YKaseHHOrO 38KOHOM oprBHa He no ttIlAYT B TeqeHHe qeTblpeX ttHeii npeSH tteHTY CeHaTa H CIIHKepy nanaThI npe ttCTaBHTeneii IIHChMeH­ HOe 3lU1BneHHe npe3H tteHT Bce ew e He B COCTOJilHHH BhIIIOnHRTh caOH 06 f 13aHHOCTH H nOnHOMO'UUl 6y tteT B cnyqae ecnH T8Koe 38 f1BneHHe nOJIyqeHo peWeHHe no 3TOMY Bonpoey ttOJI lKeH npHHRTh Kourpecc C03BaB B TeqeHHe 48 qaCOB qpeSBhI'l HHYIO cecCHlO ecnH A T BacUflbee PeHe Q lOllon-MUfUlep KOHrpecc B STO BpeMR He IIPOBO ttHT CBoe perynRpHoe sace ttBHHe ECJIH KOHrpecc B TeqeHHe 21 ttHR IIocne nonyqeHHR nocne ttHero IIHChMeHHoro 38 RBneHHR a B IIepepbIBax MeX ' l Y CeCCHRMH qeHHe 21 ttHR IIOcne COShlBa qpe3Bhl'l A HOii ceCCHH 1f3 KHlfrlf OXPAHA T ARHAJI nOnlfUIDl B Te­ POCCIfRCKA1I peWHT ttByMR TpeTRMH ronOCOB 06eHX nanaT 'ITO IIpeSH tteHT He B COCTORHHH BhlIIOJIHRTh CBOH nOnHOMo'IHR H 06 f 138HHOCTH TO BH e-npe3H tteHT npo ttOJI KaeT OCTaBaThCR HCIIOnHRlOW HM 06RS8HHOCTH IIpelH tteHTa B npoTHBHOM cnyqae IIpeSH tteHT B03Bpaw aeTcR K HcnonHeHHlO CBOHX nOJIHOMO'IHti H 06 f 13BHHOCTeti 1I0 KanyH CTaThR OT tten 18 1 26 paTHcp HpOBBHa 1 HIOnR 1971 r npaso rp X ' I aH Coe ttHHeHHhlx mTaTOB ttOCTHrwux neT HnH crapwe rOJIOCOBaTh Ha BhI60pax He tton Ho HapywaTh­ CR HnH OTpHl aThCR 3a HHMH Coe ttHHeHHhlMH mTaTaMH HJIH OT tten ­ HhlMH WTaTaMH B caRSH C BOSp CTOM OT tten 2 npaao npHHRT COOTBeTCTBYIOW He saKOHhI ttJIR o6ecneQeHHR co6nlO tteHHR SToii CTaT H npHHa ttJIelKHT Kourpecey c rryqaH HMeBnme MeCTO nOClIe peBomoIJ HH 1917 ro­ na HCHee Bcero nOKa3bmaIOT lfTO 6e3 TeXHHKH Pa3BHTOH OXpaHHbiM OT 1 elleHHeM Mano lfTO MO KHO C 1 enaTh MHHHCTP IOCTHIUDI KepeH­ CKHH 06paTH1ICH K 61 mIIIHM OBHHKaM OXpaHKH HaXO J HBIIIHMCH B TO BpeMJI B TIOpbMe 3a COBeTOM KaK lIyt1llle BcerO npOTHBOCTOHTb HHtpHI'aM 601lbmeBHKOB Cpe J H rex K KOMY OH 06paTH1ICH 6blJI reHepan fll06aQeB Halla1IbHHK neTep6yprCKOH oxpaHKH Ero apeCTO­ BallH cpa3y noclIe peBOllIOIJ HH H T '1' Ke npe J 1l0 KH1IH HCrr01lb30BaTh ero OllbIT B 60pb6e HOBoro npaBHTe1lbCTBa rrpOTHB 3KCTpeMHCTOB H xoqy paCCK33aTh 0 MoeM C06CTBeHHOM CXO J HOM OllbiTe COtpyp HH'IeCTBO C TaHHbIMH areHTaMH 3aBep60BaHHblMH B cpe J e 6yHTOB1IUfi OB He06xo J HM0 J IH n01IHTH'IeCKOH nOJ1HlJ HH HO OT 3toro ew e O'leHb na rreKO 1 0 npoBoKanHH H1IH npHMoro nO 1 CTpe­ KaTe1lbCTB8 B '1eM Bcerna 06BHHH1IH OXPaHHoe OT 1 elleHHe Ha CaMOM 1 elle TaKOro pona 06BHHeHHH Mor '1' 6bITh nO 1 TBep K J eHbI TOlll KO 0 J HHM nyTeM BparH CTaporo pe KHM8 rrpOHlBOllbHO HlMeHH1IH 3Ha'leHHe ClIOBa npoBOKaIJ HH H CT81IH Ha3bffiaTb mo60ro Qe1l0Be· A T Vassilyev Rene Fulop-Miller The