npoueHT 6aUIKHp H TaTap 6epeTCll B nporropUHH K HX 'ilICneHHOcnr 11 HaCeTlCHHH liMncpHH npHMepHo 1 K 3 wIll rpY3HII HcrroJlJ 3yeTcll TOT lICe rrpOUCHT rpaMOTHhIX 'ITO H wIll apMlIH llalKe npH OUIH60'lHOCTH 3THX npe l IIO­ I10lKeHHtt B03HHKaJOllI WI IIorpeUIHOCTb He IIPCBhICHT 1% HAIII APXHB Kapil KaYTcKuii B rry6nHKaUIDIx UCY '1HCJICHHOCTh KpacHott apMHH no rrCperrltCH He­ CKonbKO OTJIH'IaCTCll KpOMe UH PPhI 2951 ThIC 2885 ThIC MyllC'illH H 66 TbIC lKeHIJUIH rrpH pacnpCJl eIIeHltH proynbTaToB rrepCl1HCH no TeppHTOPHH CYMMapHhIe UH ppLI l aHbl 2942 ThIC 2860 ThIC MYlK'ilIH It 82 ThIC lICe KOMMYHHCTbl 3A PA60TOfi IJUIH · npaB l a aBTopbl roBOPllT He 0 '1HCneHHOCTH BOttCK a 0 HaceneHHH Y'ITeHHOM OCo6hIM rropl1Jl KOM TO eCTh apMHH H 3aKJIlO'IeHHhIx TeM 60nee HecKon ­ 3KcnponpHauWl H OpraHH33UWI KO MeHbUIaJi '1HCJIeHHOCTh MylKltHH KalKCTCll CTpaHHoil TpYJl b1 UCY T 8 BblIl 3 CTaTHCTH'lCCKHtt elKerO l HHK 1922-1923 rr BblIl 1 M 1923 L'Tp 8 BceMHpHaH BOHHa or6poCHna pa60' HH Knacc Ha3a J He TonbKO 8 JlHpeKTHBbl KOMaH l OBaHHlI pPOHTOB KpacHott apMHH 1917·1922 T 4 M 1978 CTp 130-235 9 C C KaMcHcB fpalK l aHCKall BottHa 1918-1921 T 2 M 1928 crp 1 KaMeHcB OTBe'laCT HCTOPHKY H MOB'IHHY KOTOPbltt B CTaThC KoMIIneKTO­ BaHHe KpacHott apMHH B 1918-1921 rr ony6nHKOBaJiHott B TOM lKe TOMe fpalK laHcKott BoiIHbl nHIUeT 0 COOTHOUIeHHH e lOKOB H 60iluOB UHTaTbl B craThe KaMeHeBa H3 pa60ThI MOB'IHHa 10 C60PHHK CTaTHCTH'ICCKHX CBe lCHHii IIO Co103Y CCP 1918-1923 rr UCY T 18 M 1924 crp 92 6narO J apH TOMY '1ro OHa BbI3BaJIa O J H'IaHHe nO'lTH Bcex cnoeB Ha­ ceneHHH 'ITO OHa OrCTaJIble ' aCTH nponeTapHara Bbl J BHHyna Ha ne· pe J OBble nOCTbl ero J Bl'DKeHHfI 'ITO OHa HaKOHe ero 6e J CTBWI Ge3rpaHH'IHO npeYMHOJlGfna H TeM Ha Mecro cnOKOHHoro cy l J eHHH OT J aJIa pyKOBO J CTBO OT' aflHHKl aHa cnoc06CTBOBaJIa ynpOlL' eHHKl ero B3rnH J OB TeM 'ITO CHnbHO pa3BIilla Ka3apMeHHoe MbImneHHe TO MbIumeHHe KOTopoe O'leHb J ocTynHo H HeBe l eCrBeHHOMY Ha IIO­ BepXHOCTH I H3HH 06peraKllL' eMYCH '1enOBeKY H KOTopoe CBO J HTCH K TOMY GY J TO ronoe HaCIillHe flBnflerCH pemaKllL' HM l aKTopOM BO BceMHpHOH HCTOPHH 6Y J ro J ocrarO'lHO 06na J aTb He06xo J HMOH CH' nOH H 6ecII0lL' a J HocTbKl '1T06bI oCYlL' ecT 3Hrb Bce 'ITO yrO J HO 11 llHPCKTHBbl llHT CO'l crp 180-185 CaMO C060H pa3yMeercH He cne J yeT 6Hrb B HaGar IIO nOBO J y or J enbHbIX oum60K H mynocreH COBepmaeMbIX B peBOnKl HKl Ca· MblM rH I KHM B HcropHH HBnfleTCfI nOnO l eHHe peBOJ1Kl HH B KO­ TOPOH npHXO J HrCH C' HraTbCH C COBepmeHHo HOBbIMH H J o KpaHHO· CTH HeOrJ1H J HbIMH IlOnO l eHHflMH 6bIJIO 6bI J emeBeHbKHM l apH ceHCTBOM eCJ1H 6bl Ha6nKl J arenb IlO l enaJI H3 6C30naCHoro MeeTa HnH H3 J aJ1H eTporo oeY l J arb npOMaXH nKl J eH KOTopbIe HaXO J HT' CH B eHrpe 60Pb6bl H Heeyr Ha ceGe Bce ee rHrOThI H onaCHOeTH Ho 3aro HaerOflrCJ1bHO He06xOLUlMO oeY l J arb npOMaXH BbIre­ KaKllL' He He H3 HCBepHoro HnH He J ocraTO' Horo OCBe J OMneHHH a H3 nO l HOrO npHH HIlHaJIbHOrO CY l l eHHH HX c HeoGxO J HMOeTbKl o6y· CnOBJ1l maKllL' ero OHH Moryr 6blTb ycrpaHeHbI ronbKO npH npeo J o li3 KHHI'H KapIl KaylcKHIt TCPPOPH3M H KOMMYHH3M H3 l -Bo TOBapH­ meCTBa H n JI3Jl I IlKHHKOBa BepnHH Pa60Ta 6bIIIa 3aKOH'ICHa K KayrcKHM B HlOHe 1919 r 180 181 nCHHH TaKOrO CYJK l l CHHH H OHH HBnHIOTCH yrp030H Ka l AOMY 6YAY­ 3TO 03HalJano Obi yqaCTHC B BblOOPax B KopTeCCbl B HaIJ HOHanb­ llI CMY peBOnlOIlHOHHOMY ABH I CHHIO com HX OCTaBnHIOT OC3 KpHTH­ HOC Co6paHHe H B tlCCKOrO paCCMOTpeHHH HnH AaJKe npHYKpaIlIHBalOT H tlTYT - ro nonHoro OCBOOOJK l l CHHH paoo'lero Knacca paAM paOOTC HX EaKYHHCTbI JKC XOTcnH HCMCnnCHHO­ KaK cpeACTBO AnH 3Toro npH TorAallIHCM nOnOJKCHHH I1cnaHHH napnaMeHTCKaH ACMO­ MHHMbIX HHTcpeCOB pCBonlOIlHH MapKca H 3Hrcnbca B TaKOM Hc06xOAHMOH KpHTHKe pCBonlOUHH KpanUI Obma COBepllIeHHO HenpHrOAHOH CKonb HC3aMCHHMOM OHa HC OCTaHaBmIBan HX BynKaHHlJCCKHH pCBonlOUHOHHbIM TeMncpa­ Obma AnH pa3BHTHH H C03PCBaHHH nponeTapHaTa YlJaCTHC B KaKHX Obi TO HH 6bmo Bbl60pax Ka3anOCb HM AOCTOMHblM CMCPTHOH Ka3HH MCHT 3TO MeJKny npOlJHM nOKa3bIBaeT KpHTHKa C KOTOPOH 3Hrcnbc OCCHblO 1873 r OTHCCCH B nCHnUHrcKoM Volksstaat K BOCCTaHHIO 26 COBeTbl pa60lJHX AenYTaTOB KaK CpcAcTBa 'HCMcnnCHHoro nonHO­ pccny6nHKH H nOAaBneHHoro B 3HalJHTCnbHoH Aonc C ro OCB060JKACHHH paOOlJcro Knacca cme He 6bmH H306pCTCHbl Ea­ HlOnH - B I1cnaHHH 3a HeMHOrHMH HCKnlOtlCHHHMH BoccTaHHc B rCHC npOACpJKanOCb AO HHBapH KapTa­ 1874 r TaKHM oopa30M emc AO Toro KaK BOCCTaHHC obmo nHKBHAHpO­ Ha 3Ty HCKnlOlJHTenbHO n03opHYIO HHcyppeK1lHIO ••• cOBpcMeHHH­ 3Ta KpHTHKa nOHBHnaCb B PfiAC cTaTcM 31 TOM Volksstaat r B r C H cpa nb H Y 10 C T a lJ K y pac­ BMCCTC - pacnbmCHHe 06mcro ABH I CHHfI B pHA MCCTHbIX H npOB03­ rnallICHHC ncpMaHCHTHOH peBonIOUHH KOHUOM HeCHH ObIJ1 He TonbKO Kpax ABH I eHHH pa3Ban Bccro HC­ naHCKoro HHTcpHaUHOHana HO H OTKa3 oaKYHHCTOB OT npOB03rna­ KaM B Ha3HAaHHc 1894 KYHHCTbl npOB03rnaCHnH lJneHeHHC HcnaHHH B 6eCKOHClJHbIC ManCHbKHC KaHTOHbl H C TCM BaHO 3Hrenbc onyonHKoBan YJKC CBOIO OlJeHb l CCTKYIO KPHTHKY B qTO JKC XOTcnH OHH BBccm BMCCTO H30HpaTCITbHOH 6opbObI HlOnfi 3Toro rOAa nocne npoB03rna­ pa3pa3HBIllcMYCH IlleHHH 5 npccTynncHHeM OKTHOPfl 2 H EaKYHHCTbI 3a paoo­ 5 HOH6pH BHOBb OmelJaTaHa Intcrnationales aus dem Volksstaat Dp 3Hrenbca llICHHbIX HMH n03HUHH KOTOPblC OHH nOA AaBncHHcM 06CTOH­ TcnbCTB OAHY 3a APyroH AOnJKHbI 6bIJ1H CAaTb Pa3Be HHalJe 06CTOHT Tenepb ACJ10 B POCCHH 3Ty pa60TY HccoMHeHHo npH B03HHKHoBeHHH HaCTOHmCH pCBonlOUHH cpc­ OH npeABHAeH TaM BO AM pa60lJHX POCCHH npc06naAan MapKcH3M a HC aHapxH3M KaK co­ MHorHX MCCTax TaK KaK nOnOJKeHHC HcnaHCKOH pCBonlOUHH AaBano UHanHCTHlJeCKaH TeopHH OH HHrAc HC nonYlJHn TaKOrO npH3HaHHfI MHoro aHll lIOrHH C nOnO l eHHCM HblHClIIHHX KOMMYHHCTOB KaK HMeHHO TaM Ecpmrn H3AaHHC Vorwarts Mbl PCKoMcHnyeM BCCM HHTCPCCYIOLUHMcHoonblIIcBH3MOM 3HrcnbC Ha'lHHaCT C yKa3aHHH Ha TO 'ITO B I1cnaHHH HHTcpHaUHO­ B npOAOJ1JKeHHe AeCHTHneTHH PyCCKHe COUHanHCTbI o6pamanH HanHCTbl B OOnbIlTHHCTBC npHHanneJKanH K oaKYHHHCKOMY AnnH­ HY I ny B AoopOAeTenb H B OTCTanOM 3eMJ1CACnblJCCKOM xapaKTCpc aHCY H npOAOn l aCT CBOCM CTpaHbl YCMaTpHBanH npeHMymCCTBO OHH AYManH lJTO OC­ TaTKH HX AepeBCHCKOM 06mHHbi OC06CHHO 06J1CrlJalOT BBCACHHC CO­ KorAa B jJcBpane 1873 r 6bma npoB03rnameHa pccnyonH­ Ka HcnaHCKHC aJmHaHHCTbI OlJYTHnHCb B OlJCHb THJKcnOM no­ UHanH3Ma To 6bmo 6onbilloH 3acnyroH PYCCKHX MapKcHcTOB KOTOPblC nOA nO l eHHH I1cnaHHH B npoMblIIDIeHHoM OTHomCHHH HBnHCTCH PYKOBOACTBOM TIJ1CXaHOBa H AKccnbpoAa HancpcKop 3TOMY B033pC­ CTonb oTcTanoH CTpaHOM 'ITO TaM 0 HHro BbIpa60TaJ1H HeM e A n e H HOM y6e l ACHHe '1H TIpe l Ac '1CM PyccKoro oomCcTBa Boo6mc Aeno AOHAeT AO 3Toro I1cnaHHH AOnJKHa OY­ lJTO rrpH HeAopa3BHTocTH pyccKoro nponcTapHaTa H HCH36eJKHaH pCBonlOIJ HH rrpHMcT npc­ ACT npOHTH pa3nHlJHbiC npCABapHTcnbHble CTaAMH H YCTpaHHTb KAC Bcero 6yp a3HblH xapaKTcp XOTH 6bl Ha AonlO npOJ1CTapHaTa co CBocro nYTH IJ enbIH pHA npenHTCTBHM TIpOXOJKACHHC 3THX H Bbiliana B HCM BblAalOmaHCH ponb npeABapHTenbHbIX CTaAHH B HaHKpaT'IaMllIeC no B03MO l HOCTH 3TOT B3fJ1HA nOJ1ytlHn rocrroAcTBYlOmCC nOnOJKCHHC B PYCCKOM cny­ COIJ HaJmCTHlJeCKOM ABH I CHHH rrOKa pCBonlOUHH HC rrpHBcna nponc­ '1aH YCTaHOBHTb pecnyonHKa 3TOT cnYlJaH Mor OblTb OAHaKO TapHaT K BnaCTH KOTOPaH nOCTaBHna Borrpoc 0 HCMCnnCHHOM oc­ Hcnonb30BaH B jJ0PMC AeHTcnbHoro YlJaCTHH paOOlJero Knacca 183 BpeMH OblCTPOC YCTpaHeHHe 3THX npCnHTCTBHH H AaBaJIa B nOnHTH'ICCKOH JKH3HH 182 H B AomoM YCHneHHoH 60Pb6c pacnpocTpaHHnH nonHOM OCBOOO KAeHHH pa6olJcro Knacca He MO l CT ObITb H PC­ B060 l lJ eHliH B rrOpH lJ OK lJ HH H rrOKa HOCHTeJIHMH COl HaJIH3Ma 6hI­ 60 lJ y lJ eHCTBHH H rrOIlIeJI pa3rpoM HMeHHH B caMhIX rrepB06bITHhIX JIa HHTeJIJIHreHl HH H BbICOKOrrOCTaBJIeHHaH '1aCTh pa60'lero KJIaCCa p0pMax C YHH'ITo l eHHeM MHorHX Cpe lJ CTB rrpoH3BO lJ CTBa H TeXHH­ IIocJIe lJ oBaTeJIbHhIH MapKCH3M OKa3aJICH B He06bI'IaHHO TH I e­ '1eCKHM 06HHmaHHeM KpecTbHHe B CBOIO o'lepe lJ b rrpe lJ OCTaBHJIH JIOM rrOJIO l eHHH KaK TOJIbKO peBOJIIOl HH BTHHyJIa B CBOe lJ BH I eHHe 60JIbIlIeBHKaM rrOJIHYIO cB060 J y lJ eHCTBHH B ropo lJ ax r lJ e OHH pac­ orpOMHble MaCChI PYCCKoro HapO lJ a KOTophIe 3HaJIH JIHIlIb 0 CBOHX rrOJIO l HJIH pa60'lHX B CBOIO rrOJIb3Y TeM 'ITO C'IHTaJIHCb JIHIlIb C HX HY I lJ ax 0 CBOHX CTpeMJIeHHHX H KOTophIe rrJIeBaJIH H3 TO ocymecT­ l eJIaHHHMH a He lJ eHCTBHTeJIbHhIMH YCJIOBHHMH BHMbI HJIH HeT 06meCTBeHHO rrOJIe3HbI HJIH HeT rrpH lJ aHHhIX yCJIO­ BHHX HX Tpe60BaHHH IIpoJIeTapHaT rOJIO lJ aJI '1YBCTBOBaJI ce6H yrHeTeHHbIM H JKCrrJIY­ aTHpyeMhIM H HaCTOH'lHBO Tpe60BaJI HeMe J JIeHHOrO CBep l eHHH Ka­ 11 B JTOM rrOJIO l eHHH MapKCH3M 60JIbIlIeBHKOB He BbI lJ ep l aJI HC­ rrHTaJIHCTH'leCKOrO HpMa 11 lJ eJIaH eMY yrO lJ HOe 60JIbIlIeBHKH He rrbITaHHH MaCCOBaH rrCHXOJIOrHH OBJIa lJ eJIa HMH OHH OT lJ aJIHCb Ha HMeJIH BpeMeHH HH lJ JIH H3Y'leHHH HH J JIH pa3MbIIlIJIeHHH HeMHorH­ ee BOJIIO MH TH I eJIhIMH y lJ apaMH Bce 3 lJ aHHe pYCCKoro KarrHTaJIH3Ma 6biJIO POCCHH HeCOMHeHHO OHH CTaJIH 6JIarO lJ apH JTOMY rOCrrO lJ aMH B 'upyroH Borrpoc - 'ITO OT Toro B KOHl e KOHl OB rrOJIy'la­ pa36HTO B merrb eTCH H rrOJIyqHTbCH lJ OJI I HO 3aMeHa KarrHTaJIHCTH'IeCKOrO rrpOH3BO lJ CTBa COl HaJIHCTH'leCKHM B03BO lJ H HapO lJ HhIe l eJIaHHH Ha HbI CTerreHb lJ BHraTeJIbHOH rrpY I H­ peBOJIIOl HH OHH BbI6paCbIBaJIH 3a 60PT MapKcHcTCKylO CHCTeMY BKJIIO'IaeT lJ Ba MOMeHTa OHa HBJIHeTCH C O lJ HOH CTOPOHbI COM c06CTBeHHOCTH a C lJ pyroH - Borrpo­ BorrpOCOM opraHH3al HH OHa MbIIlIJIeHHH J JIH rr06e lJ HOrO paCl BeTa KOTOPOH OHH paHbIlIe HeMaJIO Tpe6yeT OTMeHbI '1aCTHOH c06CTBeHHOCTH Ha 0PYAHH rrpOH3BO lJ CTBa C lJ eJIaJIH IIpH HX HaY'lHOH COBeTJIHBOCTH H rrorryJIHpHOCTH HMeHH H rrepeXO lJ a HX B 06meCTBeHHoe lJ OCTOHHHe B popMe rOCY lJ apCTBeH­ MapKca OHH lJ YMaJIH OrpaHH'lHTbCH HOH KOMMYHaJIbHOH HJIH KoorrepaTHBHOH c06CTBeHHOCTH Ho OHa rrpOJIeTapHaTa - ero CJIOBe'lKOM 0 lJ HKTaType CJIOBe'lKOM KOTOPbIM OHH 3aBJIa lJ eJIH C JTHM Tpe6yeT TaK I e 3aMeHhI KaJIHTaJIHCTH'leCKOH opraHH3al HH 06mecT­ CJIOBOM OHH lJ YMaJIH 06peCTH pa3peIlIeHHe OT Bcex rpeXOB H CHOBa ­ BeHHoH opraHH3al HeH rrpOH3BO lJ cTBa Hero PYHKl HH B rrOJIHOM 3KO­ lJ yx MapKCH3Ma HOMH'IeCKOM B3aHMOCl errJIeHHH 113 PeBOJIIOl HH 3apO lJ HJIaCb BO BpeMH BOHHb COJI lJ aTbI YCTaJIH BeCTH ee DOJIbIlIeBHKH 06paTHJIHCb B caMbIX peIlIHTeJIbHbIX 3amHTHHKOB JTHX ABYX rrpe06pa30BaHHH rrpOCTeHIlIHM HBJIHeTCH rrpe06­ pa30BaHHe c06CTBeHHOCTH HeT HH'lerO JIer'le KaK JKCrrpOrrpHHpo­ JTOrO HepaCrrOJIO l eHHH rrpO lJ OJI I aTb 60pb6y OHH rrOOmpHJIH BceMH BaTh KarrHTaJIHCTa 3TO - MepaMH pll3JIO l eHHe apMHH HH MaJIO He 3a60THCb 0 TOM OKa3bIBa­ KHMH lOT JIH OHH THM CO lJ eHCTBHe repMaHCKOH BoeHHOH aBTOKpaTHH HJIH rrpOMhIIlIJIeHHOrO KarrHTaJIa eme BO BpeMeHa O lJ HHX TOJIbKO TOp­ HeT ECJIH rr06e lJ HJIa He OHa H lJ eJIO rrOJTOMY lJ OIlIJIO lJ 0 repMaHCKOH rOBoro H pOCTOBmH'IeCKOrO KarrHTaJIOB MbI BCTpe'laeMCH C TaKH­ peBOJIIOl HH TO BHHa B TOM - He HX MH IIOJIHbIH pa3BaJI apMHH lJ aJI HH3IlIHM KJIaCCaM rrOJIHeHIlIYIO CB060­ COl HaJIbHhIMH JIHIlIb lJ eJIo CRJIbI H He CBH3aHO HH C Ka­ rHrrOTe3aMH JKCrrporrpHal HHMH Kyrrl OB 113 lJ aBHa lJ 0 B03HHKHOBeHHH 6aHKHPOB 3aHMO lJ aBl eB - peo­ lJ aJIaMH KHH3bHMH lJ a l e HapO lJ HOH MaccoH B Cpe lJ HHe BeKa 6b1JIH lJ y KpeCTbHHe rroTpe60BaJIH HeMe lJ JIeHHOH Pll36HBKH KpyrrHblx HMe­ JKCrrpOrrpHHpyeMbI He TOJIbKO eBpeH HO HeB3HpaH Ha peJIHrH03­ HHH H pa3 lJ eJIa HX Me l lJ y C060H B rrOpH lJ Ke '1aCTHOro BJIa lJ eHHH qTO HOCTb JrrOXH rrpH CJIyqae KpyrrHble HMeHHH rrepelliJIH K KpeCTbHHcTBy - TaK I HJIHlIrr 6biJIO HeH36e l HO HO rrpH CHCTeMaTH'IeCKOM rrpOBe lJ eHHH JTO lJ BH I eHHe MOrJIO rrpOHTH IV H l epKOBHble H Op lJ eHCKHe COKpOBHma JKCrrpOrrpHHpOBaJI BO I paHl HH B Ha'laJIe Ka He06bI'IaHHO 60raThIH Op lJ eH XIV Be­ TaMrrJIHepoB Eme lJ 0 Toro KaK TaK 'ITO TeXHH'IeCKOe 060pY lJ OBaHHe KpyrrHhIX HMeHHH He rrOCTpa­ B03HHK cOBpeMeHHhIH COl HaJIH3M HaHBHble lJ YIlIH BH lJ eJIH B 6JIaro­ lJ aJIO 6b PO lJ HOM pa360HHHKe rpa6HBIlIeM 60ra'leH H Ha lJ eJIHBIlIeM 6e lJ HH­ JlrrH Toro BrrpO'leM Tpe60BaJIOCb BpeMH a KpeCTbHHe He XOTe­ JIH I lJ aTb JIH3Ma 6biJI lJ 0 KpaHHocTH rrpocT DbiJIO B COOTBeTCTBHH C OTCTa­ DOJIbIlIeBHKH pacrrOJIO I HJIH HX B CBOIO rrOJIb3Y TeM 'ITO BBe lJ H aHapXHIO B CTpaHe OHH rrpe lJ OCTaBHJIH Ka l lJ OH 06mHHe rrOJIHYIO CBO­ 184 KOB 6JIarO lJ eTeJIH '1eJIOBe'leCTBa 3TOT crroc06 HaCa l lJ eHHH COl Ha­ JIOCTblO pyccKoro rrpOJIeTapHaTa 'ITO DaKYHHH B 1869 r HerrOCpe lJ ­ CTBeHHO rrepe lJ BOHHOH