I II -- - I IIEPECTPOfiKA 11 Orrrr03 I1UlliI TQlllill COITPYlKCCHOBEHHH Y3JIH IIPOTMBOCTOffiUIt1 t I liTO TaROe HbIHeIIIHffH OrmOSffiIVi fi OTHeceHue KOHKpeTHMX rrO HTaqeCKMX B eHMH M CM K 6 MHeHMH pasp OnnOSKqMO CTaB eTC fi CeM aC saTpy Te bHMM no napTHM BO MHOrXX cnyqaax MHorHM TIpe ­ rrpwq HaM a OnnOSHgHOHHOCTb H CaMOyTBep 8eHHe Ho e nonHT eCKMe OpraHMsaQHH H C HeHs6e HO O npOMTH epes nepMO CaMOyT­ Bep eHH fi HaMoonee 6 CTPO H HHTeHCHBHO TaKoe rrepBoHa anbHoe CaM0YTBe eHMe 11 caMOOCOSHaHHe ocymecTB ReTcR epes npoTHBoCTO­ RHze B aCTM 06 MK HAeM nOC HOM cnHCOK KOTOpOM 06mecTBy XO­ porno MSBeCTHW ITPH 3TOM OnnOSKQMOHHOCTb Hepe KO opCMPyeTcR MC­ KyccTBeHHO Vi tIpeSMepHaff eeCTerreHb Brroc e CTBMH rrpOXO HT nora­ maeTC ff no Mepe Toro KaK naHHOe nBIDKeHMe SaHMMaeT CBOIO Hl1rny B nORMTKqeCKOM MSHM 06meCTBa B HaCTozmee BpeMR nOnMTKqeCKHe CH BKnroqaR H eMCTBY­ romHe B paMK8X KnCC rrpOXO ffT epes rrepMO TaKoro CaMoYTBe e­ HUff orrpe e eHHR CBoeM Cc3MOCTI1 B TOM tIMC JIe M no oTHorueHI1IO n pyr K APyry ITpaBoMepHO rrpe OJIO MTb orrnOSff qHOHHOCTI1 - To eCTBeHHOM HeTepnI1MOCTH 11 KOHKypeHqHH QTO BC JIe CTBMe 3Toro ypOBeHb c ae B GTOM He eJIH CKopee BSaMMHOM CepbeSHMM nporpaMMHUM paSJIM­ qM fIM - MHOrOKpaTHO saBhIIIIeH no cpaBHeHMIO C HOplA 8 JIbHblM ero ypOBHeM KOTOP H orrpe neJIRJICR 6M TOJIbRO paSHOrJIaCHHMI1 rrporpaMM 6 OnrrOSI1UM ff ie AHaJUiS rrOR8 3bIBaeT iTO BHYTpeHHHe MOTl1BbI 11 HarrpaBJIeHHOCTb onrrOSl1qI10HHOCTI1 aneKO He I _____ c - r D vrr -f4 k LJ A 0 O HOSHaQHN O o ' PI tJt 2 qneonor eCKOMY ITo ypOBHR rrp 3HaKY MO HO en Tb TP OCHOB orrrr03 OHHOCTH - Orrn03K UHR rrepeCTpO Ke aR KaK CReBa TaK H crrpaBa B TOM Hcne H 3 P OB KITCC oc06eHHO KIT PC P - Orrrr03KqHR KnCC aR B OCHOBHOM OT aHTHKOMMYHHCTH­ eCKHX H aHTHCO CT eCKKX rrapT H B eHH TO He O O H TO e H HOHanHCT eCKKX CHn rrpH STOM He 06R3aTeRbHO OTBep­ raeTCH rrepeCTpO Ka - Orrrr03 HR COUHaRHCT eCKOMY B 60py - illeHHe K rrepeCTpO Ke y e cne HM mar Te e qTO H B HCTO HHKH H OTHO­ rrpe eM c yqae HO STO Hepe KO rrpO HKTOB H crrpOBO MPOBaH 06 aCTHMMH H pecrry6nMKaHCKHMH KOMHTeTaMH KITCC ITo rOCYAapCTBeHHO-§gMHHMCTpaTHBHOMY rrpH3H§Ky rpaHKqa orrrro­ 3KqHOHHOCTH Hepe KO COBrr aeT C rrpe OqTeHHeM RORRbHOCTH COIDGY H H e pecrry6 HKaHCK 60p nORRbHOCTH qaCTO MeCTHMM CTPYKTypaM COOTBeTCTBeHHO ­ 3 aeT M H eo or eCKHe rrpe OqTeHHR ITo gyxOBHOMY rrpM3HaRY rrpaBOMepHO rOBopHTb 06 o HoBpeMeHHoM c eCTBOBaHHH rrpHToM H Ha CeMqaC M peaRbHO orrrr03H H M rrceB 00rrrr03HQHH eOROrHqeCKOM HOM HarrpaB eHMRX HCb qeCKMe B M OT rocy apcTBeHHO- HHMCTpaTHB­ ECTeCTBeHHO qTO BMeCTe C Orrrr03MQMe O MBH­ Ha rrOBepXHOCTb Te eHHH M Ha COOTBeTCT IDmMe MOHapXHCTCKO-KRepMKaRb X OBHWe O M TeopeTM­ TPOQKMCTCKO-CTa­ nMHMcTcKax O HOBpeMeHHO B03PO RMCb O HaKO M TaKMe HarrpaBneHMH AY­ XOBHO H3HM 06meCTBeHHOM M 8CTeTH eCKOM cnH penMrM03Horo C03HaHMR KOTop e CTporo rOBopR CaMM ITO ce6e OITrr03MQHe He RBnRIDTCR a MHop a M fulonMTM Boo6me O HaKO CaMO MX nORBRe­ HMe HerrpMB HoCTb qaCTO BocITpMHHMaroTcR KaK rrpoRBneHMe orrrr03Kq CTaH TOH qeM 06oeKTMBHO H M nO TanKllBaIDT Te eHHR TaKMe KMeHHO B J1HOH Onn03MQHll B illKa a OUeHK Onn03wgHll ll M rrpaBafl eBaR r e CTOpO­ Ha B HaCTO ee BpeMR H3 nO TwqeCKOH KO CTM 06mecTBy HaBR­ 3 BaeTCR OUeHKa npaBOrO M eBoro He OTP afl Bce C O HOCTM npOMCXO HX B HameM06meCTBe OBHHX II nO MTwqeCKHX rrpOQeCCOB onaCHO ynpomaromaH II HCK a aH ax OueHKa rrpll KOTOpOM Ha e­ BOM cne OBaT bHO Bpo e 6 rrporpeCCllBHOM aHre nO HTwqec­ Koro crreKTpa OKa3 BaeTCR TeM eHCTB Te bHOCTb Ec KIT PC P II pO CTBeH e e CM Me C O Hee K oueHKe Hamero BHYTp rrO llTllqeCKOrO cneKTpa nO XO llTb C rr03llQHH 3a KanMT ll3M ll ll 3a COUll M3M - TO eCTb no CyTll C MepKaMll II KpllTepHflMH HOPM bHNMll opeBo roUllOHHOH POCCMM II ro60ro COBpe¥eHHoro 6yp Ya3HOrO 06meCTBa - HO Ha eBOM aHre OKa3 BaroTcR PKIT Tor a e CTBllTe b­ O T M HM rro 06 e Ho H O B eTb QTO aTO aHr - TPOUKMCTCKO-CT HHllCTCKllM TO TeM CaMUM BocrrpOM3BO llTCR paCCTaHOBKa CM e rrpO eHHafl HaMM O H C ll3BeCTHHMll pe3Y bTaTaMM M ll3 ep KaMll a r aBHoe CaMO TaKoe rrOHHMaHMe Hame BHyTpeHHeM rrO MTMKM OTKp BaeT rrpKH­ UKITll bHyID B03MO HOCTb R 06 erqeHMR BMemaTenbCTBa ll3BHe