H HeT HH1Iero nyraIOwero B TOM 'lT0 XpHCTHaHe BbIctyIlaIOT Ha CTo­ poHe 3THX H J eii - xx rO llOBInHHA IV C'E3 llA IlItCATEJlER lJEXOCIIOBAKHH HIOHI 1967 r Hao60poT TIyraeT H BbI3bIBaeT TpeBOry 'lT0 u epKOBb CTaJIa 3aWHTHHKOM HHTepeCOB pa60lJHX H KpeCThHH OT no­ C llraTeJIbCTBa npaBHTeJIbCTBa COIJ HaJIHCTHlIeCKoro rocyWlpcTBa• llo lfero l e MbI AOWJIH pa3 KaTOJIHlfeCKaH u epKOBb 60peTC ll 3a CBo60AY J1100 JUK BaQYlluK enOBa H npOTHS u eH3ypbI YCTaHOBJIeHHoii MapKCHCTaMH 3a npaBO pa60lfHX 06'beAHHHTbC ll B npO peCCHOHaJIbHbIe COI03bI KOTOP hIM 3TH pa60'IHe AOBep llIOT 3TO memento mori TaKOe 6bIDO 6bI HeB03MO lK­ OBIIACTH HO eCJIH 6bI MapKCHCTbI He H3MeHHJIH CBOHM lKe H J eaJIaM POJIb pe­ JIHrHH H u epKBH B TIOJIbWe 3Ha'IHTeJIbHO yKpeIllUIa ysepeHHOCTb B CBOHX CHJIax KaTOOHKOB B APyrHX CTpaHaX H Bbl3BaJIa YS8 lKeHHe K KaTOOHIJ H3MY Y HeBepyroWHX H ewe pa3 nOAlfepKHBaro pe'llh H J eT TOBapHWH He 0 lfHCTO peJIHrH03HbIX lfepTax nOObCKOrO KaTOJIHIJ H3Ma a 0 nOOH­ IJ HH nOJIbCKOii KaTOJIHlfeCKOii U epKBH no OTHoweHHIO K rYMaHHTap­ HbIM H 06weCTBeHHbIM npo6J1eMaM B H nOJIb3yroCb CJlyqaeM lfT06bl CKa3aTb BaM H3BeCTHoe H 6e3 MeHH H AeJIaIO 3TO TOO1 KO nOTOMY 'lT0 Y MeHH eCTb HeCKOJIbKO nOCJle lJ HHe rOAbI HaOOIOJJ aeTC ll aKTHBH38IJ H ll HenpH ll3HH npaB llwHX KpyrOB HallIHX CTpaH no OTHOWeHHIO K u epKBH B03paC­ AeJIOBbIX npeAJIo l eHHii B npoeKTe 3aHBJIeHHH C'be3JJ a rOBOpHTC ll 'lT0 CMbICJlOM COIJ HaJIHCTHlfeCKOro CTpo ll HBJI lleTCH o6ecnelfeHHe rp8 l Aa­ raeT HX Heps03HocTb H3-3a aKTHBHOCTH BepyroWHX Ha 3TO BJIaCTb peHHTerp8IJ HH lfeJIOBeKa KOTOPOMY rapaHTHpoBaH CTaTYC HMYWHe pearHpyroT ewe 60JIbWHM 38 I HMOM peJIHmH YCHJIHJIHCb HHHa fp8 l AaHHH KorA8-TO 3TO 6bIDO CJlaBHbIM peBOJIIOIJ HOHHbIM penpecCHH 38 AeiiCTBHH KOTopbIe B APYI1IX CTpaHaX MHpa C'lHTaIOT­ CH caMO co60ii p83YMeIOWRMC ll qeXOCJlOBaKHH - CTpaHa C H8HJlY1I­ CJlOBOM OHO 03HalfaJIO lfeJIOBeKa BaA KOTOPbIM HHKTO He Mor rocnOACTBOBaT1 6eCKOHTPOJIbHO HO KOTOPbIM MO I HO 6bIDO ynPaB­ WHMH npeAnOCbIDKaMH AJI ll YAOBJIeTBOpHTeJIbHbIX B3aHMOOTHOWe­ JIHTb CTOJIb XHTPOYMHO 'lT06bI Y rp8 lKA8HHHa C03AaBaJIOCb BnellaT­ HHii JIeHHe 'lT0 OH nOlfTH BO BceM nOABJIaCTeH TOJI1 KO caMOMY ce6e• COIJ HaJIHCTHlfeCKoro rocYJJ apCTBa C BepyroWHMH H u ePKBaMH npeBpaTHJIaCb B n030pHyro KOCHyro ctpaHY TIPaBHTeJIbCTBeHHaH l106HTbCH nOJIHTHKa no OTHOWeHHIO K u epKBH JJ aJIa pe3YJIbraTbI 06paTHble OlfeHb H30WpeHHOii CneIJ HaJIbHOCTH KOTOpyIO Ha3bmaroT nOJ1HTH­ HaMepeHHHM ee HHHIJ HaTopoB TIpeCJleAOBaHHH BepyroWRx penpec­ Koii CHH npoTHS HHX YCHJIHBaIOT BHHMaHHe OKPY lKaIOWRX K penHrHH rp8 lKA8HHH - BcerA8 6bID MH pHlfeCKHM nOHHTHeM H npoAOJI lK8eT OCTaBaTbC ll TaKOBbIM H nO lJ HHMaIOT npecTH I BepyroWRx 3TO C03JJ aeT AOnOJIHHTeJIbHbm B Y ynpaBJI lleMbIX TaKoro BnellaTJ1eHHH 6bIJ10 3a alfeii AeiiCTBHTeJIbHOCTH l e nOAImacTHbIii TOJIbKO caMOMY ce6e H BeCbMa cyw eCTBeHHbIii HMIIyJIbC aKTHSH3aIJ HH HHTepeca K penH­ MapKCHCTCKaH KpHTHKa BJIaCTH npoJ1HJIa cseT Ha He H3yqaB­ mH KaK Mbl BRAHM Ha npaKTHKe ad maiorem Dei gloriam T e AlIJI UIHeC ll npe e OTHOWeHH ll Me l A ' npaBHTeJI llMH H c06CTBeHHOCTbIO npoCJlaBJIeHHH MHoro Bora HbIHewmtii pe lKHM CAeJIaJI lIpe3BbfllaiiHO Ha cpeACTBa npoH3BOACTBa 3TO OTKpbITHe OAHOBpeMeHHO C nOHHMa­ HHeM HCTOPHH lfeJIOBelfeCTBa KaK HCTOPHH KJIaCcoBoii 6oPb6bI nOA­ roTOBHJIO nOlfBY AJI ll COIJ HaJIbHOii peBOJIIOIJ HH OT KOTOpoii O lKHJJ aJ1H H HOBoro peweHHH H3BellHoii npoooeMbI BJIaCTH COIJ HaJIbHaH peBO­ JIIOIJ H ll Y Hac 3aBepWHJIaCb ycnexoM a npoooeMa BJIaCTH npoAOJI­ lK8eT cyw eCTBOBaTb MbI CXBaTHJIH 6bIKa 3a pora H Aep lKHM ero HO npH nOM KTO-TO He nepeCTaBa ll IIHHaeT Hac B 3a Y BJIaCTH no Bceii BepoHTHOCTH CHOH HepyUIHMbIe 38KOHO­ MepHOCTH pa3BHTHH H nOBeAeHH ll KTO 6bI Y BJIaCTH HH CTOM 126 127 31'0 OC06blH lfellOBelJeC1 HH q eHOMeH 3aAllHHbIH TeM OCHOBaHHH JJ lIH TaI oro YTBep KJJ eHHH HaI OllJleHHble 3a rOJJ hl pa60­ 'lITO H B llJleMeHaX nepB06blTHblX llIOJJ eH 1 TO-TO JJ OIDKeH OTJJ aBaTb TbI B ra3eTax H Ha Pa lJ Ho 80 BOT JJ 01 a3aTeJIhCrnO COBceM HOBoe npHI a3bl a B co06ru ecrne 6llaropoJJ HbIX 1 TO-TO JJ OllJKeH 1 TOMY JKe 3TOT C'he3JJ C06panCH He B TOT JJ eHb 1 OTOPhIH Bhl6paJIH T fJIeHhl nH­ BnacTb - 31'0 caTellhC1 OH OPraHH3aIJ HH a B MHllOCTHBO Ha3HalJeHHbIH rocno lJ H­ CHryaIJ HH C03AaHHaH TOllb1 O lllO J bMH Dna 3aTpamBaeT H npaBH­ HOM OH KJJ eT eCTeCTBeHHO nOCI Ollb1 Y npHBhl1 1 31'0MY 3a npoIlI­ 0606ru HTb lJ HC1 YCCHIQ H cq OpMYllHpoBaTb BbIBOJJ bI BnaCTb - H npeJJ ­ ru HX H ynpaBllHeMbIX H CTaBHT nOJJ yrP03Y 3JJ opoBbe H Tex H JJ PY­ llble TblCHlJelleTHH 'lITO 3a 31'0 Mbl n01 llOHHMC II ero JJ HHaCTHH mx TblCHlJelleTHHH onblT OTHOIlIeHHH C BllaCTHMH npHBell qellOBe­ llaraIO He I JlaHHTbCH lfeCTBO 1 TOMY qTO lllO lJ H nbITaJIHCb YCTaHOBHTb onpeJJ elleHHble 33 IIBneHHH C'he3JJ a H BhllJep1 Hytb H3 Hero Bce qTO nonaxHBaeT H npeJJ lIaralO eru e pa3 nepeCMOTpeTh Te1 CT Y HapoJJ OB 1 OTOpble B3paCTHllH CBOIO 1 yllb­ npaBHJla npou eJJ YPbI BllaCTH - CHCTeMY q OPMaJIbHOH JJ eM01 paTHH ­ BepHOnOMaHHlJeCTBOM C 06paTHblMH CBH3HMH C 1 OHTpollHpyeMbIMH nepeI JllOlJaTellHMH rypy B YCllOBHX 1 pHTHI H BllaCTh HMYru HX He JJ ellO nHcaTeJIeH OT­ H OrpaHHlfeHHHMH 0JJ HaI 0 B lJeT1 O OlJeplJeHHble MeXaHH3MbI BllaCTH 6paCbIBaTb B CTOpoHY 3TH npaBHJla nOBeJJ eHHH BllJleTaIOTCH HHTepeCbl BllaCTb HMyru HX OCHOBaHHble Ha 1 aJIHTaJIe H npeJJ lIaralO 'llT06b1 1 aJK J bIH 1 TO BhlCtynHT nOClle MeHH Ha Ha BoopyJKeHHH Ha poJJ CTBeHHbIX CBH3HX Ha MOHonOllbHOM npoH3­ C'he3JJ e BHec npeJJ lIOJKeHHe 1 aI peIIIHT npo6rreMY 1 OTOPaH 6ee­ BOJJ CTBe H T JJ flpaBHJla npou e o ypbI He npenHTCTBYIOT 3JlY n03TOMY n01 OHT npe KJJ e Beero ero