KOTophle YChmmmH pa3JIaraJIH 3Ha'lHT H OfiOJIhlUaJIH TaK CKa­ BLWEPlKKH H3 KOMMIOHHKE 0 KOHCI'IEPEHUHH PYKOBO llHTEJ1EA TPEX COlO3HLIX llEPJCAB - COBETCKOrO COI03A COE llHHEHHLIX IIITATOB AMEPHKH H BEnHKOEPHTAHHH B KPLIMY 3aTh ••• j lIOBTOpH1O 'ITO H C KPHTHKOH BopOIIIHJIOBa KOTOpy1O pe3KO lIpOBO J HJI CTaJIHH H COrnaCeH fihm KaK H APyrHe lIOTOMY ' TO OH OTBe'laJI B lIepBY10 rOJIOBY HO He TOJIhKO OH KOHe'lHO He TOJIhKO OH BHHOBaT fihIJI B 3TOM OH B nepBY10 rOJIOBY fihm HO BHHOBa­ 4-11 TbI fihUIH H ApyrHe $eBpaJI H r• j lIOMHID KorAa CTaJIHH B lIbIJIY rHeBa OCTPOH lIOJIeMHKH a 3TO He Ha KaKHX-JIHfio 3aceAaHHHX no lIpOXO J HJIO Ha KBapTHpe B KpeMJIe CTaJIHHa H Ha DJIHiKHeH Aa'le BoT TaM H lIOMH1O KOrAa­ J BO J HTeJIeii Tpex COI03HhIX Aep l aB - TO fiPHtaHHH CTaJIHH O'leHh KPHTHKOBaJI pa3HepBHH'IaJICH BCTaJI 3Ha'lHT Ha BopoIIIHJIOBa BOPOIIIHJIOB TO l e oYKBaJIhHO 3Ha'lHT BCKHIleJI nOKpaCHeJI lIO lJ HJiJICH 3Ha'lHT H rOBopHT TOrAa B OTBeT Ha KpH­ THKY CTaJIHHa OH B 3TOM 3Ha'l1l1 11 ThI eMY OPOCHJI TOrAa OOBHHeHHe ThI BHHOBaT HCTpefiHJI KaApbI BoeHHhle ThI HCTpefiHJI KaAphI CTaJIHH eMY COOTBeTCTBY1OlUY1O AaJI ornOBeAh OTBeTHJI ero •• BOPOIIIHJIOB lIO'MoeMY TOrAa CXBaTHJI 3TO caMoe• • TapeJIKY Ha KOTOPOH JIe l aJI nopoceHOK OTBapHOH 3Ha'lHT H OH lIO lJ HJiJI H YAapHJI ee H YAaPHJI ofi CTOJI 3Ha'lHT ho fihIJIO TaKoe 3Ha'lHT 3TO fihIJI TaKY10 e J HHCTBeHHhIH o60cTpeHHocTh TaKOH 3Ha'lHT cnY'IaH KOTOPhIH H H HaOO1OAaJI taKOe peampOBaHHe Aa Hy KOH'lHIIaCh Bce 1I3BeCTHO 3Ta KpHTHKa TeM 'ITO Ohm oCBo60 l ll eH BopomHJIOB o60poHbI OT lIOCta OT lIOCta OT oOH3aHHoCTeH MHHHcTpa 1945 II • · I I I I ' ' 3a lIOCJIell HHe ll HeH B KPhlMY COCTOHJIaCb lCoH$epeHUHH PYKO­ Y IIpeMhep-MHHHcTpa BeJIHKO­ lJep'lHIlJI I IIpe3HAeHTa COeAHHeHHblX IIltaToB AMepHKH r-Ha I Il Py3BeJIbTa H IIpeACeAaTeJIH COBeTa HapoAHhIX KOMHccapoB CCCP 11 B CTaJIHHa lIpH Y'laCTHH MHHHCTPOB l1HOCT­ paHHbIx IleJI Ha'laJIhHHKOB IIITa60B H APyrHX COBeTHHKOB o pe3YJIbTaTaX pa60Thl KPhlMCKOH KOH$epeHIJ HH IIpe3HAeHT CIIlA IIpeACe l aTeJIh COBeTa HapoAHbIX KOMHCcaPOB C0103a Co­ BeTCKHx COu HaJIHCTH'IeCKHX PeclIyfiJ1HK H IIpeMhep-MHHHcTp Be­ JIHKOfipHTaHHH CAeJIaJIH cneAY10lUee 3aHBJIeHHe V