19 3Tol TeMe nOCBHIIJ eHa KIIHra Jl EepcHepa D Boersner The viks and the National and Colonial Question I 1917-1928 Ma1CcyiJo8 1957 20 B H nemm Co' T 35 H3A- 4-e eTp 378 21 UHTHPYeTCH no KHlire Jl EepcHepa CM npHMe' aHlle 19 HAQMOHAnbHblA COCTAD KPACHOA APMHH 22 CM V Mamatcy The United States and Central Europe A Study in Wilsonian Diplomacy and Propaganda Princeton sity Press 195 1 no nEPEnHCH 1920 rona to $ CIiJlIlIiUKHH HaUHoHa n bHaH nOllHTHl a KnCC B neplloJ C 1922 rr Cy' acHIiCTh 197 MlOllxeH CTp 243 260-261 BOChMOti C'he3A PKH 6 MocKBa napTH3AaT 1933 MocKBa fHnn 1959 1 3 24 25 H B CTaJJlill Co' T 8 CTp 151-153 TaM e CTp 152 M Fainsod How Russia is ruled Harvard University Press 1963 p 370 KaK n3BecrHo 28 aBrycTa 1920 r 6bma rrpoBeneHa rrepBaH rre­ pemfcb HaceneHHH opraHH30BaHHaH rrpaBHTenbCTBOM JIeHl fHa COBeT­ CKoe PYKOBOnCTBO rrpnnaBano eH 60nbllIoe 3HaqeHHe B M JIeHHH Ha3blBan rreperrnCb nenOM orpOMHOH rocynapCTBeHllOH BruKHOCTH l neperrHCb He ynanacb TaK KaK OHa OXBaTHna Bcero OKono 7C'f' o Ha­ ceneHHH 2 OHa He 6bma rrpOBeneHa XOTH neHHH nora Tpe60Ban Ha 60nbllIeH qacrH Torna caMOCTOHTenbHhlX COBeTCKHX pecrry6nHK YKPaHHbI H EenopYCCHH H He 3arpOHYna MHorHe a3HaTCKHe paHOHbl 1la H B CaMOH EBporreHCKOH POCClli KHTenH oc06eHHO MY K1 HHbI rrpH3bIBHbiX B03paCTOB OTHecnHCb K nOMY MeponpHHTHIO HenOBep' lIHBO QCY B TelIeHHe HeCKonbKHX rrocneAYlOlIIHX neT rrpOH3BOAHnO anMHHHCTpaTHBHYIO oueHKY qnCneHHOCTn HaceneHHH II pe3ynbTaTbI Toro YlIeTa rrpaKTHlfeCKn 3aMeHHnH naHHbIe rreperrHCH OnHaKO COBceM He Bce MaTepnanbl nepenncn 3acnY KHBalOT 6e3­ orOBopOlfHoro 3a6BeHHH HarrpOTHB MHome CBeneHHH He06hllIaHHO Ba KHbl AnH rrOHHMaHnH Toro BpeMeHH K lIHcny TaKHX pe3ymTaToB OTHOCHTCH 110 MoeMY MHeHHIO naHHble 0 qnCneHHOCTH II HaUHO· HallbHOM COCTaBe KpaCHOH apMHH KOTopbIe 6YAYT paCCMOTpeHbI B 3TOH CTaTbe MCTOlIHHKOM AnH nccnenOBaHnH nocnY KHnH e KerOAHhle cllpa· BOlIHHKn QCY 3a 1924·1928 rr B KOTOPblX B pa3nene DOeHHaH CTa­ THCTHKa lIy6nnKoBanHcb CBeneHHH 0 KpacHoH apMHH B 1920 roAY MHorna COCTaBHTenH IIpHMO YKa3bIBanH lITO pelfb HneT 0 pe3ymTa­ Tax lIepenHcH 1920 rona npHBeneHHbIe B 3Tnx Ta6nHUax naHHbIe rrpenCTaBnHIOT pe­ 3ynbTaThl pa3pa60TKH lIepenHcH KpaCHoH apMHn H c pnoTa 1920 rona TpYAbI QCY 1 XIIL MTorH rrepellHcH KpacHoH apMHH H c pnoTa 1920 rona neperrHcb apMHH 1920 r IIpO­ n3BOAHnaCb OnHOBpeMeHHo C BcepoccHHCKHMH rrepenHCHMH 1920 rona npHlfeM rrepenHcb BOHCK 6bma BbIneneHa B cOBep­ IlIeHHO oc06yIO orrepaJ HlO 168 169 MaTepHaJIbI rreperrHCH 6bIJIH C06paHbI UCY H pa3pa60TaHbi HbIX rrOMaHHbIX S H COCTaBJIHBlllHX BMeCTe 2 72% 06IUeM qHCJIeH­ ueHTpaJIH30BaHHbIM rrOpH o KOM OT o eJIOM BOeHHOM CTaTHCTH­ HOCTH apMHH Il JIH HCCJIe o OBaHHH BOCrrOJIb3yeMCH o aHHbIMH 0 rpa­ KH Bce o aHHble rrpHBOMTCH B OTHOCHTeJIbHbIX BeJIJilIHHaX TaK MOTHOCTH KaK a6COmOTHble UH PPbI rrpe o CTaBJIHIOT H3 ce6H BOeHHYIO TaM­ BOeHHOCJIY I aIUHX CM Ta6JIHUY N° rro OT o eJIbHbIM HaUHOHaJIbHOCTHM 2 B BepxHeM qaCTH crrHCKa OKa3aJIHCb