caMoro flOC1 OJ1b1 Y Mbl cornaCHllHCh Hr· JJ aJKe He3HallHTeJIbHbie CABHrH npH 1 OHCTaTau HH 3TOro q aI Ta Moryr paTb B rpa KJJ aH H yJKe nOllyqeJIH Ha 3TO pa3peIlIeHHe H llJloru 3JJ I y npHBeCTH 1 BYllbrapHOMY yrnep l JJ eHHIO 'lITO HMeHHO q OPMaJIhHaH JJ lI II Hrp pa3 Mbl eru e B TeTleHHe He1 OToporo BpeMeHH 6YJJ eM BblCTy· JJ eM01 paTHH 06YCllOBllHBaeT ITO 3Jl0 80 npaBHJla caMH no ee6e naTb TO JJ aBaHTe 6YJJ eM BeCTH ee6H 1 a1 COBepIlIeHHOlleTHHe H ca· He 6b1BaIOT HH 1 anHTaJIHCTHT feCI HMH HH COIJ HaJIHCTHlJeC1 HMH ­ MOCTOHTellbHble lllO lJ H OHH onpeJJ ellHIOT He'llTO JJ ellaTh a 1 aI npHHHMaTb peIlIeHHH 0 TOM H BblCTynaIO eeHtIaC 1 aI rpa KJJ aHHH rOCYAllpcrna OT 1 OTOpo­ 'lITO JJ ellaTb 3TO rYMaHHoe H306peTeHHe 1 OTopoe no cyru eCTBY ro HH1 orJJ a He HaMepeH OTpelJbCH HO B 1 OTOPOM H He MOry JKHTh H H nOHHMalO H T fJIeH 1 OMMYHHCTH­ YCllOJKHHeT ocyru eCTBlleHHe BllaCTH 3TH npaBHlla 06eperalOT nOJJ ­ 1 aI xoqy BllaCTHhIX HO eCllH BllaCTb pyillHTCH cnaCaIOT H llHIIIeHHbIX BllaCTH 'lITO nonaAalO B OTleHb ru e1 OTllHBOe nOllOJKeHHe HMelO B BHJJ Y rpaJKAllHC1 He npo6rreMbI OT paccTpella CHCTeMa q OPMallbHOH JJ eM01 paTHH He cnoco6CTByeT lJeC1 OH napTHH fl031'0MY H He JJ OllJKeH All H He xoqy rOBOpHTb TBepJJ OCTH npaBHTellhCrn HO o aeT oru yru eHHe 'lITO ClleJJ ylOru ee npa­ 3JJ eCb 0 napmHubIX JJ ellax 80 TaI yJK nOnyqHJIocb 'lITO HeT y Hac BHTellbCTBO MOJKeT 6bITh llyqwe Kor o a npaBHTellhCTBO na o aeT HHTlerO 'lITO Ha TOM HJlH HHOM 31'ane 06CY KJJ eHHH He 6bmo 6b1 pereHepHpyeTcH aI THBHOCTh rpaJKJJ aH a 1 or o a npaBHTellhCTBO HeH3MeHHO HeT rpaiKJJ aHHHa KYJJ a OH HClJe3aeT H He HaMepeH napmH8blM JJ ellOM KaI JKe 6bITh MHe eCllH OHH 06a THH H Moe npaBHTellbCTBO - H MOH nap­ Cp ellaJIH Bee 'llT06hl HX nOBeCT1 H AHH HJJ TH Ha nOBOJJ y y BparOB H 3aHBllHTh 'lITO rpaJKJJ aHHH nonaAlleT Ha CJlHJlHCb Boep HHO JIHTlHO H CllHTalO lJTO ITO BpeJJ HO H J Jl II napTHH llJlaxy TaI aH CYJJ h6a nOCTHrlla llHIIIh HeC1 OllhI O JJ eCHT1 OB HJlH H JJ lIH npaBHTellhCTBa 3TO co3 o aeT OlJeHb CllOJKHQe nOllOJKeHHe COTeH HaIlIHX rpaiKAllH H JJ lIH Hac C06paBIIIHXCH 3p eCb rpaJKAllH 1J neHbI napTHH He HMeIOT 80 H JJ py3hH nOHHMaIOT 'lITO 3HallHT na o eHHe rpaJKAllHHHa npaBa Bl IC1 a3bIBaTbCH 0 caMbIX Hacyru HbIX npo6rreMaX 0 60neBbix nOToMY 'lITO 3a 3THM clleJJ yeT BnaJJ aHHe Bcero HapOAll B aTMocq epy TOlJI aX nepep 6ecnapmHHbIMH a 6ecnapIHHHble He HMelOT p ocryna CTpaxa nOJIHTHlJeC1 OH anaTHH H rpaJKJJ aHC1 OH naCCHBHOCTH T e Ha co6paHHH rJJ e TOllb1 O H HMeeT CMbICll 3TH npo6rreMbl 06cyJKAllTb B 06CTaHOB1 Y B 1 OTOPOH rocnoJJ crnYIOT nOBeeJJ HeBHble 3a60Tbl fl03TOMY H Te H p pyme orpaHHqeHbI B CBoeH q YHAaMeHTaJIbHOH H MeJlI He u ellH HapoJJ nona o aeT B 3aBHCHMOCTh OT Bce 6ollbiliero CBo60JJ e - lIHClla Bee MeHbIIIHX rocnoJJ B nOJJ qHHeHHe naCTOllh1 O HOBoro B03MOJKHO 3TO npoTHBopelJHT CT He06hltIHOrO rnna 'lITO ero TpyJJ HO 06'hHCHHTh rOCTHM H3 JJ pyrOH JKe lJ HCUHllllHHHpoBaHHO COHJJ y Ha rpaJKAllHC1 oe nOlle H 6y o y rOBO­ CTpaHbl MHe JJ yMaeTCH 'lITO y HaC yJKe HeT rpaJKJJ aH 128 Y MeHH eCTb rOBOpHTb JJ pyr C p pyroM 1 aI paBHble C paBHblMH pHTb TOllh1 O 0 npaBHTellbcTBe A 20 HaweH KOHCTHtyUHH 80 II Bee B Tex CJIYTlaHX 1 or o a 3TO CllOBO 129 OK3 eTC s Hea u eKBaTHbIM H HcrrOJIh3YIO TepMHH rrpaB s IJJ He KPym · HaA ypoBHeM MOP s CTpyKTYPbl HaCeJIeHWl a HH Ha 'ITO HHoe HaII­ 3TO Ha u e Kl bIH 'aBHHIIIHHH TepMHH 6yJJY IH HeCKOJIbKO HeOrrpe e­ poTHB peaKHHH anrrapaTa Ha Bee 3TH q aKTOPbl OJI lKHa 6 b1Tb a6co­ JIeHHbIM OH Bee lKe 60JIee TOllHO Orrpe emIeT cyn eJIa ITo ' 3THM 1IIOTHO H J eHTHlIHOH - TepMHHOM rrO J J1HHHOH yHHq HUHpOBaThCH 0 OAROH H rrpa 3TOM caMOH rrpOCTOH MO ella BJIaCTbIO He3aBHCHMO OT HOMHHaJIbHblX 'OJ1 lKHOCTeH Te 'ijb s BJIaCTb BnacTb H30JIHpyeTcH a 3T0 TO lKe 3aKOHOMepHo OHa y lKe He '3a8HTe­ 3H lK l H1IaCb H3 aBHa Ha rrO pa3YMeBaJIHCb ooraTCTBe po CTBeHHbIX o6JJa u aTeJIH CB H3 s X MOHOrrOJIbHOM rrpoH3BO CTBe 06JJa u aHHH opy lKHeM H T A ITo ' 3THM TepMHHOM rrpHcrroco6aTb 3TH HOBbIe ycrrOBH H K eeOO peCOBaHa B rro J J ep lKKe - BJIaCTb OllHpaeTCH Ha caMoe ee6H lleHTp sa rrepHq epHIO H HaOooPOT OHH MoryT rrOJIHOCTbIO rr01l0 lKHTbCH rrOHHMaJIOCb H MOryIJJ eCTBO TeX KTO rrpaBHJ1 3a 3aKpblTblMH ABep s ­ a H BbIay lK J eHbl rrOJIaraTbc s pyr Ha Apyra rrOCKOJIbKY COCTaB­ MR rrOJIyqaJJ C006IJJ eHWl HO'ijbIO Qepe3 CrreHHaJIbHoro Kypbepa KTO 1IHIOT laMKHyTbIH Kpyr HHKoro He1lb3H BblpBaTb H3 3Toro Kpyra 3HaJI HHq OPMaIJ HIO H3 KynyapoB 3aKJIIO'IaJI COfJIalIleHWl eIJJ e o TO­ H HHKoro H3 3Toro Kpyra He BbmYCKaIOT BHyTpeHHHe palHOfJIaCH H ro KaK OHH Ha'IHHaJIH 06cY lK J aTbC s H KTO rrpHHHMaJI 3aKOHbI rro H OIIIH6KH BHyTpH lKe a JIHKBHAHPYIOTC H 3aTeM HaCTyrraeT crreAYIOIUHH nan KOTOPbIH aHorna orrpeAe­ KOTOPblM eIJJ e He rrpOllIJIO rOJIOCOBaHHe B rrapJIaMeHTe HCTOPH H HallIHX ABYX Hapo 'OB rrpHBeJIa HaC K COHHaJJH3MY HalIle rocynapcT­ JIHIOT BO rrocrre BTOPOH MRPOBOH BOHHbI BOCCTaHOBHJ10Cb KaK e J HHbIH B1IaCTb KaK 31an C03 'aHHH J HHaCTHH B 6JJarorrpHHTHbIH MOMeHT rrOJIHTHqeCKHH OpraHH3M e J HHCTBeHHOH 3a u aqeH KOToporo 6bIJ10 o jlOPMHTb rr01l0 lKeHHe BJIaCTa KOHCTHTYHHOHHbIM 3aKOHOM qTO 6101 C03bmaeT 3aKOHOnaTeJIbHoe co6paHHe H rr03BOJIHeT eMY Be J b eHCTBHTeJIbHO HH rrpeAIIpHHHMaJIa B1IaCTh BrrOCJIe CTBHH OHa AeJlaeT no B COOTBeT­ eCJIH a6CTparapOBaThC s OT qaCTHOCTeH 3T0 6bIJIO e J HHCTBeHHOH CTBHH C KOHCTHTYHHeH ITOCKOJlbKY He rrpoTH lKeHHH eCHTH ABaAUa­ OpraHH30BaTb CTpoHTemCTBO COHHaJIH3Ma lleJIbIO rrpoB03fJIalIlaBmeHc s rrocrre 1945 r O J HHM H3 AeKJIapHpo­ TH IIHTH ec s TH 1IeT BJIaCTh He CTaBHT 3TOT Borrpoc Ha rrOBeCTKY AHH BaHHbIX aTpH6yTOB HOBOH BJIaCTH 6bIJ10 e J HHCTBO