CKoro COumlIlH3Ma B3HIbI rrO ll apeCT tlT06bl rrpH MaJleHUlHX rrpH­ 3HaKaX llaJlhHeihueH rrpOJIeTapCKOH Orrrr03HUHH 6blTh paCCTpemIHHbl­ Jl lI TepHfiepe MH nep KaHHe Ha rrpHBH3H He llOBOJIhHOrO rrpOJIeTapHaTa - TaKOBa Ta B03BblllleHHIDI UeJIh KOTOPIDI Terrepb B POCCHH llOJI KHa OCBHIllaTb HetleCHiBble Cpe llCTBa MaCCOBblX y6HHCTB Ho 3KOHOMHtleCKOrO pa3­ BaJla 3TH Cpe llCTBa He rrpeBpaTHT B 3KOHOMHtleCKOe rrpOUBeTaHHe HHOPO llU bI ' TepMHH H HOp 0 ll e U rrOHHMaeTCH Ha H3blKe npaBHTeJIhCTBa H HaUHOHaJlHCTH4eCKOH rrpeCChl B llBOHKOM CMblCJIe CKOM H TeXHHKO-lOpHn HtteCKOM B nOJIHTHtte­ nOJIHTHtteCKOM H maBHeHllleM 3HatleHHH 3Toro CJIOBa OCHOBHhlM rrpH maKOM HHopon ttecTBa HBJIH­ eTCK H 3 hi K TOllbKO HaCeJleHUe e080pJlUlee Ha 8eJlUKOpYCCKOM nape'lUU UMeer npU8U leeWO Ha 3eanue PYCCKoeo HapoiJa Hu paca HU oflJlCe peJlUeWl HU nOIlUTU'IeCKaJl IlOflllbHOCTb He uepalOT CYUleCT­ 8eHHoil pOilU nOJIKKH 6y llYtlH cnaBKHCKOH KPOBH rOBOpJl Ha cna­ BHHCKOM n HaJleKTe Bce Ke CtlHTalOTCH HHOPOn uaMH fpY3HHbl XO­ TH H npaBocnaBHhle Bce Ke ocralOTCK HHopon lI aMH na Ke YKpaHH­ lI bl pOn Hhle 6paThH no KpOBH C BeJIHKOpOCCaMH TaKHe Ke rrpaBO­ cnaBHhle KaK rrocnen HHe HO HMelOIlI He n ep30CTb rOBopHTb Ha c06­ CTBeHHoM MaJl0pYCCKOM HapetlHH XOTH H CTonh 6nH3KOM BenHKO­ pyCCKOMY He rrepeCTalOT BO MHorHX OTHOllleHHHX C4HTaTbCH Ha rro­ nO KeHHH HHopon ueB OCT3eHCKHe HeMUbI cnaBHllI HecH CBoeH no­ HnbHOCTblO OCTaIOTCH TaKHMH Ke HHopon uaMH KaK 6YHTOBIllHKH rronKKH Ho pYCCKHe ceKTaHTbl n a Ke CaMble KpOCTHble BparH npa­ BocnaBHK n a Ke caMble rron 03pHTenbHhle B rna3ax npaBHTenbCTBa no CBOHM COll HaJlbHblM ytteHHKM HO coxpaHHBlllHe BenHKopYCCKHR ro­ BOp ocralOTCK HeH3MeHHO B cnHCKax HaCTOKIllero pYCCKoro HapO lla H BCeM XOPOIllO H3BecTHO liTO 3a nOR Knaccmi HKau ueil KpoeTCK IlpUM e'lt1l1 ue B OCHOBY noro mlepKa llemH rrOMHMO llHTeparypHoro MaTe­ pHarra CBeAeHlUI Ao6bIThle rrYTeM 6eceA H rreperrHCKH C rrpeACTaBHTeJlHMH pa3­ lIlfIlHbIX HapO IHOCTeit 3aTpanIBaeMblX B IToit CTaTl e BeeM 3THM lIHL llM aBTOp rrpHHOCHT CBOIO HCKpeHHIOIO IIpH3HaTeJlbHOCTb ' CraTbH H3 C60pHHKa 4loPMbI Han HOHaJIbHOro ABIDKeHlUI B COBpeMeHHblX roCYAapcTBax ABcrpo-BeHrpH1l POCCH1l repMaHH1I Pe IaKTOp A H KOCTe­ lIHHCKHit c -neTep6ypr H3AaHHe TOBapmn eCTBa 06mecTBeHHaH rrollb3a 224 1910 CTp 531-574 CraThH rry6llHKyeTcH C cOKpaw eHHllMH 225 KOB HO HC BOHIJ YT IPHHHbI 3arraIJ Hhle KaK 3CTbI 11 cephe3HaH 110nHnl'leCKaH CYUUIOCTb u enhIH KOMl1neKC 110J1l1TlIlle­ CKHX OTHOIllemlH orpOMHOH Ba KHOCHI Ho oqmU HanbHO TCpMHH 3TOT HMeeT ell C 11 IJ Pyroc 60ncc Y3KOC 11 TeXHlIKO-IOPHIJ H'lCCKOM K eB­ ponCHCKOH KyJ1hTypC TYT BCrpCTHTCH TaKHC HapOIJ HOCTH KaK 6po­ He MCHee CTpaHHoe 3HaqCHlie B l HHJ1HH­ IJ HH BnOJlHC lIJlH B 3HallHTCJlhHOH CTcneHH rrpll06ll lIBIIlHCCH ARlIHC qyK'lll CIJ Ba BhIIIlelJ lIIHe H3 KYJ1bTYPhI KaMeHHoro BCKa 11 TaKHC KaK TaTaphI HCI10BeIJ YIOll HC MHPOBYfO PCJ1HrHfO 11 061Ia J aIO­ CMhIcnc 1101J HHOpOIJ u aMli 110Apa3Y­ MeBaeTCH u enhIH pHIJ He-CJ1aBH HCKHX I1J1CMCH KOTopbIe B 3aKOHOlJ a­ TCJ1bHOM OTHOIllCHHH rrOCTaBJ1CHhI B oco6oc 110J10 l CHlIe KaKOBhI ll HC I1HChMCHHOCThlO PaBHO KaK 11 HapOIJ hI TypKecraHa C031J aBlIHIC BhICOKYfO KYJlhTYPY 11 rocYlJ apcTBeHHocTb HO HMCfOll HC BCC OIJ HH 06ll HH rrpH3HaK HCnpH06ll CHHOCTh HH rryrcM CBocro C06CTBCHHO­ 1 2 cH6HPCKHC TY3CMHhIC I1nCMCHa ro H3hIKa 11 JlllTepaTyphI Hli nYTeM H 3hIKa IJ Pyroro HapOlJ a K CBpO­ caMOCAhI neHcKoMY npOCBCll CHHfO 3 KalIMhIKH ACTpaxaHcKoH H CTaBpOrrOJ1hCKOH ry6cpHHH HO BOJl KCKHC H KPhIMCKlIC KHprH3hI 6 a III K H P hI rOp1 hI KaBKa3a rafOll aH B CBOCH lIHCJ1CHHOCTH 6 TY3CM1 hI TYPKccTaHa MhlKafOT HX CIJ HHOBCP1 hi H COI1J1CMCHHHKH 7 OPlJ hIH1 h1 3aKacmlHCKoH 06J1aCTli 11 HaKOHCU HMCHOBaHHH 8 CBpCH 4 5 Aancc H HX npHypanbcKHC connCMCHHHKH M e ll C P H K H OK0J10 Ten T H P 11 - 4 5 350 000 Ha ncpBoM nnaHC CTOHT Y I C rrpocTOM nCpCqCHh KaTcropHH lIHOPOAU CB CpCIJ H KOTOPhlX TaT a p hI CfOlJ a BOHIJ YT H3 HapOIJ OB CBpOl1eHCKOH POCCHH 110'lCMY-TO HC llOHCKOH 06J1aCTH HapHiJ Y C CaMOClJ aMH qmrypHpylOT H CBPCH 11 B TO I C BpCMH OTCYT­ M C H hI Aancc KyJ1hTypHhiC Y3 6 CK H TaT a p hI pa3HhIX Ha­ TfOpKH CPCIJ HCH A311H H3 KOTOPhIX K H P r H 3 - K a H C a K H K a p a - K 11 P r H 3 hI CTBYIOT TaTaphI qyBaIIlH BOTHKH 6aI1lKHphI U hIraHC 3hlPHHC rrOKa­ rpyrrrra IJ Ocm­ MHJlJlHOHa K HHM B C1I6HpH rrpll­ CBhIIIlC K a p a - K a Jl n a K H 4 MnH TYP K ­ 1 5 MnH 400 000 11 rrpoll KO'lCBHHKH - Bccro OK0J10 cap T hI I MJ1H H T a IJ K 11 K H 3hIBaCT 'ITO 0 KaKOM-nH60 XOTH 6hI I1paKmqCCKOM I1pHrOIJ HOCTli rpyl1na HapOIJ OB pa3J1H'lHhIX no KyJ1hTypC 11 HaU HoHanhHoH HH­ 3TOH KlIaCcmpHKaU lIli PC'lli 6hITh HC MO l CT 11 CBlIACTClIhCTBYCT lIIDIIh IJ lIBliAyanhHocTH HO 06bCIJ HHCHHhIX MoryllHM U CMCHTOM CIJ HHOH o TOM 6CCU CPCMOHHOCTlI C KaKoH HalIIH 6hIJ1hIC CO'lllHlITeJlll 3aKOHOB TBOplllIlI CBOH quasi KOIJ HIPHKa1 HOHHhIC llrrH HaIllcM 3alJ a'lli pOlJ qeCKHX rrJ1CMeH - 0606ll CHliH 0630pa Ha1 HOHanbHOro I1p06Y KACHliH lIHOHli nepBoe Hli TeM MeHce BTopoe TOlIKOBa­ HliC TcpMHHa HHOp0lJ eu HC MO KCT HaHTH np MeHeHlH Mbl He MO­ pClIHrHlI HaC'lliTbIBafOll HX B 06ll CH CJ10 KHOCTli 12 MJ1H H HMelO­ ll HX 3a C060H CliMnamH MHOrOllHCJ1CHHhIX KaBKa3CKHX Mycym­ MaH• 3a nOH MHOrOMllJ1nHOHHOH rpynnoH MycynbMaHcKlIX HapOIJ OB CJlCiJ YfOT nOBOlI I CKHC rrpaBOCJ1aBHhIC IPHHHhI MOp IJ B a JfCeM KJlaCcufjjUl fUp06an HapOObl POCCUU no Jl3b1KaM nOToMy 'ITO CaM no ce6e Jl3bIK K KaKOU 6bl JlUHC 6UCTU'leCKoii 2pynne OH HU npu­ rr C p M H K H HaOJleJfCM HUCKOJlbKO POlJ hI 3HallHrCJ1bHO aCCHMHJlHpOBaBIIlliCCH B KYJ1hTypHOM 11 PCJ1H­ He xapaKTepU3yer HU yp06HJl KyJlbTYPbl HU CTeneHU Ha14UOHMbHOC O C03HaHUJl eC o HOCUTeJlJl llrrH HaillCH 3alJ a'lH xapaKTep CTHKa HaU 1I0HanhHOro ABH KC­ II C P C M H C hI oKono 600 000 430 000 - 1 200 000 3 hI pH H C BOT H K H I 75 000 H - Ha­ rll03HOM OTHOIllCHHHX C PYCCKHM HaccnCHlICM HO IJ OCTaTO'IHO co­ xpaHlIBIIllic CBOH HanHOHanbHO-lIHAHBHlJ yanhHhIc 'lCPThI lIT06hI npH TepMHH lIHOP0IJ 1 hI MO KCT HMCTh TOJ1bKO OIJ HO TOlIKOBa­ 6J1arOnpHHTHhIX ycrrOBHH X BhlCTynHTh Ha nyTh Ha1 HOHanhHOro B03­ HHC HMCHHO TO KOTopoe eMY nplllJ aCTCH 6 3TH02pafjjU'IeCKOM rrOHlI­ PO l IJ CHlIH 110 KpaHHcH MCPC 06 nOM MO KHO CYIJ HTb no TOM 3Ha­ MaHHH ClIOBa T C rpynnhI HapOIJ OB J1J160 COBCCM 'lY KlJ hIX JlH60 'IlITCJ1hHOH 3HcprHH KOTOpyfO OHli I1poHBHnH B OCB060IJ HTCJ1hHOM ronhKO B O'lCHb He3HallHTCJlbHOH CTCI1CHli npHo6ll lIBIIlllXCH K CBpO­ IJ BH I CHliH K HHH rrciiCKOH KyJ1bTypC TI03TOMY HH paCOBhIH 3JlCMCHT Hli H 3hIK HH IJ a l C PClIHfHH HC HrpalOT pCIIlalOll CH POJlH TI03TOMY HanpHMCp B ny KaTcropHIO BOHIJ YT nOBOJ1 1 CKHC IPlIHHhI BpOIJ C MOpIJ BhI BOTH­ 226 nOH rpyl1l1c rcorpaIPHlIccKH H KynhTypHo KaCT KOMrraKTHhIH H KpcrrKHH TfOPKCKHH HapoA CJ1CHHOCTbfO IJ O 1 MJ1H I1pllMhI­ II Y B a III H 'lH­ HapoA 6J1H3KHH K TaTapaM 110 H3hIKY HO B 6YIJ Yll CM CKOPCC CCTCCTBCHHhIH COf03HlIK 110B0J1 1 CKHX dlHHHOB 'lCM TaTap 227 EllI e OARH ManeHbKHH HapOA cBbIllie 200 000 'len B EBponeH­ CKOH POCCHH npeACTaBJIHeT HHTepec B HaUHOHanbHOM OTHOIlleHHH Bbl B caMblX rnyxHX ylll enbHX KaBKa3a Ha BbI K KeHHhIX conHueM CTenHX KpbIMa 3aIlleBenH1IHCb Aa Ke BceMH 3a6bITble 3bIpHHe no KanMblKH 60nbilieH cBoeH 'IaCTbIO CKonHBiliHeCH B ACTpaxaH­ qTO BbI3Bano nOT B3pbIB MbI 3HaeM no BenHKHH n03YHr CBO­ CKOH ry6epHHH Mano npoHBHBiliHe ce6H B oCB060ARTenbHoM ABH­ 60 J bI rpOMKHM JXOM OT03BaBIllHHCH BO Bcex yrnax orpOMHOH HM­ KeHHH HO HMelOllI He Bce naHHble AllH HalJ HOHaJlbHOrO caMoonpeAe­ nepHH Ho npe l 1 e 'IeM nOT BenHKHH n03YHr 6bI1l npOH3HeceH npo­ neHHH TIo pace H3bIKY H penHrHH OT'laCTH cOUHanbHoMY CTpolO H H30IIllIO C06b1THe OARHaKOBO nOArOTOBHBIllee H JPy CB060 J bI H KynbType HM pOACTBeHHo MaJleHbKOe nneMH 6YPHT 330 TbIC paccenHBIlleecH B CTenHX 3a6aHKanbH H B I1pKYTcKoH ry6 nne­ B3pbIB HalJ HOHaJlbHOrO np06y 1 J eHHH - no HnOHCKaH BoHHa Bec­ npHMepHble nOp3 KeHHH PYCCKOH apMHH H pnoTa HH Ha Koro He MH KOTopoe no HPKOCTH CBoeH HalJ HOHaJlbHOH HHARBHAyanbHoCTH npOH3BenH TaKoro nOTpHcalOllI erO Bne'laTneHHH KaK Ha HHopOMeB no meprHH CBOHX nOJIlfTH'leCKHX npoHBneHHH AOn KHO 6bITb nOCTaB­ Ka l 1 oe H3 HHOpOA'IeCKHX nneMeH HcnblTano Ha ce6e B TOH H1IH APY­ neHO B nepBOM pHAY paCCMaTpHBaeMblX HaMH HapOAOB HaKOHeu rOH CTeneHH MOlll b pYCCKoro Op HH Ka I 1 oe H3 HHX 3Hano AeCHT­ elll e AaJlee K ceBepO-BOCTOKY pa36pOCanOCb ManeHbKoe HKYTCKoe KH repOH'IeCKHX H CTOHKHX nOUbITOK npOTeCTa H Bce nneMH 260 000 orpoMHaH HaUHOHanbHaH meprHH KOToporo BOC­ OHH KOH'IH­ nHCb 6e3HaAe KHbIM H 6eCnOlll aAHbIM nOp3 KeHHeM naBHO Y Ke 3a· TOp KeCTBOBaB HaA He6naronpHHTHbIMH ycnoBHHMH KnHMaTa H reo­ 6bIT0 6bI1I0 phIuapCTBO CMeHHBIlleeCH nOKopHhIM CMHpeHHeM ne­ rpa pH'leCKOrO nOnO KeHHH' HaA BceMH nOnblTKaMH PYCH PHKalJ HH peA Hen06eAHMblM KonOCCOM BceMO£y ro H 6eC'IHCneHHOro n06e­ ARTenH HHKTO TaK He HAeanH3HpOBan BoeHHOH MOlll H POCCHH KaK 3acnY KHBaeT BHHMaHHH H HHTepeca HHOPOAlI bI B TO Ke BpeMH HHKTO TaK OCTpO H e Ke'laCHO He 'lYBCT­ B caMOM AaJlbHeM yrny 3a6aHKaJlbH 3aTepHnocb HeCKonbKO no­ BOBan BceH TH KeCTH rHeTa H np0H300 KaK HHOPOAIJ bI AnH KOTO­ nyoceAllblx pOAOB TyHrycoB AaBHO OTKonOBIllHXCH OT ApyrHX BeT­ pblX caMoe ManeHbKoe Ha'laJIbCTBO HBJIHnOCb 60roM H uapeM Ca­ BeH CBoero nneMeHH HanonOBHHY 06pyceBIllHX HanonoBHny 06YPH­ MH npeACTaBHTenH BnaCTH nopoH He ¥ CTaTO'IHO Y'IHTbIBanH JTOT THBIllHXCH EllI e HeCKonbKO neT H OT noro ManeHbKoro HapOAa eA­ 6e30T'IeTHbIH CTpax HHOpOAUa nepeA cHnoH POCHH HeOAHOKpaTHO Ba 6bI COXPaHH1IOCb ero HCTOpH'leCKOe Ha3BaHHe BonpeKH BceM H 6e3 Hy K J bI OHH YCTpaHBanH 3anyrHBalOllI He HHorAa H KpoBaBhIe O KHAaHHHM B nepHOA oCB060AHTenbHoro ABH KeHHH OHH BHe3an­ AeMoHcTpaUHH '1T06bI BnyIllHTb CTpax H 6e3 TOro JHepBHpOBaHHO­ HO BblcrynHnH Ha cueny BnepeAR ApyrHx MeCTHbIX HHopOAueB My HapoAY B 1904 r cTHTYTa OHH HaH60nee CTOHKO conpoTHBnHnHcb BBeAeHHIO HH­ 3a rOA AO HnoHcKoH BOHHbI npoe3AoM B RnoHHIO BoeHHbIH MH­ KpeCTbHHCKHX Ha'laJIbHHKOB ynopHo OTKa3bIBaHCb BbI6H­ HHCTP KyponaTKHH 6bIBIllHH TorAa B 3eHHTe cBoeH cnaBbl H CH1Ibl paTh AOn KHOCTHbIX nHU H Bbl3BanH npOTHB ce6H lI enblH pHA penpec­ CHH a nocne MaHH pecTa 17 OKTH6pH OHH OAHH Ha c06cTBeHHblH CTpax H PHCK CTanH oT6HpaTh y Ka6HHeTa OTpe3aHHble y HHX 3eM­ nH I1x nHAepOM H nlO6HMblM opaTopOM Ha MHTHHrax 6bI1I nbI1I­ BO BpeMH CMoTpa BOHCK B qHTe Bbl3Ban K ce6e npeAcTaBHTeneH 6y­ pHTcKoro HapoJ a BonHOBaBilierOCH B TO BpeMH no cny'lalO rOTO­ BHBIllHXCH HOBOBBeJ eHHH B 06naCTH 3eMneBnaAeHHH H caMoynpaB­ neHHH H rp03HCb KynaKoM KnHnCH nepenyraHHhIM HaCMepTh HHO­ KHH HapOAHHK rOBopHBIllHH HM 0 caMoonpeAeneHHH aBTOHOMHH pOJ uaM 'ITO 3a ManeHIllee ocnYIllaHHe 6YPHTbI 6YAYT CTepTbI C H B03pO KAeHHH Ha cyrnaHax CHOBa pa3AanaCb TyHrycCKaH pe'lb •• nHua 3eMnH He OCTaHeTCH HH cnena HH nbI1lHHKH To 'ITO npOH30IIllIO B nCHxonorHH KpOIlle'lHOrO 06nOMKa TYH­ rYCCKoro HapOAa KaK B Kanne BOAbl OTpa KaeT TO 'ITO npOHCXO­ BOT BH l HTe - KPH'laJI OH - HAYT BOHCKa POCCHH MO­ AHno B TO BpeMH B caMblX pa3nH'IHblX popMax H B pa3nH'IHOH CTe­ KeT npHBeCTH elll e COTHH TbICH'I TaKHX ••• TaK MorYlll eCTBeH­ neHH cpeAR HHopoMeB no BceMY npOTH KeHHIO BenHKoH I1MnepHH Ha oHa 1 OT nonHpHblx paBHHH RKYTCKOH 3eMnH cTeneH MOHronHH TIPH­ 6aHKaJlbH H CpeAHeH A3HH AO AHKOH BaIllKHpHH 3a6HToH BHap­ MHH B rnyxHX AepeBHHx nOBon KCKHX TaTap cpeAR CTOHKOH MOPA- 228 Ero yrp03a 6bI1la COBepIlleHHo HanpacHa 6YPHTbi H paHbilie He COMHeBaJlHCb B nonHOM CBoeM 6eCCHnHH H TllI eTHOCTH 6opb6b1 qe­ 229 pe3 ro 3TOT rp03HbIH reHepan CTan nOJIY'IaTb nOpa eHHe 3a nOpalKe­ llIHMH npOJIHBaMH PYCCKoro HaceneHHfI B pyrHX MeCTax nocnep ­ HHeM OT MaJIeHbKOrO MOHrOJIbCKOrO HapO a BbI3bIBaBllIerO 0 Tex Hee Bpe3anOCb MHoropYKaBHbIMH nOTOKaMH 00pa3YH aManbraMY nop O HH JIHllIb HaCMellIKH CO CTOpOHbI alKe PYCCKHX npOCTOJlIO H­ 'lcpeP YIOIUHXCfI HOB CBOIO TeppHTopHanbHYIO HH Il HBHp yanbHocTb 3T1f HapO ll HOCTIf nOTe­ llopa eHHfI PYCCKHX npHHHMaJIHCb cyeBepHbIMH HHopo uaMH PYCCKHX H HHOpOp 'leCKHX nOceJIeHHH llOTCPHB PHJlH CBOH HHIJ HBH Il yanbHble '1epTbI B HacymHeHllIHX CTopOHax CBO­ KaK Kapa DOlKHfI 2 3a HaHeceHHble HM oe 'bI a MOIIIHoe B03pOlK eHHe ero COUHanbHoro ObITa O'lYTlfBllIHCb B OJIH3KOM cocep CTBe C pOC­ ManeHbKOH fhlOHHH Ka3anOCb CHMBOJIOM HX COOCTBeHHoro HaUHO­ CHHCKOH rocy apCTBeHHOCTblO OHH HeH30ell HO ypaBHHnHCb C pyc­ HaJIbHOrO B03pOll eHHfI I1HCTHKTHBHO '1YBCTBOBanOCb HMH 'lTO 3a CKlfM HaCeJleHHCM B a MHHHCTpaTHBHOM H X03f1MCTBeHHOM OTHOllIC­ Hey 'a'lHOH BOHHOH BKOHeu 'HCKpe HTHpOBaBllIeH CTapbIe nopMKH HHflX HeKOTopbIe H3 31HX HapO ll HOCTeH KaK Mop Ba BOTflKH 'ly­ OJIlKHa HacTynHTb HOBaf 3pa HOBbIX OTHOllIeHHH K BJIaCTH BallIH IIOJIyqHnH OT 310H rocy apCTBeHHOCTH H pyCCKylO peJIHrHIO COObl­ THfi onpaB anH 3TH npe qyBcTBHfI llpaBP a y Bcex 3T1fX Hapop HOCTCH COXpaHHJICfI fl3blK coxpaHH­ CJIOBHO KOJIOCCaJlbHafi TfilKeCTb CBanHJlaCb C nJle'l H KaK BO CHe e Ba BepHJIOCb HHOpO UY 'lTO 3TO peaJlbHaH ei1cTBHTeJlbHOCTb H nHCb MHorHC HCKOHHbIe OObl'laH a y HeKOTopblX B nonHOH CHJIe CO­ XpaHlUlaCb H HaUJilOHaJlbHafi peJIHrHfI KaK y TaTap y KanMblKOB TO 'lTO B nOCJle OBaBllIHH IIepHO OYPH H HaTHCKa Bceoomero 3H­ CTaBpOnOJlbCKHX H OHCKHX TY3Ha3Ma H