HOBbiE KHHrH JIeHHH B naprHIO He AYMaeT HH OnHH MOryT B03PIl3HTb 1l T0 fI BCTpe­ lIalOCb C KaKHMH-TO y w ep6HbIMH JIlOgbMH HO KaK HH CTpaHHO OHH COBepmeHHO HOPMaJIhHbI H 1l T0 OqeHb Ba I HO HCKJIlOlIHTeJIhHO Ta­ JIaHTJIHBbl tJeJIOBeqeCKHe OTHOmeHH fI P0PMHPYIOTC fI He TOJIhKO Ha OCHOBe naprHiiHOH npHHa u rre I HOCTH n03TOMY OHH Tepll fIT MeH fI B CBoeH KOMnaHHH 60JIee mro OTHOC fITC fI KO MHe C gOBepHeM It nOTOMY B MoeM npHCYTCTBHH OTKpoBeHHhI KorWl OHH BbICKll3bl­ Tepe3a TOpaHCKaJl JlKy6 EepMaH BalOT He COBeeM BepHble B3rJl fIgbl Ha nepBylO peCny6JIHKY Ha 1945 rog Ha il eBpaJIh Ha COBeTCKHH COI03 Ha HamH COlO3HH'1eCKHe OTHomeHH fI C CCCP Ha B 3all3 AftYIO geMOKpaTHIO fI cnoplO C HHMH TO ICe BpeM fI fI cnOplO H 3a HHX H OT HX HMeHH Hx HJlJl103HH HE3ABHCHMOCTb nO-COBETCKH' H CKenCHC nopo f AeHbI TeM 1l T0 nOH MOJIoge f H Wl H BceM gpyrHM cnOC06HhIM AYMaTh rp aM HameH CTpaHhl go CHX RAeH HaB fI3hl­ II BalOT aBTOpHTapHO 1l T0 OHH He reHepHPYIOTcS B CBo60AHOH AHCKYC­ qaCTL CHH nYTeM 06MeHa MHeHH fIMH TOT paKT 1l T0 qeThlpe HaIIIHX llHca­ TeJI fI - ABoe n06hWaBIllHX B IhpaHJle H ABoe - B 06'beAHHeHHOH apa6cKoH pecny6JIHKe He nOJIYIDIJIH B03MO I HOCTH BhlCKll3aTh CBOH qro 6bl 6bl COe lllllU C MUKO UlUIJUKOM eCllu 6bl OH He 6e­ B3m fIAbI Ha CTpaHHII aX rll3eTbI J1HTepapHH HOBHHhl H3 onaceHHH 1l T0 3TO nOCTaBHT JIog yrpo3Y penyTaJJ HIO npasHTeJIhCTBa 33 HJIBmerO 3ICllIl H3 BhlCIllHX HHTepeCOB OAH03HatmyIO n03HIJ HIO JlHIDb eme pa3 HJl­ - JIIOCTpHpyeT 3TY HaII Iy geHCTBHTeJIhHOCTh OgHaKO B CTpaHax 6yp­ OH He OCTaJIC fI 6hl Ha CBoeM nocTY 3TO 6hlJlO OqeBHAHO f ya3HOH geMOKpaTHH KOTOPYIO Mhl Ha3hWaeM MapHOHeTO'IHOH Ho fI He O f HAaJI lITO OH C6e f HT Mhl KaK pll3 npHHHMaJIH 3WlHHe HHorWl Wl ICe HMe fI AlI fI 3Toro HeKOTophle OCHOBaHH fI BhICTynneHH fI focllJIaHa KorWl KTo-TO CKa3aJI MHe 0 no6ere MHKOJIaHlIHKa Ha CT ax ra3eT co B3m fIWlMH OTJIH'lHbIMH OT 0 pHUHaJIhHbIX geJIO 6YAHH'lHoe B pe3ynhTaTe B 3THX CTpaHaX Ha6JIlOgaeTC fI nOJIHTH­ lIeCKa fI aKTHBH3aIJ H fI MOJIoge f H gOBOJIhHO nOXO ICa R Ha aKTHBH3a­ u KIO MOHX CBepcmHKOB B MOJIOgOCTH KorWl KCTaTH rOBOp fI y Hac B nepBhle nOCJleBoeHHhle rOgbI 6hlJl COBepmeHHO CBo60AHhIH 06MeH - nOCile pa3zpOMa nOllbCKOU KpeCTbllHCKOU napruu nCJI npuUI Ul OlJepeiJb nOllbCKOU COijUllIlUC1UlJeCKOU nap1UU nnC U nOCile pacnpa6bl C JlcHblM-3aeaocKUM U KOHonKOU HaCTllIla olJe­ peiJb rOMYIlKU MHeHH fIMH H CHOBa Bepaych K TeMe C KOTOPOH fI Haqan H KOTOPOH xoqy 3aKOHllHTh CBoe BhlCTynJIeHHe focyWlpCTBO - 3TO rocygapCTBO Wl ICe eCJlH pe'lh RAeT 0 COIJ HaJIHCTHqeCKOM rOCYWlpCTBe Y rocy­ WlpcTBa eCTh CBOH PYHKIJ HH H 06 fI3aTeJIbCTBa KOTophle pa3YMHbIH - HeT 3TO He TaK IIepBoe CTOJIKHOBeHHe C fOMynKOH npoH­ 3OWJIO He H3-3a ero BhlCTynJIeHH fI 0 POJIH KOTOPYIO HrpaJIa IIIIC a Ha rog paHhme OceHbIO 1947 r COBeTcKHH C0103 BhlCTyllHJl C HHH­ IJ HaTHBOH C03WlHH fI KOMHH p0pMa 3Ta HHHIJ HaTHBa npenOAHOCH­ rpU AaHHH gOJI lCeH npH3HaBaTh Ho Bee ICe He CJleAYeT 3a6hIBaTh 1l T0 Mhl KorWl-TO ocymeCTBHJlH KaKYIO-TO peB 0JI1OIJ HIO KOTOPa R gOIDKHa 6hIJIa peaJIH30BaTb caMhle CMeJIble MeqTh1 qeJIOBeqecTBa H B pe3yJIhTaTe KOTOPOH qeJIOBeK gOIDKeH 6hIJI CTaTh CB060AHblM • H3 KHHrH Tepe3bI TopaHcKoA OHH 3TOT COOPHHK HHTepBLIO C ObIBIIIHMH nonLCKHMH KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKHMH l eJlTelIJlMH ObIlI H3­ l aH B flom IIIe B HenO l ll eH3ypHOM H3 l aTenbCTBe TepBblO 150 C BepMaHoM Przedswit HH­ ne'laTaeTCJl C HeOOlIbIIlHMH COKpaw eHHJlMH 151 JIaCb He KaK nOnbITKa B03POAHTb KOMHHTepH a KaK C03 l aHHe He COOTBeTCTBOBaJIO TOMY 0 qeM HaM rOBOPHJI CTaJIHH fOMynKa HHCTpYMeHTa l lU KOOPAHHHPOBlIHH II l eHTeJIbHOCTH Beex napTHH no HepBHHIJaJI CraJIHH 06MaHYJI MeHH - npJIHllHllY eAHHOMbiCJ1IDi B OTJIH'lHe OT KOMHHTepHa r l e rOCDO l CT­ rOJIOCOBaTb DpoTHB C03 l aHHH HHtPoPM6ropo Tyr H DepeDyraJICH BOBaJI DPJIHllHll nO J llHHeHWI 60JIblllHHCTBY CHallaJIa Y CTaJIHHa DO­ 11 6bIBaJI fOM 'JIKa a DOTOM H 11 TOr l a e3AHJI B KHcnOBO l CK OT l bI­ CKalaJI OH - Mbl 6Y l eM Be l b nOHHMan lITO 6Y l eT eCJIH nOJIbllia DporOJIocyeT DpoTHB npH l eTCH JIHGo DpeKpaTHTb COBemaHHe JIOGo DepeHeCTO ero Ha l py­ 11 xarb H OCTaHOBHJICH B MOCKBe CTaJIHH Y3HaJI 06 3TOM H DpHrnaCHJI TOH CpoK MeHH B KpeMJIb Ha lIOH BCTpelle DPHCYTCTBOBaJIH lIJIeHhl nOJIHT6ro­ 3TO Ke DOJIHbIH paCKOJI 3TO HapYIIIHT COOTHOllIeHHe CHJI DOHMH po K l aHOB MOJIOTOB BoP01llHJIOB a TaK Ke ypueBa MeHH DOcaAHJIH PH l OM co l naHOBbIM 11 C Y l HBJIeHHeM saMeTHJI liTO l naHOB co CTaJIHHbIM Ha TbI a ClIHTaJIOCb liTO CTaJIHH Ha TbI TOJIbKO C Mo­ 11 lITO 6Y l eT 03HatJaTb HapYIIIeHHe nOJIbilieH eAHHCTBa COUUaJIOCTHlJee­ He CTOHT Ooo HCHHTb KaKHe HeCtlaCTbH CBaJIHJIHCb 6bl Ha Hac -KaKue cpa3Y DOHHJI lITO 3TO He DpOCTO l pY KeCKaH BCTpetla XOTH CTaJIHH 6bIJI qpe3BbIllaHHO JIro6e3eH fOBOPHJI B oe­ HOBHOM CTaJIHH OH CKa3aJI liTO Dpe l CTOHT COBemaHHe KOMDapTHii H 06 3TOM 6Y l eT ony6nHKoBaHo KOMMroHHKe Ha COBemaHHH 6y­ l eT OCHOBaHO HHtP0PM6ropo BOPOIlIIlJIOB Dpe l JlO KHJI C03BaTb COBemaHOe B KPbIMY KeJIaH BepoHTHO HMHTopoBaTb limy• upyrHe Ke npe l Jlo KllJIH nOJIbWY nOJIbllie HH 11 He B03pa KaJI 0 Bee OCTaHOBHJIHCb Ha MHe HH fOMynKe CTaJIHH He CKalaJI KaKyro poJIb l OJI KHO 6Y l eT HrpaTb HHtP0PM6ropo OH TOJIbKO DO l lIepKHYJI qTO B cnO KHBllIeHCH Me K l yHapO l HOH 06CTaHOBKe 03-sa CTpeMJIeHHH AMepHKH npH6paTb Beex K pyKaM Ry KHO cKOHUeHTpHpoBaTb CH­ JIbl 3TO 6bIJIO BeCKUM apryMeHTOM Be l b AMepHKa Tor l a l eHCTBH­ TeJIbHO HacrynaJIa HY KHO 6bIJIO COMKHYTb PH l b1 H l aTb OTJIOp HHtPOPM61Opo C03 l aBaJIO B03MO KHOCTb ooo eAHHHTb KOMDapTHH H CTpaHbI CO U UaJIHCTHlIeCKOro JIarepH l JlH Goph6bI C Bpa KeCKOH ar­ peccHeH H l eH 6bIJIa npaBHJIbHOH TeM GoJIee ' TO CTaJIHH 3aBepHJI MeHH liTO BO BHYTpeHHeH DOJIHTHKe DaprHH 6yAYT COBepllIeHHO ca­ MOCTOHTeJIbHbI H He3aBHCUMbi npH TaKUX 06cTOHTeJIbCTBax H He nOHMH KOro JIarepH 3TO 6Y l eT 03Haqarb H3MeRy COBeTCKoMY COro3Y JIOTOBblM H mnIlb Hae l HHe nO l aJIH tJaH DhITaJICH Ooo HCHHTb fOMYJIKe DOJIO KeHHe - Hawy PyKOBO l HIUylO rpynny nocnaJIH 6bl K IJepTY a BJIaCTb DepellIJIa 6bl B PyKO CTpaIIIHblX JIro l eH JIyqIIIe 06 3TOM He JJ yMaTb 11 He Mor nepey6e l HTb foM 'JIKY OH BeJI ee6H KaK pe6eHOK KOTO­ pbIH He nOHHMaeT Ha KaKOM CBeTe OH KHBeT 0 OTKalbIBaeTCH C'IIH­ raTbCH C peaJIbHOCTbro Mor npeO l OJIeTb nOJIHT6ropo 11 11 Y Hero 6bIJIH KOMDJIeKCbI KOTOPbIX OH He eeJI B MaIIIHHY H Doexan B BapIIIaBY C06paJIOCb l OJIO KHJI 06 06CTaHOBKe MbI nOHHMaJIH ' TO H MbI OTBeTCTBeHHbI 3a KOHKpeTHbIe pellIeHHH lIoro COBemaHHS MbI MOo KeM HaCTaHBaTb Ha H3MeHeHHH He YCTpaHBaIDmux Hac tPOPMYJIHPOo BOK H TaK MbI 0 nOcryDaJIH HO B DpHH u Hne Mbl l OJI KHbI 6bITb co­ JIH l apHhl CO BeeMH Mbl BocnpoTHBIlJIHCb fOMYJIKe 0 pe1llHJIH rOo JIOCOBaTb 3a C03 l aHHe HHtPOPM61Opo H 3a Dpe l JlO KeHHyro COBeTe­ KHM COro30M pe30JIIOUUro XOTH H C HeKOTOpblMH orOBopKaMH fOMYJIKa BblHy K l eH 6bIJI nO J llHHHTbCH HaIIIeMY pellieHIDO - Bce OC7Y lJlbHWe oelleeaquu 6wIlu 3a yBH ll eJI B H ll ee C03 l aHHH HHtPOPM6ropo HHlIero TaKoro liTO MeHH 6bI HaCTOPO KHJIO HHKaKoro OrpaHHlIeHHH CB060 l b1 HallIHX l eHCTBHH nocne 6ece l b1 H HaDHCaJI l OKJIa l Hyro 3aDHCKy fOMYJIKe H ye­ xan OT l bIXaTb 11 3HaJI 0 DO l 03peHHHX fOMynKH lITO H l eH C03 l aHHH BlOpo Morna npecne l OBaTb 0 l pyrue ueJIH KpoMe Tex 0 KOTOPblX HaC yBe l OMHJIH Mbi Dpe l DOJIaraJIH 3TO Ho DO l 03peHWI 0 l H0 a tPaKTbl - l pyroe aKTbl Ke BhII'M l eJIH l OBOJIbHO 6e306H l H0 COBeIUaHHe COCTOHJIOCb B IIlKJIHpCKOH nOpeH6e OT DOJIbCKOH Dapruu B HeM ytlaCTBOBaJIH fOM 'JIKa H MoHr 11 DpHcyTCTBOBaJI B KaIJeCTBe COBeTHHKa npoHCXOAHBllIee Ha COBemaHHH COBepllIeHHO - EcTeCTBeHHO OCOGeHHO Uxamac Tenepb OH xpa6peu a B TO BpeMH OH nocnYllIHO BbICrymm DpOTHB tPPaHUY3CKOH H HTaJIbSHe­ KOH KOMDapTHii sa TO lITO DOCJIe nOpa KeHHH fepMaHHH OHH He 60­ POJIHCb 3a BJIaCTb H palopy KllJIH CBOH napmliHbIe MHJIHIl HH CDOp o TOM pa30PY K Tb HX HJIH HeT COCTOHJICH paHbllie H 6bIJI pellieH C CornaCHa H l a Ke HHHuuaTHBbl MOCKBbl- 6bIJIO npHHHTO pellIeHHe palOpy KHTb Ho BO BpeMS COBemllHH ll Uxamac C l eJIaJI BH l 6Y l TO o cornaCHH MOCKBbI He 3HaeT H rpoMHn oGe KOMnaPTHH 3a TaKoe pellIeHHe 153 152 - - IIOlieMY Ecn u ObZ HHrPOPMOIOPO HQXOiJun OCh 8 BapUlll8e 8hZ Moen u ObZ 8n Wl1'b Ha eeo pelUeHWI - qTofiqt HX 3anyraTb B nepepbIBe MeX Dy 3aCenammMH npoH30lWlO Moe CTOJIKHOBe­ HHe co KnaHOBbIM H CKa33 ll eMY tfIO Mbl nOn KHbI BepHyTbCJlK pe­ llIeHHJlM VII KOHrpecca KOMHHTepHa KOTOPblH B 1935 r npoKna­ MHpoB3 ll Hapo lJ HbIH PPOHT H He BbICryIlllTb C pe3KHM OCYJK ll eHHeM CO 3 ll-neMOKpaTlf1leCKHX napTHH TaK KaK HMeHHO OHH MOryT no­ MO'll YKpeIlHTb n03 KOMnapTHH B 3ana lJ HOH EBpone a 3anan­ HYJO EBpony Heofixo lJ HMO OTopBaTb OT AMepHKH B nOH lJ HCKYCCHH co KnaHOBbIM JI KaK fibl nponomroUI MbIC­ IlH nOKna lJ HOH 3aIIHCKH 0 B3aHMOOTHOllIeHHJIX B nocneBoeHHoH EB­ pone 3TY nOKnlliJ HYlO JI HanHCaJI B aBrYCTe 1943 r nnJl TonbJITTH H nHCaJI tfIO nocne BOHHbI HameH CTpaTenNecKoH nenbro fiynyr TeCHbIe 3KOHOMH'IeCKHe H KynbrypHbIe CBJl3H C 3ana lJ HOH EBponoH HeofixO J HMbIe lJ IDI npenoxpaHeHHJI 3ana lJ HOH EBponbl OT aMepH­ KaHCKoro BnHJIHWI H npe J BH lJ en tfIO nocne BOHRbI AMepHKa CTa­ HeT MoryqeH nep KaBOH H Ha'IHeT 60Pbfiy 3a nO lJ 'lHHeHHe 3ana lJ Hon EBpollbI TaK OHO H cnyqHnOCb Ofi 3TOM CBH lJ eTenbCTByeT MaR MapllIanna KOTOPbIH 06011IenCJI AMepHKe O'leHb noporo HO 3aTO npHHec eii orpoMHYJO nonb3Y TonbJITTH MHe He OTBenm HO JI He COMHeBarocb tfIO OH paCCKa33 ll 0 MoeM MeMopau u yMe pYCCKHM TaK BOT ofi 3TOM JI 3arOBopIDI co f u aHOBbIM BO BpeMJI nepepbIBa Ha COBen w HHH B lIIKnJIpCKOH TIopeHfie f u aHOB nOBOObHO rpy60 OT­ BeTIDI He YMHH'laiiTe MbI B MocKBe nyqme 3HaeM KaK npHMeHJITb MapKCH3M-neHHHH3M H npOMOntIaJI H Ha 3TOM fiecena 3aKOH'lH­ naCb - Ha 3TO HHKaK Henb3J1 fibIDO paCC'lHTbIBaTb COBeTCKaH nene­ r Beer lJ 8 B COCTOJIHHH HaBH3aTb CBoe pellIeHHe MbI He nem H Mbl 3HanH tfIO ecnH IiH POPMfiropo fiyneT HaxO lJ HThCJI B BapllIaBe COBeTCKHe Bee BpeMJI fiY lJ YT npHe3 KaTb H ne3Tb B HallIH nena MO­ xeeT y Hac He TaK Barno KaK B npyrnx CTpaHax - Mbl HX npHeMbI 3HaeM HO Bee Ke MbI npennO'lnH He fipaTb Ha cefiJl Bcen THXCecm 3Toii 3aTeH TeM 6onee tfIO MbI He 3HanH B KaKOM HanpaaneHHH Bce lTO nOKamrCJI H KaKHe pellIeHHJI fiyneT npHHHMaTb Bropo K TOMY Ke Mbl He XOTenH tfIOfibI Bee BHHMaHHe cocpenOTO'IIDIOCb Ha BapllIaBe tfIOfibl OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a BCro 3ry 3aTero nema Ha Hac EcnH fibl Mbl comaCIDIHCb MbI BbIHYJK ll eHbl fibIDH fibl Becm J BOH­ HYro Hrpy a Mbl HH B KoeM cnyqae He XOTenHOfiMaHbIBaTbpycCKHX IDIH nocrynaTb no OTHOllIeHHro K HHM HenOlIJIbHO ECTeCTBeHHo Mbl fihIDH 3aHHTepeCOBaHbI B ocymeCTBneHHH HallIHX pellIeHHii HO He neHon OfiMaHa IIo3ToMY J llJl HaC fibInO BblrO lJ Hee npHHHMaTb yqacme B pafiOTe MH OPMfiropo Ha paBHbIX Ha'IaJIax C npyrHMH HO He KaK BenymaH napTHH K TOMy Ke MbI yxce Torna BepHO npennona­ nH tfIO BCJI pa60Ta KOMHH pOPMfiropo OrpaHH'lHTCJI aHTHaMepH­ KaRCKOH nponaraH J on TaK OHO H npoH30lWlO npHtleM pe3ynbTaTbi fibIDH O'leHb CKPOMHblMH H pesonroUHJIMH MH pOPMfiropo OKa3a­ nOCb MepTBOpo K J eHHblM pe6eHKOM - Hy He C08ceM TaK B UIOHe 1948 e KOMUHrP0PMOIOPO ocy­ iJun o OeOCIla8UIO npaBoHalluoHan ucTUllecKuu YKn OH 8 non hCKOU napTUU U OOR3an O Bce napTUU ocyuteCTBUTb Kon n eKTU8U3allUIO Bo BpeMJI COBemaHHJIKTO-TO npennO KHJI tfIOfibI llITa6-KBapm­ pa MH poPMfiropo fibIDa B BapllIaBe Ho Mbl Hafip3 llHCb CMenocm H oTKa3anHcb COcnaBllIHCb Ha TO tfIO TIonbllIa nepeXCHBaeT cephal­ Hble 3KOHOMH'IeCKHe 3aTpY lJ HeHHJI tfIO KaK pal eeifqac BenyrCJI C AMepHKOH neperOBopbI 0 3aRMe H B03BpameHHH 30nOTa KOTopoe HaXOnHTCJI B pYKax nOObCKoro 3MHrpaUHOHHOro npaBHTenbCTBa B JIOH lJ OHe H nOTOMY HaM HeynofiHo HMeTb llITa6-KBapTHpy MH p0PM­ firopo B BapllIaBe MbI npoCTO He XOTenH sne3aTb B neno KOTopoe 3anany fiyneT JlBHO He no nyme TeM 6onee tfIO MbI He 3HaJIH KaK Boofime cnOXCHTCH cynboo IiH pOPMfiropo cen bCKoeo X03ftUCT8a HpOHWI CyiJbOhl npOR6un aCh 6 TOM 'ITO T KOCTOB U3 Eon eapuu KOTOPhlU 6hlcrynun C OCYJICiJeHUeM iJpyeux KOMnapTUU Bceeo n UlUb eoiJoM n03J1Ce Obln Ka3HeH 6hlCrynU8lUaJZ C TaKUMU JlCe OCYJICiJeHWlMu AHHa IIaYKep U3 PyMblHUU OblJ1 a Ka3He­ Ha lleTblpe zoiJa cnYCTR a YllaCT606aBlUUU 8 3TUX OCYJICiJeHWlx CIlaHCKUU U3 Qexocn 06aKUU OC lJ CiJeH U Ka3HeH 6 TOM JlCe eoiJy 'ITO U IIaYKep