mmEPATIm rrOJIHT AtlliCKOrO PA3BHTIffi rrpaKTH eCKan a TeM 60nee nOTeH anhHaff rrporpeCCHBHOCTb CO­ QHanH3Ma KaK 06 eCTBeHHoro YKna a 6eccnopHa Co anHSM AOK8SaR CEOIO GKOHOMK1JecKyXl ii C01J KaJIbHYJ JlHSHeCnoco6HOCTb HeCMOTpH Ha Bce TRrOT HCTOPH H 06 eCTEeHHHe KaTaKJIH3MH nopo aB Ae orrpe­ n eJIeHHbIe OTRJIOHeHHH OT I-I IJ ea 'Ia Ho XM3Hb BpeMH C06bIT H nopo aDT CBOH rrap OKCbI nopo He­ Boo6pasY e K HecypaSHHe EcnH B3HTb Harne 06 eCTBO TO repOH O­ CTb ero rryTH o eBHAHa Mano Toro - nopa3 TeJIbHa CaMOOTBePKeHHO­ CTb KpaCOTa 3HTY3H8SM cnHTHe B e Kh nop nop0 I1 lH HBOH opraHK3M 06JIa n H orpOMH M 3arraCOM XH3H8CTOMKOCTH Ho Bce aTO nOpO I KJIO K rrOBHilleHHoe TpeOOBaHHR K 8TOMY o eCTBY y6e eHHe ce6H B TOM qTO OHO MO 8T B3HTb nD6 e BHCOTH H B3EanHTb Ha JIDOyID T eCTb Y eT HeH36eXHHX COU KanbHO-HCTO HqeCKKX orpa­ HMtrnT8JIef1 KaK-TO SaT8pRJIC H B 6ype CTpac'reti III C06hITH ECJIM I o6a­ BKTb K 06neKTHBHHM aKTopaM e e H OillH6KH rrp06H Hey a K rrpOC­ qeThI TO B KTore XO I1 C06HTK C opMHPOBan peaJIbHOe 06 eCTBO HBY­ ee peaJIbHOH HSHb Bo6paBillee B ceOR TIo6e H rrOpaMeHMH H npOCqeTH c acTbe H HeBsro 3HTY3Ka3M H o aHHH y aqK y I OBJI8TBO­ peHHe AOCTHrHyTHM H Tpe6oBaH¥ RMH OHCTpee BHraTbcfl Bnepe y O HHX cnO HocTH Ha Mapme nopOAKnH yHHHHe Y ApyrKX - paso­ qapOBaHHe y TpeTbKX - CTpe leHHe K aJIbTepHaTHB8 He 06R38TenbHO qaCTHOCo6cTEeHH 8cKO y qeTBepTHX - y68 eHHe B H800XO I1 HMOCTH HOBHX Mep YKpenn KX rrapTHD rocy apcTBeHHOCTb COqHaJIH3M Mo­ saHKa 60raTaH illKpoxafl -H aTO HopMaHbHO Ho TaR HJIH HHa e no TeM KnH H rrpH naM HapH c KOHCOnH­ a He B CTpaHe paSBHBaeTCff onaCHHH rrpo ecc £ _ 8 ££ 2 OXBaThIBa H 1 paSHH8 CnOH HaCeJI8HHR I1PH1lliHH VI Kpyr 2 rrpeTeH3H i oroo6pa3HH HO CaM rrpOUecc OT eTAHB HyxHH peaAb e Mep 06 e HHeHRH 06 eCTBa Ha HOBO OCHOBe CTapaH B H3BeCTHOM M8­ pe pa3MHT8 HOBaR TOAbKO C03 aeTcH Ha e aM HO e C8MO ero HaCTpOeHHe Arrpe b TIO OXHA EHmb Ha ano OTpa3 O TpeBory 38 rrpOHCXO­ ee MH3Hb BTRrHBaeT OD e TBO B 8nO j HeH36e nepeMeH BCR­ Roe TopMo eHHe rryCTb H HeOC03HaHHoe ry6HTeAbHO KpOMe rrpo ero nonHTH eCKaR cTpyHa H8CTOAbKO HaTHHyT8 qTO ITpR cpHBe Mo eT y a­ pHTb OtreHb 60AbHO I gEJIb - - iEJIQ Bo Bcex ero B3aKMOCBR3flX H rrpoHEAeHHHM - rrpOH3BO CTBO o6 eCTBO rronHTHK8 KYflhTypa 6HT HHTepecH nCHXOAorHH 3 opoBbe H T n _ - £_£0LT _ 29 §'l 2 IDl _ qe£ f 'A n KOIIEtIHHn PS3YJIbTAT YKpenneHMe H pa3BHTHe co anH3Ma YKp8llileHHe K pa3BHTHe rrap­ THH H rocy apcTBa YCKlleHHe rrpHB eKaT8nbHocTH HOBoro CTpOR ill CPE UCTBA -------­ Cero HH BOrrpOC yrrKpaeTCH He B GKOHOMMKy - 8TO nHillh MaTepHaAb- HaH ocHOBa rrpo ecca rB03 h - B rrOnHTHqeCKO CHCTeMe a BepHee ­ B ee pa60T8 B eHHH ee Ha e eHHOCTH Ha qenOBeKa ee CBH3H C qe­ nOBeKOM B CTeITeHH ee c e6HO pOAR OTc na Heo6xo KMOCTb I COmaeHH1i ITpaKTHKH COD HaJIH3Ma c ero n n ea nOM yHHtrTOJKeHH1i pa3pHBa Me cnOBOM H nenOM Bee Donee TeCHoro cn RHHR HHTepe­ COB n YHOCTH 2 rpyrrn 06 ecTBa B e OM rrOcne oBaTenhHoro H nonHoro B