DPHMEQAHHR Bela Pokol Tarsadalomtudomanyi Kozlemenyek 5IOmIeTeHl 06111eCT­ Ap'l llaOOUHZTOH 3KOJIorwmCKHE flPOBJ1EMbI BOCTO'IHOrO BJIOKA BeHHbIX HaYl 1985 r N9 1 crp 69 2 E Iet as Iroda 10m lKH3Hl H mrrepaTypa 1 HIOIDI 1983 r 3 Dr Bela Molnar Napszabadsag 16 Mal 1985 r llo He laBHerO BpeMeHH npo6JIeMa YXY1J lIIeHIDI OKp 'JICaromeii cpeAld pacCMaYpHBanaCb B KOMM 'HHC1lf1IecKOii J orMaTHKe K8I 1 e­ HOMeH IJHCTO KanHTaJIHC1lf1IecKHii KaK DpaBHJIO B Kallecme 1 aKTO­ POB Bb 3bmaroU HX 3KOJIOrHlleCKHe np06JIeMbI B MHpe COBeTCKHe H lleOJIom Ha3bmaJIH aHapxmo H HeKOHTpOJIHpyeMoe KanHTaJIHC1lf1Ie­ CKoe npoH3BO J CTBO noroHlO 3a npH6bIIDIMH H KOJIOHHaJIH3M 3Ta JIOrHKa npHBO u HJIa K 33KJ11 lJeHHIO 'ITO nOCKOJIbKY KanHTaJIH3M nopo K J 3 eT 3KOJIOrHlleCKHe npofiJIeMbI TO KanHTaJIHC1lf1IeCKHe CTpa­ RbI H J OJDKHbI HX YCTPaHJlTb COBeTCKHii 1 HJIOco 1 H T cI poJIOB m­ can no 3TOMy nOBO J y ''IIOCKOJIbKY 3KOJIOrHlleCKHH KpH3HC fIBJU eT­ CS nopO J eHHeM KanHTaJIHC1lf1IecKoro MHpa ADS yCYpaHeHIDI 3KOJIOrHllecKOii yrP03bI Heo6xO J HMO cymecTBeHHO nepecYpOHTb KanHTaJIHC1lf1IeCKyro CHCTeMY 06paTHbIii nepeBO J C aHm - Pe J • liTO l e KacaeTCS HeH36e I HocTH 3arpS3HeHIDI oKPYJlCaIOmeii Cpe J bI B KOMM 'HHC1lf1IeCKHX CYpaHax TO no MHeHHIO cI poJIosa B cYpa­ Hax r J e cymeCTByeT 06meCTBeHHaH co6cTBeHHOCTb Ha cpe J cTBa npoH3Bo J CTBa YXY1J lIIeHHe oKPYJlCaIOmeii cpeAld MO l eT 6bITb TOJIb­ KO cnyqaiiHbIM lIBJIeHHeM 06paTHbIH nepeBo J C aHrJI - O J HH Pe J lJexocnoBa ru HH KOMMeHTaTOp J oroBOpHJICS J O TOro 'ITO 3Ko­ JIOrHlleCKHX npo6JIeM B cYpaHe npOCTO He cymeCTBOBanO 6M eCJIH 6b B lIeXOCJIOBaKHH He COXpaHHJIHCb J O CHX nop aHTHCODHaJIHCTH­ lIeCKHe 3JIeMeHTbI 1 Bce 3TO He OlJeHb y6e J HTeJIbHO ADS HaCeJIeHIDI COBeTCKoro COI03a Hero KOMM 'HHCTHlJeCKHX coce J eii nOCKOJIbKY 3KOJIOrHlle­ 96 97 CKHe ''lmIuf n eHTbl'' C XO Il oM BpeMeHH 6blCTPO HaK8IIJIHBaIOTCB B03MO I BOCTBMH KOHYpOJUl cnycKaeMblMH H3 ueHYpa nnaHaMH H HCHo 'lITO PaI HOHaJIbHoe MapKCHcTcKoe IIJIaHHPOBaHHe CnpaBJUleTCB OTcyrCTBHeM npeADPHHHMaTeJThCKOH CB060AbI AOll l eH 6blIl 6bl CO enO l HbJM KOMIIJIeKCOM 3KOnOIWIeCKHX npo6neM nOpoxmeHHblX KalanOCb pemaTb np06neMbl OKPY'KaIOllleH CpeAbI ropalAO 3q q eK­ mmyCYpHanH3aI HeH HHKaK He nytIllle qeM auapxuqecKHii KanHTa­ THBHee nH3M EenH 6bl KOMM 'HHcmqecKHe npaBHTellbCTBa ny6nHKOBanH PblHOqHI IM CHnaM qeM CHCTeMa AaIOlllaB 3HaqHTellbHO 60nblDe CBo60AbI TOquMe CTaTHCTHqecKHe AaHHble 0 3apa lKeHHH B03Ayxa H 3arpRlHe­ H3 OIIbITa Coe o HHeHHblX IIhaToB cneAYeT 'lITO 3q q eKTHBHaB HHH BOAbl 06HaPY'fGUIOCb 6bl 'lITO B 3TOH 06nacTH CTpaHbl KOM­ 3aIUHTa OKPY'KaIOllleH CpeAbI Tpe6yeT nOCTOBHHoro H l aneKO HAyme­ MYHHCmqeCKOrO narepB AOrHanH H p 8 Ke neperHaJIH AeMOKpa­ ro BMemaTellbCTBa rOCYAipCTBa B 06nacTb qaCTHoro npeADpHHHMa­ mqeCKHH MHp Bblp DICeHHe KPH3HC OKPY'KaIOllleH CpeAbI CJIHIIlKOM qaCTO TenbCTBa rAe pelIleHWI Aonroe BpeMS npHHHManHCb 6eCKOHYpOllb­ HO Ho aKTHBHOCTb KOMMYHHCmqecKoro rOCYAapCTBa B pelIleHHH ynOYpe6nBeMoe H Y'Ke AeBallbBHpOBaHHOe B COe o HHeHHbIX IIlTaTax npo6neM 3KOnOrHtleCKOrO KpH3Hca He MeT nOKa HH B KaKOe CPaB­ OqeHb TOquO OIIHCblBaeT HblHelllHIOIO CHl 'an HIO B npOMbmmeHHO HeHHe C ero BeAymeH pOllbIO B TaKHX Bonpocax KaK CK DICeM PalBHTbIX CTpauax BOCTOquOH EBPOObl H B npOMbmmeHHblX paiiOHax npeAOTBp3llleHHe COBeTCKoro COI03a CnOBO KPH3HC HaqaflO p 8 Ke npoHHKaTb B IIpHHUHn UeHTpanH30BaHHOrO ynpaBneHWI 06llleCTBOM npHMTbIH BOCCTaHOBneHWI KanHTanHCTOB KaK Knacca oq HUHanbHblH KOMM 'HHCmqecKHii B3blK XOTB npHBeAeHHble Bbnne BCeMH UHTaTbl B3BTbl H3 HeAaBHHX ny6nHKauuH OHH He HnH Bbl­ P DICaBCb Toquee nepeCTanH 6blTb IMH AJUI KOMMYHHCTH­ 'lITO rocYAipCTBO pelIlano TaKHe OCHOBOnODaraIOIUHe np06neMbl KaK KOMM 'HHCmqecKHMH rOCYAapCTBaMH npHBen K TOM ' Mecra palMellleHWI 3aBOAOB npeo6naAaHHe rft l enOH HnH nerKOH qeCKOH neqaTH B KOMMYHHCTuqeCKHX CTpaHax oco6eHHo B npo­ npoMbmmeHHOCTH ynop Ha HCnOJIb30BaHHe yrJUl Heq TH HnH arOM­ MbmmeHHO PalBHTblX - HOH 3HeprHH Il aJKe BOnpoc rAe pa3pelIlaercB B IIOllblIle BOCTOquOH fepMaHHH H qexo­ I HTb nOAI aHHbIM ­ enOBaKHH BHHMaHHe cpeACTB MaCCOBOH HHq OpMaUHH CTana npHBne­ pelIlanCB rOCYAipcTBOM IIPH 