OOPbObI IIPlfllIJIOCb nepelKHTb BceH POCCHH ObITb MOlKeT BnOCJleP CTBHH HO HaHoonee HacymHbie HHTepCCbl 3THX Hapop HO­ pOJIb 3THX 3neMeHTOB Mbl YBHp HM eme B oOJIee HHTeHcHBHoH CTeneHH ObITIO IIepelKHTo cyryoo TeIIepellI­ cTeH no KpaHHeH Mcpe cpe ll H HaHoonee MHOrO'lHCJIeHHOH '1aCTH HHM HHop0 ueM 3aMe'laTeJlbHbIH paKT B 310T OypHbIH MOMeHT He HX - KpeCTbflHCKoro 3eMJIep eJIb'leCKOrO HaCeJleHHfI He npe CTaB­ pa3 anOCb HH O Horo ceIIapaTHCTCKoro rOJlOca Bce HapO bI ObIJIH JIfinH COOOIO HHqerO HHp HBH Il yanbHoro HH'lerO pe3KO OTJIH'lalOmerO­ OXBa'leHbl O HHM '1YBCTBOM Bce lKall J anH TOJlbKO CBOOO 'bI Bce lKall J anlf HaUHOHaJlbHOrO caMoonpe 'eJICHHH Ho 3a 3MOUHfiMIf MOMeHTa OJIlKHbI ObITIIf CKpbIBaTbCfI Ba Hble peaJIbHble CfI OT HHTepeCOB H npaB oomero HaCeJIeHHH llpH TaKHX ycnoBHHx B lICPHOp HHTepeCbI 3anpOCbl 1I0TpeOHOCTH Tpa HUHH CHOBOM BeCb TOT CJlOll HbiM KOMnJleKC 3J1eMeHTOB H YCJIOBHH 113 KOTOPblX CHaraeTCH HaUI10HaJIbHafi HH I1BIf yaJIbHOCTb HaUHOHanbHoe caMO­ peBonlOUHH nOJIHTH'leCKHe TpeOOBaHHfI H nOnHTH'IeCKHe BbIcTynneHHH nHX HapO 'HOCTeH B OomeM eCTCCTBeHHO llIJIH B 0 ­ HOM HanpaBnCHHH C oomepYCCKHMH OpaTOp Ha MHTHHraX y MOP ­ Bbl HIIH qyBallIeH rOBopHII Te lKe PC'lH 'lTO H B coceWieM PYCCKOM ce­ JICHHH TOJIbKO B O ll HOM CeJIeHHH OH rOBopHn no-pyccKH B pyroM C03HaHHe BecbMa HeO lfHaKOBbI ObIJIH KaK no popMe TaK H no CO­ - eplKaHHIO 3TH 3J1eMeHTbi y Ka'll ll OH H3 paCCMaTpHBaeMbIX HaMH Ha­ caMblMH lKry'lHMH TO 00 ooocooneHHOH HaUHOHanbHOH IIJIaT pop­ pOnHOCTeH H HeO HHaKOBO II0310MY KalK aH H3 HHX peampOBaJIa B nepHO ' HaUHOHanbHoro IIopbIBa Ha nepBOM IIJlaHe BblCTYIIaeT B 310M OTHOllIeHHH reo r p a p H 'l C C K 0 e Tex HJIIf pyrHx HapO HOCTeH O 'HH H3 HHX KaK Mop Ba BOTHKH p 0 n 0 JI b C K H e He 'lYBallIH H 0 H C K If e 'l e p e M H C bI n 0 JI 0 lK e H H e TaT a p bI oallIKHpbI K a JI M bl K H CTaB­ 3 bi P fI ­ HCKor a 3aHlfMaBllIHe OOOCOOJIeHHbIe Tep­ pHTOpHH Ha OKpaHHe CTpaHbl C aBHHX nop YlKe OKa3aJIHCb HHKOp­ nopHpOBaHHbIMH OKpYlKeHHbIMH MOmHbIMH nJIaCTaMH rOCIIO CTBY­ IOmero nJIeMeHH HH OnHa H3 3THX HapOnHOCTeH HC OOJIa aeT B Ha­ CTOfimee BpeMH e ll HHOH HenpepblBHOH TeppHTopHeH CaMble C'laCT­ JIHBbIe H3 HHX B 3TOM OTHOllIeHHH 'lYBallIlf HanpHMep coxpaHH­ JIHCb B BH e OOJlburnX HJIH MeHburnx OCTPOBOB pa3 eJleHHbIX OOJIb­ 230 nO-Mopp OBCKH H TaK KaK arpapHblH H npaBOBOH BonpOCbI ObITIH Me a TeM 60Jlee 00 OOOCOOJleHHOM BblcTynJleHHH H pe'lH ObITb He Momo BOT nO'leMY HeCMOTpfl Ha BbI alOmeeCfI y'lacrne MOP WbI H qYBallICH B OCBOOO HTeJIbHOM p BHlKeHIDf HX npOTeCTbI TepHnHCb B 3 OOmCM aKKopp e POCCHMCKoro llOBOJIlKbfl COBcpllIeHHO B pyroM nOJlOlKeHHH OKa3aJIHCb HapO HOCTH OK­ paU1l1lble anCKHe OT UCHTpa OOJla aBllIHe CnJlOllIHOH TeppHTopH­ eH H 3eMCJlbHble npaBa H caMoynpaBJIeHHe KOTOPbIX HCTOpH'leCKH CJIOlKHnHCb OTJlH'IHO OT pYCCKoro HaceneHHfI 3 CCb Hall HOHanbHoe caMOC03HaHHe nOKOHJIOCb Ha llIHPOKOH COBepllIeHHO cnell H pH'IeC­ KOH 3KOHOMH'leCKOH H npaBOBOH 4-MHnJIHOHHOro Hapop a Oa3e TaKoBo nonOlKeHHe K H P r H 3 - CKOTOBOp OB oecnpep enbHO p OMHHHpOBaBllIHX Ha CBoeH HeOObflTHOH CTcnH C HX KO'leBbIM XO­ 3f1MCTBOM C HX PO O-oOIUHHHOH TeppMTopHeH CBOCH BepOM CBOMMH 231 Ofil lIaHMH H XOTH H ype3aHHblM HO BCe l e CBOHM caMoynpaBJIeHH­ eM B TaKOM l e nOnO l eHHH K a n M 1 1 K H KaJIMI In KOH CTenH XOTI H B 3HaqHTenl HOH CTeneHH YTpaTHBIIlHe CBoe CTapHHHOe caMO­ ynpaBneHHe HO coxpaHHBllIHe CBOIO TeppHTopHID H C HeH Bce HCKOH­ Hble ocofieHHOCTH CBoero 3eMenl HOrO H X03 11HCTBeHHoro CTPO ll CBOIf BeKOBI Ie OfiblqaH H penHrHID B TaKOM l e nOnO l eHHH fi a HK a n I C K H e fi y P H T bI 3 a ­ ylJ ep l aBllIHe IJ O caMoro no­ cne J Hero BpeMeHH CBOIO HCKOHHyIO TeppHTopHID Ha rpaHHn e MOH­ ronHH H coxpaHHBiliHe CBoe llIHpoKoe caMoynpaBneHHe no 3aKoHY CnepaHcKoro THn qHI Ie CKOTOBOlJ bl IJlIH KOTOPblX HerrpHKoc­ HOBeHHOCTb HX 3eMenbHoro Q oHlJ a H Q 0PM 3eMneBna J eHHH COCTaB­ n lleT OCHOBHOH HepB lIX cym ecTBoBaHHH CIDlJ a l e IJ On l HbI fil ITb npHqHCneHbl H H K Y T bI Q aKTJiqeCKHe X03HeBa e J HHOH orpoMHoH TeppHTopHH coxpaHHBiliHe OCTaTKH CBoero pOIJ OBoro caMoynpaBne­ HHH 113bIK H OfiblqaH BceM nHM Hapo J aM rp03 11T J Be onaCHOCTH nOnHaH nOTep ll no­ cnelJ HlIX OCTaTKOB caMoyrrpaBneHHfl OTlJ aHHOrO Bcen eno nOIJ one­ Ky qHHOBHJiqeCTBa H CaMaH rp03HaH onaCHOCTb - nOTepfl HCKOH­ HbIX· 3eMenbHbIX BnalJ eHHH H KaK HeH3fie I Hoe nOCneIJ CTBHe pa3­ pyIlleHHe X03HHcTBeHHoro CTPOH H pa30peHHe C caMorO MOMeHTa npHCOelJ HHeHH II K POCCHH CHfiHPCKlIX HHO­ pOIJ n eB 3aKpenJleHHble 3a HHMH YKa3aMH H MaHHtPeCTaMH 3eMnH HeCMOTp ll Ha Bce 3anpeTbI n eHTpaJII HOrO npaBHTeJlbCTBa nO J Bep­ raJIHCb npH COlJ eHCTBHH MeCTHbIX BJIaCTeH CHCTeMaTJiqeCKHM 3a­ XBaTaM co CTOPOHbI npHIllJIOrO meMeHTa HO 3a nOCJle J Hee BpeM II caMO n eHTpaJIbHOe rrpaBHTeJlbCTBO B BHlJ ax BHm eH PYCHtPHKan HH HHOpOIJ n eB H B HHTepecax fiY J ym eif PYCCKOH KOnOHH3aI UfH BCTy­ nHno Ha nyTb nnaHOMepHoro ype3bIBaHHH yrOIJ HH HHOp0lJ n eB npH­ 3HaB TeppHTopHH HX Ka3eHHblMH OfipOlffihIMH CTaTbHMH npaBHTeITb­ CTBO BCTynHJlO Y l e B KHprH3CKOH H fiYP llTCKOH CTemIX K TaK Ha­ 3bIBaeMblM 3eMneYCTpOHTenbHblM pafiOTaM KOTopble B CYIll HOCTH CBOMTC II K OTMe l eBaHlflO MHJlJlHOHOB IJ ec llTHH HHopO J qeCKlIX 3e­ MeITb KaK B HaCTOHm HH MOMeHT OfiCTOHT IJ eITO C arpapHbIM BonpOCOM y KOqeBHHKOB JlyqIlle Bcero CBHlJ eTenbcTByeT peqb npOH3HeceHHaH HaqaJIb HKOM nepeceneHlleCKoro ynpaBJIeHiUl r rnHHKOH B rocylJ ap­ CTBeHHOH IJ YMe CKa3aBllIHM fiyKBaJIbHO cne J yIDm ee I UITHp no OT­ qery ra3 PeqJ OT 232 12 MapTa 1909 r npe l lJ e Bcero y KHprH3 HeT npaBa coficTBeHHocTH Ha 3eM­ JIID KOTOPYIO OHH 3aHHMaIOT 3eMn ll na Ka3eHHaH H JIHIllb oc­ TaBneHa B nonb30BaHHe KHprH3 Tpare J HH C031J aBaeMaH nOH HOBOH nonHTHKoH TeM Y l aCHee qTO HHOPOIJ IJ bI caMH TepMT OT MaJI03eMeJlb ll qTO KOqeBbH HX B ofi­ m eM COBepIlleHHO He npHrO J HbI K 3eMJIelJ enHID K KOTOPOMY OHH rro cofiCTBeHHOH HHHn HaTHBe H caMH fibI nepeIllJlH eCJIH fibI K 3TOMY fibIJIa IJ eHCTBHTeJIbHaH B03MO l HOCTb B AeHCTBHTenbHOCTH H KHP­ rH3bI H fiYP llTbI H KaJIMbIKH rlJ e TOJIbKO B03MO I H0 3aHHMaIOTC II H ceHOKOIlleHHeM H nOneBOIJ CTBOM fiYPHTbI rrpHfieraIOT IJ a I e K HC­ KYCCTBeHHOMY opOIlleHHIO HO B n eJlOM HX TeppHTopHH IJlIfl 3eMne­ IJ enHH He npHrO J Ha B a III K H P bl HanpHMep Y J e ycneJlH naCTb nOIJ TH I eCTbID no­ ro HeCqaCTb ll H T II I eCTb OKa3aJIaCb CTOJIb rrO J aBJI IIIOm eif qTO B Te­ qeHHe Tpex IJ eC IITKOB neT rrocne noro ylJ apa OHH rrOTep llJIH Y l e BC II­ Koe MY l eCTBO BC IIKYIO cnocofiHOCTb K conpOTHBneHHID H npHcrro­ cofineHHID K HOBbIM Q opMaM fibITa HapOIJ HCTOPHH KOToporo B TeqeHHe BeKOB fibIJIa CnJIOIllHOH rr03MOH pbIn apCKOH fiOPbfibl Terrepb COBepIlleHHO nOTep llJI HaIJ HOHaJIbHbIH OfiJlHK H B JIyqIlleM cnyqae ec­ JlH cYlJ bfia cnaceT ero OT OKOHllaTeJlbHOrO BhIMHpaHHH eMY npelJ ­ CTOHT COBepIlleHHO rrOTOHyTb B ofim eTaTapCKOM TeqeHHH TaKoH l e fialOH Han HOHaJIbHOrO elJ HHCTBa CJI T ofim aH BceM OIJ HHaKOBO IJ OCTYITHaH 3eMJlH y II K Y T 0 B Y K H P r H 3 M H H Y CH H CK H X Y fi Y P H T H HOp 0 IJ n e B Y Ho B OCO­ fiOM rrOnO l eHHH OqyTllJlHCb KO BpeMeHH oCBofiolJ HTeJlbHOrO IJ BH J e­ HHH rrepBble IJ Ba HapOlJ a Ha HlIX BceH T II I eCTbIO ofipyIIIHnaCb Kono­ HH3aIJ HOHHaH nonHTHKa HOBeHIIIero nepHOlJ a Em e C 1901 r HalJ rOJlOBOH fiYPHT BHCHT IJ aMOKnOB Meq KynoM3HHcKoro 3aKOHa 0 IJ YIlleBoH Hape3Ke 3eMJlH C KOHtPHcKaIJ HeH BceH OCTaJIbHOH B rrOJlb­ 3y fiy J ym KX rrepeCeJleHn eB BYP llTaM B YTeIlleHHe npelJ OCTaBJleHO nepeHTH K 3eMJlelJ eJlHID 1JlI II KOToporo lIX pO J Ha ll CTenb aficonIDT­ HO He npHfO J Ha To l e C KHprH3aMH Y KOTOPhIX 3eMneycTpoHTe­ nH OTMe l eBbIBaIDT He TonbKO 3eMJlH HO IJ a I e H BO J HbIe HCTOq­ HHKH fie3 KOTOPbIX cym ecTBoBaHHe B CTerrH HeB03MO I H0 ECJlH y TaKlIX HapOIJ HOCTeH KaK KHprH3bI H fiYP llTbI peIllaIOm H­ MH B Han HOHaJIbHOM Bonpoce IIBn llIDTCH arpapHbIe OTHOIlleHHH TO 1JlI II IJ pyrHx Ty l e pOJlb HrpaeT Bonpoc lla l e IJlIH TaKlIX HapO J HOCTeH KaK p e JI H rHO 3 H bl H MOp IJ B a BOT fl K H 233 'I Y B a lI1 1I rpOMap HaH Macca KOTOPbIX rrpHcoep HHillIaCb K rrpaBO­ lI1He B xplicTlIaHcTBe meMeHTbl lIMenli p OCTaTOqHO OCHOBaHHH l a­ cnaBHJO peJIHrH03HblH Borrpoc TeCHO rreperrnCTaeTCH C Hall HOHanb­ nOBaTbCH Ha Hall HOHanbHoe yrHcTeHlIe HbIM 3TOM p ene fIpe l p e Bcero p OBonbHO 3HaqHTenbHaH qaCTb TonbKO Mexa­ B penllrll03HOH oOnaCTli B l anOObl pa3JI HbIX HapO J llOCTeH 0P Hl 1I Te l e C TY­ HJ1qeCKH rrpHcoep HHeHa K rrpaBocnaBHJO OHa OCTpO qYBCTBYCT 3KO­ rrblM yrropcToM KOHCliCTOPllll Ha 3no rrpOCboaM rrpHXO l aH Ha3Ha­ HOMHqeCKHH HeT P YXOBeHCTBa H rrpH rrepBOM YP OOHOM cnyqac ro­ qanll 3aqacTYJO B lIHOpO 'IeCKlie TOBa OCBOOO J llTbCH OT HaBH3aHHOH penHrHH HOO CTapaH Bepa AnH HaooopOT B PyccKlie ceneHlIH CBHllI eHHlIKOB 1I3 HHOpOAlI eB 1I '1aCTO HHX rrpe l p e Bcero Bepa HX rrpep KOB Bepa HX COOCTBeHHoro Hapo­ Aa 4 IfHOpoAUbI OTKa3bIBaJOTCH rrOCelll aTb lI epKoBb B rrpeArrOqlfTaH BOT HeKOTopble p aHHble 0 rrOBOn l CKHX HHopop llax rrpllHaAne­ l alll He HaonJOp aTenJO KOToporo MeHee Bcero MO l HO 3arroA03pHTb B rrpHCTpaCTHli ceneHlIH CBHllI eHHHKOB PYCCKlIX H CBoeM CCneHJilI rrpeAlIpHHHMaTb p aneKlie nYTewecTBliH 3a HeCKonbKO BepcT B PyccKHe ceneHHH rAe ClIY I lfT CBHllI eHHHK-HHOpOp ell fopa3AO oonbIIIYJO ponb B Hall HOHanbHoM OTHoweHHlI HrpacT penHrlfH Y Hapop OB MycynbMaHcKHX ocooeHHO y Tex 1I3 HHX KO­ Topble I lfByT BrrepeMe l KY C PYCCKlIM HaceneHlICM 1I IIO OTHoweHlIIO yb 110 000 cTapO-KpCll eHbIX TaTap HC 40 000 MeHee Yb 400 000 BOTHKOB H3bI'IHHKOB OKOJIO 17 000 MycYJIbMaH OKono 3 000 OCTanbHble xpHcTHaHe HO OTcTyrrHHKoB rro BepoBaflHHM H oopa3y l H3f1H Mflomc H3 JIHX xpHcTHaH Mano OTJIH'IaJOTCH OT H3bI'IIlHKOB yb 350 000 '1epCMHC OAHa qaCTb KOCflceT B H3bl'leCTBe ApyraH OTrrap aeT B HcnaM TpeTbH O'leHb CKlIOHHeTCH OJlarOqeCTHBa sic K rrpaBOCJIaBHJO TCMHIfKOBCKIfH H K KOTOPbIM MliccHoHepcTBo p eHcTByeT Halioonce arpeCCHBHO IfMeH­ HO y rrOBOn l CKHX TaTap Y MycYllbMaH penHrHH npOHliKaeT BO BCC rropbI Hall llOHanbHOH I lf3HH HaqHHaH C OOpHp OBoro KOCTJOMa 1I KOH'laH BbIClI1HMlI rr pOHBneHlIHMH P YXOBHOH KynbTYPbl MopanbJO wKonOH rrHcbMeHHoCTbJO HaYKOH cOll HanbHOH COJIHp apHOCTbJO MO l HO pa3nH'IHO OTHOCHTbCH K TOMY 'ITO Ha3bIBaeTCH MycynbMaH­ CKHM IPaHaTH3MOM HO HeJIb3H OTpHlI aTb 'ITO TO '1eM Ka l J bIH qneH CrraCCKHH YC3P bI Hapop a AOPO l lfT OOJIblI1e qeM CBoeH l 1f3HbJO COCTaBJIHeT MorY'lHH TaMOOBCKOH ryocpHHIf C YCCPAHCM rrOCCllI aCT lI CPKOBb flO lI eMeHT Hall HOHanbHOH COJIlIAaPHOCTH H OObep HHeHHH MO l HO KpH­ B TO l C BpCMH yCCp l HO rrpHflOCHT H3blqeCKlfe l CPTBbI B P py­ TJ1qeCKH OTHOCHTbCH K rHX MCCTax H3blqCCKHC MOJICHIfH OTMCqeHbI y MOPABbl KpCllI e­ CTH HO HeJIb3H OTpHlI aTb 'ITO TO 'ITO AaeT OHa B AYXOBHOM OTHowe­ HOH 200 JIeT TOMY Ha3aA AHanOrHq HbIC HBJIeHIfH y '1yBa­ lI1en 5 lI eHHOCTHM MycynbMaHcKOH oopa30BaHHO­ HHH MycynbMaHcKHM MaccaM CTaBHT HX B YMCTBeHHOM OTHowe­ HliH HecpaBHeHHO BbIlI1e OKpY l aJOllI ero pYCCKoro HaCeJICHlfH fpo­ Ma ruIa ceTb MeKTeoe H MeApece C03AaHHaH '1aCTHOH HHlIlI HaTliBOH IICPBbIH BH J lIMbIH PC3YJIbTaT OCBoOOp HTeJIbHOrO ABH I C­ HHH - l anYCTCH CBHllI eHHIfK BHTCKOH ryoepHHIf 'ITO 1f3 lI epKBCn ocrYT Ha CTapbIC MonCHbH 6 CTOJIb pe3KO BblAeJIHJOllI aHCH Ha IPOHe lI1KOJIbHOrO YOO l eCTBa pyc­ CKoro HaCeJIeHHH AaeT MlinnHOHaM TaTapCKOro HaCeJIeHHH He Tonb­ KO rpaMOTY HO H 3Ha'lHTeJIbHYJO P yxOBHyJO nHllI y KaK OTHOCHTCH TaTapbI K CBoeH KOHIPeCCHOHaJIbHOH WKOJIe p OCTaTOqHO CBHp eTenb­ 1 000 CCMCHCTB B lpaHcKoM YC3Ae rrop anH B 1908 r rrpOlI1eHIfC ryocpHaTopy 0 B03Bpalll CHHH B IPeBpanc CTByCT TOT IPaKT 'ITO B Ka3aHCKOH ryoepHHH cpep H pYCCKoro Hacc­ 'AoaBpa­ nCHHH O J llH Y'lalll HHCH rrpHXOAHTCH Ha MOBCKYJO' BCPY 7 ccnCHHH H o l Ha Y'lalll aHCH Ha l C OAHH Y'lalll HHCH Ha TaKOC l C HBJICHHC OTMCqeHO y OYPHT I1pKYTcKon ryoepHIfIf rAc AecHTb TbICHq Kpelll CHbIX B030YAHIlH xop aTaHCTBO 0 MaHOK 55 14 '1CJIOBeK MY l cKoro Ha­ qCJIOBeK l CHCKOro y 9 MycYJIbMaH H OAHa Y'lalll aHcH Ha MarOMeTaH 12 MyCyJIb­ a rrcpcxoAC B H3blqCCTBO HC'Icro rOBopHTb 0 BC'IHOM CTPaxC B KOTOPOM l HJIIf l1cJIaM - rOBopHT OAHH oopa30BaHHb il TaTapHH CBH­ OCTaBlI1HeCH IPOpMaJIbHO B H3blqCCTBC H B onarOBcCTe CBOOO J bI YBIf­ 3aH C HalI1en Hall HOHanbHoCTbJO ECJIIf HCJIaM HC pcnlfrlfH TO AeBlI1HC HaqanO OCBOOO I IJ CHHH OT MHCCIfOHepOB Ho p a l c H OKperr­ no npeKpaCHaH IPIfJIOCOIPHH HaIIIHX rrpcp KOB EcnH MarOMcT 234 HC OblJI npopOKOM TO OH OblJI IPillIOCOIPOM ••• BepYJOllI HX I e 235 MYCYJIbMaH HHKOr J a HeJIb3»' 6Y l eT 06paTHTb B XPHCTHaHCTBO KpyIIHYIO pOJIb HaIJ HOHaJIbHOrO u eMeHTa HrpaeT peJIHrHfl H Y Ha­ nOTOMY 'ITO OHH HMelOT npeKpacHYIO peJIHrHIO KOTOPa» He pO l OB JIaMaHCTCKOH Bepbl xyJKe XPHCTHaHCTBa 9 BBe l eHHbIH cpaBHHTeJIbHO He l aBHO - Y 6 Y P fl T Y K a JI M bI K 0 B l Ba BeKa TOMY Ha3a l H lJTO Bcero CTpaHHee He 6e3 CO l eHCTBH» PYCCKoro npaBHTeJIbCTBa MYCYJIbMaHCTBO »'BJI» eTC»' HCTOlJHHKOM u eJIoro p»' l a rrOJIHTHlJe­ CKHX OrpaHHlJeHHH HalJHHaH C rrpou eHTHOH caMoyrrpaBJIeHHH H HOPMbI B lIlKOJIaX H KOHlJa» rOCY l apCTBeHHoH CJIY K60H naJIee JIaMaH3M CpOCCfl Hepa3pblBHO CO BceM KOMIIJIeKCOM HapO l HOH KH3­ HH CTaB ee l YXOBHbIM tP0KYCOM