IbiaHhI 3KOHOMHllecKoro pa3BHllUI nOJIbCKOH HapoAHOH pee ny6JIHKH COCTaBJIeHbI TaK no HX BbIDOJIHeHHe HeH36e I H0 BbI30BeT AWIbHeHIIIHH poCT COAep'Ka HW ll BYOKHCH cepbI B aTMocq epe no paC'IeTaM yqeHbIx 6eCX03 IIHCTBeHIWI 3KcrmyaTaIJ HJI npHpoAHhIX peCYpCOB npHBeAeT K HX HCTOIlleHHIO B TelleHHe 3KOJIorHlleCKoH TpeBorn npo3ByqaJI B 20·30 JIeT 6JIH'KaHweM CHrRan 6YAYIUeM 3pUKa Kaoll eijoaa HaWll CTpaHa MO'KeT npeBpaTHTbCJI B He06HTaeMYIO nyCTbIHlO rpynna nOll bCKUX 3KOII Oeoa o I1PHlIHHAX nOBldIJIEHHOrO HHTEPECA K PEJIHfmt B noene D Hee BpeMJI tJaCTO 06CYX AaIOT npH'lHHhI nOBbIll IeHHOrO HHTepeca K peJIHrHH 3TO JlBJIeHHe THnH'lHO He TOJIbKO J TIJI qexo enOBaKHH OHO KacaeTCJI He TOJIbKO KaTOJIHIIH3Ma HJIH XpHCTHaHCT· Ba llocTaTo'IHo BCnOMHHTh YCHJIeHHe POJIH HenaMa KaK cPaKTOpa ooo eARHJIIOIllerO PJlA ll BH'KeHHH H HapoAOB A3HH H AcPPHKH KOTo phIe B HenaMe HIllYT B03MO I HOCTh caMoonpeAeJIHThCJI H CTpeMJIT' CJI HaHTH c06crneHHhIH ITyYb nOA 3HaMeHeM HenaMa qTO KacaeTCJI qexoenOBaKHH TO He06xoARMbI OOJIee KOHKpeT· HbIe AaHHbIe AeHCTBHTeJIhHO JIH HMeeT MeCTO aKTHBH3aI1 HJ1 HHTepe ca K peJIHrHH H eenH lTO TaK TO KaKOBa ee CTeneHh B 'IeM ee npH' 'IHHbI H KaKHMH MOryY 6hITb noeneACTBHJI TaKOH aKTHBH3 060CHOBaHHbIH Y OTBeT Ha lTOT BOnpoc l aTh HeB03MO I H0 HaC HeAOCTaTO'IHO CBeAeHHH 0 pa3BHTHH peJIHrH03HOCTH n03To MY JI npoCTO 0606IllaIO Ha6JIIOAeHHJI H BhICKa3bIBa HW Ha lTY TeMY JIIOAeH C MaPKCHCTCKHM MHPOB033peHHeM OKa3anOCh no caM Bonpoc 06 aKTHBH3al lDf HHTepeca K pe JIHrHH JlBJIJleTCJI J TIJI HUX cnopHbIM MHeHHJI no 3TOMY nOBOAY pel KO OTJIHtmJIHCb B laBHCHMOCTH OT CpeAhI B KOTOPOH npoBOAHJIHCb Ha6JIIOAeHHJI KapTHHY HCKa'KaJI K TOMY 'Ke orpaHHlleHHhIH JIH'lHbIH onbIT Ka'KAOrO HaMIO l aTeJIJI H ero Ap CKHe CBJl3H BenH HCXO' ARTh H3 3aKOHa OOJIhIIIHX 'lHCeJI TO B MacwTa6ax CTpaHbI C ll BHr B CTOPOHy peJIHrn03HOCTH npeACTaBJIJleTCJI He3Ha'IHTeJIhHbIM eKo pee pellh MAeT 0 np06YAHBWeHCJI AYXOBHOH aKTHBHOCTH HeKoTopbIX 114 l1S rpynn 3TO ilBJIeHHe He cnen yeT OWIaKO Hep oo eHHBan nOTOMy' epKOBHbIX lITO rpynnhI 3TH BeChMa aKTHBHbI H cnoc06HbI OK3 3aTb eephe3HOe T e KaK cnop HaYKH C peJIHrHeR BJIWUlHe B 6yn y eM O l HaKO orpaHHllHBaIO X CBOOOn y HCCJIeAOBaHHJI KaK KpHTHKa npoTHBopellHii Me lKn y TeOpHeii H npaKTHKoii - cnen yeT npH3HaTb lITO K peJIHrHH AorM CTaJIH OTHOCHThCJI eepW3Hee H peJIHrH03HOCTb BbIllllla 3a paMKH XpHCmaHCKOrO 06 eCTBa KpHTHKa JIH eMepHoii MOPaJIH npHKphI rpynn KOTophle MOXQIO H3 3BaTb OTCTaJIblMH HJlH Haxo MHCJI Ha BaIO eRCJI xpHCTHaaCKHM yqeHHeM nepHq epHH 06 ecTBa Bonee Toro rOBOpJl 06 YCHJleHHH peJIHrn03 IIepHOA KPHHOJIHHOB H napHKOB He 6bIJI HAHJll1HeR H ecJIH HOCTH no JlBJIeHHe AIDKe He CBJl3bm3lOT C 3THMH rpynnaMH Hacene O eHHBaTb HHJI llllTepec K peJIHrn03Hoii H epKoBHoR JKH3HH npoJlBJIJleTCJI HOCTeH JIIOAeii H xapaKTepa OTHoweHHii Me lKn y ynpaBJlJIIO B OOJIbWeR CTeneHH B ropoAax B oc06eHHOCTH B IIpare cpe u H HH H ynpaBJIJleMbIMH TO OlleBHAHO lITO CO lKaJleTb 0 HeM HelJero Ho C TeMeKTYaJIOB H MOJIOAe KH IJ eHTpanbHblM BonpoCOM HameR u HCKyCCHH 6bmH npullUHbl peJIHrHH lIpe3BbIlIaHHO c eCTBeHHOR qepTOR lToro nepHO J a 6bIJIa O KHBJIeHHJI HHTepeca K peJIHrHH CYMMHpYJI OTBeTbI cnen yeT HCK Bepa B 6y ee XapaKTepHbIM JIIOtUfTb caMyIO rny60KyIO H c ecTBeHHYID DJIOCKOCTb B KOTOPOii ro BpeMeHH 6bID 'ODTHMH3M ysepeHHOCTb B co6CTBeHHbIX CHJlax q opMHpyeTCJI 3TOT HHTepec H ero no KpHTepHJIM HbIHewaero ypoBHJI KH3HH B03MO lK TOtfKH 3peHHJI KOTOpaJl HHTepecyeT Hac ceii lIaC T e C TOtfKH 3peHHJI AJlJI eBponeHCKoro MbIllllleHHJI TO HMeIO B BHAY TaKHe MOTHBhI KaK Bepa B qeJIOBeKa nporpecc pa3YM