3TOM yTBep l AaflOCb 'lITO Bce 3T0 KaTb TaKaB Mpaquaa H HexapaKTepHaB npexme TeMa KaK HaABHraIO­ AenaerCB B HHrepecax HapoAi lllaBCB 3KOnOrHtlecKaB KaTaeypoq a nO-BHAHMOM ' 'llT06bl 06llleCT­ IIpo6neMa 3aIUHm OKPY'KaIOllleH CpeAbI 6bllla nQAHBra Ha 3a­ BeHHOCTb He paccquTbIBana Ha cymeCTBeHHbIe YnytIllleHHB B 0603pH­ naAe KOMMYJlHCmqeCKHe nnauoBHKH nonyqunH no KpaiiHeH Mepe MOM 6YAYllleM Een HecOMHeHHaB HpoHHB CYJlb6bI B TOM 'lITO KOMMYHHCTH­ HHH C KOrOpblMH CTonKHynHCb HX MeonOIWIeCKHe npoTHBHHKH qecKHii MHp OKalanCB B KPH3HCHOM nOnO JKeHHH MaPKca KaK npeA­ Mepbl He 6bmH npHHBThI H 3T0 Henbla 06' gCHHTb TOJIbKO rynOCTbIO CTaBHTeJUI XIX CTOneTHB AeCBTb neT 'IIr06bl npHMTb Mepbl J llB npeAOTBpallleHHB ocno I He­ Hellb3B BHHHTb 'lITO OH He npeAYCMOTpeD oq HUHanbHOH Meononm BeAb nOKa KOMMYJlHCmqeCKHe nponaraH­ KaKYIO ueHy npuneTCB IIJIaTHIb 3a HHAYCYpHaJIH3aUHIO npUPOAf blMH AHcm nOXBananucb 'lITO COUHanH3M 06naAaeT BHyYpeHHHMH npeH­ peCypCaMH - BOlAYXOM peKaMH H necaMH HeCMOTpB Ha HeCKpbma­ MymeCTBaMH n03BonBIOIUHMH H36e JKaTb 3KonOIWIeCKOH KaraCTpo­ eMoe npe3peHHe MapKca K naCTOpallbHOH 3THKe AOCTaTOquo BcnOM­ q bl yqeHble 3KOHOMHCTbI pa60THHKH nnaHOBOrO annapara COllHa­ HHTb ero H3AeBaTellbCKOe 3aMeqaHHe 06 HAHOTH3Me AepeBeHCKOH nHCmqeCKHX crpaH BCHO OC03HanH 'lITO 3KonoIWIecKHe 6eACTBM l H3HH MO I HO npeACTaBHTb KaKHMH pa306naquTenbHblMH THpa­ yrpo JKaIOr COllHinHcmqeCKHM CTpaHaM He B MeHbIUeH Mepe eM aMH pa3pa3HJICB 6bl OH B aApec 6YP JKYa3HH eCJIH 6bl OH IIHcan KaIIHranHCmqecKHM ''Te3HcbI 0 np06neMax 3arpB3HeHM OKpY'KaIOllleH cpeAbI B03­ Ho Ha npeAynpexmaroIUHe CurHaJlbl C 3an8A3 He 06paTHnH BP3lllaBCb K TeMe eneAyeT YKa3aTb 'IlTO MapKCH3M Bcema npoTH­ HHKaKOrO BHHMaHHB 3r0 TeM 60nee CTPaHHO 'lITO HaH60nee cepbe3­ BonOCTaBn1lJI PaI HOHanH3M H ryMaHHOCTb ueHTpanH30BaHHOH nna­ Hble 3KonoIWIecKHe npo6neMbi B03HHKl1H B COBeTcKoM COI03e H HOBOH 3KOHOMHKH 6e30TBeTCTBeHHOH eCKOH H HenpoH3BO­ cYpaHax BocroquoH EBponbl B AHTellbHOH npHpoAe KanHTanH3Ma TeopemqeCKH KOMMYlIH3M C ero Ai pacl 'IUaB 06ecnoKoeHHOCTb 06llleCTBeHHOCTH 3aCTaBHna 3anaA­ 98 70-e H 8O-e rOAbI T e B nepHOA Kor­ 99 lIble npaBHTeJIbCTBa HaqaTh IIIHpOKHe H AOpOrOCTOHIUHe npOrpaMMbI no 3aIUHTe OKp ' KaIOmeii cpeAbI 'ITO Bbl3BaJIO B CTPaHax HanpHMep B 3ana l H0ii repMaHHH 3HallHTeJIblIble nepeMelIbl B nOJIHTHlIecKoii HanpHMep B CeBepHoii qexHH O lKH l aeMaH cpeAHHH npOAOJI lKHTeJIb­ 10 JIeT HH lKe a AeTCKaH CMepTHOCTh Ha 15% BblIIIe 06meHauHOHaJIbHOrO ypOBHH HOCTh lKH3HH l 1H M ' KlIHH Ha O iJHUHaJIbHaH peaKUHH Ha 6blCTPO YXYAIDaIOmeecH nOJIO lKeHHe KYJIbTYPe B03bMeM B KaqeCTBe npHMepa IIoJIbmy CorrraCHO o iJHUHaJIb­ HOii KJIaccH iJHK3 UHH BO l Hble peCypCbl CTpaHbl 6bIJIH paJAeJIelIbl no HX KaqeCTBY Ha qeThlpe KaTeropHH B nepBYJO 6bIJIH BKJTIOqelIbl BO­ Abl rOiJ Hble l 1H nOTpe6JIeHHH HaCeJIeHHeM BOAbI KJIaCcH iJHI HpoBaH­ Hble KaK qeTBepTaH KaTeropHH 6bIJIH npH3HaHbl HerOAHblMH l a Ke l 1H npOMbIIIIJIeHHbIX ueJIeii IIo AaHHblM OAHoro HCCJIeAOBaHHH KOJIM­ qeCTBO peK BXOAHmHX B nepBYJO KaTeropHIO YMeHbWHJIOCb C no 1977 rOA C C 22% AO 10% 1967 Eme 60JIee TpeBO l Jf 'ITO lIHCJIO peK qeTBepToii KaTerOpHH BOAbI KOTOPblX He MOryT 6blTb HCnOJIb30Ba­ lIbl Bo06me YBeJIHlIHJIOCb C 1977 no 1980 rOA C 32% AO 48% CTOJIb lKe cepbe3Hble np06JIeMbl B03HHKJIH B BOCTOllHOii rep­ BapbHpyeT OT CTPaHbl K cTPaHe KaK 06mee npaBHJIo KOMMYHHCTH­ qeCKHe npaBHTeJIbCTBa KOTopble tIyBCTBYJOT ce6H HaH60JIee yCTOii ­ qHBbIMH nOJIMTHlIeCKH paJpeIIlaIOT 60JIee oTKpoBeHHym AHCKYCCHIO o np06JIeMax OKpY lKaIOmeii cpeAbl a TaK lKe npHHHMaIOT HaH60JIee aKTHBlIble Mepbl IIo noii npHllHHe AHCKYCCHH Ha 3TH TeMbl B COBeT­ CKOM COlO3e cB060AHee qeM B CTPaHax BOCTOllHOii EBPOIThI 3a HC­ KJTIOqeHHeM IOrocJIaBHH H B03MO lKH0 BeHrpHH Ho H B COBeTCKOM COlO3e cepbe3lIble CTaTbH ny6JIHKYJOTCH B CneUHaJIbHblX lKypHaJIax C BeCbMa OrpaHHlleHHoii UHpKYJIHUHeii qTO lKe KaCaeTCH ra3eTbl IIpaBAa TO TaM no-npe lKHeMY npe06JIa l aIOT n06e l Hble napTHii m le peJ HUHH BnpOqeM B cOBeTcKoii neqaTH nOHBJIHIOTCH HHorAa co06­ MaHHH H qexOCJIOBaKHH B CeBepHoii qeXHH H3-3a 3arpH3HeHHH B03­ meHHH 06 OTOMbHblX 3DH30Aax - l yXa nepHoAHlleCKH 