l eMOKpanl'leCKlfM peq OpMaM KOTOphle e rurnCTBeHHO MOrYT cna­ cnl He3aBHCHMOCTh CTpaHhI KHWa MmlOBaHa Jl KlUIaCa llPY I oa C THTO pa3pyruaeT Mlfq 0 MWlOeall lJlCWUlC IOrOCnaBCKOM l HKTaTOpe 'lfTO H COCTaBII IleT ueHHOCTh H OrpOMHOe 3Ha'lfeHHe noii KHHrH JJlI ll 0YAYrnero IOrOCnaBHH fIlABhl H3 KHHfH llPY I BA C THTO BeT BMrue Xpa6pOCTH qeM nOJlH11llleCKaJl Bo BpeMH BOHHhI opocanach B rna3a 3aOOTa TIiTO 0 coxpaHeHHH napTHHHhIX Ka J poB a erne oonhlue ero coocrBeHHoH l H3HH 3Ta 03aOO'lfeHHOCTb KaK Ohl J a l e B03pacTana no Mepe POCTa ero pomI H nH'lfHOH BnaCTH lleno He TonbKO B 3MOUHHX TYT nplfCYT­ CTBOBaIIO H C03HaHlfe OTBeTCTBeHHOCTlf 3a napTlfIO H BOCCTaHHe QTO 6Y J eT C HHMH ecnH OH norH6HeT Ho erne 3aMeTHee 6bmo CTpeMIIeHHe THIO K cnaBe l enalme Hacna J HThCH a6COnIOTHOH BnaCTbIO 3aBeprueHHeM Ha'lfaTOrO J ena IIH IO BnaCTb H peBonIO­ l HIO THTO nO'lfTH qrO OTO l J eCTBmm Ho KaK 6hI HH oueHHBaTb ero nOBe J eHHe BO BpeMH BOHHhl Bce-TaKH HeCOMHeHHO qrO THTO HcnhIThman CHnbHYIO 03a60'lfeH­ HOCTh 3a coxpaHeHHe CBoeM apMHH a He TonhKO CBoeH nH'lfHOH 6e30rracHOCThlO B nepHO J TaK Ha3hIBaeMoro qeTBepToro HacTyrr­ l npH OKpY I eHHH B paHOHe peK PaMa H HepeTBa B Haqane neHH Il 1943 rO J a OH nOCTO llHHO MeHHII HIIH OT J aBaII J BYCMhIcneHHbIe npHKa3bl Ho B TO l e BpeMH OH CYMen npOBeCTH pHCKOBaHHyIO caMooTBep l eHHYIO H MY I eCTBeHHYIO neperpyrrnHpoBKY OTPH l OB C uenblO cnaceHHH paHeHhIX He TonhKO pa36HB npH nOM HeMueB B paiiOHe BHnHua fYBHO HO H H36aBHB napTH3aH OT HeMeQKOrO KOMrrneKca OT Bna J eBruero HMH y6e l J eHHH B npeBOCXO J CTBe HeMeQKOH apMHH Ha peKe HepeTBa THTO KaK THrp B KneTKe Milovan Djilas Druzenje s Titom Harrow Middlesex Great Bdtnin B Te'leflHe rrapTH3aHCKoit BOItHhI HeMUhI rrpOBeJIH ceMh HacTyIllleHHIt rrpoTlIB rrapTH3au 259 258 CYMeJI HaMTl1 caMoe cJIa60e MeCTO Y HTaJIbnHueB H 'leTHHKOB I HepBHblH HMlIYJIbCHBHblH THTO TOJIbKO KaK 6bI nOJJ rOTaBnHBaeT paClIlHpnn KOTOpoe XJlbIHYJI napTH3aHCKHM nOTOK B lIa'laJIe nnTO­ paC'lHm aeT nO'IBY AJUf Apyroro BAYM'lHBOrO XHTpOro OT npHpo­ ro HacTyrlJIemiH B Mae 1943 rOAa Y lIero BblPBaJIHCb CJlOBa HH­ AbI H pelllHTenblloro BpO KAeHHa fl XHTPOCTb H pelllHTenbHOCTb _ Kor a a Mbl He 6blJIH B TaKOM onaCHOCnt 3TY onaCHOCTb co3HaBa­ JIH H ApyrHe HO MeHee OCTPO a nOTOMY CJ1HlIlKOM MeJlllHJIH npeA­ npHHnTb He06xoAHMbie cnaCHTeJIbllble AeMcTBlHI A B nOM H COCTOHT MYAPOCTb H M eCTBO nOnHTH'leCKOro BO K­ An· Tor a a 6bIBaJIO 11 Ha caMOM Aene B MOMeHTbl IIpHHHTHH IIOnHTH'leCKHX pellle­ Bce 3aBHCeJIO OT HeCKOJIbKHX 'laCOB MO KeT 6blTb a a Ke MHHyr HHH OT KOroPblX MeHneTcn Te'leHHe C06bITHH THTO 6bIBaJI HeHMO­ I1pHMep TOMY - BepHO npopbIB BTopoH npoJIeTapCKoii 6pHraAbl Ha By­ 'lCBO AO Toro KaK HeMU bl 3aHnJIH BbIXOAbl H3 KaHbOHa peKH I1HBa 2 3aXBaT MorMbI JII060 6oMIJ aMH qeTBepToM 'lepHOrOpcKoH 6pHra­ 6pHraAbI JIH1 fHan pom THTo KaK KOMaHAHpa 11 nO'lIH eCJIH HenorpelllHMOCTb KOMHHTepH TO eCTb COBeT'lHKH lIa3Ha'laeT THTO rJIaBOH napTHH B 37-oM roAY BO BpeM fl 'lHCTOK nocne apeCTa ceKpeTap fl KOM­ BO Bcex HHX CXBaTKax 6bIJIa He3Ha'lHTeJIbHa eCJIH Bo06me 0 HeM MYllHCIH'leCKOii IIapIHH CTOHT rOBOpHTb Ho HMCHHO OH CYMeJI BHYlIlHTb qyBCTBO onaclioCTH nO'ITH 3aCTaBHB TeM CaMbIM H3MeHHTb xOA BOCHHbIX AeHcTBHH H HX TeMlI B Bee no nOTOMY 'lTO THTO - HenorpelllHM ro THTO H Toro ABH KeHHH KOTopoe OIl B03rnaBnnn Abl pelllHTeJIbHbrn no c06cTBeHHoii HHHu HaTHBe npopbIB I1epBoM npoJIeTapCKoH OTBa Kell OTO K Tl eCTBJIHTb C ycnexoM H ecnH CMOTpeTb C TO'lKH 3peHHH caMO­ IOrocnaBHH fopKH'la nocne Toro KaK Bcn noronOBHO 6blJIa nOCa KeHa IOrocnaBCKa fl 3MHrpaUHlI CCCP Ha nOT nOCT C npaBOM Bero KOTopoe 06JIer'lHT eMY JIH1 fHOCTb TeMlIepaMeHTllan JIerKo' 3aXBaT BnaCTH B napTHH XOT fl olla Y Ke 6bIJIa CTanHHH3HpOBaHa IIO LJJ I alOma flC fl BHelllHHM Bne'laTJIeIlHHM C BpO K Tl eHlIbIMH HHor a a KaK HAeOnOrH'leCKH TaK H no KJIaCCoBoMY COCTaBY - OH KOHe1 fHO CJ1HlIlKOM TOPOIIJIHBbIMH peaKu HnMH B HeO KHAaHHbIX H ApaMaTH­ He Mor 6bl IIOIIaCTh ecnH 6bI He 6bIJI HCnblTaH Ha npeAaHlIOCTb 'leCKHX cHTyau H flX TaKHM JIIOAnM He Bcer a a y a aeTC fl Bce paCC'lH­ COBeTCKOMY PYKOBOACTBY TO eCTb Ha HeHaBHCTb K YKnOHHCTaM TaTb 3apaHee H AOAYMaTb AO KOIIIJ a TlaHHKa H OTBara HenorpelllH­ B c06CTBeliHOH napum Ho BeAb H MHOflie ApyrHe eCJ1l1 Y K He Bce MOCTb H 3a6nY KAeHH fl B pelilellHHX TaKHX nlOAeii CMelllHBaIOTC fl TaK Ke 6bIJIH nOABeprnYTbI npOBepKe HO ee He nepe KHnH THTO CMeH flIOT OAHO APyroe CJIHBanCb B Hepa3AeJIHMOe u eJIoe BnocneACTBHH pacCKa3blBan OAHaKO C APyroH CTOPOHbl 6blJIH Y THTO H np flMO npOTHBOIIO­ JIO KHble 'lepTbI cnoc06HOCTb K Hanp fl KeHHOMY BlIHMaTenbHOMY H rny60KOMY pa3AYMblO 0 npeACTO flmHX KpylIllbIX H peu mlOmHX lIlarax Bce TO 'ITO Me K rJ y nHMH ABYMn KpaHHOCTHMH - H He ApY KHJI lIH C KeM H3 YKJIO­ HHCTOB a eJIaJI CBoe AeJIO H 6bW AOCTaT01 fHO OCTOpO KeH B pa3­ rOBopax oc06eHHO B nOMemeHHnx C Tene poHaMH OH BeHHbrn H3 KOMMYHHCTH'leCKHX BO KAeii KTO e a HHCT­ CYMen HamynaTb Me KAY Aopory CKB03b Y Kac 'lHCTOK H nHKBH a au IDf EMY y a aJIOCb no HMnynbcHBHbIMH nOAC03HaTenbHbIMH peaKu HnMH H XOpolilO npo­ Ha nepBblH B3rnnA a a Ke npoCTo 011 BOBpeMn nO'lYBCTBOBan onac­ AYMaHHblMH a aJIeKO HAYmHMH pellleHH flMH HO He eCTb c06CTBeHHO THTo 11 JlllH THTO He THUH'l­ HOCTh He nepeCTaBaH O a HOBpeMeHHO HenOKone6HMO BepHTb B npa­ no HeCMOTp fl lIa TO 'lTO H 011 BMbHOCTb COBeTCKoro nYTH B HeM coceACTBOBanH BpO KAeHHblii KaK H Bce MbI KHBeT H AeiicTByeT rJIaBHbIM 06pa30M B 3aypHA­ pe pnCKC Ha onaCHOCTb C Y Ke YCBoellHblM nOHHMaHHeM 3Ha'leHHH Hoii 6YAHH1 fHOM nOBceAHeBIiOCTH BeAb B KOlIIle KOHU OB KH3Hb BnaCIH JlllH cy a b6b1 ABH KeHHH H HAeM I10MHIO KaK B03Bpamancb H CCTb 6YAHH1 fHaH IIOBceAHeBHOCTb EYATO pe'lb HAeT 0 ABYX pa3­ HbIX nH1 fHOCT flX 110 no c06CTBeHHO TOJIbKO TaK Ka KeTcn H3 MOCKBbI H3 noM nepBOM CTpaHbI COu HanH3Ma 03a60'leHHbIM H H3HYpeHHbIM THTO HaXOAHn o6ner'lCHHC H pa a OCTb 06meHHH B cpeAe CBOHX nOATIOJIbHbIX TOBapHmeH B BoeHHO- palllHCTCKOH MOHapXO- palllHCTCKOM IOrocnaBHH lJenUtKIf cep6cKoe HaUHOHarIhHOe aHrn$lurnCTI oe lIBIf l ellHe rCHe­ pana MHxall noBH'Ia COnepHH'IalOlllee ' naprn3aHcKHM IJ BH I eHHeM B IOI'OCnaB­ CKoll rpa l u aHCI oll Boll He 2 JlI060 KOBa'leBH'I 11 liH 260 napTH3aHcKHll repoll norn6wHll B Ha'iarIe peBoflro­ KaKOBa Ke AeHCTBHTenbHaH POJIb THTO B BenHKHX 'lHCTKaX oc06eHHO B IOrocnaBCKOH KOMnapTHH KynM nH OH npOmeHHe rpeXOB npe a aTenbCTBOM B03BblCHnCn JIH KneBeTOH Ha CBOHX TOBapH­ meH 261 'IHCTKaX IOrOCJIaBCKHX KOMMYHHCTOB OKa3aJIOCb AJIfI Hero H COBep­ CJIOBa H nOHflTHfI He aHbI Ha Be'lHble BpeMeHa COXpaHfIfI CBOH B OHH He l HBYT CMbICJI BHe COII lfllJIbHOrO H A 'XOBHoro KJIHMaTa oc06eHHOCTH no BepHO OTHOCHTeJIbHO fl3bIKa nOJIHTHKH 0 'IeM 3aMe'laTeJIbHO IIHCaJI 0pBeJIJI BOT TaK H COTpYp HH'IeCTBO C COBeT­ CKHMH pa3Be U IBaTeJIbHbIMH CJIY I 6aMH B AOBoeHHble BpeMeHa ­ a Koe-rAe H AJIfI Koe-Koro a l e eme B HaUIe BpeMfl 3a 'IeCTb H TaHHcTBOM B03Harpa l AeHHe COBeTcKHe areHTbI CHJIbI n03BOJIHTeJIbHO H HCKJIIO'lHTeJIbHOCTH ynoTpe6HTb no C'IHTaJIOCb 6bIJIH oKYTaHbI