Oc06eHHO DOHMMaro nYIlIKHHa BI I 3TO HCTOpHYeCKHA MOMeHT C'-iaCr JU1B KTO nOCeT11 JI ce BCnoMHHaro C OBa MHp B ero MHHYTLI POKOBLIe R LI T ne CTBI1Te bHO MO JKeT 6I ITb HO H Ha Cbe3ne CKa3a YTO yyaCTOK HCTOpHH B KOTOpOM MHe 2le e Ha caMOM TaK He 3Haro 3TO ceHTHMeHTaJIbHLle CYaCT B npHX02lHTC C OBa YTO 3ax13aTH TOT ceAyac KHTb H pa60TaTb YTO Y Hac B KOHeYHOM CyeTe nO YYHTCH TaKOJ 1 MOMeHT 3TOT ron Y Hac OyeHb HacTynaromHA BOT 6YK13a bHO 3TH H C e2lYlOmH r02l 210 nO OBHHl I eC H Ml I ero BLI2lep JKHM MeC ULI A CaMI IH 2le HKaTHbn1 MOMeHT ceAYac f· A S HanelOCb £ Mory ce6e npe2lCTaBHTb J Ec BLI2lep iCHM TO 2lYMalO mI BLI2lep KHM H YTO MoA BH3HT Bac He HeT HeT HeT HeT 2la bIlIe 06peMeH eT HeT YTO BLI OyeHb 3aHHTI I lIa 13LI 3HaeTe Y iCe n Tb eT Y lKe npHBLIK K 3TOMY 5l BYepa C MHxaH OM CepreeBHYeM H CKa3 YTO 3aBTpa C BaMH pa3rOBapHBa BCTpeYarocb OH nO JKe aHHH 5l npOCH BaM npHBeT nepe2laBaTb CamIe 2l06pLIe nonpOCH C Y Hero Cbe32lHTb B KaHa2lY He OTnYCTH B HBape rOBopHT 13 HBape OqeHb TpY2lHl m yqaCTOK 3TH TpH Mec ua C HIlIHHM I1MIlIH rOBopHT KCTaTH Ha2l0 6Y2leT HanHcaTb nHCbMO COBeTHHKY noc aHHHKa npHr aCHTb Cbe32lHTb B HBape TaM 02lHH YHHBepCHTeT 13 KaHa2le npHCBoH MHe 3BaHHe nOyeTHOrO 2l0KTopa npa13a XaJIb LIa YTO BLI He MO KeTe npHexaTb OyeHb iCa KO -2­ e CTBHTe H1le np ' BOT 3aKOHOMepHOCTM TO A H C npyro A CTOpOHLI CHa ana B O nepHOn HeCKOnblCO pa3 lla BCeX 3TMX 3Ur3arOB C 1C0TOpLle npOHCXOlIHJill B 1933ro ro a a XO O Ha51 BO a nOTOM 3THX 3HaqHT PY3BenbT BOT ceittIac rO OBY 1C0He4H0 CTaTbHl J1 KC £ 5I 61 1 ICpwnncoBa ee rpemeH eT TOMY eC M Ham-iC 61 1 nuca ce Aqac Coelu-meHHI IX IIITaTax AMepUICH A lIa ICpUTMICoBa CerOZIH5I TaKYIO « e CTaTbHl BOT B OCH 51 npOCTO H qTO eC 11 61 ' MI I TO I e caMoe nMCanl1 CerO H5I XOTb lla u 610' 3Ha ql1 O • 4T0 IM3Hb BIo' 11 rOBOpHTe HanMca 11 Tor a ee O O 6LITb TalC nOTOMY Ba uaTb eT lCalC TO Y 4T0 MI I HW-IeMY He HaY4MJillCb OCTaHOBM aCb XOT5I 51 BaM o eH CICa3aTb 4T0 He HanMCanl1 6J 1 TY CTaTbIO TaK BCe-TalCl1 eCJlJ1 CMOTpeTb £ B 1C0HUe 61 1 0 MHoro npaB lol T5IJlCe OMY np05lB eHUro CTaJIUHa BO BpeM5I qHCTOIC B 30e rO Ll M KOHe4HO 61olJlO C lCaK CerO H5IWHHMI1 rJla3aMM Ha £ BLI 3HaeTe rOBOp5lT BOT 3TO MeH5I Ho B 4TO C06LITM5I TOJICe BpeM5I lCalC ce A-4ac 311eCb H 61 mo Y Hac He MOrJlM npH4eM He MarJIH Y HBJl5lJIo TO JlCe BpeM5I CaMOMY 51 61 1 COBeTCICO-aMepUlCaHCICMX npe B eTb Bo-nepBL 4T0 aHa HaCTYnHT B BO-BTOpI lX npl1 eT TalCoe J npe BI1 eTb MI I To a-e BaI 101 3TO BpeM5I u OTHOC OCb IC MI I 04eHb Mana MOrJill Ha eSlTbCSl 3 1 0 BLI nOHHMaeTe TenepeWHee BpeM5I MI I 3TO Hawe A CTOPOIDI on5lTb BO BpeM5I BO I H 3BeCTHoe pa304apOBaHHe 11 0T4a51HHe a OTHOmeHI151X 4T0 4T06L' TaM 6J Jno MHoro npaB I I Hee B r aBHOro e o 4eM Hac 3TO ECJlJ1 MHe ce A4ac XOT5I Bpo e 61 1 Bce-TaM Ha OTlCa « YCb Bcex Y 3TO TO I e HO 3TO TO TalCHX ICHlUCeK 6101 He Hanucan a caMoe Y Ha3a21 XOpOWO 3Haro Barny uwraul npaBU H1le HO qerO-TO HeT TalCoro 6LI 0 npaBno A lCalC CHer Ha Ha3aZI ICTO-TO npen O HT nepeU3 aTb 51 MeCTe HOBa51 3nOXa 5I caM He Xa -xa 61 1 0 COpOIC H Bo AHa nOTOM lCaICUe-TO npU3HalCU ICpaTKOBpeMeHHl lX nOTen eHHti If nOTOM HOBa51 3nOXa OTHOWeHH51X B 3TOM npMHUMne notl YT CTOJIb YMaJI eCSlTb HO He TalC HaBepHO BC5I lCalC ceR4ac 6J ICTpo neT TOMY 6LICTpO CJIO a-HOCTb Ha3a -3­ HCTopW4eCKHe 3anaTKH MHorHe nOHHMdWT Y' Ke aTMOC epa KaKOe-TO nO HO H3MeHHTbCH napTHH B 06meM-TO HCTOpHH B 06meM-TO nepen HaMH nOCTaBHna l fI'O HapaCTdlO'T ICaKMe-TO COOl ITHH nOHHMaHHe l fI'0 BCe nORXHO H3MeHMTbCH OC06eHHO nocne 56ro rona ecnH cepbe3HO rOBOpHTb nepe HBaeT TaKYW uenb KaTaKnH3MOB naneHHH K B3neTI I nOpa iCeHHH BHnHTe CHa4ana XpYmeB Harne 06meCTBO OHO 6YPnHT Ho 4epe3 TepHHH aHa nBH iCeTCH K 3npaBOMY cmlcny Ha4a 04eHb Bce nocne 20ro Cbe3na C 20ro Cbe3na n06enl l KaKOI'1Y-TO Pa3YMHOI'1Y Ha4aJIY KaKaH-TO 60 0 XOTH cnOlKHO CBOW nOnHTM4eCKYW Era OrpOI'1HaH 3ac yra l fI'O OH cnenan nena neHTenbHOCTb Era MHe iCa lla na ECnH 61 1 OH «liJl ceronHH OH 61 1 Bce nOHHn l fI'0 ceA4ac npOHCXOnI-1T • OH - Y Hero na Ho B Ha4a l1Cb CepreH4 TO iCe Bpel'1H OH HcnyraJlCH n031 IBI I K KY TY OH HcnyranCH OnHTb H4HOCTH# M BOT Ham HHKHTa AnnonHCMeHTII eMY ronOBY BCKPYIMnH A MI l e '1Y Mana n0l'10ranH J r lla 3T0 BepHo 4eM 3TO 06bHCHHTb A j OT4aCTH BJll1HHHel'1 HaWHX Ha npe3HneHTa 3HT i'3Ha3M B HaBepHoe na BO bme Bcero CBH311 C HnepIDIM 3TO 6101 O COBnaneHHe BpeMH 3T0 BOT npaBHnbHOe 3aMe4aHHe A KaK BI I no araeTe hard-liners KOTOpl le noneHcTBoBa H BOeHHl le H HeC4aCTHLIH Haw opY «lieM Ho TO iCe KaJleTCH MHe B 3TO 3T0 6'1 0 COBnaneHHe KpH3HCa B BeHrpHH C KpH3HC0l'1 B CY3UKOI'1 KaHane J lla f Bce 3TH C061 ITHH H CHTyaUHM H MemaJIH C Hameii CTOpOHI I Korna OH rOBopH 'lITO Ml 1 TOJCe era He nOHHMa J1H H Bac noxopOHW KaK OH CKa3aJl p 3aKonaw 4 3T0 He 61 1 0 npaBH Ho nOHHTO Y Hac 6yny nnHcaTb Ha BamHX noxopOHax npyroe a OH XOTen CKa3aTb He BI I Ha MOHX ne4aJlbHI IH nepHOn HameH HCTopHH l fI'0 H Ho 3TO COBceM -4­ Hy TYT KOHe4HO MHOrl1e cpaKTopLI CLlrpa rrn CBOro pOJIb MeHH lI0 CHX nop YllHBnHeT TO 4T0 B 06meM CPa3Y noc e BO I 11 Y HaC eCTb CC8TDeTCTI Tre aHe llOKYMeHTII Ha 3TOT C4eT peweHMe rOCY lIapCTBeHHoro KOMHTeTa 060POHLI no COKpaIlleHMlO apMI1M Ha MHoro MM Jl JIMOHOB cpa3Y noc ne BoJ i Hhl Tenepb pellleHMe COBeTa 060POHLI M nOJlMT6lOpo 'fl'06l 1 npe llOTBpaTMTb KaKoe- M60 HaCa lIeHl1e B CTpaHax BOCT04HO EBpOnl 1 COBeTCKO MO lIe M M3HM Ho Bce nOIll o He TaK HacTYnH TaM 1948 4911 rOll Be3 lle Ha4 MCb rOCY lIapCTBeHHLle 4 aKTM4ecKMe nepeBOpOTII na 3TO £ lla lla lIa CBoero MCTopHKa Y MeHH TaKoe BceM aTOM S lleT Bne4aT eHMe KaK ero 6M1l1b llTO 04eHb nnoxyro POJIb Mrpan BO Ha4anbHHK KrB HKBlI KaK ero EepHH 2Ia 'fl'0 ero BnMHHMe ropa3 lIo 6oJIbwe 4eM llYMalOT B 3TO BpeMH oco6eHHO B BOCT04HO EBpone nOTOMY 4TO aTM pe nIM LI aT Hero 3aBMcenM rOpa3 110 60nbllle 4eM OT HapKOM lle HnH MMHMCTpa 11H0CTpaHHLIx llen MHoro 06 aTOM CKOPO 51 llYMaro 6Y lleT Ham-KaHO nOH51TO Hy llO Hoe 3HaeTe Ha 110 OT llaTb XpymeBY llTO OH npOHBHn orpoMHoe My eCTBO BOT B aTOM llene C BepHe 3T0 Bce-TalCH ero 3aCnyra 'OH eIlle He 06na llan B TO BpeMH TaKO BnaCTbro KaK nOTOM npe llCe llaTeneM CM 6LI ManeHKoB Tor lla 6LI a neperpynnMpoBKH BnaCTM H TaKaH TeH lleHUMH TeH lleHUHH llTO OHa llO Ha COCpe llOT04HBaTbCH KaK npH JIeHMHe B COBMl1He H XpYI QeB 6Llna 6LI 1M ceKpeTapeM nOnHT61Opo UK H BOT OH TOr lla nOCTaBHn Bonpoc a BepHH lI H 3Toro Ha 110 6Llno My eCTBO OH pHCKOBan CBoe lnf3HbJO 3T0 HCHO Bce-TaKM OH HaCTOHn Y Hero llOCTano ec H BepHH 6Lln y6paH C nOnHTH4ecKoi1 apeHLI 51 llYMalO llTO eCnM 6LI aToro He 6Llno c llenaHo HalllY cTpaHY O H llana 6LI ne4aITbHaH yqaCTb oc06eHHO eCnH yqeCTb 4TO Cy6beKTHBHLIH 4 aKTop B HallieH I1CTOpMH Hrpan orpoMHYlO POJIb 3HaeTe sl 6Lln 3 lleCb no OKOH4aHHM MeCHULI OKOH4aHMH MupOBOi1 BO HLI 3 llecb Y Bac llan 4erO-TO COBceM H 4TO aTO 60nbilioe M TparH4ecKoe 4TO 6Y lleT KOe-llTO nO ll06HOe llTO 6Y lleT 60nee HOpManbHaH BO I B EBpone B nOc e llHMe 11 Y MeHH Bne4aT eHHe 4 T0 HapO ll llpyroro Ha caMOM lle e BL no pa304apOBaHHe HaCTynl1Ro llYManM CerO llHH cymeCTByeT llTO anaCTb OTHOllleHHH Me llY HapO lloM H -5­ npaBHTe CTBOM 2 lla TYT 51 Mor 611 corJIaCl ITbCH C BaMM HO C norrpaBKOH C onpe eJIeHHoH M 3HaeTe KaKo MLI ce ac CTPa aeM He TOJIbKO Tor a OT Toro 1 JT0 Hapo n Ham 6y nYYH B 06meM-TO HY corHYT11M '-iTO npHlliH6JIeHH1W nOJIHTHYeCKM cor w npHWM6JIeHHLm He OyeHb-TO 6blJl rOTOB K neMOKpaTHyeCKHM H3MeHeHHHM H ceAyac He OyeHb rOTOB Ha CJIOBaX - na a BOT Kor na nOXo nHT no npaKTMyeCKHX neJI TO 3 lleCb HacTynaeT TOCKa no «eJIe3H1IM nOp5l nKaM MJ1M no lI06poMY uapHl TeM 60JIee 3TO 611JIO nOCJIe XpYIIleBa BOT ceAYac HHor na ynpeKaHlT rOp6ayeBa B TOM 1 JT0 OH He npHHHMaeT peWHTeRbHL Mep BOT TaM necKaTb cTpeJl5iHlT BOHlHlT a OH peWHTeJIbHLIX Mep He npHHHMaeT Ho BOT XpYIUeB-TO npHHHMaJI OH npHMeH5IJI opY «M e 16 pa3 9T0 6J IJIH aTaKH Ha MBll B AJIeKcaH npMH ypoMe HOBOYepKaccKe B rop0 lIe WeByeHKO B Ka3axcTaHe H B npyrl1X ropo nax 9TH BcnIoIWKH rHeBa 1 JT0 J1M Hap0 llHOro KOHeYHO 0TPa «aJ1M He lIOCTaTOK BOCnHTaHH5I H nOJIMTHYeCKO KYJIbTYPbl H Bce TaKoe 11 HeTepnHMOCTb H HeTepneJ1HBOcTb He «eJIaHHe « aTb HO KaK Bcer a K STOMY npMMeWHBaJIMCb J1roMneHCKHe 3JIeMeHTbI KOTOpbM XOyeTC5I Bce pa3pyrnaTb H 60Rbwe HHYero He lIeJIaTb Pacnpe eJl5lTb HO He C03 llaBaTb M BOT OH npMMeHMJI opY «Me HeCKOJIbKO pa3 M 1 JT0 H3 3Toro nOJIYYHJIOCb CTpaHa OTKaTMJIaCb On5lTb Ha3a lI H C 3TO TOYKH 3peHH5i TO '-iTO HaCTYnHJIO 6e3BpeMeHb€ M 3noxa 6pe «HeBa 3TO JIOrHYHO OHa HaYaJIaCb B 06meM-TO C KOHUa npaBJleHH5i XpyweBa OH lIan B KOHue CBoero npaBJIeHM5I BOT 3TOT CTapT pa3BHTH5I HCTOpHH H 6pe «HeB JIOrHYHO B eJI H3 TO y «e 60JIOTHCTO TaKO nOYBbl KOTOpa51 OOPa30B1IBaJIaCb BO BTOPOi nOJIOBHHe npaBJ1eHM5I XpyweBa M Bce-TaKH npHYMHLI 3Toro He TORbKO B cY6beKTHBHL cnOC06HOCT5IX MJIM yePTax XpyweBa lla OH 6IolJI yeJIOBeKOM He lIOCTaTOYHO rpaMOTHLW He lIOCTaTOYHO S He lIOCTaTOYHO rpaMOTHL npHpo oi O apeHH1 Ho 3TO 6IolJI yeJIOBeK O lIa TaJ1aHTJ1HBIo yeJIOBeK peHHLI r lIe-TO M rJIaBHOe - TO '-iTO OH