YKaseHHOrO 38KOHOM oprBHa He no ttIlAYT B TeqeHHe qeTblpeX ttHeii npeSH tteHTY CeHaTa H CIIHKepy nanaThI npe ttCTaBHTeneii IIHChMeH HOe 3lU1BneHHe npe3H tteHT Bce ew e He B COCTOJilHHH BhIIIOnHRTh caOH 06 f 13aHHOCTH H nOnHOMO'UUl 6y tteT B cnyqae ecnH T8Koe 38 f1BneHHe nOJIyqeHo peWeHHe no 3TOMY Bonpoey ttOJI lKeH npHHRTh Kourpecc C03BaB B TeqeHHe 48 qaCOB qpeSBhI'l HHYIO cecCHlO ecnH A T BacUflbee PeHe Q lOllon-MUfUlep KOHrpecc B STO BpeMR He IIPOBO ttHT CBoe perynRpHoe sace ttBHHe ECJIH KOHrpecc B TeqeHHe 21 ttHR IIocne nonyqeHHR nocne ttHero IIHChMeHHoro 38 RBneHHR a B IIepepbIBax MeX ' l Y CeCCHRMH qeHHe 21 ttHR IIOcne COShlBa qpe3Bhl'l A HOii ceCCHH 1f3 KHlfrlf OXPAHA T ARHAJI nOnlfUIDl B Te POCCIfRCKA1I peWHT ttByMR TpeTRMH ronOCOB 06eHX nanaT 'ITO IIpeSH tteHT He B COCTORHHH BhlIIOJIHRTh CBOH nOnHOMo'IHR H 06 f 138HHOCTH TO BH e-npe3H tteHT npo ttOJI KaeT OCTaBaThCR HCIIOnHRlOW HM 06RS8HHOCTH IIpelH tteHTa B npoTHBHOM cnyqae IIpeSH tteHT B03Bpaw aeTcR K HcnonHeHHlO CBOHX nOJIHOMO'IHti H 06 f 13BHHOCTeti 1I0 KanyH CTaThR OT tten 18 1 26 paTHcp HpOBBHa 1 HIOnR 1971 r npaso rp X ' I aH Coe ttHHeHHhlx mTaTOB ttOCTHrwux neT HnH crapwe rOJIOCOBaTh Ha BhI60pax He tton Ho HapywaTh CR HnH OTpHl aThCR 3a HHMH Coe ttHHeHHhlMH mTaTaMH HJIH OT tten HhlMH WTaTaMH B caRSH C BOSp CTOM OT tten 2 npaao npHHRT COOTBeTCTBYIOW He saKOHhI ttJIR o6ecneQeHHR co6nlO tteHHR SToii CTaT H npHHa ttJIelKHT Kourpecey c rryqaH HMeBnme MeCTO nOClIe peBomoIJ HH 1917 ro na HCHee Bcero nOKa3bmaIOT lfTO 6e3 TeXHHKH Pa3BHTOH OXpaHHbiM OT 1 elleHHeM Mano lfTO MO KHO C 1 enaTh MHHHCTP IOCTHIUDI KepeH CKHH 06paTH1ICH K 61 mIIIHM OBHHKaM OXpaHKH HaXO J HBIIIHMCH B TO BpeMJI B TIOpbMe 3a COBeTOM KaK lIyt1llle BcerO npOTHBOCTOHTb HHtpHI'aM 601lbmeBHKOB Cpe J H rex K KOMY OH 06paTH1ICH 6blJI reHepan fll06aQeB Halla1IbHHK neTep6yprCKOH oxpaHKH Ero apeCTO BallH cpa3y noclIe peBOllIOIJ HH H T '1' Ke npe J 1l0 KH1IH HCrr01lb30BaTh ero OllbIT B 60pb6e HOBoro npaBHTe1lbCTBa rrpOTHB 3KCTpeMHCTOB H xoqy paCCK33aTh 0 MoeM C06CTBeHHOM CXO J HOM OllbiTe COtpyp HH'IeCTBO C TaHHbIMH areHTaMH 3aBep60BaHHblMH B cpe J e 6yHTOB1IUfi OB He06xo J HM0 J IH n01IHTH'IeCKOH nOJ1HlJ HH HO OT 3toro ew e O'leHb na rreKO 1 0 npoBoKanHH H1IH npHMoro nO 1 CTpe KaTe1lbCTB8 B '1eM Bcerna 06BHHH1IH OXPaHHoe OT 1 elleHHe Ha CaMOM 1 elle TaKOro pona 06BHHeHHH Mor '1' 6bITh nO 1 TBep K J eHbI TOlll KO 0 J HHM nyTeM BparH CTaporo pe KHM8 rrpOHlBOllbHO HlMeHH1IH 3Ha'leHHe ClIOBa npoBOKaIJ HH H CT81IH Ha3bffiaTb mo60ro Qe1l0Be· A T Vassilyev Rene Fulop-Miller