KaK TaTaphI HCJIaMY TaK H MOH­ rOJIbCKHe HapO l bI JIaMaH3MY 06fl3aHbi BceM lJTO Y HHX eCTb XOpO­ lIlero - IJ Ima» l 0 aHeK l OTHlJeCKHX 3Kcu eCCOB BpO l e Toro 'ITO neTep6ypr­ orraCHOCTb nOTepH CKHM MYJIJIOH 6bIJI Ha3HalJeH B CBoe BpeM»' 6e3rpaMOTHbIH H3B03­ He06xo l HMOCTb CaM0060POHbI He MornH rrOHflTHO He CO l eHCTBO­ lJHK HaKOHeu HCTO'lHHKOM BelJHOrO HaIJ HOHaJIbHOrO paJ l paJKeHH»' BaTh HaU HOHaJIbHOMY u eMeHTHpOBaHHIO H caMOC03HaHHIO • »'BJI» eTC»' arpeCCHBHaH l e»'TeJIbHOCTb MHCCHOHepOB BhI3bIBalOma» He06xo l HMOCTb B nOCTO» HHbIX Mepax caMo060pOHbI H CaMO l e»'TeJIb­ HOCTH B KOHelJHOM HTore TOJIbKO YKpeIIJI» IOIIJ HX H yrny6JI» IOIIJ HX CBoeH MOPaJIbHOH H YMCTBeHHOH KYJIbryPOH H cnenyeT oneKa Ha l BHYTpeHHHM CTpoeM u epKOBHOH KH3HH l OXO­ npyroH B3 KHbIH BelJHafl CBoero PeJIHTH03HOro l OCTOflHH» rrOCTOflHHafl 3JIeMeHT HapO l HOH HH l HBH l YaJIbHOCTH fl 3 bl K 3TO O l HH H3 Tex HaU HOHaJIbHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB KOTOPbIH Tpy l Hee Bcero nOMaeTCfl BHelIlHeMY J aBJIeHHIO H 06bIKHOBeHHO YTpalJHBaeT­ qyBCTBO peJIHTH03HO-HaIJ HOHaJIbHOrO caMOC03HaHH» KaK l eHCTBYIOT noc» raTeJIbCTBa MHCCHOHepOB Ha pacnpOCTpaHe­ Cfl rr03 Ke l PyrHX OH cnoc06eH YCTOflTb l aJKe TOr l a KOr l a HOCH­ TeJIb ero lJepe3 rrOCpe l CTBO l Pyroro 60JIee pa3BHTOrO fl3bIKa npH­ HHe BJIH» HH» HCJIaMa BH l HO oc06eHHO » pKO Ha KHprH3ax 06mHJICfl Y Ke K l PyroH 60JIee BbICOKOH KYJIuype PyCCKHH fl3bIK llOKa He 6bIJIO MHCCHOHepOB B KHprH3CKOH CTenH CKaJblBaeT O l HH MYCYJIbMaHHH pac- KHprH3bI He 3HaJIH MYCYJIb­ eCTeCTBeHHO Bce 60JIee H 60JIee rrpOHHKaeT B HHopo l lJeCKYIO cpeny HO BblTeCHHTh pO l Hble fl3bIKH l 3 Ke cpe l H HaH60JIee 06pyceBlIlHx MaHCTBa H He YlJHJIH eMY CBOHX l eTeH 3a HCKJIlOlJeHHeM HeMHO­ meMeHTOB OH OKa3aJICfl He B COCTOflHHH B IIpaBOCJIaBHbIX MOP l OB­ rHX 60ralJeH KOTophIe HaHHMaJIH YlJHTeJIeH-TaTap Kor l a Ke CKHX CeJIeHH» X rro BH l Y COBeplIleHHO 06pyceBlIlHX Pfl l OM C PYC­ »'BHJIHCb MHCCHOHephI H CTaJIH 6paHHTb HCJIaM Kor J a KHprH­ CKHM B rrOJIHOH CHJIe COXPaHHJICfl MOP l OBCKHH fl3bIK Ho 60JIblllafl 3bI nOnyMaJIH lJaCTh HHOpO l Il eB COXPaHHJIa rrOJIHOe OOHO R3bl'lue qYBalIlH HarrpH­ 'ITO npaBHTeJIbCTBO XOlJeT HX 06paTHTb B XPH­ CTHaHCTBO Bce l aJKe CaMble 6e l Hble CTaJIH 06yqaTb l eTeH Mep BO MHOrHX MecTax IiaCTOJIbKO lJY K l bI PYCCKoro fl3bIKa 'ITO B MYCYJIbMaHCKOH rpaMOTe HaHHMa1l Y'lHTeJI»'MH Ha JIeTO Tamp­ ropo l ax KyrrIU I BbIHY K l eHbl l ep KaTb yqeHHKoB Me l pece Tor l a nOJIHIJ H1I CTaJIa 3anpemaTb TaTapaM­ 061 flCHeHHH C MYJIJIaM H yqeHHKaM e3 l HTb K KHprH3aM Ho OHH CTaJIH e3­ ro rOBopHTb 0 60JIee H30JIHpOBaHHbIX OT PYCCKoro BJIHflHHfl KaJI­ l HTb Ty l a no l BH l OM ToproBu eB H KHprH3bl CTaJIH eme ycep l ­ MhIKax KHprH3ax Cpe l Hea3Hamax 6ypflTax flKYTax 1 Hee oTaTapHBaTbcfl MYCYJIbMaHCKHe MHccHoHepbl B 50 JIeT He OC06bIX rrpHKa3lJHKOB l JIfl rrpHe3 KalOIIJ HMH B 6a3apHbIe l HH lJYBalIlaMH HelJe­ 1 H rrOHflTHO 'ITO He O l HOH TOJIbKO 3MOU HOHaJIbHOH CTOPOHOH C MornH 6bI TaK OTaTapHTh KHprH3 KaK 3TO C l eJIaJIH PYCCKHe OrpaHHlJHBaeTCfl rrpHBfl33HHOCTb HHOpO l u eB K PO l HOMY fl3bIKY MHCCHOHepbl 3a 15-20 JIeT 1O HHM B TOH HITH l PyroH CTerreHH CBfl3aHbi BblCOKou eHHbIe KYJIbTYP­ Hble 3aBOeBaHH» Tenepb 6Y l eT rrOH»'THO KaKHM 06pa30M C TaKoH rropaJHTeJIbHOH JIerKOCThIO Mor 06pa30BaTbcfl B OCB060 l HTeJIbHbIH nepHO l 3aMelJa­ fl3bIKe eCTb Y MYCYJIbMaHCKHX HapO l OB Ha KHBOM HapO l HOM rpOMa l Ha» JIHTepaTypa MYCYJIbMaHCKOH 06pa30BaH­ HOCTH KOTopaH HaKOrrHITaCb B TelJeHHe 2-x BeKOB YCHJIeHHOH l e» ­ COlO 3 061 e l HHHBlIlHH Ha­ TeJIbHOCTH HHTeJIJIHTeHIJ HH H nyxoBeHcTBa H Ha KOTOPOH BocnHTa­ PO l bI caMblX PaJJIHlJHbIX lJaCTeH POCCHH HalJHHa» C apHHu eB TYPKe­ JIHCb u eJIbIe rrOKOJIeHH» H C KaJK l bIM l HeM JIHTepaTypa Bce 60JIee CTaHa npO l OJI KaH KHprH3aMH 6alIlKHpaMH TaTapaMH rrOBOJl KCKH­ rrpH6JIH KaeTCfl K KH3HH CTaHOBflCb rrpoBO l HHKOM H eBponeHCKOH MH H KPblMCKHMH H KOHlJaH MYCYJIbMaHCKHMH HapO l aMH KaBKa­ 06paJOBaHHOCTH B HapO l HbIe MaCChI 12 TeJIbHbIH 3a••• 236 M Y C Y JI b M a H C K H H 237 B To l e MO l HO CKa3aTb H 0 6YPHTCKOM H KaJIMbIl KOM H3bIKax IIIKOJIbHOH 06JIaCTH 6ecrrpaBHe H3bIKa HCrrbITbIBaJIOCb O J HHaKO­ BIIHTaBIIIHX B ce6H 6JIaro J apH JIaMaHCTCKHM IIIKOJIaM H rrepeBo J ­ BO BceMH HapO J HOCTHMH rrpHTOM B J ByX HarrpaBJIeHHHx PO J HOH HOH JIHTepaType Bce YTOH'IeHHOCTH 6Y J J HHCKOH CPHJIOCOCPHH H HH­ H3bIK JIH60 COBepIIIeHHO 3arrpeIl aeTCH rrperrO J aBaTb HarrpHMep y J YCCKOH 06pa30BaHHOCTH IlpHcrroc06HTb TaKoH H3bIK J JIH rrperro­ MOPABbI BOTHKOB qyBaIIIeH '1epeMHCOB JIH60 ero rrperrO J aBaHHe J aBaHHH Ha HeM Bcex COKPOBHIl eBporreHCKOH KymTYPbI - J eJIO O J Horo rrOKOJIeHHH OrpaHH'IHBaeTCH Il aeMOrO KaK Ho He O J HHMH JIHIIIb HapO J aMH MYCYJIbMaHCKOH H 6YMHHCKOH KyJIbTYPbI OC03HaHa HH'lTO I HbIM KOJIH'IeCTBOM BpeMeHH eMY rrOCBH­ y KaJIMbIKOB H 6YPHL C J pyroH CTOPOHbI H3bIKOM rrperrO J aBaHHH B Ha'laJIbHOH IIIKOJIe 6bIJI 06H3aTeJIbHO PYCCKHH 3Ta Ba I HOCTb COXpaHeHHH H pa3BHTHH pO J Horo J HpeKTHBa rrpOBO J HJIaCb C TaKOH rrOCJIe J OBaTeJIbHOCTbIO 'ITO Ha­ H3bIKa H rrHCbMeHHOCTH C03HaHHe HO rrpOHHKJIO H K TaKHM MaJIO­ rrpHMep 6YPHT H KaJIMbIKOB He rrpHHHMaJIH B Y'lHTeJIbCKHe ceMHHa­ KyJIbTypHbIM rrrreMeHaM KaK '1yBaUIH HKyTbI BOTHKH MOpABa H pHH cO J ep l aIl HeCH 3a'laCTYIO Ha HHopO J '1eCKHe J eHbrH L J 11 Y 3THX HapO J HOCTeH Ha'lHHaeT pa3BHBaTbCH pO J HaH rrHCbMeH­ HOCTb I1HHl HaTOpaMH ee '1aCTO HBJIHJIHCb MHCCHOHepbI KOTopbIe B l eJIHX rrporraraH J bI HbIe KHHrH rrepeBO J HJIH Ha HHopO J '1eCKHe H3bIKH CBHIl eH­ 'uOJIroe BpeMH 3TH rrepeBO J bI OCTaBaJIHCb MepTBbIMH J JIH HapO J a HO HcrrO J BOJIb O J HHO'lKH-HHTeJIJIHreHTbI BbIXO J L bI H3 CJIyqaHHo HHOP0 J l Y y J aCTCH J 06HTbCH 3BaHHH Y'lHTeJIH 11 eCJIH TO ero Ha­ pO'lHTO Ha3Ha'laIOT B pYCCKHe IIIKOJIbI T OJIbKO TaTapbI H '1yBauIH rro C'IaCTJIHBOMY HCKJIIO'IeHHIO 6JIarO J apH aBTopHTeTY H3BeCTHoro yqeHoro MHCCHOHepa H I1 I1mMHHCKoro HMeJIH CBOIO Y'lHTeJIb­ CKYIO ceMHHapHIO HO H3bIKOM rrperrO J aBaHHH 6bIJI H TyT PYCCKHH He J p HapO J a ycrreJIH Ol eHHTb 3TH HeCOBepIIIeHHbIe OrrbITbI H He­ HaKOHel rrOCJIe J HHH H HeMaJIOBa l HaH 06JIaCTb 6ecrrpaBHH H3bI­ CMOTPH Ha Bce rrperpa J bI CYMeJIH H3BJIe'lb H3 HHX rrOJIb3Y J JIH rrpo­ Ka - CBeIl eHHH HapO J a IlepHo J H'leCKaH KHHra CTaJIa rrorra J aTb B l ep­ OCTpO '1YBCTBOBaJIH 3TO JIHllIeHHe HO TaKHe HapO J HOCTH KaK TaTapbI KOBb B IIIKOJIY B B H36bI rrOCeJIHH rrepHO J oCB060 J HTeJIbHOrO 3TO 06JIacTb rre'laTH KOHe'lHO He Bce HHOPO J L bI O J HHaKOBO H 6YPHTbI J opOCIllHe J O rroTpe6HOCTH B opraHax rre'laTH H Bo06Il e B rrO J 'beMa Ha 3THX MJIa J eH'leCKHX H3bIKax He TOJIbKO 3arOBOpHJIH 0 rre'laTHbIX caMbIX cepbe3HbIX rrp e J Me Tax HO J ep3HyJIH rre'laTaTb ra3eTbI 6po­ J O IIIIOpbI CO'lHHJHb yqe6HHKH '1HTeJIbHO J JIH rrpOrraraH J bI rrpaBOCJIaBHH H 6JIarOHaMepeHHOCTH B aT 6ecrrpaBHH H3bIKa HHOpO J L bI TeprreJIH eCJIH He TaK l e OCT­ rrpOH3Be J eHHHX HCrrbITaJIH ero B rrOJIHOH Mepe EYPHTbI 1905 r HMeJIH TomKO O J HY ra3eTY H TO 0CPHl H03HYIO HCKJIIO­ TO BpeMH KaK B J a I e 60rocJIY l e6HbIe KHHrH rre'laraJIHCb raHKOM B po TO CTOJIb l e CHJIbHO KaK H 60JIee KYJIbTypHbIe Hapo J bI POCCHH J al aHax Ilpe l J e Bcero 3TO 6ecrrpaBHe oc06eHHo TH I eJIO CKa3bIBaJIOCb B 06­ paJpeIIIaJIaCb H CBeTCKaH HHTeJIJIHreHl HH 6bIJIa JIHIIIeHa KaKOH 6bI Ka3aHH J O rrOCJIe J HHX JIeT HH O J Ha rarapCKaH ra3era He JIaCTH Hapo J Horo cy J a H yrrpaBJIeHHH Y I e He rOBopH 0 TOM 'ITO TO HH 6bIJIO B03MO l HOCTH YTHJIH3HpOBarb CBOH 3HaHHH Ha rrOJIb3Y 6eCrrpaBHe MeCTHbIX H3bIKOB B 3THX 06JIaCTHX HBJIHeTCH OCKop6JIe­ HapO J a HHeM HaIIHOHaJIbHOrO caMOJII06HH H ocpHl HaJIbHbIM rrpH3HaHHeM rrpHHH I eHHOCTH J aHHOH HapO J HOCTH B rJIa3aX pYCCKoro HaCeJIeHHH rropH J OK 3TOT cpaKTH'IeCKH JIHIIIaeT HaCeJIeHHe BCHKOH CY J e6HOH H a J MHHHCTpaTHBHOH 3aIl HTbI Ha MeCTe Cy J bH H 3aKOHa UnH rrpeBpaIl eHHH HapO J a B H a l H 0 H a JI b H bI H KOJIJIeK­ rHB C03HaIOIl HH ce6H TaKOBbIM He J ocrarO'lHO KOHe'lHO O J HOH Ha­ CTaHOBHTCH JIH'lHOCTH Tex HJIH J pyrHx 06bI'IHbIX 3JIeMeHrOB HapO J HOro 6bITHH rrpeCJIOBYTbIH rrHcapb rrpocpeCCHOHaJIbHbIH rrepeBO J '1HK KaKoe rro­ KaK reppHropHH H3bIK Bepa CXO J CTBO 06bI'laeB H 06pa3a l H3HH JIe J JIH BbiMOraTeJIbCTBa 6eCCY J HOCTH rrpOH3BOJIa 3TO HcrrbITaJIH H L J 3ro Bce CbIPbJe MarepHamI rpe6yIOIl He OC060H orHeHHOH oc06eHHO OCTpO TaKHe HapO J HOCTH KaK 6YPHTbI KaJIMbIKH eIl e crraHKH B rOpHHJIe 06Il ero opraHH30BaHHOrO O'leHb He J aBHo HMeBIIIHe c06CTBeHHoe yrrpaBJIeHHe H CY J 'uOCTaTO'l­ crBa 06Il eH 60Pb6bI 3a cor p y J H H 'I e ­ caMocoxpaHeHHe HO BH J eTb 6eCrrOMOIl HOrO HHopO J l a BbICJIYIllHBaIOIl erO pe30JIIO­ o 6 Il H X l HIO KpeCTbHHCKoro Ha'laJIbHHKa HJIH rrOJIY'laIOIl erO KorrHIO peIIIeHHH Mepe Ha HerrOHHTHOM eMY H3bIKe '1T06bI rrOHHTb H 06H J y H 3JI06y 3aro­ 3YJIbraTa paIOIl HeCH B ero J YIIIe KpOMe roro 6JIarOrrpHHrHbIe YCJIOBHH '1r06bI raKHe 3MOl HH He re­ 238 H C TOp H 'I e C K H X 0 6 Il H X J e H C r B H H H C TOp H 'I e C K H X COBMeCTHOH HJIH rro KpaHHeH 3 M 0 l H H 60Pb6bI HJIH rrepe l HBaHHH - KaK pe­ He06xo J HMbI 239 pmm cBoeif 'lKHBOCTH H HPKOCTH B rraMHTH HapOna Ho 3TH 3MOIJ HH mHeCH B caMoH cTpyKType naHHoH HapO 1HOCTH He06xoAHM anna­ 3TO cOTpynHH'leCTBO MoryT oCJIa6HYTb ObIBaeT H TaK 'ITO 3TH q aK­ paT 'Iepe3 KOTOPbIH Bce CTHMYJIbI Bce 3MOIJ HH C HaH60JIbllIeH CH­ TOPbI H He B03HHKaJIH H He nOCTHraJIH TOR HHTeHCHBHoCTH npH KO­ JIOH H 6bICTPOTOH npOBonHJIHCb 110 BceMY opraHH3MY HapO D a He­ TOpOR aMopq HblR HapOIUfbIR opraHH3M npeBpaTHJICR 6bI B caMOC03­ 06xonHMa HaJIHI HOCTb JIH60 TOR HJIH D pyrOH HaKlmeeCR e D HHOe IJ eJIoe TaKHM 06pa30M MbI BH U M HapO D HOCTH o p r a H H 3 a IJ H H HaIJ HOHaJIbHO yracIIDIe H Hapo D HOCTH HHKorna He nOCTHraBIIlHe HOH B Hy'lKHyKl MHHyry HanpaBHTb pa3p03HeHHbIe neHCTBHR B O D HO HaIJ HOHaJIbHOrO caMOC03HaHHR H cymeCTBOBaHHR 06mee pyCJIO KaK AJIH B03pO'lK D eHHR HaIJ HOHaJIbHOCTH TaK H AJIR pO'lK D eHHR ee B Hem H H e C 0 IJ H a JI b H 0 H HanpHMep pOnOBOH llJIeMeHHOH Clloc06­ JIH60 eCJIH Bce CJIe D bI HCTOpH'leCKOH OpraHH3aIJ HH ycneJIH COHTH CO CIJ eHbI HaJIH'lHOCTb H H T e JI JI H r e H IJ H H ­ He06xo U MbI eme MoryqHe CTHMYJIbI He06xonHM AYXOBHOH HJIH cBeTcKoH CMOTPH no 06CToHTeJIbCTBaM -clloc06­ MOMeHT HJIH nOBTOpR KlII HRCR pR D MOMeHTOB BbICOKoro 3MOIJ HO­ HOH 3apa3HTb Maccy c06crneHHbIM 3HTY3Ha3MOM K 60Pb6e 3a HaIJ H­ HaJIbHOrO 06meHHR llnR arperaTa HapO D HOCTH He06xonHM BHem­ OHaJIbHOe oCB060'lK D eHHe oe3 OpraHH33 IJ HH 6e3 q epMeHTa HHTeJI­ HHH TOJI'IOK 'IT06bI n06Y' u Tb pa3p03HeHHbIe HecrrMHHbIe 3JIeMeHTbI JIHreHIJ HH B03pO'lKneHHe HeB03MO'lKHO C K 06meMY neHcTBHKl K 06meif 60pb6e K 3MOIJ HHM HaIJ HOHaJIbHOrO 3ToH CXeMaTHI eCKOH TO'lKH 3peHHH HHTepecHo B3rJIHHYTb Ha C03HaHHR KOTopbIe 6YAY'IH nOBTOpR eMbI npeBpaTHBllIHcb B TpanH paccMaTpHBaeMbIe HaMH HapO D HOCTH IJ HKl CTaHOBHTCH 06bI'IHbIM nCHXH'leCKHM npH3HaKoM naHHoro 3T­ MeHbllIeH CTelleHH nepe'lKHJIH B CBoe BpeMH nepHOn 60PWbI 3a HaIJ H­ HHI eCKoro KOJIJIeKTHBa KHprH3bI no CBH D eTeJIbCTBY B B PaAJIOBa H3yqaBllIero HX JIeT 35 Ha3aA HeCMOTpR Ha TO'lK D eCTBO R 3bIKa 06­ pa3a 'lKH3HH BepbI He TOJIbKO He C03HaBaJIH ce6R enHHbIM HapO D OM Bce OHH B 60JIbllIeH HJIH OHaJIbHYIO HHAHBH D yaJIbHOCTb Bce OHH OnHHaKoBO nOTepneJIH nopa­ 'lKeHHe XOTH O D HH KOH'l HJIH 60Pb6y paHbllIe npyrHe - n03'lKe Ho He O D HHaKOBbI 6bIJIH nOCJIenCTBHR 3Toro TparHtfeCKoro q HHaJIa 13 HO He HMeJIH Ha CBoeM H3bIKe na'lKe HaAJIe'lKamero CJIOBa KOTopoe MHorHe BMeCTe C HHKopnopaUHeH nOTepHJIH He TOJIbKO CBOH Tep­ BbIPa'lKaJIO 6bI 3TO nOHR THe Ho Korna PycHq HKaTopcKM nOJIHTHKa pHTOpHH H COIJ HaJIbHbIe opraHH3aUHH HO H Te HaIJ HOHaJIbHbIe TpaAH­ Y C03 D aJIa 06IIIYKl onaCHOCTb nOTepH HX yqpe'lKneHHH H rJIaBHOe 3e­ IJ HH KOTopbIe HBJIHIOTCH 3epHOM AJIH 6ynymero B03pO'lKn eH HR MeJIb OHH Ha'laJIH C03HaBaTb ce6H HapO D OM To 'lKe C 6YPR TaMH TaTap y MOP D BbI Y BOTHKOB tfYBaIIIeH 'IepeMHCoB 6allIKHp y 3b1­ Korna 3TH nOCJIe D HHe BCTYnHJIH B pYCCKoe nOMaHCTBO OHH npen­ pHH H T n HaponHOcTeH npOIIIJIaH He3aBHCHMOCTb e D Ba JIH He rryCTOH CTaBJIR JIH C060Kl arperaT pOnOB llJIeMeH HO He HapOn 06mHH rHeT 3ByK He rOBopHmHH HH YMY HH cep D IJ y KOHetfHO TOMY 6bIJIH MO­ 06mM onaCHOCTb nOTepH CBOHX npaB H 3eMeJIb rrOCTeneHHO CIIJIa'I H­ rymecTBeHHbIe npH'lHHbI - BaJIH PO D bI H llJIeMeHa B O D HO IJ eJIoe H Ha HaIIDIX rJIa3aX B MOMeHT JIeHHe pyccKoro 3JIeMeHTa HnH 3eMenbHoe pa30peHHe HO KaKOBbI BeJIH'IaHllIeH onaCHOCTH AJIR HX cymecTBOBaHHR MOMeHT nOTepH 6b1 HH 6bIJIH 3TH npH'lHHbI caMoynpaBJIeHHH H 3eMeJIb COBnaBllIHH C npyrHM BeJIHKHM CTHMy­ HO-nOJIHTHI eCKHe JIOM - oCB060nHTeJIbHOrO D BH'lKeHHR OKpbIJIHBllIerO HX Ha D e'lK D bI H BHYllIaBllIero MY'lKeCTBO - 06e 6YPHTCKHe HeTBH nO D HHJIHCb no HaIJ HOHaJIbHOrO caMOC03HaHHR B BHeUIHero C T H M Y JI a 3TOM CJIyqae MbI BH U M KpOMe r H eTa 0 n a C HOC T H npyroH Be­ JIHKHH CTHMYJI pO'lK D eHHH H B03pO'lK D eHHR HaIJ HOHaJIbHOCTH M Y JI H3BHe npHllIeAllIeH CT H ­ C B 0 6 0 n bI Ho KpoMe BbIllIeYKa3aHHbIX MOMeHTOB KaK nOTepH CIIJIOllIHOH TeppHTopHH D aB­ q aKT HaJIHIJ O He TOJIbKO HaIJ HOHaJIb­ HO B 3HaQHTeJIbHOH CTeneHH 'IHCTO HaIJ HOHaJIbHble 