rrpll He06xo llMOCTll Boopy eHHoro B c yqae COCKanb3 BaHllR 06CTaHOBKM B c paHe B CTOpOHY OTKp Toro Pp aHCKOrO KOH MKTa Ka BHyTpllrrO llT eCKOPO crreKTpa BpamaeT Hac Ha py6e 1917 llMeeT CBOro orMKY TaKaR o eH­ HO OHa B03­ roga He MeHee rrpaBoMepeH O HaKO H yrOM rro o Bo BceM Mll­ pe aBHO e rrpMHRTO CqHTaTb rrpaBHMM Tex KTO 3amllTe II coxpaHeHllro c ep MBaHllro C O HBmllXCR CTpyKTyp OT aeT rrop KoB npHopllTeT HHTepecoB rrepeMeH H ll e B03BpaTy B 60 ee M H MeH8e 4 OT aneHHoe rrpo oe eBHMM e HanpOTHB TeX KTO CTpeMHTCH K rrepeMeHaM pe OpMaM paSBXTHID - rryCTb H C pasHofi MepO r y6HHH 11 peumMoCTH COBeTCKoe 06 eCTBO y e OCTaTOQHO CTapo qT06 06pasoBa­ MCb Ha ero c06CTBeHHOW OCHOBe CBOM KOHcepBaTOpw peaKQMOHep H pepopMaTO IT03TOMY HcnOnb30BaHMe aHHO illK OQeHOK rrpe ­ CTaBnHeTCH He TonbKO 060CHOBaHHbIM HO H 60JIee rrpO DyKTMBHhIM OT­ Beq HM peaJIHffM rrepeCTpOeQHOrO 3Tana rrOJIMTHqeCKH opHeHTgpOBaH­ HHM B 6ygymee a He B npomnoe B anbHeHmeM M3JIo eHHH 6y eT WCnOJIb30BaHa MMeHHO 3Ta illKaJIa 0QeHOK r BHYTPWrrOJIHTWqeCKHH crreKTp cer08HR ITpw OrrMCaHHOM no o e rrepecTpotiKa rro rOp6aQeBy M60 cero J HR eCTb Y7Ke 11 MHbIe IIOHHMa­ HMR rrepeCTpOMKH o Ha Ha illRaRe BHyTPHllOJIMTM eCKoro CTIeKTpa 6 Tb IIOMe eHa B pasp e JIeBogeHTpwcTCKWX 8B eHMM OHa - JIeBaR vr60 opweHTWpOBaHa Ha r rry60KMe rrpe06pasoBaHMR H B TO e BpeMJI QeHTpWCTCKaR w60 Ms6eraeT HeOrrpaB aHHOrO paspymMTeRbcTBa HWrl1­ JIMSMa sa6eraHWM Bnepe arreRJIMpyeT K s aBOMY C CJIY OHa ­ JIeBaR HO He JIeBaJ4KM Ha JIeBOM WJIaHre nepeCTpOHKe K CO aJIeHMro - e HHCTBeHHoe cepbeSHoe TeqeHWe MHTeJIReKTyaJIbHO rrOJIMTKqeCKM rrpaKTMqeCKH Bo Bcex 3TMX OTHomeHWffiC npyrMM IJ O Hee IJ an eKO OqeHb MHOrOqMCRe M BJIMRTeJIbHW CTpOMKa KaK neBO QeHTpMCTCKoe K eme BH eHMe a M 3TM e JIeHMR YB eHMR COTpY HmaTb K CBOMM JIeB M He 60JIbilleMY CO aJIeHMro nepe­ O CMX nop He KMeeT HM c06CTBeHHOM opraHWSOBaHHOH COQHaJIbHO-nOJIMT eCKOM eme yrHe 6as@ HM qTO nOTeHQMaJIbHWM COID3HMKaM CTpeM­ C HMMH Ha rrpaBOM WJIaHre 06MJIMe rrOJIHT eCKMX CMJI M B eHMH MX opraHWSOBaHHOCTb M aKTwqeCKoe eCJIH H He Bcer a apopMJIeHHOe 5 BHemHe COTpY H eCTBO Oc06eHHo onaCHO B3aMMOnO Kpen ee CO­ TpY JJ HvrtleCTBO Talm x Kpal1He rrpaBbIX CVl JI KaR KIT FC P OOT Ha a M MOMeHT nepeCTpOMKa CaMa BHHOBaTa B TOM qTO eM He Ha Roro anepeTbCE CJIeBa qTO o eHO C03 aH e yrpo eM ROam1 VI VI rrpaBbIX VI pe Vl OHHhIX CVl JI Havr60JIee onacHhI cpe kf HIDe Te qTO paCnOJIaraIOT OTJIaiKeHHhIMkf Opra H 3 kfOHHb MYI CTPYRTypaMYI KBJ paMM 8 CTeneHb OpraHM30BaHHocT11 11 BJI11EHHR onn03MgHVI To 11 Y­ roe BapbHpyeTcR B OqeHb 1I1l1pOIlliX npe eJIax HaH60JIee OpraHM30BaH­ HWMM Ha cerO Hff RBJIRIDTCH orrn03 HOHHOIe TeqeHKH HCnOJIb3yromHe CTPYKTypbl RIICC HJIl1 napasHTl1pyIOI1l11e Ha IDIX aTo npelf te Bcero Iffi FC P B JI vrn e ee PyKOBO CTBa - tiJaRTI1qeCRVI y3axoHeHHM TPOQRHCT­ CKO-CTaJIHHHCTCKaR tiJpaKQHR B napTI1M 3TO 11 6b1CTpO pacT Me opra HM3 MoHHbIe CTPYKTypEJ It neMoKpaTHqeCKOH POCCID1 B TO e BpeMR l1X BJIMRHl1e B 06meCTBe HeBeJIMKO O I1H H3 rro­ CJIe Hl1X onpOCOB rrpOBe eH X B 10M nORasaJI ypOBeHb no ep KM Hill B 6 npoQeHToB a n neM-PocCJ1H B 8 rrpoQeHToB OT QI1CJIa orrporneHHblx B TO e BpeMR MX BJIVl RHI1e B rocy apCTBeHHWX CTpyKTy­ pax 3HaQ11TeJIbHO Bblme 11 cepbe3Hee XOTE M-He no aeTCR Ql1tiJPOBOM OQeHRe • npyrl1e napTMM 11 TeqeHMR Bcex HarrpaBJIeHI1H nORa ffi1 opraHM3a­ QMOHHO HM no BJIl1RHHIO He npe CTaBJIEIDT 113 ce6R cepbe3HOM BeJIH­ ql1HH BHMMaHMe 06meCTBeHHOCTl1 R HMM He Cl1JIbHO 11 He cTa6MJIbHO BO MHOrOM 060HCHReTCE nOKa rrpOCTblM JII06oITblTCTBOM He npocMaTpM­ BaeTCR nOKa TaM 11 CKOJIbKO-H116Y b HpKHX l1ryp cnoc06HOIX CTaTb JIYmepaMl1 nOTeHqHaJIbHO MOmHbIX nOJIHTMlJeCKIDC BIDKeHID1 6 Tpe6yeT ME npoqecc 30B YC nHBmMMCfl pe3KO B nocneAHee Bpe­ 06Pa30BaH H nony-06 eCTBe J rrony-nonMTM eCKMX COID­ accoqMaqM neHMR eM BH aHMR TaR e KOTO e T rr aKTaqeCKM GTO 0PPaHM30BaHHWe Ppynnw MOPyT MCrrOnb30BaTbCR M e MCrrOnbSyroTCR JIH B03 n ei1 cTB H KaK H8 aB­ orrno3M M­ o6rqecTBeHHoe MHeHl1e TaR 11 Ha pocy n ap­ CTBeHHWe 0PPaH@ rrp eM B nOCJIeAHeM CJIyqae TaKoe B03 eMCTB e He­ pe o OCTaeTCR HeB ml1pOKOM 06 eCTBeHHOCTM HeM3BeCTHMM M HerrOHRT eM 3 ecb y nepecTpoMKM