The Ochrana The Russian Secret Police J B Lippincoff Company Philadelphia and London 1930 pp 63-72 85-89 292 293 Ka TaifHo cHa6 K3BlIIerO HaC HH4 opMa n HeH areHTOM-npOBOKaTO pOM Ha CaMOM AeJIe TOtIlJOe 3Ha'leHHe noro MHOrOKpaTHO CKOM npOMeTHpOBaHHOrO CJIOBa COBceM HHoe AreHToM-npOBOKaTOpOM JlBJUleTCH JIHlIIb TOT KTO CaM 3aTeBaeT HeKoe l eHHe a peBOJIIO OHHOe KaJIH TpeHHH KpOMe Toro KaKOe-TO BpeMH YnpaBJIeHHe nOJIHIJ HH npHMeHH JIO HeBepuyro npaKTHKy OIIeHKH AeHTeJIbHOCTH CeKIJ HH - MeXaHH ABH 'IeCKH no 'IHCJIY panopToB 06 06Hap ' KeHHbIX HHTPHrax peBOJIIOIJ HO 3aTeM AOHOCHT BJIaCTHM Ha O a'leHHbIX HM JIIOAeH HepoB IIoJIY'laJIocb TaK 'ITO eCJIH B KaKOM-TO paiioHe 3arOBOpIIJ H ECJIH 3TO CJIOBO nOHHMaTb 'Ka3aHHbIM 06pa30M TO H Mory 3aBe KH He 6bIJIH O'leHb aKTHBHbI COTPYAHHK HMeJI OCHOBaHHH onacaTbCH PHTb 'ITO HaCT01lIUHe npOBOKa n HH He TOJIbKO HHKorAa He nOOLUpH DJIOXoro Bne'laTJIeHHH 0 ce6e B CaHKT-IIeTep6ypre nOCKOJIbKY OH He JIHCb UapCKHM npaBHTeJIbCTBOM HO CypOBO HaKa3bIBaJIHCb npeAOCTaBJIHJI COOTBeTCTByroIIJ HX co06LUeHHH DOJIee Toro OXPaHHOMY OTAeJIeHHIO K CO l aJIeHHIO HHKorAa 06pa30M npHBOAHJIO K 3TO eCTeCTBeHHbIM C06JIa3HHTeJIbHOH HAee C03AaHHH 6ecno He pa3pelIIaJIH YCTpauBaTb 3arOBopbI CpeAH 06pa30BaHHbIX cepeA PHAKOB nyTeM HX npOBOIJ HpOBaHHH 'lT06bI paCKpbIBIIIHH HX 04 H HHKOB POCCHH C'lHTaJIOCb MOp HbIM C nOJIHbIM OTCYTCTBHeM nOHH Uep 3aCJIY'KHJI y MaHHH H MepbI COqyBCTBOBaTb TOMY 'ITO OHH npHHHMaJIH 3a JIH6e nOJIe3Horo paJIbHbIe HAeH H B pe3YJIbTaTe aHnmpaBHTeJIbCTBeHHbIe CHJIbI OKa H PYKOBOAHTeJIeH YnpaBJIeHHH penyTaIJ HIO oc060 HeCKOJIbKO pa3 CTaJIKHBaJICH C TaKHMH CJIY'laHMH CpeAH 1906 3bIBaJIHCb CaMH no ce6e AOCTaTO'IHO CHJIbHbIMH 'lT06bI Tpe60BaJIOCb HHX Bbl J eJIHeTCH npOH301IIe J lIIHH B EKaTepHHOCJIaBe B HCKYCCTBeHHO nO JJl ep l HBaTb HX HJIH 'lT06bI OXPaHHoe OTAeJIeHHe MeHH nOCJIaJI TYAa MHHHCTP BHYTPeHHHX AeJI II H llyPHOBO OT roAY 6hl 3arOBopbI B npHDHCbIBaeMOH eMY MaHepe npoKypopa MeCTHOrO cy a H Y3HaJI 'ITO He3a J OJIrO AO Moero npHe3 OTBpaTHTeJIbHbIe CMYTbHHbI BYPUeB fepIIIYHH BaJIMaIIIOB KaJIHeB a rJIaBa OxpaHHoro OTAeJIeHHH 06HapY lKHJl nOAnOJIbHbIH ne'laTHbIH CaBHHKOB H npO'IHe co06LUa pa60TaBlIIHe AeCHTHJIeTHHMH 'lT06bI CTaHOK peBOJIIOIJ HOHepoB OAHaKO npOBO J HBlIIHe AeTaJIbHOe pac OpraHH30BbIBaJIO pa3pyIIIHTb Hamy CTPauy AO CHX nop He CMOrJIH aTb CBH J eTeJIbCT CJIeAOBaHHe 3Toro AeJIa ropoAcKHe BJIaCTH cpa3y l e 06HapY lKHJlH Ba 'ITO HX cnPOBOnupOBaJIH Ha HX PeBOJIIOIJ HOHHYIO AeHTeJIbHOCTb HeonpoBep I JIMbIe CBHAeTeJIbCTBa npoTHB paCCJIeAOBaHHH npoBeAeH