It -----BCT P E q A TOB HKOBJIeBa A H C nOCJIaMl1 COII118JIl1CTl1t1eCKl1X CTpaH aKKpe lJ l1TOBaHHbIMl1 B CCCP eBpaJIH TOB HKOBJIeB A H TOBapl1 l1' 1989 p08a HatlHeM CerO lJ HHillHroropa60TY rrpe e Bcero eCJIl1 y Bac He 6Y lJ eT BOSp eHl1M lJ oCTl1rHeM lJ OrOBO­ peHHOCTl1 TaKOM tlT06H HaIDl1 BCTpetll1 HOCl1JIM perYJIHpHbJM xapaKTep 11 no KpaMHeM Mepe COCTOHJIMCb 6H pas B MecHq H He rOBopro KOHetlHO 06 l1H lJ BM rr yaJIbHbJX BCTpetlaX B saBMCMMOCTM OT 06cTaHoBHM B SaBMCl1­ MOCTM OT nOTpe6HocTM 3TO - nepBoe BTopoe - KaK MH cerO lJ HH nocTpoMM Hamy 6ece rr y Ee eJIb KaK MHe npe lJ cTaBJIHeTCH npOl1HQopMMpoBaTb Bac 06 MTorax nporne lJ ­ rnero rO lJ a nOTOM 0 TOM tleM MH saHMMaeMCH B HaCTo ee BpeMH 11 KaK MH CMOTpMM Ha Harnl1 nepcneKTMBH BosMo eH rr pyroM BapMaHT ECJIM y Bac eCTb BonpOCH H rOTOB Ha HHX CeMtlaC OTBetlaTb eCJIM cMory eCTeCTBeHHO a nOTOM MOJKeT 6blTb OTB8TMTb Ha Te BOnpOCbJ KOTopble OCTaJIMCb He OCBe eHHbJMl1 He saTpOHYTbIMM B MoeM BbJCTynJIeHMM TO MO HO 6blJIO 6bI OCTaHOBMTbCH Ha HeKoTopb Bonpocax HarneM MSHM KaKoM BapMaHT Ms6epeM fOTOBbI JIM BbJ CeMtlaC BonpOCH s aBaTb MJIM nOTOM llepBblM BapMaHT llepBHM - TaK nepBHM KaK BH sHaeTe TOBapM M MCTeKrnMM ro lJ xapaKTepMsyeTcH rro­ pasHoMy M lJ eMCTBMTeJIbHO OH lJ aeT OCHOBaHMe nO lJ XG lJ MTb K ero MTO­ raM C pasHbDC CTOpOH tleHO c epe npeBp aeTCH B nOJIl1Tl1t1eCKoH C O lJ HOM MSHb A eCJIM CTOpOHH OtleHb MHoro C lJ eJIaHO HaMe­ B 3 KOHOMMtleCKOM rr yXOBHOM CO l1aJIbHOM C rr pyroM CTOpOHH TO MH BHXO lJ l1M Heno­ 2 cpe CTBeHHO Ha pMTb 0 MaTepMe bHOM BeHHOM He OCTaTO HOCTM nonOK B Mara3MHax B p eHH M HO enOBeKa CTopOHe M nepexo H M BO nepexoAMno Ha M AO Hero He e e ena 0 HarnMX B 3HaeTe 0 HallieM Henon Kax X03pac eT ¢aKTM eCKM npM eM ceM ac pa3BepTbIBaeTCH OXOAMT O nyHKTa KorAa C TPYAOM HO Bce-TaKM HapO Horo Ha MHaeT X03HMCTBa Ha COQM bHHe ro KaK RpKO Harne HapoAHoe X03RMCT­ B QenOM C I RHBapR KaK 3HaeTe KorAa npMHHTo pemeHMe 0 rny60KoM OHa npO OBonbCT­ 0 COCTOffHMM HalliMX Bce-TaKM paccMaTpMBaeM 1988 ro A KorAa ecnM rOBO­ ornnM nonMTM eCKOM B pe¢opMe M CBoero KynbMMHaQMOHHoro npOMCXO MT nOBopOT HallierO penbChI Harne HapoAHoe X03HMCTBO Bce 60nbrne M60nbrue npM06peTaTb coqManbHYID HanpaBneH­ HOCTb 8TO cnO HO HO sTO He06xo MMO 8TO C OmHO H Heo6xo HMO MO HO H eT KorAa peqb HOCH aH CKa3anaCb Ha cY b6ax nD eH THCRq KocHy acb He npOCTO H n eHYMOB B cOOTBeTcTBHH C pemeHHflMH 6HRO nepexo HTb K pa3 e eHHro 3aKOHo aTe