HaYKY B B03MOXQIOCTb ClIaCTbJI nOTpe6HocTb lIeJIOBeKa B a6COJlIOTHbIX HenOKOJIe6HMbIX eHHOCTJlX u rrJl Beex IIpH BeeR 6eAHOCTH TOro BpeMeHH 6bIJlO pa u H qero KHTb co anbHbIx B nepHoA nOHCKOB CMbIcna KH3HH HJlH Toro lITO J aHHbIii lIeJIOBeK Ha lITO HaAeJlTbCJI uma JIH pellb 0 CMbIcnOM KH3HH ClIHTaeT CTpeMJIeHHe npHAaTb CMbIcn H caMOMy' D BH lKeHHJIX 06 lKOHOMHqeCKHX npoeKTax HJlH 0 HayqHhIx H TeXHH YCHJlHJI MH3epHOMY c eCTBOBaHHIO npeOAOJIeTb COCTOJIHHe YHH lKeHHOCTH qeCKHX OTKPbImJIX Ao eHHoii HeCnpaBeAJIHBOCTH npeoAOJIeBaTb npenJlTCTBHJI Ha MelITa 0 cnpaBe J lIHBOCTH H B03 Me3AHH OOJIe3HH H 6ecnOMO HOCTb YTpaTa OOH3KHX H KOHD eHTpH TeJIbHbIe poBaHHbIii npoTeCT npOTHB CMepTH KaK JlBJIeHHJI KOTopoe CBO u HT H 3anpeTbI repJIJIH CHJlY Ha HeT - npHlleM OKOHllaTeJIbHO 6e3ycnOBHO H a6cyp l H0 CTpeMJIeHHJI lKepTBbI H eHHOCTH npHc e lIeJIOBeKY••• AJlJI Beex H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX He Ka3aJIHCb HanpaCHbIMH H YAaBanOCb nym K nOCTaBJIeHHOH eJIH O6JI3a caHK OHHpoBaHHbIe epKOBbIO u HpeKTHBbI B caMbIX pa3JlHlIHbIX perHOHaX MHpa pa3py Bee WaJIHCb q eoAaJIbHbIe KOJIOHHaJIbHbIe KanHTaJIHCTHlIeCKHe 06 eCT ECJlH Ba H K BJIaCTH npHXOAHllH o6e aBwae ocyweCTBHTb npHH DbI CBO HCKJIIOlIHTb Bora HaRTH Ha Bee lTO YAOBJIeTBOpHTeJIhHbIH OTBeT He OOADI paBeHCTBa H 6paTCTBa BJIaCTb HapoAa peBOJIIO IO npoJIeTa B03MOXQIO pHeB Beex CTpaa nOJIO KHTb KOHe rocnoACTBy 6eJIbIX HaYKa npeA MbI a6CTparnpyeMCJI OT lToro caMoro rnYOOKoro cnOJl CTaBHJla CBoe BHAeHHe MHpa Hero pa3BHTHlI HaYllHoe n03HaHHe DOTOMy' lITO TaKOR cnOR BcerAa 6bIJI H 6YAeT 3TO BellHhIH Bonpoc npHHecno orpoMHbIe npaKTHlIeCKHe ycneXH nOJIHOCTbIO H3MeHHB no BellHbIii BhI30B a nOTOMY OH He MO lKeT aenocpeACTBeHHO BJIHJlTb npe lK8Hii T OHHbIii CTHJlb KH3HH Beex cnoeB HaeeJIeHHJI Ha poCT HJlH ynaAOK peJIHrn03Horo C03HaHHJI O KHBJIeHHe HHTepeca OWIaKO BeK CBOOO J bI ClIaCTbJl lIHcTeii wHx oTHoweHHii Me lKn y He MeCTHoe JlBJIeHHe nOlTOMY cnen yeT 3an yMaTbCJI JIIOADMH He HaCTynHJl MellTbI 6bIJlH y6HTbI cnOCOOOM HX peaJIH3a K peJIHrHH - BaA 06 npeAIIOCbIJIKaMH lTOro pac ero HHTepeca AHH IIpo ecc ceKyJIJlpH3aIJ HH KpHTHKa peJIHrHH H epKBH B npow OHH BbIAaIOT ce6J1 H lTO He B COCTOJlHHH H3MeHHTb 6ypHbIe nepexo JIOM uma B TpeX OCHOBHbIX HanpaBJIeHHJIX - 3HI I Hii KaK npeOAOJIeHHe opeoJIa q eOAaJIhHbIX HHCTHTYTOB JIH6epanH3Ma AeMOKpaTHll C no- CO 3Ma HJlH aaapXH3Ma T e KaK OOPbOO 3a CBOOOn y paaeHCTBO H 6paTCTBO - KaK BbICTynneHHe HaYKH H KpHTHlIeCKoro e B OBaIJ HH annO ll HCMeHTbI KOTOPbIMH npeACTaBHTeJIH Ka lK J Q ro H3 HOBbIX MHpoB BCTpellaIOT nepeqeHb CBOHX AOCTH lKeHHii 3yJIbTaTe - MbIIlWeHHJI npOTHB eH3YPbI H KOHTpoJIJI epKBH BnocneACTBHH - 116 HOBbIe 06 ecTBa Ha KaKHX 6bI npHH ax OHH HH 6bIJlH OCHQ BaHb OK3 3aJIHCb KapHKaTypoii Ha HAeH 3a BODJlO eHHe KOTOPbIX npOTHB B pe nOJIHOe pa30lIapoBaHHe KpyweHHe Beex HJIJlI03HH pac repJIHHOCTb crpax nepeA 6Y M YTpaTa nepcneKTHBbI H K TOMy' lKe - OTCyYCTBHe BeJIHKoro npoeKTa KOTOPbIH 6bI CTHMYJIHpOBaJI 117 H MaHIfJI OcraJIHCh ICe - mOAB YIlIeAWHe B H30JII1UHIO rrH'lHOH KH3 eAHHCTBeHHoMy BHAY XX BeK npHBHec B 3TOT npon ecc cymeCTBeH HU OTlIlIJiHHhIH 6ecnepcneKTHBHhIH Teppop H 3aBHCTJIHBOe nO l U'rrH HO HOBhm 3JIeMeHT MhI y Ke HayqurrHCb H3rOTOBrrHTb Bem ecrBa AhIBaHHe 3a paHCKOH KH3HhIO COeeAeH KOTopbIe He lIerroBeKY Ka KeTCH cym ecrByroT B npHpoAe a CeHqaC Mbl nepeHOCHM H HayKa 06MaHyrra ero UerrhHhIH 3TH HOBIlIecrBa B ccpepy KH3HH IIoCpeACTBOM reHeTHqeCKOH HH Ke ynOPH ll OqeHHbm 06pa3 MHpa KOTOPhIM HayKa 3aMeHHJIa MHCPbI Hep Mhl JIhlraeMCH cymeCTBeHHO H3MeHHTh cBoucrBa KHBhIX op lfI npoIlIJIoro ra ICe