KOTOPbIX C06paJJH ' T06bI rrpO'lHTaTh HM ceKpeTHhIH AOKJIaA HH­ IOJlb MapTUHe K fIhI Xpym eBa • 0 TOH BTOPOH cMepTH CaJIHH 6bIJI AnH MHJIJIHOHOB KOMMYHH­ CTOB reHHaJJbHbIM 3HaMeHOCll eM MHpoBoro npOJIeTapHaTa caMhIM· BeJIHKHM rrOCJIe rreHHHa MapKcHcTCKHM TeopeTHKoM KaK cTpaTer QlHJIOCOQl rocYAapCTBeHHhIH AeHTeJIb H KopHQleii HaYKH CTamm HaJlaraJJ CBOIO rre'laTb CTBa HA BOCTOKE Tynl1K Ha Bce CTOPOHhI lif3HH COBeTCKoro rocYAap­ Ha 3KOHOMHKY HCKYCCTBO H AaJKe 6HOJIOrHIO 60JIee np51MOrO CO'leTaHlfH HaYKIf Ka3aJJocb C rrpaKTlfKoH HeB03MO HO If BO­ 06pa3lfTh XpymeB pa3pylliHJI ny rroKa3aTenhHyIO KapTHHy pa30­ B rrOnHTHKe KaK H Ha BotiHe TaTY nOJHITHKa CYAHT rro npaKTH'JeCKOMY pe3yJIh­ 3TO HCKyCCTBO Hcrronh30BaHH51 B03MO HOro YMeTh rrpOBeCTH pa3BeAKY KaK MO HO fIOJIHee rrpe J BHAeTh Bepo­ 6JIa'llfB cJIafiocTh HenOCJIeAOBaTenbHOCTh H npecTynHocTh BO AH KOTOPOMY caM llOJIrHe rOAhI CJIy l HJI He 3a CTpax a 3a COBeCTh npaBAa XpymeB peUJlIDCH OCylllfTb TOJIbKO caMoro CTaJIHHa 5lTHhIe rrperr51TCTBH51 HaHTH HanpaBJIeHHe rJIaBHOrO y o apa BhIpa60­ Hero OlliH6KH TaTh CTpaTerHiO H rJIaBHOe Y'leCTh cOBoKyrrHOcTh Bcex lifMelOmHXCH HHMaJJC51 0 ero fiYllYmeM B HaJJH'lHH CHJI 'ITO OCHOBhI COll HaJJH3Ma y e 3aJIO eHhI OCTaBaJIOCh JIHllIb rrocrreAo­ TOJIhKO TaK TeOpH51 cornacyeTcH C rrpaKTHKoH npeHe6peraH nparMaTlif3MOM JIerKO AenalOTCH YTorrHCTaMH 060pOT 11 Ha­ BaTeJIhHO no 0 nplfpoAe COBeTCKoro 06meCTBa Bonpoc He rroA­ H Toro MeHhllIe narraM llBHraThcH XpymeB YTBep llaJJ BrrepeA B KOMMYHHCTH'·lecKoe rrporrOBe t HHKH yTorrHH 06pe'leHhI Ha npaKUflIeCKHe Hey o a­ 3aBTpa PellIalOJ QHM QlaKTopoM Toro npOllBH eHHH XpymeB npo­ ECTh B HalUH AHH npaBHTeJIhCTBa KOTophIe rrpeTeH o YIOT Ha rrpH­ 06'beM rrpOMhIllIJIeHHOrO rrpoH3BoAcTBa B CCCP YBeJIH'lHBaJJcH Ha '11if AOJI aJJ C'lHTaTb 3KOHOMH'leCKHH POCT 3HaHlife Toro 'ITO HX nOJIHTHKa He TOJIbKO peaJIHCTH'lHa HO H HaY'lHO 12 - 15% BhIBepeHa X03HHCTBO OTCTaBaJJO Ha TaKHx rrpaBHTeJIhCTB 'leTbIpHa o ll aTh OHH BJIaCTBYIOT e erOAHO 1950-1956 CTpaHhI B rr a HaIlHoHaJJbHhIH AOXOA rrOCKOJIhKY cenhCKoe 8-10'% ITO rr03BOJIHJIO paCC'lHThlBaTh 'ITO B cTpaHax rAe YTBep o HJIIif CBOIO nOJIHTH'·lecKYIO MOHOnOJIHIO KOMMy­ 3KOHOMH'leCKHH rrOTeHll HaJJ B Ka AOe cneAYlOmee AeCHTHneTHe fiy­ HHCTlif'leCKHe rrapTHH lleT yBeJlH'lHBaThCH B J BOe TorAa KaK CoeAHHeHHhle illTaThI OAHaKO HCTOplif'leCKOe pa3BHTHe rrOCJIeAHHX AeCHTHJIeTHH rrOKa­ HEaJJH 6hl CBOH rrOTeHll HaJJ JIHllIh Ka llhIe 20 neT 3ano 'ITO rrpeTeH3HH rrpaBHJ QHX KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKHX rrapTHH Ha HC­ npeACTaBJIHJIOCh CTOJIb e HCHbIM KaK H CTaJJHHY KIIIO'IHTenhHYIO peamfCTH'lHOCTh HX nporpaMMhI AeHTCBlifTeJIhHOCTblO 103 AOn eH AorHaTh H rreperHaTh CoeAHHeHHble illTaTbI He B OTJIH'IHe OT CTaJIHHa XpymeB yCOMHHJIC51 nOATBep AaIOTCH B KOMMYHHCTH'leCKOM narepe paCTYT H 060­ CTPHIOTCH rrpOTHEOpe'lHH horo rrpaBAa TaM He rrpH3HalOT Ho TeM YABa­ XpymeBY Bce COBeTCKHH CO­ IlpaBAa B 3QlQleKTHBHOCTH a6­ COJIIOTHOH ll eHTpaJJl13all HH H MaKCHMaJJhHorO nOAaBJIeHHH HHHll HaTH­ 60JIee Ba HO rrpOaHaJIH3HpOBaTh 3TH rrpOTHBOpe'lHH TaKoH aHaJIH3 BhI TpyAHmHXC51 OH nbITaJICH paccpeAOTOlJHTb ynpaBJIeH'leCKHH arr­ MO eT rrpliffIO t H51Th 3aBecy 3a KOTOPOH CKPhITO 6YAyme e • napaT BhICBOfiOAIfTb pa6o'lYIO ClWy H3 JIarepeH H TlOpeM BBeCTH rrpHHll Hrr MaTepHaJJhHOH 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTH CTHMYJIHpOBaTb TPYA KpeCThHH ll06HThCH pa3pHAKH Me