Me'lTaJIH YAOCTOHTbCfI BeJIHKOH 'IeCTH Crry l HTb COBeTcKoMY COI03Y IIpH HHbIX 06CTOfl­ TeJIbCTBaX B H3MeHHBUIHXCfI ycrrOBHflX no H AJIfI KOMMYHHCTOB ­ KOHe'IHO He AJIfI Bcex H He BCIOA ' CTBOM 11 TO l e - C KJIeBeTOH C AOHOcaMH Ha CBOHX napTHHHbIX II RH a COBeTCKHe opraHbI B MOCKBe HX eme 60JIbUIe pa3A 'BaJIH AJIfI npH neHHHe npeAaHHOCTb KOMMYHHCTOB MepOH COBeTCKOMY COlO3Y CTaHOBHTCfI peBOJIIOI1 HOHHOCTH a npH CTaJIHHe ee nOAMeHfleT npe aHHOCTb JIH'lHO eMY Eme AO BeJIHKOrO Teppo­ pa TpOll KHCTbI npaBble H APyrHe YKJIOHHCTbI C03HaTeJIbHble H CJIY'laHHble 6bIJIH ny6JIH'IHO npOKJIflTbI a MHOrHe H apecToBaHbI A THTO CTaHOBHTCfI ceKpeTapeM napTHH B 1937 L B caMbIH pa3rap 6e3YMHOrO MaccoBoro Teppopa OH aBHO Y I e 6bIJI npeAaH CTa­ JIHHY 11 Ba l HO He TO 'ITO eMY KaK H MHOrHM CTaJIHH npeACTaB­ JIflJICfI 3aKOHHbIM HaCJIep HHKOM neHHHa a HMeHHO CTaJIHHCKOH AeJIO B npe aHHOCTH JIHHHH H COrJIaCHe Ha CTaJIHHCKHe MeTOAbI B nOJIHTHKe HeJIb3f1 3a6bIBaTb 'ITO I1OCH p Op03 THTO Y I e B 1938 r OKa3blBaeTCfI OAHHM H3 caMbIX BbI alOmHXCfI 6oPIIOB 3a MOHOJIHT­ HOCTb napTHH npoTHB BCflKoro B napTHHHOH npaKTHKe CBoeH ppaKIIHH B napTHH - 110CH p YKJIOHH3Ma IIoJIHeHUIafl A 'ITO no 03Ha'laeT MOHOnOJIHfI CBoeH JIHHHH TaKOBa KopeHHafl CYTb CTaJIHHH3Ma JIHTHOCTb H CTaJIHHCKHH COBeTCKHH COlO3 3aAOJIrO AO CBoero npH­ TOpOM H 06pa3I10M peUIHTeJIbHbIX H - 1935 r oOJIee Toro THTO 6bIJI HHHI1 Ha­ He eAHHCTBeHHbIM HO Op HHM H3 caMbIX caMbIX aKTHBHbIX - HOBoro MOHOJIHTHOrO H TOTaJIHTapHOro A 'xa B napTHH CTaJIHH H CTaJIHHH3M COOTBeTCT­ BOBaJIH ero MHpoomymeHHIO pOCJIH B HeM no Mepe ero c06CTBeH­ Horo HAeOJIOrH'IeCKOrO C03peBaHHfI OH H caM meprH'lHO yqacTBo­ BaJI B 262 'lHCTKe CBoeH napTHH nOTOMY JIeHHH napTHH H eCJIH OHH COBnaAaJIH C ero JIH'lHbIM B03BbIUIeHHeM K HAeaJIY H BJIaCTH • IIOMHIO KaK THTO H KapAeJIb - a OHH KaK HbIX B COBeTCKOM COlO3e IOrOCJIaBOB - rOBOpHJIH C 6JIarOAap­ HOCTblO 0 TOM 'ITO COBeTCKafl BJIaCTb H36aBHJIa Hac OT YKJIOHHCTOB ••• IIo nOMY TaK rpoTecKHo BblrJIflAHT KorAa B HaUIe BpeMfI llOJIaHII H Apyrafl MOJIOAe l b H3 THTOBCKoro oKpY I eHHfI AOKa3bIBaIOT 6YATO THTO Y I e AO BOHHbI eme B caMoH MocKBe Ha'laJI 60POTbCfI COI03Y TO eCTb CTaJIHHY OH He CTaJI H He CMor 6bI CKpblBaTb noro Aa l e OT Hac - H Y'laCTHe B MOCKOBCKHX CTaJIHHHCTOB B CTpaHe OT Hac KOTopble MOCKBbI a l e He BHAeJIH MOCKBa Ha3Ha'IHJIa nOAJIHHHO AOCTOHHyIO JIH'IHOCTb B03rJIaBJIflTb rrOAJIHHHO CTaJIHHCKYIO HJIH 'ITO TO l e caMoe JIeHHH­ CKYIO napTHIO • • JI y6e l AeH 'ITO Y'IaCTHe THTO B 'lHCTKaX 6blJI0 OrpaHH'leHHbIM H BTopOCTeneHHbIM MOCKBa 6bIJIa AO TaKOH CTeneHH pa30'lapOBa­ Ha IOrOCJIaBaMH 'ITO KaK qyTb He pacnYCTHJIa IOrOCJIaBCKYIO napTHIO AO nora nOJIbcKYIO OOJIrapHH Ha'laJIbHHK OTAeJIa KaApoB KOMHHTepHa He AOBepflJI THTO XapaKTepHCTHKH B 60JIbUIHHCTBe CBoeM OTpHuaTeJIbHble Ha 'lJIeHOB IOrOCJIaBCKOH napTHH KOTopble THTO KaK ceKpeTapb AOJI I eH 6bIJI nHCaTb OH C aBaJI Y I e nOCJIe Toro KaK HeC'IaCTHble 6blJIH apeCTOBaHbI HJIH Y I e oxapaKTepH30­ BaHbI KaK BparH IIpoJIeTapHH A B ne'laTHOM opraHe UeHTpaJIbHOrO KOMHTeTa THTO aBTOMaTH'IeCKH onpaBAbIBaJI HCKJIIO'IeHHfI H3 napTHH H apecTbI YKJIOHHCTOB 3nHTeTaMH H3 He nOAJIe l amHX 06 1 aJIOBaHHlO npoIleccoB BblUIHHcKoro TPOll KHCT npeAaTeJIb YKJIOHHCT UIIIHOH qy l U IH HJIH aHTHna PTHHHbIH 3JIeMeHT lla l e OP 3 THTO BblcTynaJI 3a CTaJIHHa 3a CTaJIHHCKYIO MOHO­ 6bITHfI B CCCP B Ha'laJIe 'IeMY yrpbI3eHHfI npOTHB CTaJIHHa H CTaJIHHH3Ma He 6YAb THTO npe aH COBeTcKoMY CTaHeT n030pOM H npeAaTeJIb­ TOBapHm eH • IIapTHIO AeHCTBHTeJIbHO pa3AHpaJIH YKJIOHbI H ppaK­ Y I e nOCJIeAOBaTeJIbHbIM H HeH36e I HbIM K COBeCTH eCJIH pe'lb lII11a 0 60JIbUIeBH3aI1 HH 0 3aKaJIeHHH H yKpen­ 6bIBUIHe MOCKBH'IH 3HaKOMbI 6bIJIH C 60JIbllIHHCTBOM apeCTOBaH­ KOMMYHHCTbI eCJIH ryT CJIOBO UIeHHO B IOrocJIaBHH napTHHHble 'lHCTKH 6blJIH 6e3 1 aJIOCTHbI XOTfI HX He npOBOAHJI THTO KOTOPbIH 60JIbllIYlO 'laCTb BpeMeHH 6b1JI 3a rpaHHIIeH Op HaKO B IOrocJIaBHH HeB03MO l HO 6blJI0 npo­ BOAHTb apeCTbI a HOBoe napTHHHoe nOKOJIeHHe BOBJIe'leHHOe B peBOJIIOIIHOHHyIO AeflTeJIbHOCTb JIH60 He nOA03peBaJIO 0 CTpaAaHHflX nOJIHTH'IeCKHX l epTB B CCCP JIH60 npeHe6peraJIo HMH KorAa THTO 6bIBaJI B IOrocJIaBHH Ha ero nJIe'lH JIO l HJIaCb caMafl OTBeT­ CTBeHHafl pa60Ta 11 XOTfI OH nOAAep l HBaJI CBfl3H C MOCKBOH H C COBeTCKHMH pa3BeA'lHKaMH 0 'IeM OCTaJIbHble 'lJIeHbI nOJIHT6lOPO 263 3HaJIH ruIH OraAbIBanHCb 6bInO qera CKpbIBaTb a H C'llUaIO 'ITO eM ' He TaK Y I MHoro THTO lIOCTelIeHHO Haqan YCKonb3aTb OT COBeTCKoro KOHTponH OH OqeHb 06pa 'OBanCH Kor a Mbl eMY coo6­ IIIruU'l lIocne ero B03BpaIIIemm H3 MOCKBbI B 1939 r 'ITO HaM Y a­ nOCb B qnmaHcoBOM OTHorneHHH lIOCTaBHTb lIapTHIO Ha CBOH HOn1­ 3TO 6bIJIO Harne rrepBoe J OCTH I eHHe HaMHoro 60nee 3HaquTenbHoe qeM HaM Tor a Ka3anOCb C HaqanOM IOrocnaBCKOH peBOnIOIU1H HaqanHCb rrpOHBnHTbCH H nOJ1llTllqeCKHe rrpoIHBOpeqHH Me l ty PYKOBO CTBOM BenHKOH ep l aBbl H nH epaMH peBOmOlI HH B ManeHbKOH CTpaHe THTO C IpY OM HaXO Hn 06IIIHH H3bIK C MOCKBOH OH COBeTOBaJICH C KOM­ HHlepHoM HO Bce Ba l HeHrnHe BonpocbI pernan caM HnH BMeCTe CO CBOHMH KOJIneraMH Ha BTOPOM Cbe3J e AHTHcparnHCICKoro Beqe HapO J Horo OCB 60 l eHHH IOrocnaBHH 1 KOTOPblH COCTOHn­ CH B KOHlJ e HOH6pH 1943 r Ba I HeHrnHe perneHHH 6blJ1H lIpHHHTbI 6e3 Be OMa MOCKBbI H BHaqane BbI3BanH ee HeoJ 06peHHe 3THMH perneHHHMH IOrOCJIaBHH rocy apcIBoM 6bIna MOHapxHH rrpoB03rnarneHa cpaKTHqeCKH l e epaTHBHbIM OIMeHeHa H Y3aKoHeHa peBOnIOlI HOHHaH BJIaCTb BO rnaBe C KOMMYHHCTaMH flo Mepe Ioro KaK peBOmOlI HH oJ ep l HBaJIa Bce HOBbIe H HOBbIe rr06eAbI B03paCTaJIa H JIHqHaH ponb THTO H era BJIHHHHe B MocKBe MOCKBa rrOllana BepxyrnKa THIO He B elO l e paccTaBneHHYIO nOByrnKY Morna BocrrpenHTCTBOBaIb C03J aBaBrnerOCH no Xo ty COBeTCKaH YKpenneHHIO KYJIbTa peBOnlOlI HOHHOrO lIpOlJ ecca H 6narOJ apH BenHKonenHO I10CTaBneHHOM rrpolIaraHJ e lIOCKonbKY B caMOM CCCP KYJlbT BO l J H He 3Han ce6e paBHbIx B nepHo Ha3pe­ BaHlm KOHcpnHKTa C COBelcKHM COlO30M KynbT THTo KOIOPbIH OT­ qaCTH HMHIHpoBan KynbT caMoro CTamilia cnoc06CIBOBan YKperr­ neHHIO He3aBHCHMOCTH yIBe J aIb 'ITO 6YJ b H eecnoc06HOCTH IOrocnaBHH IOrocnaBlfH 'eMOKpaTHqeCKOii MO l HO CTpaHOH OHa H 6e3 BCHKoro KynbTa npoTllBOCTOHna 6bI COBeICKOMY COI03Y xonI 6bI B cHny npeHM 'IIIeCTB CBoero 06IIIeCIBeHHoro YCTpoHCTBa Ho TOr a KOIOPbIM IOrocnaBHH ynpaBnHna 6bIJIa TonbKO Y I e aBTOpHTapHbIM rocy apCTBOM O Ha ycnOBHHX TOnbKO neHHHHCTCKaH HnH 'ITO TO l e caMoe CTanHHHCT­ CKaH He 6h1Jl0 flPOIHBOCIOHTb COBeICKHM rrpeleH3HHM Morna B TaKHX KOTOpaH HClIOnh30BaJIa aHanOrHqJlbIe COBeTCKHM CBOeM po HHe KaK l e THTO BOClIPHHHn KOHcpnHKI C COBeTCKHM COlO30M B 1948 r HaCK0JI6KO 6onbllIYIO HaCKonbKO Ba I HYIO ponb Chlrpan B HeM OH caM Pa3pbIB C MOCKBOH npH3HaKH KOToporo nOHBnHnHCb nOCTe­ lIeHHO rrCHXOnOmqeCKH THTO nepe l HBan OqeHb TH I eno flo MHe­ IIHIO ero 6nH3KHX a H OH caM IaK cquTan HMeHHO B TO BpeMH Y Hero HaqanHCb lIpHcTynbI l enquoro rrY3blpH Ha nlO HX OCO­ 6eHHO B lIPHCYICIBHH COTPYJ1 lIHKOB COBeTCKoro lIoconbCTBa OH BbIrnH en