I1pHMe'I8HH1I HAQI10HAJIbHA H I1POEJIEMA Wall Street Journal Oct 13 1982 panI'UUl eK CU lI U fKUU '2 NIN Beograd July 11 1982 3 Borba Beograd July 1 1982 4 Wall Street Journal Oct 2 1982 5 Saarbruckcn Zeitung July 24 La Quotidinne de Paris Aug 13 1981 Die Zeit May 7 1982 Yugoslavia freedom to Conform 6 lOrocnaBHH - K 60-neTHIO OEPA30BAHI1 H CCCP TOJlbKO nCpe HTblH OUblT MO CT 3aCTaBHTb MaCCbI YBH o eTb npaB o y H CB06o 'a nocnylllaHHll Helsinki Watch Committee paCCTanCll co CTaBmHMH 'lepeC'lyp 1982 p 27 onaCHblMH HJInI03HllMH 7 B C60pHl KC Demokracke rcforrnc nOUJl OH 1982 8 Danas 3arpe6 9 HOH6pll 1982 r ryall8 le EOI I1cHxonOrHll TOJlnbI TPH PCBOJlIOIl HH IlPOH3011InH B POCCHH B nepBblC o Ba o eCllTHne­ THll HamCrO BeKa H B Ka o OH H3 HHX npOllBHnCH KOHcpnHKT Me y ueHTpaJIbHOii BJlaCTbIO H HepYCCKHMH Hapo o aMH I1cpBall peBOJlIOUHH 6bma nO o aBJlCHHblM 6YHTOM BTOpall 3aBepmHnaCb nOnbITKOH y­ TaHOBHTb ACMOKpaTH'IeCKOe H Il JIOpanHCTH'lCCKOC 06weCTBO Ho cll e o 'J pellleHHH HOM 3a o a'lH Ua'lanaCb TPCTbll peBonIOUHH - 60nb­ meBHCTCKaH BblABHHYBlllaH nerKO YCBaHBaeMblC H nonynHpHble B MaCCaX n03YHfH 3Ta peBOJIIOUHH nopO HJIa rpa J aHCKYIO BOMHY npHBeJIa K YHH'ITO eHHIO CTapblX H CTpOHTeJIbCTBY HOBbIX CTPYKTYP BOCCTaHOBJIeHHIO TeppHTopHH pacnaBUlCMCH 6bJJ10 HMlICpHH AKTHBHble COCTaBJIHIOWHe BCCX nHX peBOJIIOUHM - HaUHOHaJIb­ Hble o BH eHHH HCpYCCKHX HaUHM 3a HaUHOHaJIbHble H rpa o aHCKHC npaBa B TpeTbeM PCBOJIIOUI IH 6blJlH naUHcpHUHpOBaHbl H o eCH a6­ CTpaKTHorO uponeTapCKOro HHTepHaIl HOHaJIH3Ma 11 He CJIY'IaHHO 'ITO C nepBoro MOMCHTa npHxo o a 60JlbWeBHKOB K BJIaCHI nonHTHKH H HCTOPHKH He nepecraIOT 3a o aBarbCH BonpOCOM KaK e HeMHoro­ '1HcneHHoii rpynue pa o HKanOB y o aJlOCb He TOJlbKO npHiiTH K BnaCTH HO H YAep aTb ec KaK y o anOCb HM opraHH30BaTb 3KOHOMH'lCCKYIO H3Hb CTpaHbl B COOTBCTCTBHH C co6crBeHHoii H o eOJIOrHeH H KaK 154 155 Y I aJI0Cb HM B BeCbMa KOPOTI Hll CpOK peCTaBpHpOBaTb 'THTeHbKHHbI CbIHKH' lIOJIyqHB MHJInHOH Ha'lHHalOT pa30pa­ II HOHaJlbHYIO HMlIepHIO CbIBaTb ero JIaKeHM H na l mHM KeH HHaM CaMa rrpHpO l a Bbl­ Ho lIpoumo 60 JIeT H CeH'IaC OCHOBHoe BHHMaHHe Y I emleTCH l BHHYJIa lIneMH PYCCKoe cpeM MHorHX l pyrHx KaK HaHOOJIee BpeMeHHoMY COBeTcKoMY rocY I apcTBY a cTpoHTemcTBo CPYH I aMeH KpelIKoe H l apOBHToe CaMa HCTOPHH l OKa3aJIa HepaBeHCTBO Ta MHorOHaII HOHaJlbHOrO CCCP CTaJIO TeMOll HCTopH'IeCKHX HCCJIe l O· MaJIeHbKHX lIJIeMeH C HaMH CKa KHTe 'ITO Tyr pa3YMHoro H I ­ TH lIpOTHB rrpHpO l bI H HCTOPHH H YTBep K l aTh paBeHCTBO KO­ BaHHll H TOJIbKO Ho Y Ke l peBHHe pHMJIHHe YTBep K l aJIH 'ITO rrpaBHTeJIbCTBa H cY I apCTBa coxpaHHIOTcH rrpH lIOMO H Tex H I eH Ha KOTOPbIX OHH' Toporo HeT 11 ClIpaBe I JIHBO JIH l aBaTb O l HH H Te Ke lIpaBa CTpOHTeml M PYCCKoro rOCY I apCTBa H pa3pYIllHTenHM ero I B03HHKaJlH B 3TOM CMblCJIe ocpHII HaJIbHblH JIeHHHH3M KaK H I eOJIO· rHH KIICC H CCCP OCTaeTCH B CHJIe He3aBHCHMO OT Toro BepHT JIK He Bce pa3YMeeTcH rrOJIHTH'IeCKHe lIapTHH l OpeBOJIIOII HOHIfOH rpa K l aHHH cTpaHbl peaJIbHOrO CO U HaJlH3Ma B KOMMYHH3M KaK POCHH pa3 1 eJIHJIH rr03HII HIO BcepoccHHcKoro HaII HOHaJIbHOrO COIO­ C'IaCTJIHBOe oy I y ee IIeHHHH3M OCTaeTCH 3a B HaII HOHaJlbHOM Borrpoce HO HH O l Ha H3 PYCCKHX lIOJIHTH'Ie­ B CHne KaK H I eH rrOJIO KeHHaH B OCHOBY lIpH 00pa30BaHHH CCCP 'IeJIOBe'leCTBa HnH Her CKHX rrapTHll He pa3paOOTaJIa lIporpaMMbI ooeCrre'leHHH HaII HOHaJIb­ KaK MeTO l lIpaBJIeHlfH HaJIpaBneHHblH Ha coxpaHeHHe TOTanHTap· HOM CBOOO l bI H He3aBHCHMOCTH HepYCCKHX Ha U HH Horo MHorOHa U HOHaJIbHOrO rOCY I apCTBa H KaK OlIpaB I aHHe CPdn Tn CKOH HMlIepHH HHKOr l a He ObIJIH OlIpeAeneHl I lIpaBOBbIe YCTaHOB­ KOTOPblMH rronb3yeTcH KIICC ll IH l OCTH KeHHH CBOHX u eneH r e B POCCHH­ KH OlIHPaHCb Ha KOTopble HepYCCKHe Ha U HH MOrJIH ObI lIPOHBHTb Ha U HOHaJIbHaH lIpooneMa ObIJIa O l HOll H3 cepbe3HeHmHX B CHHCKOH HMlIepHH H OCTaeTCH Ba KHellmeH lIpOOJIeMOll CCCP PYCH­ CBOIO BonlO XOTH Y Ke C Ha'laJIa XX BeKa lIO Mepe pa3BHTHH HaII HO­ HaJlbHOrO C03HaHHH HepYCCKHX HaII HM CTaHOBHnOCb COBepllleHHO o'le­ cpHKa U HH aCCHMHJIH u HH Ha U HOHaJlbHbIll rHeT 3aXBaT HepYCCKHX 3e· BH QHbIM 'ITO B POCCHH KaK H B l pyrHx MHOrOHaII HOHaJIbHbIX rocy­ MeJIb PYCCKHMH nepeceneH u aMH l apCTBax HaII HOHaJlbIfaH lIpooneMa CTaHOBHTCH cepbe3HbIM lIonHTH­ HOH POCCHH 11 Bce no ObIJIO H B l OpeBonlO U HOH­ BCe-TaKH HepYCCKHe HaII HH pa3BHBaJIH CBOIO KynbTY' 'IeCKHM cpaKTOpOM 3cepbI lIpaBna AonYCKaJlH cpe l epaII H1O KaK ro­ PY Ha U HOHaJIbHOe H lIOnHTH'IeCKOe C03HaHHe Do nOM CBH I eTenb­ CYAapCTBeHHYIO CPOPMY POCCHH HO HX lIporpaMMa He ObiJIa l OCTa­ cTByeT IIITepHoepra TO'lHO 'IeTKoH OOIIJ HM lIOnO KeHHeM lIporpaMM Bcex OCTaJlbHblX lIO­ I1HOpo l u bI Cy ecTBOBam H PYCCKHe lIapTHH mOBHHHCTCKoro lIYOJIHKyeMaH B nOM BbIIIycKe CTaTbH II nHTH'IeCKHX rrapTHll POCCHH 6blJI0 coxpaHeHHe e l HHOrO rOCYAap­ TOJIKa B lIporpaMMe rrapTHH BcepOCCHHCKHH Ha U HOHaJlbHbIM COI03 CTBa lionee Toro ObIJIO 3alIHcaHO Ka QeTOB Booo e BbIuma H3 BpeMeHHoro rrpaBHTenbcTBa B 3HaK lIpO­ 15 HIOJIH peBOJIIOII HOHHOrO 1917 rona lIapTHH TecTa lIpOTHB rOTOBHOCTH npaBHTenbCTBa lIOHTH Ha HeKOTopble yc­ lie3 rrpHHTHbIX Y KHMOK H nH u eMepHblX oroBopoK MbI BBe­ JIH B Ham YCTaB rrepBbIH l OrMaT HaIJ HOHaJIbHOCTH rocrro l ­ TyrrKH YKpaliHe Tpe60BaBmell aBTOHOMHH TaKHM 00Pa30M Kane­ TbI paAH 3a HTbI HHTepeCOB HMrrepHH OCna6HJIH lIepBoe B HCTO­ CTBO CBoero rrJIeMeHH B rOCY I apCTBeHHOll '1epTe MbI liO KbelO pHH POCCHH AeMOKpaTH'IeCKOe npaBHTenbcTBO II03HII HH Ka QeTOB OT­ MHJIOCTblO HapO l PYCCKHll OOJIa l aTem BenHKOll MaJIoll H pa KaJla rrO l XOA K HaIJ HOHaJlbHOH rrp06neMe 60JIblllHHCTBa rrOJIHTH­ lieJIOll POCCHH lIpHHHMaeM no OOJIa l aHHe KaK HCKJIIO'IHTeJIb­ 'IeCKHX lIapTHM B TO BpeMH HYIO MHJIOCTb liO KblO KOTOPOIO 00H3aHbI l OpO KHTb H KOTO­ pylO rrpH3BaHbi oxpaHHTb BceMepHo HaM PYCCKHM He l apOM l aJI0Cb no rOClIO l CTBO HH C Toro HH C cero l emfTb l OObITbIe II apCTBeHHbJe rrpaBa C rrOKopeHHbIMH HHopO l II aMH TYT pa3YMHoro CKa KHTe Ha MHJIOCTb HarrpOTHB 156 'ITO Ke no Bepx lIO­ BenHKOPYCCKoe 06 eCTBeHHoe MHeHHe 1910 r M CnaBHHcKHH - lIHCaJI Y Ke B AO caMoro rrocneAHero BpeMeHH MaJlO 3aHHMaJlOCb HaII HOHaJlbHbIMH BOlIpocaMH rrnoxo o u eHH­ BaH HX Ba KHOCTh nJIH TaKoro neCTporo KaK POCCHH B rrneMeHHOM OTHO­ JIHTH'IeCKOrO CJIaOOYMHH H rrpe l CTaBJIHeT COOOH HCTOpH'IeCKOe meHHH rOCY I apCTBa I1MlIepCKaH HaII HOHaJlbHaH MOTOBCTBO COBepmeHHO lIO l OOHOe TOMY KaK B KYlIe'leCTBe nonHTHKa lIpHHHMaJlaCb 06 ecTBoM KaK He'lTO 06bI'IHOe H 157 nOJIlKHOC 6e3 npOTCCTa HHOrna C CO'lYBCTBHeM 'Iall C Bcero C paBHonylllHbIM 6e3pa3nH'IHCM PenKHe npOTeCTbI nOnaBJIH­ CMbIX lIaponHOCTeH BbICJIYlllHBaJIHCb C lIeTCpnCJIHBOH H HC­ OXOTHOH CKYKOH KaK HC'ITO HanOCBlllec H nOCTbIJIOC KaK 6C3­ xapaKTcpHO HC TonbKO nllH POCCHHCKOH HMnepHH HO H llJIH CCCP XOTH I106enc 60JIbllleBH­ KOB B 3Ha'lHTeJIbHOH CTcnCHH cnoco6CTBOBan HMeHHO BblABHHYTbIH HMH JI03YHr 0 paBCHCTBC H cBo60ne HallHH H HX npaBe Ha caMoonpe­ nCJICHHe 3Ha'lCHHC HallHOHaJIbHOH I1p06JIeMbI H HcpyCCKI1X 06JIaCTCH HMncpHH Bo061l1e KaK PCBOJIlOllHOHHOro 4 aKTopa 60JIbllleBHKH no­ HHnH BCJIHKOJIeIlHO Eme no PCBOJIlOllHH OHH H3Y'laJIH TCOPHIO Ha­ llHOHaJIbHOH rrp06JIeMbI H OTHOllleHHH MelKny HallHHMH H lleHTpoM H HallHH npyr C npyroM B npyroH MHoroHallHOHaJIbHOH HMnepHH B ABCTpo-BcHrpHH OllHaKO npC lJIOlKCHHYIO aBCTpHHCKHMH COllHaJI­ nCMOKpaTaMH HnCIO KynbTYPHO-HallHOHaJIbHOH aBTOHOMHH 60JIbllle­ OTBcpnlli llJIH 60nbmCBHKOB