BepMJI B nOJIe3HOCTb KOMMYHHKaUHH Me « lIY JIHl bMH npHe3 «aJIM aMepHKaHCKHe BH HLle J1HqHOCTM OH rOTOB 6 IJI ueJIYIO HOYb C HI1MH pa3rOBapMBaTb OH BepHJI B CBoe lIeJIO 3 eCb Bepl1JI B KOMMYHH3M KaK OH ero nOH5iJI M pa 6IolJI C llpyrHMM 06MeH5ITbC5I MHeHH5iMl1 9Toro MIoI He HaWJrn Y zIpyrHX HM B 30e rO lIIoI HH B 40e HH B 50e 2 lla Kor a -6­ L Ho nepen TeM KaK npOnOJUeVlTb BeCTH no B03MO HOCTH 3ap aBefl HeMHOro Sf 6LI XOTeJI ••• 51 pan CKa3aTb no CHJIaM pa3rOBOp nO-pYCCKH HO Sf3LOC MeHSf COpOK JIeT Sf He rOBOpHJI nO-pYCCKH £ XM A 51 3HalO Sf3LIK Ho Bce-TaKH TPYLIHO MHe HHorLIa CJIYWaTb 3T0 OT BLI npeKpaCHO rOBopHTe cTapocTH ECJill JIlOnH CJillWKOM 6LICTPO rOBopSfT 6LICTPe A rOBopSfT £ 4eM B Sf aTO 3aMe4aIO OHM CTapoe BpeMSf Ce R4aC Bce 6LICTPen rOBopSfT 51 XOTeJI 611 BaM npe lwaraTb t IT06LI 6LWO LIBa npOTOKOJIa HaIlIeti 6ecenLI eCJill aTO CHUMaeTCSf ••• no-aHrJIi1 ACKH • H OnHH no-pYCCKH LIPyrOn nOCJIe t IT06LI M1 1 npOBepSfJIH nBe BepCHH H BLI MeHSf H3BHHMTe eCJIH Sf HHor na nepetiLIY K Sf HanelOCb aHrJIl ft CKOMY 2 nO aJIYi'fCTa CllaBatiTe TaK CLIeJIaeM nanMM Ha nepeBOLI npHWJIeM BaM lla LIa Ha LIBYX Sf3L1Kax CBOti TeKCT nOJIe3ffil JIlO6Lle BCTaBKH xopOWHe o6m M M Sf TO e caMoe KaKHe CneJIaeTe JIlO6Lle BLI COt ITeTe IM 51 LIYMalO 6ynYT 3a nMCbMeHHLlM CTOJIOM HHOr lla MLICJIH npHXO llSfT caMoe C lleJIalO 3T0 BLI YBH llHTe B TeKCTe H TOr lla 6Y lleT TeKCT HY HO 6Y lleT J r e BLI nOCMOTPHTe Torna eCJill Sf He Bce notiMy Sf nonpowy nOMomH H MeHSf HHTepecyeT O llHH Bonpoc KaKHM-TO 06Sf3aHHocTeti KOTOpLl A Sf llJISf ce6Sf KaKo A-To HPaBCTBeHHo A 60JIblO He3a arometi 3TO Sf BOT 6LIJI HeCKOJIbKO JIeT lla H Ce R4aC C MeHSf HHKTO He CHSfJI aTHX aTO npe llCenaTeJIeM pea6HJIHTauHOHHo A KOMHccHH KOMHCCHM no pea6HJIHTaUHH HeBHHHO OC LIeHHJ 1X B 30e-40e-SOe rO llLI 3a BpeMSf pa60TLI Hawa KOMHCCHSf KOTOPYlO Sf B03rJIaBJISfJl TaK CKa3aTb OCY LIe lX C O llHOrO MHJlJIHOHa f oCY lle 1X 1 CHSfJIa nSfTHO 1 He llaBHO H3 llaH YKa3 Bo06me pea6HJIHTMpOBaTb H npaBax Bcex eCJIH MHe no-aHrJIHticKH BL a aTbCSf Sf HHOr lla 6y llY BLI 3HaeTe C4MTaIO TO HY eH nonpaBKH B BaMH Haw pa3rOBOp ECJill Sf HHorna 6YLIY rOBopMTb no-aHrJIHticKH nepeBOn 2 MLI aTO 3anHWeM C no llOJIHTH4eCKHM MOTHEaM r BOCCTaHOBHTb B '-7­ Mo 1 f BOnpOC CBO HTCH K Cne YIDmeMY 3a 3TH rO 1 1 nepeYHT H nepenHCTan OrpOMHOe KO eCTBO MaTepHanOB Ha 3TY TeMY 0 nro HX KOTOPI paCCTPenHnH HX nOKa3aHHH CBH eTenbCTBa CBH eTene TaK CKa3aTb npOTHBOpe4HBI Ie HBneHHH KOTOpLle 61 IJrn B TO BpeMH B 06meCTBe TO KaK B4epaWHHe PY3bH npe aBanH pyr pyra CerO HH H T To eCTb nOXO Hn no rpH3H KaK rOBopHT He TonbKO no KoneHO HO H 60 we M HHKaK He nO MY B 4eM e eno BOT 51 COBeTCKH PYCCKHfi 4enOBeK HHKaK He noRMy MOTHBLI KOTopLle I1 KTOBa rrn CT HHY HMeHHO TaKoe TaKYID BOT nOnHTHKY MHe 6M 04eHb 6LIJ1O HHTepeCHO BLI Ha6nro a rrn 3TO KaK rOBopHT CO CTOpOffil BaM He rp03Hno TaK CKa3aTb OTHOCHTenbHO He rp03Hno KOHe4HO OKa3aTbCH TaM B TropbMe HnH 6LITb paCCTPenHHHLm cnaBa 60ry H TaK anee KaK Bbl 06b5lCHHeTe H KaK BLI Ha6nro anH B TO BpeM5I TI04eMY Bce-TaKH CTanHH OH Be b He CTaBHn ce6e 3a a4Y On030pHTb 06meCTBO H on030pHTb COUHanH3M y6e eH '-iTO Cy6beKTHBHO OH XOTen Bpo e 61 1 HY CTPOHTb CBOro cTPaHY c enaTb ee MOrY4e H CHnbHOt H TaK anee Ho n04eMY OH BCTan Ha nYTb 3THX MeTO OB H C napTHe H co CTPaHO H C HapO OM H C PY3bHMH H C HHTen rrnreHUHe He noRMy o CHX nop KaK BLI YMaeTe Bawa TPaKToBKa To e YMaro nOHHMaro Bonpoc BnOnHe CKopo n05lBHTCH 51 H Y Bac 60nbwa51 KHHra Moero K o n n XH3HH CTaJIMHa r- C 28ro ro a no 39 04eHb HHTepeCHaH H cepbe3HaH KHHra pe3ynbTaT MHoroneTHero H3Y4eHHH Bcero '-iTO MaTepHan KOTOpLffi y MeH5I 6Lln 3TO 4HTaJI B 3TO neTO OH 3aHHMaeTC5I KOHe4HO 3THM BonpocoM VI OH He Mor HaCKOnbKO 51 nOMHID BnonHe OTBeTHTb Ha 3TOT Bonpoc nOTOMY '-iTO 3TO BH HO '-iTO CTanHH caM ce6e Bpe Hn 3THMH MepOnpHHTHHMH oc06eHHo nocne HHe rO Ll ero nocne 35ro ro a no 38fi KOHe4Ho Y 3 eCb 51 nepefi y K aHrJI CKO Y C Bawero n03BOneHH5I MHoroe H3 3Toro npHnHcLIBaeTcSI CTPaHHo 3MOUHOHanbHO nH4HOCTH caMoro CTanHHa OH 6Lln BeCbMa JU060nLITHLIM 4enOBeKOM nOCKOnbKy C o Hofi CTOPOH r I OH 6LIn 4enOBeKOM 4epe3BLI4aIDio YBCTBHeTnbHLIM • THXHM np030pJIHBLIM H anbHOBH HIlIM OH nOHHMa Jl nID efi CH HI UHX HanpOTHB Hero B KOMHaTe VI OH 610ln a6conIDTHo paUHOHa JlbHOfi H BeCbMa Bne aTn5lromefi Jrn4HOCTbID C pyro e CTOpOIDI OH 6101n 60ne3HeHHO nO 03pHTeneH oc06eHHO no OTHoweHHlO K nID HM KOTopMe HcnOBe LIBa JUfCb eMY B npe aHHOCTH 3aBepHnH ero B TOM '-iTO BOCXHmaIDTCH HM KaK TOnbKO 3TO npOHCXO Hno OH Ha HHan HX nO 03peBaTb Y aCHO COXpaHHTb ero OBepHe 6I InO n04TH HeB03MOJeiO M eCJIH KTO-HH6Y b KaKofi-TO TPeTHfi enOBeK rOBOpHJI eMY '-iTO -8­ TaKorO-TO HanO YlCe HeB03MO lKHO OCTeperaTbC MHe 3TO BCe CnaCTH 3TOrO paCCKa3I IB a ero no e OBeKa 6 o HO Mbl H caMl1 3TO BHne M rOpa3no 6o ee HopMa bHO OHBe ce6 C nronbMM KOTOpl le He 3a5lB JII1 0 CBoeR npl1BeplCeHHOCTH K HeMY C PY3BeJIbTOM 11 ep I JIeM OHH MM BOCXHm Cb HaCKO KO 51 nOHMMalO OH 6aJI eJIOBeKOM THXMM M CTBeHHl IM JIJonH KOTOpl le He 61 1JIJ1 aCTblO nBJ1lCetrn5l He npo6YlCn aHOpMaJlbHl le epTI I ero JIH HOCTH B03MOlCHO eC I1 BI I pa3pelliHTe MHe npOnOJI »cMTb 3TY TeMY OT aCTH 3TO 06b CH5IeTC OmYmetrneM HenOJIHOueHHOCTH Bce HayaJIOCb C ero O Ymeffi1 C06cTBeHHOA HenOJIHOueHHOCTJ1 B OTHOWeHH X C JIlOnbMM 113 JIeHHHCKOro OKpY »ceHl151 C ero r aBHLIMI1 COpaTHI1KaMl1 To 61 IJIl1 npeKpacHo 06pa30BaHHl le nronl1 pKl1e l1YHOCTl1 B 60JIbmHHCTBe CBoeM B TO BpeM5I B KOHue nBanuaTL ­ HayaJIe rpl1nuaTI 51 noMHlO aCTO rOBOpl1JI CBOMM KO JIeraM YTO 3TO MOCKOBCKoe nOJIl1T6IOpO - caMoe 06pa30BaHHOe npaBl1TenbCTBO B EBpone 11 OHM HeKOTOp1 le 113 3THX nroneA cnoKoAHo pa60T 11 C Hl1M MHOrl1e 113 Hl1X 61 IJIM npeKpaCHO 06pa30Baml »cHJIH 3a rpaHHlleA • 3H l1HOCTpaHH1le 5131 IKl1 Y CTaJIMHa Hl1 ero 3Toro He 61 UIO if OH npeKpaco C03HaB CBOIO orpaHM eHHOCTb 11 OyeHb nepelCl1BaJI no 3TOMY nOBonY np05lBJl5lJIOCb 3TO nO-pa3HOMY np yeM 3TO YBCTBO HHKorna He nOKl1n O ero Bce 3TH CTKl1 11 3BepCTBa no CYTJ1 HaYaJll1Cb C ero nonLITOK YHl1 TO Kl1Tb B COBeM OKpy eHHH Bcex Tex Koro OH Mor 3anon03pHTb B npeKJIOHeHMl1 nepen ReHMHl IM 11 B MeHbweM npeKJIOHeHHH nepen cBoeA nepcoHoA OH 61 IJI JIerKO paHHMLIM yeJIOBeKOM Ye OBeKOM Y KOToporo KOTOpI GJ KaK 3TO HH crpaHHO 06 aDaJI BeJIMKMMI1 cnoc06HOCTH 11 CTPaWHO nepe aJI no nOBOny cBoeA OrpaHl1yeHHOCTH OH He XOTeJI np113aHaBaTb 3TY OrpaHaqeHHOCTb He XOTe rOBOpHTb 0 HeA 51 nYMaro HMeHHO 113-3a ToA 60pb6LI KOTOpylO OH Ha aJI To61 1 YHI1YTO KJ1Tb copaTHHKoB Reffi fHa JIMneA H3 CBoero oKpy eHMH OH nOTep5lJI YYBCTBO Mepl l OH Ha aJI paCCTaBaTbC5I C 3Tl1MJ1 nronbMl1 11 3TO Y Hero KaK 61 1 BOWJIO B npMB1 IYKY H eCTeCTBeHHO Bce 3TO OH nepeHec H Ha KO eKTMBH3aUHro H 3TO y aCHO MHe TpynHo nOH5ITb KaK e OH He Bl1neJI KaKoA Bpen OH HaHOCHT nepeBHe nepeHec OH Bce 3TO H Ha naprMro H B aTOM-TO Bce H neJIO XpymeB 06BHH HX BO Bcex pa3rOBopax 0 npyrHX B TOM YTO OHM COCT05lJIH B aHTHnapT rpynnlipOBKax Ho HCTHHHoA aHTHnaprID1HOA Cl1JIoA 61 1 CTaJIHH OH 605l c5I napTHH C caMoro HayaJIa 3TO 6111JIa He ero napTHH a ReHHHa OH Bcerna non03peB HX B TOM YTO OHI1 CMeWTC5I 3a ero cnHHoA YTO CpOHT 3arOBOpl l YTo6111 CMeCTHTb ero if Bce ero CTPaXH 6LIJIH npeYBeJnl eml Bce 3TO 51 Mory nOH5ITb Ho n03nHee npHMepHO nOCJIe 1935-1936 rona 3neCb HaYa aCb JIHXOpanKa nOBaJIbHl IX nOHOCOB MHorHe H MHOrHe -9­ JUO ZlH ZlOHOCHJrn Ha ZlpyrHX nOTOMY ITO CYMTaJU1 4T0 3TO e ZlHHCTBeHHb nYTb CnaCTMCb CaMMM TOnKHYTb nro Zle Ha 3TO - 3TO YJKaCHO BLI nOHHMaeTe YTO 51 MMelO B BH ZlY HaYaJlaCb HCTepHSI CTpaxa TIICSl4H H Tl ICSl4H JIIO Zle CaJIH lICepTBaMH HaBeTOB Zlpyrl1X nlO Zle KOTOpl le 3HanH 4TO Ha CaMOM Zlene Te Ha Koro OHM ZlOHOCHnM HeBMHOBHbl ZleMOpanM30Ban HapO Zl npM3HaIDCb Teppop nonHOCTblO 51 He Mory Bcero aToro nOHHTb nocne Toro KaK H npoYen BeCbMa n03HBaTenbHYlO KHHry ZlOYepH CTanMHa He Mory nOHHTb nOyeMY CTaJIMH n03Bom1n na e 3TOMY TaK Zlonro nponO aTbCSI HHKaKotf BblronLI eMY 3TO He npMHecno 3TO ocna6Hno apMMIO npHYeM B TO BpeMSI KOr Zla caM OH He HCKnroYaJI B03MO OCTb BOHHl 1 He CMOTpH HH Ha YTO OH He CMor OCTaHOBMTb Bcero 3Toro Zl0 1938 1939 rona Tenepb 3TO YJKe npeBpaTMnocb B HaCTOHmee 3MOUHOHanbHOe M3BpameHMe B ero C03HaHMH BOT Bce YTO 51 MOry BaM CKa3aTb Bce Zleno B 4pe3MepHotf nO Zl03pHTeRbHOcTH QT06L1 pa36Y ZlMTb ero nOn03pHTenbHOCTb nOTpe60BanaCb caMaH MaJIOCTb KTO-TO ITO-TO CKa3aJI M Bce KOHeu C Zlpyrotf CTOpOHLI KOHe4HO HY KHO Y4HTblBaTb 4TO OH o6nanaJI HeBepOSITHotf crroco6HoCTblO B3HTb yenOBeKa non KonnaK H ZlOKOnaTbcSI no Bcero ITO npOMCXO ZlMT B ero C03HaHMM BO MHorHX cnyyaHX 3TO ne BHTenbHO npoHcxonHno B C03HaHHM 3TMX nlO netf 11 OH 3Han aTO HHKOr Zla He 3a6y ZlY ITO CKa3an 0 HeM XpymeB nO-MOe Y Ha XIV XX Cbe3 Zle OH paCCKa3blBaJI KaK O lIHa l ZlLl 3awen B Ka6lrneT CTaJIHHa M TOT cnpOCHn ero QTO aTO y Te6H rna3a 6eralOT QTO y Te6H Ha YMe OH TYT lICe nOHHn ITO ITO-TO rrpOMCXO ZlMT OH 06na ZlaJI nOTpSlcalOmetf cnoc06HoCTblO 3arnSlHYTb BHYTPb 4enOBeKa npH aTOM OH BM Zlen TOnbKO nnoxyro CTOpOHY Xopomyro OH YBH