rrpaBHIJJ Hx H yrr­ a rro KOHCTHTYHHH HHKTO KpoMe BJIaCTH ero rrOCTaBHTb He MO lKeT paBJI s eMbIX KaK - BepHee HX TO lK J eCTBeHHOCTb - TO lK J eCTBeHHOCTb rro KOHCTHTYHHa - HHKTO KpoMe B1IaCTH He MO lKeT C03BaTh 3aKOHOnaTeJlbHOe c06paHHe TO KOHCTHTYHHOHHbIM rryTeM YCTaHaB­ rrpaBHTemcTBa H Hapona· SI eIJJ e pa3 Bepaycb K TOMY 'ITO s J yMaIO 0 xapaKTepe JIIOooH JIHBaeTCH BJIaCTH BH 'OH3MeHeHHe BJIaCTH H ee MaHepa orrpe eJI s IOTC H BayT­ rrOCKOJIbKY OHa coxpaa s eT O J HH HO BeCbMa CyIJJ eCTBeHHbIH eMOK­ J HHaCTHH 3TO J HHaCTH H HCTOpaqeCKH HOBoro THIIa peHHHMH 3aKOHaMH BJIaCTH H 3TH 3aKOHbl He MO lKeT H3MeHHTb HH paTHqeCKHH rrpaHUHII K HeH MO lKeT rrpacoe J HHHTbCH K3 J bIH KTO CTo s IJJ a s y BJIaCTH JIHlIHOCTb HH 3aXBaTHBmHH BJIaCTb KJIaCC rrOTOMY B 310M 3aHHTepeCOBaH DJlarOnapH 310MY rrpHHHHny J HHaCTHH He 'ITO 3T0 rrpoCTO laKOHOMepHOCTb qeJIOBeqeCKOrO rrOBe eHH s B orr­ MO lKeT BblMepeTb HH rro lKeHCKOH HH rro My lKCKOH JIHHHH pe 'eJIeHHOH cHTyaUHH y BJIaCTH ITepBblM 3aKOHOM JIIOooH BJIaCTH Hac 60JIbme Beero HHTepecyeT OAHH H3 BHyTpeHHHX 3aKOHOB COBepmeHHO KOHKpeTHbIH HeO lJ HOKpamO OllHcaHHbIii HBJI s eTC s CTpeMJIeHHe BJIaCTb HMyIJJ HX COXpaHHTb ee BJIacTh BOC­ BJIaCTH - rrpoH3BO J HTC s BO Bee OOJIee TOllHOM CBoeM BH J e BO-BTOPbIX OHa JIHTepaTYpoH H Bcerna OAHHaKOBblH 3aKOH Bbloopa rrpH6JJH lKeHHbIx rrOCTO HHHO rOMoreHH3HpyeTC s 0'lHIJJ a He OT Beero qy lKepo lJ Horo '0 Tex rrop rrOKa K3 J bIH meMeHT BJIaCTH He CTaHOBHTC s TOllHOH BnacTb Beerna OT J aeT rrpeAIIO'ITeHae TeM KTO COOTBeTCTByeT eH rro KOlIHeH BJIaCTH Boo6IJJ e rrOKa Bee ee meMeHTbl He CTaayT B3aHMO­ q HHHTe OHa BbIHY lK J eHa HCrrOJlh30BaTb H ApyrHX rrpHcrroca6JJHBa H 3aMeH s eMbIMH rrOKa rrepHq epHHHa H KJIeTKa He CMO lKeT 3aMeHHTb HX K CBOHM rroTpe6HOCT s M Iln s rrpHcrry lKHBaHHH BJlaCTH rrpHrOAHbI COooH lleHTp H rrOKa 3TH rrepHq epHHHble KJIeTKH He CMOryT B3aHMo­ eCTeCTBeHHO CTpeM HIJJ Hec s K BJIaCTH 3aTeM - '3aMeH HTbC s 003 HapymeHH H e s TeJIbHOCTH arrrrapaTa BJIaCTH Anna­ paKTepy 1IIO J H C He'IHCTOH COBeCThIO JIIO J H y KOTOPblX CTpeMJIe­ paT B1IaCTH q yHKHHOHHpyeT 003 OTKJIOHeHHH rrOTOMY 'ITO rro CyTH HHe K 6JJarOrr01lY'IHIO ycrrexaM B Kapbepe H rrpH6bIJ1a CBoeH OH He 01l lKeH pearnpoBaTb Ha H3MeHeHHe Cpe bl BblCOTbl BaIOT HpaBCTBeHHble 6apbepbl BJIaCTb rrpaClloca6JJHBaeT Ha crry lK6y BHyTpeHHeMY YCTpoHCTBY O lJ HaKO rrOTOMY 'ITO TaKHe Beerna B e­ rrocrrymHbIe rro xa­ rrpeo OJIe­ eeOO JlIO eH TPYCJ1HBbIX a TaK lKe ay lK J aIOIJJ HXCH paHee YHH lKeHHbIX 130 131 KoropDIe lJ OBeplIHBO npHHHMaIOr npe lJ lIO lKeHHe npH06umncJI K BJIaCTH H npocro mynblX Ha onpe lJ eJIeHHOe BpeMJI npH OC06blX 06cTOJlreJIbCTBaX H lJ lIJI cneUHaJIbHbIX 38 lJ a'l HCnOJIb3yrorCJI raK I e BblCOKOMOpanbHDIe H OOCKopb1CTHDIe HO He lJ OCrarO'lHO HHq 0PMH­ poBaHHble 3HTy3HaCrhl K KOrOpblM OTHOmYCb H JI B nponecce npH­ cnoco6JIeHHJI raKHX JIlO lJ eH npHMeHJIIOTCR CTaphle cpe lJ CTBa Mare­ pHaJIbHble H nyxoBHhIe co6JIa3HDI yrpo3a CTpa u aHHJI C03 lJ aHHe KOMDpoMeTHpyroumx CHryaUHH Hcnonh30BaHHe lJ OHOC'lHKOB JIIO­ lJ eH oKpJ I aIOr arMocq epoH HeOOOCHOBaHHOH nO lJ 03pHreJIbHOCTH 'leMY OHH crapalOrcJI npoTHBOCrOJlrb lJ eMOHCTpaUHeH JIOJIJIbHOCTH HX or lJ aIOr Ha MBJIOCTb H HeMBJIOCTh nO lJ lIel aM H 3areM JIHI eMepHO BbI3BOJIJllOr C03 u aerCJI 06cTaHOBKa Bceo6mero He lJ OBepHJI CaMO H TaKHe enOBa KaK npe lJ CTaBHTeJIb 3IlIUHTHHK ITYCThIM crano CllOBO lJ BH I eHHe Kor u a Bee HenO lJ BHX HO BbIJ1H pa30pBaHbI CBJI­ 3D Ha KOTOPbIX OCHOBbIBaJIaCh nyXOBHaJI CTPYKTYpa H KYJIbrypa Ta­ KHX 06w HOCTeH JIIO lJ eH KaK lJ epeBHH 3aBO lJ bI neXH 1iH'lT0 J l e He HeCllO Ha ceOO Orne1 'aTOK HH lJ HBH nyaJIbHOrO TBop'leCTBa 113 illKon 6bIJ1H H3rHaHbI npenO lJ aBaTenH DhITaBillHeCR GhIn ne lJ aToraMH 6bIJ1H YBOJIeHhI lJ HpeKTopa 3aBO lJ OB KpHTH'leCKH BblCKalbmaBillHeCJI no BonpoCaM BbIXO lJ HBillHM 3a paMKH HX npe lJ DpHJITHJI GbIJ1H pac­ nyw eHbI KyJIbrypHhIe H cnopTHBHhle om ej HHeHHR npe lJ CTaBJIJlBillHe J JI onpe lJ enemlOro enoJl nlO lJ eH BeHbJlMHH KrrH'lKa B apKe He DHcan ITOMHH 'lT0 lJ OBepHe COpTHpyroT Ha lJ OBepHe nepBoH BTOPOH rpeneH Karero­ pHH npH'leM Macee JIIO lJ eH Bo06w e He OKa3hmaeTCJI HHKaKOrO lJ o­ BepHJI 11 HHq OPMaI HJI lJ eJIHTCJI no Ka'leCTBY - Ha P030BOH 6yMare Ha 3eJIeHOH Ha l eJITOH H Ha raleTHOH CMex B 38JIe To 'lT0 JI rOBOpUJI 0 xapaKrepe BJIaCTH HMeer CaMoe 06w ee 3Ha'leHHe H lJ a I e He HMelO B BH uy BJIaCTb B COUHaJIHCTH'leCKOM roCY lJ apCTBe nOCKOJIbKY nOIDITHe COUHaJIH3M CBJl3bIBalOr C HaY'l­ HbIM PYKOBO lJ CTBOM A HaY'lHaJI TeOpHJI COI HaJIH3Ma Be lJ b npoCTo HeMbIenHMa 003 H3yqeHHR nCHXOJIOrnH BJIaCTH KaK HeB03MOX H0 ee pa3paOOTan 003 q UJIOCOq HH nonHTH'leCKOH 3KOHOMHH H COUHO­ JIOrnH TaK B HeH lJ OJIX Ha 6bITb HHKOpnopHpoBaHa H nCHXOJIOrM BJIaCTH HCnOJIb3yroW aJI lJ OCTH lKeHHJI nCHXOJIOrnH JIH'lHOCTH H 06­ w eCTBa nCHXOaHanH3a H nCHXOnarOJIOrnH H He OCTaHaBJIHBalOCh OT lJ enhHO Ha Bonpoee KJIaCCOBOro xa­ paKrepa BJIaCTH nOTOMY 'lT0 3ro 0 lJ HH H3 acneKTOB npo6JIeMhI BJIaCrH Boo6w e Y HaC 6bID npoBe lJ eH orGop JIIO lJ eH no KpHTepHIO HX npHrO lJ ­ HOCTH norpe6HOCTJlM BJIaCTH• uOBepHe npoJIBJIHIOT K JIIO lJ JIM noc­ JIYillHblM Koropble He C03 lJ a1OT TpY lJ HOCTeH He 3a u aIOT BonpoCOB ITPH Ka I lJ OM oroope OOJIhme O'lKOB nonyqan 'leJIOBeK nocpe lJ CTBeH­ HbIH a CXO lJ HJ1H co cu eHbI JIIO lJ H enOX Hble 06aJlreJIbHble KOTO­ pble 6JIaro u aPJl CBOHM Ka'leCrBaM H CBoeH lJ eJITeJIbHOCTH CTaHOBH­ JIHCb HeHa3BaHHhIM 3raJIOHOM nopHJJ O'lHOCTH COBeCTblO 06w eCTBa C nOJIHrH'leCKOH apeHbI HCqe3aJIH JIIO lJ H C qyBCTBOM IOMOpa JIIO lJ H C C06cTBeHHbIMH H lJ eJlMH ITorepJIJIo 3Ha'leHHe enOBOCO'leTaHHe nOJIHTHK-MbICJ1HTenh