe e O Il aTb 'lYBCTBO 'ITO co06IlleCTBa npHBH3aHHOCTI1 JToro Tllna KOTopoe JlIO 11 XX BeKa Hapo 3TO TeJIO BO lle BCflKuH Hapo ' 0 Tex TOJIbKO nop M HallO ' nOKa MMeeT CBoero Bora oco60ro a Bcex OCTaJIb­ HbIX Ha CBeTe 6oroB MCKJIIO'IaeT 003 BCflKoro npMMHpeHMfI TIOKa BepyeT B TO 'ITO CBOMM BorOM n06eAMT H M3rOHHT H3 HcnblTbIBaIOT K cBoeii HaIJ H11 Hnl1 pemlrl1H MHpa Bcex OCTaJIbHbIX 6oroB KTO TepfleT YPEAlI Ho pa3Be TaK Y HeB03MO H0 '1T06bl HaIJ HOHanbHOe c03HaHile nepepocno B HaUI10HaJlIl3M MHe Ka eTCH 'ITO COBpe­ MeHHbIH HaIJ HOHanH3M Bc eT CBoe Ha'laJIO or fep epa 11 eCJIH HapO OB B HblX ycnoBllflX HaIJ HOHanbHoe C03HaHI1e nepeXO llr B HaIl IlOHa­ HaJIbHafl no 3aMKHy­ TblH MHKPOKOCM CKOHIl CHTplipOBaHHblH BOKpyr H3blKa II OCHO­ H Bepy TOT y e MO l eT MMeTb Bora HCTHHHOro E HHbIH HallO ­ 60roHoceIl C HHM cornaCllTbCfI npH J eTCfI npll3HaTb 'ITO npl1 onpe eJleH­ nll3M HeIl36e HO 00 fep epy Ka afl HaIJ Hll ny He HaPO ' Ho MCTHHa O J Ha a CTaJIO 6bITb TOJIbKO e HHbIH H3 taK 3TO PYCCKllH Hapo CO'lllHeHlUIX fep epa HaCTOJIbKO nO '1epKHBaeTcfI HaIl llO­ MCKJIIO'lllTeJIbHOCTb OnpaB bIBaeTCll 6o ecTBCHHall BOCXMI U eHMe npMpo a co6cTBeHHoH HaJ MM HaIl lleH 'ITO orraJIKHBa llCb OT ero y6e 'eHHH MO HO 6bIJIO C JIerKOCTbIO BaHHOH Ha HeM KynbTypbl Ka afl HaIl llll OTJIll'laCTCH OT PY­ nepeHnl OT HaIJ HOHaJIbHOH KYJIbTYPbI K KpaHHeMY HalUfOHaJIH3­ rOH OC06bIMll nllIlIb CH npHCYlUliMll Ka'lCCTBaMH 1160 Ka afl MY HaIJ Hll Ha cnCHa OC06blM yXOBHbIM Ha'laJIOM By y'lH TBOpC­ HanoJIeoHa a 'lepe3 cro JIeT nepBa ll MHpOBa ll BOHHa nOCJIY I llJ1M HlleM Bora Ka J all HaIJ Hll CBflIllCHHa HMTIYJIbCOM Ho fep ep npe J yIIpe J an COCTaBJIlleT nllIlIb 3neMeHT paBHOIl CHeH BceM pyrHM npll 06Illero nOM 'ITO Ka all HaIl Hf1 pa3Hoo6pa311H KOroPblH 11 He Y MBMTeJIbHO 'ITO oKKynaIl llfl fepMaHHH BOHCKaMM pa3BMTHfI HalUfOHaJIM3Ma KOTOPblH BnOCJIe CTBHH npeBpaTHJIC Il B b llBOJIbCKOe 0pY He rocy apcTBeHHOH nOJIll­ TllKli 4epe3 HaIl HH npOHBnHCTCll MHoro­ CTOllOHHOCTb 'lenOBe'leCKOH llCTOPHH H Ka aH 113 HIiX BHOCHT CETOlI-YOTCOH CBOH HenOBTopllMblH BKJla B 06Illee BeJIllKOnCnlle pa3BllTHfI CTOJIb HeOTBparnM 06paTHTe BHllMaHMe Ha YCJIOBHfI npH KOTO­ 'lenOBe'leCTBa OpH Bceii CYlUeCTBeHHocrll pa3nH'lHH JIfI Bcex pblX HaIJ HOHaJIH3M pa3BHBaeTCll oc06eHHO HHTeHCHBHO 06bI'lH0 MHe YMaeTCll '1ro nOT CKa'lOK BOBce He HalI llli eCTb O IlH 06IllHH 3aKOH TonbKO BHyTpeHHRll c ep aH­ no npoMCXO 'IlT Tor J a Kor a 3JIliTa TOH HJIH HHOH 06m HOCTll HOCTb 11 YBa CHHe K pyrllM npHHOCHr HM C'laCTbe 4enOBe­ 06'be J HHeHHOH B nepBYIO O'lepe b 06I U eH KYJIbTypOH 06Hapy­ 'leCKIiH pO nHCaJl OH - C HH MbI TPY J HMCH 11 CTpa u aeM ceCM 11 l HeM Ka l 'brn JIll Bcex O J HaKO Y'leHHC 6bIJIO epOM 174 fcp epa HcronKoBaHO YHHKanbHOH COBceM I1Baer 'ITO OHa OJI Ha 3alUHm aTb 3TY KYJIbTYPY OT BJII1f1HHfI HHOCTpaHHblX nopa60THTeJIeH B pe3YJIbTaTe OHa nO J HllMaeTCll KaK 'laCTO cny'laeTCfI B HCTOPHH Ha 60Pb6y npoTllB HHOCTpaHHoro npaBJIeHH Il BO llMH HaIJ HOHaJIb­ nO-HHOMY HOH He3aBHCHMOCTH 60 l CCTBeHHOH OO '1epKHBaHlle npllpO bI HaIl uH fcp­ 3BY'laJIO KHMH A HHocTpaHHblMH ecnH HaIJ HfI no cneHa Me J y HeCKonb­ rocY J apcTBaMH OHa KaK npaBllJ10 175 HalfilliaeT CTpeMHTbCH K HaIUiOHaJIbHOMY e J HHCTBY· KaK KOHKpeT­ H onpeAenSIeT Aeii cTBHH MHOrHX npaBHTenbCTB OHH OlIpaBAbIBaIOT HO no ocymecTBnHeTCH Ha Aene 3aBHCHT OT uenoro pHna HenpeA­ CBOH penpeCCHBHble Mepbl HalIpaBneHHbIe IIpoTHB Hau HOHaJIbHOrO cKa3yeMbIX q aKTopOB - C03HaHHH HerocynapcTBeHHblX 1I0A'lHHeHHbIX HaUHH B MHOrOHaIUiO­ OT KaqeCTBa PYKOBOACTBa KaK AaHHoro HaIUiOHaJIbHOrO ABH KemUl TaK H npaBHllIeH HaIUiH a TaK Ke OT BrrHHHHH TpeTbHX CHJI He 3aBHCHMbIX HH OT HHOCTpaHHbIX npaBH­ Terrell HH OT Haf HOHarrbHoro ABH KeHHH HpKHe npHMepbl Mbl HaxOAHM B HCTOPHH nepBOH MHPOBOll BORHbI Ee HenocpeACTBeHHO Bbl3BaJIO 6po KeHHe HaUHH ABCTPO­ BeHrepCKOM H PoCCHHCKOll HMllepHH a TaK Ke BaJIKaHCKOro 1I0ny­ OCTpoBa Ho 6b1rrH H ApyrHe He MeHee Ba KHbIe q aKTopbI KOTopble cymecTBeHHO nOBnHHrrH Ha xapaKTep BOllHbl ua C03naBarra oc06bm MHP pa30 Kma HOBbIe CTpaCTH H caMa BOMHa 11 Korna Ha­ KOHeu narra ABCTpo-BeHrepCKaH HMnepHSI MaJIO KTO YBH3blBan no lIaAeHHe C OCBo60AHTenbHbIM CTpeMJIeHHeM HaIUiM IIpaBna MHonle qTO BenHKHe mOAH Toro BpeMeHH He YCTaBanH nOBTopHTb BORHa 1I0Kapana 6e3HpaBCTBeHHbiX npaBHTerreii ABCTpo·BeH­ repcKoii HMllepHH 3a HX npecTynneHHH H IIpHHecna HarpaAY 6na· HaJIbHbIX rOCYAapCTBax YTBep KnaSI 6YATO TeM caMblM BblCtyIIa­ IOT rrpOBO UfHKaMH 60nee BbICOKOH IUiBHJIH3aIUiH OHH C'lHTaIOT 'ITO He MO KeT 6blTb HeCrrpaBeAJIHBa 1I0nHTHKa HarrpaBneHHaH Ha HHBenHpOBaHHe nO'lTH KHBOrnOrO AeCTpYKTHBHOrO HaIUiOHanH3Ma HenOKopHbIX HaIUiOHanbHbIX MeHblliHHCTB Ho ecnH HCTOPHH Bo06me cnoc06Ha 'IeMY-TO Y'IHTb TO OAHH H3 nepBbIX ee ypOKOB maCHT 'ITO norrblTKH HCKopeHHTb Hau HOHanbHOe C03HaHHe nOqTH HeH3MeH­ HO 3aBepI llaIOTCa nOpa KeHHeM yrHeTaTenH XOTH no KOHeqHO BOBce He 03Ha'laeT 6YATO Te KTO Ha OCHOBe Hall HOHanbHOrO C03­ HaHIDI ' pa3 KHraeT Hau HOHaJIH3M Bcerna HCTopuqeCKH npaBbl Ho 3TO Y Ke HHaH TeMa YPEAH BbITb MO KeT CTOHno 6bI paCCMOTpeTb HeCKonbKO npH- MepoB ropO l libIM BO KASIM 'IellICKOro H IOrocnaBcKoro HapOAOB Ho ceii'lac OTqeTJIHBO BH l lia HeCOCTOSITenbHOCTb 3THX 6naroHaMepeHHbiX CETOH-YOTCOH nocne KOMIIPOMHCca 1867 pOAHbIe 06e CTOPOHbI 6bIDH IIpaBbI H HelIpaBbl 1I0-CBoeMY MO KHO THH KOHe'IHO yTBep K J aTb qTO fHTJIep OKa3arrCH HacneAHHKOM mallIa· TaeB HeMeUKOR HaIUiOHanbHOll HAeH AeBHTHaAua Toro BeKa AO­ 6bIDH IIpocBelUeHHbIMH eBporreHnaMH H nH6epaJIaMH OHH ropAH­ nHCb BeHrepcKoH KynbTypoH KOTopaSI AOCTHma 3a npe u mecTByIO­ nyCTHM DHXTe Ho 3TO 6YAeT BepHO nHllIb OT'laCTH HeBepHO AY' IUHe AeCHTHJlerna orpoMHoro nporpecca H npoAOn KaJla HHTeHCHB­ 1914 rona TornamHHe ee IIpaBHTenH MaTb 'ITO CTpeMJIeHHe HeMueB K eAHlICTBY KOTopoe pa3BHBanOCb HO pa3BHBaTbcH BlInOTb AO C Ha'larra AeBHTHaAuaToro BeKa nOA B03AeRCTBHeM repAepOBCKHX He y6e KAeHbl 'ITO cnoBaKH PYMbIHbI H ApyrHe Hau HH JIHllIb BhIW' rona H 6bmH cOBepmeHHo HCKpeH­ HAell HeH36e KH0 AOn KHO 6bIDO nopOAHTb fHTJIepa C06blTHH C panH 6bI npHo6mHBllIHCb K Heii Ha 3TOM OCHOBaHHH OHH C'lHTa­ TaKHM Ke ycnexoM MornH 3BonIOIUiOHHpOBaTb H B ApyroM HalIpaB­ nH cnOBaUKHH H PYMbIHCKHll HaIUiOHanH3M peaKIUiOHHbIM B BeHrpHH rrpaBna 6bIDH PYMbIHbl H cnOBaKH KOTopble HaCTom· rreHHH HaIUiOHamHoe C03HaHHe BOBce He 06H3aTenbHO nepepaCTa­ eT B Haf HOHanH3M B 03n06neHHe npOTHB ApyrHX HaURM TaKoe KO BrrHTaJIH BeHrepCKYlO KynbTYPY 'ITO IIpaKTH'IeCKH CTaJIH BeRr· nepepaCTaHHe cnyqaeTCa Torna Korna HaUHSI TepHeT nepcneKTHBY paMH Ho BeHrpbl HX He rrpH3HaBaJIH TonKHYB TeM caMbIM B narepb AOXOAHT AO OT'laaHHH Ho na Ke H nocne Toro KaK HaUROHanbHble CTpaCTH HaKanSIIOTCSI AO Bpa KAbI OHH Bce eme MoryT npHHeCTH nOnO KHTerrbHble nrrOAbl BbmenHB H3 HaIUiOHaJIbHOrO ABH KeHHH 60rree YMYApeHHblX OnbITOM YMepeHHbIX rocynapCTBeHHblX Ae- HTerreR II03TOMY MHe AYMaeTCSI 'ITO Te3HC HaIUiOHaJIH3M pa3pYWH­ TerreH a nOTOMY HaIUiOHanbHOe C03HaHHe HaAJIe KHT nonaBnHTb COBepmeHHO 176 XOpOllIO BCnOMHHM BeHrpHIO BTOPOH norrOBHHbI AeBHTHaAuaToro CTone­ YTBep KAeHHH Ha 06eHX CTopoHax 6bIJIH nIOAH 1I0AJIbie H Gnaro· HeBepeH I1MeHHo TaKaH npe3yMllUHSI OlIpeAenHJIa apblX HaIUiOHanHCTOB ro C03HaHHH J1 3Ta 1I0nHTHKa IIOnaBneHIDI Hau HOHanbHO' HeBeHrepCKHX HaIUiH JIHmb CTHMYnHpOBana POCT HaIUiOHami3Ma a B HTore IIpHBena K paclIaAY caMOii BeHrpHH J1 Apyroii rrpHMep xaMa B 1840 KaHana IIpH ry6epHaTopCTBe nopna lIOPH­ rOAr OKa3aBllIHcb nHnOM K nHUY C B03MO KHOCTbIO pa3Aena KaHaAbI Ha aHrJIOH3bl'IHY1O H q paHKoH3bI'lHYIO TeppHTo pHH AO ero Ha3HaqeHHH TaM Y Ke pa3pa3HnOCb ABa BOCCTaHlUl nopA lIOPHxaM IIpeACTaBHJI IIpoeKT KOHCTHTYnHOHHbIX pe«P0pM 177 3TH pe p0pMhI OhmH TlUaTeJIhHO npororMaHhI H Ha HHX AO CHX CETOH-YOTCOH nop nOKOHTCH KaHaAcKaH AeMOKpaTHH OAHaKO B OAHOM H3 AOKY­ JIH6epanhHhIe rrOIIHTHKH la no TaK HO CJIeroreT XIX BeKa CKJIOHHbI TaK I e OTMeTJfTb 'lT0 6bmH OTO l AeCTBJIJ'ITb MeHTOB 060CHOBhIBaH CBOH pe pOPMhI JIOpA llropHxaM KaTeropH­ HHTepeCbI CBo60AhI C HHTepecaMH CBoeH C06CT8eHHOU HaIUIH 3TO qeCKH 3aHBJIHJI 'lT0 rOBopHlUHe nO- ppaHUY3CKH KHTeJIH KBeoeKa ­ Mbi BHAeJIH Ha rrpHMepe rroBeAeHHH aHfJIH'laHHHa B KaHaAe HeqTO JIWAH npHMHTHBHhIe 'lT0 HX ppaHUY3CKHH J'I3hIK aHaxpoHH'leH a BocnHTaBllIee HX rorXOBeHCTBO HaCTOJIhKO KOCHO qTO JIOPA nWpH­ aHarrOrH'lHOe Ha6JIwAleTCH CeH'laC B COBeTCKOM COW3e MHTeHCH­ pHKaUHH rrpOMbIllIIIeHHoro H 3KOHOMHqeCKOro pa3BHTHH Ha 6a3e xaM OTKa3hIBaJI eMY B npHHa rvre'lKHOCTH K KaKOH OhI TO HH Ohmo MeorrorHH Me l rorHapOAHoro KOMMYHH3Ma 6e3 TPYAl COqeTaeTcH KyJIhType nOPA llroPHxaM C'lHTaJI qTO ppaHUY3CKHM KaHaAuaM C BYJIhrapHbIM PYCCKHM HaUHOHarrH3MOM PyCH pHUHPYJ'I Y36eKOB OYAeT TOJIhKO ny'lllIe eCJIH OHH paCTBOpJ'ITCH B 60JIee pa3BHTOH JIHTOBueB aHrJIHHCKOH KYJIhType Ho qTO MhI BJfAHM CTO JIeT cnycTJ'I KBe­ npaBHTeJIH XOTHT y6eAHTh H 3TH HalJ HH H oKpY I aWlUHH MHP 6YATO 6eKcKHe ppaHUY3hI npe l Ae H 60JIee nOCTOHHHO HaUHOHaJIHCTH'lHhI TpeOYWT CBoero qeM KOrAl-JIHOO OTAeJIeHIDI OT KaHaAhI rrpoCTO YKpaHHueB CTPOHT H ApyrHe COUHaJIH3M HepYCCKHe HapoAhI COBeTCKHe fOBOPJ'I a6CTpaKTHO COUHaJIH3M MO I HO C'UITaTb 60JIee pa3BHTOH POPMOH qeJIOBeqeCKoro 06ruecTBa OqeBHAHO llroPHxaM COBepllIeHHO He nOHM qTO TaKoe HaUHOHaJIh­ HO Ha AeJIe AM Y36eKOB YKpaHHueB H IIHTOBueB OH 03Ha'laeT Hoe C03HaHHe KorAl JIWAH OAHOR KyJIbTyphl 3aHBJIJ'IWT APyroH Bcero JIHllIb PycH pHKalJ Hw To l e MO I HO CKa3aTb H 0 rrOJIHKaX qTO KYJIhTypanOCJIeAHHx aCCHMHJIHUHH OHH He M 3TO COBepllIeHHO HenOJIHOUeHHa npeACTaBJIHWT no rvre l HT 06 HX peaKUHH Ha cOBeTcKo-PYCCKHH HaUHOHaJIH3M l10A PYCCKHM C qeM peUIaWTCH HrpaTh H n03ToMY AlBrreHHeM rrorrHKH BbIHY l AeHbI 6bmH 3aHOBO rreperrHcbIBaTb CBOW He3aBHCHMO OT Toro qTO HeKOTophIe KyJIhTy­ phi AeHCTBHTeJIhHO 60JIee pa3BHTbI qeM ApyrHe B McnaHHH HaJIPH­ HCTOPHW AOKa3bIBaH 6YATO He Obmo Y HHX B TeqeHHe BeKOB 60JIee HaAe I HbiX APY3eH qeM PYCCKHe TaKaJ'I PaJIhCH pHKauHH pa3Apa­ Mep MHJIJIHOHbI oaCKOB H KaTaJIOHueB 3a MHoro BeKOB ycneJIH l aJIa He TOJIbKO rrpO peCCHOHaIIOB-HCTOPHKOB HO H PJ'IAOBbIX no­ npeBpaTHThCH B KaCTHJIhCKHX HcrraHUeB BepHee 6hmH a6cop6H­ IIHKOB A pe3YJIbTaT eCTecTBeHHo OKa3aJICH coBepllIeHHo 06paT­ HbIM 3aAYMaHHoMY poBaHhI H KaCTHJIhuaMH KaTaJIOHueB HalJ HOHaJIhHOrO M Bce npoAOJI I aeT l e orrpeAeJIeHHOe 'lHCJIO OaCKOB HaCTaHBan Ha coxpaHeHHH cBoe06pa3ID1 npeBpaTHBllIHCh B CBoero BOHHCTBYWlUHX YPEAH nOJI I eH npH3HaTbCH qTO B JIHOepaJIbHOM nOAxoAe XIX Be­ HalJ HOHaJIHCTOB Ka YPEAH MorYT MHoroe rrOqepnHYTb OT 60JIee pa3BHTbIX qTOObI ohICTpee K rrpo6JIeMaM HaUHH MHoroe rrpHBJIeKaeT H MeHJ'I l10qeMY MbI AOJI l Hbi CqHTaTb rrOpoqHhIM B3rJIHA qTO OTCTaJIbIe KYilbryPbI Ho He rrapaAOKCaJIbHO JIH qTO npHHH I eHHe H nOrJIOlUe­ no HHe HenOJIHOueHHbIX KYJIhryp HerOCYAlpCTBeHHbIX HaUHH OKa­ nOAHHThCH Ha TOT l e ypOBeHb ECIIH 3aJIHCh B AeBHTHaAuaTOM BeKe COCTaBHOH qaCThW BepbI B rrporpecc BepHa H HAeH BocnHTaHlIH nepeAl'UI 3HaHHH OrrhITa H MYApoCTH H3 KOTOPOH BhITeKaiia B03MO l HOCTh rrepeBocrrHThIBaTb HeBepHO TO nOTOM He­ qeJIOBe­ OT rrOKOJIeHHH K ApyrOMY Ecml Bce KYJIbTypbI paBHbI TO noqeMY Ka y6e l AeHHOCTH 'lTO He TOJIhKO rrpaBOM HO H AOJIrOM AeMOKpa­ l e MbI TaK BOCXHlUaeMCH beTXOBeHOM H He CJIHllIKOM BbICOKO THqeCKH MhICJIHlUHX 06pa30BaHHbIX JIWAeR J'IBMeTCH PYKOBOACTBO CTaBHM rrarryaccKHH pHTyaJI xpaHeHHH CKaIIbrrOB TeMH KTO HY l AleTCH B TaKOM PYKOBOACTBe CeH'laC paCCMaTpH­ BaH 3TO HBIIeHHe peTpocrreKTHBHO MbI MO l eM cpaBHHTb ero C OTeqeCKHM qyBCTBOM rrpeBocxOACTBa H BbITeKawruei1 H3 KorAa Bbi rOBOpHJIH 0 HalJ HOHaJIH3Me OaCKOB J'I BCnOMHHJI qTO rrHcaJI ll l OH CTwapT MHJIJlb OnbIT nOKa3bIBaeT qTO flaUHH Hero MO l eT CJIHTbCH C ApyroH 6hITb nOrJIOrueHa ew H eCJIH aCCHMHJIH­ Tpe60BaTeJIbHOCTbW HO TaK HJIH HHaqe B AeBHTHaAuaTOM BeKe poBaHHaJ'I HalJ HH 6bIJIa AO noro OTCTaJIOH HJIH He COBceM nOJIHO­ He06xOAHMOCTh H Al l e 06J'I3aHHOCTb norilOlUaTh HerrOJIHOl eHHhle KyIIhTYPhI COCTaBHJIa OAHH H3 Ba'lKHeHllIHX 3JIeMeHTOB pHJIOCO pHH rrpOCBelUeHHoro qeIIOBeKa ueHHOH AJIH Hee aCCHMHJIJ'IUHH - llIar BnepeA HaBpHA JIM MO I HO Th 'lTO rvrH 6peTOHueB HJIH AJIH OaCKOB ppaHUY3CKOH Ha­ OTPHua BapphI rrOJIe3Hee 6hmo rrpHo6lUHThCH K rorXOBHOMY MMPY BbICO­ KOi1 lJ HBHJIH3alJ HH BOHTH B COCTaB ppaHUY3CKoro HapOAa nOJIyqMTb 178 179 PP3HUY3CKoe rpa l