Ochrana The Russian Secret Police J B Lippincoff Company Philadelphia and London 1930 pp 63-72 85-89 292 293 Ka TaifHo cHa6 K3BlIIerO HaC HH4 opMa n HeH areHTOM-npOBOKaTO­ pOM Ha CaMOM AeJIe TOtIlJOe 3Ha'leHHe noro MHOrOKpaTHO CKOM­ npOMeTHpOBaHHOrO CJIOBa COBceM HHoe AreHToM-npOBOKaTOpOM JlBJUleTCH JIHlIIb TOT KTO CaM 3aTeBaeT HeKoe l eHHe a peBOJIIO OHHOe KaJIH TpeHHH KpOMe Toro KaKOe-TO BpeMH YnpaBJIeHHe nOJIHIJ HH npHMeHH­ JIO HeBepuyro npaKTHKy OIIeHKH AeHTeJIbHOCTH CeKIJ HH - MeXaHH­ ABH­ 'IeCKH no 'IHCJIY panopToB 06 06Hap ' KeHHbIX HHTPHrax peBOJIIOIJ HO­ 3aTeM AOHOCHT BJIaCTHM Ha O a'leHHbIX HM JIIOAeH HepoB IIoJIY'laJIocb TaK 'ITO eCJIH B KaKOM-TO paiioHe 3arOBOpIIJ H­ ECJIH 3TO CJIOBO nOHHMaTb 'Ka3aHHbIM 06pa30M TO H Mory 3aBe­ KH He 6bIJIH O'leHb aKTHBHbI COTPYAHHK HMeJI OCHOBaHHH onacaTbCH PHTb 'ITO HaCT01lIUHe npOBOKa n HH He TOJIbKO HHKorAa He nOOLUpH­ DJIOXoro Bne'laTJIeHHH 0 ce6e B CaHKT-IIeTep6ypre nOCKOJIbKY OH He JIHCb UapCKHM npaBHTeJIbCTBOM HO CypOBO HaKa3bIBaJIHCb npeAOCTaBJIHJI COOTBeTCTByroIIJ HX co06LUeHHH DOJIee Toro OXPaHHOMY OTAeJIeHHIO K CO l aJIeHHIO HHKorAa 06pa30M npHBOAHJIO K 3TO eCTeCTBeHHbIM C06JIa3HHTeJIbHOH HAee C03AaHHH 6ecno­ He pa3pelIIaJIH YCTpauBaTb 3arOBopbI CpeAH 06pa30BaHHbIX cepeA­ PHAKOB nyTeM HX npOBOIJ HpOBaHHH 'lT06bI paCKpbIBIIIHH HX 04 H­ HHKOB POCCHH C'lHTaJIOCb MOp HbIM C nOJIHbIM OTCYTCTBHeM nOHH­ Uep 3aCJIY'KHJI y MaHHH H MepbI COqyBCTBOBaTb TOMY 'ITO OHH npHHHMaJIH 3a JIH6e­ nOJIe3Horo paJIbHbIe HAeH H B pe3YJIbTaTe aHnmpaBHTeJIbCTBeHHbIe CHJIbI OKa­ H PYKOBOAHTeJIeH YnpaBJIeHHH penyTaIJ HIO oc060 HeCKOJIbKO pa3 CTaJIKHBaJICH C TaKHMH CJIY'laHMH CpeAH 1906 3bIBaJIHCb CaMH no ce6e AOCTaTO'IHO CHJIbHbIMH 'lT06bI Tpe60BaJIOCb HHX Bbl J eJIHeTCH npOH301IIe J lIIHH B EKaTepHHOCJIaBe B HCKYCCTBeHHO nO JJl ep l HBaTb HX HJIH 'lT06bI OXPaHHoe OTAeJIeHHe MeHH nOCJIaJI TYAa MHHHCTP BHYTPeHHHX AeJI II H llyPHOBO OT roAY 6hl 3arOBopbI B npHDHCbIBaeMOH eMY MaHepe npoKypopa MeCTHOrO cy a H Y3HaJI 'ITO He3a J OJIrO AO Moero npHe3­ OTBpaTHTeJIbHbIe CMYTbHHbI BYPUeB fepIIIYHH BaJIMaIIIOB KaJIHeB a rJIaBa OxpaHHoro OTAeJIeHHH 06HapY lKHJl nOAnOJIbHbIH ne'laTHbIH CaBHHKOB H npO'IHe co06LUa pa60TaBlIIHe AeCHTHJIeTHHMH 'lT06bI CTaHOK peBOJIIOIJ HOHepoB OAHaKO npOBO J HBlIIHe AeTaJIbHOe pac­ OpraHH30BbIBaJIO pa3pyIIIHTb Hamy CTPauy AO CHX nop He CMOrJIH aTb CBH J eTeJIbCT­ CJIeAOBaHHe 3Toro AeJIa ropoAcKHe BJIaCTH cpa3y l e 06HapY lKHJlH Ba 'ITO HX cnPOBOnupOBaJIH Ha HX PeBOJIIOIJ HOHHYIO AeHTeJIbHOCTb HeonpoBep I JIMbIe CBHAeTeJIbCTBa npoTHB paCCJIeAOBaHHH npoBeAeH­ HeT Hy lKAbI CKPbIBaTb 'ITO Koe-rAe H3-3a HeODbITHOCTH MeCT­ Horo OXPaHHbIM OTAeJIeHHeM BOT KaK no 6bmo B nOMeLUeHHH HbIX BJIaCTeH npOBOKa n HH AeHCTBHTeJIbHO HMeJIH MeCTO HO eCJIH B nmorpa4 HH HaIIIJIH HeCKOJIbKO COTeH 3K3eMDJIHpOB B BbIclIIeH CTe­ YnpaBJIeHHH nOJIHIJ HH Y3HaBaJIH 0 TaKOM CJIY'lae BHHOBHbIX CTPoro neHH KPHMHHaJIbHOH 6pOlIIIOPbI H COOTBeTCTByroIIJ Hii lIIPH4 T 6bm HaKa3bIBaJIH PyKoBOAHTeJIH YnpaBJIeHHH - KOBaJIeHCKuH E H By­ yCTaHOBJIeH B CTaHKe H3yqaBIIIHH AeJIO CJIeAOBaTeJIb B3J1J1 06pa3 eu H'I M H TpyceBH'I H H - 3Toro lIIpH4 Ta H BbIHCHHJI 'ITO B KaKOM-TO MecTe B Ha60pe OTCYT­ BcerAa 'lpe3BbI'laHuO 3a60THJIHCb 0 TOM noT 'lT06bI TaKHe Hen03BOJIHTeJIbHbIe AeHCTBHH He OCTaJIHCb He3aMe'leH­ cTByeT CJIOBO HblMH He rOBopH ' Ke 06 HX oA06peHHH CJIOBO HaJIH'leCTBOBaJIO Cpa3y CTaJIO HCHO B 'IeM AeJIo OxpaHHoe DOJIblIIHHCTBO HMeBlIIHX MeCTO npOBOKa n Hii CJIeAyeT pac­ cMaTpHBaTb KaK nOCJIeACTBHH peBOJIIOIJ HH 1905 rOAa BOJIHeHHH nOKa3aJIH 'ITO nOJIHTH'IeCKaH nOJIHIJ HH 'lHCJIeHHO MaJIa 'lT06bI ycnelII­ HO YUHTb Ha'laJIbHHK 6ecnoPHAo'IHoe 6ypJIeHHe lJT06bI CMHr'lHTb no M H TpyceBH'I no 3JIO OpraHH30BaJI Ha MecTax Ho B rOTOBbIX 3K3eMDJIHpax 6pOlIIIOPbI 3TO OTAeJIeHHe HMeJIO Ome'laTaHHbIe rAe-To npOKJIaMa n HH OAHU H3 areHTOB npHHec HX B THDorpa4 HIO H 6bICTPO YCTaHOBHJI COOTBeT­ CTByroIIJ HH lIIPH4 T ECJIH 6bI 3TOT areHT He AOnyCTHJI He6pe I HocTH B BbIDOJIHeHHH CBoero 3a J auHH TpIOK Cpa60TaJI 6bI H HeBHHHbIH 'IeJIOBeK 6bm 6bI COCJIaH B CH6Hpb Ho B CJIO I HBlIIeHCH CHTYanu H CneIJ HaJIbHbIe OTAeJIbI B nOMOIIJ b cOTPYAHHKaM BeAYLUHM paccJIe­ Ha'laJIbHHK AOBaHHH nOJIHTH'IeCKHX AeJI H3-3a HeXBaTKH JIIOAeH cnoc06HbIX paCCJIeAOBaHHe 6bmo HeMe J JIeHHO npeKpaLUeHO H HH eAHHbIH BOJIOC B03rJIaBHTb TaKHe OTAeJIbI TpyceBH'IY npHlIIJIOCb Ha3Ha'lHTb Ha 3TH He ynaJI C rOJIOBbI ne'laTHHKa AOJDKHOCTH MOJIO J bIX apMeHCKHX 04 unePOB ECTecTBeHHO 3THM KOTOPbIH C06CTBeHHOpY'IH0 HanuCaJI Ha nOJIHX AOKYMeHTa OTBeT­ MeCTHOrO no OxpaHHoro OTAeJIeHHH H HOBbIM CJIY'KlUIJ HM O'leHb 'laCTO He XBaTaJIO 3HaHHH H ODbITa H B cTBeHHbIH 3a AOBeplIIeHHe Me l IJ ' HHMH H MeCTHbIMH BJIaCTHMH Hepe J KO B03HH­ Ha'IaJIbHHKY Kopnyca l aH J apMOB - 294 noJIyqHJI HarOHHH co06IIJ HJI 06 3TOM MHHHCTPY COTPYAHHK AOJI l eH HeMe J JIeHHO yHTH B OTCTaBKY He3aMeAJIHTeJIbHO C006IIJ HTb 295 o ero CMe eHHH BIDlX peBOJIIOIJ HOHepOB 3axO D Hn0 cnHllIKOM n aneKo OH nerKO Mor C n PYJ'HM cnyqaeM npOBOKar HH II CTonKHynCII KOrAll 6hUI masoii oco60ro OT n ena nommeiicKoro ynpasneHIDl Ha'laJIhHHK npe lKHeMY 06Pa3Y lKH3HH OKa3aThCII B cHryaUHH