COOTBeTCTBHH C KOHKpeTHO­ CTOpHtreCKHMH B03MO OCTKMH Ha K OM aTane neMoKpaT 3Ma 3 Pa3BHTKR H OCTK RaR caMocToRTenbHo TBop ecKo C03Ha­ TenbHo-o6De HeHHo c pyrHMH B CBOHX MHCnRX H eHcTBKRX e H 3 rrpeBp eW q K OrO enOBeKa PeanbHOrO BOBne eHKH BCeX B e CTBHTenbHOrO K OrO X03H¥ Ha CTpaHH B COBepmeHCTBOBaHHe H3 Ha uecTax H B rOCYAapCTBe B Qe OM aTO - rn8B rlKT OT KOTOpOrO SaBHCHT pemeHHe H rrepBHX ABYX QHanbHO HeYAOB eTBOpeHHO TH OTMe aTb rrOnOMHTe bHHe 3Aecb xe - OCHOBa nHKB a HH CO­ T K BO-nepBHX AH 6Y T C cABHrH TeMn KOTOpHX SHaqHTenbHO yCKOpHT­ CH BO-BTOpHX OHM ITpH06peTR BMeC C ITpaBaMR H OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb CaYH 6Y T B eTb qTO ceroAHH peanbHo a qTO - HeT B-TpeTbKX He KTO-TO CBepxy a ca d OHM waccH 6YAYT OTBeT KaMH sa Bce rrpOHC­ xo ee B TOM qKcne sa Bee HeCOBepmeHHoe H O HO HS BaxHe mHX ycnoB y eHHoe M CTOpOH To e rrpo ecca e CTBH­ TenbHoro paSBHTHH Macc KaK aKTHqeCKHX H opMa HHX XOSHeB CTpaHH COCTOHT B rrpeBp eHHH K oro qenOBeKa B nH OCTh COSH8TenhHO CTO Ha CO HanHCTw eCRO no e H Bn e D XOTR 6H aS8MH AHa­ neKTHKO-MaTepHanHCTHqeCKO MeTo onorHH eh H paCKOBaHBOGTh MHCnH 6es qero HeBOSMo MHO paSEHTMe ero TBOpqeCKOrO xapaKTepa TaRMY 06paSOM QeMeHTaI Uffi 06 eCTBa He CTOJIhKO HapyxHHMH 06­ pyqaMH Aa BHem MH K HaxO HTCH I BaHKH no OTHomeHHD K C03HaTenbHO H enoBeKy eneycTpeMneHHO B nOCTOHWrlOM H aKTHBHOM CRnaMH a HSHJTpH Kor­ CBH3aH co BCeMH BS8HMO e CTBHH PyrKWB C HKWH IToBHmeHHe AHHaMH3M8 o6 ecTBa nyTeM 60nee nonHoro Hcnonbao­ npe eCTB CTpOH paSBHTHH ero KOMMyHHCTHqeCKO rrpKPO POCT KOHKypeHTOcnoco6HOCTH B TOM cne MopanbHo-nCKXOnOrHqeCKO B 60pb6e BYX CHCTeM napannenbHOCTh pa3BHTHR rYMap CTHqeCKHX rrpe­ eCTB COUHanH3Ma Ha nepe HH nrraH Bce HBCTBeHHee B BHraeTCH rrp06T1eM8 rrono eHHH H ponH JIHqHOCTH B 06 eCTBe B3aHMOOTHOmeHHR 4 M8 HHMH CO HanH3M H eMOKpaTHR B H3BeCTHOM CMHC e TO eCTBeH­ HR KMeHHO apR COUHanH3Me B mKpOKOM 3HaqeHHH 3Toro eMOKpaTHR Ba - £E 8£ 2_ g £-8B _ HO EeM HHQ c o- ITo CyTH MH eMOKpa­ THqHH no opMe qaCTO - qT eMOKpaTHqHH ITpKBecTH OpMy B COOT­ B8TCTBHe C CO epXaHHeM CO ep aHHeM cerO Hero H 3aBTpamHero Hfl Co a 3M - 6o ee HOCTH n03TOWJ rRY60KO MHorOBapHaHTHHH eMOKpaTHqeCKH anhTepHaTHB no CBoe H B qaCT­ rrpKp0Ae CTpoA H60 eMOKpaTHR - aTO rrpe e Bcero cBo6o a rryCTb K B KaqeCTBe OC03HaHHO Heo6xo KMOCTH BH6opa HaTHBH eHTpa H3aUHE Y Hac ze - OTCyTCTBH8 a bTep­ _ _ _ _8 _ge2 E _ 2 _ ££ _ _ _£8 £ _ _£ E£ · OTCyTcTBHe BH60pa BO Bcex c epax H a Bcex cTyneHRX a3HaTC­ Roe rrpOmft-oe HCTOpKH CTpaHH Boo6 e KanHTanHCTHQeCKOe OKpyxeHHe H T Ce qac MH B e OM He nOHKMpeW CYTH e H ero H HCTOpH­ qeCKH OH 6 HeH36e Horo nepexo a OT BpeMeHH Kor a HCTOpKqeCKH HeB03YOXeH KO BpeweHH CRoro BH6opa B KOTOpOM yqaCTBOBa pa3BHBaThCH He h3H A Me 6H He 6ano BH60pa KnH Kor a 6e3 K qe OBeK TeM OTCyTCTBH€ eMOKpaTHqe­ ycnemHO £ £ 2 _ ­ no6 aeT HCKaTh ee H3BHe H KaKaR-TO qaCTh D e Ha­ XO HT ee B Tex H HHHX CTOpoHax 6YPMYa3HO CHCTe O H8 6HTh £ 2 g _ QE L 