Documents CTAThH Charter 77 on 19-th Anniversary of Invasion• •• • • • 252 H EepeloB Anatoly Marchenko The Open Letter on Czechoslovakia •••• 257 Soviet Independent Socialist Clubs Declaration ••••• •• •• 264 Our Archive PEtbOPMHCfbI B UERmOTE Declaration of Independence of the USA and the Articles of Confederation • ••• •• • • 268 About the Authors • 293 Kor u a M C fop6atreB npHUJeJl K BnaCTH 3ana J HaJI netJarb nHcana 0 HeM B u enOM COqyBCTBeHHO OAHaKO 6onbUIHHcTBo cePbe3­ HbIX Hatlmo u areneii npeAYlIpe o 'ITO He HaAO I Jl arb CJlHllIKOM MHororo B pa3BepHyBweiicH ror u a lJ HCKYCCHH HBHO 6panH Bepx re KTO He HaAeHIICH Ha cepbe3HbIe nepeMeH I B CCCP TOIffiO TaK X e paccY H H MHorne BHyrpH CrpaHbI K KOHu Y 1986 r npeo6n aAllJIo Y lKe coBepweHHo HHoe Ha­ crpoeHHe Bce rOBOpHJlH 06 ycnexax fop6a'IJeBa 0 nepeMeHax Mel1lleHHO HO ynOPHo npoBO J llJ lJ HxCH B lKH3Hb 0 nOnHTHtreCKOM TOpX eCTBe pe p0pMH3Ma B 1985 r A 3HHoBbeB Bblpa lKaH MHeHHe MHornx 3MHfpaHTOB 3aHBHJI 'lITO HOBbIii feHepanbHbIii ceKperapb HHKor u a He oCBo60 lJ Hr H3 ropbKoBCKOH CCbIllKH CaxapoBa H HHKor­ u a He BbmeAer BoiicKa H3 A praHHcraHa eCJlH X e fop6a'IJeB nonbl­ raerCH CAenaTb 3TO OH norepHeT CBOii nOCT •• B HIOne 1986 r 6blJl0 om HBneHo 0 COKpanIeHHH 'llHCJleHHOCTH 3KCne lJ HlJ HOHHorO Kopny­ ca B A praHHCTaHe a B HHBape 1987 r nOAAep lKHBaeMOe CCCP Ka6ynbcKoe npaBHTenbCTBo Y lKe 06paTHnOCb K napTH3aHaM CnpH3bl­ BOM 0 Hau HOHanbHOM npHMHpeHHH nocKonbKY MOCKBa Tpe60Bana KaK MO lKHO 6 ICTpee H B CYLu HOCTH mo60ii u eHoii C03 u aTb YCJlOBHH I1lIH BbmoAa BoiicK CaxapoB HOBbIH 1987 r Bcrpe'IJaJI Y lKe AOMa B MocKBe H Mor KOMMeHTHpoBaTb npoHcxo J llJ lJ He C06bITHH B ICTY­ naH nepeA HHOCTPaHHbIMH lKYpHaJlHCTaMH B OCTaHKHHCKOM rene­ u eHTpe XOTH pa3YMeeTcH COBeTCKHe Tene3pHTenH He nonY'lJHJIH B03MO lKHOCTb yBHAeTb ero HHTepBbIO Me lK y TeM BnaCTb fop6a­ 'lJeBa OKa3anaCb npotfHa KaK HHKor u a B AeiicTBHrenbHOCTH 3ana HbIe ou eHKH 6bIJ1H O lJ HHaKOBO 7 HeBepHbI 8 B 1985 8 B 1986 8HOCTPaHHbIX Ha6rUOnaTeneii rr 3TO 3aKOHOMepHo 6onbWUHCTBO BKJIlOtmJl 8 MHorux 3M8rpaHTOB 8CXOAWlO 83 BeCbMa nOBepXHOCTHOrO nOHUMaHUJI HalIIero 06IIIeCT­ Ba IIeccuMU3M nepBblX MeCJlu eB rop6a'lfeBcKoii 3pbl 6bID TaK JKe HeOOOCHOBaH KaK 8 nocne oylOlU8ii OnTUMU3M lrrJl TOro 'lfT06bI o B3pbme Ha yr01lbHOii waxre B lloH6acce H nOJKape Ha Be DYIIIeH reIm031leKTpoCTaHu HH A3ep6aH lJ KaHa B pe3YllbTaTe qero BCJI C8C­ reMa 3HeprocHa6JKeHHJI 3aKaBKa3bJ1 He J elllO He Morna HOPManbHO PYUKu HOHUpoBaTb lIaHTHKe 1986 