HeT Hy lKAbI CKPbIBaTb 'ITO Koe-rAe H3-3a HeODbITHOCTH MeCT Horo OXPaHHbIM OTAeJIeHHeM BOT KaK no 6bmo B nOMeLUeHHH HbIX BJIaCTeH npOBOKa n HH AeHCTBHTeJIbHO HMeJIH MeCTO HO eCJIH B nmorpa4 HH HaIIIJIH HeCKOJIbKO COTeH 3K3eMDJIHpOB B BbIclIIeH CTe YnpaBJIeHHH nOJIHIJ HH Y3HaBaJIH 0 TaKOM CJIY'lae BHHOBHbIX CTPoro neHH KPHMHHaJIbHOH 6pOlIIIOPbI H COOTBeTCTByroIIJ Hii lIIPH4 T 6bm HaKa3bIBaJIH PyKoBOAHTeJIH YnpaBJIeHHH - KOBaJIeHCKuH E H By yCTaHOBJIeH B CTaHKe H3yqaBIIIHH AeJIO CJIeAOBaTeJIb B3J1J1 06pa3 eu H'I M H TpyceBH'I H H - 3Toro lIIpH4 Ta H BbIHCHHJI 'ITO B KaKOM-TO MecTe B Ha60pe OTCYT BcerAa 'lpe3BbI'laHuO 3a60THJIHCb 0 TOM noT 'lT06bI TaKHe Hen03BOJIHTeJIbHbIe AeHCTBHH He OCTaJIHCb He3aMe'leH cTByeT CJIOBO HblMH He rOBopH ' Ke 06 HX oA06peHHH CJIOBO HaJIH'leCTBOBaJIO Cpa3y CTaJIO HCHO B 'IeM AeJIo OxpaHHoe DOJIblIIHHCTBO HMeBlIIHX MeCTO npOBOKa n Hii CJIeAyeT pac cMaTpHBaTb KaK nOCJIeACTBHH peBOJIIOIJ HH 1905 rOAa BOJIHeHHH nOKa3aJIH 'ITO nOJIHTH'IeCKaH nOJIHIJ HH 'lHCJIeHHO MaJIa 'lT06bI ycnelII HO YUHTb Ha'laJIbHHK 6ecnoPHAo'IHoe 6ypJIeHHe lJT06bI CMHr'lHTb no M H TpyceBH'I no 3JIO OpraHH30BaJI Ha MecTax Ho B rOTOBbIX 3K3eMDJIHpax 6pOlIIIOPbI 3TO OTAeJIeHHe HMeJIO Ome'laTaHHbIe rAe-To npOKJIaMa n HH OAHU H3 areHTOB npHHec HX B THDorpa4 HIO H 6bICTPO YCTaHOBHJI COOTBeT CTByroIIJ HH lIIPH4 T ECJIH 6bI 3TOT areHT He AOnyCTHJI He6pe I HocTH B BbIDOJIHeHHH CBoero 3a J auHH TpIOK Cpa60TaJI 6bI H HeBHHHbIH 'IeJIOBeK 6bm 6bI COCJIaH B CH6Hpb Ho B CJIO I HBlIIeHCH CHTYanu H CneIJ HaJIbHbIe OTAeJIbI B nOMOIIJ b cOTPYAHHKaM BeAYLUHM paccJIe Ha'laJIbHHK AOBaHHH nOJIHTH'IeCKHX AeJI H3-3a HeXBaTKH JIIOAeH cnoc06HbIX paCCJIeAOBaHHe 6bmo HeMe J JIeHHO npeKpaLUeHO H HH eAHHbIH BOJIOC B03rJIaBHTb TaKHe OTAeJIbI TpyceBH'IY npHlIIJIOCb Ha3Ha'lHTb Ha 3TH He ynaJI C rOJIOBbI ne'laTHHKa AOJDKHOCTH MOJIO J bIX apMeHCKHX 04 unePOB ECTecTBeHHO 3THM KOTOPbIH C06CTBeHHOpY'IH0 HanuCaJI Ha nOJIHX AOKYMeHTa OTBeT MeCTHOrO no OxpaHHoro OTAeJIeHHH H HOBbIM CJIY'KlUIJ HM O'leHb 'laCTO He XBaTaJIO 3HaHHH H ODbITa H B cTBeHHbIH 3a AOBeplIIeHHe Me l IJ ' HHMH H MeCTHbIMH BJIaCTHMH Hepe J KO B03HH Ha'IaJIbHHKY Kopnyca l aH J apMOB - 294 noJIyqHJI HarOHHH co06IIJ HJI 06 3TOM MHHHCTPY COTPYAHHK AOJI l eH HeMe J JIeHHO yHTH B OTCTaBKY He3aMeAJIHTeJIbHO C006IIJ HTb 295 o ero CMe eHHH BIDlX peBOJIIOIJ HOHepOB 3axO D Hn0 cnHllIKOM n aneKo OH nerKO Mor C n PYJ'HM cnyqaeM npOBOKar HH II CTonKHynCII KOrAll 6hUI masoii oco60ro OT n ena nommeiicKoro ynpasneHIDl Ha'laJIhHHK npe lKHeMY 06Pa3Y lKH3HH OKa3aThCII B cHryaUHH