2- £ - hH2_ - g Q_ _£ g 2 2 2£ pe OpMHpOBaHHH £ -£ Eq - OT 3RO­ HOMHKH o oPManhHHX BHemHKX ITpH3H8KOB eMoKpaTH3Ma 3 Q8 £ EeM Q£ H H aMe onepe a He TeMITH B qeB c¢epax rrpe e Bcero - B napTHH 5 4 £ ££ OrpaHW leHHaR JIWIIb peanbffiDdH ecID OH 6y­ T onaCHOCTHMH no pHBa yCToeB COUHaJIHSMa H yveHbmeHHR MO H nap­ THH H rocy apcTBa KaK BHemHenO HTH eCKoro KTopa rJIaBHttM o6pa­ sow BHYTpH cTpaHH - coxpaHeHHe OCTaTOqHO CHJI B YBHSKe C BHemHerrOE TH eCKKMH s aq C yqeTOM rrpouecca nOCTeneHHoro ­ rryCTb H B KUHH aJIeKOH nepcneKTHBe - oTMHPaHKH r e BOSMO O H HO - pH a rocy apcTBeHHHX 3KcnepHMeHT JIOKaJIbHOrO B npocT­ paHcTBe H BpeMeHH SHaqeHHH 5 CaM rrpouecc o eH BeCTHCb He TOJIbKO CBepxy HO H CHHSy pyKaMH Macc ITpKqeM napTHH HarrpaEJIReT H ooyqaeT KX eMOKpaTaqe­ CKKM H BMeCTe C TeM - COSHaTeJIbHO-CO HaJIHCTHqeCKKM PMaM 6 THR H MbIIIIJIeHH L tt UeMOKPaTHH OJD Ha BO TH B ITpHBwmy JIeHHH 6 ITpKBJIeqeHHe K paspa60TKe H saUHH H KOHTPO H 6 rrpoEe eHKD rrpo ecca eMoKpaTH­ sa ero rrpoMexyTOqHHMH pesyJIbTaTaMH CHJI HayKH Y l1YTI1 I ro na R CTyneHb qTO HaM y aeTcH Bnepe BBepx B Ii eJIe pa3BH­ THH rrpOH3BO Ii HTeJIbHHX CRn H JIHBaHHeM I KyJIbTYP no a corrpoB0x naTbCR Ii o e­ nepe n eJIHBarrneM Hallett COBeTcKotl CHCTew JIeHHH £ _ H3MeHeHHe MeTO OB PYKOBo cTBa o6 ecTBoM co CTOpOHH napTHH qTO O HO 03HaQaTb yCKneHHe ee MO H no c e­ cTBy £ _ 8l_ E aHO _ -£ ££ _ £ £ Me napTH HHMH H X03RtlcTBeHHHWH OpraHaMH B apcTBa no pMe H c ecTBY B nOJIb3Y napTHH - nO b3Y rocy­ no c ecTBY YCKJIeHHe pOJIH rocy apcTBa B CBH3H C Heo6xo HMOCTbID aJIbHetl­ rne X03H CTBeHHO-3KOHOYKqeCKO ueHT aJIH3aQHH no cTpaTSrHqeCKHM HaITpaBJISHHKM H o HoBpeMeHHo - ne eHTpaJIH3aUKa a Ta e no eMa 6 TBOpqeCKO aKT BHOCTH Macc rrOc e H e O H MOryT BnHfiTb Ha 06 eHapO HHe H rrpo eccH rrpe e onOCpe OBaHH e cTBHe Bcero qepes CBO Henocpe cTBeHHHH eRTe bHOCT KOHTponb rocy apcTBa qepes KX B03­ KMeHHO Ha rocy apcTBOf Ha era opraHU B ueHTpe H oc06eHHO - Ha MeCTax COBeT MHHHCTpqB - 8 eKO OTCD a - pORb p8 OHa 06­ aCTH H yrKX 3BeHbeB Hapo Hoe TBOpqeCTBO B yCTpaHeHHH He oc­ TaTKOB B 06 ecTBa pa3B THH cO HanHcTH ecKo IlpH 3THX YC OBIDDC H KOMMyHHCTHqeCKO rrpHPO RBHO B03pacTeT OTcID a 6o ee qeTKOe pacrrpe eReHHe 06fl3aHHocTe rrpaB H OTBeT­ CTBeHHOCTH Me rrapT«e H rocy apcTBoM TIapTHH HylL O EKmb Han­ E e ' OCHOBHHe Te eHQHH paSBI1TRff ro H36aBHTb ee OT qHCTO of E E£ aT XOsR cTBeHHHX npe e Bce­ opraHHsaqKOHHO-cHa6 eHqe­ CKHX KUH orpy6 RR e Ha KaROM-TO 3Tane HKBH KpoBaTb OT­ pac eBHe x03ERcTBeHHHe OT e g napTH HHX opraHoB co BCeMH BHTeK8­ KMH nocne CTBHRMH OCTaBHTb sa rrapTHe HWb rroRHTHKY orrpe e­ eHHe OCHOBHHX rrp noB 3ROHOMHqeCRO H COQHaft-bHOA nORHTHKH aTO - rRaBH rryTb 2 EOR ITo MHCnH eHHHa rrapTH Hoe PYKOBO ­ rocy apcTBeHHHMH CTBO OpraHaMK PyKoBo afl PORb napTw X03R CTBeHHoro annapaTOB a B PYKOBO HTb bUH OnxHO HOCHTb E He B no eHe rocy apcTBeHHoro H cosH aTenbHOM KOHTpORe 06 eCTBOM - qepes nD e qepes CBOHX CT8BJIeHIDIKOB - - 2 _ _gy r aE