llYHapOllHOH Harrpfi eHHOCTH H C03AaTh YCJIOBHH AJJH MHpHoro cocymecTBOBaHHH Ho He B CHJIax XpymeBa 6hIllO BocnpenHTCTBOBaTh 3apO AeHHIO MepTBIDl AorMa H 3eneHoe ApeBo JKH3HH CTaJJHHY rrpeACTOHJlO YMepeTh ABa AhI B nopa60meHHhIX CTaJJHHblM cTpaHax BOCTO'lHOH EB pOrrh H Apymx 5 HOKOH KOMHaTe Ha rroAMocKOBHOH Aa'le Heme 1956 r 62 1953 r B 0AIif­ pa3 25 QleBpaJUI MapTa Ha t e ll Ha HaIlHOHaJJbHylO He3aBHCHMOCTb H AeMOKpaTH3all HIO Koma CTaJJHH yMep QlH3H'IeCKH nOllHHJIHCb pa60'lHe BOCTO'lHOrO Eepmma KorAa nOCJIe XX C'he3Aa OH yMep MopanbHO BHpyC CB060­ rry6JIH'lHO B rrpHcyTCTBHIif AeJIeraTOB XX CM3Aa KnCC 63 Abl npOHHK B ilOnblIIY H BeHrpHlO qeM nO KOH'IHnOCb H3BeCTHO B 1l1l0 U1Tb 60nee rH6Koe nllaHHpOBaHHe rrpH3HaBanH lfaCTli'lHYIO aBTO ilOnbllle - HOMHIO OTllellbHblx npellrrpHflTHH 6aHKaM rrpelloCTaBHllH 60nee aK­ KOMnpOMHCCOM B BeHrpHH l eCTOKOH BOeHHOH HHTep­ BeHUHeH Pa3HHlIa 6bJJ1a o6ycnoBneHa BH U1MO TeM 'ITO B rrepBOM THllHYIO pom cranH MeHflTb cHcTeMy lIeHoo6pa30BaHHH 3TO eme He cnytJae MOHOrrOnbHafl BnaCTb KOMMYHHCTOB OCTanaCb HenpHKOCHO­ 6bJJ10 peBonIOUHeH HO BblxollHno 3a paMKH 06bI'IHbIX ycoBepllIeH­ BeHHOH a BO BTOPOM Ha'lana 6bICTPO pa3naraTbCfl caMa KOMnap­ CT1l0BaHlfH CHCTeMbI ynpaBneHHH peqb llma 0 TH 1 Bce-TaKH B Te BpeMeHa H B caMOM COBeTCKOM C0103e H B CTpaHax BOCTO'lHOH EBponbI nOflBHllHCb TeHlleHlIHH K llH6epaJ1H3aUHH TO 3KOHOMHKOH B qexocnoBaKHH CrpyWryPHblX pe jiopMax HO KaK TOllbKO HalfaITOCb HX ocymecTBneHHe BbIHBHllHCb cepbe3HbIe npoTHBOpeqHH H rnaBHoe Ha3pell Bonpoc yKpenRT flU OHU cYUlecT6YlOUlYlO cucTeMY UflU no­ MeHee TO 6011ee rrocllellOBaTellbHble CaMbIM pa U1KaJ1bHbIM H3 Tor­ 6IleKYT 3a co6oii ee OCfla6fleHue OTBeToM 6bmH KpH3HC llallIHHX Tpe60BaHHH 6bIlla cBo60lla ne'laTH Ho HHKTO Torlla He CTa­ npa l CKaH BecHa H HaKOHelI COBeTCKafl HHTepBeHUHH BHn rroll COMHeHHe HH 0606meCTBneHHe cpellCTB npOH3BO llCTBa HH rrnaHHpOBaHHe X03flHCTBa HH nepBOCTeneHHoe 3HalfeHHe 3KOHO­ Ho eme llO 3Toro BHHMaHHe MHpa npHBlleK 1968 r Ky6HHCKHH 3Kcne­ pHMeHT OH BbI3BaIT CHMnaTHH He TonbKO CBoeH CTHXHHHOCTbIO HO 11 MH'IeCKOrO POCTa ilporpaMMbI COUHaJ1bHbIX rrpe06pa30BaHHH TaK H peBOllIOUHOHHOH 6eCKOMrrpOMHCCHOCTbIO H He rrOflBHnOCb TOllbKO B lOrOCllaBHH B KOTOPOH llHcceHT Hafl peBonIOUHfl B KHTae KOTOpyIO CllHIUKOM nocnellIHO He C'IHTa­ B 1948 r H KOTOPaH 6bJJ1a npOmeHa XpymeBbIM Ha'l llCH B 1957 r npH­ HCb C pa3nH'IHflMH eme 6bIlla KynbTYP­ KHTaHCKHX H 3anallHbiX ycnoBHH npHHHllHCb 6mf3HllHCb K TaKoH rrporpaMMe BbIllBHHyB HlleIO npoH3BO llCTBeH­ C6JlH I aTb C npOTeCTaMH aMepHKaHCKRX CTYlleHTOB H q paHUY3CKHM HOro caMoyrrpaBneHHH Ho npoTHBOpe'lHe Me l lY npHHlIlmaMH H MaeM 1968 rOlla nOBcellHeBHoH MYHHcTH'IecKHH npaKTHKoH HHKorlla He H3rllallHnOCb H TaM KOM­ MHp pa3BHBaeTcfl TaK Me lJ1eHHO 'ITO HeBOllbHO cnpallIHBaellIb He TOrr'leTCH nH OH Ha MeCTe bbJJ1a Halle l lla 'ITO Pa30'lapOBaHHe OKa3aITOCb rrponOpUHOHaITbHO YTpa'leHHbIM Hll­ llI03HflM ilonbITKH BOCCTaHOBHTb lleMoKpaTHIO - B TpanHUHoH­ HOH HnH B HOBOH BepcHH nOBcIOllY 6bJJ1H pa3llaBneHbl OllHorrap­ no XX Cbe3ll HallyeT onYCTHSllIHeCfl rrapyca HO llO l lallHCb TOllbKO Clla­ THHHafl llHKTaTypa no6ellHlla 3HaqHT nH 60ro 6pH3a KOTOPblH ellBa ocse I Hn B03llYX Hble nOCllellCTBHH 0606IUeCTBlleHHfl cpellCTB npOH3BOllCTBa TaK llY­ HOBbIe seHHHH Ha'laITH lJ 'BCTBOBaTbCfl S 1965 r OHH CTHMyllHpO- BanHCb 3KOHOMH'IeCKHMH TPYllHOCTflMH KOTopble npoflsHllHCb K 'ITO TaKOBbl HeH36e l ­ MaIOT KOHcepBaTopbl Bcex CTpaH K HHM rrpHcoellHHHIOTCfl H HeKO­ Topble COUHan-lleMOKpaTbI fleBble COUHaITHCTbl KpaHHHe neBble H TOMY BpeMeHH He TOllbKO B COBeTCKOM COI03e HO H S 6011bIlIHH­ 3anallHble KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKHe napTHH TO OTpHuaIOT CTBe rOCYllapCTS BOCTO'lHOH EBpOTIhI E I erOllHbIH npHpOCT npOH3­ Torlla 06bHCHHTb nO'leMY BO Bcex 14-TH rOCYllapcTBax rlle '1aCTHaH BOllcTBa _ rrOKa3aTellb KOTOPbIM npe l lle KHlfHllHCb 3TH CTpaHbI pe3KO COKpaTHllCfl B qexocnoBaKHH llsa rOlla rrOllpflll rrallaITH lla l e TeMnbI 3KOHOMH'IeCKOrO pa3sHTHH B OC060M nOllO l eHHH OKa­ Ho KaK l e c06CTBeHHOCTb Ha cpellCTBa rrpOH3BOllCTBa 6bma llHKBHllHpOBaHa rronHOCTbIO rrpOHCXO U1T OllHO H TO l e l lleHHH 'ITO 11 '1eM 060CHOBaTb YTBep­ B 3anallHbIX cTpaHax B cnyqae ycnexa COUHaITlfCTH'Ie­ 3allaCb lOrocllaBHH TeMnbI pOCTa coxpaHHllH HHTeHCHBHOCTb HO lIe­ CKOH peBOllIOlIlfH Bce 6YlleT HHaqe OTBeTbI llOCTaTOqHO onpellelleH­ HOH HbI HO HaBpflll nH YllOBneTBopHTenbHbI YBenHlfeHHH HHq nHUHH ilpaBHTellbCTBa BbIHY I lleHbI 6bJJ1H lfTO-TO rrpellnpHHHMaTb HacTyrrHlla nOlloca peq opM fu 06beM H xapaKTep 6bJJ1H pa311HlfHbI lOrOCllaSHfl Ha'laITa nepe­ CCbInaIOTCfl HarrpHMep Ha OC06yIO cHTyaUHIO B POCCHH H KHTae K HalfaITY peBOllIOUlflf 06a rOCYllapCTBa cepbe3HO OTCTaBaITH B npo­ XOll OT rrllaHOBOH 3KOHOMHKH K PbIHO'lHOH COBeTCKHH COI03 orpa­ MbJUmeHHOM pa3BHTHH ilpOMbJUmeHHOCTb pa3BHBanaCb HO B CO­ HH'IHnCH rrOrrbITKaMH npellOCTaBHTb 6011bllIe CB060AbI PYKosOllHTe­ rrOCTaBlleHlfH C cellbCKHM X03flHCTBOM 06beM ee 6bIJ1 He3HaqHTelleH llflM rrpellrrpHHTHH rrepeCMOTpeTb CHCTeMY lIeHo06pa30BaHHH YK­ B perrHTb MaTepHanbHYIO 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTb OllHHM H3 KpHTepHeB CKafl 060HX rOCYllapcTBax TpanHUHH OTCYTCTBOBaITa 6YP l ya3Ho-lleMOKpamqe­ COUHaITbHble npe06pa30BaHlfH BBOllHllHCb npH He­ HapollH oro X03HHCTBa CTaHOBHTCfl npH6bJJ1b qexocnoBaKHH nonpO­ 6narorrpHflTHOH 60BaITa CHHTe3HpOBaTb cOBeTcKHe H IOrOCllaBCKHe peq opMbI CTaITH npH BceM TOM H36e l aTb BBelleHHfl llHKTaTypbI TYT eCTb BepOflT­ 64 Me l lYHapOllHOH 06CTaHOBKe MO l HO llH 6b1J10 65 na Ke 3ana l HbIe KOMMYHHCTbI HeYCTaHHO TBep J HT tITO HHKaKoro HO H J om npaB J bI Ho MO KHO nH TCM KC cnoco60M 06'bHCHHTb XO J pa3BHTHH lJcxocnoBaKHH HnH BOCTotIHOH fepMaHHH 3KOHO­ MHtIeCKH BbICOKO pa3BHTbIX CTpaH MO KHO nH TaK KC 06'bHCHHTb COBPCMCHHOC nOJIO KeHHC B COBCTCKOM COlO3e B HH J YCTPHaIlbHOM 06H3aTeJIbHOrO 06pa3ua HeT tITO COIJ HaJIH3M Ha 3arra J e J on KCH 6bITb COBceM l pymM TaKoBa 3BOnlOIJ HH OT 6C30rJIH l HOrO BOCXHIl1CHHH OT HaHBHbIX BOCToprOB nOJIHTHtfeCKHX nHJIHrpHMOB OT jJanbIIlHBO p030BbIX orrH­ OTHOIIlCHHH rrcpC J OBOM rOCY J apCTBe KOTopoe Ka3aI10Cb 6bI BOBce caHHH YBH J eHHoro - HC J OJI KHO CTpa J aTb KOMIIJICKCOM MeJK J YHapO J HoH HerrOJIHOIJ eHHO- p06KHM ynpeKaM H HaKOHeIJ CTH BeHHOH Bpa K J e6HOCTH npyrHe rrpC J JIaralOT HCXO J HTb H3 HaIJ HOHaIlbHOH CneIJ H tlHKH K J HIlnOMaTHtIeCKOH Be KJlHBOCTH 3aTCM B OT J eJIbHbIX cnytIaHX Ho Be J b Toro He l OCTaTOtIHO K K OTKpO­ Be llb TOJIbKO BcepbC3 aHaIlH3H­ KaJK J oro 3KcnepHMeHTa B OT J eJIbHOCTH KOHCtfHO Henb3H Cy J HTb pyH 06 CCCP rrpcHc6peraH oc06eHHocTHMH CBRTOH PyCH HnH 0 MaOH3­ JIOBHH npH KOTOPbIX nOnhITKH COIJ HanhHhIX npe06pa30BaHHH Mor­ HTorH KOHKpeTHbIX 3KcnepHMeHTOB MO KHO YCTaHOBHTb yc· MC He Y HTbIBaH KHTaHCKOH HCTOpHH Ho pa3Be He BepHO TO Ke ca­ JIH 6bI npHHeCTH 60nee