lleKJIapaUHH 06 oCB060 l l emIOA EBpone Mhi COCTaBHJIH H lIOAIIHCaJIH lleKJIapau H1O ofi OCBOOO l AeHHOH r'Ha 8 ' • EBpolIe 3Ta IleKJIapaUHH lIpeAYCMaTpHBaeT cornaCOBaHHe nOJIH­ f nOJIHTH'IeCKHX H 3KOHOMH'IeCKHX lIpoooeM oCBo60 l ll eHHoH EBPO­ • lIPHBOAHTCH TeKCT lleKJIapau HH t i THKH lIbI B Tpex l ep l aB H COOTBeTCTBHH ''IIpeMbep C0103a IIpeMhep-MHnHcTP COBMeCTHble HX AeHcTBHH B pa3peIIIeHHH C AeMOKpaTH'IeCKHMH npHHIJ HlIaMH HH I e COBeTcKHx COIJ HaJIHCTH'IeCKHX COeAHHeHHoro KopoJIeBCTBa H PecnyOOHK IIpe3HAeHT CoeAHHeHHbIx IIltaTOB AMepHKH KOHCYJIbTHPOBaJIHCb Me l ll y co60H B OOlUHX 6o l l eHHoH HHTepecax HapoAOB CBOHX Hapo l OB OCBO­ TerepaH RJrra IloTcJJ aM C60pHHK AOKYMeHToB lilA 2-e AOn01lHeHHOe 113 1 -BO MelKJlYHapoAHble OTHOllleHHJI MOCKBa 304 cTpan H EBpolIhI Oml COBMeCTHO 3 UIBJIH1OT 0 TOM ' TO OHH 1970r 305 nOrOBoplUlHCb MeiKilY co60H COrnaCOBblBaTb B TeqeHHe nepHOn a COBMeCTHOH BpeMeHHOH HeYCTOHq fBOCTH B oCBo60iKneHHoH EBpOne nOlHlTHKY KJIapaUHH lle­ OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH YCTaHoBneHHoH B HacTo llmeii CBOJ IX TpeX IIpaBHTellbcTB B nelle nOMOmH HapOJJ aM oCBo60iKneH­ 3TOH neKnapaUHeH Mbl CHOBa llOnTBepiKJJ aeM Hamy Bepy B npHH­ HblM OT rOCnOnCTBa HaUHCTCKOH fepMaHHH H HapoJJ aM 6bIBlIlHX UHIIbl AmaHT fqeCKOH xapTHH Hamy BepHocTb neKJIapaUHH 061 ­ rOCYJJ apCTB caTellllHTOB OCH B EBpo e npH pa3pellleHHH HMH neMOKpaT fqeCKHMH cnOC06aMH HX HacymHbIX nOllHTHqeCKHX llpaBa Me K J YHaPO J Hhm nopHnOK llOCB IImeHHbm MHpy 6e30nac­ H 3KOHOMHqeCKHX npo6lleM y CTaHOBlleHHe llOp J Ka e J HHeHHhIX HaUHH H Hamy pelllHMocTb C03JJ aTb B COTpY J HHqeCTBe C npyrHMH MHPOJII06HBbIMH HaQIDlMH nOCTpoeHHhm Ha npHHUHIIax B EBpo e H nepeYCTpoHCTBO HaUHOHallb­ Hocm cB060ne H Bce06meMY 6JIarOCOCTO llHHIO qenOBeqeCTBa HO-3KOHOMHqeCKOH iKH3HH nOlliKHO 6hITb nOCTHrHYTO TaKHM nyTeM KOTOPbIH ll03BOllHT oCBo60 K J eHHbIM HaponaM YHHqJOiKHTb nOCllen­ M 3JJ aBa ll HHe CJIenbi HaJ H3Ma H palllH3Ma H C03JJ aTb neMOKpaTHqeCKHe yq­ KH pe K J eHIDI no HX co6CTBeHHOMY BbI60py B COOTBeTCTBHH C npHH­ pe UHllOM AmaHmqeCKOH xapTHH 0 HaCTOHmylO neKJIapaIUilO TpH nepiKaBbI BbIpaiKalOT Hane K J y qTO BpeMeHHoe IIpaBHTeJIbCTBO ¢lpaHny3CKOH