I10JIHTMQeCKaH OneH­ Ka KX effTeRbHOCTH H cne OBaTeRbHO HqHOCTHaR oueRRa - sa nap­ TH HHMH opraHH3a HRMH MMeTb B RKrnb OT eJIH I 2 3 3KOHOMHqeCKO rrOJIHTHKH cOQHanbHoA nOR THKH BKn qaR BRRBneHHe 06 ecTBeHHHX cHTya­ UHH H MHeHHH eOnOrHqeCKH 7 4 opraHH3aqHOHHO-Ka poB 5 6 Me apo 2 T£ E a 2 E O Ha pa3B BaTbcfl onepe a H­ 06 MH TeMnaMH no OTHorneHHD K pyrHM c paM 06 ecTEeHHo IH3HH OTKP ­ T upHeM B napTKD rrepHO HqeCKHe OT eTH KOMMyHHCTOB Ha OTKP T co6paHHEX 0 CBoe pa60Te qTO-TO Bpo e nepeaTTeCT HH CHCTeMa o eHKH H B B eH H Ka pOB Haq Hafl C B 6opOB pyKO­ BO HTe e HH30BHX napTH opraHH3a H He HaBfl3HBaTb PYKOBO H­ Te e cBepxy Ha c06CTBeHHOM CTIHTe HaY Tb ea o eHHBaTb H B ­ BHraTb PYKoBo Te e O HO aTa pa30BbeT 3 opOBoe KpHTHqeCKOe Ha­ qano rrO RMHHO napTM HOCTH np HUHrrHanbHOCTH H OTBeTOTBeHHO­ CTR 06eCneqeHHe BHyTpH napTHH peanbHO B03MOMHOCTH BHpaMaTb CBOH B3rEfl H 8 £ £ 2 _ aL-8 £ ££H _ge cTB e CTBH B HCUOXHeHHH ITpHHflTHX pemeHH BBeCTH CHCTeMy rrpe BapHTeRhH9ro KOBO He O OCTH H nocpe CTBeHHO Ha co6paHHRX HX rrpe CTaBHTene 06CyE eWAR B rrepBHqHHX KaH aTOB Ha py­ opraHH3a HflX HEH Ha Bce B 6opHHe O HOCTH B pa ­ KOMax ropKOM8X 06KOMaX CMeHReMOCTh Ka pOB B03paCTHOa E T nR PYKOBO HTeEe o6eCrreQeHHe pa60TO THrra COBeTHHKa OTO OT­ HOCHTCfl He TORhRO K rrapTH HO HO H K COBeTCKO X03H CTBeHHO cwepaM K3HH nO Hafl rn8CHOCTh OXO OB MHorHe B CKa3 BaDTCfl 3a rrapT H roc- M8KCHMYM H MHHHMJM rrpH6n eHHe rrapTH Horo H pyrHX arrna­ paTOB K Macce·rro o6pa3y XH3HH E HHafl CHCTeua pacrrpe eneH fl a He OT eEbF fl nfl K O rpyITITH pa60THMKOB E Hafl CMCTeMa onnaTH Tpy a nHKB aQHfl KaCTOBOCTH rOCY 8pCTBeHHafl H arrrrapaT oeHHHe HHTenneKTyaTlH 6 pOKpaTHfl TeXHOKpaT fl rrapT ­ rrHcaTenH xy­ 8 eHCTBO B napTHH He o o 6HTb Cpe CTBOM KapbepH Ce qac nR MHOrKX 2 £ £ Ka_ 2 _gQ £ __ _Q E _ 2 Q Q aq Mo eT 6HTb Ha KaROM-TO STarre nOHa o6HTCH CTRa napTHH C TeM tITo6s K36aBHTbCH OT KpMrrpOMeTHpy KX ee aneMeHTOB Bo BCR­ KOM cnyqae YJl e ce qac Heo6xo nHMbI nOHCKH q OpM B03 n e CTBKR Ha qJIe­ HOB rrapTKH B CMHcne 3 MaKCKManbHO HX aKTKBH3a H M K _ n Hn Me2 ITY pa3JIHmrnMH qaCTiL i CHCTeMH yn­ paBJI8HHH 3aCTaBHT O h qaCTb rrO TaJIKHBaTb pyryD B qaCTHOCTK H806xo HMO _£Q2 om _ 8Y_ 2 _ _ £ 2 HHTeJIbHO BJIaCTbD BepXOBHHM COBeToM K COBeToM MID1HCTPOB Me7 l1Y ----------------- COOTBeTCTBY KMH HM30BHMH 3BeHbRMH Ce qac nepBaH 3 aBJIeHa BTO­ po 3aRoHO aTeJIbHHe opraHH JIKillb o6c aDT DT HCrrOJIHKTeJIbHHe KMeHHO pema T a npaKTHtIeCKH ema­ a He rrpOCTO BHTIOJIHRDT Mo eT 6HTb rrOCTORHHO ne CTBY H rrapJIaMeHTCKH arrrrapaT He 06RSaTeJIbHO 6ecrrpep Hoe o6 ee 3a e aHKe yxe HeCKOJIbKO K3MeHKT BsaHMOOTHomeHKH BnaCTe 06R3aTeJIbHOCTb pemeHHR 3aKOH0 naTeJIbHHX opraHOB BOTyMH OBepKH HCrrOJIHKTeJIbHO BJIaCTH HYERO pe3Hoe yCHJIeHHe OTBeTCTBeHHOCTK rrepe 3aKOHO aTeJIbHO H3MeHHTb rrpaKTKHy 06c eHK KOTopaH ce tIac HOCHT xapaKTep OTtIeTOB OHM HyXHH HO OJIXHH KMeTb 2£ e xapaKTep ITo HOBHM rrpo6JIeMaM B03HHKa Y rrepe n paHO 06pa3YDTCH