Ta e 6onbilloM pe3epB HeMC­ rronb3yeMHX B03MO HOCTe 2 3apo MBmHcb KOMMyHacT eCKaR onno3HgMH rrepecTPoMKe BHyTpM KITCC B 3HaqHTe bHoi1 CTerreHM no J eM­ HWM M OpPaHRSaqMOHHmM B03 eMcTBMeM ee anrrapaTa M eOJIOp eCKOPO KOMITJIeKCa oco6eHHo ITpeno aBaTeneM HayqHopo KOMMyHM3Ma MapKcMcTC Ko-neHl1HCKOM MnocapMH nonl1T3KoHOMMM coqManM3Ma o6 ecTBoBe e­ HHfl HayqHopo aTeM3Ma OBHOH M MCTOpMM KnCC a TaK e B Henocpe cTBeHHoM 11 nCMXOnOraqeCKOH 6 M30CTM K napTMl1 GTa onrr03MqMR Ha rrepBOM 3Taae ana p TeqeHl1H M cTanMHMcTcKo-TpoqKl1cTcKoro o6oe MHeHl1M Heo6oJIbWeBMCTcKOPO TO Ka Ha BTOpOM 3T rroc e HMe B pemaromeM Mepe crroco6cTBoBanM KpM­ CTallJI1138qMM eHHo-rrO MTJ1qeCKOrO CTaeT B EWcTyrr eHMRx 06JIMKa KIT PCillCP KaKMM OH rrpe ­ HHHemHepo ee pyKoBo n cTBa HaKoHeq Ha HaCTO­ HmeM TpeTbeM 3Taae 3TH TeqeHMR 06oe IJ MHeHMR 06oeKTMBHO B rron­ HRIDT POJIb O IJ HOBpeMeHHO 11 0PY IJ MR B pyKax pyI OBO J CTBa KIT FC DCP HO M cpe n CTBa J aaneHMR crrpaBa Ha CaMO GTO pyxOBO IJ CTBO KOHTponR lynbTparrpaBWX H HMM 11 Qepe3 Hero - H KOMMYHMCTaMM POCCMM TIo cBoeM OpraHM30BaHHOCTM H J1q rrpo eccMoH bHHX KaAP0B CBR3HM C pocarrnapaToM IJ PyrMM pocy n apcTBei-IHbIMM CTpyKTypaMM ITO 7 CBoeM HerrpMMHpMMOCTH BOHHCTBeHHOCTH rrpe CTaBnHeT Ha aHHHM rrepeCTpOMKe eMOKpaTHM KOMMYHMCT eCKafl Orrrr03KqMH eanbHYID MOMeHT CaMyD Cepbe3HyID 11 CTpOMTeIThCTBY rrpaBOBOrO yrPOSY rocy apCTBa 3Ta OrrnOSHIJ IDI - rJIaBHhIM Ha aHHhIf1 MOMeHT 110Te MaJIbHhli1 HCTOl llil1K rp aHCKOM BOM B CTpaHe R KOMMyHHCT ecKoi1 Orrn03 11M rrepeCTpOMKe MOryT O Tb OTHeCe­ HHMQ11aTMBHWM C e3 KOMMyHMCTOB POCCMM OO e MHeHHWM POHT TPY MXCR T MapKCHCTCKafl pa60 ag rrapTMfl-ITapTIDI MKTaTypw rrpOJIeTapMaTa MPIT-unIT COID3 B03pO eHRfl OOJIbmeBM3Ma CBB VI Ha STOM STarre PYKOBO CTBO KIT PCOCP l1x OCHOBH e M eVl VI rrpe JIo eHRff rrporp e MOMeHT@ a oueRKa rrepeCTpOMKH XpymeB Bpe HeB B paBHOti Mepe rrpOBO MJIM rrOJI3yqyID pec­ TaBp8J4 110 _KarrMTaJIMCT eCKMX 06meCTBeHHbIX OTHOmeHI1M rOp6atIeB OCyIIleCTBJIReT OypfKYa3HO-peCTaBpaTopcIrnM KypC 3TOM TaK Ha3hIBa­ eMOM rrepeCTpOMKe O IDKeH 6 Tb rrOJIOlKeH CaMhIM pemHTeJIhHWM KOHeQ H JU1Qa pas BR3 aBilll1e aHTMCOIJ vraJIMCTmeCKyIO BaIDCaHaJIMID Be-qaTb rrepe rrapTMeti ¥I HapO OM O IDKHhI OT­ ITpvropMTeT OOmeqeJIOBe-qeCKIDC QeH­ HocTetf H KJI8CCOBbIMM - SJIeMeHTapHM HJIOCexpCKO-TeOpeTHtIeCKM Oe3rpaMOTHOCTb H o RaR MOfKHO CKopee CMeHMTb RBHO 3aparropTO­ BaBmerOCR 11 K TOMy IKe 6e3pYKOrO B npaRTw IeCKOM OTHOmeHI1l1 rJIaBy rocy apcTBa CBB - TIOJII1TMKa PyKOBO CTBa KITCC RBJIReTCR aHTMpa60qeti aHT l1­ MapKCMcTCRotl a HTHKOMMyHI1CTI1qeCRO '1 MPrr-II 1 - XXYIII c e3 · VI yqpe MTeJIbHbH1 C e3 IJ PRII He orrpaB a rrI1 H elK Il KOMMYHMCTOB VI pa60Qero KJIaCCa CTpa ••• rrO IJ TBep VlJII1 QTO BHYTpM­ rrapTMMHM ruraCTb rrpOQHO y ep1imBaeTC a orrrropTyHMCTIrftIeCKI1M rrpo­ OYPfKYa3HNM PYKOBO CTBOM BO rJIaBe C rOpOaqeBWM ••• TIPOBO MTCR 8 npecTyrrHafl aHTHpa6oqaR 3KCn aTaTOpCKafl rrOnMTHKa KOTOpafl paCmHpfleT COQManbHYID 68 3y 6 Ya3HO KOHTppeBOnIDQHH COBepma­ eMOM ro a no B OM nepecTpoMKH T C 1987 - BenHKaR MHpOBM epiKaBa OK8 3aJIacb Ha rpaHH MelK I ly 6hITMeM H He6hITHeM OrJIR lJ bIBMCb Ha MHHyBIIH1e rO J bI HeBonbHO nOBillllb ce­ 6fl Ha cnH a He 6 na nH B nporpaMMy 06HOarreHaff MCKyCHO BCTpO­ eHa YraJl FCOTOpaR qeM aJIbme TeM 60nbIIIe HCK8JKaJIa 3 aMbIcen ne­ peCTpOMKH KaR OOHOBneHHH COQHaJIH3Ma H nepeBO Hna ee B npHHQHnH­ aJIbHO MHoe HanpaBJIeHMe IIepecTpOI1Ky MOHorronM3YrpOBaJIa Y3KM rpynna Ka6MHeT X nonMTHKOB-P HKaJIOE KOTOpafl MCKyCHO MaHHnynM­ pOBaJIa 06meCTBeHHhIM C03HaHHeM •••• 3 cen CYAH ITO BC eMy COCTO­ fin B TOM TOOhI rrO BeCTM CTpaHy K KpllTM eCKO TOQKe COQHanbHhIX rrOTpHceHHH rro HOMHHaJIb PyxOBOACTBOM KITCC M TIpe3 eHTa-KOMMY­ HMCTa yqHHI1Tb C HVIX pemHTeJIbHhIt t crrpOC I1 ITono3KoB TO HMo genaTb 6 - CYTb OOHOBJIeHM OJIiKHa 3aKJIIOqaTbCfl B TOM qTo6bI npeo o­ JIeTb 36-JIeTHee peHeraTCTBO HaqaBmeeCfl C cepe m'IbI CBB - sa 50-x rO OB rocy apcTBO MKTaTypw rrponeTapMaTa T e 3a MOHonap­ TMMHoe rocy apcTBeHHoe YCTpOHCTBO B KOTOpOM KOMMYHHCTMqeCKaR napTMfl - ftnepMaHeHTHO PYROBO IUiIIlM CMJIa P MKaJIbHB R SKOHOMMQeCKaH CBB pv opMa aJIbTepHaTMBHaR HOq­ HOi1 aBaHTIOpe 3-t1 STan ¥IHH HaTMBHoro C'bes a KOMMyHHCTOB POCCm1 - HeT - aHTMHapo Hoti PeIJOpMe TO eCTb rrepexo ny K PhIHKY OQ T - B03pO MTb oonbmeBMcTcKHM xapaKTep KnCe MCKJIIDqMTb 113 napTMM JIHQ BbICTyrr810mMX sa '4aCTHyIO COOCTB8HHOCTb Hya'LHO pa3MelKe­ BaHHe C OITnOpTyHMCTMqeCKHM PyKOBO CTBOM H CTKa rrapTHH O T 9 - rJPIT- cqHTaeT CeOfl rrpeeMHHKOM 60 bmeBH3Ma npOB03r a­ maeT JI03yHr na 3 paBcTByeT IJ HKTaTypa npOJIeTapl1aTa MPII-IT II TI n - eC H HOBWe CTPYKT BJIaCTH e e He C opMMpOBanHCb OHH He MoryT H H XJ e Toro He XOTRT 3aHMMaTbCR 8 OM eC H TO nap­ TMHHbIe OpraHH3 HH I1 MX KOMMTeTbI IJ OIDKHbI 6paTb ero B CBOl1 PYKl1 M IIo o3KOB - YCTPaHl1Tb 6ypKyasHbItl napJIaM8HTapH3M T e KOHo aTe bHOM 11 HcnO HTeJIbHOM pa3 ne eHl1e 3a­ BJIaCTeM ITep aTb BJIaCTb COBe­ TaM a COBeTbI - TPY JJ HMCR TpYromlMeC ff n OJDKHbI no COOCTBeHHOM HHM 11aTI1Be T C03 n aBaTb COBeTbI Bcex ypOBHe Haql1HaR C KO JIeKTHBa - BOCCTaHOBJIeHl1e BCeBJIaCTRfl COBeTOB paOOQMX 11 JIHKB a l1R Bcex MaCR11pyromHXC ff no IJ COBeTCKyro BJIaCTb 6ypmYa3 napJIaMeHTCKHX CTPYKTyp ITepe n aqa Henocp nCTBeHHOM BJIaCTl1 B PYKH CaMHX TPY IJ RmHX­ CR HeMe n JIeHHOe 11 nOBceMeCTHoe C03 n aHHe COBeTOB COID30B KOM11­ TeTOB CTaqKOMOB MPTI-TIPn - Hac Bcex HapO HhIX n enyraToB Yf3611paJIJ1 He Ha TY rrepe­ CTpOt1KY KOTOpa ff cei1tlac l1 neT IIepBvrtrnoM iNeMKOM COBeTcKoH B a­ CTH nO HbI CTaTb COBeT TPY OB1X KOJIJIeKTHBOB a Tpy nOB@e KonneK­ THBbI - rrepBJ1qHOM M3611paTe bHoM gqeMKoM M ITOJI03KOB Bee nepeQl1CJIeHHWe 3 n eCb opraHM3aqH11 rrpaBo-KoMMyHI1CTJ1qeCKo i1 onn03Hq11M nepecTpoMKe HeO IJ HOKpaTHo BbIcTyrranH C npH3 BaMH K Tpy nE­ mMMCR opaTb B aCTb Ha MecTax B CBOMX PYKM oopa3oB@BaTb C 3T0 i1 e b KOMHTe qeCKH B CTyrraJIH IJ eMcTBy en Hau110H bHoro C rrp113 Ba M11 KOHCT11TyqI1M CCCP cnaceHHH - TO eCTb 'rro CYTl1 M aKTM­ K npflMoMy HaCHJIbCTBeHHOMY HapymeHIDO 11 saKOHOB ro ITPH STOM rrpaBO-KOMMYr HCTmeCKM OITTI03m J H ff He CKphIBaeT liTO OHa rrpOT B rrepeCTpOMKH apKmHPyeT STO HIDaHC - M3BeCTHaH SBOXID­ IJ 11 ff rr03 I1M PYKOBO n CT sa KIT FCOCP B rrOCJIe IJ Hee Bpewr yTBepK IJ aIOII e­ ro qTO OHo- n e He rrpOTHB rrepeCTpO KH H 06HOBJIeHHR HO 3a rrp a­ Hl1e IDJ1 CO l1aJII1CT fqeCKOrO XapaKTepa I1 HanpaBJIeHHOCTH n pyrI18 OIJ eH­ 'KM I1 rr03HIJ MH OCTaIDTC ff rrpM STOM HeH3Me H B TO e BpeMR Bce STH CMJIbI H OpraHl13aIJ HH YTBepli naIOT 'Q'TO OHM - 3a KITCC COIJ HaJIHC­ TaqeCKHM BhI6op KOMMYHMCTKq8CRyID rrepcrreKTMBy MaCKMpyH STMM CBOro orrrr03HIJ HOHHOCTb 06HOBJIeHHID 3 AHTHKOMMYHMcTHqeCKaR orrrro3llql1 A r aBHaH qeCKOM OT aqHTeJIbHaR onrr03 UHH oco6eHHOCTb HelliHeM aHTHKOMMYHHCT11­ - TO qTO OHa B 113BeCTHOM CMWc e rrpO 3BOgHa OT rrepeCTpoHKH Cpe n H Hee npaKTMqeCK11 rrOqTM HeT CM 11 eHTe ea KO­ Topwe Be H 6hI 60pb6y rrpOT B CO l1aJIH3Ma KnCC B n o-rrepeCTpOe'Q'HOe BpeMR M HarrpOTMB BeCbMa c eCTBeHHa B HeH rrpOC OHKa BhIXo eB 113 KnCC B TOM ql1C e 113 HOMeHK aTypHHX ee CJIOeB Cpe 11 HMX HeCOMHeHHO eCTb 11 KOHoIDHKTYP HKM M paHee 06H­ eHH@e 11 KapbepMCThI C HeY OBJIeTBOpeHHHM11 aM6M MffMM Ho 6hI O 6hI OillM6KOM BHAeTb B aHTl1KOMMyHHCTHqeCKOM orrrr03m J MM TOJIbKO STM ee CTopOHbr r aBHyID POJIb B HeM MrparoT H8 n aHHWM MOMeHT I1HMe Termer-rgMM IIepBaR t1 OCHOBHM - 3MOgMOHaJIbHM peaKUMH 3Haql1TeJIbHot1 qaCTv 06meCTBa Ha Bce HeraTMBHoe BCKphIToe TIepeCTPO B HallieH 113HH rrpOlliJIOM 11 HaCTo eM He OyMeHI1H PYXHYBillMX 3TO rrpM'Q'Y MBM CMeCb rHeBa pa30qapOBaH11H H e M paCqeTOB rrepeOIJ eHK11 rrpe CTaBJIe­ Hl1 11 eHHOCTeH omymeHMM 06MaHYTOCTH Top eCTB ero 3 op CTBa 11 MHororo l1HOro B STOM B3phIBe cTpacTeH MHoro rr0311TI1BHOrO STO KpM3MC 06 eCTBeHHOrO C03HaHMR epe3 KOTOpwM HeM36e Ho On HO rrpOMTM OBHOe OOHOBneHRe KaK rrpe oc nKa 06HOaneHMfl rrpaKTwqec­ Koro OH 6 HeM36e eH erKO rrporH03HpOBanCfl To CTWXMM M rroMCK OTBeTa Ha Borrpoc RTO BIDiOBaT yqeToM Toro KTO o n Ha rrpOTff eHMH eH M 70 M' 3aROHOMepHbIM OTBeT C neT MOHorronbHOM PyKOBO ­ HarrpaBnflID eM CM OM ITo806HUe HacTpoeHMfl MO HO M H HO KOMTIeHCMpOBaTb yMHOM M TOHKOM rro HTMKOM M rrporr8 a oM BMecTo SToro - M GTO BTOpaR He­ MaJIOBillKHafl - TeH JJ e MR IDe TarOHM3MpyroT Y CTapTa wrnocTHoro Be bM rrp H rrpoBoRaqMRMH OKYMeHTaJIbHOrO M xapaKTepa Cemac - pa 