3MOIJ HH H caMOC03HaHHe HCQe3nH ilocne HHKOpnOpaIJ HH MbI He BH­ D HM HHKaKHX rrpOR BneHHH KOnJIeKTHBHOH neHTenbHOCTH HHKaKOH caMo060pOHbI OrpOMHYIO pOJIb B 3TOM TparH'leCKOM q aKTe Hrpa­ JIa pa3YMeeTCH He TOJIbKO MaJIaH KynbTYpHOCTb HO H 6ecrroman­ HOCTb 60pb6bI B 3TOH BeKoBoH 60Pb6e rrorH6JIH 6e3 COMHeHHH HaH60JIee 3HeprHl HbIe 3JIeMeHTbI a HOBbIe YCJIOBHR 'lKH3HH 6bIJIH AJIH npoIJ eCca B03PO'lK­ cnHllIKOM MaJIO 6narOrrpHR THbI AJIH Bblpa60TKH HHnHBHnyaJIbHO­ D eHHR HaUHOHaJIbHOCTH He06xo D HMbI eme 6JIarOnpHR THbIe YCJIOBHR CTeH 113BecTHbIH rrpHMep KpeCTbR HHHa MopABHHa KY3bMbI AneKce­ 11 He TOJIbKO 6JIarOnpHR THbIe YCJIOBHR 06DeKTHBHoro CBOHCTBa KaK eBa no np03BHIIIY KY3bKa BbIrO D HOe reorpaq H'IeCKOe nOJIO'lKeHHe cJIa60cTb naBHmeH HaIJ HO­ eH HaJIbHOCTH BHellIHR H nOMOmb H T n He06xo U MbI YCJIOBHH KPOIO­ D BH'lKeHHe cpenH MOP D BbI YBneKllIero 3a C060Kl TbICH'IH HapO D a 240 nponOBenbIO 06HOBneHHOH MOP D OBCKHH 60r CyMeBllIero CBO­ CTapOH BepbI BbI3BaTb MaCCOBoe 241 H Ha MOMeHT BOCKpeCHBlIIerO B MOP OBCKOM HapO e CTapbIe HaIJ 10­ HaJIbHbIe 3MOUHH - TOnbKO Hpqe rrO qepKHBaeT HaUHOHanbHOe 6ec­ CHnHe rrO 06HbIX HapOAHOCTeH Ko BpeMeHH OCB060 HTenbHOrO BH eHHH YKa3aHHbIe HaMH Ha­ PO HOCTH OqYTHnHCb TaK lInH HHaqe B TaKOM rrOnO eHHH qTO He r ' V ii ' I TonbKO CTapbIe HaUHOHaJIbHO-rrOnHTH4eCKHe 3MOUHH HO H caMbIH ' HMelOT rrym H Cpe CTBa nH 06meHHH H 06mHX eHCTBHH TO rrpaBO­ cnaBHaH MOpABa BOTHKH H p H nOH pOPMbI 06meHHH He HMelOT BceM nHM HapOAHOCTHM eme rrpe CTOHT ecnH HM CY l eHO B03PO­ HTbCH C03 aTb Ty HnH pyrylO p0PMY opraHH30BaHHoro cOIJ 1am­ HOro lInH KynbTypHoro 06meHHH CTapbIe 06meCTBeHHbIe OpraHH­ 3aUHH yMepnH yMepnH H KnaCCbI paHblIIe CTOHBlIIHe BO rnaBe 60Pb­ cTHMyn caMOCOXpaHeHHH CTHMyn orraCHOCTH H 60Pb6bI OKa3anCH YT­ 6bI H HY HbI 6bInH HOBbIe 3neMeHTbI KOTopbIe BOCKpeCHnH 6bI rre­ paqeHHbIM H60 B rren rrOTYXlIIero oqara 3TH 3neMeHTbI KaK MbI yBH HM HBlInHCb rr 0 n H T H q e C K 0 H 06naCTH OHH 6e3Ha e ­ HO rrOTepHnH Bce qTO B03MO H0 TonbKO rrOTepHTb - BIInOTb 0 Ha­ B OAHOH TonbKO 06naCTH B 06naCTH HBnHnHCb eCTeCTBeHHbIMH 3amHTHHKaMH coxpa- OT aJIeHHbIX rpaHHU OT Harropa KOqeBHHKOB H B TO e BpeMH cnY H­ HO 60nee HnH MeHee opraHH30­ nH rrOCpeAHHKaMH C COCeAHHMH TeppHTopHHMH H rrneMeHaMH BOCTO­ CT H M Y n pen H r H H B H H Ten n H r e HUH H HarrpHMep 6 y P H T bI e bI HHnCH - nHue 0 rr a C HOC T H BaHHYIO caMo060pOHY H COTpYAHHqeCTBO Cpe H 3THX HapO HOCTeH Ka B MbI HaXO HM TonbKO Y HapO HOCTeH MaroMeTaHcKHX H TO rrpeHMY­ TenbCTBO 6bInO paKTHqeCKH nHlIIeHO B03MO HOCTH orrHpaTbcH Ha CH­ BH l y y aJIeHHOCm OT ueHTpOB PYCCKOH oceWIocm rrpaBH­ meCTBeHHO Y TaTap Y KOTOPbIX HcnaM rrYCTHn rny60KHe KOpHH BbI­ ny MeCTHoro pyccKoro 3neMeHTa KpaHHe HeMHOrOqHcneHHoro Bce OCTOHHCTBa nOH penHrHH rrOMep HBaJIH B 3TO BMeCTe B3HToe 3aCTaBnHno ueHTpanbHoe rrpaBHTenbcTBo c ep H­ Maccax TaTapCKOrO HapO a CTOHKOCTb B 60Pb6e H rnaBHoe Bepy BaTh PYCH pHKaTOpCKHH rrbIn MeCTHOH a MHHHCTpaUHH H OCTaBHTb B HeCOKpYlIIHMOCTb HapO HOCTHM 0 H3BeCTHOH CTerreHH HX BHYTpeHHlO1O caMOCTOHTenb­ COKHe KynbTypHbIe flHlIIeHHbIe rrOnHTH4eCKHX opraHH3aUHH TaTapbI HMenH eCTeCT­ HOCTb B OAHOM OTHOlIIeHHH pYCCKoe Bna bIqeCTBO rrpHHecno nHM OHO aJIO HM 8HyrpeHHUU MUp OHO BeHHbIe opraHH3aUHH B CBOHX 060c06neHHbIX penHrH03HbIX 06mH­ HapO aM orpoMHylO rronb3y Hax rrpeKpaTHno Te ry6HTenbHbIe pacrrpH KOTopbIe HHKOr a paHblIIe He CTHMyn penHrH03HOH orraCHOCTH BbI3BaHHaH elO rroTpe6HOCTb B rrpeKpamaJIHCb Me y OT enbHbIMH pO aMH H rrneMeHaMH H 3Hep­ caMo060pOHe H CaMO eHTenbHOCTH HaKOHeu na crrOHTaHHaH op­ rHH KOTOPaH 0 Toro YXOAHna raHH3aUHH rnaB penHrH03HbIX 06IUHH 6e3 COMHeHHH On HbI 6bI­ 60Pb6y Terrepb Morna HarrpaBnHTbCH He TonbKO Ha MHPHYIO Kynb­ Ha pa3pYlIIHTenbHYIO BHyTpeHHlO1O nH CblrpaTb orpoMHylO ponb B rrp06y eHHH HaUHOHaJIbHOrO caMO­ TYPHYIO pa6OTY HO H Ha HaUHOHaJIbHOe 06'be HHeHHe H COTPY HH­ C03HaHHH Ho noro 6bInO He OCTaTOqHO OCTpOTa penHrH03HOH qeCTBO TaK HnH HHaqe HO nH HapOAHOCTH HapH l y CO CBoeH TeppH­ 60Pb6bI 3HaqHTenbHO rrapaJIH30BaJIa HapOAHYIO 3HeprHIO HarrpaBHB TopHeH H 3eMenbHbIM YCTPOHCTBOM coxpaHHnH 0 rrOCne HerO Bpe­ ee B Y3Koe pycno OAHOCTOPOHHHX 3MOUHH B nOM OTHOlIIeHHH Ta­ MeHH H CBOIO TapbI OKaJanHCb B TOM e rrOnO eHHH qTO H MeHee KynbTypHbIe Ha­ C Tap y 10 C 0 U Han b H Y 10 0 P r a H H 3 a U H 10 KaK HH rrpH aBneHO 6bInO HHOpO l 4eCKOe caMoyrrpaBneHHe HO PO bI IloBon bH Y Bcex nHX HapO OB CTapaH COUHaJIbHaH CTPYK­ opraHbI ero TaK HnH HHaqe HnH eHCTBOBaJIH 60ponHCb XOTH 6bI Typa PYIIIHnaCb BMeCTe C rrOcneAHHMH rrOpa eHHHMH B 60Pb6e 3a 060pOHHTenbHO H B 3TOH 60Pb6e YKperrnHnOCb C03HaHHe HaIJ 10Hanb­ He3aBHCHMOCTb YCHneHHaH HMMHrpaUHH pYCCKoro 3neMeHTa Ha­ Horo 6bITHH H e HHCTBa PH y C a MHHHCTpaTHBHOH pYCHqmKaUHeH aBHbIM aBHO pa3pYlIIH­ He 3a6y eM qTO B OCHOBe HHOpO qeCKOrO caMoyrrpaBneHHH ne­ PO HnH COlO3 PO OB - rr n e M H A nH CTapbIH PO OBOH CTPOH 3aMeHHB H caMoyrrpaBneHHe H cy 06me­ aJI PYCCKHMH yqpe eHHHMH TonbKO KOHcrrHpaTHBHO H TO B MeCTax MHKpOKOCM He TonbKO HaUHOHanbHoro HO H COIJ 1aJIbHO-rrOnHTHqe­ PO HnH rrneMH - CO crrnOliIHbIM HHOpO qeCKHM HaceneHHeM B03MO HbI 6bInH corna­ CKoro opraHH3Ma PO He TonbKO KPOBHbIH COlO3 H xpaHHTenb 06­ 11 mHX HCTOpH4eCKHX TpaAHIJ 1H H 3MOUHH HO H paCrrOpH HTenb Bcero lIIeHHH H crOBopbI OT enbHbIX cenbCKHX 06meCTB H BonOCTeH ecnH TaTapbI a eme OHCKHe H CTaBporronbCKHe KaJIMbIKH 6naro­ pO OBOrO 60raTcTBa 3eMJIU apH lIIeHHH B03bMHTe KaKoe-HH6Y b TaK Ha3bIBaeMoe UHOpOO'leCKOe 8e­ 242 HHOBepHIO H caMOCTOHTenbHOCTH uepKOBHOH opraHH3aIJ 1H perynHTop Bcex rpa l aHCKHX OTHO­ 243 OOMCT80 3TO COBepmeHHO 060c05neHHblH uenbHblH OpraHH3M nne­ Kpelll eHHH perrpeccHH rrpoTHB cTapoH BepbI HaKoHeu HHOPO 1 IJ aM MH COCTOHmHH H3 nHU 05mero rrpOHCXO K J eHHH CBH3aHHbIX 05­ rrpHXO 1 HJIOCb 6ecrrpepblBHo cne 1 HTb 3a BCHKHMH 3aKOHO 1 aTenbHbI­ meH HCTopHeH 061JlHMH repoHMH 051ll HMH 1 0pOrHMH BceM 1 eHHH­ MH H a 1 MHHHCTpaTHBHbIMH rrpOeKTaMH 3aTeBaBllIHMHCH B TOH HflH HMH H C05b1THHMH rrpomnoro 061JlHMH aBTopHTeTHblMH pO 1 0Ha­ 1 pyroH HHCTaHUHH qT05bl BO-BpeMH rrpeJJ Yrrpe 1 HTb HnH rro Kpaii­ qanbHHKaMH Y 'lJIeHOB noro COID3a e 1 HHaH 06U4llJ1 TeppUTOpUJl rrpHHa 1 ne alll aH BceM H HHKOMY B OT 1 enbHOCTH Y HHX CBOH pO 1 0­ HeH Mepe YMeHblllHTb orraCHOCTll rp03HBIllHe HX HHTepecaM norry­ qaeTCH rrOnO HM H3BeCTHe 'ITO TOT HJIH 1 pyroH MHHHCTP HnH MeCT­ Bble 60rH H CBOH penHrH03Hble rrpa3 1 HecTBa CBOH Cy 1 bH H CBOH HblH a 1 MHHHCTpaTOp rOTOBHT Ba HbIH aHTHHaUHOHanbHblH rrpoeKT yrrpaBHTenH CBOH CaMaH HHTeHCHBHaH 11 CTOM BH 1 e COUHanbHaH pa50Ta B 'lli­ BOT HaqHHaeTCH rreperrHCKa Me K J y pO 1 0HaqanbHHKaMH HnH 061ll e­ I1pH3HaHHbIMH rrpe 1 CTaBHTenllMH C05HpaIDTcH CO Bcex KOHUOB Tep­ no HaCTOHlll ee ynbTpa·HaUHOHanbHoe rOCY 1 apCTBO B HaUHOHanbHOM OTHomeHHH PO 1 0BOH CTPOH cblrpan orpoMHyID pHTOpHH Hora6nH H36HpaIDT 1 erryTaUHID KOTopaH OTrrpaBnHeTCH ponb BHYTPH PO 1 0BblX H rrneMeHHbIX COID30B C HX cyrnaHaMH XOTO' B pe3H 1 eHUHID TOro HnH 1 pyroro a 1 MHHHCTpaTopa qaCTO H B CTonH­ HOB aHMaKOB ynycoB HaKOHeu cyrnaHaMH H3 rrpe 1 CTaBHTeneH ue· uy '4 nblx rrneMeH KH elll e 50nee Tpe60BanOCb B CBoe BpeMH 1 nH H30 1 HH B 1 eHb HaqHHaH C rrOBCe 1 HeBHbIX Hacylll ­ HbIX HY K J B 1 enax 3eMenbHblX CY 1 e5HbIX rrpO 1 0BOnbCTBeHHblX H KO aH MOMeHTaMH 051ll eHaUHOHanbHbiX 5e 1 CTBHH 05be 1 HHHB­ Ha 1 opory Tpe6YIDTcH o eHbrH H He Ha O 1 HH rrYTeBble H3 1 ep ­ y6narOTBOpeHHH BJIHHTenbHblX oc06 Ha OrrJIaTY XO 1 aTaeB rrOCpe 1 HHKOB a 1 BOKaTOB H T 1 TYT-TO Ha cueHY BblCTyrraeT pOH 1 COCTaBHBIllHHCH H3 TeM­ mna HblX rr060pOB CJIyqanocb 'ITO orraCHOCTb rp03HaH a TeMHoro p OH ­ He3aMeTHaH HO HenpepblBHaH COBMeCTHaH pa50Ta HaKonnHnHCb Ha­ 1 a Mano TOr 1 a HOTa5nH YCTpaHBaIDT Me K J y C060ID rrO 1 rrHCKY· B mHMH rrpe 1 CTaBHTeneH palHblX rrneMeH B 0 1 H0 e 1 HHOe uenoe 11 ecnH TaKHX cnyqaHX KOPblCTb oTCTyrraeT Ha 3a 1 HIDi rrnaH H nHua cnblBy­ Bce 3TH rrCHXHqeCKHe 3neMeHTbI 05bNHO 1 peManH B TlI enYID H 1 0n­ Ill He B 05b1 1 eHHOH H3HH 3a nID 1 eH CKape 1 HbIX H 1 IDKe KynaKoB ryID HO% 051ll ero rHeTa TO OHH HepBHO rrpOCblIIanHCb npH nepBOH rropIDKaIOT CBoeH lll e 1 pOCTbID CYlll eCTByeT rrpeYBen eHHoe MHeHHe 6Y 1 TO TeMHble rr060pbl BbIKH 051ll ero COTpy 1 H eCTBa 051JlHx 3MOUHH H Tpa 1 HUHH OCTPOH orraCHOCTH rp03HBIlleH 1 0pOrHM yqpe K J eHHHM H CMbIKanH K cnY HJIH rnaBHblM 06Pa30M 1 flH 050rameHHH 061ll eCTBeHHbiX BO­ B03HHKanH 5e3 BCHKoro rrepepbIBa H pOTHn 3noyrroTpe6neHHH KOHeqHO 6b1BanH n050pbl 6blJIH OqeHb uerrb 061ll eHaUHOHanbHoro caMOC03HaHHH CqaCTbID HJIH HeCqaCTbID - A 3TH orraCHOCTH 1 1 IDKe B MOMeHTbl 3aTHIllbll HarryraHHoe Bo06pIDKeHHe He rrepeCTaBa· THrocTHbI 1 JIH HaceneHHH 1 0CTHraH HHOr 1 a 1 0 no O H 1 aTb rpHJJ YIll HX orraCHOCTeH H BbI3bIBano rrOCTOHHHO HarrpH­ 3T0 rrpaB 1 a HO qTO 3TH rr060Pbl 1 eHCTBHTenbHO runH 06blKHoBeHHo eHHOe COCTOHHHe caMo050pOHbI Ha rraTpHOTHqeCKHe uenH XopOllleH HnnIDCTpau HeH noro rrOCTOHHHoro para bellum cny­ py6nH C p yIllH HeCOMHeHHO OrcID 1 a CTaHOBHTCH rrOHHTHblMH 3TH 6eCKOHe'lHble 1 enyTaUHH B XVII HT cYlll ecTBoBaBllIHH Y Bcex HapO 1 HOCTeH paccMaTpHBaeMoH rpyrr­ IleTep6ypr rrorronHHIDlJlHe Ha'lHHaH C KOHlla rrbI HHCTHTYT raK Ha3bIBaeMbIX BCeHapO 1 HOe CKyID neTonHCb HHopo o ueB K Ill HeCH HaM B HaCTOHlll ee BpeMH caMo05no eHHe 1 nll 3alll HTbI OT a 1 MHHHCTpaTHBHbIX 6ecuenbHblMH nporynKaMH a B rJIa3ax HHopO 1 ueB HMeIDIll He rrepBO- perynHpHoe TeMHbIX rr050pOB no BeKa HCTOpHqe­ '5 Tbl HHopouqecKHX 3eMenb rrpHllIJlblMH 3neMeHTaMH HnH 1 IDKe caMOH CTerreHHoe 3Ha'leHHe KOHeqHO He caMH 1 erryraUHH Ba HbI H 1 IDKe He HX pe3ynbTaTbl a a 1 MHHHCTpaUHeH 1 fl1l paJ 1 aqH Ka3aKaM H rrepeCeneHll aM lanee Te Ta rrCHXHKa KOTOpaH BOKpyr HHX C03 1 aBanaCb B 3TOM BocrrHTa­ KnaCCHqeCKHe 05H 1 b1 H pa30peHHH co CTOPOHbl MeCTHbIX BnaCTeH TenbHOM CMbIcne BIDKHbI 6blJIH 6bITb MO eT elll e 60nee H 1 pyrHe KOTOPblMH pOPMbl CaM 00 50POHbl - npHTecHeHHH npe K J e Bcero neperronHeHbI 6bIBanH CHCTeMaTHqeCKHe 3aXBa­ CTapHHHbIe qen06HTHbIe HHOpo 1 ueB C HallleH TOqKH 3peHHH Henerrble C TO'l­ 06HJ1 bI H pa30peHHH KOHeqHO BblxO 1 HlJlHe H3 pH 1 a BOH H60 Ha KH 3peHHH HHOpO 1 lIeB caMble CHnbHble 06blqHble BbIMorarenbCTBa H rrpHTeCHeHHH HHOpO 1 eu He HMen HH­ MaTeplfanbHblX epTB HO If Bce061ll ero HapO 1 HOro HarrpH eHHH KaKOH B03MO HOCTH pearHpOBaTb HeManOBa HbIM rrOBO 1 0M 1 JIH Mbl rOBoplfM 0 BceHapo 1 HblX Mep caMo060pOHbI cnY HflH 05H 1 b1 MHCCHOHepOB HaCHnbCTBeHHble rr p If II T H H X 244 Tpe60BaBIllHe He TonbKO pen If r If 0 3 H bI X rrOCTbl MonlfTBbl 3aKnlfHaHlfH H LIl M e pO­ KOTopbIe 245 r· npHHHMaJUICb no HHHUHaTHBe HOTa6lleli no CJI IalO rp03HblX nOJIH­ THIJCCKHX 6CACTBHH caMo060pOHbI HO OHH B CHITY 06mCHaIJ HOHallbHblX 3MOUHli HMH Bbl3b1BaCMbIX B CHITY opraHH30BaHHOCTH 3THX MCp Tpc60BaBll1HX H MaTCpHallbHOrO H AYXOBHoro HarrpH KCHHH AOll KHbI 6bITb yIJTe­ HbI B aKTHBC AHHaMHKH TCX Clfll KOTOPbIC C03AaBallH HaUHOHallbHoe caMOC03HaHHC H COTpYAHHqeCTBO TaK AclicTBOBalla POAOBaH opraHH3aIJ HH H30 AHH B AeHb BO Bcex KOHIJaH HHTCpCCaMH BbiCOKOH Ba KHOCTH H 06meHapOAHbIMH C03Aa­ CJIO KHbIli nCHXHIJCCKHH annapaT 06mHX HaBbIKOB TPaAHIJ HH CHMnamH H 3MOIJ HH B nOM npoucccc CCTCCTBCHHO C03AaBallCH H BOCIlHTbIBaJlCH TOT 06ll1eCTBCHHO HC06xOAHMblH Kllacc ACHTCllCH ra COIJ HaJIbHaH HHTCJIJIHrCHIJ HH KOTopaH XpaHHITa TpaAHUHH 06mCCT­ BCHHoro HHTcpcca CTOHJIa Ha CTPIDKC cro H HBJIHJIaCb HHHIJ HaTOpOM BO BCCX HaIJ HOHallbHbIX ACJIax apHcTOKpamH a B n03AHCHll1CC BpCMH H AYXOBCHCTBO TIocTcrreHHo K HHM rrpHCOCAH­ yMa llHqHbIX AapOBaHHH 60raT­ HaKOHCU BCCbMa HCAaBHO HBHllaCb Ha CUCHY HOBaH 6C3POA­ HaH apHCTOKpaTHH - H H T C II II H r C HUH H • nora caMO c06010 C HaUHOHaJIbHOH TOqKH 3peHHH mCHHH Y HHopOAueB rrpOll1J1a HCTOPHH eBporreHCKoro npOCBC­ HCCKOJIbKO pa3 B rrepBhIH ncpHOA caMO IIpaBHTeJIbCTBO B BHAax 06pyceHHH npHHy KJl aJIO HHopOAueB CTBeHHoro npOCBcmeHHH OKa3allHCb AOBOJIbHO rreqallbHbIMH OTO­ pBaHHhIC HaCHJlbHO OT ponHOH cpeAbl nepeHeceHHbIC B YCJIOBHH qa­ CTO pH3HIJeCKH HeBhlHOCHMble AJIH AeTeH rrpHpO I bI HHOpOAUhI npH rrepBOM YA06HOM CJlyqae 6pocallH HerrpHBbIIJHYIO H HeHaBHCTHYIO cpeAY H B03BpamaJIHCh C paAOCTblO K CiapOH KH3HH CllOBHO HaMe­ peHHO c6paChIBaH C CTOPOHbI - ce6H Bce nYTbl qY KAOrO rrpOCBemeHHH C APyroH oc06eHHO cpeAH Tarap ropOACKHX KHTellCH - llHIJ a AO­ 6HBll1HeCH eBponeHCKoro 06pa30BaHHH OTXOAHllH OT CBoero Hapo- qeCKYIO POJIb lIacTO OHa HBJIHJIaCb If B POJIH yrHeTaTeJleH CBOHX KC COnJICMCHHIfKOB KaK n06bIJIO HanpHMCp IJHBaBll1HHCH KOHTaKT C PYCCKHMH C03HaHHe ynlJIHTapHOro 3Haqe­ HHH 3HaHHH AJIH UClleH ToprOBblX H AJIH CHOll1eHHH C anMlfHHCTpaIJ H­ eH pacnpOCTpaHeHHC ll1KOJl OTIJaCTH xpHCTHaHCTBa - rrOCTeneHHO C03AaBallH nOTpe6HOCTb B 06pa30BaHHH B nOT rrepHOA Ha060pOT 3aMeqaeTCH qaCTO TeHAeHUHH K npOTKBOAeHCTBHIO HHOpOAIJeCKOMY Hc BccrAa KOHCIJHO pOnOBaH apHCTOKpaTHH Hrpalla neMOKpaTH­ MbIKOB Y HKYTOB 1-13 HOBCHll1erO BpeMeHH Aa nopBaB C HHM BCHKHe CBH3H Ho KH3Hb 6palla CBoe Bce YBCllH­ nopbI AO BPCMCHH no 6bIJIa pOAOBaH HHJIaCb APyraH apHcToKpaTHH - rroA BJIHHHHeM eBponeHCKoro npOCBemeHHH HCHO 'ITO HBJIeHHe no OTAaBan CBOHX AeTeH B 06mHe ll1KOllbI Pe3YJlbTaTbi noro HaCHJlb­ 06JIaCTHX KH3HH HaIJHHaH C