napnaMeHTCKKe KO­ MHCCHK H T n 2 KOTOpHH 3aHKMaeTCfi nOBce HeB­ HO MH3HbID CTpaHH a He rrpOCTO rrapa HO paCCMaTpHBaeT Ba-TpH Bon­ poca UJIaH 6D eT Me apO Hoe nOJIO eHHe Onpe eJIHTb erryTaToB BepXOBHoro COBeTa CCCP K pyrKX erryTaToB oco6eHHO - Ha MecTax B qaCTHOCTH MOMeT 6HTb ITpaBO 2 Q £££ BeTCTB HX BMemaTeJIhCTBa C YCT8HOBJIeHHeM OpraHOB BJIBCTH £E2 pea KK COOT­ 9 60pH O HH 6HTb He 36paHHeM a B 6opOM rrpH eM BH6opOM Ryqmero MOL O orpaHH ATb qHCRO BHABHraeMHX KaH »AaTOB HO He Me­ Hee BYX KOHTPO b napTHH 3a B BKXeHHeM HO He CTporaR perynH­ UHR 0 KOTOPO Bce rOBopRT aBHO BCnyx paSBepCTKa CTORbKO-TO e HH CTORbKO-TO 6eCTIapT HHHX CTORbKO-TO H3 c epH H3H eCKoro Tpy a H T n erryTaT o eH 3aB ceTb OT H36HpaTene e CTBHTeRbHO aTb HX MHeHHR CBOl1MH YCT8MH a He CBoe MHeHHe OT HX HM'eHH Mo eM ynpaBRRTb TORbKO Tor n a Kor a npaBv bHo B aMeM B a­ MIl TO qTO Ha­ po n C03HaeT JIeHH o-l rrO OTqeTHOCTb H CMeHReMOCTb n enyTaTOB PeaRbHHY OT3H erry­ TaTOB - C rry6JIHKaUl1 etl 06'bRCHeHH Thfii B CHJIy MeHbme OpMaJIbHOCTH BoRee 110JIrn m neM0K1 8TH3M 60Rbillen RerKOCTH BH60pa 11 OT3HBa JIeHHH TI £ £ KORoccanbHoe B03paCT8HHe peaJIbHO OTBeT TBeH­ HOCTR nepe MaccaWA Hoe - e CTBHTeJIbHOe nO HeHHOCTH no n KOHTpORbHOCTH HM 8 rRaB­ rrpHBJIeqeHHe Macc K ynpaB eHHn eRaMH pa OHa 06R8CTH pecny6RHKH CTpaHH Qepe3 HX TIpHMoe H opran 30BaHHOe KOR­ ReHTHBHoe B03 neMCTBHe Ha nenyT8Ta Oco6eHHO a KTHBHO aTO CK8­ eTCR rrpe e Bcero Ha E _ _Q _ _g£g _ r8HH BJI8CTH 4 £ Q t L£- CH £ rocy n apcTBo CH 1IbH01'OJIbKO Tor­ n 8 Kop II a MaCChI Bce 3HanT 060 BceM MOryT Cy nHTb 11 H r y'r HaBce c03H8TeRbHo JIeHKH rJI8CHOCTb HCqepTIHBa 8R H onepaTHBHaR HH­ opMaUHR - He rrpeMeHHoe yCJIOBH8 naRbHe e neMoKpaT 3anHH o6 ecT­ BeHHO H3HH JIHrnb HH OpMHpOBaHHH qe OBeK cnOC06eH HHM aT BHO H TIJIO II OTBOpHO yqacTBoBaTb B enax 06 ecTBa B3HBaTb K rpaY aHcKo 8KTHBHOCTK n e KOTop e He pacnonara T mHPOKO HH opMaUHe H He 10 HaxO HTCR anbHOM B 6narOrrpKfiTHOW lHMaTe RH TaKO TBOpqeCKOM aKTHBHOCTH COnH­ 6eCCMHCneh 0 B 3TO e CBR3H O HO 3aMe aHHe no £ _£ £ ce2 -£ _ £ _ 2g £ _ £ ITPWQHHH 28 _ _ -£ 2 _ _2 · o CHX nop rnaBHoe HCXO Hoe rrono eHHe H eOnOraqeCKOH eH- TenbHOCTH OCTaeTCR omH6o Pema HM ycnoBHeM opMKpOBaHHH CO­ anHCTHqeCKOrO C03HaHHff MH CqHTaTb rrponaraHAY TO rrpo onxaeM eCTb rrpO KTH Hamero C03HaP H - KHHry neKQHD rrbecy HnbM OK­ Ea saHHTHe rronHTceTb H T B03MO HO 31'0 6HnO qpe3B a HO B ­ HblM B TO BpeMff Kor na napTHR He 6bIJIa npaB et Ho He C03HaHHe rrpo­ nara HCTa opMKpyeT nHcaTenff H T IT C03HaHHe Hapo a ROD a BnaCTb rrpHHa ne T eMY _ E £ £ _ 2 _ _ g £ _g2 £ _ £ L_g £_8 _£ _ £ CH Ha 3TOT C'tIeT t1MeeTCH MHoro KOHKpeTHIDC BbICKashIBaHH B LJIeHHHa rrO qepKHBa ero liTO He KaKH 9-HH6Y IJ b saHRTHff HJIH KHHrK T rr He peqH H MHTHHrH a rrOJIHTMtreCIrne e CTBHH H yqaCTHe B TIOBce n HeBHoM tHsHeHHO 60pb6e £ £ -g - £ _2E J £ £ - BOT qTO fiBnReTCR onp8 n en KM pema HM rnaBHHM ycno- BHeM KOMMyHHCTHqeCKOrO 2£ _ L_ E £ _ _££ £ ec Q£ _£ COBeTcRot l A 31'0 c epa He eOJIOrHH a eMOKpaTHH ­ C01 HaJIilICTHqeCKo'A neM0Kparl-B f 5 - ££ _£ £ _ _ _ £ _8E £ _ £ opMKpyeTcff onaCHoe MH8HK6 QTO rrpaBocy n H y Hac H8T Me y TeM 31'0 O IJ Ha H3 HaH60Eee £ £ _£yg L rrpHHuHnax CY OYCTpO CTBa rrpOCMaTp Bae clX OPM A BJIaCTH peanbHHe rapaHT H8SaEHCrnMOCTH - B rropR Ke OT3HEa H T n II § £ 2 _ ' OT3 B ft-Killb ITpH orrpe eneHMdX YCROB fiX Y Hac Me - H8 nRTb neT qeM 6R e CpOK BH6opOB TeM MeHhlle rrpaH H­ nHanbHOCTH Hecnyqa Ho rrpOHCXO HT 6ecrrpepHBHoe nepeMe eHHe cy en YBenH Tb CpOK XOTH 6H o eCRTH neT cTa6KJ1H3KpOBaTh nono eHHe CY bH Cy e6HaH eHTenhHOCTb onzHa 6HTb ITpO CCHe • Ce ac eft a oT6aBnfl BMemHBaTbCH B OTrrpaBneHHe rrpaBOCY HH XOTb Ha o paCCMaTpHBaTb TaKoe BMemaTeRbCTBO B pa3pemeHH8 KOHKpeTHHX en RaK npecTynneHne KapaeMoe ITO 3aROHY YronoB Ko eRC - TBep OCTh cTa6RnbHOCTb HeOTBpaTHMOCTb H eCTKOCTh HaKa3aHHH nR a THo6 eCTBeHHHX sneMeHTOB oco6eHHO nH BOpOB 6ecno a HOCTb - ft H y6H BMecTe C TeM - peanbHHe rapaHTHH oc eCTBneHHR npaB H OCTH nO eH 6HTb saROH 0 rrpaB8X qeROBeKa H KX rapaHTHRX saKOH 0 He­ npHKoCHOBeHHOCTH Teft e OHHHX RH OCTH eCTBa H Hft a 0 TanHe nepenHCKH pasrOBopOB nH O MHSHH OpraHH3a HOHHHe op oc eCTBReHKH rrpaBa Ha eMOHCTpa HH CBo6o CROBa COBeCTH rre aTH c06paHH ITpaBa Ha cB06o Hoe rre­ peMe eHHe MH XOTKM QT06H Y K oro 6 H BeRHKHe rp aHcKRe 06R3aHHo­ CTR HO 8TO BOSMO O nHmb B TOM cnyqae eCRM 6Y T BeRRKHe rp ­ aHCKHe rrpaBa 6 2 _ _ _ _ ITO RID60My BOrrpO­ cy BITnOTh o 06 aft 0 aHHR e cTEH rocy apcTBeHHHX aHHH o eH KMeTh ITpaBo rrpe RBHTb HCR on ocTHoMy HK3au HyxHo HMeTb a M H cTpaT BHHeccY H TOB B aM HHc paT BHHX enax 3aKoH K ITO aKoHHHet HopMaT BHHe rrepaTHBHHH xapaKTep opraHoB · PPax­ RKQY H opra­ - RR pemeHHR KOH K­ aKTH 3aKoH A y Hac 3aROHH - ITnaHH o eH 6 eTH HMeTb HM­ KOTOpYe 12 aneKO He BO BceM HcnO TCR Mo eT 6HTb aTO He O O 6HTb 3a­ KOROM llpOHYPaTypa rrpH3BaHHaR B rrpwrl ne c e Tb sa HcnO HeHneM saRoHa e3 e cTByeT no c ecTBY e MHHnCTpW He rOEopR yxe 0 COBeTe MHHHCTpOB HapymaDT 60flbillnHCTBO SaROHOB CBOHWA rrpeATIHC8HH­ ffMH H YK8SaHHKMH qe oBeK O eH HMeTb YBepeHHOCTb B nOEnbHOM K OrrepaTHBHOM paCCMOTpeHHK ero a o6 KOMneTeHTHHMH D bMH H opraHR3a R­ Ce ac sa £ _ HHKor a HKRoro He HaKaSHBa T A BOT sa Q _E Eem HaKas a T l103TOMY npHEH acb CHCTeMa CHa ana oTKas8Tb rrOTOM 06 aflOBaTb nOToM Mo eT 6HTb - rrOflO K­ TenbHO pemHTb Bo oRMTa BpeMH HepBH D e YXO RT EITyCTyD B03­ HMKaeT aTMoc pa He oBO bcTBa Hcc e OBaHHH KOnH eCTBa ECflH 6H npOBecTH cOUHo orH cKHe OTK8S0B a TIOTOM rro y eHHHX pa3pemeh OTBeTCTB8HHOCTb ox a 6HTb rrpaBH bHO pacnpe e eHa H 8 £ _ g _82 _ £ Q 2£ _ _l _ _£ £ 2£ Kopo e H OCTb o HsaHa Y aMaTb rocy apcTBo HO rocy ap­ CTBO He MeHbme 06H3aHO YB aTb HqHOCTb HHa e Me HHMH Bcer a 6y eT 6apbep a TO H paspHB H o ROHCTHT OHHO 3a HRcHpoBaTb 2 2£ _£2£ E£ _ 2_£ 2 _ _£E ' CooTHomeHHe BnaCTH BHyTP cy e6Ho CHCTeMH CY H Bcex paRr-OB 3aHHMaDTCH TonbRO npaBOCY HeM a OCTa b e HK H - B MHHHCTepCT­ Be DCTH H TaR 6 o ITpH eHMHe BepXOBHH Cy KnH rOCY 8pcTBeH­ H COBeT KOTOP pema 6m BOrrpOC 0 KOHCTHTYUHOHHOCTH Tex H H HHRX aKToB 0 COOTBeTCTBHH HX rrpHpo e COQHa H3Ma CHMOCTb BepXOBHoro Cy a OT BCHKoro aB eHMR 7 MH BpeMR • rrO HaH HesaBH­ • He Mo eM B TO HOCTH e rrpe CTaBHTb ce6e B HacToR ee Ka e C H TaRTCR H MorYT pa3BepHYTbcH rrpH cOQHanHCTH­ qeCKOM YCTpo cTBe o6 ecTBa Harne eno COCTQHT TO bKO B TOM 13 qTo6 paCqHCTHTb opory BCeM 3THM CH aM e H BaMHSnmaR PO b B paCqHCTRe OpOrH nOTeH RM COQHa 3Ma npHH e T aKOHOMHqeCKO nO HTHKe He OO eHKa ee B03MO HOCTe H 3HaqHMOCTH npo nHT 3aCTO Ha 3TOM nyTH - t _ M0 Q _ TB 9 _ §' 3HaqHTe bHOe HMO Ho yCKopeHHe 8KOHOMHQeCKOrO pa3BHTHR 3HeHHO Heo6xo­ c e aTb cpe CTBaMH 3TO TO bKO HaY O-TeXHH eCKKMH H 3ROHOMHQeCKKMH HeB03MO 0 Hy MHO BKn Tb c a H paCKpHTb nO HOCTb aKTOp MOp bHo-ncHXo orH ecKHe YOKpaT HHM A B 3KOHOMHKe COQeTaeVaR C ynpaB eHHeM H aToro Ha mHpOKaR e­ eHTpa H30BaHH M rocy apcTBeH­ eD BcRKaR eMoKpaTHH RaR Boo6 e BCHR8 ff TIOJI tTlfqeCKaR Ha CTpo a­ Ra HeH36e HaR nORa He 3aaepmeHO YH qTO eHHe KnaCCOB nORa He C03 aHO 6eCKnaCCOBOe 06 eCTBO C HT B KOHe OM CqeTe BO CTBY H orrpe eJIneTCR B ROHeqHOM CqeTe HOmeHHRMH aHHoro 06 eCTBa He ITpOH3Bo CTBeHHHMM OT­ JIeHHH B3aHMHoe E03 e CTBlie eMORpa liH T HHRaKo eMOKpaTH3M rrpOH3­ aeT if SKOHOMHRH OT e bHO B3R­ co a H3Ma HO B XK3HM eMOKpa­ TH3M He 6y eT B3RT OT e bHO a 6YlJ eT B3HT EMeCTe OKa3HBaTb CEoe BnHRHHe H Ha 3KOHOMHRY nO Ta KHBaTb ee npeo6pa30BaHH8 no ­ BepraTbCR B HRHM 3ROHOMHQeCKOrO pa3BHTHR H T TaRoBa Ha eK­ THRa JKHBOt HCTOpHH JIemm £ £ _ £ _ _ 9 L_ygE L_E §' C03 aHHe e HHCTBeHHO n03HTHBHO H caMopa3BHBa e CR OCHOB - no ­ HHHoro opraHH eCKoro rroc elJ OBaTe bHoro e HHCTBa HHTepeCOB qe­ OBeRa Ro neKTHBa H 06 eCTBa Bce nOTeH H eMOKpaTH3aqHH B XO­ 3R CTBe 3a OJKeHH B rrpHpo e co a H3Ma MOJKeT 6blTb nO YMaTb 06 op 'aHH3a RX THTIa pa60llliX COB8TOB BH HMO P-' 3Ta H eR ITpH rrpaBH bHOM 88 TO RoBaHHH He TclK'I cTpamHa 14 rrpO 3BO CTBeHHag eMOKpaTHR He B TPO CTCKOM rrOHHMaHH npOTHB nOITHTOK rrpOTHBOTIOCTaBHTb Ha BHcTyna Killb eMOKpaTMn e HHOHa an meH ID eHHH rrpOH3BO CTBe ITpaEa KonneKTHBa B TOM c e no OTHO­ K PYKOBO HTer RM rrpe npHRTH aTO aneKO He aHapXO-CH ­ Ka H3M TIPH aTOM He TO hKO HpeKTOp HO H Ko eRTHB 6y eT HeCTH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTh sa rrpe rrpHHTHe sa ero pa6oTy Xos CTBeHHHe CBRSH H £ ££ MaTep a bHaR - npRMBR eCTKaR ITpaBo HB XOSR CTBeHWJD HH aTHBY He TonbRO y KO ­ neKT BOB HO H Y nH OCTH OnHT co aRbHO-3KOHOMH eC aKcrrepH­ MeHT HarrpHMep - B c epe 06C HBaHMR KOH epHH H Tp8CTH Ha rrORHOM XOSR CTBeHHOM pBc eTe B03Mo o nO BTb a TOM To6H BCg CHCTeMB 06C Ba R H ToprOBnH 6@na rrOCTpoeH8 Ha KoonepaT BHHX Haqanax rOCY BpCTBO RcHpyeT eHy H rrpe oCTaBnfleT B Kpe HT nOMe eHHR 060pY OBaHHe nO eH 6HTb BH60p Me ByMR-TpeM MaraSHHaMH H eH Ko eKC X03R CTBeHHoro upaBa rrpa eqHHMH H T HO nHIDh rrpH caMOCTORTenb­ HOCTH ROHTpareHTOB H eH COBpeMe K30T - Y Hac