ZleTb He Mor OHM Bce eme 60SlJrnCb ero ECnM Til CKpl lBaeWb ITO-TO He Zl06poe OH Mor YBH ZleTb 3TO Ho OH He Mor Hl14erO YBI1 ZleTb ecnM KTO-TO eMY rOBopMn BOT TOJIbKO TaK 51 Mory OTBeTHTb 3T0 6LIJrn YJICaCHl le mlcnH nOTOMY ITO OHH HecnpaBe ZlnHBO rrory6HnH MHnnuOHl 1 JIIO Zleti Bcero JIIO Zleti ero OKpYJKaBWMX npellC Zle KOHe4HO KOr Zla OH M36aBHnCSI OT nepBoti ppynnLI Zletf 3HaBWMX JIeHMHa pa60TaBWMX C JIeHMHI IM BXO ZlHBI1IHX B nepBl COBeT Hapo ZlHl lx KOMMccapoB KOr Zla OH M36aBHncSI OT HHX OH OCTancSi B OKpYJKeHHH nro Zleti KOTOPL OH caM rro Zl06paJI H Bce Ie OH HX T04HO TaK I e non03peBaJI KaK H OCTanbHL He ZlYMalO IT06LI KTO-TO Mor rrOnb30BaTbCSI ero ZlOBepHeM pa3Be ITO TOJIbKO MonoToB Ho B KoHue KOHUOB H aTO M3MeHHnOCb caMotf cMepTblO OH onon 1nCH H Ha Hero B caMOM KOHUe nepe Zl -10­ 06bHBH 4YTb H TIepen CMepTbro OH ero oCBo6onHTb OT pa60TLI HOBoe OH He ycneJI nO HT6ropo YlCe He wnHOHOM H co6panCH 6L O 6e3 MO OTOBa Ho CTapLIA 6LIJI B caMOM KOHlle aTO y e HanOMHHanO HaCTOHwee CYMacweCTBHe H JIlOllH era oKpy » aBwHe 3Ha H aTO 5I To » e 6LI 3neCb B 1952 rOllY OH CHOBa 3anOn03pHJI MeHH H BLWJBLlpHY oTcrolla 2Ie o B TOM 4TO OH YBCTBOBaJI TO 3peeT onn03HUHH npOTHB Hero H OM 3anOl103pHJI MeHH B CB513HX C Heti C onno3HUHeti 5l A lIa 6LI O HO aTO 3Ha He TaK Ho fI 4TO 6LI H pa3HLle KOTopLle nopollH H ero nOllo3peHHH Ho Bce aTO fI no araro CBOllHTCH K OnHOMY nopOK npOHBHflC51 o eHb paHO CTanHH HeCMOTpH Ha CBOH 60 bWHe 3allaTKH He 6LIJI 4e OBeKOM KOTOpOMY MOIHO 6L O llOBepHTb O pYKOBOllHTb npH HHLI Be KOH cTpaHoti H aTO o eHb ne bHO TILrraHcb H36aBHTbCH OT HHX OH npOHBltll ce6f1 KaK He3aypflllHLlti nOJll1TW-IecKHn TaKTHK Br lJIO onaCHO n bITaTbCH H36aBHTbCfI OT Hero OH YMeJI C03naBaTb CHTyauHlO Ho B aTOM-TO H 6 bI a TparellHH n fI POCCHH Ha ero MeCTe Mor 6r 1 OKa3aTbCH llpyroti 4e OBeK 4eCTHLIA KOMMYHHCT HH4ero llpyrOro H He Tpe6yro HO aTO no » eH 6 bm 6r rrb 4e OBeK ypaBHOBeWeHH bill C nOHHMaHHeM H CO YBCTBHeM OTHOCHmHt CH K lIpyrHM llfiM 5l lIYMaro y neHHHa Bcero aToro 6b o 6oJIbwe oco6eHHO KOr lIa OH 6 bIJI Y BJIaCTM J TIOHHMaeTe aTO 04eHb HHTepeCHafi TpaKTOBKa Bawa Ho BOT naBai1Te nOCMOTpl1M C TaKoA eme CTOpOIDI CMOTpHTe BOT OH 6 blJI 06BHHfI Bcex TO B wnHOHa e TO B YK OHe TO TaM B nO lI03pHTe eH 3arOBope H TaK lla ee - lIO BOABr I Ha anaCb BoABa OH Be lIb BbmYCTM B Ha4a e BO 1 Ha BO H nan xopOlliHe 60JIblliHe lIOnxHOCTH - H BoeHHLIM 3a6bIB TO OHH wnHOHLI H npOM bIWJIeHHMKaM Hawl1M pYKOBOllHTe HM BoeHHoti npOmlWJ1eHHOCTH To » e 3a6bIB 4T0 OHH wnHOHLI B4epa l e OHH 6bl WnJ fOHaMH J f nOCa ICeHLI 6 1 3a aTO H Bllpyr OHH BOT TOT ICe BaHHHKOB • lIonYCTHM TYT ICe nepeexan C ny6HHKH B MHHHCTepCTBO H CTaJI MMHHCTpOM TOT » e POKOCCOBCKJ fti TaK 4ero BoopyxeHHti rOBOpOB 4TO 3TOT reHepa l r aBHOKOMaH lIYrowJ fti POHTOM aTOT MepeUKOB nOTOM CT MapWanaMH To eCTb OH BHllHMO nOHMMaJI TO aTO He mnHOIDI 4TO aTO epYHna 4YWb HO aTO eMY Hano 6blJIo BOT aTO BOT nBY e B BOARY OH ce6H BeJI lIOCTaT04HO npH H4HO OH 60H CH ca ICaTb 5I BOT TaK cKa y Ha pOHTe M bl rOBopM 4TO XOTe 06cy IC lI J f COBepweHHO npyraH aTMoc epa -11­ HHKTO Hac He ca aJI He apeCTOB rnaJI A6co HO Bot Ha CHOBa nJIeHHl le Bce noUl Jill no TlOpbMaM KaK OHH KOCMOnOJIMT I CHOBa TO e canoe JIeHHHrpa CKoe eJIO BOT HHqero KOH aCb no JIarep5lM Ha4aJIOCb Bpa4eA H nOlliJIO eJIO O H aHHe 3TO KaK pa3 TO 0 KOTOpOM 51 rOBOpHJI Hapon YMaJI qTO 3TO 6y eT npO OJI aTbC5I TaK lCaK 3TO 61 IJIO BO BpeM5I Bol1Hl l a BHnHO 6 I IJI0 o 3Toro He 6y eT II 3TO TparH4eCKHA MOMeHT nOTOM Y o Hapo 3 eCb 6 IJI Bo-nepB lX CTpalliHO YCTamIfi OT Bcero OT BOt I H HY aJIC5I KaK pa3 B 06JIer4eHHH HO 3Toro o6J1er4eHH5I He B JIO CKa HTe nO aJIYtlCTa etlcTBHTeJIbHO B AMepHKe cetl4ac Bcepbe3 nOBopa BaeTC5I 06meCTBeHHOe MHeHl1e B CTOpOHY Harnetl CTpaIDl 6JIarO eJIaTeRbHoe TaK CKa3aTb 06meCTBeHHoe MHeHHe B nOJIb3Y Harnet CTpaHbl B oueHKax Toro qTO npOHCXO HT HJIH Bce-TaKH OCTaIDTC5I KaKHe-TO onaCeHH5I H CTpaXH A HeKOTOpI le npH eTC5I OCTaIOTC5I Ha 3TOT Bonpoc MHe OTBeTHTb no-aHr JI CKH nOTOM Y qTO OH OqeHb neJIl1lCaTH ltl He nYMalO qTO aMepHKaHCKHtl Hapo Bcer a OH HHKor a co6CTBeHHO H He OTBapaqJ1BaJIC5I AMepHlCaHUeB 6 1 JIH no B JIH5IHl1eM HCTepHM X0J10 HOt BOtrnl I Ype3MepHoro npeYBeJIHqeHH5I COBeTCKoR MOmH nOJIHOrO HenOHHMaHH5I HaMepeH COBeTCKoro COlO3a Bce 3TO 61 IJIO CB5I3aHO C XOJIO HOt BOtiHoR Kor a C03 aeTC5I TaKa51 aTMoc JJepa HaQHHaIDTC5I H npeYBeJIHQeHJ151 YBepeH C Bamet CTOPOH I To e 61 IJIH npeYBe JIW IeHI151 Ho B CllA CJ10 KHJIOCb BneQaTJIeHl1e oco6eHHO nOCJIe BO I B Kopee o COBeTcKHtl COlO3 - arpeCCHBHa51 cTpaHa JI5I MHOrMX CCCP e aCCOUHHpOBaJIC5I C rMTJIepoM OHH n03HaJIH qTO-TaKOe rHTJIep II 3TO nOH5ITHe OHJ1 nepeHOCHJIH Ha COBeTCK COI03 llo eH CKa3aTb o Bce 3TO 3aTpoHYJIO 60JIbWYIO QaCTb Hawero HapOna YMalO cetiqac Bce 3HaQHTeJIbHO HCnpaBHJIOCb XOT5I MHOrHe JIIOnH eme K0J1e6 c5I 3To OTQaCTH 3aBHCHT OT reorpa HH BOJIbwe 3TO npHcYIQe MHe Ka eTC5I IOrO-3anany cTpaH I QeM CpenHeMY BOCTOKY H JIH Cpe HeMY 3ana y Ha Cpe HeM 3ana e HanpHMep Ha Moetl pOnHHe B cep ue CTpaHl l JIIO H cOBepmeHHo HCKpeHHe CTpeM5ITC5I K HCTHHHOMY nOHHMaHHIO BemeR H 51 He YMalO O aMepHlCaHCKoe 06meCTBeHHOe MHeHHe Ha CerOnH5IWHHtl neHb npe CTaBJI5IeT npo6JIeMY JI5I HaWMX OTHoweHHtl no KpatiHet Mepe O HH H3 MOMX COOTeQeCTBeHHHKOB 3 eCb nOnpaBHT MeH5I eCJ1H OH YMaeT QTO 51 He npaB H BTOPOtl KOHe o nYMalO • O 3neCb Bce HOPMaJIbHO ECTb elQe onpe eJ1eHffile KpyrH KOTop le rJIy60Ko npMBep eH 1 H3BpalQeHHotl nCMXOJIOnrn XOJIO IHOtl -12­ BOtlHlI Ol-ill ellle nOJlHOCTblO He OnpaBHJlMCb BeHTeJIbHOCTb HMelO B lCOTopaH 3apoBunacb B BeHTe bHOCTb neHTarOHa BHBY Bom a MHOrHX He TOJIblCO CYllleCTBOBaHHH nOHHMaeTe B npHB I1 JCY OHH He 3HaJOT MM TpYBHO OT Hee HB HeTCH HO 11 M Y pa3rOBOp 4TO eCJIM 6 I lCTO-ffi16y b B onxeH c e aTb OTHOlUeHI1H 611 oTBeTI1JI lla noroBopHTe BLI C 51 r yrrOCTI1 npeKpaTHTe Bce 3TI1 H T II 13 o C 3'1'0 Bce OTB neKaeT YYlUe 61 ropa3BO 3HaeTe lCor lla pacclCa3 malO BI IXO llH H 61 THXi1tl 3'1'0 HH C 3lCOHOMHyeClCHX ropo ll M Y 6 r 1 0 Ha Hac He 3TO apeMeHH r aBHI 1M 06Pa30M C 4T0 TO 4T0 MI I 4HTaJIM nOMOWblO lUnHOHa a lCOTopLle nOcTynaJIM H Bno e eraJIbHO K3Y'·IaTb 1l0CTYnHYIO C4HTalO TO 0 nOCTeneHHOM C np0 llonxaTb nOB06HYID lleHTeJIbHOCTb B 06a npaBHTeJIbCTBa 1l0 1IXHJ 1 CBe rnaHHH 3TOtt lleHTeRbHOCTI1 TalC I1Haye 3aHI1MalOlllHXCH lle o C nOTOMY 4TO C03BaeTCH OnaCHl IM BparOM 1912 a aTO Be llb He TalC onepaTMBHoro lleA YTO MI I Bce eme HMeeM M ICOHe4HO MI nl1Ca Jill 3 lleCb cepbe3HYIO onaCHOCTb BHIY HeCKOJIbKO Boe n aHOB Kor lla BY llpo BHJIbCOH 6I H36paH npe3U lleHTOM rOll YTO B 6 0 npOllO aTb Y Bne4aT eHl1e HeMuaMU CTO eT Ha3a ll OH B 'IHCHI1 6I I O a eCJlM aTO MHoro nHcan 06 OTHOWeHMHX Me llY PoccHetl C npe lle Bcero MOMeHTOB K3YYaJI aTUM caM HCTOpHlC H paHQY3aMI1 H He oc06eHHO He He OCHOBJ IBaTbCH Ha c xax Ha pa3rOBOpax a 11 T ll 3To e napaHOH ••• BHMMaTeJIbHO nOTOMY 4T0 ropa3 llo 60JIbwe MO O 6 0 eCJll1 cepbe3HO llOrOBOpI1TbCH U COBeTCKI1M 4eM Ta HH opMaW1H lCOTOPYlO HaCTOHmee BpeMH He HMeeT CM lc a H I1 H yPHa m1 MI HHlCY lla - 3TO HaIUeM CMexa He Mor H 4HTaTb llOHeCeHHH I1H opMaUHlO 1O llbMH B 4TO 51 OTHomeHHiil C co BpeMeHeM Ml 1 nOHHJlM llpYI 11X HCTOYHlli OB Y3HaTb PHre COBeTClCoro COlO3a npaBl1Te bCTBO nO 4 0 MJ I 6e3 4T06 4aCTblO npaBHTeJIbCTBeHHOA nporpaMmI Mep 6L1 0 ropa3 0 6o e ueHH1 M H3 BMeCTO Toro ra3eT H lCeM He 06111aJIMCb HanpaB eHHI X npOTI1B lla 3TO 11 He HY oKHO CB060 llHO pa3rOBapl1BaJIM Bpyr Hac He 6 IJIO no yYa H COBeTClCMe 6I I H onepaTHBHotl M Y wnHOH eM onepaUl1HMI1 6 IJI MO OBOtt npocTI1Te 51 OTlCpOBeHHL celCpeTH lx 3a llaHHiiI BBa rOBa pa6oTa a H HX H3Y4aJIH CeKpeTH1 np06JIeM I rrpe CTaBHTeJIbCTBe TOr lla MI l ClCa3aTb pYCClCHMH H BHOCHT nYTaHilllY n IOB ClCI1BaTb llett ll H BCHlCHX COI030M cpeBCTBOM lCpaTyatlllll1e CPOlCH Y Yq1J I1Tb Hallll1 eC H 6 f Ml 1 o6CY ll H 3TI1 llpyrOM C H Bal l ll1HrTOHe cnpocun MeHH YTO MJ I Mo eM q-r06 1 B H 3BeCb 6e3 Bcero 3Toro Hac 3 eCb a6CO THO HenpllHY BeHHJ H nOClCOJIblCY T pa3BeBlCH H lCalC XHTb nepeCTpOHTbCH nOClCOJIblCY aTMoc epe 3TOtl BoeHHOM Be llOMCTBe TO bKO TOr lla Y BoeHHoe MHHHCTepCTBo n aHl1PoBaHl1H BHJIbCOH Hac neHTarOHa ewe eCTb ynpaBJ1eHl1e BJ GBa COTpY llHl1lCOB 3Toro -13­ ynpaBJIeHM5I H CnpOCHJI ieM B I 3aHHMaeTeCb Y Hac 4'1'0 nJIaHHpyeTe BaWH nJIaIDI HH npOTMB 1C0ro He B I 1I0JDKHI 1 COCTaBJI5ITb HX HanpaBJIeHbI • npOTHB lCalCoti-To CTpaH ' OTBeTHJIM M I B 16HPaeM CTpaHY HaH60JIee Ha 3TO OHH eMY Bep05lTHOro npOTHBHMKa H OCYllleCTBHJIH npOTHB 1C0ro B l eCTb BOeHHl le nJIaIDI nJIaHHpyeTe 3TH onepaUHH OnepaUHH B I KaKHe CTaHOBHTC5I a6coJIIDTHo 51CHO KaK HCTOPHICY nOSBOJIHTb BoeHH 1M paSpa6aTIlBaTb nJIaffil npoTHB KaKoA'-To OHH HaYHHaIDT cOSlIaBaTb 06pa3 Bpara HaKanJIHBaIDTC5I TI IC5IYH H no ropJIo SaH5IT IMH H CTaTbH pO Tm npOTMBHHlCa J1 3TO MeH5I oropYaJIo BoiilIDI X HH ceA'yac H JIJOllH rOllaMH XOll5IT 51 eM v Koro 51 51 YTO MOCKBa XOyeT B1 I5ICHMJIH YTO Y nOCTaB5IT BI I llYMaeTe B II fepMaHHH Ho 351Ta MOlUb A 3TO rOBOpHJI rOll HasalI J1x aprYMeHTII 