CrrpasC TIHBOCTH pa l H CllCAYCT OTMeTHTb 'ITO B ITollbwe B03HHK­ 30eHeK reil3nap rrH '1PC3BbI'IaHHhIe npC nOCbIIlKH TIH OCymCCTBTIeHI1H CMOKpaTIi­ '1CCKHX pe$opM HO BCe lKe He 60JIce 6JlarOnpHHTHhle '1eM B qexo­ CllOBaKHH KOHl a 60-x rO OB B qexOCTIOBaKHH y allOCb 0611TbCH nepeCTaHOBKH Cl1rr BHyTpH npasHmeH napTHl1 H JTOT $aKT TPY HO nepeOl eHHTb C TO'lKH 3peHl1H nOJlhCKME COEbITM M nPA I CKA DECHA npOl eCca pe$opM Pa3BHTHe C06bl­ THM H B ITOTIbI11C H B qcxoclIoBaKHH 6blIl0 06YCllOBrrCHO HX OC06CH­ HOCTHMH H Me l YHapO HblM nOllOlKeHHCM B aHHblM MOMeHT ny­ TH HX He 6bmH 1136paHbl C03HaTCllbHO 06a nyTH npHBCTIH K Ha'laTIY CymccTByeT MHeHHC 'ITO BalKHeMmee 3Ha'lCHHe nOJJbCKHX C06hl­ npol ccca ncpcMcH HO HH O HH H3 Hl1X HC Mor rapaHTHpoBaTb HH THH B TOM 'ITO Onl1 CmC pa3 OKa3aTIH HCB03MOlKHOCTb OKOHlJa­ 6ccKoH$rrHKTHoe pa3BHTHC pe$opM HH TO 'ITO JTH pC$OpMbI y aCT­ TCrrhHO pC$OpMl1pOBaTh eMOKpaT113HpOBaTb 11 nalKC rrpOCTO c e­ CH 3amHTlfTb qexocllOBal KHH npOl eCC B03POlKJ CHHH npenHTCTBO­ TIaTh 60rrcc '1CTIOBC'IHbIMH nOCTICCTallHHCKHe PClKHMbI COBCTCKoro nma Ho BC b pC Ib He HnCT H HHKOrna HC Wlla 0 OKOH'IarCJIbHO TOM '1T06bl pC$OpMHpOBaTb H CMOKpaTH3HpOBaTb PC$OpMbl KaK nyT lI1 11 PCBOJIIOl HH He l Cllb a CPC CTBO D CTpaHax lKC TaK BaTI '1pC3MepHOM nOTIHpH3al HH 06meCTBa HeHTpallH3YH TeM caMbIM KpaMHHC pa HKaTIbl blC CHIlbI I1MCHHO HOJTOMY OH 6blIl JaAYweH l1HTCpBeHUHCH H3BHC TeM llCr'le 6bIllO HOPMaTIH30BaTb '1CXOCIIO­ Bal KOC 06meCTBO nOCKOTIbKY nOllHTH'ICCKHM KpH3HC He conpOBOlK­ Ha3bIBaCMoro pCaJIbHOrO COl Hall113Ma OC06CHHO BalKHO BbHlCHl1Tb allCH npl1 rrOMOml1 KaKHX cpe 'CTB B aHHbIX MClK YHapo HbIX COl HaJIb­ CTaHOBJIeHHC HCKJIIO'IHTCJIbHO 6bICTPO HblX 11 BHYTpl1rrOllI1TH'IeCKHX YCJIOBHllX MOlKHO 6C3 HaCl1llHH 11 KaTa­ fIlIIOPaTIH3M B '1aCTHOCTl1 HC3aBHCHMOC npo$COlO3Hoe 06bC HHeHHC CTpO$ Ha'laTb npOl CCC npeO OllCHHH Hc eMoKpaTH'ICCKl1X $OpM 06­ mecTBcHHOH lK113Hl1 D YCllOBl1HX PClKHMOB COBCTCKoro THna TOllb­ KO pOMaHTl1KH MoryT Me'lTaTb 0 rrpbIlKKc H306HllHll - B I apcTBo cBo6o 'hl Ii OpHeHTHpOBKa na pC$OpMbI HCCMOTPH Ha BCC nopa­ lKeHHll pcdmPMHcToB 0 Cl1X nop OCTaeTCH C HHCTBCHHO pcanhHoH BbICOKOM COl HaTIbHOH HanpHlKCHHOCTblO ITOTIbCKOe BOC­ HHCTHTYl HOHaTIH3I1pOBaTIO Olll1 apHOCTb 3TO 6bIJIO