H KOMMYHOH B B033BaHHH K PYCCKOH MOJIO­ 185 J e K11 YKa3aJl CH Ha nyTb KOTOPblM ll1CJI aTaMaH CTeHbKa Pa3I1H co­ 11M y J OBJICTBOPCHHC 60JIbll1CBHKH npl1iJ H K BnaCTH paCCCKJIH npo­ 6paBll1HH ll1aHKY C KOTOPOH OH rymm no lO KHOH POCCI1H nOKa npa­ uecc COUHaJIH3aUHH Ha J BC '1aCTI1 pa3 J eJII1JlH 06a ec MOMeHTa XOTH BI1TeJIbCTBO HC 3aXBanlJI0 11 He Ka3HHJIO cro HH O J I1H H3 HHX OC3 J pyroro HC cnoc06eH C03 J aTb HI1'1erO K113He­ npocTO KaK 3KCnpOnpl1auWl rrpoxo J HT OpraHI13aumL cnoc06Horo OHI1 CHa'iana rrocTyrrl1JIH no npcnO J aHHOMY CTeHbKOH KanHTam CTll'ICCKOe rrp0I13Bo J CTBO eCTb I1CKyccTBeHHblH opraHH3M Pa3HHbiM 06pa3Uy a 3aTCM npHHHJlHCb BOCnOJlHHTb opraHH3aUl1lO Hc TaK M03r KOToporo HaXO J HTCH B KarrHTaJlI1CTC I1JIH cro 3aMeCTI1TeJIe 4TO 6bIJIO TCCHO CBJI3aHO 11 Morno nCHCTBOBaTb JIHllIb B Hepa3pbIB­ 11 HOM C J HHCTBC ccm XOTHT YCTpaHI1Tb KarrHTaJII13M TO Hy KHO C03naTb OpraH113M ObIJIO pa30pBaHO CaM fleHHH B CBoeH 6p0ll1lOpe KOTOPblH B COCTOHHHH CPYHKUI10HI1pOBaTb 11 6C3 KanI1TaJll1CTI1'1CCKO­ OJII1 KaHll1l1e 3a J a'll1 COBCTCKOH BJIaCTI1 B anpcJIe ro M03ra TaK KC XOP0ll10 J a Ke JIy'lll1e 3TO He TaK npOCTO KaK CT J eHCTBI1H DHJIHnna IV 1918 r npH3Ha­ HJII1 CTeHbKH Pa311Ha 3TO Tpe6yeT pH J a npen­ nOCbIJIOK MaTepHaJIbHOrO H MOpaJIbHOrO CBoHcTBa BblCOKoro pa3­ IJ 0 CI1X nop Ha rrcpBoM MeCTC HaxO J I1JlHCb MeponpWlTHH BI1TWl Kanl1TaJlI1CTl1'1CCKOH opraHH3auml HC TOJIbKO npOl f3BOnCTBa no HCIIOCPC J CTBCHHOH 3KCIIp0l1pHaUHI1 3KCrrpOrrpl1aTOpoB Tc­ HO 11 c6blTa 11 J OCTaBKH CblpbH TpcoyeT TaK KC HaJIH'IHH rrpOJIeTapl1­ rrepb Ha rrcpBblH rrJIaH BblcTynacT OpraHI13aIIWl Y'leTa H KOHT­ aTa C03HalOmcro CBOI1 06J13aHIIOCTI1 He TOJIbKO no OTHOll1CHl1lO K ponH B I1pOH3Bo J cTBax B KOTOPblX KarrHTaJIHCTbI Y Ke 3Kcrrpo­ OJlI1 KaMll1I1M TOBapl1maM a 11 KO BCCMY 06meCTBY BblpaOOTaBmcro rrpimpoBaHbI a TaK Ke BO BCCX OCTaJIbHbIX oTpacnHx X03HikT­ B ccoc npl1BbI'IKI1 J 06POBOJIbHOH J I1CUl1nJII1HbI 11 caMoynpaBJICHI1H Ba J orrrOJlCTHI1M npe6blBaHI1CM B MaCCOBblX OpraHI13aUI1HX J OCTaTO'l­ Hall1a pa60Ta rro opraHH3aUI111 rron pYKOBOnCTBOM rrpone­ HO HHTCJIJIHrCHTHoro HaKOHCU J JIH Toro '1T06bl OTJIll'IaTb B03MO K­ TapHaTa Bce06mcro y'lcTa H KOHTpOJIH rrp0l13Bo J cTBa H pacrrpc­ Hoe OT HCB03MO KHOrO Hay'lHo 06pa30BaHHoro CTOHKoro xapaKTC­ J erreHHH OTCTana OT Hall1CH pa60TbI rro HcrrocpencTBCHHOH 3KC­ pOM BO K J H - OT 6CCCOBCCTHoro HCBC KCCTBCHHoro J eMarora rrporrpl1aUHH 3KcrrporrpHaTopoB C COUHaJIHCTll'ICCKHM rrpeoo­ TaM r J c nl1x YCJIOBI1H HeT Kanl1TaJII13M HC MO KCT Ha J OJIrO H C ycnCXOM 6blTb 3aMCHCH COUl1aJlH3MoM 11 B Tex 06JIaCTHX 11 pa3BcT­ BJleHI1HX npOMblll1JIeHHOCTH r J e 3T11 YCJIOBWl J ocTaTO'lHO BblCOKO pa30BaHHeM B 3THX OTpaCJIHX a 06JIaCTH 3T11 '1PC3MCPHO Ba K­ HbIC Mbl O'lCHb Cl1nbHO OTCTaJIH HMCHIIO rrOTOMY 'ITO Y'lCT 11 KOHTPOJIb HC J OCTaTO'IHO opraHlBOBaHbI pa3BI1Tbl COUl1aJII1CTI1'1CCKaH OpraHI13aUl1H J OJl KHa 6bITb 3a60TJlI1­ BO nO J roTOBJICHa BHI1MaTCJlbHblM I1CCJIc J oBaHl1eM cpaKTl1'1CCKOH 06­ fIP0I13BO J CTBa H OTpaCJII1 rrpOMbIll1JICHHOCTH rrO J BcpraJII1Cb 3KC­ CTaHOBKI1 1160 CPOPMbI KOTopbIe BPCMCHHO J OJI KHa npHHHTb HOBaH rrpOIIpHaUHH 6C3 IIpC J BapIUeJIbHOrO HccnCnOBaHI1H Toro B03MO KHa opraHH3aUHH JII1 HX COUl1aJII1CTH'ICCKaH opraHH3aUI1H HC J aHbI 3apaHcc nJIH BCCX cTpaH Bcex BPCMCH BCCX oTpacJIcif npOMblll1JICHHOCH HC cYTb coBepmeHHo rOToBbIC yTO­ 11 B 06JIaCTHX r J c TaKaH op­ raHI13aUI1H 6b1JIa 6bl B03MO KHOH J OBOJIbCTBOBaJII1Cb rrpC KnC Bccro 111111 HJlH BC'IHble 11 J caJIbI HO no J BJII1HHHCM 06CTOHTCJIbCTB MO­ O J HOH 3KCnpOIIpl1aUl1eH 1160 TOJIbKO OHa H Morna 6blTb ocymeCTBJIC­ rYT 6bITb O'lCHb pa3JII1'1HbIMH 11 J JIH ycnell1HOrO J CHCTBHH J OJI KHbl Ha 6C3 IIO J roTOBKI1 a pa60'lHe HC XOTeJII1 KnaTb HaH60JIcc uerrcco06pa3Ho COOTBCTCTBOBaTb YCJIOBWlM 3nOXI1 MOMCHTa YCTpaHcHHc H opraHH3auWl nOJI KHbl Haxonl1TbCH 06a B TCC­ fIOCJIC J CTBHH CKa3aJII1Cb 6bICTpO 3KOHOMI1'1eCKaH K113Hb POC­ CHI1 HBJIHCTCH OTCTaJIOH B TOM OTHOll1eHHH 'ITO ec rrpOMbIlunCflliOCTb HOH CBH311 J a6bl BMeCTO cymecTBYlOmero npoH3Bo J cTBa HC HaCTy­ 3aHI1MaeT rro cpaBHCHHlO C 3CMJIe J CJII1CM JIHll1b HH'ITO KHylO '1aCTb nl1J1 xaoc H nOJIHaH npHocTaHoBKa J CHTcnbHOCTH KaKoH-HI16Y J b HaCCJICHI1H Ho BHyTpH 3TOH rrpOMbilIDleHHOCTH DI1JIl1rrrr IV IIpc06J1a J alOT co­ HJIH CTcHbKa Pa3HH MOrnl1 OrpaHl1'1l1TbCH OnHOH 3Kcrrpo­ BPCMCHHbIC CPOPMbl KOJIOCCaJlbHoro np0I13BO J CTBa OHH naneKO nc­ rrpl1aUHcif H60 OHI1 HC HMCnl1 B BH J y C03naTb HOBblH cnocoo np0l13­ pepocnl1 Ty CTa J l1lO B KOTOPOH HaXO J I1JIaCb napH KCKaH npOMbIll1­ BO J CTBa fIcpexo J K COUHaJIH3MY rro TaKoMY rrpocToM ' peucrrry no­ JIeHHOCTb CTpOI1Tb HeB03MO KHO o COUl1aJIH3aUI1I1 BOIIPOC Mor H J TH JIHll1b 0 npOH3BOnHTeJIbHbIX KO­ Ho MaCCbI 6bIJIH HeTeprrCnl1Bbl OHI1 He XOTCJIH KnaTb 4TOObl naTb 186 1871 r IJ JIH nOH nOCKOJIbKY BOOOme Morna 6bITb PC'Ib OrrCpaTliBax PyCCKl1e cpa6pl1KH B orpOMHOM nOJIC 6bIJIH C rHraHT­ 187 CKHM npOH3BOnCTBOM KOrna nOCJIe YCTpaHeHHH KanHTaJIa 6JIIDKaii­ BbIX nopax npHLlaTb 3TOMY B036Y I J eHHIO KpaHHHR eCJIH xo· meM cTyneHbIO J J1H HHX rrpenCTaBJIHJICH nepexoLl HX K rOCYLlapCTBY THTe aHapXH'IeCKHH xapaKTep 3TO np06Y I J eHHe CTHXHHHbIX B rrpOH3BOnHTeJIbHbIX KoonepaTHBax noxon pa60'lero 3aBHCHT OT HHCTHHKTOB JIH'lHOCTH HepeLlKo npHHHMaeT rpy60 3rOHCTH'Ie­ pa60TbI ero Hero TOBapHlll eM Pa3Mep noro nOXona orrpeneJIHeTCH CKHR HITH ynoTpe6JIHH PHJIOco pcKoe BbIpa l eHHe 3rOll eHT­ KOJIHlleCTBOM rrponyKToB BbIHOCHMblX HMH Ha pbIHOK OHH caMH pH'leCKHH xapaKTep qeJIOBeK cTpeMHTcH B3HTb ce6e Bce nomKHbl 3a6oTHTbCH 0 C6bITe H 0 npH06peTeHHH CblpbH B nepemen­ 'ITO OH MO l eT mHX K CKJIOHHOCTH C'lHTaTbCH C 06mHM KJIaCCOBblM nOJIO l eHHeM rocynapCTBY pa6pHKax pa60'lHe no-npe J HeMy rrOJIY'IaIOT 3apa60TOK - OH LlYMaeT TOJIbKO 0 ce6e H He npOHBJIHeT TOJIbKO He OT KanHTaJIHCTa a OT rocyLlapCTBa Bbl­ OTcIOna - COTa HX 3apa6oTKa 3aBHCeJIa ropa3nO MeHee OT npOnYKTHBHOCTH HX cTpoeHHH pa60Tbl 'IeM OT HaJKHMa Ha rOCYLlapCTBeHHYIO BJIaCTb 3Ta nOCJIen­ TeJIbCKHX TeuneHlI HH KOTopble Mbl oco6eHHo Ha6JIIOLlaeM B HHH nOJI J Ha 6bIJIa 3a60THTbCH 0 c6blTe KaK H 0 Cblpbe mHpoKHX Kpyrax neKJIaCCHpOBaHHbIx 3JIeMeHTOB cTpaHbl cpe­ HY l Ha 6bIJIa 6bI npeKpaCHO nHCIJ HnJIHHHpOBaHHan H BblCOKO HH­ TeJIJIHreHTHaH pa60'laH Macca KOTopan nOHHMaJIa 6bl B KaKOH or­ HaBonueHHe TaKoro pona ne30praHH3yromH'X Ha­ H HH J HBHnyaJIHCTH'IeCKHX aHapXH'IeCKHX rpa6H­ J H npe l HeH apMHH H 3aTeM Me l J y H3BeCTHhfMH 3JIeMeHTaMH pa6o'lero KJIaCca POMHOR CTeneHH OT nponyKTHBHOCTH ee pa60Tbl 3aBHCHT 06meCT­ 6JIarOnOJIyqHe T06bl To 6blJlH COBepmeHHo HHbIe 3JIeMeHTbl He Te 'ITO B IIapH I cKoH rrpH TaKHX YCJIOBHHX npOH3BOnCTBO BeJIOCb ycnemHO Ho H npH Ta­ BeHHoe a BMeCTe C TeM - H ee c06CTBeHHoe KOMMyne YMeHbmaJIH CBOH 3apa60ToK 'IT06bI cOLleHcTBoBaTb co­ KOM pa60'leR Macce MO I HO 6bIJIO 6bl O I HnaTb nOTpe6HOH npOH3BO­ lI HaJIH3My nHTeJIbHOCTH eCJIH 6bI 6blJlH npHHHTbl He06xo J HMble opraHH3alJ H­ OHHble Mepbl KOTopbIe nOMHMO pa60'lHX npenOCTaBJIHJlH 6bl BJIH­ KaK npH TaKHX YCJIOBHHX CKJIa J bIBaJIOCb npoH3BoLlcTBO B 3KC­ nponpHHpoBaHHbIx npennpHHTHHx HCHO 3apa6oTKH B3BHH'lHBa­ HHHe Ha OTneJIbHOe npOH3BOnCTBO H BCIO OTpaCJIb npOMblmJIeHHOCTH JIHCb TaK BbICOKO HaCKOJIbKO 3TO YLlaBaJIOCb a pa60Thf naBa110Cb TaK I e rocynapcTBeHHOH BJIaCTH H nOTpe6HTem1M H eCJIH 6bl 6bl­ MHHHMaJIbHOe KOJIH'IeCTBO qTo6b1 eme CHITbHee 3aKpenHTb TaKoe 11 BOT 06HapY I H­ JIH BBeneHbl no6Y I J eHHH K pa60Te MorymHe C JIHXBOH 3aMeHHTb nOJIO l eHHe 6blJlH OTMeHeHbI aKKopLlHbIe pa60TbI KaIIHTaJIHCTH'IeCKHe noompeHHH JIHCb TaKHe pe3YJIbTaTbI KaK Ha IIYTHITOBCKOM 3aBOLle nOr110TliB­ Ho B naHHOM CJIY'Iae OTCYTCTBOBaJIa He TOJIbKO na opraHH3all HH HO H Heo6xonHMaH HHTeJIJIHreHTHOCTb H nHClI HnJIHHa pa60'leH Mac­ CbI TeM 6oJIee 'ITO BOHHa C ee nOCJIeLlCTBHHMH H 6e3 Toro HeBe l e­ meM 3a orrpeLleJIeHHbIH CpOK 96 MHl1JIHOHOB rocynapcTBeHHoH cy6­ CH J HH H naBmeM B o6meM HTore Ha 15 CTBeHHeHmyIO H HaH60JIee Hepa3BHTYIO 'IaCTb pa60'lHX nOBeJIa no ca­ rOTOBl1eHHH Moro nHKoro B036Y I J eHHH 6aHKPOTCTBO TaKoro X03HRCTBOBaHHH IIpaBna PYCCKHH pa60'lHH npHHOCHJI H3 CBoeR CeJIbCKOH 06mHHbl BblCOKoe 'IYBCTBO COJIHnapHOCTH HO 06'beM ero 6bIJI TaK l e orpa­ HHlleH KaK MHJIl1HOHOB pa6pHKaToB TOJIbKO 6e3rpaHH'IHOe nOJIb30BaHHe ne'laTHbIM CTaHKOM J J1H H3­ neHer n03BOJIHITO HeCKOJIbKO OTLlaJIHTb HeH36e l HOe Ha pa6pHKax pa60TaJIH MaJIO H B nepByIO rOJIOBY pa6o'IHe yK­ JIOHHJIHCb OT HenpHHTHoH 'IepHOH LlOKY'lHOH pa6oTbl H caMa 06l1J HHa OHO pacnpOCTpaHHeTCH TOJIbKO Ha He­ Bonpoc KaK nOCTaBHTb nH pa60Tbl B COlJ HaJIHCTH'IeCKOM o6me­ 60JIbmOR Kpyr ero TOBapHmeR OH OTHOCHTCH paBHonymHo K BeJIH­ CTBe nOCKOJIbKY OHH HeycTpaHHMbI H3naBHa 3aHHMaJI COll HaJIHCTOB KOMY 06meCTBeHHOMY lI eJIOMY Ha HeYTemHTeJIbHble HBJIeHHH 06­ 1 yPbe nyMaJI pemHTb ero TeM 'ITO npeLlOCTaBJIHJI B03HTbCH C rpH3bIO HapY I HBIIIHeCH npH TaKHX YCJIOBHHX 60JIbmeBHKH nOJI I HbI 6blJlH HepHxaM pe6HTaM JIOOHmHM KOnOmHTbCH B rpH3H l aJIOBaTbCH caMH Tpoll KHH B CBoeR 6pomIOpe Pa60Ta LlHClI HnJIH­ 3TO IOMOpHCTH'IeCKoe pemeHHe 6blJlO KOHe'lHO HeLlOCTaTO'lHbIM Ha H nopHnOK cnacYT COll HaJIHCTHllecKYIO cOBeTcKyIO pecny6JIHKY ELlHHCTBeHHoe OTBe'laIOmee COll HaJIHCTH'IeCKHM OCHOBaM H o6ema­ rOBopHT IOmee ycnex KOHe'lHO - TO KOTopoe Tpe6yeT OT TeXHHKH yCTpaHe­ HHH H3 YTOMHTeJIbHbIX OTTaJIKHBaIOlIJ HX HJIH He3L10pOBbIX pa60T HX PeBOJIIOlI HH np06ynHBman B caMbIX YHH I eHHblX C03HaHHe 'IeJIOBe'leCKOH JIH'IHOCTH eCTeCTBeHHO LlOJI I Ha 6blJla Ha nep' 188 Bpe J HbIX H OTBpaTHTeJIbHbIX CTOpOH 11 nOKYLla no He LlocTHrHYTo 189 OCTaeTCH C6aJIaHCHpOBaTb 3TH CTOPOHbI HJIH OC06CHHO BbICOKOH orr­ l1MCHHO 'ITO KacaeTCH HHTCJIJIHrCHUHH JIaTOH HJIH OC06CHHO KOPOTKHM pa60tIHM BpeMeHCM HOBoe pelliCHHe HallIJIH 60JIbllIeBHKH XOTH OHO H He OTBetIaJIO COUHamICTH'leCKHM OCHOBaM 3aTO 6blJIO B COOTBeTCTBHH C Macco­ BOH rrCHXHKOH B036Y I ACHHbIX pa60'lHX Macc OHH rrpOCTO-Harrpo­ CTO BBeJIH TpYAOBylO rrOBHHHOCTb Ho TpYAOBYIO rrOBHHHOCTb He AJIH pa60tIHX K 'leMY B03JIaraTb Ha HHX rrOBHHHOCTb TpYAa KorAa rrOA BJIHHHHeM HOBblX YCJIOBHH 3aKpbIBaJIHCb pa6pHKH OAHa 3a APyroH H3-3a HeAOCTaTKa ChlpbH TOrrJIHBa HJIH paCCTpOHCTBa TpaHcrropTa HeT TpY J OBaH rrOBHHHOCTb 6blJIa B03JIO l CHa Ha Tex KOTOPhIX rroA rrpeAJIOrOM 'lTO OHH HC pa60TaJIH 06'bHBHJIH 6ccrrpaBHbIMH ­ BrrOJIHe 3aBHCHT OT BKY­ ca COBCTCKHX Y'lPC I J CHHH OTHOCHTb JIH ee K 6YP l ya3HH HJIH HeT TO I C caMOC B OTHOIllCHHH ce H36HpaTeJIbHbIX rrpaB 06H3aHHH CC K TpY J OBOH rrOBHHHOCTH B COBeTCKOH pccrry6JIHKe Y 6YP l YCB 6bIJIH OTHHTbI 6e3 BCll­ Koro B03Harpa l J CHHll HX rrpOH3BO J HTCJIbHblC H rrpO J oBOJIbCTBCH­ H'bIC CpCACTBa HC TOJIhKO BCC HX rrOJIHTH'leCKHC rrpaBa HO O J HOBPC­ MCHHO Ha HHX HOCTb Oml TaK 'lTO 6ecrrpepbIBHO pOCJIO 'IHCJIO 6e3pa60THblX H TOJIhKO Ha HHX - B03JIO l HJIH TpYAOBYIO rrOBHH­ C J HHCTBCHHhIC B POCCHH KOTOPbIC AOJI I HhI pa60TaTb H BCC I C 6ecrrpaBHble H60 OHH HC pa60TalOT B COBCTCKOll POCCHH B KaTcropHH pa60'lHX H 6yp l YCB 3a'lHC­ JIHIOT He rro TCM PYHKUHHM KaKHC BbIlIOJIHHIOTCH B HaCTOHmec BpC­ Ha 6YP l yeB BMeCTO 06mCH popMaJIbHOH AeMOKpaTHH pccrry6JIHKa COBe­ TOB CHCTeMam'lCCKH Bhlpa6oTaHHoro rOCY J apcTBcHHoro YCTpollCTBa BBeJIa rrpOJIeTapcKylO AeMOKpaTHIO TOJIhKO pa60tIHM rrpCAO­ CTaBJIeHhI 6hlJIH rrpaBa TOJIbKO OHH J OJI I HhI 6blJIH rrOJIyqaTb J OCTa­ TO'lHOC rrpO J OBOJIbCTBHe H oxpaHY OT rOCY J apCTBa T PYTHH AOJI I HbI MH a no TeM KaKHe HCnOJIHllJIHCb J O PCBOJIIOUHH Eyp l YH B CO­ BCTCKOH pecny6JIHKe paCCMaTpHBalOTCH KaK OC06hIH COpT JIIO J CH OTnetIaTOK KOTOPhIX HCJIh3H HHtlCM CMhITb KaK Hcrp OCTaeTCH HerpOM MOHrOJI MOHrOJIOM r J e 6hI OHH HH rrOHBHJIHCb H KaK 6bI HH ncpeOACBaJIHCb TaK 6YP l yH OCTacTCH 6YP l yeM XOTH 6bI OH 6hIJIH OCTaBaTbCH 6ecrrpaBHhIMH no BHelliHOCTH --- COBceM COIlHaJIHCTH'lCCKaH MbICJIb HO IIHllIh C MaJIeHbKHM He J OCTaTKOM nO'lTH ABa rO J a cymeCTBYCT Y I e COBCT­ CTaJI HHmHM HJIH I HBeT pa60ToH 11 KaK I HBeT EYP l YH 06H3aHhI pa60TaTb HO He HMelOT npaBa HCKaTb pa6o­ CKaH pa60'laH pecrry6JIHKa H AO CHX rrop He pa3pellieHa 3ara J Ka Ha TY KOTOpylO OHH YMelOT ACJIaTb HJIH KOTOPas HM Bcero 60JIbille rro rrpeMHIO J YIlle OHH npHHY l JJ alOTCH J eJIaTb caMYIO rpH3HYlO H caMYIO OTTaJI­ 'l T o e C T h P a 6 0 'l H H OT pa3JIH'lHhIX KOMMY­ KHBalOmylO pa60TY 11 3a TO nOJIY'IaIOT HC rrOBhIllIeHHbIe a caMblC HHCTOB MbI CJIbIllIHM pa3JIH'lHbIC OTBCTbI BHatIaJIe COBeTbI pa60'lHX J cIIYTaToB 6bIJIH HC 'lCM HHhIM KaK npeACTaBHTeJIbCTBOM pa60tIHX KpyrrHhIx pa6pHK KaK TaKOBbIC OHH HBJIHJIHCb orrpe J CJIeHHblMH CTporo OrpaHH'leHHbIMH