U olYI ella 1I elJl'ap Hea8llHcmlocTll' CTaTl ll ROB eAep_ iii RoBCTIl'­ ryII i s CoeJtHHeum rrr IlITaTOll'L COliupaIOrCJI m BaeTO lml en TOIIlllri ilnBO II BeaaBllCmlO on BCJmaro 1@yroro xarepi8 lla iii npeAJ araIOrcs nyliJlllltii liea'L aariqa silt II liea'L TOJiKOllaJliJi TaJt'l lITOlis OHll xorm paaCliarpHBan e r paaliupaTI cs B cpaBllHllaTI CJI C'D Be lIlI'Iaftmel1 1IeI'­ KOCTI IO R npR cam n llmO Il mr YClIOlliJI rI MH ZIL1IlI 1l'L BeynplUlJlemIOn xipil 11K Il OJD£BJ l EIITI ll'L ynplUlJllJ­ er ron xipil OIim ecTBO BapO ll Om Il OJllltHO mTI CllOI1 a 1 KOH'li II CBOJ yqp eHi a II om m Coe ll HlIeum rrr lliTaTOB'Ir-«BepaapmHd COloo'£ COCTO 1I3'L Bepaapmmr mTaTOm -Be XOJlte'I'L lie HlITepeCOllaTI IIKCJla m ItI'L 1IIO Il e1t CTO ID IIX' ll'L JEacii nepe ll 'L pacna D elrlen olim ecTBa II omewrowreum rrr npll aptm m B BapO ll Om BlI lI lIMO BaIOAJIm llXCJI m aroHill pasPJllIeui It JAMES BROWN SCOTT 1 Bpe TOp'b Ol'i ua MeaQJ ynapoAHaro npua BamUBrTOB'D 1I R 21 anpiIJIa 1917 rOA8 t HOHCTMTYlJ 1H COEJJ MHEHHbIX'b WTATOB'b-1787 rO lJ Al MH BapO ll 'L Coe ll HlIeHllHl'L lliTaTOll'£ llllO ll Illl'L II rmeplE ll aen STY KOBcnrry u iIO COe ll lIHeHllHl'L lliTarOll'L AM epllEll C'L nIO o6paao­ BaTI lioJ ile npollHd COlOS'b rmep D 1lTI npaBoc 'Aie o6eanellllTI BuyrpeR­ Bee cnoKoftcTBie npllHllllaTI rips Il JIH o6m ell o6opom t cnOC06CTBOBaTI oIim er ry IiJIaI'OCOCTOauiIO If olieanellllTI 6J1ara c 0060 ll l l II Il llJl celi ll II s Ramero nOTOMCTBa CraTI ll I O 1 BciI aaltOBO ll aTeJlhBlllI npaBa npe ll OCT lllJIlI ems BTOil ltOBCnrry u iett Il C 1DKlII l nplIHa D JIelEaTI ltOHrpeccy COeAHlIeum rrr llim­ TOB'b ltOTOpHD Il ODteH'li COCTOJlTI 1I3'L ceBaTa 11 1I3'L n8 llam npe ll CTalllI­ meli OT ll iln 2 1 nallam npe l CTaBlireJIel1 a OJllltHa COCTOJlTI 1I3'L lIJIeBOB'II aa6Bpae pas'L ll'L A e a lla rO l a BapO l On pa3Jrrqmr mra­ TOB'b a 1l'L Eaat 'l Oll'L marl m6opID H S 1I Il OJarnH y a OllJeTB0PJlTI rlIll'L YC 1IOBiJon EaJi iJI 'Ipeliyrorcll on llLllioPID HltOm callol1 lIHOrOJIO Il Rol1 co­ CTallHOI1 iacTIl' aaRoRo a aTe n Raro colipalrla mara I He 1I0llre'l lio 1iLlTI npe l CTaBlITeJJen TOT ETO Be n OC'nII aJ I am­ mrmJ ilTWlro llOapaCTa ETO Be 1iLlJ'L 1l'L Te'leBie ceMlI J iln rpalE ll aHH­ BOll' Coe a HHeum rrr lliraTOll'D II RTO llO BpeMH m60pOll'L Be npHHa n JJe­ ZIl'l L E' 'llICJlY DTeJeil loro maTa B'L Koropon on I s6paH'li a npe l CTaBBTeJII II np lDlLle BaJlOrn Il O llWl 1iLlTI pacnpe n ilJem BelIW' pas JIII1IHLDIlI nfraramI MOryID llMH BCTyIlllT b ll'L BTOn COIOJ'L co­ paaripBo C'L lIX'L BaCeJIelrle M'L a lIT06s onpeAilJlHTI '1HCJIO 9Toro naceJIe­ ItiJr cJ iI a yen E'L olim el1 D Bljlpt cllolio a B1ilX'l' 1IIO l ell co llltJIIO'Ielrlell'L JIO a e1t noctymmna 1I m yCJlYJI'elrle Ba onpe a lllIeRHoe 'llICJIO J iln R Ill 'Tellen ROIIC'I'IITfll ilr ea I1oupaBIID lIPDAIIlll liIl aalltTE1I D yllaaare u IlIa'rH 11870 1I8peeliOTpillDla't 'eraBOm Coe a Dllemn r rr mmTOm 1878 lOAIL 11 lID eeua7C11I1l'O AODYllelrra Hl 12 6aro lIolll'Peeea I1epBol'I eeeeill 'bien erolllltia I1epO li70 O'ri inBJ llll upe a J olKeJrimal KoIIC'I'JI'rTqiJt lI'Jo CIIolSKarr De BIlol OJl ll'lCm B'Io fellen 1I0 a npe l llozems B'Io CIIotillllr onbeD aroPIDI'I OTd ton 'lenIpDIW TOI nOllp8JlIlll er 52 HOi KIIIIl'IIl 260 261 ItOHCTBTYItIH COE lJ HHE1IJf£11'L lIITATOB'D HCIWO'IeRien lleOOJlOlre a mr r lIaJ10rau l B J i il n eB'l' npH6aBIlTI ' 'pH Wl'l'1iX'J Bcilrr npo'lllrr JIJlD 'l J nepelmCD Bapo n OHaCeJIeDiJr n o uma 6un npOIlSBe n eR3 1I'l Te'leBie ' 'perr Jliln nocn nepBaro co6paBiJI EOHI'peCC3 COeAHRe a mr r illTaTOB'l' H aaTiln n OJllltBa npOJl8BO n Hn cs 'Iepes'l RU­ ARe n ec a TI JItn Tiln cnocooon ltOTOp 6Ilt YCTaHOBs T'l COe 1l HRelIl He mTaTLt OC06hlM'l SaltOIIOn npe n CTaDHTeJIell IOJDKHO 6hl1'l Re 60ne o n Horo 0T'l TpH ll n am ThlC II'l'l ZB TeJIe HO ltallQl 6IIt maT' n omell'l mn no Kem mell ripil O J IIoro npe n CTaBHTeJIa a no£ He 6y n en c n ilJlaHO nepelmCH Hapo n onaCeJIeDiJr man HblO-reMnnIDp1 6y n en DMiln npaDO m t6npaTb perr npe n cTaBHTeJIeA Macca'lYCeTTC'l -­ Bocen PO l'l -AitJIell J 'l H lliaBTan iD IIpoBH lI eHc'b--O J IIoro KORHem­ ltyn-meCTI HblO-IopR'l -mecn HblO- ep3D-'Iempe nelICIUbBa­ lIUI-Bocen l eJIaBep'b--O J IIOro MapHJIeBfl 'l -mecn BaprHRiJr- n e­ C a TI CillIepHaa KaPOJlHRa -1I a TI IOlImas XapOJIJlHa -wm reopriJr -' 'pH 4 Ecm OTltpOlOTCJI lIa1taHciD m npe n CTaBHTeJILCm ltaltoro-BR6y n r maTa TO ero HCnOJIllHTeJl DHas BJIacn n o uma pacnopJl' ll IlTI ca 0 npOH3BOP CTBillIhl6opoB'l' 1JTQ6hl sariCmTI BaltaBcilL 5 nuaTa npe n cTaDHTeJlel 6y n en Bhl6npan CBOerO Clmltepa H APJ1'HX '1 AO umOCTBbtX'f JIBll ' D 11 ell o J IIol 6Y len npHRa J Jlezan npaDO 1103­ 6yl£ l' an yrOJlOBHOe npeCJIiI n OBaBie npomB'l n o umOCTBbtX'f Im­ peachment OT n tJl'l S 1 CeHan COe 1l HReBlIhlX'l illTaTaB'L n omeH'l COCTO a TI Dn YX'l ceRaTopOB'l on ltal£ il aro mTsTa Bhl6paHRLU'L SaKOBO laTeJl DBbtMH coopa rl il MD amrr maTOm Ba mecn nn H ltallQl Id ceBaTOp1 AODeH'l Diln o n HR'l rOJlOc'l I HeKe 1I JIeHRO lIcriI n 'l sa rlIn ltalt'I OBR co6eppc a nocn nepBhlX'f mt60poB'L OHR AOJIlItHIl 6hl1'l paa n lIJIem Ha ' 'pH IIO ript B08XOZllocm paDRLU'L paaps n a MilcTa ceHaTOpOB'l nepBaro paapJl' ll a n OJlZllhl C1JlI­ TaTI C 1i Ba1taJlT IbtMD no HCTe'leBill BTOporo ro n a OCTa ceHaTOpOB'l BTOporo paapHJJ a -no HCTe'leBill 'IeTBepmro ro n a H neTa CeHaTOpom Tam 'Hepm DaplIlPatJ 'l'pe'fLIIlO o'Q ua DepBOi O'I'aTl R ItoR Coe lRRellRllrlo mTa'fOB'I R '1'a 'laCTI B'l'Oporo uaparpa fla 'fOro ze O'1' I Ua 1I00000paa 18C1IImla 8811 1' · BaURCii orxhew r C8l1J 11l 1la'fOi DODpIlBllOi Itoll 262 ItOH COW BREHHIifX'Jj lIITATOB'D ' 'peTW l'0 paapJI'JJ a -no lICTO'lOBill meCTOrO rOAa Ta K1' 'ITO O a ' 'pen CelIaTOpom 6y n en D36npan ea 'Iepea'l ltUWle J B8 ro n a a ocm QT­ Itpomca BaJtaHCiD BCn n cTBie mno n a m oTcTaBlty IllID no lQlyroit npH­ 1JlIri 1I'l TO lIpeu RaM coociJr 3a1tOHo n aTeJILHaro co6paHiJr Ba ItOro-m60 DITaTa aaltpIiTa TO lICnOJIHBTeJlI Haa BJIacn aTOro DITaT8 Komen cp tJIa'J ' BpexeJmIilJl BOOR8 'IeDiJr n o crl n ylOm eit cecciD SaItOBo n 8 TeJIl BalO co­ 6paHiJr Itoropoo TOr n 8 n o umo SaMBCTBTJ rlI B3ltaBCiD J 3 He MOlr'lTll tiun m t6pam m CeR8 TOpLt TOn ItTO Re AOCTHl I ' 'pH ll ­ n amrilTHJll'O BOspaCTa Be 6Ltll'L m Te'leBie Aell 1iTH riln rpallQl a HJmon Coe n BlIeRlllilX'L illTaTOm 11 lie npHRa J JIeaarrr 110 Bpeu m t60pom K'ft 1JlICJIY amTeJlel TOro mTaTa B'L ltOTopon npe n cTorurr m t60p1 ceRaTopa ' BHD e-npeSH lI eHT'l CoeAHRelIllliI X'1 illTaTOB'l n OJIlreH'l 6un npe l ciI­ n aTeJIen cellam RO 6ea'l npaDa rOJloca sa DCEJllO'IeBien TOro CJlyqa a Ror n a rOJIOC8 ceBaTOpOB'L paa n ilAsTca nopollBy 5 CeRan n 0UteH'l lIhl6pan CBOBX'I OCTUbRLU'L AO umOCl'l LtI 'l JI paDRO EaR' npe n cil n aTeu pro tempore n JlSl saMiJm aDiJr BHD e-npe3H­ n eHTa ltQr a a 0H'l HaxO n HTCa m QTCytCTBiD OH ltor n 3 0H'l BCnoJIJl 1ierI 06a 3aBlIOCm npeSH lI eHTa Coep BlIe a mr r illTaTOB'L II O n HOMY ceHaTy n OJIZII npHRa o JIelran npaDO npoH'3ll0 ll HTb Cy n 'l Ra l' ' l O umOCTlIb1llH JIHD amI npOTDB'l ltOTOPhlX'l Bos6yl£ l' eBO yroJIOBROe npe­ cJIt n oBaHie Impeachment Kor n a 0H'l sact n aen C'l aTalO D 'iIJIilO ero 1JJleBbt n OJlZllhl n an npDCa ry 11m a p pDpM lO Kor u a npOIlSlIO n HTCS cy n 'l Ba J 'l npeaH ll el1'lOn Coe n HRe a mr r illTaTOB'l' BepxoBIlLtit cy n b 1i n 0 1UKeH'l npe n ciI n aTeJIbC1'llOBan B BURTO Be MOlren tihl1'l npJl8HaH'l BHIIOllBbtM'l HRa'le EaR' J BYMJr ' 'peTJDlD npDCytCTBylO 'IlJIeHOB'L 1 B'l C lIf'laJIX'l Impeachment'a OOBHRHTeJILBhlit npHI'OBOP'l n O lL1lreH'l orpammmanca y n ueBien 0T'l n o umocm II sanpem eBien SaBDMan m Coe n HReHRLU'L illTal'll X'l JtaKyJO-JlH60 AOJIZIIOCn C'l ltOTopoit co­ e J BlIJleTCS nO'len l oll'ilpie IlJlH m tro n a HO JlIlD O npJl8RaHROO BHROB­ BbtM'l rlIn lie Kerle no n JleamTI OOllHReBilO cy n y B Rar asaBiIo no 8atOBan IT iln 4 l BpeMa neTo H cnocoo'l Hs6paDiJr celIaTOpom H npe n ­ cTaBBTeJIei n OJlZllhl 6hl1'l YCTaHOllJIem t 1I'l ltallQl on DITaTil ero SaltORo­ l a TeJlbmn co6paBieK'l' RO 1t0000OOC'l Kazen 110 Bcs EOe BpOU IIS n 'J ' 263 lWHCTII'rY nIR COE llAHEHHbTX' D lIlTATOB'L awtOn YCT8JI lI l aID_ H lIH HSmIlLSlO_ I1Pa BRlIa OToro po u a on l'O lll lI O He MOzeT'l JDr Iero B8nHJl TI lI BCaTe lll BO nCTa B06paJIia ce­ BMOpOB'L 2 Kompecc' b u ollmem c06npaTbc a no Mem meit npt 0 u Hll'1 paat B'l rOA' b H HeIIPUeBBO ll' b neplllilll nOHeAmBHIt'D AeKa6pa ec m He H3 u aCT'I SaROHa HasBa'lalD aro aKoit-BH6YAb IIPyrol1 Aem OT ll tJl'I 5 l Ral lI a a naJIaTa u oJCItHa caMS 6HT1' cy u l elD ll'b llOIIpOCarJ XacaTe lll HO llr r60poll'l II era 'lHClIeHHaro pe3Y lll TaTa II KaCaTelII BO Toro BlIltlOT' b m 'IlIeHLI llCi Tpe6yeMLIJ a'leCTBa a 60nmllHcTllO 8iK lI olt nallaTLt u OJCItHO COCTa B 1 $ITb quorum u lI lI I1P01I3BOACTBa u illI' bj BO Mene UOTO'IHClIeHHoe c06paHie 1I03eT' b OTRJIa u LIBaTb sact u aBia co u HJI Ra u em H MOZeT' b 6HT1' ynollHOMO'IeHO I1PBHyz u aTb OTCytCTByEOlll IIX' b 'IlIe· HOB' ' b al t Ta B I' b cnoc060 l' b II no ll ' b yrP03011 TaKlIX'I HaxaBaHiit ltO'IOpr r a 6y u yT'i YCTalioBlIem lI al lI ol1 naJIaTOl1 2 RalK ll a a naJIaTa M04eT' b YCTaHOBlI$ITb I1PaBlIlIa u u CBoero AtllOIIpa­ 1I3BOAcma Ball aSLIBaTb CllOlIX'b 'IlIeHOB' sa jea'IHHcTBa II IIC lIlO'IaTb lIX'b lin CBoero