Belll1KOTICnHO HO 'OCTHrHyTbIe rrepCMC­ HbI HI1'ICM HC 6bIlll1 3awHmeHb B ITOTIbWC HC np0I130I11TIO H$$C­ pCHl Hal HH H HCHTpaTII13al Hli annapaTOB BllaCTH a nOTOMY OKa3aTI­ CH B03MOlKHbIM H KOHTpy ap BHyTpClU HX CHll 3TOMY cnoc06CTBO­ BallH Ii JKOHOMH'IeCKI1H xaoc H COl HaTIbHaH HanpHlKCHHOCTb B pc­ 3YllbTaTC '1cro yCllOBHH B ITOJIbWe OKa3aJIHCb 60llce crrOlKHbIMH '1CM B 4CXOCllOBaKHH ncpl1o a ITpalKcKoH BeCHb D TO lKC BpCMH O'leBH HO 'ITO npOTaTIKHBaHHC pC$OpM l1X 3a­ mHTa H 'aTIbHCHWee pa3BHTHC rrpO OTIlKalOT OCTaBaTbCH CIIOlKHCH­ weM rrOIIHTI1'ICCKOH np06llCMOH Hawero BpCMCHH DOTICC Toro 0­ 6liTbCH npH3HaHHH Hc06x0 U1MOCTH pC$OpM MOlKHO TorrbKO B KpH­ 3HCHOM cHTyal HH H npl1 HaTIl1'1l1H aBlleHHH Macc A KP11311Cbl 6Y YT co BPCMCHCM BCC '1amc 11 rny6lKe XOTH B YCJlOBl1HX KalK oro KOH­ KpCTHOrO Kp113HCa $opMyrrl1pOBKH oTpalKalOmHC HC OBOllbCTBO Ha­ CCllCHHH 6YAYT 3BY'laTb no-pa3HoMy MOlKHO TaKlKC YTBcplK aTb 'ITO H B 6y ymcM waHCbl na ycnex pe$opM 6Y YT rrOCTaBTICHhl no yrp03y HH K '1CMY HC BC 'ymHMH panHKallbllbIMH BblcTyrrrrcHHHMH BCCM H3BCCTHO 'ITO B03MOlKBOCTH CHCTeMHblX ncpCMCH B CTpa­ Hax pcallbHoro COl HallI13Ma BCCbMa OrpaHH'ICHbI COBeTCKHM rere­ MOHH3MOM BceM TaK I e H3BCCTHO XOTH B JMOUHOHaTIbHOM B03­ 6YlK 'CHHH HeKoTopble 06 JTOM 3a6bIBa1OT 'ITO no npcnHTCTBl1C aTaKOH CMeCTl1 HCB03MOlKHO ••• D 6YAYmeM nOllOlKe­ HHe pa3YMCCTCH MO l CT H3MCHHTbCH HO TOllbKO HpH cyll ecTBeHHblX nepCMCHax BCCH Me l l YHapO 'HOH 06CTaHOBKH IToclle oKKynaUHH 4eXOCTIOBaKHH Ka3allOCh 'ITO MOCKBa H B 6y­ ymeM f10 aBI1T MaTIeHIlIl1e rrOTIbITKH CTpaH BOCTO'lnOM EBpOIlbI rrpo­ OTPhlBKH H3 naTbH IlOJlHbl1 TeKCT KOTOPOI HallC4aTaH B 1KypHaJle Listy 138 NQ 5 3a 1982 r BO HTb rrOJIHTHKy 60llee COOTBeTCTBYlOmylO HX HHTepecaM H 'ITO B 139 JIHX CTpaIIaX Henb3H 6YAeT A06HTbCH HHKaKHX nepeMeH K nyqlIIe­ UHH 6bIIIa 6bI HeH36e I HOH BnaCTH l e HanpOTHB BenHKonenHO BO­ MY nOKa He H3MeHHTCH nonHTHKa caMOH MOCKBbI opY I eHbI I1CXO J f H3 JIoro He CneAOBaIIO 060nbmaTbCH Hnn103H­ OAHaKO HeKO­ Topble C06bITHH 70-x rOAOB YKa3anH Ha HaIIHqHe APYrHX B03MO l HO­ CTeH YCTynaH Me l YHapOAHOMY H flMH 0 cna60CTH npaBHTenbCTBa a O I HAaTb YAapa HMeHHO OT Hero 3KOHOMHqeCKOMY AaBneHHIO MOCKBa CTana 60nee TepnHMOH K TaKHM HBneHHHM B cTpaHax Bo­ CTOqHOH