KOTopble OTPHllaJIH B03MOlK' HOCTb 3BOJIIOllHOHHoro pa3BHTHH 06ll eCTBa pe4 opMbI Bo06ll e H npH pelllCm'IH HallHOHaJIbHOH np06JIeMbI B 'IaCTHOCTH 6bIJIH HcrrpH­ CMnCMbl XOTH Ha cnOBax OHH rrpH3HaBaJIH I1McHHo HaJIbllOH M paBHonpaBHe HallHH n03TOMY 60nblllCBHCTCKaH nporpaMMa pelllCHHH HallHo Up06nCMbI 6bIJIa OallHKaJIbHOH 06 3TOM IOTCH Ha BTOPOH nJIan Ha npaKTHKC 60nbllleBHKH CTpeMH mCb K am 3TO 6C3pa3JIH'IHe K npCTCH3HHM HepYCCKHX HallHH K HX npaBaM BHKH HaI HOHaJIb­ HaH KyJIbTypa HallHOHaJIbHaH HC3aBHCHMOCTb H cB060 lJ a OTon BHra­ TpaHc4 op Ma llHH ItaijUOH t1JlbH bIX ABHlKCHHH B nBHlKeHHe npOlleTapu­ HanClKllaH THlK6a 06HBalOll crO I10pOrH HCTlla 2 a CJICnOBaTCJIbHO H K npaBaM 'IeJIOBCKa n OJIlKHa 6bITb nOn'lHHCHa H1fTepeCaM KJIaCCOBOH 60Pb6bI npOJIeTa­ pHaTa npH TaKOM nOLJ Xon e HaIUfOIIlLiIbHOC C03HaHHC TO C nHcaJI naHHblx HallHit nOCJlen CTBHH 310H nonHTHKH CKa3aJIHCb Ha BceH llleCTHnCCHTHIIeTHCH HCTOPHH CCCP nporpaMMa no HaI HOHaJIbIlOMY BOnpOCY npHHHTaH Ha Cbe3n e 1913 r Ha 3TOM COBell aHHH JI03yHr 0 npaBc HaUHH Ha caMoonpcn e­ nCHHC BnJlOTb no OTn CJICHHH OT HMUCpHH H C03n aHHH caMOCTOHTeJIb­ 1I0ro rocyn apCTBa 6bIJl OKOH'IaTeJIbIlO nHllleH KaKOrO-JIlf60 con eplKa­ HHH nOCKOJIbKY B nopoHHHCKHX n oKYMeHTax nOn'lCpKHBaJIOCb 'ITO Bonpoc 06 OTncnCHHH He lJ OnycnfMo CMelllHBaTb C BonpocoM 0 UCJIC­ 4 co06pa3HocTH OT IJ eJIeHHH Ha JTOM lKC nOpOHHHCKOM COBell aHHH 60JIbllleBHKH 3aHBHJIH 'ITO OHH OCTaBJIHIOT 3a C060H npaBo pClllaTb TOT Bonpoc HC KaK npHHUHnHaJIbHbIH a lJ nH KalKn OH HalJ HH OTn eJIb­ 110 HCXOnH npelKne Bccro H3 HHTcpeCOB COUHanH3Ma Ha nOLJ Xon 60JIbllleBHKOB K HallHOHaJIbHOii np06neMC Korn a OHH 6blJIH onn03HUHOHHOH napTHCH BJIHHJIH MHorHC nOJIHTH'ICCKHe 4 aK­ TOphI B '1aCTHOCTH np06JIeMbI BHYTpHnapTHHHOH opraHH3aUHH CO­ CTaBHaH '1aCTb POCCHHCKOH COUHaJI- IJ eMOKpaTHH UHaJI-n eMOK paTH1 JeCKaH OpraHM3aUHH OYHn - - CBpeHCKaH CO­ BblcTynHna Ha II CbC3nC PC llpn C Tpe60BaHHeM nOCTpOHTb COlJ HaJI-n eMOKpanf lICCKYIO napnflO POCCHH no 4 e lJ epaTHBHOMY npHIIlJ Hny - CJIaBHHcKHH II pc llpn 6bIJIa KOHKPCTH3HpOBalla Ha nOpOHHHCKOM COBCll aHHH B KaK napTHIO 061 ­ CnHIIHIOll YIO HaUHOHaJIbllbIC napTHH UnH fleHHHa H cro COPaTHHKOB B nporpaMMc COllHaJI'n cMoKpaTH'ICCKOH napTHH OXOTHO pHcYlOmeH 6yn Yll HH COllHaJIbHbIH H nOJIHTH'ICCKHH CTpOH B O i HaKO cOBcplllellllo O'lCBH lJ HO 'ITO 4 e lJ epaUHH 03Ha'iaeT CO­ 103 paBHonpaBHbIX napTHepOB H caMoynpaBJICHHe BHYTPH HaUHO HaJlbHblX Borrpoca OCTaJIOCb BHC rronH 3peHHH uapTHH HC cYMcna n alKe KOHUCHTpaUHH BJIaCTH B pYKax BO LJ H HJIH BCpXylllKH pa3JIH'IHTb rpaHHll 31oro Bonpoca OT cocen Hcro HO n anCKO HC 3 HnCHTH'IHoro C HHM Bonpoca 06JIaCTHoro opraHH3aUHH a no caMblX neTaJIbHbIX fIon p06HOCTHX 6ynyu cc HallHOllaJlbHOrO TBcpnOCTb fleHHHa H cro CTOPOHHHKOB -- rOBopHTCH B HCTOPHH KnCC TaKOC yrrymcHHC H TaKaH 6e3rpaMOTHOCTb HC 6bIJIH cnY'I3HHbIMH BbJABltHYB JI03YHr 0 npaBC HalmH Ha caMOOUpeneJICHHC 6OJlblllCBH­ 03Ha'laJIO 6bl KOHCU ueHTpaJIH3Ma OTCTaHBalOmHX Hn CIO C03n aHHH MapKCHCT­ CKOH napTHH Ha npHHUHnax npOJICTapCKoro HHTepHallHOHa JIH3Ma n06C IJ HJIa 5 KH H MeHbllleBHKH BOCIlOJIb30BanHCb caMblM nonYJIHpHblM cpen H yrHcTeHHbIX HallHH JI03YHrOM He 06H3bIBaH ce6H npH 310M K KaKOH' CaM fleHHH Ha3BaJI JIH60 KOHKPCTHOH nCHTeJIbHOCTH B nOM HanpaBncmlH Bcn b napnfH­ UHOHaJIbHOCTeH POCCHlf 6 HaH HneOJIOfHH Hcxon HJla H3 Te3Hca 'ITO lIallHOHanbHaH np06neMa 30BaJI ec 60JIee KOHKPCTHO 158 JTy napnflO napTHCH npOJICTapHaTa Bcex Ha­ HO B rmCbMe OpbKOMY oxapaKTcpH­ 159 HacqeT HalUlOHaJIH3Ma BrrOJIHe C BaMH cOrnaCeH 'ITO Ha­ p 0 3TJi1M 3aHHTbCH rrOCephe3Hee Y HaC OP HH qyp eCHhIH rpY3HH BeTCKoro COID3a H q OpMHpOBaHHH CTH - 3aCeJI H rrHlIIeT JIH 'IIpOCBemeHHH' 60nblIIYID CTaThID