6 'JIH apMH5I llOJUHO H OHH He CYHTaroT Y MOIHO JIH HMeTb A llYMaro maeilUapueB BnOnHe H3YYMJIH H TeopHH OyeHb XOqy I CHJIbHYJO KayeCTBe npOTHBHMKa 51 TaK YTO 3TO nOTOMY 51 51 rOBOpHJIH Ha 3TY YTO Y 4'1'0 MOIHO xopowa51 HHX eCTb nJIaHIoI BelleHM5I BoAHI 1 npOTHB HTaJIb5lHUeB HJIH nopTYraJIbueB llPyroti coce llHeA' CTpaHIoI YTO eCJrn Y npellCTaBHTeJI5IMH HATO YTO Bonpoc CTOHT TaK lleJIaJOT XOT5IT etl 3TOM BC5I TparellM5I SaCHlleJIHCb ao nOSllHa He HaSl lBaSi onpelleJIeHHYJO cTPaHY B H B 61 1Tb MeH5I Torlla npHrJIaCMJIM B TaM 51 BCTpeYaJIC5I C illBetiuapHM OHH TaK H OHM TO 1l0JUHI I 61 ITb J f nJIaIDI OHH HHKorlla 06 3TOM He SalI lBaJII1cb B Koro COSHaHMe aMepHKaHueB BO BpeM5I npMMepHO 6ecellOBaJIH BeCb Beyep J1 51 CKa3aJI 3ayeM 3TO HeMUI 1 SaKpaJIOCb 3TO OTYaCTH nOTOMY Bac eCTb 60JIbwoA' BOeHmlA' annapaT 3anallHYJO EBpOny OHM KaKHX-HM6Yllb ueJI5Ix BOT TaK M 3aKpaJIOCb Bce 3TO B XOJIOllHOA' BoA'HIoI YTO OHM OTKa3I BaJrnCb MI ICJII1Tb nOJIMTMyeCKM e BC5I BOCnOJIbSOBaTbC5I B apMHJO llYMaeTe OHM XOT5IT CHOBa nOBTOpMTb MCTOpMlO C OHH OTKa3I IBa rIHCb paCCyXlIaTb paUHOHaJIbHO KaK OHH OHH llYMaJIH HHX HellOCTaTOYHO CHJI llJI5I 3Toro BOCTOYHOrt EBponotl TeMY HO c06HpaeTC5I SaXBaTHTb 3anall VJO EBpOny BJIaCTH TaM BpeM5I YTO 3TO e KaCaeTC5I H C4MTaJI cnpaWHBaJI HX Hy noyeMY BM OHH nOCTaB5IT Y TaKHe Hy a lIa e BO n1 lTaJIC5I CnOpHTb C 3THMH JIJOllbMH TOJIbKO nO-BoeHHOMY rOBOp5lT XOJIOllHOA' nOCICOJIbKY HHlCorlIa OTKaSI IBaJrnCb mlCJIHTb nOHTHyeCHlCMH KaTerOpH5IMH COBeTcKHrt COJOS - Ho Bcerlla 3Ta OlIHa cTpaHa 3TO 6 IJIO yaCTbJO H HHKorlla 51 He BepHJI HanaCTb Ha COellHHeHHl le DJTaTII 3anallHoA' EBpOnl l cTPaIDI Hy 4'1'0 1'11 1 npellnpHMeM npoTMB 3TOil CTPaHIoI BOT TaKa51 CHTYaUH5I • • B ICTYnaeT B eCJIH 3TOT 06pa3 npHHMMaeTC5I TIIC5IYH 1I0KYMeHTOB KaK 1'11 1 6YlleM lleiilcTBOBaTb npoTIffi COBeTcKoro COlO3a 3TH JIJOllH 61 1 61 1 M I BoeBaJrn C 3TOA' CTpaHoA' eCJIl1 Tenepb MHe KOTop le MI I nJIaHHpyeM onepaUHH HJIH JIJ060tl YT06I 1 3TY np06JIeM v HCOJIbSOBa rIH BO BceA' HaweA' BoeHHO-nOJIHTHYeCKoA' iTO eCTb 060pOHlITeJIbHI le CHillI B paSYMffiIX npelleJIax 6es -14­ BC5IKHX 06pa 30B KOTOpLle HaHOC5IT CTOJIbKO Bpella ECTb eme ollHa rrp06JIeMa KOTOpa51 51BJI5IeTC5I cepbe3HbIM rrperr5lTCTBHeM ECJIM Y Bac eCTb 3TH XwrpOYMHJ le rrJIaH 1 Be ueHMSl BoRHiI rrpOTHB Koro-Hl16ylIb BoRHa HaYHHaeT Ka 3aTbC5I HeU36e KHoCTbIO 11 KaK TOJIbKO BLI rrpHHHMaeTe HeM36e »cHOCTb BoAHLI BLI lleJIaeTe ee HeM36e HoA ll e eCJIM OHa TaKOBoA Hl1Korlla paHbille He 6Lma nOHHMaeTe nOTOMY '-ITO BLI HaYMHaeTe OTTaJIKHBaTbC5I OT ee HeH36elKHOCTM 11 Torlla TO '-ITO paHbille 6LIJIO TOJIbKO B03MO KHOCTblO BLI HaYMHaeTe rrpeBpamaTb B HeU36elCHOCTb Bce 3TO rOBOplO YT06LI 06h5lCHMTb KOHCepBaTMBHOe MI lillJIeHMe BpeneH XOJIOllHOA BOHHLl KOTopoe cymeCTBOBaJIO B COellMHeHHl lX illTaTax M 51 He COMHeBaIOCb cymecTBOBaJIO 311eCb TOlKe B orrpelleJIeHHLIX Kpyrax rro KpaAHeA Mepe CYllleCTBOBaJIO JIM OHO Korlla-HM6Yllb B Hapolle - 3Toro 51 He 3HalO 311eCb 51 llYMalO B MeHbilleA CTerreHM yen Y Hac HO B 3TOM 3aK YaeTC5I orraCHOCTb c2 llJIH Me 61YHapOllHLlX OTHOilleHMH BIoi 3HaeTe lla Y Hac eCTb HaCTpoeHl151 TaKHe BOT rrpOTHB 6LICTpOrO pa30pYlCeHMH rrpOTMB lleMHJIMTapM3aUMH KOTopaH MlleT B CTpaHe BTO rrpaB lla HO 51 He llYMalO '-ITO 3TO OyeHb CMJIbHaH rpyrrrra 3TO - B OrrpelleJIeHHOA YacTM cpe llM Boe rrOCKOJIbKY 3aTParHBa1OTC5I HX MHTepeCLI B orrpe lleJIeHHoA yaCTH rrpOMI lillJIeHHOrO KOMrrJIeKca Mo eT 6LITb TaKoro rrporraraHllHCTCKoro arrrrapaTa KOTOpLIH TOlCe Ha 3TOM TaK CKa 3aTb 3apa6aTIIBaeT lleHbrM H lCH BeT BOKpyr 3Toro HO Ha caMOM-TO lleJIe H llalCe OHM OTCTaHBa51 Heo6xo llMMOCTb apM BoopYlCeHMA Bcepbe3 He BepHT '-ITO MOlCeT Bot Ha TaM 6LITb Tn HellaBHO y Hac 06cYJKllaJIC5I Borrpoc 0 KOHBepCill1 H BOT Y MeH5I 6LIJI pa3rOBOp C BOeHHLIMH C rrpOM3BOllMTeJIHMH OpYJKMH OHM TaM HaMeTMJIM CKOJIbKO COKpaTHTb TaHKOBLIX 3aBolloB KaK COKpaTMTb KOJIH 'YeCTBO TaHKOB rrpOM3BOllHML CrrpOCMJI OIlHoro caMoro rJIaBHOrO TaHKOBoro KOHCTpYKTopa A 3ayeM BOT 3TH TaHKH Bellb HMeeTCH B BH llY BLI rrpOCTO MeXa HMyeCKH COKpamaeTe TaM B llBa-TpM pa3a npOM3BollcTBO TaHKOB Ho 3Ha4MT OCTaBillMeCSl TaHKH KOTopLle B I 6Y lleTe npoM3BollMTb HMelOT KaKoe-TO ueJIeBOe Ha3HayeHMe Hy CKaJKeM BH llHMO BIoi c06HpaeTeCb aTaKOBaTb KaKYIO-TO CTpaHY 3aXBaTMTb ee KaKYIO CKaXHTe HaM Torlla MOlCeT 6LITb Hallo 60JIbille TaHKOB a He TaK MaJIO HeT rOBopMT MI l HM Ha Koro He C06HPaeMCH Hana llaTb Y Hac TaKHX nJIaHOB HeT Torlla 3ayeM BaM TaHKM 3HaeTe OH He MOJKeT OTBeTHTb Ha aTOT Borrpoc To eCTb cpa3Y 51 BaM OTBeyalO Ha TO O BLI paCCKa3aJIH OH He MOJKeT OTBeTHTb Ha 3TOT Borrpoc HO MHepUMSl Ml MJIeHM5I BOT YJKe npHo6peTaeT CBOIO JIOrHKY 3a MHOrHe rODLI OHa YJKe leaK 61 1 caMoBocnpOH3BOll5lmaSlCH HaBepHoe aTO HaDo nepeBeCTH JIOrHKa JIOrHKa nepeBoll Self-reproducing inertia of thinking intself CBOSl logic in -15­ TaK BOT 3TOT BOeHrn annapaT 3HaquT - 3TO HHCTpYMeHT nOnMTMKH HO TaKO HHCTpYMeHT KOTOPL CaM K co aneHMro nOBeneBaeT HaM 4TO OCTasaeTCH a 4T0 HM caMMM BOCnOnHHeTCH nOHHMaeTe na KOHe4HO 3TO KaK 370 BepHO TeHHHCH1 paKeTKa KOTopaH ananeeT HrpOKOM BMeCTO Toro l fT06I 1 HrpOK BnaneeT ero MnM KaK MI l rOBopMM HHorna He c06aKa XBOCTOM ynpaBnHeT a XBOCT c06aKO ce 4ac Ho KOHe4HO Mbl rOBOpHM 06 3TOM KaK 06 HCTOpM4HOM Bonpoce A cerOnHH Korna BHnHO 4T0 Bo a Me nY 60nbWHMM pa3BMTbIMM 3Ha4HT TeXHH4eCKH Pa3BI1TIIMH cTpaHaMH 4TO 3TO ne cTBMTenbHo Tenepb KaK cOBepweHHo npaBHnbHo rOBopHn HeonHoKpaTHo rOp6a4eB 3TO npOCTO He HMeeT CMbICna HHKTO HH B npM KaKHX 06CTOHTeJIbCTBaX He MO eT BLMrpaTb OT TaKO BO LI Tenepb 3TH BonpOCLI KOTOpI le Mbl C BaMH ce 4ac 06CY naeM 0 CMbICne BoeHHLIX CHn 04eHb Ba KHI le 5I KOHe1 ffiO rOTOB BHneTb 4T0 60JlbWaH CTpaHa HH Barna HH Harna He MO KeT OCTaBaTbCH COBeprneHHO 6e3 BoeHHoro TaK CKa3aTb annapaTa He 3Haro KaK 3TO 2 DOTeHUHana Ha4aJ1bHO KOHe4HO Y Bac nOJlXHa 6LITb KaKaH-TO nporpaMMa nonrOTOBKH Y Bac nOJIl HJ 1 6LITb JIIO lU1 KOTopJ le Koe-4TO 3HalOT 0 BO He 3TO nOJUHO nponOJDKaTbCH 11 Mbl nOJDKHJ I Ha TH TaKHe nYTH llnH 3Toro KOTopLle He pa3 KHraJIH 6 nOl103pHTeJIbHOCTb B JIIOllSlX Don03pMTeJlbHOCTb B03HHKaeT TaM rlle 4TO-TO llenaeTCSl B Ta e 5I nYMaro MI l BnnOTHYro nOllOWAH K 3TOMY nO-MoeMY cerOllHSl B rpynne eCTb npenJIO eHHH no cpenCTBaM CBH3H H XeJIbCKHKCKO KOHTaKTaM Me ny reHepaJIbHLIMH lliTa6aMH MOlCeT 6I ITb OHH nOMorYT npeonOJIeTb Bce 3TO 11 3TO 04eHb BaIRO MLI nOJlj HJ 1 HaY4HTbCSl Bawa CTpaHa Hawa CTpaHa llPyrHe BeAHKHe nep KaBJ I KaK nonnepj HBaTb YMepeHH1I H pa3YMHLlii BOeHmIA nOTeHUHan oco6eHHO B03MO HOCTH no npH3Lmy H nonrOTOBKe nroneR a BoeHHoe BpeMH nOTOMY 4T0 Benb HHKorna He 3Haellib nOCMOTpHTe cerOnHH Ha BJlHXHHA BOCTOK T04Hee CpenHHR BOCTOK - CHTYau»Sl TaM HaKaneHa DanbWe HeKyna HeJIb3Sl 3apaHee npenBHneTb Korna 3Ta CHTYaU»H 3aTpOHeT BoeHHLle HHTepeCJ 1 ToR HJIH HHO CTpaHLI B CBeTe HLiHewHeA cHTYaIUrn Be TIHKHM nep aBaM KaK Bawa 11 -16­ Hawa 04eHb Ba O nOnnep r HBaTb TeCHYW H nOBepHTenbHYID CBH3b 4T06LI Y Me r ny HaMM He B03HHKaJIO HHKaKMX HenonOHHMaHHR HaC4eT HaWHX HaMepeHHtf MorYT B03HHKHYTb H npyrMe non06HLle cwryaUMM KoTopLle l-HJl HaneWCL HeJlb3H ' 'T 3arpOHYTb H BalIIH H HaIlIH BoeHIDle HHTepeCLI 3Toro He np0H30RneT lIa H Bo061Ile npuHuune Ho HCKJIID4aTb TaKoR BepOHTHOCTH 6J lJlo 61 1 He r eJIaTeJIbHo KaK MHe Kal«eTCH B OCTaBJIHTb BeJIHKYro nep r aBY 6e3 BoeHHoro nOTeHUMaJIa nOToMY 4T0 Hapon 3Toro He noRMeT 4YBCTBO 6e30naCHOCTH HO ml EMY He06xonHMO onpeneJIeHHOe nOJI%HJ 1 6LITb Ha4eKY 4T06LI He nonYCTwrb B03HHKHOBeHHH He3nopOBoR nOn03pHTeJIbHOCTH He3 uopOBoro OTHoweHH51 leale 3TO npOH30WJIO BO BpeM51 XOJIonHoR BoAHbI MHe Ka r eTC51 4TO 3TO 4HCTO Hawa np06JIeMa Ho 3TO Mo r eT 6LITb HO 3TO BpeMeHHO 51 nYMaID B 1e0HUe KOHUOB IlCHXOJlOrl-Hi JIlOnCKa5I Kale-TO oToRneT OT Bcex 3THX MHJIHTapMCTCKHX nYTeR MLIWJIeHH51 Hanerocb MHe Kal«eTC51 nOBOJlbHO naJIeKO y r e 3aWJlO 4TO Ha 3anane B EBpOIle 8TO lIa-na 51 6LIJl Il03aB4epa B BepJIHHe B TOT 3HaMeHHTLIR neHb 6I IJI B HeCKO IeO 4aCOB npOBeJI B TOJIne H 51 He 04eHb 6ecnOKOWCb Ha 3TOT C4eT 4TO KaCaeTC5I HeMlleB H 4TO KaCaeTC5I MOJIOnOro nOKOJIeHM51 Bo061Ile OHM HMeroT npyrHe CJla60CTH HO BOT MHJlMTapMCTCKoro M1IWJleHHH He cYlIleCTByeT BepJlHHe H lIa-na Y Hac ceR4ac To r e 04eHb CHJIbHI 1 TeH ueHUHH nepepHeHTMpOBaTb nOJIHTHKY B CTOpOl-1Y' 3alIlHTLJ OKp 'noowe cpenLl YBCUCaTb 4eJlOBe4eCTBO nOHHTb 4T0 4eJIOBe4eCKTO - 3TO BeHeu M 3a uYMaTbC51 0 TOM 4T0 OHO neJlaeT C nJIaHeToR 3neCb BaM To r e HY%HO Koe-4TO H3MeHHTb HO Ie C4aCTbW MHOrHe MOJlOnLle JIrollH EBpone OHH TaK MHe Kal«eTC51 rrOCTYnaroT CMOTp51T Ha 3TO TaK r e 51 3Haro B 51 JIeTOM OTlII JXaro B HOpBerHM H 3HaeTe KaK 3TO 4T0 MOJlOnLJe HopBe r UI J npOCTO He nOHHMaroT MO r HO Ha KorO-TO HanaCTb 3TO npOCTO HeB03MO r H0 llJI51 HMX Ho OHM 04eHb XOT51T nOBepHYTb nOJIHTMKY B CTOpOHY 3aIIIM'n1 OKpy r aIDmet cpenI l M 3TO n03BOJl51eT Hane51TCH Ha 6ynywee 3T0 HY r HO BCH4eCKH noowp51Tb nOTOMY 4T0 3TO BepHJ 1R IlYTb BOIOCb 4TO yqemle rrpaBLl KorlIa npenynpe r nalOT npHpOlIe 4T0 eCJIH ml H lIaJIbWe 6yneT TaK