COCTaBa ABYu TpeTmuJ rOllOCOB'L 3 Ral lI a a naJIaTa u O lIlKRa llecm 3 YPHaJI' b Toro 'ITO u illIaeT' b II u OJll Ha on llpeMeHH u o BpeMeHH ony 'illHROllLIBaTb ero sa HC lIlO'Iellie l' b Ttn 'lacTeli lI OTOPIiU4 no e a mBiID cJIt u yeT' b xpamm ll' b TaIH'fl a ymePilll­ Te lll Blle II OTp TelILlIHe rOlloca 'IlIeBOB' b al lI ol1 JIaJlaTLt nO RaKOllY-6b1 TO HH 6WIO BOIIpOCY Aonmr r 6lilTL aaDlICauLI lI'l 4EYPBaJI'I no Tpe60Bs­ Hi1D OAHOIt llIlTOlt 'Iacm IIpIICyrcTBYIDIIQtn 'IJleHOB'L 4 Ra o u Ra lin nMan lie AOlllKHa BO Bpeu cecciD KOHrpeCCa OTCpa­ 'lIIBaTb jea' b COrIa ci a APyrO naJIaTLt coon sact u aRi a AOlli e 'IiIn Ba TpH u HJI BlIH nepeHOCHTb CBOH sact u aRi a H3' b Toro nCTa rAt u oJlzm 8acilAaTb 06t naJIa TLt OT ll ilJI'I 6 1 CeBaTQpbl H I1Pe u CTallHTellH u 0 lIlKRLI no n yqaTb oa CBOIO ClIyz6y u eHel HOe llosBarpaz n eHie lI oropoe u ommo t' iHTl' BaBHa'leBO awtOHO l' b II u O i ZllO ynJIa'lHBaTbcJt H3'L lta3Ha'leI1CTBa COe u BBeHHIn'I mTaTOB'L Ra lI'l RaKO I' b clIyqat aa IIclI JIlO'IeHien B8Mtm yrOJIOBBarO I1PecTynJleBia II BapymeBia 06 eCT BeBHarO CJIOll O IlCTBi a OHH Be MOryn 6lilTL apeCTOBam BH llO Bpeu nn npRCytCTBi a Ba aa ct u 8lIi a rJ CBoe JIMam BH lI' b TO BPeMSl lta ' b ompa B 1 $IlOT a Ba aactAaRia BH B1 TO KOHCT COE Jl HB E1ml 1llIlTATOB'I llpeu lta ' b l103Bp aIOTCJt OTTYAaj a aa CllOR piI'IlI II aa yqacTie lI' b I1PeRi a r Be MOryT'i jlilTL nOABepra em OTlrliTCTBeHHOCTH BH m ltaRO l' b jlJ yrO l' b lttcri SIRa CeBaTOpr r BH IIpe ll CTmmTeJIlIll'b T8'leHie l'Oro llpellleBH Ba lI OTopoe 6WIH llbl6pa m z Re MOryT'i jHTl' BaBBa'lem BH Ba lI alI YIO rpaz n aBClI YID AOlIJImOCTb IIpH COe u BBeBHLIn mTamX'L KOTOpa a yqp eRa BlIH aa ltOTOPYlO YBeJlH'leRO ZaJlOlla m e lI'l Te'leHie 9TOra BpexeBH a Ton KTO 8a mu ta eT' b RalI YlD-JIROO AOlll HOCTb IIpR Coe u BHeBIIIn'lo mTaTan lie MOl eT'I 6lilTL '1l1eRO l' b lI OTopolt-m60 naJIaTLt BO BpeU eBOero BUOl lI 8­ Bia IIpR AOlll HOCm OT u ilu 2 1 I'ralK lI aBalIl' b ltal ll aro JIlT8 ta AOJCItHbI 6HT1' IIpe u OCTaBlIeHbl AOJJ am t t RCXO ll HTb H3' b naJIaTLt I1Pe u CTa BlITeJIeit HO ceBan ltOl eT' b I1Pe araTb HlIH IIpHHRMaTb nOIIpal KH TO'IHO TaIt'D ze lta It'D B omOCD Te lll ­ RO IIPyrllX'b aall OBOIIpoeXTOm 2 RalK lI bIli 8aKOROIIpOell n ymeplK ll eHHbllt naJIaTolt IIpeACTaBlITeJlelt If eeBaTOM'I I1Pez u e 'It l' b 06pamTbCJt m aall Ol ' Aomen 6HT1' IIpe u cTa IeB'L I1Pe3B l1 e1lTY CoeABHeBHLIn illTaTOB' b OOllll I1PeSB lI eBT'I 0 u 06pBT'I ero l'O p OJImen JIo JIlIcaTb ero ecm ze Be OA06pnn l'O AOJIl em BOB­ spamTb era C'b CBOIlD B03pazeHiJIMn lI' b ry nM8ry lI OTOpOID 6b1JI' b cocTaBJIel ' a JIaJIaTa AOJll Ba BBecm ll'b CBOIt 4EYPHaJI' b Bet 8TH B03PS­ meBia B AOlIl Ha IIpIICTj'IIIIT ' b nepec IOTpY 8a KOKOIIpOeltTa ECJB nocld Toro nepeclIlOTpa u nt Tpam STOlt naJIaTLt ymep u JtT' b 8a OROIIpOeBT'I '1'0 ero clItAYeT' b OTOClIaTb lllltCTt C' b B03pazeBi a lm m u pyryEO nM8ry EOTOpa a Tage lI OlIl Ha CBOBa paacMOTpiiTL era H oom oAoopRn era ABY1f J TpeTJIW rOllocOB'I l'O om u iI lIaerCJt 8wtOBO l' b Bo llO llCtn 8T1lX'I clIyqa s rr rOllocoBaHie AOJDO I1PHCXO ll HTb m 00tnn JIaJIaTarJ nocpe u cTBO I' b ymep u IITe lll HIn'I B' OTpBll aTell HIn'I OTlrliTOB'I a DeKa no u alO l'OJIOca sa 3wtOBOIIpoeBT'I RJIIl IIpOmB'l Bero AOJOKHli 6HT1' llBeceHbl RaI1I' ll olt JIaJlaTO ll'b Z 1lBa l ' b Ecm lI aKOlt-u60 saKORa­ I1PoeltT'I Be 6y u eT' b ll03Bpa en IIpeaB ll eBTO I' b m re'leBie u ecam ABeft sa llculO'IeHien lIOCll peCHIn'I ABeft CO llpeldeBH ero IIpe u CTaBlIeBis '1'0 OB'L u illIa eTC I1 8aRORO l' b TO'IHO TaX' b ze Ra ' b oom 6b1 'iLIJl'I nO l ImClUI'L I1Pe3BAeltTo l' bj ecm ze 8wtOKOIIpoeJtT'b He Moman 6lilTL llO Bpamem 3TY CTPOllKY ClleA 'eT qm8n 1l 7 1 Bee 38KOHOrIpOeKThI rIO YBenH­ qeHHlO 1l 0X01l 0B-K83Hhl - Pe1l 264 265 1W1I COR H8 BB bIX'L Dl'l'A TOM DO DpR'IJlBt npeEpauteBi a sactp a BiIl XOBrpeCCa TO om lie DpHlll ae'l'Ca SUOHOn a BCJIKoe npeADHcame pesOJlIl IL1IlI rOJlocoBaBie A-U ltO'lOpHrf He06XO lOIMO lIS3BMHoe corJl3cie CeB3Ta 8 D UBm npeACTalIH'l'elIeI So 8CltJI1OIJeBieM'L T'lin KOrop aa KacalOTCJI OTCp01JKB S3Ctp a BiIl P O lDlmJ 6lilTb npep CTaBJlaem npeSll'JleBTY COe lOIHeHB blX'l' illmTOll'l 8 TOJlbKO DOCJIt ero op oGpeBi a lIcrynalOT'L B'I CBJIYi eCJlH ze om Be 6yp JT'I JD 'J o n 06pellli TO n OJllElIH 6s n CB01l3 yrnep3l Aem ABywl TpeTSOOl CeBaTa H DaJIB'l'liI npe CT311H'l'eJlelt COO6P3SHO C'I T'lin npa BBJI3MH 8 orpalDl1Je­ Bisnm KaKi R YCTaBOBJIem OTBOCHTeJlDHO S3KOBonpoeKTOJl' D OTp i n 8 Kourpecc'I OJIzeH'L mT1 npa Bo l BaJI3raT1 H co6Bpan DomJIHm J HaJIOrn Do n 3m 8il JIL1131JHB3T1 OJIm B npBHlDl3n MtPIi lI JIH o6m elt o6opom B lI JIH o6m aro 6 l1arococTOHBi a Coe lOIHeHB blX'l' illTBroB'l j DO BCt DO am HaJIOm H SHIiH DomJIam OJllElIH 6sn o n HBaKOBIi DO BctM'L COeAlIBeBHIiM'L illTaTaM'L 2 ll tJlaTL saJbm Ha Kpep BT'L Coe n lIBeBHIiX'l illT3TOB'I i BlPeryJlBpOB3TL roprOBJIIl C'I BHOCTpaR B WllI rocy n 3pcTBaMH Mez u y paaJIH1JHIiMH lJIT3T3MH H C'l BHAtltCKHMH lIlIeMeB3ni 4 YCTaHOBJIHTL o Hoo6paaH wl npaBBJIa B3rypaJIHSa $l a o n aoo6paame 8uom 0 6aHKpOTCTBax'I DO BctM'L COe lOIHeBm DI'i mT3TaM'Lj 5 lJeRaBHTL MOBery peryJlBpOB3T1 K3n eJl I fIBBOCTI Tan 8 I fImocn BHOCTpaHB blX'l' KOaeT'l 8 YCTaaOBJIHTL aOPNJ A-U Mtp'l a BicoB'l 6 lIpBBBM3TL JltPIi P JI a aa a3aBi a sa DOmJlEJ 6Jlll1ZllIiX'It p eBe HHrJ SBUOB'l a xop 1Joll »oaem CoeAlllleBHIiX'l mTaTOB'l 7 YIJpez u aTL DO'lTOlllilJl KOBTOPIi 8 YCTp3HBaTL DO'lTOlIliIJI p opomj S lIoom p a TL paallHTie B3YK'I 8 DOJleS m J rl 8CKyCC' I'lI'I OOeSDe1JHBU so aBTOP3MH 8 H306ptT3TeJIJllIlI aa onpeAtJIeBm tIt cpon 8CItJW' UlTeJIbJI06 Dpa BO DOJII 50BaT CJI HX'I npOH311eAeBi RMH K OTXPIiTi RMHi 9 Yqpez u aTL cy n Ii crogm ie lImIte lIepXollHaro Cyp B 10lOu pe n tJIHTL '«ITO n OJllERO C'IHTaTLCJI JlOPCKHM'L paa6oen 'rOJlO1 ­ KIiM'L npecrylIlIemen COllepmllBHIiM'L 11'1 OTEpIiTOM'L KOpt 8 8apy­ memen Kez u ya3pO aarO npaBa B DOAB pr3TL S3 BHX'I BuaaaHill U 06'1 1ll1JI a TL 1I0by lIH J aBaT1 KanepcKi R cllH l tTeJlbCTBa B B3P aBa'lJ' DpaBBJIa 0 aanaT'li BoeBBOI Ao6li11JB aa cymt 8 aa KOP 266 EOB COBAHBRBBbIl 'b Dl'l'A T0M lI Ha6BpaT1 8 COAepZaT1 3PMiB 80 acCHrBona CJMIl'L BI T 'l$ npeAJlen ae p OJIZHo n tJlo n e a ao 60ne AJIBHBJi lI cpon lJiIM'L ABI ro o 18lCa3pgzaTL 8 cop epzaT1 tJlOT'l U'lBa n aB3T1 npaBBJIo A-U MHBHCTpa $l B Opr3BB3a $l cyxOJIYTlUilX'lt B KOPCarr DOeBBHrJ CULj 15 ll tJlaT1 pacDopgzeBi a 0 cosmm IIBJIJIqiB A-U KCDOJIHeBis SaItOBOIl'1o COIl3a AU DOAaBJIeBi a lI03cTalIiI B OTpazeBis Benpi RTenCItlI X'i 8B­ mecTBilj 16 lIpBBBMaT1 riPIi A-U opraBB3aqIH MBJI- eJI lIOOpyzeBis 8 06f1Je­ B1s A8C B AU smAUBaBi a 'l'OIl eJl 1Jactill ltO'lOpU Kazen O ll 'b ynOTpe611eaa ao cl JlE6y Coe lOIHeBB LtX' D illTaTOlI'L npeAOCTalIJIJIJI Ba lEAOKY mTaTy Ba8Ba1JeBie otBIJ ep01l'l 8 npaBO 06f1J3T1 lIIlIJlBI ill DO rin npaBBJIan KaJti R npeADHCa BIi KoarpeCCOM'Lj 171lIoJl 30Ban e a B'I ltaltRX'J -6Ii TO mr 6wo CJlflJa xr r BCEJlIl1JH'l'en­ BOil SaItOHOAaTenROIl BJIacTiIl 11'1 TOM'L OEpyrt Be npeBLmIallm en CTa B Ba ApamHrJ MBJIb ltOTOpIilt KozeT'I cp tJIaT CJI ricTonpeOIillla ­ Bien npamrre n eTlla Coep BHeHB blX'l' mTaT01l'l lICnAcmie YCTJllXlI cp illIaBaol KOTOPIiMH-HB6YAI mTaTaMB 8 npBWttOIL xourpeccom B JI0l l 501lo n e a TaKO l ze BJIactill DO lICtrr Mtc' 'a 1'I EJlIlIeBHIiX'l m EalOM'L-JlH60 lJITan C'I corllaci R ero 3aKOaOAaTeJlbaaro c06paBi a AU nOCTpOlI Ru xptnocTel XaraSDOB' apCeBaJIOB' Beptell B APymrr Beot XOABMIiX'J 8AaBill B 18lBap aBaT1 Bcuie 3aIt01Ili Balde OKaZyTCJl Beo6xo n BMl I MH B yrlCT­ mMB p JI a DOJII 5OlIaBi a Ean llLmIeHC'IBCJleBBIiMH npaBaMH TaJI ' 1I11Cto APJrHMH npaBaO xaKi R npeAocTaBJlem 9TOIL xoRc ell llpaBH'l'eJlb­ CTBY COep BJleR m J rl mTllTOB'l IL1IlI BOTOPOXY-lIBOO B3'L ero AeJIapTaMeB­ TOB'l IL1IlI AO lIlEROCmHrJ lIJ1l'tF OTAtn 9 ll lIepeeeJIeme BJlB lllI03'r marr JIIlAel ltOTOpIiX' comB­ cem npHRlITI y ce6 a KOTOpIilt-l H60 B3'I cym ecTBym m e rr 11'1 BacTOmlJ ee BpeMJI mTaTOB' ae AOJllElIH 6IiTL BOCnpe eMIi KOBrpeCcon 11 0 TIiCJIIJa BOCenCOT'I BOCLxoro ro a ao Ba Taxol lIB03'l MOlEIlO aaJIaraTL 'raKcy IL1IlI DOmmuy Be npeBIimallm ylO Aec aTlI AOJIJlapoB'l C'I Ba lEAaro '9 elIa­ Bi aa OOlIpaBa npeAocTallJleBlllltJl aKTOM'L 0 IIH1JBoI cB060At Re AO lDlmJ 6IiT1 267 KOB DB speu onrnuem ecm liTO lie OlazeTM EOOOXOP lDImI ' 1f U ecTBeBIlol KOHC'l1I l'YnI I COEARBEBBJ 'IX' DlTATOB'L COmr B'H'BBBJ 'IX' DlTATOB'D 06­ ieaoIIacIIocm IIO IIpINBllt BoscTaHiJI JWI BenplEren eEa1'O E8 IIIecTBiL O 3anpe c s np aBan saROIIOIIpOeETIi 0 BaKaaaBiJI sa rocyp ap­ CTBeHlJYlO Hsoay Bill of Attainder lLlJi saKOm BOlOnUe oopa myID cuy 4 3aIIpe s oOJlaran IIOP y tmIOIO IIop an 1O BJ B p pynom IIpJlllm 1 EaJ Orrum Dalle EaR' D copaaopBO C' D n eB30H'b BJ B C' D nepeIIBCl IO 0 IIpOB3BOACm EOTOpol 'lI0XJmj'T0 BLmle C5l3anpentaeTCJ oOJlaran IIO D llIDt8 llll Bm BaJ oraD TOBapIl lImIOSB­ we B3' D EOTOparo-moo mara 6l 3anpentaeTCJI OTAaBan npep IIo'lTeBie raBaRaH'b OP BOro mara IIepep ' D raBaRaMll APyroro DITam IIOCpep CTBOH'b BBep eBiJl EaKlIX'I -mOO TOpro­ m rr r ILIB qJIIllaHCOBDlX'I IIocTaBon 1eBiIl a EOpao lI BanpaBlI lIlOnUec s X'l EaEO lj-noyn maty 11m Bmop s m ie IIS' D ero ranan lie MOlj l' D i1i1l'I nplIHJ lC ll em I BXOP HTb B'b ranam APyroro maT paarpyatan cJl mn H yruratmBan IIOIIlJInm