bHoro Horo annapaTa e aTb Bce OT en nO HTHKH CTOHTBonpoc 40% E e T c qenOBeK 6e3 e CTBOBan 8 B HTe 06pa30M YH HH GTo6 COKpa eH KOMnapTH 6Hnc OCTanOCb 9 OT ena OTHome­ arpap­ npHMepHO Ha npoH3Be eH eno eno coroSHHX pecny6­ M annapaT cOKp eH OqeHb Cepbe3Hge Ha COKpa e­ He TonbKO B STOM XOTR H STOMy B TOM GTO STOT annapaT To e He YH MM HY HO nepe aTb annapaTY qeTKaR CTpyKTypHaH napTHH 3aHHManaCb CBOHM aBaHrap a CTa pa60Ta 1064 OT ena B ropKcMax H T C OT eHOB saKOHo aTenbHOMY nOnHTHqeCKoro H O OT enOB X03HHcTBa KpoMe a pa6CTan 3HaqMT ero BO-BTOP npOBe eHa qTO-TO H eT npo ecc COKpa eHHH ynpa3 HeHo McnonHHTenbHOMY BMecTO 20 nonHTHKH AnnapaT 6onbIDoe 3HaqeHHe T HcnonHHTe b­ BpeMeHHO OCTaBneH nOCKonbKY OqeHb OCTpO COKpa eH KaK annapaTa - KOTop e HMe H Henocpe CTBeHHoe HHH napTHHHoro annapaTa Ho npH aeM UK Kpa KoMoB nHKBH HPOBaHO napTHM enanOCb qTO STO UK napTHHHoH KOHWepeHQHH H 3aBepmeHa K 1 MapTa B UK nHK 06KOMOB OT en arpapHo He BeCb o Ha 6 Tb pa KoMax STOT CM c e annapaTa H Hapo Horo HHe K BOnpOCaM oTpacneH H rtp He OBO bCTBa Bcero OHa HocHna xapaKTep ¢YH H H BaM CK Y qTO ce qac B HKBH HPOBaH HOM B TOM anna­ xapaKTep XOTR oHa MHoro npe e cy eCTBY nepeCTpOHKH napTHH no H O opManbH B 3Bana HO eH BCero nepecTpo Ka naPTH HorO rOA runa eCTKaR paTa npHqeM T K npem e 0 nOnHTHqeCKOH pe¢opMe TO OHa npom HaGanaCb ncmanyH CKa3aTb H 0 TOM GTO enOM nepeCTpO Ka TaK T e H pa60Tana BO Bcex oc eCTB Rna opraHH3a HRX 4 qepes KOMMyHMCTOB qepeS aMM K PH nOnMTMqeCKMMM cpegcTBaMH MeTO­ 06HOBneHMR SaHMManaCb 6 B pa6oTKOM nOnHTMKM 3KOHOMMKM nonMTMKM B CO ManbHOM cwepe B YXOBHO cwepe a Henocpe cTBeHHO McnonHeHMeM Tex MnM 3aKOHOTBOpqeCKHX pyrMx HapO HOX03R cTBeHH 3 aq CO ManbHHX 5 8TO CKa3aflOCb M Ha OTKpOBeHHOM 06cy eHMM Ha TIonMT6DpO Ha CeKpeTapMaTe UK KnCC pasnM Hb BOnpOCOB Pe3KO COKp eHO 06CY AeHMe B TIonMT6IDpO BOnpOCOB HenOCpe CTBeHHO KaCaID MXCR paSnM HbIX OTpacnei1 HapO HOrO X03RMCTBa npMMepHO Ha TMnOCb npMHRTMe COBMeCTHHX pemeHMH ceH ac UK 30% COKpa­ M COBeTa MMHMCTpOB OHM npMHMMaroTCJi KaK npaBI'WO TonbKO no TeM BOnpOCaM KOTopHe BHXO RT Henocpe CTBeHHO Ha nonMTMKY EcnM rOBopMTb 0 nepecTpoMKe B napTMM TO Henocpe CTBeHHoe BnMJiHMe Ha xapaKTep STOM i1epeCTpOMKM OKasbIBaflM BbI60PbI - T e OT eTHO-BbI60pHaJi KaMnaHMJi MbI OU eHMBaeM ee MTorM KaK xoporrme OHa npornna aKTMBHO T e ee nonMTM eCKaR s a a nOBbICMTb aKTMB­ HOCTb 3aMHTepeCOBaHHOCTb KOMMYHMCTOB npaKTM eCKM BbInonHeHa Ha STOM