HayKa pa36HJIa BApe6e3rH HaYKa npHAaJIa OTHOCH raHH3MOB H3HyrpH EcrrH em e HeAaBHO JII060e OTKphITHe HayKH TerrbHbIH xapaKTep BceM CBOHM nOrrO ICeHHHM H ycrro KHllJIa HX AO H TeXHHKH BhI3hIBaITO Bocropr ropAOCTb 3a no6eAY AYxa TO ceuqac raKOH CTeneHH lITO A1JH 60JIhIlIHHCTBa mOAeH OHH CTaJIH HenOHIITHhI 3THM qyBCTBaM conyrCTBYIOT a HHor IJ a 3aMem aIOT HX CTpaX nepe ll MH HenOCTH KHMhIMH lliMeHeHUe npeACTaBrreHHii 0 npoCTpaHCTBe nocneACTBHHMH KOTophIe HeB03MO KH0 npeADHAeTh K qeMY 3TH BpeMeHU crpyKType MaTepHH 0 npHquHHOCTH BcerreHHoH KOTOpoe OTKphITHH MOryT npHBeCTH B MHpHOe BpeMH H BO BpeMH BOHHhl Mbl AOJI KHhI 6hmH YCBOHTh 3a nocneAHHe TpH nOKorreHHII He HMeeT Pe HAeT He TorrbKO 0 He KerraTerrhHhlX nocneACTBHHX Ha OC ee6e nOAo6HhiX 3a BCIO HcrOPHIO qerrOBeqeCKOrO n03HaHHH MHoro HOBe HOBhlX OTKPhlruH nOHBHJIaCh B03MO KHOCTb KOHTpOJIHpoBaTh qucneHHOCTb OTKPhImH o6 beM 3HaHHH H CBH3aHHaH C HHMH cneUHa JIIOAeU MaHHnyrrHpOBaTh HMH B TaKOH CTeneHH KOTOPYIO B npoIlI JIH3aUHH C03AaIOT nOrrO ICeHHe npH KOTOPOM H BbICOKOKBaJIHCPHUH rrOM TPYAHO 6hmo IJ a ICe npeACTaBHTh ee6e 3 HaHHe o6em aBIlIee poBaHHhIH yqeHhlH B OAHOH oooaCTH OKa3hIBaeTCH COBepIlIeHHO 6ee OCBo60ABTh qerrOBeKa C03AaeT HaBeerM nOMOlI HbIM HeBe KAOH B 60rrbllIHHCTBe ApyrHX Ha pHAOBOrO qe 6oAhI rrOBeKa nonyrrHpH30BaHHaH HayKa TO 06pymHBaeT lITO BeerreHHaH 6ecKOHe'IHa TO yrBep KAaeT COBepIlIeHHO npoTHBonorrO KHoe C HJIJII03HHMH lfI yrP03Y JIHIlIHTh ero CBQ qerrOBeK OT npHpoAhI Ao6p H cnoco6eH TO K coBepIlIeHCTBOBaHHIO H lITO 3JIO ero n06Y 'AaIOT TBOpHTh JIHIlIh MhI Bee nepe KHJIH 3TH KPaHHOCTH B xOAe npaKTHqeCKOrO CPaMH HOBbm qerrOBeK HOBoro o6m eCTBa KOTOPhIH nuean JIJIaKa· peKOMeHAYeT eCTh lllJIHHaT TO coBeryeT H36eraTh ero HeOOarOnpHHTHhIe ycrrOBHH BhrumO He rryqme qeM C ApyrHMH MH npHMeHeHHII HaY'IHblX OTKpbInffi BocTopr C KOTOPhlM npHBercT ThI 0 MOpaJIH CBeTrroro 6YAYm ero THXO COIlIeJI CO cn eHhI B03pacTa BOBaJIHCb HUe arpeccHBHOCTH UHHH3Ma H paBHOAYllIHH - H306peTeHHH AOrr ICeHCTBOBaBllIHe npHHecru nporpecc H Cqacrbe qerrOBeqeCTBY y Ke Aerro npoIlIJIoro 3HaKOMCTBO C nocneA npoooeMa Bcex crpaH MHpa IIoA'heM HaAe KA CMeHHJIO nOXMerrbe BcenOAaBJIHIOm ee CTBHHMH K KOTOPhIM npHBerrH nocroHHHo pacrYIUHe B03MO KHOCTH om ymeHHe qerrOBeKa MeHIITh MHP npHBerro K TOMY lITO BocTopr CMeHHJI pyIO MhI nbeM nepeA npoAyKraMH H3 KOTOPhIX rOTOBHM eAY Ae CKeDTHUH3M H Aa ICe crpax CHM6H03 HayKH H aJI'lHOCTH npeBpaTHJI THM nepeA B03AYXOM KOTOPbIM Mbl AhIlllHM nepeA coeeAOM KO COBpeMeHHoro qerrOBeKa B KOPOJIH MHAaca Bee K qeMY npHKoCHeT CH qerrOBeK TPaHcq opMHpyeTcH B orpoMHoe 6oraTcTBo A H306HJIHe 3TO CTpaX crpax nepeA BOHHOH nepeA BOAOH KOTQ TophIii MO KeT AOHeCTH nepeA COTPYAHHKOM KOTOPhIH MO ICeT BhI KHTh Te6H C T8oero Mecra nepeA 6eJIhIMH qepHhIMH KerrTbIMH Bem eH B CBOIO oqepeAh npeBpam aeT 3eMJIIO B MYCOPHYIO CBaJIKy D BeTHhIMH npoAyKTbI pa3JIO KeHHII KOTOPOH B03BpaIUaIOTCH B KHBoe Terro qe peBaHlllHcraMH nepeA rorrOAHhIMH H nepeA BoopY 'eHHhIMH KorAa rrOBeKa qepe3 BOAY B03AYX xne6 TO rrIOAH 8 TIOphMax nHcaJIH YTOnuu Ceif qac OHH IIHlIIyr TpHJIJIephI nepeA PYCCKHMH KOMMYHHCTaMH HMDepHaITHCTaMH Ha npoTH KeHHH TblCnqerreruH qerrOBeK nOrrb30BaITCH npHpoAoH npHcnocaooHBaIT ee K CBOHM HY ' IJ aM OH nOAaBJIHJI TO lITO CqmaJI BpeAHhIM BblpamHBaIT H pa3MHO ICaJI TO lITO eMY cn o Ii B 3TOH HOBOH 3Ta 06CTaHOBKe qerrOBeK CH08a mn eT y6e KHm e B ll eHTerrhHOCTh qerrOBeKa OKa3aITaCb AOCTaTO'IHOH lIT06bl H3MeHUTh perrHrnu H perrHm03HOH o6m HHe Ero nOHCKH OOOerqaIOTCH reM OOOHK 3eMJIH lIT06hl npoCTpaHCTBO Ha KOTOPOM cocymecTBOBaITH lITO H KaTOJIHqeCKaH n epK08h H3BrreKJIa