HHTepCCOB 06bIACHHbIX H MCCTHbIX H CTBa TaKaH HHTeJIJlHreHIJ HH KOTopaH C rJly60KHM 3HaHHeM npolll1Ioro BHAeJIa 6bI HCHO ropH30HThI HacTOHmcro MOrJla HapOAHThCH TOllbKO KaK HH HCJICnbl C Hall1cli TOIJKH 3peHHH 3TH npHMIUHBHbIC Mepbl BaH ' 'l Y aCTpaxaHcKHX Kall­ HO na KC B XYAlliHX CJI Ia ax OHa BCC KC HBllH­ JlaCb CAHHCTBCHHbIM 3llCMeHTOM CTOHBll1HM Ha CTpa Ke 06meHaIJ H0­ npOCBemeHHIO oc06eHHO Ha OKpaHHax AJIH ueJIblX HapOAHOCTeH npeMlfeH 3a KpcmeHHe nocryIl K npOCBemeHHIO 6YPHT HarrpHMep HBJIHeTCH HHorAa CBepx Toro HH3111He ll1KOJIhI KOTophle CO­ 3AaBallHCb AJIH HHOPOAUCB HOCHITH HBHO 06pYCHTeJIbHblH xapaKTep H MallO AOCTHrallH ueJIH TaK KaK H3bIKOM rrperrOAaBaHHH 6bIJI H3bIK HaJlbHblX IfHTepeCOB If B rJIa3ax MaCCbI 6bIJIa CHMBOJIOM HaIJ HOHallb Horo eAHHCTBa HY KHO nOMHIfTb 'ITO caMbIH HeHaBHCTHbIH POAOBHIJ-apHCTOKpaT Bce KC 6JIIf KC HHOPOAUY IJeM PYCCKHH 'IHHOBHHK H60 KHBeT TOH KC KH3HblO 'ITO If OH H HaIJ HOHallbHOC BbICOKOMCPHC eMY He3Ha­ KOMO a COBepll1eHHO IJY KJl blH nJIH YIJamIfXCH TCM He MeHee HeCMOTpH Ha Bce He6JIarOnpHHTHbie YCllOBHH IfHTellllHreHUHH XOIH If MeWICHHO HapaCTalla TIpaBAa 60Ilbll1aH IJaCTb Bce eme OTXOAHJla OT CBoero Ha­ pona CTapaHCb KaK MO KHO CKopce CMbITb C ce6H IIHTHO HHopOA'Ie­ CTBa qT06bl 3aTepHTbCH B PYCCKOH Macce H AIDKe J1yqIlille 3llCMeH­ TbI Te KOTopbIe B CHllY CBoero IIpO peCCIfOHallbHOrO 1I0ll0 KeHIfH Ho CCllH IfCTOPHH Ha CBoeM rrYTH OTMCTaCT OT KHBll1IfC 3JICMCHTbI COCllOBHOCTH TO Ha CMeH ' HM HBllHIOTCH HOBbIe 3llCMeHTbI llHlJHOrO KaK CBHmeHHHKH yIJHTeJIH H T A He OKa3bIBallHCb rro OTHOll1eHHIO K CBOHM B POJIH A06pOBOllbHbIX 06pYCHTeJIeH A3 Ke H OHH MeHhll1e AapOBaHIfH YMa IIpOCBcmeHHH Ha cueHY HBllHeTCH H H T e JI JI H ­ r C HUH H nOT YAHBHTeJIhHhlH AYXOBHhIH pcpMeHT KOTOPbIH 110­ pcpMCHTaM OpraHHlJCCKOrO MHpa 06J1aAaCT CBOHCTBOM HC TOllbKO 6CCKOHeIJHOH pa3MHO KaeMOCTH HO H napOM rrpCBpaman Bcero AYMallH 0 KaKOM-llH60 HaUHOHallbHOM B03pO KJl eHI1H no B 60JIbll1HHCTBe CJIyqaeB 6bIJIH CKpOMHble KYllbTypTperepbl KOTO­ pble CKop6H AYll10H 0 AYXOBHOM y60 KeCTBe CBOHX COnJIeMeHHH­ KOB rrhITaJlHCb CBOHMH CnHHHqHbIMH YCHITHHMH BHeCTH KaKoH-HH­ HHCPTHOC B aKTHBHOC MCpTBOC B KHBoe 246 247 ny cpeA ' pacnpOCTpaHeHHeM rpaMOTHOCTH nepeBOAa­ HeYAHBHTeJIbHO 'ITO nepBble paCKaTbI oCB06oAHTeJIbHOrO ABH e­ MH CB1ImeHHbIX KHHr Ha HHOpOA'IeCKHe 1I3bIKH 'ITO KCTaTH rOBOp1l HH II HaH60JIee HpKHe H paHHHe nOJIHTH'IeCKHe BbIcTynJIeHH1I Ha'la­ noomp1lJIOCb H caMHM npaBHTeJIbCTBOM H eABa JIH He HAeaJIOM 3THX JIHCb HMeHHO Ha OKpaHHax B ueHTpax HHOpOA'IeCKOH OcenrrOCTH 6y z u CBeT B Ho npH6JIml aJIc1I Y e He rOBOp II 0 3arraAHOM Kpae HJIH 0 KaBKa3e H B 'IaCTHOCTH MOMeHT KorAa na aMopqJHaH HHTeJIJIHreHl H1I CHJIOH caMOH H3­ rypHH rAe ABH eHHe Ha'laJIOCb 3a rpH rop a AO IIrrOHCKOH BOHHbI H HH AOJI I Ha 6bIJIa CTaTb Ha nyTb HarmOHaJIbHOH pa60TbI 3aBeplllHJIOCb JIy lIIlHX 3JIeMeHTOB 6bIJIO MHpHoe 06pyceHHe TOJI'IOK npHmeJI H3BHe H3 Toro pOAHHKa 06me'leJIOBe'leCKOH KyJIbTYPbI AJIH KOTOPOH HaUH1I JIHKOM UBeTHHKe HapOAOB B Ha'laJIe Bcex MeCTHbIX BJIaCTeH - 1905 r Bce06ll HM BoccraHHeM H cMeHoH BcnOMHHM AaJIeKOe 3a6aHKaJIbe rAe Ma­ TOJIbKO HHAHBH J YaJIbHOCTb B Be­ JIeHbKHH H30JIHpOBaHHbIH HapoAeu AOBeAeHHbIH AO KpaHHoCTH ar­ HacTynHJIa nopa Kor J a COUHaJIbHO-nO­ peccHBHbIMH MepaMH npoTHB ero HCKOHHbIX y lpe AeHHH HatJHHM 1902 JIHTH'leCKHe H J eH H3 rOJIOB O J HHOKHX HHTeJIJIHreHTOB CTaJIH nepexo­ C J HTb CHa'laJIa B ropO J CKHe a nOTOM B ceJIbCKHe MaCCbI HocHTeJIH BOJIbHOCrH BIIJIOTb AO nOrOJIOBHbIX OTKa30B BbI6HpaTb cBepxy Ha­ nHX HAeH npe Ae OAHHOKO 6pOAHBmHe no 60JIbmHM ropOAaM B B lI3bIBaeMbIX BJIaCTeH H AO HaCHJIbCTBeHHoro B03BpameHH II 3eMeJIb nOHCKax aAenTOB CTaJIH TaK e 'IaCTbI B npOBHHUHaJIbHbIX ropoAax 6YPHTbI TYHrycbI 17 r mar 3a marOM MY eCTBeHHo OTCTaHBaeT CBOH cTapbIe KaK H B CTOJIHUax M J eH pacnpOCTpaH1IJIHCb y e He npHe3 HMH arH­ He Be3Ae pa3YMeeTcH ytJacTHe HHopoAtJecKHX rpynn BO Bce06­ TaTopaMH a MeCTHbIMH KyJIbTypHbIMH O L HHO'lKaMH BOT TyT-TO B meM rrOA'beMe oAHHaKoBo peJIbecpHo BbICTyrraJIO Ha nOBepxHocTb Y HHOpOA'IeCKOH cpeAe HBHJIC1I KaMeHb npeTKHOBeHH1I AOCTyn B Hee TaKHX HapOAHOCTeH KaK OTKPbIBaJIC1I TOJIbKO 'Iepe3 ABepb HarmOHaJIbHoro pyCCKHH 1I3bIK y e B CHJIY HX reorpacpHtJeCKoro rrOJIO eHH l B CHJIY oc06b1x yCJIO­ pyccKa1l MHopOA'IecKHH BHH KyJIbTYPbI 60Pb6a HOCHJIa IIpKO HHAHBHAYaJIbHbIH xapaKTep JI nepaTypa OKa3aJIHCb 6eCCHJIbHbIMH 6 y P II r bI H K Y T bI H3bIK 6bIJI eAHHcrneHHbIM KaHaJIOM KOTOPbIH Mor COe L HHHTb POA­ H a U H 0 H a JI b H 0 - 0 C B 0 6 0 A H r e JI b H 0 r 0 Hoe nJIeM1I C 06mHM PYCJIOM BcepOCCHHCKOH peKH HOBblX HAeH TaKHX HapOAHOCTeH KaK 3TOT 1I3bIK Ha J O 6bIJIO B03POAHTb MHorHM Aa e BHOBb H3y 1HTb 6 a m K H P bI MOp A B a K H P r H 3 bI ABH eHH II y 'I y Bam H TaT a p 0 ­ HBymHX BnepeMe KY C PYCCKHM HaCeJIeHHeM a 060raTHTb ero HOBbIMH CJIOBaMH H CAeJIaTb H3 Hero 1I3bIK JIHTepy­ rJIaBHOe B O J HHaKOBbIX C HHM 3KOHOMH'IeCKHX H 6bITOBbIX yCJIO­ TYPHbIH BH1IX ABH eHHe oc06eHHO cpeAH CeJIbCKOrO HaCeJIeHHH HH'IyTb He 3TO 6bIJIa orpoMHM pa60Ta HO OHa AaJIa H orpOMHbIe ycnexH H noMY OTJIH'laJIOCb OT o6mepYCCKoro T e e npHrOBopbl Te e HaKa3bI n06eAOHOCHOMY OpYJKHlO XOAOKaM H AenyTaTaM Te e CeJIbCKOX03HHCTBeHHbIe 3a6aCTOBKH pOCJIa JI1060Bb K ero HOCHTeJIlO pOCJIa JI1060Bb K n03HaHHlO ero ero Te e 06menapTHHHbIe rpyrrnHpoBKH Ta e arHraUH1I B BbI60PHYlO nCHXHKH ero npomrroro ero JIy lmHX CTOPOH ero CTpaAaHHH H 'IaH­ KaMrraHHlO H Te e CPOPMbI npOTeCTa npOTHB aAMHHHCTpaUHH BMeCTe C HHMH pOCJIa mo60Bb K HHH H HaKOHeu HameJIC II JI03YHr AJI II nOH pa60TbI B TaHHCTBeHHOM CJIOBe caM 0 0 n peA e JI e H He 18 Ho 3a 3THM 06mHM npoueCCOM Ka3aBmHMC1I CTOJIb OAHOpOA­ HbIM meJI APyroH rrpouecc MeHee 3aMeTHbIH HO He MeHee 3HaMeHa­ Ho TyT MbI y e nO J XOAHM K MOMeHTy oCB060AHTeJIbHOrO J BH e­ HHH TeJIbHbIH KorAa pyCCKHH KpeCTb1lHHH npHCJIYlllHBaJICH K petJH opa­ Topa y Hero CJIe3bI HaBepTbIBaJIHCb Ha rJIa3a nOTOMY 'ITO BnepBble B 1ICHbIX CHJIbHbIX H TpOraTeJIbHbIX CJIOBaX OH YCJIbImaJI TO tJeM OCB060 L HTeJIbHOe ABH eHHe 3aCTaJIO HHopoAueB AaJIeKO He CMYTHO 60JIeJIa ero p yma B Te'leHHe BeKOB Y MOp J BHHa 'IYBama BpaCnJIOx HHKorAa eme arpecCHBHM nOJIHTHKa ueHTpa He BeJIaCb BOTHKa 'IepeMHCa TaTapHHa KOTOPbIM HX c06CTBeHHbIH II3bIK Ka­ C TaKO rrOCJIe J OBaTeJIbHOCTblO KaK HMeHHO HaKaHYHe OCB060AH­ 3aJIC1I 6eAHbIM aJIKHM rrpe3peHHbIM HHTeJIJIHreHUH1I KOToporo TeJIbHOrO nepHO J a Bo Bcex 06JIaCT lIX H3HH Ha'lHHa II C 3eMJIH H 6bIJIa AO CHX nop CTOJIb 'IY Aa eMY 3TH CJIOBa nOMHMO HX COAep a­ KOH'Ia II mKOJIOH BepOH rpa J aHCKHMH npaBaMH penpeCCHH mrrH HH1I BbI3bIBaJIH OC06bIH 3HTY3Ha3M eme H noroMY 'ITO OHH npoH3­ 3a perrpeCCH lIMH a AJI1I 60JIee cTponnmbIx HaUHOHaJIbHOCTeH npeA­ HOCHJIHCb pO llHbIM 'IeJIOBeKOM AaBHo nOKHHYBlllHM ero eme B'Ie­ npHHHMaJIHCb CneUHaJIbHble MepbI pa Ka3aBmHMC II eMY 'lY J bIM cerOnIlH CHOBa CTaBmHM eMY 6paroM 248 249 r H IlpOH3HOCHITHCb Ha cro C06CTBCHHOM H3hIKC CmC Bqepa CqHTaB­ naTHH K oCB060AHrCIThHoMY ABH I CHHlO H BhI3hlBaITH K ce6c CHMrra­ lllHMCH OTBep l CHHbIM THH Macc rITaBHhIM 06pa30M 'lCPC3 3TH 3JICMCHrhI H rrpOHHKITH CO­ 11 Ha 3TOM OTHblHC CTaBlllCM AITH HCrO BABOC AOPO l C pOAHOM UHaITHCrH'lCCKHC H CH B KpeCThHHCKHC MaCChI H MbI yBH HM HH I C H3bIKC eMY rOBOpHJlH 0 IlpaaC cro B 06mCCTBCHHOH l H3HH H lllKOITC KaK HACH 3rH rrpHBCITH K HCO l HAaHHOMY PC3YIThTary K 06pa30Ba­ o IlpaBe Ha HaUHOHaITbHOC caM06bITHOe cymecTBoBamie a cmc qC­ HHIO HaUHOllaITbHO-COUHaITHCTHqCCKHX opraHH3aJJ HH pC3 HCKOTOpOC BpeMH OH caM paCIlCBaIT Ha 3TOM H3blKe 3aXBaThlBalO­ Ho rOBopH 0 pomI HHTCITITHfCHJJ HH HHKOHM 06pa30M HeITh3H 0­ mHe CTPOCPbl MapCCITbC3bI qHTaIT IlpOKITaMaUHH C IlblJlKHMH rrpH3hI­ BOITbCTBOBarhCH rrOHHMaHHCM 3Toro rcpMHHa BaMH 6pOlillOPbI 0 CCTCCTBeHHOM rrpaBC qCITOBeKa CB060AC 3CMITe CBporrCHCKOM CMhICITC 3Toro CITOBa 6paTCTBC HapOAOB TYT C03AaBaITHCb HCBCAOMblC CMY paHbllle HO OTHbIlle HCH3rITaAHMble HaUHOHaITbHble 3MOUHH 3aKITaAbIBaITCH CPYH­ Y HCKOTOPbIX B OrpaHHqHTCIThHOM HapOAROCTCH y KOTOphIX KOHTHHrCHT miJJ C CBpO­ rrCHCKHM 06pa30BaHHeM 6hIJl HCAOcraTOqCH POITh HHTCITITHrcHJJ HH AaMCHT HaJJ HOHaITbHOrO caMOC03HaHHH HC3aMeTHo co CTOPOHhI rITy­ BhIllOITHHITH H BCCbMa 3Hcpr qHO 60KO BHyTpH rrpOHCXOAHIT rrCHX qCCKHH rrpoJJ ecc KOTOPbIH 0ARO­ CHH HITH ITHJJ a rrOITyqHBlllHC pCITHrH03HOC 06pa30BaHHC 3TO MO I HO BPCMCHHO rrepeC03 aBaIT B OAHOM ropHlme H Maccy H ce HHTCITITH­ 6hIJlO Ha6ITIOAarh y IlOBOIT I CKHX Tarap y KaITMhIKOB Y 6YPHT Hc 6C3 BITHHHHH B 3TOM CITY'lac OCTaITHCh CBporrCHCKHC HACH rrpOHHK­ rCHUHIO CITHBaH HX B O HO Hepa3pbIBHOC JJ CITOC B03BpamCHHC HHOpO qeCKOH HHTCITITHrCHUHH K Hapo n y 3HaMe­ HaTCITbHCHlllHH cpaKT OCB060 HTeJlbHOrO BH I CHHH HH B OAROH cpc e HHTCITITHrCHJJ HH HC 6bIITa TaK qy l l a Maccc KaK B HHOPO qCCKOH BKYCHB rrITOAbI pyccKoro 06pa30BaHHH HHTCITITH­ rCHT IlYIUC Bccro 3a60THITCH 0 TOM qT06bI KaK MO l HO CKOPCC CMbITh C ce6H rrCqaTb HHOPOA'lCCKOrO rrpOHCXO l CHHH nCqaTb OT­ BCP l CHHH H rrpHHH I eHHOCTH 11 HITH ITHua AYXOBHbIC rro rrpocpcc­ HapO caM THrOTHBIIIHHCH CBoeH OTBCP l CHHOCThlO IIJlaTHIT CMY rITYXOH Bp8 l c6HOCTblO BHM B HCM O HOBPCMCHHO H 6apHHa H pCHcraTa OCB060 HTCJlbHhIH rropbIB BCP­ lllHe B AYXOBcHCTBO KaK TO HH CTpaHlIO HC qCpe3 POCCHIO a qCPC3 KOCHbIH BOCTOK qepe3 TYPJJ HIO H ErHrrer CreCHCHHH B opra­ HH3aUHH BbICIIlliX paccaARHKOB MYCYITbMaHCKOH 06pa30BaHHOCTH H3AaBHa rHaITH corHH MOJIOAbIX JIlO eH B lllKOIThI KOllcraHTHHOrrOITH H KaHpa r c OHH CraITKHBaITHCb CO CBOHMH CAHHOBcpJJ aMH H3 BCCX CTpaH MHpa 3ACCh OC06CHHO B KaHpc 3a6HThIC TaTapCKHC IOHOlllH MOrITH BHAeTh KaK qYAOTBOpHO ACHCTBYCT rOT PC I HM CB060AbI KO­ TOPhIH BBeITH aHrITH'laHC B ErHrrTC 3ACCh TOqHO TaK l C KaK B 11H­ AHH aHrITHHCKaH cB060 a rrOpO Hlla B MyCYITbMaHCTBC HAeH KOTO­ HyIT MHorHM HapO HOCTHM HX HHTCITITHrCHJJ HlO TaK 6hIJlO C TaTapa­ PhIM 6hIIb MO l CT CY I l CHO H3MCHHTh BClO rrCHXHKY HCITaMHcrCKO­ MH HCMHOrOqHCITCHHaH CBpOneHCKaH IillTeJIITHfCHUHH KorophIX 6hI­ ro MHpa C bC3AhI MyITIT yqaCTHC HCKOTOPhIX H3 HHX B yqHTeIThCKHX JIa COBCPlilCHHO qy l l a Hapo n y TaK l C 6bIJlO H Y TaKliX HapOARO­ opraHH3aUHHX COlO3hI CTYACHTOB MCAPCCC - CTCH KaK BOTHKH qYBanlH 6alllKHpbl 'lepCMHChI HHTeITITHrcHJJ HH KH HOBoro rCqCHIDi nO-BHAHMOMY cmc 60ITce BHAHYlO pOITh HrpaITO KOTOphIX B 6YKBaIThHOM CMbICITC ITaMaHCTCKOC AyxOBClIcrBO Y 6ypHr H HaqHHaCr HrpaTh Y KaITMhI­ CITOBa CThI HITaCb CBoero npOHC­ 19 XO l CHHH KOIIC'lHO HHTCITITHrCHUHH 3Ta xapaKTcpHbIC rrpH3Ha­ KaK HH BCITHK 6bIIT ee mTY3Ha3M KOB TaKoB 6hIJl TaK CKa3aTh aMopcpHhIH rrpoJJ ccc HaUHOHaIThHOrO BPH ITH MOrITa 6bI HCIlOITh30Barb cro CCITH 6bI B ee pHAax He 6bIJlO rrp06Y l ACHHH TaK llIJla Ta HeBHAHMaH rrCHX qCCKaH pa60ra KOTO­ 3ITeMeHTOB ycneBlllHX eme paHec 3aHHTb B CPCAC HapoAa KOC-Ka­ paH rrpOTCKaITa B THIIlli HapOARblX rrry6HH AMOPCPHhIH rrpouccc HC­ KHC n03HUHH 3TH cpaBHHrCITbHO HCMHOrOqHcrrcHHbIC HO BITHHrCITb­ H36C I HO AOIT I CH 6bIJl ncpCHrH HbIC CBOHM nOITO l CHHCM 3JICMeHTbI COCTaBITHJlH CeIThCKHC yqHTCITH JJ H H CBHmCHHHKH micapH H3 HHOPOMCB KOTophIe AO Toro nOA BITHH­ HHCM BHClllHHX YCITOBHH H qCM OC06CHHbIM CC6H HC npOHBITHITH HO B Hy HhIH MOMCHT CyMCITH BOCnOITh30BaTbCH CBOHM nOITO l CHHCM B npoJJ ecc K p H C T a JI JI H 3 a ­ Ha'lHHacTcH nepHoA 06pa30BaHHH HaUHOHaITbHbIX opraHH3auHH ncpHoA 06mCHaUHOHaITbHbIX ACHcrBHH H BblcryrrITCHHH 113 3THX oprallH3aUHH rrpc I Ac Bccro OCTaHaBITHBaCT Ha cc6e BHH­ 3TO OHH B pyr B lllKOITax B JJ CpKBHX Ha HapOAlIhIX C06paxfHHX 3a­ MaHHC MYCYITbMaHCKHH COI03 POAHBlllHHCH Ha CBcr nO I HH rOBOpHITH Ha HapOAROM H3blKe pa3 bHCHHITH C06hITHH 6Y HITH CHM­ ryCTa 250 1905 15 aB­ r CPCAH BOA OKH Ha rrapOXOAc ''fYCTaB CTPYBe ro­ 251 CTeIIpIUIMHO IIPHlOTHBIIleM H YKpbIBIIleM OT 3aIIpeTa aAMHHHCTpa­ OnHH H3 HHTepecHeHIIIHx paKToB KaK ocB060nHTel1bHoro TaK H Ha­ HOHaJIbHOrO ABH eHHH B POCCHH OH C Bel1H'1aHIIleH O'leBHMOCTbIQ IUlH IIpeACTaBHTelIeH POCCHHCKOrO MYCYlIbMaHcKoro MHpa ITo 0 pHUHaJIbHOMY THTYJ1Y CBOeMY COOpaHHe MYCYlIbMaH BCeX nOKa3bIBaeT K0110CCaJIbHYIQ c ItJ1y IICHXH'leCKOrO IIOnbeMa B 3TOT HC­ COCJ10BHH H3 pa3HbIX ryoepHHH H OOJ1aCTeH POCCHH C0103 IIpeA­ TOpH'leCKHH MOMeHT TOl1bKO B TaKHe MOMeHTbI HapOAbI C Pa3l1H'1­ CTaBlIHJ1 COOOlO TOlIbKO KaK ObI OObeAHHeHHbIX HbIM HCTOpH'IeCKHM rrpOIIll1bIM OTnel1eHHbIe Apyr OT Apyra orpoM­ OOmHOCThlO peJ1HfHH H OOmHOCTblO IIpaBOBOrO n0J10 eHHH B rocy­ HbIMH paccToHHHHMH COBepIlleHHo OTl1H'1HbIe B KYl1bTYPHOM H ObI­ Aapcrne HO no TOlIbKO IIO Ha3BaHHlO Ha caMOM e nelIe B OCHOBe TOBOM OTHOIlleHHH CBH3aHHble Me ny COOOlO TOl1bKO pel1HrHeH CBoeH 3TO He ObIlI MornH C IIOl1HOH BepOH OObenHHHTbCH He TOl1bKO MH OOmeH 60pb­ HOC T e H II H r Y II H U aMop PHbIH arperaT J1HU a C0103 COlO 3 Hap 0 n ­ HapOMbIX opraHH3aIUlH B neHCTBHTeJ1bHOCTH HapOAHOCTH eCTeCTBeHHO BX0nHBIIlHe B nOT C0103 KaK TaTapbI a3epOaH H bI KHprH3bI - IIpeACTaBJ1HlIH COOOlO OOOCOOJ1eHHbIe HaUHOHaJIbHbIe rpynnbI oopa30BaBIIlHe CBOH OCOObIe opraHH3a HH HMeBIIlHe CBOH Cbe3nbI 20 l1Ha'le H ObITb He Momo HapOMOCTH BO­ 6b1 HO H nJIH oomero nYXOBHoro B03po eHHH CM 1-4 IIyHKTbI I-ro Cbe3na • 11 eCl1H MbI BcnOMHHM 'ITO AYIllOH COIQ3a HB ItJ1HCb BOJ1 CKHe Ta­ TapbI TO HHTepec