HCKJIIO'laBllIeii B03MO lKHOCTb B03Bpa eHHII K lKaH D apMCKoro OT n ena npH OXPaHHOM OT n eneHHH lKene3HOii n oporH Cnyqanoch HHor n a 'ITO Hama areHTbI 6bInH BbIHy lK l1 eHhI B Ha D anhHeBOCTOlIHoii rpamm e KOTOPhIii CKopee Bcero npe lK J e HH Kor n a He yqacTBoBan B paccne n OBaHHlIX nomrrHileCKHX n en co06 UenIIX CaMoCOXpaneHIDl 6paTh y peBOJIIOIJ HOHepOB nponaraH J HCT n 'ITO peBOJIIOIJ HOHephl H3 POCCHH perynllpHo c06HpalOTCII B o n HOM Kny6e B TOKHO QT06hI 06e3Bpe J HTh 3THX nlO n eii coo6 OH cKyro nHTeparypy KOMDpoMeTHpyro ero XapaKTepa H n a lKe B3phIB '1aTKY oc06eHHo Kor n a B03HHKMa OnaCHOCTb n oMaIUHero 06hIcKa B TaKHX cnyqan comaCHO HHCTpYKUHH Hama nOMOJIUiHKH n 0nX eHHe H KHHynclI K llIe«py nonHIJ HH H Bee eMY co06 3TOMY HhI 6hInH npHHOCHTb nHTeparypy H B3pbm'laTbIe Be eCTBa CBoeMY HatJaIlbHHKY B OT n eneHHe nOnHIJ HH a 3aTeM 06'bIlBHTb cBoeii rpynne lKan napMcKoMY o«pHuepy HeMe llIeHHO nocnana TenerpaMMY CaMhIM 'ITO OHH 6hInH BhIHY lK neHhI ynH'lTO lKHTb MaTepHanbI TaK KaK KBap KaTerOpH'leCKHM 06pa30M 3anpe aH BhIDOnneHHe ero 6e3 'MHoii 3aTeH K C'IaCThlO TenerpaMMa npHllIna BOBpeMII npe nynpe n HB THpHaH X0311HKa CTMa 'ITO-TO no n 03pesaTb HnH HaUTH n pyroe npas HaCHnHe CDnaHHpoBaHHOe 0 l1 HHM H3 HaIImX lKe JIIO n eii OXpaHHoro oT n eneHHII Bxo nnno nOMOraTb areHTaM H3bICKHBaTb OH ynonnOMO'lHn CBoero areHTa B30pBaTh Kny6 llpo'ITlI 3T0 co06 n ono n 06Hoe 06'bIlCHeHHe B 06H3aHHOCTH Ha'laJIhHHKOB OmenoB 3THM HC'lepIlbIBalOTCII Bce H3BeCTHble MHe cnyllaa npoBoKaIJ Hii H3BHHHTeI1bHbIe MOTHBbI Ha nOTpe6y pesOJIIOIJ HOHepoB H HHOrAll Ecnn rOBopHTb oTKpoBeHHo YnpasneHHe nonaIJ HH BO MHomx J a lKe yCTpaHBaTb pa na 3Toro He60IlbIIIHe npe nCTaBneHHII TaKHM 06pa30M BnaCTH Mornn 3anOnyqHTb Ba lKHbIe n OKYMeHTbI He KOMn poMempYH areHTa B ma3ax larOBOpIIl HKOB cnyqan npolIBnMo H3nHllIHlOlO no n 03pHTenhHocTh no OTHOllIe HRlO K CBOHM nO J IIHHeHHbIM B Bonpoce c06JIIO n eHHII HMH rpaHHU HX nonnoMo'lHii Pa60Ta TaiiHblX areHTOB orpaHHllHBanaCh oTnpasneHHeM B OXPaHHoe OT n eneHHe coo6 eHHii 0 n eneIlbHOCTH peBOJIIOIJ HOHHbIX aTeIlb MO lKeT CnpOCHTb nO'leMY He Bcer n a npOH3BO l1 HnHCh apecTbI mm 0 KOTOPbIX Coo6 anH areHTbI H nO'leMY C n pyroii CTO PORbI B Te'leHHe n onroro BpeMeHH nOnHIJ H1I BhIrnH nena 6e3yqaCT rpynn HM cTporo 3anpe anocb aKTHBHoe yqacTHe B n eiiCTBIDlX HhIM Ha6JIIOAllTeneM MaxHHaIJ HH onacHhIX 3aroBop KOB 3TO 06'bllc BpaX D e6HhIX HHTepecaM rocYAllpcTBa Pa3YMeeTCH 'lneHhI peBOJIIO HHeTCII cno lKHoii CTPYKTYPoH pesOJIIOIJ HOHHbIX OpraHH3aIJ Hii Ha'laTb C Toro 'ITO TaiiHbIii