HapO r J bI N° Hy K CO l aJIeHHIO H OTHOCHTeJIbHble BeJIHqHHbI rro ueH3ypHbIM qHCJIeHHOCTb KOTOPbIX H3BeCTHa H3 Ta6JIHUbI YCJIOBHHM rrpHlllJIOCb o aBaTb B C I aTOM BH o e 3 rrOJIO l eHbI B rropH o Ke y6bIBaHHH qHCJIeHHOCTH 3TO Ba l HO OTMe­ 1 rrpHqeM OHH pac­ THTb rroToMY qTO Ha 5-M MeCTe HaXOMTCH KHprH3bI KHprH3bI KaK BH r J HO H3 rrpHBe o eHHoM UHTaTbI aBTopbI CrrpaBOqHHKa pac­ rrOJIaraJIH 3TOM CrreUHaJIbHO H3 o aHHoM rry6JIHKaUHeM UCY - TOM 13-M KHHTH He y o aJIOCb 06HapY l HTb B KaTaJIOre ITeHHHcKOM 6H6JIH­ OTeKH no e o HHCTBeHHbIM HOMep OTCYTCTBYIOIUHM B rrepeqHe H3 o a­ KaMcaKH - KaJaxH qHCJIeHHOCTH KOTOPbIX B apMHH MbI He 3HaeM Cpe o H o opeBOJIIOUHOHHoro HaCeJIeHHH Ha HX o OJIIO rrpHxo o HJIOCb 3 3% BepoHTHo BblCOKoe MeCTO B crrHCKe cooTBeTcTByeT H BbICO­ KOMY rrpoueHTy nora Hapo o a B KpacHoM apMHH B nOM MO l HO y6e o HTbCH H o pyTHM crroc060M ilo o craBHM H3­ HHM UCY HeT ero HH B 6H6JIHOTeKe HH B apXHBe UCY BepOHTHO BeCTHYIO qHCJIeHHOCTb HaUHOHaJIbHOCTeM H3 Ta6JIHUbI N° 1 B Ta6JIH­ OH BMeCTe C o pyrHMH o OKYMeHTaMH 6bIJI YHHqTO l eH BO BpeMH BTO­ POM MHPOBOM BOMHbI 4 He CCbIJIaIOTCH Ha ny KHHry H HH BoeHHaH uy 3HUHKJIOrre o HH HH l1CTOPHH fpa l o aHcKoM BOMHbI HH o pyrHe co­ KOTOPbIX HaM He H3BeCTHa OKa3bIBaeTCH OHa OqeHb HeBeJIHKa ­ BpeMeHHble HCCJIe o OBaHHH 23 7% 6 N° 2 H oueHHM o OJIIO rpaMoTHbIX cpe o H Hapo o oB 'illCJIeHHOCTb B03MO l HO 3Ta pa60Ta Bo06IUe yTepHHa TeM 60JIblllee 3HaqeHHe 3TO rroKa3bIBaeT qTO a6COJIIOTHOe 60JIblllHHCTBO B rpyrrrre rrpo­ rrpH06peTaIOT HeMHOrOqHCJIeHHble CBe o eHHH BOllle o lllHe B CrrpaBOq­ qHX COCTaBJIHIOT Hapo o bI C HeBblcoKOM rpaMOTHOCTbIO QT06bloue­ HHKH HHTb HX qHCJIeHHOCTb rrpenrrOJIO I HM qTO rrpOqHe pa3 o eJIHIOTCH HaUHOHaJIbHbIM cocraB KpacHoM apMHH rrpHBo o HTCH B pa3JIH Hble o Be KaTeropHH 1-H - Ha Ka3aXH KaJIMbIKH Y36eKH capTbI rrepCbI ­ ro o bI C Heo o HHaKoBoM rrOJIHOTOM H TOqHOCTbIO CHaqaJIa pyccKHe co Cpe r J HeM rpaMOTHOCTbIO OKOJIO 15% 2-H - 6bIJIH 06'be o HHeHbI C 6eJIOpycaMH o aHb o opeBOJIIOUHOHHOM Tpa J H­ o bI co Cpe r J HeM HBHO 3aHH I eHHoM rpaMoTHocTbIO OKOJIO 70% He­ Bce OCTaJIbHble Hapo­ UHH H KpoMe HHX BbI o eJIHJIHCb TOJIbKO llleCTb Hapo o oB yKpaHHUbI Tpy r J HO yBH o eTb qTO B nOM CJIyqae rrepBaH rpyrrrra COCTaBJIHeT rrHTb rrOJIHKH HeMUbI eBpeH TaTapbI C 6alllKHpaMH H JIHTOBUbI BMeCTe C llleCTbIX OT rrpOqHX TO eCTb 2 3% OT Bcex BOeHHOCJIY l aIUHx JIaTbIlilaMH ilo Mepe y o aJIeHHH OT fpa l o aHCKOM BOMHbI 3aCJIyrH JIa­ ilOBTOPHM Te l e paccy l o eHHH HO ypoBeHb rpaMoTHocTH TbIlileM CTaJIH 3a6bIBaTbCH H OHH KaK Hapo o B CTpaHe MaJIOqHCJIeH­ rpyrrrrbI B03bMeM 60JIee BbICOKHM - HbIM rrOrraJIH B rrpOqHe 3aTO B crrHCKe B03HHKJIH Hapo o bI ilOBOJI­ rrOTJO l eHHIO l bH H KaBKaJa CBo o Ka nHX o aHHbIX rrOKa3aHa B Ta6JIHue N° 1 113 Ta6JIHUbI BH o HO qTO rro o aBJIHIOIUee 60JIblllHHCTBO B KpaCHOM apMHH COCTaBJIHJIH pYCCKHe - 80% l1x o OJIH B BOMCKax rroqm B o Ba pa3a rrpeBbIlilaeT rrpoueHT B HaCeJIeHHH l1MrrepHH YqaCTHe Bcex