Toro paKTa oYAeT eme 60J1ee 3Ha'lHTeJ1eH Tap no 1905 Y Ta­ r HHKaKOH oomeHaponHOH OpraHH3a HH He 6bIJ10 ec­ IIleAIIlHe B C0103 ObIlIH ClIHIIlKOM OT11H'IHbI APyr OT npyra B HCTO­ l1H He C'IHTaTb O pHUHaJIbHOH uepKOBHOH OpraHH3a HH HHKaKHM aB­ pH'leCKOM 3KOHOMH'IeCKOM ObITOBOM H CO HaJIbHOM OTHOIlleHHHX TopHTeTOM y HaCel1eHHH He II0l1b3YIQmeHCH CBH3H Me y BOJ1 CKH­ Ka naH H3 nHX HapOAHOCTeH HMeJ1a CBOH OOOC06J1eHHbIe BepXOB­ MH H KPbIMCKHMH TaTapaMH nO'lTH He ObIJ10 CeJ1bCKOe HaCel1eHHe HbIe HHTepeCbI AJ1H KOTOPbIX eCTeCTBeHHO Tpe60BaJIacb CBOH COO­ He 3aHHMaJIO CIIJIOIllHOH TeppHTopHH Ho TaTapbl HMeJ1H OMO Ba ­ crneHHaH Ha HOHaJIbHaH opraHH3a HH Hoe rrpeHMymecTBO OHH HMel1H To 'ITO CIIaHlIO nH CTOJ1b pa3Ho06pa3HbIe HapOAbI 3TO 6bIJ1H 00­ I He peJ1HrH03Hble 3MO HH OOI He peJ1HrH03HbIe HneaJIbI 06maH 11 r 0 p 0 A CK 0 e Hac e 11 e H H e eCJ1H IIPHOaBHTb 'ITO B Ka3aHH caMOM KPYIIHOM IIyHKTe Ta­ TapCKOH oceAJ10CTH eCTeCTBeHHO 00pa30Bal1CH ueHTp Mycyl1bMaH­ peJ1HrH03HaH OIIaCHOCTb H OomHe IIpaBOOrpaHH'leHHH H HaKOHeu CKOH pel1HfH03HOH nHCbMeHHOCTH H peJIHrH03HOH HHTel1lIHfeH HH - 1I0HeB0l1e IIpHBl1eKIIIHH K ceoe Bce 3neMeHTbI nYXOBHoro COC110BHH BepXOBHbIH MOTHB OomaH a na KYlIbTYpHoro B03pO AeHRH Ha IIO'lBe cOJ1H eHHH MYCYlIbMaHCTBa C eBpOIIeHCKHM IIpOCBemeHH­ ecnH npH6aBHM 'ITO B Menpece KaHpa KOHCTaHTHHonOl1H H Eyxa­ eM H C HOBbIMH IIOJIHTH'leCKHMH HneaJIaMH H YCJ10BHHMH pbI npenCTaBHTeJIH caMbIX pa311H'lHbIX MeCT MYCYl1bMaHCKOH ocen­ qTO C0103 CTaB IIJI BO rJ1aBY yma BceCTopOHHOO pa3BHTHe HMeH­ JIOCTH CTaJIKHBaJIHCb Me y COOOlO H 3aBH3bIBanH nYXOBHbIe CBH3H HO aBTOHOMHbIX KYJ1bTypHO-HaUHOHaJIbHbIX opraHH3aIUlH no HB­ eCJIH HaKOHeu npHoaBHTb 'ITO Bce nH 311eMeHTbI OOJIanaJIH 06meH CTBeHHO IIOKa3bIBaeT IIocnenHHH nYHKT 5 pe30J1IQUHH nepBorO e rrHCbMeHHOCTbIQ H 06mHM H3bIKOM He TO 1bKO TaTapCKHM HO H apa6cKHM TO 6YAeT IIOHHTHO 'ITO YC110BHH MH 06benHHeHHH 6bI­ Cbe3na COIQ3a rnacHmHH l1H Hal1HUO lJ nH ycneIIIHoro nOCTH eHHH Bcex HaMe'leHHbIX ueJ1eH 11 KorAa HaCTaJI 'lac Bce06mero KJIH'Ia K 06benHHeHHIQ 3TH aTOMbl nOTHHY110 npyr K npyry H rrOTpeOOBaJIOCb HeMHoro Ha MeCTax 00pa3YlOTcH CBOU MeoJ CUllucbl pYKOBOnHMbIe lIepH­ MeH 'lT06bI B nJIaByqeM nOMe Ha OKe cpenH Bceoomero 3HTY3H­ OAH'IeCKHMH Cbe3AaMH MycYl1bMaH a3Ma ObIJ1H 3aJIO eHbI OCHOBbI orpOMHoro HapOMOCTeH POCCHH 11 COIQ3a MYCYJIbMaHCKHX TaK KaK TaTapbI H3 Bcex 3THX HapOAHOCTeH Ha HOHal1bHbIH xapaKTep nHX Cbe3nOB oc06eHHo peJ1be pHo CKa­ onHH HMel1H C ItJ1bHOe ropOnCKoe HaCel1eHHe B CHJIY reorpa pH'le­ 3bIBaeTCH B TOM 'ITO He TOl1bKO Bce COC110BHH HO H Bce lIapTHH HMe­ CKoro CBoero 1I0JIO eHHH OOl1bIUe ApyrHx corrpHKaCaJIHCb C pYCCKH­ l1H Ha HHX CBOHX IIpenCTaBHTel1eH HaUHOHaJIbHbIH IIOnbeM TaKHM MH nporpeCCHBHbIMH 3JIeMeHTaMH H CJIeAOBaTeJIbHO HMeJIH 6011b­ OOPa30M OKa3aJICH CHl1bHee Bcex IIapTHHHbIX H Kl1aCCOBblX aHTaro­ IIlHH CpaBHHTel1bHO C npyrHMH KOHTHHreHT HHTeJ1JIHreHUHH TO HM HH3MOB H no J1y t lIlmH IIOKa3aTel1b ero HHTeHCHBHOCTH BbIllaJIO Ha nOl1IQ HrpaTb nOMHHHpYIQmylO POl1b B C0103e_ BblCTYIIl1eHHe Ha cueHY MYCYJ1bMaHCKOro COIQ3a IIpenCTaBl1HeT 252 MYCYl1bMaHCKHH C0103 HMeBIIlHH TpH Cbe3Aa nOCl1eAHHH B 253 1907 r AaJI OrpOMHbIH TOll'10K caMOC03HaHHlO MYCYJlbMaHCKl1X KpaTKOBpeMeHHO 6bIllO cymecTBOBaHHe HKYTCKOH pecny6nl1­ HapOAOB 11 C03AaJI Blll1HTeJ1bHyID 11 MHOrOql1CneHHYIO ppaKUHlO B KH opraHH3aTopbI 6bIllH apecToBaHbI H rrpeAaHbI cyny Macca CMH­ rrepBbIX AByX AYMax C nOH ppaKll HeH XOTH H MaJIOql1CneHHOH Te­ pHnacb HO B nCHXHKe HKYTOB OHO OCTaBl1no BnaCTHoe BrreqaTne­ rrepb Cql1TalOTCH AaiKe B peaKUHOHHOH H BpaiKAe6HOH HHOPOnuaM HHe PeBonlOUHoHHbIH xapaKTep COI03a BbI3BaHHbIH KOHe'lHO oc06eH­ 3-H ilYMe BHAH B HeH OllHueTBOpeHHe KpynHoH CHnbI MycynbMaH­ CTBa 21 HOCTHMH CBoe06pa3HbIH HHTepeC npeACTaBllHeT HKYTCKHH COI03 C pOp­ MHpOBaBIlIl1HCH B HHBape HKYTCKOH 06nacTH 1906 r B MOMeHT Ha1160llee 6ypHoro AllH rrOAbeMa H rrpHHHBIlIHH cpa3y peBOnlOll HOHHbIH HaxOAHT CBoe 06'bHCHeHHe H BO BceH HCTOPHH H3Hecnoc06Hoe TanaHTnHBoe nneMH HKyroB CYMeBillee KonOHH30BaTb CypOBylO nonHpHYIO CTpaHY H nOKopl1Tb ee npHpoAY HacaAHTb B CTpaHe nbAOB H oonOT CKOTOBOACTBO H 3eMneAenHe npeTepneno 3a nocneAHHe Tpl1 BeKa 60nee qeM KaKoe­ xapaKTep H3 11160 APyroe HHOpOn'leCKOe nneMH fHeT aAMHHHcTpaUHH 3AeCb He 250 TbIC HKYTOB opraHH3aTopbI 3Han rrpeAenOB elue B 80-x ronax npOilinoro BeKa HaxOAHnHCb HC­ C03HaBaH ce6H B 310T 6YPHbIH MOMeHT X03HeBaMH KpaH 270 TbIC HaceneHHH 06llaCTH - MOMeHTa HKYTCKOH iKH3HH COI03a nOCTaBHB ce6e uellblO coeAHHeHHbIMH CHnaMH rrpo'IHo yCTa­ rrpaBHHKH KOTopbIe B03HnH C COOOIO uenbIe TenerH C p03raMH KO­ HOBHrb CBOH rpaiKAaHCKHe H 3KOHOMHqeCKHe rrpaBa BblCTaBHllH TOPbIMH l1CTH3aJIH HKYTOB BbIMoraH B3HTKH CCbIJ1bHble KOTopble cneAYlOmHe Tpe60BaHHH oecnpepblBHO npl1CbIllanHCb C XVII CT oecnpeCTaHHO 'IHHHnH YOHH­ CTBa rpaoeiKH HaCHnl1H HaA iKeHmHHaMH a BA06aBOK rrpHXOAHllOCb 1 2 3 rrpH3HaHHH Bcex 3eMellb c06cTBeHHocTbID caMl1X HHOPOA­ HX KOpMHTb H OTAaBaTb HM rro pacnopHiKeHHIO aAMHHHCTpall HH nyq­ ueB IlIHe 06pa60TaHHbie 3eMnH KaiKAaH nHAb KOTOPblX CTOHna HeqenO­ rrpeAocTaBneHHH HKYTaM rrpaBa HMeTb CBoero rrpeAcraBl1­ BeqeCKl1X YCl1nHH 11 TpynOB TellH B rOCYAapCTBeHHOH AYMe A y M bI cKopeHiliero YTBepiKAeHHH rrOllOiKeHHH 0 3eMCKOM caMO­ yrrpasneHHH B 1858 r 6bInH 3aKpbITbI C T e rr H bl e H ocraTKH pOAoBoro yrrpaBneHHH 6bIJ111 OTAaHbI BO BnaCTb nHcapeH H 3aceAaTeneH T eM He MeHee pOAOBaH iKH3Hb pOAO­ Bble TpaAHUHH He yMepnH KaKOBbI 6bI HH 6bIlll1 3noyrrOTpe6neHHH OTAenbHbIX TOHOHOB H pOAOHa'laJIbHHKOB OHH Bce iKe OblnH eAHH­ 4 HeMeAlleHHoro YHlftITOiKeHHH orreKH nOnHll HH HaA HHOpOA­ qeCKHMH 06mecTBeHHbIMH Y'lpeiKAeHHHMH 11 npeKpameHHH BCHKoro cHoII1eHHH C HHMH aAMHHHcTpaUHH Bnpe 'b 0 ynOBllerBopeHHH 31HX Tpe60BaHHH Koropble 6bmH ynb­ THMaTHBHO npeA'bHBneHbI IIO Tenerpa py rrpeAceAaTelllO COBeTa MH­ CTBeHHbIMH xpaHl1TenHMH HaUHOHaJIbHblX HHTepeCOB H TpaAHUHH 3TO OHH 6e3 yCTaJIH XOAaTaHCTBOBanH 0 BOCCTaHOBneHHH caMoyrr­ paBneHHH 06 OXPaHe 3eMenbHblX rrpaB 0 3aml1Te OT 06HA aAMHHH­ cTpaUHH lenanH OHH JTO KOHe'lHO B caMblX 6naroHaMepeHHblx pOPMax HO OTKa3bl cnenOBaJIH 3a OTKa3aMH Mbl TaK Aonro OCTaHaBnHBaJIHCb Ha MycynbMaHcKoH H HKYTCKOH HHCTPOB qneHbI COlO3a OTKa3bIBaJIHCb HaUHOHaJIbHblX opraHH3auHHx nOTOMY 'ITO 3TH opraHH3aUHH COBep­ 1 OT BCHKoro CHOIlIeHHH C 'IHHaMH rronHUHH H 2 rrnaTeiKa rro areH H IIoBHHHocTeH Ha yqpe HTenbHOM C'be3 e COlO3a yqacTBoBano no 400 'IenOBeK B TOM qHClle MHoro rrpeACTaBHTelleH C MeCT TOHOHbI nHcapH YBaiKa­ eMbie nHua 6narOAapH 'IeMY Ha IIpH3bIB yqpeAHTeneH OTKnHKHynHcb co Bcex cropOH uellbIe yllyCbI cneIlIHBIIlHe He TOllbKO CO CBOHMH nOAIIHCHMH HO H C BbIIIOllHeHHeM 60HKOTHbIX Tpe60BaHHH COI03a Ha MOMeHT HKyrCKaJl 06naCTb BbIIlIIIa H3-IIOA BnaCTl1 aAMHHHCTpa­ UHH IIOAaTll He rrOCbIJ1aJIHCb nOIlIaAH He OTIIYCKanHCb H C006meHHH C nOllHUHeH IIpeKpaTHllHcbY 254 IlIeHHO HOBbie BblpOCiliHe Bceueno Ha rrO'lBe oCB060AJ1TenbHOro ABH­ iKeHHH Y APYrHX HapoAHOCTeH HailieH rpynnbI Hall HOHaJIbHbIe op­ raHH3awm CTanH CKna lJ bIBaTbCH ropa3AO paHbIlIe BO BpeMH OCBO­ 60AHTenbHoro ABHiKeHHH Mbl BHAJ1M l1X TonbKO OKpenIlIHMH rrpH­ HHMalOmHMl1 60nee onpeAeneHHYIO POPMY TaK HanpHMep y 6y­ PHT 6naro apH BblCOKO pa3BHTOMY pO OBOMY CTPOIO OpraH1130­ BaHHoe HaUHOHanbHoe 06meHHe B TOH H11H pyroH popMe Hl1KorAa He npepbIBanOCb oCB060 HTenbHoe ABHiKeHHe npH ano CTapblM popMaM 06meHHH TonbKO HOBbIM xapaKTep BMeCTO C'bCJAOB TaH­ IlIeii - C'be3 bl BceHapOAHbIe BMeCTO ronblX XOAaTaHCTB rrnaHO­ 255 MepHble rrpOCKTbI OpraHli3alum HapO nHOH f H3HH H T n Y O nHOH qa­ CTH OYPHT HMeHHO HPKYTCKHX Y KOTOPblX aBHO OCJIaOJIH OblJIO OO'be HHHlOmHe 3JIeMeHTbl Mbl BH J HM BHOBb HapO f eHHe HaQHO­ Bo HMH ycrrexa CBoero rJIaBHOrO H a Q H 0 H a JI b H 0 r 0 ena OHH ipOPMaJIbHO rrpH3HaJIH ceoa BHCrrapTHHHbIMH HO B neH­ CTBHTeJIbHOCTH rro naBJIfllOmeC OOJIbllIHHCTBO qrreHOB Ka f JJ oro yqu­ HaJIbHOH OpraHH3aQHH H HaKOHeQ BrrCpBble B 3TOT rrepHO ooe OT­ TeJIbCKOrO COI03a HHor na COlO3bI QeJIHKOM IIPHHHMaJIH oomylO no­ paCJIH 0ypHTCKOrO HapO a rrOTepHBIliHe HaBblKH B3aHMHOrO Oome­ JIHTuqeCKYIO IIJIaTipopMY HHH BCTynHnH B TCCHblH OOmeHaQHOHaJIbHblH COlO3 KYJIbTypHOrO COlO30B 3apOJJ HJIOCb B caMblH pa3rap BH f eHHfI B KOTOpOM yqHTe­ B03pO f eHHH To f e qTO 0 0ypHTax 0 H3BecTHoH CTeneHH MO f HO 23 CKa3aTb H 0 KHpnnax JIfi IIPHHHMaJIH caMoe neflTCJIbHOe yqacTHe BblJJ alOmylOcH pOJIb Hr­ 11 qTOOblrrOKOHqHTb C CHOHPblO ynoMHHeM MaJIeHbKHH COlO3 MH­ HYCHHCKHX HHopo 'QeB BrrpOqeM OCTaBHBIlIHH OqeHb MaJIO CJIe 'OB H HaKOHeQ rrOnbITKY opraHH30BaTb BceoomHH COlO3 Bcex HHOpO ­ I1Haqe H ObITb He Morno OOllbllIHHCTBO PaJIH yquTeJIbCKHe COlO3bl H B H30HpaTeJIbHYIO KaMnaHHIO yqHTeJIeH B nepBylO ronOBY BblOHPaJI HapOJJ yrrOJIHOMOqeHHbIMH BbIoopmHKa MH neflTeJIbHOCTb yqHTeJIbCKHX COlO30B 3aBepllIHJIaCb Y f e B rrepHO n QCB CHOHPH nOrrbITKY OqeHb 3HepmqHYIO HO HeO f H naHHO IIpepBaH­ peaKQHH 00pa30BaHHeM HYIO oJIaro 'apH HaCTYIIHBIlIHM perrpeccHHM PHTOPHaJIbHblX COlO30B yqHTeJIeH H JJ pymx JJ eflTeJIeH rro HapO J HOMY TaKoBbI OblJIH opraHH3aQHH KOroPblC MO f HO Ha3BaTb quCTO Ha­ QHOHaJIbHbIMH a rroToMY H BHerrapTHHHbIMH PH OM C HHMH O J HH rr03 f e PyrHe paHbllIe cymecTBOBaJIH COlO3bl TO f e HaQHOHaJIbHble ip e n epa Q H H HaQHOHaJIbHbIX H Tep­ 00pa30BaHHIO Ha yqpeJJ HTeJIbHOM C'bC3JJ e 3TOH ipe epaQHH COCTO­ HBllleMCH B neTepoypre 24-25 arrpeJIfi 1907 r yqaCTBOBaJIH cyJJ H rro OTqeTY C'bC3 a B quCJIe JJ pyrHx HapO J HOCTeH apMflH rpy3HH eB­ neHCTBOBaBllIHe TO rrapaJInCllbHO TO COBMeCTHO C yrroMHHYTblMH op­ peeB OeJIOPYCOB H rrpeJJ CTaBHTCJIH HallIHX HHopo 'QeB - raHH3allHHMH HO BO BCHKOM cnyqae C HHMH He CMellIaBIliHeCH Mbl HKYTOB KaJIMbIKOB KPblMCKHX TaTap H oallIKHp pa3rpoMbI cpe nH rOBopHM 0 yqHTeJIeH nOMeillaJIH rrpHcYTcTBHIO eneraTOB COlO 3 a x y q H T e JI b C K H X H H a Q H 0 H a JI b ­ nocnY JQma neHTenbHOCTb HaQHOHaJIbHblX yqHTeJIbCKHX COlO30B B C e p 0 C C H H C K 0 r o c 0 10 3 a OT qyBaIIIeH qepeMH­ COB np Hapo nHOCTeH HO-COQHanHCTHqCCKHX TOJIqKOM K 00pa30BaHHIO OYPHT Ha­ HapH ny C 3THMH opraHH3aQHHMH ipOPMaJIbHO BHerrapTHHHbIMH Hapo nHJIHCb H OpraHH3aQHH nap T H H H bl e To OblJIH IIpeHMy­ pO J HbiX yquTeneH r e BlIepBble CTOJIKHYJIHCb yqHTenH pa3Hblx HHO­ meCTBeHHO opraHH3allHH HallHOHaJIbHO-COllHaJIHCTHqeCKHe T e opra­ PO nqCCKHX rpyrrlI HMeBllIHe B03MO f HOCTb conH3HTbcH Me f J y CO­ HH3aQHH BO-lIepBblX rrOCTaBHBIliHe ceoe QeJIblO HCKnlOqHTeJIbHYIO 0010 H ypa3YMeTb BCIO BalKHOCTb yqHTeJIbCKHX COlO30B B JJ eJIe HaQHO­ paooTY B cpe ne TOH HJIH JJ pyroH HapO J HOCTH BO-BTOpbIX rrpHHHMaB- HaJIbHOrO B03pO fCJleHHH IlIHe cBepx TOro H a Q H 0 H a JI b H Y 10 rr JI a T ip 0 pM y YqHTenH rrpeJJ CTaBllHJIH caMblH qYTKHH CBe f HH H 3HepruqHbIH 3neMcHT onH f e Bcero CTOHBllIHH K Macce Qepe3 HHX B cymHocTH TaKoBb OblJIH opraHH3aQHH Hapo nHBIlIHecfI HJIH rrOJIyqHBIliHe Bce HOBbie H neH H 1l03YHrH IIPOHHKaJIH B caMbIe rny60KHe CJIOH Ha­ oc06eHHoe pa3BHTHe B rrepHo peBOJIlOlIHH nOCMOTpHM KaKOBb pOJJ a OHH OblJIH ero eCTeCTBeHHbIMH BO f JJ HMH B rrepHOJJ BH f eHHH 6bIJIH HX qaHHHH HaCKOJIbKO OHH BbIpa3HJIHCb B HX rrJIaTipopMax HaKOHeQ Ha HHX BbIlIaJIa BCH TH f eCTb KyJIbTypHO-HaQHOHaJIbHblX 3a­ npe f J e Bcero HHTepecHo OTMeTHTb qTO HH B O J lfOH nJIaTipopMe JJ aq B03pO f JJ eHHH H3b1Ka BblpaOOTKH HOBbIX MeTOJJ OB rrperrOJJ aBa­ MbI He BHJJ HM HHH H3 aHHH HHop0JJ qeCKHX yqeOHHKOB CJIOBOM BCH Ta TBOpqe­ Q H H CKaH paOOTa KOTOPaH COCTaBJIHJIa HCTHHHoe COJJ ep f aHHe HaQHO­ HaJIbHOrO caMoorrpeJJ eJIeHHH no BHellIHeH CBoeH KOHCTPYKlIHH yqHTeJIbCKHe COlO3bl HOCHJIH H H K a K H X T e H n e H ­ TOJIbKO B e HHeHHH co BceMH Hapo aMH POCCHH B OomeH CBooo e B oome neMOKpaTHqeCKOM CTpoe Ka fCJlaH HapO J HOCTb oopeTeT CBoe nOnpaHHOe rrpaBO I1cxoM H3 noro He TOJIbKO HaQHOHaJIbHO-rrap­ rrpoipeccHOHaJIbHblH xapaKTep B TaKOM JJ yxe IIO KpaHHeH Mepe Co­ THHHbIe rrJIaTipopMbl HO H CTaBJIHJIHCb HX YCTaBbI H 1I0 IIpoipeccHOHaJIbHblM ipJIarOM OHH 1Ib ­ 3HepruqHoro TaJIHCb neraJIH30BaTbCH YMepeHHaH lIJ1aTipopMa 256 C e rr a paT H C T C K H X Ha060pOT Bce OHH npOHHKHYTbI TBepAbIM yoe f JJ eHHeM qTO yqaCTHH B BHcrrapTHiiHbIe opraHH3allHH Tpe6ylOT 06mepOCCHiicKOM nBH f eHHH HaH60JIee rrepBoro MYCYJIbMaHCKOro C'be3 a MHoro 257 MeCTa nOCBJUQaeT lfMeHHO TOMY Bonpocy MHOPO o QbI He OrpaHlfqlfBalllfCb Hlf xpaHCHIUI Heooxo o HMO maCMT 1-H nyHKT TOH rrJIaT popMbI M CBoeBpeMeHHO comDKeHHe MYCYllbMaH Bcex 06JIaCTeH POC­ ClfH Ha nO'lBe 06ruecTBeHHO-KYllbTyPHbIX H rrOJIHTHqeCKHX 3anpOCOB H 3a o a'I COBpeMeHHOH PYCCKOH l lf3HH npOCTbIM Tpe60BaHMCM co­ CTapbIX YCToeB 6bITa HM OoruMMM popMyllaMM aBTOHOM­ Hocm OHM BbIpa6aTbIBanM BCCCTOPOHHMC rrpoeKTbI rrpOCKTbI3eM­ CTBa Y MPKYTCKlfX H 3a6aHKaJIbCKlfX OYPHT 24 Y HKynJB H B THX npoeKTax If B HX MOTlfBHpOBKe OHlf OOHapYiKlfllH He TOllbKO WPHAli­ qeCKOe TBOpqeCTBO He TOllbKO rrpOHHKHOBeHHOC nOHMMaHMC YCllO­ BMH CBoero ObITa HO If C03HaTCllbHoe YCBOCHMC 11 o anec HOBblX H o CH o CMO­ Kpam3Ma B o OCTM I eHMM H ocyruecTBJIeHlfH JTHX 3a o aq nporpCCCHB- OHlf Tpe60BanH coxpaHCHHH po o OBoro YCTpOHCTBa nOTOMy qTO OoruCCTBcHHoro CO- Hall qaCTh MYCYJlbMaH pa3 o ellJlll H o eaJlbI nepe o OBoro pyCCKO­ HaBblKH ero rapaHTlfpoBanH