areHT nOnHIJ HH 06bIIIHO 3HaeT nHllIh HeMHomx IJ HOHHoii rpynIlbI B KOTOPyro BXO D Hn areHT Morna nOTpe60BaTb OT Hero BhInonneHIDl KaKoii-TO tJaCTH pa60TbI H OH He BCerAll Mor OT 3roro YBHIlbnyTh He BhI3bmaH no n 03peHHH COOTBeTCTBeHHO Mbl pa3pemanH HaIIIHM nOMOlIJ HHKaM yqaCTHe B TaUHhIX C06paHHHX H coyqaCTHe B BhInonneHHH MenKHX nopyqeHHii Ho Kor n a n eno Kaca He3Ha'IHTeIlbRbIX yqaCTHHKOB 3arOBop eCKHx rpynn B TO BpeMH KaK HaCTOII e PYKOBO J HTenn OCTalOTCII B TeHH lleno 06CTOMO TaK 'ITO n eIlTeI1bHOCTb OpraHH3aIJ Hii HMeBllIHX ueIlbIO pa3pynIeHHe POCCHHCKoro rocYAllpcTBa yx e 6bUIa HaCTonbKO Pa3pa60TaHHoii nOCb Cepbe3HhIX H onaCRbIX npe nnpIDlTHH COTpy J HH'lalO eMy C no 'ITO ee HeI1b311 6hUIO npeo n oneTb DnOXO npOAYMaHHhIMH MepaMH mm neii He pa3pemanOCb nOBHHOBaTbCII npe n BO l1 HTenIlM MHTe lKHH HaCHnHH Ecnn 6hI nonHD HH B3Ma 3a npasHnO npOH3B nHTb apeCTbI KOB H Toma BCTaBan Bonpoc KaK HaUTH 3aCnYX HBalO ii n OBepHII npe nnor nnH OTKa3a OT BbIDonneHHII HX HHCTPYKIJ Hii ll03TOMY Cpa3Y no nonyqeHHH nepBblX coo6 eHHii CBOHX OCBe n OMHTeneii areHTY 6bUIO TPY nnO C o nnoii CroPOHhI C03 n asaTb Bne'lameHHe D a lKe He 6bUIH H3BeCTHbl n eTanH 3arOBopoB H MhI HHKOrAll He CMor peBHOCTHOrO yqaCTIDl B napTHiiHbIX n enax a C n pyroii OTKa3bmaTh nn 6hl paCKpbITb nO llIHHHhIe pa3Mephl OpraHH3aIJ HH HaIlIH Bpam OHa 3anonyqana 6hI TonbKO He3HallHTeIlbRble BHHTHKH KOrophIM CII OT 3ap aHHii HaKa3yeMhIX KaK TH lKenOe npecrynneHHe EcnH TaU Mornn CMellTbCII 3a HaIlIeii CDHHoii ecnH 6bl Mbl HeMe llIeHHO apeCTO RbIii areHT He npOllBnM n OCTaTOlIHoro pBeHM OH pHCKOBan Bbl BhIBanH Man03Ha'IHTeI1bHbIX mm Bbl J BHHyT'bIX Bnepe n TaK KaK 3BaTb no n 03peHIDl CBOHX C006 KOB H OHH Morna ero y6HTb EcnH lKe C n pyroii CTOPORbI ero yqacTHe B HaCHIlbCTBeHHbIX n eiiCT- 296 3THM caMblM MhI npe nynpe lK l1 anH 6hl 06 OnaCHOCTH HaCTOII PYKoBo l1 HTeneii 297 C060H BaJIaCb H yHH ITO I aJIaCb Bce Y Koro HaxOARJIH XOTa 6bl IaCTh Bbl CTOm 'Ke CJlO KH 'lO cHcTeMy KaK H OXpaHllOe OTneneHHe PyKOBO B006me peBOJIIOWiOHHhIe 06mecTBa npenCTaBJUUIH nymeHHblX nOnpbmHbIX MaTepHaJIOB Ha 60Jlee HJlH MeHee Il lIHteJlJ l HTeJlH Ha oco60 omeTCTBeHHbIX nOCTax OqeHb pe o KO BCTpeqaJIHCh HbIe CPOKH OmpaBJlaJIH B CH6Hpb co CBOHMH TOBapHmaMH He BXO o HBDIHMH B Y3KHH KPyr aKTHBHC HaH60Jlee OnaCUbIMH BparaMH C KOTOPbIMH npHXOAHllOCb TOB H CKpbmaJIHCb non BbIMhIlWIeHHhIMH HMeHaMH 1l03TOMY 06bl'l HMen neJlO OXpaHHOMY OTneJleHHIO 6blJlH aHapXHCThl ogep I HMbIe HO peBOJllOWiOHep He 3HaJI KTO Ha caMOM neJle CTOHT Han HHM cnenoH OH palpymeHHB