npHBJIeKaTeJIbHbIe nnO l bI Hcxo J H H3 OnbITa Moe B rrpHMeHeHHH KO BceM CTpaHaM H CHCTeMaM HrrOHCKHH Ka­ 14-TH rOCY J apCTB B03rJIaBnHeMbIX KOMMYHHCTHtIeCKHMH napTHHMH rrHTaJIH3M OTJIHtIaeTCH OT aMepHKaHCKoro a aMcpHKaHCKHH B CBOIO H3ytIaH TaK Ke orrbIT crpaH TpeTbero MHpa B KOTOPbIX TO Ke 6bIJIH OtIepe J b HMeeT CBOH oc06eHHOCTH B CpaBHeHHH C rrpe l npHIDIThI jJpaHIJ y3CKHM HJIH HeMeUKHM Ho J oCTaTOtIHO JIll 3Toro tIT06bI OTKa3aTbCH OT rro­ HCKa o6ll1HX 3aKoHoMepHocTeH pa3BIHHH KarrHTaJIH3Ma HaKoHeIJ rOBopHT 06 oco60 6JIarOrrpm THblX ycnoBHHx J JIH CJIe l yeT HCKaTb nOCTpOHTb COUHaJIH3M TaKoH rro l XO l OTBeprHYT TeopeTHKaMH-MapKCHCTaMH OH OT­ BeprHYT B tIaCTHOCTH 3PHCTOM MaH l CJIeM 6e3 COMHeHHH caMbIM oCYll1eCTBJIeHHH COIJ HaIlH3Ma KOTOPbIC CJIOJKHnHCb B HHlJ YCTPHaIlb­ BbI l aIOIl1HMCH HbIX CTpaHaX 3ana J HOH EBponbI HaeMHble pa60tIHC COCTaBnHIOT TaM MHOH B 60nbIIlHHCTBO aKTHBHorO HaceneHHH nOnbITKH 06 1tYIO 3aKOHOMepHOCTb TeopeTHKOM COBpeMeHHoro TPOUKH3Ma CnopH co CB060 J HOM YHHBepCHTCTe B 6plOcceJIe MaH J em 3aHBHJI KOHUCHTpaIJ HH npOMbIIIlnCH­ 'ITO YKJIOHbI KOTopbIe HaIlO KHJIH CBOIO netIaTb Ha XO l COBepIIlHB­ HOCTH H KarrHTaIla C03 J aIIa npe J llOCbIJIKH J nH BBC J eHHH 3KOHOMH­ IIlHXCH npOJIeTapCKHX peBOJIIOUHH HeJIb3H B03BO l HTb B HCTOpHtIe­ Tpa J HUHH CBo60 llbI npOtIHO YKopeHH­ CKylO 3aKOHOMepHOCTb nOCKOJIbKY COIJ HaIlH3M HatIHHaIlH CTPOHTb nHCb B C03HaHHH rpaJK J aH H T J Bcc 3TO TaK HO Henb3H OTpHUaTb tIeCKOrO perYJIHpOBaHHH B OT l eJIbHbIX crpaHax H peBOJIIOUHH CIl1C He n06e l Hna B MaCIIlTa6ax tITO KanHTanH3M rrpeKpaCHO npHcrroco6HJICH K 3THM HOBbIM ycno­ Bccro MHpa ITo MaH J eJIIO HeJIb3H H3 HaKOnJIeHHOrO OnbITa J enaTb BHHM H COOTBeTCTBCHHO MO J H jJHll HPOBaIlCH Hc CTOHT K TOMY Ke BbIBO l bl KOTopble onpOBepraJIH 6bI tICPCCtIyP 060JIbll1aTbCH TeM tITO rpaJK J aHe 3arra J HoH EBponbI HMe­ npe l HatIepTaHHH MapKca H fleHHHa lOT HMMYHHTCT K pa3Horo COPTa J HKTaTypaM Be J b jJaIIlH3M rrepe J HJIH l a Ke KoppeKTHpOBaIlH H Bce nOToMY tITO TpOUKH3M pa3pa6oTaB TpY l aMH MaH l enH co6CTBeHHYIO BepCHIO CTpYKTYP­ BToPOH MHPOBOH BOHHOH paCIJ BCn He r J e-HH6Y l b a HMeHHO B 3a­ HblX pe jJopM Bce ell e npO l On KaeT CTOHTb Ha CTpa Ke rra l HOH EBponc - BOJIIOIJ HH MaH J em npH3HaeT tITO BO Bcex rOCY J apcTBax r J e YCTa­ B BbICOKO IJ HBHJIH30BaHHbIX fepMaHHH H HTa­ XpaMa pe­ HOBHJIaCb BnaCTb KOMMYHHCTHtfeCKHX napTHH CMhIcn peBonlOUHH JIHH EBponCHCKHC neBbIC MetIYTCH B nOHCKax BceB03MO KHbIX onpaB­ 6hIJI HCKaJKeH a BMeCTO rrponeTapCKHX rOCY J apCTB nOJIYtIHJIHCh l aHHH CBOCMY HC KCJIaHHIO npHCMOTpeTbCH K J CHCTBHTenbHOMY npo­ pa3JIO KHBIIlHeCH pa60tIHe rOCY l apCTBa IIlJIOMY HaCTOHIl1CMY H 6Y J YIl1CMY TaK Ha3blBaeMbIX COIJ HaIlHCTHtfe­ ero YCOMHHTbCH tITO HacTynHT J eHb KOr l a J BH KeHHe Macc 06HOBHT CKHX CTpaH H l aTb 3TOMY p nYMHOC 06bHCHeHHe OHH YKJIOHHIOT­ pa3BpaTHBIIlYIOCH UepKOBb BOCCTaHOBHT ee J eBCTBeHHYIO tIHCTOTY B Cfl OT nOJICMHKH C onrrOHeHTaMH nOBTopHH CHOBa H CHOBa O J HOM H Bce-TaKH C MaH l eJIeM cornaceH KaK onHCbIBaIlH pa3BHToe MbI JKHBeM BO l paHuHH HnH B KaKOH-HH6Y J b l pyroH H3 3arra J HOeBpOneHCKHX CTpaH a He B POCCHH Y CCCP H Ho H 3TO He n06Y K l aeT nO KHHKH MapKCH3Ma ecnH BcnOMHHTb COIJ HaIlHCTHtIeCKOe 06ll1eCTBO OCHOBono­ npH J eTCH npH3HaTb tITO TaKoro 06ll1eCTBa nOKa tITO HHKTO He BH J en H 6eCCMhICJIeHHO KOHetIHO npe J JIaraTb KHTafl HHble He HaIIlH rrp06neMbI a nOTOMY H rOBopHTb 0 HHX 6eCCMbICJIeHHO 