opraHH3aUHH­ MH3epHble paUHoHbI KOTOPhIMH OHH J aJICKO HC MorYT YTOJIHTb rrep­ Boro rOJIOAa l1x npOAOBOJIbCTBCHHblH rraeK COCTaBJIHeT 'leTBepTb naHKa KpaCHoapMeHCKoro HJIH CO J ep l HMOrO COBeTcKOH pecrry6JIH­ MH 6bIBllIHMH OtICHb Ba l HbIMH J JIH xOAa peBOJIIOUHH l1ACH COBC­ KOH TOB rrpHBeJIa 3aTeM K TOMY 'ITO BbIllIC J llICC H3 Bce06mcro H36Hpa­ Ha HX AOJIIO rrpHXoAHTCH O l Ha 'lCTBepTh rAe J JIH rrOCJIe l HHX TeJIbHOrO rrpaBa KapTo peJIll Ha HX AOJIIO - YtIPC J HTCJIbHOC C06paHHe J OJI I HO 6hlJIO 6bITb 3a­ Ha ee pa6pHKax pa60'lero TaM me Te rrOJIY'laIOT PYHT xJIe6a 16 p 4 MeHeHHhIM C'be3 J OM COBeTOB OAHaKO 6a3HC AJIH THX C'bC3AOB 6hIJI 113 3THX nOCTaHOBJIeHHH He BceT AYXOM crpCMJIeHHH nO l HHTb 6hI CJIHIllKOM Y30K CCJIH 6b1 OrpaHH'IHJIHCb JIHllIh COBCTaMH J crry­ rrpOJIeTapHaT Ha 60JIce BblCOKYIO cTyneHb C03AaTh 60JIee BbICOKHe TaTOB OT KpyrrHblx pa6pHK Ho KaK TOJIhKO BhIllIJIH 3a rrpC J eJIbI 3THX nOClIe J HHX H rrO l eJIaJIH HCKJIIO'lHTb 6YP l YCB H3 3aKOHa 06 pOpMbI l JA3HH a JIHIITh I a I JJ a MeCTH rrpOJIeTapHaTa B ec rrcpBO­ 6bITHeHllIHX npOHBJICHHHX Ta MCTHTCJIhHOCTb KOTopaH BHAHT Ha­ H36HpaTeJIbHOM rrpaBe TaK TOT'laC I C O'lymJIHCb B 6e36pe l HOM rrpo­ CJIa l ACHHC B B03MO I JAOCTH nOTeIllHTbCH HaKOHCU BBOJIIO HaA o6JIac­ cTpaHcTBc KaHHhIMH J O CHX nop CYAb6oH JIyqIlle O J eTbIMH JIY'lillC 06CTaBJICH­ lfCPTY MC I AY 6yp l ya H pa60'lHMH HHr J e HeJIb3H rrpoBccTH C TO'lHOCThlO OHa BJIC'lCT 3a C060ll He'lTO rrpOH3BOJIbHOC 'lTO J eJIaeT HACIO COBCTOB O'lCHb rro J aTJIHBOH K B03BcAeHHIO PYH J aMCHTa AJIH AHKTaTypbI rrpOH3BOJIa H O'lCHb HerrOAaTmmOll K C03 J aHHIO HCHO H HbIMH JIY'lille 06pa30BaHHbIMH npH pa3HY3AaHHH nOH BOJIH KaK J BHraTeJIbHOH CHJIbI PCBOJIIO­ UHH ee npOHBJIeHHH B OT J CJIbHhIX CJIyqaHx HAYT KOHC'lHO 'IaCTO J aJIbllIC 'ICM Toro xOTeJIH 6hl caMH 60JIbllIeBHKH TaK HanpHMCp 191 190 HileH 'ITO 6bIBlilHe 6YP K 'H CnlJlH Tenepb 6eCnpaBHblMH nOMOBH­ OCMenHTCH nH TpOll KHH B306paTbCH Ha nOKOMOTHB H nycTHTb KaMH TeX KTO paHblile 6bInH OX pa60'lHMH Bbl3Bana K KH3HH Ta­ ero B XOil B YBepeHHOCTH 'ITO OH Y Ke raM Ha xony Bce H3yqHT H KOe nOCTaHOBneHHe MYP3HnOBCKOrO COBeTa pa60'lox ilenYTaTOB C03ilaCT HeCOMHeHHO Y Hero OKaJanHCb 6bl Ha lJ1e l aIUHe cnoc06­ HOCTH HO XBaTHnO nH 6bI Y Hero BpeMeHH He COlilen lIH 6bl cpa3Y HaCTOHIUHM COBeT ynonHOMa'lHBaeT TOBapHIUa fpHropHR nOKOMOTHB C Pel1bCOB HnH He B30PBaJ1CH nH 6bI napOBHK npe K le 3apeeBa peKBH3HpOBaTb H ilOCTaBHTb no ero Bbl60py H npHKa­ 'leM B3HTb Ha ce6H BeileHHe 1I0KOMOTHBa Hailo oBnaileTb ero oc06eH­ 3Y B Ka3apMbI paCKBapTHpOBaHHoro B Myp3HnOBKe 6PHHCKO­ HOCrHMH TaK eClIH nponeTapHaT ilOn KeH B3HTb Ha ce6H PYKOBOil­ CTBO npOH3BOilCTBOM OH ilOn KeH CHa'laJ1a OBlIaileTb oc06eHHOCTRMH 60 KeHIUHH H ileBY­ H cneKynHHToB Ony6nHKoBaHo ilel1aIOIUHMH ero cnoco6HbIM illIR TaKOH ponH npOH3BOilCTBO He il-POM HaT BHH'l-ManeeBbIM What are the Bolschewists do­ TepnHT nepepbIBa COCTOHHHH nYCTOTbl OCTaHOBKH H oco6eHHO B rO ye 3ila apTHnnepHl1 CKOrO ilHBH3HOHa lileK Knacca 6YP K 'a3HH ing Lausanne TOM n01I0 KeHHH ilO KaKoro ilOBena BOHHa nornOTHBlilaH Bce HalilH 1919 p 10 3anacbl TaK 'ITO MbI BbIHY K leHbI nHTaTbCR 'leM oor nocnan H OCTa­ Obmo 6bI HeCnpaBe lJ1HBO OTHecTH lT0 nOCTaHOBneHHe Ha C'leT 60nblileBHKOB OHO HaBepHoe 6bmo ilnH HOX CTonb Ke rHycHo KaK HOBKOH npoH3BoilcrBa 6YileM 6YKBaJ1bHO 06pe'leHbI Ha ronoilHYIO CMepTb CaM JIeHHH C'lHTaeT He06xOilHMbIM 3aTopM03HTb npOll ecc 3Kcnpo­ ceHTH6pbCKHe y6HMcTBa ilnH 'lneHOB KOHBeHTa Ho y KaCHa MbICnb 'ITO B lI enOH MeCTHOH opraHH3all HH XOTH 6bl npHau HH H eilHHCTBeHHOH HeHaBHCTb H npe3peHHe K 6yp K 'a3HH MornH npH­ Hl1Tb TaKHe pa3MepbI 'ITO 3a ee npeilCTaBHTenHMH He TonbKO He 6bl­ EcnH Mbl 3aXOTHM ilaJ1bHeHlilyIO 3KcnpOnpHall HIO KanHTaJ1a nH npH3HaHbi npasa nOnHTH'leCKHe HO H npOCTeHlilHe 'lenOBe'leCKHe nOBeCTH B npe KHeM reMne TO nOTepnHM rrOp3 KeHHe TaK KaK Halila pa60Ta no OpraHH3all HH nponeTapcKoro yqeTa HCHO ca­ HO H BCHKoe 'IenOBe'leCKOe ilOCTOHHCTBO MOO'leBHilHO ilnH Ka K lOrO MblClIHIUerO 'lenOBeKa - OCTaeT­ CR n03ailH pa60Tbi no HerrocpeilcTBeHHoH 3KcnporrpHaUHH 3KC­ 3penOCTb nponeTapHaTa nponpHaTopoB onH KaHlilaR 3aila'la cOBeTcKoH BnaCTH ECTeCTBeHHO 'ITO MaCCOBOH nCHXHKe npHHHMaBlileH TaKHe q OpMbI H 60nblileBHKH He MornH cneno nOTBopCTBOBaTb nocne TO­ Ho JIeHHH He YHblBaeT a Ha060pOT B03BeIUaeT 'ITO HecMOTpH HH ro KaK 6YP KYH 6bInH 3KcnponpHHpOBaHbI H 06bHBneHbI BHe no­ Ha 'ITO COBeTbI BblHrPaJOT KaMnaHHIO rrpOTHB KanHTaJ1a TaK KaK KpOBHTenbCTBa 3aKOHa a nponeTapHaT 6bm B03BeileH B CBl1Tble CTa­ npouecc C03peBaHHll nponeTapHaTa HileT rHraHTCKHMH lilaraMH Bne­ nH 60nblileBHKH Bcneil 3a TeM nOilYMblBaTb 0 TOM 'lT06bI 3THX CBH­ peil OH rOBopHT TbIX ilOBeCTH ilO 3penOCTH KOTOPaH HBHnaCb 6bI npe lJ10CbmKOH BCH­ YcnOBHeM KOH COll HanH3aUHH H 3KcnpOnpHall HH nOilHHTHH nponyKTHBHOCTH TpYila HBlIHeTCR POCT KynbTYPbl H 06paJOBaHHH HapoilHblX Macc 3rOT nOilb­ MbI 3apaHee 3HanH - lI HllnHHa H T il rOBOpHT TpOll KHH Pa60Ta ilHC­ eM COBeplilaeTCH Tenepb C Heo6bI'laHHOH 6blCTPOTOH 6naroila­ pH 'ITO HaM He XBaTaeT He06xOilHMOH ilHC­ UHllnHHbl H HCTOpH'leCKOH lilKonbl MbI 3HaJ1H Bce lT0 HO 3TO HH'lYTb He Melilano HaM C OTKpbITblMH rna3aMH HilTH K 3aBoe­ BaHIDO BnaCTH Mbl 6bInH YBepeHbI 'ITO Mbl BceMY HayqHMcH H Bce c03ilailHM • nOilbeM 06pa30BaHHl1 HapoilHbIX Macc MO KeT 6bITb ilBoHKoro pOila 192 nopbIBY K CBeTY H HHHlI HaTHBe B03HHKalOIUeMY B rny­ 6HHax HapOila npH rrocpeilCTBe COBerCKOH opraHH3all HH OH MO KeT npOXOilHTb nnaHOMepHO CHCTeMaTH'leCKH nYTeM 193 llIKOJIbHOrO oGYlJ eHHH JIOCCaJIbHaH paGoTa B nOM oGJlaCTM B POCCMM rrpe 'cToHT elUe KO­ Ho BrrOJIHe OCTarOIJ HaH llIKOJlbHaH ceTb TpeGy­ eT GOJIbllIHX cpe crB UBerYlUero rrpoH3Bo 'cTBa alOlUero 3HaIJ H­ IOlUHM BCRKYIO MbICJIb BCHKHH cpaKT KOTopbIe MOrJII GbI rrOCeJlI Tb B rpY 1 paGolJ ero COMHeHHe B GO KeCTBeHHoM npOHCXO K 'eHHH co­ BeTcKoM BJIaCTH reJIbHble H3JIHllIKH PyccKoe rrpoM3Bo CTBO aeT TaKMe KaJIKMe pe 3TO KOHeIJ HO cOBepllIaeTcH B HHTepecax HCTHHbI Ee J HbIH He­ 3YJIbTaTbI IJ TO llIKOJIbHOe eJIO cTpa aeT 0 KpaMHeH CTerreHH EOJIb­ Be KeCTBeHHbIH Hapo OJl KeH GbITb orpa K eH OT JI KH H OTpaBbI llIeBHKM HeCOMHeHHO rrpMJIaralOT YCMJIHH IJ TOGbI C eJIaTb Bce B03­ GYP Kya3HoH neIJ aTM C ee MorYlUeCTBeHHbIM annapaTOM Ho r e B Gyp­ MO KHOe J JIH MCKyccTBa H HaYKH M HX pacrrpocTpaHeHMH cpe H Macc COBpeMeHHOH POCCI M 3TOT MorYlUeCTBeHHbIH annapaT alOlUMM Ho 3TH B03MO KHOCTH KpaHHe OrpaHHIJ eHbI 3KOHOMHIJ eCKMMH OKOBa­ Kya3HoH nelJ aTH rrepeBec Ha GonbllIeBHCTCKOH Ho Be b OCTpHe MH CO CTOPOHbI TaKHM oGpa30M HeJIb3H O KH aTb GbICTporo rro 'b­ GOJlbllIeBMCTCKoro Y YllIeHMH neIJ aTH HarrpaBneHO He HCKnlOIJ HTeJlb­ eMa oGpa30BaHMH oGJIerIJ alOlUero CKOPbIH M 'OCTaTOIJ HbIH POCT HO Ha Gyp a3HYIO rreIJ aTb a Ha BCHKYIO npeccy KOTopaH He npHCH­ rrpOH3BO J HTeJIbHOCTH HaoGopoT nOT pOCT HBJIHeTCH rrpe rrOCblJl­ raeT Ha BepHOCTb CYlUeCTBYlOlUeH npaBHTeJIbCTBeHHOM CHCTeMe OrrpaB aHHe nOM CHCTeMbI KopeHHTcH B HaHBHOM B3rJIH e KOM rrO DeMa oGpa30BaHMH O HaKO B3pOCJIbie JIIO M yqaTcH GOJIbllIeH lJ aCTbIO He B llIKonax Gy '­ TO CYlUeCTByeT KaKaH-TO aGconlOTHaH HCTHHa H TOJIbKO KOMMYHH­ YCTpaHBaeMbIX rocy apCTBOM MJIM oGlUMHaMH a B llIKOJIaX KH3HH CTbI Bna elOT elO nYIJ llIaH B03MO KHOCTb rrOJIYIJ HTb oGpa30BaHMe rrpe OCTaBJIHeTCH HM PyroH B3rnl1 rro KOTOPOMY Bce nHcaTeJIH He MeHee Toro TaKoe onpaB aHHe onHpaeTcH Ha eMOKpaTMeH K CYlUeCTBeHHeHllIHM ycraHOBJIeHMHM KOTOPOM rrpH­ H TOJIbKO KOMMYHI CTbI cYTb cpaHaTI KH npaB bI Ha ne KMT cBoGo a rrpeHHM H H3JIO KeHHH cpaKTOB HO KOTopaH HeceT HOCTH JI KeUOB I cpaHaTHKoB Toro IJ TO npH3HaeTcH HMH 3a Henorpe­ JI KeUbI OT pO K eHI H B eikTBHTeJIb­ C COGOH oGH3aTeJIbCTBO JIH Ka K OM rrapTHM H HarrpaBJIeHMH GOplO­ llIHMYIO HCTHHY MO KHO HaMTH B JIIOGOM JIarepe IIo JlO Kb rrblllIHee lUMXCH 3a BJIMHHHe Ha YllIOM Hapo a - rrpe OCTaBJIHTb Ka K 'OMY Bcero npOUBeTaeT TaM r e OHa He GOHTCH HHKaKoro KOHTponH r e IJ JIeHY HapO J HOro ueJIoro npaBO MCCJIe OBaTb aprYMeHTbI Bcex 3aHH­ MO KeT rOBopHTb JIlillIb npecca O l HOro-e HHCTBeHHoro HarrpaBneHMH TepeCOBaHHbIX CTOPOH M BblpaGaTbiBaTb TaKHM oGpa30M caMOCTOH­ TaKHM nYTeM OHa nOJIyqaeT OTKPbITbIH JIHCT Ha JIO Kb nO l HHMalO­ TeJIbHOCTb CY K eHHM HaKOHeu eMOKpaTmi cooGlUaeT KJIaCCOBOH lUHH yx BO Bcex KTO JIraTb MaCTep H TeM YCHJIeHHee HCnOJIb3ye­ GOPbGe BbICllIHe ee CPOPMbl I1Go npH HeM Ka K aH rrapTHH oGpalUaer­ MblH IJ eM OTIJ aRHHee nOJIO KeHHe CR K Hapo y B ero cOBoKyrrHocTM Ka K 'aH GopeTCH 3a onpe eJIeH­ CTpalliaTCH rrpaB bI I1paB 'MBOCTb Hble KJIaCCOBbIe HHTepecbI HO BbIHY K eHa BbIABHraTb Te CTOPOHbI BJIaCTBYlOlUHX l JeM GOJIbllIe OHI H 3 B e CT H H TaKHM oGpa30M HHCKOJlbKO He 3THX HHTepecoB KOTopble CBH3aHbI C OGlUMMH HHTepecaMM Bcero BbIHrpbIBaeT a Ha060pOT CTpa aeT OT YHI IJ TO KeHHH CBo60 J bI ne· Hapo a TaK cOBpeMeHHaH rocy apcrBeHHaH eMoKpaTMH rrpeB03­ IJ aTI MoraeT Y30CTb npMXO CKOM rrOJIHTMKM KaK na rrOcne J HRH Y30CTb n exoBoM I1pMBJIeKaR MaCCbI K yqacTMIO B rrOJIMTHKe eMoKpaTml He CYlUecTByeT eCTb JIHlIIb npouecc n03HaHHH eMY KaK I BceMY CO­ HeoGbIIJ aMHO paClIlHpHeT MX ropM30HT 11 nM B03MO KHOCTM oGpa30BaHMH HapO a OKa3bIBalOTCH rroxo­ no qTO Ke KacaeTCR npaB HBOCTH CY K eHHH TO npHXO lJ HTCH HOB TO­ pHTb BCJIe 3a I1I JIaTOM qTO eCTb I CTHHa A6COJIIOTHOH npaB bI KpOBl lUY lJ eJlOBeIJ eCKHX 3HaHHM HaHOCHTCl1 orpOMHbIH YlUep6 Kor­ enaeT COBeTCKaH pecrryGmfKa e­ a orrpe lJ eJleHHaR napTHH nOJIb3yeTcH CBoeH BJlaCTblO JIR MOHono· MOKpaTHH YCTpaHHeTCH JIH 3aMeHbI ee paGOIJ HMM COBeTaMM oGpa­ JIHH CBOMX B033peHMH KaK e MHocnaCMTeJIbHOH npaB I H JIH rro­ lUalOIUHMH Gyp eB B GecrrpaBHbIX M rrpeKpalUalOlUMMM CBOG0iJ Y AaBJIeHI H BCHKHX MHblX MHeHMH pOHeHHbIMM Kor a KaK rreIJ aTH CrreUManbHbIe MHTepeCbI HaeMHbIX paGOIJ MX TaKMM rrYTeM M30­ JIMPYIOTCH OT MHTepecoB oGlUecTBeHHoro ueJIoro H o 'HoBpeMeHHO paGOIJ I H JIMlliaeTCH B03MO KHOCTI caMOCTOHTeJIbHO oueHMBaTb ap­ IlecoMHeHHo MAeaJlHCTbI cpe J H PYKOBO MTeneM 60JIbllIeBH3Ma eMCTBYIOT no 06POH Bepe IJ ro OHM O HM 06JIaAalOT MCTHHOH H IJ TO TOJIbKO HeIJ eCTMBbIe MorYT AYMaTb MHaIJ e O HaKO TY l e caMYIO I1Go na oueHKa M3rOTOB­ lJ 06pylO Bepy MbI OJI I HbI npH3HaTb I 3a OTuaMM CBHlUeHHOH McnaH­ JlHeTCH J JIH Hero rrOrreIJ MTeJIbHbIM HaIJ aJIbCTBOM GOH3J1I BO YCTpaHH­ CKOH HHKBM3MUMM KYllbTYPHbIH M 06pa30BaTeJlbHblH IIOA'beM Ha­ rYMeHTbi GOplOIUHXCH KJIaCCOB H napTHH 194 195 i pOAHbIX Mace npH TaKOM peX HMe HH'IerO He BbIHrpan KOHeqHO eCTb pa3HHll a Me l 1lY OTll aMH CBHIll eHHOH HHKBH3Hll HH H BO l AHMH BbICOKaH Mopanb pa3BHBaeMaH OOPIOIll HMCH nponeTapHaToM 3aBHCHT OT nBYx MOMeHTOB KaK caMbIe oenHbIe H cnaobIe B oOIll e­ COBeTCKOH pecnyonHKH T e HHCKonbKO He nOMoranHCb MaTepHaJIb­ cTBe nponeTapHH MorYT OTCTOHTb ceoH nHIllb B caMOM TeCHOM eM­ Horo H nYXOBHoro npOll BeTaHHH Mace Ha nOH rpeUIHOH 3eMne OHH HeHHH IlpenaHHocTb H caMOOTpe'IeHHe B pHnax nponenpHaTa ll e­ COBeT­ HHTCH BbIIIIe Bcero B npoTHBOnOnO I HOCTb Knaccy KanHTanHcToB CKHe l e neHTenH nYMalOT MeTOnaMH HHKBH3Hll HH npHBeCTH MaCCbI rne YBIDKeHHe oKpY I alOIIIHX 3aBHCHT OT pa3Mepa ooraTCTB KaKHM XOTenH TonbKO OOeCneqHTh nYIIIaM cnaceHHe B HHOM MHpe M OHH K npOll BeTaHHIO BO Bcex HanpasneHHHX COBepIIIeHHO He 3a­ ObI nYTeM OHH HH ObIllH Ha I HTbI OMaKO MeqalOT KaK OHH TonKalOT nH MaCChI K orpyoeHHIO HapHAY C BbICOKHM ypOBHeM HapOAHOro 00pa30BaHHH npenno­ OnHO Moryqee 'IYBCTBO conHnapHOCTH He HanonHHeT COll HanHCTHlJeCKOH MopanH Ha KOTOPOH nOn l HO 6hITb nOCTpoeHO MO­ HOBoe OOIll eCTBO TaKoe qyBCTBO conHnapHOCTH MO l eT OKa3aTbCH panb npOHBJUlIOIll aHCH He TOJIbKO B MoryqHX COll HanbHbIX HHCTHHK­ npOTHBOOOIll eCTBeHHbIM Korna OHO OrpaHHqeHO Y3KHM KpyrOM Tax qyscrne conHnapHOCTH caMOOTpeqeHHH npenaHHOCTH HO H B n06HBalOIll HMCH CBOHX BhIrOn 3a C'IeT OCTanbHoro OOIll eCTBa HanpH­ cnOCOOHOCTH 3TH qYBCTBa pacnpOCTpaHHTb 3a npenenbI Y3Koro KPY­ Mep pOnOBHTOrO nBOpHHCTBa OlOpOKpaTHH Kopnyca oqmll epOB CbWKOH J 1lH COll HanH3Ma HBnHeTCH BbICOKaH Mopanb Macc - qTO nOAHHMaeT conHnapHOCTb COBpeMeHHoro nponeTapHaTa Ha ra TOBapHIll eH Ha Bce OOIll eCTBO TaKYIO CHflbHO pa3BHTYlO Mopam MbI Y I e HaonlOnanH cpeM npo­ JIeTapHeB IlapH l cKoH KOMMYHbI M OHa He3HaKOMa Macce KOTO­ BbICOTY COll HanHCTHqeCKOH MopanH npDlIeTapHaT lIe MO l eT nOOHTbCH paH HbIHe 3anaeT TOH Y OonbIIIeBHKOB OHa nOJI I Ha ObITb C03naua Tenepb BO qTO ObI TO HH CTano TaK no - npe I rJ e Bcero pacnpo­ CTpaueHHe ee Ha Bce qenOBe'IeCTBO ooycnoBneHHoe C03HaHHeM qTO CBoero OCBOOO I rJ eHHH He OCBO­ OO l naH B TO l e BpeMH Bcero nlOnCKoro pona Y I e MononOH 3HrenbC O