t 7 3anpentaeTc lI opan BS' D Ea 3BaqeltCTBa p eHbm Dalle KaK'b Ba OCBO­ Bam aCCBrHOBOR'b cp ilJ aHru tX' Jler3J l m IM'I CIIOCOOOM'I i a 0l'L llpeMeBJI AO speMeBJI C ilp yen OnyO 'lIIKOBIilBan IIOp pOOm Ie OT'leTli 0 rocyp apCTBe AOXOp ax'l B pacxop 8JCOe l HHellm Ie lliTam lie BOlOn IIpaBa aap aBan p nops Hcrde mty lH a TOT' ETO aalmllaen IIpB BJII'J RaKYIO-JIIIOO AO 'OKHOCn IIpHHOCJllIij'1O BW'Op LI BJlI OCBOBaHHYIO Ba p OBilpin Be KOlEen IIpnllIIlalan 6e3' D cOrJIaci a EOIlrpeCCa HlIKaKJ I'J IIOp apKOB'l Bosllarpa m D eB1Jl p oumocrelt UII TBtyJlOB'b on KaKoro-moo KOPOJl ll npBHD a BJ B mrocTpaHHaro rocyp apcTBa OTp ilJI'l 10 l HD op Hn B3' D maTOB'l Be lIoen npaBa 8aK llIO'lan 'l'paRTaTH BCTYIIan B'b C0103' D BJ B xOllqJeAepa$O BNAaBan ltalIepcRi a cBll lI ilTelI CTBa 'leJt8 llllT 1II0llety BlinYCEan Kpep llTm Ie iueTIi EaRlla'lan 1fTO-mOO KpOO 8Q lorolt II cepeops Ho1t MOBeTH cpep cTBoH'b 1f U yruram Ao troB' D BSp aBan SaROBonpoeltTIi 0 BaKa3aBiJ1 S8 rocyp ap­ 'CXGrpJl meC1'l'lIl Tp nGlIpll Bll' tTBeHHYIO BSORY aaKOHfl C' D oopamoltcll 1lOltmm saKam YBJI'lTOllta­ IOIWe OOJl1laTeJll IIYIO clLlY AOroBOPOB' D pasp anan KaEie-JiBOO p BOps Hcrtie TlIT 'J I L B HD 0P 1lII'l 113' maTOB'b Be men npaBa OOJIaran Oe3' D COrJIaci a 1I0Ilrpecca EaEH1llIl-JlHOO IIOlIlJInllaD 1LI1I BaJIOraMH npep Mem BBosa 11 BiItBOSa BCEJIIO'leBie p onYCRa eTCS TOJIl KO B'b TOH'b paaopil KaRol oeaYCJlOBIIO HeOOXOp llM'I A 1IJl nplmep eBis B' D IIcno tBeBie SaKOHOB' D mam KacaTeJll HO Bap sopa a Bcs rti1t 'lHcTIill P OXOP ' D on IIOIIlJIIlII'l H B3J OrOB'b xoropmrll OWB OOJloacem B'b mraTil npep Mem BBosa lIJlH BiItB03a p oJlzen nocTYIIan B' D II01Il SY KaaBaqeficTBa Coep HHellm IX' D lliTaTOB' D neil SaKOm I IIToro pop a P 0JIZm I IIop nepran c s nepeCIaIOTPY B EOH'rpOJlIO EOIlrpecca I HD Op llIl'l B3'l maTOB' D Be Hlalilen npaBa Oe3' D corJlaci a EOHrpecca lIaJaran ltard Jl -JlHOo IIOlJl ilH1 li Ha ltopaoexJ om Ie rpySIl cop epzan B' D KIIpBoe BpeM lI BoltcKa BlIlI BOeHm Ie ROpaoJR BCT 'lIan B' D Kard Jl - mOo cor rameBis liD p OrOBOplit C'l p pyrHlal' D mTaTOn B l C' D HBocrpallm IH'b npaBIITe n CTBOn IL'lH npep npIIHIIMan BOltHy BBa'le ltan BcJIilACTBie lIenpis re1Il cltaro BamecTBi a lIll B'b cJlY'lail Taltol aelUIllyeMol onacaG­ cm KOTOpas Be AonyCKaen llIIKaltlIl ' D npoBOJlOqen CTan s II OtAil1I' D 1 llHCIIOJIllllTe1Il Bas B 'Iacn P OJIZHa OIi1l'I npep oCTaBJIeHa IIpesll lI eHTY COep Bllel lIIiX' D lliIaTOB'b AMepHKH On p OJlZ6n COCTOs n B' D p O 'OKHOcm B' D Te'leHie llempen Jlill'L a ero B30paHie TO'lHO TaJt1 e EaK' D 1I30paBie BllD e-npeSll lI eHTa Ba TaKOI ze cPOK'b P OJIZIlO IIpQ1I3BOII IIThCJl CJlilp ymlIQlM' D CIIOCOOOM'l lilKazp lit1I mTan p o 'lZen BaSBallIlTh TilX' D cIIocOGOM'l Koroplit1l 0YlI en YCTaHOBJIen ero saKOBop aT61IJ olIlitM' D coopaBien BlitOOp KOB' D B'b 'lBCJliI paBBOn TOKY 'lHCJlY ceHaTOpOB'l B npe n cTaBlITexel EaKOe on lIMilen npaBO IIocwan B'b EOIlrpeCC' D BO Blit60pntHEOlrL Be Mozen OIi1l'I BasBa· qeH' D 1m ceBaTOp'b 1m npe lCTaBlITeJll mr TOT'b ltTO 3aBIIMaen ttplI COep mreHm IX' D lliTaTax'l EaKym-JlBGO IIoqemym un AOXOII UYro p o 'IZ­ BOCn APyrHe 269 268 IWBCTB' l'1ltUI COJWIBElJJJJJX' lIITATOB'J BJi iopIIQ KII AOJZBl'iI cotipa'l'foCj lI'I CBOBrL JIITaTarL B noopeAcnon tia uOmpOBItII nO a 8 BM'l' l'O Ioca aa AB 'X'l' mD '1i HB'l BOTOpln'£ no Mem ­ mel opil OAHO Be AOumo npDa a Jlezan It'b 1 jJCJly mrreJIelt OAHOro C'D DW JIITaTa OD lIO mBH Cocra BH'rh CIIBCOlt'D Bciln JI 311 EOTOpwr nOA8 BaJIDCl r 1 Oca B Bctn TOJlOOOB'l' no a 8JlBllU'l' aa oe H3'b 9TBrL JlDlI 'I 9TOn CIIBCOlt'D OD AO mBH nOAJIBcan H saeBH lIilreJrbcTBOBan H npDCJlan era aa ne'lata mm Jll'D lI'I OCTonpOOlilB8Jlie npaJlHTeJll' Ctna CoeADeHHlilX'l' mraTOB'l' Ha mrs npeAct llareJlJl CeHaTa npeActA t TeJh CeHaTa AOJD£eH'b BCRpIltTl' Beil saCBH lIilTeJIl' CTBOBa B HLle CIIBCltH lI'I npH­ cyrcniH ceuaTa B naJIant npeACT8 BHTeJleJl H TOl'Jl a c riJ lIyen C'lecn no a a B HLle rOJlooa TO'l'Io ETO nOJlJ'lDll'D calloe tiOJll' moe 1 jJCJlO fOAOOOB'b AOJDJteH'b i1ltTl' npeSH lleHTOlIt'f eCJlB 8TO UClO cooTaB 1lJlen iO ThmDHCTBO Bciln BaaHa'leHHlilX'l' BJi60p BOlI'I ec m EEl HilCKOJIl EO lJOJIf'l1tlll raxoe iOJIl' mHHCTBO rOJlOOOB'b B eCJIB 330 HHX'l' nOAaHO p8 BHoe qBCJlO fOJlOOOB'b TO nuaTa npeACTaBHTeJIell lIODtlla RellleAJIeHHO BJi ipan OAHOTO B3'I HHX'l' B'b npeBH lIeHnt nOCpeACTBOn tia uompoBltBj ecm me BHltTO He noJy'lHl'L ioJll' mHHcna TOJlOOOB'b TO m-ze nuaTa AODtlla Tfnr r ze cnocotion BJi ipan npeSH lIeHTa B3'b rfln rurm mD '1i BOTIl lJ 1 1l OTOJIT'b nepBlilMB B'b CIIBCltii no 'lDCJlY l'O IOCOB' Ho npB m60pil npeaB­ AeHTa cJIilAyen nOAaBan rOJlooa no IIITaTallt'f ralt'D 'ITO npe a cT8 BlrIeJIl' ­ eno ltalE ll a ro JIITaTa Brien OADH'b fOJlOC'b a u 9TOI JIB quorum AODmO COOTOJl'l'l' BB'l qJleHa BJIB 'lJIeBOB'b on AB 'X'l' rpereA maTon a AJlS1 Blil iopa Beotixo a BllO iOJll' mDBCTBO B3'b Bctn JIITaTOB'l Bo BCS1 ltOM'L eJIyqail noCJIil m iopa npesH lIeIiTa AOJIEeH'b tilltTl' npB3BaH'b BRqe­ npeaH lleHTOM'b TOT'b aa BOro tililJlO nOAaHo m iop a mr caHoe tio moe 1 jJC 110 rOJlOOOB'bj BO eCJlH iJi OKaSaJIOCr 'ITO AlIa IlIB 60JIiIe JlRqa nOJlyqDJIB o a D8 BOe 1 jJCJlO rOJlOOOB'b ro ceuan a 0JIEeH'b BJitipan B3'b HHX'l' BRqe-npe3BAeHTa nOOpeACTBOn tiaJIJlOTUpOBltH 8lRourpeec'b Mozen Onpe a tllHTl' BpeMS AJIS1 BStipaJlis BJitio B'b H AeB lI'I ROTopd OHD a OJIZHlil nOAaBan rOJlooa 9TOn Aen lIOJIEeH'b 0Jm o a BH'b B rOT'i EEl AJlJI Bctn Coe a DeHHlilX'l' mTaTOB'l 4lB'b AOumOOn npeaH ll8HTa 1l03en tilltTl' B3tipaH'b TOJIHO TO'l' L TO l 0'l' I0 uaparpatL O J iaen 270 a l ltarolO DOllPaDEOIO r 49 B'fOi IIlI IImJ IWBc nrm tIJI COE 'll1flIEHIJ'f lIITATOIr pO llBJltS1 rpalE ll aHHHon COOADeHHlilX'l' mTaTOlI'I UB ETO tililJl'I BX'l' rpalE ll 8JlRHon BO BpeU ymepz n eHiJI EOHC He 1l03en tilltTl' D3­ tipaH'b B'b 8TJ a OllZHOOn TOT'b ETO Be AOC'l'H1 JJ 'l'p a fllIIJlmJltms ro BOBpaeTa B Be Brill'b B'b Te'leHie 'le'mpH3 II l am riJn ZIITe lIl cna B'I Coe a neHHlilX'l' mTaTarr SJB'i cJlyqat YAaJIeBiJI npe3H l1eIiTa 0T'b Aoumocm BJIB B'b cJlyqail ero cMepm aw o a a lI'I OTCT8 Blty BJIB HecnocotiHoom nOJll' 30Ban ea npaBallUl B BCnOJIBJI'l'l' otis 38JlRocm ero a ODtllOCTD ero 3ariuen BRqe-npe3B­ AeHn a ltourpeCC'b MOZeT'b nocpe a cnon D3 a aJIiJI aaROHa npDJI'l'l' ups Ba ClyqaA JAueHiJI on AOJIZHOOTD cHepm OTCT8 BltH UB H8CnocotiHocm B npeaH lleHTa B BRqe-npe3H l1eHTa B oti'beHTl' xaxoe AOJIZHoomoe nm o a OJlZHO B'b TaROM'b cJlyqat sarluJlTl' npesH lIeIiTa 8TO JlRqO a OJIZHO aarlHS1 Tl' npeaH lleHTa nORa Be npeltpanrroJl npD'lDa y a aJleBiJI 8Toro noo ri a HS1 rO on jl ODmOcm BJIB noxa He tiy a eT'b BliltipaD'b BOBd npe­ aH llellT' L 6JITpesH lIeHT'b a OJIZeH'b nOJIyqan 8a CBOIO eJIYZ6y B'b BaaHaqeHHRe CpOltH B03RaI'p33 ll eHie ltOTopoe Be Momen tilltTl' HD JBeJID'leHO HD Mem ­ meHO B'b TeqeHie TOTO nepio a a Ha EOTopd 0H'b BJitipaH'b B on Be AOJIEeH'b nOJlyqan B'b reqeHie 9TOro nepio a a HHEaxoro a pyroro lIeHeZH8t­ ro BOBHaI'p33 ll ellill D on C08 a DeHHlilX'l' mTaTOB'b D on O a Boro B3'I DlTalOB'I '1 nepe a 'I BCTJlI lIeBien B'b HcnomeHie CBODn 0 ia 3aHHOOTel OH'b AOJIZeH'b Aan eJIilA IOIIij'IO npDCs ry UB a I pM IO dI TOpmeeneDo ltJIS1 BJCl' UB ynepz n alO 'ITO tiyA 'lecmo HCnOJl­ wm otiJl8aHHoom npe3H l1eUTa Coe a DeHHlilX'l' illTaTOB'b B tiy a y no rlpofl 1l0BrL CBJI'b eo6J1lOjI a'l'I oxpaHS1 n B 3 an EOHC Coe a DeH­ m rrr mTaTOB'I J OTjI lIn 2 lJITpeaH lleHT'b tiYAeT'b rJl8 BHOltOM8JlA IO apm H lIOTa Coe a BHemDilX'l' mTaTOB'l' B M R lIBI llI OT a tJll' BllU'l' malOB'b Eor a a OHa tiy a eT'b npD3BaHa Ha CJlya 6y COeADeHHlilX'l' mTaTOB'bj OH'b Mo KeT'b rpe­ tiOBan on BJiCmBrL lIOllDOCTBlilX'l' JlDlI 'I EalE ll aro B3'b HCnOJIHHTeJll' ­ m rrr a enapTaMeHTOB'b IIBCl' MeDO 113J10Z8HHaTO ullHiJI 0 BCJlKOH'l' npe a ­ Meri BXo a am en B'b c epy BX'l' Bt a OMCTBa B eMY AODmO tilltTl' npep o­ lWHC'I'Im'IUJI COE JUllIEBIIll1X' I IlITATOB'b CTa1IJleHO llpaBO orcpOTfllllaTb I IcnoJ Hellie llpIU'OBOPOm II lImJIOBaTb no llpecrynneBi s M1 llpO' l'll1l'r CoeABHemmrr illraroB'l sa I IclWO'IeBiem CJ yqa eB'L Impeachment 'a B EMy n 0JG£H0 llplmll ltJleEaTb llpaBO Sa lWOqaTb rpaltTam no COBtTY II C'L corJ aciJl CeBaTa C'L TilIl'L 'ITOOO 8TO corJlaeie 6wo Blilpal£eBO n By wJ rpeTS Ilm llpl lcyrcT Bj'lO m nr D ceBaTOpOB'L on 6rnen llpe n J araTb H no COBtty 1 1 C'L corJ aciJl CeBaTa 6y n eT'L BaSBa '1aTb nOCJlOB'L n pyrl lX'I ynOJ BOMOqeBl bl l 'r H XOBCYJ OB'L t J eBOB'L nep XOBBaro crna 1 1 BCtX L n PyrI IX'I n OJG£HOCTllliII'L J 1Ill 'L Coe n I IBeIIBLIX'L illTaTOll'L 0 cnoeoCit Ba SBa'leBill ltOTOpLIX'L Be C n ilJlaBO s n tCl BIlRaRlU'L nocraBOBJIeRilt 1 1 Jl OmHocm XOTOpLIX'L 6y n yt'L Y'IPelK lI em saxoBon 1'10 xourpecc'L KOEen no CBoeMY ycxorptBiro saXOBon llpe n ocTaBBTb Ba8Baqellie TaJi lU'L BI I8 IIIlU'L n OJIDOCTllJJlX L 1I1Ill 'L IIJIIl O n BOMY llpeBII n eB'lj' mm ey n a 'L I IJIH aa'laJIDBIIRalll'L n enapTaKeHTOB'L 3 IIpe3II n ellT'L n olI i£en lurliTb llpaBO 3arl n cmpmaro$CJI BO BpeMJI saRpLl'1'il ceccin ceBaTa BaRaBcin BI l ll aB3JI nareB ' l' li Ba n ommo­ em epoX'L xoroPLIX'L n OJl i£eB'L KOB'laTl CJl C'L oxoB'laBielll'L eri n yrom el ceccilI Ot n tJi'L S OB'L a O ll3en on npeKem n o Bpexem n OCTaBJlJl'l 'f Kourpeccy cBil n tBill 0 JIOJI03ellil l Coma Il llpe n Jlaran