c06paB Bce aBCTpHHCKHe H rrp MaTepHaJIbI ••• rpY3HHhI apMHHe TaTaphI Y Hac Ho BepHeMcH K HCTOPHH C EYHIl OM Ha KaBKa3e C p PYCCKHe pa60TaJIH 6MeCTe IIOCJIe 'OBaTenhHbIe HCKPOBllhI rrOHHMaJIH B e IHHOH c -p opraHH3alUlH 60 lbWe OeCJlTU leT 3TO He q pa3a HCTOPHH KIICC a rrponeTapCKoe pelIIeHHe HaUHOHaJIbHOrO Borrpoca EP HHCT­ BeHHoe pelIIeHHe TaK 6hIllO H B PHre PYCCKHe TOBll bI OTp eJIHJIHCh lUWI cenapaTUCTbl rro HalUlOHaJIbHOMY rrpH3HaKY OCna6HJIO 6bI ee KaK 60pll a 3a EYHP TO f e B BHJIh­ 6yoer CrrJIOtIeHHe H OOBo60 lKlmHHe yrHeTeHHhIX HapO OB 11 He rrycTHM lla H HalIIero 6paTa BeJIHKopyccoB 3 eCh rro60nhlIIe C pa60qHMH He rrYCTHM 'aBCTpHHCKoro P yxa 7 11 p eHCTBHTeJIhHO Bpop e 6hl He3HaqHTeJIhHhlll 3rrH30p - rrYHKT rrOBeCTKH P HH Ha '''PYC­ CKHM 60nhlIIHHCTBOM IIpH 3TOM neHHH-Hp eOJIOr rrpop on f aJI YT­ Bep f p aTb 'ITO He Hall HH a KJIaCC HBnHeTCH rrpep MeTOM HHTepeca rrapTHH a rrOTOMY rrponerapCKHll HHTepHa­ lUIOHaJIH3M H KJIaCCOBaH 60Pb6a JIIDUHH 11 HCKYCCHH o rrOJIO f eHHH EYHIl a B napTHH BKJIID'IeHHaH JIeHHHlI aMH B nepBhlH MhI BHP HM 'ITO elIIe p o 3aXBaTa BnaCTH Borrpoc 0 rrpOJIerap­ CKOM HHTepHaUHOHanH3Me neHHH Ha caMOM p ene pelIIan rOBopHTCH B 'ITO 3Ha'leHHe Borrpoca HeH3MepHMO mHpe B3aHMOOTHomeHHll rrapnm C EYHP OM••• Pa3 'p06JIeHHe rrapTHH naTbIlIIH nH­ HO ••• HeT TOH Mep30CTH 'ITO B ABCTPHH Y Hac He KOMMYHHCTHqeCKOH HOBOH HCTOpHqeCKOH 06unm­ COBeTCKoro Hapo a 10 COCTaBJIHIDT cop ep f aHHe peBo­ He yp JilBHTenhHO 'ITO HalUlOHaJIhHOe C03HaHHe 3alIIHTY Ha­ UHOHaJIhHhIX HHTepeCOB caMOH HalUlH neHHH CqHraeT Bpep HhIM p eJIY pa60qero KJIaCCa rrOCKOJIhKY HauHOHaJIhHOe C03HaHHe HBJIHeTCH II CDe3 e PCJJ PII H pemeHHe rrpHHHToe rro 3TOMY Borrpocy OKa3aJIH orpOMHoe BnHHHHe Ha aJIhHeHlIIHH XO HCTOPHH POCCHH I1CKJIID'IHB EYH neHHHll bI OTKa3aJIHCb or CTPOH­ renhcrna rrapTHH no q ep epaTHBHOMY rrpHHlUIny OT C03p aHHH napTJilH KaK COID3a paaHhlX H no pemeHHe Ba eCHTHJIeTHH cnYCTH norH­ '1eCKH orrpep emIJIO rrOJIO f eHHe Hall Hll B q OPMaJIhHO q e J epaTHBHOM COID3e CCP r J a rrpaBO pelIIaTh CBOID CYJl b6y He npH3HaeTCH HH 3a HHlJ HBH 'YYMaMH HH 3a Hall HHMH PelIIeHHe HCKJIIDqHTb EYHIl 6hIJIO 06cynOBJIeHO HHHCKOll q paKlUIH H TOJIhKO HHTepecaMH JIe­ HecMoTpH Ha Bce pa3foBophI 0 MH­ rrp0P YKTOM HHTepeCOB 6yp a3HH H OTHOCHTCH K 3rroxe KarrHTanH3­ pOBoH peBonIDlUIH 60nhweBHKH 6hIITH napTHeii KOTopaa eiicTBo­ Ma 3TOT CBOH rro lXop BaJIa B POCCHH H JiIX nepBootJepe J HOll ll eJIhID 6hll npHxo K BnaCTJiI K HalUlOHaJIhHOMY Borrpocy KOTOPhIll 60nb­ lIIeBHKaMH Bcema paCCMarpHBaJICH TOJIhKO KaK Borrpoc HepYCCKHX HauHif neHHH cq OPMYnHpOBaJI B 061IIeM rrOJIO f eHHH B POCCHH 3ro Hap o nOHHMaTh 6YKBaJIhHO - B POCCHH B MHorOHa­ UHOHaJIhHOH HMnepHH a He TOJIhKO B BeJIHKOpOCCHH II Cbe3 e Ho TOT f e neHHH KOTOPbIii Ha IIpOJIeTapHaT f e He TOJIhKO He 6epeTCH OTCTOHTh HaUHO­ HaJIhHOe pa3BHTHe Ka I IJ OH HalUlH a HarrpOTHB rrpep OCTepera­ eT MaCChI OT TaKHX HJInID3HH 8 PCJJ PII H3fHaJI 6YHP OB­ lI eB H BhI J enHIT 60nblIIeBHKOB B OC06YID naprHID B 1906 r CHOBa MHPHTCH C EYH OM H p IDKe BKnID'IaeT ero npe J CTaBHTeJIeii B UK PKII 6 I1HTepecHo 'ITO p 0KYMeHT B KOTOPOM neHHH caM Oll eHH­ BaeT nOT waf 6bIJI BnepBhIe ony6JIHKOBaH B 1937 r KaK Hp eOJIOr neHHH rrOHHMaJI 'ITO qeM MeHee KOHKpeTeH H TO­ qeH rrOJIHTH'IeCKHH n03YHr TeM nerqe ero BKJIID'lHTh B rrporpaMMY II03TOMY rrpHBeTCTBYH aCCHMHJIHlUIID H cnHHHHe HauHH 9 neHHH p a­ nee He YTOqHHeT KTO H C KeM p on f eH aCCHMHnHpOBaThCH H KaK no llHCJIO 'lITeHOB HalIIell napTHH CBhIwe 100 ThIC '1eJIOBeK 31 nHlueT neHHH - 06'bep HHHTenhHoM C'be3 e 3aTeM OKOJIO rrpOlf30H 'eT BeP h pe'lh Jilp eT 0 JIID 'HX KaKHe Hall HH B pe3YJIhTa­ uHan-p eMoKpaToB OKOJIO Te cnHHHHH HCqe3HYr O 'HaKO HMeHHO Ha nH