nYlJIlIHe ro oorueCTBa eiicTByeT B CMblClle YCTaHOBJleHHlI B CTpaHC TpyAHHqeCTBa H conH apHoCTlf HO B TO l e BpeMH TruaTellhHO yCTpa­ rrpaBOBoro I10pll o Ka Ha HaqanaX Y'laCTHli CBo60AHO H36paHHblX HHllH H3 Hero Bce BpeAHhle HCTOpH'IeCKlfe JlleMeHThl apHCTOKpaTlf3­ Hapo o HbIX npe 'CTaBHTeJIeH B 3aKOHo o aTellbCTBe H ynpaBJleHHH Ma BBO o JI B CBOlf npoeKThl caMoyrrpaBneHHH Bce rrpHHII lfnbI o eMO­ rocy apCTBOM rr 3 neliTenbHocTb CBOW MYCYllbMaHe Ha· npaBJIlIWT co06pa3HO C nOTpe6HOCTlIMH H 3arrpocaMH i'ocyoapcreeHHOU H3HH B POCCHH H T o n o6 J e­ 4 KpaTH3Ma Bce06ruee H30HpaTenbHoe npaBO 6e3 pa3nHlJHH nona Bbl­ 60PHOCTb BllaCTeH He3aBHCHMOCTh OT a MHHHCTpaI lfH nepe o aqy llIKOllhHoro o ena B pyKlf opraHOB caMoynpaBneHHH H 1 0 OHlf Ha­ CTaHBaJIH Ha coxpaHeHHH HCKOHHoro pO OBoro Bna o eHHH 3eMllCH IIpaB o a y HeKOTopbIX HapO 'HOCTeH KaK y OYPHT TaTap 3aMC­ 'IanaCb HHTeHCHBHaH TeH o eHIJ I1J1 C6J1H I eHlfJl C po o CTBeHHbIMM MM Ha­ po o aMH BHe POCCHH qTO no o ano nOBO o rOBopHTb 0 naHMOHronH3Me rraHMcnaMH3Me M 1 HO C6JIH I eHHe HMeno B BH o y MHTepeCbl qHCTO o YXOBHble H 'ITO 3aMe'laTeJIbHee Bcero B QeHTpe c6nH I eHHJI OrrJlTb­ TaKM CTOHna POCCHH rrpaB o a CBOOOAHaJl POCCHJI Boo6rue H3y'le­ HHe o OKYMeHTOB HaQHOHanbHoro o BH I eHHJI C O'leBH o HOCTbW CBH o e­ TenbcTByeT 0 TOM 'ITO Hlf B O o HH MOMeHT PYCCKOH lfCTOPMlf CBJl3b HHOpOAQeB C POCClfeH He 6bma CTonb KpenKa o yXOBHO KaK B ro­ hI oCB060 o lfTeJIbHOrO ABlf l eHlfH cneHHH H B TOM crrpaBe ll 11HBO BH enH 3anor pOCTa COI HanhHOH CO­ llH o apHOCTH 25 OHH BOCCTanH rrpOTHB rrOCHraTenhCTBa Ha KO'leBOH 6bIT HO B TO l e BpeMH BOTHpOBanH MepbI crrocrrellIecTBywruHe ne­ pexo o y K 60nee nporpeCCHBHhlM popMaM KyJIbTyphI ceJIbCKOXO­ 3HHCTBeHHbIe llIKonhI KypChI pepMhI H np I1HTepecHbI rrorrblTKH TBOpqeCTBa B oonaCTH aBTOHOMU3Ma 3a­ 6aHKanbCKlfe OYPHThI HarrpHMep He o OBOJIhCTBYWTCH TpeOOBaHHH­ MH llIHpOKoro caMoyrrpaBncHHH H Tpe6YWT C03 o aHHH opraHa HaI HO­ HanhHoro 06'be o HHeHHJI B JIHI e nepHo o HqeCKHX C'be3 o OB npe o CTaBH­ 3a 06ruHMH Tpe60BaHHJlMlf B nporpaMMax lfHopo o QeB cne o ywT Tpe60BaHHJI TO l e 06ruenOJIlfTHqeCKOrO xapaKTepa HO CrreU HaJIhHO HHTepecywrulfe Ty lfnH o pyryw Hapo o HOCTb H60 OHO rapaHTlfpOBano HaH60JIbmyw paBHOMepHOCTb B ee pacrrpe­ HanpHMep My­ cYllhMaHcKHH COW3 Tpe6yeT BO lfMJI paBHOnpaBlfJl Hapo o HocTeH TeneH Be o OMCTB MpKYTCKHe 6YPHThl Bhlpa6aTbIBaWT MepbI 3a­ rulfThI 0YPJlTCKoro MeHbllIHHCTBa 26 B ry6cpHcKOM 3eMcTBe HKyTbl Ha o ewTCJI OCyrueCTBHTb CBOW HaI HOHanhHYW aBTOHOMHOCTb Ollaro­ apH CBoeMY rro o aBnllwruCMY 60llhlliHHCTBY B 3eMCKHX yqpe J eHH­ lIX TaTaphl Tpe6YWT 06pa30BaHHlI MeCTHhIX MeJJ j HllHCOB PYKOBO­ OTMeHbl Bcex H3'bllTHH H OrpaHHqeHHH KOTopbIe YCTaHoB­ lIeHbI B OTHOllIeHHH MYCYJIhMaH o eHCTBywruHMH Y3aKoHeHHlI­ MH rrpaBHTeJIhCTBeHHbIMH paCIlOpll l eHHlIMH H a MHIlHcTpa­ THBHOH rrpaKTHKoii H nOlIHoro ypaBHeHHlI MycYJlhMaH C Hacc­ neHHCM pyccKoro rocy apCTBa BO Bcex npaBax rrOnHTHqeCKHX rpa o aHcKHx H peJIHrH03HbIX AHanOrHqHhlC Tpe60BaHHJI HMCWTCJI H BO BCCX OCTanbHblX rrJIaT­ p0pMax 258 o HMbIX nepHO I1'IeCKHMH C'be3 aMH MycynbMaH If TaK o ance B 06nacm J 3blKa Tpe60BaHHlI pa3JlHqHhI Y HapO HOCTeH C caMO­ CTOllTeJIbHhIMH TCppHTOpHlIMH KaK OYPHThl KaTerOpHqeCKH Tpeoy­ eTCli BBe CHHe pOAHoro 1I3hIKa B 06JlaCTH cy o a H caMoyrrpaBlleHHH Hao60pOT y TaKHX HapOAHOCTeH KaK TaTaphI TO Tpe60BaHHe He PHrypHpyeL 3aTO B 06naCTH o YXOBHoro caMoorrpc o eneHHH H lliKO­ JIbI BCC rrllaT popMhI CXO o lITCH Bcc TpeOYWT npe l o e Bcero caMOH 259 llIHPOI OH CB06o J b1 OTKphlTHH llIKOn KYPCOB H BCHKHX pOCBeTH­ TeJ1bHhIX yqpe lK 'eHHH Bceo6mero H 06H3aTenbHOrO 06pa30BaHH lL Bce O HHaKOBO Tpe6YIOT 'IT06bl H3blKOM IIpeIlO aBaHH I 6bln PO ­ HOH H3bIK 'IT06bl eno HapO UIOro 06pa30BaHH I lIepellIJ10 B PYKH OpraHOB caMoynprumeHHH r KOHe'lHO OT Tex HapO HOCTeH Y KOTOPhIX H O TOro cymecTBOBaJIH pOPMhI opraHH3aunOHHoro 06meHHH CBoe06pa3HaH cY h6a 1I0CTHrJla enYTauHIO HKYTOB nocnaHHYIO lIocne H3 aHHH MaHH pecra 9-ro HIOHH JIH HCXO OTaHCTBOBaHHH oc060ro npe CTaBHTenbCTBa nellYTaUHH 6bIJ1a pH3HaHa onaCHOH HaKOHeU BCe rOBOpHT 0 Ky lbTypHOM CaMoynpa81leHUU U Ha14UO­ HllIlU3aijUU 11 OIlHTb-TaKH H B ny H Tenerpa pHblM paCnOpH lKeHHeM B03BpameHa C OPOrH B HKYTCK p0pMyny HHOpOAUhI BKna b1BaIOT 3a enYTaUHHMH 1I0cne OBaJI nepHO C'b e 3 ' 0 B • TaKHe cBoe Ollpe eneHHoe co ep lKaHHe no 'pa3YMeBaH no nHM B03PO lK­ C'beJ J bI MhI BH HM Y 6YPHT 60JlbllIe Bcero Y KHprH3 HKYTOB Ta­ eHHe pO UIoro H3b1Ka C03 aHHe H3 Hero 0PY HH eBponeHCKoro Tap npOCBemeHHH H BHeceHHe 06mHe C'he3 J bI npo OJl lKanHCb no HeCKOJlhKY HeH H 6hIJIH BeCh­ B UHKn llIKOJlhHOrO npeno aBaHHH Bcex Tex KYJlbTypHbIX npH06peTeHHH KOTophIe Hapo C03 aJI Ha CBoeM Ma npo YKTHBHhI PO UIOM H3hIKe Or aBaH ce6e 1I0JlHbIH oneT B orpOMHhIX TPY UIO­ eKTbI 0 3eMCTBe cy e 3eMJleIlOJlh30BaHHPt H T 06CY K aJIHCb ca­ 'ena Ha HeKoTophIX Bblpa6aThIBanHCh CJIO lKHhIe IIpO­ HHopO 'IeCKHe nnaT popMbl B03JIaralOT Bce Ha­ Mble palHo06pa3HbIe CTOpOHhI 6bITa H CYM no npOTOKOJlaM Y'IaCT­ e lK J bI Ha caMo eHTenbHOCTh Hapo a H OT rocy apcrna Tpe6ylOT HHKH npoHBHnH HeCMoTpH Ha uapHBllIee B036Y K eHHe H cTpacT­ TonbKO YCTpaHeHHH IIpeJlOH K HapO UIOMY TBop'lecTBy HOCTb npeHHH caMoe cepbe3Hoe H YMenoe OTHOllIeHHe K eny He­ CTHX HOBoro KOTopble 06mHe C'be3 b1 6hIJ1H C03BaHhI caMoH a MHHHcTpaUHeH HnH TaKOBhI 6hIJ1H IInaT popMhI HHOpO 1JeCKHX rpynll Ho TaKOBhI 6hIJ1H nnaT popMbI H Bcex neBbIX napTHH BOT 1I0'le­ My Bce CHMnaTHH HHopOMeB 6bIJ1H Ha CTopOHe neBhIX ObIJIH IIpaB­ no ee nO'lHHY y HKYTOB 6YPHT aCTpaxaHCKHX KaJIMhIKOB Y no­ cne HHX 3TO 6hIJI H e 'HHcTBeHHhIH C'he3 ' • HapH Y CO C'be3 aMH 06meHaUHoHanhHhIMH lIIJlH H BceB03MO lK­ a 3neMeHThI npaBble HO TO 6hIJ1H aHTHHaUHOHaJIhHhle peaKUHOH­ HhIe 3neMeHTbI cTpaxa HnH HHTepeca pa H THrOTeBllIHe K 6lOpOKpa­ HhIe KOH pepeHUHH - THH TaKYIO ponh HrpaJIH YXOBHhle npaBneHHH TaTap B KPhIMY BeHcrna ropo 'cKHX HOTa6JleH y TaTap Ho HCTHHHaH CHJla BH lKe­ yqHTeJleH lIapTHHHhIX 'eHTeneH rpy n yxo­ lKHBllIHe KaleHHblM lKaJlOBaHheM H 06HpaTenhCTBOM lIaCTBhI TaKYIO HHH BhIJlWaCb lKe pOJlb HrpaJIO 3 eCh TarapCKoe nOMeCTHoe BOPHHCTBO OblJla Ma­ phIe HOCHJIH BceHapO HbIH xapaKTep 3 eCh caM Hapo Henocpe ­ B paHOHHhIX H M e C T H hI x c06paHHHX KOTO­ JleHbKaH rpynna np03BaHHaH HpKyTCKHMH 6ypHTaMH 06pYCHTe­ CTBeHHO npH06manCH K BH lKeHHIO H KonHn 3MOUHH H BocnOMHHa­ JlHMH-nO JIH30BuaMH BCH'IeCKH IIPOTHBo 'elicTBOBaBllIaH BCHKHM HH I nH 6ynymeH nepMaHeHTHOH KynbTYPHOH pa60TbI 3 'eCh 6pa­ HOBllIeCTBaM H Tpe60BaHH IM ObIJIa KyqKa llIonOMOBueB HCTHHHO TanaCb BnepBhle HHTennHreHUHH C HapO OM 11 3 caMOCTOHTeJlhHhIX aKTHBHhIX BhICTYllneHHH MO lKHO OTMeTHTh PYCCKHX HKYTOB BonHBllIHX 'ITO IlporpeCCHBHhIe 3neMeHTbi pa3py­ llIalOT OCHOBhI CTaporo HapO UIOro 6hlTa 06pa30BaJICH COlO3 HC­ THHHO PYCCKHX cpe UI TaTap B Ka3aHH IIpH Y'IaCTHH HeKOTopblX OTKa3 OT BhI60pOB OJl lKHOCTHbIX nHU no HOBOMY 3aKoHY - Y 6YPHT 1901 r HaCHJlbCTBeHHoe B03BpameHHe OT Ka6HHeTa oT' y lK eH­ KynuoB H Mynn Ho B 06meH CnO lKHOCTH Bce 3TH 3neMeHTbI IIpe '­ HhIX 3eMenb CTaBnHnH HH'ITO lKHhle OT6poCbl KOTophle oc06eHHO B OCB060 H­ HblX YM Y 6YPHT OTKa3 OT 1I0 aTeH H cHollIeHHH C a MHHHcTpaUH­ TenbHhIH lIepHO HHKaKOH pOJlH He HrpaJIH B lIepHO peaKUHH KO­ eli - Y HKYTOB He'lHO 3TH 3neMeHThI paHhllIe onacaBllIHeCH OTKphIToro BhICTynJle­ HHH CTaJIH CMenee B OCB060 HTenbHbIH lIepHo Kor a Ha'laJIaCb H36HpaTeJIhHaH KaMTIaHH I eHTenbHOCTh HaUHO­ HaJIbHblX opraHH3aUHH 6hIJIa nepeHeceHa B o6JlacTh Tellepb nOCMOTpHM B 'IeM pOHBHna ce6H 3 H e p r H II 3a6aHKaJIhCKHMH TYHrycaMU BOCCTaHOBJleHHe CTell­ H a U H 0 H a JI b H a H A priori MO lKHO CKa3aTh T e Jl b H 0 H a r H Tau H H HaceneHHH OTHeCJlHCh C BenH'IaHllIHM 3HTY3Ha3MOM Be J b OT nYMbI 'ITO OHa eCTeCTBeHHO OJl lKHa 6bIJ1a pOHBnHTbCH B Tex lKe pOPMax H ee npe 'CTaBHTeJleH 3aBHceno B KaKHX OHa pOHBnHnaCb B 06mepOCCHHCKOM BH lKeHHH B nepHO KOTopble IIpoBo3rnallIanHcb Ha MHTHHrax H C'be3 ax OBepH l H npeMYMbH Ha cueHe PHrypHPOBaJIH 260 e n Y Tau H H H 3 6 11 P a ­ K HeH Bce 3neMeHTbI HHopO 'IeCKOrO ocymecTBneHHe Tex pia desideria C03HaTenbHo H 6ecc03HaTenbHo H36HpaTenbHaH arHTaUHH CBO H­ 261 naCb K J BYM n03YHraM Ha BCeX CTa J l1HX 1I36IIpaTb HalI60JIee JIeBbIX a 1I3 3Tl1X IJOCne J HIIX IJOJIb30BaTbCH BCHKOH B03MO l HOCTbIO IJpOBO­ J IITb CBOIIX II TOJIbKO B cnytlae HeB03MO l HOCTII nOCJIeJJ Hero OT J a· BaTb CBOII ronoca 3a J pyrHX Ho ny I HO OT J aTb CIJpasC J JlIIBOCTb l1IIO­ pO J '1eCKOMY 3neMCHTY Hl1Kor J a OH He 3nOYIJOTpe6mm CBOIIM 60JIb­ IlIIIHCTBOM Bcer J a YCTYIJaH CIJpaBe J JlHBOe '1l1CJIO MCCT MCHbIlIl1HCT­ By C TeM 60nbIlIeH rop J OCTbIO H mTY311a3MOM Ka l J aH l1HOpO J '1e­ CKaH rpynIJa BCTpe'laJIa Ka l J Oe 1136paHHe CBOl1X B Bbl60PIlllIKl1 iIJll1 B J CIJYTaTbI IJapJIaMeHTa lleIJYTaTbI nepBOH 11 BTOPOH llYM BCTpe'la· nHCb C BeJI aHIlIl1M 3HTY3Ha3MOM lIM YCTpaHBaJll1Cb TOp I eCTBeH­ HbIe IJPOBO J bl 11 Kor J a 01I11 IJpHe3 1 aJIH Ha IJ06blBKY Ha pO J HHY Ka l J blH rOTOB 6bJJ1 Ha l epTBbI nlIIlIb 6bl 1I0cnYIllaTb CBoero J eIJY­ TaTa IJOBeCTBOBaBIIIero Ha l1X PO J HOM H3blKe 0 IJepHneTIIHX J YM­ CKOH pa60TbI MOPABa lIe e J IIHCTBeIlHoe IIHOpO eCKoe IJneMH KO­ Topoe C HaIIBHOH HO TporaTemHOH rop J OCTbIO 6epe l CT naMHTb 0 CBOllX e J IIHOnJIeMeHHHKax MPHaHOBe J eIJyraTax nepBOH llYMbl AHIIKHHe 11 nCBOHaUIIOHaJIblIble JI03YlIfH IIII0PO J UCB IIrpaJIl1 He MaJIYIO ponb B napTlIHHOH OKpaCKe J cnYTaTOB Bcero BOCTOKa POC­ CHII r J c J a l e B TpeTbIO llYMY 6JIarO J apH l1MelIHO HlIopo J uaM I1HOPO J llbI lIe J OBOJIbCTBOBaJIIICb OJJ HHM yqaCTl1eM B Bbl60pax OHII 30PKO cnc J I1JII1 3a CBOI1MII 1I36paHHHKaMH nOCbJJ1aJIl1 lIM BCJIe J HaKa3bl H OC06blX HOTa6JICH KOTopbIe B '1aCTHblX COBeIllaHl1HX PY­ KOBO J l1JlH J eIJYTaTaMH IJOMOraJIl1lIM II KOIlTPOJIIIPOBaJIlI IIX B TO l C caMOH llYMe TOJ1bKO MYCYJlbMaHCKl1e J errYTaTbI COCTaBJIHB­ HIlle BHYIIIlITeJ1bHYIO BCJ1l1QIIHY B ncpBbIX J BYX llYMax TIl rpyIJIJ 3a IJepHO J OCB0 0 l J eHIIH KOTOPaH 28 COXpaHl1J1aCb H B llYMe XOTH H B 3HaQIITCJ1bHO MeHbIlIeM Kon CCTBe TbI J pymx HapOJJ HOCTeH BXO J l1Jl1I 06pa­ llCIJYTa­ BO ppaKllHl1 TCX IJapTl1H K KO­ TOPbIM OIlH npl1Ha J Jle l aJIl1 no CBOHM y6e l J eHHHM IIpe J cTaBl1TeJIH CII611pCKIIX l1HOpo J ueB KpoMe Toro Y'lacTBOBaJIlI B pa60Tax CI16HP­ Ho HapH J Y C 3T1IM IlIJIa J PyraH pa60Ta K Y J1 b T Y P H 0 r 0 B03PO l J CHI1H Ta pa60Ta KOTopaH J OJ1 I Ha 6bJJ1a 3aIJ0J1Hl1Th rpHJJ yIlll1e IJOJIIITH'ICCKHe pOPMbI HaUI10­ HaJIbHOrO 6bITa HaUHOHaJIbHbIM cO J cp l aHHeM Pa60Ta na B TYCK­ JIoe BpCMH craporo pe l HMa Morna Ka3aTbCH 6c3Ha J e l HoH To B '1CM J yx Hapo J HoCTH HaHOOJ1eC rrOJIHO IJPOHBJIHCTCH 11 'ITO B TO l e BpeMH HBJIHeTCH e J HHCTBeHHbIM rrpOBO J HI1KOM 06Ille'leJIOBe'leCKO­ ro 3HaHl1H 11 l1 J eaJIOB B Boro 3anpCTa Maccy ce H3blK IJo J J aBJICHl1eM BeKO­ OKa3aJICH B COCTOHHHH aTpo pHH UeJIbIe IJJIeMeHa KaK MOpABa '1yBaIIIII BOTHKH He HMeJIII HHKaKOH IJHCbMeHHOCTH KpOMe rrepeBO J OB - H TO He y J OBJIeTBOpl1TeJIbHbIX - CBHIlleHHblX KHl1r a y Tex KOTOPblC HMeJIH ee KaK TaTapbl 6YPHTbI OHa 6bJJ1a IJPlICIJoc06JIeHa J JIH Y3Koro Kpyra uepKOBHOCTH Bcc 'ITO C03 J aJIH KyJIbTypa 11 HaYKa 3a rrOCJICJJ HHe BCKa 6bIJIO IJO'lTH '1Y I J O nOH rrHCbMCHHOCTl1 1I60 IlIKOJIa 6blJIa TOJIbKO KOH peCCIfOHaJIbHaH a B lIapOJJ HblH H3bIK 6bJJ1 3aIJpemeH IIpe J cToHJIa f1IraHT­ CKaH 3a J a'la IJepeCKO'lHTb 3a BeKa OMepTBeHHH If BJIHTb B CTapble H3bIKOBbIe opraHH3Mbi HOBOC CO J ep l aHl1e HOBbie H J elf HOBbie pop­ MbI HOBble CJIOBa 11 IJIIOHepbl HHopO J '1eCKlIX HapO J HOCTeH HC HC­ rryraJIIICb TpYJJ HOCTeiL O J HH rrpeKpaCHblH J CHb B HapO J HbIX IIIKOJIaX Y'IIITeJIH 3aro­ BOPl1JlH Ha pO J HOM H3blKe ytIaIllIfXCH Ha PO J HOM H3bIKe MaCCbI 3arOBOpiIJIII opaTopbI Ha MIITIIHrax MeHHOCTII HBJIHIOTCH Y HapO J OB He 3HaBIIIHX IJHCb­ rrpOKJIaMaUHH reKTorpa pHpOBaHHble JIHCT­ KI1 ra3eT MOpIl Ba BOTHKH pacrrcBaIOT MapceJIbe3Y Ha POIl HOM H3bI­ Ke KHprH3bI 3axJIe6bIBaHCb '1IITaIOT B IJepeBOll e MaHH pCCT 17-ro OKTH6pH 11 pa3Y'Il1BaIOT HalI3YCTb rrepeJIO l cHHyIO B CTHxax rrporpaM­ My K -Il Y '1YBamCH B TC'IeHHC MHOHIX MeCHueB H31l aCTCH pall HKaJlb­ HaH rrOJIl1TH'ICCKaH ra3CTa XbIlIap HBJIHeTCH UCJIblH pHil rrOJIHTH­ CKOH rpYIJilbl B napJ1aMCHTe HHOPO J QCCKHe IJpe J cTaBl1TeJ1H npHMblKaJIl1 Bce 6e3 HCKJ110QeHHH K IJpOrpeCcHBHblM rpynnaM He rrpaBee K - J II KpO­ Me Toro Bce IIOr0J10BHO BOIlIJ11I B J YMCKyIO rpyrrny aBTOHOMHCTOB PYHKU110HHP0BaBIlIYIO BO BpeMH IJepBbIX J ByX llYM '1eCKHX 6pOlliIOp a y TaTap HapO l J aCTCH cpa3y HCCKOJ1bKO IJapTHH­ llbIX opraHOB Il a l e IOMopHCT eCKlIe 1131l aHHH If UeJ1blH pHil HJ1J1IO­ CTpHpOBaHHbIX Y'lC6HHKOB 11 6pOlliIOp TeJIbCTBO Y'le6HHKOB o KpIDme 262 IJpOHBJIeHHH HHopO J '1eCKHX pa60Ta MeHee BI1 J HaH HO 6bITb MO l eT eIlle 60J1ee 3HaQI1TeJIbllaH B BpeMH 30BaJ1H caMocToHTemHYIO PpaKllHIO IJ 0 J1 II T 11 'I e C K 11 C CBeTCKOH npOlIDll1 cpaBHIITenbHO lIalI60JIee JIeBble 3neMellTbI B TaKOBbI Y 6YPHT B03HlfKaCT 1I31l a­ H IJCPCBOIl HblX KHIIr B ll aJIeKOH HKYTCKOH B03HIIKaeT ra3eTa Ha PYCCKOM H HKYTCKOM H3blKax lIKYTCKl1H KpaH Hapo l J acTCH Il a l e HaUHOHaJIbHblH TeaTp B 263 Jh YTCKe B pa3rap lBH eHlUI OTKphIBaeTC HaQHOHaJlhHhIH Kny6 nen ll