3rlB1raHMeM KaMIIaHlli1 OXOTbI Ha HaCTO M rr03MqHM HaMepeHHO npOBowmyroT HaRaJIRIOT aH­ rrOMCKOM BparOB MCKnroq MX ITpMMepoM rrpRMOM nID6 e Hapo a 3aHflTHeM rrO MTaqeCKMX OTHOmeHMR KpOMe KoH¢pOHTaQMM rrpOBOK MH RB ReTCR Ha Ham B3rn BOM rro ­ qMBillaff llapOKyro rrpeccy rrporpaMMa-90 rrpHITHC BaeMaff POCCHHCKOMy ueMOKpaTMlIeCKOM y cPOpYMY OceHbID I990 r a l1 O CMX nop OHa illM­ pOKO B M'crrO b30BaJIaCb rrpaBOKOMMYHMCT l11IeCKHMM enzx l1CKpe HTaQM'M eMOKpaT eCKHX CH co ep aHMfl nOKa3 BaeT He TO bKO OpraH M M' BM eHMH 3K eRT HOCTb BopetHIBOCTb ee rryHRTOB Ho M TO qTO K IM aHTarOHM3a HID orrpe e eHHoro C OR 06 eCTBa M eHTenRMM AH M3 ee l1 B3aMMHyIO rrpOTM­ H3 HHX Haqe eH Ha cpe3a 06 eCTBeHHHX oTHorueHMH MHoro pe3ynbTaTa 3Ta rrporpaMMa aTb rrpOCTO He Mo eT e Ha CT HM ee oOc eHMR KpOMe Toro B OTnMqMe OT Bcex oe3 HCK qeHMR yr l1X rrporp paOOqMX CaMhIX pa3HbIX C l1 HapY MBaeT HHKaKOH MH H eH cToR eM 1 OpraHM3aQHH rrporpaMMa-90 He 06­ 3a HeM cOQManbHO-TIOnHTM'qeCKOM M OCO­ B eHMH 6y ero H e HacToR ero aTe bHO H36era­ eT OHa H IOOHX OQeHOK rrepeCTpOHKH KaK rr03MTHB TaK H HeraTMBHH I2 C06CTBeHHO aHTHKOYMYHHCTzqeCKaH CKO bKMMH KaTerOpHHMH napTH onn03 Hn npe CTaB eHa H rpynrr 130 MHOrOM P83 H X He­ Me c060tt _ SMO HOHanbHo-60 e3HeHHaR C nBHO 60nb C03HaHHeM qTO OTpa taeTcn 13 ee noKYMeHTax - napTHSI neMOKpaTHtleCKHH COI03 nC - OTTanRHB aHCg 13 CBoeM aHTHKOMMYHH3Me OT norMaT eCKH noHSlTYX XpHCTHaHCKKX UeHHOCTe - POCC CKoe xpHCTHaHCKOe eMOK­ paTMQ'eCKOe D BIDIeHHe PX J JJ H XPHCTHB HCKo- neMoRpaT eCK ftt com POCCHH xnCP - HCXO nmQM 13 CBoeM 'aHTHROMMYHH3Me H3 COBpeMeHHoro C03HaHHSI H CBoero aHanH3a COBpeMeHHoro nono eHKff 13 CTpaae - Pecrry6nHKaH­ CKag rrapTM POCC CRO e nep8 QHH PIlP POCCHRcRM nH6epaJIbHO­ neMOKpaTHlieCKM rrapTM PJI II neMOKpaTJiqeCK8 fi napTHSI POCCHH UIP H BmtteHHe neMORpaTKtJeCKM POCCM np TIPH STOM 13 IIporpaMMH iX ycTaHOBKax napT BYX rrepBHX rpynrr a TaK e H ynop enaeTeH Ha HCXO nHHa aHTHKOMMYHH3M a MX Orm03 Hg KIICC BClTeKaeT H3' SToro 06mero HenpKffTM KOMMYHHCTHtleC­ np HanpOTIoiB Ha nepBoM rrnaHe C'l'owr KnCC a aHTHROMMYHH3M n T cKopee ROa H IJ eOJIOrHH VIIi PJUUI H rrO MT eCKag npoH3Bo OIIII03KQHH 0'1' eToH onrr03 H OTHomeHMe K nepecTPotiKe IUIH Bcex e'I'IDC napTH Kax npaBKJIO CTOHT Ha BTOpOM nnaae llHmb PTIP H P 13 C130HX rrporp no­ KYMeHT8X CqMTaDT oxapaxTepH3013aTb rrepeCTpo«Ky KaR peaHH­ MaqHD 06BeTmaBmeA TOTanHTapHO CHCTeMH P Ii Cp HB8HHe MHHHCTpaTHBHO-KOM O CHCTeMU em p HKOM KOTO­ C perynHpye ag­ poe HeH36e HO rrpHBe neT K xaocy H B3 BY P OcTanbHHe e He CKa3HBa Cg c06CTBeHHO rrpOTHB nepeCTpO KH C03HaBaH O e 06H38 HhI CBOIDd cymecTBOBa HHeM OT e bHrJle e nporp8 MMHhIe Tpe6oB8HID I3 3TIDC napTHtl Ha naHHOM 3Tane no CylI eCTBY He npOTMIBOpeqaT nepe­ cTpotlxe cnop CKopee H neT 0 Mepe H H npe ne ax npo nBHMeHHH B Tex HH X KOHKpeTH X Bonpocax AHTHKOMMyHH3M COBpeMeH B OTR He OT pe RrH03Horo HKTOBaH npo­ MOTZBaMH K KOTOPHM He b3H He npHc ymaTbCH HanpHMep 060CHO BaeT ero TaR KnCC H oc06eHHO ee HOMeHRRaTypa pac- CMaTpZBaIDT rocy napCTBO co aceM ero Hace eHHeM KaR CBoe rrapT Hoe ecTBO ITPH 3TOM rrporpaMM nOKyMeHT no epRHBaeT qTO p o e KOMMYHHCTR He C03HaDT Bcea rrary6HoCTZ TaKoro no o eHHH qTO He nepeHOCKT CBoe HenpHBTHe ROMMYHHCTKqeCKO H neo orHH Ha OTHomeHHe x KOHKpeTHbIM JIJJ ngM Ii He HMeeT HH MOpaJIbRoro HH IDpH nHT leCKOrO npaBa YCTaHaBJUiB8 Tb CBoero po na cy n H KrICC HH o nao H3 aHTHKoMMYHHcTwqecRKX 06ce nHHeHHa He npH3UBaeT R HaCHJIbCTB HHOMY CBe eHHD cymecT ea BJIacTH XOTH H He CRpHBaeT CBoero CTpeMJIeHHB K r 60ROMY npeo6pasoBaHHJJ CTP Qepes OTKa3 OT rrpH8HaHHH KOMMYHHCT eCKoro yqeHHH KQHaJIbHO rocy napCTBeHHO H neOJIOrHe H ycTaHOBneHHe MHOrOnapTHnHoro napJIaMeHTapH3Ma 3BaHHUX OTHomeHHHX THa B CCCP n031i B Ha­ H rrporpaMMU aHTHROMMYHHCTKqeCRHX nap­ MoryT 6 Tb COnOCTaBJIeH C rrOJIO eHHeM KOMnapTH B CTpa­ Hax 3ana na H OTHOmeHJ leM It HmJI npaB mc TaM rpynn Ii napTH B KOH­ TeXCTe rrap CKJ lX norOBopeHHOCTea 3TO HMeeT 3HaqeHHe ITporpaMMHHe n0KYMeH rrapTaa aHTHKOMMyHHCTHqeCROa onn03KQHH BKJInqaJJT CJIe nynmHe KOHKpeTHUe Tpe60BaHHH H rrpe8JIO eHHH - rp aHCRH rryTb pa3BHTHH 06meCTBa - qepes B03po eHHe JIHtIHOCTH H rpBlK naHHHa J