JIHmeHHhIe KOHKpeT­ peHCKJiIX 12 14 Tenepb ThIC 6hIJIH npep CTaBneHhI Ha 26 ThIC rrOJIhCKJiIX co­ TbIC naThlWCKJiIX H 33 ThIC eB­ Horo cop ep f aHHH n03YHrH rro cell p eHh CChIJIaIDTCH COBeTCKHe nOJIH­ THKH rrpOBO J H nOJIHTHKY PYCHq HKalUlH MHorOHalUlOHaJIhHOrO Co- 160 CTpeMJIeHHe yKpenHTh napTHID KOJIH'leCTBeHHO BOBce He H3MeHH­ no OTpHll aTenhHOro OTHoweHHH neHHHa K Hp ee COID3a Hall HOHanb­ 161 HhIX napTHM H HaUHOHaJlbHOrO npC 'CTaBHTCJlbCTBa B PYKOBO 'CTBC napTHCiL Y I C B 1914 r OH Ha3blBaCT HHTcpHaUHOHaJlbHYIO COUHaJI· CMoKpaTHqCcKYIO napn 1O POCCHH napTHcH CKJlOKH pa30qapOBa­ HHH 06H H B3aHMHblX nOMCX pc cpaUHcH XY lllcro 3TO - rHHJlbC J onoH Tlma ••• Ha VIII Cbe3 e PKIl 6 B 1919 r 6bwa I1pHHJlTa HOBaJl nporpaM­ Ma no HaUHoHaJlbHOMY Bonpocy KOTopaH npH3blBaJia TPYAJlIUHX­ CH yrHeTclIHbIX Hapo oB 06bC J HHHCTbCH B C03HaTenbHOM cOI03e B TOM nporpaMMe nO '1epKHBanOCb 'ITO PYCCKHC pa60qHe H pa60'lHe pyrHx yrlleTalOlUHX HaUHH OJl I JIbI BeCTH ce6H TO rHHJlbC 13 Tor a l C J CHHH 3aHBJUICT 'ITO 60nblllCBHKH npOTHB OT CJlCHHH HCPyCCKHX HaUHH OT HMrrcpHH H 'ITO 0 rrpaBC HaUHH Ha caMoorrpc 'e­ nCHHC BIIJlOTb 0 OT cnCHHH OHH rOBopHT JlHlllb rrOTOMY 'ITO qCPHO­ COTCHijbl H BcnHKopycCKHC HaUHOHaJlHCThI HcnoraHHnH CJlO HaUHO­ HaJlbHOrO CO l HTCJlbCTBa B nHCbMC C r lIIaYMHHy J CHHH rro qcp­ C OC060H OCTOPO l HOCTblO B OTHOllleHHH K HaUHOHaJlbHO­ My qYBCTBY YfHeTeHHbIX HanpHMep CO CroPOHbI BeJIHKOpOC­ COB yKpaHHueB H nOJUIKOB no OTHOlllCHHIO K eBpCJlM CO CTO­ POHbI TaTap K 6arnKHpaM H Ln 16 KHBaCT 'ITO UCJlblO 60nblllCBHKOB HBnHCTCH 60JlblllOC rocy apCTBO UCHTpaJIH3aUHH I C TBcp aH BJlaCTb rrpaBHTcnbCTBa Ha BCCM H BCC­ 14 MH CmmaJl 3KOHOMHKa Tpc6ylOlUaH C l IiHOrO pYCCKoro H3bIKa B TOM l C nHCbMC J CHHH OTBcpraCT TaK I C pc cpaUHIO KaK HcrrpH­ rO HbIH THII opraHH3aUHH MHorOHaUHOllaJlbHOrO rocy apCTBa CCbI­ naJlCb Ha TO 'ITO pc cpaUHH TO COlO3 paBlibIX Tpc6ylOlUHH 06­ IUcro COrJlaCHJl a B03MO I J1O JlH npaBo 0 '1I0H CTOPOHbI Ha corna­ CHC C HCH pyroH - cIIpalllHBacT J CHHH H caM l C OTBCqaCT 3TO Hc CJlCAYCT 3a6blBaTb 'ITO J CHHH CqHTan HaUHoHamHyIO np06JICMY BonpocoM BTopocTcneHHoro 3Ha'lCHHJl a nOJIHTH'ICCKHMH npeAcTa­ BHTCJlHMH HaUHH TOJIbKO TpYMIUHXCJl KOTOPbIX B CBOID O'lepe b MOrJlH npe CTaBJIJlTb TomKO 60JlblllCBHKH CaMa napTHJl Y I C 6bIJIa opraHH30BaHa no JICHHHCKOMY npHHUlmy HHTepHaUHOHanH3Ma H UCHTpaJIH3Ma TaK 'ITO CXCMa COBCPlllCHHO HCHa 60JlbllleBHCTCKHe opraHH3aUHH B HcpyCCKHX 06J1aCTJlX CTaHOBHTCH COCTaBHOH '1aCTblO C J HHOH napTHH H nonHOCTblO IIO '1HHHIOTCJl MOCKOBCKOMY UK Ha­ a6cyp IS qTO l C rr06Y HJlO 60JlblllCBHKOB rrocJlc PCBOJIIOUHH cornaCHTbCH Ha pc epaTHBHYIO POPMY COBcTCKoro rocy apCTBa H a l c Ha OT­ cneHHC OT POCCHH 1 HHJlHH HH 3CTOHHH JIaTBHH J HTBbI H flonb­ lllH OrqaCTH 60nblllcBHKH CTamt l CPTBOH C06CTBCHHOH nonHTHKH ­ BC b OHH 06ClUaJlH HepyccKHM Hapo aM rrpaBO Ha OT CJleHHC OT PYC­ CKoro rocy apCTBa Ho Ha cnc Bonpoc PClllHJlCJl COOTHOllleliHeM CHn Me l y HaUHOllaJIbllbIM BH I eHHeM B Ka l OH H3 nHX pecny6mlK H I1paBHTCJlbCTBOM JIeHHlIa fpa l 'aHCKMI BOHHa B POCCHH TO He TOJlbKO COUHaJlbHaH BOHHa 1I0 H BOHHa 3a peCTaBpaUHIO pacnaBllleMCH nocne pCBonlOUHH MHorOHaUHOllaJlbHOH HMrrepHH H HMCHHO B PYIOTCJl B HaUHOHaJlbHbIM Bonpoc BHyTpH 60JIblllCBHCTCKOH napTHH a B nOJlHTH'ICCKOH l H3HH HCpYCCKHX HauHH HaUHOUaJlbHaJl np06J1c­ Ma KaK Bonpoc BbI I HBaHHH HaUHH npoCTo OTMCTaCTCH KopoTKo JlCHHHCKYIO nporpaMMY PClllCHHH HaUHOHaJlbHOH npo­ 6ncMbI MO l HO C P0PMYJIHpOBaTb TaK BarnHM I e HCPYCCKHX Ha­ P0 OB npasoM JlBnJlCTCH cTpeMncHHc CHTPaJlbHOH BJiaCTH npaBoM HBnHCTCH K OT J CHCHHIO a HalllHM npaso HC cornarnaTbCJl COBcpllleHHo TO'lHO ny 60JlblllCBHCTCKYlO npaKTHKY oxapaKTcpH30­ BaH CTaITHH TOH HaUHOllaJIbHOH