B 3aKJIlO'leHHe H XOTeJI 6bI OTMeTHTb XOTH HaAelOCb no 6bVlO HCHO H3 CKa3aHHoro MHOIO 'ITO KpHTllKa BJIaCTH B HarneM rocyp ap­ CTBe He 03Ha'laeT KPHTHKY COWlaJIH3Ma rrOCKOJIbKY H COBepweHHO He yBepeH B He06xo UfMOCTH CTPOHTb COWlaJIH3M TaK KaK no Ae­ JIaJIOCb B Harneii cTpase H rrOCKOJIbKY H Hamy BJIaCTb He OTO l ll eCT­ BJIHIO C COWlaJIH3MOM KaK no AeJIaeT OHa caMa AOJI I IDl 6bITb TO l ll eCTBeHHoii Ecnu If CY J b6a HX He llaae 1 KOZOYT 6bI JIIO Uf KOTopbIe o ecT­ BJIHIOT BJIaCTb B HaWeM rocyp apcTBe - H ceRC KaK 6bI oTpbmalO HX OT HHCTHTYTa BJIaCTH H 06pamarocb K HHM KaK K HHAHBH lJ 'MaM co CBOHMH 'lyBcTBaMH co CBOHMH MbICJIHMH OHH rrpHIWIH CIOp a H TaK BOT eCJIH 6bI o UEH3YPE 3ap aJIH HaM O J HH-e J HHcmeHHbIii Borrpoc ocyrueCTBHMa JIH Me'ITa 0 rrpaBHTeJIbCTBe TO l ll eCTBeHHOM rpa l ll a­ HlUlY H 0 rpa l l aHHHe KOTOpbIii rrOp BJIaCTeH COK eRHbDt TeKCT TOJIbKO caMOMY ce6e TO H OHH AOJI KHbI 6bIJIH 6bI rrpH3HaTb rrpOHBJIeHHeM A06poii BOJIH C Haweii CTOPOHbI H rpa l l aHCKoii JIOHJIbHOCTH OTBeT He 3HalO Anno HCMeHThI B Op HOM H3 perHoHoB MHpa rrOHBHJIOCb HOBoe rocYAapCTBo OHO B03HHKJIO Ha HCTOpH'leCKoii TeppHTopHH MaJIOrO Hapop a KO­ TOPbIii Ha rrpoTJDKeHHH MHorHX BeKOB rrop BepraJICH rOHeHHHM H aCCHMUJIHWlOHHOMY p aBJIeHHIO COCep HHX H 3TO rrpoH3oWJIo BCJIeACTBHe BoeHHoro KOHIi JIHKTa B KOTOPOM HapoA p aHHoro rocy­ p apcTBa rrycTb H BeCbMa MaJIO'IHCJIeHHbm CbIrpaJI O'leHb Ba l H 'lO POJIb - H B pe3YJIbTaTe rrOJIY'IUJI 3aKOHHbIe r H AHIIJIOMaTH­ 'leCKOe rrpH3HaHHe Ho 3TOT MaJIbm HapoA He rrepeCTaJI 6bITb CyqKOM B rJIa3y CBOHX coceAeii HeKoTopoe BpeMH CrryCTH OHH CHOBa 3aHBHJIH 0 rrpeTeH3IDIX Ha ero TeppHTopHIO TIpeAJIOrOM AJIH 3Toro CTaJIO rrpe l ll e Bcero HaJIH'lHe Ha ero TeppHTopHH 3Ha'IHTeJIbHoro HaWlOHaJIbHOrO MeHbIlIHHCTBa HCTOpH'leCKH OTAeJIeHHorO OT cBoeii HaWlH B cocep HeM rocYAapCTBe ymep l ll aBwero 'ITO rrpaBa 3Toro MeHbIlIHHCTBa rrop aBJIHIOTCH 20 JIeT CrryCTH rrOJIO J eHHe o60CTpH­ JIOCb HaCTOJIbKO 'ITO MO eCTBeHHbm coceA CTaJI yrPO J aTb MaJIo­ MY rocyp apcTBy YHH'ITO J eHHeM Yrpo3a He 6bIJIa JIHIIlb CJIOBecHoii H BbICKa3bmaJIaCb He werrOTOM a OTKPbITO rrepeA BceM MHpoM YHH'lTO J eHHe - 3TO CJIOBO rrOBTopHJIOCb rro'ITH B Ka I ll OM BbIC­ TYIIJIeHHH mmepa MO eCTBeHHorO