Ba era YCMOrpt Die ra is XtPLl JWdJJ C'lHTaeT'L Be06 X0 n BDMLlU 1 1 nOJleBlIJJlDj OB'L XO i£en n 9XCTpeBIIJJlX L CJ yq3JIX L C03man 00'11 na Jlam BJIH o n uy H3'L JmX'L 1 1 m cJlyqat pa8HOmcl iIl XelK lI y BlUm aCaTeJJl nO BpeMeBH 3a xpLl'I'il sact n aRilt M03eT'L OTJlaraTb nr r sact n aHill Ba crO lll RO BpeKeBI I aa CXOJll XO sa6J1aropaSCrnHT D on n oJ j£en llpmtBllan nOClIOB'L H l pyrl lX'I ynOJlHOKO'leRHLIX'L n Ol lKen saCiomTbCJI 0 TOTlBOM'L HCnOJIHeHin saROHOm H n oJlzen BI l ll aBaTl naTeB ' l' li BctM'L n OJG£HOCTBLlM'L Coe a lmeRllJJlX L illTaTOB'L OT n tJI'L 4 llpeSH n eBT'L lIlIlW-JIpesII n ellT'L II lIci rpaz n ancRill Jl o muOCTBLlJI 1IIDl a Coe n mteBIIJJlX L illTaTOB' D n 0DmJi 6L1Tl y n u s em on a OJllE BOCTel B'L cJlY'lat Impeachment'a JIO 06BHlIeBiID lI'L H3rlH'fl lIO B3JlToTlBJlqecm IIJIH B'L ll pyrl lX'I BazBJiX'I llp6CTJIl IeHiarr H npo­ cTynRaX'L 272 lWHCTIIn'WJI CO IlITATOB'D CraTbJI Ill OT n tJI'L 1 Cy n e6BaJI BJl8 CTb Coe n HlIeRllJJlX L illTaTOm a 0l l£Ba 6l11Tb llpe n ocTa1lJlens OIl IIOMY BepxoBBoMY cy n y 1 1 Tillll'L HlISIIIIDl' cy n an XOTOpLle ltOlU'pecc'L 6YII eT'L on BpeMemt n o BpeKeBB yqpelK ll an• 1 I t J em nepxoBB8ro cy n s 1 1 t J em HlISIIIlU' f Cy n OB'L a OlIamIl OCT8Banca m CBOHX L 1I 0JllE BOCTlIX L JIoxa 6yp yt'L Becm ceCia 6eSYROpH3HeBBo j om P 0DmJi no­ JlyqaTb sa CBOID cJlyzCiy m naaBa'leHllJJle CpOlW a eHelE BOe B03Harpa Ell 900 Hie XOTopoe Re M03eT'L 6L1Tl 'Mellbmeno nOlta om OCTaroTCJI m a Ol l£Bo­ cm OT l tJi'L 2 llCy n eCiBaJI BJl8 Cn a 0l l£B8 npocmpaTbClI Ra Bct a ua paspilmaeMLl ll no 3aROBY HJIO CllpaBe l l RBOcrn JtaRiJl Moryn B03B l1RHyTD no nOBop y BTOft XOBCTJITYll iB H 3aROBOm Coe l l lBeHBLIX'L illTarom H no nOBo n y rpaRTaTOB'L XOTOpLle saK 1IJ qem UH 6J n fT'L 8aRJ1roqem nop 'L nr r BilP OMCTBOlll'Lj Ra Bet n ilJIa ltacaro$cJI noc 1l0B'L n pyrllX L llpaBlITeJll CTBeBHLlX L ynOJBOMOqeBIIJJlX L H ltOBCYlIOm Ba BCt a tJla xaearo$CA ap xHPa nel1cTBa 1 1 1I0pcltOi roPHcII H H Ba TmIil' m ROTOpIn'f O l l loro HB'L T ca CTOPOB'L JIBJJlroTca Coe n HB'eBme illram na rmK6I l r te E J y n Bp JI Il 'lH 60 1te mara tII Mezp y lIITaTOn H rpa E ll aBaMH n pyroro mTaTa MelK lI Y rpa E ll RHall1I pa31IH'I1IJJlX L mTaTOB'L r tez n y rp aHaMI I o n Horo mara llpep 'LJIBJI s IO HMH CBOH llpaBa na aeM 1H JIOllyqeBHLlJl B'L a ap'L on pa3JlB'lllJJlX'L lIITaTOB'L H MeJK ll y mraTOn B '1II ero rpa £JJ a Ha l H C'L op Boll cropom H l IBocrpallllID ll rocy n apCTBa l I rpa Ell aHa lIII BJlH 1l0 IJl 1lJIHIiIlDI C'L n pyroft 2 Bo BCtX L dlIa X L ltacalDlllJlXcJI noCllOB'L n pyrl lX'I ynOJIHOMO'leRllJJlX L H ltOBCYlIOB1 H B'L TilX L p tJIar r B'L xoropm'L lIITan JIBJlJIeTCJI O n HOro IlS'L Tazym nxCJI CTOPOB'L nepxOBBoMY cYP Y a OmHa llpl lBa I l ezan nepBOBa'laJIDB3JI roPHC I I I Bo BCtX'L n pyrl lX'I paH'fle ynOMJIByrm'L p tJIaX L BepxoBBoKY cy n y p O IIZBa llpHBB n lIeJB an roPIlCp mrn Ia no aJIlIel H OTBOCHTeJJl BO 88lt01Ia H OTBOCIITeJJl BO aRTOB'L C'L Til r tH HC lUID'IeIIimm l no TaJi IIM'L llpaBBJlaIl'L JWdJJ 6J n fT'L YCTaBOMem xourpecCOM' 3 Bct llp6CrynneHill all HClUIOqeBien TilX L clIyqaeB'L Itor n a Bos6yz­ lI eBO yrolIoBBoe llp6ClItp oBaBie llpOTRB'L P OJUKBOCTIIJJlX L 1I1Ill 'L Cases of 273 KOHCTllTYIUJI COE IUmE1IIThIX'l IITTATOB'l KOHC Impeachment P OllKHLt CYP HTbCJI CYP OM'L npHCm HLIX'Lj cyp 'L P OJOEeII'b 1Ip0HCXOP HTb B'L TOM'L lIITa'I'fl B'L EOTOPOM'L COBepmeso npecT 'IlJIeHie SO eCJlH OSO se COBepmeso SH B'L OP SOM'L HS'L mTaTOB'L TO CYP 'L p OlmelI'b 1Ip0HCXOP HTb B'L TOM'L MtC'I'fI HlH B'L 'I'fln riCTan EOTOPWI 6yp yn Ea3aHIil SaKOSOM'L usp asHLnI'L OT'L EOnrpecca OTp tJl'l 3 1 IIop 'L m IpazeHieM'L Hsrisa COep HHeIl1lIilM'D IIITaTaM'L COE IUmEBJII IX' IIITATOB'l Jla OCJlOBaHiH EaElJX'I JlHCio aaEOSOB'L Hm nOCTaHOBJIeHilt 9TOro p pyroro maTaj 01I'b p OJllKes'L CiL1Tb BLI lIalI'b no TPeCiOBaHiRl Toro EOMY p OJUEelI'b 6W'L HCnOlSJlTb clYlKCiy H 'IH paCiory OTp tl'L 3 l HoBLIe mTam Moryn CihITb npHHlIMaeMLI EOHrpecCOM'L B'L BTOT'L COIOS'L j so HlIEaEoA SOBLIl1 lIITaT'L se MOmeT'L CiL1Tb oprasHso­ cJltp yeT'L pasyMtn TOJihEO BoscTasie npOTHB'L HBX'L C'L opYJideM'L B'L BaS'L HJlH yqpellt ll elI'b B'L c fJept IOPHcp H1w iH EaEoro-JIuCio p pyroro mTaTaj IIHEaEOlt lIITaT'L se MOmeT'L CiL1Tb opraHHSOBaH'L nocpep CTBOM'L coep H­ PYXaX'L npDcoep HseHie Hn BparaM'L olt3 sasie nOMOIqIl H cop i l1cTBie JleHill p Byn HJlH 60lte lIITaTOB'L H 'IH qaCTel1 lIITaTOB'L Cies'L COrJIaciJI BTHM'L BparaM'L HHETO se MOmeT'L 6Ii TL npusSaH'L BHSOBIIhIM'L B'L I1SMtut ssaqe EaK'L sa ocsoBaHiH P Byn CBHp i TelLCRHn nOKasaHilt ltaK'b SaEOSOp aTeJlLlILlX'L coCipasilt BTHX'L lIITaTOB'L TaE'L H EOnrpecca B'L oTHomesiH R'L Op SOMY H TOMY lICe HBCTBeSsOMY p tl1CTBiIO rum sa ocsoBaHiH c06cTBessaro npHSSasiJI cp tJlassaro sa cyp t pHTopielt HlH p pyrolt coCicTBeSsocn lO npHsap Jlemam elt Coe llHsessLUrI 2 Konrpeccy P OJIlICHO 6hITb npep OCTaBleSO npaso sassaqaTb saKaaaHie o6xop npaBH 'Ia H PYEoBOp CTBa a B'L BTOlt EOSCTH H SnqTO Jle sa ssmmy so 06BHSHTeJlhsLIl1 npHrOBOp' nop BepralOm il1 JlHmeHiIO npaB'L P OJllKHO CiIi TL 06'L HCH HeMO B'L TaEOM'L CMLIClt EOTOpLIl1 CiLtJl'l -CiLI Jlapy­ meHieM'L npaB'L Coep usesllLlX'L IIITaToB'L HJlH op soro HS'L lIITaTOB'L K'L COCTO Hsi H u m mrpa fJy P OJllKeS'L 6L1Tb p tI1CTBUTeJleH'L TOJILKO B'L TeqeBie lICHSHll oCylK ll essaro 2 Kosrpeccy P OJIlKlIO 6L1Tb npep ocTaBleso npaBO pacnopJD£an CJI Tep­ IIITaTaM'L H Hsp asan OTHOCHTeJILSO BTOlt coCicTBessocm BCt Jle­ OTp tJl'l 4 Coep HHesHLIe IIITaTLl P OJllKHLI oCiesnequn ElUK lI OMY CTaTb H IV nrrary BcrynaBmeMY B'L BTOT'L COIOS' pecnYOJIDEascKYRl fJopMY npaBJ e­ Eia H P OJlDLI oxpasJlTb EalIt lI LIl1 mTaT'L OT'L senpiJITeJlhcEHn samecTBilt OTp tJl'l 1 B'L Kallt ll OM'L IIITa'I'fl cltp yeT'L OTHOCHTbCJI C'L nOJlHLnI'D p oBtpieM'L H YBalICesieM'L K'L ny6J1Hquwcr a Tam O fJ aJlhHLIM'L p OKy­ a no npocL6t saEOSOp aTelSarO coCipasiJI HJlH HCnOlSHTe 'ILSolt BJlaCm EOrp a SaEOSOp aTeJ Lsoe c06pauie se MOllCeT'L coCipaTbCJI P OJllKHLI oxpa ­ MeSTaM'L H cyp e6HLD 'L ptmesi HM'L lt3 lK Il aro p pyroro lIITaTa A KosrpeCC'L JIJITb E mTaT'L H OT'L BsyrpeSHllX'L JlacHJIilt MOllCeT'L 06m uMH saKosaMH YCTaSOBHTb cnoco6' EOTOPwcr cJltp yeT'L yp OCTOBtP HTb 9TH aETLI p OKYMeSTLl H ptmeHiJI H un cH 'Iy CTaT'L H V OTp tJI'L 2 1 I'pallt ll asaM'L Kal£ IJ arO lIITaTa P OJIlKlILI 6L1Tb npep OCTaBJIeHLI BCt npHBHJIeriH H npaBa rplUK ll aH'L B'L p pyrHX'L mTaTan ECJlH p Bt TPem qJlesoB'L oCitun naJIaT'L npHsSalOT'L BTO seoCixop H­ 2 ECJIH qeJIOBtK'L 06BHS HeMl Il1 B'L KOTOPOM'L-JIu60 HS'L IIITaTOB'L B'L MLlM'L EOnrpeCC'L P OJliKeH'L npep lOlKH'l'I nonpasKH BTOIt EOSCT HlH Hsmmt HJIS B'L p pyrOM'L npecrynJIesiH CnaCeTC H 6trCTBOM'L OT'L cyp e6sa ­ lICe no npocL6t saKOSOp aTeJlhllLlX'L c06pasilt P Byn rperelt mTaTOB'L fO npecJItp oBasi H H 6yp eT'L OTLlCKaH'L B'L p pyrOM'L lIITaTt TO no TPe­ P OJllKelI'b COSBan EOHBeHT'L P JlJI npep JI0mesiJI nonpaBOE'L KOTOPWI B'L 60BaHiRl I1cnOJIsHTeJlhsol1 BlaCTH Toro mTara HS'L KOToparo OH'L 6tlKa Jl'L o60HX'L cJlyqMX'L Ciyp yn Hrin OCi HSaTeJlLsylO CHJlY B'L EaqeCTBt co­ OH'L p oJlllCelI'b 6LITb BLI lIaH'L P l H ornpasm B'L TOT'L mTaT'L BtP OMCTBY EOTOparo nop cyp so npecrynJIeHie BOp aTeJlLIILIMH c06pasiJnm rpen qernepTelt mTaTOB'L H 'IH EOHBeHTaMH 3 KTO 06 Hsas'L HCnOJIH HTD KaRYIO-HH6yp L CJlYlK6y H 'IH pa60ry B'L OP SOM'L CTaBHLIX'L qacTelt BTOlt EOSC H eCJlH Ciyp yn yrnepllt ll eHLI saEO­ H3'L lIITaTOB'L sa ocsoBasiH riCTlILlX'L saEOSOB'L H y6tlKHT'L B'L p pyroA B'L TPen qeTBepTSIX'L IIITaTOB'L -TaE'L EaE'L II TOT'L H p pyrolt cnocoCi'l yrneplK ll eHill MomeT'L CiL1Tb npep lOJKelI'b EOsrpecCOM'Lj so SHEaEaJI no­ rum pa60m npaBEa yrneplK ll eHHaJI paste TLlCJl1la BOCew cOT'L BOCLMoro rop a Be maT'L TOT'L se MOllCeT'L 6Ii TL OCB060lK ll elI'b OT'L BTOlt CJIym6LI 274 KOB CO 1J WIEJIJff IX'l IDTATOB'I B8CaThCa IIepBaI'O B 'le1'lleptaro IIOCTaROB lIeHil lI'i p erurroB IIepBOI CTaTbB B BB Op JIll'l llITan He xozen OHTD 6e3'l ero CGrJlaci a mmem paBB I'O c' APyrmtB mraT8XJI IIpaBa rOJloca B' cenarlJ OJDKHa OTAiJri J BiIBB AD aTOB fOlI Y llesaBBCmrOCm CoeABHeHllli X'i I1ItaTOlI'L AxepoH B'L yp ocTOBtpeme 'ler m lIOP lIBCUBCD 1I0P 'L Bel B3JIlIDIll DeBamL lI zop n Z'D Bam HrTOJr'L UpesDAeIl'l'li II p enyTan on BrrprHRiH CTaTbll VI l BciI P O l1'l ItOTOpLle 6WB cp ilJlaHLl B BciI YCJrOBiJ JWTOPLlll OWB 8a JtJ IOQeHLl P O yrBeplEAeBiJ 8TOI ltOnC B P OJDItHLI ClllI T8TbCa 06a ­ 8aTe JILlIJiUUI p Jla CoeABHeHllli X'i mTarOll'I IIpB 8TOI ltOncrBTyD i B rOQBO TaK'L-lKe alt' L OD 6WB 06S13aTenHLl IIpB ltOaqiep epa $i ooam ltOac B TIl 8a1tOHLl COep BBeHllli X'i mTaTOll'L xOTopHe Ciyp yn B8p aBan cg B' BCIIomeme ex pa sao ltIlJt' b Bci TpaltTam ItO­ 'l'Opae aaUIOQeHLl BJIH 6y n yn 8aUIOQeHLl IIOP ' B lIaCTbIO COep BBeRllhlX'I mTaTOB'L P OJDltHlll C'lll'l'an cg BepXOBliWl'L 8altOBOllfI cTpaHLl a Cyp LB B'L lt3 l£AQlIfI llITaTII P OJDltHlll 1I0p 'lBB Irr bCa BTOMY saRony XOTa -6Ll BtEO­ 'l'OPLlll IIOCraBOB lIeBiJ B' ltOBCTl1T BJIH lI'I 8altOBar r Ra£oro-m60 mrara B naxop BJlHcl B' IIpOTBBOptlJiB C'L BIDl'I S Pall'IIe ynoM JIHyTlite ceua70pH B IIpep CTaBJITe m pa sao ltalt'L ueHLl BaEOBOp arenHLlX'L c06paRil pa3J1nHLlX'L mraTOB' B Bet nCnOJILBB­ TenBLlll II cyp e6BLlll n OJIlKBOCTBLlll Jl1Ill a ltaE'L CoeP BBeBm rrJ mTaTOB' tal 'b B orp ilJlLHLlX'L mraTOB'L P OJDltHlll p aTb IIpBCS£ry us aqiqirrpM IO 'ITO 6yp yn 1I0p p epmmaTb STY ROBCl'Il TJ'$O BO BHEorp a Be c Itp yen Tpe60BaTb IIpHBap JIelKBOCm It'L XaEOMY-JlnOO BtponClIOBilp aRiIO xan lleo6xop HM I'O YCJlOBi s p Jla 8a JJ S TiJ ItaltOI-JlB60 p OJDItHOCTH DB P Jla BClIOJlBeBiJ Ra£HrL-JlB60 o6m ec1'lIeBlDilX'I 06aaaBBocreit lI'L Btp tRiH CoeABHeHllli X'i mTaTOB' L CTaTbll vn Y1'lIepm n eme ltOBBeRTa8 p eMm nrraTOB'L P OJOEHO C'lll'l'an ca P OCra­ 'l'Oqmnr r P lIa B1lep eBiJ 8701 ROBC lI'L '1'tr1 llITaTax'L ltOTOpLle yrBepp ut ee 8mllfI clIoc060B YTBepm n eua Ba ltOBBeBTII C'L ep BBOl'JIacaaI'O o n oopeBiJ IIpBCytCTlIY­ IOm HX P mTa7Oll'L CeMBB AD aTaI'O cema6pa 1787 rop a OT' L P X B lI'L J zOB 'JJ JIaIIl' a OB 'JJ B 10 - rex nm K p 'Ii H imoJlac' I'Jm lIan HaTaBieJID rOpaK'D llacca'llyceTTc'Ii PylfJyC'L KJm rJ ItOJrlleTHKYT'Ii BlLDI DI 'D CaxI09A J zoS Com PO ll lB ep'l mepxan BI IO-IopK'Ii AieKCaB' l ep'L raMImTOB 'JJ BB IlIWDI'L 1ImJHBrCTOB 'JJ lI a sDA'L BpnpllH B ctPaBE 'IBn Po6epn Mopplic' TOMac' ctUTCIDI OBC' tmC'L BBJlbcom J lEOPA lB 'L PDA'L lI lKou' lI nKllBCOB 'JJ lI Eal1lt06' Bpyn lI m3ttMC' MEreHpB lI amen Itappoa lI lEOn BlIsp'l HI IO- lI zep8B' BltlL1WIll'D UanepcoB 'JJ lI lB oHaTaB 'JJ lI elTOm UeHCKlII BaS ia Toxac' Mil'lfJlfJmn lI lB op n m ltJIalbIep'l ilpe ll ' lIKrepcoa I'yBeps ep'l MOPPHC'L 1J 6lI aup 'Ii rOBBBBr'D Bep lfJopA'L 1Uap miil PK'Ilap ll ' Baecerr r llepHJlenp 'Ii lI am • CeIl'l'li TOKaC'f DCPep'L BBprnHla I 1B BIMC'f Ma n KCOJr'L 1Uap miil 276 277 1t0B COE I lIHEHBLIX'D lllTATOB'J CtBepBaa KapOJfBBa BHlIJIl JDrI Rlayun ThlO BBJlJIiiUlCOm I Pyr leAll'I lIap lcl IIlmIlIll BBJI 1Il JIM'I I 1O CBBAiT6JIl CTByen PRqap o66 OTaTWl IlL CnalTi IOzBaaKapoJlHBa lIap lc' l KorcBOpn lImmBB llipC' l ByrJlev r reopria A6paM'lo B lI AB BH lI lIbml'D COH' cexpmp Cran K AOnOJlBJIlOJlti a' KOHCTl 'l'yI ilO COeABBeB1 In'I illtaTOB1 AMepmnr npeAJlOmeBBl tI 1t0urpeCCOM' l B ymeplltJl eBBl tl aaltOBOAaTeJl mD c06paBimlH Ot l iJlI BI lI'l IIIT3TOB' l corxacBO C'1 JIlITOIt cTanelt nep so­ BSqanDBOA 1t0BCTBt CTaTI JI I KOBrpeCC'1 Be AOJlmeB'l B3AaBan 3aItOBOB'lo 0 BBeAeBiB EaltOlt-JlB lo pe 1lKriH UH 0 3snpe BiB CBo60ABO HcnoBt l lJlIan ESltYlO-lIHtiO peJlmilO IfJlH 0 c'l fIcBeBiB CBOtiO I LI CJlOBa B neqam UH 06'1 orpaBlAeBiB npam BapOAa MIIPBO cotiBPan CJI H otipa an CJI n npaJIHT6JIl CTBY Cl npoc ­ 6iUlH 0 npeEpa eBiB aJloynOTpetiJleBiil CTaThJI n TaIt'1 JtaR'I xopomo OpraBB30BaBBaJI MIIlImtfa BeotixoAlDla tllJl tieaonacBocm cBotioABaro rocY l apcTBa TO Be c 1I'fIAYeTJ OTBllM an J BapoAa npaJIO mrin Y cetiJI H BOCBTl opyade 'rreplIWI J eClln 1I01lp1lllOK'L KOllcTIITl'I iII Coe BlIe Il liI1' mTaTOB' I 6l U11 IIptIAJollCellJ i 8aIlOBo aTe n1l1ol1l't coopaBiJut1o OTd nIlLllt1o mTaTOIl1o lIepBIolIl't 1I01llP8CCOll'L 21S cel TlI6pll 1789 rO ll L lin l'BePAD8 clt ll l llIie mram JI oO'I II U61ris Bn l'BePlIC­ ll elris ryoopllaTOpaKB STHn mTaTOB1o 6l U11 1I0CTelleOO COOOll 6mz lIosrpeccr lIpe3 el TOll't H I - lVItep8B 20 1I0J 6pll 1789 TO II a lbPBI6JlA'lo 19 1I811aopa 1789 rOla CtneplIu KapolBBa 22 lIen6pll 1789 ro a IOlIIIIU KapOlBll t 19 lIBBaps 1790 10 ll a l -fellllmlIP 25 snaps 1790 rOlla lI elaBep'L 28 lIBBapa 1790 10 ll a neBCI IUaai l 10 lIapTa 1790 rO ll a I -IopE'lo 27 lI apTa 1790 rO ll a POll '­ Abell l 'lo 15 UoBII 1790 10 ll a BeplI oll'l'l 3 IIOSOPS 1791 10 a II Bupnmi a lIS l ella6pll 1791 lO II a B lItYPIIUIll 'L KOl I'peCCa ll OllaaaTe nCTBa 'IT 8l1li080­ JlM enlll i8 co6paaia KOBllem t 'Ta feopriu 8 MaccaqyC8TTca lIolJ a·u io J'TBepAJUII un Ill' ItOBC'1'B'n'IVJI COI 1I 8B E IHJlX't DlTAl'OB'J B r OPBoe BPen Be 1Il M nori n co a n an mr ll'lt EaKOM' l Aod tie810 couaciJl ero BJIa dJJI a a B'Io BOeHBoe Bpen HODO nodman TOnEO TaKlDI'1 cnocotion lOTop d ly a en npep nBC8 B' SaROBOlll'I CmTWl fr He CDAYeTJ Bapyman npaJIO uapoAa Ba TO 1lTO r JlBtmOCn l On 6p1arB B Be E83 lI aro tiWia orp83 ll em on mAilM' l ae lII t3BaBHl lX'II 06IiCltOB'Io a 3a maTOB'Io a npBJta3Ii 0 lIpOBsBeAeBiB 06IiCltOB'lo A0 Jlt 1fIi 61lT lIH 1I aBaem TOJI ltO Ha OCBOBaBiB npa BJI OnoAotim u'L J OTBBOB'r I1oAKpilDJIeB1 In'I npHcarolt BJlK aifliflBPHan iel B B'Io UrI AO 1IlEBO 6Iin TOtmO y a3aBO riCTO 11'1 ltOTOPOH'L c 1IiIAyen npOB3BecrH 06Iicn B OJDKmil 61lT y a3a BIi TO JI O K 'l fI Be E01'0PIiJI P OJIlKlW tillT sa­ p epmam t C aTI JI V Irmrro Be OlEen tiIiTli nplDlJleqem n OTBiIrCTBeBBOCm sa yrOJlOBBOe BJlH EaKOe-u6YAI p pyroe nooopBoe npecTynJleHie BBaqe RaE'L no otiBB­ BeHim npBCJIEBHMII BO 1Il moro l mypH 3a HCKJllOqeBieH'L AiJI'L BOaBHlta­ JOlIQiD B'Io cyxonyrBol apllliB UK BO ifI 10'l fl HJlH ll'lt MUmtiH B'L 1'0 lIpe UI Eat'L OBH BaxOAJlTCS Ba dlcTBHTeJll HOI cJlym6i1 no CJlyqalO Bolim B 1IB oti ecTBeuol onacHocm BHltTO Be HOlEen tiIiTli nop nepruyr'l ABa pasa sa OABO a TO are npeCtYUAeHie onaCBOCTB yrOJlOllH8rO BaltasaBiJIj l IIItTO Be HOlEen 6IiTli npHBYlIQI eB'L ll'lt ltaItOM'lo-JlBtiO yrOJlOBBOM'L AiI 1IiI cBlAilreJIDCTBOBan npOTHB'1 caMoro cetiJI lmitTO He HOlEen tiIiT'b JIlDneB'1 lEB3HH CB060JJ Ii BJlH cotiCTBeHBOCTB ti BaAJIelK arO CYAOnpOH8110A· CTBa 'IIacTBYlO C06CTBeBBOCn aeJI aJI OttiBPan aa 06 eCTBeBBoe ynOTpetiJIeBie tie3l cnpa BeAJlBBaro B03BarplllEAeBia C1'aTWl VI npa nciln paa6BPaT6Jll cTBax1 yro 1IOBHl lX'II Ail5 0611HBJIeHIilt Aomem n0JII 80nT CS npaBOM' l Ba CROPwt B lIJ6J11AJILIil CYAl tie3npHcrpaCTBIiX'I npHC IIlKlI1ilX' L TOro IIIT3Ta B ORPyra rd ti LL10 COllepmeBO npeAnoJJarae-­ Moe npecTynJleBie a lITOT'It OEpYfl AOJlZeBl 6hITh npeABapBT6JIl BO onpe-­ 278 279 EOH CO ROBC'1 '1 ' ll'YIl COE lOIHE'RJJJJX llITATOB'J Abem 8a EOlIOnj om lIrien np8 BO lIa TO 1 T 61 ero mmicm ll1l 0 CllOllCTlJillI 0 npIf'IJ 'f o6Bl1l1enis 'lTotn ero nocTaBIWI lIa O'lBJlO CTaBEY C'I CBH lJ flTe lIJ1lm n am nORas8 1Iis lIe mrfl n m era OlUloro 1llI'L Coe n tme1lJD'U ' mraTOB'l rpa Ell a B3 1iK lUlYToro IlITam B m rpazp auaD 11 noA l amD'iOl'II BalWro- m60 lIlIOCTpaJIEaro rocy a apCTlJa no lh3Y trro6'l OH'L npaBO nyTen npllllY3t 1J ellia m I3BaTb cBlI lI flTeleil B'l ero nOtLSY 11 n0 1l1 30BaTbc a n0140 1l SaJ Il llTlllma llITATOB'b CmM mt Jh r6opm mm n OJlUlit c06l1paTLcJI ll'b CBOurr IlITaTan 11 BH6l1paTL nocpe n cTlJon 6UJlOTllpOBEK IIpeau n ellTa 11 BHD e-IIpesu n eHTa K3'l xoropIlX'b no 14em mell npi O ll lIlI'L ue ll 0JCItem IIpllllaAlle3aTb R' 'lBClIJ CraM VIL1 DTeJIell O ll BOrO C'L BH60PIIQlltalllll llI T8 Ta Ollll ll 0JmHli HaaLIBaTb B'l OCHOBamIIi X'J Ba 06H'lHOM'b IIpant H ll' iIlIlIOCTLIl CBOurr ua6l1paTeJ bHm'L 8aJI11CBaX'b TO mn o ltOTopoe Ollll BH6l1pallT'l HCRa IIpeBLIIIIalOlII RX' I p Ba ll TL ll OJlJIapoll'L coxpaIDIeTCJI IIpaBO ey n KTbCS B'L IIpeau n eH'l'lil' H Oco6In' L aamtcKaX'b TO tHD O EOTopoe Ollll BH6l1pallT'l cyp on npH 11 lIlIROOI qJaRT'L 6LIBmilt Ba paacMorptlliu IIpU­ B' llHD e-IIpeau n ellTH Ollll ll 0DlIH COCT8 BKTb OT n i 1II HLIe CIIl1CRK Bcin CJDItBI IX'D He MOlIteT'l 6HTb nop BeprBYT'L lIepeCMOrpy Jl'I RaEOM'L-JIu60 111lll 'I ll'b no 1l1 3Y ltOTOpIn' L 6WK no n aJIH rOlloca ll lIJI 8anm eHiJI ll ODmo­ tu T me6Hm'L n i Jl'b cyp fI Coe n lIlIeHHm'L mTaTOB'L lIlIa'le Ran no YCTaB3n 06H'lHaro cm IIpeau n eHTa H BciI' JUIII ' aa KOTOPIn' L 6WK nO ll aJIH rotoca ll JUI IIpaBa aaMim ellia ll ODmocm BHD e-npe3u n ema H a 0DmH JBa3aTL 'lBClIO rOJIO­ COB'L no n allllLIX'b aa Kaz u aro 9TH CDlICRH OBK p OJlUlit nOp DllcaTb 11 VIII 1 CTaM CRpiJDlITL 11 aaTflM'L OTIIpaBllTb Sane'laTamD'iOl'II m ricTOIIpe6LIBame 3aIIpeIrt leTCJI Tpe60BaTb CJlmIIEon 60Jl1 lIIiJr o6esne'lenis Ba JIaraTL IIpaBKTe lIl CTlJa COe n tmeBHm'L mTaTOB'L Ha HMJI IIpe n ctp aTeJlJI ceBam CJImIIEOM'b ooJl1 lIIiJr ll eJIeJIOlW1 nellJl H npllTOBapllBan B'l zeCTORHn -IIpe ll cil n are n ceBam n OmKeH'L BCRpHTb Bci IIl1CbMeHlllJJt y n OCToBiJpe­ H He06IJ l1allminrI Hoaaaal mr r Ilia B' IIpKcytcmill ceUTa 1I1Ia JIam IIpep CTaBHTeJleit H aaTflM'L ll OlliKllH 6HTb CO'lTelIH 1I0p allHJi e rOJlOca -TO JIHD O EOTopoe nOJIytIllJlo CaMoe CraM IIepe1J1lCJIeJIie B'l IX 1 6OJIJdlIOe 'lUCliO TOJIOCOll'b IIpK BH60pil IIpeau n ema ll OJIlKHO 6LITb npeSK­ ROH IJ J3BiJCTBLIX'b IIpaB'L He n ODmO 6HTb 06'LJICllJIeMO B'L TaRon CMHcJIt 'lTQ ORa yHK'lTOlEaen WIU yMa JI 1I eT'l p emoM'L ec m BTO 'lBCJlO COCTaBJIJleT'l 60Jll llIlllICTBO BciJn BaaHa'leHRlill 'l llH60pmmtOB'L ectu-me IIlIRTO lIe IIOJIytIIIJI'L TaRoro 60JII IlIKBCma rOllO­ COll'L TO lIa JIam IIpep cTaJlHTeJlell ll OlllKHa BeMep JIeBBO BH6paTb noepc ll ­ npaBa oCTallmi s cs IIplllla ll lIel1tHOCTbIl Hapo ll a eTBOM'b 6aJI llOTlipOBRU IIpeau n eBTa IDl'L Tfln llBII 'l'I He IIpeBIiIIlIallm I n CTaM IIpaBa Be npep OCTaBliellHJi JI Tpen ROTOpLIJI nOJIytIllJIll CaMoe 6oJll moe 1J1ICJlO rOJIOeOB' X 1 ROHeTR eA COep UHellBJ l M'b mTamn 11 He OTBJlTlilJ l ell y maTOB' IIpHHa ll lleEaT'l OT ll ilJII BI Dl'L mTaTaM'L ll ll1I Hapo n y CTaM XI Cyp eOUaJI BJlOOTb Coe ll Blle1lJD'U ' mmTQB'l He n ODma 6HTb o I a CB II­ eMa m tallOn CMHcJIt EOTOpLIil P U'L 61l B03MOlKHOCTL pacIIpocTpaKJITL ee Ha Raxi a -1I1l60 TJDKe6BHJI llil 'la RSqaTLIJI iI 'l1l Be n Ymi a c a 280 Ho IIpR llHOOpi IIpe3u n ema rOJloca ll OJIlItHl I 6HTJ oronpaeMH no maTaM'L Tan npoTRB'L O ll lllfa l llBrlUl nOllPalJliiB RoIICTlI'fYlJ ilr Coe el l lirl mTBTOll'lo 6InB lIPe OllteD 8Bl1 01l0 BTenllWl1 c06p OT