OC­ TaJIbHbIX Hapo o OB oc06eHHO yKpaHHueB 6bIJIO 3aMeTHO MeHee aK­ qTO rro o aBJIHIOIUee JIeHHOCTb nOM cOBoKyrrHocTH OKa I eTCH 0 3% OT apMHH IOIUHe 1 Hapo o bI C MaJIbIM qHCJIOM 06pa30BaHHblx Ka3axH KaJIMbIKH l eHHH OKpaHH CTpeMHJIHCb K qHCJIeHHOCTH KpaCHoM apMHH N° 1 - H3 Koro COCTOHJIa ilpOqHe B nOM HepaClllH ppOBaHHaH rpa pa cTpoKe 06'be o HHeHbI HeCKOJIbKO o eCHTKOB Hapo o oB KaK BXO o HBlllHX B l1MrrepHIO TaK H HHocTpaH­ 170 OKOJIO 2 3% OT 2 Hapo o bI co cpe o HHM ypoBHeM rpaMoTHocTH BOTHKH 3blpH­ He KapeJIbI MOJI o aBaHe qepKeCbI OHH COCTaBJIHIOT 0 1 - peHHoro pYCCKoro HaCeJIeHHH PaCCMOTpHM Ha HX o OJIIO rrpHXo o HTCH 60JIbllleBHKOB a COBeTCKaH BJIaCTb y o ep l aB­ lllHCb B ueHTpe CTpaHbI rrpOBo o HJIa TaM MaCCOBble M06HJIH3aUHH KO­ Ta6JIHUbI 60JIblllHHCTBO B HeM cocraBJIHIOT TaKHM 06pa30M rpa pa ilpOqHe pacrra o aeTcH Ha TpH COCTaBJIH­ capTbI Y36eKH rrepcbI BblcTyrraJIH rrpOTHB BTOPOM no cooTBeTcTByeT rrpe o ­ TaKHe Hapo o bI KaK BeHrpbI pHHbI 3CTOHUbI MaKCHMaJIbHaH qHC­ THBHbIM TaKOB 6bIJI XO O fpa l o aHCKOM BOMHbI HaUHOHaJIbHble ASH­ rocy o apCTBeHHOM He3aBHCHMOCTH H 90% qHCJIeHHOCTH BOMCK 3 Hapo o bI BepoHTHeM Bcero - BbICoKo06pa30BaHHble 0 3%% OT 0 2% l HTeJIH 3arra o HbIX oKpaHH l1MrrepHH H HHocTpaHHble BOeHHOrrJIeHHble BeHrpbI cep6bI pHHbI 171 3CTOHlI hI OHH TaK Ke MOrYT COCTaBJHITb OT HOCTH BepOllTHO OKOJIO 0 1 0 3%% AO '1HCJIeH 0 2% MHororo APyroro TO Bce HeAOCTaIOll ee BOCrrOJIHflnOCb paoo TOR TbIJIa TOro Ke PPOHTa OCTaeTClI HellCHbIM Borrpoc HaCKOJIbKO rrpeAcTaBHTeJIbHbI pac B BOCCTaHOBneHHH KeJIe3HOAOpO KHbIX rrYTeH Y'IaCTBOBanH cMoTpeHHble AaHHble rreperrHCH BeAb OHH Y'IHTbIBaIOT OKOJIO Tpex H opraHH3aUHH KpaCHOH apMHH Y Ke OAlla 3Ta BOCCTaHOBH­ MHJIJIHOHOB BOeHHOCJIY Kall HX 7 a B Tex Ke CrrpaBO'lHHKaX OTMe'la KpacHoH apMHH TaM 3538 1920 TenbHall paOOTa TpeOOBaJIa '1pe3Bbl'laHHOrO HallpIDKeHHfI TbI­ r '1HCJIHJIOCb B nOBoB cnY KObI 3Aecb Bce uerrnllJIOCb OAllO 3a APyroe IIoKa TbIC '1eJIOBeK HaKoHeu comaCHO AOKYMeH KeJIe3HOAOpO KHbIe nHHHH He ObWH BOCCTaHOBJIeHbl KpaCHall eTClI 'ITO rro CrreLUiaJIbHOMY yqeTY B aBrycTe BepXOBHoro KOMaHAOBaHHff B Ha AOBOJIbCTBHH OKOJIO 5 no BpeMlI B apMHH COCTOllJIO 8 MHJIJIHOHOB '1eJIOBeK Borrpoc 0 '1HCJIeH HOCHI H COCTaBe KpacHoH apMHH 3aCJI BaeT CrreUHaJIbHOrO HCCJIe AOBaHHlI 3AeCb Ke 11 JIHllIb KOPOTKO YKa KY B03MO KHble rrpHIJHHbl DeJIo B TOM 'ITO K KOHAY rpa KAaHCKOH BOHHb KpaCHall apMHfI COCTOllJIa H3 CpaBHHTeJIbHO HeMHOrO'lHCJIeHHbIX ooeBbIX '1aCTeH H or· POMHbIX pa3paCTaIOIlUfXCfI KaK paKOBaf OrryXOJIb TbIJIOBblX opra­ no rrpOAOn KaJIa CBOH orrepaLUiH rrOJlb3YflCb KOHCKHM KOHCKHH TpaHcllopT rrorraAan B '1HCnO TbIJ10BHKOB HaAO rrOMHHTb 'ITO Bce Te KTO Ben paOOTY Ha PPOHTe rro­ nY'IaJIH rraHKH He3aBHCHMO OT Toro ObIJIH nH OHH KpaCHoap­ HeCOBrraAeHHlI pe3YJIbTaTa rreperrHcH co CBeAeHHlIMH Y'IeTa HH3aUHH COCTOflll HX Ha apMeHCKOM rraHKe IIO'leMY apMHlI TpaHcrropTOM H BOT AOOaBO'lHblH H K TOMY Ke BpeMeHHblH rrpoHcxo­ lJ H 10 BOT KaK rrbITaeTCfI