Q - co neHCTBHe CTaHO eHHID rp aHCKOrO 06meCTBa OCHOBaHHOrO Ha cBo6o ne I paIK naH npaBOBOM rocy napCTB e napJlBMeHTcKotl neMOKpa­ THH pxurp MHOrOrrapTHHHhItt napJIaMeHTapH3M Bce rrapTl1M 14 - aKQeHTKpyeTcR OTHomeH ID rrpMopMTeTHOCTb no COWi bHOn Heo6xo HMOCTb C06 eHKH K npaBBM rocy apcTBa 3aIQMTbI B rrepMOn rrepexona K pmnry a c oeB Hace eHMR 3KOXOrKqeCKaH rrO MTKKa qe OBeKa npaB He06xonKMOCTb Ta R e MaJI0HMYlItRX rrepeqMC eHHOe Bce KX - rrapTHH xo ne eonor 3 R 3KOHo eCKOn K CO KaJIbHOMY HOqHOMY rocy apCTBa rronMTHKK X03HnCTBY Ha OCHOBe TIepe­ qaCT­ orrymeHHg HoR c06CTBeHHOCTH B TOM qHCXe R Ha 3eMXID paBHonpaBHE Bcex co6CTBeHHOCTH cBo6o Horo npennpHHKMaTenbCTBa yCTpaHeHHH rocy­ napcTBa OT HenocpenCTBeHHoro PO H qeHHH ero ynpaB eHHg uaxP03KOHOMHQeCKKM rrpenrrpHHTMHMH H OrpaRH­ perY HpOBaHHeM rrpH pasHon CTeneHH rrpopa60TKH H npHopHTeTHOCTH B OTHomeHHH cYnb6 CODsa - OPM CKB3 BaDTCH 06POBO bHW 3KOHOMMqeCKH COD3 Bce rrapTHH OT e bH X BonpOCOf c e He eM CYBepeH rocy apcTB Ha 68 3e COIl3a CCP PJIllII - 3ROHOMHqeCK H BoeHHo-nOXHT eCKKn come CYBepe rry6 HK e erHpyIDmMn qaCTb HcnoxHHTe bHUX YHKqH - cyBepeHHaH enepaTHBHag POCCME CBo6o H@ QeHTpy pec­ P pecrry6 HK B@XOn M3 COCTaBa COD3a HO 6e3 HapyrneHMH rrpHHqKIla paBHorrpaBKH rp aH JJlE H HOHanbHo-rocy apcTBe - pasHo06paSMe ne- epMMH3an YHI naTbCR B pemeHHD 6e3 oe CCCP Ho npon ecc 6esoTBeTcTBeHHoe H HOH bH X rrp06 eM ECTb QTO OCTpO eCTb 3TO M B n03KQHflX CTaBH O 6 OT e eH¥fR o6 eHHe OPM B POCCHM He l OJrn eH CTp BbIPO ­ uq K - TepnRMocTb pxnn aHTMRoMMYHHCT eCKHX rrapTH HeQTO TaROe Borrpoc 0 Heo6xonWMOCTH 60pb6@ Ha Ham B3r p 15 Y B eHH neMOKpaTwqeCKaR POCCMH - Tpe6oBaHH OTCTaBKH rrpe3M eHTa npaBMTe bCTBa rrpH3 B K rp aHCKOMY HenOBHHOBe­ HMID C STOM e bro Tpe60BaHHe HaqMOH M3aQHH MMYmeCTBa KITCC Y R Pxnn - Tpe6oBaHM nO OTOBK 11 C03HBa COOTBeTCTBeHHO Y e HTe bHOrO C06paHM H BcepOCCMMCKOrO 8eMCKOrO Co6opa KOTO­ e npM3Ba no M C H STMX napT Tfl6pbCKYIM l1epeBOpOTOM 19I7 BOCCTaHOBMTb npepBaHHYD OK­ ro n a rrpeeMCTBeHHOCTb 3aKoHHoti BepXOB­ HOM B acTH COOTBeTCTBeHHO B COIDse B POCCM B o CTO O 6 rrp HflTb Bcepbes H no ep aTb BO BC KOM c yqae no n OCTOHHCTBy o eHHTb npH3 B 60 bmHHCTBa rrapTHM PITPt1 xgep PXM IDE l1Q K OTK8 3Y OT HaCHJIbCTBeHHhIX eMcTBHi1 K roqeBOH Bonpoc ce ac - CTBaMH BeCTM 60pb6y rrpOTHB P nrr KaR B KaKKK opMax M KaKMMH cpe n ­ l1Epmti aHTMKOMMyHMCTvrtfeCKOW orm03 H KaKMMH B eTb KOHeq e eJIM STOM 60pb6 3aBe OMO OTKa3 BaTb STHM napTHflM B npaBe Ha c eCTBOBaHHe Ha CBoe MecTO B paMKax MHoronapTHMHOCTH nJIIDpan 3Ma eMORpaTHH 11 rrpaBOBoro rocy apcTBa 03Ha iaJIO 601 He TOJIbKO OCJIOIKHMTb BHellIHHe YCJIOBI1 H OOHOBJIeHI1 fi HO VI rJIaBHOe J onOJIHl1Te bHy O HMtIeM He onpaB aHHyIO aHTarOHVI38 Qmo 06meCTBa rrO HTKqeCKOe npOTMBo6opcTBO C HaMM B COBpeMe YC O­ BHflX BITOJIHe Mo eT CTPOHTbCfl B paMKaX saKOHHOCTH eMOKpaTJ1lieCKotf 60Pb6 sa B aCTb B TO e BpeMR Henp HpffMag H YJIbTpanpaBoro Kpbr beB BOHHCTBeHH8 H rr03MQH rrpaBoro ROMMYHHCTHqeCKotf TOJIbKO pacTymyro p MRarrH3a MID rrapTMM orrnos HH paHee B 3 BaeT 3aHBJIRBm X He 0 CBoeH He-KOMMyHMCTwqeCKOM HO HeMTpaJIbHOH M n eOJIOrMtreCKOM rr03M MM 30I­ BaeT OHa a paCT HerrpVIfl3Hb B oOlqecTBe HeMaJIM tracTb KOToporo HaqMHaeT CtH1TaTb iTO rraPTHtiHHMM 3raMH KIIeC 3aHYIMaeTCfl co6CTBeHHHMM e aMM VI Me K­ a He np06neMaMM CTpaHH STO B CBOID o epe b I6 nopo aeT Tpe60BaHMH OTCTaBHTb eonor eCKKX coo6p eH He Memana nepexoAY K HRY KnCC B CTOpOHY He CTO bKO 3 CKonbKO npOCTO Toro a6 OHa K nap aMeHTap sMY ITpKMepOM SBon H TaKoro po a Mo eT C Tb H3MeHeH e B03­ 3pe A KCHHca ITPM orrpeAe eHHOM COBn eHHH HO Ha Ham 3 eCb B3r HA PO HTCH Ta TpeTbH 06cTORTe bCTB CH a KOTOPas HMeH­ pem T B CBO rrO b3Y MCXO rrpOTHBo6opcTBa Bce OCTpee pa3Bopa B erOCR ce ac Me nepeCTpO KO Me KOMMYH CT eCKOH H COnpOTHBneHHeM e crrpaBa a Ta e H aHTHKOMMYHHCTHqecKoa rpyrrnHpOBKaMH EC H e y acTbCg BBecTH BCD STY 60pb6y B paMRM S8XOHHOCTH OrpaHHqHTb ee 6eCKOMnpOMHCCHOCTb H BsaHMHYD HeTepnKMOCTb TO KMeHHO OTCD a PO HTCg B HTore cTa6HnbH eMOKpaT eCK rrpoQecc SToro o aKO Heo6xo KMO npHCYTCTB e ropa3 o 60nee BHymH­ TenbHHX M opraH SOBaHH X 4 ne CH qeM STO HMeeT MeCTO cero HH ITceB8o-onnosMgHH K