l HnaeT OT npH3HaHHH nora cpaKTa Be­ TpOll KHH B3bIBaeT 3TY KOMMYHHCTHqecKYIO Mopanb TOBapHIll H MbI oOH3a­ HbI HeMe J 1leHHO nponoBenOBaTh nOnnep I HBaTh pa3BHBaTb H YKpeIlJlJITb 3TO nH'IaHIIIerO nOnbeMa nponeTapCKOH MopanH B CBoeM Tpyne Ilono­ l eHHe paOoqero Knacca B AHrnHH 2 H3n CTp 299 OH npHxOnHT K 3aKnlO'IeHHIO OJIarOpOAHeHIIIaH 3anaqa HalIIeH napTHH Ha Bcex nyTHX ee neHTenbHOCTH -Paoon MCll HJIJlHHa H T n • B TOH Mepe BKaKoH nponenpHaT BOHpaeT B ceOH COUHa­ JIHCTHqeCKHe H KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHe meMeHTbI B nOH HMeHHO Mepe peBonlOUHH TepHeT B KpOBOnpOJIHTHOCTH MCTHTeJIbHO­ Ua 1lYMaeT nH TPOll KHH CYTKH JIHIIIb qTO HOBYIO Mopanb MO l HO C03naTb 3a Me J 1leHHO HapacTaeT OHa CTBa He TepnHT omaraTenbCTBa A oOHoBneHHe npoH3BOn M ecnH KOMMYHHCTHqeCKaH Mopanb He B03HHKJIa no Ha'Iana COll HanH3all HH n03nHO 1lYMan 0 ee HaCa l ne· KaKHM nYTeM xoun HacaMTb ee nOB a T b Ee XOTHT n p 0 nOB e ­ KaK oynTO Korna-HHOYUb OT nponOBeneH MopanH no­ nyqancH TonK EcnH MapKCHCTbI B03JIaralOT CBOH Hane I rJ bI Ha npo­ nOBenb MopanH TO no nOKa3bIBaeT nHIIIb B KaKOH TynHK OHH 3a· BnpO'IeM HOBaH Mopam non I Ha ObITb He TonbKO nponoBenye· Ho KaK Mopanb ecn npo1lYKT HarneH l H3HH H HaIIIHX cTpeMneHHH B HHX OHa HaxOMT CBoe nHTaHHe no HX OOPa3Y OHa cKnanbIBaeTcH 196 CTOHIll erO a He J 1lH 6ynymero OH CTpeMHTCH YCTpaHHTb KaK ByeT O l eCTOqeHHe nponeTapHaTa npOTHB CBOHX yrHeTaTeneH KaK He06xOMMOCTb KaK BIDKHeHIIIHH pbIIJar B 0 3 H H K a ­ 10 Ill e r 0 pa60qero UBH I eHHH B 0 3 B bI III a ­ eTCH Ha lJ OH OpanHCb Ma a H nOnnep I HBaeMa OH npH3HaeT ero nHIllb B ero HCTOpHIJeCKOM 3HaqeHHH J 1lH Ha­ pa3 nOT pa3 1J Op OH npH3HaeT n03TOMY nOKa pa3nOp CYIll eCT­ HHH JIHIIIb nOCJIe 3KcnpOnpHall HH M CTH H oeIIIeHcTBe CBoeM KOMMYHH3M no npHHll Hny CBoeMY CTOHT Han Pa3 1J OPOM Me I JJY oyp a3HeH H nponeTapHaTOM H H X eCTb 3THM lJ eno P a 0 0 'I H x H 0 0 H O l eCTOqeHHeM qenOBe'IeCTBa a HOO He on- KpoMe Toro HH OAHOMY KOMMYHHCry He npHneT B rOJIOBY npOHBnHTh MeCTb Ha IJ OT IJ ellbHbIMH e lJ H­ HHuaMH HnH BOOOIll e lJ YMaTb IJTO OT IJ eJIbHbIH oyp a Mor ObI 197 B HOBoH 06CTaHOBKe nOCTynaTb HHa'le 'leM nocTynaeT OH CaM H HX rOCnO lCTBO Ha'ianOCb C 06bHBJIeHHH Bcex KTO He nmIcan non I103TOMY 'leM 60IlbII1e aHrmfHCKHe pa60'lHe npOHHKHYTCH co I1X nynKY 6ecnpaBHbIMH H onpOKlmYTbIMH Ha IHO HHmeTbI OJlaro­ UHanHCTH'IeCKHMH H I eHMH TeM 60nbII1e HX TenepeII1Hee O l e· IapH TOMY 'ITO OHH YHH'lTO KeHHe KJIaCCOB CBH3aJIH C C03 1aHHeM HO­ CTO'leHHe KOTopoe OCTaBaHCb TaKHM l e HanpH I eHHblM Boro KJIaCCa pa60B H3 PH IOB npe KHeH 6yp a3HH 11 npeBpaTHB OKa l eTCH H3­ COUHanHCm'leCKYIO 60pb6y 3a OCBOOO K IeHHe H nO IHHTHe Bcero '1e­ nHII1HHM TeM 60nbII1e HX II1anl npoTHB 6yp a3HH yTpaTHT JlOBe'leCTBa Ha BbICII1YIO cTyneHb BO B3pbIB O KeCTO'IeHHH H MCTHTeJlb­ KaK Tenepb Bce l e HH K '1eMY He npHBe l eT - E xapaKTep l HKOCTH H CBHpenOCTH II1 e M 0 I 1I 0 pHaT 6 bI Jl 0 C I e JI a T b C n H 0 bI B e Cb o 'l e H b OOJlbII1eBHKH He nOnHHJIH paoQ'lero KJlaCCa Ha BbICII1YIO CTyneHb a npOTeKana Obi nponpHaUHIO 3KcnponpHaTopOB OTOpBaJlH OT ee TeCHeHII1eii 3aBHCH­ Ho 3TO Y l e lIeB03MO l HO Y Ke CnHII1· MOCTH C C03 1 aHHeM HOBOH 06meCTBeHHoii opraHH3aUHH nHII1b B CBH­ KOM n03 1 HO 3HrenbC O KH I an B 1845 r nOKa cKoporo HacTyrme­ HHH peBonlOUHH KOTopaH H pa3pa3HJIaCb B 1848 r HO He B AHrnHH a Ha KOHTHHeHTe H He KaK nponeTapCKoe BOCCTaHHe KayrcKUU JI HOCTH npOTHB OT IeJlbHbIX JlHU npe l aHHbIX HCTH3aHHHM H nblTKaM pa3BpaTHJlH ero OHH eme YBeJlH'IHJlH IeMOpanH3aUl11O TeM 'ITO 3KC­ oopb6a OHa M H pH O n p 0 JI eTa • He KOMMYHHCTH'leCKHM pa3pa3HnaCb BOO 0 • Bce Ke l YMalO 'ITO no Ha'lana COBepII1eHHO OTKPblTOH BOHHbI 6e l HbIX npOTHB 60raTbIX CTaBII1eH B AHr­ 3H C KOTOpoii na 3KcnponpHaUHR 06pa3yeT COUHaJlHCTH'IeCKYIO CTH­ XHIO OTopBaHHafI OT noii CBfI3H 3KcnponpHaUHH CO Cpe lCTB npoH3­ BO lCTBa nepeKHHyJlaCb Ha Cpe lCTBa npOnOBOJlbCTBHH OTCIO Ia oaHnHm3MY H I eaJlH3HpOBaHHoMY B 06pa3e K CTeHbKH Pa3HHa Bce­ ro nHII1b O lHH II1ar JIHH HeOTBpaTHMoii Cpe l H nponeTapHaTa pacnpOCTpaHHTCH HC­ Hble nOllHTHH 0 COUHanbHOM Bonpoce no KpaiiHeii Mepe B Ta­ OTpHuaTenbHYIO nporpaMMy 00JIbII1eBH3Ma MaCCbI BocnpH­ KOM OO'heMe '1ro KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKOii napTHH ynaCTCH npeo­ HHJIH 6e3 BCHKHX 3aTpY IHeHHH He HY KHO HH OOPOTbCH 10­ l OJleTb l lIHTenbHbIH Y Kac KeCTOKOii noii BCHKHe 00H3aHHOCTH HY KHO TOJlbKO opaTb XBaTan H H npe l OTBpaTHTb peBonlOUHOHHOH CTHXHH npHCBaHBaTb 'ITO MO KHO HJlH KaK Y I HBHTeJlbHO jJ0PMYJlH­ 9-e TepMH I Opa pOBan J1eHHH fpaOb HarpaOJIeHHOe pyccKorO 60nbII1eBH3Ma OepJlHH lleBHToe TepMH I Opa ObIJIO l HeM Korna Po6ecnbep nan H napH K­ faBpOHCKHH oanaHC 1919 CTp 39 CKoe rOCnO l CTBO Teppopa pYII1HnOCb I10 l OOHOe KpYII1eHHe XOTen B npe l OTBpaTHTb 311renbC B nOM HanpaBnemm l On KHbl 6bIJIH BOBaTb KOMMYHHCTbI ynanHH H3 KnaCCOBOH OOPbObI 3JIeMeHTbI CBH­ penOCTH H 3BepCTBa nponfB oyp a3HH H BbI IBHraH Ha nepBbIH nJIaH B TaKOM pO le no J ep KHBan H rrporrOBe l OBaJI 00JlhlIleBH3M HO­ BylO KOMMYHHCTH'IecKYIO MOpaJlh oe3 KOTOPOH HeB03MO KHO COUHa­ Bce'lenOBe'leCKHe HHTepeCbI KaK BH IHO 3HreJIbC nOHI1MaJI nO l KOMMYHH3MOM He'lTO HHoe '1eM Tenepb 60JlbII1eBHKH COOTBeTCTBHH C TaKHMH B033peHHHMH aTaMaH CTeHhKa Pa3HH yBeKoBe'leH cOBeTcKoH pecny6JlHKOii B naMHTHHKe qero XOTen 3HrelIbC Toro IOOHBaJIHCb nHCTH'IeCKOe cTpOHTeJlhCTBo 3ro 03Ha'lano JlHII1b pacTymylO Ie· MopanH3aUHIO nanbHeHIlJHX '1aCTeH pycCKoro rrponeTapHaTa KaK pa3 Te pYCCKHe COUHanHCTbI C KOTOPbIMH 60JIbII1eBHKH HaxO­ TaKoBbI 6bmH rrOcne l CTBHfl y KacHYBlllHe HneanHCTOB-OOJlbII1e· l HIIHCb B HenpHMHpl1MOM npOTHBOpe'lHH OOnbII1eBHKH O lep KaJIH BHKOB HO OHH OblJIH B COCTOflHHH 3aMeTHTb nHII1b pe3yJlhTaTbI a Bepx Ha l CBOHMH TOMY 'ITO COUHaJIHCTH'leCKHMH npOTHBHHKaMH OJIarO l apH OHH l HKOCTb H CBHpenOCTb B 0 3 H H K a 10 mer 0 pa­ 60'lero l BH KeHHH 06pamnH B IBHraTeJIbHYIO CHJIY CBoeH peBOJIIO­ UI1H onarO l apH TOMY 'ITO OHH BynbrapH3HpOBaJlH COUl1anHCTI1'1e­ He HX rrpH'lHHbI HOO no XOnHMOCTb Bbl6poCHTb nOCJlenHee 3HaMeHOBaJlO ObI c060H Heoo­ 3a 60pT BCIO HX npaBluemcTBeHHYIO CH- CTeMY· OT'laHHHO HCKanH OHH cpe lCTBa npHBHTb MaccaM KOMMYHHCTH­ 11 CKoe l BH KeHHe 06paTHB IeJIO '1eJIOBe'leCTBa B IeJlO O lHHX TOJlbKO '1ecKYIO MOpaJIb pa60'lHX olIarO l apH TOMY 'ITO OHH B03BeCTHJlH BceBIIaCTHe HaeM­ CHCTbI OTBa KHbIe peBOJlIOUHOHepbI HOBaTopbI KaK TonbKO HbIX paOO'lHX HapH I Y C oe lHeiiII1HM KpeCTbHHCTBOM B nepeBHHX KylO yBepTKy CTaporo OOmeCTBa C rrOMOmblO KOTOpoii OHO nblTa­ 198 HH'lerO HCHoro OTblCKaTb He MornH OHH MapK­ KaJI­ 199 eTCR CMbITb C ce6R CBOH C06CTBeHHbIe rpeXH T p H 6 Y Han TOp r a K a • CTBa BonH Ho KaK MO KeT OblTb rapaHTHpoBaHo CTpO KaHlIIee K a 3 H b To eCTb Teppop e lJ HHCTBO BonH nO lJ 'lIHHeHHeM BonH ThlCR 'lI Bone HeMHorHX ITeHHH lIHlIIeT B U HTHpoBaHHoH Y Ke HeCKonbKO paJ 6polIIIOpe 0 3TO no l tlHHeHHe lIpH H lJ eanbHOM C03HaHHH H lJ HCu HIIJ1HHH' 6nH KaHlIIHX 3a lJ a'llax cOBeTcKoH BnaCTH pOBaHHOCTH yqacTHHKoB ooru en pa60TbI HanOMHHaeT MR rKOe PYKOBO lJ CTBO lJ HpH Kepa opKecTpa OHO MO KeT nony'l HTb Ke· TpH6YHan R BnR eTCR HHcTpYMeHToM BOCCTaHHR lJ HCU HlInH CTOKYIO $OPMY lJ HKTaTOpCTBa ecnH OTCYTCTBYIOT H lJ eanbHaH HbI Eru e He lJ OCTaTO'llHO YR CHeH lIPOCTOH H O'lleBH l HbIH $aKT 'liTO ecnH rnaBHoe HeC'lIaCTbe POCCHH rono lJ H 6e3pa60THI a TO no 6e lJ CTBHe MO KHO lI06e lJ HTb He Me'llaMH H lIapeHHeM B 3a06na'lHbIX BbICOTax a BceCTopOHHeH BceOXBaTbIBaIOru eH op· raHH3au Hen H lJ HCQHnnHHoH 'liTO no nOMY B MYKax ronO lJ a H 6e3pa60THUbI nOB H H e H B C R K H H KTO HapYlIIaeT pa· 60'llYIO lJ HcQHnnHHY B nI060M npe lJ npHR THH B nI060M lJ ene ­ 'liTO Ha lJ O YMeTb CTaBHTb HO B H HOB H 0 r 0 nepe lJ lJ HCu HIIJ1HHHpOBaHHOCTb H C03HaHHe p a 3 bI C KaT b TpH6YHaIT H no CHX nop MbI HCXO l HJ1H H3 Toro tlTO C03HaHHe H lJ HCu HnnHHH' pOBaHHOCTb paoo'llero Knacca HBnHIOTCR npe lJ nOCbIl1KOH 3penOCTH nponeTapHaTa 6e3 CaM ITeHHH B npe lJ HCnOBHH K U HmpOBaHHOH 6pOlIIIOpe rOBopHT no· 6e3 KanOCT' nO lJ 06HaH peBOnIOu HR MO KeT OblTb ycnelIIHo ocymecTBneHa nOKapaTb nHlIIb npH 'lIeCTBe ne3 KanOCTHbIMH K'apaMH KOTOPOH HeB03MO KeH HCTHHHbIH COUHanH3M PYCCKOMY nponeTapHaTY lJ On KHa 6bITb HHManaCb Mopanb HITH nHlIIb y6HBanCR nOCne lJ HHH OCTaTOK ee ne3­ KanOCTHbIe KapbI R BnR IOTCR HeH36e KHbIM 3nOM cTaporo nOpR lJ Ka H60 eMY 3aKa3aHbI nym K c03 lJ aHHIO nYtllIIeH MopanH npH nOMoru H nyqlIIHx KH3HeHHbIX ycnoBHH COu HanHCm'leCKHH pe KHM He BH lJ R · ru HH HHoro nym l l1R np06Y K J eHIDI B npOneTapHaTe 60nee BbICOKon MopanH KaK TOl1bKO 6e3 KanOCTHbln TpH6YHan 06HapY KHBaeT TeM nHlIIb CBoe c06cTBeHHoe OaHKpOTCTBO caM 0 C T 0 H Ten b HOM HCTOpHtieCKOM TBOp' 0 n b III H H C T B a H ace n e H H H H npe K lJ e Bce· ro oonblIIHHCTBa TPY lJ R ru HXCH B6HTa KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKaH Mopanb lJ a6bl OH TaKHM 06pa30M C03pen lJ ITR COU HanH3Ma Ho HHr lJ e eru e 6e3 KanOCTHbIMH KapaMH He no lJ ' 0 H nocne Toro KaK OH 3aCBH l eTel1bCTBOBan 'liTO COu HanH3M He eCTb npOAYKT MeHblIIHHCTBa a nHlIIb 60nblIIHHCTBa H H R Hac e n e • H TOITbKO npe K lJ e Bcero a He HCKnIOlIHTenbHO TPY lJ R ru HX' CR H TaKHM 06paJOM npoTHs BonH npH3Han HeOTbeMneMOCTb lJ e· MOKpaTHH - OH npo lJ On KaeT 1IHlIIb TOr lJ a KOr lJ a nponeTapHaT H Oe lJ HeHlIIee KpeCTbR H' CTBO HaHAYT S ceoe lJ OCTaTOtiHO C03HaTenbHOCTH H lJ eiiHOCTH caMOOTpe'lleHHR CTOHKOCTH 6Y lJ eT ooecne'lieHa n06e lJ a cOu Ha· nHCTHtieCKOH pesonIOu HH llHKTa1 'pa B cyru HOCTH KaK Ka KeTCR H caM ITeHHH He O KH lJ aeT ocoooro nO lJ 'beMa MopanH OT CBOHX TpH6YHanOB HOO TOT'laC BCne lJ 3a TpeOo· BaHHeM 3THX TpHOYHanOB OH BbI lJ BHraeT HOBoe lJ HKTaTOpCKHM B n aCT HeM H AnOKa 'liTO n06e lJ a lJ on KHa OhlTb ooecnetieHa TpHoYHanaMH H Py· KOBO lJ HTeJ1 liMH npOH3BO lJ CTB 0 Ha l eneHHH HeOrpaHiitleHHbIM nonHO' PeBonIOU IDI TonbKO 'liTO pa30HJ1a cTapeiilIIHe KpentiaHIIIHe H THrtlaHlliHe OKOBbl B KOTopble MaCCbl ObmH 3arHaHbI KHYTOM PYKOBO lJ HTeneH npOH3BO lJ CTB 3 T O O bI n O B tI epa BCR KaH MexaHHtleCKaR KpynHaR npOMhllIIJIeHHOCTb a no KaK pa3 03HatiaeT HCTO'lHHK npOH3BO lJ CTBa H $YH lJ aMeHT COU HanH3Ma - 200 Tpe6yeT 6e3ycnoBHoro H CTpO KaHlIIerO e lJ HH' C e r 0 lJ H R Tpe6yeT HMeHHO B HHTepecax COu HanH3Ma C nOB H 0 r o n 0 lJ 'lI H H e H H R p Y K 0 B 0 lJ H Ten e H Ta Ke peBOnIOQIDI 0 Mac C e C n p e K o· e lJ HHOH Bone T P Y lJ 0 B 0 r o n p 0 Q e C c a 201 CB060Aa B'Iepa mUllb 3aBOeBaHHafl CerO lIffI CHOBa OTHMMaer­ CfI H60 MaCCbl He HaIllllM B ce6e AOCTaTO'lHOH C03HaTellbHOCTH MAeHHOCTM caMOOTpe'leHHfI M CTOHKOCTH Ho Ha CTp 7 H3 OTCYT­ CTBHfI 3THX oc06eHHocTeH BbJBOMTCH HeB03MO l HOCTb rrpOBe ' leHlfH COIJ Hami3Ma a Ha CTp 52 B HHTepecax COIJ HaITH3Ma 6ecrrpeKoclloBHoe rrOA'IHHeHMe Tpe6yeTcH He3pellbIx Macc ' IHKTaTopY-PYKOBO­ AHTemo 3THM HX rrOllO l eHMe HH3BOAHTCfI Ha CTerrCHb Ha KOTOPOH OHH HaxO ' lHJIHCb rrpM KarrHtaJlHCTMlfeCKOM rrpmi3BO ' lcTBe TaM OHR 6bIJIH 1l0A'lHHeHbI KarrHTaJlY HO Bce l e He 6ecrrpeKOCJlOBHO rrOAIfM­ HeHb Ho JIeHHH 3AeCb HeCOMHeHHO Haurn TOIfKH 3peHHfI COBna ' laJOT HY I AeHMfI KOTOPbIH OHa AonYCKaeT eCTb npHHY I AeHHe III H H C T a HaA M e H h III H H C T B 0 M 'ITO 3Ta AMKTaTypa B OTllMIfMe OT KarrMTallMCTMlfeCKoro PYKOBO ' lCTBa OCYllleCTBJlfleTCH MaccaMM TPYAHlllHXCfI H 3KcTmyanlpyeMblx OCYllleCTBJIfieTCH taK I e opraHM3alJ HflMH KOTopble rrOCTpoeHbl taK 'ITO MMM MaCCbI rrp06Y I J aJOTCfI M rrO ' lHMMaJOTCH K HCTOpH'leCKOMY TBOp'IeCTBY COBeTCKHe opraHM3alJ MH rrpMHa J Jle l aT K opraHH3alJ MHM TaKoro po ' la' 60 JI b ­ IIpHHY I ' IeHHe B nepc­ XOAHYJO 3noxy OT KanHTaJIH3Ma K COJJ HaITM3MY eCTb npMHY I J eHHe 60JIbIllHHCTBa TpYMlllMXCH Ha ' l MeHbIllHHCTBOM KanHTaITHCTOB Ho BO BTOPOH cTaMH peBOmOIJ HH 0 KOTOpoli rOBopMT JIeHHH Kor ' la pa60'lHe c6pOCHJIH C ce6f1 IJ enH pelfb HAeT He 06 310M 3AeCb pe'lb HAeT 0 npHHY I ' IeHHH oT ' IellhHblx JIHIJ HaA pa60lfHMH MaccaMH qTO 310T pon npHHY I neHHfI HecOBMeCTHM C ' IeMOKpaTHeli YTeillaeT ce6H M CBOJO rry6llHKY KOHeIfHO TeM l eMoKpa­ TMH TaK I e He HCKJIJOlfaeT npMHY I ' IeHHH HO eAHHCTBeHHbIH BHA npM­ JIeHHH He onpOBcpraeT HH e ' lHHblM CJIOBOM OH nblTaeTCfI C 1 eJIaTb ero npHeM­ lleMbIM npH nOMOlllH JOKyc-noKyca BhIBOAH H3 npHHY I ' IeHHfI Macc Ha ' l OT ' IellhHhIMH KanHTaITHCTaMH AllH npOBe ' leHHH COJJ HaITH3Ma BbICOKOli CTeneHH COBMeCTHMOrO C ' IeMOKpaTHeli - B ' Ia l e eCJIH OHO 03HalfaeT caMOBJIaCme OT ' ICJIbHhIX llHIJ Han MaccaMH OH YTBep l ' IaeT KaK HMeHHO YCTpaHeHHe H Y ' IYIIleHMe BCflKOH KpHTHKH crroc06­ IIOJTOMY HeT peIllHTeJIbHO HHKaKoH rrpHHIJ HnHaITbHOH pa3- cTByeT np06Y I J eHHJO Macc H rrOAHflTHJO HX K HCTopHlfeCKOMY TBOp­ HHlJ bI Me l ' IY COBCTCKOH Le COUHaJIHCTH'IeCKoH ' IeMOKpaTH­ lfeCTBY 6bIllO TOllbKO IfTO rrOKa3aHO COBeTCKaH opraHM3alJ HH HM­ eHH npHMeHcHHeM ' IHKTaTOpcKoH BJlaCm OTAeJIhHblX JIHU· Ifero HC MeHfleT B 310M CMblClle Ho KaK MO l eT l elle3Hafi IJJIKTaTY­ pa HeMHorHX rrpM 6ecnpeKOCllOBHOM rrOAIfHHeHHH Macc K CB060AHOH caMOAeflTellbHOCTH nOBeCTH Ifcpe3 opraHH3alJ HJO 3THX Macc KTO MaccaMH M36MpaeTCH HMH MO l eT 6bITb CMellleH B CBoeM rrepe­ H36paHl fH ' IOJI I eH C HHMH CIfMTaTbCfI - MO l eT 6hITb H TaK TH3M Ho B TaKOM CJlYlfae coBeTcKHli ' IeMOKpa­ flBllfleTCfI cBoe06pa3HhiM pacTeHHeM K KOTOPOMY MO l HO npHBHTh JIJ060li npoH3BOll CCJIH OH TOJlbKO npHKpbIT HMeHeM CO­ BCer ' la flBllHeTCfI 3aBMCH' MbIM OT HHX He MO l eT rrpOBeCTH HM'lerO If TO He BCTpelfaeT MX 0 ' 10­ UHallH3Ma ECJlH pa604He H3BeCTHorO rrpoH3Bo ' lCTBa ' IOll l HbI 6pemlfl OH MO l eT CllOMHTb yrropCTBO OTAellbHbIX IfJleHOB M36paB­ IIleH ero opraHH3alJ HH eCJlM OHM HAYT HanepeKOp 60llblllHHCTBY HO ero npeMy ' IpOCm HacTyrrMT CKOPbIH KOHelJ KaK TOllbKO OH nOIlbI­ TaeTCH HaBH3aTb MM BonpeKM HX l ellaHHJO CBOH 3aKOHbl IIo3TOMY llH'lHafi AHKTaTypa H ' IeMOKpaTmr HCCOBMccmMb 3TO OTHOCHTCfI TaK I C H K COBCTCKOH AeMOKpaTHH JIeHHH 3aflBllH­ CT KOHeIfHO IfTO TaKOH cnoc06 CY I ' ICHHfI HC BbI ' Icp I MBaCT KpHTH­ KH Ho KpYTOCTbJO CBOHX BbIpa l eHHH OH nblTaeTCH B03MeCTHTb cna60CTb aprYMeHTaIJ MM M60 OH HC HaXO ' lHT HH'lerO llYlfillero ' IIUI HMH a ' IOll l eH 6bITb MM HaBH3aH CTOflllleH Ha ' l HHMM HHCTaHUHeli Tor ' la IJ eHrparrbHblH HCnOJlHHTeJIbHhlli KOMlneT HaCa l ' IaJOlllHH ' IHK­ TaTopoB AOll l eH caM A06HBaTbCfI ' IHKTaTOpCKOH BJIaCTH COBeThl ' IOll l HhI npeBpaTHTbCH B TeHb a npeACTaBJIeHHbJe B HHX MaCChi noTepfiTh BCflKOC BllHflHHC C TaKHM l e ycnexOM C KaKHM MJOHxraY3eH BhlTaCKHBarr ce6f1 Hafl He aHapXHCTbl Mbl ' IOJl I JlbI npH3HaTb HeOTbeMJle­ Mocn rOCYAapCTBa Le npHHY I AeHHfI B nepeXOAHoe BpeMH OT KanMTallH3Ma K COIJ HaJIM3MY 202 11 COBeT Ja6pH'lHhIX ' IenYTaTOB B TaKOM cllY4ae TepfieT npaBo rOJIoca 3a C06cTBeHHYJO KOCY H3 60JIOTa MO l eT pa604afl Macca JIHIIleH­ B03pa l eHMfI KaK TOllbKO TO IfTO eCllH Mbl 6ecnpeKoc­ llOBHO nOA'IHHHTbCfI PYKOBO ' HTellJO TO OH He MO l eT 6b1Tb H36HpaeM C03HaTellbHOCTH HAeHHOCTH caMOOTpe'leHHfI H CTOHKOCTH caMa H36HpaTb ' IllH ce6f1 AHKTaTopa C TeM 4T06hl OH nO ' lHHMaJI ee Ha BhlCIIlYJO cTyneHb pa3BHTHH H 6e3BOllbHO CKllOHflTbCfI nepe ' l HHM 203 Korna OH Tpe6yeT OT Hee neiicTBlIH CBH3aHHbiX C C03HaTenbHOCTbIO CaMOOTpelleHHeM H CTOHKOCTbIO Ee3 YllaCTHH HHTeJIJIlIreHlI HH B TerrepelUHeH CTa lUfH rrp01l3BOnCTBa COll lIanH3M HeOCYlll eCTBliM I1 oTKyna HBHTCH 3TH nliKTaTOPhl He TonbKO C HHTenneKTYaJIb' DOKyna COIUlaJIH3M HaXOnliJICH B CTa­ JJ HlI nponaraHJJ bI rroKyna neno lUJIO 0 HCHOM C03HaHliH rrponeTapH­ HbIM HO H MOPaJIbHbiM npeBocxonCTBOM BCHKHH npOH3Bon 3aKnIO­ aTOM ero MeCTa B 06ll1 eCTBe H BbITeKaIOllI HX OTCIOna HCTopHlleCKHX 'laeT B ce6e 3apO bllll Pa3BPlllUeHlUI BJIaCTH OJIHlI eTBOpHeT JIH ee ero 3aJJ allax COll HaJIH3M HY KJJ aJICH B HHTenJIHreHTax OTJJ eJIbHaH JIH'IHOCTb HnH rpynna 6e3pa3JIHIIHo TonbKo HCKnIOIIH­ KTO OHli 6bIJIH aKanCMHlleCKli 06pa30BaHHbIe 6YP iKYa HJIli caMoyq­ TeJIbHbie HaTypbI B COCTOHHlIH y6epellbcH OT TaKfIX pa3JIaraIOllI HX KH-pa601lHe - nocneJJ cTBHH lOJl ICHbi JIll Mbi nYMaTb liTO lIMeHHO POCClIHCKlie nllK­ Torna neno lUJIO He 0 KOJIHlleCTBC a 0 KalleCTBe CHJI TaTopbI crrJIOlUb HBnHIOTCH TaKliMli lICKnIOlIlITenbHbIMli HaTypaMlI 6e3pa3nHIIHO nHIlIb JlH Bblpa60TKH H norrynHpH3all lIH ero TeopHH COBceM HHoe Tenepb Korna Mbl BCTynllJIH B rroJIocy npaKTHlle­ CKoro oCYlll eCTBJIeHHH COll HaJIH3Ma KaK KarrHTaJIHCTHlleCKOe npo­ H3BOJJ CTBO H KanHTaJIHCTH'IeCKOe rOCYJJ apCTBO He MorYT CYllI eCTBO­ BaTb 6e3 nOMOlll H MHOrOIlHCJIeHHbIX Hane l HblX TpynOJII06HBbiX H Ho COBCTCKHH pe l HM OTIlHllaeTCH OT rrpe l HHX BenHKfIX HapoJJ ­ HaY'IHO-o6pa30BaHHbiX ClIJI TaK H 06ll1 eCTBeHHoe npOH3BOJJ CTBO H HhlX JJ BlI I CHHH TeM liTO OH YCTpaHlIIl ny'llUee CpenCTBO BbIBeCTH Ha rocynapCTBeHHaH BJIaCTb pa60llero KJIaCCa He MoryT 060HTHCb 6e3 1I11CTyIO HHX Ee3 HHX a B oc06eHHOCTH BonpeKH HM COIUlaIlH3M HeB03MO­ Bony aBaHTIOpHCTOB H l ynllKoB xBacTyHoB 11 KPllKYHOB C B 0 6 0 n y rr e II a T 11 3TH JneMeHTbl TaKliM rrYTeM OCB060­ HnHCb OT KpHTHKH 3HaTOKOB JJ ena I1M npfIXO lUfIlOCb HMeTb nCilO TonbKO C HeSC I eCTBCHHbiMli pa60'IHMlI 11 COilnaTaMlI a TaK I C C He­ OnbITHblMH HOBaTopaMli I1 OHli BCXOnHJIli KaK Ha npO l I ax Ho BOT BO KJJ H 60IlblUeBliKOB pelUHIlli HaYlIllTbCH KaK OTneIlHTb l eH lnH HX npaKTHlleCKOro COTpyJJ HlIllecrna npH BBeJJ eHlIli COll lIaJIH3­ Ma He Tpe6yeTcH CTpaCTHaH npenaHHOCTb BeIlliKOMY JJ eny OCB060 1 ­ neHlIH 'IeJIOBelleCTBa KaK npll pa3BlITHH H nporraraHJJ e COll HanliCTlI· lIeCKOH Teoplili Ho no MeHblUeH Mepe He06xonllMO IlT06bI rro KpaH­ nlUeHHll y OT rrJIeBeJIOB HCTHHHbiX caMOOTBep l eHHbIX opraHH3aTO­ HeH Mepe 3HallHTeIlbHaH lIaCTb lIHTenm1TeHIUlli rrplilUna K y6e l n e - pOB OT l YIlHKOB He3anOJIrO no TOro KaK OHH HHIO B B03MO I HOCTli H BblrO UfOCTH COIUlanHCTHlleCKoro rrpO H3BO n· noM ' MOlUtHHHKOB H HaYIIHJIHCb npOH3BO lUfTeIlbHOcTb npll OTCTaJIOCTli pyCCKfIX CTBa H TaKHM 06pa30M He BblHY l neHa 6bIJIa rroCTyrraTbcH CBOHM HH­ pa60'lfIX JJ aeT ocellKY H rp03l1T nOJIHOH npHOCTaHOBKOH I1 TonbKO TenneKTOM rrpH pa60Te Ha nOIlb3Y COIUlaJIH3Ma EcnH 11 B 06naCTH JJ lIKTaTypOH pYKOBOnHTeneH HaJJ eIOTcH nOnO I HTb KOHell 6ene DPH­ MYCKYJIbHOH pa60ThI 60nee TOHKoe rrpOH3BOnCTBO HeCOBMCCTHMO XO lUfTCH pa3naBaTb HKTaTypbl JJ a l e He 6ynyqll B COCTOHHHlI cne­ C rrpllHynllTeJIbHbIM TPYJJ OM TO elll e B 60JIee ClIIlbHOH CTeneHH 310 nan He06xo lUfMbIH BbI60p I1 TaKaB nliKTaTypa - rrpaBlIIlo OTHOCliTCH K 06nacTH YMCTBeHHoro Tpyna K KOTOPOH 11 6e3 Toro HMeeTCH HeYCTpaHliMoe HeJJ OBcplle - MO l eT BIlllHTb JIlilUb OTCYTCTBHe cOMHeHlIH y HHTeIlJIHreHlI HH B oCYlll eCTBHMoCTH co­ 3nOBp en HO • I1TaK CHallaJIa np01l3Benli 3KcnponplIaII HIO a nOTOM IUlaJI1I3Ma 11 rOTOBHOCTb ee pa60TaTb Han npOBeJJ eHlIeM ero C MO­ TonbKO CTaJIH nYMaTb 06 opraHH3all HlI MCHTa Korna CMY npHHa Jle l ana BnaCTb HBnHIOTCH rrpenrrOCbIJIKa­ TaK CHallana HaCa KJJ aIOT JJ HKTaTopoB a nOTOM OTbiCKlIBaIOT cnoc06bI fIX H36paHHH 3TOT lUHBopoT-HaBbIBopoT 6bm HeH30e l eH C Toro MOMeHTa Korna rropelllHIlH BBeCTH COll HanH3M onHpaHcb nHlUb Ha l enaHlIH a HC Ha peanbHble ycnoBHH Mll COll HaJIliCTlIlICCKoro rrp01l3BOnCTBa ycnoBHHMH JJ O KOTOPblX 06­ llI eCTBO JJ on I Ho nOpacTH CCIlH OHO XO'lCT 6bITb 3peIlbiM JJ nH COll lIa­ IlH3Ma 3TO YCJIOBHe caMO HaCTyrrllT C TeM 60nblUeH CKOpOCTbIO lIeM Ho cOBeTcKoMY pe I HMy BpenliT He TOJIbKO HannblB aBaHTIOpH­ 60nbllle OCTaJIbHbIe YCIlOBHH COIUlanH3Ma 6ynYT HaJIHll O TaK liTO CTOB H l YJIHKOB KpHTHKy KOTOPbIX OH CneJIaJI nOIlTli HeB03MO l ­ neHCTBlITeJIbHOCTb caMa npllBCnCT Konc6nIOllI HXCH HHTcnnllreHTOB HoH He MeHee rp03HbIM HBJUleTCH nJIH Hero TO 'ITO OH OTTOJIKHyn K COll lIanHCTHIICCKHM y6e l nCHHHM OT ce6H HaH60JIee CTOHKfIX H OnapeHHbIx npenCTaBHTeJIeH HHTcrmH­ 3TY Ba l HOCTb HHTcnnHrCHlI HH 60nblUeBliKH nOCTHrnH He cpa­ reHlI HH 3y 1160 OHH npe l ne Bcero cncno OTnaJIHCb nOToKY COJIJJ aTcKoH 204 KPCCTbHHCKOH H pa60lleH MaCCbI 205 HHTeJlJUfreHTCKafl MaCCa C caMoro Haqana OTHOClfnaCb K HlfM Bpa l J e6HO KaK If COUlfanlfCTbI cpe J lf Hee TaK KaK lfM 6bInO flCHO TpoUKlfii HarrplfMep l anyeTcfI Ha JIO B Y l e UlfTlfpOBaHHoii 6po­ IlIlOpe Pa60Ta J lfCUlfrrnlfHa If L J OH rOBoplfT qTO POCClffl He C03pena DfI TaKoro pO J a HeMe J neHHoii Bce06meii CO­ Ulfanlf3aUlflf KOTOpylO rrpe J rrplfHflnlf 60nbllIeBlfKlf uPyrlfe HlfqerO TIepBblii rreplfO J 60Pb6bI C Ca6OTa l eM lfHTennlfreHUlflf He J YMaBIlllfe rro 3TOMY rrOBO J Y oTllIaTHynlfCb rrplf 3penlfme lfCTfI­ 3aKnlOqanCfI B TOM qTO MbI opraHlf3aUlflf Ca60Ta l HlfKOB pa3­ 3aHlfii BbIIIaBllIlfX Ha J onlO lfHTennlfreHUlflf TOT 6bIn lf3rHaH lf3 cpa6­ pyllIlfnlf plfKlf KOTOPOii pa60qlfe XOTenlf PYKOBO J lfTb caMlf 3TOT OKa3anCfI 6e3 1 anOCTHO 3TO 6bInO He06xo J lfMO If rrOTOMY crrpaBe J nlfBO rrOnlfTlfqeCKlf 6ecrrpaBHbIM lf60 BceBnaCTHble pa60qlfe COBeTbI rrpe­ Terrepb Kor J a BnaCTb COBeTOB yKperrneHa 60Pb6a C ca60­ J ocTaBnflnlf lf36lfpaTenbHoe rrpaBo TonbKO MycKynbHbIM pa60qlfM Ta l eM J on l Ha Bblpa3lfTbCfI B TOM qTO BqepallIHlfe ca60Ta l ­ HHOii 6bIn 3KcrrporrplflfpoBaH rrocKonbKY lfMen Koe-KaKoe lfMyme­ HlfKlf J on l HbI 6bITb 06pameHbI B cnyr lfcrronHlfTeneii pyKO­ CTBO If nlfllIeH B03MO l HOCTlf BeCTlf KynbTypHblii 06pa3 I lf3Hlf B BO J lfTeneii TaM r J e JIoro Tpe6yeT HOBblii pe l lfM KOHue KOHUOB J a l e rrplfcY l J eH K rrplfHY J lfTenbHoii pa60Te If ro­ nO J Hoii CMepTlf BHaqane TpoUKlfii rronaraeT TaKlfM 06pa30M qTO He06xo J lfMblii If rrOTO­ 60nbllIeBlfKlf J YManlf 060ii TlfCb 6e3 lfHTennlfreHUlflf 6e3 crreUlfanlfCToB Uaplf3M J ep l ancfI y6e l J eHlffl qTO Ka I J blii reHepan crroc06eH 6e3 BCflKOii n1060ii rrOCL crreUlfanbHoii rro J roToBKlf 3aHflTb COBeTcKafl pecrry6nlfKa Hapfl J y co MHOflfMlf J PYflf­ Mlf rr03alfMCTBOBana y uaplf3Ma If 3T0 y6e l J eHlfe - KOBO J lfTeneii COUlfanlf3aUlflf rrpe l J e Bcero Be J eT K 6e3 1 anOCTHO- MY J aBneHlflO Ha HlfX q TO rrpOlfCX O J lfT rrplf JIOM paCCKa3bIBaeT OH caM C TOii TonbKO pa3Hlfueii qTO Ha MeCTO reHepana OHa rrOCTaBlfna rrponeTaplffl Te­ opeTlfKlf 60nbllIeBlf3Ma Ha3Banlf 3TOT rrpouecc pa3BlfTlfeM COUlfa­ nlf3Ma OT HayqHOrO MlfPOB033pemm My CrrpaBe DlfBblii rryTh 06pameHlffl lfHTennlfreHUlflf B cnyr If py­ MbI pa3 J aBlfnlf cTapblii ca60Ta l If 60nbllIlfHCTBO rrpe l ­ HlfX qlfHOBHlfKOB BbIMenlf l ene3HbIM BeHlfKOM 3aMeCTlfTenlf K rrpaKTlfqeCKOMY ocymeCT­ 3TlfX rrpe l HlfX qlfHOBHlfKOB rrOKa3anlf ce6f1 B J anbHeii llIeM J a- BneHlflO CKopee 6bI MO l HO 6bInO Ha3BaTh ero pa3BlfTlfeM OT Ha­ neKO He Bcer J a B KaqeCTBe rrepBOKnaCCHoro MaTeplfana Hlf B yqHOrO MlfPOB033peHlffl K J lfnneTaHTlf3MY 0 J H0ii 06naCTlf yrrpaBneHlffl C O J HOii CTOpOHbI Ha OCB060 J lfB­ KaK B COBeTcKoii pecrry6nlfKe rrplfHflTO 3a rrpaBlfno - BO BceM PYKOBO J CTBOBaTbCfI l enaHlfeM a He lf3yqeHlfeM 06CTaHOBKlf - rro­ IlIlfeCfI MeCTa rrOIllJllf Hallilf rrapTlfii HbJe TOBaplfmlf ny lfe 3ne­ MeHTbI 60PUbI qeCTHeii llIlfe 6eCKopblcTHeii llIlfe C J pyroii CTO­ cne Toro KaK J lfTfI Y l e yrrano B KonO J eu rrOCTerreHHO rrplfllInlf K pOHbI rroflBlfnlfCb rrplf3HaHlfIO Toro qTO 6bInO He06xo J lfMO C J enaTb OCTaBllIlfeCfI rrplf CTapOM pe l lfMe He y J en Kor J a cpa3y 06­ rrOrrbITanlfCb 3a­ KapbeplfCTbI lfHTplfraHbI CBlfXHYBllIlfeCfI KpbITb KonO J eu rrplfBneqb lfHTennlffeHUlfIO K pa60Te rrOMlfMO TOii Hapy l lfnaCb rrplfHY J lfTenbHoii 0 KOTOPOii Y l e 6bIna pe% - HOBbIX KBanlfcplfUlfpoBaHHblx pa60qlfX HlfqerO He 6bInO y J lf­ K pa60Te J nfl KO­ TOPOii OHa 6bIna rrplfrO J Ha KOTOPYIO OHa 3Hana HHTennlfreHTbI rroCTyrrlfBllIlfe Ha rrpaBlfTenbCTBeHHYIO cnY l 6y He ITOqlfTanlfCb Y l e He06xo J lfMOCTb rrplfBneqeHlff J ecflTKoB TbICflq BlfTenbHoro B TOM qTO MHorlfM MapO J epaM y J anOCb rrpOHlfK­ HyTb B rropbI HOBoro pe l lfMa 6YP l YflMlf He rrO J BepranlfCb rOHeHlfflM KaK TaKOBble OHlf rro J ­ HY l HO K 3TOMY J 06aBlfTb qTO MHorlfe TOBaplfm lf pa60Ta­ HflnlfCb B Pfl J bI TpY J OBoro HaceneHlffl rrpOlf3BO J flmero rrpo J YK­ IOmlfe B pa3nlfqHbIX Be J OMCTBax If yqpe l J eHlfflX J o ClfX rrop TlfBHYIO If rrone3HYIO pa60TY 6bInlf rapaHTlfpOBaHbI OT 3Kcrrpo­ eme He rrpOflBnfllOT crroc06HocTeii rrplfaUlfii If rronyqanlf J OCTaTOqHOe cO J ep l aHlfe CKOMY HacTOii qlfBOMY TPy J y H TaK KaK He y6e l J eHlfe a CTpax rrepe J HlfmeToii If lf3 J eBaTenb­ K OpraHlfqeCKOMY TBOpqe­ MbI llIar 3a llIarOM Ha6nlO J aeM TaKlfX TOBaplfmeii oc06eHHO lf3 Pfl J OB OKTfl6pbCKlfX 60JibllIe­ CTBaMlf rrorHan 60nbllIlfHCTBO lf3 HlfX Ha rrpaBlfTenbCTBeHHYIO cnY l ­ BlfKOB B MlfHlfCTepCTBax r J e OHlf pa6OTalOT qeTblpe-rrflTb qaCOB 6y TO If pa60Ta lfX B J eii cTBlfTenbHOCTlf 6bIna Hlf OqeHb rrpO J yKTlfB­ If rrplfTOM He oc06eHHO lfHTeHClfBHO If JIO - HOii Hlf OqeHb rrone3Hoii Kor J a Bce Hallie rrOnO l eHlfe Tpe6yeT OT Hac Harrpfl l eHHeii llIe­ 206 B TaKoe BpeMfI ro Tpy J a He 3a CTPax a 3a COBeCTh 207 TaKoB 6bm He06xo 1 lMbIH HO nOCeMY OTHIOllb He cnpaBew m­ If He HBnHIOTCH npOCTblMH BnaAeTenHMH CHHeKYp 3THM nYTeM rocy­ BbIM pe3ynbTaT nonHTHKH KOTopaH nbITallaCb npHBne'lb HHTennHreH­ llapCTBeHHoe ynpasneHHe 6e UIeeT AyXOBHO H TyT - UHIO He y6e KlleHHeM a nHHKaMH canora '1HH nO'IeMY rocyuapcTBeHHoe X03HMCTBO TaK 'lacTO He B COCTOHHHH Bcnell 3areM nepernnH K llpyrOMY cpellcTBy Aa6bI 