OTBeTHTb Ha nOT Borrpoc O l HH H3 caMblX 9 aBTOpHTeTHbIX KOMaHAYIOll HX TOro BpeMeHH C C KaMeHeB MeHuaMH HnH He ObIJIH a no eCTeCTBeHHO CeH'IaC Ke OTpa­ KaJIOCb Ha '1HCne TbIJ10BHKOB OTCYTCTBHe CBoeBpeMeHHoro rrO l B03a H3-3a pa3pYllIeHHlI KeJIe3HOAOpO KHOro TpaHcrropTa BbIHY KAanO pPOHT opraHH­ 30BbIBaTb CBOH MaCTepCKHe Anll rrpOH3BOACTBa TCKYllIero peMOHTa CneAYIOll HM KPH3HCOM rrOCJIe TpaHcrropTHoro ObIJI TOllnHB­ ••• Terrepb l Ba CJIOBa Ha TeMY 0 'lHCJIeHHOCTH TbIJIa H pPOH­ Ta UH pPbl PHCYIOT YOHHCTBeHHYIO KaprnHy llITbIKOM Ha PPOHTe CTOflJIO rro '3a Ka KlJ blM l eCflTb eAOKOB B TbIJIY Ta­ Kafl apMHfI rromOll aJIa KOJIOCCaJIbHble pecypCbI rrOJIe3HblH Ke HbIH Borrpoc 3arOTOBKH APOB AnSI Kene3HblX Aopor BbIJIHn­ ClI B KOHue KOHUOB B opraHH3aUHIO pPOHTOBbIX JIeC03aroTO­ BHTenbHbIX '1aCTeH HecMoTpll Ha TO 'ITO pPOHT rrpH OOll eM rOJIOAHOM rraHKe TaKOH BblBOA HCTopHKa BceH CTpaHbI rrHTaJlClI YAOBneTBopHTenbHO Bce Ke Ha pPOH­ rro AOKYMeHTaM nOATBep KlJ aIOll HM nH UH PPbI H CBHAeTeJIb­ Tax rrepe KHBaJIHCb rrpOAOBonbCTBeHHble KPH3HCbI rrpHIJeM Bbl­ 3 p peKT ObIJI caMbIH HH'ITO KHbIB ' XOAHTb H3 HHX CTBYIOIlUfM nOT ronbIH paKT Ho rrepeHeceM ceofl XOTfi ObI MbICJIeHHO B YCJIOBHfI Toro BpeMeHH H rrOCTapaeMCfI YSlCHHTb ObIJIH nH rrpH'lHHbI K COAep­ KaHHIO TaKoro paCTO'lHTeJIbHOrO TbIJIa H eCJIH ObIJIH TO MO K­ HO nH rrpH3HaTb paOOTY nHX AeCflTH eAOKOB rrpHXOAHJIOCb OllllTb-TaKH COOCTBeHHblMH CH­ naMH H cpeACTBaMH IIo rrOAC'IeTaM rnaBCHaOrrpO l apMa K Hattany AeHHH rrpOAopraHOB COCTOSlno 130 1920 r B Be­ TaKHX rrHlUeBbIx 1919 r 3TH UH PPbI flBmWHCb HeCOMHeHHO UH ppaMH H3Aep KeK Bbl­ KO Ha pPOHT II03AHee B 3BaHHbIX HeperynHpoBaHHOCTbIO CHaO KeHHlI pPOHTOB H B rrep­ oOeCrre'lHTb ceoll OBOll aMH H OOl eMHCTbIM PYPa KOM • BYIO O'lepe l b pa3pYXOH HallIero rrpOH3BOACTBa H X0311HCTBa OHH BOCrrOnHlInH HeXBaTKY B 1l0ABH KHOM COCTaBe HallIero Ke­ ne3HOAOpO KHOrO TpaacrropTa I1x Ke paOOTa CMlIr'lana Bce M KOHettHO 3TH rrpeArrpHlITHH paOOTaJIH He Tonb­ 'HH'ITO KHOif DbIJIH Ha ppoHTe H pPOHTbI BbIHY KlJ eHbI ObIJIH rrOllIHBOttHble MacTepcKHe H carrO K­ Hble•••• Ha ppoHTax ObIJIH H CBOH llIKOJIbI KpacKoMoB 11 no ObI­ KPH3HCbI llepe KHBaeMbIe ppOHTaMH EcnH pPOHT rrepe KHBaJI no He H3 KarrpH30B He HeAOBepHeM K paOOTe ueHTpa a Heoo­ TOllnHBHbIH KPH3HC TO He rrOAJIe KHT COMHeHHIO 'ITO CeH'IaC XO l HMOCTbIO rrpHonH3HTb TY Ke 06pa60TKY KOMCOCTaBa K 'la­ Ke nOT KpH3HC OTPa KaJICfI Ha p330yxaHHH HallIHX TbIJIOB Ec­ CTlIM 11 Bce JTO rrOBhlrnano ttHCJIO TbIJIOBHKOB nH pPOHT He rronyqaJI rrpOAOBonbCTBHff OOMYHAHpOBaHHlI H 172 3Ha'lHTenhHaf '1aCTb nHX orpOMHbIX ThIJIOB He rrO l rraAaJIa rrOA BO­ 173 eHHYlO rrepemICb TaK KaK cny I a He BOeHKOMaTOB MHmnapH30 BaHHbie pa60 l IHe BpalJH H CeCTpbl rOCrrHTaneH 3arOTOBHTenH H T ll l HnH He B Ka3apMax a B CBOlfX AOMax H TeM caMblM aB r oTu TaKHM 06pa30M C AOBOJIbHO BbICOKOH Bepo51THoCTblO MO l HO YT­ Pa31J eneHHe lJ aHHblX rrepemlCH Ha CPPOHTOBble H TbI110Bble BOlicKa nHX BOHCK B