eiiCTBHTenhHoe rrOpa eHHe TOT rrCMXH'leCKMH nepeBopoT KO­ rl e CTaB T He TonbKO ll paMhI H3 KYTCKOii iKlI3HH HO ll a e onePhI TOPhlH rrpOH301l1el1 B HapO ll MOM C03HaHMM 3a oCB060 ll MTel1hHbIH ne­ C KYTCKHMH MOTHBaMH H HaCTO IlI HMH aKTepaMH H neBQaMH M3 PMO ll He rrO J ll aeTCH HHKaKHM BHell1HMM ll aBneHHHM HapO ll a B ACTpaxaHM KaJlMhIKM CTaBl1T Ha CQeHe KanMhIUKYlO JIcHXHKa HHOP0 ll Ua pap HKaJlhHO H3MeHMnaCh OH OC03HaIT CBoe CBa ll h6y ••• 3TO 6hIlla pa60Ta Tpe60BaBWal1 3HTY3Ma3Ma H orpOMHoro rrpaBO OH YBepOBaIT B ce6 OH rrpOHMKC' YBa eHHeM K ce6e Y He­ 3anaca HaCTOii'lHBOCTM M 3HeprMH ro Bl l1HCb H ll eaJIhl OH oGpen BepHYlO rrpe ll aHHYlO HHTellJIHreHUHlO HY HO nOMHHTb 'ITO OCB060 ll MTenbHOe ll BH eHHe 3aCTano HHO­ OH CTynMn HaKOHeu Ha nYTh caMop eHTenhHocrH OH y e Ha'laJI TBO­ pOp '1eCKYlO HHTennHreHQHlO B COCTOl1HMH nonHOH PYCMCjmKaQMM B pHTb nMTepaTYPY M nonHTMKY Ha CBoeM PO J HOM 113h1Ke H OH ynop­ YMCTBeHHOM OTHoweHHH KaK O ll HH H3 MHorHX rrpHMepOB MO HO HO rrpO ll On aeT ll aJlhll1e TBOPHTb yKa3aTh 'ITO Ha rrepBOM CDe3 ll e KPbIMCKMX Y'lMTeneH TaTap ll e6aThI BenHCb Ha PYCCKOM 3hIKe To e npOMCXO ll MnO Y '1YBaweii Y KaJI· MhIKOB Ka eTC ll a e Y 6YP T H HKYTOB Cpe ll H MOP ll BhI Ha­ rrpHMep Ha nepBhIX MHTHHraX opaTopbI rOBopHnH nO-PYCCKH TonhKO ll 11 Hl1l1lOCTpaQHH rrpHBO ll HnM H M ll OBOnbHO xapaKTepeH TOT j aKT 'ITO B TO BpeMH KaK B cpep e PYCCKOH HHTennHreHUHM peaKQHl1 nopO ll l l1a HaCTpoeHMe YHblHMH H paCTepHHHOCTH 3TO HaCTpoeHHe MeHhll1e Bcero KocHynocb HHO­ pO ll '1eCKOH HHTennMreHQHH KOTopaH He TonbKO He IIO J ll aITaCI oG­ 6bITOBhIe rrpHMephI Ha MOp­ IlI eMY YHbIHHlO HO HaoGopoT rrpOHBl1HeT ocoGeHHYlO l 3HeHHOCTb ll OBCKOM H3bIKe JIOHHTHO rr03TOMY nOlleMY Te caMhIe HHTennHreH· Y e B nepHO ll peaKQHH Ha'lMHalOT HBnHTbC IIonblTKH HaQMOHaITb­ ThI KOTopbIe B Ka'leCTBe nOl1HTHlleCKHX ll e TeneH HBl1HnHCb nhIllKH­ HblX opraHH3aQMH TaM r ll e OHH paHbll1e He CYIlI eCTBOBaITH HmpM­ MH arHTaTOpaMH Ha c06paHH X yqMTenhcKHX Cbe3 ll OB He MeHee Mep Y KaJlMbIKOB BhlpaCTaeT j e ll epaQHH yqHTeneii MHOp0 ll ueB rrbIllKO ll e6aTHpOBal1M Borrpochl 06 ampaBHTe op j orpaqJMH TepMH­ Y HHTennHreHTOB H3 MOP ll Bbl KOTopble B nepHO ll oGIlI ero nO ll beMa H0110rHH pe j opMe rrpeIIO ll aBaHH B MycynhMaHcKHx M l1aMaHCT· MaJlO y ll enHl1H BHHMaHHH KynbTYPHO-HaQHOHaITbHOii paGoTe Tenepb CKHX WKonax rrpoeKTHpOBaJlM j aKYl1bTeTbI HaQHOHaJlbHOrO 3HaHHH HaoGopof npOHBnHeTC oc06eHHbIH MHTepec K PO ll MOMY 3bIKY y 6YP T rrpoeKThl rrperrO ll aBaHH B BhICWHX p aQaHCKHX wKonax PO ll HOH cnOBeCHOCTM Cpe ll M raTap B03HMKaeT lI1HpOKOe j eMHHHCT­ H CTpoHnH IDlaHhl H3 ll aTenhCTB TOnKOBaJlH 06 oGIlI eqIMHcKoM aJI­ CKoe ll BH eHHe B pa3HbIX MecTax TaTapCKOH OCe ll l10CTH Bl l1HCI ne­ j aBHTe H T ll raJIH30BaHHbIe KynbTypHo-npOCBeTMTellbHhle oGIlI eCTBa Me IJ y rrpo­ Ho oCBoGO ll HTenhHhIii rrepHO ll nOl1HhIH GYPh ronoBoKpy l ­ '1HM B JIerepGypre B MOCKBe Gbll1a nOIlbITKa XOTH H TIlI eTHa Tel1hHhlX rroGe ll H GecnOIll a ll MhIX rrOpa eHHH npOM'Ianc cnHlI1KOM neraJIH30BaTb BcepOCCHHCKYlO MycynbMaHCKYIO napTHlO GhICTpO Ha cMeHy BHnaCh peaKUH M ueHTpaJIhHhlM rrYHKTOM ee '1eCKaH H3 aTenbCKaH e TenbHOCTb pa3paCTaerCl1 B03P eiicTBHll CTan MHopop eu 27 MHOPO ­ MHOrO'lHcneHHhle HapO ll HOCTH KaK KOHe'lHO peaKUHll eCTOKO rrOBpe l Hna HaUMOHaITbHOMY BH e­ KHpm3hI CapThI GYPHThl HKYThI H P p nOTepl1nM npaBO npeP CTaBH­ HHlO BbIpBaB nY'IlI1Hx ll el'lTeneii pa30rHaB nyqll1Hx Y'IMTeneH Harpo­ TenbCTBa POKOBhIe orraCHOCTH rp03MBWHe MHorHM H3 HMX KaK rrOTepH 3eMenbHoro j OH ll a H caMoynpaBneHHH CTanH eIll e rp03HhIMH '1eM KOr ll a-l1HGo Gonee He'lero H rOBOpHTb 0 '1aHHHHX KYl1b­ M03 ll HB ThICI'PIH npenoH K pocry nHTepaTypbl paCKonoB HaKoHeu KynhTypHble 3neMeHTbl Ho 3HrY3Ha3M OCTaJlCH H 3HTY3Ha3M 3 ll OpO­ BhIH 3HTY3Ha3M KOTOPhIH Me'lTaeT He oG 060coGneHMH a 0 npHCO­ TypHhIX aBTOHOMHii ywe ll WHX B OGruylO neTY 06Il1 HX norpe6eH­ e ll HHeHHM K oGIlI e'lenOBe'leCKOMY HO He ueHoii HaUHOHaJlbHOrO a HhIX Ha ll e J OCBoGO ll HTenhHoro rrepHO ll a '1epe3 HauHOHaIThHoe M npH BceM TOM 0 HaQHOHaJlhHOM ll BH eHHH MO HO CKa3aTb TO e 'ITO 0 POCCHHCKOM ll BH eHHH BooGIlI e MCTOpHH He MepHT CBOHX ycrrexoB MacwTaGoM MHMOJleTHhlX rro­ Ge ll Hl1H rrOpa eHHii MCTHHHhlM HCTOpH'leCKHM KpHTepHeM HapO ll ­ HOro pOCTa Cl1y aT ero rrCHXH'IeCKHe 3aBoeBaHMH EcnH B rrCHXHKe HapO ll OCTal1CH Ha CTapOM MeCTe l l1H rrOll1eIT Ha3a ll TOr ll a OH rrOTep­ 264 265 6 npl1MEQAHIOI npaso' 1905 r N° 4849 CTp C006l UeHO MHe 11 K 3eJIeHOBbIM DllplK Ben se'lepHllll Bblll 3889 4Il4epllHa op npOCTbiC TaTapbl C41lTalOT Hcy a'lll PYCCKIlX S RnoHHIl DOlKbell Kapoll c CTp 21 jJCBp 1908 r' 24 9 Ibid eTp 25 26 10 Ibid • CTp 25 26 11 B TO lKC BpeMH MOlKlIO YKa3aTb MHoro npHMepOB Korna PYCCKoe Ha­ Ja HeJaKOHHble no IlX MHCHIlIO AcllcTBHH MIlCCIlOHCPOB npoTIlB MY­ cYJlbMaH C R l H4cpIlHa 0 llPIlBOJllKCKIlX HHopoAuax CHI 1906 1' Tp 26 3 CeJleHHC BKpanneHHoe B CPC IlY HHOpOnUCB nOCTcneHHO TeplleT ponHoll Bnp04CM AalKe CpCAH HapoAHoCTCIl noro THna KalKAaH AUlKC BTopocTe­ neHHaH 60JUI'IKa CllCU l 'PH'ICCKaH AJlH Toll HJIH APyroll HapoAHOCTH B 3TOT rOplI'IHI ncpHO ll OC06CIIII0 'IyBcTBOBaJlaCb H BblASHraflaCb HapYlKY TaK lIanpllMCp Y BOTHKOB eCTb CneUHaJlbHaR 60JIH'IKa TaK Ha3b1BaCMal H3blK H YCBallBaeT AOMHHHpYlOl UHA HHOpOn'lCCKHA KaK 1'0 Cl1Y'lH110Cb Ha cCBepe HKYTCKOA EHHcellcKoA H T060JIbcKoA ry6epHHA KY­ MblULI a flOA nocJIc IlHcli 1l0Apa3yMcBaeTcH CaMO llCJlbHal BO llKa KOTOpylO HC­ 12 nOKOH BeKOB BOTHKIl Bbl llCJIblBaJlH AJIH CBOHX peJlllfH0311b1X npa l llllecTB Jlo ROT lIeCKOl1bKO naHHblx 3aHIl B 1903 1' 06l Uee 4HCJIO H3naHIlI HUllC'laTaHllbIX B Ka­ 250 eBblllle Ha3BaHHll H 2 5 MJlH K3eMnl1l1pOB 110 BBenCHHll MOHOnOJIHH KYMblIllKa A06blBaJIaCb COBCPIllCHHO cB060AHO 3aTeM TarapcKHc KHHfIl ne'la1'atoTCH He B onHoA Ka3aHIl a H B fle1'ep6ypre OpeH6yp­ nOlllJIll rOHCHIlH KOTOPblC' C03 uaJlH COCTOHHHC IIcnpcpblBHol BOli Hbl MelKAY reo MocKBe TaIllKeHTe baKY H EaX'IHCapae KUTa f Orn KHHlKHblX JlaSOK 3U' aAMIlHHcTpaUHel II jJaHaTwlccKIl npe llaHHblMIl KYMbIIllKc BOTlI KaMIl 1111 KJlIO'IaIOT B ce60 KpoMe COTeH Ha3BaHHli no MycyJlbMaHcKol Y'lCHOC1'H KHHrH IllTpa jJbL HII TlOpbMbl lie oCJla61lJIIl KYMbIIllC'IHOJ'O m liIa BOTHKOB KOTOPblC no Ma1'CMaTHKC H H3HI UHbIM B noli 06l Ucll 60Pb6c npOHBHJlIl cKa3KH l HllepHHa op c YAHBHTCJlbllylO COJlllnapHOC1'b KYMbIIllKa HCKYCCTBaM 21 31'0 AO pOMaHbI 1905 nOBCeTH pacCKa3bl r C 1'ex nop nOl BHJlIlCb II no­ CTaJla n03ToMY rB03 1lCM afHTaUHH C KYMblIllKIl Ha'lllHaJl 06blKHOBCIIHO CBOIO JIHTIl'leCKHC ra3eTbi Bcex HUnpaBJlCHHit a B nOCJleAHCe BpeMH IIBHJlClI ucnblll pC4b afHTaTop II OT Hee KaK OT IlCXOAHOro nyHKTa 011 YBCPCHIIO IICPCXO llHJI pHn IllKOl1bHblX YlIc6HHKOB no 06l Ue06pa30BaTCJlbHbrM npe llMCTaM K caMoAcplKaBHIO cB060AC COBeCTIl Y4penHTt'JlbHOMY c06paHIlIO COUHaJlIl3a­ UIlH 3eMJlIl Y 4yBaillcll npll Beell IlX eOJlIl apHocTIl C COCeJ HIlM PyCCKIlM Ha­ ceJlCHHCM 6b1JI B HCKOTOPblX MeCTax cBoll 60Jlbll01l Bonpoc 13 IICKOTOpblM 'lH1'aTCJlllM MOlKCT IIOKa3aTbClI CTpaHHol caMa B03MOlK­ 1'0 cnopHblc JlY­ HOCTb rOBOpHTb 0 npOIllJIot 60Pb6e T3KIlX nJlCMCH KaK BOTlIKH MOPA­ rOBblC 3eMJIH KOTOPblC 'IYTb JlH HC npll rp03HOM 6blJlH HUCHJIbHO OTHHTbl Y Ba 6aIllKIlpbl H T A Ho 3TO nJlOA MaJlOrO 31laKOMCTBa C HCTOPIlCll POCCHH B IIHX H nepC IlUHbl PYCCKHM llcpccellCHuaM 11 BOT HCCMOTPH Ha nonyJlHpHOCTb nellCTBHTeJlbHOC1'1l 3a6b1T3l HblllC 60Pb6a JTHX IIJlCMCH 3a CBOIO B HX cpcnc HACH COUIlaJIH3aUIlH 3eMJlH HMH 6bIJI Bbl llBHHyT B 06l UCpYCCKYIO AYXOBHYIO arpapHYIO 11llaTQlOPMY nyliKT 0 Mil PYCCKOI IlCTOpHIl 4 restitutio statu quo ante C JlyroBblMIl 3CMl1H­ 3TO OllCHb XOpOIllO nOHIlMalOT nalKC 60JICC TOJlKOBLIC Hl MHCCHOIICpOB 14 OAHl HJ HHX llOKOllHblll l1J1bMHIICKHlI I'OBOpHT 'ITO no B3l'JlHAY llIaMaHCTBYlOl UHX HHOpOnUCB XPHl'TH lHCKall Bepa HHK TOT lKC IllaMaH MOl1HTBbl eCTb PYCCKaJl Bepa CBHI UCIl­ TC lKe IllaMallCKHC 3aKJlHHaHIll IIo noMY Illa­ BHCIllHIOIO H He3aBHCHMOCTb COCTUBJIlIeT OAHY 113 TpOraTeJlbHClllllHX CTpaHIlU Y Ka f MbIKOB 6bIJlO B 06b14ae nOCblJIaTb nellYTaUIlH KO BClIKOMY 1I0BO­ My MHHHC1'py BHYTPCHHIlX IleJl nJIH CMa3blBaHHH Kpecna no IlX Bbl­ palKeHHlO KOTOPOC B CBoe BpeMH IlMeJIO BCPOHTHO 3Ha'lCHHC HC jJHT'ypaJlbI OC HOCJlCAHHH TaKaR nenY1'aUlUI HMeJIa MCCTO npll B K flJleBC MaHCTBYlOl U le HHOP0 llUbl He OTPHl UIOT XPHCTIlUIlCTsa a TOllbKO npHlHalOT ero Bcpoll He c Joeu a PyccKoii n04cMY Bonpoc 06 06pal UCIIIlH orpaHllllHBacTclI - RIJJ AJIH HIlX IIcpeMcHoll napOOHOC1 U Ka3allcKaH 15 1887 3 4 XapaK1'cpHO OTHOIllelllle aAMHHHCTpaUll1l K nllM AenyTaUHHM B nOCJlCnHec BpeMH OAHO BPCMH HIIOPOAlICCKliM nenY1'aUHHM BOBce 3anpCI UU­ HCAypHO CKa3aHO I HT Y l Il'lCPH­ JlOCb npHC3lKaTb B IIC1'Cp6ypl' B caMblC nOCJICAllllC rOAM 6bIBa f H CJlY'Iall Kor­ HoA l1cxoAlI H3 noll BCPHOA HnCH aBTOp ce BHACJI O HIl 1'OJlbKO HCXOA na AenYTaTOB BblnBOpl JlIl H3 CTOJlHUbl 6ypH1' HJlH B03Bpal UaJlH YlKC C nopo­ UCH1'p Kpew -TarapcKaH llIKOl1U Ka3allb CTp nJIH npHBJIC4cHHH IlHOPOAUCB K xpHCTHaHCTSY IlMellHO HaUHOHUJJIl3HpOBaHHC fH HKYTOB HJlH AalKe nOnBCpraJIH CypOBblM penpCCCHl M nOCJlCAHCrO nyTeM ncpCBO ua CBHI UCHHOrO llHcaHHll fla HHOpOA'IeCKIlC H3bIKIl 'IeHHIO -- 3a TCJlcrpaMMbl B IleTcp6ypr CCbIJlKC H 3aTO­ 60rOCJlYlKCHHH lIa POAHOM H3blKe H LA T C npCBpal UCHIlH XPIlCTHUHCTBa B HaUHOHaJlbHYIO pCJlHl'll1O KalKAoli OTACJlbHoll Hap0 llHOCTH 16 bMl1a apHCTOKpaTHH H Y IlPyrHx Hapo llOB paCCMaTpHBaeMoll rpynnbl HanpHMep Y l llllepHHa op c •• CTp 266 28 H CJI TaT a p B JlHue nOMCCTHoro ABopHHCTBa HO B BH IlY nOTepH POAOBOI'O eTpOH H caMoynpaBJleHIll OHa HHKaKoll POJlH B Hau HOllaJIb­ 267 24 HoI lKH3HH He Hrpalla HH'leM He CB1I 3aHHaJI C HapOAOM BnpO'leM B OCB060­ lHTeJ1hHhll nepHOA AalKe Y noro OTlKHBlllerO B HaIlHOHaJ1hHOM OTHoweHHH KlIaCCa npOIlBRlIHCh HallHOHallhHhle CHMnaTHH B ilOBOJIlKhe npeA -'TaBHTeJlH TaTapCKoro ABOplI HCTBa npHHlIlIH lKHBoe Y'laCTHe B MycyJlhMaHCKHX C1 C3 X H H36HPaTeJ1hllOI arnTaIlHH TOJlhKO B KphlMy TaTapCKHC Myp3hl BMCCTe C CM HanpHMep npOTOKOllhl 3aceAaHHI 0611 ero Cbe3Aa 6YPliT HpKYT­ CKOI ry6epHHH nnll 06cYlKAeHHlI BonpocoB CBlI3aHHhIX C 3eMcKoti pe­ $OpMOI HpKYTCK 1905 r H3n HpKYT OTA 1905 r 2 CTp 171 H P reorp 0611 CCTBa Cpo TaKlKC CH6HpeK Bonp 25 MYlIlIaMH OCTallHCh COBeplllCHHO paBHOAYWHhlMH K HallHOHallhHhlM H HapOA­ CO'lIlHCKHC 6YPIlThI HanpHMep HexoAli H3 o611 e6ypllTcKoro Tpe6oBa­ HHII 0 npenOCTaBlIeHHH nJICMCHH H 0611lHHaM Bcex $aKTH'leCKH 06pa6a­ HhIM HHTepccaM TblBaeMhlX opynHIIMH II CKOTOM 3eMerrh C lIecaMH BOAaMH H HenpaMH H H3 17 ilpaBO 1905 r N NQ 4849 CT 0 TOM KaK pa3BHBallOCh npaBOC03­ HAeH 060611 eCTBrreHHlI Bcex Aen KaCalOIUJlXCli HYlKA H nOllh3hl Bcero HaCeJ1e­ HHII Tpe60BallH ' T06hI Bce npO J yKTbl CKOTOBOACTBa B oc06eHHOCTB KOlKa HaHHC Y 6YPll T 6blJlH o6pa6aThIBaeMhI BHYTpH caMol 0611 HHhl nOA BCAeHHeM OpraHOB caMO­ 18 B 3TOM ABHlKeHHH npHHlI JlO y'laCTHe AalKe TaKOC OTCTallOC nneMlI KaK 3hIpll He KOTophIe Ael CTBOBallH COBepweHHO COllH J apHO C MeCTHhIM ynpaBrreHHIl CH6 Bonp 26 nporpeCCHBHhIM KpeCThll HCTBOM BOJlOrOAcKoti ry6epHHH H B H36HpaTeJlhHYJO KaMnaHHIO nO 1 lleplKHBallH JleBhIX EAHHCTBeHHoe KalKeTClI HCKlIJO'leHHC CO­ CTaBJlIIJiH KapeJ1hI TBepcKoti ry6epHHH KOTOPhIe HeCMOTpli Ha cocenCTBO C nporpeCCHBHhIM PYCCKHM HaCeJleHHeM OCTallHCh COBepllleHHO HHAH$$epeHT­ HhIMH ilO-BHAHMOMY rJlaBHhIMH npH'lHHaMH nora cnYlKHJlH OTCYTCTBHe HH­ 27 NQ 2 1905 r CTp npOTOKOllhl op cit naparpa$ 171 29 3acrrYlKHBaeT TaKlKe 6blTh OTMe'leHHol nonhlTKa 061 CAHHCHHlI Mycyrrh­ MaHCKHX HapollHoCTel POCCHIl Ha 3KOHOMIl'leCKol nO'lBC nYTeM OT­ KpbITHH 6aHKOB B KpynHblx ueHTpax MycynbMaHCKol OCe J 1l0CTH TeJ1l1HrCHIlHH nOTepll BCIIKHX HCTOpH'leCKHX TpaAHllHti H nOJIHali 060c0611eH­ HOeTh OT BHeWHHx BlIHIIHHti 6J1arOAapll 113hIKOBOI H301lHPOBaHHOCTH 19 BbIJlH KOHe'lHO cpeAH HHOPOA'lCCKOrO AYXOBeHCTBa H peaKIlHOHHhIC 3J1eMeHThI Oc06eHHO OT1lH'lallHCh B 3TOM OTHoweHHH KphlMCKHe ro­ POACKHC MYlIlIhI npHcnYlKHHKH TaTapCKOro ABopllHCTBa AOBOAHBWHC CBOJO peaKIlHOHHYJO lIpOCTh AO HaCHJlhCTBeHHhIX CTOlIKHOBCHHti C HaCeJ1eHHeM CHM­ $eponOJlh KOHcepBaTHBHYJO POllh HrpallO AYXOBeHCTBO H B KallMblllKol CTC­ nH H3AaBHa AeplKaBwee PYKY ABopllHCTBa Ho B APyrnx MeCTax Ha BOJire cpeAH 6alllKHP cpeAH 6YPllT AYXOBeHCTBO KaK Mbl CKa3allH OKa3hIBallO nOA­ ACPlKKY H 'laCTO O'leHh CRlIhllYJO CBeTcKol HHTeJ1l1HreHUHH 20 TOllhKO KYlIhTypHoe MYCYJlhMaHCKOC HaCeJ1eHHe TYPKeCTaHa e1l e He onpaBHB1I eeCll OT BeKOBoro rHeTa a3HaTCKOrO necnOTH3Ma H nocnCA­ CTBHti 3aBOeBaHHlI JlHWeHHOe nOKa eBponeticKol HHTellnHreHIlHH OCTallOCh nO-BH J HMOMY Ge3 opraHH3auHH 21 o 6YAY1I eM COlO3a TpYAHO CKa3aTh 'lTO-JlH60 OnpeAelleHHOC YlKe H TC­ neph 3ananHH'leCKHC H KOCHhle meMCHThI BeAYT MelKAY COGolO myxyJO 60pbGy KnaccoBhIC npOTHBOpe'lHII HeH3GelKHo BhIcTynaIOT Ha clleHY MeCT­ HhIe HHTepeChI OTAeJ1hllhIX HapOAHocTel 6YAyT Ha BPCMlI oToABHraTh 06IUJ1e 22 nOApo6HOC'l'H CM OT'leT 0 cYAe6HOM 3aCeAaHHH no Aeny 0 ' IKYTCKOM COJ03e' B ra3eTe IKYTCKHti Kpati 1907 r N9N9 21-26 28 29-33 35 37 23 1910 268 nOAp06Hee 0 nocneAHHX ABYX HapOAHOCTllX CM CTaTLH BYpR'l'hI II KHprn3w B c60pHHKe llOPMhl HauHOHallhHOro J BHlKeHHll •• C il 269