CTpeMHBnmeca YHH ITO I HTb Ha CBoeM Bca KoppecnouneHWiB nOCTaBJlaJIaCb no HeBHHHO Bhlrna o eBIlIHM nym nOnCTaBHbIM a o peCaM Ha 'KaprOHe 3THX JIIOneH HalbmaBIlIHMCa HHX 6h1Jlo MHoro JlIOneH C IPaHaTHlleCKOH BepoH B npaBOty CBOHX XOJlOCTbIMH 1l0 ITH Bce BenymHe neaTenH PeBOJIIOnHOHHOrO Jlare H lJ eH H He06xop HMOCTb TaKoro pona geHCTBHH Ho 6bIJlH cpep H Bcex npHBep'KeHIIeB BJlaCm H nop RJ Ka B rocynapcme Cpep H pa HMeJlH IPaJIhDIHBhIe nacnopTa H 6hIJIH CTom HCKYCHbI B coxpa aHapXHCTOB H JlIOp H npoCTO HCKaBIDHe B03MO I HOCTH ynOBJleTBo HeHHH ceKpeta CBoeH JIHlmocm ITO qaCTO ll lIa BJlaCteH HaH60mmeH pHTb CBOH H3BpameHHbIe H npeCtyIIHbIe HHCTHHKTbI rpY IIOCThIO 6h1Jlo YCTaHOBHTh KTO 'Ke B CaMOM neJle HaxOp HTCa nepenHHMH MHoro XJlOnOT P OCTaBJlBJIH OXPaHHOMY OTneneHHIO TaK Ha 3bmaeMhIe 60eBhle rpynDbI COWiaJIHCTOB-peBOJlIOWiOHepoB IaCTO Bee DHCbMeHHhle MaTepHaJThI KOTopble MomH 6hITh HHKpHMH COBepmaBIDHe nOnbITKH nOKymeHHB Ha l H3Hb 'IlleHOB IIaPCKOH HHPOBaHbl COCTaBJlaJIHCh npH nOMOmH CJlO l HhIX nmIPPOB DHCaOHCh ceMbH HJlH Ha CJlY'KamHX npaBHTeJlbCTBeHHhIX yqpexcn eHHil H nOOH HeBH lJ HMbIMH qepHHJlaMH H XPaHHJlHCb B BeChMa HCKYCHO Bbl6paH IIHH lIHcneHHocTb naBlIIHX OT B3PhlBOB H BbICTpeJlOB OpraHH30BaH HblX nOTaeHHbIX MecTax OnhITHhie peBOJlIOWiOHepbl Bcerna CTapa HbIX 3TOH teppoPHcmlleCKOH OpraHH3aIJ HeH OlleHb BeJIIIKa JlHCh YBepHTbca ITO 3a HHMH HHKTO He CJleA 'eT Ha YJlHIIax H 6bIDH l H3Hb IIapa IaCTO HaXoAHllaCb non cePbe3HOH yrP030H HaM noc CJlY'IaH TOBHHO COOGmaJIH 0 3arOBOpax C IIenhIO y6HTb MOHapxa He06xo ll pa3pa60TaHbI CneUHaJIbHble Mepbl npenOCTOpO I HOCTH Ha IJ uce HeO l H J aHHOH nOJlHIIeHCKOH 06JlaBbI BeJlH COTPY IIHKH OxpaHHoro Ma 6h1Jla npeA 'cMOTpHTeJlbHOCTb H H306peTaTeJIhHOCTb IT06bl npe OTneneHHB HeO l Jf l aHHO nOaBJlBJlHCb B KBapmpe BbI3BaBmeH Y HHX AOTBpaTHTb 3m npeetyIIDeHHB non03peHHe 3aCTHI'HYThle taM Bcerna YMynpaJIHCh 3a o eprHBaB 3aHaBeCKH HJlH KaKHM-JlH60 eme cnoco60M Co06InHTh 06 3TOM CBoeMY qeJlOBeKY n pHBmeMY CHap Ha YJlHIIe H MbI3Ha JIll ITO HHKTO H3 3arOBOpInHKOB He npH lJ eT B paCKphItyIO HaMH KBapTHpy KCTaTH roBopa 06 OTHomeHHaX Mexcn y nOJIHIIeHCKHMH Mac TaMH H peBOJlIOWiOHepaMH a XOTen 6bl B KOHIIe KOPOTKO paCCKa PyKOBO JJ lInHe pa60THHKH napmH MBTe I JIHKOB KaK npaBHJlo 3aTb 0 nOKymeHHH Ha CTOObDIHHa maBY COBeTa MHHHCTPOB noc HaxO o HJlHCb 3a rpaHHIIeH H B CHny 3Toro BHe nOcaraeMocm BJlaC KOJIbKY 06 nOM npHCKop6HOM cnyqae XO HJIH MHorOllHCJleHHble TeH B qaCTHocm lIIBeHIIapHB nOJlro 6bIDa IIeHTpOM pa3HbiX COWia H COBepmeHHO HeBepHble CJlyxH Be30TBeTCTBeHHhle