CrrpaBOlJHHKax He rrpHBOIJ HTC51 HO H3 MHorO' HcneHHbIX rrp0ll eHTHbIX COOTHOllIemm ee HeTpyiJ H0 BOCCTaHOBHTb HarrpHMep rOBopHTC51 BOHCKax l eHaTble COCTaBn51nH 43 B TbI11Y cyxorrYTHoH apMHH rrplf ' lfcneHHOCTH 2900 TbIC lJ a CnelJ yeT 'ITO B IIoneBbIX BOHCKax IIeperrHCb nOBeK no CBelJ eHH51M fnaBHOKOMaHIJ OBaHH51 MHH lJHCnHnOCb B no BpeM51 394 'ITO B rroneBblX 50 27% a Bcero B 47 36% lO OTClO­ y'l11a 1190 TbIC '1e­ B lJ eHcTBylO eH ap­ TbIC 60Hll OB Bcero 1 Ien B IlITa6ax H BeIJ OMCTBax nOlJ 1 IHHeHHblX apMHH ll OB 38 433 OXBaTbIBaIIH TeppHTopHlO C IIpeHMy ecTBeHHo pyc­ l HTeJIeH CKH rrpOXOIJ HnH 06bl' HYlO a He apMeHCKYlO rreperrHCb rrOIJ TBep I IJ aeT CKa3aHHoe lIHcneHHOCTb 3aBOJI I CKHH CKHM HaCeJIeHHeM H eCTeCTBeHHO KOMIIneKTOBaIIHCb H3 MeCTHblX 45 949 Bep I AaTb 'ITO rrepeIIHCb pe3ynbTaTbI KOTOPOH nOKa3aHbi B Ta6JlH­ ll e N° 1 rrOJIHOCTblO OTpa3lfJIa HauHoHanbHbIH COCTaB AeHcTBYlO eH KpacHoH apMHH H Bp51A JIH 3aMeTHO HCKa3HJIa 06111HH COCTaB BoeH­ HocnY l alllHX C YlJeTOM pa60TaBIllHX B TbIIIOBbIX opraHH3all HHx Bo­ rrpocbl KaKHe HMeHHO rpyIIrIhI BOeHHOCJIY I alllHX He 6bIIIH OXBa'le­ Hbl rreperrHCblO TeppHTOpHaIIbHOe pa3MellleHHe BOHCK IIO IIeperrHCH C AaHHbIMH KOMaHAOBaHIUI TbIC TbIC 60H­ Tpe6YlOT AaJIbHeHlliero H3Y'leUHH npUnO eHUR Ta6Jlu14a N° 1 TbIC nHlJHOrO cocTaBa B IlITa6ax H lJaCT51X TbI11a CPPOHTa TbIC 60Hll OB 390 TbIC nl1lJHOrO cOCTaBa 11 TaKlfM o6pa30M Hall HOHanbHblH COCTaB KpacHoH apMHH noneBble BOHCKa no rreperrHcH BKnlO1 IaIIH o' eBHIJ HO BClO lJ eHcTBYlO­ 1920 H 1926 rOAax 1913 r HaceneHHH CTpaHbl B 1897 If 1926 ronax B ylO apMHlO H rrOlJ aBn51lOlllee 60nbIllHHCTBO BoeHHocny l a HX rrolJ ­ PYCCKOH apMHH B ' HHeHHblX apMeHcKHM IlITa6aM DPOHTOBbJe IlITa6bI H MHorHe IJ pyrHe IIOlJ pa3lJ eneHHH B TOM 1 jlf­ B npoueHTax cne Bce CCPOpMHpOBaHHble WI51 OTIIpaBKH Ha CPPOHT 1 Iacrn BXO UUIH A p B TbIIIOBble BOHCKa 1 jlfCneHHOCTb KOTOPbIX no nepeIIHCH COCTaBlfIIa 1710 M Ii CT 51 TbIC 'len He 6bIIIH Y'lTeHbI apMeHcKoH rreperrHcblO MaCCbl Tbl­ 1913 %% 1920 %% TbIC ' 1923 %% 1926 %% 1897 %% 1926 %% 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 2347 67 6 22 6 64 17 6 44 3 4 4 4 7 3 2 0 9 6 3 0 9 2 5 nOBblX pa6o' HX H cnY l aIlll1X pa60TaBllIHX 1J 1151 apMHH HO He BKnlO­ ' eHHbIX B BOHHCKHe CPOpMHpOBamm TaKlfM 06P 130M rrepeIIHCb y' na HaH60nee 6ecnoco6HYlO HaH6o­ nee 6nH3KYlO K CPPOHTaM lJaCTb apMHH ho BHiJ HO B ' aCTHOCTH H3 aHa 1920 IJ HCnOKall HH BOHCK OXBa' eHHbIX nepeIIHCblO IIOlJTH IIonOBHHa HX Ha­ XOIJ HTC51 BHe EBpOIIeHCKOH POCCHH a Bep051THO B nonbllIe 151 rlJ e KaK pa3 B TbIC BHe CTpaHbl TO eCTb no BpeM51 pa3bIrpbIBanHCb PyccKHe 77 7 79 54 YKpaHHLl bI 5 86 172 oenoPycbI 2 2 65 KpOBOrrpOnHTHble Cp3 l eHH51 OTHoCHTenbHo Hall HOHanbHoro COCTaBa He Y' TeHHbIX neperrHCblO i TbmOBbIX BoeHHocny l a Hx MO I HO nHllIb BblCKa3aTb npelJ rrono l e- HHe ' TO OH He IJ On l eH 6bIJI CHnbHO OTnH1 IaTbC51 OT COCTaBa rrpo'IHX 1 IaCTeH KpaCHOH apMHH TaK KaK CCPOpMHpOBaH TeM l e rr T V