sapoAa YHH'lTO J eHHe ­ no CJIOBO e J ep HeBHo rrOBTOpHJIOCb Ha IIJIaKaTax B rre'laTH H rro pap uo TIpo J HBaBweMY B MaJIOM rocyp apcme MeHbIlIHHcmy e J eA­ HeBHO rrepecbmaJIOCb rpyrrrrbI Ha rpalIlmax op e TYp a rreperrpaBJIHJIH UfBepcHoHHbIe CKOH eHTpHpOBaJIHCb BOHHCKHe COep HHeHHH MorymeCTBeHHOrO coceAa HaMepeHHH KOToporo He BbI3bmaJIH HH­ 144 145 KaKHX COMHeHHii llna nonHOThI Kap11IHI I MO KHO A06aBHTb 'ITO cerop H llIIDieM c06pamm nODbITanHCb ony6nHKoBaTh CBOH B3rnJl ll ManOe rocyp apcTBO 6bIDO npo3aIIa n HbIM AeMOKpaTH'IeCKHM TOrAl H3 C06bITHa Ha BnIDKHeM BocToKe IIx 3a 11BDeHHa 0 J H31 0 nOA­ KaK pe I HM B MOW HOM COee J HeM rocYAapcrne 6bID TOTanHTap­ BeprnHcb eH3ype aprYMeHTHpoBaHHOH TeM 'ITO IlHcaTenb AOIDKeH HbIM HO CKpbmawumM CBOH TOTanHTapHbIH xapaKTep H CBOH 3Ko­ 3aHHMaTbca nHTeparypoH a He nonHTHKoR CneAYeT HaDOMHHTb naHCHBHbIH HaUHOHanH3M 3a neeBAOCOUHanHCTHtJeCKHMH cppa33MH 'ITO 3TO YTBep l D eHHe HaM nOBTOp llWT C 1956 r Korp a OHO 6bIDO TIonblTKH ManOro rocyp apcTBa BOCCTaHOBHTb Ha CBoeH TeppHTopHH c POPM ' 1lHPOBaHO KaK He3HalJHTenbH3 ll MOp HcpHKa HAeH 'ITO nOpa AOK H nHKBHAHpOBaTh TeppopHCTOB MOI' 'IUeCTBeHHbIH COeeA weaTenb nocpeACTBOM nHTeparypbI AOll l eH 3aHHMaTbCa npe l D e Ha3bman reHOUHAoM H HCDonb30Ban HX K31 npeAnor p na BbIp BH­ Beero nOnHTHKoH l eHH II ynbTHMaTHBHblx Tpe60BaHHH JIHoo CAaBaHTeCb nHoo 6yp ere OC06eHHOCTH 50·e rO D bI He Hay'lHllH HaC 'ITO H3 IIIIJ H3 Il CllOBeCHOCTb yHH'lTO l eHbl Jlo 3Toro MOMeHTa Bee paCCKa3aHHoe BblIlle - 3Ko­ nOJI1ilTHKy 3aMeHHTb He MO l eT H B TO l e B peM ll IlBJUleTC II B03MO IC­ KYPC B HCTOpHro BI I HaBepH IIKa 06paTHllH BHHMaHHe 'ITO a nepe­ HO ep HHCTBeHHOH CPOPMOH HCKYCCTBa KOTOPa ll He B COCTO IIHHH lJHCnHO peanbHble HCTOpHtJeCKHe CP31 Tbl npHtJeM pe'lb IlIna He 06 OCTaTbca B CTopoHe OT nOJIHTHKH apa6cKo-H3paHObCKOM KOHcpJIHKTe a 0 KOHcpnHKTe Me llC lJ Y repMa­ TOpoH 06BHHJUIH qexocnoB31 Hro B 1938 r HOH nO n nHHHOH ­ KaK 6YATO npep meCTByroume Tblca qeneTH II H B Y arpeCCHH HHeH H qexocnoBaKHeH 3Ta napannenb npHIlIlla MHe B ronoBY rHrnepoBcKoH HnH cp31 THtJeCKOH - H HaBepH IIKa MHOrnM H3 HaC Korp a B H3tIane HroH II Ha 6epery HOH - apa6cKoH - - TOR MHHMOH B Ko­ H3paHnbCKOH HOH nore bo eCTb He TonbKO