06'bHBJIHIOT COCTOHHHe TPeBorH KOr l a AeTeii 06 yrp03e Ha l BHralOmeii cH Ha KaKHe-TO BHAbI lKHBOTHbIX 06 ony­ 06 oTPaBJIeHHH KaKoii -To peKH He BbInyCKaIOT Ha ymruy a BpallH AOJI l HbI 6blTh HarOTOBe l 1H OKa­ CTOIIleHHH JIeCOB B KaKOM-TO panoHe TaKHe ny6JIHKauHH HHOr l a 3aHHH CPOllHOii Me l Hl HHCKoii nOMOmH TeM KTO nocTPa l aJI OT CMO­ BKJTIOqaIOT l a Ke pe3KYJO KpHTHKY a l MHHHCTpaUHH 3aBO l a HJIH MeCT­ HbIX 6lOpoKpaToB nOBHHHbIX B 3arpH3HeHHH OKpY lKaIOmeii CpeAbI 2 ra B HeKOTopbIX panoHax CeBepHoii qeXHH rAe B03AYX oc06eHHo Ho KOHellHO H B COBeTcKoM COlO3e cBo60Aa 06CY lK l eHHH 3arpH3HeH pa60llHM C AeCHTHJIeTHHM CTa lKeM BblDJIallHBaIOT cne­ UHaJIbHOe noc06He qT06bl B03MeCTHTb 'lUep6 3AOPOBbIO Bb13BaH­ lIblii l bIMOM HenpecTaHHO Bbl6paCblBaeMbIM Tpy6aMH 3JIeKTpo­ CTaHUHH pa60TaIOmHX Ha 6ypOM yrJIe KpoMe Toro BJIaCTH npHHHJIH CneUHaJIbHble Mepbl 'lT06bl npeAynpeAHTb MHI'pauHIO pa60llHX nOCKOJIbKY 06pa6aThlBaIOmaH H A06blBaIOmaH npoMbIIIIJIeHHOCTh 3Toro panOHa ClIHTaeTCH lKH3HeHHO Ba lKHOii AJIH 3KOHOMHKH CTpaHbl KpHTHlIeCKOrO COCTOHHHH AOCTHrJIO H 3arpH3HeHHe BOAbI B IIpare OAHOM H3 CaMbIX KYJIbTYPlIbIX ropOAOB EBPOIThI ABe Tpe­ TH KaHaJIH3aUHOHHbIX HellHCTOT 6e3 BCHKOii nepepa60TKH c6paCbI­ BaeTCH B BO l bI BJITaBbl a B CTOJIHUe CJIOBaKHH BpaTHcJIaBe OTXOAbI Bo06me He nepepa6aThIBaIOTCH B HeKOTopblX panoHax qexOCJIOBa­ KHH KaK B CTPaHax TpeTherO MHpa HBJIHeTCH Tenepb 06H3aTeJIblIb1M ynoTpe6JIeHHe ollHmeHHoii BO l bI Pa3JIHTOii B 6YTbWKH PaJAaIOTCH TaK lKe Tpe60BaHHH qT06f OqHmeHHaH BOAa H3 6yTI IJIOK ynOTPe6rrH­ JIaCb H AJIH lIHCTKH 3y60B Pe3KHii POCT 3arpH3HeHHH OKp ' KaIOmeii cpeAbI Bbl3BaJI B npoMbllIDIeHHbIX panoHax BOCTOllHoii EBPOIThI 3HallHTeJIbHOe YXYAIlleHHe nOKa3aTeJIeii 3AOPOBbH HaCeJIeHHH TaK 100 3KOJIOrHlleCKHX npo6JIeM KaK BnpOqeM H Bcex APyrHX BeCbMa OrpaHHlleHa HHKOMY paJYMeeTCH He pa3peIIlaT Aa lKe KOCBeHHO nOAHHTb BOnpOC 'ITO AJIH npeAynpe lK l eHHH 3KOJIOrHllecKoii KaTa­ CTPO iJbl He06xo l HMO CHH3HTb TeMIIbI 3KOHOMHlleCKOrO pOCTa 3Ta HAeH paCCMaTpHBaeTCH COBeTcKoii HAeOJIOrHeii KaK KaJIHTaJIHC­ THlIeCKHH 3arOBOp AJIH BocnpeDHTCTBOBaHHH PaJBHTHIO 6e l Hblx CTPaH TPeThero MHpa COBeTCKaH neqaTh nOCBHTHJIa HeMaJIO CHJI AOKaJaTeJIbCTBaM HeCOCTOHTeJIbHOCTH TeopHH PHMcKoro Krry6a 0 He06xo l HMoCTH OrpaHHlleHHH 3KOHOMHlleCKOrO pOCTa PaJYMeeTCH no AeJIaeTCH He H3 COCTPa l aHHH K HHIUHM HapOAaM A3HH H A iJpH­ KH - COBeTCKHH COI03 60JIbille APyrHX cnoc06CTBOBaJI HX 06HHma­ HHIO HaBH3aB HM nopollHYJO 3KOHOMHlIeCKYJO MOAeJIb - HO B ro­ PaJAO 60JIbIIleii CTeneHH ID-3a Toro 'ITO ero c06CTBeHHble rpa lK l aHe Bce 60JIbille paJOqapOBblBaIOTCH KaK B KOHuenUHH 3KOHOMHlIeCKoro pOCTa TaK H B npeHM 'lUeCTBax ropOACKoro 06pa3a lKH3HH OTBeTCTBeHHble 3a Bblpa60TKY O iJHUHaJIbHOii COBeTcKoii JIM­ HHH OKaJaJIHCb B YCJIOBHHX 3KOJIOrHlleCKoro KpH3HCa nepeA cepb­ 101 e3HOH lHJIeMMOH ComaCHO TparomuOHHOH n03u nHH COBeTCKaJI Ho B BOCTO'IHOH EBpone cpe cTBa nOTpa'leHHbIe Ha 06opoHY MOIItb B CO'leyaHHH C MapKCHCTCKHM pau noHanH3MOM Moryr cnpa­ BOCnpHHHMaIOTCB BHTbCB co BceMH npo6neMaMH BnpO'leM B nOcne o Hee BpeMH OKKynan uOHHOH apMHH y ep iKHBaTbCB B 3THX CTpaHaX BnacTH He KaK 06eCne'leHHe BOSMO iKHOCTH HMnepcKoii oco6eHHO nocne npHXOAa K BnaCTH rOp6a'leBa XBaCTllHBbm TOH Moryr 60nbIIIe 06pamaTbcB K naTpHOTH'leCKHM qyBCTBaM Hacene­ 3aMemO noy6aBHllCB COBeTCKHX mo eH CTaJIH OCBe OMllB Tb pea­ HHH a 3aTaCKaHHaa OrMa 'ITO npH'lHHOH Beex KOMMYHHCTH'lecKHX l1HCTH'IHee 'Iero HM l J aTb OT 6Y ll 'Inero Heyna'll HBnB eTCB KanHTaJIHSM aBHO Y iKe yrpaTHlla npHTB raTellb­ OCHOBHaJI Tpy o HOCTb J l1B KOMMYHHCTH'lecKOH npOnaraH J bI - HOCTb HY iKHbl HOBble KOHIJ enD HH H HOBaa aprYMeHTaIlWI HaRTH 06bB CHeHHe nO'leMY 3KOnOrH'leCKHe np06neMbl BpSJ l1H 6y J yT pa3peIIIeHbI B 0603PHMOM 6Y ll 'IneM HaH60nee y6e J HTenb­ HbIM 6bll1 6bl KOHe'IHO Te3HC 'ITO peIIIeHHe 3KonOrJiflleCKHX npo6­ neM HeH36e iKHO 3aMe J l1HT 3KOHOMH'leCKuH pOCT K MeHTY O o HaKO KaJI nponaraH J a HeB03MO iKHO npH6erHYTb rO bl B nepHO npaBl1eHHB repeKa Bnacm npHIIIllH K no BeeM PyrHM np06neMaM npe CTaBnB ey cepbesHyro yrpo3Y H 6e3 Toro HeYCToii'llHBoH nonHTH'lecKoii CTa6HllbHOCTH EbIl1a