ypOK H3 KpHTHKH KOTOPOH 6ecqucneHHbIe BHAbI pacreHHH H KHBOTHhIX npeBpaTHJIHCh B MecrO OHa npe6bIBaHHH rrIOAeH rAe ll onycKaeTcH JIHIlIh TO lITO CJIY KHT 3TOMY nocrreACTBHH nOTepb H nopa KeHHii KOTophle OHa nOHecrra Moryr 118 AOrr KHa 6hma npoTHBOCTOHTh UepK08h o6HapY KHJIa lITO 119 OK33aThC II 60nee u eHHbIMH qeM rr03H u HH KOTOpble OHa 3aH11Marra B npOrrmOM H C KOTOPbIX GbIJIa oT6pomeHa llepKoB'h ymna p arreKO BrrepeA rrpeOp OIIeB paCCTO llHHe OT CHIlIIa6yca K a ll I IfOpHaMeHTY OT Y3HHKOB BaTHKaHa K neTyqHM rrarraM AKTHBH3a u H 11 XXIII Torp a lICe rrOBbICHII CJI HHTepec MHPOBOH 06IIJ eCTBeHHOCTH K KaTOnHqeCKOii u epKBH HeoGbNHble rropa lKaroIIJ He HHH u HaTHBbl BaTHKaHa KacaroTCJI KaK tJHCTO u epKoBHbIX p en 3KYMeuuqecKHx CTpeMIleHHii BHYTPH XPHC THaHCTBa H KOHTaKTOB C HexpHCTHaHCKHMH penHrH03HbIMH 06IIJ HHa MH TaK H coBepmeHHo HOBOH TpaKTOBKH BOBnetJeHHOCTH u epKBH B CBeTCKyro f H3Hb llepKoBb CTpeMHTC II BblcryrraTb B ponH 3aIIJ HT HHKa KpHTHKa Bp OXHOBHTenJl a HHorp a H rrocpep HHKa He rrpHGe ra ll K Tpa I H u HOHHbIM J OpMaM rrOIIHTHqeCKOH p eJITenbHOCTH Uep KOBb 3aJIBn lleT lITO Y Hee HeT rrOnHTHl JeCKOii rrporpaMMbI OHa He aCCOIJ HHpyeTC II HH C KaKOH rrOIIHTHqeCKOH opraHH3aIJ Heii OHa He HaMepeHa BMemHBaTbC II B p ena CBeTCKoii BnaCTH HO Bee lICe OCTaB n lleT 3a co60ii rrpaBo orrpep eIIJITb CBOIO n03H u HIO OTHOCHTenbHO HpaBCTBeHHblX acneKToB rrOnHTHKH 3TO OqeHb yp oGHa II H J aKTH tJeCKH HeY ll3BHMaH rr03HIJ HJ1 OHa nOMoraeT u epKBH Bblpa lKaTb CBoe MHeHHe HO He Gep ll Ha ee6 11 HHKaKoii OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH rrpo B03rnawaTb u enH He p oK33bIBa II HX OcyIIJ eCTBHMOCTb JIro6aH BIlaCTb OKa3bIBaeTCJI B He6narOBH I HOM CBeTe Korp a ee cyeTIIHBaH npaKTHKa H3Mep lleTC II KpHTepH IIMH Hp earrOB B o6naCTH KynbTYpbI u epKOBb He I1bITaeTC II BMemHBaThCJI B TO l Jero He rrOHHMaeT OHa BbI lKH u aTenbHO TeprrHMa K HaYtJHbIM Hccnep OBaHHJIM H rrbITaeTCJI a6cop6HpoBaTb HX pe3ynbTaTbl OHa p a lICe He MemaeT eCTeCTBOHCIlbITaTen llM npoBO lJ HTb Hccnep OBaHllJI CHnna6yc - lloKYMeHThl OT 1864 H 1907 rr B KOTOPhlX nanhl OCYlKllanH IPHnocOIpcKHe H TeOnOrH'IeCKHe HanpaBneHHlI Tex BpeMeH AIIlKHopHaMeHTo - cTpeMneHHe npHcnoco6HTl llePKOBl K cOBpe MeHHhlM ycnOBHlIM Y3HHK BaTHKaHa - TaK Ha3hlBanH nan KOTophlec 1870no 1929 r He BhlXOIIHnH H3 BaTHKaHa B 3HaK npoTeCTa npOTHB oKKynallHH PH Ma KoponeBCKHMH BoltcKaMH onpep eneHHYlO OCTOPO f HOCTh H no OTHomeHHIO K oGmeCTBeHHbIM HaYKaM - OHa H36eraeT KOO J IIHKTOB eCJIH CaMa He no u sepraeTCJI Hanap eHH IIM KypHH H KaTOIIHl JeCKOii u epKBH BooGIIJ e HatJa naCb C MOMeHTa H36paHH II rrarrOH HOaHHa a6C parnpYIOIIJ HeCJI OT CYIIJ eCTBOBaHHJI Eora llepKoBb npo fIBIIJIeT EbIJIO GbI omu60tJHO BH I eTb B nHX HOBbIX tJeprax OTKa3 OT nporrmoro IlnJl u epKBH TaKoii OTKon HeB03MO llCeo Pe'D u o eT oG H3MeHeHHH rro u xop OB a oe cyIIJ HOCTH CTpeMIleHHe H crroc06HOCTh rrpHcrroco6JrrbCJI K cOBpeMeHHoMY MHpy HMelOT orrpep eneHHblii CMblcn H HMeIOT onpep eneHHbIe rpaHHIJ bl 3TO B KOHel JHOM Cl JeTe nyn npHcnoco6neHH II MHpa K u epKBH K ee yqeHHIO nOHHMaTb a ll I IfOpHaMeoTo HHatJe GblIIO 6bI HIIH HaHBHOCTbIO HIIH epeCbIO B qexocnoBaKHH ometJaTnenHCb Bce nepeqHCneHHbIe BbIme qepThl - Map33M CKerrCHC 6e3BblXO I HOCTb H anaTH II Hameii CTpa He He yp anOCb OCTaThCJI B CTOpooe OT Bee06mero KpH3Hca Hanpo THB BO MHOrHX OTHomeHH IIX p330tJapoBaHlle y Hac rny6 l1Ce noTOMY lITO CTpeMIleHHe peaIIH30BaTb Meqry 6bDIO 60nee HaCToii1 HBblM a rre peXOP OT OIlb llOeHH II K p330tJaPOBaHHIO 6bIJI cnHIIIKOM pe3KHM H GblC pblM IlocTaTOl JHO BCnOMHHTb 3H J OPHIO B MOMeOT