YPEAH Bbl CKa3anH tITO MapKC HHKOrAa He onpaB an 6bI PYC­ CKoe npaBHTenbCTBO no npHtIHHe He OCTaTKa ynHK Ho rOBopH no nAMjlTHblE COBeCTH HH MapKC HH 3HrenbC HH 110 KaKHM BH OM He OlIpaB­ AarrH 6bl H PYCCKHH Hapo H PYCCKHH Hall HOHarrbHb H xapaKTep UATbl 60 nET CCCP Be J b HMeHHO MapKC He pa3 IIO tIepKHBaJI tITO B nOJIHTHKe PYC­ CKoro rocy u apCTBa eCTb HeH3MeHHaH npeeMCTBeHHOCTb tITO PYCCKHe OTO I J eCTBnHIOT ce6H co CBOHM rOCYAapCTBOM tITO Ha POCCHH P CunuuliKUU rre lGff HeCMblBaeMbrn OmetIaTOK ee npolllJIOH HCTOPHH H T l1HTe­ nPOBnEMhl nOnHTHqECKoR H 3KOHOMl1QECKOA HHTEfPAI J HH B KAHYH OBPA30BAHHjI CCCP peCHO tITO 110 xapaKTepy lTHX CY l J eHHH MapKca HX TPY J HO CtIeCTb MapKCHCTCKHMH CKopee OHH - aHTHMapKCHCTCKHe qTO 6b HH YTBep l J an B CBOHX TeopeTHtIeCKHX TpYAaX HJIH IIy6­ JIHlI HCTHtIeCKHX CTaTbHX MapKC KaK 6bI HH HCTonKOBblBan OH Eme 0 peBO 1lOlI HH IIp05rreMbI HOBOH HCTOPHH ero BblCKa3bIBaHHH no Hall HOHanbHOMY 6yny'lH BeCbMa HeMHOrOtIHCJIeHHOH IIOJIH­ BOIIPOCY C03BY'lHbI BalllHM Hall HH He cBo60 J HbI OT CBoeH HCTO­ TH'leCKOH opraHH3all HeH 60nbllleBHCTCKaH napTHH H3yqana MeTO J b1 pHH HH J HBH J yYMaM He aHO Bbl6HpaTb ce5e Hall HOHaJIbHOCTb 3axsaTa BnaCTH C YtJeTOM TOro lITO MHOrOHaIJ HOHanbHaH POCCHH­ CETOH-YOTCOH HepyccKHe CKaH HMIIepHH OTO I J eCTBnHeTCH C rocy u apcTBOM PYCCKHX H lITO lla H HMeHHO II03TOMY MapKC BepHO OTMeTHJI pOKOBYIO IIpeeMCTBeHHOCTb PYCCKOro lKCnaHCHOHH3Ma OT BpeMeH CBHTOCIIaBa HMIIepHH C06CTBeHHoii rocy u apcTBeHHOCTblO CBOHX IIOnHTH'leCKHX nporpaMMax 60nbllleBHKH KOH­ paCCMaTpHBanH IIepClIeKTHBbI pa3BHTHH MHOrOHall HOHanbHOH POC­ l1 Ha o Be b OT u aTb eMY on lKHoe MapKc 3TO Clm CnenyeT OTAaTb HM on lKHoe Y 6onbllleBHKoB 6bIDO qyBCTBO VIII B CTaHTHHOnonlO Hall HH He 05JIa aIOT B 0 HHKOJIaH I 05a OHH yrpo lI aJ1H npH3HaJI HecMoTpH Ha TO tITO 3TO He YKna bIBanOCb B ero c05CTBeH­ rocYAapcTBeHHoro npoBH eHHH IIOCKOJIbKY OHH eme 0 peBo­ HYIO KOHIJ enll HlO HCTOpHH nlOlI HH nOHHJIH 'ITO KJIIO'IeBb MH B POCCHHCKOH HMIIepHH HBJIHIOTCH COBpeMeHHble 3aBoeBaTenbHbIe ycnexH PYCCKO-COBeTCKoro HM­ arpaPHbrn H Hall HOHanbHblii BOIIPOCbl H pa35HpanHCb B 3THX nepHa 1H3Ma eIIJ e 60JIbllle y6e HJIH MapKca H 3Hre 1bca tITO Hall HO­ Bonpocax nY'IIIle tIeM Pyrne napTHH POCCHH lITO n03BOnHJIO HM Ha 1bHaH npeeMCTBeHHOCTb He IIpepblBaeTCH a B03MO lKHOCTH PYCCKO­ B l eCTOtIaHlllHX ycnoBHHx peBonlOlI HH B03 eHCTBOBaTb Ha PYCCKYIO COBeTCKOH HMIIepHH HeCTH C c06010 MOHronbCKoe pa5CTBO ceH­ H HepYCCKHe Hall HH CHJIoii He TonbKO opY HH HO H H eononm Hall HOHanbHaH IIpo6JIeMa POCCHH 'lac HecpaBHHMbl C TeMH KOTOPb X OHH CTpalllHJIHCb IIpH l Jf 3HH Me J y IJ eHTpanbHoii YPEAH HaIIHca 1 l1CTOPHH IIOJIHa IIapa OKcaMH Be b HMeHHO 3HrenbC 18 BOCCTaHHe a HIOHH 1848 r ooHcTaTenbHYIO 13 HHBapH Toro l e ro a CTatblO IIpa l cKoe BeHrepcKaH 50Pb5a lTO npoooeMa OTHOllleHHH BnaCTbIO HMIIepHH HerOCYAapCTBeHHbIMH HaIJ HHMH IIp06JIeMa BCTana Y I e B KOHIJ e - C PyroH XIX PYCCKHMH KaK IIonHTHtIeCKH na XX B KOrAa BonHa POCCHIO XIX BeK B HCTO­ Ha'lane Hall HOHanbHOrO l BH I eHHH 3aTpoHyna H CETOH-YOTCOH Me J y Hall HOHanbHoii OO30H HMIIepHH C O J HOH CTOpoHbl H HepYCCKHMH BY b MapKc H 3Hrenbc HBbl OHH MOrJIH PHH TaK H Ha3BaH BeK Hall HOHanbHocTeii HeKOTopbIe yrHeTeH­ 5bI HeCKonbKO IIO J HOBHB IIOCnaTb CBOH pa60Tbl COBeTCKHM BO l ­ HbIe Herocy apCTBeHHbIe HaIJ HH HMIIepHH YCTpeMHnHCb K HaIJ HO­ J HM H IIpH3BaTb IIponeTapHeB Bcex cTpaH K 60Pb6e IIpOTHB peaK­ HanbHoii He3aBHCHMOCTH K C03 u aHHIO Hall HOHanbHOro rOCYAapCT­ lI HOHHOH J HKTarypbI MOCKBbI Ba CtIHTaH 'ITO TonbKO Hall HOHanbHOe rocy u apCTBO MO l eT 3aIll H­ TUTb Hall HlO H C03AaTb ManbHoro pa3BHTHH Ha 216 ycnoBHH npHHIJ HII caMoolIpe eneHHe He05xo J HMble paBeHCTBa Hall HH J JIH ee onTH­ IIpaBa HauHii npoTHBOlIocTasnHncH a6conlOTHCTCKOMY 217 npHHII Hny I1o noMY mUJ HOH3JlbHaH npo6JIeMa POCCHH CTaJIa COCTaB­ HaIJ HOH3JlbHbIX CHJI Ho HeCMOTp ll Ha 3TO AllJKe COBeTCKHe Hepyc­ HOH lJaCTbIO COIJ HaJIbHOH npo6JIeMbl npo6JIeMbl C03AllHIDI B POC­ CKHe pecny6JIHKH OCTaBaJIHCb BHa'IaJIe He3aBHCHMbIMH CaMOCTO ll­ CHHCKOM roCYAllpCTBe nOAlIHHHO rpa l J aHcKoro o6mecTBa TeJIbHbIe COBeTCKHe pecny6JIHKH 06pa30BaJIHCb H B CpenueH AlHH no peBOJIIOIJ HH H HenOJIrOe BpeMH nocne Hee nporpaMMa 6oJIb­ IIIeBHKOB no HaIJ HOHaJIbHOMY Bonpocy OnHpaJIaCb 6yxapa H XOpe3M KpoMe TOro B03HHKJIa COBeTCKa ll pecny6JIHKa Ha JI03YHrn Ha UanbHeM BocToKe KaK rOBOpHJI TOrAll JleHHH OT POCCHH JIH6epanH3Ma JI03YHrn HaIJ HOHaJIbHO-oCB060J HTeJIbHbIX nBlfJKeHHH KpoMe BeJIHKopocCHH HHllero He OCTaJIOCb 3 B PC DCP neC llTKH TaKaH nporpaMMa rOJ lfJIaCb lfl06bl 3aXBamTb BJIaCTb Ho ynepJKaTb BXOJ HBIIIHX B Hee HaponuOCTeH nOJIyqHJIH cTaryc HaIJ HH I1PH3Ha­ BJIaCTb MblIIIJIeHIDI HHe HX HaIJ HOHaJIbHOH aBTItlHOMHH 6bIJIO j aKTOM HCKJIIO'lHTeJIbHO­ roCYAllPCTBeHHOH HaIJ HH npHHIJ Hll eJ HHOH H HeneJIHMOR POCCHH ro 3HaQeHHH cBuneTeJIbCTBOM Toro 'ITO 6oJIbIIIeBHKH HanepeKOp HapYIIIaH BeKOBble TpaJ HIJ HH HMllepCKOro 60JIbIIIeBHKH He MOrJIH 1 CBoeH l1HorAll B CKyt HbIX Teopem'leCKHX cnopax a nontJac H B ropH­ napTHHHOH nOKTpHHe Bbmy l J eHbI 6bIJIH cornaCHTbCH C opraHH3anHeH COBeTCKOH POCCHH no npHHUHny j enepaUHH Onua­ I HX J HCKYCC HHX 60JIbIIIeBHKH 06CYJKAllJlH KaK MOJKeT CKa3aTbC Il KO HaIJ HOHaJIbHYIO npo6JIeMY na HOBaH j OPMa He peIIIHna - Ha rOCYAllpCTBa HanHOHaJIH3M PYCCKHX H HepYCCKHX B caMOH PC DCP HH B OTHOIIIeHH IlX MeJKny PC DCP H npyrHMH HaIJ HH