BBe e­ nO iKepTBOBaTb Ha iKeCTKaJI H Bce06beMlllOmaJI n eHsypa 3arpB SHeHHe B03 yxa H BO bI HenpurO o HOCTb npO OBOnbCTBIUI J l1B nOTpe6neHIUI nocne ­ HecoBMeCTHMYW caMY H J eJO COBeTC­ 7O-e BbIBO y 'ITO OTKPbITaJI J HCKYCCIUI no BOnpOCaM 3KOnOrHH KaK H 3KOHOMH'lecKHM POCTOM pa o H peIIIeHIUI 3KOnOrH'leCKHX np06neM KaK Bcer a OTBeprana 3TOMY apry­ nOCKonbKY HaH6Ol1ee pa D HKallbHOe peIIIeHHe npo6neMbi Haii J eHO B lIonb­ IIIe B C neHHHCKHM TeopeTH'leCKHM HaClle HeM BMeCTO 3Toro B KpeMlle H306peJIH OBOnbHO CTpaHHyIO aprYMeHTa­ CTBIUI nmpOKoro npHMeHeHIUI neCTHD H J OB - Bce 3TH TeMbi npOCTO nepecTanH OCBemaTbCB Ha CTPaHHlIax nOllbCKOH ne'lam Koma B 1tHlO comaCHO KOTOPOH B YXy J IIIeHHH OKPY iKaIOmeH cpe J bl B CO­ 1977 u nanHCTH'IeCKHX CTpaHax nOBHHeH KaIIHTaJIH3M 3Ta CTpaHHaa norH­ n eH3ype 3TOT OKYMeHT 6bIl1 TaHHO BblBeseH HS 1I0llbIIIH Bbmc­ Ka CTpOHTCB cne lYIOlIJ HM 06pa30M npaBB maa KaIIHTaJIHCTH'IecKaa HHllOCb 'lITO BnaCTH J aJIH YKa3aHHe npHKpbITb B nepByro o'lepe b 3l1HTa HaMepeHHO sa D ep iKHBana POCCHIO Ha CTa D HH cpeo J aJIbHOrO mo6ble J HCKYCCHH CBB 3aHH Ie C npo6neMaMH OKpY iKaIOmeii cpe­ 3aCTOB B lHY Um TeM CaMbIM 6ollbIIIeBHKoB nocne npHXO a K Bnac­ bI 3 UeH30paM B 'IacmocTH npe J llHCbmanocb ''3anpelqaTb Itl06ble TH npOBeCTH sa HecKOllbKO ecB THl1eTHii yCKopeHH 'lO HH J ycTpHaJIH­ MaTepufLflbl cooepJlCillque uHgJ0pMaijUIO 0 CTeneHU 3azpR3HeHWf oKpyxalOlqeU cpeobl a TaKxe 0 pacrylqeM 3aepR3HeHuu nOllbCKUX peK 6ePYlqUX HallfLflO e 'lexocllOeaKuu npou30zueozueM e pe3Yllb' TaTe OtRTe tlbHOCTU npOMbllUlleHHblX npeonpWfTUU e 3TOU CTpaHe ' 3aumo SaHB BIIIylO B KaIIHTaJIHCTH'IeCKHX CTPaHax HeCKOllbKO CTone­ THH IIITYPMOBaa HH J ycTpHaJIH3aIlW1 HMena KOHe'IHO HeH36e iKHbIe H Cepbe3HeiiIIIHe H3 ep KKH B TOM 'DIClle H 3KOnorH'leCKyro erpa­ A aumo Kor a COBeTCKHH Cro3 06HllCB HaKOHen BbI J aIOlD HXCB 3KOHOMHlreCKHX ycnexoB OCTH iKeHHIO nOllHoro KOMMYHH3Ma H 3KOnOrH'leCKOrO 6narO eHCTBIUI yrp0 iKaeT HOBaa OnaCHOCTb Bce­ MHpHblii HMllepHaJIH3M nO CTpeKaeMblH Coe J HHeHHbIMH IIITaTaMH pa3BB 3an 6ecnpen e elfTHYlO rOHKY BoopY KeHHii B KOMMY­ r Ha 3ana D e 6bIl1H ony6nHKOBaHbi llHpeKTHBHble YKa3aHHB BOT npHMep CBB SaHH IH C KOHKpeTHblM 3llH30 OM 06­ HapYJlCeHO liTO MaTepUfLfl ucnOllb30eaHHbiU OIlR U30llRijUU OKOH e ZUKOlle NOSO e FoaHbCKe COOepJICUT epeoHble eelqeCTea 3aHRTWI e ZUKOlle npUOCTaHoelleHbl CTpoxauzue 3anpelqaeTCR ny61lUKOeaTb KaKUe-llu60 MaTepufLflbl 06 3TOM ' HHCTH'leCKHe CTpaHbI nepeKmo'lHTb pecypCbI CTOllb He06xo J HMble IIpHBe eHHbIe CPaKTbI OTHIO b He HBnB lOTCB HCKJllO'IeHHeM J l1B pa3BHTHB nOTpe6HTellbCKOro ceKTopa H peIIIeHIUI 3KOnOrH'le­ MHorO'IHCneHHbIe MaTepHallbI nocrynaBlIlHe B pe J aKD HH nO J Bepra­ CKHX np06neM Ha npOH3BO CTBO paKeT H 6oM6 llHCb iKeCTKOii n eHsype HllH BOBce sanpemaJIHCb M 3TO B cTpaHe H ri eB 'ITO 3KOnOrH'leCKuH nporpecc Ol1 iKeH Ha'DlHaTbCB C e­ KOTOPaJI B paMKax COBeTCKoro 6noKa C'lHTanaCb HaH60nee l1H6e­ MOHTa iKa paKeT B EBpone H OTKa3a OT CTpaTerH'leCKOii 060poHHOH PaJIbHOii Mbi MO iKeM npe J llonO KHTb 'lITO MHOrHe CTaTbH KOTopble HHHIJ HaTHBbI COM HeCOMHeHHO 6y eT cO'lyBCTBeHHO BCTpe'leHa B Ha 3ana D e 6bll1H 6bI ony6l1HKOBaHbI B 06bl'1HOM nopS' J Ke a iKe He COBeTcKoM COlOse r e BOeHHaJI MOIItb H HMllepCKaJI 3KCnaHCIUI 6blnH AaBHO Y iKe nOHHMaIOTCB KaK 3KBHBaneHT 3KOHOMH'leCKorO pocTa BeprIIIHMH ee6B CaMOn eHsype HanHCaHbI BOCTO'lHo-eBponeHCKHMH iKypHanHCTaMH no · 102 103 l 'PHaJIHCTbI 'IeCKHMH crpaHaMH H Kpe J HTOB norryqeHHblx Y HHX lKe K 'IeMy KOM­ Bo06IUe OTKaJaJIHCb OT 60pb6bI KaKaH-TO HH4 0PMaIJ HJI K ny6JIHKe HeID 3J1 CKa3aTb MYHHCTH'IeCKHe CTpaHbI 0 rex nop He peWaJIHCb npH6eraTb TIo­ npOCallHBaeTCJI Ho lITO BOCTOllHO-eBponeHCKHe eCJIH ueH3ypa npOnYCKaeT lITO-TO TO JIHllIb Ma­ CKOJIbKY B OCHOBe CTpaTerHH repeKa JIe lKaJIa nponaraH J a ycnexa TepHaJIbI HanHCaHHble B 06lIJ HX ryMaHHbIX H pa3YMeeTCJI OnTHMH­ peWaIOIIJ HM OKaJaJICJI nCHXOJIOm'leCKHH 4 aKTOp 3TO npHBeJIO K Cl'H'IeCKHX TOHax OTCeHBaH CTaTbH nOCBJlIUeHHble KOHKpeTHbIM CO­ HeCKOH'laeMoMy nOToKY XBaCTJIHBbIX cTaTeif 0 ocTH lKeHHJIX HOB oro 6bITHJIM a TaK lKe TaKHe H3 KOTOPbIX BH UIO lITO B03HHKmyro np06­ Kypca H K