OCBO 60 lK l eHH II 1945 r •• - Pep KOTOPyro CTOIIb HHTeOCHBHO He rrepe lKHJla HH o u aa H3 BOCTOl JHo-eBporreHCKHX CTpaH 38 HCKJlIOtJe HHeM p33Be IOrocnaBHH lIT06bl YBH u eTb lITO npep CTaBneHH II 0 6Yp yIIJ eM BO Beex cnOJlX HaeeneHH II KaK 6bI OHH HH pa mHtJaJlHCb paHbme HJlH rr03 l1Ce rrOTeprrenH Kpax 1948 rop nOJIHTHl JecKHe cyp e6 HbIe npo u eccbl 5O-e ro l bl H HaKOHen aBryCT 1968-ro - 3TO py6e lKH 3HaMeoyroIIJ He yrepro rrO JBbI nop ooraMH caMblMH pa mHtJHbIMH rpyrrnaMH yreplO HMH HIlIII03HH lITO CBOH H HOBbIH MHP MO llCeT 6bITh nOCTpoeo H 6yp eT rrOCTpoeo HOBbIe rrOKOneHH II Y llCe oe palo p enJlBmHe Ha u e lK l CBOHX rrpep I lIeCTBeHHHKOB BMeCTe C HHMH ne pe lKHBarrH HX KpymeHHe HbIoemuee COCTO IIHHe o6IIJ ecma H oTHomeHHii Me lKAY nIO I bMH B HeM OIIHcaHbI B HaytJHbIX pa60Tax H B xyp O llCeCTBeHHbIX rrpoH3Be p eHH IIX Tyr HetJero HH P 06aBHTb HH y6aBHTb MHe O I HaKO XOTe nOCb 6bl KOCHyrbCJI O I Horo acneKTa - KaK HblHeillHJlJl TeOpH II H rrpaKTHKa 033bIBaeMble MapKCH3MOM'neHHHH3MOM npHTyIIIDlIOT KpHTHtJeCKoe MblIIIIIeHHe nIOp eH H rrpHBHBalOT HM npHcymee penH rHH MbmmeHHe 3HatJHTenbHyro tJaCTb Toro B tJeM pe f HM 06BHH lleT penHrHIO H npoB03rnamaeT OerrpHeMJIeMblM 00 caM HaB II3blBaeT CBOHM rpa lK l aHaM npHl JeM B BeCbMa HerrpHBJIeKaTeJIbOOH J opMe 120 121 r Pe lQfM Tpe6yeT ' T06hI rpa H AeJ1aJI BHA ' TO BepHT yrBep IC 3a CHe l HblM lIenOBeKOM q OTorpa PHpyeM neTaIOlI He TapenKH AeHHHM KOTOpble HBHO npoTHBOpe'laT ero pa3yMy H HaKOIll1eHHOMY MbI O l HAaeM npHXO o a HHOJIJIaHeTSlH H HlI eM CJIeAhI HX npe6b1BaHHH 8M Ha 3eMJIe B npownoM MhI pa3MbJIIlJIHeM HaA napancuxonorneH om lTY Pe lQfM npHHy l AaeT rpa l 11 3ll BbICKa3b1BaTbCH no Bon pocaM HHq opMaUHH 0 KOTOPbIX pe I HMOM ICe CKpbWaeTCJl Pe lQfM H 3TO eme caMhIe COJIHAHble 3KCKypcbI B MHp BonpoCUTeJIbHhIX 3Ha 06pa1l aeTCH K rp3 I AaHaM MepTBblM JIHTYprWleCKHM H3hIKOM Ha KOB CKnOHHOCTb K 06cKYpaHTHCTCKHM HAeHM H npaKTHKe WOKR KOTOPOM AOHOCHT nocmume HO He TO 0 KOTOpOM HK06hI rOBOpHT pyeT 3a 3HlJ HKJIOneAHCTaMH Hamero BpeMeHH MaHtlHT HpoHWleCKaH CJl B 06pameHHH TeHb rpaq a KaJIHOCTPO 06mecmeHHyIO H nOJIHTHqeCKyro lQf3Hb pe lQfM npeBpaTHJI B q OPMaJIbHhIH pHTYaJI - co6paHHH C'be3AhI nepBOMaHe KHe AeMoHcrpaUHH BeJIHKHe rOAOBlI HHb1 H HaKOHeu BbI60pbl ilpoB03rJIaWeHHe MapKCH3Ma-JIeHHHH3Ma rocy o apCTBeHHoH HAeOJIOrneH H BhITeKaIOII HH H3 3Toro 3a I HM peJIHfHH OKa3b1BaeT Y'Iacrne B 3THX 06pHAaX ATlH OAHHX IlBJIHeTCH YAOCTOBepeHHeM ABOHcmeHHoe B03AeHCTBHe BpOAe 6bl 6b1JIH AOCTHrHyThI orpoMHble o JIOIDIbHOcrn Al1H ApyrHX - ycnexu rJIa D KO Pe lQfM HarpaAHJI nOATBep l D eHHeM Toro ' TO Bee HAeT CBOH HHCTHTyrhI BeeMH aTpH6yraMH Or U epKBH OTOWJIH Te KTO TY o a XOAHJI no npH'lHHaM que TO nparMaTHqeCKHM TaK 6hIJlO npHHHTO TaK nOCrynaJIH Apyrne HAeaJIOB ero HAeOJIonm H 3TO o60 ICecmJIeHHe JIerKO ycrpaHHJIO AeMoHcTpHpOBaBWHe nocemeHHeM u epKBH JIOJIJ1bHOCTb no OTHowe pa3JIH'lHH Me l Ay BJf lJ HMOH H HeBH lJ HMoH U epKOBbIO HenorpeIllH HHIO K npH3HaHHhIM B 06mecme u eHHOCTHM HHbIMH CJIOBaMH MOCTb npeACTaBHTeJIeH BJIaCTH eme He B03BeAeHa B 3aKOH HO Bee Ae3epTHpoBaJIH XOAHBWHe B u epKOBb He no penurn03HbIM MOTHBaM OHa nOBeeMeCTHO H nO l H3HeHHO npH3HaeTCH 3a HHMH ECJIH He ilOCTeneHHO craJIH OTXOAHTb H BepHBWHe nOBepXHocrHO He cnoco6 KOTopble HCTHHbI npH3HaIOTCH TaKOBblMH B onpeAeJ1eHHOe BpeMH Hble BhICTOHTb 003 06meH nOMep I KH a TeM 60JIee B 06CTaHOBKe ICe TO Ha60p OCHOBHbIX Ta6y nocroHHeH H YKOpeHHJICH B MaCCOBOM Kor o a OTKpbIToe npo llBJIeHHe peJIHrn03HOCTH HaTaJIKHBaeTCH Ha C03HaHHH H nOAC03HaHHH ilepeqeHb rJIaBHbIX H BTopoCTeneHHbIX rHeB BnaCTeH 