1l0CTH'Ib Bbl­ llaIOmeMCH HcnonHHTenbHOCTH IIapH KcKaH KOMMYHa 1871 r co­ KpaTHna BbICOKHe OKna J bI rocYllapcTBeHHblx 1l0n KHOCTeH H YCTaHo­ O UIa H3 npH­ BbIllep KaTb KOHKypeHUHIO '1aCTHoro Heme 60JIbrnOM Bonpoc CMorna nH 6bl KOMMYHa OCTaHOBHTb­ 6 CH Ha 3a pHKcHpoBaHHoM eIO BblClIleM OKna J e TbIC ppaHKoB ec­ TbIC ppaHKoB BrOil COBeTCKaH nH 6bI npH HeM pa3BHnocb KpynHoe KanHTallHCTH'leCKOe a He CO­ pecny6nHKa XOTena nocnellOBaTb ee npHMepy Ho lleno He nOlllno UHanH3HpOBaHHoe npOH3BOllCTBO 'ITO O'leHb AonYCTHMO Ee AeK­ BHna KaK BbIClIlee KanOBaHbe 6 2 H TyT OHa BbIHy K leHa 6bIna nocTynHTb lIlHBOpOT-HaBbIBopOT J1e­ peT OT HHH 3aMe'laeT no nOMY nOBO lY xapaKTepe TorAallIHeM napH KCKOM npoMbIrnneHHocTH Bo BCHKOM anpenH cBHAeTeJIbCTByeT n03ToMY 0 MenKO-MernaHCKOM cnyqae 0 6ecKopblCTHH '1neHOB KOMMYHbl Mbl 1l0n KHbl 6bInH 06paTHTbCH K CTapOMY 6yp a3HOMY CpellCTBy H cornaCHTbCH Ha naT y 0 'I e H b B bl C 0 K Y IO 0 n KpynHeHlIlHX H3 6yp a3HbIX CneUHallHCTOB 3a HX cnY Ke6HbIe ycnyrH HCHO 'ITO TaKaH Mepa HBnHeTCH KOM­ npOMHCCOM OTKJIOHeHHeM OT npHHUHnOB IIapH KcKOH KOMMY­ Hbl H BCHKOM nponeTapCKOH BnaCTH 03Ha'iaeT He TonbKO ocraHOBKY HCHo 'ITO TaKaH Mepa B H3BeCTHOM 06naCTH H B H3­ KOHKypeHUHH UBeTyrneH H MOmHOH '1aCTHOR npOMbllllneHHOCTH He HBnHeTCH B COBeTCKOM POCCHH npH'lHHOM '1pe3BbI'laMHbiX OKnaAOB BbmaIOIUHXCH cneUHanHCTOB H60 3Ta npoMblrnneHHocTb 3Kcrrponpm1poBaHa HnH pa3pYllleHa H He llaeT npHHHMaTenHM 1l06aBO'IHOM CTOHMOCTH HnH 60nee 'IaCTHbIM npeA­ BbICOKHMH OKnaAaMH TaM rrpecneAyeTcH OAHa nHlIlb uenb n060pOTb aHTHrrarHIO cnoc06HeHlIlHX HacTynneHHH Ha KanHTall HO H lIlar Ha3all H3 HHTennHreHTOB K COBeTCKOR pecny6nHKe TaK KaK y6e KlleHHe He HarneH COUHallHCm'leCKOH COBeTCKOH BnaCTH Enlf KaHlIlHe AeHcTByeT 6H'IOM ronOlla He YllanOCb AOCTH'lb 3aMeTHbIX pe3ym Ta­ 3alla'lH COBeTCKOM BnaCTH' TOB OCTaeTCH OjlHO BeCTHOM CTeneHH - KynHTb nIOAeM B0306HOBneHHeM llJIH HHX no MeHbllleM Mepe KanHranHCTH'IeCKHX ycnoBHH cymecTBOBaHHH OH MbI BH 1 IM Tenepb 'ITO 3a 3neMeHTbI nOA6HpaIOTCH B COBeTCKOM He06xollHMOCTb BbICOKHX oKnalloB MO KeT 6blTb Bbl3BaHa POCCHH Ha ponH PYKOBOAHTeneH COUHallHCTH'leCKOrO npoH3BOACTBa Ho J1eHHH llYMaeT 'ITO HH'IerO llpyroro He OCTaBanOCb H npaB ABYMH npH'IHHaMH qeM 60nbllle npoH3BollcTBO '1eM MHOrO'lHCneH­ C OjlHOM CTOPOHbl Hee ero pa60'lHe TeM 3Ha'IHTeJIbHee 60PUOB 6eCnOpO'lHOrO 06pa3a MbIcneH HO Bce Ke B AenOBOM CMbI­ CTOHTenbcTBax - CTH nOcTaBnHeT O 1 lH pa60'lHM npOH3BOllCTBO ee 60'lHMH - 5000 npH O 1 lHaKOBblx Bo06rne 06­ Macca BbIpa6aTblBaeMoH HM 1l06aBO'IHOH CTOHMO­ 100 5 Map B AeHb TaKOH CTOHMOCTH H 500 Map B lleHb ee 1000 pa- pa60'lHMH llaeT Map qeM 0611lHpHee npOH3BOllCTBO TeM TpyAHee HeCKonbKO CTapblX 3arOBopIUHKOB '1eCTHbIX cne HeonbITHbIX HOBaTopOB C APyroH CTOPOHbI MHOrO'lHCneH­ HbIe HHTenmlreHTbI npOTHB CBOHX y6e K leHHM nocrynaIOmHe B pac­ nOpH KeHHe HOBOM BnaCTH B Ka'leCTBe KapbepHCTOB KaK OHM no­ CTYIIHnH 6bI B paCnOpH KeHHe BCHKOM HHOM BnaCTH HnH rOHHMbIe ero opraHH30BaTb H BeCTH TeM peAKOCTHee Hy KHbIe AnH nora CH­ CTpaxOM ronOlla H H3AeBaTenbCTB HnH HaKOHeu c06na3HHeMbIe nbI TeM KpynHee O UIaKO cpellCTBa KOTOPblMH pacnonaraIOT Bna­ BblCOKHMH OKnallaMH OAHHM cnOBOM KaK npH3HaeTCH TpoUKHM AenbUbl npeAnpHHTHH jlJIH nOKynKH TaKOM H36paHHOH CHnbI H no llaneKO He nepBOKnaCCHbIe 3neMeHTbl H Aa Ke nOCKonbKY OHH Mepe pOCTa KpynHblX npellnpIDITHR pacTyT H OKna J b1 HX PYKOBOllH­ KOe-'lTO 3HaIOT OHH Bce Ke He HaH60nee THnH'lHbIe B CBoeM 06naCTH TeneR H AocTHraIOT nopoH HeBepoHTHblX pa3MepoB C 3THM 06CTO­ J1IOllH O UIOBpeMeHHO H C BbIAaIOIUlIMHcH xapaKTepaMH H C BblAa­ HTenbCTBOM npHxollHTCH C'IHTaTbCH H rocYAapcTBy IOIUHMHCH 3HaHIDIMH cpeAH HHX - 'ITO 6enbIe BOpOHbl EcnH OHO He nOBbIlIlaeT COOTBeTCTBeHHO KallOBaHbH CBOHX BbIC­ llnH cnaceHIDI COUHallH3Ma B pyKH TaKHX meMeHTOB nepellaeT­ lIlHX '1HHOBHHKOB TO AOn KHO O KHAaTb 'ITO '1aCTHaH npOMbIrnneH­ CH 1 IKTaTOpCKaH BnaCTb KOTOPOM pa60'lHe AOn KHbl rrOA'lHHHTbCH HOCTh nepeMaHHT HX K ce6e - 208 nOCKonbKY OHH '1erO-HH6Yllb CTOHT 6ecnpeKocnOBHO BnaCTb pa3BpamaIOmaH lIyqIIIHX 311eCb OHa BBe­ pHeTCH nIOAHM Y Ke H 6e3 Toro pa3BpameHHbIM 209 CpeLlH Bce06mero 06HHmaHHH Bce06meH 3KCnpOnpHaU HH B HX pyKax cKonnRroTcR OCHOBbI LlnR C03 J aHHH HOBOrO KanHTanH3Ma KaK 06Y3 J aTh 3THX J IiKTaTopoB KOTOPbIM pa60qIlc BbI J aHbI Ha occnpcKocnoBHoe nO J 'lHHeHl1e TIPOH3BOLlCTBO TOBapOB npo J On l aeTCH J aJIblIle H J OJI I HO npo J OJI­ KaK J nH MOpaJIbHOrO rrO J beMa Macc TaK H J nH HpaBCTBCHHoro l aTbCR TaK KaK KpeCTbRHCKOe X03HHCTBO RBJIHeTCH npOH3BO J HTC­ 03 J opoBncHIDI CBOHX PYKoBo J lUcncH COBCTCKaR BJIaCTb 3HaeT O J ­ Ii neM TOBapOB H 3aHHMaeT rOCnO J CTByromee nOnO l eHHe TIPH nOM HO TOJIbKO cpe J cTBo - KpeCTbHHCKoe X03HHCTBO nOCTaBJIHeT Bce MeHblIle H3nHlIlKOB Co­ nCTapHaTa ObeT K03bIPb cro opraHH3aTopOB TO KapTy nocne J HHX BeTCKaR pecny6nHKa BpY'IaeT BCro BnaCTb B J epeBHe 6e J HeHlIleMY ObeT B CBOro OqCPCLlb K03bIPb J HKTaTYPbI TPIlOYHaJIOB TCppOp TPHOYHaIIOB ecml J HKTaTYPY npo­ KpeCTbRHcTBy He HMeromCMY B03MO I HOCTH J 06bIBaTh UK MHoro C03 J aeTCH CCTb peBonroUHOHHbIX TpHOYHanOB H qpe3Bbl'IaHHbIX qT06bI nonY'laJIHCb H3nHlIlKH J nH pbIHKa COCTOHTenbHble KpeCTbHHe KOMHCCHH no oopboe C KOHTppcBonroUHeH cneKynHll IIeH II B3RTOq­ LlOn l HbI 6e3 B03Harpa l J eHIDI OT J aBaTh B npO J OBonbCTBeHHbIe CKna­ HH'lCCTBOM IJ bI BCHKIIM Ha Koro nocTynaeT J OHOC CBOH H3nHlIlKH 3Ta npaKTHKa CCJIH OHa Bo06me ocymccTBHMa MO l eT 6bITb npoBe J cHa mlIIlb O J Ha I J bI K cTOHTenbHbIH KpeCTbRHHH B03 J ep l TCH cne J yromeMY ro J y CO­ J oobIBaTh OOJIblIle H 3TH yqpC I J CHHH pacnpaBnHroTcH no npOli3Bony CO paccTpenHBaroT nroooro KTO HM OKa3bIBaeTCH He no HpaBy a TaK I e BCHKoro 3aXBaqCHHOrO cnc­ qeM KynHHTa H MClIlOqHHKa KaK H HX noc06HHKOB cpe J H COBeTCKHX Hy l HO CMY caMoMY M npo J YKTI1BHOCTb cenbCKoro X03HHcTBa na­ qHHOBHHKOB Ho OHH HC OCTaHaBnHBaroTcH Ha nOM a HaKna J bIBaroT J er Te l e 113nHIlIKH KOTopble BCC I e oKa l YTcH y KPCCThHHHHa CBOro pyKy Ha Ka I J oro qecTHoro KpHTHKa 3Toro CTpalllHoro pacno­ OH npHnpHqeT H H3-nOLl nonbI COY J CT cncKynRHTy pR J Ka ITo J OOmHM HaHMeHOBaHHCM KOHTppeBonroll ml B O J Hy B TO l e BpeMH napaJIH3YCTCH npOMbIlIlnCHHOCTb H rocy J ap- CTBeHHble paCXO J hI npH TaKHX ycnoBHRX MorYT nOKpbIBaTbCH nHlIlb BbII1YCKOM oYMa I HbIX J eHer B TaKOH OOCTaHOBKC _ Kyqy CBanHBaCTCH BCHKaR Onn03HIl IIR H3 KaKHX ObI KpyroB H no­ OY l J CHHH OHa HH HCXOLlIfJIa KaKHMH Obi cpe J CTBaMH OHa HH OOpO­ naCb KaKHe ObI ucnH OHa HH npCCJIe J OBaJIa KaK BO BpeMH ppaHll Y3CKOH peBOJIroll HH KaK Tenepb B fepMa­ HIIH XOTR H He B TaKOM pa3Mepe BbIpacTaroT cneKynHll HI1 Ha Ba­ Ho K CO l aneHHro H 3TOT oopa3 J ei1cTBHH HH'leMY He nOMoraer K Y l acy CBOCMY qCCTHbIe OOJIblIleBHKH Bce oonblIlC npoHHKaroTcH na nroTe KOHTpaoaH J HaR ToprOBnH pOCTOBmHqeCTBO BblClIlYro pOp­ yoe l J CHHeM 'ITO qpC3BbIqaHHbIC KOMHCCHH MY KaITmaJIH3Ma TY 'ITO J aeT npOCTOp npOH3BO J HTenbHOCTH Tpy J a J a Ha 03 J opOBnCHHC pCBonroUHH TaK I e HpaBCTBeHHO pa3BpameHbI 6 H ynyqIlIaeT MaTepHaJIbHble OCHOBbI Macc npe l J eBpeMeHHO HCKOBep­ faBpOHCKHH UHTHPyCT CTp KaJIH aero napa3HTH'leCKHM HH31I1HM Q JopMaM J aJIH B03MO l HOCTb THM qpC3BblqaHHbIX KOMHCCHH nocnC J HHH Ha J C I ­ cne J YlOmHH KpHK ccp J ua M3Bec­ nbIlIlHO npOUBeTaTb COBeTCKHH pe l I1M nO J OOHO ppaH- CO BCCX CTOPOH IICCYTCH K HaM H3BCCTHH 'ITO B ryocpH­ ll Y3CKOMY Teppopy nblTaeTCH nOnO l HTb KOHell 3THM 6HqaM YHH­ CaMO COOOH pa3YMeeTCH CKHe H ocooemlO B yC3 J HbIe KOMHCCHII nbITaroTcH rrpOHIIKUYTh qTO l eHHeM cneKynRHToB ToprOBueB H3-no J nOJIbI pOCTOBmHKOB • HC TonbKO HC J OCTOHHbIC HO npHMO npccTynHblc 3J1CMCHTbI Torna HX rHJIbOTHHHpOBaJIH Tenepb B MO J e paccTpcn - O J HH E J IIHcTBeHHbIH pC3ynbTaT TOT l C 'ITO H B A pe3ynbTaT 1793 roJJY paCTeT npeMHR 3a PHCK B3bIMaeMbIH l ynblIllqeCKHM KanHTanOM faBpOHCKHH npHBO J HT TaK I C CTp 62 CBH J eTenbCTBa Toro 'ITO 3TH 3J1CMeHTbI He TOJ1bKO nbITalOTCH HO H npOHHKaIDT B KOMHCCIIH H COOTBeTCTBeHHO nOBbIIlIaeTCH pa3Mep B3RTOK TpeOYCMbIX H nony­ TaK HanpHMCp BOT 'ITO COoomaeT ll eHTpaJIbHbIH opraH PCBOJ1roll H­ qaeMbIX HOBbIMH J HKTaTOpaMH C HeOCTOpO I HbIX nona alOmHX B OHHoro KOMMYHH3Ma OT 10 OKTR'6pH 1918 r HX ceTH M 3L1eCb HaKOnJIRroTcR HOBbIe COCTOHHHR l enaromHx 03HaKOMHTbCR oonee C 3THM B3HTOqHHqCCKHM XO­ B BocnOMHHaHHRX BCCX cme l HBbI cnyqaH Kor J a MCCTHble 3RHCTBOBaHIIeM HOBOM POCCHHCKOH olOpoKpaTHH MbI OTCbIJIaeM K COBCTbI KHIIre faBpoHcKoro BanaHc pyccKoro OOJIblIleBH3Ma r J e HaqH­ MH TIpoHCXO J HT CCTecTscHHbIH no J oop B COBCTax OCTaBa­ HaR CO CTp 210 58 npllBO J IITCH cnyqaH nO J Kyna ObIJIH OyKBaJibHO TeppopH3HpoBaHbI nHCb nyqlIlHC 3J1CMCHThI B TO BpeMH KaK B qpe3BbIqaHKax CKonnHnHCb opO J HrH na J KHe J O BCHKoro PO a '''amYl'''''' '' M OT nporpaMMhI 06HOBneHHJI 'leJIOBeIJeCTBa COIIHaJJH3MOM npH 60JIbWeBHCTCKHX MeTonax B KOHlle KOHUOB OCTaeTCH JIHWb rpynnKa 3aKOHHhIM MemO'lHH'IeCTBOM H3BJleKalOmHM H3 rOpOnOB nocnen­ HHe OCTaTKH HaKOnneHHhIX npelKne H3nenHH npOMhIIIIneHHOCTH KpeCThJlHaM '1eCTHhIX 60PIIOB cpe l H pacTymero nOTOKa HeBe l eCTBa pa3Bp a m e H­ nocne pa3pymeHHH KpynHhlx nOMeCTHH 60Jll we­ I1x npHBJl3aHHOCTh HOCTH If OT'IaHHHJI nO IJ HHMalOmerOCH Bce BhIwe H rp03J1merO OKOH­ BH3M HH IerO He B COCTOJlHHH npennOlKHTb 'laTeJIhHO 3aTonHTb lfX My npeBpamaeTCJI B HeHaBHCTh - HeHaBHCTh K ropOnCKMM pa60'lHM HH'lerO He nenalOmHM BlfCTh K IIpeBpllllJ eHWI 60JlbmeBH3M8 HH'leM He cHa6lKalOmlfM nepeBHlf K He­ B HeHa­ BJlaCTBYlOmHM nOChmalOIUHM B nepeBHIO KpaCHoapMeH­ lIeB nnJl peKBH3lflllfH npOnOBonhCTBHJI B npe3peHHe K ropOnCKlfM pOCTOBmHKaM H cneKynHHTaM nhITalOlIIlfMCJI BhIMaHMTh y KpeCThHH MHorHe peBOJIIOUHOHephl 3anana C TPHYMq OM YKa3hIBalOT Ha TO H3nHWKH 06MaHHhIMH CnenKaMH BCHKoro pona 'ITO 60JlhWeBH3M TaK nOJlro neplKlfTCJI y BJlaCTH H B TO BpeMJI Kor­ na nHWYTCH 3TH CTpOKH MaH 1919 PJlnOM C nHM 'lHCTO MenKOMemaHCKHM X03J1HHH'laHbeM B ne­ r eme IJpe3BhI'laHHO KpenoK peBHJlX B roponax B03HHKaeT 06meCTBO lKenalOmee CTaTb COUHaJJH­ KpHTHKH lKe ero npenCKa3hIBaJIH eMY 6hICTPhiM pa3BaJI eme npH Ha­ CTH'leCKHM OHO Ha'laJJO C YHHlKeHHJI H pa3rpOMa BhlCWHX KnaCCOB '1aJJe ero rocnOnCTBa H K 3TOMY pa3BaJlY neno npHIIInO 6hl Y I e naBHO eCJIH 6bl 60JIbWe­ BHKH oCTaBaJJHch BepHhl CBoeH nporpaMMe OHH yneplKaJJHCh nHWb 6JIarO l apH TOMY 'ITO OHH cnaBaJJH O IJ HY 3a npyroH CBOH n03HIIHH H B KOHlle KOHIIOB npHWilH K OTpHII8HHIO Toro 'ITO HaMepeBaJIHCh 3a­ BoeBaTb 3aKaH'lHBaeT BKnlO'laeT B ce6J1 B Ka'leCTBe HOBoro KnaCCOBorO 06meCTBa OHO Tp H K n a C ca HH3wHH H3 HHX 06HHMaeT C060H npelKHHX 6YPlKyeB KanHTa­ nHCTOB MemaHCTBO HHTeJlJlHreHIIHIO nOCKOJlbKY OHH HaCTpoeHhI onn03HIIHOHHO nOmUH'IeCKH o6ecnpaBneHHhIe nHweHHhIe BCJlKHX CpenCTB OHM BpeMH OT BpeMeHH nOChmalOTCJI Ha npMHynHTenhHhIe QT06hl npHnTH K BJIaCTH OHH BhlKHHYJlH 3a 60PT CBOH neMOKpa­ TH'leCKHe npHHlIHnhI M 'lT06bl ynep l aTb 3a C060H BnaCTb OHH CBOH caMoro OTTaJJKHBalOmero xapaKTepa pa60ThI H 3a no nonY'lalOT npOnOBonhCTBeHHhIe paIlHOHhI npenCTaBJlJlBWHe C060H MH3epHeH­ COIIHaJJHCTH'IeCKlfe npHHlIHnhl OTnpaBHJlH BCJlen 3a neMOKpaTH'leCKH­ WlfM Hnlf BepHee rOnO IJ HhIH naeK An noro pa6cTBa MOlKHO cpaB­ MH OHH OTCTOJlJIH ce6J1 HlfTh nlfWh C Mep3eHwHMH pocTKaMH Korna 6hI TO HH 6hIilO nOnHH­ n e p C 0 Han h H 0 HO npHHeCJIH B lKepT­ By CBOH nplfHIIHnhl H 3THM npOHBHJIH ce6J1 B Ka'leCTBe HCTHlIHbIX MaBwHMHCH Ha nOIJBe KanHTaJJH3Ma C03naHHe noro ana JlBnHeT­ onnopTYHHCTOB liOJIbmeBH3M n06enHJl B POCCHH HO COIIHaJJH3M no­ CJI nepBopO IJ HhIM HaCHnbCTBeHHhIM aKTOM 60nhweBH3Ma ero nep­ TepneJI TaM nOp8 l eHHe BhIM BenHKHM warOM Ha nyTH K oCB060lKneHHlO '1enOBeIJeCTBa CTOHT TOJIbKO rrpHCMOTpeTbCH K q opMe 06meCTBeHlfOCTH pa3­ BHBweHCH non pelKHMOM 60JIbWeBH3Ma q aTaJJbHO pa3BHBmeHCH C MOMeHTa npHMeHeHHH 60JIbWeBHCTCKHX MeTOnOB no 6YKBe cOBeTcKoH KOHCTHTYIIIUI paCnOJIaralOT B roponax H36H­ nO l BeneM HeKOTopble HTorH paTeJlbHhIM npaBoM cB060nOH ne'laTH H KoanHIIHH OHH MoryT H3­ B TenepemHeH 60JIbmeBHCTCKOH POCCHH Mhl HaXO J HM KpeCThJlH­ CTBO Ha OCHOBe HeOrpaHH'IeHHOH IJaCTHOH c06CTBeHHOCTH H 6e3yc­ JIOBHOrO TOBapHoro npOH3BOnCTBa OHO Be l eT COBepweHHO 060c06­ JIeHHYIO lKH3Hb 6e3 BCJlKOH OpraHHlJeCKOH CBJl3H C roponCKOH npo­ MhIWileHHOCThlO M TaK KaK 3Ta npoMhIumeHHocTb He npOH3BO l HT HHKaKHX H3JIHWKOB J JlJl nepeBHH TO H n06pOBOnhHaJl neraJJhHaH nOCTaBKa CeJIbCKOX03HHCTBeHHbIX nponyKToB B ropona Bce 60nh­ we 3aMHpaeT OHa 3aMeHHeTCH 'laCTbIO HaCHJlhCTBeHHbIMH peKBH­ 3H11HJ1MH rpa6elKaMH 6e3 B03Harpa l lJ eHHJI C npyroH CTOPOHhI 212 Han 3THM KnaCCOM B