EBponbI KOTopble B nepHOA CTanHHCKOH rOMoreHH3a­ He YAHBHTenbHo qTO nonHKH TaK wm 6bIIIH npOCTO HeMbICnHMbI • HaAe l Aa nonbCKoro BOCCTaHOBneHHH 80-x rOAOB 3aKnlOqanaCb nlOTHoH cB060Ae 3TO npaBo Bcex Hapo oB MHpa Ho B IIonblIIe KaK B TOM qTO oc06eHHOCTH nonbCKO-COBeTCKHX OTHOlIIeHHH C03AaBanH H B APyrHx cTpaHax nonHTHKa - 60IIblIIHH npocTOp AIIH nepeMeH qeM KorAa 6bI TO HH 6bIIIO B APY­ HCKYCCTBO B03MO l HOro rHX CTPaHax BOCTOqHOH EBponbi MO l HO 6bIIIO O I HAaTh - lIIe CBHAeTenbCTBYIOT 0 no H AeMO­ OTKPbITO cTpeMHnHCb K a6co­ 3TO He ocymecTBneHHe MeqTbI a C TaKOH TOqKI1 3peHHH C06bITHH B IIonb­ cna60CTflX CTOPOHHHKOB rrepeMeH H 3TH qTO cna60CTH BepOHTHO npHcymH 3MaHCHnaIIHOHHbIM npOIIeccaM H B HMeHHO B IIonblIIe MOCKBa AonYCTHT TaKHe nepeMeHbI KOTopble B APYrHX BOCTOqHOeBpOneHCKHX rOCYAapCTBax lIacTO rOBopHT 0 pa3­ APYrHe BpeMeHa H B APyrHX CTPaHax OHa l eCTOKO nOAaBnHna 3Ha­ nHqHH nOnHTHqeCKHX KynbTYp CTpaH BOCTOqHOH EBponbI H CO BeT­ KpaTlfqeCKaH onn03HIIHH B IIonblIIe Ha paCcqHTblBana - qeHHe TaKoro pa3BHTHH AIIH nOCTeneHHOH nepeMeHbI nOnHTHqeCKOH CKOH OAHaKO CeHqaC Y I e H B CTpaHax BOCTOqHOH EBponbI 3HaqH­ 06CTaHOBKH BO BceM COBeTCKOM 6nOKe TPYAHO 6bIIIO nepeOIIe­ TenbHYIO qaCTb HaceneHHH COCTaBnHIOT nlO H BblpOClIIHe B ycnoBHHX Ho qT06bI Hcnonb30BaTh B03HHKlIIHe B IIonblIIe B03MO l HOCTH rOBopOB AOCTH I eHHIO KOMnpOMHCCOB Me l AY pa3nHqHbIMH HHTe­ AHKTaTypbI He HMeBlIIHe B03MO I HOCTH HayqHTbCH HCKYCCTBY nepe­ HHTb HY l HO 6bIIIO HH B KoeM cnyqae He AonYCKaTh aHTHCOBeTH3Ma HY I ­ pecaMH H B3rnHAaMH II03TOMY KorAa B nepe l HBalOmeH KPH3HC HO 6bIIIO TaK I e BocnpenHTCTBOBaTh TpaHc popMaIIHH BHYTpHnonH­ ocna6eBlIIeH TOTanHTapHoH CHCTeMe B03HHKalOT He3aBHCHMble op­ TlfqeCKHX KOH pnHKTOB B 60Pb6y 3a BnaCTb cneAOBano HATH no ny­ raHH3aIIHH OHH npoTHB BonH CBOHX PYKoBOAHTeneH npeBpamalOTCH TH KOMnpOMHCCOB H nOCTeneHHoro npe06pa30BaHHH a He CTpeMHTb­ B onno3HIIHoHHYlO cHny BCTynalOmylO B 60Pb6y 3a BnaCTh Ho AnH TaKOH n06eAbI HeT He06xoAHMbIX ycnoBHH OqeHb Ba l HO qT06bI CH K nHKBHAaIIHH cymeCTBYlOmeH CHCTeMbI He3aBHCHMble CHnbI B CTpaHe ecnH OHH oTBepralOT BoopY l eHHoe CTonKHOBeHHe npH3HanH B03MO l HOCTb pe p0pM H KOMnpoMHCCOB H TonbKO B TaKOM cnyqae OHH cMorYT 60nee 3 p peKTHBHo CAep l H­ IIpH oIIeHKe