BOHHe 60nbllleBHKH HHor a n06e l J aJlH a HHor a H OKa3bIBaJlCb UHOHaJlbHbIC np06JIeMbI rocY J apcTBa TaKHM 06pa30M TpaHc p0PMH­ npOHrpblBaJlH BbIHyJK ClIHbIMH H TH Ha BpeMeHHbIC rrcpeMHpHJl H KOMrrpOMHCCbI T OJlbKO pa H coxpaHCHHH BnaCTH 60nbllleBHKH no­ lllnH Ha HeKOTopble yCTynKH HaUHOHaJlbHbIM 1 EH I eHHHM TOJlbKO pa J H coxpaHellHH BJiaCTH Y l e rroCJle C pOpMHpOBaHHH UC3aBHCHMbIX COBeTCKHX pccny6nHK 60JlblllCBHKH nOBepHynH Ha 180 rpa J ycoB H UCHTpaJIbHaJl POCCHJl - nHCaJI OH - 3TOT oqar MHPOBOH PCBOJIIOUHH HC MO l CT oJlro cp l aTbCH 6C3 nOMolUH oKpaHH H306HJlYlOlUHX CblPbCM TOnJlHBOM npo YKTaMH npo oBOJlb­ CTBHH EOJlcc pa3BHTaH UCUTpaHbHaJl POCCHH HC MO l CT 0­ BCCTH AO KOHua cno PCBOJIIOUHH 6C3 nO J J cp l KH MCHCC pa3­ BHTbIX 1I0 60raTbIX HC06XOAHMbIMH pccypcaMH oKpaHH POC­ CHH 17 cornaCHJlHCb Ha pe epaTHBHoc ynopH J OqeHHC MHorOHaUHOHanbHoro rocy apcTBa YKperrHB CBOID BnaCTb 60JlblllCBHKH TpaHc p0PMHPO­ BaJiH p0pMaJlbHYIO pc epaUHIO B HKTaTYPY ueHTpa 162 O 'HaKO nOJlHTHqCCKaH 06cTaHOBKa Toro BPCMCHH Tpc60Bana HC­ KOTOPOM MO H pHKaUHH TOM COBCPlllCHHO IICTKOH I1pOrpaMMbf 163 I1MCHHO nonoM ' Te3ffCbI fleHffHa 00 aCCffMffRIIUffff COJIff I eHffH H Bblille MbI Y KC rOBopHnff 'ITO cpa3Y f e nocne npHxoAa K BnaCTff CJIHHHffH ObmH J onOJIHeHbI n03YHraMH 0 J OOPOBOJlbHOM COlO3e Ha­ OOJIbIlleBffKH Ha Aene OTKa3aJIHCb OT npOB03rJIamaBillerOCH ffMH J O pO J OB 0 J BYX Bff J ax HaUHOHaJIH3Ma yrHeTeHHblX H YrHeTalOmHX HaUHH rOBopHnOCb TaK Ke 0 TOM tffO HaUffOHanbHO-OCBOOO J HTeJlb­ HOe ABH KCHHe yrHeTeHHblX HaUHH cneAyeT HCnOJlb30BaTb B OOPboe 18 npOTHB 3anall HbIX J ep KaB Me KAYHapO J Hb1l1 acneKT HaUffOHanb­ peBOJIIOUHff JI03YHra 0 npaBe HalJ li H Ha OTAeJIeHHe H 3aHlIJIff OTKPbl­ TO BeJIHKOAep KaBHYIO n03ffUHIO HO HeO Kff J aHHO COrnaCffJlHCb Ha Q eAepaTffBHoe ynopHAO'lCHHe COBeTCKoro rocynapCTBa HeT COMHe­ HHlI 'ITO HapllAY C BHYTpHnOJIHTH'IeCKHMff Q aKTopaMff B 'IaCTHO­ HOH npooneMbI B 'IaCTHOCTff ffCnOJIb30BaHHe HaUffOHaJIbHO- CBOOO­ CTH CO B3PbIBOM HaUHOHaJIbHOrO C03HaHHH HepyccKffX HaUHH Ha AHTenbHoro J Bff KeHffH B HHTepecax MHPOBOM peBonlOUffH OOCY K­ peIlleHffe OOJIbIlleBHKOB Q opManbHO AonYCTHTb Q eAepauHlO nOBJIH1I­ 1920 r JIH TaK Ke Q aKTopbl BHeillHenOJIHTH'IeCKHe TIepBaH MHpOBaH BOHHa nOH B KOTOpylO BKJIlO'IHJIHCb H CoenHHeHHble lIIraTbI AMepHKH npHOJIH­ nOnbITKe TOM ffJIH HHOH HaUffH peanff30BaTb CBoe npaBo Ha KaK H npaBHTeJIbCTBa BeJIHKOOpHTaHHH H OpaHUHH nOMep Kan Tor­ AanCH Ha KOHrpecce HapOAOB BOCTOKa EaKY ceHTHopb Ha KOHrpeccax KOMHHTepHa H J pyrffx C'be3AaX npeACTaBHTeJIeH 19 OpraHH3al ffff KanaCb K KOHUY TIpe3HAeHT CoeAHHeHHbIX WTaTOB BYAPO BHJIbCOH PCOCP anH HO­ na ueJIblH pHil eBponeHCKHX HaUlfH B HX OOPboe 3a CaMOCTOlITenbHhIe ro ObIllO AOCTaTO'lHO 'ITO ObI HeCKOJIbKO MeCTHbIX KOMMYHHCTOB HaUHOHaJIbHble rocynapcTBa H CQ OPMYJIHpOBaJI 3HaMeHHTbie npHH­ 22 lJ Ii nbl BHnbCOHa fleHHH BbIHY K J eH ObIJI C nHM C'IffTaTbCH OTAeJIeHHe B J eMCTBHe BCTynaJIa KpaCHaH apMHH opraHH30BanH peBonlOUHOHHoe BblcTynrreHffe 3aHBffnff 0 TOM 'ITO OHH OOplOTCH C KOHTppeBOJIIOUffeH H nonpOCffnff KpaCHYIO MHIO npHMTH Ha nOMOmb 3Ta TaKTHKa npffMeHHeTCH MOCKBOH J O CHX nop - B BeHrpHH B raHHCTaHe B 1956 r B lJexOCJIOBaKHff B 1968 r BnaCTb OOJIbIlleBHKOB CTaOHJIH3HpOBanaCb B nepHOn Korna MH­ ap­ H B AQ ­ 1980 r CeH'Iac nOT npHeM nO'leMY-TO Ha3bIBalOT AOKT­ 17 MapTa 1920 r eme J O 00pa30­ PHHOH Epe KHeBa HO Be J b Y Ke BaHHH CCCP fleHHH B TenerpaMMe nomnpYKY KaBKa3cKoro Q POH­ pa K MHPOBOH peBOJIIOUHlf Y Ke Ha'lHHaJI pacceHBaTbClI JTO pa3YMe­ eTCH CKa3anOCb H Ha HaUHOHaJIbHOH nOJIffTffKe OOJIbIlleBffKoB He­ 3aBffCHMbIe HaUHOHanbHble pecnYOJIHKH o6pa30BaBIlIHeclI nOCJIe pe­ BOJIIOUHH 1917 r CTaJIH caMOCTOHTeJIbHblMH