6b1JIO 6hl OAllaKO HeBepHO CtlHTaTb ' TO Bee H1IH THTYJIOB PYKOBOAHTeJ1eH KOTOPbIH npHBOAHTCH C TOtlHOCTbIO Aoe 6oJIhWHHcmo paCCTaBWHXCH C penHfHeH nOcrynHJIH TaK H3 'lHCToro ToifHoH npeCTapeJIOro eeHHJIbHOrO 0Tu a HaPOAOB eme pa3 AeMOHCT onnopryHH3Ma • pHPYer ' TO HOCUTeJIb 3THX THTYJIOB - HHtlTO a Mecro B HepapxHH Bce ilOKpbIThIe llhIJIbIO pa3MOKWHe OT AO l l I TpaHCnapaHTbI H3 06mecmeHHoH l H3HH H ywJIH B u epKBH MOJIHTBeHHble H Ill1aKaTbI - 3TO paCJIHTHH BAOJIb HaWHX Aopor ilaMHTHHKOB MeHb ceMbH UepKBH B TOM 'lHCJIe KaTOJIHqeCKaH CTaJIH u epKOBHblMH UepKoBHble o6blttaH npa3A11ecTBa H 06PHAbI 6hIJlH H3rHaRbl lI mI we B03MO I HO nOTOMY tlTO npOH3BOACTBeHHbIH CpOK C03 D aHHH AHacnopaMH CKYJIhnrypbI Mor 6hI npeBhICHTb nepHOA nOKJIOHeHHH H306p3 1 ae HrpaTl pom rOCYAapcmeHHOH BceHapoAIIOH U epKBH TPYARO 6blJI0 MbIM Q PHlJ HaJIbHO pe I HM 0603HaqHJI qeTKyro rpaHHIJY Me l Ay nepeopHeHTHpoBaThCH H Ha'laTb AeHCTBOBaTb no COBepweHHO HHbIM lI mI KaTOJIHqeCKOH u epKBH KOTOpaH AOMa B HeBepoHTHblM B KOTopoe JIIOAH AOJI l Hbl BepHTb H HeBepoHTHbIM npaBHJIaM B KOTopoe BepHT u epKOBb HO 3T0 pa3JIH'lHe He BceM HCHO TaK KOJIbKY COCTOHHHe AHacnopbI ATlH HHX KaK npoq eCCHOHaJIbHbIM HAeOJIOraM UHH KaTOJIH'IeCKOH U epKBH OCJIO l lUJJIaCb K TOMY Ib-3a Aerpa o aUHH HayKH AO 3aHHTHH KOTOPhIM PYKOBO D HT H3BHe H KOTopoe BbIHy l D eHO nOA'lHHHTbCH He npHCymHM HaYKe npHBhIKJIa APyrnx u epKBeH 3TOT nepexoA 6hIJI npome noe ee OPraHH3aUHOHHOH CTPYKTYphI - 6bIJIO npHBbltlHhIM CHTya ICe H pa3pyweHHeM 6b1JIa 3aJIpemeHa AeHTeJIbHOCTb MOHaWeCKHX opAeHOB H MHornx CBHmeHHHKOB B 06mecme qeXOCJIOBaIJ KOrO peaJIbHOrO COUHaJIH3Ma U epK KpHTepHHM pH D ee OTpacneH 3arnoXlIH a B HeKOTopbIX HHhIX HCCJIeAOBaTeJIbCKHH AYX Bo06me 6bIJI y6m ilPOHCHHJIOCb eme OARO BH - napa o OKCaJIbHOe nOCJIeACTBHe OCy I D eHHe H WeJ1bMOBaHHe pe I H 3HpoBaTb H B TO ICe BpeMH 3T0 COBepweHHO 3aKOHHble HHCTHtyrhI 3T0 eAHHHIJ b1 aHOpMlllIbHble KOTophle HeB03MO I H0 HOPMaJIH MOM pH o a OTKPblTHH H HaytlHbIX AHCUHIll1HH nopOAHJIO CTpax nepeA UepKBH He HBJIHIOTCJl COCTaBHOH 'laCTbIO HaUHOHaJIbHOrO q poHTa HOBhIM npOBaJIOM CnopHbIM CTano OCHOBHoe 'ITO MO ICeT a 'ITO H TeM CaMhIM OHH CTaHOBHTCH qy ICepOAHhIM TeJ10M B CTpYKTYpe 06 He MO ICeT 6blTb npeAMeTOM HaYtlHoro HCCJIeAOBaHHH MbI rOWleMCJl mecma 3TO BblTeKaeT H3 caMoro HX cymeCTBa UepKBH D a I e 122 123 tfeCKOii q OPM311bHO He B COCTOHHHH npH3HaTb PYKOBOAffiUYIO POJIb napIHH na H napmH He B COCTOHHHH 6hma 6hI BOCOOJIb30BaTbCH TaKHM npH3 BhmOJIHHTh npHKa3 eCJIH OHH He npHMyr ero A06pOBOJIbHO Cnno qeHHOCTb BHyrpeHHHH ll HCIIHDJIHHa H 06H3areJIbHOCTb peJIHrH03HbIX AOrM - Bee 3T0 OCHOBhmaerCH TOJIbKO Ha aBTOpHTeTe B 3TOR IIepKBH ee eJIa60CTH CHJIa H HCKJIIO'lHTeJIhHOCTb Ha TeMBOM Mpa'IHOM q OHe IIepKBH BhICTynaIOT KaK 'lHCThle He3aWlTHaHHbIe yrO J BH'l eCTBOM CHMBOJIhl Hx yqeHHe HX 06pa3eII AeRcmHii pa3H TeJIhHO OTJIHlJaIOTCH OT HaBH3blBaeMbIX BJIaCTbIO OHH YKa3bIBaIOT BbIXOA H Ha u e l JJ y TaM rAe 3Toro y lKe HHKTO He BHAHT WMeHHO 3TH BepYIOIIIHH HHKoro He 06H3aH y6eiKnaTb eJIOBaMH B nOJJ J1HHHOCTH cBoero y6eiKJJ eHIDI H 6eCKopblCTHOCTH cBoeii BOBJIetfeHHOCTH - Ae MOHcrpaIIIDI npHHaJJ J1eiKHOCTH K XPHCTHaHCKOii IIepKBH He cnoco6 cTByeT KaK H3BeCTHO Kapbepe KOHTaKTbI C ApyrHMH BepYIOIIIHMH n03BOJIHIOT tfYBcmOBaTb ce6H tfJIeHOM COOOIlleCTBa 6JIaropoAHbIX JIIOAeii H oIIIymaTb CBOIO HCKJIIOtfHTeJIhHOCTb B3aHMOnOMOIllb nOA AepiKKa APyJeii T e TO tfTO B aTOMH3HpOBaHHOM 06IIIeCTBe 3aMe Mer HOpMaJIbHble 06IIIeCTBeHHble CBH3H B IIepKoBHoii 06IIIHHe AOnOJIHHerCH H MeTaq H3HlJeCKHM acneKTOM - BCTpetfeii C EorOM B 6J1HiKHeM TaKHM 06Pa30M