nOllHTHtIeCKHH HO H HpaBCTBeH­ ManeHbKOH tJeIllCKOH peqyIllKH B nO'ITH TpoIlHtJecKyw l apy a npocTo HbIR acneKT CPH3H'leCKH nOqyBCTBOBan K31 Ta I enO norn6aTb MOllO D bIM eBpea M B TOM llHcne ADa nonHTHKOB KOTopble npereHAyroT Ha npaBo cpop­ H MOnO D bIM apa6aM B CHHaHCKHX necKax II a cnpocHO caMoro ce6a eCJlH 61 1 B 1938 r qexOCnOBaKH II He KanHTynHpOBana H MbI JI K31 H Apyme CTanH 6bl CTpen llTb nepBblMH CMor JIH 6bl KTo-nH60 H3 CnpaBeADH­ 3anpery He HaMepeH noneMH3HpoBaTb C n03HUHeH npaBHTenbCTBa BbIX CYAeH H eeKYH D aHTOB Ha3BaTb 3TO arpeccueH SI HMew B BHAY II HMeHHO 3TOT acneKT Ba l eH Beerp a H Ana Beex MHpoBaTb n o MHpa K31 nWAH TBOp'IeCTBa CPOPMHPYWT ero AyIIIy SI aBTOpbI CTaThH KOTOPblX nop seprnHCb eH3ypHOMY 33HHTepeCOBaH nHIllb B TOM tJT06bI H ADa MeH II cyw eCTBOBana MOpallbHyro CTOPOHY npo6neMbI C HaY'IHOH TOtIKH 3peHH II HCTOPH­ B03MO KHOCTb 3a llBHTb OTKpbITO 0 CBoeH TOtIKe 3peHH II Ha caMble tIeCKHe napannenH pa3YMeeTCH HeTO'IHbI B CTODKHOBeHHH KOTO­ eepbe3Hb1e npo6neMbI BHYTpeHHeR H BHeIllHeii nOllHTHKH ecnH no­ poe MeC fIIJ Ha33 D npoH30IllnO Ha BnH l HeM BOCTOKe H B KOTOPOM 3HD Ha npaBmenbCTBa BbI3bmaeT y MeH II COMHeHHe B cnyqae 0 Ko­ Mbl He 6bmH HH ytIaCTHHKaMH HH eeKYH n aHTaMH a Beero nHDIb TOPOM a TonbKO 'ITO rOBopHll HanmOCb 6bl AOCTaTO'IHO 3pYAHpoBaH­ CBHp eTen llMH 6bmH HbIX cneD HanHcTOB KOTopble B03MO KH0 nOBJIH II1IH 6bI Ha Moe HHbIMH TIpe l D e Beero CHilbHbIM coceAOM B p aHHOM cnyqae 6bID Ha­ Koe-KaKHe 06CTonenbCTBa pa3YMeeTca MHeHHe H p 3 I e H3MeHHnH ero B KpaiiHeM cnyqae ocpHUHanbHble POA ew e Hep aBHO 6bmI IIHH TOBapoM Ha pbIHKe paooB II Bee l e npeACTaBHTenH npaBHTenbCTBa MornH 6bI OTMe l eBaTbca OT MoeH KaK rpa l D aHHH CTpaHI I KOTOpa ll nepe l Hlla MWHXeH a HMew non­ TOtIKH 3peHH II H OTBepruyTb ee XOTa 61 1 Ha 06bItJHbIX npecc-KoHcpe­ Hoe npaBO cnpoCHTb MO KHO nH onepHpoBaTb nOH IITHeM arpecCH Il CTonb 0 J H03Ha'IH0 KaK 3TO AenanOCb B H3IlIeH netIaTH rpa l D aHHH nOTOMY' 'ITO npaBHTenbCTBO H ApyrHX 06a 3aTenbCTB - SI rOBOpw C ytIeTOM COW3Hb1X pe KOTopbIe YCTpaHB3IOT p a l e B CTpaHax C He CTOllb rny60KH­ MH p eMOKpaTH'leCKHMH Tpa D HD Ha MH K31 qexocnoB31 HH HanpH­ Mep B HHTepHH MO l eT 3aH IITb HHYW no m r uno Ha TO C 3Toro MOMeHTa a H He