DilHCTBO a BMeCTe C HHM H paBHbIe C pyrHMH ppaHUY3aMH npaBa H npeporaTHBbI CTaTb no 3aIIlHTY ppaHUY3­ CKoro rOCY DilpCTBa H roP J HTbCH ppaHUY3CKOH CHJIOH lJeM Tep3arb­ CJi OT CBoeH HenonHou eHHOCTH 3aMKHYBIlIHCb B CBoeM MaJIeHb­ KYJlbTypa K XOTH OCToHHa YBa l eHHH HMnepHH HClJe3no ClJaCTbIO He Bce - C paClla oM Heluo BeCbMa ueHHoe _ H60 ABCTpo-BeHrepcKaJi MOHapXHH Morna CTarb MHoroo6eIIlaIOIIIHM npHMepOM 06'beAHHeHHH HeCKonb­ CHlJeCKOrO llH6epaJIH3Ma H MHe He CllbIIIIHTCH B HeM HH HOTbI IPanb- KHX Hau HH B OAHOM rOcy 'apCTBe Ho fl04eMY l e OHa Bce-TaKH IIIH••• paCnaJIaCb IIoTO MY J yMaeTCH 'ITO OHa He CYMena YCTpoHTb rocy­ KaK npo peccop BbI BJIillIHHe MeHee 60nee HaBepHHKa TallaHTllHBOrO cnoc06Horo 6bI TomKO npHBeTCTBOBaJIH H npeycneBaIOmero cTy eHTa apCTBO TaK 'lT06bI pa3BHBaIOIIIHeCH KynbTYpbl Herocy apCTBeHHblX Ha Hau HH qyBcTBoBanH ce6H CBo60AHO B MHorOHau HoHallbHOM CO Py l eCTBe H OnbITHOro • 1la H BpH nH nepBoKypcHHK HJlH MeHee O J apeHHbIH cTY eHT 06H J HTCH eCllH ero peneTHTopoM BcnOMHHTe CllOBaKOB KOTopbIe 6bIllH BepoHTHO caMbIM OTCTa­ CTaHeT cTy eHT 60llee 3HaIOIIIHH BbIPOCIIIHH B 60nee HHTennHreHT' nbIM HOR ceMbe HJlH C 60nee IIIHpoKHM Kpyr03opoM XIX BeKe nHTepaType HayKe 3TO BnHHHHe OCYIIleCTBHJlOCb CBOIO KynbTYPY allH K BepXOM COBeplIleHCTBa BOBce HeT CaMH CKa3bIBaeTCH Ha lJepKeCCKOM Kor J a PYCCKHe nbITaIOTCH - 6e3ycneIIIHo PYCCKaH npoIIIl10ro 3TO KymTYpe COBceM pyroe H pa3YMeeTCH COBeplIleHHO PYCH pHu HpOBaTb KYllbTypbI 60nee pa3BHTbIe lJeM npoTHBOpelJHT CToneTHH HO He TonbKO llH6ePaJlbHbIM TeopHHM H BeCbMa Dill1eKOMY OT nH6epaJlH3Ma YlJeHHIO JIeHHHa KOTOPbIR npH3HaBan 'ITO 60nee pa3BHTaH Kynb' TYpa Bce paBHO B KOHelJHOM ClJeTe npeO 'OlleeT MeHee pa3BHTYIO a l e ecnH 60nee KynbTYpHoe HaceneHHe nO J IIa eT no BnaCTb MeHee KynbTypHoro Hapo J a TYT npaB J a JIeHHH nOBTopM MapK­ ca HO 06 HOM n03 1 e XVIII BeKa 0 Dil­ K IIIKOllbHOMY 06pa30BaHHIO J13BecTHoe IJHCllO CllOBal KHX IOHOlI1eM H DilneK OT Toro IJT06bI 0 06PHTb COBeTCKYIO nonHTHKY PYCH­ BOpHO BbIClIleMY Kllaccy BeHrepCKoro KopOlleBCTBa a HX Kpe­ nbI TO eCTb 6b1llH HeCBo60AHbI H 6eAHbI C OTCTanOCTb HAeaJIH3HpYH KynbTypHbIM 3ana ' TO eCTb rnaBHbIM BpeMeHH no cpaBHeHHIO C nonY HKHMH lJepKecaMH H3 TOM l e 3aBOeBaJlH peHHbIM CblHOBbHM CllOBal KHX KpecTbHH 6bIlla OTKpbITa opora 06pa30M AHrnHIO H Il paHu HIO KHHrH BnonHe BepoHTHO 'ITO CeHlJaC PYCCKoe BllHHHHe 6naroT­ HX flOCTHble l HJlH TaK l e KaK Bce KpenOCTHbIe CpeAHeBeKoBOM EBPO­ BeHrpbI H aBc-rpHMlI bI CKnOHHbI 6bIllH KPHTHKOBarb c06CTBeHHYIO BOCXO 'CTBa PYCCKHX nepCOHa l eR llepMoHTOBcKoro ''fepoH HalIlero BeHrpbI flO-CllOBal KH llH60 flO-BeHrepcKH OAHaKO He3aBHCHMO OT Toro BOBce pHKau HH HO Henb3H l e OTPHWlTb HanpHMep KynbTypHoro npe· Kor Dil CllOBal Koe KpeCTbHHCTBO npo 'Oll l anO rOBO­ Ha KaKOM H3bIKe OHH rOBOpHJIH CllOBal KHe peO DilllbI npHHa ll le­ He nOTOMY 'lT0 BeHrepCKHe HJlH aBCTpHHCKHe Hau HOHaJIHCTbI CIJH­ TanH ABCTpo-BeHrpHH pHTb Ha CBoeM H3bIKe TOr Dil KaK HX peO Dill1bl rOBopHllH llH60 no BllHHHHe aBCTpO'BeHrepCKOR KymTYPbI KOTOpaH npeBOCXO J HJIa HX B MY­ 3bIKe Hapo 'OM TbICHqy neT Ha3a KCTaTH He BH H HHlJerO AYpHoro H B TOM 'ITO CllOBaKH PYMbI­ HbI cnOBHHlI bI HJlH xopBaTbI nO J IIaJIH B eno 1laBaHTe eIIle flopaccY I aeM 06 ABcTpo-BeHr­ ABcTpHHcKaH ABcTpo-BeHrepcKoR KOM MHpKe OTrOpO J HBIIIHCb OT l H3HH MHpa TaKoB ronoc Kllac­ JI CETOH-YOTCOH pHH paHblI1e flOny4aJlO 06pa30BaHHe HO TOllbKO TeOllOrHIJeCKOe flOCKOllbKY HX rOTOBHJlH B CBHl I eHHHKH Tenepb l e K HHM flPHCO­ e HHHllCH OBOllbHO lI1HpOKHH CllOH MOllO J bIX ClloBaKoB KOTO­ pble YIJHllHCb BMeCTe C BeHrpaMH H HeMuaMH IJHTallH BeHrepcKHe H HeMel KHe KHHrH B HTore OHH YCBOHllH pacnpocTpaHHBlI1HeCH B TO BpeMH H 'eH Hau HoHallbHoro CYBepeHHTeTa 'eMOKpaTHH H T n OHH OC03HallH 3Ha4eHHe CBoero Hau HOHallbHOro H3bIKa H nOllb­ 3YHCb nOllYlJeHHbIMH 3HaHHHMH npHHHllHCb 3a pa3pa60TKY llHTepa­ TypHoro CllOBal Koro H3bIKa KOTOPbIH npH3BaH 6bIll 3aMeHHTb HeCKOllbKO pa306II1eHHbIX CllOBal KHX J HalleKTOB • 1lello HO 6bIllO He06bIKHOBeHHO 3aXBaTbIBaIOI I HM C03 DilTb CllOBal KHH Hau HOHallb­ HbIM H3bIK pa3pa60TaTb ero HaY'lHO HcnOllb30BaTb ero 60raTCTBa B nO HHlJeCKOM TBOplJeCTBe Bce lTO YBlleKllO 06pa30BaHHbIX CllOBaKOB OHH nOIJYBCTBOBallH nOTpe6HOCTb H Ollr 3arOBopHTb H 6bITb YCllbIlI1aHHbIMH BceMH KOMY CllOBal KHH H3bIK 6bIll POAHOM IIpe l 'e HHKTO He YTBep l iilll a H Ka3allOCb 6bI a6cYPAHo YTBep l aTb 'lT0 cymecTByeT CllOBaUKaH HaUHH llHlllb Ha TOM OCHOBaHHH 180 'ITO OKono MHllllHOHa lJellOBeK rOBopHT nO-CllOBal KH Ho KaK 181 TOJIbKO HeCKOJIbKO TbICH'l H3 HHX nony'lHnH eBponeHCKOe 06pa30­ BaHHe OHH CTanH 06HBaTbCH J1 11 CBoero Hapo a Tex iKe CB060 CETOH-YOTCOH la KOTOPbIMH nOJIb30BaJIHCb B TO BpeMH pyrHe eBponeHCKHe Hapo­ iKHM 0 cY b6e ra6c6yprcKoii MOHapXHlf I1 0 Cepe HHbI bI MeiK lJI CJIOBaKaMH BeHrpaMH PYMbIHaMH PYCliHaMH H T n He 6bIJlH CnOBaKOB CJIOBaUKaH nOCTeneHHO MHTCnnMreHJJ HH Tpe60BaHHH KaK CTaJIH BocnpMHHMaTb KaK HauIDO a Bce 60JIee HaJJ HOlIanbHbIe TBep 'o 3TO yny'lwaTb nOJIOiKCHMe HalJ HOHaJIbHbIMH 3TO 6bIna 60Pb6a CKopee MeiK y HMYmHMH H HeHMY­ BCTpeBOiKMnO 6blIlH C a B 3THX CTOJIKHOBeHH IIX OTpa f aJIHCb KOH pJIHKTbl ra6c6yprCKOH MO­ cnOBaKOB lIO 6bIJIM HC HapXMH C COccgHMMH roCY D apCTBaMH HaUHOHaJIlf3M He ycrreJI eme ror D a rrpeBpaTHTbC II B CaMOiJ OBneIDmHH nOnHTH'leCKHH PaKTOp Ho KaK TOJIb­ rOTOBbI npe OCTaBHTb HM CTaryc HaJJ HH TaK 3aPO MnCH KOH pnMKT KO no IIpOH30mno KaK TOJIbKO H D eH cYBepeHHTeTa HaUHH CBH3aHHaH BeHCKoe npaBMTenbCTBO co CBoeH CTOPOHbI TOiKe CTonKHYJIOCb C npo6ncMoH KYJIbTYP nO BnaCTHbIX pacrrpH mHMH JIHoo Me f y COrrepHH'laIDmHMH peO 'aJIaMH MnH KHH3bHMH MHor­ BeHrepcKHx rOCY apCTBelIHbIX eHTeneH OHM cornaCHbI He06xo HMOCTbID XIX BeKa CBOM BbI BMrana HaKoHeu 06 nOM HTOre 3a6bIBaTb He CJIe yeT Ho rrpo on­ CMY C H eeH 'CMoKpaTHH Bo06me nYCTHJIa KOpHH B cpe D e HHTennHreHuHH Herocy apCTBeHHbIX HalJ HOHaJIbHOCTCH Hoo OHH nOCTenCHHO npeBpamaJIHCb B KynbTY­ C pOPMHPOBaJIHCb H HaJJ HOHanbHble Tpc60BaHHH B03HHKna HaCTOHTenb­ pbI c006mCCTB OC03HaIDmHX cefuI HaJJ HHMM ECTb nM y nOH npo6ne­ HaH Heo6xo HMOCTb KaK-TO HX Y D oBneTBopHTb MMeHHo B 3TOM CYTb Mbi peweHHc TaK H OCTanOCb HeBbIHCHClIHbIM ABCTpiiHcKHe COlJ Ha­ rrp06JIeMbI KaK y 'oBnernopHTb HaIUIoHanbHble 'laHHHH KOTopble poiK­ nHCTbI Kapn PeHHep MOTTO EaYJp pa3paooTaJIH P ll lfHTepeCHblX iJ aIDTCH B H 'eH B 'laCTIlOCTH OliM npe J10 MJ1H 'lro6bI ueHTpaJIbHOC npaBH­ uenOCTHOCTH HaUHOHaJIH3M Y D OBJIeTBOpHeTC II TOJIbKO rpaHHuaMH KO­ TenbCTBO 3aHHMaJIOCb rocy apCTBa a BonpocaMH KaiK a ll KacaIDmHMHC II Bcex rpaiK aH ''lIaJJ HOHanbHOCTb'' ecnlf rrOJIb30BaTbCH c pepe KYJIbTYPbl He pa3pYlUa ll npH JTOM roCY apCTBeHHOH Topble COBna D aIDT C HaIUIOHaJIbHbIMH O HaKO HalJ HOHanbHoe C03HaHHe HH'lerO 1I0iJ 06HorO He Tpe6yeT JlHlUb Kor a OHo nO aBnHeTCH Kor a npHMeHHBwHMCH B ABCTPHH TepMHHOM rrony'lHJ1a nonHYID Kynb­ npaB IImaH HaIUI II CTpeMHTCH D eHaUHoHanH3HpOBaTb D PyryID JIHWeHHYID TypHyID aBTOHOMHID KOTOpa ll pacnpOCTpaH llnaCb 6h1 He TonbKO Ha c06cmeHHoii rOCY apCTBCHHocm HaIUIOHaJIbHoe C03HaHHe nOH nOCJIe D ­ HeH nepepaCTaeT B HaimoHaJ1H3M HaJJ HOHanbHOCTb KaK UeJIoe HO H Ha Bcex rrpe CTaBHTeneii JTOH HaJJ HOHaJIbHOCTH r e 6bI OHH HH npOiKMBanH HarrpHMep cnoBaK iKHBymHii B TpHccTe o6na an 6bI TaKMMH iKe rrpaBaMH B 06nacTH YPliAH HaJJ HOHanbIlOH KynbTyphl KaK H cnOBaK H3 ITpcwOBa Ero eTH monIDUHeii BalUa TO'lKa B3rnH D OB 3peHlUI nO-MoeMY XOPOlUO MnJIIDCTpHpyeTC II 'lelUCKoro HCTOpHKa H rrOJIHTH'leCKOro D e llTenH 1848 OJIiKHbI 6bInH 6bI IfMeTb paBHyID B03MOiKHOCTb rrony'lHTb 06pa30Ba­ I paHTHlUCKa ITaJIaUKoro Kor a B HHC Ha PO HOM H3bIKe Ha rrpaKTMKc O HaKO 3TH H eM He ocymecT­ BOBaTb BO I PaHK pypTCKOM HaUHOHaJIbHOM c06paHHH KOTopoe npH3Ba­ ro y 'leXOB npHrJIaCMnH Y'laCT­ BHJIHCb H60 COUHanHCTbI B ABCTPHH K BnaCTH Tor a He npHlWIH HO 6blIlO npoBo3rnacHTb e HHYID HeMeUKYID pe D epaUHID B rrpoTHBoBec a H Boo6me pewaTb lIaUHOHanbHYID rrp06JIeMY OKa3anOCb cnHwKOM ra6c6yprCKOii MOHapxHH ITaJlaUKHH OTKa3aJICH YTBepiK aH 'ITO ec­ n03 I HO JIH'lHbIC KaK TonbKO BcnbIXHYJIa lIaUHOHanbHOCTH nCpBa ll MHpoBa ll BOHHa pa3­ C pOpMHpOBanHCb B CHnbHbIe HaJJ HO­ HaJIbHble BHiKeHHH KOTopbIe YiKe lIeB03MOiKHO CTaJIO c epiKHBaTb nH 6b1 aBCTpHHCKoro roCY apCTBa He CYmeCTBOBaJIO Y f e HeCKOJIbKO CTOJIeTHl1 ero CJIe D OBaJIO 6bI C03 aTb HeMe J1eHHO ITanaUKHH nona­ raJI 'lT0 B03HHKHOBeHHe e J HHoro repMaHCKoro rOCY apCTBa ocna6Mno 6h1 ABCTPHlO H TeM caMbIM OrpaHH'lMnO 6b1 B03MOiKHOCTH J1H ManblX YPliAH HapHCOBaHlIa ll BaMH KapTHHa HanOMHHaCT HCTOPHID 6PHTaHCKOii H ppaHU l3CKOH HMnepHH TaM TOiKe BBenH 06Y'lCHMe KonOHManbllbIX HapO 'OB Bcne CTBHe 'lcro C pOpMlfpOBanaCb HHTen­ JIeKTyanbHaH a rr03iKe Ha'lana 06HBaTbCH H HaUHOHaJIHCTH'lCCKa ll JJIHTa KOTOpa ll CYBepeHmeTa 3apoiK aIDmHXCH HaJJ HH 'ITO B HTore nOBeno K pacna y nHX HMncpiiH HaUHii aBCTpHHCKOii HMIIepMH npoTHBOCTO llTb naHcnaBHcTCKHM npHTH­ 3aHH IIM PYCCKoro 3KcrraHcHoHH3Ma KaK H BeHrepcKoH HeTepllHMoCTH IlaJIaUKHH B pocTe PyccKoii D epiKaBbl cTpalliHoe 3no rOHaUHOHaJIbHaH ABCTPHH ClIoc06Ha crraCTH MaJIble HalJ HH OT nOrJIOmeHH II 3THM rai- KHM H Be3iJ ecymHblM caMO D ep f aBHeM YMeCTHee 182 YCMaTpHBan BeJIHKOe 6c D CTBHe ITo ero Tor allUfeMY MHeHHIO TonbKO CMnbHaH MHO­ 6bIJlO BIlOCJIe CTBHH 6bl rOBopHTb IlanaUKHH CTaJI 0 B HalUH IlH TYT ToranHTapHOM rOCY D apCTBe yMaTb HHa'le Ho ABCTpo-BeHrepCKHii 183 KOMDPOMHCC nOJIO KHJI KOHen ero Haue K l aM Ha 06peTeHHe qeXaMH craryca paBHonpaBHoii HaU UU B paMKax HMDepHH Torua OH rrpH­ COeUUHHJICH K rraHCJIaBHCTaM H qellICKHM Hau nOHaJIHCraM liMeHHo K 3TOMY BpeMeHH OTHOCHTCH H3BeCTHble CJIOBa ITanan Koro MhI CYlIJ eCTBOBaJIH UO ABCTPHH OCTaHeMCH H nocne Hee CETOH-YOTCOH ITpaKTHqeCKOe YUOBJIeTBOpeHHe Hau nOHanbHbIX Tpe60BaHHii - 3auaqa He06bIKHOBeHHO CJIO J HaH OHa He CBOUHMa K OTHOllIeHHHM Me K Jy BbIpaX aIOlIJ eii Hau nOHaJIbHble Tpe60BaHHH rpynrroii H Hau nOHanbHbIM npaBHTenbCTBOM KOTopoe 3TH Tpe60­ BaHHH npHHHMaeT HJIH OTBepraeT BMellIHBaIOTca B 3TH OTHOllIeHHH H UPyrHe CHJIbI B03HHKaIOT TpYUHOCTH C JaKOHouaTemCTBOM B Hrpy BCTynaIOT TaK JKe 3KOHOMuqeCKHe HHTepeCbI YUeJIbHbm Bec KOTOPbIX B Hau nOHaJIbHbIX U SH JKeHHaX orpoMeH Ho npH BceM npH TOM a B03BpalIJ aIOCb K cBoeii TJIaBHOii nu ee CJIeuyeT CllHTaTbca C Hau nOHanbHbIM C03HaHHeM KaK C q aKTOM lrrH MHJInHOHOB 06uraTeJIeii 3aMHoro llIapa - 3TO caMO co60ii pa3YMeIOlIJ eeCH uaHHOCTb qepe3 KOTOpyIO OHH ce6H OC03HaIOT 6narouapH KOTOPOH MOryT OTBeTHTb caMH ce6e KTO a C KeM a ECTb npaBua - OC06eHHO B pa3BHTbIX cTpaHax - nIOUU pa3­ BHBlliHe B ce6e paBHoUYlliHe K rrou06HbIM BonpocaM HO eCTb H Ta­ KHe Koropble nepe JKHBaIOT rny60KHH UYXOBHbIii KPH3HC H60 He yMeH onpeuenHTb CBoero a OHH rrpHHHMaIOTca MeTaTbCH B rrOHC­ Kax caMoonpeueneHHH Me JKUY HOBOii H36paHHOii HMH Hau neH nH6e­ panbHbIM HHTepHau nOHanH3MOM Me JKUYHapoUHbIM KOMMYHH3MOM 06'beIJ HHeHHbIMH HaIJ HHMH H T rr Hau nOHanbHaa KynbTypa 06ecrrequ­ BaeT nIOu HM Mepy HX 6bITHH q opMHpyeT HX B nHquOCTb YUOBneT­ Bopaa HX nOTpe6HOCTb HrpaTb onpeueneHHYIO ponb B JKH3HH Pal­ BHBaa H 3alIJ HIUaa H3bIK ox 06lIJ eHHH 11 a COBepllIeHHO y6e JKUeH qTO Hau noHaJIbHOe C03HaHHe JKH3HeHHO He06xoUHMO una nCHXO­ noruqeCKoro 3UopoBba Ka JKUOrO una HallieH HpaBCTBeHHOCTH Ho Bce JKe Henb3a C TaKoii JKe YBepeHHocTbIO CKa3arb 0 UpyrOM KaKoH uon JKHa 6bITb rocyuapcTBeHHaH CTpYKTypa KOTopaa C oUHoii CTOPOHbI o6ecnequBana 6101 n eHTpanbHOMY npaBHTemcTBY 3q q eKTHBHOCTb a C upyroii - CJIOC06CTBoBana 6bI 6ecrrpenaTcT­ BeHHoMY pa3BHTHIO Hau nOHaJIbHbIX Kynbryp BpeMeHaMH MHe uYMaeTca ttTO MO JKeT 6bITb nylffile coxpaHaTb KpynHbIe MHoro· HaU UOHanbHble rocYuapcTBa cnoc06cTBYIOlIJ He CHM6H03Y pa3nHq· HbIX Hau nOHanbHbIX KynbTYP qeM uenHTb HX Ha MHO JKeCTBO 184 HeoonbIIIHX rOCYuapCTB nH6epaJIH3M KOTOPblX ua JKe B OTHOllIeHHH K C06cTBeHHbIM rrouuaHHbIM BHymaeT COMHeHHe B TaKOM CJIyqae MO JKHO H nO JKaJIeTb 0 pacnaue ABcTpo-BeHrepcKoii H EPHTaHCKoii HMDepHii BeUb C upyroH CTOPOHbI onpaBuanoCb H TO ttTO npeu­ Bnu en ITaJIaUKHii B 1848 rouy• 1locTaroquo B3TJIHHYTb Ha Kapry EBponbl ttT06bI B nOM y6eUUTbCH 2 qeMY YllHT pacnau ABCTpo-BeHrpHH YPBAH Tenepb H 06palIJ aIOCb K BaM KaK K CblHY BbIuaIOlIJ eroCH OTu a KaK BioI paCn eHHBaeTe POJIb P B CeTOHa YOTCOHa H BHKxa­ Ma CTnu a