ClIOKOHHblM H c06paHHbIM aKTepoM B pa3BeJ Ka CBoeH nOnHTHqeCKOH HMeBllIaH CB0I1X THTO 6blJ1 TanaHTnHBbIM eHTenbHOCIH areHIOB HO COBeICKaH B OKpY I eHHH THTo 3Hana lIpaB ty llepeJ 6nH3KHMH O lJ HaKO THTO He Mor a H He XOlen CKpblBalb CBOH nepe I HBaHHH B Ie MeCHlU I H HH THTO nerKO pa3 'pa l anCH H Cep HnCH B TO l e BpeMH no OIHOllIeHHIO K 6nH I aHllIHM H HaH60nee AOBepeH­ HblM roBa pHIIIaM OH lIpoHBnHn IaKYIO cepJ e'lliOCTb H TeIDIory KOTOPOH OHH aBHO He lIOMHHnH B KOHl e BOHHbl H B rrepBbIe lIocneBoeHHble rOAbI THTO Ben ce6H KaK necnOT aBTOKpaT l HK­ TaTOp orrnpaIOI JJ HiI cH lIyCIb H He Ha OqeHb OXOTHYIO HO lIPOqHYIO lIO IJAep l KY MOCKBbl B Ie rOAbI B IOrocnaBHH He 6blJ10 a l e TaKHX lIceB onapnaMeHTapHblx HHCTHryTOB KOTopble cymecTBYIOT ceH­ 'lac BOT nO'leMY TOT lIepHO 3alIeqaTJlenCH B MoeH lIaMHTH KaK HeTBOpqeCKHH H ne OCToHHblH BOnIOlI HOHepa H npeBpaTllnCH a6COnIOTHOrO MOHapxa qeM I-h B BOCTOp l eHHOrO lIHcaTenH-pe­ pynop lIporraraHAbI eme 60nee Koponb AneKcaHAP B 3amHTHHKa HeCOCTOHTenbHoro H HBIIO HecrrpaBe J1HBOrO 06IIIeCTBelillOro YCT­ poHCTBa H XOleJl BepHYTbCH K nHcaTenbcKOH neHTenbllOCTll YHTH B mneparyIY 1'1 aJKe rOBopHn 06 3TOM C THTo 011 cornaCHJ1CH OJ1 lIaKO C ycnoBHeM 'ITO H on l eH pa3 enHTb CBoe BpeMH Me l ty KOMM 'HHCTHqeCKaH napTHH KpoMe KOMMYHHCIOB J pyrHx lIOJIHTHqeCKHX CHJ1 B CTpaHe lIOqTH napTHH H lJ eH H MeIO hI B03rnaBHBllIaH H n06eJ1 l-IBmaH B peBOnlOlI HH Ha paTYPOH H lIOnHTH'IeCKOH lIpolIaraHJ oH Ho Kor J a Ha'laJI Ha BH­ raTbCH KOHcpnHKT C MOCKBOH BO MHe lIpo6Y J HJ1HCb lIepeMeHbI H 51 CHOBa omYTHn cBOH onr lIepeA Tn '''''' THeH TICHxonormeCKH THTO cTpa an H3-3 I pa3pbIBa C MOCKBOH HO oH He 3aKone6anCH 3aIIIHIIIaH CBOIO nHquyIO He3aBHCHMOCTb H TIepBoe KOMMYHHCTlPieCKOe rrpaBHTem cTBO KOTOPOC H npoB03rlIaCifliO pecnYOOHKY 264 M M 265 B He3aBJiCJiMOCTh lOr ocnaBJiJi B TpYAHhlX Ji 3anYTaHHhiX 06CTOHTelIh­ CTBax TJiTO Bcer J a pearJipOBan OlJelIh OCTPO HO no ero KalJeCTBO B KOHq nJiKTe C COBCTCKJiM PYKOBO o CTBOM o60cTpJinoch elUe 60nh­ lIIe BepoHTHo B CBH3Ji C ero 06H3aTenhCTBaMJi no OTHOllleHJilO K MOCK Be Ji eu e 60nee - TpeBoroH 3a 6YAYlUee IOrocnaBJiJi TJiTO II0CTOHHHO olUYlUalI AaBneHJie npownoro If elUe HeYMolIIfMee ­ HaCTOHll ero ll03 KC Ka KeTCH 3TO 6hIllO B cnaBCKI1X KOMMYHJiCTaX nOABeprnrn xcH 1949 B r rOBopH 0 lOro­ COBeTcKoM COlO3e pblBa OH OC03Han npeJiMYIUeCTBO nOnO KeHHH B KOTOPOM OKa3a­ naCb IOrocnaBJiH B Me KAYHapoAHOM rrnaHe Hana o eHJie Ha IOrocna­ BJilO co CTOpOHbI COBeTCKoro COlO3a Bbl3Bano 6bl Me J yHapOAHble ocnO HeHHH TeM 60nee B ycnOBHHX lIpeBaToii HenpeAcKa3yeMhlMM nocne o CTBMHMJi XOnOAHOH BOMbl llOJTOMY coxpaHeHHe CBoeH nJilfHOH BnaCTJi TJiTO OTO K o eCTBn1In C 3a1UJiToii rocy o apCTBeHHoH He3aBJiCHMOCTJi IOrocnaBMM lJJiCTKe TJiTO CKa3an Hx Ha o o 6hIllO CTYKHyTh no ronoaaM HO He 06e3rnaBJiTh A B JilOHe 1848 A6cTpaKTHble H o eOnOrHlfeCKJie cnopbi He 6h1nM caMOH CHnbHOH CTOPOHOH TJiTO B nepJiOA pa3rapa COBeTCKO-IOrocnaBCKoro KOH­ r Kor o a COCTaBnHnCH OTBeT IOrocnaBJiIf KOMI1H­ q opM6lOpO B KOTOpOM co06IUanoch 06 OTKa3e COlO3a KOMMYHI1­ CTOB IOrocnaBJiI1 IIPJiHHTh yqacme B 3ace J aHI1I1 3Toro opraHa B Eyxa­ pecTe Ha 3TOM 3aCeAaHl1Ji HaMelJanOCh IIpe o aTb Ji o eoIIOrl1l1eCKoMY CYAY lOrOCnaBCKJiX KOMMYHJiCTOB TJiTO rHeBHO IIp0113Hec Ec­ q JlHKTa TaK AYManH II MHOrJie o pyrJie HO B ponl1 PYKoBO o HTenH TMTO OKa3anCH 60nee BoneBhlM llOnI1TJiK He npIfHOCHIUJiH KepTB BO I1MH cBoeH AeHTenhHOCTI1 He rrOnJiTI1K o a Ke ecnl1 ero AeHTelIh­ HOCTh Ji He CTOI1T KepTB Bo BpeMH KOHq nIfKTa C MOCKBOH MHorIfe allrrapaTa Ji PHAOBhle KOMMYHI1CTbI 6hInJi He MeHee pellll1TenhHhl lIeM TJiTO HO ero rrOBe o eHIfe JiMenO pellialOlUee 3Ha­ lIeHl1e HHalie II 6h1Th He Morno rrOCKonhKY BCH BnaCTh 6h1na CKOH­ UeHTpJipoBaHa B ero pyKax H 6e3 TJiTO COlO3 KOMMYHMCTOB IOrocnaBJiH OKa3anCH 6hl B KOHq nI1KTe C MOCKBOH Ji OKa3an eH COllpOTI1BneHJie If H YBepeH lITO C ycneXOM Ho ecnJi 6hl TJiTO CKno­ HHnCfl lIepeA MOCKBOH xaoc Ji AeMOpanJi3al HH 6hlnH 6hl HeJi3' 6e KHhI Ho TaK TJiTO nOCTynJiTb He Mor OH CnJiIliKOM XOPOIliO 3Han Ji nOHJiMan CYTh Ji 60nhllleBHCTCKOH BnaCTH H CTanHHa nJilfHO H nonHOCTbIO OT o aBan ce6e OTlieT B TOM lIeM 6bl Bce no KOHlIHnOCb Ho no TOllbKO OAHa npIfllHHa nHlfHaH XOTH Y TJiTO mllfHoe HeB03­ MO KHO nonHOCTbIO OTAelIJiTb OT ero nOnl1TJilJeCKOH o eHTcnbHOCTH npyralI Ke IIpHlfJiHa 3aII HTa coXpaHeHJie rocy o apcTBeHHoH anaCTJi H He3aBJiCJiMOCm IOrocnaBJiH A nJilfHaH cYAb6a TJiTO nepe­ nneTanaCb II 1I0'lTJi 'ITO OTO KAeCTBnHnaCb rocy o apCTBC JIM C ero BnaCTbIO B BnaCTbIO a6COnIOTHOH KOTOpaH B MOMelIT pa3pblBa OCllapJiBanaCb TonhKO rrpOCOBeTCKJiM MeHblllJiHCTBOM B lOrocnaB­ CKOH napTJiJi B IIpomBOCTOHHHJi MOCKBe T'lTO Bl1 o en CBOH o om Kor o a COBeplllanMCh Hana lJ KH Ha 'lIaWY napTHii HYlO H o eOnOrHlO Mbl C Kap o eneM nblTanMCb y6eAHTb ero liTO 6e3 H o eo­ norHlfeCKoro CBeAeHHH ClieTOB C cOBeTcKoH CJiCTeMOH TO eCTb 6e3 H o eOnOrHlfeCKoro o60cHoBaHHH HallieH rr03Jil HJi MbI rroTepHeM IIcpclleKTMBY YBcpeHHocTb B ce6e Ji CTa6HnbHOCTb nil HaM CY K o eHO nOr116HyTh TO MhlIIom6HeM Ha POAHOH 3eMne pa60THI1KI1 MOMeHT pa3pblBa C MOCKBOH TIfTO npOHBHn YHJiKanbHylO HHTYJiTHBHylO cnoco6HOCTb K nparMam3MY Cpa3y Ke nocne pa3­ B npaBHlUeH BcpxYIUKe npomB Hc06xo o HMOCm OKa3aTb Co­ BeTaM corrpOmBneHJiC He BhlCTYITan HHKTO Ho C caMoro Ha'lana Hanrn TOlfKJi 3peHHH OTnJilJanJiCh o pyr OT o pyra Teopern'leCKaH rpynrra - KapAenb KHAPl1l1 EaKapIfll H II HeKOTopbIe o pyrl1e ­ CKnOH1InJiCb K TeOpenl'lCCKOH nOneMI1Ke C KllCC llrrH lTOH rpyn­ nbI caMO Hanl1'IHe TaKoro KOHq nJiKTa CBH o eTenbCTBOBano 0 KPJi­ 3l1Ce COBeTCKOH JiHTCprrpeTal HJi neHHHJi3Ma' COl HanJi3Ma BTopaH Ke rpyrrlla COBerCKOH Mo o enl1 rrpaKTJiKOB BO rnaBe C TJiTO M PaHKOBHlfeM XOTena OrpaHI1'IHTbCH TonbKO BorrpocaMH MC KrO­ cy o apCTBeHHbIX OTHOllleHHH B 06eHX rpynllax CTPaCTJi KnOKOTanJi TaK 'ITO nopoH H o a KC q H3H'IeCKH OIUYlUan KaK TpeCKaeTCH 6pOHH YHacne o OBaHHoro OT npownoro MexaHHlfeCKI1 YCBoeHHoro o orMa­ rn'leCKOrO MbrnmeHHH H Bce Ke HalliJi TorAalllHHe pa3nHlfIfH BO B3rnH o ax He MoryT 06bHCHl1Tb Tex 06BJiHeHHH KOTopble TIITO 6pocJiII B nMUO MHe H o PyrJiM CBOI1M 6bIBnrn M COpaTHI1KaM MIloro neT CnyCTH OH 06BHHJin HaC B TOM lITO MbI BbI'IepKHyIII1 'laCTb era OTBCTa Ha IIHCbMO MonOTOBa-CTanJiHa OT B 27 MapTa 1948 r nOM orpbmKe TJiTO AeHCTBJiTenbHO HCHO Ji lIeTKO ollpc o en1In xapaKTep OTHOllleHHH Me KJJ y COl HanHCTHlfeCKJiMI1 CTpaHaMH TeKCT IIHCbMa OH npe o CTaBJin Ha paCCMOTpeHMe HaKaHyHe 3ace o aHHH llonIfT6lOpo liTO caMO no ce6e xapaKTepH3yeT lIepCMeHbI B ero 1I0BeAeHJil1 Ji Ji3MeHJiBWYlOCH aTMocq epy Toro BpeMeHJi - npe K o e Tlno HJiKor o a TaK 6bI HC nocTynJirr Koe-KTo Ka KerCH H 3aMeTJiII caoIO CYAb6y CBOIO JiCTOpJilJeCKYlO MJiCCJilO 266 267 '110 IaKaH pOPMYJIHpoBKa OOJIhlUC Bccro B03MYIHI COBCTCKOC HMCTh ropa3AO 60ncc 3Ha'IHTeIThHh1C H rrry60KHc nOCJICACTBH Il PYKOBOACTBO nOCKOJIhKY KacaelcH C pC phi B KOTOPOM npCACla­ CCJIH Obi OHll pll cKHyrrH paCllIHpHTh CBOH HAconorH'lCCKHC pacxo J ­ BHTCJIH ACHHH co