r 19 Th Adorno Soziologische Schriften Bd I S 366 20 Revolution and Class struggle p 186 21 Le Monde 4 mai 1980 p XVI 22 L'Esprit 1976 fevr No 2 p 253 23 Partisan Review 1977 No 2 p 180 24 A H fypelm'l IIpoGrrcMbl rCHe3Hca ljJeOAaJlH3Ma B 3ana I Hotl EBporre M 1970 c 13 25 26 30eHeK MJlUHapJIC o i AKTOPAX 06YCJ10BJ1I1BAIDIIlI1X KPI1311CLI CI1CTEM COBETCKOrO Tl1nA B 80-e rO lLl R He HaMepeH 3aHHMaTbCH rrpOpOl JeCTBaMH HeiillIero pa3BHTHH TaM lKC L'Esprit 1978 No 7-8 p 27 CHCTeM COBeTCKoro THrra OTHOCHTeJIbHO Aanb­ R OCTaHOBJUOCb TOJIh­ KO Ha 06ruHX 'IepTaX xapaKTepHbIx AJUI TeHAeHUHii KOTophIe B CBO­ eii OCHOBe o6YCJlOeJleHbi JTOU cucTeMou H KOTOphIe BhI3bIBaJOI H 6y­ AYT BbI3hIBaTb KPH3HCbI B CTpaHax rAe COBeTCKaH CHCTeMa YCTaHo­ 27 28 O Sik Der dritte Weg Hamburg 1972 S 209 CM K MapKc JI 3HreJlbc CO'l T 19 c 496497 - 0 KopeHHOM OTllH­ '1HH eBponetlcKoro HCTOpH'ICCKOro pa3BHTlUf OT a3HaTcKoro BHJIaCh R rrOnbITaJOCb TaKJKe OTBeTHTh Ha KOHKpeTHbIH Borrpoc Ka­ KHMH HOBbIMH B rrpOllIJIOM erue He npOHBHBlIIHMHCH rrOCJIeACTBHH­ MH MorYT 6bITb l JpeBaTbI KPH3HCbI CHCTeMbI COBeTCKoro THna H rro­ rrbITKH HX rrpeOAOJIeHHH B 80-e rr R rrocTapaJOcb rrpOaHaJIH3HpOBaTb JIOT Bonpoc Ha OCHOBe AaHHbIX 0 BHYTpHrrOJIHTJi IeCKOM pa3BHTHH CHCTeMbI COBeTCKoro THrra H C Y'IeTOM MeJKll YHap0ll HbIX CBH3eii TeHLleHUHH npOJlBJIHJOlUHeCJI B npouecce npeOAOJIeHHJI KpH3HC3 COUHaJIhlIO-nOnHTtI'IeCKHX CKCTeM COBerCKoro THDa OrrbIT nOKa3blBaeT 'ITO HHCTHTYTbI B03HHKII1HC B COBeTCKOM Co­ J03e B 30-e rOAbI He rrpeTeprreJI i Ka'leCTeeHHbIX U3J teHeHUU no-­ rrpeJKHeMY cyruecTByeT rrOJIHOe CJIHliHHe rrOJIHTHqeCKOii H 3KOHOMH­ 'IeCKOH BJiaCm JIJOAH IlO-npeJKHeMY 3aBHCHT H B COUHaJIbHOM CMhl­ CJIe OT I10JllUHQCCKOii BJIaCTH CKOHueHTpHpOBaHa B a6COJIJOrHaH BJIaCTb no-rrpeJKUCMY PYKax ueHrpa KOMMYHHCTHl JeCKOH napmH IlO-npeJKHeMY OTcyTcTByer 06paTHaH CBH3h MeJKAY OfiruCCTBOM H BJIaCTbJO H rrO-rrpeJKHeMY AeHcrByer MexaH1UM I10JIHTHQeCKOrO Hall ­ 30pa OrpaHHQeHHH HHq opMaUHH H KOHTponH HaA YMaMH JlJOll eH OrpbqlOK H3 KHHfH Zd 1981 prispt vck k teoretickc 42 Krize v sovctskych systemech 1953­ Index K5ln 1983 43 I Hexo ' noro omm MO O np onOl''' 'ITO 'CM 'p' paTHOH CBH3H KOTopaH rr03BOJIHlla 6bl HM caMOCTOlITeJIbHO orrpe le­ 25 JIHTb CBOH lIellH H Cpe lCTBa HX IOcTHJKeHHlI caMOCTOJITeJIbHO Bbl­ Ha npOiOOlllep UUle 3a nOCllep HHe lleT nepeMeHbI npHcymHe CH­ CTeMe paKTOPbl 06YC1l0Bl1I1BalOll He ee KPH3HCbl 6yP YT p eHCTBO­ 6paTh OI1THMaJlbHbIe C HX T01 JKH 3peHH1I MepbI ABTOHOMHJI cy61 ­ BaTb H B 80-e rO J bI T e H B 80-e rop bl 6yp eT OrpaHH1 JHBaTbClI cno­ eKTa BO Bcex nHX 06JIaCTHX OrpaHHlJeHa nOllHTHlJeCKOH BJIaCThIO C06HOCTb COII HaJlbHbIX cy6 eKToB H 06mecTBa KaK lIe1l0rO K caMO­ H He TOr la KOrl1 a cy6 eKT peallH3yeT caMOCTOlITellbHOe pellleHHe a ynpaBlleHHIO YJKe TOr la KOrl1 a cy6 eKT CBoe pellleHHe TOl1bKO onpel1 eJIJIeT Kapll B Ll eHlJ TaK onpep elllIeT ycnOBH1I B KOTOPbIX cy6 eKT MO­ KeT caM C060H ynpaBmITb Bce 3TO 3By1 JHT BeCbMa a6CTpaKTHO HO HMeHHO OrpaHHlJeHHaH aB­ TOHOMH1I cy61 eKTa JIBJIlIeTClI 06mHM 3HaMeHaTelleM Tex KOHKpeT­ HbIX np06JIeM KOTopbIe 06YC1l0BllHBalOT rrOCTOlIHHO nOBTOp CaMoynpaBlllIeMblH KOlllleKTHB nOCTOlIHHO p Oll KeH nOllY­ lJaTh TpH BHp a HH POPMaIlHlf Bo-nepBbIX HH popMaIlHIO 06 OKp lOmeM MHpe BO-BTOPbIX HH p0pMaII H1O 0 npOlll1l0M eClI mH­ lIlO KPH3HCbI T e Hel1 OCTaTOlJHaH caMOCTOlITeJIbHOCTb COII HallH­ CTHlJeCKHX rrpel1 npHJITHH OTCYTCTBHe HMnyllbCOB CTHMYJIHPYIO­ lllHX HHHQHaTHBHbIe H lKOHOMHlJeCKH 3 p peKTHBHbIe l1 ei cTBHlI rrpo­ H B-TpeTbHx HH p0pMaII H1O 0 ce6e H p pyrux meMeHTax co­ H3BOI1 HTeJIeH CTaBlllIlOll HX opraHOB BJIaCTH 0 IeHCTBHTellbHOCTH OTCYTCTBHe TBOplJeCKOH CBO­ 06mecTBo B KOTOpOM l1 aHHbIH KOJIJIeKTHB PYHKII HOHHpyeT ECllH Ke Op HH H3 3TUX nOTOKOB HH p0pMa­ IIHH OKa3bIBaeTCJI HapyllleHHbIM HllH 3aCeKpelJeHHbIM 06mecT­ BO TPaHC p0pMHpyeTCJI B aBTOMar OHO TepJIeT KOHTPOllb Hap p eii CTBHlIMH He TOllbKO COCTaBlllIlOmHX ero 31leMeHTOB HO H Hap CBOHMH c06CTBeHHbIMH QeH3ypa HCKaJKeHHble npe lCTaBJIeHH1I rpaJK naH H 60 lbI HH3Be leHHe npaBocYP HJI 10 POllH 0PYII HJI HOi BJIaCTH H T n rOCYl1 apCTBeH­ B CTpaHax r le YCTaHOBHllaCb COBeTCKaH CHCTeMa MeTOl1 bI nOllH­ THlJeCKOH BllaCTH H3MeHHllHCb 3a HCTeKIlIHe 25 JIeT HO He HC1le3 TO TaJlbHbIH KOHTPOllb 3TOH BllaCTH Ha l 06meCTBOM Kor la JKe npH npo­ Bel1 eHHH pe POPM cBepxy KaK B qexOCJIOBaKHH B 1968 ITo nOH JKe npHlJHHe OrpaHHlJHBalOTCJI cnoc06HOCTH OTp eJIbHbIX Cy61 eKTOB K caMoynpaBlleHHIO nOCKOJIbKY HX aBTOHOMHlI orpaHH­ lJHBaeTClI OTCYTCTBHeM 06paTHOH CBJI3H MeJKp y cy6 eKTOM H OKpy­ JKalOmeH ero cpeP OH CBJI3H nocpeP CTBOM KOTOPOH cy61 eKT nOJIy­ r HllH B pe3YJIbTaTe HaJKHMa CHH3Y KaK B IIOJIbllIe B 1981 r CTaJlO HeB03­ MOJKHO OcymeCTBllJITb TOTaJlbHbIH KOHTPOJIb ero BOCCTaHOBHJIH CH­ JIOH llOllbITKH CMJIrlJHTb nOT KOHTPOllb HeH36eJKHO 6Yl1 YT npe lrrpH­ lJaeT HH popMaQHIO He06xol1 HMYlO eMY WJlI He3aBHCHMoro npHHJI­ HHMaTbClI H B 6YlJ yIUeM rrOCKOllbKY HeB03MOJKHO nOIJ aBHTb crpeM­ THH pellleHHH IiMeHHO no noMY Ka J p aH nOJIHTHlJeCKaH BllaCTb CTpe­ JIeHHe JIIO Ieii K He3aBHcHMoCTH K CaMOCTOlITeJIbHOMY pellIeHHIO CBO­ HX l1 eJI MHTCJI B KaKOH-TO CTeneHH HapymHTb 3Ty CB1I3b Oll HaKO npH TO­ TallHTapHOH BllaCTH 06paTHa1I CBJI3b KOHTpOllHpyeTCJI nOJIHOCTblO TO eCTb caMa BllaCTb onpel1 eJIlIeT KalJeCTBeHHbIH H KOllHlJeCTBeHHbIH xa­ paKTep nOH CB1I3H CH­ CTBeHHa1I l1 eJITellbHOCTb lTHX cTpaH HX BHYTPH06mecTBeHHble CBlI­ OCHOBblBa1ICb Ha 3TOM KpHTepHH MOJKHO Cl1 eJIaTb BbIBOI1 lJTO no­ llHTHlJeCKa1I BllaCTb 3aKOJII1 OBaHHbIH Kpyr B KOTOPOM 11 0 cux nop BpamalOTClI CTeMbl COBeTCKoro THna lIBJIlIeTCJI pe3YllbTaTOM Toro 1 JTO X031IH­ rOCrrOI1 CTBYlOmaJI B HaCTOJImee BpeMlI B CTpa­ 3H H KyJIbrypHoe TBOplJeCTBO HaIIpaBJIeHbI Ha 11 0CTHJKeHHe Oll HOH­ el1 HHcTBeHHoH lIeJIH - Ha BocnpoH3BOl1 CTBO cymecTBYlOmeH B nux Hax COBeTCKoro 6JIOKa XOTH H OTJIHlJaeTCJI OT nOJIHTHlJeCKOH BJIaCTH CHcTeMax CTPYKTypbI BllaCTH Ii KaK TOJIbKO 3al1 a1 JH 3KOHOMHKH 06­ CTaJlHHCKUX BpeMeH npO lOllJKaeT OCTaBaTl ClI TOTaJlHTapHoH meCTBeHHoro Pa lBHTHJI H KYllbTypbI CTaBlIT rrO l yrp03y CTPYKTYPY B cOBpeMeHHblx COII HaJlbHO-rrOJIHTHlJeCKHX CHCTeMax COBeTCKoro THna COIIHallbHble cy6 eKTbI 06meCTBeHHbIe HHCTHryTbI HHp HBHP YYMbI COII HaJlbHble rpyIII1hI He HMelOT TaKOH HH p0pMaII HOHHOH 06­ BJIaCTH BJIaCTb pal1 H COOcTBeHHoro CnaCeHH1I nOl1 aBJIJIeT eCTeCT­ BeHHbIe nOTpe6HocTH 06mecTBa KaKHx JKe COIIHaJIbHO-nOJIHTHlJeCKHX H3MeHeHHH CHCTeMbl COBeT­ CKoro mITa Cllen yeT oJKHl1 aTh B caMOM 6JIH KaHllieM 6yn ymeM OT­ 44 K W Deutsch Nervy vlady Praha 1971 Str 215-216 BeTHTb Ha lTOT Bonpoc MOJKHO TOJIbKO rHnOTeTHlJeCKH OII HaKO WJlI 45 rpOpMyJIHpOBKH HeKOTOphIX nmOTeJ Y l C HMCIOTCfl CepheJHhle OCHO­ BaHIUl BhITCKalOmHe HJ OnhITa npOIlInhIX neT HbIe KarrHTaJIOBJIO l eHHfl Kor a rrepc HapO HbIM X03flHCTBOM CTa B 3KOHOMU'IeCKOii 061laCTU MO l HO O I H aTh 'ITO rpaKTopbI KO­ TOpbIC BblJBanH KpHJHC B npOMhIIIlnCHHO pa3BHThIX rocy apCTBax HanpHMCp B qcxoCJloBaKHH H I'llP npmI BflTCH H B CCCP BHnHCh cOBepIllcHHo HeBbIlIonHHMble Tpc60BaHHfl r Y 11 BCC l e BhIXO H3 KP 3HCHOro rrOJIO CHHH B KaKoH-To CTcrreHli crroc06CTBOBaJIO illHPO­ nonO l HTCJIhHOe BnHHHHC KanHTaJIOBnO eHHH npoIllnhIx JICT HMeH KHC BOJMO l HOCTH MaHCBpHpOBaHHH BOJHHKIlIHC 6J1aro apfl KOH­ HO JTH nycTb 11 Hepa3YMHbIC KanHTanOBJIO CHHfl cIIoc06cTBOBaJIH IJ CHTpalJ HH JKOHOMH'IeCKOH H nOnHTH'leCKOH BnaCTH B pyKax OMO­ HOBOMy rrO 'beMY JKOHOMHKH nOJTOMY HeKOTophle 3KOHOMHCThI­ ro IJ CHTpa B npOIlIJlOM nOJBOJlflnH JKCTCHCHBHO pa3BHBaTb JKOHO­ TeopCTHKH rOBopHT 0 KBaJH-IJ HKnaX KPH3HCOB 0 rrOnHTH'leCKHX MHKy COBCTCKoro rocy apCTBa Ho KaK TonhKO rpaKTopbI JKCTCH­ UHKJlaX B HapO' HOM XOJHHCTBC opraHH30BaHHOM no COBeTCKOMY CHBHoro paJBHTHfl HC'ICpnblBaIOT CC6fl H HC MorYT 60JlhIllC 06ecnc­ 'IHBaTh POCT JKOHOMHKH peIllalOmCC JHa'lCHHC npH06pCTalOT rpaK­ TOPbI 06pall Y· nplfllHHY JTHX KpHJHCOB aBTOphI raKHX TCOPHH Bl1MT B BOJIIOHrapH3Mc H cy6'bCKrl1BH3Me IIpaBHTellcH HHTCHCHBHoro paJBHTmr POCT rrpOH3BO HTCJlhHOCTH Tpy a 2 BBC CHHC TCXHlflICCKHX HOBIIlCCTB npOflBnCHHC nH'IHOH HHHl HaTH­ ECJIl1 l C B KP 3HCHOM rrOJIO eHHH OKa3hIBaJIHCh KOHKPCTHhIC OrpaCJIH B crpcpe rrp0113Bo' cTBa rroTpe6JICHlUI HJIH HaYKl1 ro JIH Bhl H nOBblIllCHHC JrprpCKTHBHOCTH JKOHOMHKH HC OCTaTKH xapaKTcpHbIe IJ lH JKCTCHCHBHoro pa3BHTHfl JKOHO­ MHKH npH JTOM HC HC'lC3aIOT ccnbCKOC X03flHCTBO npo on l aCT OT­ PCIIlCHHH B03Hl1KIIlCH np06JICMbI lJ eHTp IIOJlHrl1'leCKOH 6eran K 'lpC3BhJ1 aHHbIM McpaM BJIaCTH npH­ JIfl aHHoH OrpaCJIH HpeKTHBHo CTaBaTh OT npOMhIIllJICHHOCTH paJJlH'IHbIC OTpaCJIH rrpOMbIIIlJICHHO­ C03 aBaJIHCh OC06blC rrpHBHJICrHpOBaHHhle ycnoBHH 06eCnC1IHBaB­ CTH npO OJI I aIOT palBHBaThCH HcpaBHOMcpHO H 'IaCTO B 3aBHCHMO­ IIlHC 3a aHHbIC TCMnbI pocTa pa3YMccTCH OIIHTh-raKH 3a C'lCT ' py_ CTH OT Toro Kal OH HJ HHX OT aCTCfl npCnnO'lTeHHe no nonHTlflIC­ mx orpacncH TaK HanpHMep B HCKOTOPhIX OrpaCJIHX BOCHHOH CKHM C006pa l CHHHM Bcc JTO 06YCJIOBJIHBaCT nOCTOflHHYIO HCXBaT­ npOMbllIIJICHHOCTH H B 06nacTH CBJI3aHHbIX C HeH Hccnc oBaHHH ra­ KY MHorHX TOBapOB a B pCJynhTaTc - KOH crroc06 IIpc 'ynpe eHHH KpH3Hca craJI HOpMOH HanH'lHC 'lCpHOrO pbIHKa npOHJBO' CTBCHHbIC npCnnpHflTHH rro-npe l HCMY PYKOBO CTBYIOTCfl HPCKTHBHblMH l aCT rrOKaJaTCJlHMH nnaHa a TO B CBOIO O'lCpC h CHH­ JrprpCKTHBHOCTh CbIphH H JHCpmH npOH3BO CTBa 'lPCJMCpHOe rroTpc6JICHHC 06pa30BaHHC KpyrrHbIx JarraCOB CbIPbfl rrony­ rpa6pHKaTOB H pC3cpBa pa60'leH CHJIbI rro aBJICHHC HOBaTOpCTBa HacTyrrHBIIll1H B KOHlJ e 70-x rO OB cna JKOHOMH'leCKOrO pocra TaKHMH MepaMH BpH JlH MO I HO 6y' er npHocTaHoBHTh nOCKOJIhKY rrpl1'lHHbI KpH3Hca 70-x rO OB Y l e HCJlh3H 06'bHCHHrh BOJlIOHrapH3­ MOM a B npHBHJIerHpOBaHHhIX ycnOBl1 f X HY aJIHCh B 70-c rO hI BCC oTpacnH x03HHcrBa KOTOPOC Morno 6bI npHBCCTH K nOBhIIlICHHIO nnaHOBbIX nOKaJaTCJICH B 6Y YIllCM HH3KOC Ka'lCCTBO H3' CJIHH OTCYTCTBHC HHTcpeca I Pa3pa3HBIlIHifcH B cTpaHax COBcrCKoro THna B KOHlJ e 70-x ro OB JKOHOMH1 CCKHH KpH3HC nOTpc6HOCTflM pbIHKa H 'lpe3MepHafl JaHHTepCCOBaHHOCTb B BhIlIon­ HCHHH nJlaHOBblX rrOKa3aTcnCH 6C30THOCHTCJIhHO K HX JKOHOMH'lC­ CKOH UCJlCC006pa3HOCTH H T 3TH flBJIeHHH HMCBIIlHe MCCTO H B OTJIH'laJICH OT rrpOllIJlhIX H TeM 'ITO He Bce 06YCJlOBHBIIlHC nor KpH3HC rpaKTophI BblTeKaJIH H3 CYIllHOCTH aH­ HOM CHcreMbI HarrpOTHB HeKoropbIe npHl HHbI KpHJHCa COBepIlleH­ HO KOHKpcrHbI rrpOIllllOM npHo6pCTYT oco6oc JHa11CHHC Kor a a e B CCCP Y C HCJIh3fl 6Y CT paJBHBaTh JI OHOMHKY JKCTCHCHBHO H MHC YMacT­ Cfl 'ITO COBCTCKM JI OHOMHKa y C BOllIJla B JTOT JTan B rrpOIllJIOM CCPhC3HhIC JKOHOMHl CCKHC KPH3HChI npeO OJICBa­ JlHCh B CTpaHax COBCTCI OrO THna B OCHOBHOM ByMfl cIIoco6aMH - mcpreTH'leCKHe PCCYPCbI 06bI'lHO JKOHOMHKa JTHX cTpaH OKa3blBaJIaCh B