HCKJIIO'laBllIeii B03MO lKHOCTb B03Bpa eHHII K lKaH D apMCKoro OT n ena npH OXPaHHOM OT n eneHHH lKene3HOii n oporH Cnyqanoch HHor n a 'ITO Hama areHTbI 6bInH BbIHy lK l1 eHhI B Ha D anhHeBOCTOlIHoii rpamm e KOTOPhIii CKopee Bcero npe lK J e HH­ Kor n a He yqacTBoBan B paccne n OBaHHlIX nomrrHileCKHX n en co06­ UenIIX CaMoCOXpaneHIDl 6paTh y peBOJIIOIJ HOHepOB nponaraH J HCT­ n 'ITO peBOJIIOIJ HOHephl H3 POCCHH perynllpHo c06HpalOTCII B o n ­ HOM Kny6e B TOKHO QT06hI 06e3Bpe J HTh 3THX nlO n eii coo6 OH cKyro nHTeparypy KOMDpoMeTHpyro ero XapaKTepa H n a lKe B3phIB­ '1aTKY oc06eHHo Kor n a B03HHKMa OnaCHOCTb n oMaIUHero 06hIcKa B TaKHX cnyqan comaCHO HHCTpYKUHH Hama nOMOJIUiHKH n 0nX ­ eHHe H KHHynclI K llIe«py nonHIJ HH H Bee eMY co06 3TOMY HhI 6hInH npHHOCHTb nHTeparypy H B3pbm'laTbIe Be eCTBa CBoeMY HatJaIlbHHKY B OT n eneHHe nOnHIJ HH a 3aTeM 06'bIlBHTb cBoeii rpynne lKan napMcKoMY o«pHuepy HeMe llIeHHO nocnana TenerpaMMY CaMhIM 'ITO OHH 6hInH BhIHY lK neHhI ynH'lTO lKHTb MaTepHanbI TaK KaK KBap­ KaTerOpH'leCKHM 06pa30M 3anpe aH BhIDOnneHHe ero 6e3 'MHoii 3aTeH K C'IaCThlO TenerpaMMa npHllIna BOBpeMII npe nynpe n HB THpHaH X0311HKa CTMa 'ITO-TO no n 03pesaTb HnH HaUTH n pyroe npas­ HaCHnHe CDnaHHpoBaHHOe 0 l1 HHM H3 HaIImX lKe JIIO n eii OXpaHHoro oT n eneHHII Bxo nnno nOMOraTb areHTaM H3bICKHBaTb OH ynonnOMO'lHn CBoero areHTa B30pBaTh Kny6 llpo'ITlI 3T0 co06­ n ono n 06Hoe 06'bIlCHeHHe B 06H3aHHOCTH Ha'laJIhHHKOB OmenoB 3THM HC'lepIlbIBalOTCII Bce H3BeCTHble MHe cnyllaa npoBoKaIJ Hii H3BHHHTeI1bHbIe MOTHBbI Ha nOTpe6y pesOJIIOIJ HOHepoB H HHOrAll Ecnn rOBopHTb oTKpoBeHHo YnpasneHHe nonaIJ HH BO MHomx J a lKe yCTpaHBaTb pa na 3Toro He60IlbIIIHe npe nCTaBneHHII TaKHM 06pa30M BnaCTH Mornn 3anOnyqHTb Ba lKHbIe n OKYMeHTbI He KOMn­ poMempYH areHTa B ma3ax larOBOpIIl HKOB cnyqan npolIBnMo H3nHllIHlOlO no n 03pHTenhHocTh no OTHOllIe­ HRlO K CBOHM nO J IIHHeHHbIM B Bonpoce c06JIIO n eHHII HMH rpaHHU HX nonnoMo'lHii Pa60Ta TaiiHblX areHTOB orpaHHllHBanaCh oTnpasneHHeM B OXPaHHoe OT n eneHHe coo6 eHHii 0 n eneIlbHOCTH peBOJIIOIJ HOHHbIX aTeIlb MO lKeT CnpOCHTb nO'leMY He Bcer n a npOH3BO l1 HnHCh apecTbI mm 0 KOTOPbIX Coo6 anH areHTbI H nO'leMY C n pyroii CTO­ PORbI B Te'leHHe n onroro BpeMeHH nOnHIJ H1I BhIrnH nena 6e3yqaCT­ rpynn HM cTporo 3anpe anocb aKTHBHoe yqacTHe B n eiiCTBIDlX HhIM Ha6JIIOAllTeneM MaxHHaIJ HH onacHhIX 3aroBop KOB 3TO 06'bllc­ BpaX D e6HhIX HHTepecaM rocYAllpcTBa Pa3YMeeTCH 'lneHhI peBOJIIO­ HHeTCII cno lKHoii CTPYKTYPoH pesOJIIOIJ HOHHbIX OpraHH3aIJ Hii Ha'laTb C Toro 'ITO TaiiHbIii