orrOTorr 06ys aTb MHHHCTepCTBO HHaHCOB ROTopoe B ITOrOHe sa cero ­ HRillHe Korre KOn nHmaeT 06 eCTBO COTeH H THCR py6nen SBBTpa K­ BH HpOBaTb HHaHCOB npO SBon BBeCTH KCHpOBaHH@e HOpMH nnaTe­ e H OT cneHHn OT rrp 6 H rrpe rrpHRTHn TpaHc opMa R MOHOnOnHH BHemHen ToprOB - pemMTenbHaR HH­ Terpa R C co a CTH eCKHMH CTpaHaMH KaK rrep STan rrpO COID3H HrpaIDT HHHe BO MHOrOM opManbWjD ponb PeSKO rro ­ HHTb X 3HaqeHHe MM HO rrpH aTb 60nee cepbe3HHe K H qeM c60p B3HOCOB H pacrrpe eneHHe ITyTeBOK orpy6nRR KOHe o 3TO xa­ paKTepHCTHKO nono eHHe en nOnHTH eCKH MH 3 eCb B rpaeM 15 KaK 6hI MbI Hce··COBepmeHCTBOBaJIH Te IDIH n pyrHe cepephI HarrpaB­ JIeHHH qaCTH MexaHHSMa A TO BBHZR He 6y n eT lO W- 06 e CJIaxeHHocTH nHIDb OT COBepmeHCTBO- CaMOerJIaBHOe - He 6y eT caMo n B eHHn o cBoe06pa3HO CaMOJIHKBa n a H He n OCTaTKOB B03bMeT Bepx 3 n paB CMNCJI rrpOH30 n eT yCTpaHeHHe HJIH c eHMe D HKTaTJPhI 6IDpOKpaTHH ECJIH rOBopaTb Bcepbe3 0 TBOpqeCTBe caMoro Hapo n a CYBepeHHoCTH BHP aeMO ero BJIaCTH opraHH3a H aa ero EhIcme n e CTBH He3hI6JI8UOCTH cTyneHH rrOJIHTHqeCKHX B aTHX eJIRX 06 eCTBeHHHe napTRD rocy n apCTBO TO Ha n o HeITpeM8HHO npHH ne qT06hI Ha epe3 H O oprah 30BaTb rrapT Horo BOBne BC n eJIO TaK pyKOBo n CTBa oco6eHHO Maccy B rrpo ecc nOJIHT qeCKHX pemeHH TIpHHRTb cne rrp QHTIHaJIbHy cxeMY PYROBO - CTBa I BepxoBHaR TIapTH HaH H rocy n apcTBeHHaR BJIaCTb OC €CTBJIR­ eTCR QE _QQg DH e flBJIffeTCfl ITpe n ce n aTeJIeM KOMMyHHCTHQeCKOrO COID38 COID3a KO fHHCTOB CCCP rrpe n ceAaTeJIeM 06oe HHeHHoro ITOJIHT6 po TIapTH BXO n HX B KOMMyHHCTHQeCWA COID3 ITpe n ce n aTeJIeM eOBeTa ITpe3M n eH­ T08 Pecny6JmK 2 ITpesH n eHT H36HpaeTcfl Ha 10 neT Ha OCHOEe ITpRMoro BceHa­ pO IJ HOrO rOJIOCOBaHHR H3 KaH IJ H n aTOB B BHHyTHX napTHRMH BXO IJ H­ MY B Q _ 3 COID3 KOMMyHHCTOB COCTOHT H3 D BYX napTH CO aJIHCTHqeCKO H Hapo n HO- D eMOKpaTHqeCKo Bceo6 He BhI60PH - K hIe 5 JIeT - cBep­ xy n OHH3Y· COID3 KOMMyHHCTOB KMeeT o6 rrpHW ITHaJIb 60JIee TIo n p06HhIe YCTaBH YCTaB TIapTHH ­ 16 4 rrpe3H eHT KMeeT rrpe ce aTe b K Hc nn Hap cor aCHTe bH opraH no napTHH no BYX BH e-rrpe3H eHToB rocy apcTBY ITPe ce aTenb KOHTpOJIR' cooTBaTcTB He rrpe3HAeHT KMeeT H rocy apcTBY B TOM CJIe KOMHTeTa H Hapo Horo pa60qHe annapaTs no napTHH rpyrrrry COBeTHHKOB no HaQHOHaJIbHO 6esonaCHOCTH 5 ilpaBHTeJIbcTBo THH Ha no6e HBme B03rJIaB neTCH BceHapo HHX feHepaJIbHHM ceKpeTapeM nap­ B 6opax 6 Borrpoc 0 pa60Te H ¢yHKqHRX BepxoBHoro eOBeTa nOAJ eXHT onO HHTeJIbHoMy rrpo aHHD BapHaHToB HO aTO yxe BOrrpOC CJIe CTBHH Bce aTO BMeCTe B3fiToe pemHT paBHO ITpH eTcR pemaTb HO JIy e 3 ecb Mo eT oco6 6HTb MHoro a He ITpHHQHna MHor e KOTop e rrpo6neMH C ynpe eHHeM 3TO 6y eT Bce peBOJID­ OHHO nepeCTpO KO £ 2E £ 2£2 E E llpecc Tpe60BaHH aKTHBHOCTb JIH OCTH CMeHa BpeMeHH OCJIa6JIeH TaKMe BonpOCH aK JIro e 6Y T ep eK 60pb6a C HHep HeM rrO THqeCKaH peaJIbHaH H T KYnbTypa cTa6 'bHOCTb pemaTbcR 6e3 OC06HX H3­ 06 eCTBa 6y eT pacTH a 3Ha T H