KaIJeCTBe cpenHero KJIaCCa HaXOMTCH Ha­ eMHhIe pa60'lHe OHlf nonHIH'lecKH npHBHnerHpOBaHhI TOJlbKO OHlf He­ 6HpaTb caMH pon CBOHX 3aHHTHH H 3a pa60TY KOTOPYIO OHH caMH J JlH ce6H YCTaHaBJIHBaIOT nOJIY'lalOT nOCTaTO'lHOe B03Harpa l lJ eHHe BepHee TaK Bce no 6hIilO H60 C TeIJeHHeM BpeMeHH BhIJlCHlfJIOCb 'ITO npH naHHOM ypOBHe WHPOKHX Macc PYCCKHX HaeMHhIX pa60'lHx npOMhIWileHHOCTb B TaKHX YCJIOBHJlX Bce 60JIhWe 3aMHpaJJa QT06hI cnaCTM npOMhIIIIneHHOCTb npHWnOCh Han pa60'llfMH CO­ 3naTb HOBbiM KJIacC 'lHHOBHHIJeCTBa KOTopoe Bce 60nee H 60Jlee npHCBaHBaJJO ce6e BnaCTh a cB060nhI pa60'lHX 06paTHJIO B TeHh 3TO npOH30II1ll0 KOHeIJHO He 6e3 conpOTMBJIeHHH pa60'lHX KOTO­ 213 poe POCllO TeM CHllhHee 'ITO npH Bce06meM pa3Bane npOMhIllmeH­ HOCTH H TpaHcnopTa H Bce YBellHqHBaromeHcfl H30llfll HH AepeBHH OT ropOAa H nponHTaHHe pa60qHX HeCMOTpfl Ha BblCOKHe 3apa60T­ Mfl KaK OHH O HOBpeMeHHo nonaAaroT B 3KoHoMH'IecKYro 3aBHCH­ Mocn KaKoH HM AO CHX nop He rrpHXO HrrOCb BbIHOCHTb 3TOM nOTepfl He 6anaHcHpyeTcfl J1fl HHX yBerrH'Ie- HHeM HX 6rrarOCOCTOflHHfl HOBafl 3KOHOMHqeCKafl HKTaTypa PYHK­ KH CTallO OTqaflHHhIM BocxHmeHHe pa60qHX 6011bIIleBHKaMH HCqe3anO y OAHOH KaTe­ ropHH pa60 x 3a APyroH HO HX Onn03Hl Hfl 6bma HeopraHH30BaH­ HOll pacnbmeHHOH H HeBe eCTBeHHOll rrHl OM K llHl y C 3aMKHy­ TOM panaHroH HX cpaBHHTenbHo 60nee o6pa30BaHHoH 6ropoKpaTHH UHoHHpyeT HeCKonbKO rry'lme qeM npell IIleCTBOBaBmafl eH 3KOHO­ MH'IeCKaH aHapXHH KOTopaH npHBerra 6bI K caMOCKOpeHmeMY KOH­ l y 3TOT KOHel HKTaTypoH 'OTcpOl eH HO He YCTpaHeH TaK KaK 3KOHOMH'IeCKH He X03HHcTByeT H HOBaH 6ropoKpaTHH KaK 0 CHX nop HeY OBneTBOpHTeJ1hHO PYHKl HOHHpyeT HOBaH C HeH OHH HHqerO He MornH 1I0AenaTb TaK H3 caMOAep aBllfl pa60qHX COBeToB B03HHKaeT caMOAep a­ BHe 6ropoKpaTHH qaCTbro BblmeAmeH H3 3THX COBeTOR qaCTbro HMH Ha3HaqeHHOH qaCTbro HM HaBfl3aHHOH 6ropoKpaTliH flBnflromeHcfl opramnal HH nOKa3bIBaeT Me y npOI HM cne yromHH TpeBO ­ HbIH rrpH3bIB KOMHccapa nYTeH C006meHHH KpaCHHa orry6nHKoBaH­ HbIH HeAaBHO llpaBAoH BOT ero co ep aHHe BblcmHM H3 Tpex KnaCCOB ropOAa 3THM KnaCCOM rocnOA pacTy­ mHM 1I0A PYKOBOACTBOM CTapblX KOMMYHHCTHqeCKHX H o eanHCToB H 60Pl OB CaMoBrracTHe qHlla CTapOH 6ropoKpaTHH B03pO AaeTCfl HO KaK MbI BHAenH HHCKOllbKO HH B nyqmeM H3AaHHH 11 H3 Hero H Pfl OM C HHM rrpopacTaroT y e npflMO 6naro apfl rrpecTyrrHbIM eH­ CTBHflM 3apO bIIIlH HOBoro KanHTanH3Ma ITO CBoeH cymHOCTH CTO­ flmero ropa3 O HH e npe HerO npOMblmneHHoro 11 CymecTByromaH CHCTeMa erre3Ho opO HOrO yrrpaBrre­ TOJIbKO CTapbIH peo anbHbIH nOMemHK He B03pO ll aeTCfl nmI rrH3Ma 1l0cne HHH oTrrpa3AHoBaJl CBoe B03po o eHHe HO B p0pMax yrHeTaroU HX H MY'lHTenbHblx lJ JIfl rrponeTapHaTa '1eM IIpe HHe qacTHblH KanHTanH3M BMeCTO BbICOKHX HHIl ycTpHarrbHbIx pOpM IIpHHHMaeT an'laHmHe npe3peHHeHmHe pOPMbI MemOqHH­ '1eCTBa H pocTOBmHqecTBa llpoMbllliJ1eHHblH KarlHTan H3 l aCTHOro 06paTHncfl B rocy apcTBeHHblH KaIIHTanH3M B npe HHe BpeMeHa 6ropoKpaTHfl npaBHTenbCTBeHHafl H KarrHTanHCTHqeCKafl OTHOCHJ1HCb O Ha K pyroH KpHTHl eCKH 3al acTYro - Bpa e6Ho eKTHBHhIMH OCnO HeHHHMH npHBena TpaHcnopT K nonHoMY pa3Bany rpaHHqameMY C OKOH'laTenbHhIeM ero npeKpame­ HHeM 2 Pa3Ban BbI3BaH He TonbKO nO IIbIMH opraHH3al HOHHhI­ MH popMaMH H MeTo aMH ynpaBneHHH He TOJIbKO yrraBmeH ero YCTpaHeHmI POCCHfl C03pena Ho He lJ JIfl YCTpaHeHl-Ifl KarrHTa­ eme 60rree 1 HHfl HapH y C C03 aBmHMHCH B Teqemle rrHTH JIeT BOHHbI 061 ­ 11 pa60'lHH TO Tpy ocrroc06HoCTbro nepCOHarra HO H cnHlliKOM '1aCTOH CMe­ HOH P0PM H opraHOB yrrpaBrreHHH 3 CToHmyro rrepeA HaMH 3a a'lY - BOCCTaHOBneHHe TpaHc­ HopTa B 06neMe OCTaTOqHOM no KpaHHeH Mepe J1H nOTpe6­ HocTeH ronO Horo rrHTaHHH H AOCTaBKH AnH npoMbImneHHo­ CTH TonnHBa H CbIPbH - ny 3a aqy Mbl MO eM pa3pemHTb nHIDb rrpH repOH'IeCKOM HanpH eHHH Bcex ene3HOAOpO HhIX CHJ1 4 3Ta pa60Ta OJ1 Ha 6bITb c enaHa TOT'IaC e HH O HH y O HOH TO Y pyroM HaXO Hll CBoe npaBO T errepb npaBHTerrbCT­ 'lac He AOn eH rrponaCTb apOM H60 HHa'ie BceM 3aBoeBaHHHM BeHHafl H KanHTanHCTHqeCKM 6ropoKpaTHH CllHTbI Boe HHO peBOJ1ro J HH rp03HT orraCHOCTb YHH'ITO eHHfl 3aKnro'lHTeJIhHbIH aKKopA BenHKoro TaKOB COl HarrHCTHl eCKOrO npe06pa­ 5 Ha MeCTO KOnrremaJ1hHOrO B eHcTBHTeJlhHOCTH 6e3­ eHHfl npHHeceHHoro 60rrhmeBH3MOM 3TO 03HaqaeT caMyro MY ­ OTBeTCTBeHHoro ynpaBJ1eHHfl BBOAHTCfl rrpHHl HrIbl e HHOJ1Hq­ TeJIbHYro THpaHHro Kor a-nH60 BbIIla aBmyro Ha onro POCCHH 3a­ Horo ynpaBJ1eHHfl H nOBbImeHHOH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH Bce OT MeHa eMOKpaTHH npOH3BonOM pa6o x COBeTOB AOn eHCTBOBaB­ CTpeJ10'lHHKa 0 '1J1eHa KOllnerHH AOn Hbl TOqHO H 6ecnpeKo­ mM crrY HTb Ha rronb3Y 3KcrrpOnpHal HH 3KcrrporrpHaTopOB npHBO­ CllOBlIO HcnOlllIHTb Bce MOH rrpeAnHcamIH Pe poPMbI rrpHO­ HT K npoH3Bony HOBOH 6ropoKpaTHH H AerraeT B03MO HbIM TO I TO CTaHOBHTb H BcroAY rAe TOllbKO MO HO BOCCTaHOBHTb cTapbIe eMOKpaTHfl CTaHOBHTCfl nfl pa60'lHX MepTBOH 6YKBOH - B TO Bpe- 214 215 no J OJJ KHOCTH H CTapbIH TeXHHtleCKHH annapaT B ueHTpanbHOM llIHB ynpaBlleHHH H Ha llHHIDIX xpaHeHIDI 3aHOBO C03J aTb TaKOH J e annapaT 6 BBeJ eHHe aKKOpJ HbIX pa60T - He06xo J l MO OHH HallIIIH ce6H BblHY J J eHHhIMH B HHTepecax caMOCO­ OHH npHllIIIH K BliaCTH KaK npOnOBeJ HHKH pocnycKa apMHH l Ie­ pe3 COllJ aTCKHe COBeTbI H36HpalOIUHe H OTCTaBllHlOIUHe CBOHX O$H­ OJ HH H3 HeMHorHX 3Hal lHTellbHbIX npaKTHl IeCKH H Ha­ uepoB H nOJ l IHHHlOIUHeCH HM KorJ a caMH Toro nO J enalOT COllJ aT­ yqHO 06pa30BaHHblx opraHH3aTopcKHX TanaHTOB COBeTCKoro npaBH­ CKHe COBeTbI HapHJJ Y C pa60l lHMH COBeTaMH 6bIIIH allb$OH H OMerOH TellbCTBa 60llbllIeBHcTcKOH nOllHTHKH HM J OIl J Ha 6bIlla npHHaJ lle J aTb BCH KpaCHH H J elle3HoJ opo KHHKH BcerJ a COCTaBmmH H36paHHYlO l IaCTb PyccKoro pa6ol lero Kllacca Eme BO BpeMeHa uapH3Ma OHH pa3BHllH XOPOllIYlO opraHH30BaHHOCTb H nOKa3anH BbICOKYlO HHTell­ llHreHTHOCTb H Bce J e TaKHe nopHJ KH no KaK TOllbKO 60llbllIeBHKH HaTKHYllHcb Ha conpoTHBlleHHe OHH nOl lyscTBOBallH nOTpe6HocTb B apMHH cnoc06HoH K 60Pb6e H BO B033BaHHe nOKa3bIBaeT HCHO l ITO He OJ HH nocneJ CTBHH B08HbI BHHOBHbI B TH J KOH pa3pyxe KaK BllaCTb Ho nOClle nHpa npHllIIIO noxMellbe l IaCTO YTBep J J aeTCH 3TH no­ ClleJ CTBIDI llHllIb 060CTPHllH pa3pyxy To He3pellOCTb YCllOBHH BbI3bIBalOmHX yrp03Y YHHl ITo J eHHeM BceM 3aBoeBaHHHM peBolllO­ UHH llnH cnaceHHH peBolllOu HH npeJ cTaBllHetcH HaCTOHTellbHO He- Bcex OTHOllIeHIDIX CTOHmeH K HX YCllyraM He B apMHH 6erymeH HllH COCTOHmeH H3 l IaCTeH rJ e Ka J J bIH 6aTallbOH BeJ eT onepau HH no CBoeMY YCMOTpeHHlO llOHal lallY BOOJ YllIeBlleHHe MorllO 3aMeHHTb nOBHHOBeHHe Hy a 3aTeM 'ITO KorJ a BooJ yllIeBlleHHe pa60l HX nOllIllO Ha y6bIllb J 06­ 06XOJ HMbIM npHOCTaHOBHTb Bce pe$opMbI BOCCTaHOBHTb CTapbIe POBOllbI J bI HBllHllHCb Bce pe J e a OTJ eJ1bHbIe l IaCTH nepeCTallH npoHB­ J OIl J HOCTH H CTaPbIH TeXHHtleCKHH annapaT TaKHM o6pa30M pe­ llHTb BepHono J J aHcTBo BOlllOUHlO l IT06bI cnaCTH C H C T e M hI M Y J e H CJ ellaTb KaK 6bI He npOHCXO J l BllIeH peBOlllOu HH H KOHel lHO 3TOT J eKpeT TaK J e MallO npe06pa3HT lllOJ eH KO­ TopbIe J OIl J HbI npOBeCTH ero B J H3Hb KaK no MallO YJ aBanOCb cTapoMY npoMbIllIIIeHHocTH llOCTH Ipe6yeT J eMoKpaTHl IeCKH H3BeCTHOH B 60ecnoco6HoH J eMoKpaTHH HCKlllOl IaeTCH MaTepHallbHOH apMHH Y J e no nOCTaBlleHHOe H npOH3­ YMCTBeHHOH 3pe­ caMoMY ee cymeCTBY BOHHa BcerJ a 6bIlla MorHlIoH J eMO­ KpanfH TaK J e H rpa J J aHcKaa BOHHa eCllH OHa 6yrnyeT J Ollro J pyrHM J eKpeTaM lloJ 06HO B BOJ CTBO KanHTallH3MY npoH3BoJ HT H nOT HOBbIH KOMMYHH3M caM CBOHX MorHllbIUHKOB Ho cTapbIH KanHTallH3M npOH3BOJ Hll He TOllbKO HX HO H HOBbIe npOH3BO J l TellbHhIe CHllhI DOllbllIeBH3M $aTallbHO npHBell K rpa J J aHcKoH BOHHe H TaK J e $a· TallbHO K YHHl ITo J eHHlO COllJ aTCKHX COBeTOB DOllbllIeBHcTcKaH J HKTaTypa HH3Bella Ha CTeneHb TeHH pa60l lHe COBeTbI 3aTPYJ HHB HO­ n03BOllHlOIUHe ero MorHllbIUHKaM Haca J J aTb Ha MeCTO OTMHpalOmHX BbIe BbI60PbI H HCKlllOl IHB H3 HHX BCHKYlO onn03Hu H1O OT COllJ aT­ HOBbIe 60llee BbICOKHe $OpMbI J H3HH KOMMYHH3M B TenepellIHHX CKHX COBeTOB na J HKTaTYpa oTo6palla Bce Ba J HeHllIHe $YHKu HH a npOJ YKTHBHbIe CHllbI TaK J e BbI60p o$HuepOB KaK H J o Toro OHH Ha3Hal lalOTCH npaBH­ KOTopbIe OH HaxOJ HT Ero MorHllbmHKIi He MorYT nepeHTH K HOBhIM TeJ1bCTBOM H TaK KaK J 06POBOllbueB MallO TO CHOBa KaK H J O YCllOBIDIX POCCHH MO J eT TOllbKO HCKa3HTb $opMaM J H3HH HO J OIl J HbI 6YJ YT Hal lHHaTb Bce 3aHOBO B OIIHlb 60llbUleBH3Ma BBOJ HTCH HaCHllbCTBeHHbIH peKpYTCKHH Ha60p 3TO B03BpaTHBllIHXCH $OPMax BapBapCTBa BeJ eT K HOBbIM KOH$llHKTaM Me J J Y HacelleHHeM H npaBHTeJ1bCT­ la J e KaK npeXOJ Hmee HBlleHHe nOJ 06HbIH pe J HM MO J eT J ep­ BOM MHOrOl lHClleHHble KpeCTbHHCKHe BOCCTaHHH B03HHKalOIUHe Ha J aTbCH llHllIb onHpaaCb Ha cpeJ CTBa HaCHllHH Ha Clleno nOBHHYlO­ nOM nO'lBe Tpe6YlOT onHTb-TaKH YBellHl IeHHH apMHH MaccoBoe J e­ mylOCH apMHlO Ee C03J allH 60llbllIeBHKH HO H B nOH o6nacTH J IlH 3epTHpCTBO Bllel leT 3a c060H MaCCOBblH paCCTpell caMocnaceHIDI nOJ rOTOBHB nopa J eHHe CBOHM c06CTBeHHbIM npHH­ u HnaM OHH Hal lallH C Toro l ITO pa3pYllIHllH rOTOBYlO rOCYJ apCTBeHHYlO MallIHHY C ee BoeHHbIM H 61OpOKpaTHl IeCKHM annapaTOM CBep­ Humanite B N° OT 29 MaH 1919 r npHBO J l T B Ol leHb J p ecT­ BeHHOM J llH 60llbllIeBH3Ma TOHe co06meHHe onHpalOmeecH Ha Ha­ 6lllOJ eHHH O'leBHJ ua H3 POCCHH H 3aKaHl HBalOmeeCH cneJ YlOIUHM 06pa30M 217 216 KpaCHaJl apMlUI eCTh npOH3Bep emle AHTaHTbI EOJIbIlleBHCT­ CKHH peiKHM nOBTOpHO npOB03rJIaillaJI CBOH aHTHMHJIHTa­ HHKaKaJl BCeMHpHaJl peBonIOUHH HHKaKa l rrOMOIUb H3BHe He MoryT yCTpaHHTb napaITH'I 60JIbIlleBHCTCKHX MeTOnOB 3ana'la eBpo­ pH3M MHpOmo6HBblH PYCCKHH HapOp nHTaeT K BOHHe cerop ­ rreHCKoro COUHaITH3Ma no OTHOIlleHHIO HH TaKOe iKe OTBpaIUeHHe KaK B'Iepa H KaK Bcerp a IIleHHO HHaJl 3a60THTbCH 0 TOM '1T06bl MOPaITbHaJl KaTaCTpO pa on­ CTOKO npoTl fBop eiicTByeT Ha60py MHH Ha6JIIOP aeTCH THPCTBO C K a x KaK B K pac H 0 H a p TaKoe npeiKP e B OH iKe- iKe p e3ep­ u apcKHx Horo onpenerreHHoro p OH K KOMMYHH3MY COBep­ MeT 0 n a COUHaJIH3Ma He CTaJIa KaTaCTpo­ C 0 U H a JI H 3 M aBO 0 6 IU e 'IT06bI 6bma npoBeneHa pe3­ BOH­ KaJl pa3JIH'IHTeJIbHaJl rpaHHua MeiKny 3THM H MapKcHcTCKHM MeTO­ HepeP Ko nOJIK He npHxop HT Ha Ha3Ha t IeHHblH eMY nOM H 'IT06bI MaCCOBoe C03HaHHe BOCnpHH lJIO TO pa3JIH'lHe Ta pa­ nYHKT TaK KaK rro p opore JIIOIlH pa36eraIOTCH nHKaITbHaJl COUHanHCTH'IeCKa l rrpecca nOHHMaeT O'leHb rrJIOXO HHTe­ peCbl COu HaITbHOH peBorrIOUHH KOTOPaJl rrOJIaraeT 'ITO CJIYiKHT HM CBoe06pa3HaH Y KpaCHOH apMHH MaHepa BhIpaiKaTb CBoe BOOp y­ IIleBJIeHHe 60JIbIlleBH3MOM BHYIIla l MaccaM MbICJIb 06 HneHTH'lHOCTH 60nbIlleBH3Ma H COUHaJIH3­ Ma H nOnnepiKHBaH B HHX Bepy 'ITO TenepeIl1HH l popMa COBeTcKoH ECJIH CTporo nepiKaTbCH paKTOB 6e3 BCHKOH HX aHaJIOrHH TO pecrry6JIHKH - TOJIbKO rrOTOMY 'ITO OHa COBepillaeT rrJIaBaHbe non nonY'IIHCH BbIBOn 'ITO H B 06rraCTH MHJIHTapH3Ma B03BpaIUaIOTC l pJIarOM BCeBJIaCTI f l pa60'IHx H COu HaITH3Ma - CTaphIe u apHCTCKHe ycnOBH l nHlIIh eIUe YXY II1eHHhIe H60 HOBblH IUeCTBJI leT COUHanH3M peiKHM pa3BHBaeT 6eccnopHO 60JIbIllYIO meprHIO '1eM CTapbll1 neHCTBHTeJIbHO oCY­ He­ CMOTPH Ha rrpOB03rJIaIlleHHe aHTHMHrrHTapHCTH'leCKHX rrpHHu HrrOB Teppop TYT rrOBTopHeTCH 06CTaHOBKa nOnrOTOBHBillaH BO paHu Y3CKYIO peBOJIIOU HIO rrpeBpaIUeHHe pecrry6JIHKH B HMrrepHIO HanOJIeOHa Op HaKO neHHHY He npenHa3Ha'ieHO 3aKOH'lHTb PYCCKHM Harrorre­ OHOM KopCHKaHeu -EoHarrapT 3aBOeBaIT cepnua paHUHH TeM 'ITO ee 3HaMeHa npOHec n06ep OHOCHO rro BceH EBpone 3TO p aBaITO yp OBrreTBopemfe OnHHM nYMaBIIlHM 'ITO HMeHHO npHHU HIlbI peBOJIIOUHH 3aBoeBbIBaIOT p pyrHM HaxonHBIIlHM eIUe 60rrbillee yp OBrreTBopeHHe B TOM 'ITO ppaHUY3CKHe apMHH rpa6HT BCIO EBporry POCCHH CHJlbHa TOJIbKO B 060pOHe Te caMble TPYnHOCTH co06IUe­ HHH KOTopble OCTaHaBnHBaIOT BTopraIOIUYIOcH B Hee apMHIO MeIlla­ lOT eH CBOIO c06CTBeHHYIO apMHIO nBHHYTb n06enOHOCHO 3a npep eJIbI CTpaHbI 11 neHHH O'leHb XOTeJI 6bI npOHeCTH 'Iepe3 EBpony n06e­ nOHOCHO 3HaMeHa CBoeH peBonIOUHH HO BHnOB Ha TO Y Hero HeT PeBorrIOUHOHHbIH MHnHTapH3M 60rrbIlleBHKOB He 060raTHT POCCHH PYCCKaJl HblHe rrpOMbIIIlneHHOCTb nOCKorrbKY OHa CHOBa npHBeneHa B nBHiKeHHe pa60TaeT rrpeHMYIUeCTBeHHO Ha HYiKnbI apMHH a He p JIH npOnYKTHBHbIX ueneii PyCCKHH KOMMYHH3M CTarr BOHCTHHY COu Ha­ rrH3MOM Ka3apMbI 3KOHOMH'IeCKHH a rroToMY H MOpaJIbHbIH Kpax 60rrbIlleBHcTcKHX MeTOnOB HeH36eiKeH OH Mor 6bl 6bITb 3aTYilleBaHHbIM ecrrH 6hI pa3­ pa3HJICH B BoeHHOM KpYIIleHHH '1eM TO 'Iero OHH XOTeJIH H OHH rrbITaITHCb BceMH MepaMH GOPOTh­ C l