JlI06HTeJlH BMe JlHCTH IeCKHX H peBOJllOWiOHHbIX OpraHH3aIJ HH HCnOJlb30BaBIDHX 3ty lIIHBaTbca B qy I He neJIa HMenH 6eCCTbIACTBO 06BHHHTb HeKO CTPaHY KaK y6e I Hme H3 KOToporo OHH ocymeCmJlaJIH CHCTeMam TOphIX 'IlleHOB HMllepaTopcKoro nOMa B KOCBeHHOM COyqaCTHH B qeCKHe YCHJlHB ll lIa nonphma IIaPCKOH BJlacm 3TOM npeCTynneHHH O HHM H3 HaH60Jlee Ba l HblX cpencm HCnOJlb30BaBlIIHXCa B aBrycTe 1906 r 6hIDO cOBepmeHo nOKymeHHe Ha l H3Hb BceMH 3THMH rpynJlaMH 6bIDH taHHbIe neqaTHbIe CTaHKH 06Hapy CTOOhOIHHa 'KHTb H 06e3BpenHTh TaKHe oqarH peBOJlIOIIHH 6blJlO O llOH H3 maB CaM MHHHCTp qynOM YIIeJIeJl HO 'IlleHhI ero ceMbH H MHorHe npyrHe HbIX JlO 3a o aq TOJlbKO OxpaHHoro C nOMOIIIhIO OTneJleHHB TaHHhIX H penmTb COrpY IIHKOB ee MQ l HO 6hl ECJlH MhI Ha XO o HJlH TaKOH CTaHOK Bca HaHneHHaa npOA 'KUIDl KOHIPHCKOBhI- 298 KOTopoe Morno 6hI CJlY I HTb npenOCTepe'KeHHeM OKalaJIHCb 'KepmOH 3Toro 3arOBopa llpeCTynneHHe 6hIDO COBep meHO Korna CTOJIhIDHH f HJl B oc06HBKe Ha AnTeKapcKOM OCTpoBe H nOBOJlbHO IaCTO YCTpaHBaJI npHeMbI qeTBepo 3arOBOpIIUlKOB 299 nOnDeXaJlH B KOnllCKe K u BepllM MHHHCTepcKOrO u OMa 0Jm Beml Ce6H KaK npHI'nameHHble rOCTH H BOllUIH B u OM 0 ll HH HS HHX 6bIn B BoeHHOH cpopMe H wneMe r u e 6bIn cnpllTaH sapll ll Il HHaMHTa Kor u a OH 6pocHII wneM nocne u OBan CTPaIIIHhlH Bspbm cpasy npe BpaTHBIUHii u OM B KytIy pasBanHH HecKOnbKO rOCTeH H MHOrHe cny rH 6bInH y6HTbl CblH H u 0'lb CTOnblDHHa 6blnH TIDKeno paHeHbI BeSYMHble y6HiinbI caMH 6blnH pasOpBaHbl na KYCKH 3TOT y KaCHbIH cnyqaH CHnbHO noBnH fln na nonHTHKy MHHHCT pa Dpexc u e OH CKopee CKnOHHnCH K nH6epanbHOH TO'lKe SpeHHH HO HatJHHaH C noro BpeMeHH SaH fln nosH1UIIO SHeprHtlHOro conpo THBneHHH pa u HKanbHblM TeH ll eHlUlJlM B cTpaHe lIy o OM cnacWHcb OT nOKymeHHH Ha ero KH3Hb OH TBep u o H pelllHTenbHO CTan npOTH BOCTOllTb BceM peBOJIlOI HOHHbIM cunaM OH oCTasancH Ha 3TOH no 3HI HH n01 a He norH6 npH u pyrOM Hana u eHHH CY ll b6a KOTOPOH KaK OH 'IyBCTBoBan OH He Mor H36e f aTb Hacmrna ero neTOM 1911 ro u a Uapb noceTun KueB H B ero CBHTe cpe u H u pyrHX BbI u aIOIUHXCH u ellTeneH 6bIn masa COBeTa MHHHCT pOB BnacTH npHHHnH Bce MepbI 'IT06bI y6epe'lb uapll OT Hana u eHHH Do npHKa3y CTonblIIHHa B03masnllTb ynpasneHHe nommeHcKoH Cny K60H 6bInO u OBepeHo reHepany KypnoBY HeCKOnbKO Il HeH CnyCTll nocne npH6blTHH Il Bopa B KueB 6bIBIllHH TaHHbIH areHT no cpaMHnHH BorpoB nOJIBuncH B MeCTHOM OT ll eneHHH OxpaHHoro oT u eneHHH H C006WHn 'ITO eMY H3BeCTeH B no u p06HOCTJIX nnaH nOKymeHHll Ha uaPH 3aMblwneHHbIH rpyn nOH