ero 6JIH3KOro upyra H nOM01UHHKa npH pacnaue ABCTPO­ BeHrepCKOH MOHaPXHH BioI HaBepHoe nYttllIe upyrox 3HaeTe ttTO ox HMeHa - He caMble nonynHpHbIe y aBCTpHiin eB H y BeHr­ pOB C upyroii CTOPOHbI B rocYuapcTBax KOTopbIe 06pa30BaJIHCb Ha pa3BaJIHHax ABcTpo-BeHrpHH OHH 6bIJ1H Oc06eHHo B u sau n a­ TbIe-Tpuu n aTble rOUbI OBeHHbl ClIaBOH Pacnau crapeHllieH HMIIe­ PHH TeMa HHTepecHaH caMa n6 ce6e HO MeHH B UaHHbm MOMeHT OHa 3aHHMaeT npe JKu e Bcero nOTOMY qTO n enHKOM nouTBepUHlIocb npopottecTBo IIarraUKoro MHOrOHaD HOHanbHoe aBcTpo-BeHrepCKoe rOCYuapcTBo nepecTano CYlIJ ecTBoBarb HO BCKope nocne KOPOT' Koro nepHoua Hau noHaJIbHOii He3aBHCHMOCTH HOBbie rocyuapcTBa npe KJJ e HerOCYuapcTBeHHbIX Han uii ABcTpo-BeHrpHH KaK Bnpo­ tteM H rOCYuapcTBeHHbIX B nponmOM Han uH nou rranH nou BnaCTb CHaqaJIa HaU UCTCKOH fepMaHHH 3aTeM COBeTCKoii PoCCHH ITpuqeM 3a HCKnIOqeHHeM ABCTPHH H OTqaCTH IOrocnaBHH OHH Bce elIJ e noU 3TOH BnaCTbIO ocraIOTCH ABCTPHHCKaH HMnepHH paCKonOBllIaHCH Ha HeCKOJIbKO pee­ ny6JIHK B quClIe KOTOPbIX 6YUYT H COBepllIeHHO KapnHKOBble _ KaKoe BenHKonenHoe nOne unH 3KCnaHCHH pYCCKoro caMouep­ JKaBHH - nHcan ITanaUKHH B 1948 rouy A B 1918 rouy B pa3fap 6paToy6HiicTBeHHoro paCKOJIa HH npaBHTeJIbCTBa AHraHTbI HH TeM oonee OTUe1IJII01UHeCH HaU UH He 6bmH HaCTOnbKO npeUYCMOT' pHTeJIbHbI ttT06bI yqpeUUTb q euepaD HIO lleHTpaJIbHOii EBpoIIbI MeHH YUUBnHeT qTO HH rocrrOUUH CeTOH YoTCOH HCTOPHK HH rocnOIJ HH BHKxaM CTnu peuaKTOp Me JKu yHapoUHoro oTuena ra3e­ TbI ''TaiiMc'' TO JKe He CMOrJIH npeU SHueTb qTO HaJIHque B n eHTpe EBponbI He60nbIIDIX COnepHHttaIOlIJ OX pecny6JIHK npeBpaTHTCH 185 B HCTO'lliHK HecTa6Hl1bHOCTH BCerO eBporreHCKOrO MaTepH- Ka omOIlIeHHH K HMrrepcKoH fepMaHHH CaMH HerocYAapcTBeHHble HalUm ABcTpo-BeHrpHH ero BHa'laJIe He HHTepeCOBallYl IlOAXOA Moero OTlJ a 6bIJI cOBepIlIeHHo HHOH OH CTOJIKHyllCH CETOH-YOTCOH IlOAXOAbl CTH H MOerO OTlI a K nOMY Borrpo­ C TOH rrpo6lleMoH 6Y lJY1JM HacTpoeH BeCbMa rrpoaBcTpMitcKM MOR CY 6bInH He COBceM O l umaKOBbl Bo BpeMR rrepBOH MMPOBOH BOHHbI OTell C'lHTaJI 'lTO ABCTPHH 6hIJIa eCTeCTBeHHbIM COlO3HHKOM DPH­ OHM TaHHH H 'lTO HX AOllrOlleTHHH APY OO AOll Ha rrpOAOmKaTbcH OH 06a pa60TaIIM B 6pHTaHCKOM MHHMCTepCTBe rrporraraHAbI H 000 rrOAlJ ep HBaJIM HAelO YHH'ITO eHHH aBCTpO-BeHrepCKOH MMrre­ rrOHYlMall TaK e pMYl EBporrbI TaK B KOTopaH 1918 OrrpeAeJIHl1a 0 pHlI HaIIbHYIO rrOllHTYlKY AHTaHThI roilY Y HMX He 6bllO pa3HornacMit HaC'leT 6YilYIllero TOH Me K lJY orpoMHoe KaK ABYMH 3Ha'leHYle ABcTpo-BeHrpHH AllH BceR reorpa pYlIJeCKH OHa cny HJ1a BOAopa3AellOM caMbIMH OrraCHbIMH HMrrepHaIIHCTH'leCKHMH CYllla­ YlMIle pMH HO rrym ee pa3Aella OHH rrpeACTaBllHllH ce6e BCe-TaKYl MH rro-pa3HOMY· MOR OTell OTMeTYlll 'lTO ABCTpMitCKYIO HMrrepHIO HY HO coxpaHMTb CTHA rrpH6bll B ABCTPHIO B Ha'laIIe BeKa rrOelle HeCKOJIbKHX fepMaHHeR H POCCHeR B O J HOIf H3 CBOHX paHHMX cTaTeii HOO TOJIbKO OHa OXpaH fIeT EBporry OT repMaHcKoro HllH PYCCKoro JIeT clly 6bI B Ka'leCTBe KoppecrroHAeHTa ra3eTbI TaHMC B MTa­ HMrrepHaJIH3Ma llHH H fepMaHHH EIlle B MOllOAocm OH rrpHIIIeJI K BbIBOilY 'lTO 6blJIa 06YCllOBJIeHa ero BOCXYlIIIeHHeM BeHrpMeH OH C1JMTaJI BeHr­ repMaHCKaH MMrrepHH 6YAeT yrpo aTb MHPY M oc06eHHO BeJIH­ K06pHTaHMH OTCIO - ero y6e AeHHOCTb B He06xoAHMOCTH OT1JaCTH rrpoaBcTpMitcKa fl 1905 HOMbIIllJIeHHMKOB HMrrepHH 6bIJIH BeCbMa rrpoxna J HbI - BH J Hble HTaJIbHRUbI 6blJIH HaCTpoeHbl rrporepMaHCKH CTHA Tor C1JMTall 'lTO ABCTPHH AOJI Ha OTIIa fOAY BO BpeMH cBoeR rrepBoR rrOe3 KM B ABCTPO­ BeHrpHIO - HeKOTopble MOero poB Hall HeR JIH6epaJIOB KOTOpa fl cpa KaJIaCb 3a CBOOOAY H OTCTOH­ JIa ee B C03 Tb aHmrepMaHCKYIO KOallHlI HlO B J1TallMH OH BCTpeTHl1 eAH­ XOTH fl03HlI HH a no 6bIJIO KorAa OTHOIlIeHHH Me lJY ABYMR 'laCTHMH OH He 3HaJI Ha %10 CTOpOHy CTaTb TaK KaK OAHHaKOBO CMMrraTH3HpOBan 060HM MHoro flY­ rrOpBaTb C fepMaHHeH H C6llH3HTbCH C MTaIIHeH HOMHHaJIbHO MTa­ TeIlIeCTBYH rro BeHrpHYl MOR OTell rr03HaKOMYlllCH C MeCTHOR Hall H­ llHH fepMaHHH H ABCTPHH COCTaBmlJIH TpOHCTBeHHbIH COI03 HO OHaJIbHOH Me Ay HMMM HMeJIHCb M O'leHb cepbe3Hhle paCXO AeHMH Ilo noMY PYMblH xopBaTOB H CJIOBaKOB H flPOHHKCH K HHM OOJIbIlIHM CO­ rrpo6JIeMoH On rrOBCTpe'lan KHTeJIeR TpaHCHJIbBaHHH CTMA BCH'leCKM CTpeMHl1CH yKperrMTb rr03HlI HIO ABCTPHM B UeHT­ 'lYBCTBHeM 3TOT MOMeHT O'lenb Ba eH He 3a6bIBaHTe 'lTO OTell PaIIbHOH EBporre C5llH3MB ee C MTaIIMeR a MO eT 6bITb H C lDpaH­ MOH C1JMTan ce6 f1 I1IOrnaHAlIeM flO Hall HOHallbHOCTH H 6pHTaHlI eM lI HeH C TaKHMH rrllaHaMH OH M rrpMexaJI B BeHy HecMoTpH Ha TO 'lT0 CmA 5bIJI Bcero llHIIIb JpHaJIHCTOM OH aKTHBHO Y'laCT­ flO rpa ncTBY· ManeHbKaH I1IOTJIaHACKaH Hall HH flOcne MHorHX KeCTOKHX BOHn 06peJIa HaKOHell MHPHYIO KH3Hb 60K 0 60K C BOBall B rrOllHTM'leCKOH H3HH pa3'bHCHHH CBOH MAeH Ka AOMY aHrnYllJaHaMH M OH 6bIJI AO nora y6e KAeH 'lTO TOT e 06pa3ell KTO rOTOB 5bIJI CJIYI illITb HO B HTore y6eAHl1CH 'lTO CBH3b ABCTPHH MO KeT 6bITb oCYIlleCTBJIeH C fepMaHHeR rrpo'lHa a H3MeHHTb ee opHeHTall HlO HeB03MO HO YBH n eHHoe B BeHrpHH HaCTp0Hl10 ero rro-HHOMY H B UeHTpaJIbHOH EBporre O HaKO BeHrpbI BOBce OH YKperrHl1CH B nOM MHeHHH oc06eHHO rrOCJIe Toro KaK MHHHCT­ He BocrrpHHHManH PYMblH H CJIOBaKOB KaK paBHbIX Donee Toro pOM HHOCTpaHHbIX Aell ABCTPHH CTall 3peHTallb He paCC1JMTbIBaH OHH rrbITamfCb TH Hall HH AeHall HOHamI3HpoBaTb JIHIIIHTb HX qyBcTBa 06IIIHOCTH 60JIee Ha TOr I1IHHX rrpaBHTelleH ABCTPHH BHII li KaK ABCTPHH rrpeBpaIllaeTcH B COlO3HHKa fepMaHHH CTMA rrOHHll He06xoAH­ B aBcTpMitcKoR 'laCTH HMIIepHH rrOllO eHHe 5blJI0 HeCKOJIbKO MOCTb rrO Aep HBaTb JII06yIO cHllY KOTOpa fl rrpoTHBoAeHcTBoBa­ APyroe lla 6bl TOR TeHAeHlI HH A TaKoH CYlllOH 6bIJIM HeAOBOllbHhle Hero­ HeMeIIKHe Hall HH HO Bce e rrOCTOHHHO HaTaJIKHBanOCb Ha CTpeM­ CYAapcTBeHHble JIeHHH 'leXOB CllOBHHlI eB H APyrYlX lO HbIX CJIaBHH BbIHTH H3-rrOA aBcTpHHcKoro rocrrOACTBa CKoro M Hall MM KOTopbIe BeHCKoro BblcryrraJIM rrpoTHB rrpaBHTeJ1bCTB Kopo'le 6YAarreulT­ rOBopH rro Aep Ka CmAoM He-HeMelUorx H He-BeHrepcKHx Hall HH 6bIJIa CJIeACTBHeM ero 186 BeHcKoe rrpaBHTenbCTBO He flbITaJIOCb OHeMe1JMBaTb He­ CHMIIaTHH Moero OTlIa 6bIJIYl Ha CTopOHe cna6bIX OH BepHl1 B B03MO HOCTb TaK peopraHH30BaTb ABCTpo-BeHrpHIO 'ITo6bI 187 coxpaHHTb e ijiHOe HaU HOHanbHble rOCY l apCTBO Tpe60BaHHH HO YAOBneTBOpHTb COCTaBnHlOmHX ero rrpH HapOAOB 3TOM 3Toro CETOH-YOTCOH Pa3YMeeTcH OTel H rrocne BOHHbI cO l anen o rH6enH ra6c6yprcKoH HMrrepHH C'IHTaH 06beAHHeHHe rocYAapcTB He cnY'IHnOCb Ha' anaCb BoHHa ABCTpo-BeHrpHH OKa3anaCb B CTaHe UeHTpanbHoH EBpOIIhI BparOB 11 MOH OTel rrpHllIen K BbIBOAY 'ITO rronHTHKa AHTaHTbI Terrepb 'ITO H 310 He orrpaBAanoCb 'ITO 6a30H TaKoro 06beAHHeHHH Aon l a 6bITb HarrpaBneHa Ha pa3Aen ABCTpo-BeHrepCKOH HMrre­ pHH KaK BHAHTe B3fnHAbI P B CeToHa-YoTcoHa Ha aBCTpHHCKYIO rrpo6neMY pa3BHBanHcb cOBepllIelllio HHa'le 'IeM Y BHKxaMa CTH­ H Aa He rrpeYBenHqy ecnH CKa l Y 'ITO BrrnOTb AO 1914 rOAa MOH OTel OCJaBanCH BepHbIM APyroM ra6c6yprcKoH MOHapxHH KCTaTH IOrocnaBCKHe APY3bH Moero MO l eT CTaTb ManaH He06xoAHMbIM OH HaLJ eHnCH AHTaHTa IIOMHIO eme MbI 3HaeM 6YAY'lH MonoAbIM 'IenOBeKoM H eMY B03pa l an BH J I B ManoH AHTaHTe Bcero nHllIb aHTHBeHrepCKHH COI03 KOTOPbIH He Mor 3amHTHTb UeHTpanbHYIO EBporry OT rrOCHraTenbCTB HH I1TanHH HH POCCHH HH repMaHHH MHoro rr03 1 e Y I e HaKaHYHe BTOPOH MHPOBOH BOHHbI OTel CKno­ OTIJ a ' aCTO ero 3a 3TO HHnCH K HAee 06beAHHeHHH rrpHAYHaHCKHX rocYAapcTB A KorAa 1943 yrrpeKanH HOCH p CMOLJ naKa HarrpHMep rrHcan OTUY BbI nY'IllIHH 3Ta BOHHa Ha'lanaCb rrpHMepHo AO Apyr MH 3MHrpaHTcKHX rrpaBHTenbcTB IIonbllIH IOrocnaBHH H qexocno­ ABCTPHH BbI B nerrelliKY pa36HBaeTeCb 'IT06bI orrpaBAaTb rOAa OTel BMeCTe C 'lneHa­ aBCTpHHl eB Bee 3TO AOKYMeHTHpoBaHo B KHHre P B CeToH­ BaKHH YOTCOH H IOrocnaBHH KOTopaH H3 l aHa COBMeCTHO 3arpe6cKHM I HH Ho KorAa AOMHHHPYlOmeH CHnOH B 310M perHOHe CTan Co­ YHHBepcHTeToM H npHTaHcKoH AKaAeMHeH B nOH KHHre orry6nH­ KOBaHa BCH rreperrHcKa OTIJ a 3a 35 neT KOTOpylO Ben MOH OTel rro IOrocnaBCKHM AenaM 113 3T0H rreperrHCKH BH J HO 'ITO OH 6bll 60nbllIHM rrOKnOHHHKOM l paHIJ a- l ep l ijiHaHAa KOHe'IHO C TO'lKH pa3pa6aTbIBan rrpoeKT UeHTpanbHo-eBporreHcKoH peAepa­ BeTCKHH COI03 Bce rroA06Hble rrnaHbI OKa3anHCb Y I e 6eCrrO'lBeH­ HbI IIOMep I HBaH MOH OTel 06beAHHeHHe COqyBCTBOBan H HapOAOB HOBbIM UeHTpanbHOH EBpOIIbI rOCYAapCTBaM KOTopble 3peHHH cerO J HHllIHero J HH Y'lHTbIBaH BeCb HCTOpH'leCKHH OrrbIT B03HHKanH Ha pa3BanHHax ABCTpo-BeHrepCKOH HMrrepHH IIOAbeM MbI MO l eM CKa3aTb 'ITO BOCXHmeHHe Moero OTIJ a 6b1no HaBpHA CnOBaI U OH nH orrpaB l aHHO HO B Te rO l bI OTel HaAeHnCH 'ITO 3T0T Hacne J HHK PYMbIHCKOH ra6c6yprcKoro TpOHa crraceT MOHapXHIO BrrnOTb AO Ha'lana BOHHbI ycep J HO Y'lHnaCb 'IT06bI pa3BHBaTb CBOH H3bIK H KYIIhTYPY OH OTel Bblcryrran 3a l enOCTHOCTb ABCTPHH H Aa l e B rrepBble BoeHHble nlO6Hn rO l bI XOTH OH H rrOMep l HBan 06be l ijiHeHHe lO I bIX cnaBHHCKHX AoroBopa Hal HH H ero BOCXHman xopBaTCKOH rrOBTopHTb 1919 r 'ITO OH BOCTopranCH MOnOAe l blO HeCMOTpH Ha H3 CnOBaI KOH KpeCTbHH KOTopaH Bce HeAoCTaTKH MHpHOrO LJ nH pa3BHTHH HapoAoB UeHTpanbHoH EBPOIIbI rrpoBHHIIHH C Cep6HeH TpaHCHnbBaHHeH H PyMbIHHeH OH Bce eme CAenaHO 6bInO MaKcHMYM B03MO l Oro K He 6bIn y6e l 1 eH B He06xOAHMOCTH nHKBHAHpOBaTb aBCTpHHCKYIO 3HaeM MOHapXHIO O J HaKO rrocne rrpOBana rrOrrbITKH cerrapaTHoro MHpa perHOHa CHOBa rrorranH rrOA HPMO crrepBa - ABCTPHH CTanHHa Ho Bce I e 6bICTpoe pa3BHTHe 3THX HaU HH rrOATBep l Aa­ C 3arra J HbIMH COlO3HHKaMH COlO3HHKH OKOH'IaTenbHO B3H­ nH KYPC Ha pa3Aen ABCTpo-BeHrpHH BeCHOH 1918 ro l a H3MeHHTb Ta­ KYIO rronHTHKY 6bInO Y I e HeB03MO l O 3TH B03MO l HOCTH coxpaHHnHCb CO l aneHHIO KaK MbI HeAonro Hal HH 3T0ro rHTnepa rr03 1 e _ eT TeHAeHIIHIO KOTopaH Ha6nlOAaeTCH Ha rrpOTH I eHHH Bcero Halliero BeKa - KaK TonbKO HapOAbI 06peTaIOT CB060AY Ha'lHHaeTCH HH­ TeHCHBHbIH POCT HX Hal HOHanbHbIX KynbTYP H O'leHb 6bICTPO OHH YPEAH IIonaran nH Balli OTel 'ITO rrocne OKOH'laHHH BOHHbI BMeCTO ABCTpo-BeHrpHH AOn l eH BXO J lT B ceMblO COBpeMeHHbIX U HBHnH30BaHHbIX HaI HH 6bITb C03 l aH KaKOH-TO ApyrOH ypaBHoBellIHBalOmHH MexaHH3M B 3TOM paHOHe YPEAH B3rnH l bI P B CeToHa-YoTcoHa Ha HaU HOHanbHbIH Borrpoc BbI 06bHCHHeTe ero nH'lHbIM l H3HeHHbIM OIIbITOM KaK 1lI0TnaHAI a rro Hal HOHanbHOCTH H 6pHTaHCKoro rpa l AaHHHa 11 Bce I e HHCKonb­ II IIepJ urnaHA A'3CTe 1863-1914 BenHKidI KHH3b HacneAHHK aBcTpidl ­ CKOro TpOHa Ero y6id1 cTBO B CapaeBe nocnYlKHnO ABCTPHH npe lnoroM Ha'llln BOltHY npoTHB Cep6HH 3 O CTaTlO Ha'illnOM nepBolt MHPOBOlt BOltHbl 188 KO He COMHeBaJlCb B 6naropOACTBe ero HaMepeHHH H CKnOHeH LJ yMaTb 'ITO OH Ol eHHn rrOnO l eHHe B ABCTpo-BeHrpHH He COBceM BepHO MHe AYMaeTCH 'ITO HH B rrOnHTH'leCKOH nHHHH BallIerO 189 OTua HJI B 14 nYHKTax nporpaMMhI BHJIhCOHa He Y'IHThIBaJIHCb n03 J H0 pa3phIBaeT MHorOHaUHOHaJIhHhIe HMnepHH Ha 'IaCTH 11 CJIO l HbIe BHYTpeHHHe B3aHMOCBH3H CMelllaHHhIH xapaKTep Hace­ H He nYMalO 'IT06hl KBaJIHcpHKaUHH MORX KOJIJIer no OKCCPOPAY JIeHHH HJIH npyrHM YHHBepCHTeTaM Morna 6bI 'ITO-TO TYT H3MeHHTb H oc06bIe Tpa u HUHH HaUHH UeHTpaJIbHOH EBP0nhl KaK P B CeToH-YoTCOH TaK H BHJIbCOH OnHpaJIHCb Ha aHmo-aMepHKaH' QTO l e KacaeTCH n03HUHH yqeHoro BO BpeMH BOMHbI TO no CKHH OnbIT H HX HAeH MO l HO 6hlJl0 6hl CCPOPMYJIHpOBaTh TaK Bonpoc He H3 JIerKHX 11 B nepBylO KaK H BO BTOPYIO MHpOByro Hallla HCTOpm y6e lHJIa Hac 'ITO HapOA KOTOPhlH ynpaBJIHeT CBO­ BOHHY yqeHbIe He MomH He npHHHMaTb 6JIH3KO K cepnuy HHTepecbI HMH AeJIaMH H CaMHM c060M ynpaBJIHeTCH XOpOlllO a nOTOMY cBoeH cTpaHhI Benb ABcTpo-BeHrpHH neHCTBHTeJIhHO 6hlJIa BIIPH­ MhI nO J lJ ep I HBaeM npaBO Ha caMoonpeAeJIeHHe K3 I AOH HaUHH l eHa B repMaHcKYIO BoeHHYIO KOJIecHHuy H COBepllleHHO He CY­ OAHaKO HaUHH 6hIBllleH ra6c6yprcKoH I fMnepl fH MhICJIHJIH HeCKOJIb­ lUecTBeHHO 'ITO nYMaJIH no nOMY nOBOAY HeKOTopbIe aBCTpHHUPI KO HHoe TOJIhKO HapOA KOTOPhIH l I fBeT B CBoeM caMOCTOHTeJIh­ roCYAapCTBe HOM cB060AeH I f I fMeHHO no nOMY MhI Tpe6yeM caMOOnpeneJIeHI fH B nepBOM CJIyqae npeAnOJIaraeTCH 'ITO caMO­ ynpaBJIeHl fe Boro HBJIHeTCH npennOChlJlKOH nOCTpOeHI fH CB060AHoro H TOJIepaHTHoro 06llleCTBa cnpaBeMI f­ TOn a KaK BO BTO­ TaKHe npY3hH Moero OTua KaK 110CHCP PeAJIHX H OCKap RlllH QeT­ BepTh