M06lfIIH3all HH ' TO H OCHOBHa51 lJaCTb lJ eHCTBYlOllleH apMHH lVW lKHV nOJI51KH 1 8 1 1 2 4 4 0 2 6 22 0 7 HeMu bI 1 3 0 7 21 0 7 EBpeH 4 0 1 35 40 3 1 4 13 121 6allIKHpbl 174 4 0 0 73 CKlfH YPaIIbCKHH 1 4 2 2 0 9 2 1 0 1 0 9 1 7 TaTapbI H neTporpaACKHH 1 1 ITHTOBLl bI CTBYlOllleH apMlflf TaK KaK 60nbIlllie BoeHHble oKpyra OpnOBCKHH 23 If naTbIIllH lJ a l e rrpelJ nOnO l HTb 1 ITO CpelJ H cnY l amHX oKpyroB 6bIII ellle nee BbICOK rrpOll eHT PYCCKHX lJeM CpelJ lf KpaCHOapMeHll eB B 8 7 21 2 175 AIlH 2 3 4 qYBaIIm 1 0 MopnBa fpY3HHbI 6 7 8 0 7 0 9 0 67 0 76 0 5 30 15 0 82 0 92 - 0 3 9 1 2 1 24 6 1 0 3 6 0 2 2 72 1 1 0 93 80 3 8 11 5 12 4 ApMHHe npO'lHe 5 4 0 1923 r naIDT AIlH HecnaBHHCKHX HapOnOB 10% TafinHua N° 1 TpYAHO CKa3aTb 'ITO IIocnY Hno HCTO'lHHKOM nJIH MaplJlana TO JIll HenOCTyIIHbIe HaM CBeneHHH TO nIl nypHO HaUHOHaJIH3M npeyBe· JIH'IHBalOmHR BKnan PYCCKOro II OOmeCJIaBHHCKoro 3JIeMeHTa B cnaBHOR IIooene 1 07 Ta6llu1fQ N° 2 fpaMOTIfOCTL BoeHHocJIY al HX MYJIC'lHH 8 CBB3H C HanHOHanLHocTbIO 2951 Bcero B 8 npoueHT8X 1897 r - CBeneHHH IIO pOnHOMY H3bIKY PyCCKHe - B 1913 r non PYCCKHMH IIOHHManHCb coficTBeHHo PyccKHe YK­ paHHUbI II fienopycbI B 1923 r PyccKHe BMeCTe C fieJIOpycaMH I1CTO'lHHKH HaponHoe X03HCTBO COlO3a CCP B uH pPax KpaT ' YKPaHHUbI BenopYCbI TaTapbI KHR CIIpaBO'lHHK UCY M KHprH3bI - BO'lHHK CCCP 3a EBpeH ­ 1924 CTp 54-55 CTaTHCTH'leCKHR cIIpa· 1928 UCY M 1929 CTp 50-51 B I1 K03noB HaUHOHaJIbHOCTH CCCP M CTaTHCTHKa 1975 CTp 34-35 249·250 JIpuMelJaHUe K Ta6llu fe nonHKH HeMUbI JIaTbIlJlH N° 1 MopnBa MHHHCTP OfiOPOHbI MaplJlaJI A A fpe'IKO IIpHBen HeCKonbKO HHbIe UH pPbI no ero cnOBaM K KOHUY BORHbI B KpaCHOR apMHH HaC'lHTbIBaJIOCb PYCCKHX 77 6% YKpaHHueB - 13 7% oenopycoB naTbIlJleR TaTap fialJlKHp II IIpenCTaBHTeneR npymx HaUHOHaJI j HOCTeR - 4 7% non KOHUOM BORHbI BHUHMO IIOHHMaeTCH 1921-1922 rr B KpacHoR apMHH y e npOlJlna 3aMeTHaH neMoolUIH3aUHH HYBlJlaH B IIepBylO O'lepenb HapOnbI nOBOn bH II A3HH B03MO HO Ha YKpaHHe rne IIpe Ae He fibmo fionblliHx MOOHJIH3aUHR OHa na pOBeneHa B no BpeMH Ho na e IIpH nHX ycnoBHHx HHe 'lHCneHHOCTH HecnaBSIHCKHX HapOnOB nO'lTH B 3 pa3a -c 4 7% - BbIrnHnHT HeCKonbKO YUHBHTenbHbIM 113BecTHbIe ApMHHe BeHrepUbI ­ BOTHKH ­ 3bIpHHe KaJIMbIKH KapenbI ­ ilHTOBUbI MonnaBaHe 12% nepCbI CapTbI CepObI ­ fpeq o 176 ­ BalJlKHpUbI - A A Bo0pYlI eHHble CHJIbl CoBeTCKOro rOCYAapCTBa M 1974 c Y30eKH ­ 86 15 85 51 86 58 52 9 15 87 93 18 86 39 89 2 96 23 69 04 74 92 41 52 91 83 67 55 79 97 18 79 77 35 90 38 61 8 20 87 12 05 77 35 11 0 177 DJ iHbI 4epKeCbI IlpHMeqaHHH 4YBaIlHl 3crOHUbI IlpoqHe 96 9 B H fleHHH 1l0nHoe c06p CO'l T 51 CTp 352 24 69 2 82 85 Bcero HCrOqHHKH C60PHHK CraTHCTHqeCKHX CBeneHHH no COW3Y CCP 1918-1923 rr M 1924 orneJI N crp 86-95 • - B CnpaBOqHHKe naHb CBeneHHH no OrneJIbHbIM B03pacraM Il lIH Ka nOH HaIUfOHaJIbHOcrH HaH60JIee COnep areJIbHbIM HBJIHerCH Il llH B flpeP BapHTenbHblx HTorax nepeTIHCH HaceneHHH 28 8 1920 r Tp UCY T 1 BbIl1 1-3 M 