66 67 TeopHlO COUHallbHO-3KOHOMlflleCKOii j OpMaUHH KOTOpoii He cyme­ cTByeT Ho C Il pyroii CTOPOHbI - H 3TO TO e Tpy l HO onpoBeprHyTb KaKHe-TO HOBble 06meCTBeHHbIe CTpyKTYPbl Bce-TaKH nOKBHJJHCb HhIM MO HO npoH3BonbHo HaBK3bIBaTb npelll1pHKTHKM ueHbI Ha IX H3Il el1HK HO H nocne nora OHH He nepeCTaHyT 6bITb TOBapaMH HaUHOHaJIH3aUHK HHa'le rOBopH He 3aTparHBaeT 3KOHOMH'leCKHX CTapllaK H3 HHX y e OTnpa31l HOBalla CBoe lleCTHll eCKTHneTHe a MeXaHH3MOB KanHTaJIH3Ma 3TH MeXaHH3MbI Ha Il ene BbI HBalOT Bce BMeCTe OHH OXBaTHnH orpOMHble TeppHTopHH 3eMHoro llapa Il a e eCl1H nHKBHAHpOBaTb KanHTaJlHCTOB Ha KOTOPbIX HBeT 60nee MHnnHapll a 'lenOBeK Ha3BaTb HX MO HO nO-pa3HOMY CKHMH nepeXOIl HblMH 06meCTBaMH HnH 61OpOKpaTH'le­ TeXHO-OlOpOKpaTH'leCKHMH rocYAapCTBeHHO-COUHallH­ HaUHOHaJIH3au KII - He nauau eD CTH'leCKHMH H T 1l Ho KaK HX HH Ha3bIBaii BCKKHii 1l 0n eH npH­ 3HaTb 'lTO B3KTbIe BMeCTe H conocraBneHHbIe OHH npell CTaBnKlOT I1MeHHo nonoMY TeopeTHKH COUHanH3Ma cornaCHbI Tenepb B c060ii H TeOpeTJ iqeCKH H HCTOpJ iqeCKH 'lpe3BbI'laiiHO Ba HbIH 061 ­ TOM 'lTO HeB03MO HO YIl OBneTBopHTbCK OIl HOH TOl1bKO HaUHOHaJlH' eKT Il llK aHanH3a calOT 1l 0 OCHOBaHHK Y e HX n06TOpJleMOCTb U iJOll2ollerue cOTpKca­ npHBbl bIe cxeMbI IIopa OTKa3aTbCK OT 6ec­ 3aUHeii HaUHOHanH3aUHK nHIIlb HCXOIl HbIH nyHKT Ho KYll a e ABHraTbCH Il allblle KOHe'lHbIX COnOCTaBneHHH Toro 'lTO nonyqHnocb C TeM 'lTO AOn ­ IIYTb no KOTOPOMY nOllIen COBeTCKHH C0103 a BCnell 3a HHM H HO 6bI nonYqHTbCK IIopa nocMoTpeTb B rna3a npaBAe IIopa 6ecnpH­ Bce Il Pyme rOCYll apCTBa B KOTOPbIX Bl1aCTb 3axBaTHJJH KOMMYHH­ cTpacTHo 06AYMaTb np06neMbI KOTopble HeH3MeHHO nOKBnKlOTCK CTH'leCKHe napTHH XOPOllO H3BeCTeH 06mecrneHHaH c06CTBeHHOCTb cpa3Y KaK TonbKO B KaKoH yrOIl HO CTpaHe 0606mecTBnKlOT cpeA­ 061 KBJ1KeTCK C06CTBeHHOCTblO Bcero 06meCTBa HnH HapOIl HOH CTBa npOH3BOIl CTBa CTBeHHOCTblO Ha nOM OCHOBaHHH Y npell npHHTHH OTHHMaeTCK npa­ KaKHe 6bI pa3nJ iqHK HH cymeCTBOBanH H3Ha'lanbHO B Tex cTpaHax c06­ BO CB060 l H0 pellaTb BonpocbI 0 KOnH'leCTBe HnH Ka'leCTBe c06­ rAe npOBOIl HJJCK 3TOT 3KcnepHMeHT Me AY HHMH 06HapY HBa­ CTBeHHbIX H3Il enHH C'lHTaeTCH 'lTO OHH npHHaAl1e aT 06meCTBY a eTCK He'lTO 06mee Ka3aJIOCb 6bl HaUHOHaJIH3aUHK npOMbIllneHHO­ nOToMY 06meCTBO H3 eAHHOrO ueHTpa HanpaBnHeT Ha npelll1pHKTHH CTH 6aHKOB ToprOBnH H CHCTeMbI yCl1yr 1l 0l1 Ha YCTpaHHTb OCHOB­ cooTBeTCTBYlOIUHe Hoe npoTHBOpe'lHe COBpeMeHHbIX HHil YCTPHaJlbHbIX 06mecTB KorAa npe HlOlO npOH3BOll CTBO CTaHOBHTCK Bce 60l1ee KonneKTHBHbIM H B H3rOTOB­ Ha3Ha'lalOTCK 'lT06bI ocymeCTBl1KTb AHpeKTHBbI pellaH l10KaJlbHble AHpeKTHBbl To 'lTO npelll1pHKTHe COXpaHHJJO CTPYKTYpy npH3HaeTcK HecymeCTBeHHbIM Il HpeKTOpa l1eHHH Ka iJ Oro H31l el1HK y'laCTByeT Bce 60l1bllee KOl1H'leCTBO npo­ TeXHJ iqeCKHe np06l1eMbI H Ha6l1lOAaK 'lTo6bl npHKa3bI cBepxy Bbl­ H3BOAHTel1eH a l1bBHHaK 1l 0l1H Cpell CTB npOH3BOAcTBa ocraeTCH B py­ nOl1ID1l1HCb Kax MeHbllHHCTBa OIl HaKO KaK nOKa3bIBaeT OnbIT HaUHOHaJlH3a­ BeHHOH ll eKTel1bHOCTH KOTopbIe B COBeTcKoM C0103e npelll10IJHTalOT UHK - 3TO Bcero l1Hllb lOpH eCKaH Mepa ORa nHKBHAHPyeT 'laCTHbIX npell npHHHMaTel1eH HO HH'lerO He MeHHeT HH B npOH3BOIl ­ CTBeHHbIX OTHOlleHHKX HH B pa31l eneHHH TpYll a HH B HepapXHH KO­ TOPaK CKl1all bIBaeTCH B npouecce pa3ll el1eHHH TpYll a 11 nOCl1e HaUHO­ HallH3aUHH COXPaHKlOTCH B Ka'leCTBe 3KOHOMH'leCKHX eAHHHU OT­ ll el1bHbIe npell npHKTHK COXpaHHeTCK HX