H B COOTBeTCTBHH C 3mM pa3pa6aTbmaJIH CBOIO nporpaMMY caMOCTO llTeJIbHbIMH COBeTCKHMH pecny6JIHKaMH nOCKOJIbKY 6oJIb­ peIIIeHH Il IIIeBHKH cpa3y JKe npHCTynHJIH K peCTaBpaUHH neHTpaJIH30BaHHOro xapaKTepe HaIJ HOHaJIbHOrO Bonpoca B POCCHH KpaCHOH HHTbIO 6oJIbIIIeBHCTCKOH nOKTpHHbI CTaJIO coxpaHeHHe KpynHoro neHTpa­ MHoroHaIJ HOHaJIbHOrO JIH30BaHHoro rOCYAllpCTBa H nOJ MeHa npaBa HaIJ HH caMOCTO llTeJIb­ BJIaCTH H roCYAllpCTBa pa3pa60TKe nOJIHTHKH 3m HOBoro C03AllHHIO HOBbIX HneOJIOrn'leCKoro nponeccbI npoxOJ lfJIH HH CTpyKryp 060CHOBaHH Il HO pellan CBOIO CYJ b6y TaK Ha3bmaeMbiM KJIaCCOBbIM nplfHUHllOM CBoeH BaJKHaH pOJIb npH peaJIH3aUHH 3TOR nporpaMMbl OTBOJ lfJIaCb Hne­ 06YCJIOBJIHBaJIH npyr npyra Ha nepenuHH MaR BblIIIeJI KOH j JIHKT onuoBpeMeHHo H OJIOrnH Hliorna npaBAll uneOJIOrH ll YAllp llJIa no caMHM 6oJIbIIIe­ MeJKny CTpeMJIeHHeM HaIJ HH K HanHOHaJIbHOH He3aBHCHMOCTH - BHKaM KaK 6YMepaur H60 HeKOTopbIe 60JIbllleBHKH H HX npOTHB­ OnuOH CTOPOHbI H CTpeMJIeHHeM neHTpaJIbHOH BJIaCTH 3KOHOMH­ HHKH BOcnPHHHMaJIH 60JIbIIIeBHCTCKHe JI03YHrH 0 paBeHCTBe HanHH qeCKH H npaBe Ha caMoonpeneJIeHHe BMOTb no OTneJIeHHH H 06pa30BaHHH pecny6JIHKH C PC€I CP - He3aBHcHMoro rOCYAllpCTBa cepbe3Ho H CCbIJIaJIlfCb Ha cnoBa 3H­ paJIbHOH BJIaCTH PC DCP B TO reJIbca 0 POCCHH KaK BJIaneJIHne rpoManuoro KOJIH'leCTBa yKpa­ paHOHHpOBaHIDl KOTOPbIH B neHHOH c06CTBeHHOCTH KOTOpyIO eH npuneTCH OTAllTb HaJan B neHb paB onHpa llCb Ha TpH j aKTopa onpeneJI IlBIIIHX TOrAll OTHOIIIeHHH pacnJIaTbI 2 MeJKny I1aneHHe napCKoro npaBHTeJIbCTBa - CHMBOJIa eJ HHOH H Hene­ C H nOJIHTH'IeCKH HHTerpHpOBaTb HepYCCKHe HaIJ HOH3JlbHbIe HepyccKHMH C npyroH OnuHM H3 HHCTpYMeHTOB neHT­ BpeMH CTaJI MaH 3KOHOMHQeCKoro 1921 r pa3pa6oTaJI COBeTCKHMH M r pecny6JIHKaMH H AneKcaun­ coBeTcKoH PoccHeH JIHMOH POCCHH a Bcnen 3a HHM neMOKpaTH'leCKOrO BpeMeHHoro npaBHTeJIbCTBa KaK H YCTaHOBJIeHHe 6oJIbIIIeBHCTCKOH J HKTaTY­ pbI 6bIJIO cnenCTBHeM nOJIHTH'IeCKOrO 3KOHOMH'IeCKOrO H nyXOB­ HOro KpH3Hca PyCCKOro rocYAllpCTBa B 1917-18 1 Bo rnaBe Bcex pecny6JIHK CTOHJIH HaIJ HOHaJIbHbIe COBeTCKHe npaBHTeJIbCTBa HanuoHaJIbHbIe JKe KOMMYHHCTH'leCKHe napTHH rr POCCHHCKaH He 6bIJIH caMocTOHTeJIbHbIMH OHH 6bIJIH TeppHTOpHaJIbHbIMH op­ HMllepHH pacnaJIaCb Ha KYCKH Ha ee pa3BaJIHHax B03HHKaJIH HaIJ HO­ raHH3aIJ HHMH KOMllapTHH POCCHH H npOBOJ lfJIH B HepYCCKHX COBeT­ uaJIbHbIe CKHX pecny6JIHKax nOJIHTHKY MOCKOBCKoro neHTpa rOCYAllpcTBa €I HHJI IlHJ HH 3CTOHH Il JlaTBHH JlHTBa H I10JIbIIIa Bo3HHKIIIHe JKe Ha TeppHTopHH YKpaHHbl 6eJI0pYCCHH fpY3HH ApMeHHH H Alep6aH 1 JKaHa He3aBHCHMbie rocYAllpcTBa 2 B j eBpaJIe 1919 r UK PKI1 6 H3naJI J HpeKTHBY 03aKJIIO­ '1eHHH BoeHHoro H 3KOHOMH'IeCKoro COIOJa 4 MeJKny PC€I CP H Hepyc­ nOCTeneHHO CTaHOBHJIHCb COBeTCKHMH COIJ HaJIHCTH'leCKHMH pecny CKHMH JIHKaMH nOCKOJIbKY npOnBHHYBIIIHeC Il B 3TH pecny6JIHKH OTp llJ bI COBeTCKOH pecny6JIHKH B 3TOT COI03 03Ha'IaJIO HenocpenCTBeHHoe COBeTCKHMH KpaCHOH apMHH PC DCP OKa3aJIHCb CHJIbHee HeKoMMYHHCTH'leCKHX nOnl HHeHHe 218 OpraHaM PC€I CP ee pecny6JIHKaMH rocYAllpCTBeHHbIX BCTynneHHe opraHOB HanHOHaJIbHOH rOCYAllpcTBeHHbIM 219 3 OTHOweHHH Me l lJy HepyccKHMH COBeTCKHMH pecnyfirrHKa­ MH H PCOCP IOpH J Hl eCKH 6bIJIH o popMlIeHbI B COOTBeTCTBHH C Y HCTOPHH oc06aH norHKa HOBoe KOMMYHHCTHl eCKOe npaBH­ TeJIbCTBO COBeTcKoH POCCHH nOCTOHHHO Ha3bIBaeT ce6H BJIaCTblO OCHOBHbIMH Teopeml eCKHMH nOnO KeHHHMH nporpaMMbI 6onbwe­ coBeTcKoH BJIaCTblO J HKTaTypoH npoJIeTapHaTa H T n A BJIaClb BHCTCKOH KaK nHcan MaKC Be6ep 03Hal ael HaBH3b1BaHHe BonH p a Ke Torp a napTHH no HaIIHOHanbHoMY Bonpocy ITonHTHI eCKaH Ke p oKTpHHa 6onbweBHKoB npH3HaBana 3a Hapop aMH npaBo Ha Korp a OTp eneHHe npoGJIeMbI HanpOTHB npe UonaraeT OrpaHHl eHHe BnaCTH H O HO­ OT pyccKoro rocyp apcTBa npaBo Ha HaIIHOHanbHoe nOH Bone COnpOTHBnHIOTCH PeweHHe Ke HaUHOHanbHOH H rocyp apcTBeHHoe caMoonpep eneHHe OHa p eKnapHpoBana OTKa3 ClopoHHero J HKTaTa lpeGyel cornaCHH H B3aHMHoro YBa KeHHH 00­ KOMMYHHClHl eCKaH napTHH HHKaKoro OrpaHHl eHHH CBoeH BnaCTH OT HaCHnbCTBeHHoro nopa60ll eHHH O Horo Hapop a p pyrHM H 6P06ollbHoe 061 eiJuHeHue paBHonpaBHbIx Hapop oB B O HOM rocy­ He p onycKana cnep OBaTeJIbHO H B ofirracTH HaIIHOHanbHbIX OTHO­ p apCTBe 3THM COBeTCKoe rocyp apcTBO P O 1 HO 6billO OTnHl aTbCH IIIeHH OHa HeH3Ge KH0 P OJI KHa 6bIJIa BepHyTbcH K CHCTeMe HaUHO­ OT uapcKoro MHoroHaUHoHanbHoro rocyp apcTBa HanbHoro OTHOWeHHH Me l lJy HepyccKHMH H PC I CP 6bIJIH o popMneHbI B KpeCTbHHCKHMH OOBeTCKHMH 1920-21 rr pecnyfirrHKaMH oc06b1MH pa60l e­ p oroBopaMH HOBbID xapaKTep Me KHaIIHOHanb­ HbIX OTHOweHHH p on KHO 6billO oTpa3Hlb cop ep Kall eeCH B JTHX HH K 6blBweH POCCHHCKOH HMnepHH HHKoro l eMY He 06H3bIBaeT 5 HepYCCKHe ooBeTCKHe pecnyfirrHKH HMenH CBOH HUnOMaTHI eCKHe - 06H3alenbHblH H JKOHOMHl eCKHH H loprOBbIe npep CTaBHTenbCTBa aTpH6YT He3aBHCHMoro rocyp apCTBa COlO3 HepYCCKHX pecny6nHK Ha3BaH loroBopHOH pep epaUHeH 6 3TOT 00103 nocnY Klfll OCHOBOH KCTaTH BClpeTHnO ropHqylO nOMep KKY o plIll epbI TaK Ha3bIBaeMbIe 6yp a3HbIe cneUbI H p p E J HHaH ueHTpanH30BaHHaH napTHH 6b1Jla yqpe K leHa Ha Cbe3p e PKIT 6 B 1919 VIII r HaIIHoHanbHble ueHTpanbHbIe KOMHTelbI UK PKIT 6 OKa3a­ CTOPOHbI HaUHOHanbHbIM KOMMYHHClHl eCKOH napTHH no OTHoweHHIO K JIHCb B nOJIO KeHHH ry6epHcKHx KOMHTeTOB BoeHHbID C PC I CP 6bIJI qrO C 60nbIIIeBHKaMH paCXO HUHCb YCTPHJIOB CMeHOBeXOBUbI CTapoe tIHHOBHHl eCTBO p oroBopax 