HeH36e lKHOMY YCTpaHeHHlO H3 ne'laTH Bcero lITO Morno JIeMy He JIerKO paJpeIIlHTb B pe3YID TaTe MHoroe 0 'IeM npeA 'II­ nOCeJlTb COMHeHHJI cpe J H nOJIJlKOB H Y HHOCTPaHHbIX BKJIa J 'lHKOB pe lKAaJIH yqeHble TaK H He 6bmo Ony6JIHKOBaHO 0 HeueJIeco06paJ­ HOCTH paJMeIUeHHJI npOMbmmeHHbIX npennpHJITHH B paifOHax C He OCTaTOllHbIM BO OCHa6 lKeHHeM MaTepHaID I 0 Pa3YMeeTCJI 6bmH YCTpaHeHbl mo6ble ynOMHHaHHJI 0 3aMe J JIemm 4 3KOHOMH'leCKOrO pOCTa H3-3a 3KOJIOrH'leCKHX npo6rreM 3arpJl3HeHHH 3aMaJI'lHBaHHe 3KOJIOrH'leCKHX np06JIeM B ne'laTH pyrnx BaJITHHCKOro MOPJl 0 BbIMHpaHHH JIeCOB H3-3a 3arpJl3HeHHJI B03 Y­ CTpaH COBlTCKoro 6rroKa He 6bmo CTOJIb nOJIHbIM HanpoTHB B 04 H­ xa 06 YBeJIH'lHBWeMCJI co ep lKaHHH ll1lT B pbI6e BbmaBJIHBaeMOH IJ HaJIbHbIX B nOJIbCKHX BO ax He 6bIJIH Ony6JIHKOBaHbI J a I e peKOMeHAan HH C BHr ECJIH B npOWJIOM 06IUeCTBeHHOCTb 3aBepJIJIH lITO 3KOJIOrH­ o KOHKpeTHbIX Mepax no 60Pb6e C 3arpJl3HeHHeM OKpY lKaIOIUeH CpeAbI BblcrynrreHHJIX Ha6mo aeTCJI OBOID HO mo60nbITHbIH 'IeCKOH KaTaCTpo4 bI MO lKHO H36e lKaTb npO J YMaHHO H CBoeBpeMeH­ HO npHMeHJIJI COIJ HaJIHCTH'IeCKHe npHHIJ HDbI TO B nOCJIe J Hee BpeMJI UeH3ypHble npeADHcaHHJI B nepHO npaBJIeHHJI repeKa He JIH­ 3a'laCl '1O MO lKHO YCJIbIWaTb HOTKH neCCHMH3Ma H 6eccHJIHJI TIepHo­ weHbI H3BeCTHOH JIOmKH repeK nO J HJIJICJI Ha BepIIIHHY BJIaCTH H3­ J H'IeCKH KJIeHMJlT KaK BHHOBHHKOB OT eJIbHbIX PYKoBOAHTerreH OARR 3a Hecnoc06HOCTH npe lKHero PYKOBO CTBa 3aJIaTaTb AblpbI B nOID ­ ynpeKaH HX B 6e3 eJlTeID HOCTH CKOH 3KOHOMHKe lITO BbI3BaJIO BOJIHY pa60'IHX BOJIHeHHH repeK 'ITO BCJI 6e a OT He J HCUHDJIHHHpOBaHHOCTH H 6e3paJJIH'IHJI TIo 'IeWCKHH H J eOJIor 3aHBHJI nOHJIJI lITO 6YAYIUee KOMMYHHCl'H'IeCKOrO pe lKHMa B TIOID we KaK MHeHHlO pyroro 'IeWCKOro o4 HUHaID HOrO npe CTaBHTeJIJl pa3­ Hero c06cTBeHHoe 3aBHCHT OT Toro CMO lKeT JIH HOBoe PYKOBO CT­ peweHHe 3KOJIOm'leCKHX np06JIeM 3aBHCHT OT ycnexa H J eOJIOrH­ BO 06ecne'IHTb 6b1CTpble TeMDbI pOCTa Ho B OTJIH'lHe OT CTaJIHHCKOH 'IeCKOH pa60TbI HeCKOID KO HHyIO n03HIJ HIO 3aHJIJIH B BOCTOllHOH 3noXH KOr a pa60'IHX H KpeCTbJIH B HHTepecax npOMbmmeHHoro repMaHHH TaM DbITaIOTCJI OTBJIe'lb BHHMaHHe 06IUeCTBeHHOCTH OT PaJBHTHJI npHHY lK J aJIH pa60TaTb TJI I eJIee a nOTpe6JIJ1Tb MeHbwe np06JIeMbI repeKY npHWJIOCb paCWHpJITb npOMbIWJIeHH 'lO 6aJY H O J HOBpeMeH­ 06'bJlCHJIJI HanpHMep BblpO ll eHHe JIecOB BCJlKOrO po a BTopocTe­ HO y J OBJIeTBOpJITb HaCTOH'IHBble Tpe60BaHHJI HaCeJIeHHJI YBeJIH'lHTb neHHbIMH npH'lHHaMH TJI I eJIblMH cHerona J aMH 6ypJlMH nrrOXHM nOCTaBKY npO OBOID CTBHJI aBTOM06HJIeH H TeJIeBH30pOB • IlrrH OCY­ JIeCoHa J 30POM H a lKe BpeAHbIMH HaCeKOMbIMH npoMbmmeHHoro 3arpJl3HeHHJI OKpY lKaIOIUeH cpeAbI IUeCTBJIeHHJI 3TOH BOHHOH 3a J a'IH repeK pewHJICJI 4 HHaHCHpOBaTb HeT HY lK J bI rOBopHTb lITO HHKaKHe He3aBHCHMble J BH lKeHHJI 3KOHOMH'leCKOe pa3BHTHe CTpaHbI 3a C'IeT TOprOBJIH C KanHTaJIHCTH­ BblcrynaIOIIJ He 3a COXpaHeHHe OKpY lKaIOIUeH CpeAbI He paJpeweHbI B KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKHX CTPaHax a K nO 06HbIM J BH lKeHHJIM Ha 3a­ KaTacTpo l a Ha 'IepH06bmbcKol aToMHol meKTpOCTaHUHH npH­ Bena K C03p aHHIO HaUHOHanbHol rpynnDI AHTH-aToM B 'IexocnoBa­ KHH 110cKonbKY 3aIUHTa oKpYlKaIOIUel cpep DI 6ecnOKOHT npep CTa­ BHTenel Bcex cnoeB HaceneHHH BnaCTb HMYIUHe BeCbMa HanyraHDI aKTHBHOCTbIO rpynnDI 3aHHMaIOIUel cH 3KOnOrH'IeCKHMH BonpocaMH 110 cnOBaM '1elIICKOro p HCCHp eHTa CTaHHcnaBa Manoro TaKHe rpyn­ nDI B cnHCKe HaH60nee onaCHDIX p nH npaBHTenbCTBa CTOHT Ha BHP ­ HOM MeCTe - 3a p BHlKeHHeM Monop DIX KaTOnHKOB US News World Report Dec 8 1986 p 45 - Pep 104 na J e KOMMYHHCl'H'IeCKHe BJIaCTH OTHOCJlTCJI C 60ID WOH OCTOPO lK­ HOCTbIO 3TO nO TBep ll aeT 'ITO KOMMYHHCl'H'IeCKaH 3JIHTa C'lHTaeT 3KOJIOrH'leCKHe np06JIeMbI nOTeHIJ HaJIbHO BeCbMa OnaCHbIMH MO lK­ HO 6bmo 6bI O l H J aTb lITO KpeMJIb 6e30roBopollHO nOMep lKHT B Ka­ DHTaJIHCTH'leCKOM MHpe 6opuoB C KanHTaJIH3MOM C ero aHTHrY­ MaHH3MOM H 6e3 yxoBHOCTbIO 3ana J a COBeTCKaH ne'laTb 060WJIa nOllTH nOJIHbIM MOJI'laHHeM 3n100 Ha TpeXMHJIbHoM oCTpoBe O J HaKO HHIJ HAeHT B a J eID 4 HH KOr a norH6JIo HeCKOID KO lOS yqaCTHHKOB o