cTaTyc coxpaIDIeTCH Cl1e­ 1l 0BaTel1bHO H B3aHMOCBK3b Me iJ y HHMH 3TO 06cToKTenbcTBo 061 · HCHKeT nO'leMY H nocne HaUHOHallH3aUHH Ka Il Oe u3iJeIlUe Korll a OHO nepell aeTCK OT O l Horo npelll1pHKTHH K Il pyrOMY OCTaeTCK TOBa­ pOM MO HO KOHe'lHO yKpynHHTb npell npHKTHK no ll enaeTCH H B HeYKOCHHTel1bHO KpHTepHH oueHKH l11060H X03HHCT­ Ha3bIBaTb noKa3aTenHMH npeAITOl1aralOT nHIIlb 6YKBal1bHOe cne· AOBaHHe nOl1yqeHHbiM cBepxy npHKa3aM TYT caMH C06010 HanpallIHBalOTcH ABa Bonpoca 1 B03MO H0 l1H PYKOBOAHTb BceMH npeAnpHKTIUIMH H3 O l Horo ueHTpa 2 11 ecnH B03MO HO npaBOMOIJHO J1M CqHTaTb nOT ueHIp Bblpa­ 3HTeneM BonH Bcero 06meCTBa HaKonneHHbIH omIT n03BonKeT OTBeTHTb 'lTO UeHTpaJlH30BaHHoe ynpaBneHHe X03KikTBOM ocymeCTBHMO HO npH 3TOM npHXOAHTCH pac­ nna'lHBaTbCH HenpOH3BOAHTenbHblMH paCTpaTaMH 3KOHOMHIJeCKOii KanHTallHCTH'leCKHX CTPaHax IIpH nOM YMeHbllaeTCH HX KOnH'le· 3HeprHH H CTBO HO COUHaJIbHO-3KOHOMH'leCKOe Ka'leCTBO OCTaeTCK HeH3MeH­ peKTopOB npeAnpHKTHH H OTBeTCTBeHHbIX pa60THHKOB Ha Bcex cry­ 68 HeHCTpe6HMbiM OIJKOBTHpaTel1bCTBOM co CTOpOHbI AH­ 69 rreHHX yrrpaBneHqeCKOrO arrrrapaTa ITpH nOM MorYT 6bITb Aa e AO­ CTHrHYTbI BrreqaTmnOmHe pe3ynbTaTbI HO nHIIIb rrpH HanH'lHH orpOM­ HbIX TpYAOBbIX pe3epBOB H npH CTpOHTenbCTBe npe f e He cymecT­ BOBaBIIIeH TH enOH rrpoMbIumeHHOCTH TpYAHm HXCH rrpOCTO MO­ 6HnH3YIOT rronHOCTbIO rrpeHe6peraH KpHTepHHMH peHTa6enbHOCTH B TeopHH MapKca no Ha3bIBanOCb 3KCTeHCHBHbIM pa3BHTHeM Ha­ pOAHoro X03HHCTBa Ho KaK TonbKO nOT rrepBOHaqanbHbIH narr 3aBepIIIeH a pa3BHTHe He rrepeXOAHT B HHTeHCHBHoe KorAa rrOHBnHeTCH He06xOAHMOCTb rrOBbIIIIaTb TO eCTb peHTa6enbHOCTb Ha­ nHqHbIX cpeACTB rrpOH3BOACTBa KaK 6bI MeHHeTCH paKYpc H Bce rro­ pOKH IIeHTpanH30BaHHoro PYKOBOACTBa BbICTyrraIOT Hapy y cnyqHnocb B KOHIIe SO-x - qanCH KpH3HC rrnaHOBOH Haqane 60-x rOAOB TorAa-TO H Ha­ CHCTeMbI yrrpaBneHHH X03HHCTBOM Tor­ Aa-TO H 6bInH CAenaHbI rrOrrbITKH pe popM ITpe06naA aIO m aH B KarrH­ TanHCTHqeCKHX rOCYAapCTBax popMa c06CTBeHHOCTH KaK MbI ro­ BopHnH OTCTaeT OT pa3BHTHH rrpOH3B0 J 1UenbHbIX CHn KOTopbIe Bce 60nbIIIe 0606meCTBnHIOTCH B CBH3H C nHM B KarrHTanHCTHqeCKHX rOCYAapcTBax Ha6nIOAaIOTCH nepeMeHbI B yrrpaBneHHH KaK caMbIMH KpyrrHbIMH rrpeArrpHHTHHMH TaK H 60nee MenKHMH Ha CMeHY 6a­ pOHaM rrpOMbIIIIneHHOCTH rrpHxOAHT TeXHOKpaTbI Ho TaKoe 0606­ mecTBneHHe He AOCTHraeT ypOBHH rrpH KOTOPOM MO HO 6bInO 6bI 06pamaTbCH C OTAenbHbIMH rrpOH3BOACTBeHHbIMH eAHHHIIaMH KaK C IIexaMH OAHoro orpOMHoro rrpOH3BOACTBeHHoro rrpeArrpHHTHH yrr­ paBnHeMbIMH H3 eAHHoro IIeHTpa KnaCCH'leCKaH qaCTHaH c06CTBeH­ HOCTb KOHeqHO He rrocrreBaeT 3a HCTOpHqeCKHM pa3BHTHeM HO Ha­ IIHOHanH3aIIHH c06CTBeHHOCTH TO e 3Toro pa3BHTHH He orrepe aeL CTapoe rrpOTHBOpeqHe rrpOCTO BblBOpaqHBaeTCH HaH3HaHKY· 06 eCT- 8eHHaR co6cT8eHHocTb OTOJICOeCT8IlReTCR C eouHou i ocyoapcT8eH­ HOll co6cT8eHHocTblO MorYT KOHeqHO B03pa3HTb 'ITO rOCYAapCTBO rrpH COIIHanH3Me - no TO e HeqTO KaqeCTBeHHO HOBoe ITpe Ae OHO 3amHmano HHTepeCbI 6yp a3HH a rrpH COIIHanH3Me OHO 3amH­ maeT HHTepeCbI TpYAHmHXCH TaK BHaqane H AYManH HO 'ITO e rro­ nyqHnocb Ha Aene TYT MbI rrpHXOAHM KO BTOPOMY H3 Ha3BaHHbIX BorrpOCOB B COIIHanHCTHqeCKHX rOCYAapCTBax Ha OHH rrpOneTaPCKYIO AOKTPHlfY Pa3Be caMH KOMMYHHCTbI KOTopbIe ocymecTBnHIOT PYKOBOACTBO - He HaeMHbIe pa60'IHe 11 BCe e cymeCTBeHHo OTnHqaIOTCH OT ApyrHX HaeMHbIX pa60qHX KO 60nee BbICOKOH 3aprrnaToH H qHCnOM rrpHBHnerHH OHH H He Tonb­ l1x