1920-1921 p aeTCli pa3pa60TKa pe3YJlhTaTOB nepenH­ CH p ml 58 ry6epliHil H OTMe'laeTClI 'ITO B l3 ry6epHlliIx nepenHch npOBeCTH He y llanOCh 06ll1 all '1HCneHHOCTh HaceneHlliI paCCMOTpeHHali 3THMH nepBblMH rry6nHKal HlIMH nepenHcH 102 MnH 'len BhIl1 3 CTp 1 npaBP a B rry l HIj ­ py BXOAllT ry6epHHH A3HaTcKoil POCCHH oueHellllbIC OT'laCTH no Il3HHhIM 1916-1917 IT B p anhHeil lllcM UCY yTO'lHlIJlO p aHHbIC ncpenHCH aAMHlIHCTpa­ THBHblM rrYTCM yBenH'IHB '1HCJleHlIOCTh lIaCeneHHlI B CTpaHe B 1920 r p o 131 MnH 'len B03pocna H ouellKa '1HCneHlIOCTH no OTP eJlhllblM TeppHTopHliM HarrpHMcp PaJHHua B '1HCneHlIOCTH lKHTeneil nOHcKoil H UapHUhlllcKOll 06­ nacTell cocraBHJla no CpaBlIeHHIO C 1914 rO llOM npH nepBhlx ny6J1HKaUHlIx He­ Hac orcyrcrBHe CBeneHHH TaK BeHrepUbI H cep6bI He HMewr naHHbIX no 20 H 22 neT oawKHpbI BorHKH 3bIpHHe H r n HerpaMOrHb crap­ we 50 ner qro rOBopHr OrqaCrH H 0 ManoH qHCneHHocrH TUX rpynn CKOJlhKO MHJlnHOHOB rra UHlj pa paccMaTpHBaeTclI lIeKOTOphlMH aBTOpaMH K3K Ol CHKa nOTcph a no YTO'lHCHHbIM P 3HHhIM 360 ThlClI'I CTaTHCTH'Ie­ - KHprH3aMH Ha3bIBaJIH rrpH rreperrHcH 1920 r Ka3aXOB H HeKoro­ pbIe npyrHe KOqeBbIe HapOnbI TypKecraHa 3 ••• 4 rpY3HHbI BepOHTHO YKa3aHbI BMecre c apMHHaMH KaK H B He- KoropbIx npyrHx CrrpaBOqHHKax CKHll elKerop HHK 1921 r BbIl1 1 Tp llCY T 8 BbIl1 3 M 1922 eIp 9 C60PHHK CTaTHCTH'ICCKHX cBcp eHHll TIO COI03Y CCP 3a 1918·1923 n UCY T 18 M 1924 paJp en 4 CTp 96 PaCCKa3hIBaIOT 'ITO B OKT1I6pe 1941 r apxHB HCY 6hIll 3aKorraH BO IlBOpe a B 1945 r Korp a el'O OTKonanH OKa3anOCh 'ITO MHorHe P O­ KyMCHTbl HCrrOp'leHhl Ha'laJIhCTBO npep no'lJlo pClllHTh np06neMY Kapp HHaJlh­ HO H BeCb apXHB 6hIn TaK Ha3blBaeMO C'haKTHPOBaH YHH'ITOlKeH 5 B rry6J1HKal HH HTorH ncperrHCH HaCeJlCHHlI 1920 r M UCY 1928 CTp 7-8 10 rOBopHTClI 'ITO npH pa3pa60TKe IlBYX Ta6J1HU paCCMaTpH­ BaIOIlllIX Y'laCTHHKOB HMnepHaJlHCTH'IecKoll H rpalKP aHCKoll BoltH HHOCTpaH­ UbI 6hInH HCKnIO'ICHhl CMelllHO 6hInO 6hI OAHaKO npep nonaraTh 'ITO OHH BO­ 061l1e He paCCMaTpHBa TJHCh B neperrHCH HaceneHHlI MH B ncpenHCH KpaCHoll apMHH Ha060poT HM 6hInO yp encHO nOBbIlllCHHOC BHHMaHHC 3aAaBaJlCli cne­ UHaJlbHblll Bonpoc 0 nOAllaHCTBe BK1lIO'ICHhI HlIOCTpflllUbI H B orry6nHKoBaH­ Hble p aHHbIe 0 HaUHOHanhHOM COCTaBe HacenCHHlI B 1920 r OHH HeCOMHell ­ HO Ij HrYPHpYIOT H B CBCP ClIHlIX 0 KpacHolt apMHH CaMO ynoMHHallHe B crrH­ CKe HaUHOHanhHocTeil KpaCHoapMclil eB BeHrepl eB H cep60B nOP TBeplKAaeT 3TO Donee Toro O'leBHAHO 'ITO pC'ih Hp eT He upOCTO 0 nHuax p allHofi HaUHo­ HanbHOCTH a HMeHHO 0 BoeHHocnYlKalll HX 6hIBlllHX BOCHHonneHHhIX TaK KaK cpep H HHX HeT rpaMOTHbIX B B03pacTe MJla ullle 20-22 neT H CTapllle 60 neT 6 flpH paC'ICTC 6hlJlH cp enaHhl He60nblllHc p oIlYlll eHHlI B rpYTIrrc lIHTOB­ l eB H naThIllleli TIpCAflOnaraCTCl 60nhwHlICTBO lIaTbllucil 178 179 npOlleHT 6amKHp H TaTap 6epeTCli B npOnOPIlHH K HX 'lHCneHHOCTH HaCeneHHH HMnepHH npHMepHo 1 K 3 WIll rpY3HH Hcnonb3yeTcli TOT npOlleHT rpaMOTHblX 