nonbCKHX C06bITHH Ha 3anaAe H B caMoH IIoIIblIIe qa­ BaTh paAHKaIIbHble HaCTpoeHHH lIIHpOKHX Macc CTO rOBopHT 0 peBonlOIIHH MH HCXOAH H3 TonKOBaHHH AAaMa MHX­ HHKa HIIeKa KYPOHH H APyrHX 06 OrpaHHqeHHOH peBonIOIIHH Ho OIIeHHBaH TaKHM 06paJOM C06bITHH B IIonblIIe cneAyeT nOM­ HHTb 0 3aKoHoMepHocTHX peBonlOIIHH I1cTopHH Yql T qTO KaK Tonb­ IIoIIbcKHe C06bITHH 1980-1981 rr pa3BHBanHcb B 3HaqHTeIIbHOH KO peBonlOIIHH AOCTHrHeT MepTBoH TOqKH I e MOMeHTa KorAa CTeneHH nOA BnHHHHeM TeopHH napannenbHblx CTPYKTYP •• B co­ MHpHbIMH cpeAcTBaMH Y I e HeB03MO l HO 3aCTaBHTb BnaCTh HATH Ha OTBeTCTBHH C noil TeopHeH peBH3HoHH3M H pe p0pMH3M nocne yCTynKH a BnaCTh Y l e He MO l eT MHpHbIMH cpeACTBaMH Bocnpe­ rrOpJ l eHHH nonbCKoro OKTH6pH IIHTCTBOBaTh THiI 1968 r 06aHKpOTHncH H HHqerO xopolIIero OT npaBHmHX KOM­ AaIIbHeHlIIeH paAHKanH3allHH HapOAHbIX Macc 3Ta 1956 r H qeXOCnOBaIIKHX C06bI­ MepTBaH TOqKa npeOAoneBaeTCH npHMeHeHHeM CHnbI B IIonblIIe MYHHCTlfqeCKHX napTHH l AaTb He npHXOAHTCH OCB060 HTenbHoe paAHKaIIbHOe npOTHBOpeqHBOe H Bce-TaKH HeAOCTaTOqHO opraHH­ ABH I eHHe Aon I Ho POpMHpOBaTbCH BHe napTHH H CHCTeMbI KaK He­ 30BaHHOe HapOAHoe ABlf I eHHe 6bIIIO 6e30pY I HbIM H He XOTeno 6paTbCH 3a opY l He nOCKonbKY B nOM cnyqae COBeTCKaH HHTepBeH- 140 3aBHCHMaH cHna H eMY He3aqeM HCKaTb COlO3HHKOB B o pHIIHanbHblx Kpyrax Ha pe l HM cneAyeT rrOCTOHHHO l aBHTb H TonbKO no AaBne­ 141 HHC MOIKCT 3aCTaBHTb BrraCTH rrOHTH Ha pe j OpMbI Borree pa UIKarrb­ CKOH CHCTeMbl HO H 6e3 nepeCTpOHKH MOIKHO pelllHTb HCKOTopble HbIH BapHaHT nOH TeOpHH rrpCnrrOrraraCT qTO TaKOe naBJICHHC YTO HaCYllIHbIC npo6neMbI HanpHMCp np06rreMY cHa6IKCHHH HarrpoTHB MHT PCIKHM C lJ cnaCT cro 6ccrrOMOllIHbIM H B PC3YJIbTaTC OH 6Y lJ eT Morrro CIIyqHTbCH qTO HC onpo6HpOBaHHbIe HHCTHTYTbI B03HHKlllHC 3aMCHCH HHbIM rrpHqCM 06 3TOM HHOM rOBopHTCH rrHllIb B 0611IHX B pC3yrrbTaTe panHKarrbHbIX nepCMeH He cpa3Y CTaHYT j YHKIIHOHH­ qCpTaX - pOBaTb 3 j j CKTHBHO a B03MOIKHO BHaqarrC OHH 6bIJIH 6bl xYIKe qTO OH 6yncT rr11 OpaIlHCTHqeCKHM H rrpH3HacT 0611IeCTBeH­ HOC caMoyrrpaBrrCHHC CTapbIX H 310 MOrJIO 6bl CKOMIIPOMCTHpOBaTb HX B rna3ax 0611IeCT­ 3TY TCOpHlO rropOIJ Hrra 06CTaHOBKa 70-x rOnOB KOma orrrro m­ BCHHOCTH ellIC no Toro KaK OHH CBOlO nCHTcrrbHOCTb HarraMT