TOJIbKO a HO H AeC IlTKH TbICH'I pa3­ OHO H npaBHTenbCTBO Ho y rpa l p aHHHa p a l e y COBepIlleHHO no ll1Ibo MOHX corpa Kp aH nepeCTanH 6bl onacaTbCa tJTO B 3TOM MHpe Horo rpa l D aHHHa MO l eT 6bITb CBO ll n03HUHa a Ha p sa D ll aTh BTo­ AHpaeMOM Ha tIaCTH B HHTepecax BnaCTb HMYIIJ HX tIenOBeK 6bID poM roilY COD HanHCTHqeCKOH AeMOKpaTHH y Hero AOn KHO 6bITh H OCTanca CTaTHCTOM H 'ITO ero OAeTOrO B pa3Hb1e nepHOAbI HCTO­ H npaBO 06 3TOH cBoeH n03HUHH 3a IIBHTb B neqaTH OTKpbITO Hac­ pHH B pa3llHtJHbIe KOCTWMbI OAHHaKOBO nepep sHl'aWT no Cl eHe a KonbKO MHe H3BeCTHO HeCKonbKO H3 npHCYTCTBywW HX Ha H3IlIeM OH CTaTHCT A3 I e He 3HaeT KTO COtIHHHn nbecy H 'ITO B Heii npoHCXO­ AHT 146 147 POJII KOTOPyro B HameM 06I qeCTBe npoAOn KaeT HrpaTI u eH­ 3Ypa HeCMOTpH Ha HOBl m 3aKOH 0 nellaTH COBepllIeHHO nOCThIA­ Ha lh CTaTbH KOTOpyro H HanHcan J llH ra3eTbI JlmepapHH HOBH­ Hbl J1HTeparypHaH ra3eTa 61 w BbItrePKuyt KaK pa3 TOT a63aIJ pap H KOToporo OHa 6bwa HaDHcaHa - noqeMY H OTKa3anCH OT CBoe­ ro nocra lIJleHa UK llepBaH npHqHHa - COI03a nucaTeneH BOT 1 IT0 TaM rOBOpH1IOCb Ham opraH He BocopHHHManCH KaK paBHOnpaBHbIH eMU HHCTHryTaMH KOTopbIe AOn f HbI 6bIJlH ero TaKOBbIM C1 IHraTh B 3TO IKe BpeMH H CYAH1ICH no f HJlHI QHbIM AenaM HaHBHO npeACTaBnHH ee6e HOBbm 3aKOH 0 nellam H nonpoCH1l nOMoraBllIe­ ro MHe B X HnHI qHOM HCKe aABOKaTa nOAaTh OT Moero HMeHH lKano­ 6y Ha HapyrneHHe noro 3aKOHa nOCKOJIbKY B BblqepKuyroM a63au e HHKaK Henb3H 6bWO yCMOTpeTb HHqerO 1 IT0 Morno 6bI HaHecm yrnep6 HHTepecaM rocYAapcma H 06I qecma R 6bW OqeHb YAHBneH KorAa MOB aABOKaT Ha cneAYIOI QHH AeHb n03BOHHn MHe H nopa­ X eHHbIH 3THM eI qe 6OnbllIe qeM H 06'bHCHHn MHe 1 IT0 TaKyro B03­ MO f HOCTb 3aIIJ HThI HOBbIH 3aKOH 0 ne1 lam He npeAOCTaBnHeT BbIcnyrnan ero 06'bHCHeHHe R 1 IT0 MHe eI qe OCTaBanOCb AenaTh H Y3Han 1 IT0 H HMelO npaBO HanpaBHTh CBOH npoTeCT TonbKO B pe­ AaKIJ HIO ra3eTbI Ecnu peAaKIJ HH BCTaHeT Ha MOIO CTOPOHY OHa ne­ peAaCT npoTeCT H3AaTenlO EcnH H H3AaTeJlb C01 lTeT 1 IT0 OH BMeCTe C aBTOPOM H peAaKIJ HeH MO IKeT HeCTH omeTcmeHHOCTb 3a MOIO CTaTI IO TO TorAa opraHbI u eH3ypbI ecnH OHH 3aHHTepeCOBaHbI H36e IKaTb cYAa AOnX HbI pa3pellIHTI HanellaTaTh CTaTblO R eI qe pa3 nop qepKHBalO qro 3TH