STane Ho STO He 3Ha MT TO Y Hac HeT np06neM TO MbI sa­ BeprnMnM STY s a - STO HeBepHO Ho ecnM rOBopMTb 06 ycnOBMJiX CerO HRillHerO HR TO Ha CerO HRillHMH eHb OHa BbInonHeHa eno Bce B TOM TO sapaHee STM C06paHMJi KaK paHbrne He rOTOBMnMCb B OTnM Me OT npornnb neT He rOTOBMnMCb M BbIcTynneHMR TeM He MeHee aKTMBHOCTb 6bIna Bbme OCTpaR KpMTMKa To e 3Ha MTenbHO Bbme a rnaBHoe TO Ha MHorMX MHorMX C06paHMJiX KOH epeHU MJiX npeBaflM­ pOBanM KOHCTpyKTMBHbIe HaCTpOeHMJi o eHb MHoro 6bIno BHeceHO npe ­ nO KeHMM npM eM o eHb MHTepeCHbIX npe n nO ll eHflH Sa11HTepeCOBaHHbIX npe no eHMM l B TO e BpeMR STM c06paHMR 11 KOH epeHqMM e e M TO HaCKO bKO HenpOCTO M e cnO HO MAeT BCKPbIBaflM nepeCTpoe HbIM npou ecc B CTpaHe T e BCKpbIBanM M TO conpOTMBneHMe KOTopoe MMeeT MeCTO M TOT SHTY3Ma3M KOTOpbIH pa36y eH nepeCTpOHKOH T e Te CTOpOHbI KaK sTOM HOBOH M3HM KOTopbIe MbI B 06 eM M CTa­ paeMCR OCTM b HOBoro Ka eCTBeHHoro COCTOJiHMJi 06 eCTBa MbI ona­ C MCb KaK 6bI pa60THMKM sacny eHHble xopomo cnY MBmMe cBoeMy 6 eny TIO TIPMH MTIY sa6annOTMpOBanM OTIpaB aHHHMM TO OHM aBHO B 06 eM-TO B HeKOToph TMBHbIe Ka M aTyp cny aT pa60TaIDT KaK 6 MX He He BO BceM OKasanMcb HarnM onaceHMH 06KOMax KpaHKOMax BOSHMKHM anbTepHa­ B BYX 06KOMax ecnM rOBopMTb 0 nepBh ceKpe­ TapHX TI06e MnM KaK pas anbTepHaTllBHhIe KaH M aTYP HO 3TO Ha ypoBHe 06KOMOB M KpaMKOMOB qTO e KacaeTcfl paHKOMOB napTMM rop­ KOMOB He rOBopH y e 0 TIepBMqHh napTMHHb opraHM3a MflX cMeHa npOMsomna OqeHb KpyTafl TaM 7 GTO-TO ORO O HHSOBOM ypoBHe 6 H anbTepHaTHBHwe RaH H aTypH H aTypa 06 eM-To BOT HamH napTH Horo cTpoHTe bcTBa sa n H cny aHHHe ID H c e anH o eHb 6paHHID H aJIbme nID H 6Y YT HH ero TO Ha RBneHHe CepbesHoe aTO c eT ROHCTHTY HOHHo-npaBOBHX HH YTb 6y eM 6y eT rrO HT6ropo TenbCTBa HH e OlliH6RH eM npecne OBaTb OT enbHHe B npomnOM rpynnoBwe cny aH MH nyranH eMarorHR HHTepec H T 6HnH HO STO HesHa­ cepbesHoe ro y R H3­ TeH eH H Hac pasBHBaTbCH sHa eHHe npH aBanH pasBHTHID ROHCTHTY HOHHo-rocy apcTBeHHHX npH aTb 60 bmee 3Ha eHHe Hac eHHro Ha TO nonHTH eCROMY He TOBapH H HOCTH - npaB a ROMMyHHCTH HHr e pasBHBaTb STy fnaBHaH CO HaJIbHHX OT e e o eHb T aTe bHO nO XO H 6ase pe opM e e KOMMyHHCTH pe opM ro eM sa a a B CRasaTb cBepxy peRoMeH OBaJIHCb T06H npH aBaTb 3Ha eHHe npHHec o aTO TOBapH H no cBoeMy no KOMneTeHTHOCTH SToro He npOHsomno HTe bHoe BHBO Y ee saKpennRTb HeKOTopHe CBO HTb TO B ropKoMH RpaMKOMH 3TO OTBeTCTBeHHO oc06eHHO C