BIDKeHHJI MYB npaB J a 'He TOObKO He 060lWIa H 'lJexOCJIOBaKHH - CTpaH HcropWleCKH CBJl3aHHbIX C 3ana J OM MOJ1lIaHHeM HO npo J OJDKaJIa pa306JIatUlTb rOHeHIDI Ha HerpOB eme HaceneHHe 3THX crpaH CKJIOHHO OTO l J ecTBJJJlTh KOMMYHH3M C HHO­ MHoro MecJlUeB CnyCTJI KpeMJIb npOJIBHJJ 60JIbruyIO OCTOpO I HOCTh crpaHHOH HMnepHeH 60JIee oTcTanoH - 3KOHOMIDleCKH H KyJIbTYPHO H no OTHOmeHHlO K 3ana J HOrepMaHCKHM 3eJIeHI IM HeCMOTpJl Ha Tor J a KaK B ou eHKe l H3HeHHOro YPOBHJI B paClIeT npHHHMaeTCJI HX HpKO BblpIDKeHH 'lO HeHTpanHCTCKyro n03H C O J HOH CTOpO­ He COBeTCKHH COI03 a ABcrPKJI 3ana J HaJI fepMaHKJI lllBeu HJI H HbI npH3HaIOT lITO MaCCOBbIe o BH I eHKJI B 3am Hl ' OKp ' KaIOmeH J pyrne npO BeraIOIIl He CTpaHbI EBponbl cpe J b1 MOryr 6blTh BIDKHbIM nOJIO I HTeJIbHbIM l aKTopoM B KJIaCCO­ KaK HH napa J OKCaJIbHO B ymep I J eHHH lITO B 3KOJIOrWIe­ BOH 60Pb6e H B 60Pb6e C MOHOnOJIIUlMH Ho C J pyroH CTOpOHbl CKHX 6e J CTBHJlx Bce 60JIbme 3aXBaTbmaIOm HX BoCTOllHyro EBPOny TaKHe o BH I eHHJI paCCMaTpHBaIOT KaK HeHa J e l HbIX COI03HHKOB noBHHeH KanHTanH3M eCTh J OJIJI HCTHHbI C nepBhIX nOCJIeBOOHHhlX l bJl nnaTli opMa CO J ep I HT KaK nporpeCCHBHble TaK H peaKIijiOH­ JIeT Kor J a B pa3pymeHHoH BOiiHoH BocrOllHOH EBpone ymep l J 3­ Hble B3rJIJl 1lbI 061 e J HHJIJI npOreCThI npOTHB MOHOnOJIHH C anOJIH11l'I­ JIOCb KOMMYHHCTHlIecKOO npaBJIeHHe 3KOHOMWIeCKHe ycnexH KanH­ HbIMH a HHor J a H aHTHKOMMYHHCTHlIeCKHMH u errJlMH TanHC11l'IeCKHX CTpaH 6bIJIH J ecTa6HJJH3HpyroIIl HM l aKTopoM no­ KaK 06blllHO HMeJl J eJIO C nOTeHIJ HanbHO OnaCHbIMH 06meCT­ croJIHHo HanOMHHaJI 0 Hecnoc06HOCTH KOMMYHHC11l'IeCKOH CHCTeMbI B eHHbIMH mmeHHJlMH KOMMYHHCThI IlbITaIOTCJI KOHTpOJIHpOBaTb H K 3KOHOMWIecKOMY copeBHOBaHHIO C 3ana J OM npaKTHlIeCKH no HanpaBJIJlTh HX B Hy lKHoe pycno a He nO J aBJIJITh OTKPblTO 03a60QeH­ 03HaqanO lITO TOJIbKO npu YCKOpeHHOM 3KOHOMIDleCKOM pa3BHTHH HOCTh rpa I J aH yxy J meHHeM OKp ' KaIOmeH CPe J bI B 60JIbmHHcTBe KOMMYHHC11l'IeCKHe CTpaHbI He 6Y J y yseJIHllHBaTh OTCTaBaHII e OT KOMMyHHC11l'IeCKHX CTpaH nO J napTHHHOH 3f'HJJ OH C03 J aHbI opra­ HH3aIUiH 3a J atUl KOTOPbIX - 3aHHMaTbCJI np06JIeMaMH OKp ' KaIOmeH xapaKTepHble nJIJI 6Q x H 70-x rO J OB He pemHJJH np06JIeMY no­ 3ana J a Ho H nOBblmeHHbIe reMnbI pOCTa COIijiaJIHCTHqeCKHX CTPau cpe J bI Ho napTHJI HanpaBJIJleT HX aKTMBHOCTh Ha TaKHe 6e306H J Hhle CKOJIbKY YCKopeHHbIH 3KOHOMHQeCKHH POCT npHBeJI K 6YPHOMY aKIUiH KaK nOCa J Ka J epeBbeB HJJH KaMnaHHH no y60pKe MYcopa Ha J o OTMeTHTh O J IlaKO litO o l HIijianbHbIM opraHH 3 aIUiJIM no 3am H­ pocry norpe6HTeJIbCKOrO cnpoca B TO l e BpeMJI TynHK B KOTOPhIH 3amna COBeTCKaJI 3KOHOMHlIeCKaJI MO J eJIb BbI3Ban 3a nOCJIe J HHe Te OKp ' KaIOmeii cpe J bI npe J OCTaBJIeHbI OTHOCHTeJJbHO mHpOKH e JIJlTh JIeT CHIl I eHHe l H3HeHHOro ypOBHJI KOHellHO eCJIH 6b1 KOMMY­ B 3MO I HOCTH 3HallHTenbHO 60JIee mHpOKHe qeM HanpHMep BCe­ HH3M paCnpOCTPaHKJICJI Ha BeCb MHP He06xo J HMOCTb B copeBHO­ B03MO l HbIM KOMHTeTaM B 3am Hl ' MHpa HJJH nO J KynneHHbIM BaHIIH C KanHTanHCTHQecKoH CHCTeMoH omana 6bI HO nOCKOJIbKY Ha BOCTOKe nO-BH J HMO­ TaKOH HCXO J npe J cTaBJJJlerCJI ManOB epOJlTHbIM KOMMYHHCTHQeC­ MY UIH ycnex 3eneHbIX H KOMMyHHCTHlIeCKHe B1IaCTH pemHJJH KHM cTpauaM OCraBanOCb JIHillb nO l epTBOBaTh pemeHHeM 3KOJIOm­ lfIO npaBHlThHO J 03HpOBauuyIO nOpIijiIO npOTeCTOB no nOBO J y yxy J ­ lIecKHX npo6neM B nOJIb3y 3KOHOMHQecKoro pOCTa KOMMYHHCTaMH u ePKOBHhlM HepapXHJIM meHKJI OKp ' KaIOmeH cpe J bI cne J yeT pa3pemHTb lIT06bI npe J OTBpa­ 3TO J OKTpHHanbHoe l epTBonpHHomeHHe CTaBHT KOMMYHHC­ THTb HenO J KOHTpoJIbHble BbIcTynJIeHIDl KorophIe MOryr noc»y I HTh THlIeCKHe CrpaHbI B Qpe3BbltUlHHO CJIO I Hoe nOJIO l eHHe oc06eHHO B 6YAYIIl eM OCHOBOH nJIJI nOJIHTHlIeCKOH onn03HIJ HH fJIaBHhlM npenJlTCTBHeM ynyqweHHJI OKp ' KaIOmeH Cpe J bI B B CBJl3H C TeM litO B HHX J o CHX nop npeo6JIa J aIOT TexHOJIOrWIe­ CKH YCTapeBmHe orpaCJIH nOTpe6JIJIIOIIl He B KaQecTBe 3HepreTIDleCKO­ KOMMYHHCTHqeCKHX CTPaHax JlBJIJleTCJI 3awe J maJI B tynHK COBeT­ ro ChIPbJl 6ypbIH yrOJIb - CKaJI 3KOHOMHlIeCKaJI MO J eJIb Bo BceH BOCTOllHOH EBpone H B He­ 3KOJIOrWIecKOH TOllKH 