BeKa cnYCTH H H Me'lTaJI 0 no6ene MoeH CTpaHhI R He 6bIJI HaCTpoeH aHTHBeHrepCKH npH'lHH MH noro Y MeHH He 6b1JI0 Ho aHTHHeMeUKHe 'IYBCTBa y MeHH 6hIJIH H JIIDlIh HenaBHO HC'Ie3nII Pa3Be Mor H Torna nOpHUaTh CTaJIHHa COI03HHKa COrrnaThI KOTO­ POM AOCTH I eHHe HaUHOHaJIhHOH He3aBHCHMOCTH npOCTO OTO I leCT­ poro rH6JIH Ha HeMeIU OM cppoHTe Pa3Be MOr H Torna nOBepHTb BJIHeTCH co CB060AOH 11 BCKope HCTOPI fH AOKa3aJIa 'ITO OTO l leCT­ paccKa3aM nOJIHKOB 0 KaTbIHH Torna H HM He BepHJI H He Mor BJIeHl fe nOJIHTH'leCKOH CB0 0 J hI C HaUHOHaJIH3MOM Ha AeJIe 03­ Ha'laeT CB060AY HauHH 6hITh ynpaBJIHeMhIMH CKBepHO H AeCnOTH­ 'IeCKH I103BOJIhTe BhICKa3aTh elUe HeCKOJIhKO KpHTH'leCKHX BepHTb XOTH CeH'Iac 3HaJO npaBbI 6blJIH OHH Pa3YMHO JIH npenno­ rraraTh 'ITO yqeHhIH 3HaeT Bce He Mory OTBeTHTb R 'IeCTHo rOBopH H Ha nOT Bonpoc 3aMe'la­ Tenepb H CHOBa B03BparnalOCh K OTUY 06pa3 ero MbIIlIJIeHI fH HHH ECJIH TaKHe HaHBHhIe mUi He cnIDlIKOM 06pa30BaHHhie nOJIH­ CPOPMHpOBaJICH He TOJlbKO aHrnocaKCOHCKHM OnhITOM OH yrnerr XIX BeKa THKH KaK AOrryCTHM nJIOHA ll KoPA l qeM6epJIeH HJIH BYAPo C rorrOBoH B HeMe1 KYIO JIHTepaTYPY BHJIhCOH 3aJI orpOMHoe BJIHHHHe onbIT HeMeUKoro oCBo60nHTeJIbHoro nBH­ 3HaHHH KOTOPhlX 6hlJIH 'IHCTO KHH I HhIMH CYAHJIH 0 Ha l H3Hb ero OKa MHPOBhIX np06JIeMax HJIH nhITaJIHCh HX pelllaTh HaCKOJIhKO HM l eHI fH 60Pb6bI 3a e J HHCTBO HeMeIU Oro rOCYAapCTBa BepOHTHO no n03BOJIHJI HX JIH'lHhIH OrpaHH'IeHHhIH onhIT nO elUe MO l HO OH nepeOueHHJI JHIOepaJIH3M HeMueB Ho ny OlllH6KY COBeplllHJIH nOHHTh Ho KaK OTHeCTHCh K CJIHBKaM HallleH HHTeJIJIeKTYaJIhHOH H APyrHe TaK HJIH HHa'le ero KOHuenUHH 0 oynYlUeM ra6coyprcKOH H 6hI CKa3aJI xpaHHTeJIHM HarneH cOBecTH KorAa OHH MOHapXHH BKJIIO'lHrrH B ce6H He TOJlbKO aHrJIOCaKCOHCKHH HO H 3JIHThI BCTynaJIH B nOJIHTH'lecKyro l H3Hh OKOH'lHB OKCcpoPA HJIH nOA06· HeMeUl HH Hhle caMoonpeneJIeHHH QTo l e KacaeTCH CnIna TO ero llJIaHbI YTBep l le­ l e npeCTH I HhIC yHHBepcHTeThI C cOBepllleHHo TaKHMH l e JIH6epaJIH3M xapaKTepHble AJIH nOcrre J Hero MOneJIH lllOPaMH Ha rJIa3ax 11 AaJIee npOCTHTeJIhHO JIH Y'lCHOMY AeTep­ HI fH neMOKpaTHHH B UeHTpaJIbHOH MHHHpOBaTb CBOH oueHKH nOJIHTH'leCKHX C06hITHH BO BpeMH BOHHhl Ha CPPaH1 Y3CKYIO MOneJIb HH TOT HH ApyrOH llJIaH He OblJI pea­ HHTepecaMH cBoeH CTPaHhl KOTOPaH yqacTByeT B nOH BOHHe JIH30BaH Ho COMHeBaIOCb 'ITO HMeHHO aHrJIOCaKCOHCKHH YKJIOH MhIIlIJIeHHH Moero OTIIa - CETOH-YOTCOH BepoHTHo Bhl npaBhI Ho cpaKT OCTaeTCH cpaK­ TOM KorAa KyJIhTypHhle co06lUeCTBa HCIIhIThIBalOT HeynOBJIeTBO­ peHHOCTh CBOHM nOJIO l eHHeM a HaAHaUHOHaJIhHhIH EBpone onHparrHCh CKopee npaBHTeJIh MHorOHaUHOHaJIhHOrO rOCYAapCTBa B KOTopoe OHH BXOWIT 'Iy­ nOJIO l eHHH npH'lHHa HeCOOTBeTCTBHH HhIHelllHero UeHTpaJIbHOH EBPOllhI ee Hane l laM OblJIa elUe H CPPaHUY3CKaH MOneJlb KOTopaH He OTBe'laJIa peaJIbHOCTHM UeHT­ parrhHOH EBponbI H HeMel KaH KOTOPaH K C'IaCTblO He peaJIH30Ba JIaCb H60 OKa3aJIaCb CrrOMJIeHa CTOHBlllaH 3a HeH CHJIa l aK He MO l eT HX HaUHOHaJIhHhlX Tpe60BaHHH YAOBJIeTBOpHTh OHH CTaHOBHTCH B3phIB'IaThIM B elUeCTB OM KOTopoe PaHO HJIH YPEAH PeIIUITeCh ·rrH BhI YTBep l laTb ceH'IaC 'Iepe3 llleCTbneCHT JIeT nocrre KpYllleHHH ABcTpo-BeHrepCKOH HMnepHH 'ITO Barn 190 191 OIeu H BHKXaM cum neHCIBOBaJIH XOnI 61 1 C 1914 no 1918 r UeHTpaJIbHYID EBporry Korna TaM npeycrreBaJI 4 arnH3M Ho 'lI06bI oueHHBaTb Iy HJIH HHyro nOJIHTHKy HY HO copa3MepHTb ee C nOTpe6 B npaBUJIbHOM HanpaBJIeHHH HOCTHMH BpeMeHH BOHHbI ee 4 opMHpOBaHHH npoulB ABCTPHH BemfK06pHTaHHH Torna a 6bma B HaUHOHaJIbHhle KOHe'lHo ceH'laC H BID ' C06bIIHH B COBeprneHHO COCTOHHHH HHOH nepcneKIHBe B HHOM MeJK J YHapOnHOM KOHTeKCle Bo Bpe­ nBH eHHH MeHa Moero OIua cyrnecIBOBaJIa CIa6UJIbHaH H 'lpe3BbI'laHHO Mory­ B nOCJIenHHe HeneJIH BOH HbI He opHeHTHpOBaTbCH Ha HHX 6bmo 6bI meCIBeHHaH 6PHIaHCKaH HMnepHH H OH na e He 6yny'lH HaHBHbIM HeB03MO HO ECJIH 6bI 6pHTaHCKoe pPaHUY3CKoe H aMepHKaHCKoe CETOH-YOTCOH nonpbIBaJIH MOfJIH aBClpO-BeHrepCKYID 3aClaBHTb CBOHX MOHapXHID rp3 naH H3HYTpH HMnepHaJIHCTOM HMeJI OCHOBaHHH nYMaTb 'lTO 6eJIbIe aHrJIOCaK­ npaBHleJIbCTBa COHCKHe nOMHHHOHbI OCTaHYTCH B COCTaBe AHrJIHH ABCTpo-BeH­ HOCHTh BoeHHble MYHUHPbI nOCJIe npeKparneHHH BoeHHbIX neHCI­ npOnOJI alb repCKaH HMnepHH KaK HaM H3BeCTHO CeH'laC 6bma JIHlIIb nepBOH BHH 'lI06bI cnoc06CTBoBaTb OnTHMaJIbHbIM H3MeHeHHHM B EBPO­ H3 BeJIHKHX HMnepHH KOTOPOH npenCTOHJIO paCnaCThCH no nora ue 3TH H3MeHeHHH BepOHTHO 6bmH 6bI HHbIMH MO HO 6bmo 6bI He 6bmo npeueneHIa eCJIH He C'lHTalb pa3YMeeTCH pa3BaJIa OT­ HaupHMep n06HTbCH jT06bI TeppHTopHH 3a THCOH He 6bma OIopBa­ TOMaHCKOH HMnepHH Ho Torna rneCThneCHT JIeT Ha3an MaJIO KTO Ha OT BeHrpHH HJIH YCTaHOBHTb 60JIee CnpaBe lllHBbIe rpaHHUbI lllH cnoc06eH 6bm MbICJIHTb 0 MYCYJIbMaHCKOH HM­ BOJIrapHH Ho enBa JIH CTOHT 06 3TOM rOBopHTb npH yCJIOBHHX nepHH B Tex e KaTeropHHX 'lI0 H 0 xpHCTHaHCKHX Torna HeJIh3H 'lTO BeJIHK06pHTaHHH l paHUHH H AMepHKa nOJIHOCTbID neM06H­ 6bmo erne npenaHneTb KaK nOBJIHHeT naneHHe BeJIHKOH xpHcTHaH­ CKOH HMnepHH H Ha COCTaBJIHIDlUHe ee HaUHH H Ha oKpy aIDrnHe JIH30BaJIH CBOHX COJInaT H BePHYJIH HX Ha ponHHy H3 eBponeHueB ClpaHbI OnHaKO aHaJIH3HpYH ceronHHlIIHHH MHp HeJIh3H He BHneTh YPEAH 'lTO paCKOJI 6PHIaHCKOH HMnepHH npOH30rneJI COBeprneHHO HHa'le rocynapCTBeHHbIX neHTeJIeH 3anana KOTopble HeCKOJIbKO HHa je 'leM aBCTpO-BeHrepCKoH KpoMe Toro npeKpaTUJlH CBoe cymecTBo­ npaBna CKa3aJIHCb H nOCJIe BTOpOH MHPOBOH BOHHbI na 3TO eme OnHO ne jaJIbHOe CBHneTeJIbCTBO 0 Ka jeCTBax BaHHe H pPaHuY3CKaH H npyrHe MeHee KpyrrHbIe KOJIOHHaJIbHhIe HMnepHH Ha'laJIa pa3BaJIHBaThCH H pyCCKaH HMrrepHH HO ee CETOH·YOTCOH Ho 3TO e H CBHneTeJIbCTBO 0 ne4 eKTax CnaCJIH 60JIbrneBHKH CneJIaB erne 60JIee eCTOKOH 'leM UaPCKaH neMOKpaTHH Bo06me Hano npH3HaTb 'lTO B YCJIOBHHX HeCTa6UJIh­ I10 nOMY naneHHe ra6c6yprcKoH HMnepHH CJIenyeT paCCMaTpHBaTb He H30JIHPOBaHHO a KaK nepBbIH aKT B MHPOBOH npaMe pacrrana Horo MHpa neMOKpaTHH - HMnepHH I10 noMY 'lT06bI rrOHHTh 'lTO 6bmo rrolepHHo rrpH Kpy­ JIy' rne HHKTO nOKa He npHnYMaJI HHH Qep'lHJ1J1h 3TO He CaMaH 34 4 eKTHBHa H popMa npaBJIe­ npH3HaBaJI n06aBJIHH JI OnaaKO jTO HH'lerO He YBepeH 'lTO 3TO 3By' HT rneHHH ABCTPHHCKOH HMnepHH H 'lTO nOJIyqHJIH rocynapcTBa KOTO­ y6eUHTeJIhHO rrpH Bcex 06CTOHTeJIbCTBaX 'lTO BCHKoe aBIOKpaTH­ pbIe B03HHKJIH Ha ee pa3BaJIHHax CJIenyeT nOMHHTh 0 60JIee 1I03n­ 'leCKOe HeM OUbITe HMnepHH - 11 Torna He MO eT 6bITb nayx MHeHHH Ha pa3BaJIHHaX BO HMH caMoynpaBJIeHHH CrrpaBe lllHBOCTH H n 06pono­ rocynapCTBo rrpH JIID6bIX 06CTOHTeJIbCTBaX xy e Mac­ COBOH neMOKpaTHH Benh aBIOKpaTHH HJIH OJIHrapXHH B OTJIH jHe OT neMOKpaTHH cnoc06HbI no KpaH HeH Mepe nOCJIenOBaTeJIhHO pMO'lHOCTH B03HHKaJIH OnHO 3a npyrHM rocynapcTBa C HCKyccIBeH­ n06HBaThCH HbIMH npaBHTeJIbCTBaMH nOJIHTHK KOTOPbIH cTpeMHTcH CneJIaTh Kaphepy B neMOKpaTH jec­ H rnOBHHHCTH'leCKHMH HneOJIOrHHMH C nOJIHTH'leCKOH cHcTeMoH KOM rocynapcTBe BbIHYJK J eH neH CTBOBaTh B COOTBeTCTBHH C CHID­ rpaHHuaMH C HaUROHaJIHCTH'leCKHMH ocyrneCTBJIeHHH enHHO ALI npHHHThIX perneHHH A BeCbMa naJIeKOH OT HneaJIOB neMOKpaTHH DeHoMeH MaJIbIX rocy­ MHHyTHbIMH eJIaHHHMH H36HpaTeJIeH a no npH3HaTbCH He JIy' ­ napCTB KOTOPbIH B03HHK B UeHlpaJIbHOH EBporre B 1920·e rOALI II1HH peuenr pacnpOCTpaHUJICH 3aTeM Ha IO HYID A3HID H A PPHKY 11 Bce e oueHHBaH nOJIHTH'lecKyro n03HUHlO OIua H no BceH BepOHTHOCTH OTHeCYCh K HeH nOJIO HTeJIbHO 11 He rrOTOMY jTO OHa rrpHMH3H­ JIa Hac K HneaJIY H npeKpaCHO 3HaIO jTO 3TO He UK H60 BHneJI 192 YPEAH Ho BO BpeMH BOH HbI 3ananHbIe neMOKpaTHH Bce-TaKH nponeMOHCTpHPOBaJIH CBOID crroc06HOCTb K caMOUHCUHJ1J1HHe I10'leMY e OHH He YMeIDT nO HHaTb J1J10AbI CBOHX n06en I10'leMY 193 OHH Hccnoc06HhI COXpaHHTh TID yIO Ke o HCUHIUIHHY KOr o a3aMOn· KaIOT nYIIIKH nepe o MO KCT 6hITh nOpa KeHHe qep'lHnnH Ha BhI60pax OKOH'laHHC' BTOPOH MHPOBOH BOHHhI 'ITO-TO npOHCHHeT B 3TOM BOnpOCC CEI'OH-YOTCOH TIpe K o e Bcero cne o yeT OTMeTHTh pa3nH'lHe Me K l y POCCHHCKOH HMnepMeH M ABCIpo-BeHrpHeH J1 B nponmoM M CeHlJaC POCCHH npe o cTaBJIHeT C060H yrp03y JIH o pyrHX CTPaH qero 06 ABcTpo-BeHrpHH CKa3aTh HeJIh3H 3TO He 3HaqHT qTO B ABcTpo-BeHrpHH B pa3nH'lHbIe nepMOAhI ee HCTOPHH He COBepIIIanHCb CEI'OH-YOTCOH COrnaCeH qep' HlUIh pO K l CHHe o eMOKpaTHH OH BOBce He THnH'lHOe no­ BhIxo o eu H3 apMCTOKpaTOB M 06pa3 ero MhIIIIneHHH OTnM'laJICH OT pH o OBoro 6pHTaHua cepe o HHhI 40-x ro o OB CYIUeCTBeHHoe JIH qep' HnJIH He 6hIJIO TaKOBhlM JIH Mac­ npecTyweHHH qTO TaM He Ohmo penHrH03HhIX rOHeHHH HO rao­ coyprcKyIO MOHapXHID Henb3H CpaBHMBaTh o a Ke C J1cnaHcKHM KOpOJIeaCTBOM OHa HMKor o a H HHKOMY B EBpone He yrpo Kana COBepeIIIHHO HHoe o eno POCCHH POCCMHCKaH HMIIepHH pa3paCTa­ COBoro MHeHHH I OJIhIIIMHCTBO nOJIHTH'leCKHX o eHTeJIeH KOTophle naCb KaK paKoBaH onyxom c06cTBeHHo M BepiliaT HCTOPMW KaK B I pMTaHMM TaK M B o pyrMx KeCTBa npeBpaTHBIIIMCh B orpOMHYIO o ep KaBY OT 3m6bI 0 0 KaM­ o eMoKpaTM'IeCKMX rocy o apcTBax o OCTMraIOT BJIaCTM nocpe o cTBoM BhI60pOB Henocpe o cTBeHHo Bcne o 3a OKOH'IaHHeM nepBoH MMpO­ I IOH BOHHhI CTOHBIIIMe Tor o a y BJlaCTM nOJIMTMKH Mano 3a60THnMch 06 06ecne'leHMH npO'lHOrO M cnpaBe JIMBOrO MHpa B UeHTpanhHoH EBpone H60 He no BonHOBano H36HpaTeJIeH 06IuaH nocneBoeHHaH YCTanocTh CJIa6aH HHIPOpMHpoBaHHocTh H OTCYTcTBMe TBep o oro nonHTH'IeCKOrO PYKOBO o CTBa a pe3yJIhTaTOM Bcero noro OKa­ 3anCH nocne BOCHHOH KaTacTpoIPhI He o OCTaTOlJHO npo o YMaHHhIH MHP KOTOPhIH nocnY KHJI nOlJBOH JIH HOBbIX eIUe 60JIee KeCTO­ KHX BoeHHhlX KaTacTpoIP H3 ManeHbKoro MOCKOBCKoro KHH­ qaTKM O I HOBpeMeHHo HaCa K l aH nOBCIO o y TbMY COBepIIIeHHO HenOHHTHO noqeMY TeppMTOpManbHaH HenpHKOCHO­ BeHHOCTh nora HMMaThCH KID orpoMHoro rocy o apCTBa-Monoxa o on KHa BocnpH­ CBHIUeHHaH KopOBa Me K l YHapO I HOH nOnMTHKH I y o eT TonhKO KO onary ecnM na HMIIepHH pa3BanHTCH M3HYTpM a BXO I HlUMe B Hee HaURH OT o eJIHTCH qTO COOCTBeHHO H CJIY'l HnOCh C ABcTpo-BeHrpMeH 51 eIUe pa3 no o qepKMBaIO qTO K HaUHOHanhHhIM KynhTypaM yr­ HeTeHHhIX HaUMH cne o yeT OTHOCHThCH C YBa KeHMeM TIpaBo HaUHO­ HanhHOH KynhTYPbI Ha CYIUeCTBOBaHHe KaK M npaBo nIO o eH paJ· nH'lHbIX HaUMOHanhHOCTeH pa3BHBaTh KynhTypy CBoeH HaIJ HH CTOJIh Ke HenpenO KHO KaK npaBO qenOBeKa 6b1Tb CBOOO l HhIM rpa K o a­ 3 COBeTCKHH HMnepHanH3M HMHOM CBoeH CTpaHbI TIpaBo YKpaMHueB HnM TaTap TIOBOJI KbH ooeperaTh M pa3BHBaTh CBOIO o peBHIOIO KynhTypy YPBAH B nOCJIe I HHe rOAhI He o OBonhCTBO HepyccKHX HaUHH CCCP npH6JIH KaeTCH K nYHKry Kor o a no o yrp030H MO KeT OKa­ 3aThCH uenOCTHOCTh COBeTCKoro rocy o apCTBa TO eCTh C03 o aeTCH cHTyaUHH no o 06HaH aBCTpO-BeHrepCKOH B nOCJIe I HHe rOAhI npaB­ neHHH fa6c6yproB TIo TeJIhCTBa ero CTpeMneHHe nO I BeCTM Bce HaUHOHanhHbIe B TOM ' Hcne M PYCCKYIO KyJIhrypbl no o TOTanhHhlH KOHTpOnh rocy o apCT­ Ba Hero ueHTpa B MOCKBe OCYIUeCTBJIHeTCH I ByMH nyTHMH H ooeMM 3THM TeH o eHUHHM CJIe o yeT npOTHBOCTOHTh o aHHbIM nOCJIe I HeH nepenMCM HaceneHMH y o enhHbIH Bec PYCCKHX B CCCP pe3KO ynan Cei1 'lac OH COCnlBnHeT OKOJIO He nO JIe KHT COMHeHMIO HblHeIIIMHH Ke HMnepCKaH nOnMTHKa COBeTCKoro npaBM­ 50% Bo-nepBbIX oonee nonOBHHbI HaceneHMH CCCP KHBeT B ycno­ BMHX B KOTOPbIX MX npaBO Ha HaUHOHanhHoe CYIUeCTBOBaHHe HO npo o on KaeT na o aTh TaK 'ITO M HaUHOHanhHaH CTpyKTypa CCCP IIo o aBJIHeTCH J1 ecnH MhI o eHCTBHTenbHO BepMM B npOB03rnanreH­ npH06peTaeT CXO o CTBO C HaUHOHanhHOH CTPYKTYPOH ABcTpo-BeHr­ Hhle HaMH npHHUMIIbI TO o OJI KHbI pHH HaKaHYHe pacna o a HMnepHH aBCTpHHCKHe HeMUbI M BeHrphI COCTaBnHnH Tor o a 60% 400 0 HaCeJIeHHH a Herocy o apcTBeHHhle HaUHM KaKoBo nO-BanreMY 3Ha'leHHe nMX o aHHhlx no npaBO HauHif 3aIUHIUaTh BO-BTOPbIX nhITaHCh nMIllHTb HaUMH IIpaBa Ha HaUHOHanhHoe CYIUeCTBOBaHHe qTO BnpOqeM oe3 reHoUM o a BOOOIUe HeB03MO K­ HO COBeTCKoe npaBHTeJIhCTBO C03 o aeT KPM3HCHYIO cHTyanmo CTHMYJIHPYH KOHIPJIHKT KOTOPbIH no o pbIBaeT YCTOHllMBOCTh caMO­ 194 ro COBeTCKoro oOIUecTBa A 3TO qpeBaTO cephe3HoH onaCHOCTbIO He TOJIhKO I JIH COBeTCKoro COI03a HO H JIH Bcero MHpa 195 KaK MbI nOJDKHbI OTHOCI1TbCH KO BCeMY 3TOMY JlOIDKHbI JIH 6eraJIH rOJIblIUOM no necaM 3ana J HOH EBponhI TypKecTaH Y l e MbI CO'lYBCTBOBaTb HepYCCKHM yrHeTeHHhIM HaUlUIM HJIH l e CTapa­ 6bll pa3BHTbIM KymTypHbIM ueHTpoM 06 3TOM OnHaKO HHKTO HCh COXpaHHTb ueJIOCTHOCTh COBeTCKOH