npeeMCTBeHHOCTh HCTOpHH HX lJ epeBHH o6JIaCTH H rocy u apCTBa cnOCOGHOCTb - MY lTO lJ ep30CTh 3TO oCKop6JIeBBe Ha1 'aJ1bHHKa H nOTO­ Mox elID RJIH He MO lKeIID ocraBaHCJI mynee 6peBH3 H Tor u a GY lJ eillb X HTh 6JIaronOJIY'lHO H lJ onro H He lJ Onx eH GhIJ1 lJ aX e 3a­ 'lHTbIBaTh 3TO no GYMaX Ke JI Mory 3ry q palY nOBTOpHTh HaH3YCTh nOTOM ' 'lT0 JI rOBOplO ITO CaM ee6e nocrommo 3THM enOBaM Gonee copoKa neT H OTHOCHJ1HCb OBB K oGw eCTBY lJ 0 peBOJIJOUHH Ho Tonb­ KO noene Hee OBB npH06penH illHpoKoe 3HalleHHe H MYApocn enOB KrrH'lKH Mor Ha coGCTBeHHoM ODhITe npoBepHTb Ka I lJ bIH Bbl 06pa· THJ1H BHHMaHHe 1lTO Bee Mbl qeXH H enOBaKH nonaraeM 'lT0 Ha pa­ oore HaMH Beer u a pyKOBO lJ JlT JIIO lJ H MeHee cnocoGHhIe lleM Mhl 11 Bee MbI C06HpaRCh B KOMDaHHJIX THXO X aJIyeMCJI Ha lTO 3TO OTBpaTHTenbHO nOTOMY 'lT0 HapJIAY C TeMH y KOro B03MO I H0 ecn nOBO lJ I aJlOBaThCR pyraIOTCJI H OO3 u apHhIe JIeHTJIH He lJ OY'lKH H npocro JIIO lJ H CllaGhIe nyXOM 11 OHH KpHllaT 'lT0 He HMelOT B03­ MOX HOCTH He HMelOT npaBa OGpalOBanOCh q aJIhIIIHBOe H Bpe lJ Hoe e lJ HHCTBO JIIO lJ eH Korophre He HMeJl HH'lero o6mero lJ pyr C lJ py­ roM om e lJ HHeHbI HeBH lJ HMbIM CBJI3yrow HM Bew eCTBOM - oGw HM HeCMOTpJl Ha pa3J1H1JHe MOTHBOB OTBpaw eBBeM J1ro lJ H npaKTHqeCKHe HamJIH lJ J1JI eeGJI lJ OnonHHTenbHoe none lJ eJITeJIbHOCTH HenpaKTH'lHhIe qeHHKa TpHeyTCJI Ha lJ CBOHM opeonoM MY­ Ha JIHTepaTypHoM pbIHKe CTaJIa MO lJ HOH lJ enpeCCM nyXOB­ HbIH pa3BpaT HHrHJ1H3M Opm II CHOOOB TaK H YMHbIH qenOBeK CTa­ Her lJ ypaKOM Ho HHor u a B HeM npoJIBJIJlerc II HHCTHHKT CaMOCOX­ paueHHR - H Tor u a eM ' XO'lerc II lJ aBaTh nOw e1lHHhl HaneBO H Han­ paBO ITOTOM nOCMOTpHT HaBepX - KTO croHT H8 lJ HHM B3rJIJlHeT BHH3 H YBH lJ HT 'lT0 H HaXO lJ lIIl HeC II BHH3Y MOry OKa3aThC II H8 lJ HHM H cnpOCHT Bo l e MOH 3a 'lT0 lTO 132 133 TIOnyMaHTe BOT y Ke B TetIeHHe armaTH neT HaH60JIbIImX MO l HO npaB lJ a lJ OrOBOpHTbCJl lITO no lJ HayqHbIM MHPOB033peHHeM ycnexoB lJ OCTHraIOT Te y Koro HaHMeHblU81I conpoTHBnJleMOCTb K nOHHMaeTCJl onpe lJ eneHHbIH Ha60p Te3HCOB HO TOr lJ a B03HHKaeT pa3Bpary conyrcTByrow eMY BnaCTH TIOnyMaHTe TOJIbKO JIIO lJ H C tJ IlyrOH Bonpoc He JlBnJleTCJl nH Hawe rOCY lJ apCTBO lJ OKTpHHap­ xpynKOH COBeCTbIO He B COCTOJlHHH HaHTH nO lJ lJ ep Kl Y 3aKOHa HbIM a He HaY'IHO ynpaBJIJleMbIM KaK BepOJlTHO nonaranH 3aKOHO­ nOMolUb co CTOPOHbI BnaCTH KOTOpaJI B COOTBeTCTBHH C 6YKBOH 3a­ lJ aTeJIH KOHa 06Jl3aHa HX 3aw HlUaTb ECRH rOBopHTb 0 6YKBe 3aKOHa TO Moero BwcrynneHHJl C03 l aeTCJl BnetIarneHHe lITO lJ eHCTBYIOW Hii Haoop npaa 06Jl3aHHOCTeH KOTOPbIH CJIy KHT ew e O l HH npHMep Henocpe lJ CTBeHHo KacaIOw HHCJl TeMbI CTaTbJI Y HaC lJ eHCTBHTenbHO cyw eCTByeT H H 28 KOHCTHTyunH rOBopHT B COOTBerCTBHH C HHTe­ pecaMH TpYWlW erOCJl Hapo lJ a BeeM rpa lJ aHaM rapaHTHpyeTCJl CBo­ CBo60 lJ HOMY BeeCTopoHHeMY pa3BHTHIO H npHMeHeHHIO cnoco6­ 6o l a BbICKa3bmaHHJl BO Bcex o6JIaCTJIX 06w eCTBeHHoH lKH3HH H B HOCTeR rpa lJ aH H O lJ HOBpeMeHHO YKpenneHHIO H pa3BHTHIO COUHa­ lIaCTHOCTH cBo60 l a CJIOBa H nelIaTH JIHCTHlleCKOro 06w eCTBa CT H 19 KOHCTHTyunH t CCP Pa60Tas B ra3eTax H Ha pa l Ho Jl y6e lJ HJICJl lITO B lJ eHCTBHTeJIb­ ee6e JIH'IHO CtIHTalO lITO nepetIHCJIeHHbIe CBo60 lJ bI y Ke caMH no CJIyxcaT HHrepecaM TpyWIlUHXCJl n03TOMY l aHHbm OooPOT Hoem rpa lJ aHe OtIeHb pe lJ KO rOBOPJIT 0 co6JIIO lJ eHHH CBOHX KOHCTH­ COBepmeHHo H3JIHlUeH 60JIee Toro OH BHOCHT HeJlCHOCTb npe lJ oc­ ryu HOHHbIX npaB nOTOMY lITO nI060H annapaTtIHK - TaBnJlJl KOMY yrO lJ HO TpaKToBaTb lITO BbIpaX aeT HHTepecbI TpYM­ l axce nepncllepHHHbIx OpraHOB BnaCTH - npe lJ CTaBHTenb Moxcer nOCTaBHTb no HX w eroCJl HaPO l a H nyMaIO lITO cneUHanHCT eCJIH 6bI OH Hcnonb30­ npaBo B 3aBHCHMOCTb OT 06cTOJlTeJIbCTB H YCJIOBHH KOTopbIe He Ban 3TO BbIpIDKeHHe Cllen 6w He06xo l HMbIM nepe'IHCJIHTb lITO B HH­ YKa3aHbI H He MOryT 6bfIb YKa3aHbI B KOHCTHTyunH Tepecax TpYWIlUeroCJl HaPO l a a lITO 3THM HHTepecaM npoTHBopetIHT B nOCJIe lJ Hee BpeMJl Jl lIaCTO 3afJIJl lJ bman B KOHCTHTYUHIO H npHlUeJI K BbIBO tJ Y lITO 3TO HeY lJ a'IHO coCTaBneHlihIH lJ OKyMeHT H HMeHHO n03TOMY OH nOTepJIJI aBTOpHTeT Y rpaxc tI aH H OpraHH3a­ UHH C TOtIKH 3peHHJl CTHJIJl 3TO MHOrOCJIOBHbIH lJ OKYMeHT npHtIeM a cKpynyne3HbIH 3aKOHO l aTenb Boo6w e nOcrapanCJl 6bI H36e Kan TaKOrO nepetIHCJIeHHJl JlH'IHO Jl npe lJ DOllen 6bI naKOHHtIHyIO cIl0pMynHpoBKY CO lJ ep­ X aHHe KOTOPOH He BbI3bmano 6bI COMHem TonbKO KOPOTK81I CJIHlUKOM lleTK81I cIl0pMynHpoBKa npH UileT 3aKOHaM xapaKTep pacnpoCTpaHeH­ ryMaHHbI TIpHBen y npHMep KOTOPbIH OTHOCHTCJl K ccIlepe YMCTBeH­ HOH Hapo tl HOH MY lJ POCTH TOJIbKO TaKas cIl0pMynHpoBKa OCTaeTCJl Horo TpY lJ a H 60nblUe lJ pyrnx KacaeTCJl lJ eJITenbHOCTH HalUero B C03HaHHH H lJ eHCTByer HaCTOJIbKO cIleKTHBHo lITO IJ lJl o6ecne­ HeKOTopbIe HCKJIIOtIHTeJIbHO COI03a IllIcaTeneH CT 16 BIDKHbIe cIl0pMynHpoBKH KOHCTHTyunH ccIlOpMynHpoBaHa CJIelJYIO IUHM o6pa30M KynbryPHas nOJIHTHKa pa3BHTHe 06pa30BaHHJl BOCIIHTaHHe H 06yqeHHe Be tJ YTCJl B t exoCnOBaKHH B nyxe HaY'IHOrO MHPOB033pe­ HHJl MapKCH3Ma-neHHHH3Ma H B TeCHOM KOHTaKTe C KH3HbIO H pa60­ TOH nIO lJ eH Ka lJ bm XOPOIllHH ne l afor CtIHTaeT CaMO co60H pa3YMeIOIUHM­ CJl lITO BOCIIHTaHHe Hepa3pbmHo CBJl3aHO C TpY lJ OM H lKH3HbIO HO BCe-TaKH MHe HeJlCHO KaKOR opraH H KaKOH CY lJ 6Y lJ eT npHHHMaTb pelUeHHe 0 HaY'IHOM xapaKTepe Toro HJIH HHoro MHPOB033peHHJl Kor lJ a yxce caMO nOHJlTHe B3fJIJl lJ OB B HflYKa OXBaTbmaeT lJ BHXCeHHe H 3BonIOUHIO COOTBeTCTBHH C Bee paCIllHpJlIOIUHMCJl n03HaHHeM H KOr l a 3TOT lJ HHaMH3M HaYKH npoTHBOpetIHT HeH3MeHHOCTH H 0 lJ ­ H03Ha'IHOCTH 134 tIeHHJl npaBa Her naxce Ha lJ 