'lTO H WIll apMJIH lla l e npH OWH60'lHOCTH 3THX nO l eHHll B03HHKaJOUl aH norpeWHOCTb He npeBbICHT 1% HAIII APXI1B Kapil KaYTcKuu B ny6nHKau HJIX llCY 'lHcneHHOCTb KpacHoii apMHH no nepellHcH CKonbKO OTnH'laeTCH KpoMe IlHlPpbI 2951 TbIC 2885 TbIC MY l ' HH 66 TbIC l eHlllHH npH paCIIpe IleneHHH pC3ynbTaTOB nepellHcH no TeppHTOtlRJI cyMMapHble IlHlPpbI UaHbI 2942 TbIC 2860 TbIC MY l llHH H 82 TbIC KOMMYHI1CThi 3A PA60TOA npaB Ua aBTOpbJ roBOPHT He 0 'lHCneHHOCTH BoRcK a 0 HaceneHHH HOM OC06b1M nOPJiAKOM TO eCTb apMHH H 3aKnJO'leHHbIX TeM 6onee HeCKom i KO MeHbWaJI 'lHcneHHocTb MY l llHH K eTCH crpaHHoR TpYIU I llCY To 8 BbIn 3 CTaTHCTH'leCKHR e l ero UHHK 1922-1923 Bbln 1 M 1923 CTp 8 8 3KcnponpHaIUIH H Opf'aHH3an HH BceMHpHaH BOHHa oT6pocyIJla pa60t mH Knacc Ha3aIJ He TonbKO J HpeKTHBbI KOMaHll OBaHHlI IPPOHTOB KpacHoR apMHH 1917-1922 T 4 M 1978 cTp 130-235 6nar OIJ aplI TOMY 'ITO OHa Bbl3Bana 01J H'IaHl1e nO'ITH Bcex cnoeB Ha· C C KaMeHeB rp ll aHCKali BoRHa 1918-1921 T 2 M 1928 CTp 1 KaMCHeB OTBe'laeT HCTOPHKY H MOB'lHHY KOTOPbIR B CTaTbe KoMnneKTo­ BaHHe KpacHoit apMHH B 1918·1921 rr ony6nHKOBaHHOR B TOM lKe TOMe rpalKll aHCKoll BoRHbl nHweT 0 COOTHOWeHHH e UOKOB H 60it1lOB llHTaTbI B CTaTbe KaMeHeBa H3 pa60TbI MOB'lHHa pelJ OBble nocrbi ero 1 BHJKeHHH '1ro OHa HaKOHeI ero 6eIJ crBHH 9 ceneHHlI 'ITO OHa OTcranble 'IaCrH nponerapHara BblIJ BHHyna Ha ne­ 6e3rpaHH'IHO npeYMHOJKHna H TeM Ha Mecro cnOKOHHoro cYJKlJ eHHH omana PYKOBOIJ CTBO OI'laHHHIO OHa cnoc06crBOBana ynpOll eHHIO ero B3rnHIJ OB reM 'ITO CHnbHO paJBMa Ka3apMCHHoe MblwneHHe TO MblIIIDeHHe Koropoe O'leHb 1J 0crynHo H HeBeJKeCrBeHHOMY Ha no­ BepxHocTH JKHJHH 06peralOIl eMycH '1enOBeKY H Koropoe CBOIJ HTCH 10 11 C60PHHK CTamCTH'leCKHX CBe UeHHR no Co103Y CCP 1918-1923 rr llCY T 18 M 1924 crp 92 llHpeKTHBhI llHT CO'l cTp 180-185 K TOMY 6yJJ T0 ronoe HaCHnHe HBnHerCH peWalOIl HM paKToPOM BO BceMHpHoH HcropHH 6YIJ TO 1J 0CrarO'lHO 06naIJ arb He06xoIJ HMOH CH­ nOH H 6ecnOll a1J HOCTbIO '1T06b oCYll ecrBHTb Bce 'Iro yroJ Ho CaMO C060H paJYMeerclI HC cnelJ yeT 6HTb B Ha6aT no nOBOIJ Y OrlJ enbHblx oWH6oK H rnynocreH COBepwaeMblx B peBOnlOIJ HIO Ca­ MbIM TlIJKKHM B HCTOPHH HBnlICTCH nOnOJKeHHe peBOnlOl HH B KO­ ropOH npHxOIJ HrCH C'IHTarbCH C COBepweHHo HOBhlMH H IJ O KpaHHo­ CTH HeOrITHJ HbIMH nOnOJKeHHHMH DhIITO 6bl lJ eWeBeHhKHM paPH­ ceHcrBOM ecnH 6bI Ha6nlOIJ arenb nOJKenan H3 6e30naCHoro Mecra HnH HJlJ anH CTporo OCY IJ aTb npoMaxH nlOlJ eH Koropble HaxOJ Hr­ ClI B IJ eHTpe 60pb6hl H HecyT Ha ce6e Bce ee rlIrorhl H onaCHocrH Ho 3aro HacToHTenbHO He06xoIJ HMO oCY IJ aTb npOMaXH BhIIe­ KalOIl He He H3 HeBepHoro HnH HelJ OCraTO'lHOrO OCBelJ 0MileHHH a H3 nOJKHoro IIpHHIJ HnHanbHoro CYJKlJ eHHH HX C Heo6xoIJ HMOCTblO o6y­ CilOBilHBalOll ero OHH MoryT 6hIIb YCTpaHeHhI ronbKO npH npeolJ O­ 113 KHHrH Kapn KayTCKHH TeppoPH3M H KOMMyHH3M I-hU-BO TOBapH­ ll eCTSa H n naAJ DKHHKOBa BepnHH Pa60Ta 6hma 3aKOH'IeHa K KayTCKHM B HlOHe 1919 r 180 181