STOMY pa3pH MO O OTHeCTH Be KaTeropH rrapT H B eHHA - co6cTBeHHo nonMT eCK e rrapTHH H B eHKR 3aHB R He 0 CBoe eonorKqecKoA CTaB He H nonHT eCKoA He-KoMMYHMcT HOCTM HO He B rrporpaMM He 3 a onrr03WQHH KnCC MepOM rrapTHH TaKOra eMOKpaTOB BH BMr He Ha nepB rr aH rrpaKTKqeCKH MapKCH3MY KOMMYHHCTKqeCKOR eo orHH ITpM­ po a Mo eT C HTb rrapTHH KOHCTHTYQHOHHUX K eTOB - OpraHH3aQMM M 06oe K HeHHR HenonaTKqeCKOrO xapaRTepa PO b H eHTe bHOCTb KOTOP MorYT O H8KO ITpH orrpe e eHH X 06CTOH­ TenbCTBax peSKO rronHTH3HpOB8TbCH 1 3e e e KpMillHaHT yrHe penMrHOS e B eHHH I7 K e rOBOpRT 0 TOTanHTapHOM KOMMYHRCTKqeCKOM peKKMe O HaKO He rrp 3 BaDT K orrn03 HH rrporpaMM e rrpe o eH fi - rrpRopHTeT rrpaB Knee panH CaMO Onn03HqHH Kx TaKO OCTH no OTHomeHMD K rrpaSaM rocy apcTBa H mo6bIX 06rqecTBeHHI lX rpynn - BepXOBeHCTBO 3aKOHa H BceMB DO 3aKOHH@MH aKTaMH - MHor006paSHe 3KOHOMIDUf H IJyXOBHOtl 'lH3HH paBHorrpaSHe Bcex OPM 3Toro MHor006pasHfi - HenpHeuneMocTb HaCH bCTBeHH X crroc060B paspemeHRfi rrO HTH­ qeCKHX H C H b RO KTOB - nn6Ne OPMH H eo orHH - qacTHoe e o rp aH - He eOJlorIDr a srnpaBHtit CM1i£CJI H HOpMbl 06rqeqe OBeqeCKott MopanH Be eHH Bcex 06 eCTseHHHX e C yqeToM Toro O e CHnaM - CTOpOHHHRaM rrepeCTpO K H O Ho eHHH rrp eTCH KOHRypHpOBaTb rrpaKT eCKH sa O Horo H Toro e H36HpaTenR rrpe CTaBnReTCR He CTOflb y HeB03MO M COID3 nepe­ CTpOI1Inr BpeMeHHbII1 ym r 60JIee npo nOJIiKVITeJIbHhIM C CMJIaMM cerO HR e e BOCTIpMHHMae H 5 KaK orrrr03KqHfi H3-3a HX HerrpMB OCTM esoCOurraRMcTwqecKMe nB eHMR OHM rrORa HeMHOrOQHCJIeHH@ He o eHb C H CTa KHBaIDTCR C oc06eHHo Cepbe3HMMM TPY HOCTRMM CaM0YTBep eHHR eHTM M MPOBaTb ce6R MM C O HO C rrepeCTpO ROa rrOCKOJIbKY rrepeCTpOMKa Tec­ HO ' Bfi3aHa c rrpe cTaB eHM ffMM 0 KrICC OHM He MOT'YT H He XOTRT npOTMBorrOCTaB flTb TM ecRoi1 ee ce6H HB KnCC CO HaJIHCTKqeCRoMY BH6opy cO HanHc­ TO e BpeMR aIDTCR B co6CTBeHHOM nKqe OCTaeTCR rrpaKT eCRM O MH rryTb - no RpaMHeti Mepe 1 0 Tex TIOp nORa nepeCTpOMRa He rrp eT xx no CBoe KP O - rrOBTopHTb B Ham 18 YCJIOB ffi COQMaJI- n eMOKpaTflqeCKYIO JIHHHD RaE OHa CJI01KHJIacb cet1 Qac B MHpe qTO n eJIaeT oTe ecTBe e HacTo ee BpeMR BHyTPKnOJIHTKqeCK eBoco anHCT eCKHe n B eHRH B BeCbMa Yfi3B H oc06eHHO BHYTpM KnCC H B pOCCHaCKOM ee qacTH aTO HanpaBJIeHHe npe n CTaB eHO ceRqac MapRCHcTCKot1 nJIaT OpMO B KIICC MIT eMOKpaTlNeCKmA IJ BmlteHHeM KOMMYHHCTOB nuK COD Ha- JIHCT ecKott napTHe CIT H CO Y 8JI- n eMORpa THtreCKO napTHea POCCIm C J TIPL MapKCHCTCKM IlJIaTli op 18 13 KIICC Ilo rr n ep2ltaJIa 06p8 30BaHHe KIT PC@CP KaK cIloc06HOa rrpOTHBOC OfiTb aHTKKOMMYHHCT eCKRM napTHRM n BIDlteHHmA B nepBYD o epe b 6JIOKy eMOKpa THtleCKM POCCHJI GHa TBep n o CTOHT aa n03HQKffX COD HaJIHCT eCKoro CT eCRO IlepCIleKTHB B TO e BpeMJI B 60pa H ROMMYHH­ CKa3UBaeTCJI 3a YRpenJIeHHe 3aKOHHOCTH H nop Ka C06JIID IJ eHHe KOHCTHTyQHH BepXOBeHCTBO COIDS­ 3aKOHOB nOJIHTHQeCKyID 60pb6y TOJIbKO Ha rrpaBoBot1 H KOHCTHTY­ QHOH O OCHOBe GHa no e HBaeT p@HOK 6e3 3KcnJIyaT HH H B CTY­ rraeT 3a JIe H 6JIOK CO BceMH KTO pa3 n eJIHeT COD HaJIHCTHqeCKHe H IJ e aJIbI • neMOKpaTHQeCKOe 8B eHHe KOMMyHHCTOB He onpe n eJIRH nOKa CBOK rr03 mo no KOHKpeTHblM BorrpOC8M BbtCKa3hIBaeTCH 3a IIPe06p83 oBaHHe KIlCC B napTHIO pa3 rr eJIHIOOQ7lO npH mm neKJIap H CoqIDiTepHa ITo n yxy H rrCHXOJIOrHH OHO B TO e BpeMH BO MHorOM 6JIH3KO K MIT 3TH n B eHHH CgrpaJIH CBOD POJIb B CTKMyJIHpOBaHHH TBOpQeCKot1 BHyTpMIlapTH HO n HCKyCCWH ITpe rr CTaBJIHeTCJI O IJ HaKo COMHHTeJIb qT06 B CJIyqae rrpo o eHRJI H yr 6JIeHHJI H IJ e HOro H OpraHH3aQHOH­ Horo pa3Me eB81nUI B KIICC OHH cMor vr 60r OTTJIHyTb Ha ce6 H 3 opOBbIe l P HOHaJIbHbte CHJIbl B napTHH r9 CogHan-8eMOKpaTHqeCR - nonHT ecKYD napTHH POCCHH CKaS BaeTCR sa 3ROHo ecKYD Ii conHanbHyD eMOKpaTliD _ OTHomeHHH rpa AaHCKOrO Mapa Me OHanbHott rapMOHHH Ii CO lianbHoro napTHepcTBa - nocne OBaTenbHU pepOPMli3M H npOTHB peBon H - TepnHMOCTb H B03BpameHHe POCCHH B pycno M OBO 'qMBHnH3a­ -'yTBe eHHe COQH Horo PHHoQHoro XOSR CTBa CB060 TPy­ a npe pHHHMaTenbCTBa - npliBaTH3 HD H paBHonpaBHe Bcex OPM co6CTBeHHOCTH - acTHYID co6CTBeHHOCTb Ha SeMnD - CO HanbHyID H 3KOnOrKqeCRyID 3amHTy - rp aHCKOe 06 eCTBO