06HOCTH B CY lJ ax H3bIKOBaJI Ke He6pexc­ HOCTb nOHJlrHH onpe lJ eneHHbIX npaBOBbIMH HOPMaMH HeTO'IHOCTb MbIlliJIeHHJl o6yCJIOBIlllBaIOT HeB03MOXCHOCTb Ha6JIIO lJ aeMbIe ee B co6JIlO lJ eHHJl KOHCTHTYUHH TeM caMbIM BbIClU81I npaaOB81I HopMa OCTaeTCJl nHllib lJ 06pbIM HaMepeHHeM H nporpaMMoH HO He ITpH3HaHHbIM rapaHTOM npaa rp8 K llaHHHa KOHCTHTyruut lJ 0JI l Ha OTBetIan TeM Ke TpeooBaHHJlM lITO H nlO60H lJ pyrOH npaBOBOH lJ OKYMeHT C TOH JlHlIIb pa3mm eii lITO HHKaKHe nO lJ tIHHeHHbIe eH HOPMbI npe lJ DHcaHHJl YCTaBbI nOCTaHOBJIeHHJl l HpeKTHBbI He lJ on l HbI KOHCTHryu H1O HH orpaHHtIHBan HH lJ enaTb HeJlCHOH H BbICKa3an CBoe MHeHHe 0 xapaKTepe pa3BHTHH H nOBe lJ eHHH BJIaCTH Boo6w e H CTapaJICJl nOKa3aTb lITO KOHTponHpyroIUHe MaCTb MexaHH3MbI nO OWlT H n03TOMY rpa lJ aHHH He TonbKO Te· pJleT yB HHe K caMOMY ee6e HO H 06'beKTHBHO yrpatIHBaeT 135 CTaryc rpa a Kor u a TaKOe nOJIO KeHHe WIHTCR YaK AOnrO pRTCS 0 npasunax MHpHOro cocyruecmOBaHHR llHcaTenu - nIOAH KaK y HaC OHO eCTeCTBeHHO HaKna tn maeT Ome'laTOK Ha C03HaHHe npaBRlUHe KpyrH TO l e COCTO l1T Hl nIOAeH EcnH KTO-nH60 H3 Hac MHorex nIOAeH Ha MHpoB033peHHe MonOAoro nOKOneHH I1 KOTopoe cnyqaHHO OKa l eTCR B opraue nOnHmqeCKOH Bnacm H nepe I HBeT HH B yqe6Hl IX 3aBeAeHWIX HH Ha npaKTHKe He Y3Hano lITO qenOBe­ BHYTpeHHIOIO nOJIRpHlaIJ HIO OH 6YAeT BOeBaTb caM C C060H CB060­ 'IleCTBO BeKaMH xnonOqeT 06 YCraHOBnemm cOBeplUeHHoH AeMoKpa­ AonI06HBhIH qenOBeK qenOBeK HeCKonbKO 3rOHCTH'IlHhIH 06ecnOo THH EcnH no nOnO KeHHe He H3MeHHTC I1 H B AanbHeHlUeM H eCl1H He KoeHHhIH TeM cpa60TaIOT 3aIJ U1THl Ie peaKIUfH nIOAeH TO B 6y u yn HX nOKoneHWIX OKpY l aIOruero MHpa qenOBeK C03HaIOIUHH cnO KHOCTb npo6neM HO 'llT06hl He OCKBepHHTh ee6 11 6onblUe qeM rpR3hIO H3MeHHTC I1 caM xapaKTep HaIIIHX HapOAOB CKenmqeCKOe Kynbryp­ Me'IITaIOIUHH 0 TOM 'IlT06hl OHH CTanH npoCThIMH TO eCTh nOlT Hoe co06rueCTBO llIOAeH 3aMeHHT nerKO ynpaBnHeMOe HaceneHHe roc­ unH MY3hIKaHT B OpraHhl rocy u apCTBeHHOH BUaCTH He BoiiAeT nOAcmOBaTh HaA KOTOphIM 6hInO 6hI HaCl1 HHeM H IJ IR HHOCT­ llOlT-MHHHCTP no nHlUh rpaIJ H03Hl IH peBepauc Bnacm pam t a He CTOunO cyeTHThC I1 ThIC I1qy neT 'llT06hl AOHm AO KH3HH lAeCh 0 HeCOBMeCTHMOCTH a He 0 Bpa I Ae6Hocm PaCCKa K ' BaM 'lITO npoH30llInO co MHOH TaKoii llOCKOJIhKY HHKTO H3 HaC He POAHllCR An I1 Toro 'llT06hI n03BO­ H rOBOpIO 3a nOCl1eA He ABa AHR R HeCKOnbKO pas BCllOMHHan 3TOT cnyqaH B MapTe npOllInoro rOAa R KaK 'llneH peA­ nHTh nerKO ynpaBllRTh co60H R npeMaraIO lIT06hI COI03 nucaTeneii KOJIJIerHH raseThI JIHTepapHH HOBHHhI 6bITh MO KeT B coTpyrom'llecme C C0I030M K 'pHanHCTOB H APYrHMH 3eTa - TBOpqeCKHMH cOI03aMH npeMo Kun AKaAeMHH HayK qCCp npoBec­ 1lJIR Tn lKcnepTH3y KOHcmryr um H B Cl1yqae He06xoAHMOCTH paspa60­ CTonOM HanPOTHB ceKpeYapR J1HTeparypHas ra­ PeA 6hIn Ha 3aeeA8HHH oTAena HAeonorHH Hac 3TO 3aceAaHHe 3aKOHt HllOCb He6narononytIHo UK Aup KH UK I IN H CHAen 3a feHApuxa TaK 'lITO BHAen TaTb peKoMeH J ar um no ee H3MeHeHHIO AAaAeMHH HaYK qCCp MOo He ero KOHryPhI KaK 6bmano B npollInOM a nHll O - nHll O M ' I tIHHhI KeT HanpHMep nopyqHTh CBOHM 'llneHaM noceruaTh BO BpeMR npeA­ HaMHoro CTaplUe MeHR HacTonbKO craplUe lITO C HHM KaK MeH1l C06PaHHR H AOMa R AOJI I eH 6hIn 6hl n03AopoBaThCR nepBhlM 3TO 6hInO nOA HMaTh Ha HHX 3TOT Bonpoc H Clloco6cmOBaTh TOMY lIT06hI nHIJ 0 qenOBeKa KOTOPhIH nepeCTan 6hlTh M I1 MeHH HHCTHtyTOM CTORlUeii H36HpaTenhHOH KaMIIaHHH npeABhI60pHhIe nIOAH Ha BbI60pHhIX noCTaX AeiicTBOBanH B nOJIHOM coomeTCTBHH npeBpaTHBIIIHCh B KorO-TO y Koro KaK H Y MeHR eCTh 3a60ThI - no C KOHCTHTyl HeH MO KHO nOCTynHTh H HHaqe IH H3 HaC MO KeT AOMY no pa60Te BOlMO l l O H ApyrHe HaaepHRKa H 3a60ThI Y He BCTpeTHThCR co CBOHM AenyTaTOM H nonpoCUTh ero BhIABHH 'Th ro Cl10 l l ee MOHX H l HBeT OH C HHMH AonhlUe Bonpoc 0 KOHcmTyIUfH B nap1laMeHTe BhlCTynan Tor u a H H He OqeHh y u atIHO nhlTancs rOBopHTh COBeplUeHHO OTKPhITO H OTK­ BhlCTynaH eeH'laC nepeA BaMn 11 He HCnhIThIBaIO Toro qyBCTBa pOBeHHO HO nyrancR H OTCTynan MHe Kasanoch lITO OHH npHllHCbI­ CBo60AhI KOTOpoe 06hltIHO OXBaThmaeT qenOBeKa Kor u a OH CB060A­ BaIOT 3TO APYrHM MOTHBaM 0 qeM-TO OHH Bee BpeMH lUenranuCh HO rOBopHT lITO AYMaeT Y MeHR CKopee oruyrueHHe lITO HO TpycnHBO HCnOJIh3YIO MOMeHT nepeMHpHH R AOBOJIh­ Me r OM 11 nOqyBCTBOBan 6ecnOMOIUHOCTb H 3TO O'lleHl yHH I ano MeHR KorAa R BepHyncR AOMOH TO KpoMe paCTpellaHHhIX MhlCl1eH 0 TOM UK H BnaCThIO 3nOynOTpe6n l1IO TeM lITO B 3m rom 3aHrphmaIOT C nuca­ 'lITO npoH30llInO B TenRMH H APYrHMH TBOpqeCKHMH pa60THHKaMH KaK Aonro TaKOe BOlMO KHO He MhICl1b a 6ecnOKoIOruee OruYlUeHHe KOTopoe Meruano BpeM I1 npOMHTCR HeH3BeCTHO B03MO KHO AO 3HMbI B03MO KHO AO 3aBTpa 11 He BepIO 'lITO BnaCTh MO KeT OTO KAeCTBHTh ce6R C rpa K­ A8HHHOM 11 He BepIO lITO npasHTenu H ynpasn l1eMbIe MOryT 3aneTh Bce BpeMH B03Bparuanach HOBas MhICl1b MHe npoBecm qeTKYIO rpaHHIJ y Me ABYMH nonIOcaMH Me 3THMH Mbl H OHM H qyBCTBOBan lITO Ha MeHH nOAYn BeTepoK HeH3Becmoro lITO 11 YBHAen npo6neMbI H HenpHHTHocm C ApyrOH B yHHCOH H He BepIO lITO BnaCTh H HCKyCcmO 6yAYT MHpHO CO KH­ CTOpoHhI llepe KHTOe MHOH OruyrueHHe Henbl l1 OIIHcaTh pacnpoCTpa­ TenhCmOBaTh He 6yAYT He B COCTORHHH nOTOMY 'lITO OHH palHhIe HeHHhIMH TepMHHaMH TUna KnaccoBas TO'llKa 3peHHR onn03H­ nOTOMY 'lITO He nOAXOAHT APyr APyry OAHaKO nOHHMaHHe nOJIO Ke­ HH I1 H rpa KA8HaMH H BnaCThIO BCen l1eT 136 HaAe lITO OHH AorOBOo IJ H I1 H T n 3TO BoeHHhle TepMHHhl MHe Hy I HO 6bInO KaK-TO onpe­ AenHTh CBoe OTHOlUeHHe 'llT06hI R Mor npoAOn l aTh BeCTH neperOBO­ 137 pbI Ii TOrna JI CKa3aJI ceOO Moe TJI f eJloe OW YIUeHHe - COCTaBHIIJI Hx KaK 6bI 3acraBHllH DpHHHTb