npaBH1Ia AOn f HbI C06nIOAaTbCH eCJlH peTh H lJ eT 0 npo6neMax 06I qeCTBeHHO 3Ha1 lHMbIX KaK B BbIqepKuyrOM a63au e MoeH CraThH HO HH B KoeM cnyllae - H 3TO nOHHTHO - ecnH peTh H lJ eT 0 Bonpocax KOTOpbIe MOrJlH 6bl HaHeCm yrnep6 o60poHo­ cnoc06HOCTH rocYAapcma H1IH npoTHBOpeqHJlH 6bI KOHCTHTyIJ HH Ho 3TO Bce B TeoPHH llpaKTHKa IKe raKOBa 1fi'0 u eH30pbI CBOIO nellaTb He nOCTaBHT nOTOMY 1 IT0 OHH y6eX lJ eHbI 1 IT0 HHKTO Ha HHX X anOBaTbCH He 6YAeT 3aKOH 0 nellaTH nepeqepKHBaeTCH napmHHbIM nOCTaHOBJleHHeM B HHCThI coomeTCTBHH C KOTOPbIM H3AaTenH-KOMMY­ 06H3aHbI o6cYAHTh Bonpoc B UK mIl COOTBeTCTByroI qeM OTAene Pe3ynbraT 3Toro TonbKO 0 lJ HH 3a HeCKOJlbKO nocneA­ HHX MeCHIJ eB 6bWO 3anpeI qeHO lleCKonbKO AeCHTKOB CTaTeH HaDH- 148 nH Ony6nHKOBaHbI nOTOMY 1 IT0 3a 3TO BpeMH nOTepJDIH aKTyanb­ HOCTI EbITI MO IKeT TOBapHlIJ H 1II0Tona IIInuTIJ ep H llTa1 lHHK coo6­ I qaT HaM TO'IHble AaHHble CKOJlbKO 6bWO nOAaHO X an06 Ha opraHbI U eH3ypbI pennHKa llTa1 lHHKa R 1 IHCTO BHeIlIHHH HeKOTopbIe Ba f HeHllIHe pelle­ HHH 6bIJlH npHHHTbI HeCMOTpH Ha HaIlIH AeJIOBbIe H o60CHOBaHHbIe B03p8 KeHHH caHHbIX J llH ra3eThI JlmepapHH HOBHHbI HeKoTopbIe nocne BMe­ IlIaTenbcma napTHHHbIX opraHOB Bee IKe BbIIlIJlH MHorue IKe He 6bl­ AYMalO H aIlI C'be3A - HH pa3Y C'be3 lJ COI03a 3Ha1 lHTeJIbHaH 1 IaCTb qne­ HOB KOToporo - nucaTeJlH-ny6nHIJ HCTbl - AonX eH Tpe60BaTh TaKoro AononHeHHH K 3aKOHY 0 nellam B coomeTCTBHH C KOTOPblM KaX ­ p bm aBTOP HMen 6bI npaBO 3aI qHI QaTb CBo60AY BblCKa3bIBaHHH B paMKax - nOAqepKHBaro - B paMKax KOHcmryIJ HH If npeX Ae H HbIHe KaX p bm aBTOP HeceT OmetcmeHHOCTb H 3a CBOH B3rnsp bI H 3a CBoe TBopqeCmo orneTCTBeHHOCTb MOpanbHYIO KorAa ero KPHTHKylOT ny6nH'lHO OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb MaTepHanbHyro KorAa ero npoH3BeAeHHe 3anpeI qaeT u eH3Ypa H OH nHllIaetCH TeM caM'bIM rOHopapa H OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb IOpHAHqeCKyro 3a 3ry TpOHHyro OT­ BeTCTBeHHOCTb eMY cneAYeT npeAOCTaBHTI e lJ HHCTBeHHOe H eCTeCT­ BeHHoe npaBo 3aI qHI QaThCH C nOMOI qblO 3aKOHa KOTOPbIH B cnyqae ecnH aBTOP qeM-TO npOBHHHnCH MOX eT 6bITb HCnOJlb30BaH npoTHB Hero R npeJl Iararo 1 IT06bl 3Ta peKOMeHp aIJ HH 6bwa BKnlOqeHa B llOCTaHOBneHHe C'be3Aa KaK