OTHOCMTbC51 K TO Bp51n JIH npOCYIIleCTByeM eme CTO JIeT BTo cepbe3HO -17­ oc06eHHO n H HaWHX BHYKOB np0H30we netiCTBHTe bHO Q BI I 3HaeTe BOT Y HaC cetiy ac B CTpaHe nOBopOT B C03HaHHH Cetiy ac Y Hac HeB03MOXHO npOCTO nCHxo orHY eCKH nO UTMY eCKH COUHanbHO HeB03MO%H0 nOc aTb CKa «eM BoeHHl 1X 3a rpaHMUl 1 Haweti CTpaHl l Ec Ha Hee He HanaJIl1 KOHeY HO HeB03MO «HO BOT cetiYac Hac oy eHb y aCTO cnpawI1BaIOT A KaK BI I c06HpaeTeCb B J 1paK noc aTb C06MpaeMC5I MI l H He c06HpaeMC5I - MI I 3HaeM OnHO '-ITO 3TO HeB03MOXHO 3T0 6yneT npOTeCT no Bce cTpaHe He pa3pewaT nH He pd3pewaT 3T0 Me nY npoY MM noc e A raHHCTaHa noc e J2 B pe3Y bTaTe A raHHCTaHa YBune Bce HecnpaBennHBOCTb BOtiHiI 6e30TBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3Toro mara 61 mwero pYKOBonCTBa CTpaHl I Oy eHb orpOMHoe nBM t eHMe BOT MaTepeti noru6WHX TaK CKa3aTb TaM B A4 raHMCTaHe A r aBHoe ­ 6eCCMI IC eHHOCTb 3Toro ne a 6eccmIC eHHOCTb BOT ce 4ac pe6HTa 3TH a raHw I OHM Me '-lYTC5I C onHO CTOPOHiI OHM neticTBHTe HO Bl mO H CBoti no r 3TO co naT Han HUM 61 1 o PHuep - OH Bl mO 51 CBO no r A C npyroti CTOpOHl I OH BepHY CH H OKa3a rIC5I Bpolle KaK 61 1 nOll 06weCTBeHHiIM Te eCKonOM '-ITO OH Bpolle lle a rI '-ITO-TO He TO ne aJI n oxoe J 1 BOT 3THX pe6HT O lla e BOT Tex BepHYBWHXC5I nOHUMaeTe H BOT ce Y ac CKa eM noc aTb KorO-TO BoeBaTb rlle-TO Y Hac • HeB03MO%H0 HeB03MOIHO nOHUMaeTe TaKoti CHnbHl nOBopOT B C03HaHMH BTopoe KOHe4HO BI I npaBJ Ml 1 Bce B 06weM-TO nOCTapa Cb B6HTb B rO OBY nroneti B Toti H llPyroti CTpaHe BOT 3TY B3aHMHYIO onaCHOCTb J 1 Ha caMOM lle e KaK paccYXllaJI P5l110Boti COBeTcKHti Y e OBeK AMepHKaHCKHe BoticKa P5l110M B EBpone HellaJIeKO OT HaillHX rpaHMU U 3TO HeMell eHHO HaK allJ maJIOCb Ha Onl lT C repMaHMeti COpOK nepBoro - COpOK n5lTOrO rOlla BOT 3Ta nCHXo orHH CTPaxa OHa KOHe '-lHO nOllrr ma a H rrHTaJIa 60nbillHe onaceHHH He TO '-ITO CKO KO AMepHKa rrpOH3BOllHT rrymeK TaM caMo eTOB ewe '-ITO-TO a BOT TO '-ITO BoticKa pHllOM HeHY HOCTb 3TO 1 f lTO TYT-BOT - TaHI H TYT - paKenl BOT PHllOM C Haweti CTPaHoti 3T0 C OllHOti CTOpOHl I 6I 1 0 peaJIbHl IM 4»aKTopoM cTpaxa peanbHI IM a C llPyroti CTOpOHI I orrpelle eHHI le JUOllH H nOJlb30B Cb 3THM B HapaWUBaHHH BoOpy eHHti 6eCKOHeY HOM 11 oy eHb y aCTO HeHY%HOM KOJIW-leCTBe BoOpYXeHHti Halle aTb 63 nlCH4M TaHKOB - HHKTO Bellb ceti '-lac Ha Mo eT 06b5lCHHTb ll H 4ero 3TO 3T0 HCHO '-ITO 6I illa HHepUHH Bl mYCKa TaHI OB TaHKH TaHKH TaHKH -18­ BLI 3HaeTe 3epKaJIbHOe OTpa teeHHe TOrO 4T0 BLI rOBopwre cymeCTBOBaflO C HaWe CTOpOHLI MO teeT 6LITb npeYBenH eHHOe HO BCe-TaKH HaKOnJIeHHe COBeTCKMX BOtiCK B BOCT04HO EBpOne 3aK mO eHl1e 3Ha T Hana uemUI Ha 3ana uHI le CTpaHLl ' J M11-TO Bo06me ueticTBOBarrH COBepWeHHO 3epKaJIbHO B OTHOWeHI1H upyr upyra Y BaC O-TO M306peTeHO - HeMe uJIeHHO Y Hac 6pocalOTCSI Bce CH TJ1 I Ha TO 06LI nOJI H Y Hac TO tee caMoe 3aqeM HI1KTO Be ub He OT uaBaJI ce6e o eTa 3a eM aTO HY «HO Ho BOT o 61 1 Y Hac 6J IJIO TO tee caMoe CTOJlbKO tee eCnH He 60JIbwe HaBepHoe reHepaJIJ 1 HaCTaHBaIDT Ha 60JIbWeM KOHe o J Ha 60JIbWeM aTo SICHO COBepmeHHo Ho CJIaBa Eory aTa 3noxa npOlliJla XOTSI C03HaHHe BOT MeH BOJIHYeT np06JIeMa 3HaeTe Bce aTO rOBOpHJI no nOBO uy Bawero Bonpoca 06 06meCTBeHHOM MHeHl1I1 B AMepHKe 2 lIa nOHHMalO uYMalO O 3TO He OqeHb Cepbe3H1 m Bonpoc H uYMaIO 3TO 60JlbWe Bonpoc npaBMTeJIbCTBa H nOJIMTHKI1 BHelliHe nOJIl1THKI1 3TO KOHe o He l1 ueT OT Hapo ua H KacaeTC 3TO BJIM HH KOHrpecca BJIH HH nOJlHTH4eCKHX KpyroB uetiCTBMTeJlbHO uetiCTByeT 3 ueCb M 3TO HHor ua nyqwe HHor ua xy «e 06meCTBeHHOrO MHeHH ElIlBaIDT BpeMeHa 6J IBanH BpeMeHa He uaBHO Kor ua BJIHSIHHe KOHrpecca Hd npaBMTeJlbCTBO 6J IJIO OqeHb nOJIe3HO BJ lBaJrn upyrHe CJIyqaM B Haweti I1CTOpI1l1 r ue aTO xy tee 6J IJIO r ue KOHrpecc 6J IJI 60JIee BoeHHO HaCTpoeH qeM caM npe3H ueHT JI Bce paBHO y Hac y «e npOSIBJI eTCSI f y Hac nOSIBnSIeTCSI MMHMcTepCTBO HHOCTPa ueJl BHeCJIO npe uJIO teeHHe 0 uorOBopax 0 npeKpameHHH uorOBopa 0 COTPy uH eCTBe BoeHHO nOMOmH H T u KaK OH Ha3J rnaeTCSI craP A C repMaHCKoti f'epMaHHeti lIeMoKpaT ecKoti Pecny6JIHKoti J TaK B BepxoBHoM COBeTe pa3ropeJlaCb BOCT04Hoti u CKYCCH o -19­ npaBHTenbCTBO He 3a60THTc 0 nOCTaTOYHO WHTepeC11 nOJUITHKY Be neT H BO CKax nYCTb T n TaK 04eHb eCTKHMM XOTSI He B OTCTaHBaeT HacrpoelH1 ewe Hapone CJIoe 3al1HTepeCOBaHH11X 1O neti He O TaeTCH neCKaTb O O OnSlTb e B O 3a OCTalOTCSI TaKHMI1 onpene eHHOM H 3TO 611CrpO Ho 3TO npoti neT npoPineT Iii Tor na OCTaHYTCH npyrl1e 60JIbUll1e 51 HanelOCb f EOJIbWl1e Y Bac np06 eml MellCny 6y nYIIllifM 11 npOWJILIM B 3Toro np06 eMLI no Mepe Toro - 11 npH 3TOM KOTopaSi 6yneT HaneqaTaHa B cne nYlOweM MeCSlue B BotlHLI npenOCTaBJIHeTCH B03MO OCTb B3rnHHYTb ee nOJIHOM 06beMe HarrHca ' · cTaTbH 3TH Ho 1 OlUi BHOBb B03H HKalOT nOMOIIlbW COBeTCKoro Hapona CTaTbe ' KaK HaqaJIO Bocnonb30BaTbCSI CTaTblO OPI1H A l $epc teYpHaJIe nOTOMY O 3TO 6y nYT Bametl crpaHe Bce 3TH BonpOC11 BCTalOT cetiqac Ha COBeTCKYro I1CTOPl1ro B J np06JIeml 6ynywero POCCl1l1 11 CBH311 CTO eTI1j i nHTHanuaTOro oco6eHHO BonpOC11 npellCHI1X np06 eml 3 lleCb X cTaTbH X 11 3Ta CTaTb5J 6LI a Hanl1CaHa B KaK 6Llno 3anYMaHO 1917 BepHYTbcH K nOKo eHHe 3TO rony nOTOMY qrO llPyrMe JIl nH 113MeHI1JIMCb BMeCTe C HeKOTOpLIMH 1-13 np06neM nOllxOnl 1 K KaK H Torna llYMdlO 11 np06 eMlI POCCI1I-1 M 3TO HO Bce paBHO 191 7 BMeCTe BC 191 7 3TO H rOllY C npl1lleTC5J BHOBb BpeMeHa CT l1Ha lUi He nYMalO qTO Ha 3THX np06JIeMax MO O qeMY-TO Iii 3TO MeHH 60JIbme Bcero l1HTepecyeT KaK I1CTOpHKa qr0611 qrO-TO B OHI1 nepeMeHaMM BO rona Morn 51ITb TOYHO TaKHMM- e CTOI1T 113Y 4l1Tb CTOnLITII1HCKl1e pe«t opml nJIH Toro - He COBceM Te e caMLle MeHH OqeHb HHTepeCyeT 1l06pOCOBeCTHO I1X BOCnpOI13BeCTH d 3Ta xo ollHofi Ho HeCMOTPSI Ha 3TO KOTopLle CTOSl B pemeHillO np06 eM HaYqHTbCH a cetiqac e npyroe KOHeqHO nOCKOJ1bKY l1X Henb3H 61InO pemaTb HH BO npH BpellCHeBe KOHlle qrO HYXHo C llenaTb pa3Bl1THeM TeXHl1KH BHeillHeM MMpe 11 nepeMeHdMM B pemdTb nOnOJIHeHl1e K XOJIO nHOtl Bomul 6yneT ony6 mucoBaHa B I13BeCTHOM cmlc e Bce B I1neT B 11 51 06 3TOM r SlnH Ha BeCb nepl10n KOMMYHl1CTHqeCKotl BJIdCTH H Bl1l1CY qrO B KaK 61 1 Haqane 51 B HlICY HO nJ1S1 Toro H 06LI nOTOMY qrO BpeMeHa cetiYac npyrl1e HHX nOqepnHYTb M HaBepHoe 1C0e-qTO nOJIe3HOe 06 YCTdHOBneHl1H napJIaMeHTCKHX «t OpM npaanelUiH MO HO Y3HdTb 113Y4l1B OnI IT nocne nHl1X JIeT uapcKoro pelGfMa BLI 3HaeTe H nOHl1MdlO CJIO OCTH Hanrn B HaCTOHlQee BpeMH OqeHb cepbe3IDle -20­ J 04eHb rny60KHe Bbl 3HaeTe eCnH HX aHarrH3HpOBaTb TO He Bcerna na e 3HaeWb 4eMY OTnaTb npenn04TeHHe 0 npH4HHe 3TUX C O HOCTe TO H 3KOHOMHKe TO nH no e TO nH HCTOpHH TO nH nCHxonorHH TO nH OTBep eHHW HenaBHero npow oro HoO Bce 3TO TaK nepeMewaHO nCHxo orHH nOBnHHna Ha n o y n o a - Ha nCHxonorHW HO MeHH 60nbwe Bcero BOnHYeT Bonpoc 4TO Hapon Haw ceR4ac BOT nonan To e B TparenHnHyw no ocy Pa3BMTHH r 1 ll04eMY nOHHMaeTe na e Ha npOTH eHHH 3Toro CTOneTHH PeBonroUHH 1905 rona peBonwUHH eBpanbcKaH peBonwUHH OKTH6pbcKaH rpa naHcKaH Bo a KOnneKTHBH3aUHH HHnYCTpHanH3aUHH 37-o ron CO BceMH np ocawmHMH K 3TO Y rony neCHTHneTHHMH BoRHa rrocneBoeHHaH rnOTOK KaKOn-TO He06I NHoi1 CB060 ll1 1 llnH Hawero 4enOBeKa BO BpeMH XpyweBa nOTOM - KpM3MC pa3BHTHH n04eMY lla nOTOMY 4TO y e Ha4 0 paCTH Bne4aT JleHHe 4TO TaK lla bWe Henb3H a KaK HY O HTb HHKTO He 3Han cMerocb nOTOMY 4T0 T04HO BOT BI I ceR4ac CKa3anM 9T0 Bce HanHcaHO B 3TO CTaTbe KOTOpYID H y e HanHC Ha4HHaH C peBonroUHH 1905 rona paCCKa 3 IBaH 0 Bcex Tex oenax KOTOpl le HCrr ITl ffian H Hec Ha cBoen cnHHe cOBeTcKMM Hapon J Tparen HOn n04eMY H roBopw 0 nonoce llOTOMY 4T0 eMY WOK H eMY HanO nOHHTb Korna ero ooMaHLmanM a Korna OH Ben rrpaBenHYID 60Pb6y HCKpeHHroro qeCTHYID Korna OH 3a6J1Y n CH a Korna Y Hero Ol lnH KaKHe-TO TaK CKa3aTb np03peHHH Ha 6Ynywee Me4Tl 1 H Bce TaKoe M Bce 3TO BOT ceti4ac c anOCb BO BpeMeHM BOT ceH4ac BOT OTCWna Bce 3TH CTpaCTH H HaUHOH HCTH4eCKHe cenapaTHCTCKHe cnop 1 no 3KOH0MH4eCKHM BonpocaM TO nH OCTaBMTb cTapyro MOnenb TO nH HOBYro KaKYW-TO Monenb eCnH HOBYW TO KaKYW Y HO £ J nepe Tb BOT 3TO rnaBHI Borrpoc eCnH HOBYro TO OTKyna no a TpaHcrr aHTaUHro KaKaH OHa 6l ITb Henb3H CnenaTb npHMO BOT B3HTb aMepHKaHCKYID MnM maenCKYID MnH repMaHCKYW npHMO BOT TaK Ha Hawy n04BY Henb3H A nOTOM Ha KaKYro n04BY Ha PYCCKYID HnH Ha TyPKMeHcKYro MnM Ha TanIHKCKYro H Ha Y30eKCKYro HnM Ha cH6HPCJCYro BM e 3HaeTe Bce pa3HOe Y Hac pa3HLle CTaPTOBI le YC OBHH pa3HI le YC OBHH Pa3BHTHH pa3HaH nCHxonorHH pa3HaH peJIHrMH Pa3ffiIti KYnbTYPffi rA yPOBeHb Benb npHBHBKH nenaroTCH OT JCaKoA-TO 60 e3HH KOHKpeTHOn a Henb3H npOCTo TaK A I 3THX npHBHBoK nopoA He 3HaeM Y Hac MX npOCTO -21­ HeT KpOMe Taro KpH3MC 3ame HaCTOnbKO D eKO 4T0 6L a rrOTepHHa MaTepH bHaH 6a3a BeDb COBepweHHO Dpyro pa3rOBOp 6LI ce Yac weJI Ha DpyroM 6LI yPoBHe npeDCTaBbTe ce6e DorrYCTHM eC M 61 Y Hac Ha rromcax B Mara3MHax Bce 6LI O B rropHDKe 102IH 6l 1 He HYJKDa Jll1Cb BO '-iTO ODeTbC5i y JIroDetl 6LlJUf KBapTHpLI r De Tb a BOT yeJIOBeK Haw rrpH 3TOM HCTOpHYeCKOM