KPH3HCHOM B ro C BpeMJI HH TCXHlflICCKHH ypoBeHh HH rpHHaHcoBbIC B03MO l HOCTH CCCP He oCTarO'lUbl J1JI 3KCIIJ1yaralIHl1 3aJIC eH mepmH B TH I CJ10 ocrYIIHbIx paiiOHax CH6HpH 1 cBponeifcKOH 'laCrH CCCP Y C HC MoryT rrOKpblTh rrorpc6HoCTH Bcero COBCTCKoro 6J10Ka 3ro 06CTOHrCJ1bCrBO craBHT no yr­ p03y JKOHOMH'lCCKOe pa3BHTHe Bcex eBpOrreHCI HX rocy apCTB CO­ nOnO l CHHH KaK HanpHMcp B Ha'ianC 60-x ro OB rrOCJIC TOro KaK BcrCKOH CrpCPbI BJ1HHHHH rrOCKOJlhKy OHH lIenHKoM 3aBHCJIr OT no­ B cTpanc Ha npOTfl CHHH HCCKOnhl HX JICT OCYIlICCTBJIflJlHCh HepCaJIh- CTaBOK mcpreTH'lCCKOrO CblphH H3 CCCP 46 47 - C CepenHHbI70-x rOnOB B crpaHax 'lneHaX C3B nOCrOHHHO CHIDKaerCH 3q q eKrMBHOCrb KamliarrOBrrO KeHHH ro eCIb Ha Ka KUbIH npOueHr npHpOCra HaUHOHaJJbHOrO npOnYKTa Heo6xonHMO 3arpa'lH­ BaTh 60nbllIe KanHraJJOBnO KeHHH 'leM B np0llIJ10M neHCTBOBaTh 3KOHOMH'leCKO-COUHanhHbIe Mexamf3MbI COBpeMeHHbIX HHn ycrpHaJJhHhIX 06llIeCTB H '1ro 3neMeHTapHhIe nOTpe6HOCTH 60nh­ meH '1acrH HaceneHHH COBeTCKoro 6noKa no cpaBHeHHro C pa3BMTbI­ MH CTpaHaMH 3anana ynoBneTBopHroTCH Hen OCraTO'lHo KpOMe CCCP KoropblH KaK 3KcnopTep Heq TH H npHpOa HOrO CHcTeMhI cOBercKoro rHna ellIe He nOCTHrnH nana 6rrarOCOCTO­ ra3a norrY'laeT npH6bIJIb or I H Tenus-of-Trade pOCT MHPOBbiX ueH HHHH Ha KoropOM Y Ke HaXOnHrCH pa3BHTbIe 3anaa HhIe rocynap­ cephe3HhIe TPYa HOCTH nrrH npyrHx crpaH CTBa 3KOHOMH'leCKHH KpH3HC 80-x rOn OB HaBepHHKa 3aropM03HT 3an Orr KeHHOCTh 3IHX CTpaH 3anan y H nOnhITKH nOCTH KeHHe TaKOH CTeneHH 6narOCOCTOffHHH 3ro 3aMen neHHe MO­ ynY'lIliliTh 6aJJaHC BHeUlHeH ToprOBnM B CBOro O'lepen b OTpHuaTenh­ KeT 6hIrb '1peBaTO cepbe3HblMH COUHanhHbIMH nocnen CTBHHMH KO­ Ha 3TH npOn YKTbI C03n aeT - 'lrreHOB C3B HO BrrHHroT Ha pa3BHTHe ToprOBbiX OTHOllIeHHH JTHX crpaH C 3ana­ Tophle B CBOIO O'lepenh npHn an yT 3KOHOMH'leCKOMY KPH3HCY ellIe nOM H HX 3KOHOMH'leCKOe pa3BHTHe Boo6llIe 60nee OCTPblH xapaKTep nOCKonhKY OTHOCHTenhHoe yn OBneTBope­ - paCXOUbI Ha BoopY KeHHe H coxpaHeHHe COBeTCKOrO BnHHHHH B pa3HhiX KOHuax 3eMHoro llIapa nOCTOHHHO pacrYT H no TO Ke or paHH'lHBaeT B03MO KHOCTH 3KOHOMH'leCKOrO pa3BHTHH CTpaH COBeT­ HHe nOTpe6HrerrhCKHX norpe6Hocreif HaceneHHH crpaH COBeTCKoro nma KaK pa3-TO H craJJo On HHM H3 Ba KHeHmHX q aKTopOB cpaBHH­ renhHOH cTa6HnH3aUHH 3IHX CTpaH B KOHIle 60-x rOn OB l BOBce He YTBep KLJ alO 'ITO B 80-e rOnhI nOT q aKTOp nepeCTaHer n eikTBOBarh CKoro 6rrOKa YpOBeHh KH3HH B CTpaHax COBeTCKoro rHlIa HH30K H nOTpe6HTenh­ B pe3YJlbTaTe B03neHCTBHH nepe'lHCneHHhIX BbillIe q aKTopOB 3KO­ HOMH'leCKOe pa3BHTHe COBeTCKoro 6nOKa B 80-e rOUbI HeH36e KHO 3aMen rrHTClI 3TO KCTaTH npen YCMaTpMBaroT H Oq HUHaJJhHble nrra­ Hbi X03HJfcTBeHHoro pa3BHrHlI CTpaH COBeTCKOH cq ephI BJ1IHIHHff B n eHCTBHTerrhHocrH Ke 3aMenrreHHe OKa3hIBaeTCff ellIe 60nhllIe 3anna­ HMpOBaHHoro CKHe Tpe60BaHHH HaceneHHIO npHXOa HrCH yn oBneTBopHTh npH no crOHHHOH HeXBaTKe OTnenbHbIX TOBapOB n03IOMY H npH HeH3MeH­ HOM ypOBHe KH3HH MO KHO nOBbICHIb ynOBJleTBopeHHe norpe6HO­ creH HaceneHHH H TonbKO B03pocurne TpYa HOcrn ellIe 60nhllIHe ne pe60H B cHa6 KeHHH npOnOBOJlbCrBHeM H TOBapaMH rnHpOKoro no­ Tpe6neHHH KaK 3IO npOH30llIJ10 HanpHMep B nOJlbllIe Moryr npH­ Bplln rrM n03rOMY crren yer paC'lHThIBaTh 'lTO HenOCTaTKH Bbl­ BeCTH K B3PbIBY HenOBOJlhCTBa H MaCCOBhIM BOJlHeHHHM 3BaHHble HMMaHeHTHblMH nrrff COBerCKOH CHCTeMhI q aKropaMH 6y­ BeChMa B03MO KHO 'lTO 3KOHOMH'IeCKHH KPH3HC 3aTpOHeT H n py­ n yT Crrra KeHhI 6rraronpMffrHblMM BHernHMMM 06CTOHTenhCTBaMM HH rHe CTOPOHhI KH3HH HaceneHHH crpaH COBeTCKoro 6JlOKa TaK Ha nepe'lMcrreHHhIe BhIrne q aKTophI 3KOHOMH'leCKOrO pa3BHTHH CTpaH ­ 'lrreHOB C3B HH HBrreHHH 06ycrroBrrHBarollIHe KpH3HC 3anaa HOlf 3KO­ HOMHKH He nalOT OCHOBaHHH n nH TaKHX Hane Kn K cepenHHe 80-x rOn OB 3KOHOMM'leCKHH KpH3MC B CTpaHax COBeTCKoro THna OTMeTHT npHMep CKphITall 6e3pa6oTHua TO eCTh 3KOHOMH'IeCKH He3q q eK­ rHBHaH 3aHHTOCTh MO Ker npHBeCTH B 80-e rOUbI K cepbe3HblM no­ cnen CTBHHM YCHnHTCH HanpHMep rHUbI Ha ypoBeHb n aBneHHe CKPhITOH 6e3pa60­ 3apnnaTbI B pe3ynbTaTe 'lero pearrbHaH 3apnna­ CBoe n eClITHrrenre 'lro norrHOCThlO pa3pyrnaeT MHq 06 MMMYHHTeTe Ta He ronhKO He B03paCTer a Bcnen CTBHe pOCTa HHq mIUHH YMeHh­ cOBeTcKoH 3KOHOMH'leCKOH CMCTeMhl K KpH3HcaM llIHrClI 'ITO MO KeT nOKone6aTb nOHnhHOCTb HaCeJleHHH no OTHOllIe­ B COBeTcKoM COlO3e JKOHOMH'IeCKMH KpH3HC 80-x rOnOB BhIa BH­ HeT npHHUHnHanhHblH Bonpoc MorYT nH CYllIecrBYlOllIHe HhIRe B COBeTCKOH CHcreMe CBH3H Me Kn y 3KOHOMHKOH H nOnHTH'IeCKOH BnaCTbIO 06eCne'lHIb nHHaMH'IeCKOe pa3BHTHe 3KOHOMHKH H BhIBe­ HHIO K pe KHMY nOCKonhKY OHa nO mep KHBaerCH yn OBneTBopeHHeM Hacenemfff npenMeTaMM nepBOH Heo6xon HMOCTH MO KHO npennOJlO KHTh 'lTO B 80-e rOUb nOHH3HrClI ypoBeHb Bcex Y'laCTKOB COUHaJJbHoro 06CJlY KHBaHHH ynoBnerBopeHHff n yXOB­ CTH ee H3 COCTOllHHH ynan Ka npM paCCMOTpeHHH noro Bonpoca He­ HhIX 3anpOCOB 3npaBooxpaHeHHH 06XOnHMO HCXOa HTh H3 Toro 'lTO CTpaHhI COBerCKoro THna Bce ellIe T n 'ITO B CBOro O'lepeUb nOn OpBeT COUHanbHYro YBepeHHOCTh Ha­ He n OCTHrrrH 3KOHOMM'leCKOrO ypOBHH HHnYCTpHaJJbHhIX CTpaH 3a­ nana 'ITO B crpaHax C COBeTCKOH CHCTeMOH nHllIb Hen aBHO CTanH 48 KynbTypHoro 06cnY KHBaHHH H CeJleHHH MO KHO O KHn aTh 'ITO B CTpaHax COBeTCKoro rHna B03HHK­ HeT MaCCOBaH 6e3pa6oTHua - 3TO MO KeT npOlOOHTH B cnY'lae JlHK­ 49 BH aUlm He3tPtPeKTIfBHbIX npOH3BO CTBeHHbIX