MeCT YCTaHOB eHHID BHABHHYT Tpe6oBaTenbHO MH 6y eM R nO HTHRH BO HOB HCb OCTOMHHX nID eM ypOBH o eHb Be o H K POBOM npe n naraJIHCb 06KOMaMH UK TaR KOMMYHHCTH anbTepHaTHBHHe RaH­ cooTBeTcTBY He M npHrnnH R a Hs6panH HpaBCTBeHHoMy TOBapH H 6 nH napTHH HacTpoeHHe H36paHH Ha CaMOM no no om H OTBeTCTBeHHO He Hapo oM ROTopHe n06e H B o eH saBepHTb eMoRpaTH ecRHx nopR ROB nO bsy H e ceKpeTape Ha pa RoMax cMeHeHH Bo MHorHX Bce aTO B HecoMHeHHyID 60% rrO OBHHH e 60 ee ORO O Bcex 3THX peWOPM - H B cYMMe H no nO HT eCRHX rrpaB MH paCCMOTpenH OCHOBH OCHOB cy e6HoH PeWoPM 060r eHHro e OBe eCRHX Yro oBHoro paCCMOTpe H OT enb­ npaB rrpaB saROHo a­ npoeRTH saROHOB 8 o neqaTM paSpa6aT BaeTCH npoeRT saROHa 0 cBo6o e aRTHBHO saROH 0 n aHe 6y eT y e eCTb COBeCTM H YMaD nocne 06paSOBaHMH BepXOBHoro COBeTa 3Ta saRoHoAaTenbHaR qeCROM MORo e M saBepmeHa eRTenbHocTb B npaRTM­ 9 H MaID qTO nocne C OpMMpOBaH R BepXOBHoro COBeTa y e 3Ta saKOHoAaTenbHaR AeRTenbHOCTb B rrpaKTMqeCKOM nnaHe 6YAeT saBeprneHa BOT 3TMM saKOHaMM CeMqaC rnaBHaR saAaqa M BH 3TO xoporno nOHMMaeTe RBnReTCR npOBeAeHMe BH60pOB B BepXOBHHM COBeT COIDSHh CCCP a oceHbID BH60pOB Ha MecTax B BepXOBHHe COBeThI pec­ rry6nMK 06KOMax paMOKMaX paMcoBeTax ropCOBeTax M A qTO MMeeM CeHqaC KaKaR B cMTya MR 06mecTBeHHh opraHMsa MRX nepe A CeMqaC perMCTpa MeH cy ecTByeT Ha 750 MeCT Ka aTypa 871 Ha 1500 MeCT B TeppMTOpM8 JIbHHX M Ha MOH8 JIbHO-TeppMTOpM8 JIbHh oKpyrax 7 THC 300 K aTYp Ka aTOB KOnMqeCTBO OT oKpyra Kone6neTCR aT I Ha oKpyr MO I2 T e pas6poc OqeHb 6onbrnoH B u enOM Ke Ha Ka aTYP AMTb K hIM BHAB raeTCR oKp HHe o6cy aTb oKpyr no 5 qenOBeK B MocKBe 60nbrnee qMCnO Bce Ha oKpyr OT 6 AO 12 CeMqaC Ms6MpaTenbHHe co6paHMfl KOTopHe y e npoxo­ pas 6YAYT sacnyrnMBaTb rrpM He06xoAMMOCTM Ha c06­ Ka MAaTypH paHMRX oT06paHHHx e e 6Y T R ronOCOBaH R nIDMeM TYT Mon HH 6HTb co6nroAeHH rronHOCTbID HarnM saKOHhI Ms6MpaTenbHHe KOMMCCMM AOn KHH rrOCMOTpeTb He rrpOMsornno nM HapymeHMM rrpaB KaK M rrpo eAYpH Bh B eHMR BCKpHBaroTcR cnyqaM o opMneH nIDAeM Ha co6paHMM HeT a npOTOKon M8 JIbHOM rrOAxoAe BHRBnRIDTCfl xs6MpaTenbHafl KOMMCCMR crroc06Hh MnM 8 JIbCM¢MKa MM TaK 6HBaeT rrpM TaK KorAa op­ TaKMe cnyqaM - ABa cnyqaR KorAa BHHy eHa 6Hna OTMeHMTb npMHRTHe AOKyMeH­ TH M KaK rOBopMTCfl aH8 JIMSMpOBaTb HMM KaK Bh BMraeMh MMeID MX aKTH npOBeAeHMfl TaKMX c06pa­ rrpaBO BHABMraTb Ka MAaTOB 3TO Ha KaH J MAaTax He CKashIBaeTCR rroToMy qTO B AaHHOM cnyqae 