3aHBneHHe I TO paKT npe KHeH npHHa JJIe KHOCTH He3a­ BHCHMbIX pecnyfirrHK K rHeTa ClOpOHHHKOB Hep eJIHMOH POCCHH KOTopble no p pyruM BonpocaM MbI Y Ke rOBOpHnH KOMMYHHcmtteCKHM qrO C O HOH naplHHM OTBO J HJIaCb POJIb e IHHCTBeHHOro nOJIHml eCKOrO npenClaBHlenH HaIIHH a C npyroH CTOPOHbl OHH roIH peCTaBpaIIHH e J HHoro ueHTpanH30BaHHoro MHOrOHaIIHOHanb­ GbIJIH MeCTHbIMH OpraHH3aIIHHMH e J HHOH napTHH H B JTOM Kal eCl­ Horo rocyp apCTBa HO npH coxpaHeHHH OOBepweHHO HOBOrO JJIH Be PaCCHH KOBCKOro napTHHHOrO ueHTpa npoBO J Hlb ero nOJIHTHKy IT03TOMY cTaryca HTenbHblX HepYCCKHX Hapop OB KaK HOMHHanbHO caMOCTO­ rocyp apCTBeHHbIX 06pa30BaHHH 3acnY KHBaeT BHHMa­ nOn KHbI BHaqane 6bIJIH 6e30roBOPOI H0 opraHH3aIIHOHHoe nOp I HHHlbCH npHKa3aM Moe­ e J HHCTBO KOMllapTHH p ep KanOCb B HHH I TO B TO BpeMH JIeHHH Tpe60Ban nOp I HHeHHH HaIIHOHanbHbIX ceKpele ITpaBp a KOMMYHHCTHl eCKHe opraHH3aUHH Ha HepYCCKHX HepYCCKHX pecny6nHK opraHaM PC I CP HK06b1 nHWb Ha BpeMH TeppHTopHHX 6bIJIH npeHMYll eCTBeHHO PYCCKHMH 3TO GbIJIO pe3ynb­ BOHHbI Ho B xop e TaK Ha3bIBaeMoH KnacooBoH 6oPb6bI 6onbweBH­ TalOM pa3Mell eHHH npoMbIumeHHoclH ell e B KH YHHI TO KanH B nepBylO Ol epep b BbIpa3HTeneH HaIIHOHanbHoro Korp a He TOnbKO rocyp apCTBeHHaH H JKOHOMHl eCKaH aAMHHHCTpa­ C03HaWiH HepyccKHX HaIIHif npep ocTaBnHH B03MO KHOCTb BbICTY­ IIHH HO H HaH60nee KBanH pHIIHpoBaHHbIe pa60l He GbIJIH B OCHOB­ naTb OT HMeHH HaIIHH nHwb HaIIHOHanbHbIM KOMMYHHCTHl eCKHM 7 napmHM HOM npenCTaBneHbI PYCCKHMH TaKHM 06pa30M H B HepyccKHX C 1919 n03YHIH r 60nbweBHCTCKaH napTHH npep ana 3a6BeHHIO CBOH no HaIIHOHanbHOMY Bonpocy B npep peBonlOIIHOHHbID pecnyfirlHKax nOJIHTHKY 1924 r cpenH KOMMYHHCTOB 6bIJIO Bcero JIHlllb napTHH YKpaHHbI K 3ap aqy 40 8% 1 HHBapH 1921 Gblno IIHOHanbHOM BeHHoro arrnapala YKpaHHbI H Hep enHMOH POCCHH 220 TO Kp eCTBeHHOM npe KHeH e J HHOH npoBO J HJIH PYC­ 1924 r 6bIJIO 5% Ka3aXOB B KOM­ 34 3% YKpaHHueB H PYCCKHX B A3ep6aHp KaHe PYCCKHX cpe J H qJIeHOB naplHH 30 7% KOBCKOro ueHTpa Bce I all e H rpoMl e Clana Hp m pe% 0 MHorOHa­ rocyp apcTBe ueHTpa CKHe IlnH rrpHMepa rrpHBeneM CJIep yIOll He naHHbIe B Ka3aXClaHe B nepHOp H BO BpeMH peBonlOIIHH BbI BHHyB Ha nepeIJ l IHH unaH nO I HHeHHH HepYCCKHX HaIIHH aGoonlOTHOH BnaCTH MOC­ MOCKOBCKoro uapCKHe BpeMeHa B r H3 Ka K bIX 35 100 pa60THHKoB rocyp apcT­ GbIJIH pyccKHe HecMoTpH Ha lO 221 80% 'ITO HaeeneHHj YKpaHHbJ Tor u a COCTaBnMH yKpaHHU bJ pa60­ HauHOHaJIHCTOB BenHKopycCKHX llJOBHHHCTOB KOMMYHHCTOB-HH­ TepHaUHOHaJIHCTOB B 3TH rO J bJ IIO YKpaHHe IIpoKaTHnaCb BOnHa t HM j 3bJKOM rocYAapcTBeHHoro annapaTa 6bIn PYCCKHH 8 UeHTp ynpaBneHHj HaXO J HnCj B CTOmrn e PC I CP B BOeHHOM OTHOllJeHHH PC l CP 6bIna CIDIbHee Apymx peCIIy6nHK lloroBopHOH l eCTOqaHllJHX BbICTpenOB eBpeHCKHX IIOrpOMOB Tpy J HO CpeAH CTOHOB KPHKOB H paccnbJllJaTb roJIoca BbJCTynaBIIIHx Ja 6bInO HeH AOMHHHpyromee HaUHOHaJIf-HOe B03po l J eHHe YKpaHHbJ H HeJaBHCHMoe YKpaHHCKoe IIOnO l eHHe COBeT Hapo J HbJX KOMHccaPOB PC I CP KaK IIpeAce­ rOCYAapCTBO I1pHXOA K BnaCTH KOMMYHHCTOB B HeKOTopoM CMbJC­ u aTenb CHK JIeHHH q aKTHqeCKH 6bIn rnaBOH nHllJb pyccKoro IIpa­ JIe BHTenbCTlIa HMen CBOHX ynOnHOMOqeHHbJX IIpH rocYAapcmeHHbJX ueHTpa 6bIna AeHaUHOHaJIH3aUJij YKpaHHbI H ee IIO J KJIroqeHHe K l eAepaJ UfH a IIOTOMY PC l CP JaHHMaJIa B YCIIOKOHn YKpaHHY O J HaKO uenbro KOMMYHHCTHqeCKOrO peCrry6nHK PYCCKOMY roCYAapCTBy llHpeKTHBbJ H3 PYCCKoro ueHTpa 6bInH 3TH ynonHOMOqeHHbJe He TonbKO BMeJJJHBaJIHCb B pa60TY opraHOB CTOJIb 6ecuepeMOHHbI 'ITO 3aAeBaJIH HaUHOHanbHbJe qyBcma J a l e opraHax HOMHHaJIbHO HeJaBHCHMbJX HaWiOHaJIbHbJX ynpaBneHHj HO qaCTO IIO J MeHMH HX BCKPbIBaH TeM caMbJM q HK­ YKpaHHCKHX KOMMYHHCTOB-HHTepHaUHOHaJIHCTOB B03MYmaBllJHXCj THBHOCTb CYBepeHHbJX IIpaB HepYCCKHX peCIIy6nHK QTO MocKBa o6pamaeTcj C YKpaHHOH KaK C 6ecIIpaBHOH Kono­ 1922 ponH HaUHOHaJIbHbJX roCy u apCT­ HHeH BecHoH C rocy u apCTBeHHbJMH OpraHaMH HapYllJeHHj MocKBoH coro3Horo pa60qe-KpecTbj HcKoro AOroBOpa PC l CP 6bIna ponb KOMMYHHCTH'leCKOH IIapTHH KaK CBj 3yromero IIpeACTaBHTeJIj MH Hapo J HbJX KOMHccapHaToB PC l CP H HeYBa l eHHH 06paTHo IIPOIIOPWiOHaJIbHOH BeHHbJX opraHOB B cpaBHeHHH 3BeHa Ho Bee-TaKH HaWiOHaJIbHbJe KOMJIaPTHH He 6bInH IIonHocTbro HMH CBo60 J HbI OT BnHj HHj H Hy I J CBoeH HaWiOHaJIbHOH cpe J bJ By­ AoroBopoM AeKpeTbJ H3 u aBaeMbIe BcepoccHHcKHM HCIIonHHTem ­ H HJiOKeCTOj I I UfMH IIO OTHOllJeHHro cYBepeHHbJX r UK KI1 6 YKpaHHbJ IIpoTecTOBaJI IIpoTHB IIpaB YKpaHHbJ B COOTBeTCTBHH C COro3HbIM K ueHTpaJIbHbJM rrapTHHHbJM HbIM KOMHTeTOM H CHK PC l CP He 6bInH 06j 3aTeJIbHbI J JIj HauHO­ opraHaM HaWiOHaJIbHbJe KOMIJapnrn Bee l e CTpeMHnHCb 3ammuaTb HaJIbHbIX pecIIy6nHK 6e3 cornaCHj Ha TO HX BepXOBHbIX 0praHOB HHTepeCbJ CBOHX HaWiH KaK TonbKO ueHTp IIPHHHMaJI pellJeHHH YKpaHHUbl HAY e Bpa3pe3 C 3THMH HHTepecaMH B CIIOpaX Me l J y ueHTpaJIb­ 3TOT IIpHHUHII AorOBopa HapYllJaJICj HarrpHMep B HOH H 06nacTHOH BnaCTbro H3-Ja He06xoAHMbJX J JIj pa3BHTHH o6nac­ opraHbI PC l CP H3AanH AeKpeT 0 HeMe J JIeHHOM BBeAeHHH HaJIO­ IIPHBO J HnH B CBoeM IIpoTeCTe AOKa3aTenbcma Mae qTO 1922 r cpeAcm 6onbllJeBHCTCKoe IIpaBHTeJIbCmO 06bNHO OTBepraj roB Ha TeppHTopHj X pecIIy6nHK OpraHbI YCCP 3aHBHnH 'ITO 3TO Tpe60BaHHj 06naCTeH oCy I J aJIo HX KaK IIpoj BneHHe MecTHoro pellJeHHe IIpoTHBopequT YKpaHHCKOH KOHCTHTyUHH KpoMe TOro IIaTpHOTH3Ma HrnopHpyromero K TOMY l e 06merocy u apcmeHHbJe I1pe3HAHYM