HaMepeBaIOIUeHcll oCYIUeCTBHTb CBOH saroBop B KueBe Coo6 IUeHHe BorpoBa lByqaJIO OlJeHb npas u ono u 06Ho H Bnacm npHHHnH u a Ke 6onbIllHe lJeM 06bl1JHO npe u oCTOp0 f HOCTH Ho HHlJerO oco 6eHHoro He npOHCXO IJ HJIO u o BpeMeHH DpOrpaMMa npal u HeCTB BKnIO'Iana CneKTaKnb B KueBCKOM TeaTpe IhmnIme rOBOpHTb 'ITO B MecTe r u e 6bInH HMnepaTOp H BbICWHe u OJDKHOCTHbIe nHQa ero COnpOBO K ll aBIIIHe npoBepKe roc TeH 6bInO y u eneHO oco60e BHHMaHHe feHepan KypnoB npHHHn Bce npe u OCTOpO f HOCTH 'IT06bI HHKTO KpoMe Tex OTHOCHTenbHO Koro He Momo 6bITb HH ManeHIllHX no u 03peHHii He HaxO IJ HJICH Pll ll OM Bcne u CTBHe 3Toro Bce n03BOJIHJIH ce6e 6blTb 6ecne'IHbIMH B 3TOT Be'Iep HHKTO He HMen HH ManeHwero npenlfYBCTBHH 'ITO BO BpeMH npe u CTasneHHH 6y u eT y6HT npeMbep-MHHHCTp 3TO COBepWHII TaHHblH areHT BorpoB Do u KaKHM-TO npe u no rOM OH nOHBHnCll B TeaTpe Kor u a nma m eca nepe u an KYn fl6KO KOTOpbIii 6hIn nepBhIM SaMecTHTeneM mashl CneUllanbHOH nOnH UeHCKOH Cny K6bl B Kuese Ka1 yro-TO COBepweHHO HecymeCTBeHHyro HHCPOPMaQHIO TaKHM 06pasOM KynH6Ko nOBHHeH B HeOCTOpO f HOCTH nOBneKweii CaMbIe cepbelHble nocne u CTBIDI nocne Toro KaJ BOrpOB nepe u an KynH61 0 CBoe u OHeceHHe TOT C1 asan BorpoBY 'IT06bI OH ymen HO He npOBepBJI 6bInO mI BhmOmleHO no pacnopH f eHHe OCTaDHB BorpOBa 6es npHCMOTpa KYn fl61 0 SaH flnCH u pyru MH u enaMH H BorpOB Hamen BOSMO f HOCTb 'Iepel 1 aJ oe-TO BpeMH npOC1 OnbSayTb HeSaMe'IeHHblM B lpHTenbHbIH lan OH cpasy BbICTpe nun B CTOnblUHHa HeC1 Onb1 O pal H TOT yuan TIDKeno paaeHblM qepeS Il Ba ll H fl OH YMep OT 3THX paHeHHii B 6onbHHD e 3TOT cnyqaH u an BparaM reHepana KypnOBa XopoIUHii nOBO u ymepxc u aTb 'ITO OH 1 aJ masa cneIOfanbHOH nOJIHQeHCKOH Cny K6bl nHtlHo OTBeTCTBeHeH sa 3TO HeclJaCTbe Ero BemllJecTBo pacnop fl lJ HJI Cll 0 npOBe u eHHH paccne u OBaHHll 1 OTOPbIM u On f eH 6hIn PYKOBO Il HTb TpyceBHlI maDa POCCHHCKOH nOmlIOfH XOTll TpyceBH'I He· O'leHb XopoWO OTHOCHnCll K reHepany KypnOBY paccne u OBaHHe HH 1 'IeMY He npHBenO H B KOHQe-1 OHQOB 6bInO npeKpaIUeHO no pac nopIDKeHHIO u aPH KaKHe 06cTOJlTenbCTBa n06YAHJlH TaHHOrO areHTa BorpoBa y6HTb CTOnbUIHHa He Bnonae llCHO u o CHX nop BhITb MO f eT OH Il aBHO XOTen COBepWHTb 3TO npecTynneHHe u nH noro BTepcH B u 0 BepHe K BnaCTllM u OCTaDnllll nO f Hl Ie CBe u eHHll 0 ll Ha1 0 60nee npas u ono u 06HbIM 1 8 f eTCll 'ITO waH1 a larOBopIUHKOB 1 KOTOPOH OH npHHa u ne f an Bhl6pana ero B CaMbIH nocne ll HHH MOMeHT Il nH y6HiicTBa npeMbep-MHHHCTpa H OH He nOCMen onacaHCh HX MIUeHHll OT1 asaTbCH BhlDOnHHTb HX npHKas 300 301