rrOBopOTe De CTBHTe bHO HCTOpHYeCKOM K cB06oDe DeMOKpaTHH K 2IOCTOMHCTBY K 3DpaBOMY CMI IC OH rrpHllie 6e3 KBapTHp He OyeHb-TO xopOWO TaK CKa3aTb eMY C TOYKH 3peHHH rrHTaHHH eMY HaDo B OyepeDHX CTOHTb TPaHcnOpT rrJIOXo DpyrMe XH3HeHffiI HeYD06cTBa 3KO OrHyeCKaH 06CTaHOBKa THJKe aH '-iTO HH rop02I ­ TO TaM DLm H cpaM B CenbCKOM X03HRcTBe B TyrrHK 3aWnH C 3TOR CHCTeMO Ye oBeK caM no ce6e Pa3YYH CH pa60TaTb OH CKopee XOyeT rro YYMTb OTKYDa Y Hac BOT 3TOT WYM 0 npHBH erHHX DYMdro Y KorO-TO 6lol TU1 KaKHe-TO npHBH erHH HO mYMY 60nbille yeM rrpHBH erH nOyeMY OT 3Toro rrCHXo orHH pacnpe2IenHTenbCTBa rrYCTb 6YDeM Bce HHII1He HO paBHbl M KaK TO KO Y KorO-TO nOHBHTCH Ha TLICHyY PY6JIe 60 we 3TO YJKe Dpyro 3TO ­ aMepI1JCaHeu aTo f rrpeODo eTb THJKe o BIoI 3HaeTe THj e o Ho DO yero BOT 3Ta HJKDHBeHyeCKa5i nCHxo orHH OHa Bbe aCb BbI 3HaeTe OyeHb KperrKO B nopllI yeJIOBeKa H 06IllecTBa Bcero M 3Decb MI I HaUUCaeMC5I Ha MHorMe rrpOTHBOpeYM5I KOHeYHo De aeM 01IIH6KM De aeM MI I caMM 3HaeM HeI136eJKHO De aeM clJHHaHcoBO lla oWH6KH H HHor Da rpy6Lle oc06eHHo B c4Jepe MloI pacrrycTM DeHbrM nOD HaJKHMOM ' BOT HeyeM 3apn aTY n aTHTb M 3MHCCMH TaM DBa-TPM MM apDa a 3TO Bce HeOTOBapeHHllle TOBapOB nOD cHH DeHbrH HeT Hy H BOT DeHbrH eCTb B CTPaHe Y De a KyrrHTb Heyero KaK 3TH DeHbrH B3HTb MIoI He 3HaeM eIlle rrOKa Ho ceAYac BOT nepBIl YKa3 Ope3HDeHTa cerODHH HarreyaTaH 0 nepBOOYepeDHL Mepax rro orrTOBO Toproane Mill DYMaeM 4T0 1I0roBopIDIe ueHLI 6yDYT B orrTOBoA ToprOB e Bce HMKaKHX YCTaHOB eHIDIX ueH lIpyrHe 6YDYT 00 HHoCTPaHHL MHBeCTHUHHX 6YDeT YKa3 0 cB060De npeDnpHHMMaTenbCTBa 6YDeT YKa3 TIpe3MDeHTa H 3aKOH 06 aHTm HUHoHID Mepax oYDeT aHTHMOMHOnOnbHIl 3aKOH nOTOMY 4T0 TaKHX MOHono KaK Y Hac 51 DYMalO aMepHKaHUaM Hac B 3TOM OTHOWeHHH He nOrHaTb Y Hac eCTb npennpMHTHH KOTopIole llMKTYIOT Bo06me H ueIDI M Bce rrOTOMY -22­ YTO OHO OnHO Ha BeCb COBeTCK COroB KaK Y Hac nonY OCb C 3TMM saBonOM B ApMeHMH BOT nnH Ta6aKa-TO HnbTPbl llenaeT IPHnb TpI 1 Onl1H saBon B ApMeHHH OCTaHOBI1JI CBOIO pa60TY - Bce T 6a'lHbIE 5 IITlol ne¢illlHT Ta6aYHloIX I1snenHti HenbSH TaK HanO HMeTb n060JIbllie TaKHX saBonOB HO 3TO Hano Bce nenaTb Tenepb MLI caMH BHY1l IHJIH YTO TaKoe pI IH04HaH 3KOHOMHICa 3T0 ­ 6espa6oTHua 3TO - XOTb H BpeMeHHoe HO naneHHe XH3HeHHoro yPOBHH 11 MI I 3TO BHYllianH B TeyeHHe ceMMneCHTH neT npOTHBOnOCTaBnHH COUHaJIH3M KanHTaJIH3MY H T n Tenepb Mil caMH ce6e CnenaJIH nOBYWKY Tenepb HaM npHXOnHTCH nOKa3bffiaTb YTO HeT He 6yneT 6espa60THml MI l KOMneHcaUHIO JKHSHeHHOro yPOBHH 6yneM KaK-TO npOH3BOlll b naBaTb lleHbrH nronHM KOMneHcHpyeM SaTpaTI I H T n H T n JlJo llH He BepHT BOT eme Y Hac np06neMa HeBepHH nroneti HellOBepHH H H nroneti nOHHMalO H caM rne-TO npo ce6H YBCTBYIO YTO MeHH To e HeCKOJIbKO pas 06MaHYnH ceflyac JIIOZUl nYMaIOT YTO 3TO Mo eT 61 ITb OYepenHoti 06MaH YTO Mo eT H sneCb YTO-TO He TaK BOT BHnHTe KaKoe HHTepecHoe HBneHHe BOT Mil CTanH rOBOpHTb a Bce Tpe60BanH MHTHHrH 61 IJm MHOrOnapTHfllioCTb MHOrOnapTH1hmocTb MHoro napTHti - 3TO XOpOlliO Hy nanHO MHoro napT MHoronapTHtiHocTb a napTHM He 06paSYIOTCH 11M HHKTO He MelliaeT 06paSOBJ IBaTbCH a HX aKTlf' eCKH HeT To eCTb OHH eCTb ManeHbKHe HO KTO 0 HHX YTO SHaeT H KaKoe BJIHHHHe OHH HMeroT - HeT nOyeMY Y e HenOBepHe K HHCTHTYTY napTHH KCTaTH He TO KO B Haweti CTpaHe HaCKOnbKO H nOHHMalO a H BeSne TaK CetiYac e 60 llie BepHT KaKHM-TO HeO¢OpMJIeHHI IM llB eHHHM sa YTO-HH6ynb 3KOJIOrHyeCKHM nB eH11HM seJIeHOMY nBH » eHHIO TaM yepH06 1JIbCKOMY llB eHHIO eme KaKOMY-TO nBH eHHlO BOT 3TO 60JIbllie nO llXonHT llJIH nIO llefi KaK 61 1 opraHHsaUHH no HHTepecaM napTHH - HeT TaK rOBopHT BOT H SHalO napTHH A YTo Mo eT OHa To e 06MaHeT H 3Ta naPTHH He XOyy CY l aTbCH C 8THM BOT ynpaBJIHTb ce AYac H 06wecTBeHHl IM MHeHHeM KaK-TO BJIHHTb Ha Hero cetiYac B YCJIOBHHX pa3BaJIeHHOrO nOTpe611TeJIbCKOrO pl lHKa orpOMHoti MaCC 1 lleHer Ha pYKax Y JIIOneti KOTOpl le C'be lIalOT Bce t 1 npH na lIeHHM npOH3BO lICTBa ynpaBnHTb H BnHHTb Ha 3TO 06meCTBeHHOe MHeHHe OyeHb CJIO » HO H Mil Bce BpeMH XO lIHM KaK 61 1 • no KpoMKe JIb lIa OTBaJIHTCH 3TOT KYCOK Ha KOTOpOM MI l CTOMM HJlH He OTBaJIHTCH - TaKHe BOT OJKH lIaHHH npHYeM ewe np06JleMa ­ 3TO OyeHb HH3KaH nOJIHTHyeCKaH KYJIbTYPa M I He Bb a60TanH ee • lIa H OTKY lIa eti HBHTbCH MHe y » e npHXO lIHJIOCb He Pa3 rOBOpHTb H nl1caTb YTO TbICH4Y neT PoccHeti npaBHJlH BCe-TaKH JIIO lIH a He SaKOHI I H cetiYac saKOHoB MHoro HO orpOMHa CTeneHb npaBOBoro HHrHJIHSMa YenOBeK npHSHaeT saKOH lIJIH lIpyr x HO He llJIH ce6H -23­ 3To He aJIyroCb a npOCTO paCCKa310rnaw TaK KaK OHO eCTb C KaKHMH TpYDHOCT MH HaM npHXODHTC BCTpeqaTbC B 3THX YCJIOBH X KOHe o 1 111 cetiqac nOJI KH11 B 60JIbweti CTeneHl1 qeM noc e XX Cbe3Da HY KDaeMC B KaKoti-To nODDepXKe B nOHHMaHHH Toro O Y Hac npo cxODHT nOqeMY BaM 3anaJI 3TOT Bonpoc OTHOCHTeJIbHO 06meCTBeHHOrO MHeHH B CiliA ero 3anaJI nOTOMY qTO qYBCTBYro o Ha 3anane eCTb KaKaH-TO HeYBepeHHOCTb TO JIM nOMoraTb TO JIH He nOMoraTb TO JI Bce TYT notineT Y Hac HOpMaJIbHO TO JIH HeYDaqH nOCJIeDYroT MO HO Y Ra nOMoraTb 9T0 OCTPaHHOH Dep KaBe HO B OqeHb OrpaHHqeHHOM MacWTa6e 3neCb np06JIeMa Y Bac C CTeMHa 3Ha T MI l nonpaBI1Tb 3TO He MO KeM KpH3 C f f ceJIbCICoro X03 tiCTBa HO 3TO HaDO DYMaTb nonpaBHTC TalC HJIH HHaqe Ho DOJIrOBpeMe KPH3 C Y Bac rJIY6 Ke MHe ICa eTC H 3TO TPYDHOCTH HYJKnaeTC Bo-nepB MHe TalC Ka KeTC BioI MeH nOnpaBHTe eCJIM 51 ourn6aWCb nOCJIenCTB SI Bcex 3THX neticTBHH 11 nOCJIenYIDmHX Bcex netiCTBHti OqeHb TSI Ke le nOTO Y O pa3pYWHJIaCb no H3BeCTHOH CTeneHH high degree pa3pYWHJIaCb ceMetlHa CTPYICTypa Y Bac 3HaquT cTpawffile 6 JIH nOTepl1 31IeCb Y CKOrO HaCeJIeHHSI BO BpeMSI Botim KpoMe Toro Bawa 6wpoICpaTH apMHSI sucked in how would you say oT6HpaIDT 60JIbwYro qaCTb Y KCKoro MOJIODorO HaCeJIeHH B nepeBHe HaCICOJIbICO I MO KeM BHDeTb TaM OqeHb OTCYTCTByeT My KClCa MOJIOne l eH1lll1HI I 1l0JI KHbI HeCTI1 ICOJIOCCaJIbHOe 6peM no BOCnHTaHHe lIeTeti 6e3 OTUOB qaCTO M Bce 3TO 3TO rJIY60ICMe nOBpe KlIeHHSI Bcero HaCeJIeHH fiOTOMY o no MoeMY JIH OMY y6e KDeHHID 8TO 1I0JI eH CKa3aTb no-aHrJIHAcKH PeaJIbHOe OmYmeHHe JIH4Hoti 6e30naCHOCTH nOJI KHO HCXODHTb M3 ceMbH Ero HeJIb3 HCICYCCTBeHHO C03DaTb OpraHM3aUMO MM MepaMH Ka DL Do eH ueHHTb 3HaqeHHe CeMbH coxpaH Tb ee MOPaJIbffiIti KJIHMaT 11MeHHO B ceMbe qeJIOBeKa 06yqawT a JIWDeti HY O yqHTb npO BJISlTb HHHUMaTHBY 6paTb Ha ce6 OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a CBOH DetiCTBHSI He TOJIbKO 3a DeticTBHSI B 06meCTBe HO H 3a JIH oe nOBeneHHe BceMY 3TOMY 610IJI HaHeceH 3Ha eJIbmlti YlQep6 B TeQelUfe DeC THJIeTHti BaweR TapHr QeCKoti CTOpHH Pe lleT He ToJIbICO 0 nepeMeHax B nOnMTHqeCKoti snaCTH HO 06 YIacax BTOPOti MHpOBoti BOAHLI ICOToplole nepe kKTlI-t BaWM JUOlI KOToploie npaK QeCK He HMeIDT aHaJIOrOB B qeJIOBeqeCICoti CTOpHH Bce 3 rJIY60ICHe cnBHrH npOH3Belle Ie B COBeTCICOM 06meCTBe Heo6xOlIHMO HHBeJIMpOBaTb H BIo aCTHTb HOBoe nOICOJIeHHe B 60JIee HOpMaJIbffilX YCJIOBH X B 60JIee HOPMaJlHIo llPYJKeCICHX YCJIOBHSlX 061oI Y HHX 610lJIH CeMbH HaCTO mMe CeMbH OTUIoI MaTep JU060Bb 51 CMOTpW -24­ Ha 3TH np06JIemi CO CTOpOHlol H nOHHMalO 4T0 3TO ZIe CTBl1ebJIbHO OrpOMHlole CJIOJKHI Ie np06JIeml KaK 3TO 6Y ZIeT npOHCXO ZIHTb YeM-TO 3aWHTO CeMbH nOJKaJIY ZIOJIJKHa 3aHHMaTbC uepKOBb He TOJIbKO xpHCTHaHCKa HO H ZIPyrHe uepKBI1 He TOJIbKO npoTecTaHTLl HO H Bce ZIpyrHe BK mOt ra H peJIHrH03HLIe ceKTLI DpeJK ZIe Bcero uepKOBb ZIO Ha HayqHTb JIID ZIe TOMY KaK OTHOCHTbC ZIJIpyr K ZIpyry Hayql1Tb HX CaMOyaaJKeHHIO Bce Ha ZIO HaqJfHaTb C caMoro HaqaJIa C H YJI nOTOMY 4T0 CJIHIIIKOM BeJII1K ymep6 HaHeceHHL C0611T11T MJ1 0 lCOTOpLIX BLI paCClCa31 IBaJIH - BOtiHoti C SInmrneti BTOPOti MMpOBOti BotiHoti HeClCOJIblCl1MM peBOJIIOUMHMH PemaTb 3TH np06JIemi 6Y lleT MHoro TPY llHee qeM B HOpMaJIbHLIX YCJIOBI1 X H C HOpMaJIbffilM HapO ZIOM 3HaeTe eCJIH 6LI MeH cnpOCI1JII1 '-ITO C' lliTaro Hal160JIee cePbe3HLIM Ymep60M HaHeCeHHLIM pel HMOM CTa mrna '-IacTM'-IHo EpeJKHeBa BarneMY HapO ZIY 61 1 OTBeTMJI 4T0 ymep6 3aKJIro6qaJIC He B TOM qrO OHM HenOCpe ZICTBeHHO C ZIeJIaJIH JIro ZIHM a BTOM BO qrO OHM npeBpaTHJIH JIl l lleti B TOM 4T0 OHI1 JIHII Il1JIM I1X cnOC06HOCTH BI1 lleTb peaJIbHLle np06JIeMLI 6Y ZIYlIlero ilOHHMaeTe CeMb ZIeC T JIeT nO llaBJIeHH JII060ti JIM4Hoti HHHUI1aTHB1J JII060ro npOHBJIeHHH JII14HOCTI1 B1 1 nOHl1MaeTe 5I lla KOHeqHO K 3T0 61 IJIO Qpe3B1 lqatiHo onaCHO ZIJI o6111eCTBeHHO aTMoceJlep11 11 nOHI1Maro KaK TPY ZIHO BaM cetiqac Bce 3TO HCnpaBJIHTb B11 cpe ZI11 npoqero ynoMHHYJII1 CKenTHUI13M JIID ZIeti llHHI14HOCTb OHI1 CqI1TaIOT '-ITO OT napTHti H npaBHTeJIbCTBa HHqerO xopomero JK ZIaTb He npI1XO llI1TC 3T0 YJKaCHO HO He 3HalO lCaK peWHTb 3TY npo6JIeMY He 3Haro KaK BOCCTaHOBI1Tb ZIOBepl1e B03MOJKHOCTH ueplCBH orpaHl1qeIDI MHe KaJKeTCH '-ITO 11 B03MOJKHOCTI1 naPTl1I1 TOJKe orpaHl1QeHLI Ho YCJIOBH He06xo ZIHMO I1CnpaBJIHTb Ha 3TO nOTPe6yeTCH MHoro BpeMepHM He ZIYMalO 4TO 3TO MOl HO C ZIeJIaTb 6LICTPO ELlTb MOJKeT nOTPe6yeTC ueJIoe nOKOJIeHHe 2 l lla BioI npaB1 I 1-1 6Y ZIeT TPY ZIHO SI JIH4HO