no­ UHOHHble CHIIbI BCCX CTpaH COBCTCKoro 6JIOKa j OpMHpOBarrH CBOH 310MY ucrrccoo6pa3HbI 6bIJIH H BpeMCHHble qaCTHbIC MeponpHHTHH n03HUHH OHa 6C3YJIOCHO cnoc06CTBOBarra B03HHKHOBeHHIO Co­ B ocyllICCTBJICHHH KOTOPblX COJIHnapHOCTH CJIenOBarrO npHHHTb I1HnapHOCTH H npyrHx He3aBHCHMbIX nOIlbCKl1X opraHH3aUHH yqacTHe OnHaKO nocIIc B03HHKHOBeHHH COJIHnapHOCTH nJIH narrbHCH­ lllcro pa3BHTHH nCMOKpaTHqeCKHX pe j opM Tpc60BarrOCb cOTpynHH­ qeCTBO naparrncnbHblx CTpyKTyp C PC j opMHCTaMH B npaBHllICH rrap­ THH H YKpcmlcHHc HX n03HUHH Ho no TeopHH napaJIrrCJIbHbIX ' nHCKYCCHH 06 OlllH6Kax rrOJIbCKOrO nCMOKpaTHqeCKOrO lJ BHIKe· CTPYKTYP HC3aBHCHMbIC HapOnHble nBHIKCHHH He MoryT HMCTb HH­ HHH 1980-1981 rr He06xonHMa rrocKorrbKY 3TO nOMOIKeT TCM KTO qero 0611Icro C KOMMYHHCTaMH B TaKOH 06CTaHOBKc KOMMYHHCTbI­ B 6ynyrucM OKalKeTCH ncpen pCllleHHcM aHaJIOrH'IHbIX np06neM PC j OPMHCTbI 60ncc paIJ HKarrbHOro TonKa BbIIIIJIH H3 napTHH a 60­ Onn03HUHoHHbIC CHJIbI B CTPaHax BOCTOqHOH EBponb pa3pa6OTaB­ nce YMCPCHHbIC nCpeCTaJIH nOMcplKHBaTb He3aBHCHMbIC nBHIKeHHH lllHe CTpaTerHlo H TaKTHKY KOTOPbIC COOTBeTCTBOBarrH YCJIOBHHM T e n03HUHH KOMMYHHCTOB-PC j OPMHCTOB HC TOJIbKO He YKpenH­ 70 x rOnOB nOJIIKHbI 6YAYT MHoroc 3a6bITb H MHoroe BcnOMHHTb naCb a HanpOTHB B napTHH YCHJIHnOCb BnHHHHC KOHccpBaTHBHbIX 3rreMCHTOB ' Bonee Toro TeopHH ' naparrnCJIbHblX CTPYKTYP oTBepralOllIaH KaKoc·llH60 cOTpynHMqCCTBO C PCIKHMOM nOMClllaJIa onpCnerrHTb MOMeHT Korna H3-3a OTCYTCTBHH TaKoro cOTpyAHHqeCTBa He3aBH­ CHMoe nBHIKeHHC YTpaTHJIO BnHHHHC Ha pa3BHTHe C06bITHH Clla6b1e H HeHHcTHTyUHoHarrH3HpoBaHHblc nBHIKeHHH npoTccTa cymecTBo­ BaBlllHe no 1980 r MOrJIH n03BOJHlTb ce6e TaKYlO He3aBHCHMOCTb KOTOPaH K TOMY IKe HX 3allIHllIalla 310 OTHOClfTCH H K XapTHH 77 B qexOCJIOBaKHH Ho TaKaH opraHH3aUHH KaK MHJIllHOHHaH COJIH­ napHOCTb HC lJ OJIlKHa 6bIJIa HrHopHpOBaTb peIKHM••• YqlfTblBaH rophKHH OnbIT npollllloro MOIKHO nOHHTb nOqeMY CollHnapHOCTb OTKa3b1BarraCh 6paTh Ha ce6H OTBCTCTBeHHOCTh 3a KaKHe-rrH60 MeporrpHHTHH 6C3 CTPYKTypHblX ncpeMcH B 3KOHOMH­ Ke Ho H B 3TOM CoJIHnapHOcTh OKa3arraCh IKCPTBOH CBOHX HJIJllO­ 3HH HCT COMHCHHH qTO nOllbcKYlO H He TOJIbKO nOJIhCKYro 3KOHO­ MHKY MOIKeT cnaCTH JIHIlIb paIJ HKarrhHaH nepeCTpOHKa 3KOHOMHqe­ 142 143