CTarrHHblM H CCIm XOAiKa caM HC Ohm ObI CKrrOHCH nOA­ COBCICKoro rOCYAapCIBa C'IIUaJIH CCOH CAIffiCIBCHHbIM aBTopHICTOM KapACJIh PaHKOB H APyrHc COmaCHJIHCh CO MHOM AaBaThCH H PClUHJIH 'ITO CKa3alb 00 310M Tino AOJIiKCH H '110 H H CACJIan CCTh XOA nOJIiiIH'ICCKOM OOPhOhl ll pa3BHTHc nOrrHTH'ICCKHX B38 HMO­ MarH3MY BrraCTH H HAeOnOrHH OAHaKO HCTOPll H TO THIO He B03paiKaH Hawy peKOMCHAalUlIO npHHHJI BCKope ooa OTHOlUCHHH HC BhlOHpacT BOiKACH a BOiKAH BhlOHpalOT ifCTOpHIO Ie'leHHH CJIHJIHCh B 0AHO B TOM 'ITO THTO OTOiKACCTBHJI cefiH C ll CTopHeii B popMHpoBaHHH cpa3Y iKe nocne KOTOPOM cYiKAeHo eMY ohmo HrpaTh caMYIO 3Ha' HTCrrhHYIO POJIb THIO IeOpCUr'leCKOe H nparMaIH'IeCKOC npHHHJI CMepnl HAcOnOrH'IeCKHC ClaJIilHa OH OIOPOCHJI HOBlUCCIBa Ho HX KaK nOnHTH'ICCKHM OanJIaCT yrpoiKaBlUHH OAHaKO ero nH'IHOii BnaCHr THTO THiKcno ncpCJKHBan KOH pnHKI C MOCKBOM HO OH iKe ero H cIHMynHpoBan XOIH B 310M Acnc OH HC Obm HH CAIffiCTBCHHbIM HH caMbIM OhIJIa H CHrra THTO H era cJIa60cTh C oAHoii CTOPOHhl AO caMoOTBCP­ iKCHHOCTH OTBaiKHOC OC03HaHHe nOTpefiHocTcH BpcMeHH C APyroM rOTOBHOCTb nOpa60Il aTb CHJIbI iKH3HH OrpaHH' HBaTh rpaiKAaHCKHC CBo60AhI MaHHIIyrrll poBaTh rrIO bMll ll Hap0AaMH • • paAHKaJIbHbIM OTHOlUCHHH C MOCKBOM pa3BHBanHCb 3Hr3arooopa3HO nOKa COBeICKOC CTPCMllCHHC K 3KOHOMH'ICCKOM H nOnHIH'lCCKOM rcrCMOHHH HC CTano O'lCBHAHbIM B 3aBHCHMOCIH BepHOCTh H J eJlM H KOPbICTb BnaCTOnI06HJl 01 OfiCIOHIcnhCTB MbI 10 YCIynanH 10 conpOIHBnHnHCh He nocry­ naHCh npH 310M HH CBOHM aBIopHTCIOM HH C HHCTBOM HalUHX pHAOB IIOCIcnCHHO cncpBa B Y3KOM Kpyry PYKOBO Hlcncii a MOiKHO YOC HThCH 'ITO HMCHHO C TO'IKH 3pCHHH MapKCH3Ma KaK H rrI060ro Apyroro KOMMYHHCTH'lCCKOrO yqCHll H Hll OAHH n03iKe H B 60ncc IlIHPOKOM Mhl CIanH KpHIHKOBalh COBCTCKYIO H3 KOMMYHHCTH'lCCKHX BOiKAcii He Ohm KOMMYHHCTOM KOMMY­ CHCTCMY H rronHTHKY CCCP no OTHOlUCHHIO HHCTOM Hcnh3H npH3Halb fleHHHa ll rrll lUh C 6orrhlUoii HaIHiKKOM K ffirocnaBHH H Boc­ TO'IHOH EBponc THTo Obm OCTOPOiKCH HO HcrrOKoncOHM pa3YMc­ CTCH B Y3KOM KPYry nOHHMaH KaKoii onaCHOCTH nOABepraCT OH caMoro CcfiH H CBOC ACTHIl C - ffirocrraBHIO MapKca H 3Hrcnbca KaK MOiKHO COrrraCOBaTh C KOMMYHHCIH'lCCKHM HHICpHalUfOHanll 3MOM TO HanpHMep OOCIOHTenbCTBO 'lTO flCHHH HC Mbl MY' HTCnhHO npO HpanHCb CKB03h 3apocrrH AorM KOIOphIC npCHcopcr plffiaHCOBOM nOMOIl hIO HeMeUKoro rCHcpaJlhHoro IllIaoa a 3aTCM OIpaOOlarr 3IH ACHhrH nO IJ fmcaB MHpHblM AorOBop caMH CIl C B'ICpa ll cnOBCAblBaJIH 310 Ohm 6orrC3HCHHbiM npouccc C BHJlhrerrhMOBCKHMll reHcpanaMH B EPCCT-flHloBCKe nO'lIll Ha3aBT­ HO OH HC TonhKO HC CKOBblBaJI THTO a HanpOTHB KaK ObI BCCrrHJI pa nocnc 3aXBaTa BrraCIH 3HrcnhC Ohm npoMbIllmeHHHKOM C apH­ B Hcro MYiKCCTBO H Acrrarr cro ooncc HaXOA' HBhIM CIOKpaIH'lCCKHMH 3aMaIllKaMH a MapKC cneKynHpoBarr Ha OHpiKe B 310M 60Phfic C MOCKBOii B 3Tll X HallIHX cTpacTHx Ohmll ll B rOIOBHOCTH KneBClaTh Ha CBOHX nOrrHTH'leCKHX concpHHKoB OlUll fiKll H npOC'ICTbI 310 KacacTcH npciKAc Bccro ynpHMoM nOnhlT­ MapKca MOiKHO C' HTaTb npCATe'lCH CIanHHCKHX MCTOAOB qIO iKe KH BhlpBaTh AIIoaHHIO H3-nOA COBCTCKoro BrrHHHHH ll nOA' HHHlb KacaeTCH CTanHHa 10 OH nepeOHn OJl HHX KOMMYHHCIOB- no o pH­ ec ffirocnaBHH OTBCTCTBCHHOCTh 3a KOTOpyIO HCC caM THTO CIanlffi UHaJIbHhIM H 'lCM BCC BMCCTC B3HThIe pcaKlUfOHcpbl COBCTCKOC npaBHTcnhCTBo Hcnonh30BanH 3TH HcnpOAYMaHHhIC npOCKTbI IOrocrraBCKoii rcrCMOHHH HaA AIIfiaHHcH KaK noBOA JJ1H HpOCTHbIX HanaAOK H onpaBAaHHH MCp no AaJIhHCMlUCMY nOA' HHC­ Pa3pbIB npH3HaHHHM nOrrHTH'IeCKOM KOH HCH30CiKCH I1 npHorrll 3HlerrbHO pHIlOCO pHH 700 000 - C nOrrHTH'IeCKOM OOJIbIllC npaKIH­ 'ICM OOJIhillC nOrrHTH'lCCKaH pHIlOCO pHH npe­ HHIO BOCTO'IHO-CBpOnCHCKll X CTpaH IIonon3HoBcHHH THTo HaC'ICT ICHAYCT Ha HaYllliOCTh H HcnorpclUHMOCTh ICM pa3pbIB rrrYOiKC ArrfiaHHH He'ITo nOAOOHoC Obmo H C pcnHrHCM B npOIllnble BpcMeHa AYxo­ C OAHOM C APyroii CTOpOHhl CTOPOHbl KOllll pOBanH COBCTCKHC MCTOAhI MblcrrHrrHCh KaK OAHH H3 crOCOOOB OT HHX BeHCIBO PCAKO HBJlHrrO oopa3cu AOopoACIcrrcii KOIOPblC npono­ 3aIl HTHThCH OAHaKO HaTonKHYBIllHCb Ha COBCTCKOC H anoaHCKoe BCAbIBanO a CHIlbHhlC MHpa HacaiKAaJIH CBOIO HCIHHHYIO BCpy npOTHBOAeiicTBHC nocpeACTBOM pe3HH H rpaOciKcH fl1060e nOnHIH'IeCKOe Y'leHHe ­ OH pa3YMHO oTcTynHrr ConpOTHBrrCHll C IOro­ crraBCKHX KOMMYHHCTOB COBCTCKOMY 3KcnaHCHOHH3MY Morno Obi 268 269 nocKonbKY BCe OHH B KOHe'lHOM HTOre npeJ CTaBmlIOT co60ii Bcero CTOHT eme pas ynOMHHaTb 0 Bce eme HeHS KHTblX J aHOBCKHX nHllIb J yXOBHYIO H nOrHlJeCKyro KBHHTJCceHIJ HIO rrpeJ CTOlImeH rrpHeMax nOJ aBneHM KynbTypbl B IOrocnaBHH 3a KoropbIe comac­ rrepeJ HaMH J eHCTBHTenbHOCTH - HO oq HIJ HanbHbIM H rronyoq HIJ HaIlbHbIM HCTOlJHHKaM OTBeTCTBeH­ BblcrynaeT KaK 06'beJ HH1IIOmHH H MOJ enHPYIOIUHH q aKTOp COSHaHM KaK opHeHTHp H M06HnH­ HOCTb Hecy HCKnIO'lHTenbHO H OJ HH 3aTOp orrpeJ eneHHblX 06meCTBeHHbiX rpynn KHBalI CHna KOTOPblX u am neT BblpaCTaeT HS MHO KeCTBa pasHo06pa3HblX H HerrpeJ CKa3yeMbIX COCTaBnlIIOlll HX 11 KOMMYHHCTnqeCKHX nH l epoB He 6bmo 6bl OCHO­ 06BHHlITb BaHHH 6onbllle lJeM J PyrHX rrOnHTnqeCKHX J elITeneii J a e rro npOllIeCTBHH TPH l ­ MbI y acanHCb CTaIIHHCKOH KneBeTe H HanaJ KaM nocne 1948 r HO BeJ b J O JTOrO MbI TOlJHO raK e rOpJ HnHCb CTaIIHHCKHMH nOXBaIlaMH IIOMHIO KaK neTOM 1946 r 11 eXaII H3 EneJ a B JIy6­ B HeIIocneJ OBaTenbHOCTH H J a e 6eCIIpHHIJ HIIHOCTH ecnH 6bl OHH nlIHy C O l HHM H3 'lHHOBHHKOB IIonbCKoro MHHHcTepcTBa HHOCTPaH­ He rrplITaIlH CBOH rropOKH IIpHOOralI K HeTepIIHMOCTH H HaCHnMM HbIX J en lJenOBeKOM cnHllIKOM MonOJ bIM nnH TaKoro BblCOKoro ecnH 6bl OHH He J yIllHllH KPHTHKY H He IIPOTHBHnHCb 3apo l eHHIO nOCTa HO KOMMYHHCTOM H OH pacCKaSbIBaII MHe KaK CranHH HOBblX EcnH BparaM oCY J an CY l HTb 0 THTO cornaCHO MapKCHCTCKHM KpHTepMM nonbcKYIO 11 J eneraIJ HIO OH npeJ CTaII 6bl IIepeJ HaMH KaK OJ HH HS caMblX HerrocneJ OBa­ rrepe6Hn H TenbHblX caMbIX HeKOMMYHHCTnqeCKHX KOMMYHHCTOB 11 Bepo­ paIlbHOMY KOMHTery H lITHO erO KoponeBCKHe saMallIKH 6bmH 6bl TYT cymecTBeHHeil 3a HsnHIillIIOIO CTaBHn HM B rrpHMep THTo ''THTO rrepenan ny YMepeHHocTb K MonOJ eIl OH Bcex HCroPHIO CBOHM TOBapHmaM no Il eHT' MbI HcrrblranH cypoBoe HO OTHIDJ b He HerrpMTHOe qyBCTBO Mbl 6bmH rOp l bI rOBOpIO H JTO BOBce He aBTopHTapHblX MeTOJ OB ero IIpaBneHHlI HarrepeKOp BceMY JTOMY ­ nnlI Toro 'lT06bI OCY KJ aTb Koro-nH60 HnH onpaBJ bIBaTb caMoro a no cymeCTBY HMeHHO 6naroJ aplI BceMY JTOMY - ce61I - O l HHM H3 caMbIX OH OKaSaIlClI B lJeM-TO 11 6bm xy e B lJeM-TO nYlJllle J pyrHX H npocTo YJ al JJHBblx HeMHOrHe KOMMYHHCTbI SaXOTlIT c006maIO HCTOpnqeCKHH q aKT paJ H ypoKa Ha 6Yll Ymee IIonHTH­ IIOM1IHyTb ero J 06pb1M cnoBOM HO HM1I ero He B036YJ HT H TaKoro KY HeB03MO H0 HH nOHHTb HH npaKTHKoBaTb BHe KOHKpeTHbIX y aca H raKHX rrpOKnlITHH KaK HM1I CranHHa TaKoBo no KpaH­ CHryaIJ HH O l HH H Te Ke nIOJ H B pa3Hblx ycnOBHlIX MoryT peam­ Heil Mepe Moe y6e J eHHe XOTH OHO H 06peMeHeHO MOHM co6cTBeH­ pOBaTb Ha OKpY aIOmee C pa3HoH CTerreHbIO H l eonOrnqeCKOH oJ ep­ HbIM npornnbIM COTpY l HnqeCTBOM