in m rrJ mTBTOB'II ' peTI llll'll 1I0mpeccoll 'll 5 apTa 1794 rO lB II 0 TOll'll 'lT0 olla 6101 1B rmeplEAellB SaKOIIOl aTenlUlXll co6palliJnll l ' pen lIemepTei mTBTOIl'L 6liUO 06' b o 1 e110 ll'lo noc vmia lIPe81Il elITB lI1 lIollI'peccy on 8 IIlllIBpa 1798 rOAa t ItBba l llaTa ll nOllPalJliill RoIIC'1'l 'l'JldIl Coe el l lirl mTILTOll'l 6101 1IL lIPel lI0lltelllL 8aKOHOJJ BTe LIIIoIlG co6pa uisn OTAUI lIloll'I mlLTOll'lo BOCb mrl ItOllI'peCCOll'L 12 J 6I1B6pa 1803 rOlla liB lticTO nepllOB8'18DHlIfO ' p6T'L1IlO naparpaWIL nepllaro oT in IlTOpoi CrIL'tL1I I I 0 TOJ 'L 'I 'rO Olla 6101 1IL rmeplEAeBIL aBll OIlOAILTe lJ lIbIlI1 I co6pamll 1 1 ' pen 'IeTllepTei maTOB' ' ISInO 061o l11ellO ll'lo lIPOI£ IIL av i B rocYlIILpCTllel llalO eellperBpa on 25 celITa6pa 1804 lOAa 281 EOHC'l'BT' VI IJI COE ltHHgHHF IX$ DlrArOlm 'I lTO 1 npep C1'8lJl ' reILCTlIO E8JK ltaro IlITam JDrlIl o 0 ltllll'L mlOO'L quorum AU IlTOI ru Dm0 COOTOJlTI mrr 1UeHa JWI mrr 1UeIlOm on AB 'T I TPeTeIi IlITaTO n a OJD DDmCTlIO Bcfln IlITarom Be06 x o ADO AU m6opa Ee m -ze nuaTa npe ACTlIBRTeJlel lie m6epen p o 'llmepTaro 1DICJlIo CJIi lU'IDm aro K3pm DCaD a npe8llAeBTa m Ton CJIf'Iai EOr Aa npll B TaEOfO BK60pa npe u OCTlIBJIeHO ell TO B e-npe8BBel1TJ' P 1l lIZeH' D AtICTBOBan 8a npeSllAeRTa T01DI0 TaJt'b ate Dlt'L J m CJIYIl8 i CKepm npeSllAeRTa JWI era lleCnOC06Bocm It'L OTIIpllBJIelliJD AODmOOTIL O nOJIyqBBmee caMoe OJD mee 1DICJIO roJIOcom npll BH60pt e­ npeSB D ellTa A0Dm0 jll1'l'b B e-npe8llAeRTOn ec m 8TO 1DICJlO COCTau m­ en jOJD DDmCTBO Bcin liallHaqeHllm' L m jop B'D eCJll-ate JIlmTO Be nOJlyq lt1l1 jOJlbmBBCTBa rOJIOOo n TO CeBaTl' u o m eH' D BK6pan B e­ npe31lAeHTa IlB'L u B 'X'L lIml 'I CTo n BO rJlaBi CnDCD AJIa 8701 If kJIIl quorum u ontHO COCTOJITb 1l3'b l Byrr 1peTel Bcero 1DICJIa ceHa ­ '1'Opom a 6oJlbIlImJCTBO Beero 1DICJIa Beo j x o u BMO u m m jopa Ho BB­ ltaKOO JI O He COOTBiTCTBYIDm ee YCTaHOBJIeBBKn ltOBcTllT ' qieID YCJlD­ Bimr r AU B36p8B iJI m npe3llAeRTK lie KOlEen 6l11'l'b m6paHO m mm e­ npe8llAeHTK Coep BBeHllm' L mmTOB'L CmTWI XIII OTp f rr 1 HB pa jcTBo BB B LllIJllQI eBBoe Huoz a eBie m YCJlyzeBiK lie P O 1EHLt cym ecTlIOBan BB m Coep BBeHHKX'b IIlTaTax'L BB m SaEOn­ IB6o Dcn nOA'llBBeBBOn Krr Jl PBC u B B sa BCUJl qeBien nn CJIyqaeB'L ltOr u OSII CJIj'lKaTl' HaHaaaBien 3a npectynJleme AOJtaBaJI­ Boe YCTaHOBXeHH6UC cnoco6o OT u f 11' 2 Kompeccy P 0Dm0 jll1'l'b npe u oCTlIBJIeBO npaBO ll3 AlIBan P JI II Ilcno 11BeBiJI IlTOft CTan B piicTHKe BaItOHU lIl a l a'u noupaBsa ROBCnrry$r Coe emm rJ mrlTOlI'L 6ma upe 1 lOZ6B 8aBOBO a eJl Bliln c06pallisn OTJltnllKl'1 llITaTOlI'L 'rpll 1 l a'rD-BOCloKr nn EOlllPeCCOn 1 lfIeBpLl l 1865 rO la B 0 on 'ITO on 6w a J'I'l epZ leBa 88J OBO l 'le UoIIliIlB coopaBiIlD a ll am ceKB BIl'Io 'rpIlJll am lIIecm llITaTOS r 6mo 061 a B l eBo lI'L UPOE­ lanI iB rOCYlIapCTBellllaro ceEpeTaplI 01 l 18 leEa6plI 1865 rO la 8m IIITBTIiI ern lI r lllllOB PO ' b-Abell 1 'l Mlm r ll'l Mspl lell 1 'I lhlO-Iopn SanaJIBIIII Bupl'llllia MailrJ RaB8ac Maccll'l1cmc'I ileBcB lua IIiJi Bllpl'lllli a Oraiio MorPB HeBaJla lIB 11i ll J1II3iaBa MBBBeCOTB BIICSOBCBB'I BepKOJl'l l TeBBeCB ApX B3ac'I ltOlllltlTllEJ' 'L IhIO-reJUllllllll1 IOlUU KapoDB A ra6 11a CiBepBu KapO IBBa II reopr Ui 282 EOH CO DlrATOB'1J CTaTLll XIV · 0Tp f n 1 BCJDWI POAllBmiltc II m CoeAHHeHlIHX' mmTaI'£ rum npB'llllcle1lBliIll n Krr BaCeJlelliJD BcJIi AcTBie HaTYPa JIH8 B nO IJ qJl­ JIe1lBliIll IlX'b mpBC ABK$J C'llHTaeTCa rp aHBBOM'b COe IJ BBeHllm' L DlTaTOm B TOra 1lITan m ltOTOpOn Dten lIt'IICTO mrre n CTBa HHEa­ EOI mTaT' lie AOJIlIWH' ll3P auan JWI npllBO A1lTI m Ilcno 11BeBie lWde­ IIl6o 8aEOm EOTOPKIIB orpaHB'llHBaIDTC II npBBBJIerfB J JUI npllBa rpaz u aH' Coe u BBeHllm' L illmTOm BB KaEOil 1lITaT' Be A0JIzeH' D lOra­ ' ltl'l'lllPBaJll a'l'lIII noup llB RoBCnrry$r CoeJlllll mm rJ mTBTOlI'II 6w upe 1 lozeB IIIE0BOJla eJl Br nn c06pallisll'l OTJIIDIILLI'I llITaTOll'L 'rpBlI l aft a eBftIilK' ' J OlllPec­ eon 16 m lll 1866 rOJla 21 il lll 1868 rOlla EOlllPeCC'I npllllll l'l B IlpBBeA n clIiltiBiJO rocYlI apCTBeBHarO ltenapt ll8na peao n JlUlO e' J OTOpoli 8B qB lOCl 'ITO 8aJtOBOll are n 1IWI coopallis llITaTOa'l KORlltlTllEYTa TeBBeccB lhlO- llll'epSII Operolla BepKOBT fulO - lopKa Orafio HuHIJOII SallaAlloA BBprBBiu RaBaaca M ilBa HeB I IoI MBarPB HB IIiaaH MBBIIBCOTIiI IhlO-f8Jmll1Bjla Macca'l1ceftCa He6p csB AiOBH ApE IIaaca 'hOpaJlH Cisepllol KapolIIBlol An6aIlH IOlEIIol KapO lBBlil a JlIIsialllol COCTaB llllOlI lI1'I 6 ie 'lin 'rpll '1eTBepm acm lBTaTOe' COlDSa J'I'l ep­ AB IB qeTIiIJIII Jll aTJ'lO nonpaBIIY KOBCnrry$r COBIUIB811l1LL1'1 illTaTOB nOpSlI EOK'I 1I 1 8 1 10ll'8B11 'lO lB1 II11 'rpeT8 II11 saZ loi n8UTIiI 'rpBlI l aTl a ellSiTaro ROlllPecca H E'I 6I0I l0 pillleBo 'ITO CBHllleJ'llOIUlSYTaJI qeTlilpllaJll aT8JI CTBTI II CII'II'I 06'l IIlI III8'fCII upBBllTOi san qaCft KOBCmTYu iB CoeABBeBI LLl'J illTOTaB B 'ITO OBa lOJlIIlla 6h1 T1io JleranllO 06BOpall OaaBBOi rOCYll apCTa8BBLIJ '£ ceEpenpeKu rOCYJlllpCTBellm ti eespenpr couaCBO C'I 8 BJ '£ 06BapOll Oa l'l lIpoE lanu i JO 28 mill 1867 rOAI lI'L lIOTopoli 6w 0 o6'I aBJUBO 'ITO 1Ip8l1 JOlllellllall 'lUTlilpSaAllaTU 1I0npaBEa Gwa J'I'l epZ lella IIIlEe-1II0KSBJ'TIiI II'I clloc060n saEOBOll aTe Jl BHKB co6paBiSl llB 'rpIlJll am 'B3'1 'rpll 1 l am 1118cm IIITa'l'OIl'l 8m mTaTlii crn KORllemRJ'T ' 80 ilDBII 1866 ro a lhlO-fell1llllllp'L 7 ho lll 1866 rOAa TelllleccB 19 mJll 1866 rOAa Hl lD- 1 lEep3l1 11 eeBTII6pII 1866 rO l a II 8 EOBO laTe u aoe c06pallie Toro mTan nplIlIlI IO pe30JlOu i JO lI'L lIIIpirl 1868 rO la mlOlII1lO IItn OTE a ftCII on corueill aa lIee Operoll r 19 c8BTII6pII 1866 lOlI a BeplloJl'l l 9 1I0l10PS 1866 rOAI reoprill o 6pocB la eo 13 Jl0II6pII 1866 rO l a II J'I'l 8pJIIUa ae 21 m lll 1868 rOAI Ctsopau Kaponma OroPOCIU ee 4 len6plI 1866 rOll a B J'I'l ep l B llI ee 4 ilD III 1868 rOlla lOJitBU KapomBII OT6pocB la ee 20 Jlen6ps 1866 lOAa 'B mepAlUa ee 9 WII 1868 rO la Bl lO-Iopn J'I'l epAII I'I ee 10 SBBapll 1867 rO la Oraio mapAan ee 11 anapll 1867 rO l 1I B saJtOBOJla eJl BOe co6paBie STOro IIITaT UPBIIII IO p8aOJlD u ilD lI'II lIBBapi 1868 rOA ' nilOlII1lO ItIl n OTBaaaTl C1I 01 l corncis Ba Bee HuDOB J'I'l epAan ee 15 lIapll 1867 rOAa San l BU Bllplllllis 16 lIaplI 1867 rOAa KaB3ac 18 anapa 1867 rOAa Mslim 19 IIRBaps 1867 rOAa HeB I a 22 llEBapll 1867 rO l a MB8ypB 26 _PII 1867 rOJla lIB liaua 20 llEBaplI 1867 rOAa MmmeeoTa 1 lfIenp l ll 1867 rOJla POJl'l -Ai reBJl'L 7 lfIeBp l1l 1867 rOAa BBCEOBCBB'I 13 lfIellpLl l 1867 rOAa ileBcl IUaBiR 18 lfIeBp8 111 1867 lOAa MBqman 15 4IeBpLI I 1867 rOll a Macca'l1ceTTC'I 20 Kapta 1867 rOJla He6paclta 15 ilDlm 1867 rOlla AAoaa 3 aupfI u 1868 rOlla APE IIlI C 6 allpW 1868 rOAa I0PIl la 9 maSi 1868 rO la JI1B3iaBa 9 il lll 1868 rOA II A I 6aK 18 m lll 1868 rO la reopria owm J'I'l epJIIUa noupauy 2 lfIeBpa tJl 1870 ro l TeEc c'I OT6pocan ae 1 BOll6pII 1866 ro a B J'I'l epABn ee 18 IfIeBPLl l 1870 lOla Bl pl'llllill oropocl la ee 19 lIBaaplI 1867 rOAa B 7TB8P I B I ee 8 ORTl 6ps 1869 rOAa iloupllBn 6wa OT6pomeBII IllTaTOn KemEB 10 lBBaplI 1867 rOAa l eusepon 8 lfIeBpa ra 1867 rOA M PB l8BIIOK'I 28 lIapTa 1867 ro B 1I0ed SToro OBa Be 6wa YTBepZ lolla STIIKB maTallB 283 ltOH m oman asm eB06o lfllt COOCTBeHHOCm 6e8'l Ba a Jle3 a II¥lro cy u onpOB81lO u CTBa J He u o lllCen OTBasmaTb B'lJ pamron co BCtlrlH no­ EPOBUTe lI1 O'Drll SaEOROB'lJ EOMY-JlH60 no u tIHBeHHOMY ero lOpHCA lI OTAtn 2 npe u CTaBlrleJIH u O lUlOIS 6L1Tb pacnpeAt 1 em xelK ll Y or u tn urom maTaJlll COpasMtPRO C7 lIHC 1 on BaCe 1 eRill npH IlTOn c rll u yen BltJIlmlaTb m C'Ien Bctn m IITeJleI mara sa J CUlO'IeRien Be06 1 ozeHH1ilI'I Haxorau HHAtftD eB' Ho ec m npH HaaHa'ieRiB m60p­ IIQ KOB'lJ npe3lI l1 eHTa H Bn n e-npOOlI ll eHTa Coe u HReHH1ilI'I illTaTOB' DH DpJ m60pll npe u cTaBHTeJlel B' KORrpeCC'L a a r mmtcTpaTHBIIIilX1 11 ey u e6BJilX'L u OJG lIOCTD h1X'I 1IBll 'I maTa lUll 1 JIeHOB'lJ SaKOHOAaTeJfbHaro c06paRill IlJTlI ra 6y u en omasaHO B'lJ npaBt rOJIoca KOMY-JlH60 H3' amTeJlell nrraTa KylItCKarO non mlOmeMY u B aTb OAHH'b rOA' on po u y H npHRa u JIezam eMY It' lIHCJIY rpa lK ll aR' COe lOlReHHI IX' illTaTOII' lfllt eCJIH aJtml'L-HH6y cnoc060 ll7 iYAen orpaRneHO 8TO npaKO HHa'le EaK'L sa yqacTie B' MJITeZiI DH sa KaKOe-HR iYAI u pyroe npectynJIeHie '1'0 npeACTaBHTeJlLCTBO nrrara u 0 'IlKB0 6ht'1'1 YMem meHO copaaripHo C7 rlIn EaK'L lIHCJlO Taltll X'L rpa lK ll an MYZCKaro nOJla OTHOCHTC a n o6meMY lIHClIY rpalK ll aR' 8TOro IlJTlI Ta 'OCTBl'IIIlIX'L AB am O u Boro ro u a OT u lIJ1' S He MOliteTT 6ht'1'1 ceHaropon lUH npeACTaBlrleJIen B7 EOHrpecclI lUH Bl t60pm mtoll'L npeSlI lI eHTa I Bn n e-npe3lI l1 eHTa DH sa­ BHMaTb KaKyIO-Jm60 rpa lK ll aHCKYlO llJIH BOeHHYlO AO llICHOCTb npH Coe u HHeH­ BJilX'L illTaTan lUH npJ ItOTOpon-JlH60 nrrarll TOT' ItTO B7 Ea'leCTBt 1 JIeHa KOHrpeCCa HJII u O lllCHOCTHaro Jln n a Coe u HHeHHl lX' illTaTolI' PH 1 JIeBa SaEOHo u aTeJfbHaro c06paRill RaKOro-JIH6o JIl'IaTa PH a u MBHH­ CTpaTHBHaro lfllt cy u e6Haro u OJOltllOCTHaro JIlllI a KaKOro-JlH60 maTa noltJlJtJle a nOMepmmaTb KOHCl'H1' 'II i lO Coe u HReHBJilX'L illTaTOB'L a nOTon DpRHJIJI' yqacTie B' B03craRiB WIH ltIITelId e a Bparan Ho ltoRrpeCC7 tozen OMHHTb TaEOe