areHT nOnHIJ HH 06bIIIHO 3HaeT nHllIh HeMHomx IJ HOHHoii rpynIlbI B KOTOPyro BXO D Hn areHT Morna nOTpe60BaTb OT Hero BhInonneHIDl KaKoii-TO tJaCTH pa60TbI H OH He BCerAll Mor OT 3roro YBHIlbnyTh He BhI3bmaH no n 03peHHH COOTBeTCTBeHHO Mbl pa3pemanH HaIIIHM nOMOlIJ HHKaM yqaCTHe B TaUHhIX C06paHHHX H coyqaCTHe B BhInonneHHH MenKHX nopyqeHHii Ho Kor n a n eno Kaca­ He3Ha'IHTeIlbRbIX yqaCTHHKOB 3arOBop eCKHx rpynn B TO BpeMH KaK HaCTOII e PYKOBO J HTenn OCTalOTCII B TeHH lleno 06CTOMO TaK 'ITO n eIlTeI1bHOCTb OpraHH3aIJ Hii HMeBllIHX ueIlbIO pa3pynIeHHe POCCHHCKoro rocYAllpcTBa yx e 6bUIa HaCTonbKO Pa3pa60TaHHoii nOCb Cepbe3HhIX H onaCRbIX npe nnpIDlTHH COTpy J HH'lalO eMy C no­ 'ITO ee HeI1b311 6hUIO npeo n oneTb DnOXO npOAYMaHHhIMH MepaMH mm neii He pa3pemanOCb nOBHHOBaTbCII npe n BO l1 HTenIlM MHTe lKHH­ HaCHnHH Ecnn 6hI nonHD HH B3Ma 3a npasHnO npOH3B nHTb apeCTbI KOB H Toma BCTaBan Bonpoc KaK HaUTH 3aCnYX HBalO ii n OBepHII npe nnor nnH OTKa3a OT BbIDonneHHII HX HHCTPYKIJ Hii ll03TOMY Cpa3Y no nonyqeHHH nepBblX coo6 eHHii CBOHX OCBe n OMHTeneii areHTY 6bUIO TPY nnO C o nnoii CroPOHhI C03 n asaTb Bne'lameHHe D a lKe He 6bUIH H3BeCTHbl n eTanH 3arOBopoB H MhI HHKOrAll He CMor­ peBHOCTHOrO yqaCTIDl B napTHiiHbIX n enax a C n pyroii OTKa3bmaTh­ nn 6hl paCKpbITb nO llIHHHhIe pa3Mephl OpraHH3aIJ HH HaIlIH Bpam OHa 3anonyqana 6hI TonbKO He3HallHTeIlbRble BHHTHKH KOrophIM CII OT 3ap aHHii HaKa3yeMhIX KaK TH lKenOe npecrynneHHe EcnH TaU­ Mornn CMellTbCII 3a HaIlIeii CDHHoii ecnH 6bl Mbl HeMe llIeHHO apeCTO­ RbIii areHT He npOllBnM n OCTaTOlIHoro pBeHM OH pHCKOBan Bbl­ BhIBanH Man03Ha'IHTeI1bHbIX mm Bbl J BHHyT'bIX Bnepe n TaK KaK 3BaTb no n 03peHIDl CBOHX C006 KOB H OHH Morna ero y6HTb EcnH lKe C n pyroii CTOPORbI ero yqacTHe B HaCHIlbCTBeHHbIX n eiiCT- 296 3THM caMblM MhI npe nynpe lK l1 anH 6hl 06 OnaCHOCTH HaCTOII PYKoBo l1 HTeneii 297 C060H BaJIaCb H yHH ITO I aJIaCb Bce Y Koro HaxOARJIH XOTa 6bl IaCTh Bbl­ CTOm 'Ke CJlO KH 'lO cHcTeMy KaK H OXpaHllOe OTneneHHe PyKOBO­ B006me peBOJIIOWiOHHhIe 06mecTBa npenCTaBJUUIH nymeHHblX nOnpbmHbIX MaTepHaJIOB Ha 60Jlee HJlH MeHee Il lIHteJlJ ­ l HTeJlH Ha oco60 omeTCTBeHHbIX nOCTax OqeHb pe o KO BCTpeqaJIHCh HbIe CPOKH OmpaBJlaJIH B CH6Hpb co CBOHMH TOBapHmaMH He BXO o HBDIHMH B Y3KHH KPyr aKTHBHC­ HaH60Jlee OnaCUbIMH BparaMH C KOTOPbIMH npHXOAHllOCb TOB H CKpbmaJIHCb non BbIMhIlWIeHHhIMH HMeHaMH 1l03TOMY 06bl'l­ HMen neJlO OXpaHHOMY OTneJleHHIO 6blJlH aHapXHCThl ogep I HMbIe HO peBOJllOWiOHep He 3HaJI KTO Ha caMOM neJle CTOHT Han HHM cnenoH OH palpymeHHB CTpeMHBnmeca