BeepoCCHHCKoro COBeTa Hapo J Horo X03HHCTBa YTBep­ HHTepeCbl J HJI C03 aHHe KonnemH YKpaHHCKoro COBeTa HapO IHOro X03HH­ TH H TOqKa Ho B MHoroHaWiOHaJIbHOH lloroBopHoH q eAepaJ UfH TaKHe CIIOpbJ Cpa3Y l e IIpHHMH xapaKTep HaUHOHaJIb­ CTBa TorAa KaK B COomeTCTBHH C COro3HbIMH OrOBOpaMH 3aKnID­ HblX KOHq nHKTOB IIOCKonbKY ueHTp KOMMYHHCTHqeCKOH BnaCTH qeHHbJMH Me l J y peCIIy6nHKaMH opraHbI PC l CP He 6bIn TaK I e AaHHoro pyCCKHM IIepHO u a MbJ HaUHOHaJIbHbIM IIOCTOj HHO UeHTpoM I1PH CTaJIKHBaeMCj H3yqeHHH K 1921-22 rr CTaJIO OqeBH J HO qTO IIOnO l eHHe HaWiOHanbHbJX HepYCCKHX CYBepeHHbJX q eAepaWiH HX pecIIy6nHK He YAOBneTBopj eT B paMKax HaUHOHaJIbHbIe qyBcTBa yKpaHHIWB oCKop6nM Te3HC oq H1 UfaJIb­ C TepMHHaMH BenHKOAep l aBHbIH llJOBHHH3M H MeCTHbIH HaUHOHaJIH3M 9 lloroBopHoH 06meq eAepaJIbHbJX opraHOB IIpaBneHHH He 6bInO H HX q YHKUHH q aKTHqeCKH BbllonHMH opra­ HOH I1CTOPHj YKpaHHbJ B IIepBbJe rO J bI IIocne OKu6pj 6bIna He06bIKHOBeHHO IIaJIH 222 Apyr 6ypHOH IIpoTHB C Apyra 1917 IIO paJnJiqRbIe 1920 r rpynIIbJ 3AeCb BbJCTY­ YKpaHHcKHx IIpOIIaraH J bI j Bnj eTCj 'ITO nHllJb IIporpeCCHBHoH PYCCKaH I1onO l eHHe IIpoJleTapcKaj KynbTYpa HaKanHnOCb HaCTOJlbKO 'ITO J JIj paccneAOBaHHj IIPOTHBOpequii Me l J y Hapo J HbJMH KOMHC­ capHaTaMH PC l CP H YKpaHHbI 6bIna C03 aHa oco6a B KOMHCCHH UK PKI1 6 IIO IIpe Ce aTenbCTBoM M B l pYH3e 10 I1PH HbJ PC I CP I1epBbIe IIpoTeCTbJ IIpoTHB nora IIpo3ByqanH Ha YKpa­ HHe 6bUIH IIonHO­ MOqHbI IIpHHHMaTb TaKHe pellJeHHj paccne OBaHHH YKpaHHCKHX IIpoTeCTOB IIO J TBep J HnHCb JIpoj BneHHj BeJIHKO ep l aBHOrO llJOBHHH3Ma co CTOpoHbJ armapa­ Ta PC I CP IIOJlHT6ropo Ha UK OCHOBe PKI1 6 C06paHHbJX IIpHHMO KOMHCCHeH MaTepHaJIOB IIOCTaHOBJleHHe B KOTOPOM 223 nO ll TBep l llJ1aCb He3aBHCHMOCTb YKpaHHbI H OCY lK aJIHCb ll eiiCTBIDI Hapo J Horo KOMHccapHaTa HHOCTpaHHbIX ll en PC J CP nocnaslIIero HOry OT HMeHH YKpaHHbI H ll OKYMeHTbI KaCaIOIIlHeC f YKpaHHbI 6e3 YBe ll OMneHIDI Hapo J HOrO KOMHccapHaTa HHOCTpaHHbIX ll en YKpaHHbI 11 npaBHTenbCTBa Ha cnOBax npH3HaBaBlIIerO CYBepeHHTeT Hepyc­ CKHX COBeTCKHX peCny6nHK Ha ll ene OKa3aJIaCb COBeplIIeHHO HHOH 3TO 6bInO O pHIUlaJIbHblM nO ll TBep K J eHHeM TOro 'ITO 6onblIIeBHCT­ peBOJIIO f ll eKnapHpoBaBlIIa f 03 ll OpoBJIeHHe HaIIHOHaJIbHbIX OTHOlIIeHHK H YHHqTO lKeHHe rocY J apCTBeHHOrO lIIOBHHH3Ma 3THX 06elIlaHHH He BbInOnHHJIa CaM neHHH YKpaHHe H B oco6eHHOCTH no OTHOlIIelIlfIO K nlO J fM OTCTaHBaBlIIHM ee Ha o­ Teppop qK npoTHB YKpaHHIIeB 6bIn XOpolIIO OCBe ll OMneH 0 npo­ HcxO J flIleM Ha YKpaHHe II03 lKe Kor J a nonHT61Opo UK PKII 6 onpe ll eJI fJIo CBOIO nHHHIO B OTHOlIIeHHH K fpY3HH KaK H B nepHo ll 06pa30BaHH f CCCP nelIlfH nHCaJI 'ITO MexaHH3M ynpaBJIeHIDI Ha3BalIHbrn l HKTarypoil nponeTapHaTa HaXO l HTC f B PYKax IIapcKHX 61OpoKpaTOB H BeJIHKOpYCCKHX lIIOBHHHCTOB Ho YKpaHHa HanOM­ HHJIa eMY 06 nOM paHblIIe qeM fpY3H f BoeHHOM OTHOlIIeHHH MOCKOBCKHH IIeHTp He ll On lKeH 6bIn CHJIa 6bIna npe ll CTaBneHa B pe ll epaIIHH TonbKO KpaCHOii apMHeH PC J CP B HepYCCKHX pecny6nHKax 6bInH C pOPMHPOBaHbI HX C06CT­ BeHHbIe He60nblIIHe BoeHHble 'laCTH HO H Te B paMKax BoeIIHO­ nOnHTHqeCKOrO COlO3a 6bInH nO ll 'lHHeHbI KOMaH l OBaHHIO KpaCHoii apMHH PC J CP CMblcn nora MeponpH fTH f 3aKnlO'laJICH B TOM 'ITO Ha OHaJIbHble apMHH KaK aTpH6YT HaIIHOHaJIbHOrO CYBepe­ 6bl CBH ll eTeJIbCTBOBaJIH 0 KaqeCTBeHHO HOBOM OTHO­ lIIeHHH KOMMYHHCTH'leCKOro npaBHTenbCTBa POCCHH K HepYCCKOMY HaCeJIeHHIO IIocne 06pa30BaHHH CCCP na nponaraH l HCTCKaH ll eMOHCTpa f ll 06poii BonH npo ll On KaJIaCb HO B 1938 r Bce HaIIHOHaJIbHble BOHHCKHe qaCTH 6bInH pacnYlIleHbl O PH aJIbHO MexaHH3M npaBJIeHIDI KOMMYHHCTHqeCKOH napTHH KaK e l HHOH AJI f PC J CP H HOMHHaJIbHO pecnY6nHK OpraHH3alI HH Ka30B 224 MOCKOBCKoro opraHH3an Hii KOMMYHHcTlflIecKoii napTHH Ha J BH lKeHHH HanpaBneHHoro Ha o6ecneqeHHe HaIIHOHaJIbUOrO H rocy­ caMoonpe ll eneHHH H oTKa3a OT colO3a C PC J CP MeCTHbrn HaIIHOHaJIH3M opraHH3aIIHIi KOMnapTHH Ha HepyccKHX TeppHTOpH fX 6bIn nHlIIb P06KOH nOnblTKOH OTBeTHTb Ha arpec­ CHBHOCTb PycCKoro BenHKO ll ep lKaBHOrO lIIOBHHH3Ma H60 JI03YlIrH 0 paBeHcTBe HaIIHH paCTBopHJIHCb B IIeHTpaJIHCTCKOM xapaKTepe pe­ ll epalI HH IIo OTHOlIIeHHIO K napTHH H rocY ll apcTBY 6ecnoMolIlHblM OKa3anCH Ka lK J bIH HH J HBHAYYM HO TaK lKe 6ecnOMOlIlHbI no OTHO­ CYBepeHHbIx HepyccKHX COBeTCKHX 06ecne'IHBaJI npoBe ll eHHe B lKH3Hb npH­ IIeHTpa H ll a lKe HaIIHH HaIIHoHanbHoe C03HaHHe HepyccKHX UapO ll OB npo ll on­ lKaJIH nO J aBn fTb H3 onaceHIDI 'ITO eCJlH no C03HaUHe TpaHC PoPMH­ pyeTC f B opraHH3YIOIIlHH nOnHTHqeCKHH paKTOP ll HKTaTypa IIeHT­ PaJIbHOH BnaCTH 6Y ll eT HapYlIIeHa a ll MHHHCTpaTHBHo-nOnHTHqeCKOe B TaKoH CHCTeMe He TOJlbKO 3a­ lKHMaJIaCb KpHTHKa HO H pH3If1IeCKH nHKBHAHpOBaJIHCb caMH KpH­ THKH 12 MOHononbHYIO BnaCTb napTHHHoro 3HaqHTeJIbHOH Mepe TO IIeHTpa o6ycnoBnHBano B 'ITO B ero KOMneTeHIIHH 6bInO H ynpaBne­ HHe 3KOHOMHKOH XOTH B nepBbIe rO ll bI COBeTCKOH BnaCTH KOr IJ a rnaBHblM onacaTbC f KOH PnHKTOB BHYTpH loroBopHoii J e ll epa H BoeHHaH HHTeTa KaK H3 lIIeHHIO K IIeHTpy 6bInH OT ll enbHble COIIHaJIbHbIe rpynnbI KnaCCbI H npoBo J HBlIIHii no OTHOlIIeHHIO K HaJIbHble HHTepeCbI nonHTHKY TBep ll oii PYKH H 6narocnoBHBlIIHii B O ll Ha HepyccKHX TepPHTopHHX He 6bIna OpraHH3aTOpoM HalI HOHaJIbHOrO J apcTBeHHOrO TaKHM 06pa30M nonHTHKa MOCKoBcKOro KOMMYHHCTlflIeCKOrO CKa f e l HHCTBO MHOrOHaIIHOHaJIbHOii pe ll epaIIHI1 