C Tmo H OCHOBbIBaIO ero HMocrn Ha OIl eHKe KaK KOMMYHHCTnqeCKHX TaK H BCHKHX npo'lHX peBO­ OTKnoHeHM THTo OT KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKOH J OKTPHHbI KaK no nIOUHOHHbIX aBTOKpaTOB 0 I1 HH MOH J pyr OCTpOyMHO 3aMeTHIl 6bmo BnpolJeM H y CTanHHa H y Mao cKopee nOJ TBep l J aIOT ero qeM KOMMYHHSM HerrocneJ OBaTenbHee TeM OH nYlJllIe• • O l HaKO H3 Bcero CKa3aHHoro OTHIOJ b He cneJ yeT lJTO THTO CTOHKYIO H HerroKOne6HMYIO BepHocTb MapKCH3MY H COIJ HanH3MY cy­ HnH TO'lHee neHHHcKoH BepcHH KOMMYHH3Ma meCTBeHHO OTTIHlJaIlCH B nylJlllyIO HnH xYIl lllYIO CTOPOHY OT J pyfHX qeM 6bma nnH THTo H l eOnOrM MapKcH3Ma-neHHHH3Ma qTO KOMMYHHCrnlJeCKHX BO J eH HIlH lJTO OH 6bm MeHee rrpeJ aH MapKC­ OH ClJHTaII B HeH caMbIM cymecTBeHHbIM He3bI6neMbIM H HepYIllH­ HCTCKo-neHHHCKOH H l eOnorHH OH rOBopH rronpocry BbIHY J eH MbIM 6bm IIpHcnoca6nHBaTbCH K 06CTOlITenbCTBa cnO HBIllHMCH 06CTOlITenbcTBaM A MeHlInHCb 6bICTPO H pesKo - oc06eHHo nocne 1948 r 06meHSBeCTHO CTonKHOBeHM C COBeTCKHM COI030M B 113 nHlJHOrO CBoero YlJaCTM B PYCCKOH peBOnIOIl HH H rrporra­ raH l HCTCKHX ee HHTeprrpeTaIJ HH - a HeCOMHeHHO lJTO H TO H J PY­ roe OKaSaIlOCb pellIaIOmHM B q opMHpoBaHHH rrOnHTnqeCKHX B3TnH­ C KaKOH eCTOKOCTbIO OOs BClIKOrO pas60pa nHlJHoil BHHbl 06py­ J OB THro - IllHIlHCb Ha KoHTppeBOnIOIJ HOHepOB rrocne HailleH rr06e l bl Xo­ HeocymeCTBHMbI pollIO eCTb H l eOnOrHlJeCKH H opraHH3aIJ HOHHO CrrnOlJeHHOH rrapTHH 3TO H3BeCTHbI H paspYIllHTenbHbIe nocneJ CTBM aHTHCTanHH­ OH YCBOHIl 'lT0 peBOnIOIJ HlI H YTBep J aeMalI eIO BnaCTb H HeJ onrOBelJHbI 6e3 rraprnH HOBoro THIla TO CKOH HaCHnbCTBeHHoH KonneKTHBHsawrn B IOrocnaBHH KOTOPyro ero IIPOBOJ HnH 'lT06bl J OKa3aTb HenpaBory cranHHCKHX 06BHHeHl ll 0 B HK06bI KynaUJ oM YKTIOHe IOrocnaBcKoH KOMnapnrn 11 eJ Ba nH Ha6nIOnan nocne B03BpameHM H3 PoCCHH rJ e OH HaxoJ HnCH B 270 y6e l eHHe rrpollIno rrpoBepKY OlJHCTHnOCb H 6nY J aHMX H HeYJ alJaX IOrocnaBcKoH rrapTHH yKperrHnOCb KOTopble OH 271 B nJIeHY nOCJIe nepBOH MHPOBOH BOHHbL THTo 6bIJI no HaType HJ eaJIOM TO B CCCP ycrreJIO CJ enaTbCH nOJIHTHKOH npHBHJIerHpO­ 'IeJIOBeKOM J eHCTBIDl CJIOBa pellH c06paHIDl 6bIJIH eMY HeCHOCHbI BaHHoro KJIacca KorJ a B 1937 r nOCJIe apecTa B MocKBe ceKpe­ eCJIH He HCIIOJIb30BaJIHCb lUI nOJIHTHlIeCKHX ueJIeH KaK napTHHHbIH TapH KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKOH IIapTHH IOrOCJIaBHH fopKHlIa H J pyrHX H npo JlCOI03HbIH aKTHBHCT THTO ClIHTaJI He TOJIbKO 6ecnJIOJ HbIMH H pa3pYUII1TeJIbHbIMH J JIH napTHH JlpaKUJiOHHOCTb cnOPbI H HO yKJIOHbI nOCKOJIbKY B ooPb6e 3a YTBep eHHe CBOeM peBOJIIOUJiOH­ HOM J HKTarypbI napTHH HY Jl aJIaCb B eJ JiHCTBe CKJIOHHJICH H OnbIT K JIeBbIM J PyrHx OJ HaKO ero Do 1928 r THTo c06cTBeHHbIH MOJIOJ bIX aKTHBHCTOB KOTopbIe OnbIT KaK BbIJl BHHYJIHCb IOroCJIaBCKHX BOJ CTBOM 6eCKOMllPOMHCCHO J eHHbiX Jl HKTaTypoH 'IaJIOCb B 'IaJIe YKpeIIHJIH B HeM HJ eIO MOHOJIHT­ Ha3Ha'laeT THTO JIa IIOJIHOCTbIO 60JIbllleBH3HpoBaTbcH H YTBepJl HTbCH B HeIIOKO­ HaUJiOHaJIHCTOB napTHH IOrocJIaBHH 1928 r - KoMHHTepH B caMOH cTpaHe napTIDl Y Ke ycne­ ne6HMOH IIpeJ aHHOCTH COBeTcKoMY COI03Y H CTaJIHHY IIOJ PYKO­ H3 napTHHHbIX HH30B a TaK Ke BblCTYIIJIeHHe KOMHHTepHa npoTHB OTKpbITOe nHCbMO qneHaM KOMMYHHCTHlIeCKOH rrOJIHT3MHrpaHTOB rnaBoH IOrOCJIaBCKOH napTHH 6 peBOJIIOUJiOHHYIO 30-x roJ OB BOHHCTBeHHbIX J eHTeJIeH IIOPO K­ HHBapH Moe nOKOJIeHHe KOIOpoe BKJIl ­ 60Pb6y H BCTyIIHJIO B IIapTHIO B Ha­ 6e3YCJIOBHO IIPHHHMaJIO Bce H JIeHHHH3M H KOMHHTepH H COBeTcKHH COI03 a C CepeJ JiHbi 3Q x rOJ OB - H HOH napTHH OI HmeHHOM OT JlpaKUJiH H no nOMY 60JIee 3 Jl JleKTHB­ CtaJIHHa H lIHCTKH H Bce npouecCbI ITo IIpaBJ e rOBopH Harna HO J eHCTBYIOmeH B Maccax B HH Jl0pMHpoBaHHocTb 060 BceM 3TOM 6blJIa HaMHOrO cJIa6ee HarneH 3apOJ blllle 3TO H 6bIJI CTaJIHHCKHH BapHaHT JIeHHHCKOH napTHH nOCKOJIbKY HJ eOJIOrHl eCKOe eJl HHCT­ BepbI BO 6bIJIO CTaJIHHCKHM H306peTeHHeM KOTopoe J OJI KHO 6bIJIO npe06­ a 6bITb MO KeT J a Ke H IIpeHMYmeCTBO ••• ITpeKpacHO Bce no rrOHHB pa3HTbCH B HJ eOJIOrH'IeCKYIO l1Jl eOJIOrHl eCKOe C peJIHrH03HOH COBeTCKYIO eJ JiHCTBO MOHOIIOJIHIO THIO C'IHTaJI HenOKOJIe6HMOCTbIO IIapTHIO KaK 06pa3eU BOCIIpHHHMaH BO KJ H JIeHHHH3M ITapTHIO HaJ JIe KHT OllHmaTb OT JlpaKUHH lUI lIero HMeeTCH HaJ e KHbIH cnoc06 IIapTHHHOrO anpHopHOH J aHHOCTbIO H IIPOCTO eJ JiHCTBeHHbIH H caMbIH HeYTOMHMaH paOOTa H MOHOJIHTHOe PYKO­ BOJ CTBO Ho lUI peBOJIIOUJiOHepOB - THTO IIpHCIIOCa6JIHBaJICH K 3TO He 06H3aTeJIbHO H3'bHH HOBbIM IIapTHHHbIM KaJ paM J a Ke H B nOM HBJIHH C060IO eJl Ba nH He HCKnIO'IeHHe cpeJl H CTaplllero IIapTHHHoro IIOKOJIeHHH 3TO 6bIJIa IIapTIDl KOTOPYIO OH XOTeJI 3a KOTOpyIO 60POJICH H TOMHJICH B TIOpbMe H eMY CY KJ eHO 6bIJIO BIIOJIHe 3aCJIY KeHHO CJ eJIaTbCH ee Bo eM OH H CtaJI eJ HHOJIH'I­ HbIM BO KJ eM Jl HKTaTOPOM KOToporo IIO TeM BpeMeHaM MOrJIH HarpaJl HTb BJIaCTbIO TOJIbKO B MOCKBe MOCKBa Ke MOma lTY BJIaCTb EYJl Y'IH eJ HHO KJ bI npHHHTa TaKaH KOHJl emum IIapTHH H PYKO­ H oT06paTb HO TorJ a THTO ee BnOJIHe YCTpaHBaJI Y'IaCTHe B KJIaC­ BOJ CTBa npeBpamaeTCH B HeIIpepeKaeMYIO HCTHHY Ha IIpOTH KeHHH COBOH 6opb6e Ha pOJ JiHe H npHBbIlIKa K Jl BYJIHlIHIO B MocKBe BHY­ nHTHJIeTHerO TIOpeMHOrO 3aKJIIOlIeHHH Y THTO He 6bIJIO B03MO K­ rnHJIH eMY liTO BO BCHKOH H oc06eHHO KOHe'lHO KOMMYHHCTH'IeC­ HOCTH c03J aBaTb H CIIJIallHBaTb TaKYIO rrapTHIO eCJIH He C'IHTaTb KOH IIOJIHTHKe Bce pelllaeT COOTHOllleHHe CHJI H HHTepeCOB lITO MaJIeHbKOH HeB03MO KHO BbICTOHTb H BbI KHTb HaXOJl HCb IIOCTOHHHO B c Jlepe rpynnbI ero TIOpeMHblX TOBapHmeH OJ HaKO KorJ a B HHBape 1929 r B IOrOCJIaBHH 6bUla IIpoB03mailleHa a6COJIIOTHaH BJIaCTb Kopmm ArreKcaHJ pa Ha'laJICH IIPHJIHB B IIapTHIO HOBbIX J eHCTBHH COBeTCKOH HJ eOJIOrH'IeCKOH THpaHHH He HMeH onopbI B CBoeH CTpaHe MOJIOJ bIX KOMMYHHCTOB Ha KOTOPblX He JIe KaJIO 6peMH IIpOlIIJIbIX OJ HaKO HJ eOJIOrHH Ma pKca H neHHHa OCTaBanaCb J JIH Tmo YKJIOHOB H KOTopbIe 3aOJ H0 C rOTOBHOCTbIO IIPHHHMaJIH H JIeHH­ J O HH3M H He TOJIbKO IIOJTOMY BeJ b 3Ta HJ eOJIOrHH npeJ OIIpeJ eJIHJIa B03­ JIeHHHCKO-CTaJIHHCKHH THrr IIapTHH KaK Y Ke rOTOBbIH caMoro KOHWl HeIIpepeKaeMOH HeH3MeHHoii H HepYllIHMOH IIpOBepeHHbIH H J JIH peBOJIIOUJiOHHOH 60pb6bI eJ JiHCTBeHHO B03­ HHKHOBeHHe MO KHbIH TaKoBa 6blJla napTHHHaH aTMoc Jlepa B KOIOpyIO THTO napTHH HO taK Ke H eJ HHOJIH'lHOrO BO KJ H MH IIO KpaHHeii Mepe IIorpY3HJICH nOCJIe BbIXOJ a Ha CB060J Y B Y Ke BHJ eJI Teppop KOTOPbIH 1934 orrpaBJ bIBaJICH r B MocKBe OH He06xoJl HMOCTbIO He TOJIbKO 60nbllleBHCTCKOH KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKOH IIpaBHmeii BepXYlllKH KOTopble IIpH3BaHbI BeCTH IIapTHIO H 6JIIOCTH ee HJ eOJIOrH'IeCKYIO lIHCTOry l1J eoJIorHH H IIapTHH KH3HeHHO HJ eOJIOrHlleCKoro eJ HHCTBa H C03J aHHeM IIpeJ IIOCbIJIOK J JIH 6ec­ B3aHM03aBHCHMbI KJIaCCOBOro 06mecTBa qIO J JIH IOrocnaBoB 6bIJIO peBOJIIOUJiOHHbIM 'ITO HJ eOJIOrHH He MO KeT H He J OJI I lla MeHHTb CBOHX OCHOB a 272 06YCJIOBJIHBaH OJ Ha J pyryIO TaKHM crrOCOOOM 273 napnm AOmKHa HeYClaHHO 60poTbc II 3a MOHOJIUTHOClh