3TM KaH­ MMAaTH OKa38 JIMCb Bh BMHyTh M rax B rOBopro 06 3TMX B 3TOM OTHorneHMM y Hac aKTax e e Ha saKOHHOM OCHOBaHMM B yrMx OKpy­ ITOTOMy qTO OHM MMeroT MeCTO OrrHT Man roAM He rrpMBHKnM 0AHM C 3HTySM­ ro a3MOM BOCnpMHMMaroT HOByro npaKTMKY yrMe - paBHogyillHO TpeTbM rOBOpRT - no6anyeMcR HOBh M BepHeMCR HaS PaSHHe HaCTpOeHMR Ho 3TO HOpManbHO 4TO e e TyT B CO ManbHO-o6 eCTBeHHOM nnaHe 06HapY MnOCb II SM OPHR Bce TyT eCTb eM orHH naHHKa H conpOTHsneHHe KOHcepsaTHBHOM Hac nOAAepmHSaIDT H sanyrHBa T H HOHanH3Ma KOTop e Mema T ocooeHHO eHHH rpyn osoM ECTb H srOHSM H Bce eCTb ECTb Bcn KH S ero SKCTpeMHCTCKOM rpynnoB HHa HB B pa­ oo eCTBeHH X opraHHsaqwRX cpeAH HHTenRHreHqHM H cpeAK paOoqero Knacca npH HenpaBKHbHOM SKOHOMHqeCKOM nORKTHK6 npH HeHopManbHOM B KonneKTHBe KorAa BHHMaHHe qepea sapnnaTy qepes npH6 H PYKOBO HTenflM K COBeTCKO RBneHHe BnonHe BosMo oe Ha 3 O pac eHKsaeTCR pacnpe eneHHH OTHomeHHe K snaCTM H T A H T A OTO - RBneHHe npH TaKHX nOBopoTax MHorHX neT SKOHOMHqeCKOH KOH eHTpHpyeTcR aTMoc epe HeHs6e Hoe Bce-TaRH npH OTCyTCTSHK B TeqeHHe eMOKpaTMH Ho 3TO H O SKOHOMMQeCKO nORHTHKH 3TO BHAeTb EcnM He yBHAeIDb 3TO - nnoxo a KorAa YAaeTCR npasHnbHO OQeHHTb peanHCTHqeCKH 60nbmOM oeA sAeCb H8T TeM oonee 3TO He MaCCOBH XapaKTep HO CMOTpeTb HaAO He Mory He CKasaTb qTO Hac oecnOKOflT Me HaQXO­ HanbHHe OTHomeHHR TOT nponaraHAHCTCKo-nOnHTHqeCKKH Kypc KOTOpYM r ecTBosan nOflBHnaCb npo6ReM csoe sAecb cepbe3Ho OIDxoanKcb WKaK TonbKO y RIDAeM B03MO OCTb OTKP TO rosopKTb K AeHCTBosaTb TO BMnR@nX Hasepx 3TO xopomo no cBoeMy cOAep aHHro CYmHOCTH ilnoxo APyroe KorAa Te MnM HH@e peTaIDT HauHoHanHCTHqeCKM 6RaropoAH e HaMepeHHfl xapaKTep KorAa npeTeHsH cK eM - pasBKBaTb HauHD KynbTypy QHH - BAPyr nepepaCTaIDT B HacTpoeHHfl HnH xapaKTep Ae cTBMfl KaKo -To CTap e no npM06­ 3aKoHH e flS K TP K­ HCKRroqHTenbHOCTM K APyrHM HaQHflM B noKeR BHHOBaTNX Ha CTopOHe TO Bce 3TO HaqHHaeT nepepaCTaTb B HaQHOHanMsM M3 HauHO­ HanbHoro BOT ySy AeTb sTy rpaHb nepepaCTaHMR - OORsaHHOCTb nap­ THH H 06 eCTBO He Aon HO MHMO npOXOAHTb a rnaSHoe - npeACTOHT I2 60RbmaH pa60Ta qT06 OKa3 Th ED RM qTO K HM nOBOpOT B HaqMOHaRMCTMqeCKOe PYCRO - 3TO aHHOM H MM npe e YHM aeT aHHYID Ha MID BCerO OnaCHOCTb R 13 14 YHIDKaTb rr aHHYIO HaU I1IO JII06hIM npOTI1BOrrOCTaBJIemleM IJJlyroM HaU MM YHIDKaeT qeJIOBeKa rr aHHoM HaU I1M Y Hac 6Y rr eT ilJIeHYM 11 3 8TO SHaeTe rro HaU MOHaJIbHOMY Bonpocy HaM rrpe rr cTOI1T