YHH ITO I HTb Ha CBoeM Bca KoppecnouneHWiB nOCTaBJlaJIaCb no HeBHHHO Bhlrna o eBIlIHM nym nOnCTaBHbIM a o peCaM Ha 'KaprOHe 3THX JIIOneH HalbmaBIlIHMCa HHX 6h1Jlo MHoro JlIOneH C IPaHaTHlleCKOH BepoH B npaBOty CBOHX XOJlOCTbIMH 1l0 ITH Bce BenymHe neaTenH PeBOJIIOnHOHHOrO Jlare­ H lJ eH H He06xop HMOCTb TaKoro pona geHCTBHH Ho 6bIJlH cpep H Bcex npHBep'KeHIIeB BJlaCm H nop RJ Ka B rocynapcme Cpep H pa HMeJlH IPaJIhDIHBhIe nacnopTa H 6hIJIH CTom HCKYCHbI B coxpa­ aHapXHCTOB H JlIOp H npoCTO HCKaBIDHe B03MO I HOCTH ynOBJleTBo­ HeHHH ceKpeta CBoeH JIHlmocm ITO qaCTO ll lIa BJlaCteH HaH60mmeH pHTb CBOH H3BpameHHbIe H npeCtyIIHbIe HHCTHHKTbI rpY IIOCThIO 6h1Jlo YCTaHOBHTh KTO 'Ke B CaMOM neJle HaxOp HTCa nepenHHMH MHoro XJlOnOT P OCTaBJlBJIH OXPaHHOMY OTneneHHIO TaK Ha­ 3bmaeMhIe 60eBhle rpynDbI COWiaJIHCTOB-peBOJlIOWiOHepoB IaCTO Bee DHCbMeHHhle MaTepHaJThI KOTopble MomH 6hITh HHKpHMH­ COBepmaBIDHe nOnbITKH nOKymeHHB Ha l H3Hb 'IlleHOB IIaPCKOH HHPOBaHbl COCTaBJlaJIHCh npH nOMOmH CJlO l HhIX nmIPPOB DHCaOHCh ceMbH HJlH Ha CJlY'KamHX npaBHTeJlbCTBeHHhIX yqpexcn eHHil H nOOH­ HeBH lJ HMbIMH qepHHJlaMH H XPaHHJlHCb B BeChMa HCKYCHO Bbl6paH­ IIHH lIHcneHHocTb naBlIIHX OT B3PhlBOB H BbICTpeJlOB OpraHH30BaH­ HblX nOTaeHHbIX MecTax OnhITHhie peBOJlIOWiOHepbl Bcerna CTapa­ HbIX 3TOH teppoPHcmlleCKOH OpraHH3aIJ HeH OlleHb BeJIIIKa JlHCh YBepHTbca ITO 3a HHMH HHKTO He CJleA 'eT Ha YJlHIIax H 6bIDH l H3Hb IIapa IaCTO HaXoAHllaCb non cePbe3HOH yrP030H HaM noc­ CJlY'IaH TOBHHO COOGmaJIH 0 3arOBOpax C IIenhIO y6HTb MOHapxa He06xo ll­ pa3pa60TaHbI CneUHaJIbHble Mepbl npenOCTOpO I HOCTH Ha IJ uce HeO l H J aHHOH nOJlHIIeHCKOH 06JlaBbI BeJlH COTPY IIHKH OxpaHHoro Ma 6h1Jla npeA 'cMOTpHTeJlbHOCTb H H306peTaTeJIhHOCTb IT06bl npe­ OTneneHHB HeO l Jf l aHHO nOaBJlBJlHCb B KBapmpe BbI3BaBmeH Y HHX AOTBpaTHTb 3m npeetyIIDeHHB non03peHHe 3aCTHI'HYThle taM Bcerna YMynpaJIHCh 3a o eprHBaB 3aHaBeCKH HJlH KaKHM-JlH60 eme cnoco60M Co06InHTh 06 3TOM CBoeMY qeJlOBeKY n pHBmeMY CHap Ha YJlHIIe H MbI3Ha­ JIll ITO HHKTO H3 3arOBOpInHKOB He npH lJ eT B paCKphItyIO HaMH KBapTHpy KCTaTH roBopa 06 OTHomeHHaX Mexcn y nOJIHIIeHCKHMH Mac­ TaMH H peBOJlIOWiOHepaMH a XOTen 6bl B KOHIIe KOPOTKO paCCKa­ PyKOBO JJ lInHe pa60THHKH napmH MBTe I JIHKOB KaK npaBHJlo 3aTb 0 nOKymeHHH Ha CTOObDIHHa maBY COBeTa MHHHCTPOB noc­ HaxO o HJlHCb 3a rpaHHIIeH H B CHny 3Toro BHe nOcaraeMocm BJlaC­ KOJIbKY 06 nOM npHCKop6HOM cnyqae XO HJIH MHorOllHCJleHHble TeH B qaCTHocm lIIBeHIIapHB nOJlro 6bIDa IIeHTpOM pa3HbiX COWia­ H COBepmeHHO HeBepHble CJlyxH Be30TBeTCTBeHHhle