CBOeH BJIaC­ TH - no KpaHHeH Mepe AO HacrynlIeHHH TOro YIOnH'leCKOrO 6yAY­ - rOTOB JIH Thl 3aJlBHTh 3TO ny6JIH'lH0 51 OTBeTHlI C nareTH'leCKOH HCKpeHHOCTbIO lUero B KOIOPOM He 6YAeT y f e HH KJIaCCOB HH BJIaCIH HH nOlIH­ - B JII060e BpeMJI H THKU KOHe'IHO AO nora He AOIIIJIO nOCKOJIhKY BCKOpe Ha OCHOBa­ Pa3YMeeTCH IaKaH BlIaCIh He MO f eI CYlUeCIBOBaIb 6e3 YTOnH­ lIeCKOH UAeOlIorHH TuTO He IOJIhKO 3ay'IHlI ny UAelO HO H Bocnpu­ HlUI ee BceM CBOUM C03HaHueM - KaK He06xoAHMOe YCJIOBUe H HUH C YAOBOJIhCTBHeM AOKJIaAa KapAeJIJI Ha nneayMe UeHlpaJIhHOrO KOMHTern JI 6hIJI OCy f JJ eH 3a peBH3HOHH3M a THIO ou eHHlI MOH B3rJIJI I hI KaK Bhma3KY KJIaCCOBOro Bpara B napTHH KOH1 lIHKI TUTO co CBoeH CTaJIHlIhlM 06HapY f HlI B03MO f HOCTh H BepoJlIHOCTh BOHH Me f AY JIHlIHOH CYAb6bI l1 AeolIorHH H TeopHH 6hIJIH M II Hero HeOTAeJIHMhl KOMMYHHCTHlleCKHMH rOCYAapCIBaMH HO OTIllOAh He H3MeHeHHJI 01 nOlI1UHKU TIpaBAa OH HHKOrAa He npeBpalUaJI HAeOJIOrHIO B CIPYKryPhl BlIaCTH H HAeOlIorUH BayTPH 3IHX rOCYAapCIB cpeAcrno o uno CBoero c06CTBeHHoro lIUlI1h cpeACTBO BlIaCTH B03BhIlI1eHHH YCTpoeHHH 'ITO xapaKTepHO MH Bo3MO f HO JIH H3MeHHTh HlIH pa3BHBaIh MaPKCH3M-lIeHHlIH3M COBeTCKHX PYKOBOAHTelIeH O unaKO H OH He OIAeJIlUI BJIaCTb OT HAeOJIOrHH He nOAphmaH OCHOB MOHonomm napIHH Ha BJIaCIb Hero 060pOTHblMH CTopOHa­ Y f e EaKYHHlI C npoHHu aTenhHOCThlO aHapxnlleCKoro YIonHCla MU O unOH H TOH IKe MeAaJIH l1 3BeCTHaH maCTHlIHOCIb lIH6epaJIh­ 3aMeTHJI 'ITO YlleHHe MapKca HeH36e f H0 BlIelleI 3a co60H C03Aa­ C03HaTeJIhHOCTh H BlIaCIb 6hIJIH MH ItI HOCIb KOIOPyro OH BpeMeHaMH AOnyCKaJI B IeOpeIH'leCKHX cno­ Hue 'lYAOBHlUHOH rOCYAaPCIBeHHOH MalllHHbl yrneleHHJI pax HHKorAa He nepeXOAHlIa rpaHHUhI TaK Ha3blBaeMOH KOHCTpYK­ HO Ha poAHHe EaKYHHHa 6bIJIO nOKa3aHO liTO IaKaH H Aa f e elUe 'lYAOBHlUHaH MalI1HlIa AeRCTBUlelIbHO HMeH­ IHBHOH KPHTHKH H KOHellHO He AonYCKaJIa KpHIHKH AHKrn­ ooJIee Iyphl npolIaTepHarn TO eCTh MOHonOlIUH napTHU Ha BJIaCIh TIoc­ cnYllaHHo H 10 'ITO MH ReUHHa BCH CYIb MapKCH3Ma CBOAIDIaCb OCYlUeCTBHMa He KOlIhKY OOphOO 3a uY BJIaCTb ee crpYKTypa H BaylpunapTHHHbIe K YlleHHIO 0 BlIaCTH 0 AHKlaIYpe npolIernpHaIa C nOJIHIUlleCKOH OH TO'IKU 3peHHJI COBeplI1eHHO He CYlUeCIBeHHO npaBAa JIH 310 OIHO­ BMeJI JIH'lHY1O yrp03Y B MalIeRlI1HX npH3HaKax KpHIHKH lIeHHlICKHX CUTelIbHO MapKCU3Ma a CYlUeCTBeHHO TO 'ITO ReHHH 3IY IeopHIO nOHHTHH 0 BJIaCTH TO eCIb rOBopH HHalle nonhlTKH peBH3HH JIe­ H3 MapKCU3Ma U3BJIeK 'lT06bl npHMeHHTb ee B POCCHHCKUX YC JO­ OTHOlI1eHHH ofiecne'IHBaJIH JIH'lHY1O BJIaClb U caMOro THTO - HHlIH3Ma na f e BO BpeMeHa CTOJIKHOBeHHH co CTaJI 1lIhIM Ka f JJ hIH BHJlX TeopHH MapKCH3Ma KOIOpaH He CJIy f HT HAeOJIOrH'leCKHM pa3 KOrAa BhICKa3hlBamfCb COMHeHHH B COIJ HaJIUCIH'leCKOM xapaK­ onpaBAaHlfeM B JaCIH B Hame BpeMJI cYlUecrnyeT lIHlI1b B 3anaA­ Tepe COBeICKoro COI03a a npH 3TOM caMO C0601O HanpalllHBaJIaCh HhlX YHHBepCHTeTax aHaJIOrHH C nOJIO f eHHeM B caMOR IOrOCJIaBUH THTO He IOJIhKO MapKCH3Ma KpoMe ero lIeHHlICKoro BapHaHla KOAeKC 1l0BeAeHHJI AaBaJI CTpalliHhm onHYM 3TOMY OTIlOp HO U C'lHlaJI ce6H JIUlIHO OCKop6JIeHHhIM l1 HorAa MHe Ka3aJIOCh 'ITO OH HrpaeT pOJIh nepBOCB IIlUeHHHKa KO­ OCHOBbl HAeOJIOrHH KOMMYHHCIH'leCKHX Clpauax HeT HlIoro C03HaHHJI HeH36e f Hhm 3lIeMeHI BlIaCTH MapKCU3M THTO He OT JH'IaeICH OT MapKCH3Ma APYI UX KOMMY­ HHCTH'leCKUX ClpaH no CBoeR 1 YHKUHH Ioporo B03MYlUaeT epeCh lIeKTHKa HCIOPHH KaK MH B MalepHaJIH3M MaTepHaJIHCTH'leCKaH AHa­ 00 ph 00 xapaKTep Bblpa f aeICH nHmb aKueHloM Ha rOCYAapcrneHHOH He­ KJIaCCOB HeH36e f HOCTh n06eAbI BnaCIb 3aBHCUMOCIH nparMaTH'leCKUR neHHHH3M CMelI1aHHbm C COUHaJI-AeMOKpaIH'lec­ 6bIJIO COMHeBarhCH KaK H B lIH'lHOM npeCTH f e H nOlIO f eHUH caMO­ B HHBape 1954 r KOrAa II B CBH3H C MOHM AeJIOM KOH Ha c06CTBeHHyro lOrOClIaBCKHH COIJ HaJIH3Ma BO BceM MHpe aBaHrap una ll POJIh napTHU B nOCTpoe­ ro THTo npaBe ClleIJ H1 U'IeCKH HHH 6eCKJIaCCOBOro 06lUeCTBa BO BceM nOM Hen03BOJIHTeJIhHO H aero oCBHlUalb H onpaBAbIBalb MOHOnOJIbHyro MOAeJIb TUIOBCKHH 1 pa3eolIorueH KapAenH 1l0ClelleHHO npeBpalUaeICH B IOro­ cnaBCKHH BapHaHT MaPKCHCICKoro aBTOpurnpH3Ma MOHOIlO JbHa ll 6hIlI Bhl3BaH K THTo KOIOPhlH npHlIlUI MeHH B npHCYlcTBJUf PaH­ BlIaClb 06peTH He3aBHCHMOClb ay f AaeTCH H B CBoeR c06crneHHOR KOBH'Ia H KapAeJIH B KaKoH-Io MOMeHT II Me f iJ y npO'IHM 3aMe­ HenOrpelI1HMOH HAeO JorHH THJI 'ITO 3HrelIhc 01I1H6aJIc II B CBOHX paccY f AeHHHX 0 AHaJIeKIHKe npHpoAhI TorAa TUTO cnpocHlI MeHH C Bhl30BOM H HeAoBepHeM 274 OCHOBbl CH rnKUM MeonorHH 06pa30M a COOTBeTCIBeHHO HeTpoayThIMH HlIH H Aa f e BJIacrn OClaIOT­ pa3BHBaIOICJI H 275 COBepweHCTBYIOTCH Y THTO He 6bIJIO HHKaKHX npWDm 6bITh npo­ THBHHKOM TaKoro pO 1 a TeopemqeCKHX HOBweCTB xonr 1 a Ke HX npHHYIK D eHHR BO Bcex ccpepax 1KH3HH IOrocllaBHH KOTOpaR npoWJIa qepe3 cypoBble HCIlblTaHHH peBOllIOII HH OTllHqaeTCH B 3TOM orno­ OH IlpJUIHMan O J HHM H3 IlOCne J HHX ITocne pa3phIBa C CCCP OH weHHH OT D pyrHx Hap0 l llblx D eMOKp3THM Bcero llHWh TeM ' TO CKOpO IlOHRJI 'ITO AHKTaTOpCKaH BnaCTb oc06eHHO B ManeHhKOH BHOBb BBO l HMOe YrHeTeHHe 6hIJ10 TaM H pa D HKallbHee H Bceox­ H cna60 BaTbIBaIOll ee 3Ha'IHTellbHaR D OllH qaCTHOH c06CTBeHHOCTH Bce eIl e pa3BHTOH CTpaHe 3acrnHBaeTCR H Ha'IHHaeT rHHTh KaK TOJIhKO IlpeKpawaeT cTHMynHpoBaTb COII HanhHhlH 6a3HC Ha Kom­ coxpaHHllaCh pOM nOKOHTCR H D alKe Ha MellKHe qacTHbIe npe l llpHHTHR Ho TeM He MeHee 6e3­ PeWHTeJIbHbIH H Ha D eneHHhIH IlpaKmlJeCKHX D enax THTO TBOpqeCKHM Bo06paIKeHHeM B 6bIJI OCTopOlKeH lJpe3MepHO OCTOpO­ KeH Kor D a pe% lIma 0 IlpHHR THH IlOJIHTWIeCKHX HAeH He rOBOpR ylK 06 HX H3 KpynHblX H D eH IOrocnaBCKoro KOMMYHH3Ma He J1 D M caMoy paBneHHH B03HHKJIa B 1950 r y MeHR a pa3pa­ 6 naJIH ee KHAPHq H Kap D eJIb TeIlepb IlapTHHHaR BepxywKa D ora­ B03BeCmTb 6Y D TO C COBeTCKHM COI030M 60llhwee qeM llI06aR D PyraR H3 CTpaH HapO D ­ IOrocllaBHIO caTellllHTOM HOMep OAHH MbI IOrOCJIaBbI 60llbIlle IlO l 1 aKHBallH MOCKBe lJeM npHHa l JIeIKHT nHIffiO eMy D anaCb 3aKOHHR H IlPHHYIK D eHHR pa3poCllHCh D O TaKOR CTeneHH qTO IOro­ cnaBHR IlpH06pella CHllbHoe CXO D CTBO XOTR H He TO l D eCTBO HOH D eMOKpamH J1 Bce IKe 3aIla D 6bID He IlpaB KOr D a Ha3bIBan TBOpqeCKOM pa3BHTHH HH O D Ha KpeCTbHHCKaR c06CTBeHHOCTh Ha 3eMJIIO Ha D OMa npHHII HIlbI caMoynpaBneHHR IlpaKTH­ 1 a l e He HBHO KOHeIffiO cnywaJIHCh liollee Toro IOrocllaBHH KaK 6bI COCTR 3anaCb C MOCKBOH 3a 06lla D aHHe Ilepe D OBOH pollhIO B IlOCTpoeHHH KOMMYHH3Ma HaH60llbwee CXO D CTBO C COBeTCKOR CHCTeMOH 06HapYIKHBallO KOBanHCb C caMoro HalJaJIa HaweH peBOJIIOII HH MHe 6e3pa3nH' Ha ce6H CJIaBa nepBOOTKpblBaTenR HO HHTepeCHO IlO D qepKH 'Tb ' TO THTO pR BHaqane caMoynpaBJIeHHIO COIlPOTHBJIHJICH •• caMOH 3HeprH'lHOH OTeqeCKOH 3a60TbI H O l lIOBpeMeHHO TBep D bI­ B TOM 'ITO R Ha3bIBall qHCTOH nOl1 lUHKOR HnH HHalJe rOBO­ B 'IHCTOH BllaCTH KOTOpaR 6bIJIa H OCTanaCh npe D MeTOM HeH J10CHcpa lipo3a THTO HenpepbIBHO pa3MHO l allaCb 6IOpOKpaTHH Bcex COPTOB TOJIhKO oOna 1 aHHe 6IOpoKpamqeCKHM IlOCTOM rapaH­ BO K D b H CHCTeMa