HMnepHH H npHBMerHpO­ H HI1KOI J a BaHHOe n0110 l eHHe PYCCKOH HaUlm B HeH 3aHHTb CTOPOHY HMnep­ rOBOpHT HHKTO el1Ie H3 npe J CTaBI1TeneH 3ana J a He BbIcTynM B CKOrO COBeTCKOrO PYKOBOIJ CTBa 51 11H'IHO - Ha CTOpOHe yrHeTeH­ C IpH6YHbI OpraHH3a u HH 06bC ll1HeHHbIx HaUHH He OOH C rpe60BaHHeM npe J ocTaBI1Tb He3aBHCHMOCTb Y36eKaM HbIX HaUHH MbI BCe nOn l HbI clJ enaTb TaKOH BbI60p BO-nepBbIX nOTOMY 'ITO 3TH HaUHH 3aCnY l HBalOT YBa l eHHH H CHMnaTHI1 CO YPEAH CTOPOHbI CB060 J HbIX HapOnOB 11 BO-BTOPbIX nOTOMY 'ITO COBeTCKl1e CCCP KaK B Me l J YHapOnHbIX enHHoe uenoe 11 OTHOIUCHlUIX MbI BocnpHHHMaeM eCJIH MbI npHMeMcH BhIcTynaTb 3a PYKOBO J HTe11H BCer J a H Be31J e BbICTynalOT npOTHB naIUHX HHTepe­ npenOCTaBJIeHHe He3aBHCHMOCTH BXO J Hl1IHM B CCCP HaUIUIM TO COB MbI IJ 011 1 HbI HaKOHeu OC03HaTb TOT npOCTOH Q aKT 'ITO OHH KaK HaJllH nOnHTH'leCKHe neHTenH H l ypHaJIHCThl CMorYT onpaB­ H CCTb HalUH npOTHBHHKH 3TO He 03Ha'laer 'ITO CJlelJ yer J aTb raKHe J Ba B3aHMOHCKJIIO'IalOl1IHe nO 'xo J a pa3BH­ 3bIBaTb BOHHY 'Iero MbI He XOTeJIH B npOIUJIOM 11 He xorHM ceH­ 'lac 1I0 MbI HH B KoeM cnyqae He nOJl l HbI cnoc06CrBOBaTb yKpen­ CETOH-YOTCOH neHHIO B I1X BnaCTH HanpOrl1B MbI BCH'IeCKH IJ On l HbI CTaparbCH ec OCJIa6Hrb 51 He BH I Y 3neCh HHKaKoro npOTHBOpe'lHH KOHUe KOHUOB COBerCKHH COlO3 caM Ha3hIBaCT ce6H MHoro­ HaUHOHaJIhHbIM rOCY J apCTBOM COBCTCKHe PYKOBO J HTenH npl13Ha­ IlOMep l Ka CHn OCJIa6mllOl1IHX MOl1Ib nporHBHHKa - pa3YMHoe nOJIHrH'IeCKOe nOBeneHHe COBCrCKI1H COlO3 TaK nocrynaeT BCerlJ a lOT pa3JIH'IHH Me l J y YKpaHHuaMH HanpHMep 11 6eJlopycaMH HJlH '1epKecaMH TaK nO'ieMy 06 JIHX pa3nH'IHHX He MO l eM rOBO­ 11 nOBCIO J y OrKpbITO H raHHO OQ I1Ul1aJIbHble COBeTCKHe npencra­ pHrh MbI B Me l J YHapO J HbIX OTHOIUeHHHX H COe J HHeHHble IlITaTbI BHTC11H H COBeTCKHe areHTbI Hcn011b3YlOr npOTHB Hac mo60e npo­ H COBeTCKHH COlO3 npl13HalOT rpaHHUhI J pyr IJ pyra HHKTO C06CT­ 6ynb n0 O J HO H3 nneMeH M03aM6HKa BeRHO H He Tpe6yer '1T06hI COBeTCKHH COlO3 OTKa3aJICH OT npH­ KOTopoe MO l HO BOBne'lb B napTH3aHCKYlO BOMRY B POlJ e3HH 3HM­ HBneHHe HaUHOHaJIH3Ma Ha J JIe l al1IHX eMY TeppHTopHii Ho eCJIH l enaHHe OT J eJlHThCH BhIpa­ 6a6Be H11H YTOH'ICHHble Q paHUY3CKHe HHTeJIJIHreHrbI Yl1IeMneH­ l alOr Herocyn apcTBeHHhJe HauHH CCCP 3T0 COBceM J pyroe neJIo HOCTb KoropblX no OTHOIUeHHIO K COCIJ HHeHHbIM IlIraraM npOHBJIH­ BHHMaHHe K HepyccKHM HaUHHM COBercKoro COlO3a H nO J ep l Ka eTCH COBepIUeHHO HHa'le HO nOnHTH'IeCKH B onHllaKOBOH CTeneHH HX I1cnonb3ycrcH B HHTepecax COBeTCKoro COI03a npOHBJIeHHe 11 raK KaK 111060e HenpHH3HH K 3analJ HbIM crpaHaM craHOBHrCH op ' KHeM CCCP nporHB Hac ro Heneno HC OTBe'larb rCM l e_ B OpraHH3aUHH 06be J HHeHHbIX HaUHH craJIO CBoero pOlJ a nor­ cTpeMneHHH coxpaHHrb HaUHOHaJIhHYIO KYJlbrypy 'Iero OHH He MorYT ClJ enaTb B HbIHelUHHX ycnoBHHX BOBce He nO J crpeKa­ TenbCTBO K 6YHry H OT J eneHHIO Eor CBH J eTem 'ITO COBeThI nOJI­ HOCTbIO OBJlalJ eJIH IlocMoTpHTe 'ITO HCKYCCTBOM pa3 I HraTb HeHaBHCTh K npOHCXOnHT B 3anan y l1pJIaHnl1H 11 KaK HCnOJIh3YlOT Y MOH 'Iro C60e npaBHre11bCTBO Ba I Hee xopOUle20 npaBHTenbCTBa COBeThI 3T11 BOnHeHI1H B CBOHX HHTepecax HaH6011ee npaBa '1HTaTb HaM MOPaJIh eCJIH MbI J a l e HanOMHHM yrHeTeHHbIM nOCJIe J OBaTe11bHO npHnep I HBalOrCH raKOH TO'IKI1 3pe­ HI1H crpaHbI rpeTbero Ml1pa B COOTBerCTBHI1 C JIOH IJ OrMOH Hace­ HI1X HeT HHKaKoro HaUHHM CCCP 0 npaBe HaUHH Ha caMoonpe J eJIeHHe neHHe BepXHeH B011brbI H11H 111060ro nO J 06Horo perHOHa I1MeeT no MHCHHIO CTpaH TpeTbCrO MHpa npaBO Ha HaUHOHa11bHYIO He3a­ BHCHMOCTb 51 He 3HalO eCTb 11H y HaceneHHH BepXHeH BonbTbI CBOH HaUHOHaJIbHaH KynbTypa HO eCJIH eCTb TO OHa HMeeT nonHoe YPEAH COBeTCKHH COlO3 npenCTaBJIeH B OpraHH3aUHH 06benH­ HeHHhIX HaUHH TpeMH H3 15 COBeTCKHX pecny6JIHK DhITb MO l eT I1pHIUJIa nopa HalUHM nOJIHTHKaM npe lJIO I HTh COBCTCKOMY npa­ npaBO Ha HaUHOHaJIbHOe CYl1IeCrBOBaHHe Ho no KaKOH l e npH'lHHe BHreJIbCTBY OTKphITh nOCOJlhCTBa 3ana J HbIX cTpaH el1IC H B KHeBe rOf J a oTpHuaeTCH raKoe l e npaBo Ha HaUHOHaJIbHOe cYl1IeCrBO­ H MHHcKe BaHHe 3a Y36eKaMH l1x KY11hTypa B03HHKJIa 60JIee 3-x ThICH'I JIeT Ha3a J Korna HalUH npenKH 6bIJIH el1Ie IJ HKapHMH KOTopble 196 197 CETOH-YOTCOH II no 6b1J1o 6hI BrrOJIHe 060CHOBaHHO MOiKHo KOHeqHOM CqeTe XIX Bcero qeJIOaeqeCTBa IIMeHHO HCXO J H H3 3T01'O 6hmO 6hI OTKphITh rrOCOJIhCTBO H B Y36eKHCTaHe Bep h no OqeHb JIH6ePaJIbI B KpynHaa pecrry6JIHKa TaKoro pop a rrpe llllO l eHHa y e BHOCHnHCb HalUlH B OAHOM rocyp apcTBe JIpep CTaBJIHeT C060H rapaHTHIO HX BepHnH qrO cocymecTBoBaHHe HeCKOJIbKHX rO lJ hI HO COBeTCKHe rrpaBHTeJIH HX OTBeprJIH a rr03 e HX CB060 lJ hI Ha nOM MeCTe MOH Bo06pa aeMbIH COBeTCKHR rrpep CTa­ KaK-TO 3a6hmH••• OAHaKO Tpe60BaHHe 0 CBa3ax C COlO3HhIMH pec­ BHTeJIh MO l eT rrpHBeCTH lUITary H3 KHHrH AKTOHa TaM rp e rry6JIHKaMH Ha ypOBHe rrOCOJIhCTB COBeprneHHO 3aKOHHO 'lIHTepec­ HalUlOHaJIbHhle rpaHHUhI COBrrap aIOT C rrOJIHT eCKHMH 06meCTBO B 40-e rrepeCTaeT pa3BHBaThCa a HalUla OKa3bIBaeTca B rrOJIO eHHH qeJIO­ HO KaK pearHpOBaJIH 6hI Ha no pYCCKHe CeHqac IIomITaeMca rrop BeCTH HTor CKa3aHHOMY IIpaBo HalUlH 6hITb BeKa KOTOPhIH OTKa3bmaeTca 06maTbca C p pyrHMH JIIOP bMH HalUleH HeocrropHMO qTO l e KacaeTCH rrpaBa HalUlH Ha CaMOCTOH­ B TeJIbHOe rocyp apcTBO no Borrpoc HHOH HalUla HO y6e J eHHe QTO HalUla MO l eT 06pa30BaTb rocyp apcTBO OT COOTHOrneHHH CHJI Ero perneHHe 3aBHCHT Me J y HalUlHMH B MHorOHalUlOHaJIbHOM rrpOTHBOpeqHT rrpHpop e COBpeMeHHOR lI HBMH3alUlH HallleMY rocyp apcrne ECJIH cornaCHa rro nOMY Borrpocy B MHorOHalUlO­ HaJIhHOM rocyp apcTBe He p OCTHrUYTO a XOTa 6hI oAHa H3 HaIUrii rrpop OJI aeT CTpeMHThca K OTp eJIeHHIO TO C03p aHHe ee He3aBH­ PaMKax rocyp apcrna CO BpeMeHeM MO l eT cQ OpMHpOBaThCa H COBeTCKOMY c06eceP HHKY MO l eT rrOKa3aThca qyO 3THM OH noqTH BhlHrpaJI crrop H OH 6yp eT rrpop OJI aTh TaK Hayq­ 3TO BhIcrnaa cTyneHb rro CpaBHeHHIO C 6yp a3- HhiH COlUlaJIH3M CHMoro rocy o apCTBa 3aBHCHT OT ee crrOC06HOCTH nora P OCTH% HhIM JIH6epaJIH3MOM COBeTCKoe rocyp apcTBO - II Bce l e rrpaBO HaUHH 6hITb HalUleii eme He 03HaQaeT qTO Ka J aH BOBaHHaH rrOJIHT eCKaa HaIIHH AKToHa a COBeTCKHR rpa J a­ no YCOBeprneHCT­ H3 HHX p OJIiKHa HMeTh He3aBHCHMoe rocyp apcTBO p a e eCJ1H eH HHH - yp acTCH ro Hapop a 3aKoHhi cocymecTBoBaHHH HaIlHH B cOBeTcKoH rrOJIH­ P 06HTbCH He3aBHCHMOCTH rrpH HalUlH Ha Hall HOHaJIhHOe rocyp apCTBO rrOMomH He CHJIhI IIpaBO CJIep yeT B03BO J HTb B p orMY Torp a KaK rrpaBO HalUlH Ha HaUHOHaJIhHOe cymecTBoBaHHe ­ npep CTaBHTeJIb 3TOR HOB OR rrOJIHTHqeCKOH HalUlH COBeTCKO­ T ecKoH HalUlH rapaHTHpYIOT Ka p OH HaIlHH H Ka P OMY rpa ­ P aHHHY rrpO HBaromeMY rrop TOTaJIhHbiM KOHTpOJIeM COIlHaTlH3Ma rrOJIHYIO cBo6op y A 3aKOHqHTb CBoe BhIcTYI1JIeHHe 3TOT cOBeTcKHH HX HeOT'beMJIeMOe rrpaBo rrOJIHTHK MO eT eme OAHOH CChIJIKOH Ha AKToHa CaMhiM OrraCHhlM YPSAH ECJIH 6h1 a B 6ecep e C BaMH rrpeP CTaBJIaJI COBeTcKHH rrpoTHBHHKOM HalUlH rroHHMaH COI03 a BhICTynaJIH6h1 MbI rrepep aHrnO-aMepHKaHCKOH aYAHTO­ MeHHaH pHeH P OJIiKHhi TO rrhITaaCb 3aBOeBaTh pacrrOJIO l eHHe rry6JIHKH a BOBce He CChIJIaJICa 6hI Ha JIeHHHCKyro HaUHOHaJIbHyro TeopHIO a rrpOCTO orpaH Hnca 3aMeqaHHaMH Bpop e TaKOro B XIX TeopHH CTaBHT B HaIIHOHaJIH3Ma HBJIHeTCH cOBpe­ HalUlOHaJIbHOCTH YTBep J aa 6bITb paBHOBeJIHKH Hall HHM HepaBHOrrpaBHOe rrOJIO eHHe qTO rocyp apcTBa na TeopHH Ha rrpaKTHKe Bce HalUlH BXO J HmHe B B HeKOTophle COCTaB MHorOHalUlOHaJIhHbIX rocyp apCTB H crroco6cTByeT HCTpe6­ HCTOPHKH HarrpHMep AKTOH oyqeTJIHBO pa3JI aJIH CBH3b JI OCTH JIeHHIO HerrOJIHOIleHHbIX pac HX rropa60meHHIO HJIH JIHrneHHIO Bcex C ero paCOH HJIH HaIIHeH qHCTO Q H3 eCKyro CBa3b H CBa3b qeJIO­ rrpaB IIpH6JIH3HTeJIbHo TaK Mor 6bI rHrrOTeTHqeCKHH cOBeTcKHR rrpep ­ BeKa C rocyp apcTBOM HnH rrOJIHTHqeCKOH HalUleil TO eCTh HaUHeil rrpaBO KOTOPOH Ha He3aBHCHMoe HalUlOHaJIbHOe rocyp apcrno rrpH3­ HaeTca - Peo rrOHHMaH ny CBa3h KaK HpaBCTBeHHYIO BHOJIO­ CTaBHTeJIb rOBopHTb B 3anaoHou He MapKCUCTCKOU ayouTOpuU BepHYBlllHCb oAHaKO B MocKBY OH CHOBa 6yp eT rroBTopHTh CTaH­ r eCKaH CBa3b JI HOCTH C ee HalUleii rrpe06JIap aJIa B rrepB06hIT­ p apTHhle HOM HO rrOTepana 3HaqeHHe B lUIBHJIH30BaHHOM 06meCTBe BJIaCTH HaIlHOHaJIbHOH rro Q 0pMe H COlUlaJIHCmqeCKOH rro cop ep­ llHBHnH3alUla KaK 6h1 Tpe6yeT rrpH3HaHHH JI OCTblO BepXOB­ JIeHHHCKO-CTaJIHHCKHe Q OPMYJIHPOBKH 0 cOBeTcKoH aHHIO H 0 TOM qTO aCCHMMHlUIH 3TH eCKHX rpylI1l H HX H3bI­ Horo aBTopHTeTa rocy o apCTBa HJIH rrOJIHTHqeCKOH HalUlH TaK KaK KOB TOJIbKO B ropHIDIe rocy o apCTBa rrpOTHBOpeqHBhIe H 3rOHCTHQeCKHe a3blKe rrpOHCXOAHJIa eme P O C03p aHHH COll HaJIHCTHQeCKOrO rocy­ HHTepeCbl p apCTBa JIIOP eH OAHOH HalUlOHaJIbHOCTH TPaHCQ OPMHpyroTca B rapMo oe e J HHcrno Ha 6JIaro rocyp apcrneHHOH HalJ HH a B H KpynHhlMH TaK HalUlaMH KaK rOBopHmHMH MaCCOBoe KarrHTaJIHCT eCKHR PbIHOK Ha pacrrpOCTpaHeHHOM KarrHTaJIHCT eCKoe CTpeMaTCH K rrpOH3BOP CTBO YHHQ HKalUlH - B TOM CJIe H HalUlOHaJIbHOH 198 199 CETOH-YOTCOH ro nOJIHTHKa fl BaRHff AKTOHa HeBepHa fl BbI BeJIHKOJIerrHO CrrpaBHJIHCb C pOJIblO COBeTCKO­ OJ HaKO OrraCaIOCb qTO MOH orneT Ha BbICKa3bI­ 6Y lJ eT OqeHb npOCT ero KOHuenUH H HCTOP H - lJ onycKalO qTO TaKaa oueHKa AKTOHa Mo eT IIlOKHpO­ Bblpa eHlIff CTaJIHHa COOTBeTCTBHlI TO rrO-MoeMY ero CJIen yeT HcnpaBHTb C lJ eHCTBHTeJIbHOCTblO BeTCKHH COlO3 CJIe u YIOlUHM 06pa30M B Co­ 3TO rOCY lJ apCTBO COUHaJIHCTHqeCKOe no cpopMe H HMrrepHaJIHCTHtIeCKOe no con ep aHHlO BaTb llOKa3aTeJIbCTBO Moero YTBep lJ eHlIff rroTpe60BaJIO 6bI MHoro BpeMeHH H 3TO HHKaKoro OTHOIIleHlIff K TeMe HaIIleH C BaMH 6ece l hI He HMeeT ITHtIHO II C 60JIbIIleH cepbe3HOCTblO OTHOIIlYCb K lJ OBon aM 4 YCBOlIT JIH Hapo u hl A J PHK ypOK 3 CTOP KOTopble npHBOAffT COBeTCKHe npen CTaBHTeJIH BOT O lJ HH H3 TaKHX eBponeitcKoro HIlUHOHaJIH3Ma n OBO lJ OB HaUHH COBeTcKoro COlO3a H BOCTOqHOH EBporrbI UHaJIHCTHqeCKHe HaUHH KpecTbffH no xapaKTepy HX PYKOBo lJ HTeJIH - nH n eTH pa60qHX H HaUHH OTJIHqalOTCff OT KOTopble HatIHHaJIH HaUHOHaJIbHOe lJ BH eHHe 11 co­ 6yp a3HbIX 3TO BepHo IIpaBH­ YPEAH Bbl y e rOBOpHJIH qTO B HaIIle BpeMff HaKOl1J1eH 60nbIIlOH OnbIT HaCqeT Toro qeM tIpeBaT pacna u BeIIHKHX HMnepHH H qero B rrepHO lJ pa3BaJIa ra6c6yprcKoH MOHapXHH lJ a e He rrpen nOJIara­ ny TeJlbCTBa ynpaBnHlOlUHe COBeTCKlIM COlO30M II cTpaHaMH BOCTOtI­ nH HOH EBponbI B OCHOBHOM COCTOffT H3 JIlO lJ eH HMeHHO TaKoro COUH­ tITO MHorHe n aJIbHOBHJ HbIe HCTOPHKH KaK TonbKO yBJi lJ HT tITO aJIbHOrO npOllCXO lJ eHlIH Ho TeM He MeHee OTHOIIleHHe HbIHeIIlHHX MbI rronb3yeMcff He lJ OCTaTOqHO y6e lJ HTenbHblMH aHaJIOrHffMH 06BH­ BeHrpOB nOJUIKOB H Y36eKOB K HHT Hac B rrpen B3ffTOCTH pyCCKHM MaJIO qeM OTJIHtIaeTCH fl npe JIaralO rrpo u OJI HTb TeMY HMeff OJ HaKO B BHn y OT OTHomeHlIff HX 6yp ya3Hblx npen IIleCTBeHHlIKOB IIo HbIHeIIlHe­ My HaUHOHaJIbHOMY C03HaRlIlO nonffKOB BeHrpOB II Y36eKOB He CETOH-YOTCOH nOXo e tIrO OHH BOCrrp HlIMalOT COBeTCKYlO lIMnepHlO KaK rocy­ ABCTPHHCKOH n apcrBo KynbTypa KOToporo KaqeCrneHHO rrpeBOCXOn IH lIX HaUHO­ UY3CKOH HaJIbHble KynbTypbI BTOPOH n OBO lJ COBeTCKHX npen CTamueneH K aHaJIOrHH BCer lJ a OTHOCHTeJIbHbI HO II rrocrapaIOCb u OKa3aTb qTO KOTOPOMY H II HMeeTCH OTHomYCb cepbe3HO 3aKJIlOtIaeTCff B TOM qTO C 1917 HeKOTopblX aHaJIOrHH On Ha H3 HHX KacaeTCff rocy u apCTB B03HH­ r HaUHlI MbI u eHCTBHTenbHO MO eM cpaBHHTb pacrran HMnepHH C TpaHccpopMaUHeH fOJIJIaHn CKOH H EpHTaHCKOH IIopTyraJIbCKOH HMrrepHH n OCTaTOtIHO Han e Haa OCHOBa no KpaHHeii Mepe JIH CCCP n 06l1JIHCb KOJIOCCaJIbHOrO 3KOHOMHqeCKOrO rrporpecca rro­ KalOlUHX Ha TeppHTopHHX 6bIBlIIHX HMrrepHH lJ pyraa BbICHJICff H ypoBeHb HX 06pa30BaHHocTH - nHTHtIeCKOrO HHbIMlI CJIOBaMH COBeT­ CKlIH pe HM nOCTpOHJI JIff nlOn eH cpa6pHKlI H IIlKonbI rrp Hecff TeM Bce no 01IIH6aIOTCff nonaraH qTO 3a caMbIM npaBlUeJIlI 60nbIIlYlO nonb3y rrpaB lJ a Ho COBeTCKHe 3TO HepyccKlIe HaUHlI 6yn YT 6naro lJ apHbI CBOHM pyCCKHM X03ffeBaM Y36eK paccMaTp ­ $paR­ KOHeqHO pa3BHTHff MeTpOrrOIIHH nOCJIe nan eHHff BHyTpHno­ HMnepHH ABCTPHH AHrnHH l paHUHH Pa3BHTHe UeHTpaJlbHOH EBpOIlhI nOCJIe pacrra a a ABCTpo·BeHrpHH xapaKTepH3yeTcff HenpepbIBHbIMH KOHcpJIHKTaMH Me lJ y CTpaHa· MH KOTopble B03HHKJIH Ha ee Pa3BaJIHHax He Bce OHH 6bmH no lJ ­ BaeT ynytIIIleHlIe cBoeH H3HlI KaK