npe npHHTHH H3Me­ HeHHH CTPYKTypbI H nepeKBaJlHtPHKaUHH pa60qeH CHlTbl H T n HallI aHaJIH3 HCCJIe yeT B OCHOBHOM BOnpOC M02YT AU crpaHbt C6aTOB lJaCTb nOJIHTHqCCI OH 6IOpOI paTHH nOJIHueHCI HH arrnapaT a npH 06cY f IleHHH OT IleJIbHhIX BonpocoB H BoeHHble 6y IlYT CTpe­ cYllleCTBYIOIl eH C08eTCK020 TUna npeOOOAeTb na08U2alOU4UUCR na nux KPU3UC De3 MHTbCH U3MeHeHUJl CTPYKTYPbl BJIaCTH cOXpaHHlIH CBoe rrepBOO'lepe llHOe 3HalJeHHe rro CUCTe Mbl De3 U3MeneHUR ODU4eCT8enno-nOAUTU'leCKUX C8R3eu Koropbte 8 3TOU CUCTeMe YCTanOBUAUCb 0 H03HaqHO Ha K TOMY lJT06bl 3a llaQH BocrrpoH3BO pTBa cpaBHeHHIO C 3a llaQaMH 06eCrrelJeHHR IlHHaMHI H 3I OHOMHlJeCI Oro 3TOT Bonpoc OTBenfTb HeB03MO KH0 nOCKOJIbKY KPH3HCHbJe HBJIe­ BocrrpOH3BO llCTBa HHH B 3KOHOMHKe CTpaH COBeTCKoro THna BbI3BaHbI MHO f eCTBOM lJaCTb X03i HCTBeHHoro anrrapara 6Y IlYT 3a UHmaTb rrpOTHBOnOlIO f ­ npwmH H He Bce OHH KaK MbI Y f e rOBOpHJIH BbIllIe BbITeKalOT H3 CHCTeMbJ caMoH He Bbl3blBaeT O J HaKO COMHeHHH 3KOHOMHlJeCKHe npHlJHHbI 3aCTaBHT B qrO HMeHHO 6JIH f aHllIHe rO J b1 co BceH cepbe3HocTblO H3YtJHTb BJIHHHHe CHCTeMHbIX tPaKTopoB Ha 3KOHOMH­ llpyraR 'laCTb HYIO TeH IleHUHIO Ha rrpaI TIfI e nOJIHTHlJeCKoro H BJIHHTeJIbHaH no rrpOTIfBOpe'lHe He rrpOHBJIHeTCH B 'lHCTOM BH Ile KaI MO f eT rrOI a3aTbCH Ha nepBblH B3rJIR Il TaI I aK Bce 3TIf rpyrrrrbI CBR3blBalOT H CMe f HbIe HHTCpeCbI B 1953 r nOqrH Bce rpynrrbl npaBHllleif 3JIHTbl 6bIJIH 3aHHTepecoBaHbI QT06bI nOJIH­ KY cTpaH COBeTCKoro 6JIOKa 3TOT Bonpoc Y f e CTaBHJICH B npo­ ueHCKHH arrnapaT nepeCTaJI 6bITb llIJIOM HO nOqTH Ba uaTb JIeT Ha3a ll ero CHHJIH C nOBeCTKH J HH 0 ­ nOCKOJIbKY BceMorYillHH nOJIHueHCI HH arrrrapaT yrpo f aJI BceM He­ rocygapCTBOM B rocygapCTBe HaKO nOT CTapO-HOBbIM Borrpoc Tpe6yeT B CBOIO OlJepe b pellIeHHH KOTopble 06mHe HHTepecbI 6Y IlYT 06'he llHHHTb 3TIf rpynIlbI H B 80-e CMe KHOrO Bonpoca a HMeHHO YBH3KH 3KOHOMHQeCKHX petPopM C rO bl H rrpe f ge Bcero HX 06111aR 3aHHTepecoBaHHocTb B coxpaHeHHH nOJIHTHlJeCKHMH lJTO nOCTaBHT PYKOBO llCTBO CTpaH COBeTCKoro 61I0­ f H3HeCnoc06HoCTH 06111ecTBeHHO-rrOJIHTH'lCCI oif CHCTCMbl HeOT Ie­ Ka nepe TeMH f e np06JIeMaMH KOTopble OCTaJIHCb HepellIeHHbIMH B JIHMO if QaCTblO KOTOPO if na 3JIHTa HBlIHeTCH 50-e H 60-e rO llbI 11 Tpy IlHo orrpC IlCJIHTb crrycTR I aKOe BpCMR 3TOT 06111HH IlJIH rrpa­ B 6y yru eM npH pellIeHHH B03HHKllIHX np06JIeM PYKOBO ll­ BHmeH 3JIHTbI HHTcpec Ha'lHeT onpe leJIHTb rrOBe lleHHe Bg ex ee rpynn CTBO 6y eT CTpeMHTbCH coxpaHHTb TOTaJIHTapHbIH xapaKTep CBoeH MO J HO O IHaI O rrpC IrrOJIO f HTb 'ITO no Mepe 060CTpeHIfH 3KOHO­ BJIaCTH MHQeCKOrO I pH3HCa H orraCHOCTH MaCCOBoro corrpOTHBJIeHHR pe J H­ O HaKO HapH Y C 3THM CTpeMJIeHHeM 60JIee 3aMeTHO npo­ HBHTCH TaK J e CTpeMJIeHHH K H3MeHeHHIO CTpYI Typbl TOTaJIHTapHOH MY 6YlleT CHCTeMbl oc06eHHO B Tex 06JIaCTHX IlOJIbllIH 80·x rO lOB HeH3MeHHO OI a f eT BJIHHHHe Ha Bce CTpaHbl CO­ BeTCI OrO 6JIOKa r e CYlllecTBYlOlllaH CTPYI TY­ pa TOPM03HT 3KOHOMHlJeCKHH pOCT KaI nepBaH TaI H BTopaH TeH­ eHUHH HMelOT CBOHX npOBO J HHKOB B CTpaHax COBeTCKoro THna no­ 3TOMY MO f HO npe J ITOJIO f HTb lJTO B 80-e rO bl Cpe H BJIaCTb HMY­ YI pCrrJIHTbCR ellHHCTBO BCCX rpyrrrr 3JIHTbl IlpHMep PaCCY f aH TeOpeTHlJeCKH MO f HO 6bIJIO 6bI rrpe llnOJIO f HTb 'ITO CTpaHbI COBeTCI oif ctPepbI BJIHRHHR rrOM IYT no nym OT IeJIeHHH f10­ lllHX B03HHKH 'T TaI He f e pa3HorrracHH I aI B 1953-1956 rr Tor a JITHlJeCI o if BJIaCTH OT 3KOHOMJilleCKOif f10CI OJIbI Y TaI aH Mepa rro­ nOCJIe cMepTH CTaJIHHa B ueHTpe BHHMaHHH OKa3aJIaCb pOJIb anna­ 3BOJIHJIa 6bI Ha HeI OTOpOe BpeMH XOTH 6bI OT'laCTH cTa6HJIH3HPO­ paTa oCYllleCTBJIHBllIerO MaccoBbIH Teppop ceiitJac f e B 80-e rOMI BaTh CHCTeMY· IlpaB Ila ueHTp nOJIHTHlJeCI OH BJIaCTH Y f e He Mor 6bI Ha nOBCCTI Y J HH BbIXO HT pom annapaTa OCYllleCTBJIHlOllIerO PY­ f10-npe f HeMY rrOJIHOCTblO KOHTPOJIHpOBaTb 3I OHOMH'leCI YIO f H3Hb KOBO CTBO HapO HbIM X03RifcTBOM CocTaBHble qaCTH COBeTCI OH CTpaHbJ HO 3aTO 3I OHOMJilJeCKHe Cy6'heI TbI f1pH06peJIH 6bl 60JIb­ npaBHllleH 3JIHTbI -- nOJIHTHlJeCI aH napmHHaH H rocy apCTBeHHaH IlIYIO 61OpoKpaTHH 3KOHOMHlJeCKaH 6IOpOI paTIfR rroJIHueikKHH annapaT B03MO f HOCTH I OHTPOJIR Ha l 06111eCTBOM 06eCrrelJHJIH 6bI Be llYlllylO H apMHH - rr03HUHIO BbIHY f eHbI 6y IlYT Bblpa60TaTb CBOIO n03HUHlO OTHO­ CHTeJIbHO rJIaBHOH npHqHHbI KpH3Hca HO Ha 3TOT pa3 npHqHH ' co­ CTaBJIRCT ueJIbIH KOMnJIeKC np06JICM CBR3aHHblX C ynpaBJIeHHeM 3KOHOMHKOH Y f e CCHlJaC MO f HO onpe lleJIHTb HeKOTOpbIe HCXO J Hble nYHI Tl I 50 aBTOHOMHIO IlpH nOM OCTaBIUHeCH 3a rrOJIHTlf4 eCI OH BlIaCTblO noif BJIaCTH B CTpaHe JI nH Toro 'lT06bI TaKoe rrOJIO f eHHe C03 1laJIOCb B CCCP COBeTCKoe PYKOBO CTBO IlOJI f HO rrORTH rro rryTH XOTH 6bI TaI HX 3KOHOMH'leCI HX petPopM 3allaqeH I OTOPbIX 6Y lleT He OnTHMaJIbHOe paJBHTHe COBeTCKoro HapO J HOro X03RHCTBa a Il0­ CTH f eHHe HeH3MeHHoro ypOBHH f H3HH H 06eCrreQeHHe OCHOBHbIX rro­ Tpe6HOCTeH HaCeJIeHHH MHHHMYM Ha 10 JIeT HanoMHHM QTO B 70-e 51 rO lJ hI OOecrreqeHHe OCHOBHhIX rrOTpeoHocTeii HaCeneHHH CTaOIDIH3H­ pOBaJIO nOJIO KeHHe B BOCTOWOeBponeii cKHX roCYMpCTBax Pe i OpMa ynpaBneHHH HapO l HhiM X03Hii CTBOM KOTOPaH Morna OhI rrpHBeCTI f B COBeTCKOM COI03e K aHaJIOrWlHbIM pe3ynbTaTaM ObI­ lIa ObI OOnbmaH aBIOHOMHH npe lJ npHHTHii B oonaCTH KaITHTanOBno­ KeHHH H Hcnonb30BaHHH paOOqeH CHnbI cnOCOOCTBOBaJIa Obi COKpa­ lIIeHHIO CKPbITOii oe3paOOTHIJ hI nOCKonhKY oonee rHOKO pery­ JIHPOBaJIOCh Ohl pacnpe lJ eneHHe IPY lJ OBhIX pe3epBOB TexHoKpaTUflecKo-6lOpoKpaTUfleCKOU pe¢opMOU He Hapyma­ IOmeii xapaKTepHbIX l JIH COBeTcKoii CHCTeMbI cBH3eii TO eCTb OOY­ Bce 3TH pe3ynhTaTbI MorYT OhlTh lJ OCTHTHYTbI B COBeTCKOM Co­ cnOBJIeHHbIe caMoii CHcTeMoii rrpHqHHhI HhIHemHero KpH3Hca lJ eii ­ I03e Bonee Toro OHH MorYT OhITb lJ OCTHTHYTbI lJ IDKe B TOM cnyqae CIBOBaJIH ObI H B lJ aJIbHeii meM HO OlIaTO lJ apH pe i opMe KpH3HC MO K­ ecnH OCTaHYTCR HepemeHHbIMH HeKOIopbIe npHHn HrrHaJIhHbIe oOllle­ HO OhIJIO ObI Ha BpeMH npeO lJ OJIeTh CTBeHHo-nonmuqeCKHe npOOneMhl ABTOHOMHbIe npe l llpHHTHH npo­ IIpoBe lJ eHHe TaKoro pO lJ a Pe P0PMbI B COBeTCKOM COI03e npHBe­ lJ On KaJIH ObI OCTaBaThCH rOCY lJ apCTBeHHhIMH T e no lJ KOHTponeM OIOpOKpaTHH a K pemeHHIO npooneMhI KonneKTHBHoii COOCTBeHHO­ 1I0 ObI K TaKHM rrOCJIe lJ CIBHHM CTH CBH3aHHoii C caMoynpaBneHHeM npOH3BO lJ HTeneii B Tel eHHe orr­ - rOCY lJ apCIBeHHbIe npe lJ npHHTHH TnaBHhIM oopa30M B ner­ pe lJ eneHHoro nepHO lJ a MO KHO OhIJIO ObI BOOOllle He npHcrynaTb KOii npOMbIlllJIeHHOCTH OKa3aJIHCb ObI no lJ OOJIbmHM lJ aBJIeHHeM llrrH Toro l TOOhI TaKoro pO lJ a pe i opMa npeO lJ onena CYlIIeCTBY­ pbIHKa B CBH3H C KOnHqeCTBOM KaqeCTBOM H accopTHMeHTOM H3 lJ e­ IOlIIHH HbIHe KPH3HC HapMY C pe i opMoH HO Ile3aBHCHMO OT Hee He­ lIHii B03pocmee B pe3YJIhTaTe pe i opMbI npe lJ nO KeHHe B CBOIO oqe­ OOXO lJ HMO pemHTh cne l yIOlIIHe BonpOChI pe lJ b rrOBbICHJIO Obi 3HaqeHHe nOTpeOHTeJIbCKHX i aKTopOB no­ npooneMY 3 i i eKTHBHoro Hcnonb30BaHHH HOBhIX HCIOl HHKOB CKOlIbKY HCqe3JIH ObI TPY lJ HOCTH BbI3BaHHhie xpOHuqeCKHM lJ e i H­ IJ HIOM pa3nuqHhIX H3 lJ eJIHii B03POCJIO Obi 3HaqeHlie npHHIJ Hrra MaTepHaJIbHoii 3aHHTepeco­ BaH HOCTI f KOIOPblii ceii qac H3-3a HeB03MO KHOCTH npHoopeCTH Ha 3apaOOIaHHbIe lJ eHbrH HY KHbIe JIIO l HM TOBapbI ocoooii POlIH He HT­ CbIphH B a3HaTcKoii qaCTH CCCP qTO BpH lJ nH MO KHO OCYlIIeCTBHTh oe3 yqaCIHH HHOCTpaHHOrO KanHTaJIa - npooneMY BHe lJ peHHH HOBOii TeXHHKH B COBeTCKOM X03Hii CT­ Be KaK rrOCpe lJ CTBOM paClllHpeHHH H ynyqmeHHH HaYWO-HCCne lJ OBa­ TenbcKoii lJ eHrenhHOCTH B COBeICKOM COI03e TaK H rryTeM 06ecne­ paeI l eHHH lJ ocryrra K HHOCTPaHHhIM HOBmecTBaM - aBTOHOMHH rrpe l IlpHHTHii npOMbIlllJIeHHOCTH TOBapOB mHpo­ Koro rrOIpeOlIeHHH cnOCOOCTBOBaJIa ObI YCTpaHeHHIO pe3KHX lJ HCnpO­ rrOpIJ Hii B COBeIcKoii 3KOHOMHKe TaKHX KaK rrpe l IlOqTHIenbHoe OT­ HomeHHe K OTpaCJIHM TH KenOH npOMbImlIeHHOCTH xpOHuqeCKoe OT­ CIaBaHHe c i epbl oocnY KHBaHHH H T n npooneMY C06nIO lJ eHHH 3KOHOMHl eCKH npHeMneMoro HH COBeTCKHX paCXO lJ OB Ha BoopY KeHHe ypOB­ 3TH TpH npooneMhl O l HaKo CBH3aHbI C BHemHeii nonmHKoH TaKHM 00pa30M nO l bITO KHBaH CKa3aHHoe MbI YTBep K l aeM l TO - aBTOHOMHH npOMbIlllJIeHHbIX rrpe l IlpHHTHii rrpOH3BO l HmHX H3­ OOPboa cpe l H BnaCTh HMYlIIHX B CCCP B 80-e rO l bI oY lJ eT BeCTHcb lJ eJIHH l lIH CeJIbCKOTO X03Hii cTBa CeJIhCKOX03Hii cTBeHHbIe MalllHHhI B nepBYIO Ol epe lJ h B CBR3H C BbI60pOM pernelUlH 3KOHOMH'leCKHX HCKYCCTBeHHbIe Y lJ OOpeHHH H T lJ crrOCOOCTBOBana ObI KOOP lJ H­ npooneM rrpuqeM B nOMep KKY rrpOBe lJ eHHH Hal epTaHHOH HaMH pe­ HaIJ H1 1 lJ eHIelIbHOCTH 3THX OTpacneH C nOTpeOHOCTHMH cenbCKoro i OPMbI OY l yT lJ eHCTBOBaTb cne l yIOlIIHe i aKTopbI X03HikTBa CeJIbCKOX03HHCTBeHHoe rrpOH3BO lJ CTBO TO Ke norraJIO ObI no lJ COBeTcKoe OOllleCTBO Y Ke HaxO lJ HTCH Ha TaKOM Jane pa3BHTHH KOr lJ a Hal HHaIOT lJ eHCTBOBaTb TeH lJ eHIJ HH B rrpOlllJIOM nOBnHHBlllHe BnHHHHe pblHKa qTO crrOCOOCTBOBaJIO ObI YCTpaHeHHIO lJ Hcrrporrop­ Ha nepeXO lJ HH l yCTPHaJIbHO pa3BHTbIX crpaH 3ana lJ a K OOllleCTBY II Hii Me K l y npOMbIlllJIeHHblM ceKTopOM HapO l HOro X03HHCTBa H nOTpeoneHHH K roCY lJ apCTBY 6narOCOCTOHHHH Ka K l bIH mar Co­ cenbCKox03Hii cTBeHHhIM BeTCKoro PYKOBO lJ CTBa B HanpaBneHHH K TaKoMY THny OOllleCTBa 52 BCTpeTHT orpoMHYIO nOMep KKY HaceneHHH H HanpoTHB KIDK l bIH 53 Illar YBOiJ Hll MH OT Hero MO KeT BbI3BaTb B3pblB 06ll ecTBeHHoro He­ 70-x KOrna IiHIH ijfaTlma HaXOnlmaCb ell e B PYKax nOJThCKOrO py_ YJlCe HalJAAalOT ee e Jie He BbIHYJK J eHbl ycrynliTb TaK KaK B CCCP HeT Mac­ KOBOnCTBa B nocrreLUme rOIJ bI COBeTCKlie BrraCTIi lJ OBOJIbCTBa B nOJIb3Y TeXHOKpaTlilJeCKO-6IOpOKpaTHlJeCKOH pecpopMbI roBO­ PHT H TO 'ITO TaKaH pecpopMa n03BOJIHT npaBHw eH 3JIliTe rrpOHBMTb TepHTb HO COBOH opraHli30BaHHOH ClIrrbl KOTopaH BbIcTynaeT npOTMB Brracm HHHIJ HaTliBY M B 80-e rOIJ bI KaK 6bIJIO B 1953-1956 rr Korna Onn031iIJ IIH Tpe6yroll 3H npOBeneHIiH 3KOHOMlilJeCKOH pecpopMhI Ii CTpeMJIeHMe Y lJ ep KaTb HHMlI MaTHBY B CBOMX pYKax OKa3aITOCb nOCJIe OnHOBpeMeHHO nOmUlilJeCKOro nrrlOpaITli3Ma B COBeTCKOM COlO3e CMepm CTaITMHa rITaBHbIM MOTMBOM Bcex neHcTBIiH cOBeTCKoH Bep­ XYIIIKH 06 nOM CBHneTeJIbCTByeT TaK Ke COBeTCKaH nOJIIiTIiKa B BOCTOlJHOH EBpone B nocrreCTarrliHCKIiH rrepHOn IiHTepBeHlI HH B BeCbMa cJIa6a Lla Ke COBeTCKlie nliCClIneHTbl B 60JIbIllllHCTBe CBoeM CTpOHT aHTIiTOTaITIiTapH '1O nporpaMMY He Ha npMHIJ Mnax rrOJIlITlilJe­ CKOH neMOKpamli xapaKTepHbIX lJ rrH COBpeMeHHbIX IIH J YCTpMarrb­ BeHrpHH B 1956 L oKKynall MH llexocJIoBaKMIi B 1968 r H rro lJ J ep K­ HbIX rOCY lJ apCTB 3arra lJ a a Ha Tpa lJ MIJ 1I0HHbIX IJ eHtroCTHX Ka BBeneHMH BoeHHoro rrOrrO KeHHH B TIOJIbille B 1981 r CTPMaITbHOH POCCMM 3Ta Orrn0311IJ MH COCTOIlT B