Bee xopoillee H He xoqy 6bITb 1IllCTb neperoBopoB Bee coBepIlleHHO eCTeCTBeHHO Y Hero Jlpo6ne­ HeCJlpaBeA IHBbIM MbI nOTOMY 'ITO OH XOqeT 3aHHMaTbCJI TeM lJeM 3aHHMaeTCJI XOTJI HHe BHYTpH npaBJIw HX KpyrOB 3a JlI06yro nOnbITKY yJlyqIIIHTb H He p OJl f eH a JI - TO ICe xoqy 6bITb peP aKTOPOM ra3eTbI Torna JI CHOBa 33 1 yMaJICJI 0 BJlaCTH KaK 0 OKa3bIBaeTCJI qeJlOBeK H cmyamm Ii H yOO K J eH 'ITO 3a JlI060e 6naropO J Hoe lJ BH Ke­ BOT CTHllb 6bIJla 3ann alJeHa p oporaJI n eHa 6bIJlH npHHeceHbI f epTBbI B KOTOPOH H K3 K J Oe 3aMeTHOe YllyqIIIeHHe 6bIDO p ocmmyro C TpYP OM TaK 0 3aBepIII3IO Moe OTcrynJIeHHe H B03Bpa­ w aroCb K TOMY 0 lJeM JI rOBopHll paHbille IIHcaTellH - JlIOAH H npa­ KaKOM PYKoBop CTBe H 0 KaKOM BOAHTeJlbCTBe MO f eT HATH peqb BH Ky TOJlbKO TOpMO f eHHe 3a p eCJlTKH JleT nOCJle OlJepeAHbIX BJlw Ke Kpym COCTOJIT H3 JlIOp eH IlHcaTellH He CTpeMJITCJI K aHap­ BbICTynJIeHHii PYKOBO J HTeJleH JI HH pa3Y He n0p yMaJI KaKlIJI6neCTJI­ XHH nOTOMY tirO OHH XOTJlT KHTb B KpaCHBbIX roponax HMeTb W IIJI H IleJl H COBepIlleHHO HOBaJI K TOMY ICe HanPOTHB JI OlJeHb npeKpaCHhIe KBaprHpbI H lCeJlaIOT noro p pyrHM OHH 3aHHTepeCOBa­ 1IllCTO rOBopHll eeOO nOp yMaeIllb BeAb 3TO J 3 BHO BeeM H3BeCTHol HbI B pa3BHTHH npoMbDlIJIeHHOCTH ToprOBllH B BbICOKOH npH6bIJlH A AJIJI Beex Ii Bee 3TO Hep OCTIDKHMO 003 OpraHH31lUH0HHOH p eJlTeJlb­ HOCTH npaBHTeJlbCTBa TeM KOro HHKorna He BH J HIIIb liCKYCCTBO He MO ICeT OTKa3aTbCJI OT TeMbI BJlaCTH nOTOMY tirO OCYIUecTBllJlTb BnaCTb - ew e qaw e JI nyraJICJI KaK MO KHO npH 3TOM CJlaCTH CBOH H IleH KaK HX nepeXHTpHTb nOTOMY 'ITO HeB03MO KHO HHlJerO Om JlCHHTb 3TO 3HatIHT nOCTOJlHHO npJlMO HJlH KOC­ BeHHO npHHHMaTb peIlleHHJI 0 KH3HH JlIOp eH 06 HX 6naronoJlyqHH H pa30tlaPOBaHHJIX 0 TOM 'ITO Hepa3peIllHMO Boo6w e Ii BOT Ra poTHBJleHHe He apryMeHTbI - naTb KaK npe K J e IIpOBaJI 3a KOTOpbIii MbI Bce pacDllatIKBaeMCJI 6naronOJlY'IHeM H HepBaMH BeHHOH p eJITeJlbHOCTbIO H nOJIBllJIeTCJI KaKOe-TO peIlleHHe liCKYCCT­ HYIO BO He MO ICeT OTKa3aTbCJI OT KpHTHKH BJlaCTH nOTOMY tirO BJlaCTb CJlOBa tirO MbI IIHTq OHA tirO MbI y H BH Ky onaCHOCTb JI BH Ky HeH3MeH­ BOJlIO BepHYTb npe ICHHe cTpaIIIHbIe BpeMeHa lITO Torp a 3RalJaT KaKaJI ORa eCTb H MeTOAbI npH nOMOW H KOTOPbIX ORa npaBHT HallIe npaBHTeJlbCTBO HanpHMep pap yeT XYP O KHHKOB Korna HMH ee He yOOAHIllb TOJlbKO npoBa­ JlbI nOBTOpJlIOw KeCJI npoBaJIbl TaK KaK BJlaCTb He nepeCTaeT noCTy­ nOM Hepa3peIIIHMOM p eJITeJlbHOCTb BJlaCTH CTbIKaeTCJI C xYP O ICeCT­ no npoJIBJleHHe KyJlbryPbI Hapona H BH Kf H CJlbIIllY 'ITO BJlaCTb YCT 'llaeT TOJlbKO Torp a Korna ORa BH J HT H CJlbIIllHT CHllbHoe con­ no Zy'lu Zu no Zy'lu zu COI03 nHcaTeJleH 'ITO MbI no Zy'lu zu H3p aTeJlbCTBa H ra3eTbI Yrpo3Y 'ITO Hac Bee no MOryr OT06paTb eCllH Mbl He 6yp eM BeCTH ee6J1 KaK CJlep yeT EcJIH 6bI JI rOTOB 6bID npH3HaTb 'ITO Bce 3TO npHHa ­ XBaJIHT HX 3a BellHKOJlenHbIH DaBHJlbOH Ha BeeMHpHoH BbICTaBKe Jle KHT HM TO CKa3aJI 6bl KaK rOBopHT MOJI ceCTpa KTO P aJI ORo C YP OBOJlbCTBHeM Cp eJlaeT 3TO nOTOMY tirO TaKaJI nOXBaJIa ­ B3J1Jl ••• Ho pa3Be OHH p eHCTBHTeJlbHO X03J1eBa Beero nOllHTH'IeCKHH aKT H B03MO KH0 nOXBaJIHT HCKpeHHe 3TO O J H3KO Torna OCTaeTCJI p pymM ECJlH HHlJero TO He3aqeM HaM Torp a 3p eCb A TOT tirO ICe He 3HatIHT tirO XYP O KHHl H 6YP YT P OBOJlbHbI CBOHM npaBHTeJlbCT­ co6HpaTbCJI IIyCTb CK IIyCTb CTaKeT JlCHO BeeM 'ITO KyqKa BOM IIOTOMY tirO TaKOH naBHJlbOH HcnOJlb3yroID Hii B onpep eJleHHOM JlIOp eH HaMepeRa peIllaTb - CMbICJle npaBa 3KCTeppHTOpHaJIbHOCTH p eMOHCTpHpyeT tirO XYP O IC­ P OJl KHO 6bITb cp eJlaKO 0 lJeM CJlep yeT p yMaTb KaK Hy KH0 qyBCTBO­ HHKH MomH 6bI C03naTb p OMa eCllH 6bI HX Bec Ha poAHHe PaBWDICJI BaTb Ii 6bITb HJlH He 6bITb BeeMY pewaTb tirO 3TO 6yp eT CBH IleTeJlbCTBOM nOJlO ICeHHJI KYJlbryPbI B rocy­ Ii npH3H3IOCb JI MHoro pa3 3ap yMbIBaJI­ napCTBe 3TO 6yp eT KpHTepHeM KYJlbTypHOCTH Hapop a a He npoH3Be­ CJI Ha TeM He CJIy KHM JlH MbI 06MaHY Korp a CTpoHM npeKpaCHbIe p eHHJI KyJlbtypbI p 06HBIIIHeCJI BbICOKOH H3BeCTHOCTH H on eHKH HX Me K J yHapo J HOMY Becy naBHJlbOHbI 3arpaHHn eH 3HIIJI tirO HaIIIH JlyqIIIHe npoH3Bep eHHJI ­ B nOCJle u Hee BpeMH HaM tlaCTO npHXommOCb CJlbIIIIaTb qTO He f eJlaHHbI 'ITO Bee tirO MbI D eJlaeM 3TO no MHJlOCTH BO KbeH npaBHw He KpyrH npH3RaIOT onpep eJleHHyro aBTOHOMHIO KYllbTypbI 'ITO CPOK npH6nH K3eTCJI a MbI p 3 Ke He 3HaeM TOlJHOH p aTbI Bce qero p OCTHrJla RaIIIa KYJlbrypa KaK H Boo6w e Bce xopo­ Illee 'ITO C03 J aJIH HaIIIH JlIOAH - H3p eJlHJl nocTpoHKH OTKpbITHJI HCCJlep OBaHHJI Bee 3TO 6bIDO cp eJlaKO BonpeKH npaBHw HM KpyraM 138 HO TOJlbKO B paMKax KYJlbryPHOH p eJlTeJlbHOCTH DyCTb MOJl p eJITe llH KyJIbrypbI He cePAJITCJI Korna BCTynHB B o6naCTb nOllHTHKH OHH nOJlyqaIOT 3aMe1lllHHJl IIpH 3TOM nOJlb3yroTCJI H3IIIHMH ICe ap­ ryMeHTaMH Hac ynpeK3IOT B HapYIIIeHHH Hawero ICe yrnep K J eHHJI 139 1lr0 Ka K lyIO pa60Ty AOmKHbI BbIDOOWITb CneD HaJIHCTbI R COrnaeeH npeCTynHHKH HeT COMHeHHJI 1lr0 HaW naplIaMeHT BeJIHKOJIeIlHo Nullum 1lr0 nOJIHTHKoii AOJIXCHbI 3aHHMaTbCJI cneD HaJIHCTbI Ho OTKYAa Y 3HaeT OAHH npaBOBoit npHHD HII - nOJIHTHqeCKHX AeJITeJIeii YBepeHHOCTb B TOM 1lr0 OHH-TO H JlBJIJlIOTCJI npeCTynJIeHHJI 003 3aKOHa 3TOT npHHD HII naplIaMeHT o eCT­ CneD HaJIHCTaMH R COMHeBalOCb B 3TOM H nonp06YJO AOCTynHO crimen sine lege - aeT BJIJleT npoH3BOAR AJIJI rOCYAapCTBa CTOJIbKO npeCT 'IIHHKOB CKOllb­ o61 JlCHHTb npH'IHHY MOHX COMHemm Bpaq HaBepHJlKa cneD Ha­ KO Tpe6yeTCJI A n nO ll HCMeHTbl llo' eMY JIIO H KOTOPbIM Y Hac He JIHCT - OH JIyqwe HaC MO ICeT onpeAeJIHTb HarH03 OH 3HaeT KaK Hac HpaBHTCJI He MOryT y6paTbCJI K'lePTy H noqeMY JIIO l H KOTOPLle npoq