He3aBHCHMbIX pecny6­ nHK HH MeTO ll OM ynpasneHHH 6bIn Teppop 3KOHOMH'leCKaH aKTHBHOCTb noqTH He npOHBn fJIaCb IIocne OKOHqalIlfH BoeHHoro KOMMYHH3Ma C BBe ll eHHeM H3IIa Ha'IHllaeTCH nepexo ll K IIempa­ nH30BaHHoMY ynpaBneHHIO He TOJIbKO caMOH napTHeH 110 H X03HHCT­ BOM CTpaHbI IIapum HaqHHaeT yrrpaBn fTb rrpoMbIlIIJIeHIIOCTblO napTHH lKe H onpe ll enHeT nOJIHTHKY KanHTaJIOBJIO lKeHHH qTo Kaca­ eTCH H3IIa H H3rrMaHOB TO 3TO 6bInO BcnoMoraTenbHblM Cpe ll CT­ BOM AJIH o6ecneqeHHH HaCYIIlHbIX lKH3I1eHHbIX nOTpe6HOCTeH uace­ neHHH a He aBTOHOMHOH 'laCTblO P0PMHpYlOlIleHCH nOnHmqeCKOH H 3KOHOMHqeCKOH CHCTeMbI COBeTcKoii POCCHH H3nMallbi 6bInH BbI lKaTbl KaK nHMOH B 06CTaHoBKe 3KOIIOMHqeCKOrO KPH3Hca HO C caMoro HaqaJIa H3IIa CY J b6a ero 6bIna npe ll pemeHa BpeMeH­ Hbrn xapaKTep H3IIa IJ a lKe He CKPbIBaJICH 0 pHIIHaJIbUbIMH npe ll CTa­ BHTenHMH COBeTCKOH POCCHH Ho caM paKT nepexo J a c06CTBeHIIOCTH Ha cpe ll CTBa npOH3BO ll ­ CTBa K p0pMax Bonpoc nOnHTHqeCKOR BnaCTH nOCTaBHJI H rrepe ll HeR Borrpoc 0 H MeTo J ax yrrpaBneHHH 6bIn pelIIeH C03 ll aHHeM Hapo J HblM X03HHCTBOM IIeHTpaJIbllOrO opraua 3TOT onpe ll e­ nHlOlIlero npoH3BO ll CTBeHHble rrporpaMMbl H ll Pyme 3KOHOMHqeCKHe 225 nOKa3aTeJIH 1 J1H OTneJIhHbIX COBeTCKOro rocynapcTBa - npenrrpHHTHH rOCnJIaHa 13 B MaCllITa6ax BeerO BbInOJIHeHHe ero n HpeK­ Toro rrapTHH Morna npH 3TOM BbICTyrrHTb B POJIH 3allIHTHHKa npaB HepyccKHX HaponOB C03 n aBaH HJIJII03HIO qTO TaKHe npaBa HMelOTCH THB 6bIDO 06H3aTeJIbHbIM BCKope o n naKO rOCIIDaH CTaJI Tpe60BaTb H qro PYCCKOMY llIOBHHH3MY B OT nOmlTHqeCKOH BJIaCTH KOOpnHHaIJ HH ee YKa3aHHH C roclUlaHOB­ 3aKpbITa O n naKO B TaK Ha3bmaeMOH 6oPb6e napTHH npoTHB MeCT­ COBeTCKOM rocy n apCTBe nopora CKHMH H JIHKBH n aIJ HH npOMe l 'TOlfHbIX 3BeHbeB ynpaBJIeHHH KO­ HOro HaIJ HOHaJIH3Ma H BeJIHKOnep aBHOrO llIOBHHH3Ma COBepllIeH­ TOpbIe neHCTBYH aBTOHOMHO HapYllIaJIH HCKJIlOquTeJIbHOe npaBO HO He nonYCKaJIOCb TaKoe OTKJIOHeHHe OT rrapTHHHOH JIHHHH IJ eHTpa pacnOpH I llTbCH BaJIOBblM 06meCTBeHHbIM nponyKToM penepaIJ HH I1CXOJJ H H3 3THX coo6pa eHHH rOcrrJIaH H rrpoBo n nHK enHHCTBa rrOJIHTHKH H 3KOHOMHKH mamaTaH y e BO Bpe­ MeHa IloroBopHOH penepaIJ HH BbICTyrraJI npoTHB HepyccKHX HaIJ HO­ pa3neJIeHHe MeCTHbiX HaIJ HOHaJIHCTOB H BeJIHKOnep llCllB­ napcTB TIepBblM KpyIIHbIM MeponpHHTHeM no BHenpeHHIO e n HHoro 1 J1H BeeM IlOroBOPHOM penepaIJ HH yrrpaBJIeHHH 3KOHOMHKOii 6bID HaJIbHbIX OPTaHOB CTpeMHCb Boo6me JIHKBHJJ HpoBaTb HX I1HTepeCbI lUlaHOBoro X03HHCTBa H 3KOHOMHqeCKOH n HKTarypbl IJ eHTpa KaK HbIX llIQBHHHCTOB nYTeM 06pa30BaHHH caMOCTOHTeJIhHbIX rocy­ npoTHBOpelJaT o n naKO rrporpaMMHbIM JI03YHTaM HaIJ HO­ lUlaH 3JIeKTpH pHKaIJ HH - r03nPO Tor n a e 6bID BbI n BHnyT H lUlaH 3KOHOMHqeCKOrO paii oHHpoBaHHH CJIenyeT OTMeTHTb O HaJIbHOH nOJIHTHKH KOMIIapTHH 0 paBeHCTBe HaIJ HH H HX npaBe Ha HneH 3KOHOMHqeCKOrO paHOHHpoBaHHH H n03 e BbI n BHraJIaCb caMoorrpeneJIeHHe Benb caMa IloroBopHaH penepaIJ HH B03HHKJIa Heo n nOKpaTHO Ho Korna 6bi H B KaKOM 6bI BHne na H n eH HH rrOTOMY qTO JIeHHHCKOe rrpaBHTeJIbCTBO He MOrJIO rr03BOJIHTb ce6e HrHopHpoBaTb HaIJ HOHaJIbHOe C03HaHHe HepYCCKHX HaponOB H BbI n BHraJIaCb ee ocymeCTBJIeHHe Beerna 6bIDO CBH3aHO H ocraeTCH nbITaJIOCb XOTH 6bI pOPMaJIbHO OTMe eBaTbCH OT JI03YHTa e n HHOH HOMHqeCKOrO H HeneJIHMOH H K 11 POCCHH BOT Ha 3roM pOHe HCrrOJIHHTeJIbHbIH TOMY e HerrOJIHTHqeCKHH OPTaH - rOcnJIaH - nOTpe60BaJI CBH3aHHbIM C HaIJ HOHaJIbHOM npo6JIeMoii ABTOPbI npoeKTOB 3KO­ paHOHHPOBaHHH npH3HaBaJIH no BeJJ b KaK y e 6bIDO CKa3aHO IJ eHTpaJIH30BaHHoe ynpaBJIeHHe X03HHCTBOM npe­ n yCMaTpHBaeT IJ eHTpaJIhHylO BJIaCTb Mecro npe6bJBaHHH KOTOpOii - rrpHHIJ HnHaJIbHblX na e C P0PMaJIbHO-lOpH n HqeCKOH TOqI H 3peHHH TepPHTopHH rocrronCTBYlOmeii B rocy n apCTBe HaIJ HH HaIJ HOHaJIbHble H3MeHeHHH e OpTaHbI CTpeMHllIHeCH K rrpoH3BOnCTBeHHOH H ToproBoii aBTO­ rrOJIHTHKH KOMMYHHCTHqeCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa rro OTHOllIeHHIO K HepYCCKHM HaIJ HHM rOClUlaH n06HBaJICH no cymecT­ HOMHll BY JIHKBHnaIJ HH HepyccKHX pecny6JIHK JIHKBHnaIJ HH IloroBopHOH yrrpaBJIeHHH KaK HeHY HbIH 6anJIaCT 14 BnepBbIe IIJIaH 3KOHOMH­ penepaIJ HH H C03naHHH KperrKoro He CquTalOmerOCH C rrpaBaMH qeCKoro 1919-1922 HaIJ HH COBeT Hapo n noro X03HHCTBa IJ eHTpa MHoroHaIJ HOHaJIbHOrO rocynapCTBa 3TO HeCOOT­ paCCMaTpHBaIOTCH paii oHHpoBaHHH BeTCTBHe KpaCHOil HHTblO rrpoXO n HT qepe3 BCIO HCTOPHIO COBeTCKO­ C HHHIJ HaTHBOH ro rocy n apcTBa - HaIJ HOHaJIbHbIe npoTHBopeque Me Jy CTpeMJIeHHeM K 3KOHOMH­ qeCKOMY H rrOJIHTHqeCKOMY IJ eHTpaJIH3MY H P0PMaJIbHO-anMHHHCT­ paTHBHbIM pa3neJIeHHHM rocynapCTBa rro HaIJ HOHaJIbHO-TeppHTO- PHaJIbHOMY rrpH3HaKY· TIPH rrOMOmH HK06b1 HenOJIHTHqeCKOrO opraHa - H3MeHeHHH MHeHHlO CTopoliHHKaMH 06Cy JJ aJICH B IJ eHTpaJIH30BaHHoro CHX PCCI CP HCKJIlOquTb H3 c J epbI aBTOPOB co6cTBeHHOCTH Torna yrrpaBJIeHHH X03HHCTBOM OpTaHbI HepyccKHX pecrry6JIHK pOPMbI rr BblCIIIHH BbICTyrrHJI TaK He06xo n HMOCTb KaK B BBHny HHX no IIJIaHa omaJIa Ho C06CTBeHHOCTb-TO Ha neJIe HaxO n HJIaCb B pyKax KOMMYHHCmqeCKOH rrapTHH rr03ToMY 3KOHO­ rOClUlaHa - JIeHHHCKaH n HKrarypa eme no 06pa30BaHHH CCCP rrpOBeJIa KaK 6bI peKOrHOCIJ HPOBKY HaIJ HOHaJIbHOro C03HaHHH HepYCCKHX Hapo­ MHtfeCKHe KOH PnHKTbI IIPOHBJIHJIHCb KaK KOH pJIHKTbl BHYTpHIIap­ THHHbIe B 1924 r B KHHre 'TepOHqeCKHH nepHOn BeJIHKOH PYCCKOH nOB ECJIH OHH OKa3bIBaJIH conpoTHBJIeHHe JIeHHHCKoe