OCHOBHOM M3 rrpen­ TO eCTb lJ OMH lJ Y­ lJ JIH coxpaHeHMH MHHlI HaTHBbI B PYKax lI eHTpa HMrrepHH COBeTCKoe CTaBMTeJIeH MHTemmreHIJ MII M BbIcTynaeT OHa rrpOTIiB aKIiX meMeH­ pYKOBOnCTBO OTnaITO npe lJ nO'lTeHlie TOB COBeTCKOH CMCTeMbl KOTopbIe B HaCTOHll ee BpeMH OlJeHb CMJIb­ BoeHHOMY peIlleHHIO np06JIeM B03HHKIIIHX Ha ee nepMcpepHH B onpeneJIeHHOM CMbICJIe BoeHHoe HbI rrOJIIITlilJeCKIiH Ha lJ 30p Ha lJ 06ll eCTBOM IIHcpopMaIJ MOHHaH 1I30­ BMeIllaTeJIbCTBO B CTpaHbI BOCTO'lHOH EBponbI 6bIJIO lJ JIH COBeTCKMX JIHIJ MH II T lJ nOlJm He IiHTepeCYHCb BOnpOCaMli ynpaBrreHIIH X03HH­ BJIaCTeH peIlleHMeM JIOKaITbHbIX np06rreM TaKOe Ke peIlleHlie MO­ KeT I5blIb MCnOlIb30BaHO H npH nOnaBJIeHMM rrOKaITbHbIX npoTeCTOB CTBOM XOTH MMeHHO 3Ta 06rracTb nepe KMBaeT TH KeJIbIH KpM3I1C 3KoHoMliKa Bo06ll e OKa3bIBaeTCH BHe norrH 3peHlIH COBeTCKIiX lJ IIC­ B COBeTCKOM COI03e O lJ HaKO npHHlI HnliaITbHbIe np06JIeMbi COBeT­ cM lJ eHTOB II lJ 0 CMX nop ell e He 6bIJI npO lJ eJIaH 3KOHOMMlJeCKMH aHa­ CKoro JIM3 Ha OCHOBe KOToporo orrrr03l1IJ MH MOrITa 6bI pa3pa60TaTb CBOIO COI03a 06ycJIoBJIliBalOll Me KpM3MC COBeTCKOH 3KOHOMHKM COBeTCKaH BoeHHaH MHTepBeHlI HH peIIIMTb He B COCTOHHHH B OTJIII'Ilie OT pYKOBOnCTBa TIOJIblilll COBeTCKoe pYKOBOnCTBO ew c MO KeT HeKOTopoe BpeMH coxpaHMTb MHMIJ MaTMBY B CBOMX PY­ Kax CTerreHb MneHTlIcpMKaIJ MM HaIJ 1I0HaJIbHbIX MHTepeCOB C COBeT­ aITbTepHaTMBY· B03HlIKillee B COBeTCKOM COlO3e MHaKOMbICJIMe pe3YJIbTaT HpaBCTBeHHoro M KYJIbTypHoro KpH3liCa COBeTCKOH CIiCTe­ MbI a Ha nOH apeHe BpHn JIIi npOM30H lJ eT peillalOll ee CTOJIKHOBeHMe C rrpaBHll eH 3JIliTOH CCCP CKOH CMCTeMOH B POCCMH HaMHoro BblIlle 'leM B TIOJIbille MJ1H B npy­ I1MeHHo no noMY MO KHO rrpenrroJIaraTb lJTO B 80-e rOIJ bI B Co­ rMX cTpaHax BOCTO'lHOH EBponbl I1cTopMlJeCKMe TpanMlI HH KOTopbIe BeTCKOM COlO3e OKOHlJaTeJIbHOe CJIOBO B npoIJ ecce npeOnOJIeHMH CMCTeMbI B CCCP B pe3YJIb­ KpM3l1Ca 6Y lJ eT 3a npaBHll eH 3JIIiTOH BepHee 3a TOH '1aCTblO 3rrllThI TaTe naBJIeHHH CHM3y HarrpOTHB He H lJ yT HH B KaKoe cpaBHeHMe C KOTOpa s O lJ ep QfT n06eny B 6oPb6e 3a BJIaCTb KaK no npOli30IllJJO rr03BOJIW1H I5bI HaneHTbCH Ha nepeMCHY TpalJ HUHHMH BOCTOlJHOeBpOneHCKHX rocynapCTB B COBeTCKOM CO­ nOCJIe cMepm CTaITMHa B 06ll MX lJepTax cOBeTcKYIO 3JIlITY MO KHO 103C nepeMeHbI B 3Ha'lHTerrbHOH CTerreHM 3aBMCHT OT neHCTBHH BJIaCTb pa3 lJ eJIIITb Ha lJ Be rpynTIbI CTOPOHHMKIi 3KOHOMMlJeCKOH pecpopMbI HMYll MX rrOCKOJIbKY COBeTCKoe 06w ecTBo 60JIee HHepTHo nOJIHTH­ TexHoKpaTbI II ee npoTMBHMKIi lJaCTb nOJIIITHlJeCKOH TO eCTb nap­ 'leCKH 'leM 06w eCTBeHHocTb lJ PyrMx cTpaH COBeTCKoro 6JIoKa T1iHHOH Ii rOCY lJ apCTBeHlfOH 6IOpOKpamll CTOJIKHOBeHIIH no BO­ ECJIH pe3Ko yxynlilllTcH cHa6 KeHHe HaCCJIeHHH TO H B CCCP B03MO KHO Ha'lHYTCH pa60'lMe 3a6aCTOBKH H neMOHCTpaIJ MM BeCb­ Ma BepOHTHO lITO B TaKOM CJIYlJae BJIaCTM npM5crHYT K HaCHJIHIO npocy pecpopMbl 6Y lJ YT O lJ HaKO rrpOXO lJ lITb He TOJIbKO Me K lJ y nM­ MM lJeTKO OlJeplJeHHbIMM rpynnaMM HO Ii BH 'TPM Ka K lJ OH 1i3 HIiX K 3KOHOMlilJeCKOH 61OpOKpaTIIIi HanpliMep OTHOCHTCH KaK HOCIi­ O lJ HaKO B 6JIIi KaHillMe rOnbI TaKoro pO lJ a MaCCOBble npOTeCTbI ec­ TerrM TexHOKpaTlilJeCKMX TeH lJ eHu MH TaK Ii npoTMBHMKH pecpOpMbI JIH OHM H HalJHYTCH 6ynYT M30JIMpOBaHbi rrOKaITbHO B paMKax 3a­ TIpOTMBHHKIi - BO lJ a MJIM ropona M He nepepacTyr KaK B TIOJIbIlle BO BceHapOn­ TerrbHOCTblO annapaTa Ii nOJIO KeHMe KOTOPbIX 311JK J eTcH Ha CYll eCT­ no B nepBylO OlJepe lJ b Te KTO TeCHO CBH3aH C neH­ Hoe lJ BH KeHMe corrpOTMBJIeHMH Ho eCJIIi rrpO lJ OJI QfTb cpaBHeHMe C BYIOll eH B HacTOHll ee BpeMH CIiCTeMe IJ eHTpaITbHOrO lJ lipeKTIiBHoro TIOJIbIlleH TO cpaBHHBaTb CCCP 80-x rOnOB CJIenyeT lIJ1aHMpOBaHMH 54 C TIOJIbilleH pa60THliKIi MMHHcTepCTB Ii nJIaHOBblX opraHoB 55 pOnb B CBepJKeHHH XpymeBa CTOnb BlUKHYIO nHtIHO J nn HHX cTa6HnbHOCTb 3nl-TO nlO J H H ChIrpanH BlUKHeiiurylO UHeH H apMHeH AficTpaKTHO paCCYJK J aH MOJKHO npH J TH K BbIBOgy 3amHman H 3amHTHB 'ITO HH nOJIHU fn HH apMHn He 3aHHTepeCOBaHbI B TOM 'IT06bI COBeT­ CHCTeMbI CKM 3KOHOMHKa rrepeJKHBana XpOHH'leCKHe TpYAHOCTH TaK KaK 1965 B rrepHO J C rro 1975 rr CHCTeMa J eHCTBHTenbHO 6bIna OT­ OHH MoryT BbInHTbCH B MaCCOBbIe rrpOTCCTbI H ocna6HTb BoeHHYIO HOCHTenbHO cTafiHnbHoH O J HaKO B HaCTonmee BpeMn COBeTCKan MOJUb rOCY J apCTBa Ha J eJIe JKe H rrOnHU fH H apMHH 6Y J YT Bepo­ 3KOHOMHKa rrepeJKHBaeT KpH3HC HMeHHO rrOTOMY 'ITO rrpOBanHnaCb nTHO CTpeMHTbcn KOHuemUIn rrpOTHBHHKOB peqlOpM TaK 'ITO B 6Y J ymeM HX rronOJKe­ j OPMbI He OrpaHH'IHnH HX BnHHHHn B rocY J apCTBe H He rroKonefia­ HHe OKaJKeTCH COBceM He nerKHM JIH HX rro3HIIHIO B paMKax rrpaBHmeH 3nHTbI IIonHTH'IeCKan 61OpOKpaTHn rnaBHbIM ofipa30M rrapTHHHhIii an­ rrapaT TOJKe He MOHOJIHTHan rpyrrrra Ecml 3KOHOMH'IeCKaH pe j op­ K TOMY 'ITo6bI B03MOJKHble 3KOHOMH'IeCKHe pe­ qTO JKe KacaeTCH rrOJIHlIeikKoro arrrrapaTa Mbl HMeeM B BH J y Ty ero 'IaCTb KOTOpaH ocymeCTBJIneT nOJIHTH'IeCKHH KOHTPOJIb Ha J Ha­ Ma B CCCP 6Y J eT rrpoBe J eHa H J lUKe ecnH OHa 6Y J eT HOCHTb He J e­ CeJIeHHeM TO ero MOJKHO 6Y J eT npHBne'lb Ha CTOpOHy 3KOHOMH'Ie­ MOKpaTH'leCKHH a TeXHOKpaTH'leCKHH xapaKTep pe j opMa Bce paB­ CKHX pe j opM HO TonbKO HO OT J CMOKpam'leCKHX OHH He CTaBnT no J yrP03y TOTanHTapHYIO CHCTC­ OrpaHH'IHT B03MOJKHOCTH rrapTHHHoro arrrrapaTa rrpOH3BonbHO BMeUIHBaTbcn B X03HHCTBeHHYIO JKH3Hb CTpaHbI Cne J