EcnH npeHefipe'll MenKHMH neTaJIHMH KOH pnHKT C IOrocna­ BHeH fibtn nopo K J eH CTpeMneHHeM COBeTcKoro Coro3a yCTaROBHTb CBOH nOpJl J OK B BOCTO'IHOH H UeHTpanbHOH EBpone B TO BpeMJI 155 154 npe l IaraJIHCb pa3llHllHble BapHaHTbI 4 e pauuH mmpHMep 06be­ o uHeHRe I10nblllH C llexocnoBaKHeii MbI 6bIJIH Henpo'lb HO He XOTenH npHHYJKA3Tb K STOMY qeXOB a qexn H3-3a Toro lITO I10nbma ropa3 1J O 6onbme He BbIpIDKaJ1H no nOBO uy SToro npe l IO l eHWI HH­ KaKoro BOCTopra OHR 6bIJIH npoTHB 4 e lJ epaIJ HH BTOPOH napoH lJ on l HbI 6bIJIH ClaTb IOrocnaBHJI H BonrapHJI H He HCK1IlOqanOCb lITO K HRM npHcoe o uHHTC$I An6aHH 11 BeHrpbI 6bIJIH caMH no ceOO Ho Bce STO 6bl1l0 Ha ypOBHe pa3rOBOpOB nOTOMY lITO H B COBeTCKOM PY­ KOBO lJ Cme He 6bIJIO e o uHoro MHeHWI no STOMY Bonpocy Bonpoc 4 e lJ epauuH BbI3bman OCTpble npeHWI H cnopbl CTaJIHH 6bIJl 3a 4 e­ lJ epaumo I10nblllH H llexocnoBaKHH HO npoTHB ofi'be IJ HHeHWI IOroc­ lIaBHH C BonrapHeH Y Hero 6bIJIH nO-BH o HMOMY CBOH paClleTbI IluMHTPOB C caMoro HaqaJIa BblCTYfi3Bunt H 3a 4 e lJ epaIJ HlO C IOrocna­ BHeH OKa3anC$I B HenOBKOM nonO l emIH Ha lJ onro nOCKonbKY ero JmllHoe npHcyTCTBHe B HTaIIHH HCK1IlOqu­ TelIbHO B3 l H0 TOnb$lTTH nOBTOpHJl H8IJl npHeM HO 60nee nOBKO H ycnemHo I10cne OTKa3a Tonb$ITTH e HHKTO He COMHeBanC$I lITO KOMHH4 OPM lJ OlIrO He npocyw eCTByeT I10cne CMepTH CTaIIHHa Me l llYHapo o uoe nOlIO l eHHe H3MeHHJlOCb OKOHqHJlaCb KopeiiCKaJI BoiiHa HaqanaCb snoxa BeHCKoro KOMllpoMHCCa H BlOpO nepeCTa­ 1I0 lJ eiiCTBOBaTb fOMYnKa He nOHRMa1I Hameii n03HIJ HH OH He nOHHMa1I lITO BlOpO Ha lJ O paCCMaTpHBaTb KaK HeH3OO I HOe 3 0 3anaCTHCb Tepne­ HReM nO lJ O l J 3Tb H lJ YMaTb He TonbKO 0 CBoeii CTpaHe a He 3a6bI­ My1IKa 6bIJI 0OOcnoKoeH TeM lITO lJ enelIbHOCTb KOMHH4 opMa or­ paHHlIHBaeT aBTOHOMHIO nonbcKoii napTHH Ho 3aTeM y Hero B03HHK­ - na ro lJ CnyCT$I lIa HOBaJI H IJ e$l I10cne COBell aHH$I B IIIKMPCKOH I10peH6e OH npeA­ nO l HJl noexaTb K CTaIIHHy H nOTpe60BaTb - KaK U KOCT06 nO r tnHcaTb AOKYMeHT rapaHTHpyJOll nH HamH 3ana llHble rpauHlI bl OH He nOHRMa1I liTO KOCTOBa KOTOPbIH TO I e 6bIJl CTOPOHHHKOM o6be IJ HHeHWI paCCTpelI$I H HO $I He 3HaIO 3a STO Jm IlpHIIHH Momo 6blTb HeCKOnb­ KO IluMHTpoB CKOHqaJIC$I HOPMa1IbHO - eCTeCTBeHHoii CMepTbIO He Bee lITO rOBOp$lT 0 Y COBeTax npaB IJ 3 HHX lJ OCTaTOIIHO rpexoB H npeYMHO l 3Tb HX HeT Ha lJ 06HOCTH B 310 BpeM$I npoH30meJI pa3pbm C IOrocnaBHeii Me l IHJl C oCY I JJ eHReM IOrocnaBHH A H npaB IJ a B IJ pyr HaH IJ eTC$I KOMllpoMHC­ CRoe pemeHRe H MO i HO 6Y IJ eT o60HTHcb 003 cKaunana In YCKHH J a I e e3 J H1I B Benrpa lJ HO Bee STO OKa3a1IOCb HanpaCHbIM - H 6bl OCYOUllU lITO 6bIJIO lJ enaTb He Morna l e nonbCKaJI lJ ener BeCTH ce6$l KaK fOMY1IKa B IIIKn$IpCKoii I10peHOO llepe3 ro lJ aKTHBHOCTb KOMHH4 opMa 3aMeTHO CHH3HJIaCb Hac­ KOlIbKO MHe H3BeCTHO B COBeTcKoM COlO3e TO l e nOH$l1lH lITO B npHHrume 310 6lOPO HH K lleMY lITO OHO OO3 1J eiiCTByeT BCTpequ npoHCxop urm pe J KO BbICTYJI1IeHHJI Ha HRX 6bIJIH COBepmeHRO ce­ 156 THe 310ro nOCTa nOIpe60Ba1Io 6bl ero nOCTOJIHHOrO npe6bmaHRII B ByxapecTe a HTaIIb$IHCKaJI KOMnapTU He cornaCHTC$I OTnyCTHTb ero BaTb 06 e IJ HHCTBe coU larep$l H60 3TH HHTepeCbl Hepa3pbmHbI fOo HYMep _ A pble llT06bI O I HBHTb KOMHH4 OPM CTanHH npe l Io I HJI nOCTaBHTb BO maBe ero TOlIUTTH HO TOT OTKa3bma1IC$I ofi'b$lcH$I$I lITO lIpHH$l­ 3THM OH OCKOp6m CTa1IHHa 3aTe$l 3Ta He 6ma CBH IJ eTeJIbCTBOM ero He lJ 06po l enaTenbHOCTH K COBeTCKOMY COI03Y HeT fOMy rIKa BCer 1J 3 6bIJI 1I0MeH K CCCP B STOM HeT HHKaKHX cOMHeHHii Ho OH He nOHRMa1I lITO I101IbIna BXOAHT B coo6ll eCTBO CTpau KOTopoe HH­ TepecyeTC$I npoHCXO J $lll HM y Hac lITO I10mma lJ 01I I Ha CllHTaTbC$I C TeM lITO OCTa1IbHbIe CTpaubI XOTn AOKa3aTelIbCTB H8IJleii nO$l 11­ HOCTH KaK qrreHa 3Toro C006ll eCTBa fOMYnKa He CYMeJI 38ll HTHTb nonbCKyJO BnyTpeHHlOIO H BHem­ HlOIO nonHTHKY 003 KOH4 nHKTa C COBeTCKHM COI030M y Hero He XBaTHlIO J M SToro nOnHTHlleCKOro qyTb$l OH qaCTO He YMeJI npa­ BHJIbHO Ou eHHTb nlOAeii 4 aKTbl H 06cTaHOBKy B 310M CKa3bmanOCb lITO OH He I HJl CTom npo lJ on I HTeJIbHOe BpeM$I KaK Ml l B CCCP I1PaB IJ 3 OH yqHJlC$I B COlO3e B napTIllKone H HeKOTopoe BpeM$I pa­ 60TaII BO lliBOBe o upeKTOPOM Ma1IeHbKOrO 3aBO lJ a HO Bee l e He ycnen 03HaKOMHTbC$I CO CTpYKrypoii COBeTCKoii B1IaCTH C TeM KaK OHa 4 YHKu HOHHpyer H 310 Mema1IO eMY BeCTH C HHMH lJ elIa - On OWl TQM '1YJICUM 157 - fOMYlIKa npOCTO He 3HaJI qeM Bee no naxs eT - KOTOPU BClIblXHeT TaM H npHHeeeT C co60ii H8 Ae KJJ y Ha OCBo- 30TO npUOlllClCeHHb e FOMYIl U YT6epJlCOOIOT lITO 6b' Be- PYT U MUHu He 3H JIJU 1I01lbWu - B3 r OP He CTOHT r a Ke CnOpHTb B HIOHe pel IIIDI BldetyI1HTb Ha IUIeHapHoM 3ace r aHRH pblH He Ohm COrJIaCOBaH C IIOlIHTOIOPO' H 1948 r 6o l J eHHe CTpaHld H C03 D aHHe He3aBHCHMOro IIOJIhCKOrO rocY rJ ap­ CTBa fOMynKa UK C r OKlIa r OM KOTo­ C r elIaJI eMY 3aMelfaHHe - 2S aBryCTa 1948 r BO BpoLtJIaBe HatmJICR KOHrpecc HH' npe rJ ynpe o HB tfI'0 YaK nocrynaTb He ClIeAYeT Ho fOMynKa KaK TeJUIeKtyaJIOB - 38 lUHTHHKOB MHpa liHHl HaTopoM ero OblJl E'KH Beer rJ a HaCTaHBaJI Ha CBoeM Tor rJ a S npe r 1IOiKHJl eMY nOA'lepKHYTh Bopeiiwa C 3THM KOHrpeCCOM OH CBS3bmaJI 601IbwHe Ha rJ e K QbI B BhICTyIUIeHHH tfI'0 r OKlI8 A OTpIDKaeT ero nlfllHlde B3rJIS QbI H60 B 3a TpH He r enH r 0 HaqaJIa paOOTbI KOHrpeCca Bopeiiwa nHCaJI MHe npoTHBHOM cnyqae S OYAY BhlHY I J eH 3asBHTb BO BeeYClIhIlIlaHHe EClIH HaM He npHKIDKyt npHKpblTh Bce 3a r eHb r 0 HaqaJIa H eclIH H3 tfI'0 Mid C ero B3rJIS rJ aMH He cornaCHbI fOMynKa TaK H noctynHJI COBeTCKoro COI038 DpHe r et r elIera u mr Ha nO D XO D arueM ypOBHe TO KOurpecC MO'KeT CTaTb KpyJIHblM CoobITHeM A eClIH Mbl YMeno no­ r orpeeM KnHMar BHyTpH CTPaHhl TO KOurpecC OY r et BenHKOneJIHblM Mbl - 3TO Bbl BepYT U MUHu HHTepMe o Me O o HOH CHMcpOHHeH CpYPH030 H BTOpoii KOTO­ - lla II03HUHS fOMYJlKH obIJIa OTKnOHeHHeM OT napTHHHoii pyro Y Hac T B CaMoe OJIH KaHwee BpeMR lIHHHH H npH3HaKOM HapaCTaIOruero KOHcpJIHKTa TeM 6onee tfI'0 IIOnytm JIOCb 'Ke COBceM nO- D pyroMY COBeTCKU rJ elIerau mr fOMYnKa He O p cyw eCTBOBaHHR KOHcpnHKTa HH ClIOBa He CKa· nepe D one3 r OM BO Bpo r JIaB BCTpeTHlIaCb co KD aHOBbIM KOTOPbIH 3aJI Kor rJ a OH HatmJICS H KaKOBhl ero npHlIHHbl tfI'0 HMeHHO npHBe· 110 K KpH3HCY B PYKOBO r CTBe lIaptHH H BelIeJI BhAepKHyTb B CTe· ObIJI Tor rJ a nepBldM ceKpeTapeM neHHHrp8 AcKoii naprOpraHH38 1lHH H 1I100HMlIHKOM CTaJIHHa e r HHcrneHHbIM KIDKeTCS lDIeHOM IIo HorpaMMe 3aee rJ aHHR npe r 1IO'KeHHe fOMYlIKH noexaTh K CTaJIHHY JlHTOIOPO KOTOphlii ObIJI co CTaJIHHbIM Ha TbI aHOB BepoSTHO 38 rapaHTHeH HaIIlHX 3aJI8 AHbIX rpa mw Y'K ClIHIllKOM lTO OhIJIO lI II JI r elIeraTaM coorneTcrnYlOlUHe YKa3aHHS KOMIIpoMempyrolUHM 38 RBJIeHHeM npHWJIOCb Y3HaTb KaKHe Ii HaM OqeHb CKOPO Ha KOHrpecc npHeXaJIO OKOlIO 500 r elIeraTOB H3 45 - CTpaH 3TO r aBaJIO B03MO KHOCTb npeBpaTHTb KOHrpecc B co6hlrne nepBoCTe­ qTO JlCe 1'0 020 CTpOWH020 C Q3 JIJ FOMYIl O 0 lIIlC neHHoro 3HaqeHHR COBeTcKu r eJIerau mr O D HaKO pel IIIDIa copBaTb - qTO H8 AO BldCOKO r eHHTh TPa I tHIUf1O 6opbobl nnc 38 He3a· KOurpeCC QHa npHOhlJla C TeKCYaMH pe3KHX arpecCHBHbIX Bblcryn­ lIeHHH Ee PYKOBo r HTeJIH TpeOOBaJIH OCTpbIX aHTH3an8 AHbIX BhIlIa' BHCHMOCTh r OB H OT Hac 08 AeeB BbletynHJI 60nee qeM pe3KO - nO-x aMCKH qeM -A He Haao OOH D eJI MHOrHX 3aD8 AHbIX HHTeJUIeKTYaJIOB Y HHX OblJIH OCHOBaHHR - lJ J1S 3Toro HeKOTopbIe MeCTa ero D OKJI8 Aa OblJlH npoCTO B03MytH TenbHhI 3TO 3aBHCHr OT Toro KaKOe MeCTO 3aHHMaeT 6oPb6a 3a He· 3aBHCHMOCTb B nporpaMMe napmH IIIIC HeCOMHeHHO BHeClIa CBOIO Mid pellIHJlH He neqaTaTb B nOJIbCKoii npecce arpeCCHBHbIX oeo lIenry B 6oPboy 38 He3aBHCHMOCTb HO Henb3S 3aOhmaTb tfI'0 OOlUHe Kop6HTenbHbIX BbICTyIUIeHHii l1HTepatypHU raJeTa neqaTaJIa a nonO'KeHH lt nporpaMMId nnc BpeMeH nepBoii MHpoBoii BOHm I MId HeT 3TO Ohmo He e r HHCTBeHHbIM MY'KeCTBeHHbIM aKTOM C Ha­ weH CTOpoHbI IIOClIe BldCTyIUIeHHR 08 AeeBa MHome 3aDa o Hble coornetCTBOBaJIH KOH r eIIll HRM nernOHOB IIHnCY r CKoro - Pe r nnc KaK H naH IIHlICY r CKHH H8 Aesnacb BbIHr­ HHTeJUIeKTYaJIld nOKHHYlIH 38 JI 38 ee rJ aHHii Tor r a Ml I nOTepRJIH paTb IIonbmy Y O o Horo H3 noOe r HTeneH KOMMYHHCTId ClIHTaJIH XaKCJIH OH BhletynHJI C nporeCTOM yexan B nOH r OH H HaM 60nbWe alTO 3HallHT tfI'0 tfI'0 rJIaBHOe - 158 3TO COlO3 C pa60llHM rJ BH'KeHHeM POCCHH H peBOJIIO' 159 HHl OrWl He Y la1IOCb CKJlOHHTh ero K nO JJl ep lKKe KOMMymICTHtlec­ XOJIO o HaR BOHua HaJIO KHJIa TlI KeJIbIH Omell3 TOK Ha uawy KyJIbtyPH 'lO nOJIHTHKy HeT COMHeHHH Koro gBIDKeHIDl llpyrne rOTOBbl 6bIDH nOKHHYTb 3aJI 3ace ll8HHH B JIIo60ii MOMeHT BeqepoM Eopeiiwa n03BOHRTI MHe B BaplllaBY OH - rOMYJlKa 3TOZO He nOHUMaJZ 6bID B OTllaRHHH H npoCmI nOMOLIUl 3aTeM 06CY IlHB nOJIO KeHHe C EepyTOM 11 noexa rr BO BpourraB 1JT061 1 On eHHTb nOJIO KeIDIe Ha MeCTe H n03BOHHJI MOJIOTOBY H DbITaJIClI Ooo lICHHTb eM ' 1JT0 HeT CMblCJIa cpblBaTb KOHrpecc 1JT0 TaKoii CpblB HaHeeeT p eJIY TOJIbKO Bpep Mbl pa3rOBapHBaJIH MHHyT 15 H Y MeHlI C03 1laJIOCb BneqaTJIe­ IDle 1JT0 Me K J y MOJIOTOBblM H OBbIM cytQeCTBYIOT pa3Homa­ CHlI no TOM ' Bonpocy Bo BCHKOM CJIyqae nOCJIe Moero pa3roBo­ pa C MOJIOTOBblM H3 MOCKBbl npHIImH HOBbie HHCTPYKn HH Kourpecee BblcrynHJI MJIbH Ha - HeT OH COBepllleHHO He nOHUMIIJI HallleR TaKTHKH B KOHn e 1948 aBrycta r HaqaJIOCb Oqepe o HOe ImeHapHOe 3acep aHHe H 11 C rope'lblO YIHf ll eJI 1JT0 Mbl HaXO llHMClI Ha rpaHH gBYX mox 1JT0 no­ pa OC03HaTb rp e pacnOJIo KeHa IIoJIbllla H 3aHBHTb C KeM Mbl H YBHJJ eJI 1JT0 OH He HaMepeH comawaTbClI C pellieHIDlMH KOTopble Mbl ClIHTaeM e l HHCTBeHHO npaBmIbHbIMH 3peH6ypr OH npoH3HeC pellb KOTOpaR - CKaKUMU KOpeHHbIM 06pa30M H3MeHRTIa n apHBIIIylO Ha KOHrpecee aTMocq epy IIa BTOpoii H1DI TpeTHii HI KOHrpeCca OB HeOXCH llaHHO YMep Kourpecc HHTe JIJIeKtyaJIOB B 33LIUITY MHpa 33K0HtlHlIClI yc­ DeUIHO H CTaJI CHMBOJIOM CIDIbI gBH KeHIDl 3a MHp H nporpecc Ha Beex KOHTlUleHTax IleMOHCTpan Heii e 1HHCTBa H COTpY llJlKlleCTBa Ha­ I lDl CTpeMJIeHHlI o6ecnellHTb MHpHbIH XOP KOHrpecca Hawe 06pawe­ HHe K MOCKBe He MOrJIH CyJn eCTBeHHO nOBJIHHTb Ha HOBbie nOJIHTH­ qeCKHe BeHHHlI HO Mbl Bce Ke npe llDpHHJ UIH nonblTKY 3aTOpM03HTb XOJIO llHYlO BOiiHy Mbl nOHHMIIJIH 1JT0 OHa HeH36e K83 HO nbITa­ JIBCb npHp aTb eii 60JIee eBponeiicKHH xapaKTep Mbl DbITaJIHCb 3awH­ THTb He TOJIbKO Hawy nOJIbCKylO HHHn HaTHBy HO H Haw nOJIbCKHH nyTb K COn HaJIH3M ' H3I lDl KYJIbtypHble CB1I3H C 3ananuoii EBponoii MOll Koun eDn HH KOurpeCca COCTOHJIa B O llHOM - He nopblBaTb C 3ananuoii EBponoH He OTphIBaTbClI OT eBponeHCKOH KYJIbTypbl He IlOnyCTHTb 'lT06bl IIOJIbwa 6bIDa npHB1I3aHa TOJIhKO K O o HOM ' pernoHy 3eMHOrO lIIapa 3Toro yp IIJIOCb p OCTHlIb HO K CO K8JIeHHIO He Hap OJIro - CTBe HeCKOIlbKO MeCJllfe6 cnVCTJl 6 Mae 06 YCKOpeHHOM npoMbIIIIJIeHHOM pa3BHTHH 0 nepeYCTpoR­ p epeBHH C pellieHIDlMH HanpaBJIeHHbIMH Ha yCKopeHHe CTpoHTeJIhCTBa COn HaJIH3Ma XOTlI TaK Mbl HX Torp a He Ha3blBaJIH 3Toro Tpe60BaJIa HOBaR lnoxa H Mbl BblHy K lleHbl 6bIJIH 6opoTI ClI 6opoTbClI He C fOMyn KOH a 3a fOMyn KY 30BaJI H3I lDl ll eHCTBHH H npocmI TaK 11 Torp a xapaKTepH­ ero He y6eran B CYJIeeBKY - lTO 6eccMbICJIeHHO II03 Ke MeHH ynpeKIIJIH 1JT0 11 6bill qepecqyp YMHbIM e B 1948 r nOCKOJIbKY npegBHJJ eJI 1JT0 fOMyn Ka KaK H llHJI­ CYP CKHH yep eT B CYJIeeBKY a nOTOM BepHeTClI H 'ITO 11 HK06bl 60HJIClI Toro H He TOJIbKO He 60HJIClI ero B03BpaweHIDl HO BOOG­ me He P YMaJI 06 lTOM llJIlI MeHH CYJIeeBKa 6bIJIa CUMBOJIOM n06e­ ra ye llHHeHIDl a He B03BpaweHIDl Torp a-TO H pa30lIIIIHCb H3I lDl C fOMYJIKOH p oporn KOTopble B 6YJJ YIn eM 60JIbille HHKorp a He CXO J HJIHCb A KaJIb fOM 'JIKa Tep­ 33JI ee611 JIOMaJI He 6y llYllH B COCTOHHHH npHHHTh KaKoe-JIH60 pa­ n HOHaJIbHOe pellleHHe OH He XOTeJI a B03MO KH0 p eHCTBHTeJIbHO He Mor nOHHTb H3I lDl pellieHIDl OH He XOTeJI mIH 6bID Hecnoco6eH 1949 nOHHTb 'ITO Mbl TO Ke CTpeMHMClI 3awHTHTb nOJIbCKHH nyTb K CO­ e Ha nOC6Jl­ U4eHHOU 60npOCaM Ky lbTYPbl napTUUHOU KOHtjiepeHlfUu 6bl CKa3a­ JlU Mbl OOllJlCHbl 60CnuTaTb OT6paU4eHue K uCKyccmy 3anHTHaH­ HOMY tjiOPMaIlU3MOM 6e3NOeUHOCTblO lfUHU3MOM OT6paU4eHue K oeKaoeHTCKOMY KanUTaIlUCTU'IeCKOM Y uCKyccrny K aMepUKaHCKO­ My KOCMonOJlUTU3MY Mbl 6yoeM 6e3JICaJZocTHO tJopOTbCJI C tj aWU3­ n HaJIH3MY H COXpaHHTb nOJIbCKOe JIHn o K3 K J bIH H3 Hac npep ­ CTaBJIHJI ce6e lTOT H Ta Ke - IlYTh no-pa3HOM ' HO n eJIb y Bcex 6blJIa op ua coxpaHHTb caMOCTOllTeJIbHOCTb aBTOHOMHIO IIoJIblllH fo­ MYJIKa He BepmI mIH He XOTeJI BepHTb 1JT0 Mbl KaK H OH BOBee He Me'ITaeM 0 KOJIJIeKTHBH3an HH 0 npeCJIep OBaHHHX KaTOJIHlIeCKOii n epKBH 1JT0 HaM TaK Ke He XOTeJIOCb Ocy K J aTb IOrOCJIaBHlO H1DI MOM 6 UCKYCCT6e U 6 nepeylO O'lepeOb C peaKlfUOHHblMU KaTOJlU­ '1eCKUMU TeHoeHlfWiMU ••• 160 161 ECJlH MbI H l enanH - B ByxapeCTe COCTOIDIOCb 3aee l aHHe KOMIfH popMa H H npe l ­ Bce 3TO TO TOnbKO no He06xo l HMOCTH nOHeBone Bbl6Hpag MeHbW­ nO l HJl nonpaBKy K pe30nlOlUW 0 3aMeHe cnoBa KOJUIeKTHBH33 ll HH BCTynaTb B KOMIfH P0PM C03 l aHHbIH CTanHHbIM wee H3 300 HenOHHMaHHe fOMynKoH 06cTaHOBKH l OKa3bmanO ero Ha cnOBO apreJlH3aI Wl MeW nopa3Hn CTanHH HaCTaHBaBl tIHH orpaHHlleHHOCTb y30CTb B3rng l OB fOMynKa oqem npOTHBopellHBM HMeHHO Ha KOJUIeKTHBH3alUW OH XOTen H l TH HanponOM He 60HCh JlHQHOCTb nO l o6HaH repojiM weKcnHpoBCKHX Tpare l Hii cnOB H MOe npe l lIO KeHHe 6bmo OTKnOHeHO BepHee MHe npHlWlOCh CWlTb ero BO HWl coxpaueHHg e l HHCTBa fOM 'nKa 3Han B lleM l eno - FOMY flKa noaoepJKUeM KO fl fleKTUeU3aijUIO 3Han OH H 0 MoeM npe l lIO KeHHH HO OH 0603nHncg H ynpeKan MeHH B TOM 'lT0 nonbCKM l eneraI Wl nporonOCOBana 3a KOJUIeKTHBH3a­ - HeT Ho Be l h H Mbl He XOTeJlH ee CnbIxanbCKMH - OH 6bm B ByxapeCTe CHaMH nblTanCH Om HC­ HUTb fOM 'nKe 'lTO C06CTBeHHO npoH30lWIO 'lT0 JIKy6 npe l lIO l HJl - KaK JICe He XOTe flU eC flU 3TO sanucaHO e npOi PaMMe napTUU H3MeHUTb pe30nlOl ijflO HO no OKa3anOCh HepeanbHbIM Ho fOMYJIKa B36eCHnCH HeT H HeT nonhcKM l eneral ijfg He l on KHa 6bma rono­ He XOTeJlH H CTanHH roBOpHn 'lT0 He 06H3aTenbHO npoBD­ COBaTb 3a KOJUIeKTHBH3a nOTOM OH YTBep K l an 'lT0 3 an ARTb KOJUIeKTHBH3 1O l epeBHH JI nOMHIO pa3rOBOp C HHM B e l HHonH'lHble KpeCThHHCKHe X03HHCTBa 3TO npaB l a HO Be l h Mbl 1946 TO Ke anH - r KOr l a OH CKa3an B HaweH cmyalUW Mbl l 0n KHb1 6bInH npoBecTH KonneKTHBH3aUHIO a BaM He06g3aTenbHO - KaKUM JICe 310 06pasOM - npaeoa A oea i ooa cnycTJI - - B 10 BpeWl 06cTaHOBKa 6bma ICe coBepweHHo HHOH Mbl He XOTeJlH npoBO 1l HTh KOJUIeKTHBH3 1O no COBeTCKD­ M ' 06pa3UY nocpe l CTBOM penpeCCMH HaCHnO KeCTOKOCTeH Ha CKOPYIO pyKy - Ona CTMa flY'IUle 6bl1lu oflJfCe OTMeHeHbt npoiJYK1Oebte Kap­ TO'lKU JI He CTaRy 06UCHHTh nOlleMY B COlO3e OHa npOHCXO l Hna HMeroiO TaK 3TO BeeM H3BeCTHO lle popM81UiH npo l on K8lOmagCH l onrne rO l bI Oca l a no cyrH OHH H npHBeJlH K BblpO K l eHUIO nepBO­ Ho HeH3BeCTHO 6bmo Ha l onro JlH Be l h HatmHanaCb XonO l ­ Ha'lanbHbIX H l eH KOJUIeKTHBH3aI Wl KaK H BcgKag pe pOPMa 06xo­ HM BOHHa He06xOARMO 6bmo KaK MO KHO CKopee npHCTYllHTh K HH­ l HTCH l OPOro H KOM '-TO npHxOARTCH pacnnaIBIBancg Cpe l CTBa Ha - JJ YCTpHanH381UiH rOCY l apCTBa H K ero co anH381UiH Ho l a Ke 3TO MO KHO nonytmTb OT npoMhllWIeHHOCTH HO B CCCP 310 6bInO He­ TOr l a MHHu YTBep K l an 'lT0 B nonhwe He 6Y l eT KOJUIeKTHBH3 H B03MO KHO nOTOM ' 'lT0 llaCTb Cpe l CTB KOTopbIe MO KHO 6bInO BbI l e­ 1948 r Ha C06paHHH napTaKTHBa OH 3MBHn 'lT0 Y Hac KOJUIeKTH­ llHTh Ha npOH3BO l 'fTB0 HJlH l lIg l epeBHH lWIa Ha BoopY KeHHH 'lT0 BH3aI Wl He MO KeT 6blTh nOBTopeHHeM TOro 'lT0 6bmo B CCCP no­ Beno K na l eHHIO H 6e3 Toro HeBblCOKoro ypOBHH KH3HH H TeMnOB B TOM ' 'lT0 TaM He 6bIDO cenbCKOX03HHCTBeHHbIX Mannm a Mhl 003 TeXHHqeCKOrO nporpecca TaKHX MaIllHH Bo06me He MO KeM npHCTynHTb K KOJUIeKTHBH381UiH KaBwee Ha pa60tmx 6peWl HMeHHO n03TOMy KonneKTHBH3aI Wl B 3TO 03Ha'lanO 'lT0 ecnH Mbl H npHCTynHM Kor l a-JlH60 K KOJUIeKTH· CCCP 6bma ocymeCTBneHa n enHKOM 3a ClleT l epeBHH Henh3H 6bInO eme 60nbwe YCHnHTb ne· BH381UiH TO TonhKO KOr l a y Hac 6yJJ YT l lIH 310ro pHHaHCOBble B03MO KHOCTH - Ho eeob '1epe3 oea MeCJl14fl - CKO flbKUX JICepTe OHa C1OU fla - He 3Haro Ho 3Haro 'lT0 Bee 'lT0 npoHCXO l HnO 6bmo l pa­ MOH Mbl He XOTeJlH lToro H pe30nlO g KOMIfH popMa l aBana HaM 162 163 12 B03MOxaIOCTb npoBeCTH KOmIeKTHBH3an HIO nO-HameMY MbI peI llHJIH Moero X030Ha 30Byt BapaH Y Hero TOrAa HCDOnb30BaTb TpH BHAa KOmIeKTHBHorO X03gHCTBa - MeCTax KnOt KOB 3eMTIH 9TO lKe MYKa pa60TaTb Ha HHX na H qero HOCTbIO non­ KOmIeKTHBH3HpoBaHHOe nOnYKOmIeKTHBHOe H npoMe lKy­ TOlJIlOe H BOBee 610mB 6e30IIIH60lffibIMH HO Bce-TaKH OHH 6bD H HOBbIMH 60nee He ytBep lKAaIO tITO nplfAYMaHHbIe HaMH BapHaHTbI CTOHT ero pa60Ta BeAl He BbeAeWb TpaKTOpoM Ha 12 KnOt KOB ­ 3T0 pa3Apoi5rteHHe UPOCTO HecqaCTbe HameH AepeBHH KpoMe HeAoe­ TaTKa eenbcKoxo HcmeHHbIX MaIIlHH HMeHHO pa3Apoi5rteHHe 3eM­ nH nHWaeT HaC KaKHX-nH60 maHCOB paUHoHanbHo OpraHH30BaTb pauHoHanbHbIMH H HX MOxaIO 6bD 0 coBepweHCmOBaTb HaH60nee paUHoHamHoH Ka3anaCb HaM B03MO lKHOCTb AaTb KpeCTb BbI60p B KaKOH THn X031lHCTBa OH XOqeT BCrynHTb B nepBbIH BTOPOH HnH TpeTHH - pa36pocaHHbIX B pa3HbIX cenbCKoe X03gHCmo IIOlTOMY MbI J yManH 0 KOOnepaTHBax npH nOMOUJ H KOTOPbIX MOxaIO 6YAeT oGbe J HHHTb 3eMnIO 60nee nbrOTHbIH KOTOPbIH n03BO­ ngn COXpaHHTb 60nbIUyro qaCTb nHlffiOH co6CTBeHHoCTH H B KOTOPOM - 3TO OOmtalO 6blflO CTaTb nepeblM 3TanoM KpeCTbgHHHY npeAOCTaBngnOCb onpeAeneHHoe BpeMg J 1Ig peWeHHg 9TO Aon I HO 6bDlO CTaTb BbIXOAOM H3 nonO lKeHHg J 1Ig O J HO­ XOqeT nH OH BCTynHTb B KonneKTHBHoe X03gHCTBO HnH Het coma­ eeH nH nHIIIHTbCg npaBa Ha Bna J eHHe 3eMneH HnH HeT ro- ll BYx nOKoneHHH Mbl BeAl 3HanH KaK TPYAHO BeCKHMH apryMeHTaMH - - A 6bIIlTO CQMu He 3HfJIlU lJ a I e caMblMH y6eAHTb KpeCTbgHHHa OTKalaTbCg OT 3eM­ nH OH AOn lKeH caM AO J yMaTbCg AO lToro IIo3TOMY Mbl XOTenH tIT06bI KpeCTb fIHHH nOHgn Bee npeHMyulecma KOnneKTHBHorO Tpy­ - 3HanH tITO CHaqana He 3aXOqeT - J 1Ig KpeCTbgH KOnneKTHBH3 - lTO npaBAa 3HanH tITO Aa lfI06bl OH nOHgn tITO HMeHHO KOmIeKTHBHbIH TPYA OCBo60AHT nyrano lITO OHH 60mcg ee ero OT HenOCHnbHOH pa60Tbl H OTKpoeT nepeA HHM uepCneKTHBbl H lITO He TaK npoCTO oT06paTb y KpeCTbgH 3eMTIIO HOBOH KH3HH IIocne 3Toro MbI DnaHHpoBanH paCIIIHpeHHe npHyca­ Ae6HbIX yqaCTKOB KaK B BeHrpHH KpeCTbgHHH qyBCTBOBan 6bI tITO - KOTOPYlO Heoa6HO TOpJlCeCreeHHO pa30etlUllU Me JICOY HUMU He npa60a flU Bna J eeT KnOt KOM 3eMnH a rocyAapcmy OT lToro 6bD a 6bl TonbKO nonb3a B BeHrpHH nonoBHHa MonOlffiblX npo l yKToB H Bee CPPYKTbI npoH3BO l lTcg Ha HH l HBHpyanbHbIX ylIaCTKax BeAl MYxaIK BbIKo­ - Ii BCe-TaKH KpeCTbgHe B BeHrpHH H qexocnoBaKHH C lTHM CMHPHnHCb MOxaIO KHTb H 003 nHlffiOH co6cmeHHOCTH MO I HO lTO nallHBaeT H3 HHX Bce tITO MO KHO Ii Y Hac KpeCTbme nonylianH 6bl HeManyIO npH6bInb B AononHeHHe K 3apa60TKaM B Konx03e B ce6e npeoAoneTb - A liTO OHU UMetlU 6bl OT KOflX03a -H03alleM CenbcKOXO HcmeHHble - KOOnepaTHBbI AOnxaIbI 6bD H qT06bI lKHTb nyqwe Mbl XOTenH tIT06bl KpeCTbgHHH Ha co6­ nonyqaTb AonOnHHTenbHbIe accHrHOBaHHB Ho Be J b 3a nporpecc cmeHHoH IIIKype yOO J HnCg tITO pa60ra B KonneKTHBHOM X03gHCT­ HYxaIO nnaTHTb QT06bI AOKalaTb npeHMyuleCTBO KOnneKTHBHoro Be AaeT eMY B03MO lKHOCTb KHTb nyqwe tITO TaM OH nepeCTaHeT xO Hcma Ha J HH l HBHpyanbHbIM - lfY'KH0 AOnnaTHTb Ho lTO CTOHT 6blTb pa60M H TPYA ero He 6YAeT cronb pa6CKH TIDKenblM lITO CTHnb AenaTb ecnH B lKH3HH npH6nH3HTCg K CTHnIO l H3HH pa60qero qTO OH OKa KeTCg Tex HeCKonbKHX KoonepaTHBax KOTopble nenH nIO J H KHByt B HHbIX ycnOBHBX 6YAeT pa60TaTb 8 qaCOB nonytlHT OmyCK Bee 6YAyuleM YAaCTCg nonytlHTb nOnb3y Y I e ceHqaC B nyqwe qeM B 06bItlHOH AepeBHe 6YAeT nO-ApyroMy BOT eeHqaC CMOTpIO KaK KHByt KpeCTbme 6e­ H - 3HaIlUT no-eaweMY 20floOHafl CMepTb no Kpa meu Mepe rOBOpIO 0 cpe J He3a KHTOlffibIX H 6eAHblx Be J b OHH lKHByT 6e J H0 7 MIlH KpeCTbftH 60 6peMft C06eTCKOU KOlllleKTU6U3a14uu 6b1lla pe­ eeAYJO C HHMH H He rOBOpIO 0 6oraTblX TeM BeerAa XopOWO 3YflbTaTOM 3a60TbI 0 IIe tlOeeKe 164 165 - CKIDKeM npBMo M ' KHK roX e MO f eT CXBaTHTb 3a mOT­ - Ho 6eOb MOIlOOe3lCb U la 3a 6aMU KY eCJIH B AepeBHe Y Hac He 6YAeT HHKaKOH onopbl Mbl He AOJI f ­ Hbl nonaCTb B 3aBHCHMOCTb OT HH J HBH l yaJIbHOrO X03J1HCTBa IIo'le­ My MbI eeHlJaC TaK 6apaXTaeMCJI rrO'leMY Mbl He MO f eM HaHTH Bbl­ XOA H3 rrOJIoX eHHJI IIoTOMY 'ITO He XBaTaeT - lla HO Mbl He XOTeJIH H lJ TH HaIIPOJIOM H rrpHHHMaJIH BO BHH­ MaHHe COOTHOllIeHHe CHJI B AepeBHe rrpoH3BOAHMoro B CTpaHe 3epHa HaM npHXOAHTCJI y6e f lJ aTb KpeCTbJIH 'lT06bl OHH - 3lia'lUT 6bl OTCTynaeTe nepeo CUIlOU AaJIH HaM 3epHO - A - Ha 3anaoe oalOT ho 3Ha'IHT 'ITO Mbl C'lHTaeM He06xoAHMblM AeHCTBOBaTb ot­ roPOX HO MeAJIeHHO HATH BrrepeA y6e f lJ aTb 06'hJlCHJlTb rrOJIb3y IIoToMY 'ITO npoH3BoAHTeJIbHOCTb TpYAa TaM BcerAa 6bIJIa - KaK 6 rpwjjUlfax BbICOKOH - B - A nOlleMY He 6 C06eTCKOM COI03e rpHIPunax HaIIIJIHCb AOKTpHHepbl CBepXCTapaTeJIbHble OHH rreperu 'JIH rraJIKY CJIHllIKOM yxc rrpHX HMaJIH KpeCTbJIH XOTeJIH rrOXBaCIatb rrOKa3aTeJIJIMH H CTaJIH rrpHMeHHTb HaCHJIHe a rro OTHa­ KOJIJIeKTHBH3aI J RJI B XOpollIaJI BeW b eCJIH rrpoBOAHTb ee HOPMaJIbHblX YCJIOBHJlX C COOTBeTCTByIDlI HM 060pYAOBaHHeM H He06xoAHMblMH MJI KaIIHTaJIOBJIO f eHHH cpeACTBaMH TO eCTb llIeHHlO K CaMblM yrrpJlMblM - perrpeCCHH lTO rrpoTHBope'lH1IO Ha­ llIHM HaMepeHHJIM Mbl He XOTeJIH 6blJIH rrpaBbl - H rrpaKTHKa rrOKa3aJIa 'ITO MbI KOJIJIeKTHBH3HpoBaTb Bce X03aHCTBa H cpa3Y Mbl He eCJIH He KOBepKaJI HAelO l yMaJOT 0 TOM KaK rrpOBeCTH ee B f H3Hb XOTeJIH MHPHTbCJI C TaKHMH MeTO lJ aMH H HeO lJ HOKpaTHO OCy f IJ aJIH pa3YMHO H AellieBO MO f HO rrpH 3TOM HCKaTb H rrapaJIJIeJIbHbIH rrYTb HX Ha lIJIeHapHbIX 3aeeAaHHJIX UK KOTOPbIH rr03BOJIHJI 6bl neHTpaJIbHOH BJIaCTH HaRTH BblXOA H3 TpYA­ HOro nOJIO f eHHJI rOMynKa B HMeJl B03MO f HOCTH 1956 B03POAHTb r no HaKOHen rroHJUI HO He - TOllbKO OOUli pa3 apTeJIH pellIHJICJI Ha COBX03bI rOMYJIKa CaM y6eAHJICJI 'ITO HaJIH'lHe apTeJIeH HJlH COBX030B rrpeA­ - Hu'lero rroA06Horo Mbl MHoro pa3 rOBOpHJIH 'ITO B IIOJIbllIe CTaBJIJleT onpeAeJIeHHylO CBo60 l y l eHCTBHH rapaHTHpyeT rrOCTaBKH KOJIJIeKTIiBH3aIJ HJI He 6YAeT rrpoBOAHTbCJI HaCHJIbCTBeHHO YCTpOHJIH meGa He3aBHCHMO OT OTHOllIeHHJI KpeCTbJIH K BJIaCTH IIpas lJ a C nOKa3areJIbHblH rrponecc HaA TeMH KTO 3JIoynoTpe6HJI BJIaCTblO COBX03aMH TO f e He BbllIIJIO H nOJIHOMO'IHJlMH B rpHIPunaX llOllbCKue KpeCTbRHe OKa3MUCb 60llee ynopliblMU 'le M 6eH­ zepCKue U IIeWCKue CKOllbKO JfCe KOlllleKTU6liblX X03RUCT6 6aM yOMOCb C03­ OaTb - HeT 3TO Mbl OKa3aJIHCb 60JIee m6KHMH - Be TaK MHoro KOJIJIeKTHBH3HpoBaHO 6bIJIO HJIH OT CHJIbl - KaK JfCe 3TO TaK 13% 10 MOX eT 12 KpeCTbJlHCKHX X03J1HCTB H He 6bIJIO YKa3aHHH 'ITO 3TOT rrponeHT YBeJIH'lHTcJI IIo3 f e B 1956 r Bee 3TH X03HHCT­ Ba caMopacrryCTHJIHCb B Te'leHHe HeCKOJIbKHX lJ HeH A3 Ke OtJeHb Be3 nopbIBa Ge3 3HTY3Ha3Ma Ge3 MOJIOAeX H AHJIO He TaK KaK HaAO Bce BblXO­ nepcneKTHBHble X03aHCTBa H He OCY f lJ alO no B onpeAeJIeHHOH CTeneHH 3TO 6bIJIO HeH36e f Ho O lJ HaKO Ha'IaJICJI 3TOT rrponecc JI B 3TOM ysepeH rro CHfUaJIY cBepxy 166 167 1949 z J epeeHJl U 14epKoeb HeopzaHU3oeaHHo HO 01 lllJlHHO conpOTUellR10TCR Bce euoHble Oe RTetlU OeUJICeHUR 3a He3aeUCUMOCTb 'JICe e TIOPbMOX llepecTMa cYU4ecT80eaTb llRC KpeCTbRHCKaR 3a CqeT l H3HeHHOro ypoBHfI 3ana J HaII EBpona HaKanrrHBaITa KanH­ TaIT 3a CqeT 3KcnrryaTa u HH orpoMHbIX GoraTCTB KOJIOHHH A TaK KaK napTUR He OCTMOCb Oollbwe lIaCTHblX MaZa3UH08 6bl lU pacnYU4e­ HeGo HaM HHKaKHX cpe l CTB He nOCllaJIO HaM HY'KHO 6bVIO HX Ha· Hbl He3aeUCUMble 06U4eCT8eHHble opzaHU3a14UU U npo¢eCCUOHMbHble KOMeHHe o6ecnellHTb aCC014U014UU He CTMO CaMOCTORTetlbHblX peM eCfleHHUK08 He OCTa­ - llO'leMY JtCe ebl TOzoa OTKa3MUCb OT n n aHa MaplU J Jl 1 a 1l0Cb HU OOHOU He3a8UCUMOU Za3eTbI llapTUR KOH7pOllupyeT ece c¢epbl 06U4eCT8eHHOU KYllbTyPHOU HayttHOU JtCU3HU llapTUR n08­ - CI00V B RCflRX Ha 3a800ax 8 OollbHU14e OaJICe 8 noXOPOHHblX 61OPO B 3TO 8peM R 'JICe HUKTO U HUll TO He yZpOJICMO napTUU U38He U OHa MOZlla noo PYKoeOOCT80M 8eOYU4eu 7pOUKU - EepYT EepMaH 3TOT MaR BbI3BaIT onpe l eJIeHHbIe COMHeHHfI y Beex B TOM tDlClle H y COBeTCKoro COI03a Koe-KaKyro nOMOUU Ml I norryqa JlH etne B 1947 r H cpaly nOCJIe BOHHbI l O 04 Horo 000 0­ JIeHHfI nrraRa Mapmarrrra H HaM y D aJIOCb norryquTb HeManO Ho no­ MUH14 - C7pOUTb e llOllbwe C014UMU3M He TI1K IlU TOM Bee ICe nepeBeCHJIH cooGpa l eHHfI 0 He06xoABMOCTH OTKaJaTb­ - HeT lT0 HeBepHaII Kapnma IIn eHapHoe 3aCe l aHHe 6 l HTeJIbHOCTH KOTopoe COCTOJIJIOCb B HOfI6pe 1948 UK 0 r H Ha KOTO­ poM fI He BbICT 'lIaIT 6e3YCllOBHO HarrO llODlO orne1JB TOK Ha Hamy no­ JlHTHKy Ib UK 6bVIH Bbme l eHbI rOM 'JIKa CnblxaJIbCKHH H KrrHm­ CfI OT 3Toro Mana Be l b Bcrre l 3a l eHbraMH H l eT 3aBHCHMOCTh OT AalOillerO H 3a JII06ylO nOMOillb npHXO l HTCfI pacnrrallHBaTbCfI Ha 06­ MaRe l aITeKO He ye l emb B rrro6arr Hblx MaCillTa6ax 06MaHyTb HeJIb3fI Mbl Bee 3TO BH l eJlH H nOHHMaJIH IIepe l HaMH BCTarr Tpy l · KO HacT 'lIHJIo TpY J Hoe BpeMfI KOTopoe npO l OIDKaJIOCb l 0 caMoH m rH Bonpoc CMepTH CTarrHHa Ho H CTarrHH He 6bIJI TOJIbKO qepHbIM IIfImOM KaK He l OBOJIbCTBO HaeeJIeHHfI H l eHCTBHTeJIbHO BbI3BaITO B o HeM roBOPfIT ceiiqac BOBce HeT He Bee lITO MDI l eJIaITH 6bVIO npa­ HITH He CTpoHTb H JIHillHTb IIOJIbmy KaKHX-JIHGo nepcneKTHB MbI BHITbHbIM 6bVIO l onymeHo MUoro OllHGoK R He OTPHD aIO lITO HX MO KHO 6bVIO H36e ICaTb Ho l eJIO He B 3TOM He Clle D yeT pHcoBaTb Te rOAbI TOJIbKO tJePHbIMH KpaCKaMH yTBep KJ1 llTb lITO Bee lITO Tor­ Aa npoHCXO l HJIO 6bIJIO pe3yrrbTaTOM HaCHITHfI BeAb 3TO 6bIJIH TaK­ ICe rO l bI BeJlHKHX Ha l e l Il Ha C03AaHHe HOBOH IIoJIbllH rOAbI Tpy­ CTpoHTb 3a cqeT nOTpeGrreHHfI - npHHJIJIH pemeHHe - a 3TO Morno Bbl3BaTh 1956 r ABHaMHlJHoe palBHTHe TaKHM 06PalOM Y HaC 6bVI JIHillb 0 l HH BbIXO l - MaReBpHpoBaTb TaK lIT06bI nOT npo­ l ecc He CllHillKOM CKa3aITCfI Ha ypoBHe l H3HH H B TO ICe BpeMfI CTpoHTb KaK M0 l 80 GoJIee KpynHbIe 3aBO l bI KOTopbIe B CKOPOM 6YAYtneM HalJHYT npHHOCHTh npH6bVIb AOBoro nopbma H 3HTY3Ha3Ma 1JIeCTHJIeTHHil MaR l OIDKeH 6bIJI - npeBpaTHTb arpapuyro HepalBHl 'IO IIorrbmy B COBpeMeHHoe MOlUHoe HH D yCTpIDVIbHoe rOCY l apCTBO CeiitJac MbI MO ICeM Bblpa l aTb COMHe­ HHe OmOCHTeJIbHO Toro Clle l OBaITO JlH npOBOABTh HH D yCTpIDVIH3a­ u H1O TaKHMH TeMnaMH Ho TOrAa 3TH TeMlIbI 6bVIH 06YCllOBJIeHbI Me l l yHapo J HbIM nOJIO ICeHHeM XOTfI B03MO KHO 3TO 6bIJIO OllH6­ IlU llpozpaMMY pa8HOMepHOZO pa38UTUR KOTOpylO npeollaza­ npo¢eccop E06p08CKUU U llOllbCKaR C014UMUCTU'leCKaR nap­ TUR 8bIOTeep2llU - lla Haqarracb XOJIO J HafI BORHa H lT0 BbIHY l HJIO Hac yc­ KOH nOCKOJIbKY pe3YJIbTaTOM 6bIJIO pe3Koe na D eHHe l H3HeHHOro KOPHTb npol eCC HHAYCTpHarrH31il HH H nOBbICHTb HOPMY HaKOMe­ ypoBHfI Ho Be l b 3TOT MaR 6bIJI 0 l 06peH HapoAOM mOAB XOreJIH HHfI BbVIO JIH no ollH6KOH B03MO KH0 B HeKOTopbIX CllyttafIX paGoTaTh H paGoTaJIH H yCTaBarrH TOJIbKO Tor D a KOrAa eCTb 6bIJIO Heqero A e l bI He XBaTaITO nOTOMY lITO CTPaRa 6bma palpymeHa 3TO 6bIJIO Bbl3BaRO He06xoABMOCTblO B HeKOTOpbIX - HenpaBHIT HW­ MH pacqeTaMH H nporuo3aMH H MDI CTpoHITH 3aBO l bI rOJIbIMH PYKaMH HaKaMHBaII Heo6xoABMl Ie J 1lfI 3Toro Cpe l CTBa 3a CqeT paGotDIx KorAa KanHTaITOBJIO ICeHHfI npeBbIillaIOT 168 25% a TaK 6bVIO B Te rOAbI lTO Beer l a npoHcxOABT - KaKaR 001l1l 8M080Z0 Ha14UOHl lbHOZO ooxooa UIIla Ha 80eH­ Hble HYJlCObl 169 - lloBonbHO oonhUIaJl TO'lHbIX D HCPP JI He noMHlO HO no BceH BepoJiTHOCTH 15% a MO f eT H oonbUle YKJlOHJITbCJI OT 3THX WaBCKoe KHJI f eCTBo lla 1 a B BapUlaBCKOe KHIDlCeCTBO - 1 Pymx nepcneKTHB 8 He BH Ky pacxo J oB MO f HO 6bIIIO TonbKO J O onpe 1 eneHHOH CTeneHH 1 aIIbUle - A 7 10 6bZ Y HaC 3a6pfJll 3TU 3anaOHbze 3eM1lU A Mepu7 a Toro npe 1 ena ' f e Henb3J1 6bIIIO J BHraTbCJI OCTaBaIIOCb MaHeBpHpo­ Barb TyT npoHBHIlCJI TaIIaHT Mmma HeCOMHeHHO OH 6bII1 CaMbIM - cnOC06HbIM H3 HaC HalllH TOBapHID H 003 06HHJlKOB 3aHBIDDIH HaM pa3 Mbl C006lJlHHKH BbI He MO f eTe YKJlOHHTbCJI OT CBOHX repMaHH 8 ECTeCTBeHHO repMaHHJI AMepHKa HeMe r vIeHHO C 1 enaIIa 6bI CTaBKY Ha repMaHHlO H HanpaBHIla 6bI 06'be 1 HHeHHe J Byx HeMen KHX rOCY 1 apcTB If ecnH CBOH yCHJIHJI Ha 6bI AMepHKe no­ 06J13aHHOCTeH If OHH 6bIIIH npaBbI BbIBaIOT MOMeHTbI Kor 1 a HeT B03MO f H0C­ Bemo TO Ha CD eHy CHOBa BblJlIIIa 6bI arpeCCHBHaJI npo f OpllHB8 8 TH ype3aTh 38TpaTbI Ha BOOp ' f eHHe Hanponm HX He06xo 1 HMO YBe­ repMaHHJI KOTOpa s 6bJIIa 6bI elD e onacuee TaK f e KaK HaMHOrO onaCHee repM3 HHH BHJIbreJIbMa OKa3aIIaCb rHTJIepoBCK8 8 repMaHHJI JIHI1HTb BbIXO 1 a HeT 1fIIH BbI napTHep HJlH HeT llIIJI HaC 3TO 6bJII0 1 OqeHb eephe3HOH npo6JIeMoH a B03MO f H0 - Ho 6eOb 6bZ He 6bl lU napmepa M U oaJICe 6 Teopuu H HOBOH yrP030H 06 e 1 HHeHH8 8 repMaHH 8 eCTeCTBeHHO 6bIIIa fibI - H npoaMepHKaHCKOH llocne CMeprH CTaIIHHa Mbl CTaIIH oonee He3aBHCHMbIMH ll03TOMY JI H p83 1 enHII HCTOPHIO Ha J Ba 3Tana - npH f H3HH CTaIlH­ Ha H nocne ero CMeprH Ho 1 a f e npH f H3HH CTaJIHHa MbI CTapaJIHCb H 3Ha'IIHT BpIDlCJJ e6HOH COBeTCKOMY COI03Y HaM AMepHKaHCKHH DIIan 1 aPM Ha TeppHTopHH rpaHHllaID eH C CCCP HeH3OO f H0 npHBen fibI K CTOJIKHOBeHHlO nOCKOJIbKy B03HHKJla fibI yrpo3a nO 1 l1HHeHHJI BeeH EBPODbI AMepHKe HaM COXpaHHTb aBTOHOMHIO llonbUlH IfMeHHO TaK MbI nOHHMaIlH nOIIbC­ npHlJlIlOCb fibI pacnna'IIHBaTbC 8 nepBbIMH nOTOMY lITO MbI- nepBbIe KHH nYTh K COD HaJIH3My ua oqepe 1 H MbI Be 1 b nOcepe 1 HHe H HaC pa3 1 aBHIIH 6bI B JIenellIKy If BOT TOr 1 a y HaC 0TH s JlH fibI 3ana 1 HbIe 3eMIIH nOrHKa HCTOpHH - Ho 6eOb 6bZ He o6ecnetlU lU HU a6TOHO MUU HU He3Q6UCU­ nO 1 TBep f JJ aIIa 'ITO HeMD bI K 3TOMY CTpeM 8 TC 8 CTpaTefHJI A J e­ uaY3pa fibIIIa HanpaBIIeua Ha TO lIT06bI B nOAXO UII D HH MOMeHT OT­ MOCTU 1101lbWU HJlTb Y Hac 3TH 3eMIIH TaK fibI TO H 6bIIIO - HenpaB 1 a llocne 1949 H YBepeH llOCMOTpHTe r HMeJIHCb npH3HaKH OrpaHHqeHHJI CKOJIbKO JIeT npoIIIJIO nocne OKOHllaHHJl BOHHbI a npo6JIeMa nbBOBa HaUleH CaMOCTOJITenbHOCTH a HawH nonbITKH 38ID HTHTb ee TOpM03H­ H BHJIbHlOca Bce elD e ocraeTC 8 f HBOTpenelD yID eH 1 Jl s nOJI 8 KOB na 3CKaIlaIJ HJI XOnO lJ HOH BOHHbl H yrpo3a co CTOPOHbI COe 1 HHeH­ If TaKOH f e OOJIeBOH TOllKOH JlBJI 8 eTCJI Bonpoc 3ana IJ HblX 3eMenb HbIX lJITaToB Ho 1 8 f e B TaKOH 06cTaHOBKe MbI Bee f e CTapaJIHCb r vI 8 HeMD eB Be 1 b Ha 3THX 3eMJIJlX KOe-lITO npe o npHHJlTh tITO npoHCXO 1 HIlO TOr 1 a AMepHKa nbITaIIaCb TaM PO 1 HIlHCb H poCIIH C KaKOH f e CTaTH paJJ H qero OHH 1 OJI f HbJ f HJlH H MHJIJlHOHhI HeMD eB OHH 38XBaTHTb BCIO EBPOny nOKopHTb ee H craTh 'IIeM-TO Bpo 1 e 1 HKTaTO­ fibIJlH 3afibITh npo 3TH TeppHTopHH pa AMepHKaHIJ bI CIIytlaH HeMD bI nOTpeOOBaIIH fibI 3TH 3eMIIH Ha38 1 H H8BepHJIKa 6bIJlH 3aHHTepeCOBaHbl B KanHTaIIOBnO f eHHJlX yOO f 1 eH lITO nO J BepHHCb OTCIO 1 a nII3 H MapUlaIIIIa KOTOPblH J on f eH 6bIII 06ecne­ 003 KaKOH-JIHOO KOMneHC8J UfH 38 HHX If 3TO JIom'IIHo Be 1 b MbI He I1HTh 3aBHCUMOCTb EBponbl OT AMepHKH AMepHKa TaK f e CTpeMH­ MO f eM TpeOOBaTb OT HHX Ha'llaTb BOHHy C COBeTCKHM COI030M 38 JIaCb OTKOJIOTb HalJlH BHJIbHlOC H nbBOB TeM oonee 'ITO HaeeneHHe3THX ropo 1 OB B EBpone - COD HaJIHCTHqeCKHe CTpaHbI OT COBeTcKoro COI03a TaKOBbl 6bIIIH aMepHKaHCKHe HaMepeHHJI C KOTOpbIMH He MornH pe3KO H3MeHHJIOCb tITO OCTaIIOCb fibI TOr 1 a OT llOJIbUlH Hy 'ITO CMHPHTbCJI HH Mbl HH COBeTCKHH COI03 OCOOOHHO Mbl nOTOMY lITO BapUl8BCKOe KHIDlCeCTBO MO f HO CMHpHTbC 8 H C TaKHM HCXO J OM HO r vIJi Hac 3TO 6bIIIO KaTaCTpoCPOH - H C roey 1 apCTBeHHOH H C H 1 eOIIO­ pa3Be OH y J OBJIeTBOpHJI fibI rOp 1 OCTb nOII 8 KOB J ep f aBHyIO H 1 elO mqeCKOH TOqeK 3peHHJI Pa3pbW C COBeTCKHM COI030M 03Haqan 6bl nOJIbCKOrO Hapo 1 a 3Ta npo6JIeMa fibIIIa aKTYaIIbHOH Ha npoTJI f e­ yrpary 3ana J HbIX 3eMeJIb H llOJIbllla CHOBa npeBpamnaCb 6bl B Bap- HHH Beex nOCIIeBoeHHblX JIeT He 3HaIO KaK MO f HO 6bIIIO 3Toro He 170 171 1I0HHMaTh BeAl J yMaTh Ha l1 O He B Y3KOM Macwra6e lI031hIllH a B Macwra6ax eBpolleHCKHX BeeMHpHhIX lIo31hwa - 3TO JIHIIIh lIeIIIKa He CPa3Y Pa3peIIIHB HaM OCTaThCH Ha HHX HeKOTOpoe BpeMH Ho B KOHelJHOM HTore MhI 6hI HX 1I0TepHJ1H B HI'pe H 1I03TOMY TPY l1 HO rOBOpHTh 0 1I0 l1 llHHHO aBTOHOMHOH 110­ H COlfUO lUCTbl JIHTHKe HY l Ho qeTKO Ollpe l1 eJIHTh Ha KaKOH CTopoHe MI I H BhIlJHC­ TOJICe 3TOZO He nOHUM lIlU JIHTh pe3Y31hTaThI TaKOro peweHHH IIpyroro BhIXO l1 a HeT B 3TOM - TO f e H 3aKJllOlJaeTCH HCTopHlJeCKaH B03MO I HOCTh KOTOPOH MhI MO f eM Bocn031h30BaThCH HJIH HeT MhI - KOMMYHHCThI MhI B3MH Bee B H FOMYIl1 O CHOH PYKH H MhI C I1 eJIlIJIH CBoe I1 e31o EClIH 6hl He 6hWO KOMMYHHC­ TOB B03MO I H0 I1 pyrHe C I1 e3111J1H 61 1 3TO HO M1 I 61 IJIH H B oocTa­ HOBKe KOTOpaH cymeCTBOBaJIa TOr l1 a - M OH MI I cyMe31H OIlOO f1lJHTh 33IIll l HhIe 3eMJIH HaBeCTH B HHX 1I0pMOK 3KOHOMHlJeCKH o61 e l1 H­ HHTh C HaMH HaIllHM maBHhIM K03hIpeM 61 wO HOBoe 31H1l0 lIo31h­ llIH Kor l1 a 1I031HKH 3TO 1I0iiM 'T He 3Halo• fI He rOBOplO 0 Maccax He 1I0HHMaJI ECJ1H 6hl OH 1I0HHMaJI TO He IIpOTeCTOBaJI 61 1 llpoTHB C03 11 aHHH KOMHHq opMa 1I0TOMY lITO H 3T0 Momo 06ep­ HyThCH llpoTHB Hac KaTaCTpoq oii Y f e TOr l1 a 3TO rpo3HJ10 HaM paToii 3aIIa l1 HhIX 3eMe311 B 1I031h3y rlIP yr­ llPOCThIX TeMHhIX He06pa 30BaHH1 IX H rOBOplO 0 IIpOCBemeHHhIX - FJlPTOZOO ezqe He 6blflO pa 3YMHhIX o6 JIa l1 alOlUHX 310mqeCKHM MhIIIWeHHeM 1I031hCKHX HH­ TeJ1J1Hrenrax fI Ha l1 eIOCh OHH 1I0HMyT qTO It IIpOTHBHOM CJ1yqae Hy tJTO f TOr l1 a B II031h3Y KOrO-31HOO I1 pyroro He 6y J y IIpH I1 pyrOM COOTHOWeHHH CHJl lIo31hwa OKa3aJIaCh 6hI B llpoHrphI­ we H tJTO T031hKO HaM Y l1 aJIOCh BOCII031h30BaThCH HCTOpHqeCKHM CTpoHTh m1lOTe3 waHCOM Kor l1 a TaKOH wanc 1I0BTOPHTCH He 3Halo• fI He IIpOPOK l1 a - H OllaCHO llpe l1 CKalhIBaTh BeAl Bee B Pa3BHTHH Bee eme 6Y I1 eT MO l1 Hq HUHpoBaThCH H3MeHHT1 CH pa3BHBaThCH jJ f e MOry CKaJaTh OAHO Mhl KOMMyHHCThI cnaClIH lIOJIhWY EClIH 61 1 He MI I OHa CTa­ 31a 6hl BapUIaBCKHM K8H f eCTBOM KPOXOTHOH n eHTpaJI1 HoeBpolleiic­ KOH CTpaHOH 6e3 lIepcneKTHB pa 3BHTHH HJIH ee Bo06me 61 1 He 6hWO • IIU1 OOYlUUlO CT lIlUHO 0 He nOTOMY 'ITO Ta1 pelUUIl Z BeflU1 aJl 'leT­ eep1 o CT lIlUH He 6blfl e COCTOJlHUU ype30Tb TeppUTOpUiO nOllblUU o JJICe npu eOlUeN COZIIOCUU 1 01 U AMepU1 O He 6blflO e COCTOJlHUU 6e3 - YTO'lHUM KpeCTbJlHC1 aJl napTWi nen TOJICe XOTeJUl Ho OHU O'leHb eaJICHbl u60 eolUU yT6ep3lCoeHUJl UCXoOJlT U3 npeOnoCblfl1 U 'ITO nOllblUO eoc1 peCflo 6flozooapJl zqeOPOC7U UflU ee­ PUC1 O eouHbl 06'beOUHUTb FepMOHUIO 6e3 COZIIOCUJiI He TOllb1 O CCCp HO U PaHlfUU AHZIIUU DeflbZUU U FOIlIlOHOUU npeepaTUTb nOllblUY e 1 opllu1 oeoe zocyaapcTeo Mi 1 6hWH Ha B0310CKe OT TpeTheii MHpOBOH BOHnhI EC31H 6hI - OHH f HJIH B MHpe HJ1J1I03HH KaK H 3KCTpeMHCThI C031H­ l1 apHOCTH He 3Halomne KY l1 a OHH H l1 yT ECJ1H 6hl OHH 3HIIJIH TO Ha­ AMepHKa 61 Illa yeepeHa qTO lIOJIhllia crpeMHTCH B1 IpBaThCH H3 COII JIarepH OHa HaBepHHKa llpeAIIpHHHJ1a 61 1 lITO-JIHoo BepHoe OTCry rmnH 61 1 Ha3a l1 To 0 lJeM OHH J yMaIOT HeB03MO I H0 ocymeCTBHTh Y Hac KOMMYHHCTOB 6hWH rapaHTHH COBeTcKoro COlO3a OTHOCHTe31hHO 3aIIa l1 HOH rpaHHII hI ITO UMeHHo - He 3HaIO lITO-TO KOHKpeTHoe A lITO 6hWO Y HHX MnllIa­ 3HH MeqTI I lITO pa3phIB C MOCKBOH B03MO f eH H lITO MO I HO I1 06HTh­ CH 1I0 l1 llHHHoii HelaBHCHMOCTH lI031hIllH Ka f Al m 1I031HTHK 06Jl3aH peaJIhHO B3BeCHTh B03MO I HOCTH a - OHH He 6hIJIH B COCTOHHHH 3To­ ro C l1 e31aTh Bhl He 3HaeTe 11 0 qero 61 1 ow I1 OBeJIH lIo31hWY a H A pa3Be BbI 3aHHTepecoBaHhl B BoHne Pa3Be B1 I He 1I0HHMaeTe lITO BORHa 6hIJ1a 6bI l1 llH Hac CTpawneiiweH KaracTpoq oH Hac 61 1 pa3 l1 aBHJIH IIpH lIepBOM CTOOK­ HOBeHHH 3HaIO OW JIHWHJIH 61 1 lIoJIhWY 3aIIa l1 HhIX 3eMeJIh XOTH B03MO I HO 172 173 - 3HalO 8 lleneWKY 3H a'lUT HUKTO HUlielO He nOHUMtlIl a 3HtlIlU 8ce TOllbKO 8bl - JiepMflH JiepYT U MUHlf MOCKoeCKaJI lpyn­ na KaK eac TOloa Ha3bletlllU 1l0euu u60 Kyllbry Xl tj0pMupyeT oywy Hapooa a He lpaHUijbl Bbl # U30ptlllU 7peTUU U Ca M bIU onaCHblU nyTb - COeeTU3aijUIO Hapooa CTanHH TO f e 3HaJI H nOHHMan 3TO OH pa3 l emm Hluny 03a­ JIB COBeTCKHH CTPOH cIl0PMbl rOCY l apCTBeHHoro ycrpoHCTBa COBeTe­ 6o'leHHoCTb B 1952 r OH nblTaJIca BbI l BHHYTb KOHIl eIIU HIO o6'be l H­ HeHHoH HO HeHTpaJIbHOH fepMaHHH TO eCTb o6l e l HHeHHOH HO l py­ HenpaB l a HeT npaBAa na f e eCJIH MbI llIHpoKO nepeHHMa­ KHH OnbIT 'ITO eCTeCTBeHHO nOCKOJIbKY COBeTCKHH COI03 6blJI e l HHCTBeHHOH CTPaHOH B KOTOPOH CTpoHJICa COD HaJIH3M nOTOMY-TO f eCKH HacTpoeHHoH K HaM H HeHTpaJIbHOH flliqero He BbIIlDIO Mbl H nOJIb30BanHCb onblTOM H B 3TOM HeT HH'lero npe l OCY l HTeJIb­ HaM OCTaBaJIOCb TOJIbKO 0 l H0 - Horo Mbl HHKOr l a He KOJIHPOBaJIH COBeTCKHH COI03 aBTOMarH­ mo60H n eHOH COXpaHHTb cIlYH l a­ MeHT 3aJIO f eHHbIH nOCJIe BTOPOH MHPOBOH BOHHbI H60 Bce no­ 'IeCKH HanpoTHB Mbl Bcer n a - DbITKH pacwaTaTb HJIH pa3pyumTb ero n rra Hac BblJIHJIHCb 6bl B Ka­ no Mepe B03MO KHOCTH COXpaHHTb aBTOHOMHIO H conpoTHBJI1IJIHCb nO l 'IepKHBaIO Bcer n a - CTapaJIHCb TaCTpoclly H MbI 6bDIH f H3HeHHO 3aHHTepeCOBaHbl B COxpaHemm nOnblTKaM ynpaBJI1ITb TIOJIbllIeH Ha COBerCKHH M3Hep H cneno nepe­ cTaryc KBO COrJIaCOBaHHoro B TIoTCAa Me HHMaTb COBeTCKHH onbIT Mbl Bcer n a nbITaJIHCb 3aI D HTHTb HallIY caMoCTOaTeJIbHOCTb B o6JIacm KyJIbrypbJ H 3KOHOMHKH TaM r l e - KaKou ijeHou Mbl C'lHTaJIIf 3TO He06xo l HMbIM MbI coxpaHH lIH aBTOHOMHIO TIpHMe­ poM MO f eT 6bITb KaTOJIM'IeCKa1I n epKOBb - ECTeCTBeHHo BblCOKOH Mbl lDIaTHJIH - B03bMeM u rm npH­ Mepa yrOJIb no OTHOllleHHIO K HeH Mbl laHJlJIH n03HD HIO nOJIHOrO HeBMellIaTeJIbCTBa B HCnOJIHeHHHnaCTblpe­ KHX 06a3aHHOCTeH 'ITO COBepllleHHO npOTHBOpe'lHJIO npoHCXO l 1l111e­ MY B POCCHH B OTHOllIeHHH peJIHrHH - MeH JI uHTepecyeT MOptlllbHaJI ijeHa - K ijepKeU Mbl eU e eepHeMCR - 1JTO f e 6blJIO l eJIaTb JII060e conpoTHBJIeHHe CTaJIHH C'IH­ Tan HapyweHHeM JI01lJIbHOCTH a no 3Ha'IHT 'ITO OH CH1IJI 6bl C ce6a OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb la Haum l eJIa TIepe l HaMH 6blJI BbI60p HJIH pal­ - Ho ro 'ITO Mbl npH3HaJIH MHOroo6pa3He MHPOB033peHHH TO f e 0 'IeM-TO CBH l ereJIbCTByeT Mbl BOBee He 6bDIH a6COJIIOTHO peWHTb COBeTCKOMY COI03Y nocrynaTb C HaMH no c06CTBeHHOMY 6ecnOMOlllHblMH H 6eCCHJIbHblMH Mbl BJIM1IJIH Ha C06blTHa MbI nbl­ YCMOTpeHHIO TaK KaK Mbl pacnOJIO f eHbI nocepeAHHe H OT CCCP TaJIHCb KOHTpoJIMpoBaTb HX 3aBHCHT 'ITO 6yAeT C HaMH HJIH nOHTH C HHM Ha KOMnpoMHCC B PaJIHCb M3HeBpHpoBaTb H l TH B 06xo l npHcnoca6iIHBaTbca K 06­ B TO Tpy l HOe H Mpa'IHOe BpeM1l Mbl CTa­ O f H l aIDIH 60JIee 6iIaronpHaTHblX 06CTOaTeJIbCTB 3TO He npoCTo CTaHOBKe Mbl He BblJIOJIHJlJIH TaK f e Bcex peKOMeH n an HH COBeTCKHX Tal HJIH HHa'le y TIOJIblllH HH TorAa HH ceH'laC WHpoKoro Bbl60pa COBeTHHKOB B TIOJIbllIe OHH Be l b npe n rraraJIH - HJIH COBeTOBaJIH He 6blJIO Mbl MOrJIH TOJIbKO COXpaHHTb 06JIHK TIOJIbWH TaKHM apeCTOBaTb l eCaTKH JIIO l eH a MbI 3alllm tJ aJIIfCb HeT OHH He 6blJIH KaKOB OH eCTb 3TO 6blJIO HallIeH e l HHCTBeHHOH B03MO f HOCTbIO y HaC ry6ePHaTOpaMH a Mbl He 6blJIH CTOJIb nocnYWHblMH KaK HallIH Pa l H 3Toro llIaHca PaAH 3THX rpamm CTOHJIO HATH Ha YCTynKH coce l H - H f epTBbl l epTBbl - KOMHCCHIO n rra npoBepKH 06pallleHH1l C laKJIIO'IeHHblMH npHMeH1lIOT BpeMeHHoe 1IBJIeHBe TIpaB n a nOCTpa n aJIH OT l eJIbHble JIIO l H HO o6iImc TIOJIbWH ee BeJIH'lHe - 3TO 6a3a n rra 6yAYI D HX nOKOJIeHHH 'Iexu 6oJIrapbl BeHrpbl Mbl C03 n aJIH l HCD HIDIHHapHyIO JIM B TIOpbMax nbITKH HaM YAaJIOCb COXpaHHTb f H3Hb reHepany TaTapy H l pymM nOJIbCKHM ocllHD epaM B 'IeM H Moa 3aCJIyra Mbl He l OnyCTHJIH CMepTHblX npHrOBopoB Ha npon eccax H3 l KOMMy­ - Henpaeoa Jia30 - 3TO Hapoo elO 7paouijuu elO Kyllbry­ Xl - 1l106aR U npoepeccUeHaJI UpeaKijuoHHaJI no eaweu TepMUHQ­ 174 HHCTaMH H He CY l HJIH fOMynKY 175 - TozOa 803HUKJlO uae f 1l0llbWU KaK 17-u pecnyfilluKU - llpaBoa IlU 'ITO npoeKT KOHCTUTY14UU KOTOPblU Dblll nOCilaH B MOCK8Y eepHyllC f C 82-J4Jl nonpaBKOMU - HH'Iero nOn06HOrO - JIO Kb TaKoro He 6blJIO TOJIbKO B npeaM6YJIe - llpeonoJlOzflIloCb U3MeHUTb ZUMH U zepD ZOcyOapCT8a - FocnooUH XaUH He owu JaeTCH Beob OH npuHUMflIl y'iOCTue e pafioTax no peiJaKTUpoeaHulO KOHCTUTY14UU - Henpaana - H - Ro B opyzux C014UflIlUCTUlleCKUX zOCYOapCT6t1X CMeHUIlU rHH - MO KeT naMHT MHe H3MeIDleT HO H He noMHIO 'lT06bl Mbl TO Ke npHHHMaJI B 3TOM ytIaCTHe BbIDH ABe pe ll KOJIJIe­ napTHHHaH H npaBHTeJIbCTBeHHaH Bo rJIaBe npaBHTeJIbCTBeH­ HOH B KOTOPOH pa60Tan XaHH CTOHJI H3BeCTHbIH IOpHCT npo jJec­ 3aHHMaJIHCb 3THM BonpocoM He HCKJIIO'IeHO 'ITO KTo-TO Mor Bblcry­ cop PalMapHH a BO maBe napTHHHOH ­ H llpaana H npHcyTCTBOBan nHTb C TaKHM npeAJIO KeHHeM HO MbI pyKOBOnCTBO oTBeprJIH ero He Ha Beex 3aeenaHHHX HO 3aKJIIO'lHTeJIbHbIH TeKCT KOHCTHTyllHH F060P fT COM CTflIlUH K020a EepYT 8blCTYnUil C TaKUM Aa Ke OHH H 6blJIH TO He3Ha'IHTeJIbHble jJopMaJIbHOrO xapaKTepa H BHneJI H H He noMHIO HH O ll HOH cyrneCTBeHHOH nonpaaKH ECJIH o KOTOPblX MeIDl ll a Ke He HH jJopMHpoBanH H60 Ha xapaKTep KOH­ npeiJllo JKeHUe M CTHryn HH OHH He BJIHHJIH MO T 6bITb 3TO Kacanocb BBeneHHH - He HCKJIIO'IeHO Mano JIH nO ll XaJIHMoB OHH npeMaranH HeKOTopblX nacca KeH auanOrH'lHblX COBeTcKoH KOHCTHTylI HH BCSKoro pona 3aTeH Korna CTpeMHJIHCb yrO n HTb 3aTo Y CTaJIHHa KOTOPas C TO'IKH 3peHHH neMOKpaTH'IeCKHX npHHWlnoB 6bIDa XBanmo YMa He nOKpoBHTeJIbCTBOBaTb TaKHM 3aTeHM OH 3TO nOKa­ BeJIHKOJIenHO H JIHOOPaJIbHO OTpeAaKTHpoBaHa XOTH 3TH ee '1epTbl 1952 r Korna Mbl noeXaJIH B MOCKBY 06Cyx JJ aTb lJaCTO CTHparoTCH npaKTHKoH K CO KaJIeHHIO TaK 'ITO eCJIH H 6hl­ HOBYIO KOHCTHryu HIO Mbl nOKa3aJIH eMY npeaM6yny K HeH B KOTo­ JIH KaKHe-JIH6o H3MeHeHHH TO HecymeCTBeHHble Cepbe3HOH 6hDla poH rOBOpHJIOCb 'ITO B npollIlIOM lloJIbIIIY OKKynHPOBaJIH ABe TOJIbKO nOnpaBKa K npeaM6yne H Mbl npHHHJIH ee KaK KeCT CTane­ 3bman He pal B Bp e6Hble eH CTpaHbl - AaCTpIDI H repMaHHH PenaKTOpbl KOH­ CTHryu HH 60HJIHCb ynOMHHYTb POCCHIO 1IT06bl He Bbl3BaTb Heno­ BOJIbCTBa CTaJIHHa CTanHH npo'leJI H na KOTOPhIH noweJI naBCTpeqy aHTHPYCCKHM HaCTpOeHHHM nOJIH­ KOB nOKa3aB TeM caMblM 'ITO 3HaeT 06 3TOM Torna BCTan Bonpoc ynOMH­ nyTb 0 napCKOH OKKynan HH HJIH HeT OH npeAJIO KHJI ynOMHHYTb llpOMOO'IaT ­ 6eCCMbICJIeHHO a B ynoMHHaHHHnapCKoHoKKynallHH - B oDMeH 3a 3TO nOllbCKue cnopTcMeHbl OD f3aHbl DblllU npouzpaTb C08eTcKUM HeT HH'lerO aHTHCOBeTCKoro OH HaM o'lem nOMor H MbI npH3naJIH - A 'ITO OTKa3bmaThCH OT COCTH3aHHH oKKynall HlO napCKOH POCCHH - ReT HO He ellU fTb Ha pe3YllbTaTbI - 3Ha'lUT cnpaWU8fl1lU - A 'ITO B 3TOM y ll HBHTeJIbHoro Y JII06oro MO KHO cnpoCHTb - Ua Ho Be ll b no xony cnoprHBHblx COpeBHOBaHHH npoHBJIH­ COBera H 3TO BOBee He CBHneTeJIbCTByeT 0 3aBHCHMOCTH HJIH npe­ JIHCb CTaphle aHTHpyccKHe H HOBble aHTHCOBeTCKHe HaCTpoeHHH no­ BOCXOnCTBe Toro Koro cnpalllHBalOT K TOMY Ke H3MeHeHHe B JISKOB H He Hama nponarauna 6bDla BHHOBaTa B 3TOM XOTH H OT npeaM6yJIe H nepe'IHCJIeHHe Tpex OKKynauToB npHHeCJIO HaM nOOH­ naweH H He 6blJl B BOCTopre 3TO 6bDlO peJyJIbTaTOM nepeMeH B TH'IecKyIO nOJIb3y CTpaHe 176 - H - H He 3a 3TO HoOO 6bZllO 6Jza20oapUTb C08eTCKUU C0103 e JICeo­ npoTHB KpHTHKH • CaM KPHTHKOBaJI He pa3 Ho KpHTH­ KOBaTb HanO YMHO YMelO'IH Ha Ba f HKa 06pymHJlCJI He TonbKO S He8HO HO H npyrne HanpHMep Pmuapn CTp Kenen KHii OTpHD aTeJlbRbIe JIB­ - A lfl'o Bo06LQe He rOBOpHn Ib6eran OOaronapHOCTeH lla S 3HaIO 6bIJIH TaKHe rocnona K 'PHaJIHCTbI H AeSTe1IH KOTO­ neHHS HeH36e KHbI Pa3Be pa3BHTHe EBponbl B XIX B npoHCxo HJlO Ge3 HHX HeT 6bIJlo eLQe x e HaM ynanocb H36e KaTb 3Kcnnya­ pble Y f CJIHIIIKOM yeepnCTBOBaJIH B CBoeM BOCTopre Mbl 3HaeM Tan HH neTCKoro Tpyna - a Be b B npoInnOM 3TO 6bllO MaCCOBbIM TaKHX K IH XOTen nOK83aTb lfl'0 C HHM Bee B nopS D Ke SBneHHeM 10-12 neT CTpOHJIH HH yCTpHaJIbHYID EBPOny H neTH llbITaJICS 06pa3YMHTb TaKHX BpeMS OT BpeMeHH S opraHH30BbIBaJI A npeCCoKOH€pepeHIJ HH H cnpaBe lIHBbIX '1eM XOTH He Bcerna OHH 6bllH ynatJHbIMH Mo­ KeT H S He C1IHIIIKOM YMen 6eeenOBan C HHMH HeCOMHeHHO lfl'0 Mbl 3TO npoBenH B YCJIOBHJIX B neCSTb pa3 60nee ryMaHHbIX 3ana n A eLQe Baii n a C ero p € HJIbMOM qeno­ BeK H3 MpaMOpa Morno 6bITb lfl'OGbI npHI'nacHJIH napHKMaxepa H e rOBOpHJI lfl'0 B Hameii nponaraH e 6bllO MHoro rnynoCTeii Henenoro BOCTopra cneJIaTb npH'leCKH CTaxaHoBnaM lla Morno npOCTOnyII IIDl Ho Be b TPY D HO 6bllO He llHcaTb 0 roM lfl'0 6naro­ GbIllH CJlyqaH npHMHTHBHOii H rnynoii nponaraH D bI Ho Be b 3TO OT­ naps COBeTCKOMY COlO3Y B CTpaHe npoH30nmH eep e3Hble nepeMe­ nenbHble 3llH30 bI a BOBee He xapaKTepHble lIS mOXH MOMeHTbl RbI HJIH He BCnOMHHaTb 0 TOM lfl'0 OOaronaps COBeTCKOMY COlO3Y BbIJl H 3HTY3Ha3M B pa60Te H ropnOCTb ycnexaMH MO KHO cnopHTb MbI npHCOe n HHHJlH K IIonbIIIe 3ana HbIe 3eM1IH nOCTaTOtJHO nH Mbl npHJIO KHJlH YCHJIHii lIS ycoBepIIIeHCTBoBaHHS CTaxaHoBcKoro BH KeHHJI MO KHO GbllO npoBO HTb ero YMHee - OCTa8UM 3TU 3e M 1U 8 n01 oe J a8aUTe n02080pUM 0 Hapooe MO KHO 6bIJlO KOe-lfl'O H3MeHHTb paHbIIIe B03MO KH0 Reno 0 HaK0 OAR KOTOP020 8bl W C08eTCKUU MaHep npuoYMfl lU cTaxaH08cKoe He B 3TOM a B TOM 'ITO '1erO-TO MbI 6naronapJl 3TOMY BH KeHHlO 08UJICeHUe 2epoe8 Tpyoa nOCTHrnH 11 MHororo Be3 CTaxaHOBneB He GbllO 6bI HH HOBOR ryTbl HH B03po f eHHJI CTapoBKH CTapbIR ropon B BapIIIaBe na - CTaxaHoBcKoe BH KeHHe 6bIJIO nO HHbIM H 6opb6a 3a npOH3BO HTeJIbHOCTb Tpyna KOTOPbIH 3TO He nyCTOH n03yar 3ro n03yar H caMa BapIIIaBa - Hennoxoii ropon - BXO HT B nepe'leHb HanIH X ycnexoB C 3HTY3Ha3MOM nO XBaTHJla MOnOne f b ECTecrneHHO eeiitmc Han 3THM nemo CMesncs npeBpaTHB cTaxaaoBcKoe BH Ke­ - HeT COMHeHWl HO Bapwa8a M02Aa 6blTb el#e Kpacu8ee eUle HHe B KapHKaTypy lla H B TO BpeMS Koe-KOMY He HpaBHJIHCb IIIe­ Ay'lWe eCAU 6bl 8bl He OTK03fl lU Kop6103be KOTOPblU npeOAOJfCU l peHrH CTaxaHOBneB Ha napanax Ho Henb3S 3a6bmaTb lfl'0 3TH nlO­ 8KAlO'lUTb 8 npol4ecc n0020T08KU nAaH08 803pOJfCOeHWl Bapwa8bl AH Ay'lWUX apXUTeKTop08 Mupa 8 pa MKax nOMoUlu U KaK npu3HaHWl B pa60TanH C Bepoii B TO lfl'O OHH TBOpST BeJlHKOe neno 1956 A nOToM r HeKTO AnaM Ba f HK HanHCaJI II03MY lIS B3POCJlbIX 2epOU'leCKOU ucropuu Bapwa8bl nbITascb Bce 000Hn rps3blO IIo'leMY IIo'leMY OH nHCarI lfl'0 TaM 6blJlH rynSLQHe neByuIKH lla Ke eC1IH TaKHe CJIyqaH 6bIBanH TaK lfl'0 - H He nOMHlO nonp06HOCTeii HO TaKOe Morno CJIyqHTbCS O HaKO Kop6lO3be H npyrHe C OrpOMHbIM HHTepeCOM Ha6nlOnanH 3a peKOHCTpYKD Heii BapIIIaBbI OHH npHe3 KanH CMOTpeJlH Ho MbI - 06 3TOM woo paCCKQ3bI8aTb He MornH Bocnonb30BaTbCJI HX ycnyraMH TaK KaK B TO BpeMS B CO­ - MbI caMH 6opo1IHcb C oTpHnaTeJlDHbIMH SBneHHSMH HaMH KopGlO3be CTaJIH C'lHTaTb CJlHIIIKOM CMenbIM HOBaTopoM BeTCKOM COlO3e Ha'IaJIaCb 3pa MOHyMeHTaJIbHbIX 3naHHii C KonOH­ IIoMHlO JI KaK-TO noexan B JIeHHHrpan Ho 8 203erax nUCfl lU TOAbKO 0 nOAOJfCUTeAbHbIX TowHUAO 178 ropon Kyna KpaCHBee MOCKBbI MeHJI conpoBO f aJI ceKpeTapb neHHHrpanCKOH napTopra­ HH3an HH Ha OAHoii H3 y1IHn OH nOKa3aJI MHe nOM nOCTpoeHHbIii 179 no DJlaHaM mm COBeTaM Kop6I03be H OT03BaJICJI 0 HeM 6e3 BOC­ Topra MHeHHIO 6hlll JI 'lIWe qeM CTPOHTeJIbCTBO COBMeCTHhIX yrOJIbHhIX - Ha3eart UMnepuatlUCTUfleCKW4 - HeT CJIHlIIKOM HOBaTOpCKHM B COBeTCKOM COI03e K TOMy BpeMeHH Kop6I03be yxce paSBeHtIaJIH Ero CTaJIH 06BHHJlTb B tIpe3­ MepHOM Mo n epHH3Me HaCT 'DHJla snoxa KJIaCCHtIeCKHX KOJIOHH orpoMHhIX nOCTpoeK IZU HaM J1eope14 KylZbTYpbZ U HaYKU eMeCTO paiiOHa 3ICUJlbZX 00­ Moe He BephTe Y HaC KOM6HHaToB A COBeTbI npenrraraJIH HMeHHO STO I10CblJIaJl yrom Mhl B o JIytIlIIHX BpeMeH 3aJIHChIBaJIH H no n CtIHThmaJIH H 6JIaro n apJl STOMy fOMYJIKa CMor n03X e npe J 'bJIBHTb CtIeT 6bI A ecn H Mhl COfJIaCHJlHCh Ha COBMeCTHhle KpyrrHbIe KOM6HHaTbl TO Mhl yTpaTHJlH 6hI KOHTPOJIb Ha n yroJIhHOn npoMhIIIllleHHOCTbIO MH CtIHTaJI lITO C03 n a HHe n IDKe O J Horo yroJIbHOrO KOM6HHaTa npHBe n eT K B03HHKHOBeHHIO HOBhIX H K3 K J hIH H3 HHX nOCTaBHT no n yrpo3 ' - H IlT06bZ yeoOUTb C08eTCKOMY pYKoeoOcTey ebZ nooapu­ - lITO napoM HO STO MbI H36panH TaKOn nyTb KOTOplltii no HallIeMy He 6hlllO BhI60pa Kor n a CTaJIHH npenrro­ KHJl nOCYpOHTh HellTO Bpo n e CHMBOJIa n pyxc6hI H nOMOlUH MH CTaJI MetITaTh 0 paiioHe KHJlhlX n OMOB HO CTaJIHH STY 3aTeIO OTBepr ueCMOTPJl Ha TO tITO MbI npenrrOXCHJlH Ha3BaTb STOT paiiOH ero HMe­ HeM B Ko e KO OB OH pellIHJI tITO nonapoK-TO OT Hero a eMY XO­ treTCJI nOnapHTb HaM HetrTO BeJIHKOJIenHOe orpoMHOe HenOBTopH­ Moe H CHMBOJlHt eCKoe l uJIon paiiOH STHM ycn OBHJlM He coomeT­ CTBOBaJI nOCKOJIbKY OH 6hlll noxoxc Ha n pyrHe XCHJlble paiiOHhl H trepe3 HeKoTopoe BpeMJI Bee 6bI 3a6hlJlH KTO nOnapHJl 3TOT paiiOH H B qeCTb Koro OH Ha3BaH CTaJIHH XOTeJI nOCTpoHTb J Bopen KOTO­ HallI 3KOHOMHtIeCKHH cysepeHHTeT OlleHb JIOBKO H36excaJI STon yrP03hl XOTJI COBMeCTHhle npe n npHJITHJI 6blJlH C03 n aHbI B KH­ Tae H PyMbIHHH I10DhlTKH HX C03 n aHHJ1 6hlJlH npe n nPHHJITbI TaKXCe B T eXOCJIOBaKHH - BaM IZUIlHO HpaeUllCJI lleope14 KYlZbTYPbZ - BepyTY HpaBHJlCJI OH 60JIbme Beex HaC HHTepecoBaJICJI apXHTeKTYpon BOCCTaHaBJIHBaBmeHCJI BapmaBbI ECTb n axce J OTo­ rpa J HJI Ha KOTOPOH CHJIThI BepyT Bce nOJIHT6IOpo I10PII H ap­ XHTeKTophI OHH paccKa3hIBaIOT 0 CBOHX npoeKTax a MbI n eJIaeM 3aMellaHKJl 3TOT CHHMOK J hIWeT npaB n on nOKa3hlBaeT omomeHHe BepYTa K CTpoHTeJIbCTBy BapmaBhI OH rny60Ko HHTepecoBaJICJI HM tIaCTO rOBOpHJI 06 STOM H n eHCTBHTeJIhHO n asaJI COBeThI apXH­ TeKTOpaM phIH 6hlll 6bI BH n eH H3 JII060ii TOtrKH ropona r n e 6hlllH 6b1 pacnOJIo­ xceHbI KHHO TeaTphI H n pyrue KyJIbTypHbIe 3aBe n eHHJI IlOJIXCeH npH3HaTb tITO COBeTCKHe apXHTeKTophl OlleHh CTapaJIHCb tIT06bI nOCTpoiiKa 6hllla BeJIHlleCmeHHon OHH e3 J HJlH B JII06JIHH H 3aMOCK ­ - lllZOU4aOb CnaCUTeJ1 R C ype3aHHbZM KynolZoM Kocrena U lllZOU4aOb Ha PacnYTbu C lleopl4OM KJlIZbTYPbZ - npRMo KaK e MocKee H3ytIaTb nOJIbCKYIO apXHTeKTYPY cpe n HHX BeKOB H snoXH B03poxc n e­ HHJI C TeM trT06bI HHKopnopupoBaTb HeKOTophIe 3JIeMeHThI nOJIhC­ Koii apXHTeKTYpbI B CBon npoeKT I1OJIytIHJlOCb-TO He OtreHb HO OHH CTapaJIHCb H BepHJlH tITO CTPOJlT HetrTO TaKOe llero eme B MHpe He 6hlllO IlBopen Mexc n y npOllHM o60merrcJI PYCCKHM OlleHh n o­ poro TaK KaK 3a Bee DJlaTHJlH OHH - A MbZ W4 3a 3TO - Haw YZOlZb - TaKHe npoeKTbI 6hlllH HO HaWK apXHTeKTOphI BHOCHJIH nOnpaBKH H B Ko e KO OB OT HHX OTKa3aJIHCb Ho no Tpe60Ba­ JIO YMeJIbIX 3aMetIaHHii H HallIero KOHTpoJIJI 3aTeH BepyTa He Beer­ n a 6hIJIH ynatrHhIMH a OH 6hDI B CBOH 3aTeH BJII06n eH KaK BCJIKHii Ho Ha IJ O npH3HaTb tITO TeMDhI H pa3Max BOCCTaHOBJIeHHJI Bapma­ BhI - 3T0 ero 3acnyra - KaKUM 6bZlZ BepYT - 180 3TO npasna MhI nOCTaBJIJlJIH HM yrOJIb n apoM HJlH nOllTH 181 - CT3J1HH ysa l 3J1 H Il emm ero H npaBHJIhHO CAeJI3J1 nOCTaBHB - TOJIhKO B He3HallHTeJIbHOii CTeneHH BHHoBaTa 6blJIa Me lJ y­ Hapo J HaJI o6cTaHoBKa XOJIO J HaJI BoiiHa KOHq JIHKT B Kopee ero BO maBe rOCYAIlpCTBa B03HHK BoeHHbIH nCHX03 nCHX03 non03pHTeJIbHOCTH nCHX03 ocan­ - YMHbIU Horo nOJIo eHWI TaKHe e HaCTpoeHWI rOCIIOnCTBOB3J1H B COBerCo KOM CalOle TaM CJIHWKOM paliJ 'JIH HX a no B CBOIO oqepenb - Ee3 COMHeHIDl HO nOBJIHJlJIO Ha nOJIO eHHe B IIoJIhwe 3TO H cr3J1O npHttHHOii yCHJIe­ -HeOOY'lKa TH B HHJI penpecCHR co CTOpoHbI opraHoB rOCYAllPCTBeHHoii 6e30naCHOCo TaKOH 06CTaHOBKe npoHCXO l HJIH 6eccMbICJIeHHble apeCTbI BHHOBHhIX H HeBHHOBHbIX npHqeM nOBO J bl J JIJI apecToB 3a' aCTyIO - He B nOM neJIo OH 6bIJI caMO IKoii HO CTpeMHJICJI K 3Ha· 6bIB3J1H coBepweHHo a6CYP J HblMH JlI06aJ1 HeYAIl' a Ha npennpHJI­ HHJIM MHoro lIHT3J1 HeDJIoxo 3H3J1 JIHTepaTYPY HHTepeCOB3J1CJI THH omJlCHJlJIaCh BpeIJ HTeJIhCTBOM Bee 3TO 6blJI0 crpawHo HO CTH­ aCTpoHOMHeii apXHTeKTypoii Ho Y Hero 6bIJIH HenpeOnOJIHMbIe MyJI HCXOnHJI OT CCCP KOMDJIeKCbI OH 6bIJI COBepweHHO JIOJIJIeH no OTHOWeHHlO K COBeTCo - A Y Hac noOxBaTUllu KOMY COlO3Y H q aHarH IHO BepHJI B norMY a 3TO BJIHJIJIO Ha ero pe­ WeHHJI B OTJIHttHe or JIaMlle EepYT B MOJIOnOCTH npHHa J lle 3J1 K - TaK Ha3bIBaeMOMY 6oJIbWHHCTBY 6yIJ T0 6bI K 60JIee rn6KHM 3Ha­ KOMbIM C npHHIl HIlaMH 6YP Ya3HOii neMoKpaTHH Ho BnOCJIenCTBHH jI He OTpHII a1O Ha HMa CT3J1HHCKOrO annapaTa Ha H8llI H eCTeCTBeHHO pe3YJIbTarbl 6bIJIH yrKHMH Ho JI y e Torna 6bIJI JIaMIIe cYMeJI OCBo60 J HTbcJI OT MHornx norM a Eepyr C rOnaMH y6e IJ eH 'ITO 3TO BpeMeHHoe JlBJIeHHe He HMelOIIl ee ero 06lIl e­ Ha060POT CTaHOBHJICJI Bee 60JIee KOCHbIM H He CYMeJI H36aBHrbCJI ro C cyThlO COBeTCKoro rocynapCTBa 'ITO OHO pe3YJIbTaT CDJIeTeHWI OT MHorHX y e OT HBIIIHX npHHIl HnOB HeCMOTpJI Ha 3TO MbI 6b1­ HCTOpJllleCKHX q aKTOPOB H OTHOWeHHJI CT3J1HHa K HHM H 'ITO Kor­ JIH CBJl3aHbI KpeDKOH npy 60ii B3aHMHoii CHMIIaTHeii H MbI Xopo­ na-HH6ylJ b 3TO Bee npeKpaTHTCJI WO cpa60T3J1HCb Eepyr ' aCTO J aB3J1 MHe ttHTaTb CBOH nOKJIa J bI H pettH - BbZ PYKOBOOUllU Toeoa opeaHQ Mu H BbICryn3J1 C HHMH JIHIIlb nOCJIe o6cy IJ eHWI co MHOR jI ' aCTO BHOCHJI He60JIblIIHe nonpaBKH HHorna KOe-lITO no6aBJ JIJI H OH comaw3J1CJI EepyT Il eHHJI MOH COBenI Pe D lCO CJIY1I3 l10Cb lIT06bI OH He BOCnOJIh30B3J1CJI HMH - BbI l YMKH jI TOJI KO KOHTPOJIHPOB3J1 HX AeJITeJIhHOCT B paMKaX PYKoBo J JIlIl eii rpoHKH MOH OTHOWeHIDI C EepyroM 6bIJIH 60JIee TeCHbIMH qeM C MHH­ Il eM MHHIl HH C KeM He npY HJI q oTorpaq mo - YSa l 3J1 OR - KTo ICe pelUtl l Toeoa Bce Bonpocbl 6bIJI CYXOBaT IIocMorpHTe Ha 3TO 3aMeTHO Ho MHHIl 6bIJI MOHM npyroM Eepyr ero 3a CBeTJIblii YM H 3HaHHe 3KOHOMHKH Koropoe ' aCTO HaC oqeHh BblpYQ3J10 MHHIl HeCOMHeHHO 6bIJI OqeHb YMeH HO H OH - BeeM pyKOBO J HJI H Bce KOHTPOJIHPOB3J1 Eepyr ECJIH MHe­ HHJI He COBnanaJIH TO TOJI KO B MeJIO'IaX a He no cyIII eCTBy B03­ OIIIH63J1CJI KaK H Bee MbI B nepBble e ro J bl Haponuoii IIOJIhIIIH MO HO MHe He CJIenOB3J10 6bI nora rOBOpHT nOCKOJI KY JI He Xo­ MHHIl CMeJIO BbI J BHHYJI Ha Kpynuble nOCTbI nOBoeHHbIX cne J H3J1HCo qy TOB HO n03 e OTKa33J1CJI or 3roii nOJIHTHKH Ha Hero KaK Ha Bcex HaC nOBJIHJIJI KJIHMaT xOJIo J Hoii BoiiHbI H nOn03pHTeJIbHoCTH orOBapHBan Eepyra KOTOPbIH 6bIJI OqeHh BeJIHKOAYWeH KO MHe H JI eMY 3a MHoroe 6rrarOnapeH Ho B TO BpeMJI 3aKpeIIHJICJI nopJI· nOK nponOJI aBIIIHHCJI H npH rOMYJIKe 'ITO IIepBbIH nOMHHHpyeT Han BeeMH qneHaMH nOJIHT6IOpo Bee napTHH nOnt HlDlJIHC 3TOMY no­ - Ho BeOb Bbl-TO 'JTOT KIlUMaT U H flCaJlCOtlllu Bbl EepYT UMUH14 182 pJl D lCy BO HMJI e J HHCTBa KOTopoe JlBJIJleTCJI rapaurOM CHJIbI CttHTa· JIOC lITO palHOmaCHJI OTpIDKalOT BuyrpeHHlOIO CJIa60CTh B Haweii 183 TpoiiKe MH H n 38Be rn maJI 3KOHOMHKOH a MHe 6hDIH ll OBepeHhI BonpoChI KynhTYPhl npoCBemeHlHl BhIcume Y'Ie6Hhle 3aBe ll eHHJI AKap eMHJI HaYK nponaraH U a BHeUlliJlJl nOnHTHKa H ll eonOfHJI H KOHTponh Ha ll OpraHaMH roc6e ronaCHOCTH Kor n a rOMynKa ywen BepyT 06paTHllCJI KO MHe C npeMO llCeHHeM COBMeCTHO KypH­ poBan MHHHCTepCTBO rocy n apCTBeHHoH 6e30IIaCHOCTH H cornaCHII­ CIt H nO-BH ll HMOMY 3pJl nOTOMY tlTO Bnocne ll CTBHH BO BeeM 06BHHIDIH MeHJI H KypHpoBaJI opraHhI a BepyT BoeHHyIO pa3Be ll ­ KY H Bee tlTO CBJllaHO C pa3Be ll KOH KOHTppa3Be ll KOH 6opl 60ii C HHOCTpanHhlMH areHTYpaMH H IIlI1HOHa lKeM TaK pacnpe ll enJlJ1H OT­ BeTCTBeHHOCTh H MhI H OHH B CCCP - Pe ll B MHHHCTepCTBe 6hmo 60nee ll eCJITKa OT ll enOB B Ka lK ll OM - COBeTHHK H KOnnefHJI KOTOpas peI1lllJ1a cnopHhle Bonpochl B CDy'lae oco60 Cepl e3HI IX pas­ HOrnaCHH HllH no nOBo ll y KpynHhIX ll en 06pamaJIHcI K BepyTY CMepTHhIX npHroBopoB TaM me Mor pa3YMeeTCJI 3TO 6hmo He TaK npoCTO nOCKOnl KY 'laCTI ll en KaCaJIaCI He opranOB a pa3Be ll ­ KH H KOHTppa3Be ll KH a TaK lKe nOTOMY 'ITO BllHJlHHe COBeTCKHX co­ BeTHHKOB B CTpane 6hmo orpoMHhIM H npHHecno 6onbmoH Bpe ll MHoro ll en BhlX0 ll HJ10 K CO lKaJIeHHIO 3a paMKH MOHX nOnHOMO'IHH a MHoro 6hmo TaKHX K KOTOPhlM II He Mor ll 06paThCJI TaK tlTO Hee­ MOTPJl Ha MOH nOnbITKH KOe-tlTO C ll enaTI no He Bcer n a nonyqa­ noCl PyKH 6hmH KOpOTKH H nOCTaBHn nepe ll co60ii ll Be ellH ­ 6e3 CMePTHhIX npHrOBopOB H 6e3 opraHH CY ll e6HhIX npo ee­ COB Ha ll KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKHMH llH ll epaMH H MHe Y ll aJIOCI 06e 3TH eJ1H ocymeCTBHTb IIepBym npaB 1 a nHllII OT'laCTH CMepTHhIe npH­ roBOphI 6bDIH npaB n a He B rnaBHhIX npo eccax Ha ll con n aTaMH ApMHH KpaiiOBOH a B MeHee KpynHhIX ll 0 KOTOPhlX Moe BJ1HJlHHe y lKe He ll OX0 ll HJ10 HJ1H K TpoiiKe KpoMe KonnefHii B OT ll enax cymeCTBOBaJIa Kon­ - lla6aiiTe no O'lepeOu Cpa3Y noclle a62YCT06CK020 MeHYMa nefHJI Ha ypoBHe MHHHcTepCTBa B Hee BXO ll HJ1H MHHHCTP 3aMMH­ HHCTphl Ha'IaJIhHHKH HeKoTophlX OT ll enOB 0 pe3ynl TaTax pa60Tl I na KOnnerHJI ll OKlla rn maJIa MHe BepYTY HllH TpoiiKe B laBHCH­ 6 1948 2 6bl l apeCT06aH AllbfjipeO Rpowe6U'I a MeCJl14 cnYCT R BIl003UMe JK Dex06U'l - MUHUCrp cHa6 xceHlLfl MOCTH OT ll ena Ko MHe HHor n a la COBeTOM HHor n a C ll OKlla ll OM npHXO ll HJ1 MHHHCTp Pa ll KeBH'I Ho 'lame OH 6hffiaJI Y BepyTa H lICe 06hl'1Ho BCTpe'IaJICJI C 3aMMHHHCTpaMH OC06eHHO C POMKOBCKHM A C B03HeCeHCKUM CKYllb6awe6cKuM - C06eTCKUMU nOIl­ - 3TO ll eno ll 0 CHX nop OCneTCJI ll J1JI MeHJI HeJlCHhIM H OHO He paccne ll OBaHO ll 0 KOmta - 3Ha1lUT BepYT Ha rpeTbeM MeHYMe IJK 6 19492 cnpa6eo­ K06HUKaJrIU PYK0600UTe tlRMU 6oeHHoii pa36eoKu U Korppas6eo­ IlU60 KpU'latl 'ITO pe3YllbTaTOM ux OeJlTeJZbHOCTU 6bl l0 y6uiicT60 KU 6bZ He 6bl lU C6 R3QHbl H060TKU np060KaTOpoM - OHH 61 mH Y MeHJI HeCKOnl KO Pal no ll eny Kor n a He Mor­ a TaK xce apecT U 2u6eJZb T06apuU eu f JuHoepa U Rcu f JoPHatlbCKOU apecT U 2u6eJZb RHeKa Kpacu14­ K020 J1H nOIIaCTI K BepYTY HJ1H Kor n a ero He 6hmo B BapIIIaBe B cymHoe­ TH II He KYPHpoBaJI pa3Be ll KY H KOHTppa3Be ll KY HO HHor n a OC06eH­ HO B OTCyTCTBHe BepyTa MHe npHX0 ll HJ10Cl 3THM 3aHHMaTl CJI K MHHUY XO ll HJ1H H3 3KOHOMH'leCKOrO OT ll ena He Mor lICe II Pal6H­ paTI CJI BO BeeM Ko MHe HaIIpaBnJlJ1H ll ena He3Ha'IHTenI HhIe Bonee KpYJIHhIe peI1lllJ1HCI Ha 3aee IJ aHlHlX TPOHKH H Y Bepyrn H rOBopw - HeT HHKaKHx YKa3aHHii Ha npH'laCTHOCTI apeCToBaHHhlx K HX m6enH He 6hmo - Bce 3TO ll ora ll KH H BhIMhICllhl HpomeBH'I H JIexOBH'II ll 0 BOHHbl pa60TaJIH BO BTOPOM OT ll ene reHillTa6a T e B OT ll ene 060POHbI 3aHHMammeMCJI palBe ll KOH H KOHTppa3­ Be ll KoH no He nOTOMY tlTO xoqy onpas n aTl H o6enHTl ce6J1 Oum60K 61 mo ll ooymeHo MHoro H He Bee npHHJIThle C MoeH no n a'IH pemeHHJI - B TOM 'lUCIle U a2eHTaJrIU C06eTCKoii pa36eOKU 6hlJ1H y n allHhIMH Ho MHe Ka lKeTCJI tlTO MHOfHX MHe Y ll aJIOCb cnaCTH Kor n a nO ll fOTaBJ1HBaJIHCI KpYJIHhIe cY ll e6HhIe npo ecchI II CTapaJICJI BocnpeDJITCTBOBaTI HX npoBe ll eHHw HllH He ll onyCTHTI BhlHeceHlHl 184 - 3TOMY HeT ll OKa3aTenbCTB Bo BpeMJI BOHHhI OHH BCTYDHllH B rBap ll HIO JIW ll OBY H ApMHIO JIW ll OBY H pa60TaJIH co CnhlXaJIl e­ 185 KHM KOTAli TOT 1I0C'JIe BOHHhI B03TJIaBWI pa3Be qICy H KOHTppa3­ BeAKY OH B3JfJl HX K ce6e IIoC'JIe 1948 T KOTAll BpeMJllIepe lJ bIlI IKH 38KOHtlWIOCi H CTWIa B03pacraTh OII8CHOCTL IIpoHHKHoBeHIDl BparoB - 3TO 6bIlIO HecnpaBe ll llHBo HO IIPHIIHHOH 6hlJla aTMociPepa 1I0 ll 03pHTeJIbHOCTH leJIo JIeXOBHIIa XOTeJIH 06'be ll HHHTL C ll eJIOM CIIDIXaJIbCKOTO B 3TH OPTaHLI HX 6HOTpaCPHH MOTJIH Bhl3BaTL 1I0 1l Q3peHHe 3m BIIOJIHe IIOHJITHO IIOTOMY 'lITO B lIepHo ll OlIaCHOCTH YCHJIHBaeTCR - CnblXfJIlbCKOZO nocaoullu B Mae 1949 1950 z ao 3TOZO B aBZYC­ CTpaX TeM 6oJIee 'ITO 1I0 ll 03peBaeMhle BeJIH ce6R CTpaHHO HMeJIHCL Te 3JIeMeHTLI llOllbUlY IlTOObI pa3blCKaTb opaTa H03M JlKOObl nponaBUlezo a IIPOBOK lUHH H All Ke BpeJJ HTeJILCTBa OpramI CTWIH BbIRBJIRTh COTpY ll HHKOB BTOPOro OT D eJIa pa60TaBIlIHX TaM ll 0 BOH­ z Bbl apeCTOBfJIlU repMaHa fiJWZbOa KOTOPblU npueXfJll B Ha CaMOM oelle apecToBaHHozo ml H HpoIIleBHII H JIexOBJIlI CTapaRCL BLITOPO ll HTL ee6R 06BHWlJIH ll PYTHX COBeTHHKH 1I0 ll XBaThWWIH HX 06BHHeHIDl Ha JIery H IIpe ll ­ - leJIo J HJIb ll OB - aMepHKaHCKHX JIeBLIX - pa3hlTpallOCb B JIaTWIH HaM apeCTOBaTL ll eCRTKH JIIO ll eH 1I0 ll 03peBaeMhlX B COTPY ll ­ TO BpeMSI KOTAll Y Ke BeJIOCL C'JIe ll CTBHe no ll eny JIexOBHIIa HPOIIle­ JIHlIeCTBe CO BTOPblM OT ll eJIOM Kpyr 1I0 ll 03peBaeMhlX Bce 60JIee BHIIa H ll p paCIlIHPMCR TeJIbHOCTH KOTOpaR pacnpoCTpaHHJIaCL Ha Bee CTpaHhl BoCTOtDlOH ApeCT WILAll 1I0nO J HJI HallWIO aTMoc4 epe nO ll 03pH­ EBPOIIhl H BI IJlHJIaCL TaM B BOJIBy MaCCOBLIX apeCTOB ApeCTOBbIBa­ - 104 lIe1l0BeKa - OT Tex KTO ObW B APMUU KpauoBou 00 JIH Beex KTO 3Hall HJIL ll OB HJlH BCTpellallC B C HHMH a TalC KalC WII ll 1 3HallH MHOTHX KOMMYHHCTOB TO IIHC'JIO apeCTOBaHHLIX KOMMYHUCTOB 61 mo OTpoMHhlM 3TO eme 60JILIIle crymWIO aTMoc4 epy CTpaxa Ko MHe H TOTAll 6bm B MocKBe BMeCTe C BepyTOM Ha O ll HOM 3aeeAllHHH BO BpeMJl nepepLIBa KOT ll a Mhl OCTallHCb TOJIbKO 1I01I8A8JIH MaTepHWILI C'JIe ll CTBHR B KOTOpLIX 6LWIlIHe roJoetJHHKH BTpoeM COTpY ll HHKH BTOPOTO OT ll eJIa - Pe ll 06BHWlJIH ll 8 J e BHJlHLIX lypall coTpY ll HHu e Moero eeKpeTaPHaTa HeBeCTKe Teo ll opa lypalla KOMMYHHCTOB MHe IIpe ll CTaBHJlH CIIHCOK C CPaMWIMMH JIIO ll eH H3BeCTHoro ll 0 BOHHLI a D BOKaTa KOTOPI IH 38Il 1 HlIl all KOMMYHHCTOB KOTOPhlX R 3HWI JIIfllHO - HX 06BHHMH B TpoUKH3Me B CCCP 3a TpOU KH3M HaKa3bWWIH 3HaIlHT H Mhl ll OJI J H 1 6hlJlH B036YJJ HTh ll eJIO IIpoBo ll HJIoCL C'JIe ll CTBHe - H CO CTWIHHblM OH HeO J l A8HHO cnPOCWI MeHJI 06 ABHe cpa3Y Ke nOHM B lIeM ll eJIo AHHa 6bma B ApMHH J1IO ll OBOH H KaK yl 8CTHHK BapIIlaBCKOrO BOCCTaHH B nOIIWIa B HeMeu KHii JIa­ lIeCTHO WIH HeT He MOry CKa­ TepL IIoTOM OHa e3 ll HJIa JIeIlHTLC B B lII seHu apHIO BMeCTe C ll pyTHMH 38Tb Bo MHOTHX cnytraJlX HaM Y ll WIOCL 38MRTL ll eJIO HaCTOJILKO a6­ 1I0JIbCKHMH KOMMYHHCTaMH TaM HX OlIeKall H03JIL J HJIb ll Ha ne­ 1946-47 rr b ll npHexan B BapIIlaBY H IIDITWICR IIpH cyP ll HLIMH 6hlJlH 06BHHeHM ECTeCTBeHHO npH nO ll ll ep J Ke BepyTa peJIOMe Ho He TalC MHOTO R MOT C ll eJIaTL He XBaTWIO MaTepHallOB lITO­ nocpe lJ HHlleCTBe ABml BCTpeTHTbCSI co MHOii WIL ll CKa3aJI eil liTO 6hl ll OKa3aTL HeCOCTOmeJIbHOCTb 06BHHeHHii IIO ll 03peHlfR 6LIIIH XOlleT 06paTHTbCR KO MHe 3a 1I0MOmbIO 'IIT06bI BbISICHHTh HeKOTO­ KacaIOJUHeCR ero cpalCThl OH no p J HBall CB B 3L C KOMHH­ CIIHIIlKOM TYMaHHhIMH H 38IIyTaHHhIMH HO HX TPY ll HO 6bIlIO OIIPO­ pble BepTHyTb TOJIbKO BpeMJl MOTJIO cnaCTH JIIO ll eH H Mhl nhlTaJIHCb TepHOM ll 0 BOCnOJII 30BaTbCR 3THM OTTRTHBaR IIpou eCChl ClleJI u eJIeCo06pa3HbIM BCTpellaTbCR C HHM HO COTJIaCWIC B npHHRTh 1937-1938 rr H ceil llac XOTeJI ee BOCCTaHOBHTh H He eTO IIHCbMO C pa3'bSICHeHHeM npocL6hl ReXOBUII U RPOUleBUII nOIlYIIWZU npUZOBOP nOClle Ce Mwzer­ 3TO IIHCLMO R nOKa3WI BepYTY HO 1I0nbITKH HJIb D a BbISICHHTh HelO CIleOCTBUR B xooe KOTOPOZO ux nbU'fJIlU llPUZOBOP ObW Bbl­ cHryaD HIO OKa3allHCb TmeTHI IMH Mo B POJIL OrpaHHlIHJIaCb 3THM Ho - Z T e lIepe3 OBa zooa nOClle cMepru CTfJIlUHa C MOMeHTa apeCTa HJIb ll a KOTAll eTO 06BHHWIH B H3MeHe IIlIIHOHa­ A eU e lIepe3 zoo OHU OblllU oCBo60 JKoeHbl U nOIlHOCTbIO peaowzuru­ Ke TpoD KH3Me KOCMOnOJIHTH3Me H lIepT 3HaeT B lIeM eID e H KOrAll HeceH B wOlle poBaHbl 1955 ero ll eJIO nPHBR3WIH K ll eJIY JIaC'JIO PaRKa H All Ke 1I0ca D HJIH ero Ha ry Ke CKaMbIO nO ll CY ll HMhlX Bee CTallO BhlTJIH ll eTL ollem cepbe3­ 186 187 HO H paCCKa3Wl CTamlHY npo AHHy JYpall HO MOH OOb llCHemUI He nepey6e lJ lll1H ero 3TO 6bIJlO KaK nOTOM OKa3WlOCb MoeR nOClle lJ ­ neR 6ece lJ OR co CTWlHHbIM a AHHy BCKOpe apeerOBWlH - B TO BpeMH y HHX B ra3erax erWlH YKa3b1BaTb B CKO Kax HaCTOHILtHe paMHJIHH - - H na 6ac npa6iJa Ha KOCMonOJIHTa DOPb6y C KOCMOnOJIHTH3MOM CTWlHH Ha­ l Wl B 1948 r gro 'ITO - ITo JIHlIHOMY' YKa3aHHIO CTWlHHa H II HWlero He Mor C IJ eJIaTb ITPOCTO Kor lJ a 1U THPOBaJIH KaKorO-TO eBpeHCKoro lJ e llTe­ Y lJ aP 6bDI HanpaBJIeH npoTHB MeHH H TaK 3TO 6bDIO BocnpHHHTO JI II C PYCCKOH PaMHJIHeH B CKo6Kax nellaTWlH HaCTO llI UY O 3TO BceMH H 6bIJl CHrHaJI lITO ero BbI6paCblBaIOT Ha CBWlKy H lITO OTKpbIBaeTCB BaKaHTHOe Meero - llO'leMY npoTU6 6ac - 3Ha'lur aHTUceMUTU3M - CTWlHH BH lJ HO pelllHJI 'ITO II ero n01J BeJI na HO CTWlHH Ha3bIBWl 3TO 6op 60H C KOCMOnOJ1HTH3MOM - Bbl - Cr JllUH f iblll aHTUCe MUrOM - 06'h llCHHTb 3TO He npoero HO TOJIbKO TaK MO KHO nOHHT nOlieMY' ero OTHoweHHe KO MHe H3MemmOCb D o CTanHHa HaBepHoe - DbIlIO 6bl ynpo eHHeM Ha3BaTb ero aHTHeeMHTOM HO B Y 'e paHbWe lJ OWJIH Cllyxa 0 MoeR 6ece lJ e co K iJ aHOBbIM B IlIKJI IIpc­ KaKOR-TO ereneHH aHmceMHT lJ peMan KOR TopeH6e nepe lJ C03 1J aHHeM KOMHH popMa OceHbIO 1947 r H 0 DpOJlBJIJlJIOCb Ho B 30-e rO lJ b1 B CCCP lIaero BCIIOMHHanH ero MoeM npeAJlO KeHHH 3aMeHHTb CllOBO KOnneKTHBHlaI1 IDl CllOBOM BbICKa3bIBaHHH apTeJIH3aI1 IDI Bo3MO KH0 eMY' erano H3BeCTHO 0 qeM-TO e e EBpeRCKoro TeJIerpa pHOro areHTCTBa 3Ta 6eee 1J 8 COerOJIJIaCb 18 He 3HaIO CTWlHHy no MOrJIO He nOHpaBHTbCH H OH Bepo llTHO JlHBap ll 1931 r Tor lJ a CTWlHH CKa3an pellDfJI lITO II ero B qeM-TO n01J BeJI A B 6ece lJ e B HeM ITy6nHl HO no He C aMepHKaHCKHM KoppecnoH lJ eHToM TOTO KTO n01J BeJI M0 K80 nO lJ 03peBaTb BO BceX rpexax IJ a KC B TOM lITO OH aMepHKaHOKHii HaijUOH JllbHbIU U paC06blU 1U06UHU3M ecTb nepe JICUTOK llIDHOH Tor lJ a Y K lJ OCTaTOllHO MeJIOTJH HanpHMep paKTa lITO MOB 'IeIl06eKOHeHa6UCTHU'IeCKUX Hpa606 c60ucrneHHblX nepuo­ ceKpeTapwa 6bDIa 3HaKOMa C llHnb lJ OM ECllH 3TO 3HaKOMCTBO npenO IJ HeCTH e e B COOTBeTerBYIO eM BH IJ e TO Bee craHeT COBep­ weHHO Ha MeCTO oY KaHllU j lIlU3M a AHTUceMuTU3M KaK KpaUHJVI ffjoPMa paC060Z0 IU06UHU3Ma 116MeTCJI Hau60 n ee OnaCHblM nepe­ JlCUTKOM KaHHu j lIlu3Ma AHTUCe MUTU3M 6blzooeH 3KcMya­ TaTopaM KaK ZPOMOOT600 6bI6oDJlU4UU KrITlUf JIlU3M - Cr JllUH CaM 3TO npuoYM JIl us-noD yOapa - npa6U lbOOZO nyTU U npUBOOJlUl 1 R UX B OJICYHZJ1 U l103TOMY rpYOJlU4UXCJI He 3HaIO MO KeT 6blTb npHCIIy KHHKH nO lJ cyHyJIH H IJ eIO MO­ rpyOJlU4UXCJI AHTUCe MUTU3M onaceH OM KaK n OJlC1Ul'1l rponuHKa Cf iUBa1OUI 1 R UX C KeT 6bITb DepH II Y CTWlHHa Bee 6bIJlO BJaHMOCB II3aHO a II 6bIJl KOMMYHUCTbI KaK noc n eoo6aTeIlbHble UHTepHaijUOH JIlUC­ BeJIHKOJIeIlHbIM KaH IJ H IJ 8 TOM Ha KOCMonOJIHTa Tbl He MOZYT He f iblTb HenpUMupUMblMU U 3aKMTbIMU 6pa­ ZaMU aHTUCeMUTU3Ma -HaKOZO B CCCP CTpoJICaulUe npec neoyercJI 3aKOHOM aHTUCe MU­ TU3M 188 KaK JlB n eHue n yf ioKO 6paJiCOef inoe cOBercKoMY 189 CrpolO AKTUeHble CCCP cMepmou 11 aHTUceMUTbI KapalOTCR no 3aKOHaM Ka3HblO ' He enyqaiiHo npo7J HmpoBaJI nOIIHOCTblO H rOllRo 3TH enOBa CTaJIHHa MO lKHO nH BepHrb CKa3aHHoMY HM KorAa AeHcrBHTenb­ HOCTb JIBHO noMY npoTHBope'IHT BpoAe Gbl Henb3S 07J HaKO C8MOCTORTeIIbHOH peCny6rrHKH IJ llS ycneumoro pa3BHTWI nora MeHbllIHHcrBa TaKas reJmeHlUUI cyIUecmOBaJIa AO MaCCOBhlX lIRC­ TOK lKeprBaMH KOTOPbIX CTaJIH H MHorne KOMMyHHCTbl-eBpeH MHorHe norn6rrH 3arnoxna H AeneIIbHocTb BHpoGHlJ I llHa OKPyr npoAOII lKaJI cyIUecrBOBaTb HO nepeCTaJI 6bITb aKTHBHbIM llpaBAa TaM H3 n aBaJIH KaKHe-TO ra3eTKH raM GbIIIH IIIKOIIbl H HeCKOIIbKO - Jl Hcue Uifja nbUl Ue KYIIbryPHbIX ll eHrpoB HO Bee YBIDIO AerpaJJ HpoBaJIO B KaKOH-TO MOMeHT BO BpeMB BropoH MHPOBOH BOHHbI nOKaJaJIOCb qrO BHPO­ GHlJ jf aH O lKHBaer O lKHBWIaCb raK lKe eBpeHcKas lKH3Hb eBpeHCKas - netmTb CraJIH laMemee eBpeH pa60TaIOlIUle B PYCCKOS3bllffiOH ne­ tmm BbIII OCHOBaH EBpeHCKHH aHTH j aumCTCKHH KOMHTeT H no CTaJIHH KaK H ApyrHe OlleHb nporHBopellHB HeT lTO y lK enHIUKOM ynpomeHHo Uenb HCTopHKa - BbIJIBHTb H npoaHaJIHlHpoBaTb KOpHH JIBneHHS llolleMY B HeKoro­ HMeJIO pbIX enyllasx OH npoJIBnIDI nonHOe 6e3pa3IIHlIRe a B ApyrHX ­ Bee no nOHHMaJI• 1leIIeraJJ HJI EBpeHCKoro KOMHreTa B KoropyIO BXOll HIIa rpynna nHC8TeneH noGbIBaJIa B AMepHKe rAe cblrpana CBepxnoA03pHrenbHOCTb H He3AopOBYIO G7J HTenbHoCTb Bee no CBH­ AeTeIIbcmyer 0 BHYrpeHHHX npoTHBope1lHJIX - Ha rpaHH aHOMaJIHH HO He 0 n lKH nOll JJ alOmeHCS 07J H03HallHOH HHTepnpeT llJ HH TOIIbKO npoTHBopellHBOCTblO nHlIHOCTH CranHHa MO lKHO OG'hSCHHTb qrO orpoMHoe nponaraH7J HCTCKoe BIIHSHHe CranHH xopoWO BHll HYIO ponb B MOGHIIH3aUHH nOMomH rOIIOll aBmeMY BO BpeMB BOHHbI HaceneHHlO CCCP - j JI R 3TOcO OHU U 6blJlU nOCJltlHbl 6eeell Ys co MHOH HIIH C MHH7J eM OH BAPyr HallHHaJI npoHlHOCHTb enOBa H j pa3bI napo7J Hpys eBpeHCKoe npoHlHoweHHe A HHorAa - II 3ro CIIHWKOM ynpomeHHO CTaJIHH 6bIn 3aHHrepecoBaH KorAa eMY qro-ro GbIIIO HY lKH0 OT HaC OH CTaHOBHIICS otmpoBaTenb­ HbIM TonbKo npoTHBopellHBOCTbIO nHlIHOCTH CraJIHHa MO lKHO He CTonbKO B AeHbrax HeCKOIIbKO MHnIIHOHOB AonnapoB npo6rre­ o G'hSCHHTb qrO C 07J HOH CTOPOHbI OH YCTpawm napmHHbIX H rocy­ Mbl He peWanH CKonbKO B o6ecnelleHHH MOPaJIbHOH nOMep lKKH AaPCmeHHblx pa60THHKoB - eBpeeB a C APyroH - JJ aJI cornaCHe Ha C03JJ aHHe B 30-e rOlJ bI aBTOHOMHOro eBpeHCKoro oKpyra B BHpoGHA­ llHe KOTOPbIH BnoeneACTBHH Aon lKeH GbIII craTb lIeM-ro BpoAe COBeTcKoro COIOla B Coe7J HHeHHbIX ffiraTax lloClle no6elJ b1 06cra­ HOBKa CTaJIa MeHRTbCS Co BTOPOH nonOBHHbI 4O-x rOAOB nOA03pH­ q yHJJ aMeHTa GYJJ YI U eH COBerCKOH eBpeHCKOH PecnyfirrHKH K no­ MY CTpeMHIIHCb corpYlJ liHKH eBpeHCKOH eeK7J HH BKll G OHH 6bl­ IIH CBS3aHbI C eBpeHCKHM HaJJ HOHaJIbHbIM ll BH lKeHHeM OneKaJIH eB­ peHCKHe IIIKOIIbl H reaTp B MOCKBe Ha H7J HIU - OJJ HH H3 IIyllWHX B CTpaHe XYAO lKHHKOB nnC8TeneH H3JJ arenbCTBa pacnpOCTpaHSBume KHHrn Ha H7J HIU BO BceM MHpe - 3TH KHHrn nOIIb30BaJIHCb orpoM­ HblM ycneXOM OHH 3TH nI07J H crapaIIHCb COXpaHHTb eBpeHCKHe TpaJJ H7J HH B HX CBeTCKOM a He penHrn03HOM BHAe II BHallaJIe Cra­ renbHOCTb CTaJIHHa noCTO IIHHO poena OH nOBcIOll Y BHAeJI BparoB H peillWI t fO eBpeHCKoe MeHbillHHCTBO - nylIWHii onopHbIH nYHKT aMepHKaHCKOH arpeccHH H D es noceneHHS eBpeeB B KPbIMY OCTaB­ neHHOM KPblMCKHMH TaTapaMH' 3TY HAeIO Bbl7J BHHYnH HeKoTopble BHlJ HbIe eBpeHcKHe AeneIIH Ka3aIIaCb CraIIHHY BeCbMa nOA03pH­ renbHoH KPblM C'lHTaJI CraJIHH OlleHb YAo6Hoe MeCTO IJ ll R B03MO lK­ HOH BblC3 7J KH aMepHKaHCKOrO AeCaHra a eBpeH - C yqeToM HX ce­ MeHHbIX Me lK7J YHapo7J HbIX CBS3eR - C8MbIH noll XOll JII1UIR meMeHT ECTecmeHHoH 6bIIIa H 3BOIIIOll HJI n03H7J HH COBercKoro COI03a no IIHH 3TH crpeMIIeHHS nOMep lKHBaJI 3a60ra 0 eBpeHCKOH 061IU1He OTHomeHHIO K 113paHIIIO KOMMYHHCTHlIeCKoe ll BH lKeHHe KaK H3­ AOII lKHa GblIIa npoAeMoHcrpHpoBaTb qrO B C07J HaJIHCTHlIeCKoM rocy­ BeCTHo BeerAa BbICrynaJIO npoTHB CHOHH3Ma H ocyjf ll aJlo CHOHHC­ AapCTBe neKytCS 0 MeHbillHHcmax H Aa lKe 7J YMaIOT 06 OCHOBaHHH TOB H60 Te HcnonblYs CHOHHCTCKHe HIIIII03HH CTapanHcb npHBnelJlo Ha CBOIO cropoHY eBpeHcKHe MaCCbI llonbcKHe KOMMYHHCTbl rO lKe lit 13 CTp 28 30 HOa iPR 1936 r H B CraIIHH COIIHHeHHR T HO B ra3eTe npaBAa BnepBLIe orry iIIHKoBa­ 6opoIIHcb C cHOHHCTaMH HHOrAa Aa lKe ApanHCb C HHMH B BblCIIIHX ' ICpLIMCI He TarapLI 3CMIIH B Mae 190 1944 r - iLIIIH HaCHIIbCTBeHHO BLIceIIeHLI CO cBoe il Pe u 191 yqe6HhIX 3aBe lJ eHHHX 00060 l eCTOKHe CThNlCH npoH30UDlH BO - 3aID HTHn B TOM CMbIC le BpeWI BOCCTaHHH apa60B B llaneCTHHe lloC le BOnHhI H no'lTH no­ ronoBHoro ymt'lTO l eHHH nOnhCKHX eBpeeB Ha TeppHTOpHH llonhIllH 'ITO ee cocn8JIH B narepb a Be J h MornH H paCCTpemrn npaB J a Ero BepoHTHO JaCTaBHnH pa3Bec­ ymt'ITO I MH H eBponenCKHX eBpeeB CHOHHCTCKHe opraHH3au HH THCb CHen TaK KaK OH pa3BeJICH a nocne CMepTH CTamma Kor J a 'lT06hI o6ecne'IHTh CY J h6y eneBIIIHX nOC le BOWhI eBpeeB nhITa· OHa BepnynaCh B MOCKBY OHH lJ 0 ee KOH'lHHhI nHCh C03AaTh ueHTP r lJ e eBpeH MornH 6hI l HTh HOPManbHO OHH CTpeMHnHCh C03AaTh He3aBHCHMOe eBpenCKoe rOCYAapCTBo CTa­ nun 0 lJ 06pHn ny MeIO oco6eHHo nOTOMY 'ITO llaneCTHHa HaxO J H­ naCh no lJ oKKynaUHen BenHK06pHTaHHH H C03 lJ aHHe eBpenCKoro rOCYAapCTBa YAapHnO no AHTnHH Sf He crauy lJ eTanhHo aHanH3H­ POBaTh MOTHBhI 06ycnoBHBwHe ero peweHHe Bo BC1 I 0M cnyqae I HnH BMeCTe OTHOCHTenhHO MHfKO pacnPaBHnHCb C MHxo mCOM - BbI J aIO­ mHMCH al TepoM AHpeKTOpoM eBpeHCKoro TeaTpa nI06HMD eM nyOOHICH OH norn6 B HHCUeHHPOB8HHOH KaraCTpo$e H 6hm noxopo­ HeH C nO'leCTHMH Ho MHX03nc peWHnH npoIlle l1x HCKJIIO'leHHe C lJ pyruMH Bonpoc paCCTpeJIHBanH no npuroBOpy BoeHHoro CY J a Tal norn6 D BeT JIHTeparypbl H eBpeHCKoH Kyn hrypbI Ha H J HII l COBeTcKHH COI03 6hIn cpe J H CTPaH BhICTynHBWHX 3a C03 lJ aHHe H3paHnH - H3paHnh 6b1n C03 lJ aH AHTmlll 6hIna BhITeCUeHa H3 lla­ neCTHHhI Ho H OTHoweHHe COBeTcKoro COI03a K H3paunro 6hICTPO H3MeHHnOCh OC06eHHO Kor J a HOBoe rocY J apcTBO BhUIBHnO cBon aHTHapa6cKHH xapaKTep aHHeKCHpOBaB HOBbie TeppHTOpHH Koe­ KTO B COBeTcKoM COI03e CTan onaCaThCH 'ITO B CBH3H C CYIlleCTBO­ J aBauTe Hf130BeM ¢aMU lUU XOTb HeC1 O lb1 UX nozuoUlUX cpeOu 1 OTOpblX ObIAO 89 XY0OJl HU1 06 238 nucaTelleii 104 a1 Tepa 19 MY3bl1 aHT06 U C1 yllbnTopoB - paCC7pe tmHHbIX U lU YHUIlTOJlCeH­ HIlJX B llazepJIX 4 e¢ep Eepze tlbCOH Map1 uw B 3ICU6bJX OCTallCR HllbR 3peHoyPz BaHHeM H3paHnH 6Y lJ eT nO J HHT Bonpoc 0 ABOnHOn nOHnhHOCTH - TeM 6onee 'ITO nepBhIM nocnOM H3paunH B CCCP CTana fonl1a MeHp nonh30BaBWaHCH 60nhWHM BnHHHHeM H aBTOpHTeTOM cpe­ J H COBeTCKHX eBpeeB OrnoweHHH C H3pauneM oxna n enH H CTa­ nHH BhIABHnyn n03YHT 6oPb6hI C KOCMOnOnHTH3MOM AnSI OTcrpa­ HeHHH eBpeeB OT JaHHMaeMhIX HMH lJ oJDKHocTeii llO lJ 03peuHH YCHnHBanuCb apeCThI CTaHOBHnHCh Bee 60nee MaCooBhIMH 'BenH­ 3peH6ypr HHl or J a He BXO J Hn B 3TOT KPyr OH He ytlaCTBo­ Ban B o6cyx ' neHUH BonpoOOB CBH38HHh1X C eBpenCKOH pecnyOOH­ Kon OH 6hm PYCCKOH3hI'lHhIH nucaTenh ero CTaThH BoeHHOro BpeMeHH 3aBoeB8JIH eM ' orpoMHyIO nonyJIHpHOCTh B CCCP CTa­ JIHH 6hID K HeM ' pacnonO l eH To nH nOTOM ' 'ITO 3peH6ypr Bep­ uynCH H3 3MHrpauHH TO nH 6ecnpH'lHHHo CTamm HHOr J a nI06lU1 'lHBanOCh 'lHcno CY lJ e6HhIX npoueCCOB O J Hon H3 l epTB 6hIDa eHa nOMoran HnH OKalhman pacnOJIO i eHHe KOMy-nH60 H3 H3BeCT­ MonOTOBa - HhIX nucaTeneH H HHTennureHTOB OH Mor n03BOHHTb H CKalaTh cneu ua nHCT no nap$IOMepHon npoMhIUDleHHOCTH K TOM ' l e 3acn ' l eHHhIii cneu uanuCT 0 J HaK0 nOCKonhKY B CBoe Bpe­ Tennoe C lOBO HnH C lJ enaTb 'ITO-TO xopowee Tal 6hmo C Byn ral o­ WI OHa HHTepeOOBanaCh B03MO I HOCTbIO nepeeeneHHH eBpeeB B BhIM KOToporo nocne lJ onrux neT 6e3pa60THD hI Cramm YCTpoHn KphIM H B03MO I H0 0 lJ 06pHTenbHO OT03BanaCh 06 3TOH H lJ ee 3TO HnH C llaCTepHaKOM KOTOPOM ' OH n03BOHlUl 'lT06bI nO J HHTh HaCT­ CO'll1H lJ OCTaTO'IHhIM nOBO lJ OM - BhI nOHHMaeTe - 'lT06hI pacnpa­ BHThCH CHen H oocnaTh B nareph poeHHe Kor J a eM ' 6hIDO O'leHh TPY J HO H3 J aBaTh CBOH npoH3Be lJ e­ HHH KHHr llaCTepHaI a npaB J a H nocne 3Toro He H3 J anH HO 3TH nOCTYIIKH CTanuna 06paCTanu nereH J aMH - - J He nOHUMa1O a liTO MOIlOTOB - D n H Hero 3TH penpecCHH OKOH'IHJIHCh OOaronony'lHo OH y lJ ep I 8JICH Ha CBoeM noery 0 HHX paccKa3hm8JIH H 3TH paCCKalhI pacnonaranH K HeM ' 06IIleCTBeHHOCTh 3TO CT8JIHH 'Men lJ enaTh C D BeTOM eBpeHCKon nHTeparyphI OH pacnpaBHnCH CTOKO He C'lHTaHCh C 06IIleCTBeHHhIM MHeHHeM 3afpaHHUeH A Be lJ b nepe lJ JarpaHHuen XBaCT8JIH 'ITO BOT Mon B CCCP CYIIleCTByeT npoD Be­ - OH He 3aU4UU4f11l ee TaIOmHH ueHTP eBpenCKOH KynhryphI r lJ e H3 J aeTCH JIHTeparypa HMeeTCH BenHKOnenHhIH TeaTp H T lJ IiHKTO Be J h He Mor taM nOBepHTh 'ITO nucaTenh KHHIlI KOToporo OH 'lHTan IIJIlHOH 192 193 - A - He BepIO J HKHH 6peA 6bl n06epUi1u _ HeT KOHe'IIHo HeT H 3HaJ1 'ITO Bee - A 3TO BpaHl e M021l0 CIlYl4UTbCJI l4TO 6bl 06 3TO M npOCTO He SHfLIlU - D a MOfllO -Hl4TOJfCe BeAb MeHH YJKe nOA03peBaJIH MOH ceKpeTapwa 6bDIa 3HaKOMa C cDHJIbAOM caM H eBpeii H K TOMY JKe BCTpe'IaJICH _ qro If 'ITO JKe BeAT Bce 3TO npoHcxoAHJIO B 06CTaHOBKe C AelleraIUleii EBpeiicKoro aHTH pamHCTCKOro KOMHTera nepeA ee H HHKOrAa He 3Hty3Ha3Ma BbI3BaHHoro OKOH IIllHHeM BOHllbI H cnaceHHeM eBpeeB one3AOM B AMepHKY or nOJIHoro yHH'lTOJKeHWl Hanm npoTeCTbI npoIllJIH 6bI He3aMetreH­ no HHKaKOrO 3HatreHHH nOTOMY 'ITO Beex HX 06BHHHllH TeM caMhlM CKPbIBaJI 3Toro HO 3ro He HMe­ H H npeBpaTHJICH B HAeaJIbHOrO KaHAHAaTa Ha ponb nonbCKoro HbIMH CnaHCKoro Bee IllJIO K 3roMY H HeH3BeCTHO qeM 6bI 3aKOH'lHJlOCb - A 6bl XOTJl 6bl nbl'mllUCb npoTecT06aTb eCJlH 6bI He CMeprb CraJIHHa llpeATIOrOM ATIJI 06BHHeHHH 6bDIO 6bI Aeno cDKJIb OB Bepyr npoJIBHJI xapaKrep CTOHKOCTb H nOJlllbHOCTb _ HeT HHKaKHX pa3roBopoB 0 60Pb6e C KOCMOnOJIHTH3MOM He 6bDIO • D a H OHH He HIDKHMaJIH Ha Hac He rpe60BaJIH npoBeCTH raKyro JKe KaMUaHHlO B llOlThme EcrrH 6bDI KaKoii-ro HllJKHM TO no OTHOWeHHIO KO MHe OH ycroJlll nepe HaJKHMOM H 3aIl1HII aJI MeHH 0 KOHU a HeCMOrpJl Ha Bce nOnbITKH CraJIHHa cnOMHTb ero BeCbMa CKPbITbtii - KaKU M CnoC060M _ A KTO npeO la2a l cosOaTb la2epH OM KOCMonOllUT06 HIl - Masypax llpHBeAY TonbKO OAHH npHMep CraJIHH KaK-TO cnPOCHJI Bepyra Kro BaM opoJKe - BepMaH HJlH _ 1l0 MeHH AOHeCJlHCb crryxn 0 TaKHX npeAJIOJKeHWlX HO MHHIJ Bepyr nOHHMaJI B qeM eno H 'ITO OT ero OTBeTa 3aBHCHT cYAb6a O l Horo H3 Hac n03JKe B03MOJKHO 3Tor crryx paCnyCKaJIH KaK cnneTHlO a He KaK OH OTBeTHJI raK KaK OTBe'lalOT etH Ha Bonpoc Koro OHH 60nbwe J HpeKTHBY He HCKlllOtreHO 'ITO 6bD1o KaKOe-rO ceKperHoe peweHHe nlO6J1r - nany HJlH MaMY•• OHH MHe OAHHaKOBO oporu - CKa3aJI BepyT BbDIH H Apyrue pOPMbI HllJKHMa 60nee npJlMbIe _ JIa2epH OOIlJICHbl 6bl1lu crpOUTb COIlOaTbl -KaKue - MOJKeT 6bIrb cnyxn nOIllJIH OT HHTeHAaHTCTBa -He CKaJKy - To eCTb OT POKOCC06CK020 - E20 nV2fL1lU l4TO l4TO-TO CIlVl4UTCIl C Ce Mbeu _ COMHHrellbHo llpaBAa OrpH AT I CHa6JKeHWl 6bD1H nOA1DUIe­ HbI nOllbcKoMY KOMaHAQBaHHIO TO eCTb POKOCCOBCKOMY HO pewe­ HWl He 06H3aTellbHO npoXOAHJIH Qepe3 ero PYKH Bee 3TO Aor8 l KH 1loKa3arellbCTB Y MeHH HeT HHKaKHX lIHBaTl Her TaKHM xaMOM CraJIHH He 6bDI He crreAYer npeyBellH­ OH n03BOllJlll ce6e 6bITb rpy6blM O l HaKO B Tex cny'IaJIX KOr a 3HaJ1 'ITO C HHM rOTOBbI coTpYAHH'larb a Bepyr COTPYAHH'IaJI ero nOBe l eHHe He BbIXOAHJIO 3a paMKH AonYCTHMOro _ A 0 CrpOUTeJZbcT6e cne14UfLIlbHOU TlOpb Mbl OM KOC MOnOIlU­ T06 6bl CIlbIXa lU 194 - A BepYT 6oRllcJI 195 - - BblBaJIO Ho rOBopHn 06 3TOM H He 6yAY llOTOMY lITO 3TO IIpas o a MOIO o Ollb HeO JJ HOKpaTHO o PalHH­ JJH B WKOJIe HalbmaH ToprOBKon Cene r J KOR - E20 yOfJ lOCb CIlOMUTb He BO BeeM B MoeM CJIyqae - - H ebl He nOHUMaeTe nOIle MY HeT XOTH Bee ClIHTaJIH Bepyra - CYMaCWeAIIIHM H3-3a Toro lITO OH TaK ynOpHO 3aIl Hlll aeT MeHH OT 06BHHeHHii B KOCMOnOJIHTH3Me 3a KOTOphlMH o OJDKHbI IIOCJIe o OBaTh HeT He IIOHHMaIO H KaK H Bepyr 6hIJI IIpoTHB Toro lITO­ 6b1 CJlHIIIKOM MHoro eBpeeB pa60TaJIO B QeHTparrhHhIX OpraHH3a­ H YSOJIhHeHHe H cy o e6HhIH npOI ecc llrrH Bepyra 3TO He 6hIJIO nerKHM QHHX peweHHeM HO OH npHHHn ero H npoTHBOCTOHJJ mo60MY AllBneHHIO pe3ynhTaToM o 6CTOHTenhcm Kor o a nOnhCK3JI HHTeJJJlHreHQHjJ or­ ClIHTaJI 3TO HeIIpaBHJJbHbIM XOTH H IIOHHMaJI lITO 3TO 6hIJIO Ka3aJIaCh C HaMH COTPY n HH1Jan H ofibJIBHJJa 6oAKoT Ho ysepRIO Bac - 3Ha11UT e IIollbwe KaMTzaHWl 60Pb6bl CKOCMonOIlU7U3MOM He npoeOOUllaCb lITO B Ka o POBbIX Bonpocax H PYKOBO o cmOBaJICH TOJIhKO KpHTepHH­ MH IIOJIh3hl a He nll'lHhIMH OTHOWeHHHMH RllH JIHlIHOR CHMIIaTHeR Kor o a H CHHMaJI Koro-HH6ylJ b C o on KHOCTH TO TO Ke crapWICH c o e· - llpoBO r J HJJaCh KOHeIJHO BelJ b MIll 06H3aHh1 6hlJlH IIo o pa­ Drb COBeTCKOMY COI03Y BO BeeM rOM Ha ny H nan 3TO TaK lIT06hl He YHH3HTh H He 06H o HTh qeJIOBeKa He pal pa3rOBapHBaJI C Bepy­ TeMY H OH TO Ke 6hIJI nponm 3TOR KaMIIaHHH HO OHa BCe-raKH npoXO r J HJJa npoHHKna B llonhWY He3aBHCHMO or n03HUHH PYKOBo o CTBa 3ra IIpo6neMa B CCCP 6hma nOCTaBneHa CTonh OCT­ - A apeCTbI Ha nepellOMe 1948-1949 22 6bl lU apecTOeaHbI 'lIleHbl c030aHHo2o npu APMUU Kpauoeou CoeeTa noeo #u eepeJlM f ErOTA po lITO HeKorophle 3neMeHThl 3TOR KaMIIaHHH IIPOJIBHJlHCh H B pellH fOMYnKH Ha 06'be J HHHrenbHOM C'he3 o e B 1948 r He3a o OJIro o 0 3TO­ ro fOMYJIKY npHmaCHJJ K ce6e CTaJIHH H npoBen C HHM rrpo o OJI KH­ - 3TO IIpaB o a llo o y o aPOM OKalaJIHCh Bce CBH3aHHhle C Ap­ MHen KpanoBon TeJJbHyIO 6eeeAY Co o ep KaHHe 6ece r J bI MHe He H3Becmo HO fOMYJI­ Ka taM CrOJIbKO yCJIblWaJI 0 KOCMOIIOJIHTaX lITO B CBoeH pellH OH CKa3aJI 0 KOCMOnonHTH3Me KaK 0 peaJIhHOH oIIacHocrn H nhITaJI­ CH nOJIeMH3HpoBar C HHM pa3YMeeTCH He Ha3blBaH Be eH CBOHMH HMeHaMH HO He Bcer o a y o aIJHO nOCKonhKY nOnb30BaJICH H CBe o e­ HHHMH 06 ApMHH KpailOBOR KOTophle MHe IIo o cyHynH B 1949 - IIoCllywauTe op2aHbi 6e30nacHocTU e KOTOPblX ece UIlU nOIl7U ece pYKoeOOJl #ue pa60THUKU - eepeu apecToeblealOT no­ IlJlKOe 3a TO liTO eo epeMJI OKKYTzallUU OHU cnaCa lU eepeee a ebz YT6epmaeTe liTO ece nOIlJlKU aHTUCe MUTbII Pa3ee 3TO cnpaeeollueo r fOMYJIKa COWeJJ co CQeHbI HO 60ph6a C KOCMOnOJIHTH3MOM CTaJIa lJaCTbIO HaweR nponaraH r J bI O r J HaKO MbI nhITaJIHCh CBecrn ee 0 0 MH­ - 3TO 6b1JJO HeBepHO cornaceH B TO BpeMH H He 3HaJI l eM 3aHHMaJICH COBeT IIOMO H eBpeHM TOJIbKO nOTOM Mon 6paT pac­ HHMYMa TaK lITO TaKHX MacIIITa60B KaK B CCCP OHa He IIpH06pena CKalaJI MHe lITO 3T0 6hma He6onhWaH HO Ol eHh aKTHBHaH rpynrra nelJaTH 3Toro nOllTH Bo06 e He 6bIJIO HO 3aTO 3Ty JIH­ nIO o eR KOTOphle PHCKYH co6cmeHHoR KH3HhIO OIIeKaJIH eBpeeB B napTHHHOR HHIO npoBO r J HJlH ra3eThl H3 o aBaeMhle llAKCOM B HHX nHQa eBpeHC­ Koro npoHcxO K r J eHHH KPHTHKOBaJIHCh He 3a HX o eHTenbHOCTb a 3a TO lITO 6blJlH eBpeHMH llpas o a TaM HHKor o a He IIeqaTaJIH B CK06­ BO BpeMH BOHHhI H caM n03HaKOMHJJCH C Ke HOR KOTOpaH cnaCJIa H3 reTTO HeCKonhKO o eCHTKOB eBpeRCKHX o eTen OpeHa CaB8QKaH cDnewapoBa BHTBHQKHH CraBHQKHH CYIIpyrH Kynh Kax HaCTOmQHX eBpenCKHX cpaMHJJHR HO Ha3hmarrH HX YCTHO 3ep­ Bna o HCJIaB BaproweBcKHH B o eHTenhHOCTH noro COBeTa npHHHMaJI HO na o aJIO Ha 6naro o aTHYIO nOllBY nOCKOJIhKY 6oJIhW3JI lJaCTh no­ aKTHBHOe YlJaCTHe H MOR 6paT A o onhcp IIOCJIe TOro KaK 6naro o apH JIHKOB - aHTHceMHTbI nOMO H l JleHOB COBera eMY y o aJIOCb 6e Kar H3 reno llOTOM Mhl HX Bcex OCB060 o HJIH - H 3TO 20eopUTe ebl Rbi 196 197 - aOUC lae BapTOWeeCKUU CUOe l 7 leT - KOHe'IHo no 6blla rpyrrna qpe3BbIl aftHO 6naropOAHblX mo- AeR - He 3HaIO CKOJIbKO Ho HeT cOMHemdi tJTO OH 6bill penpec­ - Bcezo lUWb CHpoBaH H OTCHAeJI CBoe - flo 0 ezo oceOOOJlCOeHUU X lOnOTM JJeoH XauH a He eaw OpaT - IIoRMHTe HX apeCTOBaJIH Ha HUe CTaJIHHa KO MHe A u OJIb p paCCKa3aJI MHe tJTO npep CTaBJIHJI cooon COBeT nOMOWU eBpeHM JIHWb MHoro JIeT cnYCTH 1950 nepeJIOMe 1949-1950 rr H ' ICe p o HeKoTopon CTeneHH OC03HaBaJI CBoe nOJIO lKeHHe H OTHowe­ B H nOHUMaJI tJTO eCJIH II 6yp y BMeWHBaTbCH B 3TH AeJIa H BonpeKH YKa3aHHHM COBeTCKHX COBeTHHKOB CTapaTb­ TO BpeMH T e B CH tJTo-TO H3MeHHTb CTaJIHR ' p oHecyr KaK Bep eT ce6H EepMaH r OH 3MHrpHpoBaJI B H3paK1Ib OH 6bll p eHTeJIeM UeHTpaJIb­ HY lQlo 6billO JIHOO yHTH JIHOO npop OJI lKaTb MaHeBpHpoBaTb H ABa Horo eBpeRcKoro KOMHTeTa K TOMY BpeMeHH AeHTeJIbHOCTb UEK pa3a nO 1l 8BaJI Eepyry nOABepmaCb Y lKe cepbe3HblM orpaHHqeHHHM H OH nOHHJI tJTO npoHe­ o6nacTH KOHTPOJIH Hap opraHaMH XO J fT tJTO B03MO IQIOCTH tJTO-JlHOO CAeJIaTb orpaHHlIHBaIOTCJI Bee lIHcnOM p pyrnx Bep OMCTB H pa60Tbl y MeHH 6bllO 60JIee qeM p oe­ 60JIbwe H 60JIbWe H OH peWHJI yexaTb H3 IIOJIbWH 3amm eHHe 06 OTCTaBKe He nOJIHOn HO B H H TaK PYKOBOJJ HJI orpoMHbIM TaTO'IHO Ho Eepyr He COmaCHJICH MOH OTHoweHHH C HHM 6billH TaKOBbl tJTO II He Mor CKa3aTb eMY He xoqy - -A ebl HeT OCTaTbCH H MaHeBpHpoBaTb H orpaHHlIHBaJI H Bee IIpHWJIOCb CBoe yqaCTHe BO MHO­ rux p eJIax CTapaJICH HanpaBJIHTb HX P pyruM II npocHJI EepYTa - H - HeT ECTeCTBeHHO J fT B IbpaK1Ie H 3HaJI II HHTepeCOBaJICH TeM tJTO npoHCXO­ npHHHMaTb peweHHH a CaM 3aHHMaJICH BTopocTeneHHblMH p eJIaMH TaM MHorux H 6paT MeHH yrOBapHBWl CaM llHorp a OTKJIlOtJaJICH OT pa60Tbl OpraHOB rocOO30nacHOCTH Ha Hec­ OH 6bill B nOJIHOM BOCTopre H3PaHJIb 3acny lKHBaeT BHHMaHHH KOJIbKO MeCHIJ eB Ho Torp a EepYT rOBOpHJI Ha Koro lKe MHe pac­ H B3BeCHJI Bee 3a H npoTHB H peWHJI cnyqae no He 6bill 6bI ryPH3M 06bI'lHoe tJYBCTByeT ee6H elUe OOJIee 6ecnOMOlUHbIM tJTO npOCHT cne J fTb Ho II OTKa3aJICH OT noe3JJ KH tJTO HeT CMblcna nyreweCTBHe H B MoeM ClIHTblBaTb eCJIH TbI He XOqeWb nOMOtJb OH rOBOpHJI tJTO 6e3 MeHH cqeJI HeUeJIeco06p83HbIM C03 1l 8BaTb eeOO AOnOJIHH­ 3a AeJIaMH H II B03BpaiUaJICH HCTOPHH paccy J fT 6billa JIH MOH TeJIbuyro onaCHOCTb H3-3a noe3JJ KH B H3paK1Ib HJIH APyryro KanHTa­ TaKTHKa JIOBKOR MO lKeT 6blTb BepHee 6bllO 6b1 TBepP O OTKa3aTbCH 6bI paCueHeHa COBepweH­ OT KypHPOBaHHH OpraHOB KTO 3HaeT Il JIH MeHH 3TO 6bllO 6bI no­ HO 0 J f03Ha'IH0 H KOMMeHTap 6bllH 6b1 BeCbMa HenpHHTHbIMH JIe3Hen HO B03MO IQI0 peweHHH npHHHTble 6e3 Moero ytJaCTHH OH 6bill TaM-TO H TaM-TO BCTpetJaJICJI C TeM-TO H C reM-To M 003 TO­ 6hIJIH 6bI elUe XY lKe JlHCTHtJeCKYIO CTpaHy TaKaII nOe3 1l Ka 6billa ro rOBOPHJIH MHoro A Qepe3 HeKoTopoe BpeMH y lKe He CTaJIO B03MO IQIOCTH noexaTb IIocne 1956 r Y lKe He 6billO Ton CBo60 l bI - COTOMY 'lTO HQ eawe MeCTO npUWe l ObI OPYZOU - xYJlCe eac - BaM He OMU ObI 3azpaHurmblu nacnopT - HJIH APyrOH - H Pa3Be TOJIbKO ecnH 6bl II peWHJI 3MHrpHpoBaTb OCOOOHHO nocne 1968 r Ho noro H He XOTeJI H - PaOKeeU'l KaJlCeTCJI TOJICe nooaeM e OTCTaeKY UYWe l 6hI HHKorAa noro He CAeJIWl - - Bce 'lIleHbl Coeem nOMOUlU eepeJlM Obl lU peaOU lurupoeaHb' nocn e 1956 z 198 x ' ICe MeHH HJIH Bce JIemo 6bl Ha nnellH EepYTa He IlbITaJICH nOJIYllHTb ero HO P YMaIO tJTO He AWlH 6b1 TaKHe cnyqaH 6bmaJIH OH rOBOpHJI tJTO YCTaJI OOJIeH Ho AeJIO 6bllO He B 3TOM OH He XOTeJI npHHHMaTb yqaCTHH B TOM lITO npoHCXOJJ HJIO MhI KOJIe6anHCb OTIIyCTHTb ero HJIH 38 1l eP lKaTb 199 - XOretlU 3tlMeHUTb 20 Mo'lllpo M - Ila HeT tJl'0 Bbl KeM yrO J HO HO He MotmpoM OH BeJI ceOH nO-xaMCKH Ero HeHaBH ll eJIH Bce Motmp Y lKe TorA BbICTaBJIHJI Ha­ Kopec MeoeeOee nOKaJ CBOH aHTHCeMHTH3M OKOHIJ8HHe B cnenylOw eM HOMepe rOPBA'IEB lIepeeoO Exu Eex x epa BHYTPEHHIDI nOJIHTUKA nepBbIH ron nocne npHXOA rOpGatieBa K BJIacm OI ID OTMe­ qeH 6ecnpeneneHTHO Kpy tlHbIMH H3MeHeHIDlMH B nOJIHTOropo H npa­ BHTeJII CTBe H ObIeTPbIM onpeneJIeHHeM 3KOHOMHtleCKHX neJIeH H MeTOnOB 3KOHOMHqeCKOrO pa3BHTHJI Ha 6JnDKaiiwHe IS JIeT 0 J HaK0 BO BceX DpotIHX OTHomeHHJIX H3MeHeHIDl BO BHYTpeHHeH nOJIHTHKe ObJJIH lIHCTO KOCMeTH'lJeCKHMH nOJIHTH'lJeCKHe aKD HH JIY'lJWe npeno J HoCHJIHcl CTIfJII CTan oOJIee COBpeMeHHl JM HO no cymecTBy ManO tirO H3MeHHJIOCI npHllHHa noMY He B KpaTKOCTH nepuOA H He B COCpenOTOtleHHOeTH Ha 3KOHOMHtleCKHX 3anatmx YcnOBIDI J JIJI onpeneJIeHHJI HOBOH BHyTpeHHeH nOJIHTHKH ObJJIH OCo­ 6eHHO 6JIaronpHHTHblMH B 1985 rony Torna palpaoaTI IBaJIHCI HOBbIe nporpaMMhl H yeTaB napTHH nOJIrocpo'IJHl le 3KOHOMHtleC­ KHe nporpaMMbl npenOCTaBJIJIJIH xopomne B03MO lKHOcm H ObIDO npoBeneHO MHoro Me lK J yHapo J HbJX BeTpetl B CBJl3H C KOTOPblMH ny6JIHKOBaJIHCI 3aJIBJIeHHJI KacaromueCJI BHyTpeHHeH nOJIHTHKH npH npe x cMeHax PYKOBOnCTBa HOBbIH BOXQ1P BbIuy lK­ neH OI ID non J aBJIeHHeM OOCTOHTeJIbCTB npennpHHHMaTb neHCTBHJI qpeBaThle cepl e3HI IMH H ll eOJIOrH'IJeCKHMH H Me lKAYHapoAHbIMH OTKJIHKaMH HanpHMep XpymeB CMeCTIfJI BepIDI H 06'bJlBIfJI 0 CTa­ JIHHCKHX npecrynneHHJlX tlrOObI rrpenOTBpaTHTI KalHb Bbl J 8JOlD HXCJI OTPblBKH H3 KHHrH Zhores A Medvedev Gorbachev W W Nor­ ton Company New York-London 1986 CTp 208-242 200