JlI06HTeJlH BMe­ JlHCTH IeCKHX H peBOJllOWiOHHbIX OpraHH3aIJ HH HCnOJlb30BaBIDHX 3ty lIIHBaTbca B qy I He neJIa HMenH 6eCCTbIACTBO 06BHHHTb HeKO­ CTPaHY KaK y6e I Hme H3 KOToporo OHH ocymeCmJlaJIH CHCTeMam­ TOphIX 'IlleHOB HMllepaTopcKoro nOMa B KOCBeHHOM COyqaCTHH B qeCKHe YCHJlHB ll lIa nonphma IIaPCKOH BJlacm 3TOM npeCTynneHHH O HHM H3 HaH60Jlee Ba l HblX cpencm HCnOJlb30BaBlIIHXCa B aBrycTe 1906 r 6hIDO cOBepmeHo nOKymeHHe Ha l H3Hb BceMH 3THMH rpynJlaMH 6bIDH taHHbIe neqaTHbIe CTaHKH 06Hapy­ CTOOhOIHHa 'KHTb H 06e3BpenHTh TaKHe oqarH peBOJlIOIIHH 6blJlO O llOH H3 maB­ CaM MHHHCTp qynOM YIIeJIeJl HO 'IlleHhI ero ceMbH H MHorHe npyrHe HbIX JlO 3a o aq TOJlbKO OxpaHHoro C nOMOIIIhIO OTneJleHHB TaHHhIX H penmTb COrpY IIHKOB ee MQ l HO 6hl­ ECJlH MhI Ha­ XO o HJlH TaKOH CTaHOK Bca HaHneHHaa npOA 'KUIDl KOHIPHCKOBhI- 298 KOTopoe Morno 6hI CJlY I HTb npenOCTepe'KeHHeM OKalaJIHCb 'KepmOH 3Toro 3arOBopa llpeCTynneHHe 6hIDO COBep­ meHO Korna CTOJIhIDHH f HJl B oc06HBKe Ha AnTeKapcKOM OCTpoBe H nOBOJlbHO IaCTO YCTpaHBaJI npHeMbI qeTBepo 3arOBOpIIUlKOB 299 nOnDeXaJlH B KOnllCKe K u BepllM MHHHCTepcKOrO u OMa 0Jm Beml Ce6H KaK npHI'nameHHble rOCTH H BOllUIH B u OM 0 ll HH HS HHX 6bIn B BoeHHOH cpopMe H wneMe r u e 6bIn cnpllTaH sapll ll Il HHaMHTa Kor u a OH 6pocHII wneM nocne u OBan CTPaIIIHhlH Bspbm cpasy npe­ BpaTHBIUHii u OM B KytIy pasBanHH HecKOnbKO rOCTeH H MHOrHe cny­ rH 6bInH y6HTbl CblH H u 0'lb CTOnblDHHa 6blnH TIDKeno paHeHbI BeSYMHble y6HiinbI caMH 6blnH pasOpBaHbl na KYCKH 3TOT y KaCHbIH cnyqaH CHnbHO noBnH fln na nonHTHKy MHHHCT­ pa Dpexc u e OH CKopee CKnOHHnCH K nH6epanbHOH TO'lKe SpeHHH HO HatJHHaH C noro BpeMeHH SaH fln nosH1UIIO SHeprHtlHOro conpo­ THBneHHH pa u HKanbHblM TeH ll eHlUlJlM B cTpaHe lIy o OM cnacWHcb OT nOKymeHHH Ha ero KH3Hb OH TBep u o H pelllHTenbHO CTan npOTH­ BOCTOllTb BceM peBOJIlOI HOHHbIM cunaM OH oCTasancH Ha 3TOH no­ 3HI HH n01 a He norH6 npH u pyrOM Hana u eHHH CY ll b6a KOTOPOH KaK OH 'IyBCTBoBan OH He Mor H36e f aTb Hacmrna ero neTOM 1911 ro u a Uapb noceTun KueB H B ero CBHTe cpe u H u pyrHX BbI u aIOIUHXCH u ellTeneH 6bIn masa COBeTa MHHHCT­ pOB BnacTH npHHHnH Bce MepbI 'IT06bI y6epe'lb uapll OT Hana u eHHH Do npHKa3y CTonblIIHHa B03masnllTb ynpasneHHe nommeHcKoH Cny K60H 6bInO u OBepeHo reHepany KypnoBY HeCKOnbKO Il HeH CnyCTll nocne npH6blTHH Il Bopa B KueB 6bIBIllHH TaHHbIH areHT no cpaMHnHH BorpoB nOJIBuncH B MeCTHOM OT ll eneHHH OxpaHHoro oT u eneHHH H C006WHn 'ITO eMY H3BeCTeH B no u p06HOCTJIX nnaH nOKymeHHll Ha uaPH 3aMblwneHHbIH rpyn­ nOH