OTnH'lHe 3aKnIOqaeTCH B rrpHcBoeHHoM HMH rrpaBe cYBepeHHo paCrrOpH aTbCH rrpH6aBOqHOH CTOHMOCTbIO c03AaHHoH TpYAOM Bcex TpYA pa60qHX H APYTHX TpYAHmHXCH HerrpepbIBHo C03AaeT rrpH- meeCH 60raTcTBo HAeT B TaK Ha3bIBaeMbIH KonneKTHBHbIH POHA H3 KOToporo OrrnaqHBaIOTCH COIIHanbHbIe pacxoAbI KarrHTanOBnO e­ HHH BoeHHbIH 6IOA eT H LA ITocKonbKY HHKTO H3 rpa AaH rrpH­ 6bInH H3 Horo KonneKTHBHoro pOHAa He rronyqaeT Ka3anOCb 6bI H caMO yrroTpe6neHHe nora TepMHHa rrpH6bInb CBH3aHHoro C KarrHTanHCTHqeCKOH 3KcrrnyaTallHeH TYT COBepIIIeHHO HeYMeCTHO lleHcTBHTenbHocTb O l HaKO OKa3bIBaeTCH CnO Hee rrOCKonbKY Aa­ e rrpH OTCYTCTBHH HHAHBHAYanbHoro rrpHCBoeHHH rrpH6bInH pac­ rrpeAeneHHe AOXOAOB B COlIHanHCTHqeCKHX rOCYAapcTBax AaneKO He paBHoMepHo A no 3Ha'IHT 'ITO KaKaH-TO qaCTb rrpH6aBOqHOH CTOH­ MOCTH rrepepacrrpeAenHeTCH rrepeXOAH OT 0AHHX rpyrrrr HaceneHHH K APyrHM B OTnH'lHe OT KarrHTanH3Ma B COlIHanHCTHqeCKHX CTpa­ Hax TaKoe rrepepacrrpeAeneHHe ocymecTBnHeTCH He CTonbKO Ha ypOB­ He rrpeArrpHHTHH CKonbKO B 06meHapOAHOM HnH 06merOCYAapCT­ BeHHOM MaCIIITa6e B rrpHBHnerHpOBaHHOM rrOnO eHHH OKa3bIBaIOT­ CH He TonbKO PYHKIIHOHepbI rrapTHH HO H Te KTO rro 6narocnOBe­ HHIO rrapTHH OAapHIOTCH BbICOKOH 3aprrnaToH OBOpH TeOpeTHqeCKH 3TO rrpoTHBOpeqHe KaK H MHorHe ApyrHe rrpH cOIIHanH3Me rrpo­ CTO MacKHpyeTcH Pom MacKH HrpaeT rocYAapcTBo EouHaR HbIH IIeHTp BorrnOmaeT HHTepeCbI 06meCTBa KaK IIenoro Pa3Be BO rnaBe rOCYAapCTBa He CTOHT KOMrrapTHH Pa me He rrpOB03rnaIIIaIOT 6aBo'IHYIO CTOHMOCTb ITo MapKcHcTCKOH TeopHH 3TO HaKorrnHIO­ B COBeTCKOM COI03e H B 60nbIIIHHCTBe COIIHanHCTHqeCKHX CTpaH no rrOnO HTenbHO TaM 6e3ycnoBHo rrpH3HaIOT 'ITO BHOBb 06pa30BaH­ MO HO 6bInO 6bI A06HTbCH qT06bI HepaBeHCTBO 3aprrnaT COOTBeT­ CTBOBano p33nH'lHHM TpYAa Ho Bo-rrepBbIX B KaqeCTBe H HHTeHCHBHOCTH 3aTpaqeHHOrO BpHA nH MO HO TOqHO H3MepHTb HMeeT nH rrpaBO AorrYCTHM HH eHep TOH HnH HHOH KBanH pHKaIlHH Ha B03Harpa AeHHe KOTopoe B ABa TpH HnH AeCHTb pa3 rrpeBbIIIIano 6bI 3aprrnaTY HeKBanH pHlIHpOBaHHoro pa60qero BO-BTOPbIX oqe­ BH l HO 'ITO 60nbIIIaH qaCTb rrpHBlUIerHH Tex HnH HHbIX COlIHanbHbIX rpyrrrr 06ycnoBnHBaeTCH rrOnHTHqeCKHMH KpHTepHHMH HnH CnO HB­ IIIHMCH B rOCYAapCTBe COOTHOIIIeHHeM CHn HOT Bonpoc OTBeqaIOT CTPax rrepeA rronHIIeHCKHMH perrpeCCHHMH KaK H HeYCbIIIHbIH KOHTponb HaA HaceneHHeM CO CTOPOHbI rrapTHH rrperrHTcTByeT pa60­ 70 71 4eMY Knaccy OTKPbITO BbICTYIIMTb rrpOHIB YCTaHOBneHllli KOTOpble C03AaHbI ero rOCYAapCTBOM OT ero HMeHli Ho KaK TOnbKO KOHTpOnb H CTpax cna6elOT BCrrbIXHBalOT 3a6aCTOBKH H 6YHTbI 0 4eM CBM JJ eTenbCTBYIOT rrOnbCKHe C06bITHH H BCrrbIllIKH HeAoBonbCT­ Ba B KHTae BpeMeH KYnhTYPHOH peBonIOUHH OCYAapCTBO OKa3bIBaeTCH C06CT8eH H WWM cpeACTB rrpOH3BOA­ CTBa HO rreperropY4aeT yrrpaBlleHHe HMH orrpeAeneHHoH COUHallbHOH rpyrrrre TaHHoe CTaHOBHTCH HBHbIM IIpeBpaTHTb 06meCTBeHHYIO c06CTBeHHOCTb B c06CTBeHHOCTb Bcero 06meCTBa OKa3allOCb HeB03­ MO KHbIM 06meCTBeHHOH c06CTBeHHOCTbIO OHa CTaHOBHTCH 4epe3 nocpeOCT80 cocyoapcTI3a OHa rrorraAaeT B PYKH arrrrapaTa yrrpaBlle­ HHH H 1l0AaBneHHH KOTOPbIH BeKaMH 6bI1l opy J HeM rocrrOACTBYIO­ mHX KnaCCOB a B HOBblX YCllOBHHX crroc06CTByeT pOpMHposaHHIO HOBoro rrpaBHmero cnOH OCYAapCTBeHHaH 6yp Kya3HH CnO KHnaCB He TOllbKO B CCCP HO H B HeKOTopblX rOCYAapCTBax TpeTbero MHpa me CTall AOMHHHpOBaTb 06meCTBeHHblH ceKTOp 11 B 3THX CTpaHax COBepllIeHHO TaK Ke HHCTpYMeHTOM 0606meCTBneHHH CTaHOBHTCH OAHa rrapTlIH