Pecny6JIH­ MOiKeT npHCOe J HHHTbC II K HHM B npeMOiKeHHOH npoueny­ npaBe Bcex HaponOB H36HpaTh POPMY llpaBJUellbCTBa llpH KOTOPOM OHH 6YilYT iKHTh nOlliKHO VI 0 DOJIhwe 6bITb o6eclleqeHO BOCCTaHOBlleHHe CYBepeHHblX npaB H caMoy paB­ lleHH M Tex HapOnOB KOTopble 6blJlH lTHlIleHbI Toro arpeCCHB­ Hl IMH HaUH MH YTeM HaClUlHH MhI C06paJIHCb Ha KpbIMCKYIO KOH pepeHIJ HIO pa3pelllHTb H3lIlH yllY'lllIeHIDI YCllOBHH npH KOTOPhlX oCB060iKneHHhie Hapo­ pa3HornaCH II no nonhCKOMY BOllPOCY MbI llOJIHOCTblO 06CY H hI MorllH 6hl ocymecTBMTb 3TH npaBa TpH IIpamfTellbCTBa 6YilYT Bce acneKTbI llOJIhCKOrO BOllPOca MbI BHOBb llO J TBep J HJ1H Halile COBMeCTHO 06mee llOMorarb HaponaM B JTI060M oCB060iKneHHOM eBpo­ iKeJIaHHe BH J eTb YCTaHOBneHHOH CHnbHYlO CBo60nsylO rocynapcTBe-CaTeJTJlHTe He3aBHCHMYIO H neMOKpaT fqeCKYIO IIonbmy H B pe3ynbTaTe HalllHX OCH B EBpone rne llO HX MHeHHIO 06cTOHTellbCTBa lToro llOTpe­ neperOBopoB MbI cornaClUlHCb 06 YCJIOBH IIX Ha KOTOPbIX HOBoe neHCKOM rocynapcTBe 6YIOT a lUlH B 6hIBlileM b C03JJ aBaTb YCllOBIDI BHYTpeHHero MHpa llpOBOnHTb BpeMeHHoe IIonbcKoe IIpaBHTenbcTBo HaUHOHanbHOrO EnHHCTBa HeOTJTOiKHble MepollpIDITH no OKa3aHHIO llOMOmH HYiKnalOmHMCH 6yneT C popMHpoBaHo TaKHM nYTeM qr06hI nonyq fTh pH3HaHHe HaPOJJ aM co CTOpOHbI Tpex rnaBHblX nepiKaB c C03JJ aBaTb BpeMeHHbIe llpaBHTellbcTBeHHble BllaCTH lIlHpoKO llpenCTaBll IOIUHe Bee neMOKpamqeCKHe 3lleMeHThi Hace­ lleHIDI H 06H3aHHbie B03MOiKHO CKopee YCTaHOBHTb nYTeM cBo60n­ HhlX Bhl60poB npaBJUellbCTBa OTBeqalOmHe BOlle HaPOJJ a H d CllO­ nOCTHrHYTO CJIenylOmee cornallleHHe HoBoe nonOiKeHHe C03JJ allOCb B IIonbille B pe3ynbTaTe llOJTHOrO oCB060iKneHIDI ee KpacHoH ApMHeH 3TO Tpe6yeT C03JJ aHH II Bpe­ C06cTBoBaTb rne 3TO OKaiKeTC Heo6xonHMhlM npoBeneHHIO TaKHX MefIHoro Bbl60poB illHPOKYIO 6a3Y qeM TO 6blJl0 B03MOiKHO paHbllle no HenaBHero TpH IIpaBHTellbcTBa 06be J HHefIHh1MH KOHCYJIbmpOBaTbc 6YilYT HaUHHMH H C BpeMeHHblMH C npynfMH BJTaCT MH lUlH C IIollbcKoro IIpaBHTenbcTBa KOTopoe HMeno 6bl 60nee oCBo60iKneHH II 3ana J HOH qaCTH IIonblllH neHcTBYlOmee HblHe B IIollbille BpeMeHHoe IIpaBHTellbCTBo nOJT KlI O 6bITb llonoMY peop­ npyrHMH llpaBHTellbcTBaMH B EBpone Korna 