npHlJHHbI npHTHraTeJIbHOCTH peJIHrHH H u epKOBHoii 06IIIHHbI COBepweHHO O lJ H03HatfHO JIeiKaT BByrPH ca Moro 06IIIeCTBa B JIanmcKoH AMepHKe HhIHeillHHH nana BeJIHKOJIenHO nOHHMaeT nOJIHTHKY KOMMY HHCTHtfeCKHX napTHii H rOCY D apCTBeHHbIX OprauOB COIIHanHCTHlJeC KHX CTpaH OH 3BaeT 3TO H3HyrpH OH nOHHMaeT CMhlcn 3awHq POBaH HhIX q pa3 3HaeT orpaHHtfHBaIOmHH a HHorna ynpaBJIHIOmHH CMhlcn BpoAe 6bI 6ecCOJJ epiKaTeJIbHbIX BBOJJ HbIX cnOB H HeynoBHMhIX MeTOAoB Ha KOTophle HHKTO KpoMe Tex KTO CT3llKHB3llHCh C HHMH nOBCeAHeBHO JJ aiKe He 06paTHT BHHMaHHH Kor D a nany cope CHJ1H KaKoii 6YAeT ero nOJIHTHKa no OTHoweHHIO K COIIH3llHCTHtfeC KHM rocynapcmaM OH omeTUJI tfTO HaHBHoii OHa He 6YAeT 3TO Toq Hoe H mepAoe ofu HcHeHHe KatfeCma IIepKBH npHTHrHBaIOT JIIOAeii KOTOpbIM OTBpaTHTeJIbHbI 6eccoAepiKaTeJIbHOCTb H 6ecnepCneKTHBHOCTb OKpy lKaIOIllero MHpa CBRIIIeHHHKOB BeHBH••• HllHHeM UepKBH JIHIlIeHhI KaKoro-JIH60 yqaCTHH B AeJIax CTpaHbI H B 'lHCTO IIepKOBHhIX paMKax HeB03MO KH0 npHH ' ll HTb BepYIOIIIHX BOBJIetfeHHOCTH MO J eT npHBecm K coBepweHHo HanpacHoMY nOBTopeHHIO CTOJIKHO KaKYIO pOJIh MOiKeT HrpaTb u epKOB'I B CTpaHe ynpaBJIHeMOH KOMMyHHCTHlJeCKoii napTHeH B KOTOPOH K TOMY iKe pa3MeIIIeHbI CO BeTCKHe Boii cKa nOKa3hlBaeT IIoJIbwa IIoJIbwa O lJ HaKO KpaHHHH cnyqaii 3TO CTpaHa B KOTOPOH HapHAY C TpaJJ H u HOHHbIM tfpe3BhIllaii HbIM BJIIDIHHeM KaTOJIHIIH3Ma AeHCTBYIOT TaKiKe HHble q aKTOPbI B JJ pyrHX CTpaHax He npoHBJIHBWHeCH CTOJIh HHTeHCHBHO OtfeHh JIerKO nOAo6paTb IIeJIbIR pHA aprYMeHTOB nOJJ TBepiKnaIOIIIHX tfTO B qexOCJIo BaKHH nOJIO J eHHe nyqwe H tfTO Y Hac n ro npOH3oii TH He MOiKeT IIoJIe3Hee OAHaKO Y'IHThmaTh tfTO B sroA IJaCTH MHpa I t epKBH YA3ll0Cb HetfTO HeBepoRTHoe OHa BbIcrynaeT Tenepb KaK 3aII l HTHHK npaB tfeJIOBeKa H rpaiKnaHCKHX CBo60A KaK JaIIIHTHHK HauHOHaJIh Horo C03HaHHR H HaIIHOHaJIbHOrO eAHHCTBa KaK npoBo lJ HHK HHTepe COB 6eAHbIX KpeCTbHH H pa60tfHX UepKOBb B Hame BpeMH BocnpH HHMaeTCH HMeHHO TaKHM 06pa30M EOPb6a 3a CBo60p y 3a npaBa qeJIOBeKa H rpaiKnaHHHa 6opb6a 3a COIIHaJIbHyIO cnpaBe J 1IHBoCTb npoTHB rocnOAcma oAHoro KJIacca OrKa3 OT nOHCKOB BHHOBHOro B HAeOJIOmlleCKOM HaiKHMe HaJJ APYrHM H 3KCDJIyaTaIIHH HH B KoeM cnyqae He RBJIHIOTCH AOMH H3BHe He 03HatfaeT tfTO HhIHeillHHH xapaKTep H nOJIHTHKa peJIHrH03 HaRTOH IIepKBH WCTOKH nOR 60Pb6bI HaxoARTCH Ha cOBepmeHHo HbIX u eHTpoB Ja py6eiKOM KaK H JJ eHTeJIbHOCTb IIepKBH B APyrHX npoTHBonOJIO KHOM nOJIIOee eBponeii cKoro MbWIJIeHIDI - CTpaHax Bo06Ille BHKaKoii POJIH He HrpaIOT Oco6eHHO HpKO 3Ta ART KOpHRMH B paIIHOHaJIHCTHtfeCKYIO Tpa D H u HIO BeAYIIIYIO OT Pe CBR3b npoRBJIHeTCH y KaTOJIHKOB HOBoe iKe B TOM tfTO BaTHKaH HeccaHca tfepe3 IIpocBeIIIeHHe K MapKcu3MY H nocne H36paBHH nanoii nOJIbCKoro CBHIIIeHHHKa He TOJIbKO o6rranaeT He HaMepeHa YTBepiK D aTh tfTO OHH yxo 3TH HAeH npoTHBopetfaT AOCKOHaJIbHbIM 3HaHBeM npo6rreMaTHKH CTpaH C KOMMYHHCTHtfec XPHCTHaHCKOMY yqeHHIO tfTO OHO He Morno HX HHCOHpHpoBaTh KHMH peiKHMaMH HO H Aeii cmyeT Ha OCHOBe 3Toro 3HaHHH MO KHO ECJItt CKa3aTh tfTO BaTHKaH 3TO 3HaHHe naiKe a6COJIIOTH3HpyeT pacopoCT MapKCHCTaMH H XpHCTHaHaMH Boo6m e OKa3aJICH 6bI HeB03MOiKHbIM 6bI 3TO COOmeTCTBOBaJIO AeHCTBHTeJIbHOCTH TO ll H3ll0r MeiK DY paHIDl ero H Ha APyme o6rraCTH B KOtoPhIX o6IIIeCTBeHHO-nOJIHm qeCKag curyaIIIDI ll HaMeTp3llbHO npoTHBonOJIo KHa CTOHKOCTb nOJIhCKorO KaTOJIHIIH3Ma HecpaBHHMa C PeJIHm03HOCTbIO B 3anaA HbIX rocynapcmax HenpIDITHe TeOJIorHH oCBo60iKJJ eHHR H nOJIHTH 125 124 H HeT HH'lerO nyralO ero B TOM 'ITO XpHCTHaHe BblCTyIIalOT Ha CTO poHe 3Tnx H u eH - xx rO nOBIIUDIA IV C'E3 llA