Ii eMOKpaT eCKoe rrpaBOBoe rocy apCTBO KOHRpeT e OPMH ROToporo O H 6 Tb pa60TaHH H3HbD - KOaJIHqHID co BceMH KTO rrpOTHB sa peMbHYD peCTaBp HH MHoronapT HOCTb H ITOnHT eCKJ i TOTMHTapJ i3Ma nnmpaHH3M CogHanHcT eCKaR naprHH npOB03rnamaeT CBO rryTb KaR peBOnD­ qHo e P OPMH co anHCTwqeCKoe 6y ee Hame CTpBHU B e­ MOKpaT eCKOM e OHa - sa CMemaHHyD 3KOHOMHRY pa3HbIe c06CTBeHHOCTH rrpH CTHMynHpOBaHHH 06 eCTBeHH X Ii epopw pOCrryCK KonxOSOB COBX030B Ii CB060 B 6op epOpM cenbCKoro X03RHCTBOBaHHR BRnro­ trM J 06pOBonbHbIM B03BpaT K HbIHeDlHHM C06CTBeHHHKaMH npe IU1PH$ITH H HHBeCT HOHHb1X lflOa nOB n OJDltHbl CTaTb COBeTbI IlonMTHtrecKM H 31 0­ HOMHQeCKM eMOKpaTHH KynbTypHO-HaqliOHaJIbHM H TeppHTOpHaJIbHM aBTOHOMliH epe n ep Hfi Ha OCHOBe HOBoro COD3HOrO n orOBopa 3amHTa rrpaB qenOBeKa ConH bHO-3KOHOMHqeCKHerapaHTHH eMOKpaT eCKaR 60pb6a sa BnaCTb 20 rrpOBOSr amaff CBOR nporp BO MHOrOM rrepeRnHK RecR C nepeCTpO KO HO Roe B qeM R OTnHqHHe OT ITna op e CTB KnCC HM C HH CIT He nOABepraDT Han RaM KOMMYHMCTOB KnCC He aKQeHTHpyDT CBOD Onn03 QROHHOCTb KnCC O HaKO B e OM ro oc eBOCO HanHCT eCKHX CRn KaK B KITCC TaR H B 06 eCTBe B e oM 3ByqHT nORa c a60 H He-BrreqaTnHTenbHO qTO 06 CHgeTCR He B noc e HD Oqepe b KpaHHeH cnO HOCTbID CTO­ Hme rrepeA HHMH 3 a HMeHHO HM 06oeKTHBHO npe CTOHT TBrH­ BaTb CO HanHCT ecKYID eID TeopeT eCKoro H3 nepemHBaeMoro em H npaKT eCKOro ce ac HAeMHO­ KpM3Hca Bo BCHKOM cnyqae KOH­ cepBaTOpu Ha STO RBHO He crroco6 • 6 I B0H¥ KnCC He 06Hapy Hna nOKa BO H H cnoc06HOCTH K pemHTe bHOMJ neMOKpaTHqeCKOMY CaM006HOBHeH eHTp Hg B Hea npOHcxOAHT ycKopeHHaH KOH­ H OpraHH3 OHHOe CnnOqeHHe CHn Bce 6o ee HenpHMHpHMO H BOHHCTBeHHO B CTyn MX npOTHB nepeCTpO KH HB IDTCR Teope­ THqeCKHe KOHQe HH H nCHXonor eCKHe CTepeOT Ra3 OCb 6 AaBHO OCTaB eHH e B npomnOM RKTaTypa npo eTapHaTa 060CTpeHHe KnacCOBoa 60pb6H rrpH CO H H3Me H T n HapacTaDT HaCTpoeHHR SKCTpeMHSMa B TO e BpeMH He npOHcxOAHT CO CTaBKMOM KOHcon aQHH CRn KOTo e nOAKpen gnM H paSBHB H 6 nepeCTpO KY B TeopHM H npaK­ THRe EC H TaKHe npo ecc H HAYT TO nORa OHR B OCHOBHOM oCTaur­ CR nOA cnYAoM M60 B BaDTCH sa npene KITCC 2 ITPH KM Bce ynpeKoB H B p cnyqaeB oCTpoTe SaHHTHX n03KQHtt B3a­ 06BHHeHH mnH bKax H - no KOHKpeTHHM BOnpOCaM npaKTwqecKoM BHTI ax B ec yr yra H3EH Me CaMUMH napTHKMH 06HapY HBaeTcR nopasHTenbHHtt oBeHh COBITggeHRR Pa3 2I B08opa38e rrpOXOHllT He CTonhKO Me 8Y rrepeCTpOHKOH M orrrr03HUMex en CKonhKO Memgy KOMMYHHCTH eCKOM orrn03MUHe rrepeCTpO Ke H Bce­ MH OCTaJIhHbIM CllJIaMYJ EblCTyna IDIgY1MH 3a 06HOBJIeH e Barnero 06rneCTBa XOTfi H rro pasHOMY rrpe8CTaB flEmRMH-ce6e rny6HHy H mopMH TaKOrO 06HOBJIeHIDI Oco6eHHO o eBff8HO 3TO B cffiepe BHeillHen rrO HT RH Ha cero TO bKO 0AHa rrapTIDt ctPoPMYmq OBaJIa nO Oi'KeHIDI ITPRMO OTBepraIQmHe HOBoe rrOJIHT eCKoe eHHe py 8Ta napTHfi - KIT rrpH3UBaDmHe K rrOJIHoMY ero rrepeCMOT­ pc p H BCH THrbTeDmaH K He KOMMYHRCTYJqec­ KaH orrn03HnHfl nepeCTpO Re Bee OCTaJIb e napTHH JIH60 8KT eCKH no e HBaroT BHemHID nO HTHKY nepeCTpoaKH JIH60 He B CKasNBaIDT npflMO OTp aTe hHoro eJIb ee OTHomeHHH K 3Toa rrO HTHRe B QeJIOM RJIH OT­ COCTaB WM ITpaBoMepeH B BO O OCTpOTa nO HT eCRHX npOTHBOCTOHHH 060RCHHeTCH ceWqac ByMfl r aBH@MH tPaKTOpaMH - rrpOHCXOnH T eCTeCTBeHHaH B eMOKpaTaqeCKKX YC OBHHX Mei'K­ napTHnHaH 60ph6a KOHKypeHUHfl 3a B acTh H BJIHHHHe B 06m e CTBe KOTopaa B HaIDKX 06CTOflTe hCTBax B CTpaHe OC Oi'KHReTCfi KpH3HC rro o eHHeM OTCyTCTBHe nO HT eCKoro OllHTa HeTepnHMOCThID nOTpe­ 6HOCThID napTHM H B eHHM B C8Mo eHT HK HH H CaMoYTBep eHHH - HO eCTeCTB€HHOCTh 3Ta HapymaeTcH npOfianeHHRMK Heo6oJIhme­ BHCTCKO HeTeprrHMOCTH HMH KaK C rrpaBoro TaR H eBoro aH­ ra KaK ll3 pH IJ OB KIICC H KIT PC P TaR H rrpOTHBOCTO MX HM 8 HTH­ KOMMYHHCT eCK 06oe KHeHMn O axo C 6o ee cH hHoro o THoro BJIacTHoro H cnpoc o eH 6@Th 6o hme 3 HacTyrrHJI MOMeHT Kor a rrepecTpo Ka 8o Ha onpe8eJIHTbCH C co6cTBeHHoM rrOJIHTHqeCKOH nOHJIbHOCThID Ee eOJIOr eCKaH JIOHJIb­ HOCTb HeH3MeHHa 3TO rrpHBep eHHocTh COQH HcT ecKo ee TIOJIHTM­ qeCKH iKe rrpe cToMT B 6op qTO e op0i'Ke - KnCC JIH He3aBMC O OT ee peaJIhHOrO o6JIMKa HJIM iKe H eH cOQHanH3Ma 6JIaro Hapo a Qe H H e o6HoB eHMH