caMoCToHTenbHbm nyHKT AnnoAHc­ MeHTbI BoiiHa Ha EnH f HeM BoCTOKe H 3aKOH 0 ne1 laTH npHHHTbIH Hep aBHO B IIexocnoBaKHH 3TO ABa Bonpoca KOTopbIe Ha nepBbIH B3rn 11 l HHKaK He CBH3aHbI Ho K CqaCTblO HHOrAa npaBAa K COM­ IDfTenbHOMY ClIaCThIO KPyr MOHX ApY3eii H 3HaKOMbIX B 3Ha1 lHTenb­ Hoii CTeneHH COCTOHT H3 MOJIOAbIX nlOAeii - 20-25 net - T e JIIOAeii Ha nOKoneHHe Mnap llIHX MeHH B OCHOBHOM cryAeHTOB Moryr BOl­ pa3HTb 1 IT0 Moe OTHOllIeHHe K 3TOMY I10KOJIeHHlO HeCKOJIbKO cym eK­ THBHO nOCKOJIbKY Ha l a6pHKax H Ha I10nHX no MHeHHIO HeKOTO­ pbIX anIlaparquKOB AO CHX I10p X HBet H TPYAHTCH MOnOAeX b 1 IHCTaH u enb KOTOpoii - BCTynneHHe B KOMMYHHCTHqeCKyro I1apTHIO IIexocnoBaKHH uaX e eCOH 6bI 3TO 6bWO TaK H Bee PaBHO He MOry H36aBHThCH OT THX eCTH Ha eepp n e TaK KaK H3 HeCKonbKHX AeCHT­ KOB MOHX MOJIOAbIX APY3eii - 6yp yrnux HJlH Y IKe OKOH1 IHBllIHX HHCTHtyTbI HFOKeHepoB apTHCTOB apxmeKTopoB H Bpaqeii T e H3 nlOAeii KOTopbIe B BeK HaY'lHO-TeXHHqeCKOii peBOJllOIJ HH 6yAY HaxOAHTbCH Ha KaDHTaHCKHX MOCTHKax CBOHX I1po l eCCHH 0 Bcryn­ 149 HOBbIE KHHrH nemm B napmlO He A 'MaeT HH OAHU MoryT B03pa3HTb 'lITO a BCTpe­ tmlOCb C KaKHMH-TO Y'lUep6HbIMH nlOAbMH HO KaK HH CTpaHHO OHH COBepllleHHO HOPMaDbHbI H 'lITO O'leHb Ba'ICHO HCKnIO'lHTenbHO Ta­ naHmHBbI qenOBe'leCKHe OTHOllleHHH CPOPMHPYIOTCH He TonbKO Ha OCHOBe napTHHHOH npHHa n rre'ICHOCTH n03TOMY OHH TepMT Meua B CBoeH KOMnaHHH 60nee Toro OTHOCHTCa KO MHe C AQBepHeM Tepe3a TOpaHCKaH H nOTOMY B MoeM npHcyTCTBHH OTKpoBeHHbI Kor lJ a OHH BbICKa3bI­ RKy6 BepMllH BalOT He COBeeM BepHble B3rna lJ bl Ha nepBYIO pecnyt'iJrnKy Ha 1945 ro lJ Ha 4leBpanb Ha COBeTcKHH COlO3 Ha HalllH COI03HH'leCKHe OTHOllleHHH C CCCP Ha 3ana tJ HyIO lJ eMOKpaTHIO a cnoplO C HHMH B TO lICe BpeMH a cnoplO H 3a HHX H OT HX HMeHH Hx HnnlO3HH HE3ABHCHMOCTb nO-COBETCKH H CKenCHC nopo I AeHbI TeM 'lITO 3TOH MODO lJ e lKH lJ a H BceM lJ PyrHM cnoco6HbIM tJ yMaTb rpa lK lJ aHaM HameH CTpaHbI lJ 0 CHX H lJ eH HaBa 3bI­ 11 en BalOT aBTOpHTapHO 'lITO OHH He reHepHpyroTCH B CBo60 lJ HOH lJ HCKYC­ CHH nyTeM 06MeHa MHeHHHMH TOT CPaKT 'lITO 'leTblpe HaIlIHX Tena - lJ Boe n06bmaBlllHX B Ibpanne H lJ Boe - mea­ B 06'beAHUeHHoH apa6cKoH pecnyMHKe He nonY'lHnH B03MO'ICHOCTH BbICKa3aTb