OqeHb MHoro TyT pernMTb rrp06JIeM KOTop e KaK-TO s ep aJIMCb B CBoeM pemeHI1M Peqb M rr eT a cTaTyce pecrry6JU1K - COIQSHbIX aBTOHOMHbIX HaU MOHaJIb­ Hb oKpyroB 06 06eCneqeHMM HaU MOHaJIbHbIX npaB JIID60M HaU MOHaJIb­ HOM rpyrrrr B Tex OPMax KOTop e crro6cTByIOT paSBMTMIO rr aHHoM HaU MM H o pernaTb Bonpoc COOTHorneHMH U eHTpaJIbHOM BJIaCTM M BJIa­ CTM Ha MecTax H o npaBMJIbHO pemMTb rrp06JIeMy cTaTyca Bcex Ha­ U MOHaJIbHhIX 06pasoBaHMM B HameM CTpaHe H o BM rr I1MO HaMTM TO ODTI1MaJIbHOe pemeHMe KOTopoe He PO aJIO 6 Me HaU MOHaJIbHOM POS­ HI1 He rrpI1BO MJIM 6 K 060CTpeHMIO Me HaU I10HaJIbH X H o KaK OTHorneHMM KOHeqHO rropa60TaTb OqeHb cepbeSHO 11 H TaKI1M BorrpOCOM MCKJIIO eHI1e BOSMO HOCTM MaHMrryJII1pOBaTb Ha MOHaJIbHb Borrpo­ COM CO CTOpOHbI 8 KOHOM eCKMX rpyrrrr CO CTOpOHbJ MarPMM M IJJlyrMx SaMHTepeCOBaHHbIX JIMU rroToMy qTO Cy rr B rro BceMy JIerqe Bcero MaHMrryJIMpOBaTb Ha HaU MOHaJIbHb rrp06JIeMax rrO TI xmraTb HaU MOHaJIb­ H e qyBcTBa BOT rro rr 8TOM rrJIeHKoi1 CKpbIBaIOTcB Ka3aJIOCb 6bJ BrrOJIHe crrpaBe rr JIMB e SKOHOMMqeCKI1e I1HTepeC oT rr eJIbHb rpyrrrr KaK STO rrpOMSOmJIO B APM8HMM M Asep6aM aHe Cei1qac Bce STO Bb JIO Ha rroBepxHocTb KTO MaHMrryJIMpOBaJI KaK SaqeM B qbMX MHTepecax M B KaKoM CTerreHM MJIM BSRTb OT rr eJIbHble aKT KaPAa OT rr eJIbH e JIIO rr M KOTop e sapeKOMeH IJ OBaJIM ce6H CaMb M 0PTO rr OKCaJIbHb M rro­ CJIe rr oBaTeJIHMM MHTepHaU MOHaJIMSMa Ha CaMOM rr eJIe CTOflJIM y MCTOKOB rro rr orpeBaHMH HaU MOHaJIbHb CTpacTei1 T5 HatI8JIa pa60TaTh KOMI1CCMfl no rrO IJ rOTOBKe OtIepKOB rro MCTOptIItII KIICC Mbl rrpli IJ aeM 3TOMy 60JIhIDOe SHat eHtlIe 11 npM naBM 3TOMy 60JIb­ oe SHatIeHMe rroJI T6 po yTBep IJ V JIO reHepaJIhHOrO ceKpeTapH Hame napTHH PYKOBo rr TeneM KOM CCHH rrOJIHT6 po HaKonHBm CH npli rr aTh eMy HayqHY HayqH Bepc ID rr OCT eHHRX HO 6es ny6JIHQ cT qeCKH xapaKTep cTop ecKlix MaTep an UK HaM 0 npOmJIOM HameM napTHH OKYMeHTHpOBaTh rrpoQeccoB BO Bcex 11 rr aTh Hapo y TPY rr HOCTRX n06e rr ax fJIaBHOe QT06H 3TO 6 no 06ceKTHBHo Hayq­ COKP T R qero-JI1160 M 6es HarOBapHBaH R B eJI rrepB M HOMep ypHana l1sBecTHR B H O 0606 Tb UK KrICC M07KeT He ycneJIH HJI ycrreJI e OSHaKOM ThCfl HO R 6 BaM peKOMeH­ OBaJI Ha TtII BpeMfl C HKM n03HaKOMMThCR rr OKYMeHT B HeM cero rr HRmH e H He orry6JIHKOBaHH e 6y eM ny6JI KOBaTb rr o C x nop rrpH aeM 3TOMy t1Is rr aHHID 60JIhIDOe SHaqeHHe Ho y e C TOqK speHHR 06ceKTHB­ rrpe rr CTaBJIeH R Horo 