yaepeH '-ITO 3TO MOJKeT H 6Y ZIeT C ZIeJIaHO MHe KaJKeTCH B PYCClCOM HapO ZIe H He rOBOplO 0 ZIpyrl1X nOTOMY 4T0 He 3Haro HI1'-1ero 0 KHprH3aX HO B pYCClCOMH Hapo ZIe MeIOTCS orpOMffile pe3epBLI He TOJIblCO BpOJK ZIeHHOt HHTeJlJll1reHTHOCTH HO H qyBCTBa MOpaJIH KOTopoe nopOJK ZIaeTC TOJIbKO 3 ZIeCb eCJII1 Ha ZIeH npaBHJIbHLIti no ZIXO ZI lC HapO ZIY ilOHHMaeTe 51 HC'-IKpeHHHt nOlCJIOHHHK AHToHa qexOBa Ero npa-npa ZIe ZI 6I IJI pa60M H Bce JCe B ero nOlCOJIeHHM He 6I IJIO '-IeJIOBeKa lCOTOP1 JIYqwe Hero pa36HpaJICH 611 B Bonpocax MOpaJIH OH pa36HpaJICH B HHX JIY'-Ime TOJICToro yqwe llOCToeBClCoro HMeeHO nOTOMY '-ITO cMoTPeJI Ha MHp 60JIee peaJII1CTH'-IHo • -25­ O nd H COrndCeH C BaMH K MHe Kd eTCH 4T0 aTO nHillb He60nbWdH 4aCTb OnHd CTOPOHd d B03MO HOCT PYCCKoro Hdpond BL BdTbCH K3 ne4anhHOro npomnoro OrpOMHlI 3To Bne4dTnHeT HMero B BI mY CKopee MOPanhH YIO CTOpOHY Bonpoca He enM KdK e-To YCHnHH Hanerocb aTO nOMo eT aTO npOH30AneT B BdweA cTpdHe H pa306pancH B BaweA npo6neMe HO non eH npH3HaTb 4TO He nnOCTaT04HO XOPOWO npe CTaBnHro ce6e KaK K HeA nODCTYnHTbCH 3TO B 3Ha4 ITenbHOA CTeneHM 6yneT 3dBHceTb OT Y4HTeneA H Y4HTenR 04eHb YdCTO nOHMMaroT aTO B POCCHM xopOWHe Y 1TenH OHM MeHH OyeHb TpOHYnH OnHa H3 MOHX DOYepe Y4 naCb 3neCb B WKone BO BpeMH Bolmbl B 06bl4HOtI PYCCKOI'1 WKOJIe lIJIH DeBOyeK - BIB 1 eHCKoA WKOJIe - 3 eCb B MocKBe Y4HTeJIH aToA WKOJThI npOH3BeJIM Ha MeHH 04eHb 60JIbWOe BneqaTJIeHHe 3T JIroDH 6LlJIM onep ml OHM 61 IJIM npendHhl lIeny 3Ha4MTenbHO 60JIbwe 4eM yYHTeJIR B HdweA cTpdHe OHM OTHOCHJIMCb K cBeoA npo4 ecCMI1 KdK IC CBHTOA rrpoepeccMH KdK K uepKBI1 11 6LITb MO l eT OHM nOMorYT OHM rOTOB 1 ClIendTb aTO HO 1M Y Ha nOMomb BJIaCTeI'1 napTHH 11 lIPyrl1x KOHe4Ho nYTb npencTOMT llOnrHA aTO JIMWb OlIHd H3 3a ldY KOTopble HY HO peUlHTb HO eCTb eme MHo eCTBO lIPyrMX 3a ld4 • KOTopble TaK e He06xo lHMO peWHTb 4T06LI npOH3BeCTH nepeCTpoAKY aKOHOMMKH MHe npelICTaBnHeTCH qyO nepeCTpO Ka CeJIbCKOrO X03RRcTBa caMaH CJIO HdH 3d la4d nOCKOnblCY HeT 06pa3ua IC 1C0TOpO Y MO O 6LIJIO 6b1 B03BpaTHTbCH EDHHCTBeHHoe 4TO npHXOlIHT B rOJIOBY B aToA CBH3H aTO CTOJIbInHHCICHe pe4 opml 1C0Topble B ueJIOM 6LIJIM nono nrrenbHLI MHe ICd eTCH Ba KHl IM rrpH3HaTb qyO cenbClCoe X03HACTBO OTJIM4aeTCH OT lpyr x cepep H3lli1 M 4TO MO HO D06HTbCH 60JIbWMX YCneXOB C nOMombID epepM KorlIa epepMep HeceT Bcro OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a MenlCHbX ceMe Hb CBoA TpYll B CenbCICOM X03HAcTBe He uOJDKHO 6LITb a lMHHHCTpHpOBaHMH Y MeHH Y caMoro eCTb epepMa B CoelIHHe IX lliTaTax TaM Y Hac pa60TaeT epepMep npHilleJI OH MHoro JIeT Hd3an MOnOlILIM napHeM ceA4ac eMY Y I e JIeT 45 - 50 Ha SToA epepMe OH OTBe4aeT 3d Bce OH XOPOWHA epepMep 3HaeT leJIO H ICO BceMY OTHOCHTCH BHHMdTeJIbHO MHoro pa60TaeT EcnH H04bffi KopOBa 3a6oJIeeT OH BCTaHeT B OBeT BeTepHHapa OH 3aMHTepeCOBaH MHe lCa l eTCH 4TO STa epopMa Be ueHHH XOX3H CTBa JIY4WaH 6LITb MO l eT He lInH 3epHOBo uyeCKMX X03HRcTB TaM lPyroe DeJIo Kor lla 06pa6aTIIBaeTCH HeCICOnblCO TIICH4 aKpoB B ODHOM MecTe aTO 60JIbwe 4eM Y Bac B COBX03ax Ho nOHHMaeTe B POCCHM 04eHb MaJIO TaKoro on ITa oco6eHHO B UeHTPdJIbHoA POCCMH Be3 ue r lIe CymeCTBOBaJIO pa6CTBO BaM uOCTdJIOCb TH oe HaCJIe uCTBO nOTO Y 4TO pa6CTBO TO%e JIHWaJIO JIro leA YBepeHHOCTH B ce6e JIHWdJIO MX HHHUHaTHBl J A TaM r ue pa6cTBa BHe 6I 1JIo lCalC HanpHMep B Tex - 26 ­ oTKy a PO OM MeCTax 60 ee 3 OpOBb M 6LIJlO pa6CTBa r-R TpYllHa5I fla BHOBb Ka eTC Ho 3TO MHe M 311eCb eCTb C0311aHHLI OTHOWeHM 4e OBeKa 10p6a4eB KaK MHe e To Ka eTC 04eHb conpOTMB eHMe KpeCTb5IHcKJ1A COI03 e aeT Bce apeHllaTopOB M TaK OHa Tep5IeT anee 3TO HHTepeCa B Toro H TaK npOM3Be eHHoe 3aUHTepeCOBaHa B TOM BOT Bce-TaKM npOBelleM B ceKTope arpapHOM anee XOT5I Kpax MHepTHa K llaHHO npoBollMTb KaK Torlla BOT 3TY r 06anbHYIO eKO eKTMBM3aUMIO ' TaM r e COBX03 pa60TaeT XOpOIUO cBo60 HLle 3eM M r lie KO X03 npOBe eM He conpOTH eHMe nOMeUU1KOB 1011eA MLI He nYCTb pa60TaeT r e eCTb n Olllallb 06pa60TaTb KOTOpylO epMepbl nYCTb pa60TalOT 3TOMY M He 60 bwoe HO H PSIllOBJ lX 113 lleYt Y Ty bCKOA EOJIbwo KO 03 TO bKO CO CTOpOHLI npeBpaTM MCb MeH Y Hac B IOLlen BJ ILle M C CeJIbCKOX03 YtCTBem-u IM MM no 60 reKTapOB apeHllaTOpJ 1 pa60TaTb lla HM KpellHT HO pa60TaTb MHTeHCI1BHO HaYa H e 06 acTI1 KO X03 BOT 400 TaKO 4e OBeK Xopoume 1l0XOllbl M TeM He 06pd30BaHMeM C BbICillHM pa60Ta Te H BOT rOBopMT KynH M OHM no TpaKTOpy He TaK KaK B pa6oTaTb TaK BOT llH BOT TYT TpM MeHee OH 6YllYYH Ye OBeKOM nporpeCCMBHJ a OH KaHJlMllaT 3KOHOMMyeCKI1X HaYK rpaMOTHblYt Ye OBeK OH peIUM BJ ILle MTb TpOMX nYCTb fla nYCTb Ha 3110pOBbe pa60TalOT Ha M paCCKa3J ffiaeT Y Hero xopoillHA TPYllOCnoc06HblX c06CTBeHHOCTM XBaTMT BOT TaKHX MaCCOBJ IX KOTopble B 06IlleM-TO 6LI npellce aTe b KO X03a Ka3a4eHKO KO X03e a HalUe M KaK HaYa M 60 ee B OLlHY HOYb llBa TPaKTopa 6J I M C OMaH J fla LlPyrHMM' -5J r OyeMY A YTO t e OHM 3aBTpa MMpoellaMM 6YLlYT f HeT r 06a bHYIO Ko eKTMBM3aUMIO Mo eT lOlle pa60TalOT KaKHe-TO rpynnJ 1 a ee Bce-TaKM pa60TaeT xopomo nYCTb pa60TalOT apeHllaTOpJ l MHTepece HO OPM M nYCTb pa60TaeT Ho TaM KO X03 npellcellaTe e KO X030B M TaK CMCTeMe HeT MHTepeca Ho MJ I 3eMe bHYIO pe OpMY TaKYIO TaK CKa3aTb a ee BOT 1O eY1 He npOM3Be eHHOMY YTO BJ lpaCTeT M TaK B OYeBM HL OHa He MO t eT npOKopMHTb 6y eM Ha3aJl BOT HanpMMep OH KaTeropM4eCKM Ha npaKTMKe paBHOnpaBM5I Bcex Ma eHbKMX M 04eHb no BYM opMaM - KO X03HYIO M YT06hl He 6LWO epMepOB He 6b1 0 KOTopa C O M aCb CHCTeMbI MMeeT 60 bmoe He aKTM4eCKM aKTM4eCKYIO OTCTaMBa5I COBX03HYIO 06beMC 6hl M r e TaK e 60 bIUa np06 eMa 04eHb conpOTMB 5IeTC KaKMM- 60 3a B eHM M 3TO 3eM e C M B CM6MpM t Ky aKaMM - 27 ­ f lla a Ha caMOM e e KaK OH 06b CHH npH HHa COBeprneHHO B pyrOM RID H BOT 3TH BOT He apeH aTophI OHH Hcnyra HCb YTO e o H eT K TOMY YTO HM npH eTC TaK e pa60TaTb KaK BOT 3TH TPoe BOT B yeM neno Bce lla OHH y e pa3Y H HCb pa60TaTb OHH YMeIDT eHbrH no yYaTb TO bKO Ar Y HO 06H3aTe bHO npeo o eTb 9TO J t KOHeYHO KOHeYHO A KOHeYHO He pa60TaTb BceM J Hy HY HO n03BO HTb eCTOKYID 3KCn yaTallHID ID eM Ha o a Ho Bce-TaKH HY HO n03BO HTb HM they have to be allowed to earn certain amount of money That's have to be enough so that it encourages them to think that they can really do something useful for themselves and for their family and for their children 1 e KacaeTC rOBopH H Bonpoca 0 KOTOpOM B11 BOT 0 Mopa HOM B03pO eHMH cor aceH YTO Ha 3TO nOTpe6yeTC lle oe nOKo eHHe t fTO BOT HHTepeCHoe nonyyaeTCH sneCb ecnH TaK BOT BHHMaTenbHO Ha6nID aTb 3a 3HbID BOT ce Yac Hac 06BMH IDT B TOM TO t fTO MhI 'J C Hac 06BHHHIDT B TOM COUHaJIH3Ma TO MLI paCTep nH H nOry6HJIH H ea JUI Dory6HnH J nOrY6HnM Ho Kor a rOBopHWb KaK IKe MLI CMor JIM Y6MTb ea TI11 EC H Hao6opOT ea ml CB06o J lleMOKpa'I J-rn llOCTOMHCTBa eJIOBeYeCKoro ero TBOpYeCKO MHHUMaTMBJ I ero CBo6o lUI TBOpYeCTBa KpoMe MHTeJI reHUMH 3TO He BOCnpMHMMaeTCH Hy KH11 KaKMe-TO pyrHe H ea 11 TO nM OCHOBaHHhle Ha n e TO JIM Ha nO MHeHMM TO M ellle Ha eM-TO 3TO Bpo e M M ea m J a Bpo e KaK 61 1 HeT Bpone KaK-6hl M He nO XO HT Bpo e KaK-6J 1 M He OpraHMYH1J H Ye OBeKa a ella MLI npen O HJIM - 28 ­ BOT HY I H11 KaKl1e-TO MO l eT CKa3aTb TO a 3TO 4eJlOBeKa 61 1Jla Y ero KOTop11e TBOp4eCKoe Ha4aJlo nepeCTpofUca llI1BHJIH3aUyIOHHi IM CKa3aTb KCTaTI1 nepeJIOM B HaBa l lleHJ1e BOT HaM Ha 110 KOTOpl lM nOHHMaeTe l H3HH M 1 1 He OHa KOHe4HO TOJIbKO Moen CTpaHe CKa3aTb • TO BO ECTeCTBeHHl lM nYTeM 4TO X04eT BepHTb A Ea CKOJIbKO JleT COpOK n Tb CTBa MeCCl-fH 4TO BLI xoporno nepMaHeHTHO orpoMHLli1 Bpe ll Moe'i CTpaHe nO l aJIy'icTa TaK nYCTb Ka l llhli1 BepHT B 60POTbC 3a KaK nOJIY4J1JIOCb B 3TO Ho BOT BOCT04HOi1 COpOK n Tb JIeT 04eHb Ba l HO 3TO O He 3Toro TO l e He nOHHMaWT lla H TaK l eJIaHHe Haca llHTb KOMY-TO KaKoi1 -To COpOK n5iTb JIeT TaK llYMaW H OCB060 l llaTbC OT cnoco6eH BepHTb 3TO 6e3Ha lle Oe lleJIo EBpone MeCCHaHCKoe BOT 3TO HeeCTeCTBeHHoe Hac a l lleHJ1e 3TO HaCHJIbCTBeHHoe HaCa l lleHHe CTpOfi H OCB060 l llaTbC nOTOMY HaHeCJIa HOpMaJIbmItl npe llJlaraeM He4TO TaKoe 3HaeTe BOT 3Ta TeopH OKT 6pbCKO peBOJlWUHH peBOJlffiUHI1 nOpa l eHO BCTYnHTb B He TOJlbKO HaM AMepl1KH Ha 110 OT 3Toro CB060 llY 61 ICTpO H lleH npeKpaTHTb 3TO 61 1 CKa3aJI BceM Hano 3TO pernaTb Coelll1HeHH11M IlITaTaM T aK Hy BOT HaCKOJlbKO 3anYTaHI I MI l BJleHl1eM OHO Hecnoc06Ho BOCnHpH5iTb npe llJlaraeT HJ1KTO He 3HTY3Ha3M n04eMY HeJIb3 BepHTb B a MdCCOBO-CKJlepOTH4ecKHM 06wecTBeHHoe MHeHMe KaKHe CBoe BpeM Bephl Hac B TO XopOWO Bepa BO B CKa3d 61 1 llpyrl1e l1 lleaJlI I COllHaJlH3Ma BOT nOToMY o Y Hac MHOrHe CymecTByeT qHCTa cB060 lla 6e3 That freedom can be defined only in terms of the restraints we take OTBeTCTBeHHOCTI1 3TO HY O H Y 3Toro He nOHMMaffiT BpeMeHI1 3TY Bac H 3TO HY I HO aHra l HpOBaTb C lleJIaTb Mec ueB nO l aJIY f CKa l HTe nOTOMY 4TO 3TO llaJIH llOCTaT04HO 61 1JI llYMaw 4TO nOH Tb BCW VI OyeHb MHorHe y O llHH ro ll CeMbffi CKa3aJI HJlH B O llHO WKOJIbHOM B03paCTe pO llHTeJle 4T061 1 llJI MOHX OyeHb Ba l HO Bce Ml lCJIeti Ha HeCKOJIbKO