He C 6JIarOCJIOBCHHH 60JIbIlleBHKOB a nOTOMY 'ITO MeCTHble OOJlbIlleBHKH H KpaCHaH apMHH PC l CP 6bIJIH B MOMeHT HX OT J eJIeHHH cJIa6ee HalJ li OHaJIbHblX Ta nHCaJI CHJI TaKHe OKpaHHbl KaK EeJIOpYCCHH YKpaHHa ApMeHffH A3ep­ B3HTb EaKY HaM KpaMHe KpaHHe HeOOXO J HMO Bce YCH­ nHH HanpaBbTe Ha no npH'IeM oOH3aTeJIbHO B 3aHBneHHHX ObITb cyryoo iJ HnJIOMaTH'IHbIMH H Y J ocToBepHTbcH MaKCH­ MaJIbHO B nO J rOTOBKe TBep J oM MecTHoH cOBeTcKoH BnaCTH To Ke OTHOCHTCH K rpY3HH XOTH K HeH OTHOCHTbCH cOBeTYlO cme oonee OCTOPO f HO 20 OaH J f aH rpY3HlI H CpenHHH A3HH npocymecTBOBaJiH KaK He3aBH­ CHMble OT POCCHH rocynapcTBa Bcero nllTb JIeT AO HX BTOpffqHOrO BKJIIO'IeHHlI B MHorOHaUffOHaJIbHOe rOCYAapCTBO Ha nOT pa3 He B POCCHIO a B CCCP 11 TO 'ITO CCCP Obm C03naH KaK Q eAepaTffB­ Hoe rOCYAapcTBo CBHAeTeJIbCTByeT 0 KH3HeCnoco6HoCTH HaUHH 0 TOM 'ITO B npouecce HX HaUHOHanbHO-OCB06oiJ HTeJIbHOrO nBff f eHHlI OHff C03AaJIH TpaAHUHH HaUHOHanbHOH Eme oonee oTKpoBeHHo no nOBo J Y rpY3HH rOBOpHJI TpoUKHH nO J 'IepKHBaBIlIHM 'ITO oe30naCHOCTb POCCHH TpeoyeT BBeAeHHH B rpY3HIO rOCYAapCTBeHHOCTH C KOTO­ pblMH BblHY KneHO 6bIJIO C'lHrarbCH H npaBHTeJIbCTBO COBeTCKOH POCCHH TIoCJIe 06pa30BaHHH CCCP HalJ li OHaJIbHaH npOOJIeMa o6cY K J aJIaCb apMHH PC OC P DOJIbIlleBHKH POCCH t YTBep K J aJI XII C'be3 J e PKTI 6 anpeJIb 1923 r KHM npH3HalOT H nOMep KHBalOT npaBO HaUHH Ha caMOOnpeAeJIeHHe Ha Kor J a 3a Hero OOPlOTCH B Q eOAaJIbHbIX KanHTanHCTH'IeCKHX HMne­ 6bIflO BbIcTynaTb C KPHTHKOH BeJIlfKO J ep KaBHOrO pYCCKoro lUOBH­ B TO BpeMH eme MO KHO pHaJIHCTH'IeCKHX rOCY J apCTBax Ho Kor J a npaBO Ha caMOOnpeAeJIe­ HH3Ma Ho HeCMOTpll Ha pHil pe30JIIOUHH npOTHB Hero H HHe CTaHOBHTCH opY KHeM oyp a3ffH npOTffB npOJIeTapCKOH peBO­ fleHHHa nlOUHff Y OOJIbIlleBffKOB HeT npffqffH nffCan TpOUKffH OTHOCHTbCH 6bIJIO nOMeillaTb B K HeMY HHa'le 'IeM K J pyrffM npffHUHnaM ff3BpameHHOH KanHTaJIff­ 21 CTffqeCKOH AeMOKpaTffH 164 KPHTHKY HacTynJIeHHIO BeJlHKOAep KaBHOrO IlI0BHHH3Ma y Ke HCJlb311 1926 r CTanHH BblcTynHJI npOTHB Ba KHeHIlIHX 165 rrpHHUlUlOB HaUHOHallbHOH aBrOHOMHH B qaCTHOCrH rrpOrHB HCrrOllb­ 30BaHHH B rocY lJ apCTBeHHbIX yqpClK o eHHHX HCpYCCKHX H3bIKOB IIpHMeqaHHH Hellb3H 3aCraBHrb pyccKHe paOOqHe MaCCbI nHH B rrHCbMe KaraHoBHqy rrHCall Cra­ orKa3arbCH or pYCCKoro H3bIKa J oPMbl lIal l OllallbllOrO JlBl lKeHIU B COBPCMCHHhlX rocYJlaperBaX C nCTcp6ypr 1f3Jl OGmeerBcHHalI nOllh3a 1910 erp 296-297 H PYCCKOH KyllbTYPbI H rrpH3Harb CBoeH KYllbTYPOH H CBOHM H3bIKOM YKPaHHCKHH B ro BpeMH KaK 2 CKHe rrponerapHH H HX KOMMYHHCrHqeCKHe rrapUlH rronHbI CHMrrarHH K 'MOCKBe' YKpaHHCKHH KOMMYHHcr XBHneBOH TaM lKe CTp 291 TaM lKe CTp 297 He IIMeer CKa3aTb B rronb3Y 'MOCKBbl' HlIqerO npyroro KpOMe KaK rrpH3BaTb YKpaHHCKIiX lJ CHTellCH OeIKaTb OT 'MOCKBbI' 'KaK MOIKHO CKopee 23 B 4 Knec B pe3011lOlIlU X l pewelllfllx C'he3JlOB KOII¢ epelll lfil IDIeHYMOB UK 'I 1 1f3Jl 7 fOCnOJll TIf3rtaT 1953 r CTp 40 315-316 B H JIe­ HIfH CO'l T 19 4 1f3rtaHMC erp 386 TOM IKe IUICbMe Cramm rrpe ocreperaIT qro lJ BHIKCHIiC 3a B03­ pOlK eHlIe Heroplfll KnCC T I H3Jl n011IfT mlTepaTypbl MocKBa 1964 cTp 454 YKpaHHCKoro HaUliOHanbHoro C03HamUi H YKpallHCKOH HaUHOHaITbHOH KymrYPbl MOlKer rrepepacUI B lJ BlIlKeHHC rrporHB KYllbrYPbI COBerCKOH MOlKer rrpHHHrb 6 B H JIelllfll CO'l T 19 4'e M3rt erp 219 7 B H JICIlIfII CO'l T 35 8 B H JIelllfll CO'l T 20 4-e 1f3rt eTp 19 9 TaM lKe xapaKrep OOPbObI npOTIiB 'MOCKBbI' BOOOII e rrpOTHB PYC­ CKOH KynbrypbI H ee BbICIIIero lJ OCTHlKeHHH B KOHue 20·x - HaqaJle 30-x rO lJ OB nCHHHH3Ma 24 HaqanaCb 'lHCTKa B HCpYCCKHX pecnYOllHKax CCCP IIpecne lJ OBaHHe OOBHHeHHbIX B MecrHOM HaUHO­ Hanll3Me ObIJ10 HCKllIOqHTenbHO lKeCTKHM i e lJ epam 3M rrpeBparHJl­ CH B rronHYIO pHKUlIIO a YCHneHlIe Bnacrll CTamrna Ha lJ napTHeH CO­ rrpOBOIK lJ aITOCb Bce oonbIIIHM nO lJ 'lHHeHHeM HaUIiOHaITbHbIX Hepyc­ 25 CKHX pecnYOllHK Ka3allOCb 'ITO C HaUIiOHaIThHbIM C03HaHHCM OnHaKO rrpoIIIJ1o 60 E011hWC Bcero PYCIf¢ IfKRl MlI B oG11aerlf 1I3hlKa ¢ oPCl pYCTClI B pewe­ IIlf1lX TaJlIKeHfCKOil KOll¢ epcHl IfM nocBlImcHlloll npenon aBaHlfIO Pyc· 1I3blK JlPYlKGbl If COTpYJlHl 'IeCKoro 1I3hfKa lIepyccKIfM PyCCKllii 1I3blK CTBa HapOJlOB CCCP 22-24 Mall 1979 r • 11 HeropHlI KnCC T 1 H3rt 11011l T l1IlTepaTyphf MocKBa 1964 cTp 454 12 B H JIeHIfH CO'l T II 1f3rt 4-e erp 168 13 B H JIelllfH CO'l T 35 1i3Jl 4-e erp Ill 14 B H JIClIIiH CO'l T 19 15 TaM lKe 16 CM B H JIellHH CO'l 17 H B CTalllfH CO'l T 4 CTp 351 18 CM B H JIelllfH CO'l 341 T 23 erp 48-50 neT HO HaUIiOHaIThHaH npoOrrcMa rro-rrpCIKHe­ My OCTaeTCH O lJ HOH 113 BalKHeHIIIHX rrpooneM B COBeTCKOM COI03e 1f3Jl rrp 58-59 10 rrOKOHqeHO 4 1f31l 4 erp 452454 PeIIIeHlIe TOH rrpooneMbI no-npelKHeMY OCTaCTCH O lJ HOH 113 OCHOB· HbIX rrpe lJ rrOCbIJ10K H3MeHeHlIH COBeTCKOH TOTanliTapHOH CHCTCMbI OrrbIT HaUlIH HaKorrneHHbIH 3a JTH ny 166 60 neT nOMor HM YBlI lJ eTb rrpas­ T 29 1f31l 4-e erp 107 1 22 1f3Jl 4-e eTp 136-140 296-299 340­ 167 19 3Tol TeMe nOCBHIIJ eHa KIIHra Jl EepcHepa D Boersner The viks and the National and Colonial Question I 1917-1928 Ma1CcyiJo8 1957 20 B H nemm Co' T 35 H3A- 4-e eTp 378 21 UHTHPYeTCH no KHlire Jl EepcHepa CM npHMe' aHlle 19 HAQMOHAnbHblA COCTAD KPACHOA APMHH 22 CM V Mamatcy The United States and Central Europe A Study in Wilsonian Diplomacy and Propaganda Princeton sity Press 195 1 no nEPEnHCH 1920 rona to $ CIiJlIlIiUKHH HaUHoHa n bHaH nOllHTHl a KnCC B neplloJ C 1922 rr Cy' acHIiCTh 197 MlOllxeH CTp 243 260-261 BOChMOti C'he3A PKH 6 MocKBa napTH3AaT 1933 MocKBa fHnn 1959 1 3 24 25 H B CTaJJlill Co' T 8 CTp 151-153 TaM e CTp 152 M Fainsod How Russia is ruled Harvard University Press 1963 p 370 KaK n3BecrHo 28 aBrycTa 1920 r 6bma rrpoBeneHa rrepBaH rre­ pemfcb HaceneHHH opraHH30BaHHaH rrpaBHTenbCTBOM JIeHl fHa COBeT­ CKoe PYKOBOnCTBO rrpnnaBano eH 60nbllIoe 3HaqeHHe B M JIeHHH Ha3blBan rreperrnCb nenOM orpOMHOH rocynapCTBeHllOH BruKHOCTH l neperrHCb He ynanacb TaK KaK OHa OXBaTHna Bcero OKono 7C'f' o Ha­ ceneHHH 2 OHa He 6bma rrpOBeneHa XOTH neHHH nora Tpe60Ban Ha 60nbllIeH qacrH Torna caMOCTOHTenbHhlX COBeTCKHX pecrry6nHK YKPaHHbI H EenopYCCHH H He 3arpOHYna MHorHe a3HaTCKHe paHOHbl 1la H B CaMOH EBporreHCKOH POCClli KHTenH oc06eHHO MY K1 HHbI rrpH3bIBHbiX B03paCTOB OTHecnHCb K nOMY MeponpHHTHIO HenOBep' lIHBO QCY B TelIeHHe HeCKonbKHX rrocneAYlOlIIHX neT rrpOH3BOAHnO anMHHHCTpaTHBHYIO oueHKY qnCneHHOCTn HaceneHHH II pe3ynbTaTbI Toro YlIeTa rrpaKTHlfeCKn 3aMeHHnH naHHbIe rreperrHCH OnHaKO COBceM He Bce MaTepnanbl nepenncn 3acnY KHBalOT 6e3­ orOBopOlfHoro 3a6BeHHH HarrpOTHB MHome CBeneHHH He06hllIaHHO Ba KHbl AnH rrOHHMaHnH Toro BpeMeHH K lIHcny TaKHX pe3ymTaToB OTHOCHTCH 110 MoeMY MHeHHIO naHHble 0 qnCneHHOCTH II HaUHO· HallbHOM COCTaBe KpaCHOH apMHH KOTopbIe 6YAYT paCCMOTpeHbI B 3TOH CTaTbe MCTOlIHHKOM AnH nccnenOBaHnH nocnY KHnH e KerOAHhle cllpa· BOlIHHKn QCY 3a 1924·1928 rr B KOTOPblX B pa3nene DOeHHaH CTa­ THCTHKa lIy6nnKoBanHcb CBeneHHH 0 KpacHoH apMHH B 1920 roAY MHorna COCTaBHTenH IIpHMO YKa3bIBanH lITO pelfb HneT 0 pe3ymTa­ Tax lIepenHcH 1920 rona npHBeneHHbIe B 3Tnx Ta6nHUax naHHbIe rrpenCTaBnHIOT pe­ 3ynbTaThl pa3pa60TKH lIepenHcH KpaCHoH apMHn H c pnoTa 1920 rona TpYAbI QCY 1 XIIL MTorH rrepellHcH KpacHoH apMHH H c pnoTa 1920 rona neperrHcb apMHH 1920 r IIpO­ n3BOAHnaCb OnHOBpeMeHHo C BcepoccHHCKHMH rrepenHCHMH 1920 rona npHlfeM rrepenHcb BOHCK 6bma BbIneneHa B cOBep­ IlIeHHO oc06yIO orrepaJ HlO 168 169