pe3ynbTaT CBoero Tpyn a H npo­ JIHHHblMH HaUHHMH-rocy u apcTBaMH nOCKOJlbKY MHorHe BKnlOqaJIH ffBJIeHlIff nOnO lITenbHbIX KaqeCTB CBoeH HaUHH cqHTaff IIpli nOM B ce6H KpynHble HaUHOHaJIbHble MeHbIIlHHCTBa OJ HaKO OHH 6bmH tIrO nporpecc 6bm 6bI elUe 60nbIIle eCJIH 6bI Ha IIlee Y36eKOB He HaUHOHaJIHCTaMH B TOM CMbIcne qTO B03rJIaBnHJIHCb HaUHOHaJIHCTa· CH lJ eJIH pYCCKHe BeCbMa BepOffTHO qTO Y36eK nOT HenpaB HO MH ero qYBCTBa HMeHHO TaKOBbI TOqHO TaK e KaK y HH D yca HaxO­ C n pyrOM tIeM Bnocne u crnHit BOCnOIIb30BaJICH fHmep lJ HBIIlerOCff rron HaUHOHaJIHCTHtIeCKHe rrpaBHTenbcTBa BPa n OBaJIH n pyr ro cnO lJ CTB OM TaK qTO COBeTCKaff HetITo rro lJ 06HOe Ha5IIlOn aeTcff ceHtIac B AcpPHKe ECTb KOHeqHO lIMnepllH non nan aeT no lJ lJ eHCTBlIe on Horo H3 Ba HeHIIlllX 3aKOHOB H pa3JIHqHH HOBbIe BHOBb B03HHKalOlUHe aCPPHKaHCKHe rOCY lJ apCT­ HCTOPHlI 3aKOHoMepHocreH CTOp qeCKOrO pa3BlITlIff KaK npen ­ Ba KOTopble CKna u blBalOTCff Ha MeCTe KOIIOHHH OXBaTblBalOT non nOqHTalOT 6PHTaHCKlIM 3TH rOBopHTb pyccKHe HEEITAfOllAPHOCTI1 200 qTO e 3AKOHA KOITOHllAnbHOM KacaeTCff rrpHBe lJ eHHoro BaMlI On HOM BnaCTblO MHO eCTBO pa3HOH3blqHblX l1J1eMeH Y MeH MO eT B He lJ aJIeKOM 5yn YlUeM pa3BHTbCH 3THX rrIIe­ HaUHOHaJIbHOe 201 C03HaHHe H Torna OHH HaqHYT nOOHBaTbCJ'l CaMOOnpeneJIeHHJ'l BnJIOTb nOHJ'lTHHM BOnJ10THJ1a HX ycnex rapMoHmo KaK OHH ee nOHHMaJIH no OTneJIeHHJ'l MJ'l npHMepa MO J HO BcnOMHHTb 3aHp H AHrOJIY qTO Ke KaCaeTCJ'l aMepHKaHueB ro OHH npHBerCTBOBaJIH HaCHJ1bCr­ Ho CeHqaC rOBopHTb 0 non06HOH B03MO J HOCTH eme npe KneBpe­ BeHHoe 06l eAHHeHHe Hapo J oB HHrepHH a TeM caMblM H nO J aBJ1e­ MeHHO IloKa3aTcJIbHo B nOM OTHomeHHH COMaJIH rne Hau HOHaJIb­ HHe Hoe nBH KeHHe COMaJIHHueB nopa3HTCJIbHO nOXO Ke Ha n BH KeHHJ'l npe J cTaBneHHJ'l 0 rocynapcTBeHHOCTH Bce eme nHtalOrCJ'l BOcnOMH­ pyMbIH H cep60B nepen I1epBOH MHPOBOH BoHHon Ii nBH KeHHe liHacppbI no COBepIIIeHHo HHbIM MOTHBaM AMepHKaHcKHe HaHHeM 0 rpa KJ1 aHCKOll BOHHe CeBepa npOTHB lOra OTneJ1eHHe B COMaJIHHueB HanpaBJIeHO Ha OO'henHHeHHe Hau HH qacTb COMaJIHn­ CBere nora OnbITa BbIrJ1J'l J HT KaK J'lBneHHe orpHuarCJ1bHOe no ca­ ueB nonaJIa non BJIaCTb 3qmonHH npyraH - MOll CBoeH cymHOCTH BO K J b cenapaTHCTOB liHacppbI BOcnpHHHMaJI­ non BJIaCTb KeHHH a B03HHKIIIee COMaJIHHCKOe rocynapCTBO CTpeMHTCH HX OO'beAH­ CfI aMepHKaHUaMH KaK CBoero pona qepHbIll l KecpcpepCOH lell­ HHTb aHHCKCHPYH TeppHTopHH Ha KOTOPbIX COMaJIHHlf bI COCTaBJ1J'l­ BHC lOT Hau HOHaJIbHbIe MeHbIIIHHCTBa napCTBeHHOH ueJIOCTHOCTH TaKHM 06pa30M HenpHH3Hb H BemfKO­ Ero CJ1e J OBaJIO pa3rpOMHTb qT06bI ycrpaHHTb yrp03y rocy­ IloJ1HTHKa 3CPHOnHH npH HMncpaTope XaHJ1C CeJ1aCHH 6bma B 6pHTaHHH H Coe J HHeHHbIX lIIraroB K He3aBHCHMOll EHacppe AHKTO­ CYIIUIOCTH cOBepIIIeHHo TaKoH Ke KaK nOJ1HTHKa BCHrpHH npH BaJIaCb rJ1y60Ko YKopeHHBIIIHMHCJ'l B 3THX crpaHax crepeOTHnaMH llBollcTBeHHoM COI03e eCJ1H Ma bHpH3au HIO 3aMeHHTb B naHHOM MbIIIDIeHHfI Il03TOMY nOCJ1e Toro KaK EHacppa 6bma paJrpOMJ1eHa CJ1yqae aMxapH3au HeH H aMxapHllcKHM Ha3bIBalOT H3bIK nOMHHH­ yqpe K J eHO ueHrpaJIbHOe npaBHreJ1bCrBO aHrJ10J'l3bNHbIll MHp pYlOmell B 3cpHonHH HaUHH la H CellqaC XOTJ'l TaM UapHT xaoc BepHJ1 'ITO npaBHTeJ1bCTBO e J HHOH HHrepHH OTHecerCfI K n06e K J eH­ Bce Ke 06Hap BaeT ce6H CTpeMJ1eHHe HaBH3aTb aMxapHHCKYIO HblM C BeJ1HKO J yIIIHeM a HHrepHil cKaH npOOJ1eMa 6Y J eT nOJ1HOCThlO KyJ1bTYPY npyrHM HapO n HOCTJ'lM HaCeJ1HlOlUHM 3cpHonmo B HHre­ pemcHa O J HaKO CpaBHHBarb HHrepHIO C Coe J HHeHHbIMH lIITaraMH PHH n0J10 KeHHe KaK 6ynTo 6bI HHoe HO H TaM MbI 06Hap BaeM t 860-x aHaJIOrHH C UeHTpaJIbHOH EsponOll nOCJ1e pacnana ABcTpo-BeHr­ CeBepa H lOra npHHa J1e KaJIH K O n HOH Hau HH XOTJ'l Ka3aJIOCb QTO pHH KaK H B npyrHx acppHKaHCKHX KHByT OHH B HHrcpHH COCTOHT H3 rocynapCTBax HaCeJ1eHHe MHO KeCTBa pa3HOH3bNHbIX nJ1eMeH cpenH pe3Ko ronOB pa3YMeeTCfI a6CYP J HO H60 6eJ1bIe aMepHKaHUbI pa3HbIX moxax A pa3J1H'1HbI 3necb n06ena nJIeMeHa HhIHeIIIHeH HHrepHH lIeHTpaJIbHOrO npaBHTeJ1bCTBa KOTOPbIX eCTb HeCKOJ1bKO KpynHbIX H BbmeJ1HlOmHXCJ'l pa3BHTOH He rapaHTHpyeT cnOKOHCTBHJ'l B KYJ1bTypOH HeCKonbKO J1eT Ha3a KOHCPJ1HKT Me Kny nneMeHaMH MoryT CHOBa B0306J1a J aTb H Torna 'ITO BeCbMa BepOHTHO HH­ BbIJIHJ1CJ'l TaM B rpa KJ1 aHCKYIO BOHBy B KOTOPOH norH6J10 OK0J10 repmo nOCTHrHer cYlJ b6a ABcrpo-BeHrpHH 2 6Y J ymeM UeHTp06e J Hhle CHJ1bI MJ1H qeJ10BeK Il06eAHJ10 KaK H3BeCTHO UCHTpaJIbHOe npaBH­ TenbCTBO KOTopoe nOnnep KHBaJ1H H CocAHHeHHble IIlTaTbI H BenH­ YPEAlI K06pHTaHHH IloqeMY He BbI cnpocHTe IloTOMY nyMaeTcH 'ITO qpe3BbNaHHO Tpy n HO nOHJ'lTb cHTyau H1O B rocynapcTBC HHoro THna qeM c06CTBeHHoe B 3TOMY Bonpocy CHJ1bHOrO J1066H BenHK06pHTaHHH 06meCTBCHHoe MHeHHe no CPOPMHPOBaJIOCb KOTopoe B COCTOHJ10 OCHOBHOM H3 non BJIHHHHeM 6bIBIIIHX qHHOBHHKOB no nenaM K0J10HHH H npyrHX J1lOneH KOTopbIe HMenH OIlbIT pa60TbI Ho nOCJ1 T He eJ1H HCropHfI OTpe3BJ1f1lOlUHM eBponellCKoro ypOKOM Hau HOHaJIH3Ma J1H HapO J OB ACPPHKH Hey KeJ1H acppHKaHIlhI HH'lerO He H3BJ1eKaIOr H3 OIIblTa HaIIIHX 6paTO­ y6HHcTBeHHbIX BOllH replleH KaK-TO CKa3aJI 'ITO HCTOPHJ'l qeJ10­ BelleCTBa - 3TO XpOH0J10rHJ'l HeCnpaBe J1HBOCTeH H60 nOTOMKH Moryr BOCn0J1b30BarbCJ'l nJIOnaMH onbITa npenKOB He npHJ1araH npH 3TOM HHKaKHX C06CTBCHHbIX YCHlIHH B K0J10HHJ'lX Bce OHH BocnpHHHMaJIH HHrepHIO C ee 50-MHJ1J1HOH­ HbIM HaCeneHHeM ceHqaC TaM Y Ke OK0J10 80 MJIH KaK HaCJ1enHC lipHTaHcKoH HMIICPHH KOTOPbIM OHH rOpJ1 Hl1Hcb C HaqaJIa HaIIIerO CTOJ1CTHJ'l AHrJ1HJ'l CHJ1bHO BJ1HJ'lna Ha pa3BHTHe nOH CrpaHbI AHmH­ a lllKetlltllepcoH ll3itBHC 1808-1889 rrpe nUJ eHT KOHtIlep epauHH IiliKHhlX IiITaTOB AMepHKH KOTOphle XOTenH OTp eJ1HT1 CJl OT CeBepa - Pea 3aTeM npe J ocTaBHJ1H en He3aBHCHMOCTb EAHHaH HHrepHH no HX 203 qaHe 202 BbIpa60TaJIH J1H HHrcpHH cpenepaJIbHYIO KOHCTHTYu HIO CETOH-YOTCOH Ha eIOcb 'ITO C06blTHH rrO TBep HT CJ10Ba repueHa HO rrOI a 0 JTOrO arreI o 06pa30BaHHble acpPHI aHUbI BeCbMa HCI aJKeHHO rrpe CTaBJ1HIOT ce6e rrp06J1CMbl I OTOpble 6bIJ1H rrOpOJK J eHbl rrpHMepHO TO eBpOnCHCI HM JKe HaUHOHarrH3MOM H60 3HaIOT 0 HHX 'ITO H aHrl1HqaHC cppaHUY3bl HJ1H rropTyrarrbUbI COBepllICHHO aCPPHI aHUbI YHryp HHOM UHBHnH3aUHH nerqe I OTOpble 5bI VIII B HaMHoro TpY Hce B03MOJKHO rrOHHnH I OqeBHble rrneMeHa rrCqeHerOB H BCI e YHHqTOJKanH HapOJ bI BOCTO'IHOH EBporrbI MOJKeM nH Mbl OJKH aTb 'ITO OHH YCBmn YTOHqeHHbIC HIlCH eBporreHCKHX COUHaJ1HCTOB oappa H PCHHepa TO eCTb B CYlUHOCTH HC 3HaIOT HH'lerO BbI BC b 3HaCTe I aI MarrO BHHMaHHH y enHeTCH HCTOPHH llcHTpaJ1bHOH EBpOrrbl B aHrmiHCI HX CETOH-YOTCOH HnH CKHX rrOnHTHI OB 6eJ1brHHCI HX Cpe HHX lllKonax B nyqllIcM cnyqae 3HaHHH KOHeqHO no HC rrpoCTO Ho cpellH acpPHI aH­ eCTb OCTaTOqHO OIlbITHble ECTb B ACPPHI C H acppHI aHUeB Ha JIOT CqCT rrOBCpXHOCTHbl H HaHBHbl OOnbllIHHCTBO HHTcnnHrCHTbI I OTOPbIC crroc06Hbl BHHI aTb B CYIUHOCTb rrp06nc­ JKe Bo06lUe HHqerO He 3HaeT 0 llcHTparrbHoH EBpone 'ITO OJ HaKO Mbl BOBCC He 05H3aTCJ1bHO PCaJ1H30BblBaTb B AcpPHI e rrpOeI Tbl He MellIaeT a PPHI aHCI HM HaUHOHarrHCTaM I pHqaTb 05 YJKace BCpO­ oaY3pa H PeHHepa HO 5bllO 5bl rronC3HO 0 HHX 3HaTb ' T06bl Bblpa­ HTHOH 6arrI aHH3aUHH ACPPHI H 06 JIOM HanpHMcp qaCTO rOBO­ 50TaTb c06CTBeHHoe pCllIeHHC 3TO MHoro pa3YMHCC qeM rro qH­ pHn HI pYMa I or a 6bIJ1 rrpaBHTcncM raHbl IIo-BH HMoMY acpPH­ HHTbCH COBeTCI OMY rocrrOIlCTBY H rrorraCTb B COBeTCKYID HMTIepHIO I aHCI He rrOnHTHI H YMaIOT 5Y TO HX HaUHH 1l0CTaTOqHO pa3BHTbI rrpH I OTOPOM pOJ1b JKaHllapMOB ACPPHI H HrpaIOT I y5HHUbI qT06bl He orrYCTHTbCR 0 ypOBHH TaI HX 5arrI aHCI HX rocy apCTB I aI oonrapHR CCp6HH H IIp Ho rOBopR no COBCCTH ccnH 5bI COBpeMeHHble acppHI aHCKHe rocy apCTBa XOTJI 6bl HanonOBHHY YPEAH B HauHoHaJ1H3M - paJHbIX rOCYllapcTBax IIIHpOI oe nOHHTHC B pa3Hble JrrOXH OH PR D HTCR B caMble pa3Ho05pa3HbiC rrpH6nH3HnHCb I TOMY I aI ynpaBnRJ1HCb oonrapHR HJ1H CCp5HH HllconorHlJCCI He OIlCJK J bI Bbl caMH rrHCaJ1H 05 OTIIHlJHHX nH6cpaJ1b­ 110 BTOPOH MHPOBOH BOMHbl JIO 6bllO 6bl 60nbllIHM 1l0CTHJKeHHeM HO-lleMO I paTHlJCCKOrO HaUHOHaJ1H3Ma HaqaJ1a H cepellHHbI IIepexOIl pa3HOH3blqHblX acppHI aHCKHX rrJ1eMeH B HaUHH TonbKO HaUHOHaJ1H3Ma I OTOPbIH XIX B OT XIX H OXBaTHn EBporry Ha rrepenoMc HaqHHaeTCH II03TOMY I aI MHC I aJKeTCH HlleH KOTOPblC BbIIlBH­ XX rarrHCb B rry B UCJ10M YqHTbIBaR JIH BallIH XapaI TepHCTHI H HaUHOHaJ1H3Ma ABCTpHH OTTO oaY3pOM H KapJ10M PCHHCPOM MoryT BB rropO D HB BepoRTHo IlBC MHPOBbIC BOHHbl H ocna6HB EBPO­ elUe 0I a3aTbCH rr0J1C3HbI J J1H ACPPHI H IIOCI OJ1bI Y CCHqac nJ1eMCH­ MOJKHO IlYMacTcH CI a3aTb 'ITO HbIHCIIlHHe acpPHI aHCI He OCB050­ Hoe C03HaHHe IlHTcnbHblC elUe He pa3BHnOCb 0 HaUHOHarrbHoro 1l0CTaTOqHO YMHbIe rocy apCTBeHHblC CHTenH HMCIOT elI e B03MOJKIIOCTb yIlOB­ 1848 r BOMHbI 5J1H3I H CI opce K eBporreHCKHM C05b1THRM ACPPHI aHUbI BbIcTynHnH OIlHOBpCMeHHO H rrpOTHB HHOCTpaH­ neTBopHTb qaHHHH acppHI aHUCB BBe H I ynbTypHo-HaUHOHaJ1bHYIO Horo BnallblqeCTBa H 3a eMOKpaTH3aUHIO CBOHX 06lUecTB MOJKHO aBTOHOMHIO Toro THrra 0 nH CllcnaTb TaI OH BbIBO H3 BallIHX pa60T I OTOPOM rOBopHnH oayJP H PCHHep TeM caMblM MOJKHO 6bllO 6bl ClUC rrpHMHpHTb JIH rrnCMCHa C UCHT­ CETOH-YOTCOH PaJ1bHbIM rrpaBHTenbcTBoM HeT QT06bl rrpOHCHHTb rrp05ncMY llaBaMTe BcrrOMHHM rnaBHblC JIarrbl pa3BHTHH HaUHOHaJ1H3Ma IIo-BallIeMY YPEAH Ho 6y 'eM CrrpaBc lJ nHBbl I aCPPHI aHUaM Be b cnc 'yeT HaUHOHaJ1H3M 6bIJ1 rrOnOJKHTenbHbIM 110 rrpH3HaTb 'ITO rrpaI THqeCI Oe YCBOCHHC YP0I OB HCTOPHH ra6c6yp­ naJ1CR rOB B rrepBoM rronOBHHe rrpellI1oJ1araJ1o 6bl TaI OH KynbTYPHbIH CI aqOI I OTOPbIH He CYMena COBepIIIHTb HH OJ Ha HaUHH I OTOPbIX rrpeOlloneBaTb I ynbTypHbIe aJKe HrrOHUbI crroc06HOCTb 6apbepbl orpOMHa DaJKe oTpHuaTcnbHbIM XIX 1848 DeMcTBHTcnbHocTb L a rr03JKe CIlC­ MHoro CJ10JKHce B HaUHOHaJ1bHbIC IlBHJKCHHH BOOllYllIeBnH­ nHCb nH6epaJ1H3MOM TO eCTb rrpHHUHrraMH CB050llbl HHIlHBHIlYYMa ElUe 0I 0J10 1870 rrOqTH HlleonorHCH ­ L BOJK J H HaUHOHaJ1hHbIX caMH HaUHH lleHTparrbHoH EBporrbI BCC CUIC He oCBo501lHJ1HCb OT IlBHJKeHHH HCKpcHHe BepHnH 'ITO rpaJKllaHCI aH H HaUHOHaJ1hHaH CBoero rrpOllUloro PYMbIHbl BCC elUC BPaJK yIOT C BeHrpaMH cno­ CB060J bI HCllenHMhl TaI oB 5bll nH6epaJ1bHhlH HaUHOHaJ1H3M BaI H Ero 204 - C qeXaMH cep5bl - C XOpBaTaMH A YCBOHTb yp0I H rcpoeM MOJKHO CMeno Ha3BaTb rapH6arrb H XIX B IIoTOM B 205 nOnHrnqeCKHH npouecc HallanH BOBneKaTbC I IIIHpOKHe MaCCbI 6HpaTenbHbIX CTPaHHnHCb 113­ npaB Ao6HnHCb HOBbIe Ofil UeCTBeHHbIe cnOH pacnpo­ COIIHanHCTH1IeCKHe nOCne1J HHe narrbI pa3BHTHH HaUHoHanbHbIX COIIHanHCTH­ HaIIHoHanH3M H HaqHHaeTC I IIceBAoKoMMYHHCTHlIeCKHH Ofia 3TH HarrpaBJIeHH I 1I0nb3yroTCH TeMH Ke MeTOAaMH KOTopbIe YCBOHnH MaCCOBOH AeMOKpaTHH YKperrHnHCb H3yqaeillb lIeCKHe naprnH JlHfiepanbHble onHrapXHH 1I0CTerreHHO 3aMeH InHCb rOCYAapCTBaMH HAeH KorAa 11 BH KeHHH TPyAHO onpeAeJIHTb rAe KOHlIaeTCH rrceBAo$aIllHcTCKHH B 3TOT rrepHOA BO K l H HauHOHanbHblX ABIDKeHHH Ha1lHHaIOT fionbille 3afiornTbC I 0 cYAbfiax Macc lIeM 0 CBofioAe HHAHBHAYYMa Me K l Y eBpolleHcKHe $aumCTbI 20-x-30-x rr XX B - AOIIYCTHM eJIe3HaH rBapAHH B PyMbIHHH HnH HHITaIllHCTbI B BeHrpHH Jil KOMMYHHCTbI H $aIIIHCTbI alleJIJIHpyroT K CaMbIM HH3MeHHbIM HHCTHHKTaM MeCT­ rrepBOH H BTOPOH MHPOBbIMH BOHHaMH HaIIHOHanH3M Hora HaCeJIeHHH AeMafOmqeCKH onepHpy I JI03YHraMH cOUHanbHoH rrpe06pa3HnCH B EBpO rre KOma Ka3anOCb fiYATO rrOfie K l aeT $a­ peBOJIIOUHH IIIH3M HaIIHOHanHCThI yCBOHnH ero HAeOJIOrHIO A B KOJIOHIDlX He HMeIOT B03MO KHOCTH IIpeCJIeAOBaTb eBpeeB HO 3aTO B A$pHKe A3HH H A$pHKe - H pacoBoro IIpeBocxoAcTBa A$pHKaHUbI IIpaBAa HaIIHOHanH3M rrpeBpaTHJIC I rro cyrn cBoeH B eCTb KHTali cKaH AHacrropa a TaK Ke ToprOBUbI H3 fpeIIHH H JIHBa­ aHTH6pHTaHCKHe H aHrn$paHUY3cKHe ABH KeHH I Bo K1J H ero Ha­ Ha OHH-TO H HCIIOJIb3YIOTCH AJIH POJIH a$pHKaHCKHX eBpeeB Bo­ IIpHMep Hacep H CaJ aT KaK H ApyrHe MOJI01J bIe erHneTCKHe O$H­ rrpeKH uepbI CMOTpeJIH Ha fepMaHHIO H JilTanHIO KaK Ha oCB060J HTeneH anH3Ma floA06HbIe Ke HaCTpOeHH I pa3AeJIHJIa H rrapTH I JilHJ HHCKHH KOHr­ BocTOKa Bce Hpqe ofiHapY KHBaIOT ce6H KaK ABIDKeHHH $aIIIHCTCKHe pecc H el Ue HammeHHOH HMH Ha cefiH MaCKe MapKCHCTCKoro COIIH­ A$pHKH H BJIIDKHerO 60JIee oTKpoBeHHo HaIIHOHanHCTbI IOro-BocT01lHoH A3HH KOTopbIe CB I3anH CBOH lIa lHH I C COI03HHKOM $aIllHcTcKHX YPEAH rocYAapcTB EBPOllbl - HnoHHeH BbI