0 eRTeJIhHOCTM napTHH 06 eCTBa KaK B n pOmJIOM TaK H B HaeTOfl eM OCHOBHO rrpHHQ n 3Toro HS rr aHHfl - rr OKyMeHTH­ pOBaTb H qerO He co06 aTb TaKoro qTO He 6 0 6 no rr TBep eHo rr oKYMeHTaMH rry6JIHKOBaTh CaMH IJ OKYMeHT rrpHRTH e HJI Henp flTH e ­ RaK e eCTh HaQaJI B XO rr Th llpaBI1TeJIhCTBeHHbti1 BecTHHK flo 38M CJIY rrpe ­ ce rr aTeJIR COBeTa MHHHCTpOB OR OJI eH rr eRTeJIhHOCThID npaBHTeJIhCTBa 11 ero 3HaKOM Th C COBpeMeHHOv BSrJIR aMM HanpaBJIeHMRM ECTeCTBeHHO TOBap tITO 60JIhme Bcero Hac 6ecnOKOMT 3KO­ HOMMKa MHoro B neqaTH nHmyT BOT nOKa qTO p opMa HMqerO He IJ aJIa Bee 3TO HaBepHoe BepHo eCJI11 He 6paTh Kpa HHe cy rr eHMfl M CKJIOHH CMOTpeTh HeCKOJIhKO no IJ rr pyrHM yrnoM speHMR a qTO SaJI07KeHO sa 3TO BpeMfl qT06H 3KOHOMHKa aJIa OT aqy M CqHTaeM 16 qTO 3anomeHO OqeHb MHOrO 3Haq TeRbHM nOTOK eHemH BROmeHH H eT B MO epHM3aQHID 6YKBanbHO THCRq npe pHRTH M CqHTaeM qTO 3TO HaqHHaeT pa60TaTb np HeCeT npO YKQHID aTO - pas T e eTpyKTypHaH nORHT Ka OCYIl eCTBRHeTCR BeCbMa H BeCbMa aKTHBHO BO-BTOpMX M pa60TaeM ce qac H TeM qTo6 COKpaTHTb qHCRO BCHKHX KpyrrHHx PHraHTcKHX HCBOCTpoeK BO HTb H RHHHID Ha 3aM CROB Mo epHHsaQHID c eCTBYID HX rpe He npe rrpHHTHH Ha HOByro TeXHOROPHID H KOTop e epqe KOTop e a npoeKTOB npo­ anbme nepeCTpOHTb Ha CTOHT KaK OKasanOCb CTpOHTb MeRKHe HOB R emeBRe 17 o H Pax HX MO HO rOBopHTb He 6yAY BH HX qHTanH Bce ony6nMKoBaHO aHanHSHpOBaTb aHanMSHpOBaTb no-pasHOMY 4TO Hac 60nbllie Bcero 6ecnoKoMT Hac oonbllie Bcero oecnoKoMT HaR CMCTeMa Ha TIonHToropo MH oocy anM MHaHcoBo-KpeAMT- STOT Bonpoc CosAaHa KOMMCCMfl TIonHToropo no STHM AenaM T e sa STOT rOA M He TonbKO sa STOT MH Bb enHnH AeHer SHaqMTenbHO oonbme qeM npMSBenH TOBapOB a GTO npHBeno K TaKoMy COCTOflHHro KorAa AeHbrM nMlliHHe AeHbrM He ooeCneqeHHbIe TOBapaMM CnenH Bce qTO ObIno Ha rrpM­ naBKax H CAenanH STH nonKH nycTbm¥ XOTfl npOHSBeAeHO Anfl sTMX nonOK oonbme npOHSBOAMTenbHOCTb Hama nOBHCMnaCb a nonKM CTanH nYCTb M nOToMy qTO AeHer CTano oonbme BOT TonbKO sa B enHnH 48 npollinbIH rOA MH MnpA pyoneH AononHMTenbHO nIDAflM a TOBapOB Anfl HMX npOHSBenH Ha 26 MnpA pyoneH EcnM HaM STOT AHcoanaHC B 22 MnpA pyoneH He nMKBMAHpOBaTb TO SKOHOMMqeCKOe pasBHTMe Mo eT non3yqaR HH flUHfl T aTenbHo HO H HaCTo afl HH nflUMfl paOOTaeT KOMMCCMfl AeHe HHe BaTb saxneoHYTbCfl H Hac Mo eT nopaSMTb He TonbKO MaCCbI C H TOBapHo CHpOBaHHfl MO HO npOBeCTM BOT nOqeMY o eHb TeM KaKMM OOpasOM coanaHcHpo­ MaccoH