llOBOJIbHO XOPOWO B H O Mory Hac 3ai1 MeT MHoro qT061 1 Y nOHMMaw Hac B VI rJIy6HHY 3TO'i np06JIeMaTHKH BaM Bcero xopowero no «aJIY CTa KTO KOHe4HO 3TO HY l HO Ha4HHaTb B nOCTapalOCb C lleJIaTb Bce 11 Hac OHH HeJIerKHe nOH JlH H3MeHeHl1W Y KTO 3TO OyeHb Ba l HO H OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb BI I MHe BaWH np06JIeMI I TO l e 3TO He nOMHW np06JIeMY HeJIb3 peWWTb B lleC THJIeTHe nO-MOeMY 3TO npOCTO 061 1 cnoc06CTBOBaTb AMepHKe 3TOMY l eJIalO • B1 1 JIH4HO BepHTe B Haw IDlHeWHMA 3KcnepHMeHT f YTO H 5l C4HTalO qTO OHM B r JIy6vIHa np06JIeM JIY4llJe qeM 51 caM H lletiHoM CMLICJIe COBepweHHO npaBHJIbHl le peaJlH3aUHH 3TI1X MI ICJIe co06paJiKY H 60JIbWe no «a ny Ho 3TO 60JIbWe qeM BI I caMH coo6pa3l1Te - 29 ­ J COBeprneHHO BepHO 3a MeT M yTO 3TO Bl lHrpaTb 3TO BpeM51 Ho 2 H 3TO 04eHb TpynHo BCe-TaKM 60Rbwe BpeMeHM MO geT 6hlTb 3TO r JlaBH1m Bonpoc BLI npdBhl 51 nYMdIC 4TO B KpaTKOBpeMeHHJ le paMKM HY I HO KOHet IHo nonpdBMTb 3TO 3KOHOMM4eCKoe nOJlO l eHMe 3TO 04eHb Bd O C Toro HY I HO HdYdTb l JlIC e TpY d JlIC e HdnO ycnoKoMTb HdcTpoeHMe npMBeCTM ero B HOpMdJlbHOe COCT051HMe BhlBeCTM ero M3 nOJlOCLI 3J106LI OlCeCT04eHM51 HeTepnMMOCTM nepeHeCTM B 60Jlee cnOKO Hoe pYCJlO Tpe3BLle oueHKM nOHMMdHMe TdK CKd3dTb A C pyro CTOpOH1I HdnO BLlBeCTM Jlw efi M3 COCT051HM51 3 OPMM CKd l eM HaUMOHdJlHCTM4ecKo cenapaTMCTCKofi BOT 3TO BOT CYBepeHHTeTa MaJlO nOHHMa51 K 4eMY OH npHBeneT Bce OJl l HO Bce 4TO 3TO TaKoe ce 4ac I'OBOp51T 0 CYBepeHMTeTe CYBepeHHTeT TaK CKa3aTb aKTM4eCKM ce Yac 6LITb peaJlMCTHyeCKM oueHeHO KaK MaWI1HLI 4To6 npOC4HTLIBaJlM a MLI nOKa ewe C4MTaeM Ha 3MOUM51X BOT 4TO Y Hac UH P HaM He XBaTaeT M Bce 3TO noJIXHo 6LITb npOC4MTaHO KOMnbICTepe 3MOUMH KOMnbWTep 3Ha4HT paC4eTOB l eCTKMX ce Yac pa60TaeT Tpe3BL Hano Ha A HaM HY I eH paC4eTOB 3TOI'O nOKa M YMeHM51 He XBaTaeT H Bce-TaKH 51 nYMa51 YTO eCJlM OTBeTMTb Hd BaWY pennHKY B OTHOWeHMM COe MHeHHJ IX lliTaTOB AMepMKM 51 YMdIC 611JlO 61 1 3HaYI1TeRbHO JJY4we eCJlM 6 MLI I'Jly6 1 e Ha4aJlM 11 cKopee nOHMMaTb npyr npyra 11 OTHOCMTbCH C OBepl1eM Cen4ac YlCe 51CHO YTO HI1KTO He X04eT HMKoro 06MaHYTb HI1KTO He XOyeT KaK-TO CXMTPI1Tb KanKaH11 paCCTaBMTb KaKMe-TO M11 TOJlbKO M YMaeM KaK 2lpyr 2lpyry HaBpe21MTb 3TOT M3BeCTH1m Bpaye6H1m npMHUMn HaBpe M nOM04b TIo-MoeMY 3TOT npMHUMn 51 2lYMalO KaK Mhl He21aBHO HaM 611 He HaBpe21M He HaBpe21M a 4TO YMaJIM nepe TM JIeYM Hd HO He eCJIM MO l HO TO M 3TO 6LIJlO 61 1 BeJlMKOe 2leJlo He TOJlbKO peaRbHO oueHMBaTb CMTyaUMW ECTb 2lBe cTpaH11 nOKa MX 6Y21eT 60Jlbwe TaKMX CTpdH B 21 BeKe Ha n021cTYnax 3ana21HaH repMaHM51 nOHH51 Epa3MJlH51 ABCTpaJIM51 KaHa21a HH21oHe3MH MHoI'o cTpaH KOTOplle 6Y21YT Ha nHTKM HaM BceM HaCTynaTb HO nOKa 4TO 2lBYM51 rapaHTaMl1 MMpa M cTa6HJlM3aUMM Ha 3TOM MaJleHbKOM mapl1Ke HBJl51WTC51 ClliA M COBeTCKI1 COICG CneJlaeWb L TaK HCTOpH51 paCnOpH21I1J1aCb KOHeYHO TYT YX HH4ero He ECJlH MO l HO cnpOCHTb 1IJl51 COBeTCKI1X KOTopLle K HaM npl1e3 1 aWT 3TH 06MeH11 11 KOHTaKTII nOJle3H11 - 30 ­ 2 OyeHb nOJIe3ffile lIYMalO 3TM 06MeHI 1 51 lIYMalO OyeHb nOJIe3Hl le Ho MOJI02l1H111 nap nal'i€ H TapH51Mvl 06MeHax MOJIOlIe Kl1 HOBYIO 3noxy B CiliA Ea OHl1 TO Ke nOHl1MaIOT npMIlIJIli M Bce cTapllle CA np06JIeMI I cepbe3HLle rOBopSIT YTO B YT061 1 nepelllarHYTb B HallO Ha4l1HaTb J 1 He Bce 06pa30BaTeJIbHblA ypOBeHb 6JIarOnOJIY4HO Bal'1l1 nalIaeT C Y npMe3 KaroT B 3TOll CTpaHl 1 04eHb cepbe3Hl le MHOrM e lIYMalOT J 1M He np06JIeMl I B ropOlIax TYlIa TaK OHU He CBoeM MOJIOlILIX aMepM I aHUeB 60JIee OT Ballll1X cepbe3Hl I HO 4eM Y Hac orpOMillle 4eM BaIliM CHl1 KalOlUerOCSI Halllet $MHaHCOBotl lIe30praHl13aUl1M J 1 no MHOrMM BonpocaM Y 4TO BOT 1I0JI KHLI nOJIaraTb pelllHTb Halllel1 UI1BMJIM3aUMI1 Hac Ha6JIIOlIaeTCSI cnan eCJIH KorlIa-HM6YlIb 3TM MOJIOlIlIe JIlOlIM noelIYT 4TO OHM npOCTO-HanpOCTO 1I0JI1illLI nOlIpa KaTb MOJIOlIl IM aMepHKaHuaM KpHTM4eCI H M 4TO B OHM 1I0JI Kffil nOMHMTb OTJIMl iHJ le HapI OTMKOB Y Hac HaweA CTpaHe KOTOpl le Ha cetl pa3 Hallie npaBMTeJIbCTBO He B COCTOSIHI1H pelllHTb aKTMBHOCTH J 1 Hac TO Ke eCTb CJIelIyeT lIYMaTb CTpaHY OHH ropa31I0 60JIee cepbe3HI I 06pa30BaTeJIbHOrO ypOBHSI TaKMe HalliY eCTb CBOIi np06JIeml np06JIeml np06JIeMl 1 HHlUeTl 1 B MOJIOlIe lKH MOJIOlIJ JMl1 JIlOlIbMH nOBelIeHHM OHM 1I0JUCHLI 6paTb npl1Mep CO Bcex 4TO C 30 JIeT 1I0 HaweA CTpaHe Y np06JIeMJ J lIa Ke C KorlIa OHM HO BOT M3 neHliHrpalIa noeXaJIa rpynna YTO Halla nOCl lJIaTb HO CJIelIyeT nOMHl1Tb eCTb 4TO C 06MeHax 45 0Hl1 rOBopSIT cepbe3Hl le TYT lIBa lIH Ha3alI pa3rOBapHBaJI OHH HaCTaMBalOT Ha 3TMX 3nOxy KM3Hl1 Ii MI IIlIJIeHl1SI BOT OHM KO MHe 4pe3BI IyatlHo nOJIe3HlI J1x HalIO HaY4HTb 4TO n03aMMCTBOBaTb MO KeT 6l lTb a CMOTpeTb Ha HMX 4TO M KOrlIa-Hl16Yllb M OTBeprHYTb H3 OHM CMorYT HaM nOMOYb 2 3TO Bl 1 04eHb npaBMJIbHO 3aMeTMJIM TeJIeBM3MOHHYIO nepelIa4Y CTYlIeHTl I BocnMTaTeJISIMM lIeTetl HelIocTaTKaMM B pe6SITa TaK - a Hac 31IeCb OlIHOM Ho npUeXaJIH C a C AMepMKe MI I noeXaJIli C lIpyrMM 4TO B HO 3TO np06JIeMLI X04eT noexaTb B OH 1I0JI KeH lIYMaTb 0 18 4aCOB B CYTKM C 1 $M3M4eCI Mm1 C OTpHuaTeJIbHl IX 3MOUMt Y MbI y 3HaJIM AMepHKH HOpMaJIbHl lMM lIeTbMM OHIi npSIMo CKa3aJllf KTO-TO 113 Bac pa60TaJIM no CJIYyae lIeTeA YBa KeHMeM K HO KaI HX-TO CMOTpeJI BepHYJIliCb HalliM pe6SITa CoelIMHeHHl IX UlTaTax lIPyroM CJIY4ae C He HalliM np06JIeMLI TypH3Me B 0Hl1 npHeXaJIM C CKa3aTb BLI3BaJIO Y KOTOpl le pa60TaJIli B HelIaBHO SI ClllA AMepMKY pa60Te TO HliX 3TO He OlIHliM HacTpoeHMeM eCTb Cepbe3HJ le J1 BOT 3TM HOBI MM 3HaHMSIMM CBOIi np06JIeMl I np06JIeml OH 1I0JI KeH lIYMaTb He OH 1I0JI KeH pa60TaTb lIeTMIlIKaMH no 18 1 4aCOB B 3T0 ECJrn MLI CYTKM 0 - 3 ­ 1 f I HI1KTO Bellb BaM lIeHbrU npOCTO 3a KpaCUBLle r JId3a He jJaCT Itlx Hano 3apa6oTaTb 3TO He TO 4TO Y Hac B crpaHe - pa311aWT lIeHbrl1 nOTOMY 4TO npHWeJI Ha pa60TY TOJIbKO TaM rOBOpl1T HajJo 3Tl1 lleHbrH 3apa6oTaTb B OomeM H TaK nOpa3l1JICH 3TO He nO lIrOTOBJIeHHoe OHl1 rOBOpl1JUl TO 4TO lIYMd f Il1 CBOl1 Bne4aTJIeHl1H paCCKa3h1BaJII1 KapTLI pa3JI114HLle I1CTOpl1l1 B ueJIOM OHl1 npUBe3J1l1 04eHb nOJlOllCl1TeJIbHOe Brre4dTJleHHe 0 KOHTdKTax C TdKOtf lICe MOJlOllellCbW Ho l1HTepeCHd TaKaH 3HaeTe Tpe3BaH peaJI11CTl14eCKaH oueHKa t t llYMaw OCHOBa Hawetf 6Yllywetf nOJlOCLI COTpYllHl14eCTBa KOTopoe llOJl l HO rrepetfTl1 Ha HOBLIt1 ypOBeHb OHO llOJIlICHO 6LITb OCHOBdHO He Ha rrpeKJIOHeHl111 llpyr nepell llpyroM He Ha YHl14I1lKeHI1l1 llpyr llpyra a Ha Tpe3Boti peaJIbHO OCHOBe KOTopaH nO-MoeMY TOJIbKO l1 p0 l llaeT B3al1MHOe YBa l eHl1e 3TO BepHO It1 BOT 3a 3Tl1M YCJIOBl1eM TO l e O lI06PHffi 3Tl1 nYTeWeCTBl1H COBeTcKotf MOJIOlle l J1 Ho l1X HYlICHO HeMHO l KO npl1rOTOBI1Tb nepell TeM KaK OHl1 ellYT 11 Hawl1X TO l e 4ero O l l111aTb l1 KaK CMOTPeTb HeMHO l KO rJIy6lKe 4eM nOBepXHOCTHO 3TO TOlKe HaM HYlICHO Torlla 3TO MOlKeT 6LITb rrOJIe3HO 04eHb MHoro 3aBl1CMT OT Tex KTO l1X conpoBolKjJaeT l1 Y Hac 11 Y Bac ECJ1l1 3TO pYTMHHLIt1 M 04eHb Ba l HO 4T06l npl13HaJIl1 CJIa60CTM Hawetf Ul1Bl1JII13aUl1l1 llYMaTb BMeCTe 4TO C 3TOtf UMBl1Rl13aUl1eA lIeJIaTb - Bcerlla rOBOpl1JI HaillMM no nOBOllY I1HOcTPaHHLlx CTY lleHTOB He nOKa3LIBatiTe BLI 11M TO 4TO BLI C4l1 TaeTe CBeTJIotf CTOpOHOtf aMepl1KaHCKOJ1 lICl13HI1 OTBe3MTe MX JIY4ille B rOpOllCKl1e reTTO nOKa l l1Te ' 11M HaWI1 HellOCTaTKl1 HO l1 nOKallCMTe HM KaK TPYllHO MCnpaBHTb 3TO nOJIO JkeHl1e A nonhlTKl1 l1CnpaBl1Tb 3TO nOJIO JkeHHe Y Jke npellnpl1Hl1MaWTCH BOT Torlla-TO Y HMX C OpMMpYeTCH JlY4illee MHeHlle TOlKe MO JkHO CKa3aTb 11 0 COBeTCKOM COID3e llallCe B COBeTCKoe BpeMH AMepl1KaHULI npl1e3lCaJ1l1 11 CJIywaJ1l1 llBYCMLICJIeHffile pa3bHCHeHMH l1HTYPl1CTOBCKMX rl1ll0B KOTopLle TBeplll1JIM UM 4TO Bce 3 lIeCb npeKpaCHO B03BpalllaJllllCb TypMCTLI C 4YBCTBOM nOl103pMTeJIbHOCTM U C OTpl1uaTeJIbHhIMl1 Bne4aTJIeHI1HMM Te l e 113 Hl1X KOny Y lIaBaJIOCb 1136e l aTb 3TOrO l1 YBMlleTb nOllJIIiIHHLle np06JIeMLI COBeTClCoro HapOlla B l1CTl1HHOM CBeTe KaK 6b1 M3HYTPl1 B03BpawaJIl1Cb C qyBCTBOM rJIy60Koti Cl1MnaTI1l1 C MHTepeCOM 04eHb pall YTO MHe npellOCTaBl1JIaCb B03MOlCHOCTb norOBopMTb BOT TalC CerO lIHH YTPOM XOTH MLI M rOBOpMJll1 0 rpYCTHLlX BelIlax 51 xoqy n06JIarOllapMTb Bac 3a Bawe TepnaHeHl1e l1 nOlCeJIaTb BaM Bcero caMoro HaMJIyYwero Hallerocb 4TO 3TO Bce KaK-TO MO l HO 6ylleT l13JIO i MTb B nHCbMeHHOM BHlle TaK 4T06J I MJ I - 32 - MornM 03HaKOMHTbC5I C 060MMM npOTOKonaMM pYCCKMM M aMepI1KaHCKI1M I10-PYCCKH 51 lIHTalO CB060 l1HO H Mo «eT MOM n03HaHHR MHe ewe npHrO HTCH § CnacH60 60nbwoe 51 04eHb pa ll 4TO BI HawnH BpeM5I npl1eXaTb ClO lla K HaM EcnH Bbl Korna-HH6Y l1b On5lTb npHeneTe K HaM B CeBepHYIO AMepHKY 51 3HalO 4TO Bhl lonro 61 Inl1 B KaHane 11 ecnl1 51 ellle npOCyweCTBYIO 51 06513aTenbHO BaM laM 3HaTb 11 51 YBepeH npO «HBeTe He o6emalO Cer021H5I 61 1 LiTO BioI ewe MHe CTonbKO neT HO 51 6y llY 04eHb pa ll Bac BI1 lleTb eCJII1 51 npH Y B rOCTHHI1UY B 7 4aCOB Ml I CMorJIlt n006e aTb OyeHb XOpOlliO KaK MI I Ha31 1BaeM nOYXJ1HaTb fiP5lMO y Bac B rOCTMHMue Ha TpeTbeM 3Ta «e i OCTOBCKM A 3a n TaKoti eCTb CnacI1 60 60 nbllIoe