He TO K l eCTBeHHbl THpOBallO HO B3aHMOCBH3aHbI llHH HH o J Ha IlOJIHTWIeCKaR CHCTeMa He CPopMHpyeTcH eJIHKOM IlO Bone BOIK D eH Jla Ke IlpH caMOM lKeCTOKOM Teppope H cBepxy HaBR ­ 3aHHOM KOJIneKTHBH3aII HH COBeTCKaH CHCTeMa OTpaIKaJI3 He Tonb­ enH H MeTO D bl CrnnHHa IIoJIHTHqeCKaH CHCTeMa oc06eHHO KO HOBaR CKJIa D bIBaeTCH B HTore cTa6HlIbHOCTb IlOllOlKeHHR H IlepCIleKmBY KapbepbI I1cKllIOqeHHe H3 3Toro IlpaBHlla He Ilpe D CTaBllHllH H opraHbI HaCH­ B3aHMO D eHCTBHR 6eC'IHCneHHbIX 0 o6eHHO IlOllHTHqeCKoro HaCHJIHH TO eCTb TaHHaH IlOllHII HH HeCMOTpR Ha Bce IlOIlbITKH npHAeplKHBaTbCH CTporHX KpHTepHeB IlpH Ilo D 60pe Ka D poB 3m opraHbI YKOMIlJ1eKTOBbIBanHcb BHaqane caMbIMH H36paHHbIMH Ilpe D aHHbIMH 6eCKOMIlpOMHCCHbIMH KOM­ MYHHcTaMH O J HaKO HMeHHO 3TH opraHbI CTaJIH BCKope qpe3BbI­ qaHHo pHBlleKaTellbHbI l J1R nOllHTHqeCKHX KapbepHCTOB H IlOClle­ H HeYJIOBHMbIX CHlI KOTopble BbIXO D R T Ha apeHY HCTOPHH H3 B3aH­ peBOnIOII HOHHbIX MOCBR 3eH cmXHHHblX D BHlKeHHH IlO J HHMaIOIl HXCH CHH3Y H opra­ D lIR caMOH BllaCTBYIOll eH IlapTHH eIl e 60llee ry6HTenbHbIM 6bIJ10 HH3aII HOHHbIX CTPYKTYP CIlYCKaeMbIX cBepxy OT HCKYCCTBa IlonH­ TO qTO TaHHaH IlOnHII HH paCIlpOCTpaHHlla CBOH KOHTponb Ha Bce THKa 3aBHCHT YCTaHaBnHBaTb paBHOBeCHe 3THX CTHXHHHbIX H opra­ ccpepbI IKH3HH pO HThIBaR Bce ee IlOPbI rrpoHHKaH B ceMbIO H qacrnyIO IKH3Hb HH3YIOIl HX Ha 'Ian EcnH KOHKpeTH3HpOBa Th HOT Te3HC IlpHMepoM nocneBoeHHOH peBOJIIOII HOHepoB B 1947 r JlnH 06Il eCTBa H D a l e MOH IlepBaR lKeHa MHTpa rrOlKanOBanaCb MHe qTO D a l e H HM qJIeHaM UeHTpanbHoro KOMJUeTa Cep6HH IOrocJIaBHH TO C O J HOH CTOPOHbl Mbl HaH D eM pBYIlIHeCR KO BceM PHXO D HllOCh BH l aM npH TOBapHIl ax OTBeTCTBeHHblX 3a pa60TY rocY 1 apcTBeHHoH 6e30­ IlpHBHJIerHH npoTHBneHHe rOM 276 CTOPOHbI IlapTHHHble MaCCbI a HeCOII HaJIHCTHqeCKHX eneHaIlpaBJIeHH 'IO TaKlKe CTHXHHHoe CO­ cnoeB 06Il eCTBa a C D py­ opraHH3aumo TOTanbHoro D ep l aTbCR OCTOPO l HO B Cf ' ilX BbICKa3bIBaHHR X naCHOCTH MO HO Ilpe D cTaBHTb 'ITO D on I HO 6bIDO TBOPHTbCR B KaKHx-HH6Y D h rrpOBHHII HanhHblx 06nacTHbIx KOMHTeTax 277 KOHTponb HaA napTHeH 'lepe3 nOCpeACTBO TaHHOH nonHIUfH Ha6moAeHHe Ka l AOrO KOMM 'HHCTa 3a OCranbHbIMH 6e3YCJIOBHO H306peTeHO MocKBoH JIeHHHblM H CTanHHbIM THTo H THTOBUbl nO npOCTO 3aHMCTBOBanH OWIaKO He 060umOCb TyT H 6e3 caMO­ CTOHTenbHoro TBOp'leCTBa napmH oc06eHHO nocne no6eAbl paCTeT H craHOBHTCH MaCCOBOH H60 ecnH 6bI Horo He npOHCXOAHJIO YKpenJIeHHe HOBoro rocnOACTBYIOluero nOA nOCTOHHHOH yrp030R C napTHHHaH BepxylllKa Knacca OCTaBaJIOCb 6bl ApyroH CTOpOHbl napTHH TO eCTb AOJI I Ha 3TOT npouecc KOHTPOJIHpOBaTb 'lT06bl He CAenaTbCH A06bl'leR 'lY I 1J bIX KOHTppeBomoIUfOHHbIX CHO 3TO H nopo l 1J aeT uenb oTpHuaTenbHblX nOCJIeACTBHR raHHaH nOnHUHH npeBpaUl aeTCH B He06xoAHMOe cpeACTBO BepxymKH IH ee BJIaCTH HaA napTHeH B X03HHHa HaA CBOHMH HOBbIMH X03HeBaMH POJIb napTHH YMeHbmaeTCH a B HTore cna6eeT aKTHBHOCTb H HHH­ IUfaTHBa napTHHHblX H HapoAHblX MaCC nOCJIe pa3pbIBa C MOCKBOH KOe-'lTO H3MeHHJIOCb - rJIaBHblM UHH JIHmb B03pOCJIa B Ha'laJIe 3TO 6bmo HeH36e I H0 H3-3a AeHTeJIb­ Hocm npOCOBeTCKHX 3neMeHTOB Ho H nOTOM KorAa HanpH I eHlle OTHOmeHHHX C COBeTCKHM COI030M CTaJIHHa XOTH ocna6JIo nOCJIe CMepTH 6bwa BOCCTaHOBneHa XOTb KaKaH-To 3aKOHHOCTb BHe nOnHTH'leCKOH CtPePbl ponb TaHHoH nonHUHH OCTanaCb npe l ­ HeR 113MeHeHHH npoH30umH XOTH H 1966 AOn I HTenbHOe BpeMH B nOBepXHOCTHO H Ha Henpo­ r KOrAa peBOnWIUfOHHaH nonH­ ueHCKaH CHCTeMa Ha'laJIa ce6H H3 I HBaTb H KOrAa THTo 3allOA03PHJI HJIH BepoHTHo Aa l e pacKpbID 3aroBop BHyTpH caMOH CJIY I 6bI rocYAapcTBeHHoH 6e30nacHOCTH no 06U1 eM ' MHeHHW 3aroBop 3TOT He 6bW HallpaBneH nHtIRO npoTHB THTo HO OH Mor nOBne'lb 3a C060H OCJIa6JIeHHe ero BnaCTH OOJIbmHHCTBO 'lHHOB rOCYAaPCT­ BeHHOH 6e30naCHOCTH 6bmo TorAa ornpasneHo Ha neHCHW HJIH nepeBeAeHO B ApyrHe BeAOMCTBa CeKpeTHaH nonHUHH no KpaH­ HeR Mepe TeOpeTHtIeCKH 6bma OrpaHH'leHa BO BnaCTH BCKope npo­ HBHJIH ce6H H AeMOKpaTH'leCKHe TeHAeHIUfH ''HaUHOHanHCm'leCKHe'' B TeXHoKpaTH'leCKHe B XopBaTHH BHYTpH napmH ­ nH6epanbHble B Cep6HH CnoBeHHH THTo npHcnoca6JIHBancH KO BceM 3THM HallpasneHHHM H nepeMeHaM HO ero CTpeMJIeHHe K nH' HOH BJIaCTH OCTaBaJIOCb HeH3MeHHbIM TaKoB 6bID HaH60nee nH6epanbHbm nepHoA npaBJIeHHH THTo OTMe'leHHblH Bce-TaKH OrpaHH'leHHeM ero nH' HOH snaCTH HAeOnorHH 278 THTOBCKOH CHCTeMbI H TeM caMbIM nOnO l eHHW caMoro THTO B 1971-72 H rocnoACTBa AorMaTH3Ma B rr THTo C nOMOUl bW apMHH O'lHCTHJI napTHlO H B03POAHJI TaHHYw nonHIUfw BnacTb THTo H tPopManbHo CTaHOBHTCH a6COJIIOcHOH On Bce pe l e npHcYTcTByeT Ha pa3HbIX 3aceAanHHx Bce 'laUl e BbICJIymHBaeT BepHonOAAaHHH'leCKHe AOKJIaAbI TorAa l e 6bma BBeAeHa 06H3aTenbHaH IH Bcex wrocnaBOB OT AeTeH AO rrry60KHx CTapHKoB nporpaMMa H3y'leHHH AOKTPH­ HepcKoro Ha J yMaHHoro THToBcKoro MapKcH3Ma OH CTaHOBHTCH IH cBoeH cTpaHbI eAHHCTBeHHbIM 6e3YCJIOBHbIM aBTOpHTeToM a IH OCTaITbllOrO MHpa - B 060 l aeMbiM KOMMynHCTH'leCKHX H KallHTaITHCTH'leCKHX cTpaHax a oc06eHno B CBOHX eAHHHBlllHXCH paBHbIX 06pa30M K JIY'llleM ' OAHaKO BnaCTb Be3AeCYUl eH TaHHOH nonH­ B Ho KaK 6bl TaM HH 6bIDO 3a nHTb JIeT 3TH HeJIeHHHCKHe HaCTpo­ eHHH Ha6panH TaKYW CHJIy 'lT0 Ha'ianH yrpo l aTb CTa6WlbHOCTH CTpaHax npOCnaBITHeMbIM roCYAapcTBeHHbiM AeHTeITeM He Pe I HM HenpHCO­ 3HaWUI HM ce6e rOCYAapcTBeHHaH CHCTeMa 3Ha'lHTenbHO H3MeHHJIHCb HO THTo ero POITb H MeTcNJ bI OCTaJIHCb TaKHMH l e 3TO 6bIDO 6bl HeB03MO l HO eCITH 6bI MOHO­ nonHH napTHH He coxpaHMaCb KaK KpaeyrOITbHbIH KaMeHb CHCTe­ Mbl BepHee CKa3aTb 'lT0 MeHHITCH TaK I e THTo KaK MeHHITHCb Hero npHeMbI BJIaCTBOBaHHH HO nOCKOITbKY no OT Hero 3aBH­ ceno nepeMeHbl umH nHmb B CTOPOHY YKpenneHHH ero ITH'lHOH BnaCTH B napmH H HaA napmeH ••• TYT nOpa l aeT cBoe06pa3HaH a6cYPAHaH AHaITeKTHKa THTO yAaBaJIOCb OCTaTbCH B He3aMeHHMOM nOJIO l eHHH TO eCTb yKpen­ JIHTb CBOW ITH'lHYW ' HCTYW BnaCTb HMeHHO nOTOMY 'ITO OH He npemITCTBOBaIT nepeMeHaM B pa3HbIX o6JIacnlx H Aa l e CHCTeMbl B ueJIOM He CITY'laHHO KOHe'lHO 'ITO THTO 'lpe3Bbl'laHHO peAKO npOHBnHIT HHHUHaTHBY B ctPepax BHenOnHTH'leCKHX HanpHMep B 3KoHOMHKe H KYITbTYpe Ho KOrAa H3BeCTHbie petPOPMbl HJIH H3MeHeHHH JaBoeBbIBaJIH npH3HaHHe Aa l e B nonHTHKe oc06enno eCnH OHH OKa3bIBaITHCb nITOAOTBOpHbIMH THTO Aa l e HX nOMep­ l HBaJI C HCKpeHHHM JHTY3Ha3MOM Kor J a KHAPH'l H Apyme 6JIH3­ KHe eM ' napTHHHble 3KOHOMHCTbi H TeopeTHKH na'laJIH npHcnocofi JIHTb WrOCITaBCKYW 3KOHOMHKY K CBo60WlOMY PbIHKY THTO HX 3Hepnl'ruo nOMep l aJI npoB03rrraCHB HCHbIH H npOCTOH npHHUHll BCHKYW CTOHMOCTb H3MepHTb AHHapoM 11 Bce-TaKH THTO AO caMoro CBoero KOHua ne COrrraCHJICH OueHHBaTb B AeHhrax nOITH­ TH'leCKHe MeponpHHmH 3apnJlaTY napmHHhIX tPYUKIUfOHepOB MOnOAe I Jlble CTPOHKH peBonwIUfOHHble W6HJIeH H npO'lee 279 pe3ynbTaTe EcnH Obi rrocne CTOnKHoBemur C COBeTCKHM COI030M B 1948 r BcerrpOHHKalOmeH HH o OKTpHHal HH H IOrocnaBWI COXpaIIHna B 3KOHOMHl-leCKOH ctj epe TaK Ha3blBaeMbIe Ha a rJ MHHHCTpaTHBHbIe rrapTHH B 0praHax caMoynpaBneHWI 0 0 MeTO U I ynpaBneHWI 3KOHOMHKOH