orpaRneHie npam u Byu a TpeTJllIlI roJlOCOB' BaJIr 1J oll naxam OTAm 4 He u oJDItHa 6Im nO ll BepraeKa oomBim 06 1I3aTeJILHIIJI ClUa paaptmeHHaro o imeeTBeHHaro u oua Coe u HHeHHl lX' illTaToB'b co BEJII 'IeHien u OJIrOB'lJ c u 1IJlaHRI IX' u U yn 1Iam neBcil B Barpa u 8a ycJIYl1I OKa3a BI1Wl Dpl nOAaBJIeRin B03cTaRill lfllt lILIITe3 a HH Coe u HHelmHe illTam llH ROTOpwt-JlH iO H3' OTAtJILBJilX'L mTaTOB' He AO 1ll mlil 6pan Ha celia lfllt yn 1Ia'WllaTb RaJtie-JIH6o u oJlrn lUH u eBeatBIiIJI 06 1I3aTeJlLCTBa ROTOPW 6WH nocJlt u cTBien nOlrlom H oKaaallHol BOBCTaHiIO lUI l IJl'l'eJKy npOTHB'lJ Coe u HReHHl lX' illTaToB'L B He u O 1ll mlil y u OBJIeTBOp lITb HHltaIl'llX'I rpe60BaBiI B03HorpalK ll eRia sa ytpary lUll sa IIMan n mI$ RaKOro-JIH io BeBO 1IDllHKa BCt ralde u OJIrR u eHe3BIitlI 06J13aTeJIhCTBa II rpe60BaRill B03HarpalK ll eRia u OJlJKBl' t C'lHTaTLCJl Heaa­ ROHBlilMll I Be u tIlCTHHTeJlLBl tMlI 0TAtn 5 RoRrpeccy u OJI3l BO 6ht'1'1 npeAOCTaBJleBO npano lI3 u a nan yrlcTme 3aKOBH u u npne u eRill ll' llcnOJIlleHie nOCTaBOBJIeRil lI3J10lKeHHl lX' B'lJ npe u mecTBymmel CTan t CTaTbJI XV OTAtJI' 1 npaBO rpalK ll an Coe u HHeHBJilX'L illTaTOB'lJ yqacTBOBan no u a'lt rOJloeoll'L He p OJIlKBO 6IiTb YHH'lTozaeMo lIJIlI eOKpam aeM O HB Coe u HHeHBlilMll illTaTaJlll HH ROTOPliDl'l'rJlH60 lI3' maTOB' B'lJ BlI lI y pacli D BtTa EOlKH HJlII npelKBJIrO a8XOlK ll eRill B'lJ yCJlymeRiB lI'L OTAtn 2 KORrpecey u OJIlKBO 6Im npe u oCTaBJIeBO npaBO lI3 u a nan S8KOBH u JIJl npne u eHiJI B'lJ llCnOJIlleHie 8TOtt CTal' lL ·Il aTB lIJIIlaTU IIOllpllBKa KOllcT I'fYI1ilr C06 1 11l181 1ot1' 1 mUfOlI full llpe lo m eB 8aKOllO llaTe ILIIloI'Il1 c06p8JIiBn OT IItnl lot1' l mTIIT081 COPOKOllLlll'J xOBl'Jleccoll'l 27 tjieBplWI 1869 rOAa II II 1lp0KUllaqiK rocY IIapC7BeBll lO eeKpenpa 0'1 1 SO lIapm 1870 ro a GIUO OOuuelio 0 TOII'lo '1 '1'0 olla 6wa JTlIeplQella 8aKOllO aTenlllillB oo6palli a II B AlIlIJIIlam BS'I '1'PlIAI am cen mTaTOM C rtllJllll ie mum f '8ep l lLlll eo 'I'aKoro B TaKOro TO 'llI1l la Ollll IlpOllOJlllTC8 BAter 81 Ton nOp IIAKt II XOTOpOII OBli 11 111 8Ban ofrr IITon rocY IIapC7BeBBOIIY AenaptaIlBI TY Ctllepl IIll ItapO llflla I I18pta 1869 rO II SaIIII I lIas BlIprmrill S IIIpta 1869 ro a MaccnYCeTfC'r 9-12 1 IIptli 1869 ro a BIiCKOBCBI 'l 9 I18pTII 1869 rOAa Mam 12 I18pta 1869 roAllj JlYlIaialla I I18prll 1869 ro u J fJmn'am 8 lIapra 1869 ro lla IOlI JIlI KapO lllBllt 16 I18pta 1869 rOAa lIeBcanB BiJI 26 lIapTIi 1869 rOA l ApKaBSaC7 80 lIap'll 1869 rOAaj KOlflle'tlllfYT'I 19 lias 1869 rOAII J oPI Aa 15 iIlu 1869 ro a Bnm 01l I IIlIpTIi 1869 rOAa IiB i8 l a 18-14 lias 1869 ro a lhll-Iopn 7 IIl1pra-14 IIjlW 1869 rOAa u 8aKOBOAaTenilOe co6pl1l ie IIToro maTa IlpIlBlllG pe80U 1l I IIIIlIlIpll 1870 ro a mllll YlIl xtf n o'1'PeKanCli 0'I h coullcill aa llee lhll-rellllllllllP1 7 iIlu 1869 roA HellaAa 1 l apT 1869 rOA l1 BepllOIl'1 r 21 ORTII6ps 1869 roJtal BlIpnmis 8 ORTII6pa 1869 rOl a Ml ayplL 10 lIIIlIaps 1870 rOlla Ml CCIICCIIIIlllI 15-17 lIIIlIaps 1870 rOJta Oraiio 27 lIIIlIaplI 1870 rOAa AlOlla 9 tjieBp81a 1870 ro a Kallsac1 18-19 lIIIlIapn 1870 rOAa MlIlUIecora 19 tjieBplWI 1870 ro a POA1 -llieBII1 18 lIIIlIaps 1870 rOlla He6pacs a 17 tjie8plWl 1870 rOAa TeKcaC1o 18 tjieBplWI 1870 rOAa mran reopriK _ fl'BepAUL DOllpllBlll 2 4ieJIPlWI 1870 rOlla IIPOTHB HHX HJlH OKa3bIBa1I COp eiiCTBHe H IIop p eplKKY BparaM COeAHHeH­ HbIX mTBTOB 284 EOHOTBT' VJ 'Q' COE QBBI BBbTX'L IIITATOB'£ COE ll BBEB'HI X1 IIITATOB'L - Pen 285 EOHCTH'n'IQJI COE EOHC'I'BTYI IH COE f I1HEHRbIX$ IIlTATOB'I IIlTATOB'I Oran a XVI t JItT' II ceuaTOp' lI OJJ3ell'I otn O ll HIl'I roJlOC'l KoBrpeccy OJlmBO 6HTh npe ocTaBJleRo npllJ lO HaJJa ra n B COfiHJ 8n BufiopmttRH B'l X OM'l DlTarll OJlJ HJ t YAOBJleTJl0PJiTb rlIn YCJI01liJln xaKiJI UaJJOm Ha a OXOAJi OTRY a fiu OHa ae npOUCXOAHJJH He pa cnpep ilJI Il ll Tpe6yIOTCJl OT' 1Iblfiopm llKOB'l caMolt MHOrOJlID l Uoit cocTaBuoit 'laCIn lIX'I KelIQI Y OT lI t n Hwm DlTaTaMU H fie3'l B3rJI II71 a Ha X8Jtoit-Jlufio D eJI8'I 38JtOHo aTeJlbIllil X'1 c06paniJ mara BJJB nepelmCb 9 Ecm OTKpOIDTC li BaKaHciD 1I'l npeACTaBBTeJJ1 CTB'B xaRoro-HH6yp r Cra TbJl lIlTaTa B'l ceHaTll TO HCnOJlHBTeJIbHaJr 1IJIacrr 9Toro mara p OJDKHa xrn pacnopmKarr c s 0 npOu311op cm wfiopoB'l llT06u amm arr Tam l CeBan COe ll HBeBBl ln mraTOB'l lI OJJ3e1l'Io COCTOJITb H3'l II I1YX' ceBaTOpOB'I on Ra m n aro lIlTaTa H3fiupaemn ero BapOII On Ba meCTb t mecl'lIlI IIl 1I 7 'II Il' lIollpll llRII Eollcmryl ill Coe l llllell l Ll l'l mrll -oll'Io 6lU llpe ll lG lKeI eaaOBo a II re n I WI'J C061l Bil K'I pa8 lB'illt I 'I'L mfa -oB'I meCTl I eCllf'I nepllml'J aOH1'pec­ COK'I 12 iI u 1909 rOAIi II Il1 AOlUll I i 0f'I 25 qieBpam 1913 ro ll lI locYAapCTlleBBlilli ceapera pl o aJIIl l'I 'iTO oua 6wII yuepllUeua aUOI OAa reUBIilKH c06paHiJlKH c rlAYlOlI IIr It 'l'p1l l 1I11 'l1I 1I0Cl KI 113'I COpOlt1l 1I0Cl KH mTaTOB'Io AU6aKa 17 aBrycr 1909 ro l lI KeaTYltB 8 qieBpII U 1910 ro l lI IOlEI lI B Kapo ll aa 23 qieBpau 1910 ro l lI liu 1 I 01l 1 Kllpra 1910 rOA MlICCliCCIIIII1B 11 Kaprll 1910 rOA Teacll c'J 17 Brycra 1910 ro lI Ofano 19 IBBII Pl 1911 rO l a AiiAafO 20 IBBII P l 1911 ro OperOB'I 23 IBBapl 1911 rOA BamaBrToB'lo 26 IBB p l 1911 rOI Kua jlopaill 31 l BBapl 1911 ro a Momll aa 31 IIRBapll 1911 101 11 HB iaBa 6 cjJeBpUl 1911 rOAa HeBII I 8 lfleBpam 1911 rOila He6paclta 11 qieBpam 1911 10 1 11 C hepBII B Kapoll I a 11 qieBpulI 1911 rO l a KOlopa o 20 qieBpam 1911 rOI C t Bepa ll l aItOTa 21 qieBpulI 1911 10ila lIfa'lllf B'lo 23 cjJeBpau 1911 ro l lI AiioB 27 cjJeBpUl 1911 rOAII Kaa8ac'I 6 KapTa 1911 ro l MBsyplI 16 Kapra 1911 ro l Mem 31 Kapr 1911 10Aa TeaBeccli 11 allpllu 1911 10Aa Apltaaaa e'I 2S auptu 1911 10 1 11 BaCltOBCBa'lo 26 KII B 1911 rOlla lhlO-Iopn 12 iJO 1l 1911 rO l a IOlKlIlI B l uora 3 jIeBpam 1912 rOAa AP1l301la 9 II npw 1912 rO J a MmmecOTa 12 iloBl 1912 rOAa lJyBsiaaa 1 iJo u 1912 rOl a l e lll Bep'I 3 jIeBpau 1913 ro J lI Bali oKBaf'I 3 qieBpUIi 1913 IO J a lhlO- Eep3ll 5 jIeBj am 1913 IO J II lhlO-MeltcBlto 5 qieBpulI 1913 rO J 1L mTII rlil Koueraayn Hul-reKIIllIllp'I POA Abell l 'I H IOTa OT6pocam STY lIonP lllty CeKHIl I l raa nOllpaBlt KOBCTII' 'y$ Coe l llllellH i l'I mrll 'I'OB'J 61i1 1a llpel lOJKeB 1I ItOIlO ll II reuaOln C06paHiJlK'I paa JB'lII1iIft mUTOIl1 meCTl eclIT'I IITOPml'I xoarpec con 16 KII B 1912 rOAa II B'J Il olt la li on 31 KII B 1913 rocY l apcTBellJllolii CeKpeT pl 06 L l1BBn 'ITO 01111 6ma 'TBeplK I eaa BaKOHoAaore ll BIilKa c06paHiJlKH cn J YlDIlla n 'l'pBl l lI m AByn as'I copan 1l0Cl KB mraTOB'I MaccaqyceTTc'I 22 KIl I 1912 rO J a ApaaoB 3 iJoI B 1912 rOl a MBaaecora 10 iloall 1912 rOI lhlO-Iopx'I 15 IIIlIapl 1913 roAa KaBaac'J 17 IBIlRpli 1913 rOl a Operoll'lt 23 IIBBapli 1913 rOAa CtBepBII B li apo lua 25 lII I apli 1913 10 1 Kamqiopaia 28 IIlIBII Pl 1918 r03 MB'IIIfllll'I 28 IBBapli 1913 rOAa A iil aro 31 1IJlII Pl 1913 ro l a Sanll l BII B BaprlllliR 4 lfleBpuli 1913 rOAa He6pa elta 5 qiespul 1913 rOI AHOBa 6 qieBpUl 1913 ro a Momll xa 7 qiellpam 1913 ro l lI TeltC c'I 7 Iflespull 1913 rO ll a Bam lBfTOlI'Io 7 qie BpUl 1913 IOAII BaiiOKBUf'I 11 qieBpau 1913 rOAa KO Iopa ll o 13 qiespul 1913 10 1 11 B uaHoB 13 qieBpulI 1913 rOAa CiBepBII B l aaOTa 18 qiespam 1913 10Aa HeB Il a 19 qieBpul 1913 ro l BePKOBf'I 19 qieBpUl 1913 10 1 11 Main 20 qieBpua 1913 rcAa HI IO-I'ellllllll p'lt 21 qieBpam 1918 ro ll OlUafOKa 24 qieBpuli 1913 rOl a Oraiio 25 qieBpau 1913 rol IOlEI lI B l aKOTa 27 qielJPau 1913 rOAa liB J iaHa 6 Kapra 1913 fO ll a Musypu 7 Hapra 1918 ro l lI BaJO-MeltcBlto 15 Kapra 1913 ro lI BaIO- EepsB 18 KII pT 1913 10 11 Tell'llecca 1 allpW 1913 rO l a APRaBBII C'It II npW 1913 rOAa li oll'lleTIIRyn 15 II npt 1l 1913 10 1 11 ileBclWsa sia 15 lIpt ta 1918 rO l ll i BHCltOIl­ CIlll'I o 9 IIII B 1913 rOI a BaKanciH Ho aaKOBOp aTeJJ BOe cofipaHie xaxoro-JIu60 lIlTaTa MOllteT'l ynOJIHOMO'lBTl HCnOJlBBTeJIBBTeJIbBym BJlacrr ero c l il rarr BpeMeBBbl lt aa3Ba'leuiJI P O TOro BpeMeHH Kor a Bapo ' aa1lttcTIlT'I 9TH BaKaBciu nocpO ll CTllOM'I Bbl60poB'l no BaKaay 3altOB ll aTeJlbBarO c06pauia 3 ara nonpaBlta Be lI OJImBa H3JIaraTbCJl B'I TaRon CMblCJI'B 'lT0 OBa HM'Ben 06paTBym CHJlY Ba Bbl60p' HJIH CpOR' ltaltOro-Jlu60 ceBaTopa H3fipaBBaro paHbme u n OBa c 'hJJaeTCJ1 lI tttCTBBTeJJ1 BOID xaR'I llacn XOBCTH a 286 287 JIaCJ 6hI HX CJlyxdia eCJlH 6101 3T8 CTaTDJI He 6hIJIa pamCPHUHpoBaHa CpoK CJIY'IC6hI HX npeeMHHKOB Ha'IHH8eTCJI B TO l e BpeMJI OTAeJI 2 KOHrpecc AOJl l eH co6HpauCJI He pe l e 'IeM pas B rOA nepa8JI ceCCHII KOHrpecca AOJl l H8 Ha'IHHaTDCJI B nOJlAeH 3 JlHB8PJl eCJIH He 6yAeT nPHHJIT saKOH nepeHoCJIlIQlH H8'1aJIO cee­ OT PE ll AJ I Urn CHH Ha Apyroe BpeM OTAeJI 3 B CJlyqae cMepm npesH D eHTa B nepHOA Ha KOTOp Iil OH 6hIJI H36paa npesH D eHTOM CTaHOBHTCJI BHUe-npe3H D eHT ECJlH B noC leoYIOUlue ZOObl KOHZpeCC npuH JlJl OOnOIlHUTe t'lbHble nOnpa6KU K KOHCTUTYijUU npeSH D eHT He 6hIJI Hs6paa K MOMeHTY KorAa H8'IHH8eTCJI cpoK AeJITeJI HOCTH HOBOro npe3H D eHT8 HJlH eCJIH H36paHH IiI DpeSHAeHT He CMor B TOT MOMeHT npnCTYDHT K HCDOJlHeHHIO mOHX 05JIaaHH0e­ CTaTf R 18 p8THcpHUHPOB8B8 16 JlHB8PJl 1919 r TeR TO 06J13aHHOCTH npeSHAeHTa HCDOJlHJIeT H36paHH IiI BHUe-npe­ SHAeHT AO npnCTynneHHJI npe3H D eHT8 K