rrpaaHTeJIb­ peBOJIIOIJ HH H3BecTHbIH 3KOHOMHCT n KPHIJ MaH IIHcaJI 0 CTpeM­ CTBO oTcTynaJIO He eJIaH OTKPbITOro KOH PnHKTa C HaIJ HOHaJIbHbI­ JIeHHH KOMMYHHCTHtfeCKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa IIOJIHOCTbIO IJ eHTpaJIH­ 3TO 3HpoBaTb 3KOHOMHKY YHH O H8 Bee O nOH IJ eJIH npeIIHTCT­ 6bIDO yno6Ho rrOCKOJIbKY MO i Q 6bIJIO rrpH He06xO n HMOCTH OTCry­ ByeT 3Ta nOJIHTHKa rrpaaHTeJIbCTBa npoBO n Rl1aCb 3KOHOMHtfeCKH­ rrHTb He rronpbIBaH rrpeCTH 6oJIbllIeBHCTcKOH HneOJIOrHH DOJIee MH 0PTaHaMH COXpaHHBllIHMHCH MH 226 opraHaMH JIHKBH n aIJ HH KOroPbIX Tpe60BaJI rOClUlaH OT oopeeOlllOijUOHHOU POCCHH 227 rocy uapCTBCHHbIMll MHHHCTCpCTBaMH KOTOPbIC 6bmH J1Hlllb rrcpc­ KOHIIcrrlUfIO HMCHOBaHbI B HapOAHbIC KOMHccapHaTbI H CHHJl HKaTaMll rrcpCH­ OOJHpyeTC» MCHOBaHHbIMH B rJ1aBHbIC rrpOMbIlllJ1CHHbIC yrrpaBJ1CHHH rnABKH Ecm1 cpaBHHTb CTapbIC H HOBbIC 3KOHOMH'ICCKHC opraHbI KpHIIMaH KHM J1CrKO 06HapY I IBaeTCH rrHcaJ1 rrpeeMCTBeHHocTb He 6Y lJ YT cpHHaHCHpoBaTbCH COBeTcKOH PoccHeH H 'ITO opraHbI ynpaB­ 3TO 6bm rrcpHO lJ rpa l uaHCKOH BOHHbI H BOCHHoro KOMMYHH3Ma JACTO'IHHKOB cpHHaH­ cHpoBaHHH y IICHTpanbHOH BnaCTH HC 6bmo PyCCKHC o6rracTH CHJ1bHO 3aBHCCJIH OT nOCTaBOK H3 HCPYCCKHX COBCTCKHX pccny6­ JIHK JAHbIMll cnOBaMH rrpHHHMaH nOCTaHOBJ1CHHe 'ITO 3KOHOMHKa HCPYCCKHX pecrry6nHK 6Y lJ CT cpHHaHCHpOBanCH OpraHaMll PCOCP CHX rrpe J 10naraJI rronY'lHTb CpC lJ CTBa 1J J1H 3Toro cpHHaHCHpoBaHHH OT caMHX HCPYCCKHX pecny6mIK Tpe60BaHHc PbIKoBa 06 YHHqTO­ I CHHH HaIIHOHaJIbHbIX opraHoB MHQCCKOrO eJl HHCTBa VIII pccrry6rrHK cnC3 lJ PKll 1 B HHTcpccax 3KOHO­ OTHOCHTCH K flo CHH KOTOPbIH 6bm pa3pa6OTaH B 1921 r COTpY lJ HHKOM rOcrrnaHa JInaH 3KOHOMHqeCKOrO paHOHHpoBaHHH pa3 lJ enCHHH TpY lJ a CnO l HBWCMCH Y I C BO BpeMCHa POCCHHCKOH HMncpHH OnHpaHCb Ha CYlIIeCTBYIOlIIec pa3­ lJ CnCHHe TpY lJ a paIIHOHaJIbHOrO ArrCKcaH lJ POB pa3BHTHH pa3pa60TaJI TeopHIO npoH3BOJl HTCJ1bHblX CHJ1 HaH60J1cc rrpHHHMa» BO BHHMaHHC TOJIbKO 3KOHOMHqCCKHC KpHTCpHH HaIIHOHaJIbHbIC rpaHHIIbI He Y' HTbIBaJIHCb Bo061IIC ArrCKcaH lJ POB 06'bHCHHn CBOIO 228 lJ OJI KHO C lJ HHCTBO JKOHOMHKH HapYIIIan 06pa3a COBeTCKHX 1 13HH H KYJIbTYPbl Hap0 lJ OB JInaH ArreKcaH lJ poBa 6bm nOCTpoeH Ha TaKOM IIpHHIIHIIe HaIIHOHaJIbHblX OTHOlUeHHH B MHorOHaIIHOHanbHOM rOCY J apCTBe B COOTBCTCTBMH C KOTOPbIM HepYCCKHe HaIIHH paCCMaTpHBaJIHCb KaK no pcrHOHaJIbHbIC H3bIKY· ' aCTM AHaJIH3HpYH e lJ HHOro opraHM3Ma OTJ1lfqaHCb JIHIIIb OAHaKO MaH ArrCKcaH lJ poBa my6 1 c MO KHO 3aMCTHTb 'ITO OH npC lJ YCMaTpHBaJI Hc TOJIbKO 3KOHOMH­ qCCKOC C lJ HHCTBO B rocY lJ a pCTBe f aKTHqeCKH 3TO 6bm rOCIDIaHOB­ CKHH npoeKT e lJ HHOH roCy uaPCTBCHHOH OpraHH3aIIHH MHoroHaIIH­ OHaJIbHOro 06IIIeCTBa rOBOpHJ10Cb TaK HaIIpHMep B MaHe AJl'eKcaH lJ poBa Kor lJ a Mbl nOrHqCCKH pa3BHBaeM OCHOBHYIO M lJ eIO COBpeMeHHO­ CCPOPMYJIHpOBaHa B nnaHC 3KOHOMHqCCKOro paHoHHpoBaHHH Poc­ Ha ArreKcaH lJ poBa He TOMY HaH60ncc qCTKO H lJ CH TOTaJIbHO IIeHTpanH30BaHHoH JKOHOMllKH OCHOBbIBaJ1ClI MaHY pecny6nMK I C B peMcHH JA r ArreKcaH lJ pOBbIM 15 HaIIHOHaJIbHbIC J BH KeHHH POCCMH NIeKcaH lJ pOB Ha3BaJI orpaHHqeHHbIMll H IIOnaraJI 'ITO I eCTKYIO PYCHcpHKaTopCKYIO rrOJIHTlIKY H rrpHMeHJUIO npH 3TOM nCHHH JKOHOMHKOH pccny6J1HK 6Y lJ YT OT lJ aHbI no lJ PYKOBO lJ CTBO atmynHpoBaHo o6rracTH cpe lJ CTBa OCKop6JIHIOlIIHe Hapo lJ bI POCCHH H Be lJ YIIIHe K MX 06HH­ lIIaIIMIO 18 MY HapH lJ y C 3THM CHX rrpHHfIn pellleHHC 'ITO BCC pecny6m1KH 6bmo rrpaB HbIM 06pa30M Kor lJ a npe KJlec npaBHTeJIbCTBO IIbITaJIOCb npOBO lJ HTb pecny6nHK H pa3pa60TaTb C lJ HHyIO npoH3BO lJ CTBCHHYIO nporpaM­ OHO CYBCpeHHbIX OHM aKTHBH3HPOBaJIHCb nMlllb B He6rraronpHHTHbIC nepHO lJ bI maB­ COBCT HapoAHoro X03HHcTBa PC f CP rrOCTaHOBHJ1 06'bCJl HHHTb OCHOBHblC OTpaCJ1l1 Hapo lJ HOrO X03HHCTBa H COxpaHeHMeM ' aCTCH MMlIepMH 6bma aBTOHOMHH 17 B C qClllCKOro - rrOCTaHOBJ1CHHH conpoBO l 1J aJIOCb HanpOTHB MaKCHMaJIbHOH CBo60 lJ OH KOTopaH 6bma Y HeKOTopblX lJ 0 KOHIIa 06paTHbIH nCpeBO lJ CHX PCOCP Pecrry6JuIKaHcKHe opraHbl BblCTynHJ1H rrpOTHB noro lIenCCOO6pa3Horo Ha OCHOBe paIIHOHaJIbHO-3KOHOMHqec_ HH» KaKoH-nH60 06naCUi K POCCHH HH pa3Y no npHCOC 1J tmeHHe CKHe 3KOHOMHqCCKHC opraHbl npoBO lJ HT 3TH TeH lJ eHIIHH nocrre lJ O­ f C 1919 r BblClllHH aBTOHOMHbIX 06rracTcH npHHIIHne ArreKCaH lJ poB HCXO 1J HJ1 TaK Ke H3 TOro 'ITO B crrY' ae npHCOeMHe­ Ho­ BbIe C03 uaHHble peBOJ1l0IIHeH X03HHCTBeHHble opraHbI HMeIOT Te B MapTc C03 lJ aHHH HOBOM KOH a HC Ha OCHOBe nepe l HTKOB YTepHHHbIX CYBcpeHHbIX npaB 16 I C TCH lJ eHIIHH 'ITO H rrpe l 1J e HO B OTJ1H'lHe OT npOlllilbIX COBeT­ BaTeJ1bHO CTPCMHCb lJ OBCCTH HX Haw IDIaH COBCpWCHHO pa3 lJ eJIeHHH roCy uapcTBa TO He rro BTopOCTerreHHbIM a rro 061IIHM 3KOHOMlf1IeC­ rrpH3HaKaM TaK Ha ro cpC lJ epaJIH3Ma npMMeHHTenbHO 1J J1H POCCHHCKOH pccny6mfKH TO lJ OJI KHbI npH3HaBaTb 'ITO Bce K 'IeMy Y KC npMBbIKno HaCeJIeHMe rro XO lJ Y pa3BHTHH CTpaHbI - KaK K rrpeporaTlIBC rOCY lJ apCTBcHHoro IICHTpa C OMOH CTOPOHbI H 'ITO He TOPM03HT pa3BHTHe MeCTH0I1 caMOCTOHTeJ1bHOCTlI B ee rrOJIHOM 06'beMe C lJ PyroH rrpHqCM BCC TO OTHOCHTCH J1HIIIb K 3KOHOMHqCCKOH lJ eHTeJ1bHOCTH lJ On l HO OCTaTbCH B KOMrrCTeHIIHH cpe lJ cpanbHOH BJIaCTH 1lpyrMMM crroBaMM 8 KOMneTeH fUU feHTpallbllOii 8110CTU 01111 POCCUU 6bl lO 6bl qelle­ coo6pa Jlto COXpaUUTb 3 TaMO KCHHyIO Kpe lJ HT 5 1 CBH3M C 3arpaHHIICH nOJ1HTlIKY MamCTpaJIbHYIO 4 CCTb cpHHaHcbI 2 apMHIO H CPJ1OT M rocY