HaMepeBaIOIUeHcll oCYIUeCTBHTb CBOH saroBop B KueBe Coo6­ IUeHHe BorpoBa lByqaJIO OlJeHb npas u ono u 06Ho H Bnacm npHHHnH u a Ke 6onbIllHe lJeM 06bl1JHO npe u oCTOp0 f HOCTH Ho HHlJerO oco­ 6eHHoro He npOHCXO IJ HJIO u o BpeMeHH DpOrpaMMa npal u HeCTB BKnIO'Iana CneKTaKnb B KueBCKOM TeaTpe IhmnIme rOBOpHTb 'ITO B MecTe r u e 6bInH HMnepaTOp H BbICWHe u OJDKHOCTHbIe nHQa ero COnpOBO K ll aBIIIHe npoBepKe roc­ TeH 6bInO y u eneHO oco60e BHHMaHHe feHepan KypnoB npHHHn Bce npe u OCTOpO f HOCTH 'IT06bI HHKTO KpoMe Tex OTHOCHTenbHO Koro He Momo 6bITb HH ManeHIllHX no u 03peHHii He HaxO IJ HJICH Pll ll OM Bcne u CTBHe 3Toro Bce n03BOJIHJIH ce6e 6blTb 6ecne'IHbIMH B 3TOT Be'Iep HHKTO He HMen HH ManeHwero npenlfYBCTBHH 'ITO BO BpeMH npe u CTasneHHH 6y u eT y6HT npeMbep-MHHHCTp 3TO COBepWHII TaHHblH areHT BorpoB Do u KaKHM-TO npe u no­ rOM OH nOHBHnCll B TeaTpe Kor u a nma m eca nepe u an KYn fl6KO KOTOpbIii 6hIn nepBhIM SaMecTHTeneM mashl CneUllanbHOH nOnH­ UeHCKOH Cny K6bl B Kuese Ka1 yro-TO COBepweHHO HecymeCTBeHHyro HHCPOPMaQHIO TaKHM 06pasOM KynH6Ko nOBHHeH B HeOCTOpO f ­ HOCTH nOBneKweii CaMbIe cepbelHble nocne u CTBIDI nocne Toro KaJ BOrpOB nepe u an KynH61 0 CBoe u OHeceHHe TOT C1 asan BorpoBY 'IT06bI OH ymen HO He npOBepBJI 6bInO mI BhmOmleHO no pacnopH­ f eHHe OCTaDHB BorpOBa 6es npHCMOTpa KYn fl61 0 SaH flnCH u pyru­ MH u enaMH H BorpOB Hamen BOSMO f HOCTb 'Iepel 1 aJ oe-TO BpeMH npOC1 OnbSayTb HeSaMe'IeHHblM B lpHTenbHbIH lan OH cpasy BbICTpe­ nun B CTOnblUHHa HeC1 Onb1 O pal H TOT yuan TIDKeno paaeHblM qepeS Il Ba ll H fl OH YMep OT 3THX paHeHHii B 6onbHHD e 3TOT cnyqaH u an BparaM reHepana KypnOBa XopoIUHii nOBO u ymepxc u aTb 'ITO OH 1 aJ masa cneIOfanbHOH nOJIHQeHCKOH Cny K6bl nHtlHo OTBeTCTBeHeH sa 3TO HeclJaCTbe Ero BemllJecTBo pacnop fl lJ HJI­ Cll 0 npOBe u eHHH paccne u OBaHHll 1 OTOPbIM u On f eH 6hIn PYKOBO­ Il HTb TpyceBHlI maDa POCCHHCKOH nOmlIOfH XOTll TpyceBH'I He· O'leHb XopoWO OTHOCHnCll K reHepany KypnOBY paccne u OBaHHe HH 1 'IeMY He npHBenO H B KOHQe-1 OHQOB 6bInO npeKpaIUeHO no pac­ nopIDKeHHIO u aPH KaKHe 06cTOJlTenbCTBa n06YAHJlH TaHHOrO areHTa BorpoBa y6HTb CTOnbUIHHa He Bnonae llCHO u o CHX nop BhITb MO f eT OH Il aBHO XOTen COBepWHTb 3TO npecTynneHHe u nH noro BTepcH B u 0­ BepHe K BnaCTllM u OCTaDnllll nO f Hl Ie CBe u eHHll 0 ll Ha1 0 60nee npas u ono u 06HbIM 1 8 f eTCll 'ITO waH1 a larOBopIUHKOB 1 KOTOPOH OH npHHa u ne f an Bhl6pana ero B CaMbIH nocne ll HHH MOMeHT Il nH y6HiicTBa npeMbep-MHHHCTpa H OH He nOCMen onacaHCh HX MIUeHHll OT1 asaTbCH BhlDOnHHTb HX npHKas 300 301