3peHKJI K TOMY l e 3KOHOMHlIeCKaJI CHCTe­ CKOJIbKO MeHbmeH CTeneHH TOnJIHBO HaH60JIee pe3pymHTeJIbHOe C B COBeTCKOM COI03e Cra6HJJbHOCTb Ma KOMMYHHCTHlIeCKHX CTpaH conpOTHBJJJleTCJI nepeMeHaM B Coo­ KOMMYHHCTHlIeCKOH CHCTeMbI Bcer J a CBJl3bmanH C 3KOHOMHlIeCKHM J HHeHHbIx IIIUTax 3KOJIOmQeCKHH nporpecc 6bIJI J OCTHrHyr He POCTOM H nOJIHOH 3aHJlrOCTbIO KaK rJIaBHbIMH cpe J CTBaMH 06ecne­ TOJIbKO B pe3YJIbTaTe 60JIee l ecTKoro 3aKOHO J aTeJIbCTBa 3KOHOMH­ lIHBaIOIUHMH JIOJIJIbHOCTb HaCeneHHJI 3KOHOMHqeCKHH POCT oc06eH­ Ka - HO BIDKeH nJIJI npaBHTeJIeH nOJIbmH BeHrpHH BOCTOllHOH fepMaHHH 6bICTpO nepeCTpaHBaTbCJI B COOTBeTCTBHH C TeXHOJIOrWIecKHM npo­ 106 BBHAY OTKPbITOCTH 06mecTBa - OKa3anaCh B COCTOJIHHH 107 rpeCCOM 3TO He 3Ha'IHT qrO KOMM 'HHCnflleCKHe CrpaHbI Boo6w e He cnOC06H1 I K MO J epHH3alUlH HeJTh3J1 3a6bIBaTb qrO B CCCP npo­ llpe lK J e Bcero J ecJlTHJleTHJI KOMM 'HHCnfllecKoro npaBlleHHJI OyYliH­ H3BO rvtTCJI MHorne BHAbI HaH60llee pa3pyrmrreJThHOrO OpY'fGIJl Ho 31'0 pa3YMeetCJI B ropa3 J O 60llbweH creneHH nOllHTH'leCKaJI He lKellH MOKpanflleCKHX CTpaH B TOM 'lHClle HeCOMHeHHO H B COe J HHeHHI 1X llH 06w ecmeHHOCTb OT OTKPblTOH J HCKYCCHH B 60JThwHHcme J e­ TeXHOllornqecKaJI npoooeMa OnblT COe J HHeHHl IX IIITaTOB nOKa3bI­ IIITaTax 3KOllOrH'l eCKaJI 3THKa CTaJla 06J13aTeJThHl IM 3lleMeHTOM BaeT 'lITO 3noxa nOCTHHJl YCTpHaJlbHOH 3KOHOMHKH nopO lK J aet ne­ 06w ecmeHHoro llblH PJl J 60lle3HeHHl IX H J eCTPYKTHBHbIX nponeCCOB - nOBbIWeHHe nponecc ew e He HaqanCJI XOT fI MapKCHCTCKaJI nponaraH l a He YCTa­ C03HaHHJI B KOMM 'HHCTH IeCKHX cTpaHax 3TOT YPOBHJI 6e3pa60TH bI J erpananmo crapblX npOMbIWlleHHl IX neHT­ e nOBTOpJlTb qrO '''HeT TaKHX KpenOCTeH KOTOPblX 6b1 He B3J1llH pOB C J bIMJlIIJ HMH npe rm PHJITHJlMH J eKBaJlHil HKa H1O MHJlJlHOHOB 60JThWeBHKH HaCeJlemt e CTpaH peallbHoro COIJ HaJlH3Ma OTllH1lHO 3aH fITbIX B OT lKHBaIOIIJ HX OTpaCllJlx 3TH nponeccbI C03 J aIOT Cepbe3­ nOHHMaeT qrO B J eHCTlIlTeJThHOCTH J JIJI Hero BPJl J llH B03MO lKH0 Hble np06lleMbI J JIJI JlI060H nOllHTH'l eCKOH CHCTeMbI HO B ew e 60llb­ qrO-llHOO BblXOWImee 3a paMKH Y J OBllemOpeHHJI OCHOBHbIX lKH3­ weH CTeneHH OHH onaCHbI J JIJI Tex pe lKHMOB KOTopble OCHOBbmaIOT CBOIO llerHTHMHOCTb Ha npe J OCTaBlleHHH YBepeHHOCTH B 3aBTpaUIHeM gHe B TaKHX CTpaHax KaK llOllbllia J a lKe YBellHqeHHe neH Ha BeT'l H­ BY CB fI3aHO C nOllHTH'l eCKHM pHCKOM Ho H B COBeTcKoM COlO3e nOBblweHHe neH Ha npO J YKTbI 60llee lKecTKHe HOPMbl BbIpa60TKH npHBO J HlIH yX e He pa3 K OTKpbITbIM 6ecnOpJI J KaM He Y J HBHTellbHO n03ToMY qrO KOMMYHHCTHqeCKHe pe lKHMbI 60JITc fI Pa IJ HKaJThHbIX nepeMeH KOTopbIe npHBellH 6b1 HeCOMHeHHO K nOllO lKHTellbHl IM J OllfOCPO'l HbIM pe3YJThTaTaM KaK J JIJI 3KOHOMHKH TaK H B J elle 3a­ IIJ HTbI OKPyX aIOw eH Cpe J bI BOJITcJI nOToMy qrO B KpaTKOCPO'l HOM llJlaHe 3TO nOCTaBHT no J yrp03Y Bce06wyro 3aHJ1TOCTb HaCelleHH fI B 6JlH lKaHWeM 6ynyw eM MO lKHO O lKH J aTb TOJThKO YXy D IIIeHH fI 3KOllOrH'l ecKOH np06lleMaTHKH llOCKOllbKY COBeTcKHH COlO3 no­ CTOmmo nOBblwaeT neHbl Ha He t Tb 3HepreTHKa CTpaH BoCTO'l HOH HeHHblX nOTpe6HOCTeH Bllacm lKaJlYIOTC fI Ha anaTHIO H 6e3pa3llH'lHe oc06eHHO cpe J H MOllO J e lKH Ho HMeHHO 3TH Ka'l ecTlII Bcer J a H8Ca lK­ J 8Jla KOMM 'HHCTH IeCKaJI CHCTeMa cpe J H OCHOBHOH MaCCbI HaCelle­ HHJI BCllbWIKH nOJlH HqeCKOH aKTHBHOCTH HanpaBlleHHOH Ha llH6e­ p aJIH3a HIO pe lKHMa npOHCXO J HJlH H B BOCTOllHOH fepMaHHH H B BeHrpHH H B lJexoCllOBaKHH a· B lloJThwe J a lKe HecKOJThKO pa3 Bee OHH 6bIllH nO lJ mmeHbl HeY J HBHTeJThHo qrO HacelleHHe cTpaH cOBeTcKoH HMnepHH CKenTHqeCKH OTHOCHTCJI K B03MO lKHOCTH ''nepeMeH H3HYTPH B KOMM 'HHCTH IeCKHX CTpaHax ecTb H y6e lK­ J eHHble KOHcePBa HOHHCTbI H J a lKe BeCbMa PanHKaJThHble 60p bI npoTHB IlpHHeceHHJI OKPY lKaIOw eH CPe J bl B lKepmy 3KOHOMlf1leCKO­ My pocry Ho 3KOllOrH'l ecKHe peil oPMbl cTaHYT B03MO lKHbI TOJTh­ KO Kor J a KyqKa aKTHB a TOB 6Y J et nO J' 1lep lKaHa IlIHPOKOH 06w ecT­ BeHHOCTbIO fuIHe TaKOH nO J' 1lep lKKH HeT H B nOMHHe a ny6llHKe no­ EBPOllbI Bce B 60JThWeH CTeneHH 6Y J eT 3aBHCeTb OT nOTpe6lleHHJI npe lKHeMY B J aJl6llHBaIOT qrO HY lKH0 ew e HeCKOJThKO