OBaTeJIbH My H TeXHOKpaTH'IeCKHX TaK KaK B OTllH'lHe ponb rrOJIHTH'leCKOH nOJIHIIHH BeCbMa B03MOJKHO 'ITO B rrpo­ 'IaCTb anrrapaTa KOTopan ocymeCTBJIneT rrapTHHHoe PYKOBO J CTBO lIecce npOBe J eHHH pe j opMbI pom rronHlIeHcKoro annapaTa eme 60­ 3KOHOMHKOH HeH36eJKHo fiY J eT rrpOTHBHTbCH 3KOHOMH'IeCKHM pe­ nee B03pacTeT OH CMOJKeT CTaTb UCTO'IHUKOM UHtfioPMalluu 0 cOIIHa­ j OPMaM llpyrHe anbHO-nOJIHTH'IeCKHX J BHJKCHHnx H UHCrpYMeHToM noiJa8 leHUJl B 3a­ JKe COTPY J HHKH rrapTHHHOrO arrrrapaTa 3aHHMaIOT­ CH HHbIMH BorrpocaMH H rrOCKOJIbKY rnaBHaH uenb rrapTHHHOii 610­ pO J bIllIe Bcex HeJKenaTenbHblx nnn pOKpaTHH - B ycnOBHnx 3KOHOMH'IeCKOrO KpH3Hca J aJKe Kor J a ero cTapaIOTCJf COXpaHHTb PYKoBo J nmylO pOJIb rrapTHH orrpe J eneHHbIe Kpynl rrapTarrrrapaTa B03MOJKHO rro J J epJKaT pe j opMY COBeTcKHH OrrbIT rrOKa3bIBaeT 'ITO PYKOBOJJ Hman pom rrapTHH­ HOH filOpOKpaTHH MOJKeT fibITb 06eCrre'leHa JIHllIb rryTeM J OCTHJKeHHn KOMnpOMHcca MeJK J y OCHOBHbIMH rpyrrrraMH rrpaBHmeH 3nHTbl TaK BJIacTH TeH J eHIIHH IIocKonbKY npeo J OJIeTb B03HHKaeT orraCHOCTb B3pbma OfimecTBeHHoro He J o­ BomCTBa TO napTHHHan 61OpOKpaTHH J JIn coxpaHeHHn CBoeH PYKO­ BOJJ HmeH poml MOJKeT nOMepJKaTb H 3amHTHTb nOJIHlIeHCKHH arr­ rrapaT 'ITO J OCTHJKeHHe OCHOBHOH ueJIH rrapTHHHoro arrrrapaTa 3aBHCHT OT DOJIee cepbe3HYlO np06JIeMY npe J CTaBJInIOT BoeHHble TaK KaK ap­ ueJIoro pMa j aKl'OpOB a He TonbKO OT COXpaHeHHn 3a arrrrapaTOM MHH HrpaeT He TonbKO BHYTpHnOJIHTH'leCKYIO HO H BHMylO BHellI­ rrpaBa BMeIllHBaTbCH B rrpHHHTHe 3KOHOMH'IeCKHX pellIeHHH HenOJIHTH'IeCKYIO POJIb MOJKHO rrpe J rroJIO HTb 'ITO rrpHHHMaH pellIeHHe 0 nynix npeo­ J OJIeHHH 3KOHOMH'leCKOrO KpH3Hca COBeTCKan nOJIHTH'IeCKaH filO­ pOKpaTHH 6Y J eT rrpeJK J e Bcero PYKOBO J CTBOBaTbCH cnegylOl1 IHMH rr03BOJIHT TH'lecKylO 3KOHOMH'lecKYIO pe j opMY HO npH YCJIOBHH 'ITO OHa He nO J opBeT npHBHJIerHpOBaHHoe nOJIOJKeHHe BoeHHOH rrpOMbIUIJIeHHO­ CTH H nOJIHTH'IeCKOe BnHHHHe BoeHHbIX MOJKHO TaKHM ofipa30M YTBCpJK J aTb 'ITO HHTepeCbI pa3nH'lHbIX KpHTepHHMH l BoeHHbIe MornH 6bI nOMepJKaTb TeXHOKpa­ JIH J aHHoe pellIeHHe COXpaHHTb PYKOBOJJ HmylO rpynn npaBnmeH COBeTCKOH 3nHTbI He HaCTOJIbKO rrpOTHBOpe'laT pom rrapTHliHoii 61OpOKpaTHH H COlO3 Bcex rpyrrrr rrpaBHllIeH 3JIH­ J pyr J pyry 'IT06bl BocnpenHTCTBOBaTb pellIeHHIO 3KOHOMH'IeCKOro TbI H KpH3Hca B CCCP nYTeM rrpOBe J eHHH pe j opMbI TeXHOKpaTH'ICCKOrO 2 yKperrHT nH J aHHoe pellIeHHe COBeTCKYIO rereMOHHIO B COBeT­ THrra 113 noro O J HaKO He BbITeKaeT 'ITO TaKan pe j opMa rrpOH­ no CKOM finoKe Y J oBJIeTBOpHTb O J HOBpeMeHHo H rrepBbIH H BTOPOH 30H J eT Ho J aJKe eCJIH COBeTCKHe BJIaCTH ec ocymecTBJfT KpHTepHii 6Y J eT COBceM He nerKO He OTKpoeT rryTb K J eMOKpaTH3aIIHH cOBeTcKoH CHCTeMbI B OTllH­ B rrpouecce rrpeO J oneHHH 3KOHOMH'IeCKOrO KpH3Hca rrapnlHHOH filOpOKpaTHH rrpH J eTcn Bblpa60TaTb HOBbIH BH J OTHOllIeHHH C rronH- emc 'IHe OT BOCTO'lHOeBpOneHCKHX rOCY J apcTB B KOTOPbIX 8ce rrOTIbITKH rrpOBe J cHHH 3KOHOMH'ICCKOH pe j opMbI YBn3blBaJIHCb C He06xo J H­ MOCTblO J eMOKpaTH3aIIHH peJKHMa • 56 57 Ila e ycnex TeXHOKpaTH'IeCKOH pe pOPMbI B COBeTCKOM COlO3e He 6yneT 03Ha'laTb pe POPMbI KOMMYHH3Ma KaK CHCTeMbI IIonbITKH pe popMHpOBaTb KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKYIO CHCTeMY B03MO HO 3apO lJIT' CH B cpene KOMMYHHCTH'leCKOH HHTeJIJIHreHlllfH HO OHH BpHA JIH 6naronpHHTHYlO no'lBY cpe J H BJIaCTb HMYIIIHX He IIonY'IaT IIo J J ep KH Pe POPMHcTcKHe KOMMYHHCTH'leCKHe HneH H cpe J H aK· THBHbIX rpynn HHaKOMbICJIHIIIHX nocKonbKY OpHeHTaII HH COBeT­ CKoro HHaKOMbIcnHH cOBeprueHHo HHoro TOJIKa qTO e KacaeTCH HneOnOrH'IeCKOrO 060cHoBaHHH TexHoKpaTH­ '1eCKOH pe pOpMbI TO no BceH BepOHTHOCTH Ha Boopy eHHe 6YAeT B3HTO He'lTO BpOne npHHII Hna 3 p peKTHBHoro 06IIIeCTBa B CO BeT· CKHX yCJIOBHHX TaKOH JI03yHr 6YAeT BbIABHHYT BO HMH ocyIIIeCTBJIe­ HHH ITeHHHCKHX HAeH JIeHHHCKHX MeTOAOB npOH3BOACTBa OH 6YAeT paCCMaTpHBaTbCH KaK opY J He CTpOHTenbCTBa KOMMYHH3Ma H Ln Bo HMH nora npHHUHna 6YAeT HaCa AaTbCH nopHAoK BMe· CTO cYIIIecTBYIOIIIeH aHapxHH a nOA aHapxHeH nOHHMaeTCH H Ae­ MOpaTH'IeCKHH nJIlOpaJIH3M Ha nepeAHHH nJIaH BbIH J yT KpHTepHH paUHOHaJIbHOrO H 3 p peKTHBHoro npoH3BoACTBa OnHpaHcb Ha Ta· KHe HneOJIOrH'IeCKHe nocTynaTbI npaBHIIIaH 3ITHTa CMO eT H B 6YAY­ IIIeM coxpaHHTb TOTaJIHTapHblH xapaKTep nOnHTH'IeCKOH BJIaCTH H nOnaBITHTb Bce CTpeMJIeHHH K AeMoKpaTHH H nJIIOPaJIH3MY· CITenyeT OTMeTHTb 'ITO TeXHOKpaTH'leCKaH pe popMa B CCCP Bce e MO eT C03naTb npennOCbIJIKH AJIH AeMOKpaTH'IeCKHX nepe­ MeH B 6ynYIIIeM Be J b 3KOHOMH'IeCKaH pe popMa nYCTb H TeXHO­ KpaTH'IeCKOrO THna CTaBHT MeHe J epa B 60nee npHBHJIerHpOBaHHoe nOJIO eHHe no cpaBHeHHIO C nOJIHTH'IeCKHM 6IOpOKpaTOM B HaCTO' HIIIee BpeMH KpHTepHeM KBaJIH pHKaUHH 6lOpOKpaTa HBnHeTCH Mepa ero nOCJIYWaHHH Ha'laJIbCTBY Ho AO CHX nop HeCMOTpH Ha TO 'ITO MHorHe MapKCHCTCKHe HCCJIenOBaHHH COBeTCKoro 06IIIeCTBa OTMe­ '1alOT BbI J BH eHHe TeXHOKpaTHH TeXHOKpaTbI npOAOJI aIOT no CBO­ eMY 3Hat leHHlO yCTynaTb annapaT'lHKaM BHenpeHHe KpHTepHH 3 p peKTHBHOCTH npaBHIIIeH 3JIHThI HeH3­ 6e HO nOBne'leT 3a C060H HCnOJIb30BaHHe TaKHX MexaHH3MoB KOHTPOITH npH nOMOIIIH KOTOPbIX MO HO 6YAeT onpeAeJIHTb ny 3 p­ peKTHBHOCTb B nOJIHTH'IeCKOH CHCTeMe rAe AO CHX nop npOBepH­ ITaCb ITHillb CTeneHb JIOHJIbHOCTH K BbIruecToHIIIHM onpeAeJIeHHe 3 p­ peKTHBHOCTH CTaHeT cepbe3HOH nepeMeHOH K