Ha OCHOBe sToro coanaH­ pe opMY ueHooopa30BaHHfl KOTOpaH KO­ HeqHO flBnfleTCfl B HWHemHeH cHTyaQMH TOpMOSOM nepeCTpOHKM cepbe3­ Hb TOpM030M npe Ae Bcero qepes XOSpaCqeT TIepecTpOMKa SKOHOMH­ qeCKaH He Mo eT OHTb oe3 X03paCqeTa X03paCqeT He Mo eT OHTb oe3 HopManbHoro ueHooopaSOBaHMfl 8TO asbI nOnMTMqeCKOH SKOHOMHKM He Mo eT OWTb Cb bfl H Bb e QeHa rOTOBOH npoAYKUMM qeM COCTaBHHe qaCTH KOMnneKTYID He HSAenMfl npM X03paCqeTe He Mo eT CTPOMTbCfl TpaKTOp Aopo e qeM MeTann nOTpaqeHHbIH Ha STOT TpaKTOp TaK B HopManbHOH SKOHOMHKe He Mo eT ObITb HopManbHoH SKOHOMHKM ecnH Te HnM APyrHe oTpacnM AaTaQMMpYIDTCfl rOCYAapcTBoM npHqeM lB HenocpeAcTBeHHO A y Hac Ha MHAnHapAHH py6neM AOTaQ arponpOAYKQ fl BHXOAHT Ha 19- 20 3TO He 3HaqMT qTO STH MH RHap HY HO 3aBTpa He aBaTb OHM e pa3H e Mo eT 6HTb STH oTaqMH OT aTb B 3apnnaTY R ARM npH nOB eHMH saKynOqHWX qeH y arpapHO npOM@ill eHHOCTH qTo6 OHM raMH pacnopH aHHCb OTanHHMH ECRH 30 MRp YXO HT Ha OT Hro MHca nOqeMY 6 R HM He pas aTb HX Ha 3apnRaTy qTo6w OHH pacnopH anHCb 3THMH Mv RnHap aMv H nOKynanv STO MHCO dKOHOMHqeCKH STO npHBe eT K OS opoBReHHro 3KOHOMHKH Rro H 6Y YT nOHHMaTb qTO TaKoe ce6eCTOMMOCTb peHTa6e bHoCTb npH6w b HO Ha HOPManbHOM OCHOBe 3aKOH CTOHMOCTM 3TO - 60 bmaH npo6neMa qTO TyT ee c ep MBaeT Bo-nepB X STO CRO OCTb BO-BTOpMX HaCTpoeHHH y Rro eM TaKHe qTO Hac onHTb XOTHT 06MaHYTb rOBOpHT 0 nOB eHHM eH H 60HTCH SToro Ho peqb eT He 0 noBwweHMM eH qTo6w cpe cTBa STH eHbrH oTaqHH npoHsBoAcTBa nepe aTb a 0 TOM Ha ceRbCKoe XOSHMCTBO Ha nOKynaTenro HO KOHeqHO qeHH Ha TOBapw OR H 6WTb nOBHmeH@ CK eM ce6eCTOHMOCTb MHca B KORxose K eTCH 2-20 a B MaraSHHe npo aeM 3a 2 pyORH H o ero npo aBaTb no TOM qeHe CKORbKO OHO CTOHT C HSnepmKaMH sa TpaHCnOpT H T 3aTO STO eHbrH To6 nOKynaTeRb Mor cno­ KOMHO nOKynaTb BOT B qeM np HHw Ho B STOM H O nIDAeM y6e HTb B UK nocTynaIDT nMCbMa OT neHcHoHepoB HH3KOOnnaqHBaeM X nro eM OHH 60HTCH SToro eRa KaK rOBopHR M C rop6aqeB nro H He onmHW OT SToro nOCTp aTb HH Ha o y KoneHKy HHSKOOnnaqHBaeMHe nonyqaT o 18 py6 npH6aBKH npH HameM BapHaHTe HO B COKOOnnaqHBaeM e TepyIDT OKORO 8 py6 C KOrreMKaMH HaqaRHCb KOHKpeTH e npopa6oTKH 3THX Be eM •• Ho H TyT Y Hac rOBopH 3TOT Bonpoc HBnHeTCH MnOHHMaeM eCTb crropH KaK nonyqHTCH Kopoqe npe eTOM T aTenbHoro qTO nepeCTpOMKa anbme He MomeT H TH paCCMOTpeHMH 6e3 3KOp OM e­ CKHxnpeo6paSOBaHHM Kor a BCH Harna npOMHIDneHHOCTb HapO Boe X03HMCTBO nepeXO T Ha XOSpaCqeT