6YilYT paccMaTpHBaTb­ raHH30BaHO Ha BonpoCbl B KOTOPblX OHH np Mo 3aHHTepeCOBaHbl lJeHHeM neMOKpamlJeCKHX ne llTeneH H3 caMOH IIoJIbillH H nOJI KOB KorJJ a llO eBponeHcKoM MHeHHIO Tpex IIpaBHTenbcTB ycnoBIDI oCB060 K J eHHOM rocynapCTBe H3-3a rpaHHUhI 3TO HOBOe IIpaBHTellbCTBo nOJIiKHO 3aTeM Ma3bl­ BaThCH IIoJIbCKHM BpeMeHHbIM IIpaBHTeJIbcTBoM HaUHOHaJIbHOrO 6hlBlIlHX roCYJJ apCTB-caTenllHToB OCH 6ynYT HeMenneHHO OHH EBpone B nlO60M B JTIo60M H3 neHcTBHH He06xonHMb1MH B lUlH cnenalOT TaKHe KOHcynbTH­ poBaTb MeiKilY co60H 0 He06xo J HMhIX Mepax no ocymecTBneHHIO 306 60nee illHPOKOH neMOKpaT fqeCKOH 6a3e C BKJIIO­ E J HHcTBa B M MOJIOTOB f-H B A fapPHMaH H C3P Apq f6anbn K Kepp ynOJIHOMalJHBaIOTC II KaK KOMHCCH II npoKoHcYJIhTHpoBaTbC B 307 MocKBe B nepBYIO OqepeJJ b C 'IneHaMH TerrepellIHerO BpeMeHHOrO IlpaBHTel1bCTBa H C JJ PYrHMH rrOl1bCKHMH JJ eMOKpamqeCKHMH I1HJJ epaMH KaK H3 caMOl IlOl1bIIlH TaK H H3-3a rpaHHI_U I HMeH B C006meHHe JIIOJJ MHIlbI AneKceeBOH BHJJ Y peopraHH3aUHIO TenepellIHero IlpaBHTeJIbCTBa Ha YKa3aHHbiX aBTopa CTaTbH BbllIle oCHoBax 3TO IlOl1bCKoe BpeMeHHoe IlpaBHTel1bCTBO Hall HO­ HaIIbHOrO EJJ HHCTBa JJ OJI l HO npHHHTb 06H3aTeJIbCTBO JlBHlKeHHe 3a COIUIIIIlbHO-3KOHOMH'lecKHe npaoa B CCCP TIpOBeCTH B HOMepe34 cB060JJ Hble H HHqeM He BocrrperrHTCTBOBaHHble Bb160Pbl KaK MO I HO CKopee Ha OCHOBe Bce06lI1ero H36HpaTeJIbHOrO rrpaBa TIpH TaiiHOM Ha CTpaHHll aX 174-175 BblIIycKa 34 IlBE H rrHcana 0 CB060JJ HOM rOJIOCOBaRHH B 3THX Bbl60pax Bce aHTHHall HCTCKHe H JJ eMOKpaTH­ qeCKHe rrapTHH JJ OJI l Hbl HMeTb IlpaBO 11pHHHMaTb Yllacme H BbICTaB­ K I1HTb KaHJJ HJJ aTOB KorJJ a I10JIbCKOe BpeMeHHoe IlpaBHTeJIbCTBO Hall HOHaJIbHOrO EJJ HHCTBa 6YJJ eT CIPOpMHpOBaHO JJ OJI l HbIM 06pa30M B COOTBeTCTBHH C BbllIleYKa3aHHhIM IlpaBHTel1bCTBO CCCP KOTopoe 110 JJJ eplKHBa­ eT B HaCTOHIll ee BpeMH JJ HIIJIOMaTHqeCKHe OTHOlIleHHH C HbiHelIlHHM BpeMeHHblM IlpaBHTemcTBoM IlOJIbIIlH HeHHoro KopOl1eBCTBa H IlpaBHTeJIbCTBO IlpaBHTeJIbCTBO CoeJJ H­ ClIIA ycraHoBHT JJ HIlJl0­ MaTHqeCKHe OTHOlIleHHH C HOBhIM I10JIbCKHM BpeMeHHblM IlpaBH­ Tel1bCTBOM Hall HOHaJIbHOrO EJJ HHCTBa H 06MeHHIOTCH 110CJIaMH 110 JJ OKJIaJJ aM KOTOPblX COOTBeTCTBYIOIll