JIy'lilleMY 3TO He 03­ Ha'iaeT 'ITO yCTaHOBHTCH 06paTHaH CBH3b CYIIIeCTBYIOIIIaH B neMo­ KpaTH4eCKOM 06IIIeCTBe HO B03HHKHeT HOBbIH HIlI CBH3H Me AY BBelJ CHHe npliHUHna 3 p peKTHBHOCTH He 03Ha'laeT IJ eMOKpan 3a UHH nOJIHTH4eCKOH CHCTeMbI COBeTCKoro THna Bonee Toro eCJIH B pe3YJIbTaTe TeXHOKpaTH4eCKOH pe popMhI nOHBHTCH B03MO HOCTb Ae· MOKpaTH3aUHH CHCTeMbI TO 3TO npOli30lllJ eT BonpeKH HaMepeHHHM npaBHIIICll 3nHTbl ueneHanpaBneHHOCTb KOTOPOH H B AaJIbHelliueM 6YlJ CT aIITHlJ eMOKpaTH4eCKOH B CTOPOHY cTa6HJIH3aII HH TOTaJIHTap· HOH CHCTeMbI HO CCJIH B BO·e rOAbI pe popMa OCYIIIeCTBHTCH OHa BCC C 3aTpOHeT ABa Ba HeHIIIHX 3neMCHTa COBpeMeHIIOH COBeTCKOH CH­ CTeMbI npeAOCTaBneHHe aBTOHOMHH I1eKOTOpbIM 3KOHOMH4eCKHM cy· 6beKTaM HapyIllHT Hepa3pbIBHYlO CBH3b nOJIHTH'IeCKOH H 3KOHOMH­ qeCKOH BJIaCTH BHelJ pCHHC KpHTepHeB 3 p peKTHBHOCTH YCTaHOBHT CBoero po­ IJ a 06paTHYlO CBH3b MC IJ Y 3nHTOH H HeKOTopblMH Y4acTKaMH 06­ IIIccTBeHHoH AeHTCJIbHOCTH JPH 3an031J aJIOM peIlleHHH KOH pJ1HKTOB Me AY OTAeJlbHblMH rpynnaMH npaBHlI eH 3JIHTbl B COBCTCKOM COlO3e MO eT C03AaTbCH TaKoe nOnO eHHe KOTopoe npHBelJ Cr K B3PblBY 06IIIecrBeHHoro He· IJ OBOJ1bCTBa JOllY4aerCH CBoero pOAa napaAoKc crpax COBerCKoro PYKoBoAcrBa nepelJ npoTcCTOM Macc MO CT nOMeruaTb CBoeBpe­ MeHHoMY npOBelJ CHHIO pe poPMbI KOTopaH MOrJ1a 6bI Ha HeKOTO' poe BpeMH cTa6HnH3HpOBaTb HbIHeIIIHlO1O CHCTeMY 1'1 BocnpenHTCTBo­ BaTb npOHBJ1eHHHM HenOBOnbCTBa ECJIH oCYIl eCTBHTCH TaKoH Ba· pHaHT TO COBeTCKoe PYKOBOACTBO HeH36e HO npH6erHeT K HaCH­ J1HIO 1'1 nOJIHUeHCKOMY Teppopy C BbITeKaIOU HMH 1'13 nora nOCJ1eA· CTBHHMH Ho KaK 6bl TO HH 6bmo HanpaBJIeHHC no KOTOPOMY nOH' AeT COBeTcKHH COI03 onpelJ eJIHTCH B nepBoH nOJIOBHHC BO·x rOAoB BrOPbIM paKTOPOM KOTOPblH MO eT nOBJ1HHTb Ha Bbl60p MeTO­ nOB npeOnOJIeHHH 3KOHOMHQeCKOrO KpH3Hca B CCCP HBJIHeTCH no· JIO eHHe B CTpaHax UeHTpaJIbHOH EBponbl 3TH CTpaHbl COBeTCKOH C pCPbI BJIHHHHH OTJIHllalOTCH OT CCCP TCM 'ITO npOBeneHHe 3KOHO' MH4eCKHX pC pOpM TaM HeJIb3H OTlJ eJIHTb OT nOJIHTH4eCKHX B IIOJIb­ rue HanpHMep npOCTO HeB03MO H0 npenOCTaBHTb 66JIbillYlO caMO­ CTOHTeJlbHOCTb IIpeIJ IIpHHTHHM He BOCKpeCHB npH 3TOM npH3paKa He3aBHCHMbiX npo pCOI030B B qexocnoBaKHH rAC Hc06xo J HMOCTb npoBcAcHHH 3KOHOMH4CCKHX pe p0pM naBHo Ha3peJIa HX HeB03' MO HO 6YACT OTAenHTb OT KpHTHKH TaK Ha3blBaeMoH HOpMaJIH3a­ B cTpaHe C 1969 r ECJIH e COBCTCKHH COlO3 B IIonbille H qcxOCJIOBaKHH TO TaKOH npaBHIIIeil 3JIHTOH H 06IIIeCTBOM 58 59 II I mar oYMepaHrOM YAapliT no COBeTCKOMY PYKOBOACTBY B BeHrplili li rnp n0J10lKeHlie HeCKOJ1bKO liHoe HO TOlKe OTJ1liIJaeTCH OT n0J10­ lKeHliH B CCCP nOCKOJ1bKY B 3TliX CTpasax OomeCTBO OOJ1ee HaCTOH­ IJHBO TpeoyeT npOBeAeHliH peepopM HeAOCTaTKOB li K ee AeMOKpaTH3aIl HH B03MOlKHOCTH 3TliX rpynn YBenHIJaTCH 5J1aTOAapH B03HHKHOBeHHKl 3J1eMeHTOB IIl1KlParIHCTH­ IJeCKOH CHCTeMbI no XOAY 3KOHOMHIJeCKOH peepopMbI ECJ1H lKe CO­ BeTCKaH CHCTeMa B 80-e rOAbl 5YAeT AeplKaTbCH Ha BoeHHO-nOnHII eH­ Pa3J1HIJliH B ypOBHe paJ liTHH MelKAY cTpasaMli COBeTCKOH cepe­ CKOM HaCHnHli TO HeH35elKHbIe B 0YAYIUeM KPH3HCbI eme 50J1bme pM BJ1HHHliH KOTopbIe OOycnOBliJ1li Kpli3HC 50-x rOAOB He BhIpaB­ o50cTpHT KOHepJ1HKTbl BnJ10Tb HHJ1liCb AO CliX nop B liHTepecax YKpenJ1eHliH CBoeH rereMOHHli CO­ cHTyaIl HH BeTCKaH BepxYIIIKa 3aTOpM03liJ1a pa3BHTlie He TOJ1hKO CTpaH BOCTOIJ­ AO 05pa30BaHHH peBOJ1KlUHoHHOH ITo KaKoMY 5bl nym HH nomeJ1 COBeTcKHH COKl3 B 80-e rOADI HOH EBPOIIl I HO li CCCP He liCKJ1KlIJeHO IJTO OHa npOAOJ1lKliT Ta­ OIJeBHAHO OAHO npOTHBOpeIJHH MelKAY KYKl nOJ1liTliKY li B 80-e rOAbI TYT OAHaKO BCTynaeT B AeHcTBlie MH 3aAaIJaMH CCCP H cTpaH BOCTOIJHOH EBponbl 5YAYT nOCTO l1HHO HOBhIH epaKTop B yrJ1y6J1HTbC I1 1956 li 1968 rr COBeTCKoe PYKOBOACTBO eme COIl HaJ1bHO-nOJ1HTHIJeCKH­ Morno nOAaBHTb peepopMbI B CTpaHax BOCTOIJHOH EBponhI He CTa­ BH npH nOM nOA yrp03Y CTaOliJ1bHOCTb CBoero rocYAapCTBa B 80-e rOADI COBeTCKoe BMemaTeJ1bCTBO cTpaH OKaJarIOCb ObI IJpeBaTbIM B AeJ1a BOCTOIJHOeBpOneHCKliX Cephe3HeHmHMH nOCJ1eACTBliHMli AJ1H COBeTCKoro COKl3a li J1liKBliAlipOBaTb 3Tli nOCJ1eACTBliH COBeT­ CKoe PYKOBOACTBO MOrJ10 ObI TOJ1bKO nYTeM MaCCOBoro Teppopa IToKa eme TpYAHO OnpeAeJ1liTb KaKOMY pemeHHKl OTAaAYT npeA­ nOIJTeHHe COBeTCKlie PYKOBOAlfTeJ1li - nOJ1HII eHCKOMY HJ1H 3KOHOMli­ IJeCKOMY 11 He liCKJ1KlIJeHO IJTO liHTepeCbI COXpaHeHliH rereMOHHli B 0J10Ke CTaHyt COBeTCKOH TeM epaKTopOM KOTOPblH nOMemaeT npOBeAeHHKl 3KOHOMliIJeCKliX peepopM B CCCP ITOABOAH HTorli CKa3aHHOMY MOlKHO CAeJ1aTb CJ1eAYKlIUHe BbIBO­ AbI B 80-e rOADI I1 eHTp THlKecm Kpli mca KOTOPbIH nepelKlfBaKlT CHCTeMbI COBeTCKOrO mna nepeMeCTliTCH B CCCP KaK B 1953 rnaBHoH CHJ10H KOTopaH r nplicTynliT K pemeHliKl nora Kpli3lica 0YAeT COBeTCKa npaBHmaH 3J1liTa B HaCTOHmee BpeMH Kpli3liC Bbl­ 3BaH 3KOHOMU'leCKUMU TPYAHOCTHMli HO pemaTb ero OYAyt HCXO­ AH H3 nO lU1U'leCKUX liHTepecoB cOBeTcKoH 3J1HTbI B 80-e rOADI BpHA J1H npOH30HAYT cymecTBeHHbIe H3MeHeHHH Tex cBH3eH KOTO­ pble CJ10lKliJ1HCb 3a rOADI cymecTBoBaHliH cOBeTcKoH CHCTeMbl H KO­ Topble AeJ1aKlT ee TOTarIliTapHoH Ho eCJ1li B np0Il ecce npeOAOJ1eHHH 3KOHOMHlJeCKOrO Kpli3Hca COBeTCKoe PYKOBOACTBO npH nOMOIIJ H 3KOHOMliIJeCKliX epaKTopoB A05beTcH OTHOCHTeJ1bHOH CTa0Hl1li3aIl HH CHCTeMbl TO paCIUlipliTCH npOCTOp AJ1H AeHTeJ1bHOCTH COIl liarIbHhIX rpynn CTpeMHll liXCH K npeOAOJ1eHHIO xapaKTepHblX AJ1H CHCTeMbI 60 61