lJ apCTBeHHbIH I enC3HO lJ opO KJlbIX lJ opor H 229 BHYTpeHHHX BOWlhIX nyTeH MOpCKHe nOpThI H OpraHH3att HID MOP­ 6 CKHX Tpacc MarHCTpaJIhHYIO meKTpo3aBoWlYIO ceTh H rocYAap­ CTBeHHhIe meKTpOCTaHIl HH 7 KpynHhle rocYJJ apCTBeHHhIe npeA­ npHHTHH H rocYAapcTBeHHhIe npeAllpHHTHH HefioJIhIIIHX pa3MepoB 8 HO rocYAapcTBeHHoro 3HaqeHHH 9 HYIO 3eMJIIO cofiCTBeHHocTh Ha He3aCeJIeH­ BOWloe X03HHCTBO H pacnpeAeJIeHHe BOAhI MeJIHO­ paIJ llOHHYIO CHCTeMY perYJIHpoBKY nOTpefiJIeHHH BOAhI H3 KPyn­ 10 HhlX HCTOqHHKOB 11 MHHepaJIhHhle pecypchI HHe naTeHTOB H npHBeJIerHii 12 npeAOCTaBJIe­ 13 JIeCHOe X03HHCTBO npeAo­ CTaBJIeHHe KOHueccHH Ha C03JJ aHHe rOCYAapCTBeHHblx npeAllPHHTHH 14 Bceofimee rpa K J aHCKoe TpYAoBoe 3aKoHoJJ aTeJIhCTBO rOBJIH 17 IS JaKoHoJJ aTeJIhCTBO 16 Bceofimee perYJIHpOBaHHe BHeIIllieH TOP­ ynpaBJIeHHe nOlfTaMH H TeJIerpa4 oM 3 2 OfiJIaCTHOH TpaHcnopT MeCTHhle HaJIOrH H MecTHhm 4 MeCTHhIe H nOCeJIKOBhle 5 3JIeKTpocTaHIJ lIH H ceTh MecTHoro 3HaqeHHH nOMOmh HaCeJIeHHIO x03HHcTBeHHhiM npoJJ aiKH ceMeHHoe HHBeHTapeM X03HHCTBO CeJIhCKox03IDi cTBeHHhIx npoAYKToB 8 roprOBJIH arpoHoMmecKaH cHafiiKeHHe peryJIHpoBaHHe MeAHl HHCKOe H rHrHeHHqeCKOe oficnYiKHBaHHe 9 AorOBOp BhICTynHJlH QTO OH nOCKOJIbKY npornB HapYIlIaeT nrraHa AneKcaHApoBa Ha TOM COI03HhlH 3KOHOMHQeCKHe pa60qe-KpeCTbHHcKHH paHOHbl ynpaBJIHllHCb fibl HenOCpeACTBeHHO COBeTOM HapoWloro X03HHCTBa PC IlCP a HaIJ HO­ HaJIbHble pecny6J1HKaHcKHe opraHbl JIHIlIHJlHCb fibl CBOHX npaB Ho UeHTpaJIbHOe npaBHTeJIhCTBO HAeIO YKpenrreHHH ueHTPaJIHS­ Ma 3a CQeT HepYCCKHX HapoAOB fibmmeH POCCHH He OTfipoCHJlo IT03iKe OHa JIerna B OCHOBY pa3pa60TaHHoro CTaJIHHbIM nrraRa aBTOHOMH3aIum • Qepe3 HeCKOJIbKO 1922 AeKafipb QeHbI KOMMYHaJIhHOe X03HHCTBO KpeAHT OCHOBaHHH r MeCHl eB B pe3YJIbTaTe OfipaSOBaHHH CCCP 3KOHOMHQeCKaH HHTerpaIUfH pecny6J1HK fibIDa AOBeAeHa AO KOHua a HX cyBepeHHbIe npaBa OKOHQaTeJIbHO yTpa­ ITpaBa OfiJIaCTeH 1 o6J1acTeH AOJIiKHO fihlTh oroBopeHo OCOfihIM cornaIlIeHHeM O lHaKO pecny6J1HKH H 6 7 B COBeTcKoM COI03e fibIDH COSJJ aHbI ueHTPaJIbHbIe opraHbI MHorOHaUHOHaJIbHOro rOCYAapcTBa KOTopbIe HaKOHeU-TO nOJIyqH­ JIH npaBo npoBOAHTb 3KOHOMHQecKYIO nOJIHTHKY He npHHHMaH BO BHHMaHHe CYBepeHHble npaBa HepYCCKHX Ham ceJIhCKO­ opraHHJal HH OfimecTBeHHoe perYJIHpoBaHHe ynpaBJIeHHe npeAllpHHTHHMH o6JraCTHoro 3HaqeHHH perYJIHpOBaHHe MeCTHhIM rpY30BhlM TpaHcnopToM CKJIaJJ aMH 3epHoBhIX H T n AYKIJ lIH II 10 perYJIHpoBaHHe MeJIKOH peMecneHHoH npo­ peryllHpoBaHHe HCnOJIb30BaHHH CeJIhCKoxo3IDi cTBeH­ HOH 3eMJIH B CeJIhCKOX03HHcTBeHHbIx o6JracTHX 12 KYJIhTYPHO­ TeXHHqeCKaH AeHTeJIbHOCTh MeJIHOpaUHH H cHafiiKeHHe BOAOH 3a­ ceJIeHHbIX MeCT H CeJIbCKox03IDi cTBeHHhIx KYJIhTYP 13 COUHaJIh­ Hoe ofieCneqeHHe MeCTHhlX o6JracTeH 310 THn aBTOHOMHH o6JracTH Ha Mecrax qTO KacaeTCH ynpaBJIeHHH fiYAYT npeACTaBHTeJIH ueHT­ pa 19 B nrraHe ArreKcaHApoBa npeAYCMaTpHBaJIOCh HanpHMep pa3Ae­ JIeHHe YKpaHHhI Ha ABa 3KOHOMHqeCKHX paHOHa He CBH3aHHhIX APyr C APyroM HO HenocpeACTBeHHO nOAqJiHeHHhIX MOCKBe EeJIo­ PYCCHH CTaHOBHJlaCh qaCTbIO 3anaAHoro paHOHa H T A fOCnJIaH PC IlCP npeACTaBHJl 3TOT nrraH BhIllleCTOHmHM opraHaM ITpe3HAHYM BUI1K PC IlCP OAofipHJl 13 anpeJIH 1922 r Te3HCbI o paHOHHpoBaHHH B COOTBeTCTBHH C 3THM llJIaHOM AOfiaBHB 'ITO npHcOeAHHeHHe pecny6JrHK K peIlIeHHIO 0 C03JJ aHHH 3KOHOMHqeCKHX 230 231 9 Tal 13 Pe30JIIOIUUI X C'hC3A11 PKn 6 0 HaUIIOHaJIhHOM Bonpocc aHa npHMeqaHHB xapal TepHCTIlKa BeJlHKOpYCCKHX I OMMYHHCTOB pa60TaIOIl HX B Ol paHHHhlX o5naCTJiX T C cpe lH HCpYCCKHX HapoIl OB 1 0TOPhlC H l0 06Pa30BaHID C' o103a 1l0CTaro'IH0 1l0CMOTPCTh Ha COBCTCKOC rocynapCTBo C TO'lKH 3PC­ HID 'lHCJ1CHHOCTH HaccrreHHJi H pa3MCrn CHID rrOrre3HhlX HCKOnaCMhlX rrpOMhllllrreHHOCTH CCrrhCKOrO X03Jiil CTBa 'IT06hl YBHIl CTh B KaKoil CTe­ nCHH MOlUh HhlHClIDiCro CCCP 3aBHCHT OT HCpYCCKHX HaJ l 1Ifi 1'1 HCpYCCKHX CCP 1l 0 lcl a6pJi 1922 r C'lHTaJIHCh lKHTCJIJlMH Ol paHHHhlX TCPPH1'OpKl rocY lapCTBa XOTJi o6lUcro rocYAllpCTBa crn c HC 5hIl10 B PC30JIIOUHH OTMe­ 'laCTCJi ' TO HX C03HaHHC PoPMHPOBaJIOCh l aK C03HaHHC rrpcL cTaBHTeJIcll npaBJirn cil HaUHH OHH HC rr03HaJIH HaUHOHaJIhHoro rHCTa 1'1 n03TOMY HC lO­ HCpYCCKHC Il Be OU CHHBaIOT HaIJ HOHaJIhHhIC oC05eHHOCTIl HC 06parn a1OT Ha HHX BHHMaHID TpeTH CCCP rro HhIHeUIHCMY all MHHHCTpaTHBHOMY ll enCHHIO -- COlO3HhlC 1'1 HC 3HaJOT KyJIhTYPY 06pa3 JKH3HH 1'1 HCTOPH'lCCI OC npollll1oc 1'Oro HJJH HHOro TCPPHTOPHil rOCYlJ apCTBa OK0J10 rr0J10BHHhl HaCeJlCHIUI aBTOHOMHhlC pccny6rrHKH HaUHOHaJIhHhlC 06JIaCTH H oKpyrn HCpYCCKHX HapoAli HauKl H ll a JKe B PC 1 CP 53 5% TeppHTopHH 'lHCJ1HTCJi 3a HepyccKHMH HaJJ H­ 3ro 05CTOJiTeJ1hCTBO BCIl CT I YI J10HY OT I OMMYHH3Ma B croPOHY BCJIHI O­ JiMH 3aJIell H HC PTH 30rrOTa ypaHa yrJIJI H np B OCHOBHOM HaXOMTCJi Ha Il CpJKaBHOCTH HepyccKHX TCpPHTOPID X HCpYCCKOC HaCCJ1CHHC CTaHOBHTCJi OCHOBHhlM BYJIhrapW3HpYIOT 1'1 K0J10HH3aropCTBa rrapTIlH B HaIJ HOHaJIhHOM BcmfKopycCKoro Bonpoce 1ll0BJiHH3Ma TaKHM 05pa30M pe30JIlOIJ HJi X C'hC3A11 npH3HaBaJIa 'ITO HC 1 0MMYHHCTH'lCCKOC MH­ poB033PCHHC HCTO'lHHKOM TpYIl OBhlX PC3CPBOB 1'1 HOBhlX PCKpYTOB J ilJi apMHH nOJIHTIlKY a BeJ1HKOIl CPJKaBHhlil 1ll0BHHH3M Il OMlfHHPOBaJI B nO lXOne K HCpYCCKHM HapoAliM YJKC B Ha'laJIhHhlil COBCTCKHil ncplfo l 3ro JKC I OHCTa­ mpycTCJi 1'1 B Il pyrnx rrapTHil Hhlx Il 0KYMCHTaX HO 3a'laCTYIO B oc05eHHOCTII K MapKc 1 3HI'eJlhC Co'l T 16 CTp 160 Y 3 CTaJIJiHa KPHTHKOil B M nCHHH