CBOH qTO 6bl ew cOeIUlIlU C MUKollaiilluKoM eCllu 6bl OH He 6e­ B3rnH lJ bI Ha CTpaHHnaX ra3eThI llinepapHH HOBHHbI H3 onaceHHH 'lITO 3TO nOCTaBHT no lJ yrpo3y penyTaIUUO npaBHTenbCTBa 3aIUlBlllero JICQIl H3 BbIClllHX HmepeCOB 0 lJ H03Ha'lHyro n03Hl HIO nHlllb eme pa3 nn­ nlOCTpHpyeT 31y Hamy lJ eHCTBHTenbHOCTb O tJ HaKO B CTpanax 6yp­ OH He OCTaDca 6bI Ha CBoeM nocry 3TO 6bmo O'IeBH lJ HO lK 'a3HOH lJ eMOKpaTHH KOTOpylO MbI Ha3bmaeM MapHOHeTO'lHOH Ho a He 0 lKH tJ an 'lITO OH C6e lKHT MbI KaK pa3 npHHHManH 3 tJ aHHe HHor tJ a tJ a lKe HMea AlIa nora HeKOTopbIe OCHOBaHHH BbICTYIDIeHHH focDnaua Kor tJ a KTo-TO CKa3an MHe 0 n06ere MuKOnaH'lHKa ua CTpaHHnaX ra3eT co B3rnH lJ aMH OTnH'lHbIMH OT OCPlmHaDbHblX lJ eno 6Y lJ HH'lHoe B pe3yJIbTaTe B 3THX CTpaHaX HaMIO tJ aeTCH nonHTH­ qeCJ aH aKTHBH3aUHa MonO lJ e lKH lJ OBODbHO nOXO lKaH Ba aKTHBH3a­ - oClle pa3zPOMll OJlbCKOU KpeCTbJlHCKOU napTuu CJ1 npulUJlQ OllepeOb OJlbCKOU C014UaIlUC7UlleCKOu nap7Uu C u n1O MORX cBepCntHKOB B MOnO lJ OCTH Kor tJ a KCTaTH rOBopa y Hac u noCile pacnpaew C RCHbw-3aeaOcKUM U KOHonKoii HaCTMa Olle­ B nepBbIe nOCneBOeHH ble rO lJ bI 6bm COBepllleHHO CB060 lJ HbIii 06MeH peob rOMYIlKU MHeHHHMH••• H CHOBa BepHYCb K TeMe C KOTOPOH a BallaD H KOTOPOH xoqy SllKOHllHTb CBoe BbICTYJmeHHe focy tJ apCTBO - 3TO rOCY lJ apCTBO tJ a llCe ecnn pellb H lJ eT 0 CO CTH'leCKOM roCY lJ apcme Y rocy­ tJ apCTBa eCTb CBOH CPynKUHH H 06H3aTenbCTBa KOTopbIe pa3YMHbIH - HeT 310 He TaK llepBoe CTODKHOBeHHe C fOMYDKOH npoH­ 30UDIO He H3'3a ero BbICTYJmeHHH 0 PODH KOTOPyro Hrpana ll11C a ua ro lJ paHbllle OceHblO 1947 r COBeTcKHH COlO3 BbICtynHn C HHH· UHaTHBOH C03 tJ aHHH KOMHHcpopMa 3Ta HHHUHaTHBa npenO lJ HOCH­ rpa ll tJ aHHH lJ on llCeH npH3HaBaTb Ho Bee lICe He C'JIe tJ yeT 3a6bmaTb 'lITO MhI Kor tJ a-TO OCY'lUeCTBHnH KaKYIO-TO peBODIOIUUO KOTOpaa lJ OJDKHa 6bIDa peanHlOBaTh CaMbIe CMeJlble Me'ITbI qenOBe'lecTBa H B pe3ynbTaTe KOTOPOH 'lenOBeK lJ OJDKeH 6bIn craTh CB060 lJ HbIM • 1'13 KHHrH Tepe3w TopaHcKoA OHH 3TOT C50PHHK HHTepBblO C OWBWHMH nonbCKHMH KOMMYHHCTH'leCKHMH jJ e llTen llMH own H3­ jJ aH B flonbwe B HenOjJ u eH3ypHOM H3jJ aTenbCTBe TepBblO 150 C BepMaHoM Przedswit HH­ ne'laTaeTCJI C HeOOlIbWHMH COKpalIleHHJIMH 151