HCDOJlHeHHlO ero 06J138HHoe­ OTAeJl 1 rOA CIIyCTJI nOCJle p8mcpHK8 L1 HH STOR CTan H sanpe­ TeR ECJIH I e HH npeSH D eHT HH BHUe-npe3HAeHT He B COCTOJIHHH w aeTcJI npoHsBOACTBO npo o a lK8 H nepeBOSKa CDHpTHhIX H8DHTKOB npnCTynHTio K HCDOJIHeHHIO moRX 06J138HHOCTeH AO MOMeHTa Beryn­ B paMKax HMnOPTa HJlH SKCDOPT8 B CmA H H3 CllA STOT 38npeT JIeHHJI B AOJl l HOCTh HOBOro npe3H D eHT8 TO KOHrpecc HMeeT npaso paCDPOCTpaHJleTCJI H8 TepPHTOpuH nO D Jle e IOp8CAHK Coe o HHeHHhlx mTaToB OTAeJI 2 B8n I e on­ pe o eJIHT nopa o oK H36p8HHJ1 JI KOTOp Iil 6YAeT sm OM38HHOe­ KOHrpecc H OTAeJlhHhIe mTaThI HMeIOT npaBO Hsp a­ COOTBeTCTBYIOw He 38KOHhI D JlJl OTAeJI 3 KaK peWHT KTO 6YAeT HeDOJIHIlT 06J138HHOCTH npe3H D eHTa HJIH cotimoAeHHR 9TOiI CTaT H STa CT8Tf R He o eil CTBHTeJll H8 AO ee pamcpHK8 L1 HH KOHCTHTYUHOHHOil nOnpaBKH m BhIDOJlHJIT H STO JIH O AOJI l HO AeRCTBOB8U AO npnCTynneHHJI K 06J138HHOCTJIM npe3H D eHTa HJlH BHQe-npe3H D eHTa OTAeJI 4 B CJIY1l8e CMepm OABoro H3 KaH D HA8TOB HS KOTa­ 38KOHOA8TeJlhHhIMH opraHaMH phIx naJI8Ta npeACTaBHTeJIeil Hs6HpaeT npe3H D eHT8 a T8K I e B CJIy­ onpeAeJIeHHoro KOHCTHTYUHeH 'lHCJI8 mTaTOB B TelleHHe ceMH JleT co 1I8e cMepm OABoro H3 JIHQ HS KOTOPhIX CeHaT H36Hp8eT BHUe-npe­ ABJI npeACT8BJleHHII HM 3TOil nonpaBKH KOHrpecCOM 3H o eHT8 KOHrpecc np8HHMaeT 38KOH 06 HX 38MeCTHTeJIJIX OTAeJI CTaTioJl 19 p8THcpHUHpoB8Ba 18 aaryCTa 1920 r 5 OT o en 6 npaBO rpa K t aH Coe D HHeHHhIx mTaTOB rOJlOCOBaTh Ha BhI60­ pax He AOJl l HO Hapyman CJI HJlH OTp8 aTioCJI B aaBHCHMOCTH OT nOJl8 KOHrpecc HMeeT npaao o6ecne'IHTh C06JIIOAeHHe STOR nonpaB­ OTAeJIhI 1 H 2 AOJI l HhI BOiI TH B CHJly 15 OKTJl6pR nOCJIe pamcpHK8 L1 HH D 8HHoil CT8TDH ST8 CT8Tf R He o eRCTBHTeJIi0H8 AO ee pamcpHK8 L1 HH B K811eCTBe nonpaBKH K KOHCTHTYUHH 38KOHO o aTeJIDHhIMH OPraHaMH TpeX lIeTBePTeR mT8TOB B Te'leHHe ceMH JIeT nOCJIe TOro KaK Koar­ pace npeACTaBHJl mTaTaM 3Ty nonpaaKY KH nyTeM np8HJITHJI COOTBeTCTBYIOlIQIX SaKOHOB CT8Tf R 21 p8THcpHUHpoBaHa 5 AeK86pJl 1938 r CTaTf R 20 paTHCPHUHpoBaHa 23 JlHBaps1933 r OTAeJI 1 OTAeJI 1 CPOK npe6hIBaHHJI npeSHAeHTa H BHQe-npeSHAeHTa Ha HX nOCTax SaKaH'lHBaeTCJI B DOJl D eHio 20 JlHSaps CPOK npe6hIBa­ HHJI Ha HX nOCTax ceH8TOPOB H qneHOB naJIaThI npeACTaBHTeJIeR 38­ KaH'IHB8eTCJI B nOJIAeHio 3 JlHB8PS B TOT rOA B KOTOp Iil 3aKOH1IH­ 288 OTMeHHeTCJI CTaTf R 18 nonpaBKH K KOHCTHTYItHH Coe o HHeHH IX mTaTOB OTAeJI 2 BB03 cnHPTH JX H8DHTKOB B Coe D HHeHHhIe mTaThI H Ha TeppHTopnH KOTOphIMH BJIaAeIOT Coe D HHeHHhIe mTaThI 8 TaK­ I e 'HX nepeBOSK8 no CllA H 3THM TePPHTOp8J1M JlBJIJIIOTCH H8pyme­ HHeM saKoHa H OT o en CTaTloR Sanpe IUOTCR 3 24 paTH«pHll HpoBaHa 23 RHaapH 1964 r 3Ta CTaTWI He o eHCTBHTen Ha 0 0 ee paTH«pHKa QHH OT o en B Ka'l eCTBe nonpaaKH K KOHCTHTyuHH 3aKOHo o aTen HhIMH opraHa­ 1 HH Coe o HHeHHhIe illTaThI HH OT o eJIltHhIe WTaThI He MH WTaTOB KaK aToro Tpe6yeT KOHCTHTyIJ HR B Te'l eHHe ceMH neT o OJI I HhI OTpilll 8T npaso rp8 I AaH nocne TOro KaK KOHrpecc npe o CTaaHJI WTaTaM aTY nonpaaKY H o pyrHX BhI60pax npeSH o eHTa HJIH BHQe-npeSHAeHTa Bhl60p HKOB npeSH o eHTa HJIH CTanR 22 paTH«pHQIIPOBaHa 27 «pespanR 1951 r Ha yqaCTHe B npe o aapHTeJILHhIX BHQe-npeSHAeHTa ceHaTOpa HJIH 'I J1eHa llanaThI npe o CTaBHTeJIeii Coe o HHeHHhIX illTaTOB no npil'lHHe HeynnaThI HMH KaKHx-JIH60 HanorOB OT o en 1 OT o en HHKTO He MO l eT 6hln Hs6paH npeSH o eHTOM 60nee o ayx pas H HHKTO KTO SaHHMan noCT npeSHAeHTa HJIH BhIDOnH RJI 2 npaso npHHRTIt COOTBeTCTBytO He 38KOHhI AJIH 06eCneQeHHR co6JIIo o eHHR 3TOii CTaTLH npHHaAJIe I HT KOHrpeccy• 06RSaHHOCTH npeSHAeHTa 60nee o ayx neT B CPOK Ha KOTOPhIH 6h1JIO Hs6paHO HHoe J IHUO He MO l eT 6h1T Hs6p8H Ha noCT npeSH o eHTa CTaTItR 25 paTH«pHIJ HpOBaHa 10 «pespanH 1967 r 60nee o o Horo pasa 3Ta CTaT R He pacnpoCTpaHReTCR Ha S8HHMaa­ OT o eJI WHX noCT npeSH o eHTa B nepMo o Kor o a KOHrpecc npe o CTaaHJI aTY nonpaBKY H He npenRTCTByeT S8HHMaaWHM noCT npeSH o eHTa HJIH OT o en HCnOJIHRBWHM ero 06RS8HHOCTH 0 0 BCTynneHHR aToii nonpaaKH B CHJIy HaXOIJ HncR Ha noCTY npe3H o eHTa HJIH HCnOnHRTIt 06R3aHH0C­ OT o eJI KaK 2 nOnpaBKH 3Ta CTaT R He o eii CTBHTeJI Ha 0 0 ee paTH«pHKa QHH K KOHCTHTyuHH 3aKOHo o aTen HhIMH cnyqae OT3hIBa npesHAeHTa C nOCTa ero CMepTH 2 npH oceo60 l l eHHH nOCTa BHIl e-npeSHAeHTa npe3H­ o eHT aa3Ha'l8eT HOBoro BHIl e-npeSHAeHTa KOTOPhIH npHCTynaeT K ceOHM TH npeSH o eHTa 0 0 HCTe'l eHHR cpOKa 1 B HJIH yxO o B B oTCTaaKY JIpesH o eHTOM CTaHOBHTCR BHll e-npeSHAeHT 06R38HHOCTRM nocne ero yTBep I I eHHR 6on WHHCTBoM o6eHx nanaT KOHrpecca OT o eJI opraHaMH 3 EcnH npesHAeHT nO o BeT BpeMeHHoMY npeSHAeHTY TpeX 'l eTBepTeii WTaTOB B Te'l eHHe ceMH neT c MOMeHTa ee JIpe o ­ CeaaTa H CIIHKepy nanaThl npe o CTaaHTeJIeii DHCltMeHHytO o eKnapa­ CTaaneHHR KOHrpeCCOM IJ HIO 'ITO OH He B COCTORHHH BhIDOJIHRT ceOH 06R3aHHOCTH TO 0 0 ero DHchMeHHOro SaRBneHHR 0 BOSBpa eHHH K 06H38HHOCTRM npe­ CTaTWI 23 paTH«p HpOBaHa 29 MaPTa 1961 r SH o eHTa ero nOJIHOMO'IHR H 06R38HHOCTH nepexOAHT K B e·npe9H­ o eHTY KOTOPhIH CTaHOBHTCR HCOOJIHHIO HM 06RSaHHOCTH npeSH­ OT o eJI 1 OKpyr KOTOph1H RBnReTCR MeCTOM npe6hIBaHHR o eHTa OT o eJI npaaHTeJI CTBa Coe o HHeHHhIx illTaTOB B COOTBeTCTBHH c peweHHeM KOHrpecca Hs6HpaeT CTonhKO l e Bhl60pu g lKOB npeSHAeHTa H BH­ 4 ECJIH BHQe·npeSHAeHT H 6onltWHHCTBO npe o CTaBH­ TeJIeH HCJIOJIHHTeJI HOii BnaCTH HJIB o pyroro opraHa YKa3aHHOrO ll e-npe3H o eHTa CKOnltKO COCTaaHJIH 6hI B CYMMe ceaaTophl H 'I J1eHhI KOHrpeCCOM nanaThl npe o CTaBHTeJIeii OT noro OKpyra ecnH 6hl OH 6ltIJI WTaTOM npe o CTaBHTeJIeH DHCltMeHHoe SaHBJIeHHe 0 TOM 'ITO npeSH o eHT He HO He 6onhwe 'l eM WTaT c HaHMeHltlIlHM·HaCeJIeHHeM aTH BhI60p­ B COCTORHHH BhInOJIHRTIt ceOH nOnHOMO'IHR H 06l'l3aHHOCTH TO BH­ u g IKH npMCOeIJ HHfUOTCR K Bhl60pu g lKaM OT WTaTOB H paCCMaTPH­ ll e'npeSHAeHT o OJI l eH HeMeAJIeHHO BSRTh Ha ce6R nOJIHOMO'IHRH 06H­ BIUOTCR Ha Bhl60pax npeSHAeHTa H BHQe-npe3HAeHTa KaK BhI60pu g l· SaHHOCTH npeSHAeHTa B Ka'l eCTBe HCJIOJIHfUO erO 06RSaHHOCTH KH OT WTaTa OHH o OJI l Hhl co6panCR B OKpyre H BhIDonHHTh Bce SH o eHTa nocne TOro KaK npeSHAeHT nepe o aCT npeSHAeHTY CeaaTa 06HsaHHOCTH npe o YCMOTpeHHhle CTaT1teii 12 nonpaaKH K KOHCTHTY­ OT o eJI 2 npaao npHHRTIt COOTBeTCTBytOu g Ie o6ecoe'l eHHR 3TOii CTan H npHHaAJIe I HT KOHrpeccy saKOHhl AJIR ope­ H CIIHKepy nanaThI npeACTaBHTeJIeii JIBCltMeHHoe 3aRBneHHe 'ITO OH B IJ HH nepeAaAYT npesH o eHTy CeaaTa H CIIHKepy nanaTW COCTORHHH BhIDOJIHRTh ceOH nOJIHOMO'IHR H 06RSaHHOCTH OH BOSB aeTCR K lIIHHCTBO HX HCOOJIHeHHlO ecnH BHIl e-npeSH o eHT H 6on npe o CTaaHTeneii HCJIOJIHHTeJILHOii BJIaCTH HJIH o pyroro 290 291 yt 83Il1UI0ro S8lCOHOM oprllHa He no o 8 Ilyr B Te'leIUIe 1leThIpeX ll Heii npeSH II eHTY CaaTa H CllHKepy IlaJIaThI npe o CTaBHTeJIeil DHCIoMeH­ Hoe 3aRBJIeHHe 'ITO npeSH II eHT Bee ew e He B COCTOJ'IHHH BhIDOJIHIITI esOH 06H3a1U10CTH H nOJIHOMO'IHK 6y o eT B cnyqae ecnH TaKoe SaKBJIeHHe nOJIyqao peweHHe no STOMY Bonpocy o OJI KeH npHHKTh KOHrpecc COSBaB B Te1leHHe 48 UCOB qpeSBhltJaifHyro eecCHlO ecnH A T BaCUllbee PeH e f' JlOllon-MWLllep KOHrpecc B STO BpeMK He npoBO II HT CBoe perYJIKpHoe sace o aHHe ECJIH KOHrpecc B Te'leHHe 21 o HR nocne nOJIY1leIUlK nocne o Hero DHC MeHHoro 9aKBJIeHHK a B nepephmax Mexc o y eeCCHKMH qelUle 21 II HR nocne COShJBa qpe9BhI'lmHoil ceCCBH H3 KBHfH OXPAHA POCCHRCKMI TARHAJI nOJIHQIDI B Te­ peWHT o BYMK TpeTKMH rOJIOCOB 06eHX nanaT 'ITO npeSH o eHT He B COCTOKHHH BbJOOJIHHTL CBOH nOJIHOMO'IHK H 06H3aIUlOCTH TO BHI e-npeSH ll eHT npo o OJI KB eT OCTaBaTLCK HCllOJIHRIOW HM OMsaHHOCTH npeSH II eHTa B npoTHBHOM cnyue npeSH II eHT Bompaw aeTCK K HCnOJIHeHHIO CBOHX nOJIHOMO'IHH H 06H3a1U10CTeA nO lKarryii cnyqau HMeBlIlHe MecTO rrocne peBomomm CTaThK OT o en 18 1 26 paTHcjllD HpOBaHa 1 HIOJIK 1971 r llpaoo rpaxc o aH Coe II HHeHHhlX mTaToB o OCTHrlUHX JIeT HJIH CTapwe rOJIOCOBaTL Ha Bhl60pax He o OJI f HO HapywaTJ ­ CK HJIH OTpHI aTLCK sa HHMH Coe II HHeHHhlMH mTaTaMH HJIH OT o enL­ HhlMH WTaTaMH B CBH3H C BOSpaCTOM OT o eJI 2 1917 ro­ Aa HCHee Bcero nOKa3l lBaIOT lJTO 6e3 TeXHHKH Pa3BHTOii OXpaHHl IM OTAeneHHeM Mano lJTO MO lKHO CAenan MmmcTp IOcmmm KepeH­ llpaoo nplUllITI COOTBeTCTByroW He 9aKOHhI MK o6eClleqeIUIK co6rno o eHHK SToA CTaTIoH nPHHa o ne f HT KOHrpecey CKHii 06panmcH K 61 IBlIlHM lIHHOBHHKaM OXpaHKH HaXOAHBlIlHMCH B TO BpeMH B TIOpl Me 3a COBeTOM KaK nytruIe BCerO npoTHBOCTOHn HHTpHfaM 6oJ1l weBHKoB CpeAH Tex K KOMY OH 06paTHnCH 6hlJ1 reHepan fn06alleB Ha1lanl HHK rreTepGyprCKoii OXpaHKH Ero apeCTO­ BaJIH Cpa3Y rrocne peBOnIOUHH H TYT lKe npeAnOil HnH HCrrOnl 30Ban ero Ol1l IT B 60pl 6e HOBoro npaBHTemCTBa npoTHB 3KCTpeMHCToB R X01lY paccKa3an 0 MoeM C06CTBeHHOM CXOAHOM Ol1l ITe COTpYAHHlIecTBO C TaiiHhlMH areHTaMH 3aHep60BaHHI IMH B cpeAe 6YHTOBIIUiKOB He06xoAHMo Ana nOJIHTHlIecKoii nOJIHmm HO OT 3Toro elUe 01leHI AaneKO AO npoBoKauHH HnH rrpHMoro rroACTpe­ KaTenl CTBa B lIeM BcerM 06BHHRJIH oXPaHHoe OTAeneHHe Ha CaMOM Aene TaKOrO POM 06BHHeHIDI MorYT 61 ITb rroATBep lKAeHhI TOnl KO OAHHM nyreM BparH cTaporo pe lKHMa rrpoH3BOnI HO H3MeHHJlH JHaqeHHe cnOBa npoBoKaUHH H CTaJIH Ha3I IBaTh J1I060ro qenOBe­ A T Vassilyev Rene Fulop-Miller The Ochrana The Russian Secret Police J B Lippincoff Company Philadelphia and London 1930 pp 63-72 85-89 292