eCCHOHaJIbHO JIell'HTb Ho Bpa' HH B KoeM crryqae He MO ICeT He 3aHHTepeCOBaHhI B ycnexe npeAllpHHJITblX Mep no AeMOKpaTHla nyrnue HaC 3HaTb KaK MbI ce6JI qyBCTByeM nOCJ1e ero JIeqeHHJI lJ HH He YXOART co CBOHX nOCTOB CJIeAj'eT OTMeTHTb 1lr0 6bIJIO npHHJlTO HeCKOJIbKO HOBhIX TOJIbKO maplIaTaH a He Bpaq MO ICeT CAMaTb HaM onaCHeiiwyIO one­ H HeDJIOXHX 3aKOHOB CJIeAyeT OTMeTHTb paD HlO He nOJIyqHB Ha Hee Hawero ORCbMeHHoro cornacHJI ABTOHOMHJI HCKYCCTBa H KYJIbTyPbI 3TO Beero JlHIIIb JI03yar tj'TQ pa3pa6aTbmaIOTCJI c­ nOJIHHTeJIbHble 3aKOHbI CJIeA 'eT TaK lKe OTMeTHTb 1lr0 HOBhlH la­ H BpeMeHHaJI TaKTHKa CeroAWI rOBOpJlT OARO 3aBTpa Apyroe KOH 0 BbIrJIJI l HT no nO-pa3HOMY HO He HyJKHO 6bITb KpynHl IM cneD Ha­ peAaKD HJI 3aKOHa 0 pJlAe rpa AaHCKHX CBo60A B qaCTHoem 0 CDc­ nell'aTH xopomo MeTeT 1l0 n roTaBmmaeTCJI TaK lKe HOBaJI JIHCTOM 1lr06bI YBHAeTb 1lr0 Bee 3TO H3 oARoii 6oll'KH HO H3 pa3H1 IX 60Ae co6pamrli H o61 e J HHemm 3TOT npoeKT rOTOBHT MmmCTepcy KPaHOB BO BHYTpeHHHX AeJI Y lKe Ha6paHHaJI B JImepaTypHOH ra3eTc R He qyBCTBylO ee6J1 B OO30naCHOCTH B TOii OficTaHOBKe B 06­ JIaem KYJIbTypbI H nOJIHTHKH KOTOpylO npaBJllIUle KPym MoryT R CTaTbJl Ha 3Ty TeMY 6bma 3anpe eHa R He BH lKY rapaHTHii KaKlOt rapaHTHH He 3HalO Ha 3TOM JI OCTaHOBJIIOCb nOTOMY 1lr0 lAecr JI CTeH noro 3aJIa TO eCTb 3a npeAeJIaMH Moeii cnopTHBHoii ItnO 3A­ nOAOmeJI K TOMY B qeM JI COMHeBaIOCb 60JIbWe Beero HMelOT llH rapaHTHH npaB lIIIl He Kpyrn npaBHTeJIbCTBO OTAeJIbHbIe MHHHCTpLI KH HH'lero MHe He CAeJIaJIH HHqerO co MHoii He npoH30lIDIO B Hawe HMelOT JIH OHH rapaHTHlO CBOHX rpa AaHcKHX CBo60A OOl KOTOPhIx HaKaJIJlTb AO paCKOJIa He qyBCTBYJO ce6J1 B OO30nacHoem BHe BpeMJI TaK 60JIbme He nOCTynalOT R AOJI cH 6bITb 3a 3TO 6JIaroAa­ peH Ho JI He HCnbITbmaIO 6JIaroAapHOCTH nOTOMY 1lr0 601OCb R He BHJKY HHKaKHX c eCTBeHHI IX rapaHmH OO30naCHoem CYAbI AeiiCTBHTeJIbHO pa60TalOT JIyqwe HO CYAbH paHTHH R pa3Be Y HHX eCTb ra­ BHJKY 1lr0 npoKypaTyPbI pa60TalOT nyrnue HO pa3Be y HeB03MO H0 TBOPHTb B TOM lI'HCJ1e H nOJIHTHKy Ha nOM nyHKl'e MOJI xapaKTepHCTHKa BHYTpeHHHX 3aKOHOMepHOCTeH K3 AOH BJIae­ TH KOHll'aeTCJI H JI MOry TOJIbKO COCJIaTbCJI Ha CJIOBa KOTopbIe 6bDlH CK3 3aHhI AO MeHJI - 0 lKepHOBax nepeMaJIbmaIOlIUlX HHorA3 H Tel KTO paCKpymJI HX npoKypopoB eCTb rapaHTHH pa3Be OHH qyBCTBYJOT ee6JI B OO30nac­ CreneHl KyJIbTypHOem Mep He06xoAHMbIX AJIJI HaJIa lKeHHOfo Hoem ECJ1H XOTHTe JI Mory B3J1Tb y KorO-TO H3 HHX HHTepBblO AJIJI XOAa AeJI B rOCYA3pCTBe JlBJIJleTCJI MepHJIOM ero nOAJIHHHOH KYJIh­ ra3eTbI BbI AYMaeTe 3TH HHTepBblO YAaJIOCb 6bI Hanell'aTaTb R ro­ TypbI II03TOMY KYJIbTypa nOJIHTHKH eeRc Ba Hee nOJIHTHlOt cnPOCHTb ero B KyJIbTYpe TaM rAe nOJIHTHKa nOJIHTHKOB KYJIbTypHa HH ORca noqeMY HeBHHHO OCY AeHHbIX H y e peaOOHTHpOBaHHbIX He BOC­ TeJIb HH XYAQ HHK HH HH lKeHep He AOJI cH TpaTHTb CHJI Ha XJIOIIo­ TOB B3J1Tb HHTepBblO H y reHepaJIbHOrO npoKYpopa - CTaHaBJIHBalOT aBTOMaTHqeCKH B npaBax nOqeMY MeCTHbIe BJIaCTH Tbl 0 CBOHX npocpeCCHOHaJIbHl IX u eXOBbIX BeAOMCTBeHHbIX H APY He B03B aIOT HM HX KBapmpbI H AOMa Ho TaKoe HHTepBblO He 6YAeT Hanell'aTaHO 1l0qeMY nepeA 3THMH JIIOAbMH He H3BHWITCJI no­ THX npaBax He AOJI lKeH nO lJ tj'epKHBaTb cneD HtPHKY cBoero TPYAa qeMY Y HHX HeT npHBHJIerHii 6bmIIIHX nOJIHTHqeCKHX 33KJIlOqeHHbIX KpeCTbJlH noqeMY C HHMH TOPryIOTCJI 0 KOMneHcaIJ HH IIo' eMY MbI He HMeeM HO He HaxoART cpeACTBa npeOAOJIeHHJI u eHlYPhI AJIJI 3aJIBJIeHllfl npaBa HTb rAe XOTHM IIoqeMY HaIIIH nopmbIe He MOryT noexaTb TaM OH He BbI3bmaeT HeAOBOJIbCTBa ApyrHX rpa AaH1 - pa60llHl CJIY lK31IUlX KOTophle 06JIlAaIOT TeMH ICe npaBaMH 1lr0 Oll' o CBOHX MbICJIJIX HJIH IIepeBOA3 CBOHX qyBCTB Ha Jl3hIK HCKYCCTBa B 1lr06bI C006 h 0 HHX JIIOARM Qepe3 KOHCTpyKD HlO HJIH KpaCKII llapH lCe H HMeTb npaBO B JII060ii MOMeHT BepHYTbCJI AOMOii He KaK Qepe3 atPopH3M CTHX HJIH MY3bIKaJIbHoe npoH3BeAeHHe HMeHHO Ha TpH rOA3 B BeHY a HawH XYAO HHKH He MOryT HTb 140 30 JIeT HeKyru TYPHaH nOJlHTHKa a He nnoXllJl nOJlHTHKa B Kyru TYpe C03naeT XOAHMOe - O'lafH 6oPb6bI 3a CB060AY oCKop6ruUICb npH 3TOM tiro 0 cB060Ae neHH II KaK He 6bInH YAOBneTBopeHhI H TaKHe nOTpe6HOCTH 'IenOBe­ He nepecTaroT rOBop Tb H He nOHHMaH lITO c606ooa OOCTUZnYTa Ka KOTopbIe HeAeMOKpaTHtlecKHe CHCTeMbI Bo06rne He B COCTO llHHH rOJZbKO TaM zoe 0 neil Her HUKaKoil Haoo6HocTU Z060PUTb HeKynb­ YAOBneTBOpHTb - TYpHaH nOnHTHKa HeAOBOnbHa Korna nroAH rOBOpHT lITO BHAHT tlHHeHHe nOnHTHqeCKHX peweHHii KpHTepH IIM 3THKH Bepa B 3HatIH­ H BMeCTO Toro lIT06bI H3MeHHTb YBRAeHHoe nro l bMH K nytlUIeMy OHa npe I IaraeT HM pa3HbIe OtIKH YXOAHT B neTY A B 3TO BpeMH OO3B03BpaTHO TO eAHHCTBeHHoe lITO AOCTOii Ho Bceo6mero nopbI­ KBapmpbI IIIKonbI npeAMeTbI nOBCeAHeBHOrO nOTpe6­ qyscmo lITO rpa K J aHHH eH 06rneCTBY nOA­ MOCTb nro60ro Tpyna AOBepHe Me KAY nroAbMH poCT uapoAHoro 06pa30BaHH II H He rOBOpro Y K 0 TOM lITO H Ha Me K J yHapoAHOH apeHe MbI HHKaKHX ycnexoB He A06HnHCb HMH HarneH pecny6nHKH MetJTa 0 npaBHTenbCTBe TO K J ecmeHHoM rpa K J llHHHy H 0 yrpaTHnO CBoe npe KHee 3Ha'leHHe 3a nocneAHHe rOAbI MbI He nanH rp8 I J 8HHHe KOTOPbrH ynpaBnHeT C060H notITH lITO caM HBnHeTCH 'IenOBeqecmy HH OAHQii 0pHrnHanbHoii RAeH HH OAHoro KOHCTPYK­ sa - TRBHOrO npeAnO KeHIDI HaJJpHMep KaK npH pa3BHTHH npoH3BOACT­ JllI Jra MelITa OcyIUeCTBHMOH Ha nym K JrOH MellTe K KOTOPOH HaIIIH HapOAbI CTpeMHJlllCb Ba He yrOHyrb B OTXOnaX Jroro npoH3BOACTBa MbI AO CHX nop ryno C AaBHeHmHX BpeMeH HallleH HCroPHH MbI A06HnHCb KaKHX-TO yc­ nOBTopHeM oIIIH6KH AonymeHHble H Ha BOCToKe H Ha 3anaAe neXOB OAHHM H3 HHX 6bVlO B03HHKHOBeHHe caMoCToHTenbIiOH Harne 06rnecmo He C03 l an0 HHCTHTyra KOTOPbrH 3aHHManCH 6l I qexocnoBaKHH - BonpocaMH CTHn ll 1Q13HH TeM KaK 06HOBHTb HaW 3aDbVleHHbrH 6naroAapH nporpeCCRBHhIM CHllaM Hapona H npor­ peCCRBHbIM nOnHTHKaM 0 'IeM KCTaTH He rOBopHTCH B npoeKTe 3aHBneHIDI C'be3na H lITO II nporuy TaM OTMeTHTb BeAb HMeHHO H ruyMHbrH 06pa3 1Q13HH H He yrBep K J aro lITO MbI KHnH Hanp8CHO H lITO 6bVlO cAenauo Torna B03HHKnO rOCYAapcmeHHoe 06pa30BaHHe KOTopoe HeCMOT­ He HMeeT HHKaKoii u eHHOCTH UeHHoe eCTb HO B03HHKaeT Bonpoc pH Ha Bee HeAOCTaTKH 6bVlO BblCOKO AeMOKpaTH'IeCKHM no CpaBHe­ He llBn lleTC II JllI 3TO u eHHoe cBoero pona npeAYDpe K J eHHeM 1103­ HHro C cymeCTBOBaBlllHMH B TO BpeMH pe IQIMaMJI H KOTopoe He HaHH II qenOBeqeCTBa paCIIIHPHnHCb 6bl H 003 Toro HO HHCTpYMeHTOM BOCDHTanO B CBOHX rpaJlCASllax HenpH ll3HH K RAeanaM COll HanH3Ma n03HaHHH He Aon KHa 6bITb CTpaHa KynbTypHoe npownoe KOTOpoii H AIlJlO HCMeHTbI HMeHHo npeeMcmeHHocTb HAeH 0 roCYAcpcme npeAYnpe KnaHo 06 onaCHOCTH COll HanbHorO 000cneqeHIDI n03BOnHna nocne BTOPOH MHPOBOH BOH ­ B 3aHBneHHH lITO 6bDIO H3BeCTHO qexocnoBau KOH KYnbType B HhI npeACTaBHTb nporpaMMy COll HanH3M3 Oco6ble ycnOBH II B KOTo­ rOAbI HnH lITO no KpaHHeii Mepe npeACTaBHTenH HarneH KynbTYpbI pbIX 3TY nporpaMMY HalffiJIH ocyrnecmnHTb H rnaBHbIM 06pa30M ornymanH Torna npe I Iararo n03ToMY OTpa3HTb 30-e nOnO KeHHe B CTpaue e n0OOAHBwero COll HanH3Ma npHBenH y B nocneAHee BpeMH MHe npHBenocb n03HaKOMHTbC II C u enhIM HaC K Aeq op M H C06bITH IIM KOTopbIe HHKaK HeB03MO KH0 P IIAOM YAHBHTenbIiO CBe IQIX nroAeH Pe'lb RAeT 0 HecKonbKHJ nH'I­ 06'hHCHHTb HaIIIHMH KJIHMaTHlIeCKHMH ycnOBH IIMH xapaKTepoM HOCT IIX H HeCKonbKHX KOnneKTRBaX - TPYAOBbIX H TBOPlleCKHX Halllero Hapona HnH HaWeii HCTOpHeii rOBOpH 06 3TOM nepHoAe l1opa3HTenbHo conpoTHBneHHe KOTopoe OHH OKa3anH BnaCTH HX Aeq opMaJJ HH Aeii cmH II COOTBeTCTBOBaBIIIHe ApeBHHM 6naropoAHbIM npHHu HnaM nbITaroTCH HaHTH o6'h llCHeHHe nO'leMy nponano CTonbKO HpaBCTBeHHbIX H MaTepHanbIibIX u eHHocTeii noqeMy Mbl TPYAHTbC II qeCTHO co6nronaTb cnOBO He npeAaBaTb caMHX ce6 11 He TaK OTCTanH 3KOHOMH'IeCKH n03BOn llTb 3aMopo'IH'Ib ce6 11 Hap IIAY C 3THMH B npHHu Hne KJIaCCH­ I1paB IIIlI He Kpyrn 3a 11Bn lllOT lITO 3TO H AYMaro lITO I I II HaC Bcex 3TO He 6bIllO HeH3OO K­ qeCKHMH 'IepraMH XOpoWHX nroAeii OHH npH06penH erne OAHY Ho­ HO HO He HCKJIroqeHO lITO JrO 6bDIO He06xoAHMO I I II AYXOBHoro Byro OTCYTCTBHe qysCTBa AHCTaHD HH Me KAY HalffiJIhCTBOM H nOAtIH­ 6bVlO HeH3OO KH0 pa3BHTHH oprauoB BnaCTH KOTopbIe H BceX 38UlHTHHKOB COll HanH3­ HeHHbIM Me KAY BbIWe· H HH KeCTO llIll HM H KaK JrO HH CTPaHHO Ma 3aCTaBHnH npoAenaTb JrOT npou ecc C HHMH HMeHHO 3Ta 'lepTa npHcymaH B npownOM neHT II IIM H 6poAHraM B 3a AB3 AIJ 8Tb neT y HaC He 6bVla peweHa HH OAHa H3 HacyIUHbIX npo6neM 'IenOBe'leCKOH 1Q13HH - He 6bVlO 06eCneqeHO caMoe Heo6­ CO'leTaHHH C KJIaCCHlIeCKHMH nOnO KHrenbHbIMH 'IepTaMH C03 l aBana BneqarneHHe HOBoro qenOBeKa KOTOPbrH He HaMepeH yHH KaTbCH paAH KYCKa xne6a 142 143 B 3aKJIIOtreHHe JI XOTen 6b1 OTMeTHTb XOTJI Ha o eIOCh 3TO 6hDIO JlCHO H3 CKa3aHHOrO MHOIO trro KpHTHKa BnaCTH B HallIeM rocy o ap­ CTBe He 03HaqaeT KpHTHKY COD H3J1H3Ma nOCKOJIhKY JI COBepIlIeHHO He ysepeH B He06xO o HMOCTH CTPOHTh COI J HaJIH3M TaK KaK 3TO o e­ JIaJIOCb B HaweH CTpaHe H nOCKOJIhKY JI Hamy BnaCTb He OTO l ' leCT­ BJIJlIO C COI J HaJIH3MOM KaK 3TO o enaeT OHa C3Ma o on KHa 6bITb TO l ' leCTBeHHoH ECJIH Ii CYAb6a HX He Haeen KO OYT 6b JIIOAH KOTopble ocymeCT­ BJIJlIOT BJIaCTb B HallIeM rocy o apCTBe - JI eeHllac KaK 6bI OTpbIBaIO HX OT HHCTmyTa BJIaCTH H 06pa maIOCb K HHM KaK K HHAHBH DyMaM co CBOHMH qyBCTBaMH co CBOHMH MblCJIJlMH - TaK BOT eCJIH 6hI o UEH3YPE OHH npHlIlJIH CIO o a H 38AaJIH HaM OAHH-e o HHCTBeHHbm Bonpoc ocymeCTBHMa JIB Metrra 0 npaBHTenhCTBe TO l ' leCTBeHHOM rpa l ' la­ HHHY H 0 COKpam eHHIdA TeKCT rpa l ' laHHHe KOTophm nO o BJIaCTeH TonhKO C3MOMY ee6e TO H OHH o OJI KHh 6bIJIH 6b1 npH3HaTb npoJIBneHHeM o 06POH BOJIH C HameH CTOpoHh H rpa l ' laHCKOH JIOJIJIhHOCTH OTBeT He lHaro AwtoAHCMeHTbI B O o HOM H3 pernOHOB MHpa nOJlBHJIOCb HOBoe rocy o apCTBO OHO B03HHKJIO Ha HCToplflleCKOH TeppHTOpHH MaJIoro Hapo o a Ka­ TOPbIH Ha nponm eHHH MHornx BeKOB nO o BepraJICJI rOHeHHJIM H aCCHMHJIJlI J HOHHOMY o aBJIeHHIO coce o HHX HaI J HH 3TO npoH30WJ10 Bcne O CTBHe BoeHHoro KOHIPnHKTa B KOTOpOM Hapo o o aHHoro rocy­ o apeTBa nyCTh H BeCbMa MaJIo'IHCJIeHHbiH CblrpaJI OtreHh BIDKII 'IO pom - H B pe3YJIbTaTe nonY'lHJl 3aKOHHble rpa HHIU I H o HnJIOMaTH­ lIeCKOe npH3HaHHe Ho 3TOT MaJIbIH Hapo o He nepeCTaJI 6b1Tb cyq KOM B rJIaly CBOHX coee o eH HeKoTopoe BpeM II cnyCTJI OHH CHOBa 3aJIBHJIH 0 npeTeH3HJ1X Ha ero reppHTopHIO npe VIOrOM VIJI' noro CTaJIO npe l ' le Beero HaJIH'lHe Ha ero reppHTOpHH 3Ha'IHTeJIhHorO HaI J HOHaJIhHOrO MeHhIIIHHCTBa HCToplflleCKH OT o eJIeHHOrO OT CBoeH HaIJ HH B coee o HeM rocy o apcTBe ymep l ' laBmero trrO npaBa nora MeHbillHHCTBa no o aBnJlIOTCJI 20 JIeT CnyCTJI nOnO ICeHHe 060CTPH­ nOCb HaCTOJIbKO trrO MOl 'lQeCTBeHHbm coce o CTaJI yrpoX 8 Tb MaJIa­ MY rocy o apCTBy yHHtrrO ICeHHeM Yrpo3a He 6b1JIa JIHillb cnoBeCHoH H BbICKa3bIBaJIaCb He wenOTOM a OTKPbITO nepe o BeeM MHpoM• YHHtrrO ICeHHe - 3TO CJIOBO IIOBTOPJIJIOCh nOllTH B Ka I ' lOM Bb C­ yYJIJIeHHH JIH ll epa MOl 'lQeCTBeHHoro Hapo o a YHHtrrO lCeHHe ­ 3TO CJIOBO e ICe o HeBHO IIOBTOPJIJIOCb Ha IIJIaKaTaX B nellaTH H no pa o HO npo ICHBaBWeMY B MaJIOM rocy o apCTBe MeHhillHHCTBY e lCe O ­ HeBHO nepeCblJIaJIOCh opY I He TY o a IIepeIIp8BJIJIJ1H AHBepCHOHHbIe rpYIIJIbI Ha rpamm ax CKOHn empHpoBaJIHCh BOHHCKHe coe o HHeHHJI MOl 'lQeCTBeHHoro coce o a HaMepeHHJI KOToporo He BbI3bIBaJIH HH­ 144 145