DHCATFJIE9 lJEXOCJIOBAKlfH Hao60poT IIyraeT H Bbl3blBaeT TpeBOry 'ITO HlOIIL UepKOBb CTaJIa 3a HTHHKOM HHTepeCOB pa60lJHx H KpeCTbHH OT no 1967 r CHraTenbCTBa npaBHTenbCTBa COUHaJIHCTBNeCKOrO rocy u apCTBa Jlo tIero ICe Mbl u OUInH pa3 KaTOnBNeCKaH uepKOBb 60peTCH 3a CBo60 u y JIIO06UK Ba14YJlUK cnoBa H npOTHB UeH3ypbl YCTaHOBneHHOH MapKCHCTaMH 3a npaBO pa60tInx 06'be u HHHTbCH B npO peCCHOHaJIbHble COI03bl KOTOPhlM 3TH pa60lJHe u OBepHIOT 3TO memento mori TaKOe 6bmo 6bl HeB03MO IC HO ecnu 6b1 MapKCHCTbl He H3MeHHnH CBOHM ICe H u eaJIaM Ponb pe o BJIACTH nHfHH H UepKBH B IIonblue 3HalJHTenbHO yKpenuna yBepeHHOCTb B CBOHX cunax KaTonHKOB B u pyrnx CTpaHaX H Bbl3BaJIa yBa I eHHe K KaTOnHll H3MY y HeBepylO X • H e e pa3 no u tIepKHBaIO pellb u u eT TOBapHIll H He 0 tIHCTO penHrH03HbIX tIepTaX nonbCKoro KaTonHlI H3Ma a 0 n03H H lI HH nonbCKOH KaTonuqeCKOH UepKBH no OTHOllleHHIO K rYMaHHTap HbIM H 06 eCTBeHHblM np06neMaM B nocne z r HHe npaB nx rOAbI nonb3YIOcb cnyqaeM tIT06bl CKa3aTb BaM H3BeCTHoe H 6e3 MeHH H u enalO 3TO TonbKO nOTOMY 'ITO y MeHH eCTb HeCKonbKO HaOOIO u aeTCH aKTHBH3all HH HenpHH3HH KpyrOB HaIIlHX CTpau no OTHOIlleHHlO K UepKBH B03paC u enOBbiX npeAnO ICeHHH 'ITO CMblcnOM B npoeKTe 3aHBneHHH C'be3 u a rOBopHTCH COll HaJIHCTHtIeCKOrO CTpoH HBnHeTClI o6ecnetIeHHe TaeT nx HepB03HOCTb H3-3a aKTHBHOCTH BepylO X Ha 3TO BnaCTb peHHTerpall HH tIenOBeKa KOTOPOMY rapaHTHpoBaH CTaTYC rpa l lJ a HM He pearHpYIOT e e 60nblllHM 3a I HMOM penHfHH HHHa fpa I IJ aHHH Kor u a-TO 3TO 6bmo cnaBHblM peBonlOlI HoHHbIM YCununuCb ua u penpeCCHH 3a u eHCTBHH KOTopble B u pyrnx CTpaHaX MHpa ClJHTaIOT cnOBOM OHO 03Hat aJI0 tIenOBeKa ClI caMO co60H pa3YMelO CH qexocnoBaKHH - rocno u CTBOBaTb 6ecKOHTponbHO HO KOTOPblM MO I HO 6bmo ynPaB cTpaua C Haunyq KOTOPblM HHKTO He Mor IlIHMH npe u nOCbmKaMH AnH y u OBneTBOpHTenbHbIX B3aHMOOTHOllle nHTb CTonb XHTPOYMHO 'IT06bl Y rpa l lJ aHHHa C03 u aBaJIOCb BnetIaT HUH COll HaJIHCTHtIeCKorO rocy u apCTBa C BepYIO MH H UepKBaMH neHHe 'ITO OH nOt TH BO BceM nO u BnaCTeH TonbKO CaMOMY ce6e npeBpaTunacb B n030pHylO KOCHylO CTPauy IIpaBHTenbCTBeHHaH Jl06HTbCH y ynpaBnHeMbIX TaKOrO BnetIameHHH 6bIDO 3a u atIeH nOnHTHKa no OTHOllleHHIO K UepKBH lJ ana pe3ynbTaTbl 06paTHbie OtIeHb H30 peHHOH Cnell HaJIbHOCTH KOTOPYIO Ha3bWaIOT nonHTH HaMepeHHHM ee HHHlI HaTopoB IIpecne u oBaHHH BepYIO X penpec KOH CHH npoTHB HHX ycunHBalOT BHHMaHHe OKP X K penHrHH rpa I D aHHH - Bcer u a 6bm MH pHtIeCKHM nOHHTHeM H npo u on l aeT OCTaBaTbCll TaKOBblM H nO z r HHMaIOT npeCTH IC BepYIO X 3TO C03 u aeT u ononHHTenbHbIH B u eHCTBHTenbHOCTH ICe nO z r BnaCTHbIH TonbKO caMOMY ce6e H BeCbMa C eCTBeHHbIH HMIIynbC aKTHBH3an uH HHTepeca K penH MapKCHCTCKaH KpHTHKa BnaCTH nponuna CBeT Ha He H3ytIaB fHH KaK MbI BHAHM Ha npaKTHKe ad maiorem Dei gloriam T e AnH llIHeCH npe l J e OTHOllleHHH Me l D y npaBHTenHMH H co6CTBeHHOCTblO npocnaBneHHH MHoro Bora HbIHelllHUH pe I HM c u enaJI qpe3BbItlaHHO Ha cpe u CTBa npoH3Bo u CTBa 3TO OTKpblTHe O u HOBpeMeHHO C nOHHMa HHeM HCTOPHH tIenOBetIeCTBa KaK HCTOPHH KnaCCOBOH 60Pb6b1 no u rOToBuno nOtIBy AnH COll HaJIbHOH peBonlOlI HH OT KOTOPOH O I HIJ anH H HOB oro pellleHHH H3BetIHOH npoooeMbI BnaCTH COll HaJIbHaH peBO nlOlI HH y Hac 3aBeplllHnaCb ycnexoM a npoooeMa BnaCTH npo u on lCaeT eCTBOBaTb Mbl CXBaTHnH 6blKa 3a pora H u ep I HM ero HO npH nOM KTO-TO He nepeCTaBaH mmaeT Hac B 3a D Y BnaCTH no BceH BepoHTHOCTH CBOH HepYIIIHMble 3aKOHO MepHOCTH pa3BHTHH H nOBe u eHHH KTO 6bl Y BnaCTH HH CTOM 126 127
35+ YEARS OF FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACTION