- XOTeJJU 3aMeH UTb - lla HeT ezo Mo'lflpoM tfl'0 Bbl KeM yro J HO HO He MOllaPOM OH BeJl ce6Jl no-xaMCKH Ero HeHaBH ll eJIH Bee MOllap Y Ke TOrWi BbICTaBJlJlJl Ha­ nOKa3 CBOR aHTHeeMllTH3M JKopec Meoeeoee OKOHtlaHHe B CJle lOW eM HOMepe rOP5AlIEB lIepeeoo EJICU BeKKepa BHYTPEHIDUI DOJIHTHKA TIepBbIH rOA nOCJIe npHXOWi fop6aQeBa K BJlaCTH 6bIJl OTMe­ lIeH 6ecnpeueueHTHO KpynHblMH H3MeHeHHJlMH B TIOJlHT6IOPO H npa­ BHTeJlbCme H 6bICTPbIM onpeUeJIeHHeM 3KOHOMHtleCKHX ueneH H MeTOUOB 3KOHOMHtJ eCKoro Pa3BHTHJl Ha 6nH KaHwHe 15 JleT 0 J HaK0 BO Beex npormx OTHOWeHHJlX H3MeHeHHJl BO BuyTpeHHeR nOJIHTHKe 6bIJIH tlHCTO KOCMeTHqeCKHMH TIOJlHTHtJ eCKHe aKUHH nyqwe npeno J HOCHJIHCb CTHlIb CTan 60nee coBpeMeHHhIM HO no cyIUecmy Mano qTQ H3MeHHlIOCb DpHrmHa 3TOMy He B KpaTKOCTH nepHoWi H He B cocpeUOTOqeHHOcrn Ha 3KOHOMHtJeCKHX 3auatJllx YCJIOBHJl AJIJI onpeueneHHJl HOBOH BuyTpeHHeH nOJlHTHKH 6bIJIH Oca­ 6eHHO 6naronpHJlTHbIMH B 1985 roAY Torua pa3pa6aTbmanHCb HOBbie nporpaMMhI H YCTaB napTHH UOJlrocpO IHbIe 3KOHOMHtleC­ KHe npOrpaMMhI npeUOCTaBJlJlJlH xopoIIIHe B03MO KHOCTH H 6bIJlO npoBeueHo MHoro Me KAYHapo J HbIX BCTpeq B CBJl3H C KOTOPbIMH ny6nHKOBaJIHCb 33JlBJleHHJl KaCaIOIUHeCJl BuyTpeHHeH nOJlHTHKH DPH npeAbIAYIIIHX cMeHax PYKoBoAcma HOBbIH BO KAb BbIHy K· u eH 6bIJl no u lJ aBJleHHeM 06CTOJlTeJlbCTB npeAfiPHHHMaTb ueHCmHJl tJ peBaTbIe cepr e3HbIMH H ll eOJlorHlleCKHMH H Me KAYHapoAHbIMH OTKJIHKaMH HanpHMep XpYIUeB CMeCTHlI BepHJl H 06'bJlBHJl 0 CTa­ JIHHCKHX npecyYnJleHHJlX tfl'06bl npeUOTBpaTHTb K83Hb BbIAaIOIUHXCJl OTphIBKH H3 KHHrH Zhores A Medvedev Gorbachev W W Nor­ ton Company New York-London 1986 CTP 208-242 200 201 Bpa'CJeH OCY'KAeHHbIX H npHl'OBopeHHI IX B ljIeBpane 1953 ron a B o6JIaCTH BHeIIIHeH nOJIHTHKH 6bIJIO HaCTOHTenl HO He06xo 0 3aKOHlIHTh BOHHy B Kopee TIPH Iipe meBe 61 IDO MeHl We Me l lly­ aapo ll HhlX KPH3HCOB Tpe60BaBIIIHX HeMenrreHHoro pa3peweHUH HO OH Hero KonnerH 3HeprWlHO o eHCTBOBaJIH B KOHcepBaTHBHOM CTH­ ne tfr061 I H3MeHHII nH6epanI HI Ie TeHJJ emum B HAeOnorHH H Bayr­ peHHeH nOJIHTHKe B03HHKII1He npH XpymeBe 3anperuaH ny6JIHKa­ D HIO KHHf BblnyCK pHnI MOB H T 0 fop6atfeB npUJJ li K BnaCTU BU­ o en caMYIO Heomo myIO 3a u aQY He B KaKHX-TO o eHCTBHHX a B COC­ TaBneHHH o OKyMeHTOB npe KJJ e Bcero nporpaMMI I napTHH r o e co o ep K3JlHCb 6bI peKOMeHJJ aD Hu 0 6y u yruei BHYTpeHHeH nOJIHTHKe H nonmKeHHH CCCP B MHpe OKOH lfaTenl HI m BapHaHT 3THX o OKy­ MeHTOB nOKaaan tfrO HOBoe PYKOBO o CTBO erue He rOTOBO K o ei cT­ BeHHI IM HAeOnOfH'CIeCKHM H nOnHTH lfeCKHM HHHUHaTHBaM MHorHe 06rueCTBeHHhle H npoljlecCHOHanl HI Ie rpynnbI Bbma­ IIIHBaJIH aa u e K lJ bI tfrO HOBoe PYKOBO o CTBO pa3peIIIHT HaKannHBaB­ IIIHeCH ro o aMH a TO H o eCHTHneTHHMH 3a u allH UeHTpanl HI IH KOMH­ TeT llpe3HAH 'M BepxoBHoro COBeTa H pe u aKTopbI BeA 'lURx ra3eT Bcer o a nonyqanu MHoro nuceM a nocne CMeHl I PYKOBo o CTBa OHH nOKaTHnHCI naBHHoH 3TH nucbMa a He BI I60PbI B BepXOBHI m CO­ BeT OTpIDKaIOT 06rueCTBeHHOe MHeHHe B HatJane 60-x ro o OB Ma­ BecmH co06ruanu tfrO nOJlYlJaIOT 0 0 2000 OUceM B o eHl a TIPaB­ u a MO KeT 61 ITI nonyqana erue 6onl we TIOtfrH K IH rpa KJJ a­ HUH CCCP XOTh pa3 B KH3HH Hanucan nuCbMO Ha IfHHaIOUJ eeCH 06­ parueHHeM YBa KaeMbm TOBapuw H a u peCOBan ero KpaTKO MocKBa KpeMnb Tenepl Kor u a 3THM TOBapHIUeM CTan 3Hep­ m'ClHhlii fop6atfeB OH HaBepHOe nony lfHn HeCKOnl KO MHJIJIHOHOB nuceM co o ep KaBWUX He TOnl KO n03 o paBneHUH HO npeMO KeHUH npOOKTbI npoCl 6bI Kan06hl Tpe60BaHHH cnpaBenrrHBOCTH 06paw e­ HUH no nOBO o y 3aKnIO'CJeHHbIX ux B CCCP 60nee 2 MllH tfenOBeK OT nOnHTHtfeCKUX 3aKnIOtfeHHbIX H OT HHaKOMblCOHIUHX BCHKOro po u a nOtfrH Bee UaBeCTHI Ie COBeTCKHe HHaKOMbICOHUJ He Ha IfaJIH CBOIO 06ruecTBeHHYIO o eHTenbHOCTI C OUCI Ma B UK HJ1H TIOnHT6IO­ po 3TH nuCI Ma - Ba KHbm acneKT coBeTcKoii nOnHTH'CJeCKoH H3HH OHH nooruPHIOTCH KOHCTHyYD HeH CTaThH 49 KOTOPOi rna­ CHT K H rpa KJJ aHHH CCCP HMeeT npaBo BHOCHTh B rocy u ap­ CTBeHHble opraHl l H 06rueCTBeHHbIe OpraHH3aD HH npeMO KeHHH 06 202 y rryqweHHH ux o eHTenbHOCTH KpuTHKOBaTI He o OCTaTKH B pa60Te lon KHOCTHhle mrua OM3aHhl B YCTaHOBneHHble aaKOHOM CPOKH paccMaTpHBaTI npenrrO KeHHH U 3aHBneHHH rpa KJJ aH o aBaTb Ha HUX OTBeThI H npHHHMaTh He06xoJJ HMble Mephl TIpecoe o oBaHHe 3a KpH­ THKyaanperuaeTcH l 3Ta Ba KHaH CTaThH cOBeTcKoH KOHCTHTyD HH 03HatfaeT tfrO ecnH nocnaHO cooTBeTCTBYIOruee nuCbMO B TIonHT6IOpo unH B UK u a Ke caMaH paJJ HKanl HaH nOnHTH lfeCKaH KpHTHKa He o on KHa HCTon­ KOBblBaThCH KaK aHTHCOBeTCKaH nponaraa u a EcnH TaKHe OUCI Ma He 61 1JlH npe u aHhl IIIHPOKOH rnaCHOCTH He pacnpoCTpaHHnHCI B CaMH3 o are H He OmpaBnHnHCb 3a rpa HJmy aBTOp HJ1H aBTOPbI He o On ml l npHBneKaThCH K cy o y ECTeCTBeHHO OUCbMa TaKOrO po u a MOryT nOnaCTI B CaMH3 u aT HJ1H 3a rpamwy He no Bone aBTOPOB Ho oljlHD Hanl Hble JIHu a paCCMaTpHBaIOT 3T0 KaK npe rr n or AllH npe o 1 HBneHHH 06BUHeHHH B HapymeHHH 3aKOHa TIOXO Ke fop6a'leB nOHHn Ba KHOCTI 3THX nueeM KaK 6apo­ MeTpa 06rueCTBeHHoro MHeHHH OH HeO ll HOKpaTHO U HTHpOBan UX B peqax no nOBO o y 3KOHOMHtfeCKHX npo6JIeM B UenHHOrpa u e Han­ pHMep OH D HTHpOBan OUCbMa npoCTblX nIO o ei KOTOpl le npeMara­ nH nO J HHYI u eHY Ha xne6 tfr06bl ero He CKapMllHBanH CKOTY Op­ raHH3au HH OTBeTOB Ha 3TH DHCbMa 61 IDa npe o MeTOM ero nepBOH BHYTpeHHeH nepeCTpoHKH B UeHTpanbHOM KOMHTeTe lJuCJIeHHOCTh 3THX nueeM Tenepl TaKOBa tfrO 6onbwoH OT o en co 150 COIp ' ll HHKa­ MH He CDpaBnHnCH COTBeTaMH Ha HHX nOCKonbKY 3aKOH YCTaHaBnH­ Ban O J HOMeCH lfHbm CPOK AllH OTBeTOB Ha DHCbMa IihlDO peweHO paCnyCTHTI OT o en H pacnpe o emlTl notfrY no coomeTCTBYIOIUHM OT­ o enaM UK 3TO 6bIDO 3 o paBoe peweHUe TaK KaK MHome nuCl Ma 6bIDH CJIHWKOM cneD HanI HI I tfr06hl Ha HHX MornH OTBeTHTh COIPY o ­ HHKH oTJJ ena DHceM O ll HaKO nepBbIM HJJ eonOm'leCKHM HCnbITaHHeM AllH HOBoro PYKoBOJJ CTBa OKa3anCH TaK Ke KaK H J lIH npe J lUeCTBeHHHKoB fop­ 6atfeBa Bonpoc 0 CTanHHe B MapTe nmH HHTeHCHBHhle npuroIoBne­ HUH K npa3nHOBaHHIO COPOKOBOi ro o OBruHHbl lHH no6e J bI TIepe o CMepTbIO qepHeHKo 6bIDO 061 HBneHO 0 BhlnycKe IjIHnbMa TI06e u a CHJlTbm B 1983-1984 roJJ ax IjIHnbM npe o cTaBnHn CTanuaa My o PbIM repoeM a qepllHJIJIH H TpYM3Ha oTpuu aTenbHI IMH nepCOHIDKaMH ManO CJJ eJIaBIIIHMH tfr06bI nOMO% yCunHHM CCCP B BoHHe HY KHO 61 IDO peIIIHTb BhlDycKaTI nH 3TOT IjIHnbM Ha 3KpaHl l I1MeJIHCb 203 rpynnhI B lIaCIHOCm BeTepaHOB BoiHhI KOTOphIe HaCTaHB3nH Ha 1983 pea6 CTamma BOJIrOrpa nCKHH rOpCOBet H 06IueCTBo 3T0 MHoro HH J e cpeAHero YPOBHJI BeTepaHOB 06paTHlIHCb C neT eil 0 BOSBpameHHH ropoA ' Ha 3BaHIVI OKono CT3nHHrpaP H rOBOpHlIH lITO lIepHeHKo 6blJI rOTOB nOPnHCSTb B COOTBeTCmyrouum YK33 fOp6atIeB nOWeJI Ha KOMIIpoMHCC cIlHJIbM xonop H3JI BoiHa nOftBHlICJI Ha SKpaHaX HO BOJIrorpa n OCT3nCJI BonrorpaP OM MHo­ H me HHTenneKty3nhI 6hIJDI ycnoKoeHhI STHM peweHHeM naHHhIe 06 SMHrpaUHH npHHJITO pacCMaTpHBaTb KaK cyWeCT­ BeHHhm nOKasaTenb OTHoweHHJI COBeTCKHX BJIactei K npo6neMe PetIb fop6atIeBa B KaHYH lHJI no6eAhI 8 MaJI He 6hDIa HHTe­ 1979 100 ro u a Kor u a e J eMeCJlt HO eBpeeB nOJIytIllJIH paspewellHe B pasrape SMHrPaUHH 51 330 HOBaJI 9 447 B 1881 r r 1IHcneHHOCTb SMHrpaHTOB Bospocna AO YMeHhWHlIa HX tIHcno AO 2 692 B 1982 r 100 ThIC peCRoi llO-BHp HMOMy petIb 6blJIa HanHcaHa ARJI Hero TaK lJIO STO npaB tIenOBeKa WSBecmo lJIO npHMepHO 6hDI OtIeHh O P hHhIH H Cp eP'KaRHbIH aHalIHS OAHaKO fop6atIeB AaH nop anH sa llBneHHJI H J A 'T p33peWeHHJI yexaT a 1IHcneHHOCTh 30 COBetCKHX rpa J npH3H3n H8JIH'lHe olIDl60K H npoCtIeTOB B HatIane BoiHhI npep weCT­ OTK33HHKOB COCTaBJIJleT OKono BOBaBlIDIX no6ep e H ynoMJIHYn HMB CTanHHa TonbKO oAHH pas xapaKTepHsyroT H 06I UHii ypoBeH p eMOKpaTHH BHyTpH CIpaHbl EcnH H cyweCTBOB3nO HaMepeHHe pea6HJIHmpoBaTh CTanKHa OT He­ ro OtIeBHAHhIM 06P330M OTKa33nHCb C p pyroi CIOPOHhI TpaAH­ H Me J A 'HapoAHYlO CHtyaUHlO B OKTJl6pe 3m UH PPhI CROBa Hec­ KonhKO BOSPOCJ1H B CBJlSH C BHSHTOM fop6atIeBa BO cJ pam t H1O UHOHHaJI 106HlIeiHaJI aMHHCTHJI 6blJIa p330llapoBaHHeM YKas 06 H npHrOTOBJIeHHJIMH K BCIpetIe C npe3Hp eHTOM PeiraHOM B OKTJl6­ 124 Com 44 HS 128 tIeJIo­ aMHHCTHH npHHJIThIH llpeSHAHYMOM BepxoBHoro COBeTa B KOm t e pe anpemI 6hDI OtIeHh Hs6HpaTenbHhIM ftBHhIM 06paSOM HCKnlOlIaBwHH CIaThH yronoBHoro Kop eKca HCIIonbsyeMhIe npoTHB nOnHTHqeCKHX MOCKB I H BeK 33KnlOtIeHHhIX WCKnlOtIanHCh p ajKe Te KTO nonyqHJI MeHee Tpex 191 1 YK 2 TaKHe nOnHTSaKJIlOtIeHHhIe KaK IOpHi Op­ tIeB npop on J 3n ymep J p 3Tb lJIO SMHrpaUHlO Hap O paccMatpHBaTh neT no CTaThe eBpeJi nOKHHYJIO COBeTcKHH ThIC tIenOBeK 3m AaHHhIe 1 B TOM 1IHcne H3 neHHHrpa u a s B HOJl6pe 3MHrpHpoB3nO B HHTepBblO Ppam t y3CKOMy TeneBHAeHHIO 30 ceHTJl6pJl fop6a­ nOB H Cepreil KOB3neB yxce oT6hmlIDle ceMHJIemee SaKnlOtIeHHe B TonhKO KaK BOCCOeAHHellHe ceMei 3TO SHatIHT lJIO AJlJI COBetc­ narepe H HaxOAHBlIDIeCH B WlTHlIeTHei CChDIKe TO J e He nonanK KHX eBpeeB HeMt teB rpeKOB H p pymx HaUHOHanhH IX MeHhWHHCTB nop aMHHCmlO 3TO 6blJIO 6esoWH60tIHhIM npHSHaKOM lJIO HOBhm He CyWeCTByeT eCIeCTBeHHoro npaBa nOKHHYT CTpaHY no peJIHmos PYKOBOAHTeJIh He JlBJIJletCJI nH6epanOM HhlM HaUHOH3nbHhIM H KYJI typHhlM MOTHBaM B TOM J e HHtepB 1O 3TO 6hDI He nepBhm npH3HaK HO HHTenneKty3nhI npop OJI J a­ fop6atIeB nOK333n lJIO OH HMeeT OlJeHh cna60e npep CIaBJIeHHe JIB Hap eJIThCJI lITO nocne BCIynneHHJI fop6atIeBa B p omKHOCTh npoH­ o cyweCTBe eBpeHCKoi npo6neMhl B CCCP OH ymep J IJ aJl lITO soiAYT KaKHe-TO HSMeHeHHJI EBpeH- OTK33HHKH Hap eJIJIHCb lJIO nonO J eHHe eBpeeB B CCCP nyqwe lJeM rp e 6hI TO HH 6blJIO B MHpe 0 69% SMHrpaURJl p3KmtIeCKH npeKpaTHBWaJlCJI npH lIepHeHKo 6yp et EBpeicKoe HaceneHHe COCIaBJIJIlOwee o6nertIeHa llOHatIllJIy CHTY3UHJI K333JIaCh 06Hap e l lBalOweil B Map­ 98 tIenOBeK 3 B anpene B nOJIHTHtIeCKoi H KYJI typHOil J H3HH npep CTaBJIeHO B KOJlHt eCT­ Be OT 10 p o 20% 6 OR 6hIJI npaB B OTHOWeHHH yp eJIhHOrO Becs Te nOJIytIHlIH paspeweHHe SMHrpHpoBaTh 166 HaceneHHJI CTpaHbI tIenOBeK npH6hIJIH B BeHy cpeAH HHX 6hDIH nlOAH HS MOCK­ eBpeeB B tIHCneHHOCTH HaceneHKJI CCCP HO OtIeH tpYAHO H3MepHT BhI H neHHHI'p3A3 OTKY u a paHee 6hDIO TpYAHee Bcero SMHrpHpo­ BaTh 4 OAH3KO nop rOTOBHTenhHhIe onepaUHH KOTophIe HaARe J HT HaCKOJI KO OHH npep cTaBneHbI B cOBeTCKoi KYJIhtypHOil J H3HH llOMHMO Bcero npotIero TO BOnpOC He TOJI KO npaBHTeJIbCTBeHHoil npop enaTh ARJI SMHrpaUHH T3K cnO J HhI lJIO Sa llBneHHJI Tex KTO nOJIHTHKH HO T3K J e Bonpoc CBJlSaRHhIi C HHAHBHAYan HhIMH YCH­ yeS J 3nH B anpene P OmKHhl 6hIJIH paCCMaTpHBaTbCH MHoro paRee JIHJlMH H CKnOHHOCTJlMH W CK33aTh tITO eBpeH npep CIaBneHhI neTOM lJHcno P33peWeHHHH Ha SMHrpaUHlO CT3nO YMeHhUIaThCH B COBeTCKoi nOJIHTHtIecKoi J H3HH B npep enax OT ewe H K aBrycry ynano AO 3040 B MeCJIll B STO tIHcno He BXOp JIT HeM­ I bI llOBOn J bJl 0 KOTOphIX H3BecTHbI TOJIhKO AaHHbIe sa BeCh roP 10 p o 20% JlBJIJletCJI oqeBHAHhIM a6cYPP oM B npaBHTeJIhCTBe eCTh TOJI KO OAHH eBpeil BeHHaMHH IMWHIQ a no MeHee eBpeeB B KOMMyHHcTHtIeCKOi napTHH 6hIJIa paBHa 1% llponopUHSl 1A% B 1983 r 204 205 H TOm KO Owm eBpeH Be3Aecy m HH llblMIlIHrO cpenu 311 lJJ1eHOB II K Co BpeMeHH nepBoro BRlHTa B COBeTcKHH COI03 rpynnhl YCHJleHHOH OXpaHOH MHJlHUHH - cnyqanOClo 'ITO MHJlHIUlORepOB OKa­ 3bmaJIOClo 6onloUle qeM rOCTeH llpe q eCTHBaJIh MOnOAe KH B 1957 r' l 6loIJI paAOCTHLIM H CBo60AHLIM C'be3AOM IOHOUleH H AeBY­ aMepHKaHCKHX ceHaTopoB H KOHfpeccMeHoB B anpene rop6aqeB UleK Ha nOT pal aTMoccpepa GhlJIa OOBceM RHOH rOCTJlM BhIAaJIH nony'IRlI MHoro nH'lHhiX oGplllQeHHH no nOBo o y nOJIHTH'leCKHX laK­ nponycKa C HX cpoTorpa PHJlMH KOTopble OHH AOJI l HhI 6loIJIH HOeHTb nIOqeHHhIX H oTKa3HHKoB Ero orneT GhlJI 06hI'lHbIM llOlBom Te HaM caMHM pewaTb HaI IIH BHYTpeHHHe npo6JIeMbl 7 OH TaK Ke 1IeCKRe TeMb C IIBHOH aHTH3anaAHoH HanpasneHHoCTbIO nOCTOJIRHO• llHCKYCCHH npoBoAHJlHcb fJIaBHLIM 06pa30M Ha nOJIHTH­ npoAOJIJK3J1 ep l AaTb 'ITO nOJIHTHqeCKHX p HcCHAeHTOB cyMT llOnO l eHHe B COI03e nHcaTeneH R Apyrnx ooI03ax TBopllec­ TonbKO TOrAa KorAa OHH HapywaIOT JaKOH XOTJI OH AOJI KeH lHaTb KOH HHTeJIJIHfeHnHH PHaJIHCTOB KOMll03HTOPOB KHHeMaTorpa­ 'ITO COBeTCKHH 3aKOH 06paI IJ aeT HHaKOMhICnHe B npeCTYIIJIeHHe TeM 'CPRCTOB H T A OGloI'IHO MO KeT enYJKHTb XOpoUlHM nOKa3aTeneM He MeHee nepeA KeHeBCKOH BCTpeqeH Ha BblCUleM ypoBHe 6bIJI CAe­ BHyTpeRHero nOJIHTHqeCKorO KJlHMaTa BeerAa RMeIOTCJI AeCJITI H naH KeCT AOGpoH BOJIH B HOJlGpe EneHe EOHHJp KeHe COenaHHOrO nOBeCTeH q HJlhMOB nbeC H T A npeACTaBJIeHHhIX JlIJI Ony6JIHKo­ AlmpeJl CaxapoBa 6h1Jlo pa3peUleHo BhlexaTb 3a rpaHHQY Ha caMOM BaHHJI HJlH JlIJI pa3peUleHHJI nOCTaHOBKH Ha cu eHe RJIH JKpaHe Aene CaxapoB Ha'IaJI CBOIO TpeTbIO ronoAoBKY no 3TOMY nOBO O Y Bee nbeCbl R CPRJIbMbl AOJI I HbI nOnyqHTb pa3peUleRHe cnenuaJIbHOrO B OKTJlGpe TpeGYJI 'lT06hI ero KeHe GhlJIO pa3peUleHO BblexaTb KOMHTeTa B03fJIaBJIJleMOrO oooTBeTcmyroI IJ HM neH3opoM Ha o JJl1J1 neqeHHJI Y Hero cna60e 3AopoBbe eMY 6hlJIO 64 rOAa OH GhlJI naCTHOM OqeHb ena6 noene npe I HHx ronoAoBoK laKOH'IHBIlIHXCJI B 6onbHH­ TeaTpy 3Ha'IIHTenloHaJI 1IaCTlo ne npHHYAHTenhHbIM KOpMJIeHHeM Ero KH3Hb GhlJIa nOA yrpo30H OTJIO KeHa AO BHeeeHRJI H3MeHeHHii ABToPhl pe L aKTophI H pe KHc­ ypoBHe eCJlH meca npeACTaBneHa npoBHHUHaJIbHOMY lTHX pa60T 6hlJIa oTBepfHYTa RJIH ECJlH 6hI OH yMep B HOJIGpe HerOAOBaHHe B CIlIA GhlJIO 6bl CJlHIJl­ eepbl cpep H HHX OqeHL R3BecTHble HeHJGe I HO OGplllQaJIHCb K Ho­ KOM CHJIhHblM 'lT06bI rop6atIeB Mor paCC'IHTblBaTlo Ha KaKOH-TO BOMY PYKOBOp HTenIO JJl1J1 pa3peUleHHJI HX TpYAHOCTeH C neH30paMR ycnex B JKeHeBe CTaBKH GhIJIH CJlHIJlI OM BhlooKH H B KOHne OKTJI B anpene nORBRJIHClo 06HaAe I HBaIOI IJ He npR3HaKH TOro 'ITO RlMe­ pJl EneHe EOHHlP COOGI IJ HJlH 'ITO OHa MO l eT BblexaTb la rpaHHQY HeHRJI HOCJITCJI B B03JJ YXe rOp6alleB OTKa3aJICJI YSHAeTbCJI C ABy MR HeMeJJl1eHHO CaxaPOB GhlJI KpynHeHUleH npo6JIeMoH JJl1J1 rop6aqe­ H8H60nee Ba B o6JIacTH npas qenOBeKa OH GhIJl BhlenaHB rOpbKHHB 1980 r Ge3 CYAa H cYAeGHoro pa36HpaTem cma 3TO 6h1Jlo CAenaHO KrE neH - KOHeepsaTHBHblMH PYKOBOAHTeJIJlMH r MapKoBblM npeAeeAaTeneM H A COI03a nHcaTe­ qaKOBCKRM pe L aKTo­ poM nmepaTYpHOH raJeTbl EMY nonaraJIOCb BCTpeTHTbCJI C HHMH nOA nO l HhIM npeJJl10rOM 'ITO CaxapoB pacnOJIaraeT rocYAaPCrneH­ 'lTOGbl HaJIaAHTb xopoIlIHe OTHOUleHHJI C JTHMH orneTCrneHHloIMH HLIMH ceKpeTaMH nO l HhIM nOTOMY 'ITO CaxaPOB GlolJI YSOJIeR pa60THHKaMH H3 HHCTHTYTa aTOMHOH 3HepTHH B 1968 r ABeRaAnaTbIO roAaMH AlmponOB BHAeJICJI C HHMH B AeKaGpe 1982 r H Bhlpa3RJI RM CBoe AOBepHe HO RM 6blJlO CKa3aHO 'ITO ropGaqeB paHee R He npHHHMaJI yttaCTHJI B OpHeHTHpoBaHHLIX Ha BoeHHhle enHIJll OM 3aHJIT CTaJIO HJBeCTHO TaK Ke lITO lleTp lleMH'leB MR­ HY l Abl HCeneAOBaHHJlX C 1964 r OT npaB03aI IJ HTHLIX rpynn B CCCP OC06eHHO OT tfJIeROB HHCTp KynbTYPbl KaH Il HAaT B lDIeHbl llOJIHTGIOPO H 6blBumii rnaBa MOCKOBCKOH XenlocHHKcKOH rpynnhl H lMHfpaHTOB - GblBIJlHX no­ Be l llHBbl C nOeeTHTenJlMH C ApyrOH CTOPOHbl llPR6hITKOB owm HJ oTAena nponaraHAbI II K R ero AOn I HOCTHLle mw a CTaJIH Gonee JIHT3aKJIIOtIeHHloIX npoAOJI I aJla nocrynaTb RHq oPManRJI 06 apeCTax fJIaBHLIX nOMOI IJ HHKOB qepHeHKo GlolJI Ha3HaqeH 38MeCTHTeneM HHaKOMbICJlJlI IJ HX H aKTHBHLIX npasOJaI IJ HTHHKOB H CYAJI no KOMHTeTa no oXpaHe rOCYAapcmeHHLIX eeKpeTOB B nettaTH OcpH­ e KeHeAem HLIM COO6I IJ eHHJIM 0 HapYUleHHJlX npas 1IenOBeKa H3Aa­ nuaJIbHOe Ha3BaHHe OOBeTCKOH n eH3yphI llnJl llpHGbITKOBa 3T0 BaeMloIX KpoHHAOM nI06apcKHM BO BTOPOH nonOBRHe 1985 r He 6hlJI0 3aMemo CYI IJ eCTBeHHhIX H3MeHeHHH CHTYanHH 8 MOCKOBCKHH pbl EhlJIH CJIyXR 'ITO rOp6a1leB H MHXaHJl 3HMJIHHH BTOPOH eeKpe­ Me l AyHapo l HloIH 206 q eCTHBaJIh MonOAe KH npoxoAHJl nOA 00060 GlolJIO nOHH KeHHeM H Re cynHJlO HH'lero xopoUlero B o6JIaCTH n eH3Y­ Tapb HAeOJIOfH'leCKOrO OTAena II K BTOPOH qeJIOBeK noene Cyeno­ 207 Ba BbDIonwmIIIHii ry l e ponb npH JlHraqeBe He nonlAJfJlH Ho no­ BHARMOMy- HHKat HX HOBbIX HHCTpYKI Hii He 6bmo H CHrylI H II He ynyqunmaCb H rr eonOrHtJeCKHe 3a llBneHIDI rop6aqeBa 6bIllH W3yc­ MbIcneHHbI H He o6HapY KHBaJIH HOBOro no Uo na llOXO Ke 6bmo tJTO rop6a'lleB IIel1HKOM nopYtJHJ1 Hp eonOrHlO JlHra'lleBY H CKOHIIeHTpH­ POBaJI CBoe BHHMaHHe Ha 3KOHOMHKe B aBryCTe EBremm EBrymeHKo H3Becmlil'H n03T H nOllHTH­ ' IeCKH npoTHBopetJIfBaJI cpurypa HanHcaJI rop6a'lleBY nHCbMO 0 nna­ ' IeBHOM COCTO IIHHH COBeTCKOH llHTeparypbI H 'llpe3MepHOH CTporoc­ TH IIeH3ypHbIX OrpaHH'lleHHH B more B llpaBp e 9 ceHT II6p ll 6bIJ1a ony6mn oBaHa ero KOPOTKaJI n03Ma B KOTOPOH nop p ep KHBa­ naCb 3KOHOMHlJeCKaJI nOllHTHKa rop6a'lleBa COp ep l aJlHCb HanllAKH Ha 61OPOKpaTOB 6o IIIIIHxc II HOBoBBep eHHH H npoTHBJDInlxC II HM H BOCXBaJI IIJ1C 11 WeCTHMeC II'IIHbm COBeTCKuH MopaTopuH Ha Mep­ HbIe HcnhITaHHJI KaK 6ecnpeIIep eHTHOH cMenocm nOW3Hr BO HM II MHpa 9 ll03Ma cop ep KaJla Tat Ke CKpbIryIO KpHTHKy KOJ1J1eKTHBH­ 3lIIHH H OTKPhITYlO KpHTHKy JIhIceHKo CB II3bIBl ll HblHeWHHe Cel1hC­ Kox03JriiCTBeHHble Tpy D HOCTH C 6mpoKpaTmleCKHMH nperpanaMH Ho H3 n03MbI IICHO cnep OBano tJTO He napTH II a 61OpoKpaThI omeT­ CTBeHHbI 31 Bce 3TO B TOM Ke MeC IIIIe rop6a'lleB Ha3HatJHJ1 AlleKcaHApa HKOBneBa rnaDOH OTp el1a nponaraHAhI UK CMeCTHB CryKaJIHHa Ha3Ha'lleHHOrO nocnOM B BeurpHIO 3'r0 paCCMaTpHBaJIOCb KaK XOPOWUH 3HaK OTp en nponaraHJ hl IIBJ1 11eTC II KlllO'IIeBhIM 3BeHOM l1HI'a'lleBCKOro H 1l eonOrHtJeCKOrO ceKpeTapHaTa lloxo l e Ha3Ha' leHHe 3TO 6bIJ10 npoH3Bep eHO B cneWKe Kat H Ha3HaqeHHe Pa3YMOBCKoro rnaBOH OpraHH3lI HOHHoro OTp el1a Tat Kat 06bl'IIH0 rnaBa OTp ena npona­ BaTOp HO OH nonytJHT BnH llHHe TonhlCO ecnH 6yp eT H36paH B UK HOBbIe Ha3HaqeHIDI B HAeonOrHtJeCICOM OTp ene BbIrn IIA IIT BeChMa o6eII alOII HMH rpy60 rOBOp ll COBeTCICHe HAeonorHtJeCKHe pa60THHICH p en IITc II Ha W3e rpynnhI 1C0HCepBaTHBH 'IO 0PTOAQIC­ CaJ1hH 'IO 1C0TOPym nOp p ep KHBaJIH CycnOB H neMH'IIeB H 60nee clCnoHaym IC pecpopMaM YMepeHHO nporpecCHBH 'IO lHpeICTOP HHcmryTa CIlIA H KaHaAhI reopruH Ap6aTOB 6bIBWuH peAaKTOP llpaBAhI a Teneph ARpelCTOP HHCTHtyTa COIIHOnOrHH AllelCceH Py-M IIHIIeB CTapWUH COTPYAHHK Me KAYHapo D Horo OTp ena UK H nnop OBHThIH nHcaTenb no BonpocaM COIIHaJIH3Ma H KOMMfHH3Ma r InaXHaJapoB AlleICcaHAP BOBHR H cI ep op BypnallKHH 06a H3­ BeCTHhIe KypHallHCTbl - OTHOC llTC II KO BTOPOH rpynne CKllOHaym IC peCPOPMaM rpynny TO'IIHee Ha3BaTh nporpeCCHBHOH qeM nH6epanh­ HOH Y 3TOH rpynnhI YCTaHOBHllHCh xopowue OTHoweHIDI C AHApo­ nOBbIM 1C0r na OH p o 1967 r 6hm celCpeTapeM UK llocne HeKoTopo­ ro cnlna BnH IIHH II OHH nOXO l e BHOBh BhICTynuJIH Ha CIIeHy nocne CMepTH Bpe f leBa rop6aQeB He HMeBWHH co6CTBeHHoro HHTennelC­ ryaJIhHOro OICpy l eHIDI BHAHMO Ha6Hpan COBeTHHICOB nOMoIUHH­ ICOB H p pyrux p On f lOCTHbIX llHII H3 3TOH rpynnhI Ho ne'laJIhHO H3BecmhIe CBOHM lCoHcepBaTH3MOM 3HM IIHHH rnaDa OT ll ena lCynh­ ryPhI UK Inaypo H peAaKTOP KypHaJIa BonpoChI 3KOHOMHKH H ARpelCTOP HHCTHryTa 3KOHOMHKH XatJaTypoB COXpaHHllH BllH llHHe H B03MO f lO HMelOT nyqwue 'IIeM nporpeCCHCThl OTHOmeHHJI C JlHraqeBbIM TpeTb ll rpynna - IIeHTpHCTClCa II B Hee BX0A IIT pe naICTOp llpaBAhI ACPaHaCbeB H pep aKTOP Teopem'lleCKOrO napmHHoro KYpHaJIa KOMMyHHCT PHtJapp KOCOnaDOB llOCKonhlCY COBeTCKuH a HKOBlleB COlO3 IIBJ1 11eTC II Hp eOnOrHtJeCICHM rocyp apcmOM nyooHKlIIHU B Tat OBbIM He 6bIJ1 OH 6bIJ1 3aMecmTeneM 3aDe lylOII ero Omel10M napTHHHbIX oprauax netJarn 06bI'IIH0 6hIBalOT HaH60nee 3HatJHMhlMH nOKaJaTen llMH TeKYII HX nonHTHtJeCICHX H HAeonOrHtJeCKHX TeHAeH­ raH IJ bl IIBJ1 IIeTC II 'IJl1eHOM HJ1H Ka H lJ H J aTOM B 'IJl1eHhI nponaraHAbI HO 6bIJ1 CMeII eH CycnOBhIM B 1970 UK r OqeBHARo 31 ny6mnc lI H1O B nOllHTHtJeCKHX H llHTepaTypHbIX lKYPHaJIax CTaTeH C KpHTHKOH HeOCTaJIHHHCTCKHX H pycOcpHllbCKHX TeHAeHI Hii H HaJHa­ qeH nocnoM B KaHaJJY B nOM Ka' leCme OH conpoBO KnaJl rop6aqe­ IIUH· MapKCH3M-neHHHH3M IIBJ1 IIeTC II CYII eCTBeHHbIM CB II3ymIIIHM 3BeHOM Me KAY pa3J1H'llHhIMH rocy napcmeHHhIMH yqpe KAeHIDIMH H neranH3yeT BepxoBHym BnaCTh napTHH H ee reHepanbHoro ceKpe­ H Me KAY HHMH YCTaHOBHllHCb tap ll Hp eonorHtJeCKHe CB II3H MelKA ' pa3HbIMH qaCT IIMH rocyp ap­ xopowue OTHOWeHIDI HKOBneB 6hIll B03BplII eH B MOCKBY H Ha3­ CTBeHHOH MaWHHbI COXpaH IIT CBOIO npOlJHOCTb ecnH COXPaHHT­ Ha' leH ARpeKTOPOM HHcmryra MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKH H Me KAYHapop ­ C II IIeMeHTHpymmaH ponh HAeonorHH 3Ta ponh Ba BO BpeM II ero BH3Hta B KaHaJJ y IIBHO YMeHhIlIH­ HbIX OTHowemm OH conpoBO KnaJl rop6a'lleBa BO BpeM II ero BH3HTa B BeJIHK06PHTaHHIO B 208 1984 r C'llHTaeTC II tJTO HKOBneB He 1C0Hcep­ 209 JIaCb BO BpeMeHa Bpe lQ eBa HO 3TO fibIJlO BbI3BaHO He CTPYKryp­ KOMMYHHCTbI H Bce Tp KeHHKH CTaBpOnOJIbIU HHbI 6ec­ HblMH H3MeHeHHHMH a CBoero POIJ 8 H lJ eOJIOrlflleCKHM CKJIepo­ KOHelJHO 6n arO J apHbI JIeoHH J y HnbHlfY Bpe HeBY 3a ero 30M BepXH napTHH fiblJIH He cnocofiHbI C031J 8Tb If l1 eOJIorlfllec­ KHH CO J HaJIbHbIH IDIH nOJIHTlflleCKHH J OKyMem nO J JIHHHO B J OXHOBJIeHHYIO napTHeH JIHTeparyPHYlO pa60TY K KOTOPOMY B KOTOPOH HCTOlfHHKH BeJIHKOro nO J BHra HallIeH repoHlJec­ Ofipa30BaHHbIe KpyrH MornH fibI OTHeCTHCb eepbe3HO B 1970-x H KOH CTpaHbI ee JJ YXOBHOH H HpaBCTBeHHOH CHJIbI ee CIOH­ 1980-x ro J aX nytflIIee qyO MOrJIa npe J JIO lO Tb napTHH J JIS B J OXHo­ KOCTH H M KeCTBa BCKPblTbI C I HJIOCOI CKOH rnyfiHHoH BeHHS HapolJ 8 fibIJIH TPy ru I Bpe lQ eBa - BOcnOMHHaHHS 0 ro J ax OfipaTHbrH nepeBO J C aHrn - Pe J 10 BOHHbI 0 u eJIHHe H T JJ npHMHTHBHO H y60ro HanHCaHHbIe 3a Hero ras 3TO HeYMepeHHoe BOCXBaneHHe nOBepXHOCTHoro H noe­ J pymMH H nopo lJ HBIillIe 6eCq CJIeHHbIe aHeK J orbI CaM rOpfialJeB TO e He H36e aJI HeKOTopoH npHtJaCTHOCTH pe J CTBeHHoro COlJHHeHHH Bpe lQ eBa HeJIb3S He nOqyBCTBOBaTb qro K npHMHTHBHbIM H 6ecCMbICJIeHHbIM H J eOJIOrlflleCKHM MaTepHanaM ero o J eOJIOrHqeCKOe B03 J eHCTBHe SBJISeTCS ofipaTHblM KpoMe Bce­ Toro nepHolJ 8 B peq Ha KOHl epeHU Hli no BonpocaM H J eOJIOrHH B ro npoqero H3JIO eHHe Bpe HeBa HCKa aeT HCTOpHIO CTaBponOJIbCKOM Kpae B Mae 1978 r Kor J a OH eII e fibIJI eeKpeTa­ B 1943 r COJI J aTOM TaMaHcKoro I poHTa H Manas 3eMJIS fibIJIa H CaM fibIJI Beero JImllb ero He60JIbIilllM 6eperoBblM aBaHnOCTOM B03HHKIillIM peM rOpKOMa ropfiaqeB CKa3aJI BO BpeMH HaYlJ 8lJHOro HacTyIlJIeHHH Ha HOBOPOCCHHCK B anpeJIe reHepanbHbIH ceKpeTapb UK KnCC npe J ce J areJIb IIpe3H J HyMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP JI H Bpe HeB ­ cofiblTHS TaM KaK OCHOBHYIO fiHTBY OHH fibIJIH He3HalJHTeJIbHbIM raJIaHTJIHBbrH PYKoBO J HTeJIb JIeHHHCKOro THna Ero THTa­ BoeHHbIM HHlJecKas nOBce J HeBHas pafioTa HanpaBJIeHa Ha YKpeIIJIeHHe H TOJIbKO O J H I noJIYqJIJI nOBb1lIIeHHe B lJHHe B 1941 r OH fibIJI MOII H CTpaHbI nOBbJIIIeHHe 6n arocoCToSHHS rpy J lIIU HXCS nOJIKOBHHKOM a K 1945 r CTan reHepan-MaH0poM Ho B 1978 r He J aBHO MbI paCKPbIJIH CTpaHH J bI 3aMelJaTeJIbHOH KHHrH TOBapHII a J1 H fiYKBaMH 3aJIelJaTJIeHbI 3JIH30 J OM Bpe HeB fibIJI Tor J a nOJIHTKOMHccaPOM ol HUHanbHas npecca CTMa nucaTb 0 HeM TaK KaK fiY J TO OH fibIJI Ha ynpoqeHHe MHpa H fie30naCHOCTH Hapo J oB Bpe lQ eBa • Manu 3eMJIS r J e 3OJIOTbIMH 60JIee Bbl J alOII HMCS BoeHHbIM repoeM qeM MapUIan KYKOB MHorHe napTHHHbIe lJHHbI nOBa Hee ropfiaqeBa B 1978 r noprpeTbI JIereHlJ 8pHbIX repoeB paCTOlJanO HeofibIlJaHHbIe nOXBanbI fipe HeBCKOMY JIHTeparypHOMY 60es 3a CeBepHbrH WKaJ HeMHoro BpeMeHH npoIIIJIo co onycy 3TO CBH J eTeJIbCTByeT 0 nyCToTe J erpa J aU HH 0 pa3JIO eHHH J H I 210 H 3aTeM B Mae 1943 r IIoKa Bpe HeB 30 JIer CnyCTS He H30fipaJHJI ny6n HKau HH KHHrO HO BOCnOMHHaHHH BbI3BanH o J eOJIOrHH JIerKo nOHHTb KynbT BO BpeMeHa CranHHa Kor J a BceofiII Hii nO J JIHHHO BceHapo J HbrH HHTepec qTofibI Y J OB­ J OJI HOCTHble JI8 J a onacanHCb 3a CBOO H3HH Ho B 1978 r OHH JIeTBopHTb 6ecq CJIeHHbIe 3anpocbI Tp KeHHKoB CTaBpo­ pHcKoBanH TOJIbKO 3a J ep KOH B nOJIbIU HHbI B l eBpane 3TH BOCnOMHHaHHH fiyJJ YT nepene­ IDIO YTpaTOH KaKOH-TO npHBIDIerHH npo J BH eHHH no J OJI HOCTH lJaTaHbI H3 'YpHana HOBbrH MHP B HallIHX KpaeBblX TaKOM OfiPaJOM B 1985 r Kor J a ropfiaqeB cran reHepanb­ raJeTax CTaBponOJIbCKas npaB J a H KaBKa3CKas 3 J paB­ HHu a HbIM eeKperapeM Heofixo J HMOCTb HOBbIX H J eH 0 HHHUHarHB B 06­ JIaCTH H J eOJIOrHH CTana BeCbMa HaCrOSTeJIbHoH BbIJIO OqeBO J HO B KHHre • Manas 3eMJIS He TaK MHoro crpaHH J HO no qyO ropfiaqeB He cofiHpancs caM y J OBJIerBopHTb 3ry Heofixo J H­ rnyfiHHe H J eOJIOrHlJeCKOrO co J ep aHHH no IillIpoTe 0606­ MOCTb II eHHH 0 MbICJIeH aBTOpa OHa CTana 60JIbIilllM COfibITHeM fiaHKa H J eH HalJHHaBUIerO B03HHKan Or J eJIbHbrH pa3Be TOJIbKO B pOJIO PYKOBO J HreJIS H J eOJIorulJeCKOrO OfiII eCTBeHHOH H3HH OHa BbI3Bana rop OTKJIHK B CTan l opMHpoBarbCS BOKpyr JIuraqeBa 3ro C03 J aBanO B03MO ­ eep J J ax COBeTCKDX mO J eH 0 BOCX8II eHHble OT3b1BbI COJI­ HOCTb fiyJJ YIU HX npOTHBopelfHil Me J y rreBblM H IIpaBbIM Han­ IJ 8T-I POHTOBHKOB Ha q TaTeJIbCKDX KOHl epeHUHSX H B nelJaTH paBJIeHH IMH HO HeJIb3S fibIJIO Cpa3Y onpe J eJIHTb HX reH J eH I QiH fiaHK H J eH 211 H o eaJlbHoii apeHoii AllII CTOJIKHOBeHHa 6bIJI npoeKT napTHHHoii nporpaMMl I no 'roTaBJIBBaBumiica K XXVII C'De3 J y napTHH 3a J a­ BaJla 003 pOPMaJlbHOii nporpaMMl I MHorne rO J bI B npaBJIeHHe CTa­ JIHua XpYlUeB o6HapY KHJI 1JT0 eMY OHa O'leHb ny KHa Ero KpHTH­ BnyTpeHHHX KOBaJlH KHTaiicKHe aJl6aHCKHe H 'pyrHe PYKOBO IWTeJIH KaK pe­ H Me l J yHapo lJ HblX npo6rreM H Bbl J BIDKeHHe HX KpaTKOCPOlJRblX BH3HOHHCTa H OH ny l J aJlca B OKYMeHTe KOTOpbIii YJaKOHHlI 6bl lJeii nporpaMMbI asJIaeTCa TOJIKOBaHHe TeKymHX COBpeMeHHblii KOMMyHHCTH­ ero H J eH 0 KOMMYHH3Me H COBeTCKoii nOJIHTHlIeCKoii H 3KOHOMH­ IIeCKHH MaHH peCT HOBas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa BeCbMa He06xo IWMa IIecKoii CHCTeMax H c eJIaJl 6bl HX Mo eJIhlO AllII pyrHX CTpaH C pellleHHii npyrHMH CIIOBaMH 3T0 - 20 JIeT KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHMH npaBHTeJIbCTBaMH OH Ha J emlC9 TaKHM nyreM HaMeqarra OlIeHb onpe eJIeHHble ueJIH KOTopble HHKor a He 6bl­ npHOCTaHOBHTh paCKOJI HaMeTHBmHiiC9 B Me l J yHapo J HOM KOMMy­ TaK KaK npe JKlU a 6bIJIa npHHHTa B Dna 1961 r Ha 6rrH l aii ume H KHraii JIH OCTHfnyTbl 1JT0 C KaKOrO-TO MOMeHTa CTaJlO C03 J 3 BaTI Tpy '­ HHCTH'IeCKOM J BIDKeHHH HOCTH H CHH fCaTb nOJIHTHlJeCKyro JIerHTHMHOCTh napTHH HOBas aJlbTepHaTHBHbIe MO J eJIH KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKOro palBHTHH H MHOrHe H IOroerraBHH npe J lIO KHJIH nporpaMMa 6bIJIa HY'Klfll H I Jla BnyTpHnapTHHHbIX ueJIeii TaK KaK KOMMYHHCTH1IecKHe napTHH MHpa paCKOJIOJIHCb Ha conepHHlJalOnIHe CYlUecmyeT npoue J ypa npHeMa B napTHIO HOBhlX IIJIeHOB 3aJIBJIHIO­ pPaKUHH TaKHM 06pa30M na Me l J yHapo J Hoii apeHe TpeTha nap­ B HTO­ IUHX 0 CBoeM corrraCHH C nporpaMMOii H I Jla ny l J Me I J yHa­ THiiHas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa J a Ke B KHee IIeM Ha BnyTpeHHeii PO J Hoii nOJIHTHKH - re nporpaMMa OKa3aJlaCh XBaCTJIHBOii ee nepenoJIHHJIH 06enraHHH nporpaMMa KIICC CIIY'flliT Mo 'eJIbIO npor­ H npHTa3aHHs paMM PYrHX npaBalUHX KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKHX napTHii HecMoTpa Ha ycneXH JIeHHHCKOii KOMMYHHCTHlIeCKOii nap­ THH KOHTpoIIHpyronreii 3Ha1JHTeJIbHyro IJaCTh MHpa POPMaJlbHas B nporpaMMY 6blJI BKJIlOlIeH MopWlhHhm Ko eKc 33 HMCTBOBaHHbm H3 XpHCTHaRCKOro yqeHHH HfHopHpyeMbIH ca­ MHMH PyKOBO IWTeJI9 MH onpe eJIeHbI 3KOHOMHIIeCKHe H 06nreCT­ 70-e 8O-e rO J bI HO BCKOpe BbIHCHHlIaCh HX Hepea­ nporpaMMa Beer J a 6blJIa H3 H60JIee erra6blM MeCTOM Me I J yHapo '­ BeHHble ueJIH ua Horo KOMMYHHCTHlJeCKorO J BH KeHHa JlIOGaa nporpaMMa ycrape­ JIHCTHIIHOCTh a TaK Ke HeHa J e KHOCTb H HecoBepllleHHOCTb CHCTeMbl H BaJla B TelIeHHe J Byx-TpeX JIeT noerre ee npHHHTHH H BHOBb BCTy­ nJIaHHPOBaHHH XpYlUeBcKoii a J MHHHCTpaUHH IIporpaMMa 0OOnraJla nalOnrHe H3yqarrH co6cmeHHo He nporpaMMY a noerre J HHe nap­ 1JT0 THiiHble C aMepHKaHCKHMH nOKaJaTeJIaMH K 'OKYMeHTbl H nOCTaHOBJIeHHH IIepBas o PHUHaJlhHas nporpaMMa 6bIJIa npHHHTa B 1903 r Ha II C'be3 e napTHH B BplOcce­ 1980 BaJlOBOe npoH3Bo CTBO H norpe6rreHHe CCCP CpaBH9 IOTC9 1970 r H npeB30ii J yT HX K r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH 6y eT nocTpoeH KOMMYHH3M H JIIO IW JIe H 3aTeM B llOH J OHe r e npoH30llleJI paCKOJI Me K J y 6oJIbllleBH­ 6y J yT nOJIyqaTh Bee He06xo J HMoe no CBOHM nOTpe6HOCT9 M COBeTc­ KaMH H MeHbllleBHKaMH IIporpaMMa Tpe60BaJla HeOrpaHH1JeHHoii KHii COlO3 OCTHrHeT HaHBbICllleii npoH3Bo IWTeJIbHOCTH Tpy J a B MH­ CB060 J b1 COBeCTH errOBa npecCbI co6paHHii 3aGaCToBoK H npo p­ C01030B 11 CJIe J yronras npOrpaMMa 6bIJIa COCTaBJIeHa lleHHHbIM KOJIX03bl H COBX03bl CTaRyr npoD BeralOIUHMH H OXO J HbIMH a UHTa­ H TpoIU HM H 0 06peua VIII napTC'be3 oM B 1919 r Ona oTpa KaJla yCJIOBHH rpa l J aHCKOii BoiiHbI H CHCTeMbl BOeHHorO KOMMYHH3­ Ma 3Ta nporpaMMa 6bIJIa H Pa J HKaJlbHOii oua oTpa KaJla Ha J e K J y na HeH3OO KHOCTb MHpoBoii peBOJIIOUHH H yronHlIecKoii 06enras oTMeny eHer H cOBepllleHHo HOBbm 3KOHOMHlJeCKHH nopH J OK XOT9 noerre BBe 'eHHii B 1921 r H3IIa Bee 3TO yrpaTHJIO CMblCII HOBoii nporpaMMbl He 6bIJIO 0 cMepm CTaJlHHa TaK KaK CTaJlHH npaBHlI KaK J HKTaTOP H POJIb napTHH 3HaIIHTem HO YMeHblllHlIaCh oTCyTcmHe nporpaMMbl 6bIJIO HeCYIUecmeHHbIM TpeTb9 nporpaMMa nO J fOTaBJIHBaJlaCb C H 6bIJIa npHHHTa ua 212 XXII 1954 r no 1961 r C'be3 J e KIICC XOT9 napTHH npoCYIUecmo- pe Ka K J a9 eeMb9 6y eT HMeTh oT eJIbHblii OM HlIH KBapTHpy HHe HaeeJIeHHH 6y eT 6alHpoBaThCa Ha HaY1JHblx HopMax B nporpaMMe YKa3blBa­ 5 pa3 Bblllle lJeM B 1960 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH CCCP 6y 'eT npoH3BO IWTh 2700 MJIP KHlIOBaTT-IJaCOB 3JIeKTpo3HeprHH B ro Ha eJIe B 1980 r 3TOT no­ KaJaTeJIb 6bIJI 1295 MJIP 700 MJIH T He pm B 1980 r 6bIJIO '0­ 6bITO 603 MJIH T 300 MJIH T lepHa ypo fCaii 1980 r 6bIJI 189 MJIH T H 30 MJIH T Maca npOH3Bo CTBO M9 ca B 1980 r 6bIJIO 15 MJIH T 12 He 6bIJIa oCTHrnyra HH 0 J Ha H3 HaMe'leHHblX UH PP JIyqume nOKalaTeJIH OKa3aJlHCh no XJIOnKy - 9 96 MJIH T B 1980 r npH 000nraHHblx 10 MJIH T HH'Iero H3 3Toro He 6blJIO OCTHfHyrO JIOCh 1JTO HaJIHOHaJlbHbm OXO B 1980 r 6y eT B 213 3TOT KpaTKHH o63op npe KHHx napTHiiHbIX nporpaMM 06'bHC­ HOCTO 06muH BbIBOp -lPanbIIIHBbIH COBeTCKuii COlO3 op eT BO rna· HHeT nOlleMY TOH HOBOi nporpaMMhI GoJIee CKPOMHbIi IIpoeKT Be MHpoBoro H TeXHH'leCKOrO nporpecca Bee HaIllIcaHO aM6HBa­ nporpaMMhI nO J I'OTaBJIHBanH co BpeMeHH XXVI CDe3 COCTO B­ JIeHTHO YaK 'lT06bl Cp eJIaTb B03MO f HbIMH pa3DH'lHble TOJIKOBaHHH IIIerOCH B 1981 r TorAS 6bIDa Yllpe ll eHa KOMHCCHH no nop rOTOBKe IleMoKpaTHH TpaKTyeTCH KaK peanbHO cyw eCTBYlOmaH p eMOKpa­ npoeKTa nporpaMMhI nop npep eeAS TeJIbCTBOM Bpe f HeBa 3TY THH CBoGop a HHIPOpMaUHO KaK P ocryn KO BceM HCTO'lHHKaM p OJI f HOCTb YHaCJIep OBan AH D ponoB a nOTOM qepHeHKo IIpoeKT 3HaHHH npH 3TOM MHome acneKTbI OHIPOPMaD HH K KOTOphIM nOCJIep OBaTeJIbHO OTpa KllJI MHeHHH o'lepe J Horo reHepanbHoro eeK­ Y COBeTCKOX rpa HeT p ocryna onpep eJIHIOTCH KaK ReH ' l loe peTapH Ho He TaK Ba f HO 'ITO MHorHe BHeCJIH CBoe B OKOH'laTeJIb­ 3HaHHe HecymecTBeHHoe AJIH HX H ' Il a 0 H 'IO peAS KUHIO p OKYMeHTa onyooHKoBaHHoro AM 06CY ll eHHH 3aH0 'ITO no nOHHTHe HanOJIHeHO p ei CTBHTeJIbHO 1 13HeHHO BIDK­ B OKTH6pe 1985 r 13 Op 06pHJI OKOHlJaTeJIbHyro BepcHIO fop6a'leB HbIM cop ep KaHHeM H HX TeCHO CBH3bIBalOT C 06S 3aHHOCTHMH npaBax 'IeJIOBeKa CKa­ H OHa BOMeT B HCTOPHIO napTHH KaK rop6alJeBCKaH nporpaMMa B HOBOi nporpaMMe HeT OTp eJIa nOCB 8 I D eHHoro CeJIbCKOMY X03 s HCT­ XOTH B nporpaMMe OTpax eHbl HHTepeCbl MHomx rpymrnpoBOK BY B nporpaMMe 1961 r npo6JIeMbI eeJIbCKOrO XOl s HCTBa paccMaT­ H HMelOTCH pa3JIH'lHH B pa3p eJIax npHrOTOBJIeHHbIX pa3HbIMH OTp e­ JIaMH UK B nporpaMMe oTpa3HJIaCb JIH'lHOCTb fopGa'leBa OKOHlla­ pHBanocb 0 He 06Cj'iK J aIOTCH mo6aJIbHble npoooeMhI p eMOrpalPHH H OKp ' KalOmei CpeADI BbIABHH 'BlIloeCH Ha nepeAHuii DJIaH B pal­ TeJIbHOe 0p 06peHHe Ka ll OrO pa3p eJIa npHHa J JIe KllJIO eMY H n03TO­ BHTbIX CTpaHaX MHpa B 1970-e 0 1980-e rOADI C p pyroi CTOPOHbI MY OKOH'laTeJIbHaH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a nporpaMMY B n eJIOM JIe fQfI MeHee Ha HeM 06mero 0 npocpeccHoHanbHoro 06pa30BaHHs B COBeTCKHX IIIKOJIaX BIDKHble npo6JIeMbl TaKHe KaK OnTHManbHOe COlJeTaHHe IleTanH HOBOi nporpaMMbl MOryT 6hITb HeBIDKHbI B nOJIHTH­ 06CY ll alOTCH p eTanbHO 06mee Bne'laTJIeHHe OT HOBOi napTHHHoi lIecKoi 6HOrpa1PHH HO B Hei HMelOTCH nOJIe3HhIe YKaJaHHH Ha Me­ nporpaMMbI TaKOBO 'ITO KOHCepBaTHBHOe HAeOJIOm'leCKOe KpbIDO TOADI H B03MO f HbIe HanpaBJIeHHH nOJIHTHKH fop6alJeBa 3Ya npor­ npop OJI KaeT P OMHHHPOBaTb B paMMa MHoro KOPOlJe xpyw eBcKoi H Kyp a MeHee D BeTHCTa OHa UK BOT O J HO Hl npoTOBOpellUii B nporpaMMe B Hei npH3HaeTCH HaillicaHa JIIOADMH Y KOTOPblX MeHbIIIe HnJII03Hi OTHOCHTeJIbHO 6y­ 'ITO n eHbl P OJI I IbI OTpa KaTb 3aTpaTbl Ha npoH3BOP CTBO npop yKTa p ymero OHa o6emaeT B OOIDKaHIIIeM 6YAYllIeM He KOMM 'HH3M a CJIep yeT COBeplIleHCTBOBaTb n eHo06pa30BaHHe C TeM 1IT06bl n e­ 3peJIhIii COD HanH3M He npeABemaeTCH B 6JIHlKaHIIIeM Hbl TO'IHee OTp8 KaJIO ypoBeHb 06meCTBeHHO He06xoAHMblX 3aT­ TOJIbKO 6y uymeM H 3aKaT KanHTanH3Ma BblH ' ll eH COUHaJIH3MOM KanHTanH3M BbJ KllBeT YaK KaK HATH Ha ycryI1KH HaPOp y MHorHe HCTO­ paT a TaK Ke Ka'leCTBO npop yKD HH 0 YCJIyr lS Ho nporpaMMa TaK Ke CYJIHT yseJIH'lHTb nOKynaTeJIbHyro cnoco6HOCTb PYOOH 'ITO ECJIH n eHbI OT­ pHlIeCKHe lPaKTbI HCKU eHbI HJIH Bo06me He ynOMHHyThI OTCyTCT­ 03HallaeT cOBepIIIeHHo 06paTBoe CKa3aHHoMY BbIIIIe ByeT KpHTHKa npOIIIJIDIX OIIIH60K H TpareAHii IIpH3HalOTCH HeKOTO­ pa KaIOT 3aTpaTbl Ha npoolBOP CTBO n eHbI Ha npop yKThI DHTaHHs KYJIbT JIH'lHOCTH CTaJIHHa p OJI f Hb1 6bIDH 6bl pe3Ko nOAHHTbCH B nporpaMMe 3TOT aHanH3 CBS ­ BOJIIOHTapHCTCKoe 0 cy6'beKTHBHCTCKHe OIIIo6KO Xpyw eBa Ref ­ pbIe Hep OCTaTKH PYKOBOmrreJIei 3aH C HAeHMH COUHanH3Ma 0 KOMM 'HH3Ma 06 ypoBHe nOTpeooeHHH JIarOnpOHTHble TeH J eHQ HH H TpYAHOcrn C03p aHHbIe Bpe l leBbIM COBeTcKHe pYKOBOmrreJIH BeerAS 06emano 'ITO npoH3BOp CTBO npo­ HO Bee no B npoIIIJIOM H napTHH npoHBJIHH 60JIbIIIeBOCTCKYIO p yKTOB IllITaHHH nOTpe6HTeJIbCKHX TOBapoB 0 yCJIyr 6yp eT yseJIH­ npHHUHIllIanbHOCTb 0 caMOKPHTO'IHOCTb paGoTaeT Hap YCTpaHe­ HHeM 3TOX nOCJIep CTBoi 14 lIHBaTbCH 0 'ITO ypoBeHb KH3HH nOBhICHTCH B COUHaJIHCTH'leCKOi TeopHH 3TH o6emaHHH CBHlaHbl co cnOC06HOCTblO COUHaJIHCTOlleC­ MelK J yHapOAHbIH OTp eJI npOrpaMMbI BanHT Bee HeraTHBHble KOi CHCTeMhI cymeCTBeHHO nOBhICHTb npOp yKTHBHOCTb npOH3BOp ­ MOMeHTbl Ha KanHTan03M H Bee n03HTHBHble 03MeHeHHH accOD HH­ CTBa ero TeXHHlleCKuH ypoBeHb 0 T p TeM CaMhIM CHH KaH npoHl­ pyeT C COQ HaJIHCTHlIeCKHMO CTpaHaMH Me KAYHapo J Hoe nOJIO Ke­ Bop CTBeHHhIe 3aTpaTbi 0 06ecnellHBaH CHH KeHOe n eH HAes npOCTa HHe OillicaHO B QepHo-6eJIblX TOHaX H aHan03Y Hep OCTaeT 06'beKTHB- HO Ha p eJIe npop yKTHBHOCTb npoH3Bop CTBa paCTeT B BblcIIIei CTene­ 214 215 HH Me l lleHHO B CCCP TeXHlflleCKHH nporpecc OTCTaeT OT TaKOBorO C KOHUaMH HH3KOOnnallHBaeMble neHCHOHepbI HHBaJIHAbI B Kamrr3JIHCTHtfeCKHX CTpaHax 3aTpaTbI Ha npoH3BOACTBO nOCTOJlH­ IJ bI HO paCTy-r a nOKynaTeJIbHaJI cnoC06HOCTb py6JIJI OCHOBaTeJIbHO no­ BOHRbl H BAOBbI Ho nOBbImeHHe neH BO MHomx ceKTOpax HeH3· AOpBaHa OO I HO npoeKT YCTaBa 6hID ony6nHKOBaH COBeTCKoe rOCYASpCTBO B 3HaIJHTeJIbHOii CTeneHH cy6cHAH­ pyeT OCHOBHble npoAYKTbI H ycnym xne6 MonOKO KBapmnaTy OTonneHHe 3APaBOOXpaHeHHe 06pa30BaHHe 06w eCTBeHHbIii TpaHC­ nopT neHCHH COIJ HaJIbHble 6JIara H T A 3TO AenaeTCJI BO MHOrHX CTpaHax HO COBeTCKHe PYKoBOAHTeJIH nOIIIJIH AaJIbme CTpamaCb OTCTynHTb OT AOrMbI H CTpeMJICb YCTaHOBHTb P83YMHoe COOTHome­ HHe Me npoH3BoACTBeHHbIMH 3aTpaTaMH H neHaMH cy6cHAH­ PYlOT TOBapbl H ycnyrH He TOJIbKO nepBOH He06xoAHMoCTH OT Ke­ POCHHa meKTpHtfeCTBa nOtfTOBbIX H TenecpOHHbIX ycnyr AO TaKHX npo AYKTOB ITHTamm KaK Macno caxap paCTHTenbHOe Macno HO H neHbI 3a roCTHHHIJ y BOOAYillHble ny-remeCTBHJI TyPH3M TaKCH KHHO TeaTpbI nOJIHTH'IeCKHe H XYAO l eCTBeHHbIe KHHm npeccy H T A rOCYASpCTBO OnnatfHBaeT AOMa H 000cnetfHBaeT ra3 BOror H TeJIeBHAeHHe OOcnnaTHo B pe3ynbTaTe 3TH 6JIara HcnOJIblYlOTCJI He3KOHOMHtfHO H paCTOtfHTenbHO B 30-e rOAbI KorAS ropoACKoe HaceJIeHHe COCTaBJIJlJIO 30­ 40 MJIH tfeJIOBeK 6bIDO OTHOCHTenbHO npoCTO 000cneIJHTb 3TH yc­ nym Ho B 80-x KorAS ropoACKoe HaceneHHe Aocrnrno 180·190 MJIH qenOBeK 3TO CTaJIO tfpe3BbitJaHHO TpYAHoii 38AStfeii EAHHCTBeHHbIM ny-reM npoAOJI I 8Tb TaKHe cy6cuAHH 6bIDO 38MopIDKHBaHHe AOXo­ AOB B HTore B03HHKJIH JIlO60nbITHbIe AHcnponopII HH Ha neHbl pa3HbIX TOBapoB HeKoTopble 6bIJIH HCKycCTBeHHO 3aHH I eHbI HeKO­ Topble HOPMaJIbHbI a HeKoTopbIe B Bblcmeii CTeneHH BblCOKH oAe l ­ AS 06ynh PSAHoo60pYAOBaHHe XOJIOAWIbHHKH lfaCbI M8illHHbl 2 HOJl6pJl1985 r 16 OCHOB­ Hble YCTaHOBKH OCTaJIHCb HeH3MeHHbIMH HO 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI meMeH­ TbI yCHJIHB8lOlIJ He BnaCTh reHepanbHoro ceKpeTapJl npe I HHe nap­ THHRbIe YCTaBhI He YK83hIBaJIH KaK HMeHHO AOJI l eH H36HpaTbCJI reHepanhHbIH ceKpeTapb 3TOT noCT B03HHK HCTOPHtJeCKH H3 opra· HH38IJ HOHHOH He06xoAHMOcrn Bo BpeMeHa JIeHHHa OH 6bIJI rnaBOH napTHH HO He reHepanhHbIM ceKpeTapeM CTaJIHH 6bIJI H rJIaBoii H reHepanbHbIM eeKpeTapeM HO nocne BOHHbI OH ynpa3AHHJI 3TOT noCT XpymeB 6bIJI nepBbIM CeKpeTapeM a nOCT reHepaJIbHOro ceKpeTapJI 6bID BOCCTaHOBneH Bpe I HeBbIM B 1966 r HO 003 H3Me­ Hemm napTHHHOrO yCTaBa B HOBOM YCTaBe THTyn 6hIJI JIer3JIH30­ BaH H paCCMaTpHBaeTCJI KaK npeponTHBa OcpHIJ HaJIbHOrO JIHAepa napnm BnepBbIe 6bIDO npH3HaHO cyw eCTBOBaHHe napTmiHoro aJI­ napaTa npeAhJAYIII He yCTaBbI onpaBAhm3JIH C03ASHHe UK H pemo­ H8JIbHhIX KOMHTeTOB HO He cneIJ HcpHIJ HpoBaJIH CTPYKTyPY H CPyHK­ IJ HH annapaTa o6CJI alOw ero KOMHTeTbI TaKHM 06pa30M MaCca OTAenOB H eeKUHH napTHHHoro annapaTa KOTopbIe He npoCTO cymeCTBOB3JIH HO H pacnOJIaraJIH orpoMHOH BnaCTblO AO CHX nop He 6bIJIH npH3HaHbI CPOPMaJIbHO HOBbIH yCTaB nOHH3HJI ypoBeHb HenpHKOCHOBeHHOCTH qneHOB napTHH nepeA 38KOHOM 3TO Ba I Hoe H3MeHeHHe Ha OCHOBaHHH npeAhIAyw HX YCTaBOB 6bIDO HeB03MO I H0 06BHHHTb qneHa napTHH B yronoBHoM npeCTyUJIeHHH ecnH OH He HCKJIlOtfeH H3 napnm 3TO 6bIJIO peaKIJ Heii Ha CT3JIHHCKHH Teppop KOTAa qneHOB napnm Bee OTHOCJlTCJI K nocneAHeii rpynne B tf8CTO apeCTOBbmaJIH 003 BCJlKHX 06BHHeHHii Ho B HTOre nOJIyqH­ pe3YJIbTaTe COKpaTHJIOCb nOTpe6neHHe AoporHX TOBapoB H B03HHKJIa nOCb TaK tfTO qneHbI napTHH nOA03peBaeMbIe B KOPPYDIJ HH HJIH KaJIbKYJIJlTOPbl H T A - HeXBaTKa CPOHAOB l llJl cy6CHAHpoBaHHJI AemeBbIX rop6atfeBY He nOBe3JIO npH3HaHHe HHCPJIJIIJ HH H nOBbnIIeHHe MHomx pacneHOK HHbIX npeCTyUJIeHHJIX MornH H3OO l aTb cneACTBHJI H CYAa TaK KaK MeCTHbIe KOMHTeTbI napTHH OTK83hIBaJIHCb HX HCKJIlOlIHTb B HOBOM npoH301IIJIH npH HeM a He npH AHAponoBe HJIH lJepHeHKO 3Ta nOT­ yCTaBe TaKaJI HenpHKocHoBeHHoCTb 6bIJIa YHHtfTO l eHa PemeHHe pe6HOCTh B03HHKJIa e AaBHO BHAHMO rop6atJeB c06HpaeTCJI napTHH 06 HCKJIlOtfeHHH ee qneHa CTaJIO 38BHceTb OT pemeHHii opra­ nepeCMOTpeTb 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe npHopHTeTbI H yneJIHtfHTh 3apnnaTy XOTJI 6bI TeM KOMY He06xoAHMbI TOBapbI H ycnyrn H3 Hecy6cHAH­ pyeMoro ceKTopa HanpHMep 3KOHOMHtfeCKHe KHHm HJIH KaJIbKY nJlTOpbI H TeM KOMY nnaTJIT TaK MaJIO tfTO TPYAHO CBOAHTb KOH­ HOB cneACTBHJI H CYAS qneH napTHH npH3HaHHbIH HeBHHOBHbIM He HCKJIlOtfaJICJI Ho 3TO nOJIO l eHHe B TO I e BpeMJl YCHJIHBaeT BJIaCTb KrB H MB J Co CTporo TeopeTHtfeCKOH 38KOHHHtfeCKOH TOtfKH 3pemm HOBbie npaBHJIa BepHbI H npHeMJIeMbI Ho nOCKOJIbKY B COBeTcKoM C0103e HeT He3aBHCHMOCTH 3aKOHa B HTore reHepaJIb­ 216 217 HhIii IC eeKpempb H IIoJIHT6IOpo npH06peJIH ew e 6oJIbmyIO MaCTb HHH AHmKOpp OHHaJl BeB03MO I HOCTb npolr OJ KaHCb 3aTpoHyJIa MecTHhlX napnmHbIX 'llHHOBHHKOB H HeKOTOpbIX 'tJlleHOB UK HaIIpH­ KaMIIaHWI CO ICaJIeHHIO nOXO ICe litO eeii ttac H36paH BroPOH nyTb Ho 000cnetteHHJI AeHCTBHTeJIbHOrO 3KOHOMHlIeCKOro nporpecca 3THMH CpeAcmaMH MO ICeT nOBepuyn rOpGalleBa Ko­ Mep ACaHW ACKapoBa eeKpeTaps 06KOMa B lCa3axcTaBe Bro 06­ tOpbIH nOKa ew e Ka lCetCJI cnOC06eH MeHHth JIHHHIO nOBeAeHHJI BHHHJIH B paCTpaTe 60JIbIIlHX CYMM omyw eHHbIX Ha CTpoHTeJIbCTBO 06rIaiJ aHHe BJIactbIO H3MeHHet lIeJIOBeKa HO rOpGatteB 1IHIIlb B uatta­ AJIJI coopY lCeHHJI qaCTHbIX OXOTHH' IbHX yroAHH H T A 17 Ha AeJIe JIe 3Toro nyTH B KaKyIO CTOPOHy OH 6YAeT H3MeHHTbCJI B JIyqmyIO npHBHJIernH HJIH 'tJlleHOB IIoJIHT6IOpo H eeKpeTapeH 06KOMa HMeTb XYAmyIO - nOKa lCet BpeMJI Qepe3 70 JIet noene peBOJIIOUHH OXOTHHttbH yrOiJ bJl 6bIJIH BBeAeHbI npH Bpe ICHeBe H AeJIO ACKaposa y COBeTCKoro 06w ecma HMeeTCH JIHIIlb o J Ha B03MO ICHOCTb - AOJI lCHO 6bIJIO noen b npeIJ YRpe KlJ eHHeM OCTaJIbHbIM eeKpeta­ AeJITbCJI Ha· pHM 06KOMOB B 06w eM rOpGa1leB BBeJI 01leHb MallO 06w ecmeHHo H nOJIH­ HOBAn IlmInOMATWI IIPH TOR ICE BHEIIIHER IIOnHTHKE TH1IeCKH 3Ha' IHMbIX H3MeHeHHii B TelleHHe CBoero nepBoro rOiJ a npe6bmaHHJI Ha noCTY reHeeKa B nOM CKa3aJIHCb qytbe npo4 ec­ HeKOTopble 3aIIa J Hble iJ HllJIOMaTbI ymepllOJ aIOT litO u eJIH co­ CHOHaJIbHOrO napmiiHoro lIHHOBHHKa nOHHMaIOw ero litO JIH6epa­ BeTCKOH BHeIIlHeH nOJIHTIIKH He MeHHIOTCJI co BpeMeH BTOPOH MHPO­ JIH3aII IDl H AeMOKpaTH3aII IDl MOryT o6epuytbCJI npoTHB ero KaCTbI BOH BOHHbI HJIH co BpeMeH peBOJIIOI J HH litO 3T0 BeeriJ a 0iJ Ha a mK HHTepecbI HOBOH ropGaqeBCKOH KOMaHiJ bI rAe HH llHraqeB u eJIb - 3KCnaHCHJI H MHpOBoe rocnOACTBO O J HH y6e KlJ eHbI liTO 3KCRaHCHH npHcyw a HMeHHO KOMMYHHCTH1IeCKOH HiJ eOJIOfHH H HiJ ee HH Qe6pHKoB HH PbI lCKOB He HMeIOT HH MaJIeHillero lCenaHHJI CAe­ JIaTb cHcTeMY JIHOOpaJIbHee OHH He C03HaIOT lITO HeKOTOpaH CTeneHb MHpoBOH peBOJIIOI J HH IlpyrHe AOKa3bIBaIOt eme 60JIee y6e 1 HTeJIbo il J lJI HecornaCHblX He06xo 1 HMa B HiJ eOJIOrnqeCKOH o6rIac­ HO litO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M npeil IIlecmoBaJI TenepelIIHeMY pe ICHMy TOJIbKO B3aHMOAeHCTBYJI C KaKOH-TO 4 OPMOH Onn03HI J HH ttTO OH 6bIJI npHCYW nOJIHTHKe POCCHiiCKOH HMnePHH Ha'IIHHaH CBo60iJ bI TH litO XV npasmnaH napmJl MO ICeT H36e Tb AOrMaTH3Ma HiJ eOJIornqeCKOrO C 3aCTOH H TeopeTH1IeCKOH 6ecnnOiJ HOCTH CBOHX nOJIHTH1IeCKHX npHH­ npaBHTeJIbCTB He3aBHCHMO OT HiJ eOJIOfHH 18 HeYil HBHTeJIbHO lfrO B liTO 3KcnaHCHOHH3M - OTJIH' IHTeJIbHaH qepTa p y C C K H X UHIlOB OTKJIaiJ bmaHHe ocyw eCTBJIeHHJI nporpeCCHBHblX ua'IIHHaHHH 000 3TH TOttKH 3peHHJI OTpHI J aIOTCH B pa60Tax COBeTCKHX HCTOPH­ B 06w ecmeHHoH H nOJIHTH' IeCKOH o6rIaCTJlx noene BCTynneHHJI KOB OHH OObJlCHHIOT npeApeBOJIIOI J HOHHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO POCCHH KaK rOp6aqeBa B AOJI lCHOCTb n03BOJIJIIOT 60JIee KOHeepBaTHBHbIM me­ 06l eiJ HHeHHe HJIH npeA- H ooenepeBOJIIOI J HOHHYIO 3KCRaHCHIO KaK MeHTaM YKpenHTb CBOH n03HUHH Ho cyw ecmyeT npoTHBope' IHe He06xoiJ HMOCTb 3alI J HTbI HapoAOB A3HH OT 3aIIaiJ a npe KlJ e Beero nOCTaBJIeHHbIMH rOp6aqeBbiM 3KOHOMHqeCKHMH u eJIJlMH OT repMaHHH IIaMJITb 0 repMaHCKOM BTOp ICeHHH H nOCJIeAOBaBilleH Me lCil y H Tpe6yeMoH AJIH HX AOCTH lCeHWI MOAepHH3au HeH Hero nORbITKOH AOCTHttb 3THX u eJIeH HCROJIb3YH Bee H HeAeMOKpamqeCKYIO ry l e nOJIHTHqeCKH Hern6KyIO CHCTeMY B03MO I H0 rOp6atteB ew e He 3a HHM Boii He 1941-1945 rr AO CHXnoponpeAeJIJleT COBeTCKyIO OOJIHTH' IecKYIO MeHTaJIhHOCTb Ha AeJIe reppHTOpHaJIhHaH 3KCnaHCHJI npHcyw a MHOrHM Ha­ npor­ I J HJIM ua npoTJI lCeHHH TbICJlqeJIeTHH Ho 6OJIhlIIHHCTBO Hau HH 3aMe­ peCCHBHbIX H JIHOOPaJIbHbIX 3JIeMeHTOB B napTHH HJIH OH He B COCTOJl­ HlDIH TeppHTOpHaJIbHyIO 3KCnaHCHIO ApymMH ee 4 oPMaMH - 3KOHO­ OC03HaJI HaCTOHTeJIbHyIO He06xo J HMOCTb nOMep ICKH 60JIee MH1IeCKOH H HlJ eOJIOrntteCKoH 3KOHOMHtteCKaH 3KCnaHCHJI H C03Aa­ HHH 3TO CAeJIaTb BCTb iJ Be B03MO I HOCTH C6aJIaHCHPOBaHWI HenonyJIHpHbIX HHe 3KOHOMH1IeCKHX HJIH roproBhIX HMnepHii eCTb HenocpeAcr­ 3KOHOMHlIeCKHX Mep KOTopbIe He06xo J HMO ocyw eCTBHTb IIep­ BeHHhlii pe3ynbrar CROCOGHOCTH HHil yCTpHaJIbHbIX KanHTaJIHCTH' IeC­ BaH - KHX crpaH K HayqHOMy H teXHH' lecKoMY nporpeccy BBHJJY KOBKy­ 3TO JIH6epaJIH3aU HJI H nORbITKa nOJIy' IHTb AeHCTBHteJIbHO 3TO HCnOJIb30BaHHe KOHcepBa­ peHI J HH HaH60JIee rH6KHe H MOw Hble 3KOHOMHlleCKHe CHCTeMbI THBHbIX MeTOAOB YCHJIeHHe JIH' IHOH BJIaCTH HaCHJIHH H orpaHHqe- HaIIpHMep aMepHKaHCKaH HJIH JlROHCKaH CTaJIH JIHiJ HpyIOlI J HMH BceuapoiJ HyIO nOMep ICKY BropaH - 218 219 TaKHMH KaK aMepHKaHCKOe nopa l eHHe BO BheTHaMe COUHarIHCTH­ B MHPOBOH 3KOHOMHKe H J eOJIOr8trecKOH rum nOJIHTH'leCKOH 3KCIIaHCHR 06bI IH0 nO J BepraroTCJI CTPaHbl nepe f HBlIIHe BuyrpeH­ HHH nOJlHTH'leCKuH KpH38C 8 pa3BarI npo J aJl HOH He3q q eKTHBHOH aBTOpHTapHOH rum KOnOHHarIhHOH C8CTeMl l Pa3BarI rum peBOmO­ IJ lUI IaCTO Bhl3bIBaeT J BIDKeHHe K COUHarIH3MY COUHaJIHC'I'H1IeCK8e H J eH CTarIH npHBneKaTenI Hbl B XX BeKe OC06eHHO p JIJI CTpaH 'leCK8e npeo6pa30BaHHJl B Anrone MOJaM68Ke R 3q HOlIHH 8 HH­ TeHcuq HKa1 HJI peBonlOUHoHHbIX J B8 1 eHuH B JIaTHHCKoii AMepHKe Ho nocne KaJI J Oii ycnelllHoii COUHaJIHCTH'leCKOH peBonlOUHH BHOBh B03HHKlllaJI 6paTCKaJI CTpaHa Tpe60BaJIa 3KOHOMH'leCKoii nOMOllUl 8 He Morna HH'lerO npep JIO ICHTb B3aMeH Hecrroco6HoCTb CCCP OKa3aTb XOTb KaKyIO-TO nOMOlI h ronO J alOlI eii 3q HOlIH8 COBeTCKaJI 1I06e J Hee J llII KOTOPbIX 3aIIa J HaJI H J eJl CB060 J Horo MHpa elI e ne laTb He co061I aJIa 0 rono J e 60nee ro J a a Kor J a coo61I eHHJI 60nee yTOJIHIIHB 'leM MapKC8CTCKaJI H J eJl ueHTparIH30BaHHOH 3KOo 06 3TOM nOJlBHnHCb OHH 6bInH RCK8 I eHHbIMH HaRTH nonHTHtreC­ HOMHKR 8 crrpaBep JIHBOrO pacnpe J eneHBJI6nar EcnH paCCMRTpHBaTb coBeTcKym BHellIHlOlO Koe un8 BoeHHoe pellleHHe aq raHCKOrO KOHq nHKTa CBH J eTenhCT­ nonHTHKY no ByeT 06 orpaHH'leHHOCTH COBeTCKoro 3KOHOMH'leCKOrO 8 BoeHHoro 3THM ynpolI eHHbIM CXeMaM OHa npe J CTaBnJleTCJI IaCTH'lHO cne J ­ MOfYIIIeCTBa CTBHeM Booro npo8CXO J JllI ero B MHpe a 'laCTH'lHO HTorOM BHYTpeH­ 1984-1985 HHX HY'K l 8 Tpa 1 HUHH Ecnu nOlIblTaTbCJI cyAHTh 0 HaMepeHHJIX rop­ 6atreBa BO BHelllueii nOJlHTHKe B COOTBeTCTBHH C ox OTpa l eHHeM 3HepreTH'leCKuH Kp838C B BoCTO'lHOii EBpone B rr 6bIn cne J ylOllUIM TpeBO lCHbIM C8MlITOMOM 3aB8CU­ MOCTh CCCP OT KanHTaJI8CTH'leCKHX CTpaH 3ana J a B 06n aCT8 pa3B8­ THJl nepe J oBoii TeXHonorHH 8 nOCTaBOK TaKOX TOBapOB KaK 3epHO B HOBOii nporpaMMe napTHH TO H J eonorn'leCKaJI 3KCnaHUHJI CCCP MftCO caxap H Macno 83-3a HeXBaTKH BHyTpH CTpaHbI TO l e ChIrparIa B 6Y I1 'J UeM J onxma COKpaTHTbCJI no CpaBHeHHlO C TeM 'ITO 06elI arI8 pOJIb B nepeoueHKe npHOpHTeTOB BO BHellIHeii nonuTHKe IIpe J bI J yIUHe lIporpaMMbI O J HH 83 pa3 J enOB HOBOH nporpaMM1 I 1I0CBJlllJ eH TeopHH 6oph6bl Me fC J Y CHnaMH nporpecca 8 peaKUml B03paCTalOII aJI C0103a ynpaBneHHe cnO I HOCTb BHelllHeii BHelllHHX CBJl3eii COBeTCKoro nOJIHTHKoii Ha pa3HhIX ypoBHHX B COBpeMeHHOM MHpe Bce nporpeCCHBHoe accoUHHPyeTCJI C CoBeTC­ J HIInOMaTH'leCKOM KHM C01030M 8 COUHarI83MOM B TO BpeMft KaK KanHTaJIHCTHtreCKuH HOM nonuTH'leCKOM OCYllleCTBneHHe ee uenocpe J CTBeHHO rum 3KOHOMH'leCKOM BoeHHOM pa3Be J bIBaTenb­ MHP H OC06eHHO CllIA o6'bJIBnSeTCJI 8CTO'lHHKOM Booro peaKUHOH­ 'lepe3 nocpe J HHKOB IaCTO 6e3 KOOP J HHauHH Me fC J Y 3THMH ypOBBJI­ HOro Ho lIporpaMMR He co J ep llOfI reHepaJIbHOrO unaHa 6oph6hl MH 83-3a H30JlHpOBaHHOCTH COOTBeTCTBYlOllUIX OT J enOB ceKpeTHOC­ C peaKUHOHHl IMH CHnaMH MHpoBoro HMlIep8aJIH3Ma E J 1IHCTBeHHoe TH 8 61OPOKpaTH3auHH C03 J aJI8 K KOnuy 6pe I HeBcKoii 3pbI cnrya­ SCHOO 3aJmneHHe 0 uenJIX BHelllHeH nOJIHTHK8 - 0 COTpY J HH'leCTBe UHlO B KOTOPOH COBeTCKHH C0103 60nee He Mor n03BonuTb oo6e C COUHaJtHCTH'leCK8MH CTpaHaMH Ha B3aHMOB1 IrO J H0ii OCHOBe pa­ IInaTHTb npe lCHIOlO ueuy 3a CBOlO 8MlIep81O rOCY J apCTB-KnueHTOB J 1I oCYIIIeCTBneHBJI COUHaJIHCT8'leCKOH 3KOHOMHtreCKOii HHTerpauHH OKa3arIOCb cnHIIIKOM MHoro a BbIro J bI - R o6'be J HHeHBJI YcnnHH J 1lJI coBMecrnoro pellleHBJI3a J a'l HCTOPH­ pa3pJI J KH 8 HOBaJI rOHKa Boop eHHii npHBenu K HeraTHBHblM 'leCKoii 3Ha'lHMOCTH - B1 IXO J y Ha nepe J OB1 Ie py6e I H HaYK8 8 Tex­ HHKH 19 Cy J H no nporpaMMe XO J COpeBHOBaHRJI COUHarIH3Ma C KanHTaJlH3MOM B orpoMHoii CTeneH8 3aBHCRT OT ycnexoB C03H J a­ renbHOH J eJITenbHOCTH KaJI J OH CTpaHbl 20 IIporpaMMa TaK lCe 06e­ lI aeT C01lH l llpHOCTh C He J aBHO OCBo60 l1 HBIIIHMHCJI CTpaHaMH H COT­ 21 pY J HH'leCTBO C HHMH HO He HOBym CYIIIeCTBeHuym nOMOlI b K 1985 r COBeTcKOO PYKOBO J CTBO OC03HaJIO 'ITO oc060e nonO ICeHHe CCCP KaK CBepX J ep l aBhI 8 e OCYIIIeCTBneHHaJI H J eonorH'leCKaJI H 1I0nuTH'leCKaJI 3KCnaHCRJI Tpe6ymT O'leHb BhICO­ KHX 3KOHOMHtreCKHX 3aTpaT R npHHOCJlT MaJIO BblrO J bI Bpe I HeBC­ cnHIIIKOM MarIO IIpOBarI nocne J CTB8HM HO COBeTCKuH C0103 ynOpHO OTp8ua eT 'ITO 8HTep­ BeHUIDl B Aq raHHCTaH B B 1980-1981 rr XOTJI 1979 r 8 nonuTH'leCKHH KpH38C B IIonI me 61 1 B KaKOH-TO Mepe cnoc06CTBOBan8YXY l1 ille­ HHlO nono l eHHJI rop6a'leB nyqm e npHcnoco6neH K BHelllHenOnmH'leCKOH J eJITenbHOCTH 'leM ero npe l1 illeCTBeHHHK8 3TO BbIJIBHnOCb BO Bpe­ Mft ero nOcelI eHBJI BpHTaHHH B 1984 r Kor J a OH CTaJI nm6HMUeM 3aIIa J HOH npeccbI KaK nOn8TH'leCKHH J eJlTenb OH npo83Ben Bne laT­ neHHe Ha Bcex nOnHTHKOB 3a rpaHHIl eH HMeBIIIHX B03MO ICHOCTb 6ece J oBaTb C HHM OH OXQTHO B1 ICTynarI Ha npecc-KoHq epeHUIDlx Koe PYKOBO J CTBO rop J HnOCb CB08MH Me IC J yHapO l1 Hl lMH ycnexaMB 221 220 BaJI nOrlAHbIe XOTH He Bcer TOllHble OTBeThI Ocooo cnenyeT PeHraHa C npe JllO l eHHeM 0 BCTpetJe O'HHJI 6bIn OqeHb BnetJameH OTMeTHTb ero BbIHBHBrnylOCH Tor cnOCOOHOCTb OOcy l ll3 Tb WHpO­ rop6a'leBbIM H WHPOKO HpoBanOCb ero BblCKa3bmaHHe lfl'0 KHH Kpyr npo6JIeM ytIHTbmaJI lfl'0 0 1984 r ero OnbIT B ofinacTH rop6a'leB 6hIn 6b1 BeJIHl OneJIHbIM IOpHcrOM BbI J lllOWHMCH a J BO­ BHeWBHX oTHoweHHH ObIn 'OBonbHO orpaHH'leHHbIM Ho HHor OH KaTOM OH Macrep cnoBa MaCTep nOnHTHtJeCKorO H J HJIJIOMaTH'leC­ fibmaeT 'lpe3MepHo caMoyBepeH H nblTaeTC l peWHTb npofineMbl KO­ Koro HCKYCCTBa 24 TOPbIX He 3HaeT TaK rOBopH C cppaHU Y3CKHMH KoppecnOH J eHTaMH o HeM KaK 0 xopoWO HHCPOPMHPOBaHHOM JIH J epe C npeKpaCHbIMH AMepHKaHCKHe HaJIHCTbl TO l e JIHcaJIH Henocpe CTBeHHO nepe CBOHM BH3HTOM BO tl PaH lO OH C J enan MaHepaMH 3HeprH'lHOM TBep OM OCTpoYMHOM H KpOMe Beero nopa3HTenbHoe 3aHDneHHe lfl'0 COBeTCKHe 'OCTIDKeHH l B ofinaCTH npo'lero o6JI lOweM J HC HHHpOBaHHbIM YMOM 25 Ho OHH He npaB laMeTHJIH HHKaKOrO H3MeHeHHH B COBeTCKOH nOJIHTH'leCKOH nHHHH 'lenOBeKa MOryT ObITb ou eHeHbI no 'lHClleHHOCTH paoolJHX co ep H cpe J H enyTaTOB B BepXOBHOM COBeTe TaM CKalan OH HMeeTC l 3aJI BneHH l 60nbwe npe CTaBHTeneH pa60'lero Knacca tJeM Bo Beex napnaMeH­ COBeTCKOH JIHHHH HO npenO J HOCHJIHCb OHH He B OObl'lHOM ne J aHTH'l­ Tax B3HTblX 2 2 HOM COBeTCKOM CTHJIe 26 OHH nOHHMaJIH lfl'0 rop6a'leB B03HeCCH caMOM l e 11 ene BepXOBHbIH COBeT tJaCTO nO J BepraeTCH KpHTHKe Ita BepWHHY BJIaCTH 6JIaro pH CO'leTaHHlO H J eoJIOrH'leCKOrO OrMa­ Ha pa3BHTbIX KanHTanHCTH'leCKHX CTpaH BMeCTe rop6a'leBa ure l e 3JIeMeHThI l eCTKOH la npeo6JI HHe B ero COCTaBe npocpeCCHOHanbHblX napTHHHbIX TH3Ma y6e l J eHHOrO KOMMYHHCTa C HHTenneKTOM nOJIHTH'leCKHM H rOCY J apCTBeHHblX 'lHHOBHHKOB B 1950 r TonbKO 7% enyTaToB MaCTepCTBOM H CHJIOH nH'lHOCTH ObIJIH pa60'lHMH 3TO tIlfCJIO B03POCJIO 0 11% B 1962 r H J O 18% B 1974 r coBMeCTHaJI 0JI l napTHHHblxHrocy apCTBeHHblXolOpoK­ paTOB ObIna COOTBeTCTBeHHO 45 40 H 36% 23 3TO nOKalanO lfl'0 Bo MHOrnx OTHOWeHH lX MOCKBa B 1985 r CTana J HJIJIOMaTH­ tJeCKOH CTonHu eH MHpa IIonHTH'lecKHe JIH J epbl BbICTpaHBaJIHCb B o'lepe J b Ha BH3HT K rop6aqeBY OH 3Han lfl'0 HeKoTopble ero rop6atJeB He 3HaeT lfl'0 Ha 3anaAe 'Il1eHCTBO B napnaMeHTe - pa60Ta l eCTKHe MepbI BHYTpH CTpaHbI oco6eHHo 3KOHOMHqeCKHe H KaMJIa­ 3aHHM3lOwaJI Bce BpeMH napnaMeHTapHH H OH He 3aHHMaeTC l HH l npoTHB nbHHCTBa Bp l J nH C03 J a J yT eMY nonyJIHpHOCTb 'ITO HH'leM pymM TaKHM OOPalOM 6JIeCTmu ne JIHttHble cnOCOOHOCTH JIpo OJI I 3lOWaJI CH K J HJIJIOMaTHH HHor J a npO lBJI lnHCb JIHWb BCJIe CTBHH cnaOOCTH on I HOCTHblX JIHu Ita MecTax H B u eHTpanbHblX MHHHCTepCTBax onnOHeHTOB rop6a'leBa MO l eT BbI3Ban HacTopo l eHHOCTh napTHHHOH 3JIHTbl B TO l e BpeMH PeHraH OCHOBaTeJIbHO rOTOBHJICH K CBoeH BCTpeqe C rop6aqe­ Me l J YHapO J HaJI KaMJIaHH l apeHa npoTHB J aBaJIa eMy KOPpynu HH H CMeWeHHe H J eaJIbHylO B03MO I HOCTh BbIM H 3T0 CKalanOCb nOnO I HTenbHO Ha HHTenneKTyanbHoM ypoBHe npe CTaBHTb ce6H KaK BbI J aIOWerOCH nH J epa MHoro c eJIaBwero HX neperoBopoB I1x nOKa3b1BanH no COBeTCKOMY TeneBH eHHIO JlI l CBoeH CTpaHbl H J 1IH coxpaHeHH l MHpa XOTH OH CTan reHepanb­ COBeTCKHe 3pHTeJIH He BH J eJIH HHtJero nO 'OOHoro co BpeMeH Xpy· HbIM eeKpeTapeM H HaH60nee BJIHHTenbHbIM nHU OM B IIOJIHT6IOPO weBa 3TO Bbl3BanO HHTepec J a I e OObl'lHO anOJIHTH'lHOH COBeTCKOH OH Bee ewe C l B nOMep I Ke ero OCTanbHblX 'Il1eHOB Bee MOJIo e I H 06aHHne rop6a'leBa ero qyBCTBO IOMOpa OblCTpoTa Ba l Hble peweHHJl npe cTaBJIHJIHCb KaK COBMeCTHbIe pe30JIlOlI HH OTBeTOB nOnblTKa HaHTH y6e J HTeJIbHbIe 'OBO J bI H He OqeHb tJaCToe UK oopaweHHe K eMarOrHH B pyr BBeJIH JIH'lHOCTHbIH 3JIeMeHT B npo­ H 3KOHOMHKe He Morno H3MeHHTbC l MrHOBeHHO • THBOCTO lHHe BOCTOKa H 3an 3TO caMe no ce6e cnocofiCTBoBano 6bIJIH rOllbl 6el YBepeHHOCTH OC06eHHO B eeJIbeKOM X03HHCTBe 'ITO YMeHbweHHIO HanpH I eHHH ropfiaqeB lBHO He noxo J HJI Ita qeJIOBe· Booowe 'ITO-TO BblH n eT HHKaKHe JIHlIHbIe J aHHble PYKOBO J HTeJI l He Ka rOToBoro npH nepBOH B03MO I HOCTH C6POCHTb Ita 3a na u HbIe MornH o6ecne'lHTh 6blCTPblH poCT npoH3BO CTBa 3epHOBblX HO CTpaHbI H J epHble 6oMObI H COBeTa MHHHCTpoB IIono l eHHe B eenbCKOM X03 lHCTBe D rr a 3Toro Hy I Hbl CHJIbHble Cl'OPOHbI ero JIH'lHOCTH H nOJIHTH'leCI oe MaCTepCTBO MornH B anpeJIe aMepHKaHCKHe KourpeCCMeHbI nOeeTHJIH COBeTCKHH npHHeCl'H 60raTbIH J HJIJIOMaTH'leCKHH ypo l aH OH OJI I eH ObIn COlO3 H HMenH 'leTblpeXtJaCOByro BCTpeqy CrOp6atJeBblM THJI O'HHJI lCHO C03HaBaTb lfl'0 HMeHHO B 3TOH o6JIaCTH eMY cnenyer C03 Tb CJIHKep Kourpecca CllIA Bpy'lHJI rop6aqeBY JIHCbMO npe3H J eHTa ee6e nonyJIHpHOCTh H KynbT JIH'lHOCTH K TOMY l e BO BHeWHeH 222 223 nOJIHTHKe OH Mor 6hIn YBepeH BO BceoomeH nO J lJ epIKKe BHyrPH IIpo oJI lKeHHe npo3By'IaJI0 KaK TOp lKeCTBeHHoe npoB03rnameHHe erpam I He TOJIbKO no H J eOJIOrHlIeCKHM npHlIHHaM H B cHJIY napTHH­ OOpoH BOJIH COBeTCKoro PYKoBO CTBa HOH JJ HCn mmHH I MHome COBeTCKHe rpa l ll aHe HaOllIO IOT 3a ero H C 3Toro l HJI - xoqy nO 'IepKHyrh - COBeTcKHH COlO3 BhIerynneHIDlMH Ha Me J lJ yHllpop HOH apeHe B 3rOM tmCTO Hrparor BBO l HT MoparopHH Ha pa3BepThmaHHe CBOHX paKer cpep HeH l IIJll ­ POJIb Ha n HOHMbHaJI rop ocn H naTpHOTH3M a TaK lKe TOT pe3KHH HOCTH npHOCTaHaBJIHBaeT ocymecmJIeHHe Kompacr KOTOPhIH npo I BmIJICJI npH CpaBHeHHH rOpOa'IeBa co 0 l HaI 0 OH CTaBHJI YCJIOBHeM 'ITO COeJJ HHeHHhle hImThI OJI lKHhI CO CBoeH CTOPOHhI npeKpaTHTh pa3BepThmaHHe paKeT cpe l HeH l IIJll ­ CKOBaHHbIM H KOCHO ll3hI'II1l IM Bpe lKHeBbIM Bo PYrnx OTBeTHhIX Mep 2 8 BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKe ropoa'IeBY HeoOXOJJ HM OhIJI KOHKpeT­ HOCTH B EBpone COBerCKHH MOpaTOpHH OJI lKeH l JlHrbCJI 0 HOJIo­ HhIH ycuex H 3Ha'IHMhIM ycnexoM MOrJIO 0hIl'b TOJIbKO YJIy'IWeHHe pJI Ha CaMOM eJIe OH He OhIJI CHJIr H n03p Hee PemeHHe 3ro ObIJIO C ChIAo KOHe'IHO 60JIee nonyn JIPHO B BOCTO'IHOH EBpone r e OJI lKHhI ObI­ KJIIO'IeBOH erMa npo6JIeMa rOHKH BoopY lKem XOTJI OHa H He He­ JIH pa3MeCTHTb COBeTCKHe paKeTbI ' eM B ChIAo r e C'IHTaJIH OTHomem C 3anap HOH EBponOH H 'ITO eme Ba lKHee - ' epmmaJIa CJIO lKHoro KOMnJIeKca OTHowem Me lK l y BoCTOKOM 'ITO pa3BepThmaHHe aMepHKaHCKHX paKer eCTh peaKUHJI Ha y lKe H 3ana o OM BTopoe Mecro 3aHHMaJI AqlrlulHCraH na npo6JIeMa HMeBmee Mecro COBerCKoe HapalUHBaHHe CHJI KaK MO lKHO ObIJIO HrpaeT POJIb H BO BHyrpeHHeH H BO BHelliHeH nOJIHrHKe BOHHa npe l BH J eTb ChIA omeprJIH npe ll llO lKeHHe 0 3aMOpa lKHBaHHH Ha TOM 3aTJIHyJIac OHa Y lKe Il IlHTCJI HaMHoro OJIhwe 'IeM BeJIHKaJI OTe­ OCHOBaHHH 'ITO TO COXpaHHT COBerCKoe npeHMYlUecmo H 'ITO npe ­ 'IecmeHHaJI BORHa H KO He BH J HO STO C03 aBaJIO H nOJIHTHlIee­ JIO lKeHHe CCCP HMeer UeJIhlO BOHTh KJIHH Me lK l y ChIA H HX eBpo­ KHe H BoeHHhIe 3aTpyp HeHHJI BbDlH H pyme npo6JIeMhI - neHCKHMH COI03HHI aMH B tmCTHOCTH C'IHraJIOCh 'ITO OHO nOBJIHJIeT KmaH lfH l wI IIaKHeraH BJIH lKHHH BOCTOK Kyoa HHKaparya AHrOJIa Ha IO lKHaJI Aq pHKa BberHaM H KaMny'IHJI BORHa B IIepcH J cKoM 3a­ OJI lKHO ObIJIO O Th pa3peIIIHTh JIH pa3MemeHHe JIHBe - TbIX HO HH O l Ha H3 3THX npo6JIeM He OhIJla HeOTJIO lKHOH ECJlH peweHHe rOJIJIaH l CKOrO npaBHTeJIbCTBa Koropoe B HOJIOpe paKeT Ha reppHTOpHH HH epJIaH l OB 48 KphIJIa­ peweHHe npHH IIToe rOpOO'IeB XOTeJI YCKopHrh 3KOHOMH'IeCKOe pa3BHTHe rJIaBHOH 3a­ n03 lKe OKa3aJIOCh KOMnpoMHcCHhIM - u a'IeH ero l HIIJlOMaTHH OJI lKHO OhIJlO CTaTh YMeHhweHHe 3aTpar HHe KphIJIaThIX paKer npH YCJIOBHH cOKpameHHJI pymx BH J OB Ha I BHelliHeH nOJIHTHKH 'ITO 03Ha'IaJI0 cymecmeHHoe COKpa­ BOOpy lKeHHJI • eHHe BoopY lKem OhIJIO pa3peweHo pa3Meme­ BeceHHee l HIIJlOMarHlIecKoe paCUHCaHHe ropoa'IeBa He OhIJlO CTpaTerHIO ropoa'IeBa OhIJIO HeTpyp HO npe CK83aTb B Ha'IaJIe HeO lKH J aHHbIM B anpeJIe OH OTIIpaBHJICJI nO l IIHcaTh COrJIameHHe 0 20 anpeJIJI OhmmHH npe3H J eHT ChIA PHtJap HHKCOH c eJIaJI TaKoe npo ll lleHHH BapwascKoro OrOBOpa eme Ha npe CKa3aHHe raM B HanpJI lKeHHOM oOcy l ll eHHH npo'IHX npo6JIeM BXOWIlUHX JIer H yqacmOBaJI rJIaBHaJI npo6JIeMa rOpOa'IeBa BHyrpH CTpaHhI - 3KOHOMHKa B OpraHH3a n H1O BapWaBCKOrO OrOBOpa erpaH lImI MHorHX BOCTOq­ B 3TOH o6JIaCTH 3ana CHJIeH H OH Hy lK Il aeTCJI B HameH nOMomH HoeBponeHcKHx JIH J epOB TO OhIJlO nepBoH B03MO lKHOCThlO YBH en EMY HY lKH0 3a60THTbcJI 0 BOerO'IHOH EBpone H pyrnx CIpaHax ero nOCJIe noxopoH qepHeHKo B Mae npeMhep-MHHHCrp HH l HH Jho6aJI I OJIOHHJI COBeTCKoro Pa l KHB raH l H HaHeC o PHUHaJIbHhIH BH3HT B MOCKBY XOTJI rOpOa­ BXO l JIlUHX B COBeTCKYIO HMDepHIO COI03a - 00y3a H rpeoyer MarepHaJIbHOH nO J lJ epIKKH 27 'IeB H XoreJI CHH3HTh paCXO hI Ha COBeTCKoe BMewareJIhcmo 3a rpa­ rOpOa'IeB c eJIaJI nepBhtH XO l aB TpaJJ HD HOHHoe HHTepBhlO HHueH HH l HJI ObIJIa Ba lKHhIM py lKecmeHHhIM rocy pcmoM B IO lK­ HeHa3BaHHOMY pe KTOpy • rrpaB l hI OHO OhIJIO OnyOJIHKOBaHO HOH AlHH H COJIH J HhIM HMDOprepoM COBeTCKoro npoMhWIJIeHHOrO 8 HCnOJIh30BaJI CTaH l aPTHyIO q 0PMYJIHPOBKY 'ITO o60pY OBaHHJI H BOOpy lKeHHH Ho HHJJ HJI HMeJIa orpHuaTeJIhHhIH oa­ Me lK l yHapop Hhle OTHOWeHHJI onpe eJIJlIOTCJI cymeCTBOBaHHeM l Byx JIaHC B rOprOBJIe C COBeTCKHM COI030M H Hy lK l aJIaCb B nepHO l H­ anpeJIJl OH pa3JIH'IHhIX oomeCTBeHHhIx CHCTeM H 'ITO OCHOBOH 3THX OTHowem ' eCKHX 3aHMax BbIJIO nO l IIHCaHO HeCKOJIhKO cornameHHH 0 Koro­ JIBJIJleTCJI MHpHOe cocymecmoBaHHe COAHaJIH3Ma H KaDHTaJIH3Ma phIX coo6mHJIa COBeTCKaJI npecca O D HaKO He COOOmaJIOCh 0 npe oe­ 224 225 TaBJIemm HH lJ HH 3aHMa B pa3Mepe 1 MJIPA 200 MJIH AOJIJIapoB raHa COCTOM B npHrJIaIlleHHH COBeTCKHX Cneu HaJIHCTOB npHcyrCTBO­ AeTaJIH 0 KpeAHTax H CPH­ BaTh Ha HAepHhIX HCnhIT3 HH JIX B HeBa l e fop6a'leB OTBepr 3Ty HaHCOBOH nOMonm He ny6nHKYIOTC JI H He Tpe6YIOT OA06peHHH Bep­ MelO H npoB03rJIaCIDI O J HOCTopoHHHii rutTHMeC JI'lHhIii MopaTopHii XOBHoro COBeTa Ha Bee JI J epHhIe HcnhITaHHH Ha'lHHaH C aBrycTa B 40-10 rOAOBIUHHy B 3TOM He 6hIJIO HHtlero He06hJ tIHOrO - OCHOBHhle J HnJlOMaTHqeCKHe C06hITH JI ro J a HaMe'laJIHCh Ha pa3pYIlleHHH XHPOCHMhI aTOMHOH 6oM60ii OH He cAeJIaJI HHKaKorO oeeHh IIepBhIM 6hIJI OCPHInlaJIhHhIH BH3HT fop6aqeBa BO DpaHll HIO xreCTa A06poH BOJIH B o6nacTH npaD qeJIOBeKa XOTH Mor KOe-'lIO npe n n O lKHTh B Ha'laJIe OKT JI6p JI 3a KOTOPhIM B KOHlJ e Toro xre MeC JIml AOJI I Ha 6hIJIa nOCJleAOBaTh BCTpeqa Ha BblcweM ypoBHe B COCPHH y laCTHH­ KOB BapIllaBCKOrO AorOBopa H B HO JI6pe - BCTpeqa Ha BbICIlleM XeJIhCHHKCKHe COrJIaWeHHH npe J ycMaTplIBaJIH COBMeCTHhle peIlleHHH no paCIIIHpeHHIO 06MeHa HHcpopM lu HeH lIH'lTo He npoTIIBo­ ypoBHe C npe3HAeHTOM PeHraHOM B l eHeBe BHHM3 HHe Beero MHpa pe'lHT 3THM pe30JIIOIJ H JIM 6oJIee qeM npaKTHKyeMoe B CCCP rJIYIlle­ 6h1JIO cocpeAOTO'leHO Ha nOCJle J HeH BCTpeqe Ho cnepBa fopGaqeB HHe nepeAaq BH-BH-CH foJIoca AMepHKH HeMeIJ KOH BOJIHbI AOJI lKeH 6hIJI ccpopMHpOBaTh CBOIO KOMaH J y no BHeIllHeH nOJIHTH­ H nOA06HhIX HM pa J HOCTaHIJ HH BemRlOnmX Ha PYCCKOM H APyrHX Ke BhIJIH 3aMeHeHhl MHome nocnbl HO rJIaBHhIM C06bITHeM 6hIJIO JI3hIKaX HapOAOB CCCP BOJIee Toro rJIYIlleHHe npoH3BO J HMoe Hec­ nOBblIlleHHe fPOMhIKO AOJIhIlle Bcex B MHpe 3aHHMaBIllerO noCT KOJIhKHMH ThICH'laMH cneu HaJIhHO n n JI 3Toro C03AaHHhIX nepeAaT­ MHHHCTpa HHOCTPaHHhIX AeJI Hero 3aMeHa lIIeBap J Ha l 3e COBepIlleH­ 'lHKOB 06XO J HTC JI COBeTCKOMY npaDHTeJIhCTBY B H3pHAHYlO CYMMY HO HeH3BecTHoro BHe CCCP Ha caMOM AeJIe HeOnblTHOCTh lIIeBapA­ AeHer HH BayrPH CCCP HH BOBHe rJIYIlleHHe HHKOMY He HPaBHTC JI Ha J 3e BO BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKe 6h1JIa BhIrO J Ha eCJlH HaMe'laJIHCh nOCKOJIhKY H3MeHeHHH B 3TOH nOJIlITHKe BhIJIH H APyrHe Ha3HaqeHH JI Ha PYKo­ Hax XOTH HHorAa rJIYIlleHHe npeKpamaJIH HanpHMep C 1954 r AO BOA JInme AOJI I OCTH B o6naCTH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH HHKOJIaH IIa­ BTOp lKeHHH COBeTCKHX T3 HKOB B BYAaDeWT B 1956 r 3aTeM B IllYM MewaeT CJlYIllaTh Bce nepe J a'lH Ha KOPOTKHX BOJI­ TOJIHqeB MHHHCTp-BeTepaH BHeIllHeii TOprOBJIH 33 HHMaBIllHH 3TOT 1960 r H B nepHO J bI oCJIa6JIeHHH HaIIp JI KeHHOCTH B 70-hIe rO r TPI noCT C 1958 r 6bIJI OTCTaBJIeH H 3aMeHeH BOPHCOM APHCTOBhIM OHO CTaJIO oc06eHHo HHTeHCIIBHhIM H 3cJ cpeKTIIBHhIM B 80'ble ro­ COBeTCKHM nOCJlOM B IIOJIhIlle C 1978 r 3TO MHHHCTepCTBo 3aHH­ MaeTC JI npeH eCTBeHHo TOprOBJIeH C KanHTaJIHCTHqeCKHMH CTpaHaMH COBeTcKHii nOCOJI Ha Ky6e KOHCTaHTHH KaTYIlleB 6bIJI r TPI fOAOBIUHHa XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIameHHii npeACTaBJI JlJIa HAeaJIh­ HYIO B03MO l OCTh npoAeMOHcTpHpoBaTh npeKpameHHe nOJIHTHKH nopo lKAeHHOH napaHoiieii fop6a'leB ynyCTIDI 3Ty B03MO I HOCIb OT03BaH B OCKBY H Ha3HaqeH npeAee J aTeJIeM fOcY J apCTBeHHoro H HHKTO Hi 3ana l e He yKalaJI eMY Hi TO 'lT0 rnyIlleHHe HapywaeT KOMHTeTa no BHeIllHHM 3KOHOMH'leCKHM CB JI3 J1M KOTOPhIii 33 HH­ AYX XeJIbCHHKH MaeTC JI TOprOBJIeH C COu HaJIHCTH'leCKHMH CTpaHaMH PaHee KaTYIlleB 6bIJI BH J HOii CPHrypoii OH 6hIJI ceKpeTapeM 3aMeCTHTeJIeM npeAee J aTeM COBeTa UK B 1972-1977 rr MHHHCTpoB H COBeTCKHM BCTpe'lH fopGaqeBa C 3ana J HhIMH JIHAepaMH nocne HeCKOJIh­ KHX MeC JIIJ eB ero npe6hIB3 HH JI B AOJI lKHOCTH He J aJIH HH MaJIeHwe­ ro YKalaHH JI Ha H3MeHeHHH B COBeTcKoii BHewHeii noJIHTHKe BhIJIH npeACTaBHTeJIeM B COBeTe 3KOHOMH'leCKoii B3aHMOnoMonm Ero CAeJIaHhI HOBhIe npe n n O lKeHHH 0 pa30pY lKeHHH HO OHH 6hIJIH TaK CqHTaJIH B03MO lKHhIM npeeMHHKoM KOChIrHHa Ha nOCTY npeAce J aTe­ TeCHO CBH3aHhl C Tpe6oB3 HHHMH npeKpameHHH nporpaMMhl 3Be3A­ M COBera HHHCTPOB HO OH JIHlllIDIC JI nOCTa Me lK J yHapO J HOH 3Ha­ 'lHMOCTH B 1980 r H 3aMeCTHJI BOpOTHHKOBa Ha Ky6e B 1982 r HhIX BoiiH IDIH npaDIDIhHee nporpaMMhI B paMKax CTpaTernqeC­ KOH 060POHHOii HHHInlaTlIBhI 'lIO AOCTHxreHHe COrJIaIlleHHii 6blJI0 IIpa3 J HOBaHHe 1O-oii rOAOBIl UlHhI XeJIhCHHKCKHX corJIaIlleHHii MaJIOBepOHTHhIM XOAIDIH cnYXH 0 B03MO lKHOCTH B0306HOBJIeHHH B aBrycTe npeAoCTaBIDIO 06eHM CTopoHaM B03MO l OCTh CAeJIaTh J HnnOMaTHqeCKHX OTHOIlleHHii C H3paIDIeM HO Ha AeJIe JIeTOM co­ JIH6epaJIbHhIe lKeCThl B Ha'laJIe aBrYCTa 35 AeJIerau Hii C06paJIHCb BeTCKaH aHTHCHOHHCTCKaH nponaraH J a YCIDIIDIaCb CaMOH cepbe3­ B CPHHCKOii CTOJIHlJ e Ha TpeX J HeBHoH KOHcpepeHIJ HH HeH36e lKH0 HOH npo6neMoH BHeIllHeH nOJIHTHKH OCTaBaJICH AcpraHHCTaH IIpH­ AOJI lKHhI 6hIJIH o6cY K J aThc JI npo6neMhI npaD qeJIOBeKa l eCT Peii­ CYTCTBHe B AcpraHHCTaHe eeMH HJIH BOChMH J IIBH3HH 120 TbIC qeJIO­ 226 227 BeK 6bIJIO rJIaBHOH nOMeXOH BO BHeWHeH nOJIH1'HKe BOPbGa TaM mrreHCH pHIlKpoBaJlaCb C Mapra H He06xoAHMbI 6bmH HOBbie HHH­ IlKaTHBbI H npennO KeHHH BOHHa taKoro poA3 He MOJICeT npoAOJI­ Jl 8TbCH 6ecKoHelffiO CeMH HJIH A3 JlCe AeCHTH AHBH3HH 6bmO HeAOCTa­ TO'IIHO ll lIH COXpaHeHHH B CTpaHe 3 P peKTHBHOH OKKynamm RarepH 6eJICeHUeB rAe HaxoAHIlHCb OKono 5 MllH 'IenOBeK CTanH HAeanbHOH CpeAOH nnH BOCnHTaHHH MOnOAi IX 60HU OB 3a HCJIaM CHryaIlKH 3Ta BeCbMa CXOAHa C HCIIhITaHHOH H3paHJleM B CBH3H C naneCTHHCKHMH 6eJICeHCKHMH narepHMH B HOPAaHHH CHpHH H flHBaHe HO OKa3anOCb elD e CJIOJICHee C03AaTb xopomo o60PYAOBaHHylO Harnyxo 38 KpbI­ tyIO norpaHHlJHYIO 30Ry BOKpyr 6onbmoro ropHcToro H peAKO Hace­ neHHoro A praHHCTaHa lloxoJICe 3Ta npofiTIeMa He HMeeT pemeHHH COBeTCKoe BTOpJICeHHe B llaKHCTaH no aHaJIorHH C H3paHJIbCKHM BTOpJICeHHeM B RHBaH B 1982 r He 6bIJIO 6bI npHBneKaTeJIbHl IM TaK KalC MOfno 6b1 npHBeCTH IC 60JIbmOH BoiiHe B paiioHe 1C0TOPbIH YJlCe eeii'lac TpYAilO KOHTponHpoBaTb OnaCHOCTb 6bIJIa B TOM 'ITO rOpGa'leB cofiTIa3HHTCH npHHHTb BoeHHoe pemeHHe He nonbITaB­ WHCb HaiiTH nOJIHTH'IecKHii BblXOA KaK npeACKa3bman KHcCHHAJICep B 1978 r 'ITO B03MOJICHO HOBoe nOKoneHHe COBeTCICHX PYKOBOAH­ TeneH 6YAeT CB060AIloo OT COMHeHHH B BepHOCTH CBOHX pemeHHH H nOCICOJIbKY Y HHX He 6YAeT KOMnneKca HenOJIHOD eHHOCTH OHH MOryr nOBepHTb B TO 'IeM XBacralOT H MOryr BCJIeACTBHe 3Toro 0ICa3aTbCH MHoro onaCHee 29 HeoJICHAaHHoe B03B eHHe MapI1IaJIa OraplCOBa H BbIXOA ero KHHrH HCTOPHH yqHT 6AHTeJIbHocTH B HIOHe Ka3aJlHCb npH3HaKaMH ero pea6HJlHTaD HH OJICHAaJIOCb 'ITO ero Ha3Ha'laT rJIaBHOICOMaHAYlO­ ID HM CHJlaMH BapmaBCKOrO AorOBOpa HO GbIJIO paBHO BepoHTHO 'ITO OH craHeT BoeHHbIM COBeTHHlCOM rOpGa'leBa 06bI'llHO reHepanb­ Hl Iii eeKpeTapb HMeeT JIH'llHbIX BoeHHblX COBeTHHKOB HO HX HMeHa He OTlCpbmalOT BpeJICHeB 60nbme 'IeM BeeM APYTHM AOBepHJl reHe­ pan-nOJIICOBHHlCY KOHCTaHTHRy rpymeBOMY npHHTeJIIO BpeJICHeBa co BpeMeHH HX CtyAeH'IeCKHX AIleH B 1lHenpoAlepJlCHHCKe H KOJIJIe­ re no 1lHenponeTpoBCKOMY OGKOMY rpymeBoH OCTanCH B apMHH nOCJIe OKOH'laHHH BOHHbI CTaB Ha'laJIbHHKOM nOJIHTOTAena MOCKOBC­ Koro BoeHHoro oKpyra Ero TeCHaH CBH3b C BpeJICHeBbIM CTana O'leBHAilOH TonbICO nOCJIe CMepTH rpymeBoro B 1982 r KOrA3 OH Heo O 6bm noxopoHeH Ha KpacHoH nnOID aAH Y BpeJICHeBa 6bIJI TaKJlCe COBeTHHK no paKeTaM COnpOBOJICA8BWHH ero Ha nepero- BOPbI no orpaHH'leHHIO CTpaTefH'leCKHX BOOpyJICeHHii rOpGaqeBY HyJICHa GYAeT rpynna 60nee Mono rw x BOeHHl lX COBeTHHlCOB 'lTOGbI HMeTb cBeJlCHii B3rJIHA Ha COBeTCKoe BoeHHoe npHcyrCTBHe B MHpe OrapKoB 3HepJ1flffibIH H pa3GHpalOlD HHCH B TeXHHKe MapmaJI CMe­ lD eHHbIH tIepHeHKo GbIJI 3aMellaTeJIbHl IM KaHAHA3 TOM Il lIH p0PMH­ poBaHIDi TaKOH rpynRbI B03MOJl HO BoeHHbIe COBeTHHKH rOpGaqeBa H npennaraJIH yCHJlHTb BoeHHYlO alCTHBHOCTb B A praHHCTaHe B 1979 r rJIaBHOH u enblO BpeJICHeBa B A praHHcraHe GbmO 06e30naCHTb KaGyn Apyrne KpynHbIe ropoA3 H Bee AOporH H KOMMYHHKaD HH B Te'leHHe rom HJlH l ByX 3Ta taKTHKa 0ICa3aJ1aCb O'leHb ycneWHoH B tIeXOCJIOBaKHH B 1968 r Ho B A praHHCTaHe OHa nopoAHIla 3aTHJICHyIO napTH3aHC­ KylO BOHHy Ha HCTOlD eHHe H MHJl1IHOHl I 6eJICeHUeB H3 eeJIbCKOH MeCTHOCTH AHAponOB oTAena 6e30naCHoCTH - OAoGPHJl paClIIHpeHHe MOryID eCTBeHHoro KXA Il a praHCKOH C1IyJlC6bI roc6e30naCHoc­ TH nOCTpoeHHOH no 06pa3D y KrB H HMeBmeH cneIlKanH3HpoBamu Ie oT60pHble norpaHH'lHbIe 'laCTH KXAll 38Bep60BaJI MHOfHX HOBbiX areHTOB H HX npoHHKHOBeHHe B CHJlbI conpoTHBJIeHHH YCHJlHJlOCb rpynRbI KXA Il A3 JlCe C03AaBaJlH napTH3aHCKHe OTPHAbI 'lT06bl BbI3BaTb HeAoBepHe MeCTHOro HaceneHHH K CORpoTHBJIeHHlO H nopo­ AHTb nOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb B u ensx AeMopanH3auHH pa3beAHHeHHbIX CHJl conpoTHBneHHH TeXHHlCa HH pHJlbTpaD HH ycnemHO HCnOJIb3o­ BanaCb npoTHB HHaKOMbIC1IHlD HX B CCCP H BHeCJIa CBOH BK1I8A B npou ecc HOPMaJIH3auHH B tIexoC1IOBaKHH KorA3 tIepHeHKO HaC1IeAOBan AHAponOBY OH AoGaBHJl CBoe B 3TOT penepryap - C03­ A8HHe HaPOAilOH MHJlHIlKH HapHAY C peryJIHPHOH a praHCKOH apMHeH TaK KaK HaeeneHHe npoTHBHJlOCb CJIyJIC6e B peryJIHpHbIX llaCTHX apMHH HaAeH1IHCb 'ITO MHJIHU eHCKHe llaCTH OKaJlCytCH 3aMemrreneM cnocoGHbIM a praHH3HpoBaTb KOH pJIHKT rOp6a'leB CTan HacrynaTb H Ha BoeHHOM H Ha nOJIHTJlTleCKOM PpoHTax BHOBb C03A3 HHOe B a praHCKOM npaBHTenbCTBe MHHHCTep­ CTBO no AenaM HC1IaMa HCKaJlO nyreH CMHfl eHHH KOH pJIln ta MeJICAY HCJIaMOM H MapKCH3MOM 6hVIH BOCCTaHOBneHbl COBeThl CTapeii UIHH B paHOHax npoJiCHBaHHH nneMeH H OAIlOBpeMeHHO 6bI1IH paClIIHpeHbI BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH liHTeHcHBHeH qeM paHee CTaJIH MHHHpoBaTb norpaHH'llHble AoporH H 06b1'IIHbIe apMeHCKHe coeAH­ HeHHH 6bI1IH 3aMeHeHhl COBeTCKHMH 'laCTHMH THna KOMaHAOC YCHJlHJlOCb A8B1IeHHe Ha llaKHCTaH 'lT06bI npeKpaTHTb nOCTaBKH 228 229 nonyaBTOHOMHOH CHDbHO BoeHH3HpoBaHHOH 30HOH KOTOPyro OP ' KWI rpymJaM conponmneHH fJ H B anpene YlIRCTHJIHCb 60MOOP­ n HpoBKH naKHCTaHCKOH TeppHTOpHH 30 B COBeTCKOH nellRTH CTanH naKHCTaHCKaH 6om me DHcaTb 0 6oHX npHMo YKasbIBaH Ha aMepHKaHCKOe BMema­ H KOTOpaH B TelJeHHe MHOfHX neT JlBnHeTCH HCTOlIHHKOM HeCTa6HOb­ TenbCTBO HOCTH B Aq raHHCTaHe HrpaH ponb aHanorHlIHoH TOH KOTOpylO Cblr­ CTaTbH B lhBeCTruIx HanpHMep ymep lJ aJIa trIO apMHH He Mox eT 34 q eKTHBHO KOHTponHpoBaTb TOnbKO B ITemaBape no MeHbmeH Mepe 200 aMepHKaHCKHX A06po­ pan lJ JIH BbeTKoHra CeBepHbIH BbeTHaM BoeHHbIe AeHCTBHH CCCP B BonbueB nepeoAen lx aq raHCKHMH nOBCTaHUaMH npHHHManH yqae­ THe B 6oHx 31 nenanHCb nonblTKH nooynHpH3HpOBaTb BOHHy Aq raHHCTaHe KOHellHO He npeAalOTCH rnaCHOCTH C TaKOH ooo eKnm­ Hcnonb3YH nOA1 eM naTpHOTH3Ma B CBH3H C copoKaDeTHeM no6eAbl B EBpone CTanH DHcaTb KaK 0 repoHX 0 COD l aTaX rOTOBbIX nox epT­ C APyroH CTOPOHbI CCCP HMeeT Kyna MeHbmyIO MeX AYHapoAHylO BOBaTb co60H 3a PO l Hy1O CTpaHY ITo COBeTCKOMY TeneBH l eHHlO HeCKonbKO pas nepeAanH cueHbI 6HTB trIO 6bIDO 6ecnpeu eIl eHT­ 30BanHCb ClJIA B HOCTblO KaK AeHCTBKJi CDIA BO BbeTHaMe OCBelUanHCb B AMepHKe nO l Aep l l y npaKTHlIeCKyro H MOpanbHyro lJeM Ta KOTOPOH nonb­ 1963-1973 rr BOHHa B Aq raHHCTaHe HMena eepbe3Hble noeneACTBruI ADH HbIM 32 XOTH fop6aqeB yrBepX Aan trIO OH npeAIIOllHraeT nOnHTH­ COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro HCTa6nHlliMeHTa BblHCHHnOCb trIO TPYAHO qeCKOe pemeHHe Bonpoca 6bIDO noxox e trIO OH HaMepeH 6bICTPO BeCTH npoAOOX HTenbHyIO BOHHy ManbIMH CHDaMH TonbKO CnOMOlUblO 33 KOHllHTb BOHHy BOeHHbIMH cpeACTBaMH ITO-BHAHMOMY nOJlBH­ HOB06pauueB B nOCb HaMepeHHe co3AaTb BoeHH3HpoBaHHYIO 30Hy BAonb rpaHHUbI CPOllHHKH C ITaKHCTaHOM nOA06HylO cyrueCTBYlOlUeH Me CCCP H KHTaeM H connaTbI H MOaAlllHe oq HUepbl YlIRCTByroT B 60ax BnnOTb AO OKOH­ apMIDI WIHTenbHoH Bowe yqaCTByroT COD l aTbI-Aonro­ nOCTeneHHO npH06peTaeT q POHTOBOH ORbIT BOHHbI ApMIDI MHpHOrO BpeMeHH COCTaB KOTOPOB nOCTOHH­ HOH IfPaHOM If306paX eHHe BOHHbI B Aq raHHCTaHe KaK MeCTa 6oe­ qaHH f BbIX nO l BHrOB 6bIDO nepBblM marOM nOAl OTOBKH HaeeneHHH K YCH­ HO 06HOBnHeTCH Ha AonrHe nepHO l bl Mox eT COXpaHHTb nHllIb orpa­ neHHIO COBeTCKoro BMemaTenbCTBa CnyxH 3a Py6eX OM B TeqeHHe HHqeHHbIH KOHTHHreHT ODbITHblX KaIl poB ConnaTbl AeMo6HDH3yroT­ neTa trIO fOpOOlJeB B03MOX HO 06 l yMbIBaeT nocTeneHHbIH OTBOA CH nocne AByxneTHero cpOKa Cl'IyX 6bl KpoMe TOro HaeeneHHe COBeTCKHX BOHCK qT06bl BblCB060 l HTb cpeACTBa lJ JIH BHyTpemmx Y3HaeT 0 BOHHe Bee 60nbllle H3 cnyxOB H paCCKa30B OlJeBH l UeB peq oPM 33 npeyseDHlIHBaDH 3KOHOMHqeCKHe noeneACTBruI BOHHbI If BOHHa CTaHOBHTCH Bce MeHee H MeHee nooynHpHoH CoBeTcKoe Macmra6bI BoeHHbIX onepanHii HeBenHKH lJ JIH COBeTCKOH apMHH a PYKOBOACTBO nOnHTHqeCKaH ueHa pemeHH fJ eenH 6bl OHO BbIfJUIAenO KaK nopa­ B3HTb 10-20 AHBHlHH npoq eccHOHanbHbIX COnAllT AOCTaTOllHO 06y­ OKa3anOCb nepeA cnoX Hoii npo6neMoH OTKyAll x eHHe lJ JIH fopOOqeBa 6bIDa Kyna BbIllIe IJeM lJ JIH AHAponOBa qeHHblX lJ JIH HaCTOHlUHX cpaX eHHii He06xo n HMo 6bIDO 3aMeHHTb H qepHeHKO E l HHCTBeHHO npHeMOeMblM lJ JIH fop6aIJeBa C nOOHTH­ u enHKOM nOnHTHlJeCKHB nO l XOA COBeTcKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH l OBa­ qeCKOH TOllKH 3peHruI 6bIDO 6bl coxpaHeHHe MapHOHeTOllHoro aq HH fJ B TO BpeMH KaK apMIDI nOBCTaHD eB COBepmeHCTByeTcH H Ae­ raHCKOrO npaBHTenbCTBa npH COKpalUeHHOM npHcyrCTBHH COBeTe­ naeTC fI Bee 60nee npoq eCCHOHanbHOB B COBeTCKOB apMHH OlJeHb KHX BOHCK B Aq raHHCTaHe BOHHa B Aq raHHCTaHe Aoporo 06XO J HllaCb H ClIIA TonbKO B HH30K MOpanbHblH ypoBeHb H HOB06paHUbl nnoxo nOAl OTOBneHbI K UPY 470 MOH AonnapoB Ha 06y­ Bce 60nee H 60nee enOX Hoe opYX He H orpaHHlJHBalOTC fI Hanall eHH fl­ IJeHHe 6oHuoB aq raHCKOrO conponmneHHH H o6ecneqeHHe HX opY­ MH Ha cTpaTerHlJeCKHe ueHTpbI H peHnaMH AecaHTHHKOB CoBeTCKo­ 1985 r KOHrpecc ClJIA aCCHfHOBaD TaKOMY moy BOBHbI B HTore COBeTCKHe BoeHHbIe CHObI npHMeHHIOT X HeM 34 qacTb BoopyX eHH fJ nOCTaBMeMOrO Hl ClJIA He Aomna AO MY DapTH3aH napm3aHCKaH BOBHa C HcnaMCKHMH q YHAiMeHTanHCTaMH MHoro OHO AOCTanoCb naKHCTaHCKOH apMHH · BpaX AYIOIUHM Me co60H UDeMeHaM B norpaHHlIHbIx paHOHax HOH ToproBua M BoeHHoMY KOMaH l OBaHHIO CTaHOBHTC fI Bee 60nee fICHO trIO TpYAHee qeM OHH OX HAanH HapKOTHKaMH KOTopble JlBnHlOTCH CeHIJaC OCHOBHblMH nOCTaBlUHKa­ KaK H3BeCTHO fop6alleB C03 l an CDeD HanbHylO KOMHCCHIO MH ODHYMa H repoHHa rnaBHbIM 06pasOM Ha 3ana DIHPOKaH COBeTHHKOB no HenaMCKHM AenaM KOTOpaH AOnX Ha AOKna l bIBaTb norpaHHlIHaH nonoca MeX AY ITaKHCTaHOM H Aq raHHCTaHOM CTana IIOnHT6IOpo B03MOX H0 3TO OKa3anO onpeAeneHHoe BnH flHHe sa 230 231 nOJIHTHKy B OTHOmemm Aq raHHCTaHa Ho B03MO fCH0 TaK e lITO re­ HepanbI H Oq Hllepbl HMeWLUHe onbIT BOHRbl B Aq raHHCTaHe 6YAYT npo HHyTbI B 1987 r Kor n a BJlaCTb fop6alleBa YKpenHTCJI H OH npHCTynHT K oMonO l eHHW COBeTCKoro BoeHHoro KOMaH ll OBaHHJI Jlo CHX nop BoeHHhle Bepxu B CCCP COCTO l1H H3 oq HllepoB YllaCT­ Tpy o HOCTJIX H 6e3pa60THu e B 3ana o uOH EBpone H Ha IIHlIHOM 06aJI­ HHH HOBoro PYKoBO IJ HTeng BHe COMHeHHJI fop6aQeB lIyqIIIe no n a­ Ban H o ew COBeTCKo-eBponeiicKoro COTpY o HHlIeCTBa qeM ero npe o ­ meCTBeHHHKH Ho 3ana o uaJI EBpona O OCTaTOllHO H30mpeHHa lIT06bl MO fCHO 6bmo npeycneTb TOIIhKO Ha owmm BOBaBlllHX B BeIIHKOii OTelleCTBeHHoii BoiiHe Tenepb OHH cocTapH­ TIOe3 o Ka fop6aQeBa BO Cl paHu HW B OKTJl6pe 6bma npoBepKoii IIHCb H OTCTanH OT BpeMeHH Kor n a HX HatIHyT 3aMemaTb BeTepaubl Aq raHHCTaHa OHH MOryr BbIcrynHTb 3a YCHIIeHHe COBeTCKoro BoeH­ peanbHoem COBeTCKHX 0 H ll a HHB OHa npHHeena IIHlIHbIH ycnex Horo npHcyTCTBM ClIHTaJI lITO yxo o 6y o eT B03MO eH TOIIbKO noc­ 3ana o HblX Cpe o CfB HHq OPM3 IJ HH He o ana nOIIHTHlIeCKHX H 3KOHOMH­ npe emaeT HHlIero xopomero B co­ lIeCKHX pe3YIIbTaTOB OH BHOBh npo o eMOHCTpHpoBan CBoe nOIIHTH­ BeTCKO-aMepHKaHCKHX OTHOmeHHJIX 33J IBlleHIDI fop6alleBa 0 B03­ QeCKOe MaCTepCTBO crroc06HOCTb K COBpeMeHHbIM q opMaM 06meCT­ BeHHbIX KOHTaKTOB 3HeprHIO H3J1meCTBO HO He OTKa3aIICJI OT lIe HOPMaIIH3aIJ HH 3TO He MO fCHOCTH nOIIHTHlIeCKoro pemeHM aQ raHCKoii npo6J teMbI06MaH­ fop6alleBY HO aTaKa rop6alleBCKoro 06aJIHIDI no BbIpax eHHW OR HH B lIHBbI EMY He C KeM ee 06c Tb palBe co CBOHMH K01I1IeraMH no TPa o HD HOHHbIX COBeTCKHX u eneii TIoIIHT6wpo EenH Beem neperoBopbl C COee o HHMB HenaMCKHMB Ban OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a HeBepHoe nOBe o eHHe HIIH OlllH6KH CCCP KoeM enyqae He rrpH3Ha CTpaHaMH TO OHH HeH36e fCH0 nOCTaBJIT yenoBHeM OTBO o COBeTCKHX B rrpoumoM Ero rr03HD HJI OCHOBbmanaCb Ha TOM lITO Bee o eH CTBM BoiicK a aq raHH3aIJ HH BoiiHbl HMeeT Mano maHCOB Ha ycnex COBeTCKoro COW3a B npoumOM H B HaCTOameM npaoHIIbHbI H no TI03TOMY COBeTH3aIJ HH Aq raHHCTaHa nyreM cymeCTBeHHOrO YBe­ He rrpoH3Beno xopomero BneqameHIDI B 3ana o uoii EBpone CTHIIb IIHlIelDlH TaM lIHeneHHoem COBeTCKHX BoiiCK npe O CTaBIIJIeTCJI oePOJlT­ XpymeBa 6bI1I MeHee H3blCKaHHbIM KOCTWMbI ero 6bIIIH CTapoMo o ­ BbI a MaHepbI HHKaK He o HII1IOMamllHbI Ho OH o eiiCTBHTenhHO Bell HbIM pemeHHeM He 6bmo HHlIero Heo oro B 3ana o uoii nonHTHKe fop6a­ HOBYW rrOIIHTHKY H OKa3anCJI cnOco6HblM npH3HaTb lITO COBeTC­ tJeBa OH Ha o eMCJI nOIIytlHTh nOMep I KY 3ana o uoii EBpoRbI B KaM­ KHH COW3 He Beer n a 6bm rrpaB EenH 6bI fop6alleB namm npoTHB COlf H 3a JI o epHOe paaopY l eHHe OH XOTen TaK I e K CBoeMY AHIUIOMamllecKOMY MaCTepcTBY npoJlBHII nonHTHlleCKyro B o 06aBOK lff06bI CTpaHbI 3ana o uoii EBponbI npHHMH y-qaCTHe B coBeTcKoii rH6KOCTb OH 6bI 60nbIIle npeycnen B EBporre Ho OH pa3 o pax ancJI H BOCTollHoeBponeiiCKoii nporpaMMax TeXHOIIOrHlIeCKOii Mo o epHH­ rrpH Bonpocax 0 npaoax lIenOBeKa H no nOBO o y 3MHrp3 IJ HH H HeBep­ 3llUHH H Ha o eMCJI Ha eenapaTHble neperoBoPbI C BeIIHK06pHTaHHeii HO rrORM rrOIIHTHKy Cl paHu mf H CllpaHUHeii 06 HX g o epHbIx CHIIax 3TO Morno 6bl HaiTH OTKIIHK eenapaTBble rreperoBopbl 0 JI o epHbIX BoopY l eHHJlX eCIIH 6bl fop6aqeB BbICKa3an XOTb KaKYW-TO CKIIOHHOCTb K IIH6epa­ IIH BHYTpH CTpaHbI KaK 3TO c o eIIan XpymeB 0 0 H noene BTOp l elDlH B BeHrPHW B 1956 r lipe fCHeBCKaJI nOIIHTHKa pa3pg o ­ ua o eJlCb yrOBOpHTb MHTTepaua Ha B KOHlle OKTJl6pJl fop6alleB npHH l1 yqacme B YXMeBHOM COBemamm TIOIIHTHlIeCKOrO KOHCYIIbTaTHBHOrO KOMHTeTa CTpaH BapIIlaBCKOrO o orOBOpa B COq HH noene KOToporo 6bmo OrryW lH­ oq HllHaIIbHOe 3aJIB1IeHHe r o e nOBTop l1HCb Bee Te l e KH 6bI1Ia npo O OII I eHHeM HHIIUHaTHB XpymeBa H TO l e 6bI1Ia CBJl3a­ KOBaHO Ha C orpauHQeHHOH IIH6epanH3aJ n1eii o oMa npe l J e Beero C pa3­ 3ae3 1 eHHhle o eKIIapau HH 6e3 nOIIHTHlIeCKOH HHHllHaTHBbI cnocofi rpeKaM H apMJIHaM 3MBr­ Hoii Bbl3BaTb HHTepec BUYTPH H1IH BHe COBeTCKoro 6non B 3aJIBIIe­ r Kor n a B TIonbme eme COXpaMIIHCb 3aKO­ HHH 6hmo CKa3aHO lITO PYKoBo o meIIH CTpaH BOCTOllHoii EBponhl pemeHHeM COBeTCKHM eBpeJIM pHpoBaTb Ho B 1985 He RbI BoeHHoro BpeMeHH Kor n a npo O OII I anaCb BOHRa B Aq raHHCTaHe 06cy I J aIIH 06mHe 3KOHOMHlleCKHe rrpo6neMhI HO KaKHe HMeHHO 3MHrpanIDl 6hma 33 Mopo l eHa HaYllHbIH H KynbryPBbIH 06MeH He rOBopHIIOCh BOCTollHoeBponeiicKHe PYKOBO IJ HTeIIH He nonyqH­ C CCCP npHOCTaHOBIIeH He 6bI1I0 06'beKTHBHbIX yenoBHH AJlII yIIYQ­ IIH HHKaKOro BhI60pa KpoMe rrOMep I KH COBeTCKOH nOIIHTHKH melDlH OTHomeHHH C 3ana o uoH EBponOH COBeTcKHe Ha o e l J bI Ha a pa3HOrnaCBJI OCTanHCh 3a 3aKpblTbIMH epbMB TIollTH OlleBH o HO ycnex 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha yx q aKTOPax Ha 3KOHOMHlleCKHX lffO HaCTynaWmaJI 3HMa BhIHY I J aIIa TaKHe CTpaHbI KaK PyMbIlDlH 232 233 qexocnoBaKWl II IIonbwa Ao6HBarbC fI 'BemrqeHllJl nOCraBOK COBerc­ KOH He pm H 6eH3HHa lIT06bI H36e lKarb 3HeprerlflreCKOrO KpH3HCa KOrOpblH HMen MeCTO B 1984 r COBercKHe nOCTaBKH He pm Bocroq­ HOH EBpone B 1985 r 6bIJIH cOKpameHbl H3-3a npoH3BOAcrBeHHbIx npo6JIeM rop6alleB He Mor HM HHlIero o6e aTb H B HO fl6pe n eHa Ha ropwlIee B IIonbwe H B ApyrHX erpaHax 6bIJIa pe3KO nOAHllra lIT06bI COKparHTb norpe6JIeHHe BepH 'BWHCb H3 CO pHH rop6alleB cran rorOBHrbC fI K OCHOB­ HOMY AHIIJIOMamlleCKOMY c06blrHID rOAR - Bcrpelle C PeHraHOM B l eHeBe COBerCKaH n03HD H fI Ha lKeHeBCKHX neperOBOpax Y lKe 6bIJIa pa3pa60raHa H ee OA06pHJlH COBerCKHe COW3HHKH B Co HH O lKHAa­ noCb co06IlleHHe 0 CYIlleCTBeHHOM COKpamemm 06Illero lIHcna erparerHlIeCKHX fIAepHbIX 6oeronoBOK Koropble Moryr AOCTHlIb aMepHKaHCKOH reppHropHH - coBercKoe npe llIO lKeHHe IIpe J yc­ MarpHBano lITO Ka K J 8 fl eropoHa MO lKer HMerb no 6000 6oerono­ BOK 3roro AOCTarOllHO llI fI B3aHMHOrO YHHlITO lKeHH fI HO Ha 50% MeHbwe lIeM npe J ycMarpHBanocb cornaweHHeM OCB-2 COeAHHeH­ HbIe rnrarbI B npHHD HIIe COrnaCHJIHCb Ha no HO Me K J y cBepxn ep­ lKaBaMB B03HHKJIH pa3HOrnaCH fl no nOBOA ' pacnpeAeneHllJl npe llID­ KeHHbIX coKpameHHH CrnA AoooBanHcb cYIlleCTBeHHOrO cOKpame­ HlIJI COBerCKHX paKer Ha3eMHoro 6a3HPOBaHH fI rnaBHaH lJaCTb co­ BerCKoro MepHoro apceHana Co CBoeH CTOPOHbI CCCP HaCTaH­ Ban Ha BKJIWlIeHHH B no lIHcnO aMepHKaHCKHX paKer cpeAHeH AaJIb­ HoerH pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone H cnOC06HbIX Aocmllb COBerCKOH reppHropHH a raK lKe Ha 06Cy lKAeHHH Bonpoca 0 paKerax CC-20 cnoco6HbIX AOCTHlIb 3aIIa J HOH EBponbI Ha orAe rrbHOM COBe a­ HHH ECreCTBeHHO 06 3rHX Aeran fIX MOrnH OKOHilarenbHO AOrOBD­ PHTbC fI rOJIbKO 3KcneprbI HO He nonHTHKH BO BpeM fl ABYXAHeBHOH BcrpellH OAHaKO B npHHD Hne coBercKoe npe llIO lKeHHe 6bIJIO pea­ JIHCTHlIeCKHM H C03 J aBanO nOllBY llI fI 06cy lKAeHllJl eCJIH 6bI OHO He CB fI3bmanOCb C rpe60BaHHeM npeKparHTb Bee HccneAoBarenbCKHe pa60rbI no npoeKry COHo COBerCKHH erpax nepeA COM nOH fITeH ECJIH CrnA CYMewr C03Aarb HT 3 IllawJ I tHH HX reppHTOpHW or paKerHoro yARpa AMepHKa CMO lKer caMa HaHeCTH nepBbIH YARP llax e eCJIH IllHT He rapaHTHpyer nonHOH 3amHTbI or Heo KH J 8 H­ HoereH OH CYIlleCTBeHHO H3MeHHr erparemlleCKHH 6a rraHc Jloro­ BOp 06 OrpaHHlIeHHH npoTHBOpaKerHbIX CRcreM nO J IIHcaHHbIH B 1972 r pa3peman Ka lKAOH cBepxn ep lKaBe HMerb oAHY Ha3eMHyW CRCTeMY llI fI 3amHrbI Hace rreHHbIX n eHTpoB Ho CUCTeMbI C meMeH­ raMB KOCMHlleCKOrO 6a3HPOBaHH fI fIBJI flWrC fI COBepmeHHO HOBbIMH H CmA 6JIaro J ap fl rexaOJIOrHlIeCKOMY npeBOCXOACTBY npH06pe­ rawr BeAYIllYw ponb CrOHMOCTb HccneAoBarenbCKHX pa60r no COM orpoMHa 20-30 MnpA· Ao rr rrapoB HO He B nOM rnaBHaH np06neMa xor fl llI fI CCCP OHa eIlle eepbe3HeH H3-3a rexaonOrHlIeCKOfO orcraBaHH fI CrOHMOCTb caMOH CHcreMbI 6YAer eIlle 6oJIbwe YlIeHbIe B03pa KaIDr nporHB 3rOH HAeH noroMY lITO nOHHMaIQr KaK rpYAHO C03ARrb HenpOHHD aeMbIH IllHr Ho 3rH B03pa lKeHH fI OCHOBaHbI Ha npeAnono­ lKeHHH aMepHKaHn eB lIro CCCP HaHeeer nepBbrH YAap Ho Ha caMOM Aene npo6JIeMa B rOM lITO ecnH CmA BbIpByrC fl BnepeA B pa3pa­ 60TKe COH COBerCKOMY COW3Y npHAerc fI 3aMeH flTb npaKTHlIeCKH Bce CBoe CTparefHqeCKOe 0pY KHe JloroBop OCB-2 OrpaHHlIHBaro­ IllHH pa3pa60TKY HOBblX THUOB paKer OKa lKeTC fI COBepmeHHO HeHy KHbIM H HalIHerC fI HOBbrH Ha 60nee BbICOKOM rexaonOfHlIeC­ KOM ypoBHe 3raII rOHKH BoopY lKeHHH qr06bI OCna6HTb B03pa lKe­ HH fI 3ana u aoeBponeHCKHX COW3HHKOB no nOBOA ' COM CrnA npeA­ nO KHJIH pa3AeJIHTh HccneAoBareJIbCKHe pa60rbI H BbIpa3H ITH rorOB­ Hoerb cy6CHAHpoBaTb HccneAOBaHH fI B Apymx crpaHax Ha 3ro 6bI­ JIH OTIIYIlleHbI OlleHb 60nbWHe CpeACTBa H 3anaAHaH repMaHH fI H BenHK06pHraHH fl pellDfJIH npHcOeAHHHTbC fI K pa60raM COBerc­ KOMY COW3Y rpYAHo nporeCToBarb nporHB HccneAoBaHHH He 6bIJIO Me lKA 'HapoAHbIX cornaweHHH 3aIIpe x HccneAOBaHH fI B nOH o6JIacm COBeTcKHe YTBep KAeHllJl lflO 3TH o60poHHTenbHbIe YCT­ poHCTBa Ha caMOM Aene fIBn flWTC fI HaerynarenbHbIMH He nonHoerbW 6e3 OCHOBaHH fI ECJIH IllHT MO lKeT pa3PYWHTb paKerbI B nonere TO nocne He3HallHrenbHbIX 83MeHeHHH ero MO KHO 6YAeT Hcnon ­ 30BaTb H npoTHB APYrux n eneH COBerCKOMY COW3Y 6YAeT HeBe­ PO flTHO TPYAHO C03ARTb raKyro lKe CHereMY lJaCTH'lHO 83-3a pa3pbIBa B TexaonorHH aMepHKaHD bI npe llIaraIQT nOAenHTbC fI TeXHonomeH HO K 3roMY HHKTO eepbe3HO He OTHOCRrC fI CCCP AOn lKeH 3amH­ maTh KYAR 6onbwyro reppHTopHID KpoMe Toro COBeTCKHH T He 3aID HTHT OT paKeT IIepillHHf-2 pa3MeIlleHHbIX B EBpone raK KaK BpeMH HX nonera llI fI AOCrH KeHllJl HMB uenH cnHWKOM KopoTKoe Bo BC fIKOM cnyqae BPM nH PeHraH npaB ClIHraH lITO COM nonD­ KHT KOHen fI J epHbIM BoopY lKeHllJlM HaCrynHT rOJIbKO HOBbIH H OqeHb AoporOCTO fl H 3TaII fOSKH BoopY lKeHHH 234 235 EbInO fICHO lITO fop6aqeB B ' KeHeBe cOCpe o OTOllllT BHHMaHHe lTO xpynKoe o OCTH KeHHe MaJIeHI1IHii Me K JJ yHapo J HbIH KPH3HC Ha o OBO o ax npoTHB COlf B TO BpeMJI KaK PeHrau 6y o eT npo o OJI­ Bcer o a B03MO KHbIH B paHOHax KOH4 PO MO l eT palB fIJaTb lKaTb HaCTaHBaTb Ha npaBe JIl060H CTpauhl l HI UaTb ce6 fI H nOB TO­ Bpa K J e6uylO nponaraH o y IIOe3 JJ Ka fop6aqeBa B CrnA B p fITb 06em aHH fl no o eJIHTbC fI TeXOOJIOrHeH KpoMe Toro O i H J 3 JIOCb H PeHraHa B CCCP B BKJIIOqeHHe B nOBeCTKY J H fl perHOHaJIbHhlX KOH4 JIHKTOB Bo B peMJI JIeHO npo o OJI K'aT npo u ecc yrryqweHH fl oTHowem Me lK o y cBepx­ o ep l aBaMH npe JJ BapHTeJIbHbIX neperOBopoB HHlITO He YKalbIBaJIO Ha BOlMO K­ 1986 r 1987 r eenH OHH COCTO flTC fI KaK 6bInO yenoB­ HOCTb o OCTIDKeHH fl Ha BCTpeqe B Bepxax KaKoro-JIH60 comameHH fl IIo B03Bpam eHHH B MOCKBY fop6aqeB c o eJIaJI o eTaJIbHbIH B Boopy KeHH flx IIeCCHMHCTbI nOJIararru lITO BCTpeqa TOJIbKO yxy o ­ o OKJIa JJ 0 BCTpeQe B ' KeHeBe Ha cecCHH BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 3S lllHT OTHOWeHH fl Me lK J y CBepx o ep lKaBaMH H lITO maBbI rocy o apcTB OH 6bIJI c o ep lKaHHee H YMepeHHeH B xapaKTepHCTHKe aMepHKaue­ 6y o yT OpaTb o pyr Ha o pyra lla l e OnTHMHCTbI He O i H J 3 JIH HHKaKHX KOii n03H u HH HanpHMep OH He HalhlBaJI aMepHKau u eB arpeccopa­ HlMeHem palBe TOJIbKO HeKOTopOH nOJIblbI OT JIHqHoro lHaKOMCT­ MH XOTb H yrnep K J aJI no-npe KHeMY lITO OHH XOT flT o 06HTbCJI Ba Peiiraua H fop6aqeBa lf OnTHMHCTbI He o YMaJIH lITO nO flBHTC fI npeBocxo o crna Me lK o yHapo J HbIe COBMecTHoe la flBJIeHHe nonararrH qTO Ka K J bIH H3 pyKOBO J HTeJIeH lIHBbIMH HO Bcen flJIH 60JIbwe Ha JJ e K J qeM B He mmHee BpeMJI OTHOWeHH fl OCTaJIHCb HeYCToH­ BblpalHT HecomaCHe C TOt KOH lpeHH fl o pyroro B 6ecKOHet HbIX Me K J y TeM cym ecrnyroT npo6rreMbI Ky o a 60JIee npoCTbIe JJ HCKYCCH flX HHTepBblO H nOJIHTHlIeCKHX aHaJIHlax no TeJIeBH JJ eHHIO qeM COlf pewaJI KOTopbIe fop6aqeB Mor 6bI npO flBHTb 3 o PaBbIH 4 HO fI6p fI Ha npece­ H pa JJ H0 HaKaUYHe BCTpellH B Bepxax Bce CXO J HJIHCb Ha TOM lITO CMbICJI yrryqwuTb Me K JJ yHapo J Hy1O cHTYa u ulO BCTpeqa npoBaJIHTC fI EenH 6bI fop6aqeB ene o oBaJI COBeTaM CBOHX KOH4 epeH u HH B IIapIDKe ero cnpoCHJIH lyMaeTe JIH BbI B 6rrID aj COBeTHHKOB HanpHMep 3aMJITHHa BnH flTenbHoro qeJIOBeKa B UK weM 6y o ym eM OTKpbITb JJ BepH CCCP OOJIee WHpoKO H JJ aTb B03­ WIH KopHHeHKo nepBoro laMeCTHTen fI MHHHCTpa HHOCTpaHHbIX MO KHOCTb COBeTCKHM JIIO J flM cBo60 o uo npHe3DTb Ha 3ana o a o eJI BCTpeqa o OJI KHa 6b1JIa 6bI npoBaJIHTbC fI H qeJIOBeqeCKHH nlO J JIM C 3ana o a npHe3 lKaTb B COBeTcKHH COI031 36 fop6aqeB 4 aKTOP He Mor 6bI nOBJIH flTb Ha ee HCXO o TonbKO la CqeT JIHt HbIX He OTBeTHJI Ha nepByro qaCTb Bonpoca OH onpe o eJIeHHO He HaMepeH KaqeCTB fop6aQeBa H PeHraHa BCTpeQa OKa3aJIaCb OTHOCHTerrbHO OTKpbITb JJ BepH COBeTCKHM rpa K J aHaM qTO KacaeTCJI JIIO o eii Ha 3a­ ycnellIHoH XOT fI OHa H He npHHeena HHKaKHX cym ecrneHHhlX pelyJIb­ na o e OHH MorYT npHe3 1 aTb B CCCP npH yenoBHH t T0 HX nOe3 JJ KH TaTOB He 6y o yr CB fIJaHbI c nOnbITKaMH HCnOJIblOBaHH fl B nOJIHTuqec­ Ba KHbIM 4 aKTOPOM ycnexa 6b1JIa opraHH3allHJI BCTpellH Ha KOTOpoii J H fl JIHt Hble KomaKTbI CTaJIH OCHOBHOH qaCTblO nOBeCTKH YcTauOBJIeHHe JIHqHbIX OTHowem Me lK o y maBaMH CBepx o ep­ lKaB laTpY J HHJIO Bnoene o CTBHH ny6rrHqHble BbIna J hl C 000HX CTOpoH KHX npoBOKa U UOHHbIX u eJI fIX C TeM lIT06bI OTpaeJI flTb aTMoc4 epy BMeWHBaTbC fI BO BuyrpeHHHe o erra 37 o lI ruI npHMepa OH paCCKalaJI rpynne aMepHKauCKHx TYpHCTOB COBeplllHBWHX noe3 JJ Ky no Bonre OH nO-BH JJ HMOMY He nOHHMaeT lITO eenH 6bI COBeTCKHe 06a yqaCTHHKa BCTpeq nOHHMaJIH H BOlMO KHO 06c H no B rpa K J aHe MorJIH caMH npHHHMaTb peweHHe 0 nyTewecrnHH no MIle­ palrOBopax Me lK o y C060H t T0 o pyrOH YMepeHHee qeM ero nOJIHTH­ CHCHnH no f5bInO 6bI BeJIHlIaHwHM CKaqKOM B palBHTHH CO U Ua­ KH- fICTpe6bI C KOTOPbIMH Ka K J OMY npe o CTO flJIO HMeTb o erro no JIHCTHqeCKOH o eMOKpaTHH H BeJIH1 aHlllHM YKpenneHHeM o eJIa MHpa B03B eHHH o OMOH Y ooon 6bInH OCHOBaHH fl npe o CTaBHTb BCTpeqy KaK ycnex 3aKJIIOlIHTeJIbHOe fop6aqeB Hero KOJIJIern no IIOJIHT61Opo HMelOT BnaCTb lTO c o enaTb TaKOH cnoco6 cpaBH flTbC fI C CrnA rryqwe QeM nbITaTbC fI C03 o aTb HelHallHTeJIbHhle nporpaMMY 3Be3 J HbIX BoHH 3TO o eweBJIe H npom e CopeBHOBa· COmameHH fI 0 KyJIbl 'PHOM 06MeHe H T n - Bce lTO 6bInO nopo­ COB MeCTHOe la flBJIeHHe HHe B o6rracrn JIHqHbIX CBo60 o 6bIJIO 6bI OOJIee nonyJI flpHbIM B 000n CTeneHHbIM Hauoonee Ba KHbIM HTorOM nOH BCTpellH 6bInO oena6­ CTpaHax qeM copeBHOBaHHe B B03MO KHOcrn BlaHMHOrO yuuqrO l e­ JIeHHe B3aHMHoii Bpa K J e6HOH pHTOpHKH H CTpeMJIeHH fl HcnopTHTb HH fl Kor o a COBeTCKoe PYKOBO o CTBO HaqHeT BepHTb CBOHM rpa K J a­ penyra u HIO o pyrOH CTOpOHbI IIOJIBHJIOCb B3aHMHOe YBa KeHHe Ho HaM H npe o OCTaBHT HM lllHpoKHe BOlMO KHOCTH JIHqHoro Bbloopa 236 237 H CBo60 tn I mo IJ H B n pyrHX CTpaHax IIOBepHT B MHpHbIe HaMepeHHH 10 CraBpOnom cKa Il npaBAIl 6 Ma Il 1978 r 11 l Schapiro The Communist Party of the Sovien Union 2 ed l lon­ don Allen Unwin 1970 12 IIpoI'paMMa KIICC 1961 r 13 IIpaBAIl 26 OKTl'll5p ll 1985 r 14 TaM lKe 15 TaM lKe 16 YCTaB KIICC IIpaB a 2 HO llOp ll 1985 r 17 IIpaBAIl 14 COBeTCKoro PYKOBO n Cma IIPHME'IAHHR 1 KOHCTHTyu wI COI03a COBeTCKHX IIpaB 4 HIOIDI 1917 r CO HCTHllecKHX Pecnyl5lJHK HIOlLIl 1985 r 18 YKal IIpe3H llHYMa BepxoBHoro COBeTa CCCP 06 aMHHCTHH B CB Il3H C 40-JIeTHeM nol5ellLI COBeTCKoro HapOAil B BeJIHKoit OTe'leCTBeHHoit BoitHe 1941-1945 rr JbBeCTH ll 28 anpeJI ll1985 r Richard Pipes Russia under the Old Regime Harmondsworth Middx Penguin 1979 p 79 19 IIpoeKT IIporpaMMhI KIICC IIpaB IJ a 26 OKT IlIlp ll 1985 r 3 20 TaM lKe 21 TaM lKe 22 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 252 2 Jews in the USSR fA Weekly Information Bulletinl Vol 14 No 14 April 11 1985 p 4 4 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 17 May 2 1985 p 4 5 TaM lKe Vol 14 No 42 November 7 1985 p 4 6 M Gorbachev A Time for Peace New York Richardson and Steirman 1985 p 253 23 J F Hough and M Fainsod How the Soviet Union is Governed Camb­ ridge Mass Harvard University Press 1979 p 364 7 TaM lKe 24 Time April 22 1985 p 7 8 K J1I06aPCKHlt BeCTH H3 CCCP MIOuxeH 25 Time September 9 1985 p 4 9 E EBTytUeHKo Kal5bI'IeroHeBbIIlll1HCTLl IIpaBAil 9 ceHT Ill5p ll 1985 r 26 TaM lKe 238 CTp 252 CTp 5 239 27 Time April 22 1985 p 8 28 IIpllBna 8 anpeJlJl 1985 1' 29 HAIII APXHB Henry Kissinger The White House Years London Weidenfeld Nicol­ H3 DHCLMA B PE IlAKIUOO son and Michael Joseph 1978 p 1141 30 Sunday Times April 21 1986 p 22 Time April 22 1985 'P 16 31 B KPOTKOB llymM IHLI C 8MepHKlIHCKHMH nacnOpTaMH 1'13BeCTHlI 6 Hog6pg 19851' 32 Serge Schmemann Afghanistan war creates Soviet heroes International BaUlUHZTOH B 1952-1953 22 5 iJeKaDpR 19862 11 3a8eiJ06fl1l HefJo ftbUlOU cnpa80 rmou DU j Herald Tribune November 13 1985 ftUOTeKOU nocO ftbCT8a CoeiJuHeHHblx IJ TaT06 8 MOCK8e llPU80iJ1I 8 Newsweek August 19 1985 p 26 HUKa U30aHH020 8 nOpR OoK UMe8UlUeC1I Tf1 M KHU2U 11 HaUle rt 100 3K3eMM1Ipo8 cfJop­ 33 pa 34 Time December 9 1985 p 10 1919 2 JOHiJOM KapHe2U no YKpenneHUlO MU­ Carnegie Endowment for International Peace 8 KOTOPOM 8 ne· pe80iJe Ha PVCCKUU 1I3blK Dbl rtU Hane'laTaHbl OeK rtapaltWl He3a8UCU­ MOCTU CTaTbU KOHr JeiJepaltUU U KOHCTUTYltWl CoeiJuHeHHblX IJ ra­ 35 H3BeCTHll 28 Hog6pg 19851' T08 C 880iJHOU craTbeu 'oJICeuMca EpaVHa CKorra 3TOT CfJoPHUK 11 nocbl rtalO 8aM 8 npWlOJICeHUU 36 H3BeclllJl 6 OKTg6pg 19851' HeT COMHeHWl 'l TO l Je8pa rtbCKaR pe8O rtlOltWl noc nvJICU l l UMnV ftbCOM iJ rtJI U30aHWl JOHiJOM KapHe2U 3TUX iJOKYMeHT08 HIl 37 TaM ICe PVCCKOM 1I3blKe C TeM 'l TODbl 03HaKOMUTb POCCUUCKUX pe80 ftlOltUo­ Hepo8 C H08blMU uiJeJl MU OiJHaKo K MOMeHTY OKOH'laHWl nepe80iJa U U3iJaHWl cfJopHuKa no ftOJICeHUe 8 POCCUU U3MeHWlOCb CfJoPHUK OCH080nO rta2alOU UX iJoKVMeHT08 f1 M epUKaHCK020 20cyiJapcT8a no­ nail ryiJa c nUUlKOM no3iJHO Mbl YJtCe He noiJiJepJltU8fl1lU iJuMoMaru­ 'l eCKUX OTHOUleHUU C Poccueii U 81919-192022 3TU DVpJICVa3Hble iJoKVMeHTbI VJJre He M02 ftU CTaTb 8K ftaiJoM 8 iJe faTbl a KOHCTUTVltUU H08020 C08eTCK020 20CYiJapCT8a Pu'l apiJ T 'o38UC IIocoll COe ll HHeHHIdx MTaTOB B BapmaBe B 1972-1978 rr 240 241