lKepmeHHbIX 6yporo yrllJl XOTJI 3KOllOrH'l eCKHe CTaH l apTbI 6bIllH nOBbIWeHl I lleT - 3TO He conpoBO lK J aJlOCb YCHlleHHeM Tpe60BaHHH HX C06JlIO J eHHJI HeHHO B0306HOBHTC fI YBellH'l eHHe mrpail oB - H Mapw K KOMM 'HH3My C ero nOllHblM H306HllHeM HecOM­ MaJlO3 l il eKTHBHbIH HHCTpyMeHT B 60Pb6e C 3arp fl3HeHHeM OKPyX aIOw eii cpe J bI 3aBo J aM MeHee BblrOgHO YCTaHaBllHlII Tb O'l HCTHTellbHble YCTpoHcma qeM llJlaTHTb OTHOCH­ TellbHO He60llbWHe mrpail bI J JIJI norameHHJI KOTOPbIX Ha MHornx llpe rm PH fITH fIX COJ J aHbI CneIJ HaJThHl Ie il OH J bI Ew e O J HHM cnoco­ 60M 060HTH npo6lleMy 1IBJlJleTC fI IlIHPOKO pa3peKllaMHpOBaHHaJI npaKTHKa nOCa J OK J bIMOCTOHKHX J epeBbeB Haca lK J aeMbIX BMeCTO llecOB norn6WHX B pe3YJThTaTe C lKHraHHJI yrll fl Ha npOMbIWlleHHl IX npe rm pHJITH fIX KOHellHO HY lKH0 yqHTbmaTb H nCHXOllOrnqeCKHe il aKTOpbI 108 109 CHf 1 nPHME1fAHHH np06neMa YXYAilleHHH OKpYlKlllO ell cpeAbI B KOMM 'HHCTIflleCKOM MHpe C He I8BHero BpeMeHH CTaJIa npHBneKaTh BHHMaHHe 3ana IUlldX yqeHldx H lKYPHanHCTOB HaH60nee HHTepecHlde pa60Tld - KHHra Ue Eapnene6eH OKPYlKlIIO aH cpena H MapKCH3M-neHHHH3M H CTlIThH KPHCTHH 3BoceK YxYAilleHHe OKpYlKlllO ell cpe J ld B BOCTO'IHOII EBpone none3HbIil MaTepHlin MOlKHO Hail TH TaKlKe B HccnenOBa­ TenbCKHX 6lOnneTeHHx H3 I8BaeMIdX 1'aJ r H0 CB060 J HlIJI EB pona l'aJ r Ho CBo60na 1 2 3KOnOfHQECKORTPEBOfH OTHOWeHHe norrbCKHX BrracTeH K 3KorromlleCKHM npo6rre­ MaM Bblpa l eHO rr03yHroM lJerroBeK - X03HHH npHpoAbl 3TOT 06muif npHHWIII HeooMHeHHO OTpaJHJICH BO Bpa l l e6HOCTH BrraCTeH KO BCHKOH He3aBHCHMOH HHH aTHBe HanpaBrreHHOH Ha npell oT­ B eHHe npH6rrH l alO eHCH 3KOJIOrH'leCKOH KaTaCTpocpbI XOTH 3KOrrOrH'leCKaH HHCPOPM B IIorrbwe 3aceKpelleHa TeM He MeHee Korna B 1983 rony Ha YKpaHHe npOpBlinO naM6y H TId­ CH'IH TOHH OTpaBneHHolI BOnld npoHHKnH B BOnld peK - co06 eHHe 06 JTOII 3KOnOmqeCKoII KaTllCTpO pe He nOHBnHnOCb B ne1JllTH weCTh J aHHble Henenb Hau60rree nocTpa J aBlIIHe panOHbI - 3 CM The Black Book of Polish Censorship nepeBOn H penaKUIDl Jane Leftwich Curry H3n-BO Vintage 4 CnpaBennHBOCTh Tpe6yeT OTMeTHTh QTO B nonxone nOnbCKHX BnaCTeIl K 3KOnOmQeCKHM npo6neMaM co BpeMeH repeKa HaMemnCH H3Becr­ HIdiI nporpecc O o HHM H3 BalKHldX no60'IH1dX pe3YnbTllTOB 3noXH COnK­ napHOCTH 61dn0 nOHBneHHe nOnbCKOrO 3KOnOmQeCKoro Kny6a He3aBHCHMoII OPraHH3BUHH eCTByJO ell H nOHldHe He MeHee BlIlKHldM C06ldTHeM 61dnl1 ny6nHKaIJ HH OTQeTll nOjU'OTOBneHHoro nom ­ CKOII AKaneMHell 06 eCTBeHHldx HayK cornaCHO KOTOPOMY nonOlKeHHe C 3arpH3HeHHeM OKpYlKlllO ell cpe J ld B nonbWe xYlKe QeM B nJ06011 npyroll CTpaHe MHpa ComaCHo JTOMy OTQeTy TPeTb HaceneHHH cTpaHld lKHBeT Ha rpaHH 3KOnOmQeCKoII KaTllCTpOq Id KOTOPbIMH MbI pacnorraraeM nOKaJbIBaIOT trrO TpeTb HacerreHHH CTpaHbI l HBeT B panOHax ' Ke nOpa l eHHbIX 3KorrorH­ llecKoH KaTaCTpoCPOH HJIH HaXO J H XCH nOll yrP030H KanCTpocpbl npoMbIWJIeHHbIH panOH BepXHeH KpaKOB Hero OKpeCTHOCTH CHJIe3HH npH6pe l Hble BO J bI BaJITuHCKOrO MOpH f J aHbCKuH 3arrHB npoMbIWJIeHHbIH panOH ne a TaK I e npoMbIWJIeHHbIH KOMnJIeKC BapWaBbI He HMeH B03MO I HOCTH oxapaKTepH30BaTb Bce 3TH panOHbI MbI OCTaHOBHMCH nOll po6Hee Ha npo6rreMax HHAYCTpHaJIbHOrO panOHa BepXHeH CHJIe­ 3HH B KOTOpOM OKpy I aIO aH cpell a H YCllOBHH 06HTaHHH rrlOll eH HaXO J HTCH B 00060 onaCHOM nOrrO l eHHH Ha npoB 1O KaTOBHu e 3aHHMaIO yro IIorrbIIIH npHXoAHTCH 3arpH3HeHHH 60% 30% 2 1% om eMa 3MHCCHH nbIJIH 3arpHmeHHH TeppHTOpHH 40% npoMblWJIeHHbIMH ra30Boro OTXOll aMH 1984 r KorrHlleCTBO nbIJIH Ha 1 KB KM 1l 0CTHfJIO B 3TOM paHoHe 75 2 T a raJa - 300 8 T Ha 40% 3arpH3HeHHe TeppHTopHH paHOHa B BbI3BaHO pa60ToH WaxT B 3a6p l e THnHllHOM ropoll e 3TOH npoBHH­ H MaCKHMaJIbHO 1l 0nyCTHMbIH ypoBeHb 3arpH3HeHHH 24 nOJIJIIO­ TaHTa 1 ' Ke npeBbIWeH CpeAHerOll oBoe llHCllO Cll 1lleB rrelleHHH Joan DeBardeleben The Environment and Marxism-Leninism H3n-BO Westview Christine Zvosec Environmental Deterioration in Eastern Europe Survey Winter B nOrrHKJIHHHKax H 6orrbHHU ax B 3a6p l e npH HacerreHHH llerrOBeK 1l 0CTHfrro 2 5 30 200 TbIC TbIC ll eTeH 3a60rreBaIOT Bocnarre­ 1984 1 24 3arpH3HHIO HX 110 MJIH areHTa 111