He IlpaBHTeJIbCTBa 6yJJ yT Tpex IlpaBHTeJIbCTB C'lHTaIOT 06beJJ HHeHHlI TPYMIll HXCH CMOT 'ITO 1981 rOJJ Y OT Hero HHqerO He OCTanOCb KpOMe rpynllbl H3JJ aIO­ Ill eH I1HIPOpMall HOHHbIH 6IOI1JIeTeHb OJJ HaKO CeHqaC CTano H3BeCTHO 'Ira CMOT COXpaHHJICH H JJ alKe pa3poccH 17 HIOHH 6bIJIH apeCTOBaHbl qneHbl COB eTa npeJJ CTaBHTeJIeii CMOT BJIaJJ HMHp fepIllYHH 11 Bane­ PHH CeHJJ epOB H rrpOlllJIO HeCKOJIbKO 06bICKOB no lIX JJ e11Y B MOCK­ Be 11 KlieBe K nOMY BpeMeHH BbIlileJI 31-ii BbmYCK 'ITO BOCToquaH rpaHHua IlOJIbIliH JJ Ol1lKHa HJJ TH BJJ OJIb JIHHHH Kep30Ha C oTcTynl1eHHHMH OT Hee B HeKoTopblX paHoHax OT 11HTH JJ O BOCbMH KHIloMeTpoB B n011b3Y I10JIbIliH rl1aBbl Tpex IlpaBHTel1bcTB npH3HaIOT 'ITO IIOJIb­ lIla JJ OJIlKHa nOl1yqHTb cYIll eCTBeHHoe npHpaIll eHHe TeppHTopHH Ha ceBepe H Ha 3anaJJ e OHH C'lHTaIOT 'ITO no Borrpocy 0 pa3Mepe 3mx 11pHpaIll eHHH B Ha l JIelKaIll ee BpeMH 6YJJ eT cnpOllieHO MHeHHe HOBoro I10JIbCKOrO IlpaBHTeJIbcTBa Hall HOHaJIbHOrO EJJ HHCTBa H 'ITO BCl1eJJ 3a TeM OKOHqaTeJIbHOe onpeJJ el1eHHe 3anaJJ Hoii rpaHHll bI IlOJIbllIH 6YJJ eT 0T110lKeHO JJ O MHPHOH KOHlPepeHll HH I1HIPOpMall H­ OHHoro 6I01111eTeHH CMOTa 11 cOJJ ep aHlIe ero CTaIIO 611HlKe K nep­ BOHaqaIIbHoMY 3aMhICJIY Ha 06bICKax 6bIJIH oro6paHbl BbIIIYCKH 32­ 35 HaXOJJ HBIliHeCH IllYHH B npoll ecce nOJJ rOTOBKH B CBH3H C JJ eJIOM fep­ CeH J epoBa BCrrJIbI110 HeCKOJIbKO JJ eCHTKOB HMeH yqacTHlI­ KOB CMOTa coxpaHHBIIIHXcH OCBeJJ OMJIeHbl 0 rrOJIOlKeHHH B IlOl1blIle JIaBbl MelKrrpOIPeCCHOHanbHoM B TaHHe B03MOlKHO cpeJJ H HHX rro­ CTaBIll HKH HHIPOpMall HlI JJ JIH 6IOJIJIeTeHH TaKHM 06pa30M npece qeHHe OTKpblTOrO CYIll eCTBOBaHlIH He3aBlICHMoro np OIPCOI0 3a Bbl­ HyJJ HJlO ero YHTH B 11oJJ nol1be HO He rrpHBe110 K ero YHH'lTOlKeHHIO 113-3a TaHHocTH nOM JJ eHTeJIbHOCm TPYJJ HO CKa3aTb qTO-I1H60 0 ee MacllITa6ax If xapaKTepe BeCHOH 1982 r B MocKBe a B03MOlKHO H B JJ pyrHX MecTax B noqTOBble HIll HKH HeCKOJIbKlIX lKHl1blX JJ OMOB 6bIJIH nOJIO eHbl JIHCTOBKH C np1l3bIBoM OTKa3hIBaTbCH OT yqaCTHH B cy660THlIKax 3TH JIHCTOBKH 6bIJIH HaHJJ eHhI Ha 06blCKax Y CMO­ TOBll eB XOTH na IPOpMa JJ eHTel1bHOCTlI HOBaTeJIHMH CMOTa He npeJJ YCMaTpHBaIIaCb OC­ 308 309