rrYCTb H He KOMMyHHcTH4eCKaH 113 CKa3aHHoro cneAyeT 4TO pe4b HAeT He 0 KaKOM-TO crreUH p H ­ 4eCKOM HBlleHHH KOTopoe MO KHO 06bHCHHTb OC06bIMH HaUHO­ HallbHbIMH 06CTOHTellbCTBaMH a 0 3aKOHOMepHOCTH KOTopaH rrpo­ HBnHeTCH rrOBCIOAY rAe COUHallH3auHH rrpOBOAlnCH rryTeM ueHTpa­ llH3auHJ 1 11 HeT HHKaKHX oCHoBaHHH paCC4HTbIBaTb 4TO B TOH HllH HHOH popMe TO Ke HBlleHHe He B03HHKHeT B HTore HaUHOHanH3aruIH rrpOMblllIneHHOCTH B CTpaHax 3arraAa HarnH J HblH TOMY rrpHMep Ky6a IIOClle CBep KeHHH D lTHCTbI TaM 6blll0 HeCKonbKO rrapnrH a HOBoe rrpaBHTenbCTBO Aa Ke He Ha­ 3bIBallO ce6H cOUHanHCTH4eCKHM Ho KaK TonbKO Ky6HHUbI rro pe­ llIeHHIO ¢lHAenH KaCTpo H qe eBapbI BCTyrrHllH Ha rryTh couHanH3­ Ma H rrpHHHllHCb ero CTPOHTb rrOA 3HaMeHeM ueHTpallH3aUHH B rrpOMbIlJmeHHOCTH H MHllHTapH3aUHH CYAb6a cTpaHbI 6bllla pellIeHa B cenbCKOM X03HHCTBe Ky6HHCKHH 3KcrrepHMeHT HeH36e K­ HO AOn KeH 6bI1l rrpHBeCTH K C03AaHHIO rOCYAapcTBa cOBeTcKoro TH­ rra TaKoro pOAa CHCTeMbI xapaKTepH3YlOTCH rrpOTlIBOpe4HHMH H KpH3HcaMH OAHaKO HOBbie rrpaBHmHe CllOH HayqHllHcb HX rrOAaB­ llHTb C O J HOH CTOpOHbI OHH rrpH6eralOT K perrpeCCHHM a C APyroH CTOpOHbI HAYT Ha KOMIlPOMHCCbI H yCTyrrKH 4TO Ha orrpeAelleHHOM narre rr03BonHeT CTHMynHpOBaTb TeMrrbI 3KOHoMH4eCKoro pa3BH­ THH 72 CaMoH HacymHOH 11H CTpaH COBeTCKoro THrra CTana rrp06neMa TeXHOKpaTHH TeXHH4eCKHX KaApOB KOTopble BO HHKaIOT KaK ClleA­ CTBHe HH yCTpHamI3aUIIH qT06bl rrpHBne4b HX Ha CBOIO CTOpOHy KOMMYHHCTH4eCKHe rrapTHH 06ecrre4HBalOT HM rroTpe6neHHe rro Ka­ IlHTallHCTH4eCKOH MOAenH KBapTHpy Aaqy MallIHHbI TaKaH rrOllH­ THKa KOMMYHHCTH4eCKHX rrapTHH ycrroKaHBaeT arraAHbIX 6YP KYa H Te Ha4HHalOT AenaTh KarrHTallOBll0 KeHHH B COUHallHCTH4eCKHX ro­ CYAapcTBax Ho Ta Ke rroTpe6HTellbCKaH rrOnHTHKa KOMMYHHCTH4e­ CKHX rrapTHH BHOCHT 3aMellIaTenbCTBO B pHAbl CTOPOHHHKOB cOUHa­ llH3Ma Ha 3arraAe KOTopble Ha4HHalOT Bce 6011ee KpHTlt4ecKH OTHO­ CHTbCH K ueHTpallH30BaHHbIM H aBTopHTapHbIM popMaM yrrpaBlle­ HHH Ho KaK H36e KaTb TaKHX pOpM B03MO KHO nH 1l0CTPOHTb corum­ nH3M ApyrHM rrYTeM CTOPOHHHKH COUHallH3Ma AOll KHbI pellIHTb B03MO KHbI llH Bo06­ me B rrpHHUHrre ApyrHe OTllH4Hbre OT cOBeTCKoro pOPMbI cOUHa­ nH3Ma B03MO KHbl llH ApyrHe CTpyKTYPbI KOllneKTHBHoH c06CTBeH­ HOCTH KOTopble OTnH4allHCb 6bI OT rocy apCTBeHHOH pOPMbI c06­ CTBeHHoCTH CTOPOHHHKH COUHallH3Ma Ol1 KHbI pellIHTb HaCKonbKO oTAenbHbIe CllOH 06mecTBa pa604He TeXHH4eCKHe KaApbI HHTen­ llHreHUHH MenKHe 4aCTHble co6cTBeHHHKH H KpeCTbflue crroc06ubI rrpoTHBOCTOHTb 6IOpOKpaTHH llBa COUHallHCTH4eCKHX rocyll apcTBa rrOrrbITallHCb 4TO-TO Cll enaTh B nOM HarrpaBlleHlIH JOrOCllaBHH KO­ TopaH BBella CHCTeMY caMoyrrpaBneHHH Ha rrpenrrpHHTHHX H KHTaH rll e 6bI1lH C03ll aHbI Hapo Hble KOMMYHbI 11 B ll PYrHX rocyll apcTBax BpeMS OT BpeMeHH CllbImaTCH rrpH3bIBbI K rrepeopHeHTaUHH Ha CTpoHTellbcTBo COUHallH3Ma CHH3Y ll ellalOTCH rrOrrbITKH orrepeTb­ CH Ha HHHUHaTHBY Macc Ho H Te KTO BbICTyrraeT C TaKHMH rrpH3bI­ BaMH He KenaeT OTKa3aTbCH OT BnaCTH OHH rrpOll Ol1 KaIOT KOHT­ ponHpOBaTb HHHUHaTHBY OHH HpeKTHBHO HaBH3bIBalOT ll a Ke pe­ pOPMbI He rr03BonHH KpHTHKaM H orrrrOHeHTaM BbIXOll HTb 3a CTpO­ ro orrpe eneHHble rpaHHUbI C pOpMHpOBaHHoe CTallHUH3MOM MblllmeHHe HbIHellIHHX pyKO­ BO HTelleH COUHallHcm4eCKHX rOCYAapCTB He MHPHTCH C B03MO K­ HOCTblO CTonKHOBeHHH pa311H4HbIX rrOnHTH4eCKHX rrporpaMM llnH HHX cymecTByeT llHllIb OAHa reuepallbHaH llHHHfl a Bce OCTallbHoe YKnOHbI 73