TO eCTb aOCOJIlOTH3alJ lfH JIH'lHOH BJIaCTH THTo l eHTp rrapTHHHOH o eR TenbHOCTH nepeHOCHTCR caMoyrrpaBJIeHHe 'ITO rrpHBeJIO K YBeJIH'IeHHlO ' HCJIa 'lJIeHOB 90'% H 6onee TaKHM oopa­ COBeTCKYlO 3KOHOMHtleCKYlO MO o enb OHa BrraJIa ObI B HHmeTY H 30M xaoc 'ITO rro o opBaJIO Obi rocy o apCTBeHHYlO BnaCTb a TeM caMbIM y'lacTOK napTHHHOH paOOTbI CaMblM H3BeCTHbIM TeopeTHKOM 3TO­ caMoynpaBJIeHHe Ha' HHaeT COCTaBJIR Tb HaHOoJIee Ba KHblH H BJIaCTb THTO rrOCKonbKY OHH ObillH Hepa3 o eJIbHbI A 3TO OTKPbIDO rO o eMOKpaTH'IeCKOrO TOraJIHTapH3Ma Obm Kap o eJIb ocooeHHO Obi B03MO J IOCTb AJIH JmOCTpaHHoH HHTepBeHIJ lfH - B ero rrOCJIe o HeH pa60Te ITYTH pa3BHTWI nOnHTH'IeCKOH CHCTeMbI npe K o e Bcero co CTOpoHbI COBeTcKoro COIo3a KOTopaa 3a o ep KlUIa ObI HaIJ lfO­ COl HaJIHCTH'IeCKOrO caMoyrrpaBJIeHWI KOTOpaH BbI3Bana BOCTopr HanbHoe pa3BHTHe Ha MHOrHe o eCHTHlleTHa 3KOHOMHtleCKHe npe o ­ o a Ke HeKoropbIx cnelJ lfanHCTOB Ha 3aJIa o e rrpWlTHB nOJIY'IHJIH He3aBHCHMOCTb 'ITO Obi OHH tj YHKIJ lfOHHpOBam1 ITOCKOJIbKY HAeR caMoynpaBJIeHWI pa3BHJIaCb H3 rrpOTHBOCTOR ­ 60nee HJIH MeHee 3tj tj eKTHBHO HO JIHIllb nOCKOJIbKY 3T0 He nOCH­ HWI CTaJIHHY H COBeTCKOH CHCTeMe H HMeHHO rrOTOMY 'ITO OHa rano 1I0Teprrena 1I0pa KeHHe rrpH 1I0lIbITKaX OrpaHHtlHTb nonHTH'IeCKYlO Ha BJIaCTb rrapTHH To Ke caMoe cnyrmJIOCb H B ctj epe KYJIb­ TYPbI rrOCKonbKY OHa He 3aTpanmana 3anpeTHbIe TeMbI napTHH­ BnaCTb rrapTHH OHa OKa3anaCb y o o6HoH AJIR C03 o aHWi HOBoH HAeo­ HYlO MOHOnOJIHlO HCTOPHlO peBOJIlOlJ lfH H KOHe'lHO caMoro THTO norHH AJIR nponaraH U 1 HOBoH OTnH'lHOH OT cOBeTcKoH YTonHH nHlIIfO PeanbHoe CJIHJIOCb C HAeanbHblM caMoynpaBJIeHHe - C HenOJIHOH AHTHCTanHHH3M H CBOOO o HbIH PbIHOK npHIIIDH B rrpOTHBoperme H HerrOCJIe o OBaTeJIbHO ocymeCTBJIeHHOH 3KOHOMHKOH CBOOo o HOro C rocno o CTBOM OlOpoKpaTHH H Be3 o ecymeM nOJIHIJ lfH 113 OOPbObI pbIHKa Ho pa3Be Morno ObITb HHa'Ie npH CHCTeMe rrOnHTH'IeCKOH rrpoTHB CTaJIHHCKOM THpaHHH H Me'lTaHHH 00 HCTHHHOM o eMOKpa­ THtieCKOM COlJ lfaJIH3Me 3apoAHJIaCb B KOHe'IHOM C'IeTe HAea caMO­ ynpaBneHWI KOTopoe JIeranH3HpoBaJIO MOHOnOJIHH Ha BJIaCTb CaMoynpaBJIeHHe ooepHyJIOCb HOBOH COlJ lfa­ JIHCTH'IeCKOM TeopHeH HOBbIM yrorrH'IeCKHM B o OXHOBeHHeM aHTHOlOpOKpaTHtieCKYlO THTo HHKor o a He Obm H He CTan CTpaCTHblM rrOKJIOHHHKOM KPHTHKY OrpaHHtlHJIO OlOpOKpaTHtieCKHH npOH3Bon Ha rrpe o npHa­ caMoynpaBneHWI OH H He Mor HM CTaTb ecnH He Kenan no o aepr­ TWiX H yKpenHJIO 3KOHOMHKY 60nee HJIH MeHee CBoOo o Horo pbIHKa HYTb pHCKOBaHHblM HcrrblTaHWIM co6CTBeHHYlO CBOIO BJIaCTb 11 Bce O o HaKO 3T0 He nOBnHaJIO cymecTBeHHO Ha xapaKTep BnaCTH H 1950 Ke OH nOMep KHBan 3Ty H o elO B r THTo Ctj OpMYJIHpoBaJI rrOJIHTHtIeCKYlO CHCTeMY ITpH coxpaHeHHH o o HOnapTHHHOrO CTPOH H npHBeJI B o eHcTBHe 3aKOH 0 caMoyrrpaBneHHIi OH nOHHMan 'ITO Be3 o ecymeH raMHOH nonHIJ lfH H eAHHOBnaCTHOro BO K o H caMOynpaB­ CBOOO o HbIH PbIHOK neHHe KH3Hb He MOrJIO c o eJIaTbCH o eHCTBHTeJIbHO o eMOKpaTHtieCKHM a H caMoynpaBJIeHHe O KHBR T 3KoHoMHtlecKYlO H o eOJIOrH3all HR Ii a6COJIlOTH3al Wl caMoynpaBJIeHWI B o eHCTBHTeJIbHO 3tj tj eKTHBHbIM Bca rrOJIHTH'IeCKaH KH3Hb IOrocJIa­ reopHH YKpenHT He3aBHCHMOCTb H no o '1epKHYT HCKJIlO'IHTenbHOCTb BHH rrpOTeKaJIa BHe ctj epbI caMoyrrpaBJIeHWI BnacTb TaRHOH rrOJIH­ IOrocJIaBHH Ho HH Ha Illar o aJIbIlle CaMoynpaBJIeHHe He o OJI J IO IJ lfH TO YCHJIHBanaCb TO YObIBaJIa B napTHH 3apO K o aJIHCb Orrrr03H1I H­ 6biJIO nepecTynaTb onpe o eneHHYlO rpaHHl Y a TeM OoJIee nocnaTb OHHbie Te'leHWI - Ha CHCTeMY BJIaCTH KOTOpaR 3apO o HJIaCb B peBOJIlOIJ lfH rrOJIHOCTblO Bce 3TO BHe BCHKOH 3aBHCHMOCTH OT caMoyrrpaB­ neHWI HH O o HOH 3aOacToBKH oYKBaJIbHO HH O o HOH - a HX 3a cooTBeTcTBYH ero c06cTBeHHbIM YCTpeMJIeHWlM H yOe K o eHHR M nocne o HHe rO U I Obmo OeC' HCJIeHHOe MHO KeCTBO KpaTKOBpeMeH­ l1 o eaJIH3HpOBaHHaR o eHCTBHTeJIbHOCTb caMoynpaBJIeHWI pe o KO Tpe­ HbIX H C 3KOHOMHtleCKHMH TpeOoBaHHHMH - BO KHJIa nOAJIHHHYlO o eHCTBHTeJIbHOCTb ' HCTOH BJIaCTH THTo He rrpOBenH opraHbI caMoynpaBJIeHWI HnH npotj C0103bI PbIHO'IHaR Kopo'le rOBopa caMoyrrpaBneHHe KOTopoe HeCOMHeHHO HBH­ TeM caMbIM 3KOHOMHKa 06ner'IHJIa onarOnpHR TCTBOBana CB060 o y poCTY nepe o aH KeHWI paOo'leH H 3aHflTOCTH nOCb o OCTH KeHHeM B OOJIaCTH ooeCne'leHWI rrpaB rrpOH3Bo o HTeJIeH H 3KOHOMHKH CBoOo o HorO pbIHKa HHKaK He BJIHR eT Ha rronHTH­ '1eCKYlO cne o HHe 280 CHCTeMY Ha '1HCTYlO rrOJIHTHKY · o eCR Tb JIeT nocne ' HCTOK B Bonee XOpBaTHH Toro 3a rro­ H CepOHH B B 3ana J Holt Enpone nOCTO llHHO pa60 raer OKOJIO MHlImtOHa IOrocrraBCI HX pa60'lHx 281 IOroCJ1aBHH OTKpblJIa CBOH rpaHll UbI WIH TypH3Ma 3aKOH H npa­ BOnOpH l OK CTanH oonee 06H3aTenbHbI a l e wm ll X oqmUHanbHbIX 6mOCTHTeneH lhMeHHJ1ll Cb pOPMbI npeCne l OBaHll H nOnHTH'leCKll X npOTHBHHKOB HaKa3aHHH 6bIJ1H CMHf1 eHbI ll CTaH l apnI3HpoBaHbl llOKYMEHThi O l HaKO l a l e CeHlJaC nOJIHTH1 JeCKll X npOTHBHll KOB MorYT a lJaCTO H l eHCTBHTenbHO npll rOBapflBalOT K 3aKnlO1 JeHHIO Ha l OnrHe CpOKll OTPblBOK 113 llOKJIALlA nPEllCELlATEJUI COBETA HAPO lHblX KOMI1CCAPOB 11 HAPO lHOrO KOMI1CCAPA I1HOCTPAHHblX llEJ MOJIOTOBA HA 3ACE lAH1111 BEPXOBHOrO COBETA COlO3A CCP 31 OKTRliP» 1939 rOLlA npOCTO 3a nepeCKa3 KaKorO-Hll 6Y l b aHeK l OTa ll nH BbICKa3blBaHll e Bpa l eCKHX MblCJ1eH B Kpyry l PY3eH MexaHH3M nOnHTHlJeCKOH cnelKKH 3a rpa l aHaMH H3MeHeHll H He npeTepnen •• llepe600 M MuxauJlo Ja TOBapH IlUI l enYTaTbI 3a nOCJ1e l HHe l Ba MeCHU a B Me l l yHapOJ HOH 06CTaHoBKe npo­ H30 llIJ1H Ba l Hble nOnO l eHHIO B H3MeHeHHB EB pone HO 3TO OTHOCHTC1I npe l l e Bcero K TaK I e H K CTpaHaM HaXOMlllHMC1I J aJIeKO 3a npe l enaMH EBponbl B CBH3H C 3THM Ha l O YKa3aTb Ha TpH OCHOBHbIX 06CTOHTeJIbCTBa HMelOlllHX pernalOlllee 3HalJeHHe Bo-nepBblx Ha l O YKa3aTb Ha H3MeHeHHB npOHCrne l llIHe B OTHO­ rneHHBX Me l Jl y COBeTcKHM COlO30M H fepMaHHeH Co BpeMeHH 3aKJ1101 JeHHB 23 aBrycTa coBeTcKo-repMaHcKoro l OrOBOpa 0 HeHa­ na l eHHH 6blJI nOJIO l eH KOHeu HeHopManbHbIM OTHOrneHHHM cy­ Il eCTBOBaBrnHM B TelJeHHe pH a JIeT Me l l y COBeTcKHM COlO30M H fepMaHHeH Ha CMeHY Bpa l JI bI BCH1 JeCKH nO l OrpeBaBrneHCH co CTOpOHbI HeKOTopbIX eBporreHCKHX l ep l aB npH llIl1o c6JIH I eHHe H YCTaHOBneHHe l PY I eCTBeHHbIX OTHorneHHH Me l l y CCCP H fepMa­ HHeH lanbHeHrnee ynyqrneHHe 3THX HOBbIX xopornHX OTHorneHHH Ha llIJ10 CBoe BbIpa l eHHe B repMaHO-COBeTCKOM l orOBope 0 l PY K6e H rpaHHIJ e Me l l y CCCP H fepMaHHeH nOJ IIHcaHHOM 28 ceHTH6pH B MocKBe IIpoHcrne l rnHH KpYTOH nOBopoT B OTHOrneHHBX Me KJl y COBeTcKHM COlO30M H fepMaHHeH Me l Jl y l BYMH caMbIMH Kpyn­ HbIM rocY apCTBaMH EBponbI He Mor He CKa3aTbCH Ha BceM Me l ­ JJYHapo l HOM nOJIO KeHHH IIpH nOM C06bITHH uenHKOM rrO l TBepJ H­ JIll TY OUeHKY nOnHTH'JeCKOrO 3Ha1 JeHHB COBeTCKo-repMaHCKoro c6JIll I eHHH KOTopaH 6bma aHa Ha np0 llIJ10H CeCCHH BepXOBHoro COBeTa BO-BTOPbIX Ha l O YKaJaTb Ha TaKOH paKT KaK BoeHHbIH pa3rpOM IIonbrnH H pacna IIonbcKoro rOCY apCTBa IIpaBHlllHe KpyrH IIonbrnH He Mano KH1 JHJ1HCb npO'IHOCTblO CBoero rocYAapCTBa H 282 283