flocrre HaUHoHanHCTHqeCKHe 11 BH KeHH I 1I0pIDKeHHH $aIIIH3Ma aHTHKOJIOHHanbHble 11 BH KeHH I YqHTbIBaH nOAofiHble IIpO lBJIeHH I HaUHoHanH3Ma KaK oueHHBaeTe 1I0JIbCKHe H BeHrepCKHe COfibITHH 1956 r HJIH 1968 r lIeXOCJIOBaUKHe B03HHKJIH TaK Ke H Ha TeppHTOpH IX IO KHee CaxapbI Ho Tellepb HaIIHOHanHCTHlIeCKHe CHnbI rrOTep IB 1I0AAep KKY pa3rpOMneHHbIX CETOH-YOTCOH $aIIIHcTcKHX BOPHJIH HH1IerO ofil Uero He HMeIOT BbICTYllaH rrpOTHB 1I0CJIeAHeli rocYAapCTB Aep KaBaMH npHH IJIHCb COBeTcKoro COI03a KOTOPbIe ee HCKaTb BoeBanH Y C KOJIOHHanbHblMH rrOfieJ HBillerO fepMaHHIO JIHAepbI HaUHOHanbHbIX 11 BIDKeHHH YCBOHnH B COBpeMeHHOM MHpe KOJIOHHanbHOH HMllepHH BeTCKOH - MapKcHcTcKHe n03yHrH KOTopble OHH KCTaTH H He rrOHHManH Horo a caMH 11 BIDKeHH I IIpHOfipeJIH MapKCHCTCKYIO - BeHrpHH BepHee KBa3H­ CeHlIaC MbI HafiJIIOAaeM lIeTblpe BHAa HaIIHOHanH3Ma ­ a HMeHHO CO­ OHH TeM caMbIM BOCCTaHaBJIHBaIOT TOT THrr JIH6epanb­ HaIIHOHanH3Ma 1956 KOTOPblH rrpeACTaBJIHJI L H B qexocrroBaKHH 1968 CXOACTBa C HaUHOHanbHbIMH ABIDKeHHHMH MapKCHCTCKYIO OKpaCKY JilTaK 3TH COfiblTHH C TeM 0 lIeM MbI TOJIbKO lITO ro­ fapHfianbAH Jil B r MO KHO HaRTH lIepTbI 1848 L Jil B 3TOM HeT HHqerO HeO KHAaHHoro flPH MeTTepHHXe JIIOAH TaK Ke cTpaAanH IIceBAonH6epanbHbIH rrceBAOMaCCOBOAeMOKpaTHlIeCKHH rrceBAo$a­ OT OTCYTCTBHH nOJIHTH1IeCKHX cBofioA KaK H rroA BnaCTbIO PaKoIIIH IIIHCTCKHH H nceBAOKOMMYHHCTHlIeCKHH H HOBOTHOro HeCKOJIbKO yrrpol UaH MbI MO KeM IIPHHTH K TaKoH Terrepb COBeTCKHH rraprn3aH He TonbKO OH COI03 ofiyqaeT apafiCKHX H a$pHKaHCKHX $opMYJIe op e H COBeTHHKOB flpH1leM 3arraAHOrO 1I0CTaBn leT HM rrapTH3aHCKHM ABH KeHH IM HO H e nonyqHBIIIHM KorAa HaUHOHanbHoe rrapJIaMeHTapHoro ABH KeHHe pe KHMa OHO HarrpaBJIeHO rrpoTHB OKa3bIBaeTC I JIHfio rrOJIy$aIIIHCTCKHM JIH60 1I0JIYKOMMYHHCTHlIeCKHM KorAa Ke OHO He3aBHCHMOCTb rOCYAapCTBaM B3aMeH a$pHKaHCKHe BO KJ H AeKJIa­ fiopeTcH rrpornB TOTaJIHTapHOro pe KHMa OHO rrpOHBJIHeT cefiH KaK MHpyroT MapKcHcTcKHe $pa3b1 H paccY K l aIOT ofi a$pHKaHCKOM JIHfiepanbHoe 01J HaKO HaAO rrpH3HaTb 'ITO He CTOJIb y K 01leBH1J H0 COIIHanH3Me COBeTcKHe MapKCHCTbI KOHellHO HaA nHM B Ayme HaCKOJIbKO cMeIOTcH HO H 3KcrrnyaTHpyroT CrrOJIHa BYAyqH AeHCTBHTenbHO 1956 neHHHuaMH peanHcTaMH OHH rrOHHMaIOT 'ITO aHTH3arra1J HbIH HaIIHO­ HanH3M HapoAoB A$pHKH H3rOTOBJIeH fiYATO no HX 3aKa3Y 206 peIllaIOUleH fibma 1968 rr CKopee Bcero COfibITHH 1956 H 1968 rL B H ponb HaIIHOHanH3Ma B COfiblTHHX ee rrpeyBeJIH1IHBaIOT caMH pyccKHe BeHrpHH H qexOCJIOBaKHH KaK H 207 B 1848 J bI r HaqaJlHCb C TpeooBaHlfii KOHCTHTYIJ lfOHHbIX npaB CBOOO­ JlHtIHOCTH J BH f eHHH CnpaBeJ lllfBOCTH COIJ lfaJlbHOii BblJlHJlHCb B B OOOHX CJIyqaHX HaIJ lfOHaJlbHO'OCBooO 1 lfTeJlbHbIe JlHIJlb ceOH CaM HCTOPHK J OJl f HbI JlH Mbl C Heii COrJlarnaTbCH Ha nepBbIii Borrpoc BM OTBeTHTe oe3 Tpy o a OR HceH qTO f e KacaeTCH BTO­ por TO Hero HeCKOJlbKO YTOqHIO BepOHTHO H 01IIH6a1OCb HO nocne cOBeTcKoH HHTepBeHlUIlf KOTOPaH BbI3BaJla MaccoBbIH B3pbm Barn Te3HC npoTecTa B030Y 1 lfJla HaIJ lfOHaJlbHbIe 'l YBcTBa H aHTlfpyccKlfe HacTpo­ Welgericht TO eCTb qTO J eiiCTBHTenbHO TO H pa3YMHO B BeTXOM HarrOMHHaeT CnOBa ferenH Die Weltgeschichte ist das emIH BeHrepcKaH H qeXOCJlOBallKaH peBOJllOIIlflf OblJllf no cBoeMY 3aBeTe cymeCTBY He HaIllfOHaJlbHbIMH a COIIHanHCTHqeCKHMH OHH CTpe­ Me3JJ HH comaCHO KOTOPOH 3a rpeXH OTIIOB J OJl f HbI pacrrnallHBaTb­ MHnHCb BOCKpeCHTb rropyraHHble COBeTCKHM HMnepHaJlH3MOM nHOepaJIbHbIe lIeHHOCTH MO f HO C BaMH comaCHTbCH KorJ a BbI HaCTaHBaeTe Ha pa3nH'UiHX Me f J Y nOCJleJ OBaTenbHO MO f HO rrpOCJleJ HTb HJ elO B03­ CH J eTH HH HaIllfH HH HHJJ HBHJJ YYMbI He B CHJlax H30e f aTb rrpe o ­ HaqepTaHHoii HM cYJ b6bl XOTH OHH ee He H30PaJIH Ii He Ha HHX Jle f HT YPEAH OqeHb HaIJ lfOHaJlbHbIMH peBOJlIOIJ lfHMH rro o OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a o eHHHH rrpOlllJloro XPHCTHaHCTBY HOO HeCOBMeCTHMa C f epTBoii 3Ta H o eH qy f J a XpHcTa KOTOPbIH paCHCT­ B3HJI Ha ceoH qY f He rpexH H HCKyrrHll rpexH H HaIJ lfH H OTJ eJlbHbIX CKO-KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKlfMH Jl03YHraMH H HaIJ lfOHaJlbHbIMH peBonlO­ JlIO o eii TOJlbKO TeOJlOrH-KaJlbBHHHCTbl BepoHTHo nOJ lJ ep f HBalOT IJ lfHMH noJ n03YflraMH JlHOepaJIH3Ma Ho KaKOH f e BMBOJ MO f HO oHoneiicKYIO J OKTPHHY npeJ onpe o eJleHHocTH Ho cornaCHBrnHCb H3 noro H3BnetIb qTO J eMOKpaTHH pO f J aeT THpaHHlO a THpaHHH C Heii MbI ceoH 00e30p M HOO cornaCHMCH 'ITO H3BeCTHbIe - no OTJlH'l aeTCH OT H3BeCTHOrO Te3Hca liTO J eMOKpaTlflO Ho 'l eM ocooeHHOCTH J aHHOH HallHOHaJlbHoii H3HH KaK H CYJ bOY HaIJ lfH HCTOPHf J BH f eTCf no CrrHpaJIH rrepeJ enaTb HeB03MO f H0 I1MeHHo taK B03HHKaeT rrOpOtIHbIH KPyr CETOH-YOTCOH maJIOCb HallHOHaJlbHOH Bpa f J b1 H OTtIY f J eHHOCTH H3·3a KOToporo CBep­ KOHeqHO 3TO He HOBO HO HanOMHHTb 00 nOM MHoro 3na B rrpOIllJlOM KaK BrrpOqeM H rrpoJ on f aeT cne o yer Ba f Ho He 3aObmaTb 'ITO HallHOHaJlH3Mbi ObmalOT pa3HbIe cOBepmaTbCH B HarnH BpeMeHa HarrpHMep ceiiqac IIIHPOKO pac­ 'l TO 0 HaIJ lfOHaJlH3Me HeJlb3f CY 1 lfTb Booome npoCTpaHeHO MHeHHe OYJ TO COBeTCKaH CHCTeMa 60JlblIIe PycCKaH K J o6PY OH HJlH K XYJ y HY f HO 06 nOM HanOMHHaTb rrOTOMY 'ITO B Harne BpeMH qeM KOMMYHHCTHtIeCKaH HOO OCHOBaHa Ha PycCKoii rroKopHoCTH H o a f e OqeHb oopa30BaHHbIe 3arraJ HbIe lfHTenJleKryaJIbl He o OCTaTOtIHO npeKJlOHeHHH rrepeJ CHlloii fiOqTH 0pHeHTHpYIOTCf B 3THX Bonpocax H Y f e He roBOPIO 0 3arraJ HbIX 2000 JleT Ha eBpeHx Jle f aJla KOJl­ neKTHBHaH BHHa 3a paCmlTHe XpHcTa H TonbKO nocJle HCTpeOneHmI nOJlHTHKax BbI caMH 3TO npeKpaCHO 3HaeTe K TOMY f e f He Mory 6 cornaCHTbCH C YTBep f J eHHeM noro 06BHHeHHH fipo o OJl f aH B TaKOM KnlOqe MO f HO YTBep f o aTb 6YJ TO J eMOKpaTHH pO f J aeT TH· MJlH eBpeeB HallHCTaMH KaTOJlHtIeCKaH UePKOBb OTKa3aJlaCb OT PaHHIO BrrpOqeM 06CY f J eHHe noro Borrpoca OTBJleKnO Obi Hac 'ITO CJlHlIIKOM J aJleKO OT 06CY f o eHHH HalIIeH TeMbl BpeMeHa rrOBHHHbl B J eHCTBHHX CBOHX OTIIOB HeMUbI KOTopble o a f e eme He POJ HllHCb B rHTJlepOBCKHe A KpOBaBbIe H3· oHeHHH B CeBepHoH I1pJlaHJJ HH MO f HO rorJ a rrpHnHCaTb TeMHbIM npOHBJleHHHM cBoeoopa3HoH HpnaHJ cKoii nCHXHKH KOTopaH Bce S MapKC H COBeTCKIUI HMnepmI eme HBO pearHpyeT Ha Bpa f J Y npoTecTaHToB H KaTonHKOB KO­ TOpaH HMeJlO MeCTO YPEAH B rrocne J Heii BarneH KHHre HaIJ lfH H rOCYJ apCTBa HJ ef 300 JleT Ha3aJ KaK HaIJ lfH HJlH HHAHBHJJ YYMbl CMorYT HaqaTb HOBYIO cTpaHHUY HaIJ lfH npeJ CTaeT KaK HeqTO HeH30e f HOe pa3 H HaBcerJ a o aHHoe CBoeH HCTOPHlf H H3HH ecnH npH3HaTb liTO HM HHKorJ a He OqHC· HaIlHH He MorYT OTKa3aTbCH OT COOCTBeHHOH HCTOPHH a HH lJ H­ THTbCH OT MHHMOii HllH J eHCTBHTenbHoii BlfHbI CBOHX npeJ KOB BHJ YYMY He J aHO BbIOHpaTb K KaKoH HallHH ce6f OTHeCTH 3TO YTBep f J eHHe Bbl3bIBaeT cpa3Y ABa Borrpoca JlH OHO q aKTaMH f H3HH H JlHlIIb 208 0 HpaaCTBeHHoii 2 1 rroJ TBep f J aeTCf eCJlH pe'l b HJ eT He 0 q aKTax a Bcero n03HIJ lfH KOTOpylO YCTaHaBJlHBaeT J llH KOHeIlHO HCTOPHK J on f eH orrHCbIBaTb H OO bHCHHTb npOlllJlbIe J eHHHH nlOJ eii HO pa3Be He J on f eH OH OTKpbmaTb HaIlHHM KaK HM OTopBaTbCH OT rrpOlllJloro a OTJ eJIbHbIM JlIOJ HM OCTaeTCH BM60p J a f e OTHOCHTeJlbHO liTO Y HHX CBoeH HalllfOHaJlbHOii npH­ HaJ lle f HOCTH 209 CETOH-YOTCOH BbI 3aTpOHYJIH O lJ HY H3 ClIO J HeHIIIHX H BOBce He YTBep JI JJ alO 'ITO HalUiH J O GeCKOHe'IHOCTH npoGJIeM J OCTOHHbIH oGpa3ell cbIHoBeH lleJIOMYJ peHHoH fepMaHHH KOTOpaH HeCYT Ha H30GHJIyeT nO'lTeHHblMH xapaKTepaMH H no-npe J HeMY J HBeT MHpO­ ceGe KJIeHMO CBOHX npeJ KoB H J OJI J HbI npHBJIeKaTbCH K cYJ Y JIIOGHBO J a J e nOCJIe ceMH HawecTBHH 3a npoIIIJIoe IIpHMep OTHOWeHHH KaTOJIH'IeCKOH QepKBH K eBpe­ HM O'leHb YJ a'leH HMeHHO nOToMY 'ITO KOHQenQHH KOJIJIeKTHBHoH CETOH-YOTCOH BHHbI eBpeeB 3a paCnHTHe XpHcTa HBHO aGcYP lJ Ha Ho He MeHee J O aGcyp lJ HO C'lHTaTb Bcex HeMQeB HC'IaJ HeM 3JIa JIHIIIb Ha TOM OCHOBa­ o fepMaHHH cOBepweHHo H3MeHHJIHCb HO He HaJ O 3aGblBlTb 'ITO HHH 'ITO fHTJIep Gbm BpeMeH HMeHHo TaK BOCnpHHHMaJIH HeMQeB BIIJIOTb EHcMapKa IIoToM KOHe'IHO HaIIIH IlpeJ cTaBJIeHHH OJ ep J HM J bHBOJIOM B MoeH KHHre KOTO­ B palJIH'lHble 3noXH Hal HOHaJIbHOH J H3HH BblcrynalOT Ha rrepe lJ HHH PYIO BbI TOJIbKO 'ITO IUUHPOBaJIH H XOTeJI JIHWb HanOMHHTb 'ITO IIJIaH pa3JIH'lHble acneKTbl COBpeMeHHbIe HeMl b1 COBceM He Ha­ HCToplflleCKoe npOIIIJIoe HauHH cymecTBOBaJIO q aKTlflIeCKH H 'ITO nOMHHalOT HeMlleB HauHHM He CJIeJ yeT npeJ aBaTb ero 3aGBeHHIO HeJIb3H KOHe'lHO H31 HTb TpeGoBaTb OT Bcex npeJ CTaBHTeJIeH J aHHOH HaQHH rnyGoKHx HCTO­ GyJ TO pH'IeCKHX n03HaHHH HeJIb3H TpeGoBaTb 'ITOGbI OHH KoppeKTH­ B H3 TpeTbero peiixa HO Bce J e fHTJIepa e He repMaHCKOH HaQH3Ma He HCTOPHH Ka JI IJ OH POBaJIH CBoe nOBeJ eHHe HeYCTaHHbIMH BocnOMHHaHHHMH 0 npow­ BIIJIOTb J O JIOM Ho Ka JI IJ bIH J OJI J eH GbITb rOTOB K TOMY 'ITO npOIIIJIoe 3a BapBapaMH HCTOPMH HHeB03MO J H0 cJ enaTb BM Gbmo HaI HH MO J HO HaHTH He'lTO IT030pHmee XVII COBpeMeHHaH B GbIDH J HKHMH H KPOBO J aJ HbIMH q paHIIY3CKaH Hal ID1 Cq OPMHpOBaJIaCb KOTOpoe Mbl eCTeCTBeHHO He B OTBeTe cnocoGHo HaJIO J HTh ne­ B 'IaTb H Ha Hawy JIIflIHYIO J H3Hb H Ha J H3Hb HaQHH OBJIaJ eBaH 3aBOeBaHHH Ha'laTbIe B HMH nOJ oGHo pOKY rpe'leCKHX TpareJJ HH paBHbIX KOTOPblM no J eCTOKOCTH GbIDO He CTOJIb MHoro BO BcnOMHHM onHTb-TaKH fepMaHHIO HeMellKoe npOIIIJIoe no pe3YJIbTaTe BceH ITOKOpeHHH ceBepHblMH XIII q paHIIY3aMH lO J aH 3TH B ClIO J HJIHCb B AITHHHYIO Ilem BOHH HCTOPHH 'IeJIOBe'leCTBa ApMHH ceBepO- ppaHIIY3CKHX KOpO­ KapTHHbI JlIOpepa My3blKa Eaxa noGeAbI DPMPHxa EapGapoccbI JIeH paCnpaBJIHJIHCb C BparOM C TaKOH CBHpenOCTbIO 'ITO BOHHbI H BapBapCKaH KyJIuypa KOTOPYIO OTKpbID 3a PeHHOM TaQHT H EHCMapKa BblrJIHJJ HT Ha nOM q OHe KaK 3BaHblH 'Ian B neHCHOHe OnHCaJI B CBoeH fepMaHMH Bce no BOIIIJIO B HeMeIIKYIO KYJIb­ GJIarOp0 lJ HbIX TYPY q OPMHPOBaJIO ee fHTJIep B nOH M03aHKe - Bcero JIHWb YTBep JI JJ aTh 'ITO WOTJIaHJJ l bl HJIH HeMI bI HJIH q paHIlY3bl ITO Tpa­ T e He TaK J HIIHH ITO npupO lJ e CBoeH BapBapbl KOTOPbIM ITpHcymH HH3MeHHbIe OJ HH KYCO'leK CMaJIbThI Eme B cepeJ MHe Y J J aBHO - OKpY J alOmHH XIX B - MHp BocnpHHHMaJI fepMaHHIO KaK KOHrJIOMepaT MeJIKHX KHH J eCTB HaCeJIeHHbIX MHJIbIMH oe3HaJ e J ­ HO HenpaKTH'IHbIMH MHrKHMH JIIOJ bMH C KOTOPbIMH nOTHrHBaH J eBHIl Ho TeM GOJIee Gbmo CTpaCTH BeAb B KOHe'IHOM C'IeTe Bce Mbl GbI HeCnpaBeAITHBO HaClIe lJ HHKH Hawero HaQHOHaJIbHOrO npOIIIJIoro XOTHM MbI Toro HJIH HeT Mbl lJ OJI J HbI o HeM nOMHHTb HO OTHlO IJ b He OCTaBaTbCH ero nJIeHHHKaMH BHHO MO J HO 'IaCaMH paccY f JJ aTb 0 q HJIOCOq HH ECTeCTBeHHO HeMI bI TorJ a HHKOMY He yrpO J aJIH HGo He GbIDH opraHH30BaHbI a HX HeMellKoe roCYJ apCTBO He B Te BpeMeHa MHp CTpawHJICH J pyroro HapOJ a - Gbmo YPBAH IIpoIIIJIoe KaK Bbl rOBopHTe COCTaBJIHeT GoraTcTBo eJ HHbIM Ka JI IJ OH HaIlHH OTKJIa l U maeTCH B ee TPa lJ HQHHX Ho BeJ b B Ka JI IJ bIH CHJIbHOH BeJIH­ J aHHbIH nepHO lJ oTGHpaeTcH HMeHHO TO H3 npOIIIJIoro 'ITO COOT­ KOJIenHO BoopY J eHHOH DpaHQHH BeTcTByeT ero lJ yxY Pa3YMeeTCH GbIDa fepMaHHH H TeBTOHCKHX pbIllapeH H KaHTa H EeTXOBeHa H CTpaHxepa H T IJ 3TO J onycTHM YPBAH H3 II03BoJIbTe HanOMHHTb GaJIb3aKOBCKoro MeCbe fepMaHa KpacHoH rOCTHHHI bI 3ro GbID GJIarOJ ywHbIH TOJICThIH HeMell 'IeJIOBeK oGpa30BaHHbIH H CO BKYCOM 3aHAITbIH TPyGOKYP C BeJIHKOJIenHOH 'IHCTO HlOpHGeprcKoH WHPOKOH q H3HOHOMHeH KOTOpylO OCeHHJIH 6eJIOKypble J HJ eHbKHe KYJ pHWKH IlaJ aBIIlHe Ha KpYTOH nOpHJ I OM oGJIbICeBIIlHH JIoG OH npeJ CTaBJIHJI COGOH 210 TaK Ho 'ITO lJ eJIaTh eCJIH BO BceM nOM HaGope HeT HJIH nO'lTH HeT HH'IerO JIHGepaJIbHoro A KaK GblTb XOTH npOIIIJIOM H HaCTOHweM KOTOPOH TO J e caMOJ ep J aBHe 11 Gbl C PoccHeH B Bce TOT J e J ecnOTH3M Bce eCJIH no BaweH TeopHH Ha HaI HH OTne­ 'IaThIBaeTCH ee npOIIIJIoe TO He npMeTCH JIH npH3HaTh 'ITO COBeT­ CKHH COlO3 B npMHQHne He cnocoGeH npeAITO J HTb 'ITO-JIHGO 211 n03HTHBHoe HH C06CTBeHHOMY HaCeJIeHHIO HH TeM 60nee OCTaJIb­ YPEAH HOMY MI1PY cOBpeMeHHblx PYCCKHX Ho He npaBbl pa3Be - nyCTb XOTH 6bl oT'lacrn HHTeJInHreHToB KOTopbIe Te H3 rOBopHT 'ITO OKa3aBlillICb nepBOM l eprnOM KOMMYHH3Ma HCIlbITaB Ha cefie H CETOH-YOTCOH 0 COBeTCKOM COI03e HMeHHO TaK R H uYMaIO TeM caMbIM pa306na'lHB nepe u MHPOM POCCHH npH3BaHa cnaCTH Ho CnpaBe UJIHBOCrn pa UH cne uyeT nOMHHTh H 0 uPyroH CTopOHe 