rrpOTlIB Hero Ho MepbI 3TH B KOHl e KOHUOB CBOnHJlHCb K TOMY iKe peu eIlTY ITO KOTOPOMY 60JIbIlleBHCTCKHH peiKHM lJ eHcTByeT C ca­ Moro Ha'lana K HaCHJlHIO K rrpoH3Bony HeCKOJIbKHX nHKTaTO­ pOB rro OTHOIlleHHIO K KOHM naiKe CaMa l CKpOMHa l KpHTHKa HeB03­ H 060raIUaIOT paHUHIO OH MOiKeT CTaTb JIHillb HOBblM HCTO'lHHKOM ee 06HHIUaHH l 11306paiKeHHoe 3p eCb pa3BHTHe B03HHKJIO KOHe'lHO He ITO iKena­ HHIO 60JIbIlleBHKOB Ha060pOT OHO lBHnOCb COBepIlleHHO HHbIM MOiKHa Teppop peiKHM YiKaca CTaIT HeH36eiKHblM ITOCJIenCTBHeM KOMMYHHCTH'leCKHX MeTonOB 3TO - OT'Ia lHHa l ITOITblTKa yCTpaHHTb HX pe3YJIhTaTbI CpenH lBJIeHHH 06HapYiKeHHhIX 60JIbIlleBH3MOM Teppop Ha'la· TblH C YHH'lTOiKeHI f l BC lKOH cB060nbI ne'laTHOrO CJIOBa H BOCCJIaB­ neHHbIM CHCTeMOH MaCCOBbIX paCCTpeJIOB - caMOe ITOpa3HTeJIbHOe H OTTaITKlifBaIOIUee TO lBneHHe KOTopoe BbI3bIBaeT K 60JIbIlleBHKaM HaHGOJIblllYIO HeHaBHCTb 11 Bce iKe lBJIeHHe TO HbIH POK He BHHa HX - JIHillb HX TparH'l­ nOCKOJIbKY BooGIUe rrpH TaKOM rHraHTCKOM MaCCOBOM nBHiKeHHH MOiKeT H TH pe'lb 0 BHHOBHOCTH KOTOPa l B CYIUHOCTH rOBOp l Bcerna MOiKeT 6hITb TOJIbKO JIH'IHOH KTO iKerraeT 06CYiKJJ aTb BonpocbI BHHhI TOT nOJIiKeH HCCJIenOBaTb HapYIIleHHe MOPaITbHbIX 3anOBep eM M H 0 T n e JI b H hI M H JI H U a ­ H60 H BOJIH Gep l BOITPOC rJIyGoKo Bcerna MOiKeT HCXO­ 219 218 AHTb nHllIb OT OTAenbHbIX nHU Macca KnaCC HaUIDI B Aeii cTBHTenb­ CTBeHHOMY rrpOH3BOllY KepTBYIOT '1ellOBe'leCKOIO KH3HblO ATIH ynep­ HOCTH He MorYT HMeTb BonH ATIl' Toro Y HHX HeT COOTBeTCTBYlOlUe­ KaHHH 3a C060R BllaCTH EOllbllIeBHKH Ke MorYT no AenaTb JIHllIb ro opraHa nonoMY OHH He MorYT H rpeUIHTb Macca HnH opraHH3a­ H3MeHHH rrpHHl umaM CBHTOCTH '1ellOBe'leCKoii l H3HH KOTopbIe OHH UIDI MorYT c06cTBeHHo HO BCe Ke MOT H ­ caMH B03BeCTHllH KOTopbIe HX caMHX rrO l HJlllH H OrrpaBAbIBanH Pa3­ Ka I AOrO H3 Y'taCTHHKOB Aeii cTBHH OCTaIOTCH BecbMa pa311H't­ Be MbI He 60peMCH co BceMH nHMH 6apOHaMH H reHepanaMH KaK B bI A e ii C T BOB a T b HbIMH A MOTHBbI Me KAY TeM HrpalOT pellIalOlUYIO POllb B orrpeAe­ neHHH BHHbI pa3 rrOTOMY 'ITO ATIH HHX '1ellOBe'leCKOH l H3HH rpOllI ueHa 'ITO OHa ATIH HHX - llHllIb cpeACTBO ATIH HX BllaCTHbIX uelleR MOTHBbI 6011bllIeBHKoB 6bIl1H HaBepHoe HaHllY'tllIHMH B Ha'talle CllelJ yeT KOHC'IHO B03pa l eHHe 'lTOB uellOM-TO H eCTb pa3HHua CBoero BllaAbI'teCTBa OHH rrpoHBHllH ce6H HcrrOllHeHHbIMH HAeallOB BblCllIaH uellb OCBHlUaeT cpenCTBa KOTopbIe B PYKax BJIaCTHTeJIeH rYMaHHOCTH nOpO KAeHHbIx KllaCCOBbIM rrOllO KeHHeM npolleTapHa­ CTaHOBHTCH 3110AeHCKHMH H60 HX uellH - Ta Iix nepBbIii AeKpeT OTMeHHll cMepmylO Ka3Hb Ii Bce Ke ecnH ro­ uellb OCBHlUaeT He BCHKoe cpeACTBO a llHllIb TaKoe KaKoe HaXOnHT­ 3110neHCKHC Ho Benb BOPHTb 0 BHHe C HX CTOPOHbI TO OHa B03HHKaeT KaK pa3 B nepHOA CH noro AeKpeTa KorAa OHH pellIHnH paAH BllaCTH rrocrynHTbCH npHH­ KeT 6hITb OCBHlUeHO nOH IIellhlO KaK Hellb3H OTCTaHBaTh KH3Hb UHnaMH AeMOKpaTHH H HCTopH'teCKoro MaTepHallH3Ma KOTopbIe OHH rrpHHeceHHeM B KepTBY Bcero 'ITO COCTaBJIHeT ee COAep KaHHe H AeCSITHneTHHMH HenpeKllOHHO 3alUHluallH Iix BHHa naAaeT Ha TOT ne­ CMhICll TaK Hellh3H 3alUHlUaTb CBOH rrpHHUHrrbI HapyrneHHeM HX pHOA KorAa OHH nOA06Ho 6aKymrcTaM IiJcrraHHH B 1873 r rrpoBo3­ B rrOllHOM C03B IHH C HeH HenocToHHoe ueJIH cpenCTBO He MO­ no6poe HaMepeHHe MO KeT CllY l HTb H3BHHeHHeM ATIH Tex KTO rllaCHllH HeMeATIeHHOe nonHoe ocBo6o KAeHHe pa6o'tero Knacca npHMeHHeT HenpaBHnbHhIe cpenCTBa HO caMH 3TH cpenCTBa OCTaIOT­ - He B3HpaH Ha OTCTanOCTb POCCHH H AllH noii UCllH - CH Bce Ke HenOCTOHHhIMH IiJ TeM 60nee HenOCTOHHbIMH IteM orpOM­ MOKpaTHH OKa3anaCb 6eccHllbHoii - TaK KaK Ae­ BBellH C06CTBCHHYIO AHKTa­ Hee BpeA HMH rrpH'IHHHeMbIH Ho H caMH-TO uellH 60JIhllIeBHCTCKoro Teppopa naneKO He 6e3­ TYPY rrOA pHPMOii AHKTaTypbI npOlleTapHaTa 3AeCb HY l HO HCKaTb KopeHb HX BHHbI KaK TOllbKO OHH BCTyna­ yrrpe'lHhI l1x 6JIH KaHllIaH 3ana'la ynep KaTb C03naHHbIH HMH MH­ nH Ha ny CTe31O OHH Y KC He MorllH He npaKTHKOBaTb Teppopa llHTapHcTcKH-6lOpoKpaTH'IeCKHii annapaT Bo 'ITO 6bI TO HH CTano no MbICllb 0 MHPHOii Aeii cTBHTCllbHoii AHKTaType eCTb He 6011ee KaK Hll­ nOll KHO 6blTh OCYlUeCTBneHO HCTpe6JIeHHeM KOppyrrUHH BHYTPH ca­ llI03HH Moro arrrrapaTa C03AaHHHMH Teppopa CTanH PCBOlllOUHOHHbIC TpH6YHanbi H 'tpe3­ B npaBne OT 1 arrpellH noro rona npo peccop nYKellbcKHH Tpe­ BbI'taHHble KOMHCCHH 0 KOTOPbIX MbI Y KC rOBopHllH KaK OAHH TaK 60Ban O'IHlUeHHH 60llbllIeBH3Ma H rrpaBHTellbcTBeHHbIx yqpe Kn eHHR H APyme X03HHHH'tanH CTpallIHO HC rOBopH Y KC 0 KapaTCllbHbIX OT Bcex rronYT'lHKOB 6aHAHToB H aBaHTIOpHCTOB rrpHMa3aBllIHxcH K 3KcrreAHUHHX 'tHCllO KepTB KOTOPbIX HCB03MO KHO YCTaHOBHTb Ii KOMMYHH3MY KOllH'teCTBO rraBllIHX OT PYKH 'tPC3BbI'IaCK TaK Ke BpHA llH KorAa­ cTynHblx IIelleH Ha TO JIeHHH B03pa3Hl1 ATIH 3KCIIJ1yaTaIIHH ero panH co6CTBeHHhlx rrpe­ HH6YAb 6YACT BbIHCHCHO Bo BCHKOM CllY'tae OHO AOCTHraeT TbICH't MHHHMallbHaH CTaTHCTHKa onpeAellHCT HX B 6000 HeKoTOpblc yKa­ 3bIBalOT AByxKpaTHoe Aa KC TpoeKpaTHoe nora 'tHcna K TOMY Ke 6ecKoHc'tHbIH pHA 6POllICHHbIX no npoH3BollY B TeMHHUbI 3aMY­ 'ICHHbIX HacMcpTb H rrpHKOH'ICHHbIX rrbITKaMH 3aIi luHHKH 6011bllIeBH3Ma CCbIllalOTCH Ha TO 'ITO HX rrpOTHBHH­ ABTOp nHCbMa Tpe6yeT '1To6bI MbI O'lHCrHllH Harny rrapTHIO OT aBaHTlOpHcTOB H 6aHAHToB cOBepllIeHHo crrpaBeATIHBOe Tpe6oBaHHe KOTopoe MhI Y Ke AaBHO BhICTaBHllH H rrpoBoAHM EaHlJ HTOB H aBaHTlOpHCTOB H 6 Y A e M H B n pen b M bl pac C T P e JI H B a e M pac C T P e JI H Bar b Ho KH 6CllaH rBapAIDI I HHllHHAHH 6annrHCKHe 6apOHbI uapCKHe reHe­ 'tro6bl na '1HCrKa nOllIl1a 6hlcrpee H OCHOBareJIhHee HaM HY K­ panbI H aAMHpanbI nocTyrralOT He llY'IllIe Ho pa3Be BOPOBCTBO MO­ Ha rrOMOlUb HCKpeHHeR H 6eCrrapTHii Hoii HHTellllHreHIIHH KeT 6bITb orrpaBAaHo TeM 'ITO H APyme BOpYIOT Ho ApyrHe He YHHMalOT CBOHX rrpHHUHnOB KorAa OHH rro c06­ 220 PaCCTpen - OH cran anb pOH H OMerOH KOMMymrcrH'IeCKOH npa­ BHTellhCTBeHHoii MYApocrH Ho pa3Be JIeHHH He npH3hIBaeT HHTeJIJIH­ 221 reHI H O Ha rrOMOmb B 60Pb6e C 6aH liTaMH H aBaHTlOpHCTaMH na HO OH nHIIIaeT ee e nHHCTBeHHOrO neHCTBHTenbHOrO OpY KlUl 6 0 n bI n e 'I a T H KOHTponb C B 0 6 0 n H 0 H C B 0­ ne'laTH caM no ce6e crroc06eH nep l aTb Ha y3 ne 6aH nHTOB H aBaHTIOpHCTOB KOTopbIe HenpeMeHHO BTHCKHBaIOTCH BO BCHKHH caMOBnaCTHbIH 6ecKOHIpOnbHbIH npaBHTenbCTBeHHbIH arrnapaT KOTopbIe YHHqTO l e­ HHeM CB060 o hI neqanl BocnHTblBaIOTCH H B3pamHBaIOTcH A PyccKaH neqaTb HaXOAHTCH Tenepb HCKnIOqlUenbHO B PYKax CaMble CMHpeHHble BblPa lKCHHH He nOBonbCTBa Bbl3bIBaIOT TaKHC l e yrp03bl KaK H 6aH nHTH3M 11 3TH yrp03b1 He OrpaHHqHBaIOTCH Y I e HHKaKHMH rrOCTaHOBneHHHMH H60 OHH KacaIOTCH 06naCTH r ne qeCTHbIC KOMMYHHCTbl H 6aH IHTbl O lHHaKOBo 3aHHTepecoBaHbI l1pOTHB KpHTHKH COBeTCKoro pe l HMa OHH BbICTynaIOT e lHHo nYUIHO H TYT Y I e HeT pe'lH 0 CHHCXO l ICHHH TaK COBceM He naBHo BcepOCCHHCKaH KOMHCCHH rro 60Pb6e C KOHTppeBOnIOIJ HeH 06'bHBHJIa npaBHTenhCTBeHHblx yqpe l neHHH B KOTOPbIX paCnOnO l HnHCb aBaH­ TIOPHCTbl H 6aH IHTbl 11 KaKHMH rapaHTHHMH pacnonaraCT 'ITO 6aH IHTbl H aBaHTIOpHCTbI HC npOHHKnH TaK I C B peBonIOu HOHHble PH n BOJIHeHHH pa3pa3HBllIHxCH B nOCnC IHeC BpeMH CBH­ neTcnbcTBYIOT 0 TOM 'ITO naBpbl KpaCHOBa HC IaIOT nOKOH ne­ BbIM COIJ HaIIHCTaM-pCBOJIIOIJ HOHepaM H nCBblM MCHbllICBHKaM TPH6YHaJIbl H qpC3BblqaHKH C nOMOmbIO KOTOPblX 000 nOCTaBHT K CTeHKe HCKPCHHIOIO H 6CCnapTHHHYIO HHTennHrCHI HIO cnoc06­ BCH HX neHTCJIbHOCTb HanpaBJIeHa HCKrrIO'lHTCJIbHO Ha pa3­ BaJI HaUICH apMHH EpHHCK CaMapa CMorreHCK Ha pa3py­ HYIO BbiBeCTH HX Ha qHCTYIO BO lY 11 KaK pa3 qpC3BbIqaHHble KOMHCCHH no 60Pb6e CO B3HTOqHHqCCT­ IlICHHC HallICH rrpOMblllIJleHHOCTH l1eTpOrpa l Tyna HallIero BOM 06na naIOT caMOH HCOrpaIHlqeHHOH BnaCTbIO COBepllICHHO CBO­ TpaHcnopTa H l erre3HO lOpO l HOrO lena 60 lHbl OT BCHKoro KOHTponH H TaKHM 06pa30M ICHCTBYIOT B ycno­ CTaqKH • BHHX nopO l IaIOmHX TO InH 60Pb6b1 C qeM OHH C03 1aHbl PCBonIO­ I HOHHblH TPH6YHaIi BnaCTbIO npoH3Bona 1793 I ene3HO lOpO l Hble BcepOCCHHCKaH qpe3BblqaHHaH KOMHCCIDI HaCTOHmHM nOBO­ ro na TaK I C 06na nan Y I e HecnblxaHHOH nHT no CBC IeHHH 'ITO OHa HC 6Y IeT IenaTb HHKaKoro pa3nH­ l1paBoBble rapaHTHH 06BHHHCMl IX 6bJJ1H HHq­ qHH Me l IY 6enorBap neHIJ aMH H3 PH IOB KpaCHOBCKHX BOHCK TO I HbI Ho Bce-TaKH OH CY IHn rry6JIHqHO H HCKOTOPblH KOHTPOJIb H 6enorBap neHIJ aMH H3 napTHH MeHbllIeBHKOB H COUHaImCTOB­ ero ICHCTBHH 6bJJ1 B03MO l CH Qpe3BblqaHKH COBeTCKOH pccny6JIHKH peBOrrIOIJ HOHCPOB rreBoro Kpbma Cy IHT TaHHo 6e3 c06nIO ncHIDI KaKHX 6bl TO HH 6bmo npaBOBblx ra­ paHTHH 06BHHHCMbIX He C'lHTaCTCH 6c3ycnOBHO He06xoAHMblM cnYllIaTb HX He rOBopH Y I e 06 HX CBH IeTenHX ca rrpocToro no n03peHHH - KapaIOmaH PYKa qpe3BblqafIHOH KOMHCCHH C B 0 H 6 C C nom a n HOC T b IO 0 1 H H a K 0 ­ onYCTHTCH Ha rOJIOBbl KaK O nHHX TaK H IpyrHX H pacnpaBa rOTOBa 3Ta MCP30CTb npHHHna TaKHC pa3McpbI 'ITO rrpHIlIJIOCb pacnopH­ ApeCTOBaHHble JIeBble COUHanHCTbI-peBOnIOIJ HOHepbl H MeHb­ IHTbCH 06 CC YHHqTO l CHHH EblJIO rrOCTaHOBJIeHO 'ITO 'lpC3Bbl'laH­ meBHKH 6YAYT CJIY I HTb 3aJIO l HHKaMH H cY Ib6a HX 6Y ICT 3a­ KH HC IOn l Hbl rrOCTaHOBnHTb rrpHrOBopbl 0 paCCTpenc 6C3 cne nCT­ BHceTb OT nOBe lCHHH 06eHX BHH H cY Ia Ho rrpOH3Bon TaK crraHH C IHKTaTYPOH 'ITO cro Henb3H YCTpaHHTb KOr la nHKTaTypa OCTaeTCH YKa3aHHoe rrOCTaHOBnCHHe l1pe nCC IaTenb BcepOCCHHCKOH qpe3Bbl'laHHOH KOMHCCHH­ P JbepJICUllCKUU CBOAHT caMO ce6H Ha HeT B TY MHHYTY KOr la OHO nonYCKaeT HC­ KnIO'leHHe npH OTKPbJTO KOHTppeBOJIIOUHOHHblX 3aroBopax 3THM nOHHTHO OTKpbIBaIOTCH UIHpOKHe B03MO l HOCTH InH nI060­ B3HTO H3 113BecTHH BcepOCCHHCKoro rrOnHHTenhHOrO KOMHTeTa N° 59 OT IJ eHTpaJIbHOrO HC­ 1 MapTa 1919 r ro npOH3BonbHoro paCCTpena 11 ecnH 3TO rrOCTaHOBneHHe 6y neT TO'l­ HO HcnonHHTbCH TO OHO 6y neT oxpaHHTb nHlIIb pa360HHHKOB H 6aH­ I1TaK I10TOMY 'ITO B apMHH 06HapY l HJIHCb npH3HaKH pa3ITO l e­ nMTOB a He HCKpeooIOIO H 6ecnapTHHHYIO HHTenmlreHlJ HIO npH CO­ HHH cpe nH cpa6pHqHO-3aBO lCKHX pa60'lHX H l erre3Ho nopO l HHKOB TpY IHH'leCTBC KOTOPOH non l Hbl 6bJTb OqHmeHblnpaBHTenbCTBeHHblC paCTeT He nOBOJIbCTBO yqpC I nCHMH 1160 'lTO l e TaKoe 3Ta caMaH qHCTKa KaK He KOHTP­ peBonIOUHH 222 PYKOBO lHIUHC 3rreMeHTbl Hc6orrbllIeBHCT­ 223 CKoro COUHaJIH3Ma B311ThI nOJ apecr IIT06bl npH MaJIeHUIHX npH­ 3HaKaX J aJIbHeHilieH npOJIerapCKOH Onn03HIJ HH 6bIIb paCCrpeJIlIHHbI­ JJ lIJTepH6epc MH Llep lKaHHe Ha npHB1I3H HeJ OBOJIbHOrO rrpOJIerapHara - raKOBa Ta B03BbIIlIeHHaH IJ eJIb KOrOpaH renepb B POCCHH J OJJ lKHa OCBlImaTb HelIeCTHBbIe cpeJ crBa MaCCOBbIX y6HHcrB Ho 3KOHOMH'IeCKOrO pa3­ BaJIa 3TH cpeJ crBa He npeBpaur B 3KOHOMHIIeCKoe rrpOIJ BeraHHe HHOPOJlIJ bJ TepMHH H HOp 0 J e IJ nOHHMaerClI Ha H3blKe npaBHreJJbcrBa H HaIJ HOHaJIHCrH'IeCKOH npeCCbl B J BOHKOM CMblcne CKOM H TexHHKo-ropHJ HlIeCKOM B nOJIHTHlIe­ nOJJHTHlIeCKOM H rnaBHeHilleM 3HalIeHHH 3Toro CJIOBa OCHOBHbIM npH3HaKOM HHopOJ IIeCTBa HBJJH­ erCH H 3 bI K TOAbKO HaCeAeHUe c080pRUlee Ha 8eAUKOPYCCKOM H apeQUU UMeeT npU8UAe2U10 Ha 38aHue PYCCKOcO Hapooa flu paca H U O JJfCe PeAUCUR HU nOAuruQeCKa R AORAbHOCTb He UcpalOT CYUleCT­ 8eH H oii pOAU IIOJJHKH 6YJ YQH CnaBR HCKOH KPOBH rOBopH Ha cna­ BHHCKOM J HaJIeKTe Bce lKe clIHraroTcH HHOpOMaMH fpY3HHbI XO­ u H npaBocnaBHble Bce lKe oCTaroTcH HHopOMaMH Lla lKe YKpaHH­ IJ b1 pOJ Hble 6paTbH no KpOBH C BemlKopoccaMH TaKHe lKe npaBO­ cnaBHbIe KaK nocneJ HHe HO HMeroIUHe J ep30CTb rOBopHTb Ha c06­ CTBeHHOM MaJIOpyCCKOM Hape'IHH XOTH H CTonb 6nH3KoM BenHKO­ pyCCKOMY He nepecTaroT BO MHorHX OTHOIlIeHHHX CIIHTaTbCR Ha rro­ nO lKeHHH HHopOJ IJ eB OCT3eiicKHe HeMIJ bI cnaBHIUHeCH cBoeii no­ HnbHOCTbIO OCTaIOTCH TaKHMH lKe HHopOJ IJ aMH KaK 6YHTOBmHKH nonHKH Ho pyccKHe ceKTaHrbI J a lKe caMble HpOCTHble BparH npa­ BOcnaBHR J a lKe caMble nOJ 03pHTenbHble B rna3ax npaBHTenbCTBa no CBOHM COIJ HaJIbHbIM YlIeHHR M HO COXpaHHBiliHe BenHKopYCCKHH ro­ BOp OCTaIOTCH HeH3MeHHO B cnHcKax HaCTOHmero pYCCKoro HapOJ a H BceM XOpOiliO H3BeCTHO lITO 3a 3TOH KnaCCHcpHKaUHeH KpoeTCR llpUMellallue B OCHOBY nora O'lepKa lIernH nOMHMO lIHTepaTypHOro MaTe­ pHa1Ia cBeAeHlm Ao6bIThle nYTeM 6eceA H nepenHCKH C npeACTaBMTe1 J'lMH pa3­ lIH'lHbIX Hapo UlOCTeA 3aTpantBaeMblx B noA CTaTbe BceM nHM lIMIJ aM aBTOp npHHocHT CBOIO HCKpeHHlOIO npH3HaTeIIbHOCTb 224 CraTLJI H3 CoopHHKa loPMbI HaUHoHa1IbHoro IBH lKeHlm B COBpeMeHHblx rocYAapcTBax ABCTpo-BeHrpIDI POCCIDI fepMaBIDI Pe IaKTOP A H KOCTe­ lIJ'1HCKHA C -ITeTep6ypr H3AaHHe TOBapHlUecTBa 06m eCTBeHHlI II n01lb3a 1910 CTp 531-574 CraTbH ny611HKyeTcJ'I C cORpam eHIDIMH 225