CO'l T 27 H31l 4 CTp 342 KpHTHKa MeCTHOrO BeJIHKOll cPJKaBHoro HaIJ HOHaJIH3Ma n 3TOM OTHOllIeHHH KJIaCCH'lCCKHM nplfMepoM 4 PHTCJi B Heil - Cpo neHHHcKKI C60pHHK 34 CTp 118-119 1lI0BJiHlf3Ma Pe30JIIOIJ HH X c corrpoBOJKAllcTCJi C'hC3A11 JiBJIaCTCll Il pyroil CTOPOHbI - B roBO­ KOMMYHHCThl-TY3CMUhI ncpelKHBllIHc TJiJKCJIhJil ncpHO l HaIUt­ OHaJIhHOro meTa 1'1 He BIIOJIHe crn c OCBo60 lHBImICCH OT npH3pal OB rrOCJIe l­ s McropHH COBCTCKOil KOHCTHTYUHH B 1l 0KYMCHTaX 1917-1956 HCro HCpell KO rrpcYBCJIH'lHBaIOT 3Ha'lCHHC HaIJ HOHaJIhHhlX oc05eHHoCTCil B napTKI Hoil H COBeTCl oil pa60Tc OCTaBJIaH B TCHH KJIaCCOBhIe HHTCPCChI MOCKBa 1957 cTp 229 TpYMlllJixCJi J1H6o npoCTO CMClllHBalOT HHTCPCChI TpYll JillIHXCJi laHHOil Hau HH 6 3roT COI03 6hlJi O POPMJ1CH B COOTBCTCTBHH C HHCTpYKUHcil nCHHHa o BOCHHOM CJ1HJiHHH HaUHOHaJIOB C PC 1 CP 0 CIl HHOM KOMaHIl OBaHHH BOOpYlKCHHhlX CHJJ H 0 uCHTpaJIH3aI 1I-lH HcnOJIh30BaHID pecypcoB COll Ha­ J1HCTH'lCCKHX pccny6nHK cp B M nCHHH CO'l T 29 H31l 4 CTp 373­ 374 H B COOTBCTCTBHH C Il CKPCTOM BUMKa OT 1 HIOHJi 1919 r 06 o6'hc­ l HHCHHH COBeTCKHX COUHaJIHCTH'leCKHX pccrry5J1HK PoCCHH YKpaJiHhl nHTBhl JIaTBHH H EenopycCHH L JIJI 6oph6hl C MHPOBhlM HMJ1CPHaJIH3MOM XOTa Il CKPCT C TaK Ha3hlBaeMblMH 06rn cHaIJ HOHaJIhHhIMH HHTcPCcaMH roil JKe HaIUlH He yMCli BhIll eJIJiTh rrcpBhIC H3 nOCJ1e lHHX H CTpoHTh Ha HHX rrapTHil HYIO pa60TY 3ro 06CTOHTeJlhCTBO B CBOIO O'lCPC lh Be leT K YKJIOHY OT KOMMyHH3Ma B CTOpoHY BeHHoe ynpaBJ1CHHC BOOpYlKCHHhlMH CHJJaMH 1'1 rrOIl 'lHHllrr uCHTpy rrYTCM C031l aHHJi o5lUero l l1Ji BCCX pCcny5J1HK COBcm HapOIl HOrO X03JiftCTBa 10 Cp 06pa30BaHHC CCCP C60pHHK fmon 1960 CTp 8 lleCJiThJil 51Ky60BCKaJI CTPOHTCllhCTBO COlO3HOro COBeTcKoro roCYAIIPCTBa AH CCCP 1960 CTp 124-130 II 12 L OKYMCHTOB M-n AH CCCP CTp 126 CJ C3Il hl COBCTOB B 1l 0KYMCHTaX 1917-1936 npHHHMalOlUcro Ha BO 'TOKC M 1 PYH3C 5hm Torll a 3aMCCTlfTenCM rrpell ceL aTena CliK YCCP CM CM lKCJ1C3l1hle ll oporH pHHaHchl pacnpcll CJ1CIIHC TPYIl OBhlX PCCypCOB BHClll­ 111010 TOprOBJ11O H Cpell CTBa CBJi3H HaUHOHaJIH3Ma C'he31l PKn 6 CTeHorpa pH'lCCKHil OT'lCT M 1963 CTp 606-607 npH3HaBaJI caMocTOliTenhHOCTh KalKll oft PCcny5nHKH OH paKTH'ICCKH yTBCplKnaJ1 BJ1aCTh ueHTpa rrcpCnaBaJi MOCKBC HcrrOcpc lcT­ 6ypJKya3Ho-nCMOKpaTH'lCCKoro HHOrAli PoPMY naHHCJIaMH3Ma I1aHTIOp1 H3Ma Cp BorrpocbI HCTOPHIf Pe% H l eT 0 N23 1956 CTp 14-15 KpHTHKaX H3HYTPH KOMrrapmH nocKollhKY I pHTHl a BHC I1apTHll Hhlx paMOI cpa3Y JKC rrpHpaBHHBaJIaCh I ''HaIJ HOHaJIHCTH'lCCKoll KOHTppeBOJ1IOUHH BHa'laJIC KPHTHKOB-KOMMYHHCTOB Ha3b1BaJIH MCCTHhIMH UeJlH HaIJ HOHaJIhHoil nOJ1liTHKH 6hll1H C POPMYJIHPOBaHhl crn c no HaIJ HOHaJIHCTaMH rr03JKC rrOCllC KaTCroPHIO H l ell'Horo pa306na'lCHHJi HX nCpCBeJlH KOHTPPCBOlIlOIJ HOHHhIX 5ypJKya3Hhlx HaUHOHaJIH 'TOB 1 0­ UCPBOM MHPOBOil BOftHhl H BOlllJ1H B nOJIHTII'lCCKYIO rrporpaMMY 6oJIhlllC­ 13 BHKOB ncpHOna nO lI'OTOBKH K 3aXBaTY BJIaCTH 7 -Ji anpCJ1hCKaJI KOH pe­ Tophle I1POHHKJIH B rrapTHIO H npHKphIBaJiCh rrapmil HblM PCl ulUl 19171' TaM BpaJKnc5HYIO Hapoll Y ll eJiTeJIhHOCTh 8 232 13 napTHJi B UH PPOBOM OCBcrn cHIU1 M 1926 CTp 76 6HlICTOM BcrrH focnJIaH 6hJJ1 C031l aH ll eKpeTOM CHK PCCl1CP OT 22 peBpaJIJi 1921 r 233 14 15 CM A H PLIKoBa Ha VIII C'be3Jl e PKn 6 B 1919 r PKII 6 M napTH3JJ aT 1933 CM BhIcrynneHHe BOCbMOR C'be3A n KpHUMaH fepoH'IecKHR nepHOA BeJlHKoil PycCKoD peBOJlIOUHH ME llYHAPOllHhlE OPfAHH3AQHH M 1924 1917-1929 C60pHHK MaTepIHIJ10B H CTaTeD fOcnOJIHTH3JJ aT M 1957 CTp 72 16 BoIIPOCbI 3KOHOMH'IecKOro paAoHHPOBaHHli 17 TaM Ke 18 TaM Ke 19 TaM Ke CTp Ila6en J UT6Wl06 o llEMOKPATH'lECKOM HHTEPHAI J HOHAflE 19 MapTa 1979 r B Hbro-iiiopKe B 3ane lloMa CBo6o J bI 6bInO 06'bJIBneHO 0 C03 1aHHH neMOKpaTH IeCKOrO l1HTepHamm­ 76-78 Hana nOM CBo60 J bI - O J Ha H3 HaH60nee CTapbIX M YBaJKaeMbIX npaB03amHTHbIX opraHM3aUMH - nepBbIM 06'bHBMn 0 CBoeH nO J ­ J ep Ke neMOKpaTM IeCKOrO l1HTepHamIOHana neMOKpaTH IeCKMH HHTepHaUMOHan nOMep anM MHorHe J pyme rpynnbI M opraHM­ JaUMM cpe J M HHX AMepMKaHCKHe npO pcoro3bI BKnro laH pyKO­ BO J CTBO AMepHKaHCKOH l e J epaUMM TpYM - KOHrpecca IIPOM3­ BO J MTenbHblx IIpO pCOro30B A l T-KIIfI RH6epanbHbIM WHTep­ HaIUfOHan CTOJImaJI BHe napu H aMepHKaHCKaJI opraHM3aUMH Common Cause 06mee J eno CTaBHmaJI CBoeM IIenblO ynytJUIMTb PyHKUMOHHpOBaHMe aMepHKaHCKOH nOnMnl IeCKOM CMCTeMbI KOOp J MHaTOpOM neMOKpanl leCKOrO WHTepHaIIHOHana CTan Te J KaKeHe a Paynb MaHrnanyc H JI co-npe J ceMTenHMM Te J caM Ben 6onbrnyro IaCTb e e J HeBHOH pa60TbI opraHH30BblBan BCTpe lH HCKan J eHbrH Ben nepenMCKY BblcTynan BO MHOrMX ropo J ax H CTpaHaX MMpa 6e3 YCTanH npOnaraH J MpYJI M J eM nnlOpa­ nHCTM IeCKOH J eMOKpaTHH H neMOKpaTM'leCKOro WHTepHaUMOHa­ na Be3BpeMeHHaH CMepTb Te J a B oKTH6pe 1979 r He Morna He CKa3aTbCJI Ha J eJITenbHOCTH eme He BCTaBIIIeH npo lHO Ha HorM MorrO J OH 0praHH3aIIHH HeKOTOpoe BpeMJI J ena neMOKpaTHtJec­ Koro l1HTepHaUMOHana Berra eHa TeM BMKTopMH IIOCTeneHHO C npHcoe J MHeHHeM COTeH HOBbIX IJIeHOB neMOKpaTM IeCKMH l1H­ TepHaUMOHan CTan paCIIIHpJITb CBOro J eHTeJIbHOCTb BbmM BbIUy­ meHbI ABa HOMepa 6ronneTeHH fInropanHcT rpynna Y laCTHMKOB neMOKpaTH IeCKOrO l1HTepHaUMOHana Ha lana pa60TaTb Ha J OKy­ MeHTanbHbIM KMHO pMnbMOM KanCTpO pa TpeTbero MHpa o reHOUM J e B TM6eTe WH J OHe3HH BMa ppe BaHrna J eIIIe YraH J e H KaMIIytJMH IOrOCnaBCKMH J HCCM J eHT 6bIBIIIHH nOnHTHtJeCKMH 235 234