'IenOBe'leCTBO OT CTpalllHOH onaCHocrn TaKoB f I 06HOBJIeHHblM PYCCKOH Tpa UHlll1H B JIOH Tpa umum HJIH rOBopR TOl Hee B PYC­ BapHaHT pYCCKoro MeCCHaHCTBa Be'lHO CTPa I UYll HM Hapo u npo­ CKOM npaBOCnaBHH rny60Ko 3aJIO l eH3 H ueH uYXOBHOM CBo60 Ub1 XO uH CKB03b O'lHCTHTeJIbHbIH orOHb KOMMYHH3Ma HCKynaeT rpe­ paBeHCTBa nIO ueH nepe u EoroM Pa3Be JIO He 3acnY l HBaeT yaa­ XH HenOCBHll eHHoro 3ana ua JTOT MOTHB JIerKO npOCne I HBaeTCH l eHHH COn l eHHI U IH H y COJI I eHHI U IHa H B BenHKOJIenHOM pOMaHe MaKCHMOBa CeMb HMeHHO nora HaCTaHBaH JneMeHTa Ha PYCCKOM nepBOCTeneHHOM Tpa UHll HH 3Ha'leHHH CJIf l HT u06pOMY ueny O uHaKO OH Bna uaeT B KpaHHOCTb COn l eHHl U 1H npaB Ilbl­ uHeM o TBopeHHH OH Bcero JIHllIb BapHall HfI CTapo uaBHeH TeMbI 6eCKOHe'lHbIX CTpa uaHHHX pYCCKoro Hapo ua KOTopbIe c uenaJIH TaHCb peafiHJIHTHpOBaTh PYCCKoe npOlllJIoe OTBepraH CTepeOTHllb1 ero BocnpHHTHH JII060ro PYCCKoro KaK BenHKaHa·nIO uoe ua no u'lepKH­ 'IeJIOBe'leCTBa 060pOHHB OT MepKaHTHJIH3Ma H rHHeHHfI 3alla ua xpHcrnaHCKHM 110 npeHMYll eCTBY 6JIIOCTHTeJIeM COBeCTH BaH nOJIO I HTeJIbHOe B PYCCKOM HCTOpHH He Bcer ua C HHM corJIa­ llIaelllbCH HO fibIBaeT 'ITO npaB ua H Ha ero CTopOHe Kanb TonbKO CETOH-YOTCOH 'ITO nOJIeMHKa Me l uy HHM Hero onnOHeHTaMI1 He MO l eT BecrnCb OT PYCCKHX Ky ua cTynHT PYCCKHM con uaT TaM TpaBa He paCTeT OTKPbJTO B caMOM COBeTCKOM COI03e Bcero nora H He pa3 uenHIO EO l e xpaHH Hac KOHe'lHO Mbl Bce B uonry y PYCCKHX con uaT KOTOpbIe BoeBa­ JIH Ha HallieH CTopOHe B nOCne UHeH BOMHe H BHecnH HenerKyro YPEAH COJI I eHHl U 1H YTBep UaeT 'ITO llIecrn ueCHrnneTHHH Tpa­ JIemy B pa3rpOM rHTJIepOBCKOH fepMaHHH lla H B Ha'laJIe XIX B re UHH PYCCKoro Hapo ua COBepllIeHHO TaK l e KaK H Tpare uHH MbI eBpOlleHI U I uon l Hbl 6bIDH 6naro uapHTb PYCCKHX 3a H36aBne­ uPYrHX Hapo uOB KOTOPbIMH - HHe OT HanOJIeOHa Ha UO Bce-TaKH He 3a6b1BaTb ynpaBJIHJIH pYCCKHe HBHnaCb pe3YJIbTaTOM n06e UbI B KopHe 'IY' l ­ uOH PYCCKHM MapKCHCTCKO JIeHHHCKoM H UeOJIOrHH HO HHKOHM 06pa30M He cne uCTBHeM OpraHHlJeCKHX H3'bflHOB pYCCKoro Hall H­ OHaJIbHOrO xapaKTepa A 'ITO l e Ha caMOM ueJIe 'Iero 60JIbllle B COBeTCKoH CHCTeMe - pyccKoro HnH KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKoro Ho 'ITO Mbl BH UHM 1I0TOM B THJIHCb peBelllHBaeT Cnell H i HKa ilepeBapeHHblH BHOBb 1945 r pa60'lHMH BHOCH CTaJII1Ha 1815 r pyccKHe COJI uaTbI B03Bpa­ 6e3ponoTHo CTaTb KpenOCTHbIMH OHH onHTb c uenaJIHCb KpenOCTHbIMH CBOH BKJIa u B oCB060 l ueHHe OHH HHKor ua He YMeJIH oCB060 UaTb CaMHX ce6H Jm HeYMeHHe pyc­ Bcero nOHeMHO l KY HO B KOHe'l HOM C'IeTe ne­ Bce-TaKH PyccKaH 'IT06bl KpeCTbHHaMH KaK B CKHX CETOH-YOTCOH uOMOH Poc­ BbIpBaTbCH H3 pa6CKoro COCTOHHHH uaJKe 1I0 l eprnOBaB TbICHl aMH l H3HeH pa uH CnaCeHI1H OT pa6CTBa upyrHX IIpH3HaTbCH CTaBHT MeHH B TynHK He JIa JII1 oc06eHHocTb 06'bHCHHeT lIo'leMY CHeH MapKCH3M-neHHHH3M npeBpaTHnCH B HOBYIO pa3HOBH UHOCTb MaJIeHbKOe MOCKOBCKoe KHH I eCTBO PyccKoro KOTopaH nornOll aeT Bce HOBbIe H HOBbIe TeppHTopHH HaCaJK UaH MeCCHaHCTBa BepHee Ha060pOT Tpa UHll HOHHO PYC­ CKHe H ueH H pYCCKoe MeCCHaHCTBO OKa3aJIHCb OCBoeHbI cnell Hqm­ 'IeCKOH pa3HOBH uHOCTbIO MapKCH3Ma-neHHHH3Ma XIV B pa3pOCJIOCb B HMnepHIO 1I0BCIO uy pa6CTBO H Tl1paHI1IO MapKCH3M-ne­ PyCCKHe HeCOMHeHHO 3aCJIY I HBaIOT JIyqllleM yqacTH O uHaKO B HHHH3M KOHe'lHO 3Ha'lHTeJIbHO nOnOJIHHJI H 6e3 Toro HeMaJIblM HX 1I0JIHTH'IeCKOM YCTpOHCTBe KaK H B HX nCHXOnOrHlJeCKHX Me­ peeCTp H3Bpall eHHH H l eCTOKOCTeH uecnOTH3Ma KOTOPbIMH H3BeCT­ xaHH3Max 'IerO-TO He uOCTaeT Ha POCCHH Ho He 6y Ub uaJKe MapKCH3Ma HaBpM JIH pYCCKHe 6bIDH TOPblM C06paJI 6bl Boe uI1HO 6JIaropo uHble JIH'IHble Ka'leCTBa PYCCKHX KaKorO-TO ueHTpa IIpHTH I eHHH KO­ fib C'IaCTJIHBbl H OTHOCHJIHCb u06pococe uCKH upyr K upyry HnH HX 6JIeCTHll He aHaJIHTHlJeCKHe Clloco6HOCTH KOTophle 1I03BOJIHlOT HHOnJIeMeHHHKaM MHoroe H3 HX npOlllJIoro JIoro He no uTBep l ­ HM y6e uHTeJIbHO onHCblBaTb co6CTBeHHoe lIe'laJIhHOe nOJIO l eHHe uaeT C BoneR H3MeHHTb ycnoBHH CBoeM l H3HI1 212 JTOT pa3phIB Me Uy 213 cnoc06HOCTblO 06HIDKaTb CBOH PaBbI H HeYMeHHeM 'ITo-nH60 npe ll ­ npHHHTb pa ll H H36aBneHHfl eBponeHcKHx HalOiH Bor PyCCKHM nHcaTenflM H OT HHX OmHlJaeT PyCCKHX OT Bcex CBH ll eTenb He HaM paCTonKOBblBaTb PYCCKHM HHTennHreHTaM 'ITO TBOPHTCfl Ha HX pO ll HHe OHH ll YManH H nHeanH 06 nOM C TaKOM rny6HHoH C TaKoH TBOp'IeCKOM OT ll a'leH 0 KOTOPblX Ha 3ana ll e HHKTO H He Me'lTaeT HeT COMHeHHfl 'ITO COniKeHHlJ bIH MaKCHMOB CHHflBCKHH H ll Pynfe urnPOKO H3BeCTHble MbICJIHTenH H IIHCaTenH IIpe ll CTaBnH­ lOT C060H JIHillb BepllIHHY aHc6epra B POCCHH ll OJDKHbI 6b1Tb TbICfl­ 'IH ll pyrHx TaKHX iKe TanaHTJIHBbIX HO IIOKa HeH3BeCTHbIX Tpare­ OKa3anOCb 6hI 'ITO eCTeCTBeHHafl llaHlUlra HJlH lIlelUlHa ll 0 TpHecTa 11 rpaHHIJ a POCCHH H ll eT or IIOCKOJIbKY 0 ll H0 3aBoeBaHHe HeH36e f H0 Bne'leT 3a c060H ll Pyroe a O ll Ha aHHeKCHH ll pyrylO 3aBoeBaHHe TYPIUIH PoccHeM flBHJlOCh 6bI ronhKO IIpenlO ll HeH K aHHeKCHH BeHrpHH IIpyccHH fanHIUIH H K OKOH'IaTeJIbHoMY C03 ll a­ HHIO TOM CJIaBflHCKoH HMlIepHH 0 KOTOPOH Me'lTanH q aHaTH'lHhle q HJlOCOq bI IIaHCnaBH3Ma QT06bI oxapaKrepH30BaTb ren y6epe% EBpony MapKc B TOlJRee fl3BY or KOTOPOH OH 1856 r XO­ ll 06aBHJI He B CypoBOM repoH3Me HOPMaHCKOM 3IIOXH a B KpoBaBoH ll Hfl o ll HaKO B TOM 'ITO H OHH Bce BMeCTe He B COCTOflHHH C ll BH­ TpflcHHe MOHronhCKoro pa6cTBa 3apO ll HJlaCh MOCKOBHfl H cOBpe­ HyTb CTpaHY C MepTBOH TO'lKH MeHHafl POCCHfl flBnfleTCfl HH 'IeM HHhIM KaK IIpe06pa30BaHHoM MocKoBHeM YPEAR A MOiKeT 6bITb na HeCIIoc06HOCTb PYCCKHX HHTeJIJIH­ reHTOB K IIpaKTHlJeCKOH ll eflTeJIbHOCTH nHllIb IIOCne ll CTBHe 06no­ I1HTepecHo eCJIH 6hI MapKc YBH ll en HhIHellIHlO1O cOBeTCKYIO HMllepHIO CTan nH 6bI OH eBpOKOMMYHHCTOM MOBlllHHbI BflnOCTH He3q q eKTHBHoCTH I1nH C ll pyrOH CTOpOHbI He Bbl3BaHa nH na HecIIoc06HOCTb IIo ll c03HaTenbHblM iKeJIaHHeM PYCCKHX cTpa ll aTb H60 rOJIbKO IIpH C03HaHHH IIpH'lHHfleMOH HM CETOH-YOTCOR MapKc pe3Ko OTpHIJ aTeJIhHO OTHOCHJlCH KO BceMY 'ITO ll eJIaJIa POCCHH OH HHKOr ll a 6bI He BbIHec PYCCKOMY HecnpllBe ll JIHBOCTH paCIl BeraeT PYCCKaH ll yrua JIH'lHO MHe HeiKe­ IIpaBHTeJIbCTBY OlIpaB ll areJIbHOro IIpHrOBOpa no npH'lHHe He ll OCTaT­ naHHe COJIiKeHHlJ bIHa OCTaBHTb POCCHIO IIpe ll CTaBnfleTcfl cOBepllIeH­ Ka yllHK ECJIH 6hI MHe ll OBellOCb nHCaTb 0 POCCHH BpeMeH MapKca HO eCTecrBeHHbIM eMY llyJ Cell fYJIAf A Be ll b ll IDKe rnyxoH 3a60p fl 6bIlI 6bI HaBepHHKa CHHCXO ll HTellbHee MapKC B03MYlUanCfl TeM KOTOPbIM OH OTr0P0 ll Hn CBOH ll OM B BepMOHTe He 3aMeHfleT narepb KaK B POCCHH omOCHllHCb K eBpeflM XOTfl ero c06CTBeHHbIe B3rnH­ CETOH-YOTCOH Y Hero 6bInO MHoro ll PY3eH cpe ll H nOnHKOB K KOTOPbIM MapKc ll bI Ha eBpeMCKHH Bonpoc OTHIO ll b He OTJIHlJanHCb 0 ll H03Ha'IHOCTbIO MOiKeT 6b1Tb Bce 3TO H TaK Ho HaM rnfl ll fl C IIO'ITHreJIbHOrO paCCTOflHHfl ner'le BOCXHlllarbCfl YTOH'leHHbIMH HClIbITbIBall 60JIbmyIO cHMnaTHIO H He Y ll HBHTeJIbHO 'ITO OH pa3 ll e­ OTKnOHeHHflMH PYCCKOM IICHXHKH 'IeM TeM Y Koro PYCCKHe CH ll flT llflll MHeHHe MHOrHX eBponeHCKHX lleBbIX 'ITO PoCCHH - Ha llIee HeHllIaH H3 UiKTaryp KOTOPYIO He06xo ll HMO pa3rpoMHTb 3TO onac­ I KaK H BbI He Y ll HBHJlCfl 6bI HeiKeJIaHHIO COniKeHHlJ bIHa OCTa­ B03MO f HO 'ITO B HbIHellIHHX YCllOBHflX MapKC CTall 6bI eBpo­ BHTb PO ll HHY HO 061 flCHHJI 6bI no HHbIMH MOTHBaMH KaiK ll 0MY KOMMYUHcrOM HO He HCKlllO'IeHO 'ITO OH OTKa3allCfl 6bI OT KOMMY­ IIHCareJIIO TPY ll HO OTOpBaTbCfl OT CTPaBbI Ha fl3bIKe KOTOPOM OH HH3Ma Bo06IIIe C1 e3 ll HB TypHCTOM B COBeTcKyIO HMlIepHIO H YBHAeB nHllIer r ll e OH pa3BHBaeTCfl H paCTeT BMeCTe C PO ll HbIM fl3bIKOM BOO1JHIO tITO TaM CO ll eflHO ero HMeHeM OH CKopee Bcero BepH 'llCfl YPSAH HHTb CBOM MeTO ll K aHallH3Y COBeTCKoro 06lUeCTBa H KllHHYCb 6bI B EBpony IIOTpflCeHHhIM BhITb MOiKeT MapKC CYMell 6bI npHMe­ 06a MbI BbICKa3anH MHoro He ll 06poiKenaTenbHoro H 0 PYCCKOM HalOiOHaJIH3Me H 0 PYCCKOM HMnepHH Ho HHrepecHo 3TOT MaTepHan CTOHJIO 6bI nO'lHTaTb HH 0 ll Ha MapKCHCTCKaH pa60ra 'Iro O ll HHM H3 caMbIX OCTpbIX KPHTHKOB PYCCKoro 3KClIaHCHOHH3­ o COBerCKOH HMrrepHH Ma 6bIn He KTO HHOM KaK caM Kapn MapKC OH BH ll eJI B naHCJIa­ ro epeTHKa Py ll Ollbq a Bapo Koroporo fl Ha3Ban 6bI KOMMYHHcrH­ BH3Me TO iKe caMoe 'ITO Mbi renepb BH ll HM B KOMMYHH3Me - 0pY ll He pacnpOCTpaHeHHfl MOCKOBCKOH THpaHHH B anpeJIe IIHcan 214 1853 r MapKc 'IeCKHM ll aiKe HCClle ll OBaHHe BOCTO'lHO-repMaHCKO­ MapTHHOM JIIOTepoM C KpHTHtIeCKHM pa360poM npo ll enan 6bI MapKC He BbI ll epiKana peanbHoro 6bI cpaBHeHHH COlUlanH3Ma KOTOPbIH 215 YPEAH Bbl CKa3aJTH qTO MapKC HHKorna He onpaBnaJI 6bl PYC­ CKoe npaBHTeJTbCTBO no npH He HenOCTaTKa YJTHK Ho rOBopH no llATbi IIAMjlTHblE COBeCTH HH MapKC HH 3HreJTbC HH non KaKHM BH lJ OM He onpaB­ naJTH 6bl H PYCCKHH Hapon H PYCCKHH HaUHOHaJTbHbIR xapaKTep 60 JIET Be lJ b HMeHHO MapKC He pa3 nOIJ qepKHBaJT qTO B nOJTHTHKe PYC­ CCCP CKoro rocynapcTBa eCTb HeH3MeHHaH npeeMCTBeHHOCTb qTO pYCCKHe OTO KneCTBJTHIOT ce6H co CBOHM rocynapCTBOM qTO Ha PoCCHH $ ClLflHUijKUU JTe KHT HeCMbIBaeMbm OrneqaTOK ee npollDIOR HCTOPHH H T n MHTe­ peCHO qTO no xapaKTepy 3THX CY KIJ eHHH MapKca HX TPy lJ HO CqeCTb MapKCHCTCKHMH CKopee OHH - M aHTHMapKCHCTCKHe qTO 6b1 HH YTBep K aJT B CBOHX TeopeTuqeCKHX Tpynax rulH ny6­ JTHUHCTHqeCKHX CTaTbHX MapKC KaK 6b1 IIPOBJIEMbi IIOJIHTMqECKOR 3KOHOMMqECKOR MHTEfPAUMM B KAHYH OBPA30BAHMjI CCCP HH HCTOJTKOBbIBaJI OH Eme no peBOlIlOIl HH np06JTeMbl HOBOR HCTOPHH ero BblCKa3blBaHHH no HaUHOHaJIbHOMY 6ynyqH BeCbMa HeMHOrOqHClIeHHOH nOlIH­ Bonpocy C03BYqHbi BaWHM HaUHH He cBo60nHbI OT CBoeR HCTO­ THqeCKOH opraHH3aIl HeR 601IbweBHCTcKaH napTHH H3YqaJIa MeTO lJ bI pHH HH iJ HBHJJ YyMaM He naHO Bbl6HpaTb ce6e HaUHOHaJTbHOCTb 3aXBaTa BlIaCTH C YlleTOM Toro qTO MHoroHaUHOHaJIbHaH POCCHH­ CETOH-YOTCOH HepyccKHe cKaH HMilepHH OTO KIJ eCTBlIHeTCH C rocynapcTBOM PYCCKHX H qTO lla H HMeHHO nOJTOMY MapKc BepHo OTMeTHJT pOKOBYIO npeeMcTBeHHocTb PYCCKOro JKCnaHCHOHIDMa OT BpeMeH CBHTOCJTaBa VIII CTaHTHHOnOJTIO B M no HHKOJTaH I 06a OHH yrpo KaJTH KOH­ HanO Benb OTnaTb eMY IJ OJT KHoe MapKc no HaIl HH He o6JIanaIOT B HMilepHH co6cTBeHHoR rocynapCTBeHHOCTblO CBOHX nOlIHTHqeCKHX nporpaMMax 601IbweBHKH paccMaTpHBaJIH nepcneKTHBbl pa3BHTHH MllOrOHaUHOHaJIbHOR PoC­ CHH ClIelJ yeT OTnaTb HM IJ OlI KHOe y 601IbweBHKoB 6bllO qyBCTBO npH3HaJT HecMoTpH Ha TO qTO JTO He YKJTanbIBaJIOCb B ero c06CTBeH­ roCYIJ apCTBeHHoro npoBHneHHH nocKOlIbKY OHM eme no peBo- HYIO KOHuenUHIO HCTOpHH 1I1OIl HH nOHMH qTO KlIlOqeBblMH B POCCHRCKOH HMilepHH HBlIHIOTCH COBpeMeHHbIe 3aBOeBaTeJTbHbIe ycnexH PYCCKO-COBeTCKoro HM­ arpaPHbm H HaIl HOHaJIbHblH BonpoCbI H pa36HpalIHCb B JTHX nepHaJTH3Ma eme 60JTbwe y6enHJTH MapKca H 3HreJTbca qTO HaUHO­ Bonpocax lIyqwe qeM npYI1le napnul PoCCHH qTO n03BOlIHJTO HM HaJTbHaH npeeMCTBeHHOCTb He npepblBaeTCH a B03MO KHOCTH PYCCKO­ B KeCTOqaHllIHX YClIOBHHX peBOlIlOUHH B03neRCTBOBaTb Ha pyCCKylO COBeTCKOR HMilepHH HeCTH C C06010 MOHrOJTbCKOe pa6CTBO ceR­ H HepYCCKHe HaIl HH CHJTOH He TOlIbKO opY I IDI HO H HneOlIonm HaunoHaJIbHaH npo6JIeMa POCCHH - qac HecpaBHHMbI C TeMH KOTOPbIX OHH CTpaWHJTHCb npH KH3HH no npo6JIeMa OTHOWeHH Me KJJ y UeHTpalIbHOH BlIaCTblO HMilepHH Me KJJ y YPEAH HaJIHcaJT MCTOPHH nOJTHa napanOKcaMH BeIJ b HMeHHO 3HreJTbC 18 BOCCTaHHe a HIOHH 1848 r 6JTHCTaTemHYlO 13 HHBapH TOrO Ke rOIJ a CTaTblO IIpa KcKoe BeHrepcKaH 60Pb6a pyCCKHMH KaK HaUHOHaJIbHOR 6a30H HMilepHH C O lJ HOH CTOPOHbI H HepyccKHMH HerocynapCTBeHHblMH HaUHHMH npo61IeMa BCTaJIa Y KeB KOHue - C npyroH IIolIHTuqecKH na XIX - HaqaJIe XX B Korna BOlIHa XIX BeK B HCTO­ HaunOHaJIbHOrO rolH KeHHH 3aTpOHYlIa H POCCHIO CETOH-YOTCOH BYnb MapKc H 3Hremc KHBbI OHH MomH PHH TaK H HaJBaH BeK HaunOHaJIbHOCTeH HeKOTopble yrHeTeH­ 6bl HeCKOJTbKO nO lJ HOBHB nOCJTaTb CBOH pa60TbI COBeTCKHM BO K­ Hble HerocynapCTBeHHbIe HaunH HMilepHH YCTpeMHlIHCb K Hauno­ 1M H npH3BaTb npoJTeTapHeB Bcex CTpaH K 60Pb6e npOTHB peaK­ HaJIbHOR He3aBHCHMOCTH K UHOHHOH iJ HKTaTypbI MOCKBbI Ba C TaH qTO TOlIbKO HaunOHaJIbHOe rocynapCTBO MO KeT JaIUH­ TUTb HaUHlO H C03naTb MamHoro pa3BHTHH Ha 216 C03naHHlO HaunOHaJIbHOrO rocynapCT­ YClIOBHH IIpHHunn caMoonpenelIeHHe He06xonHMble paBeHCTBa HaunH J1H ee npaBa OUTH­ HaUHif npoTHBonOCTaBlIHlICH a6colIlOTHCTCKOMY 217