r 8 nOnmaTbCJI nOIDITb IIo K8TaHCKOMY KlJIeHAaplO 3TO 6 I11 ro J TUrpa U1IU ro J KaTaCTpo P 8 nepeMeH YBlIe'lfeHUe BOCTO'IfHOii aCTpollorueii pacnpo­ CTpaHUBmeeCJI nOBClO oy B EBpone C KOHD a 70-x rO J OB J 3 BHO YJKe CTlJIO TUIIU'lfHO 8 I TlJl HaWHX 1I1O J eii Ho HHKOrna elUe K a3HaTCK8M npHMeTaM He OTHOCU1lUCb TaK cepbe3HO H306paJKeHUJI TUrpa nOJl­ BH1I8Cb 6YKBlJIbHO Be3 J e B CTeHra3eTaX Cepbe3HhlX yqpeJK J eHUH nOMelUa1IHCb ropocKonbI YKa3 IBaBWHe Ha HeH3OOJKHOCTb n01lHTH­ 'lfeCK8X nepeMeH O p8u HlJIbHble H3naHUJI Ha nocne J HUx CTpaHH­ u aX HenpeMeHHO J aBlJI8 aCTp01l0r8qeCKHe nporH03bI C CC I1IKOH Ha 3aUa J Hble U1IU a3HaTCK8e 8CTO'I HUK8 MOJKHO CKa3aTb 'lITO BceMU npe J qyBCTB8J1 ru6e1lU aTOMHOH nO J BO J HOH 1I0 J KH B AT­ H He Coo6mHllH HHKaKHX nO J po6HOcTeH J opor MeHee Bcero Hccne J OBaHHbIH HaH60nee nOKa3aTelleH Ha npoTJIJKeHHH MHorux lIeT 3 J eCb HaKaImHBlJIHCb HepelIIeHHbIe npo6­ 8X BH 'TpeHHlOlO 1I0rm y OBlIa J e1l8 0 TaK Bee 3TU HenpHJITHOCTU He 6bIDH cnyqa8HbI IIpHMep JKelle3HbIX pa306paTbCJI B 3TOM napamlKce Heo6xOWlMO CHOBa npoaHal1H38po­ BaTb C06blTUJI npoTUBope'IfUBOro BlIacm HOBbIX B03MOJKHOCTeii 8 CTpax nepe J lIeMbI EpeJKHeBCKHHnpHHu Hn He TporaTb J peOO3JKalUHH MeXaHH3M B ll' IlHHOM cnytme 6bID npoBe J eH B JKH3Hb nocne J OBaTellbHO H 6YK­ BlJIbHO B H3BeCTHOM CMbICJIe 6peJKHeBCKHH nO J XO J ce6J1 onpu­ nan CUTYau HJI YXY J lIIlJIaCb HO Me I TleHHO H nOCTeneHHO Hanpo­ TUB Kor ll' ll HOBoe PYKOBO J CTBO CTlJIO TpeOOBaTl OT MHHHCTepCTBa pe3KO YllY'IfWHTI n01l0JKeHHe 3TO npHBe1l0 1I8lII1 K BbIJlBlleHUlO CKpbITbIX npo6n eM HeKOMneTeHTHhIe nocnelIIHbIe Mepbl no 03 J 0­ poBlIeHHlO JKelle3HO J opoJKHOro X03J1HCTBa ll' Il1IH 06paTHhIH 3 P peKT KOllH'lfeCTBO aBapHii BblPOCJIO B 1986 r Ha 30% XOTJI 'lfHCJIO Mae3­ J OB Ha nbJlHblX CnJllUHX Ha pellbCaX COKpaTH1l0Cb Ha pJl aHTUlJIKorOllbHOH n01l8TUKe rop6a'lfeBa 20% 6n aro J a­ CTaPIlJlCb 6bICTPO yrIyqWHTI nOKa3aTellH paooThI J opor MHHHcrepcTBo npHOOrno K MaCCOBbIM H 6e3JKanOCTHbIM YBOllbHeHWIM 3aCTaBHB OCTaBlIIUXCJI HeKOHTpo1I8pyeMblMU OnaCHOCTJlMU XY J O 118 XOPOlIIO 118 HO rO J OnpaBnan CBoe Ha3BaHHe H Ka­ TaCTPO P 8 nepeMeH 6bIDO nOBClO oy C 836bITKOM y68HCTBO IIIBe­ J CKOro npeMl ep-MUHUCTpa IIlJIbMe ruOO1lb aMepUKaHCK8X aCTpo­ HaBTOB Ha OOPTY KOCMU'lfeCKoro 'lfenHOKa CBepJKeHUe J HKTaTYPbI MapKoca Ha CJ Hn8nIIUHaX 8 T J 8 T n TeM He MeHee COBeTCKHH C0103 KaK Bcerna n06H11 Bce peKOP J l I O J HOH 1I8lII1 KaTaCTpo Pbl B qepH06bIDe XBaTH1IO 6bI 'I T06bI 3TOT ro J HaBCerna OCTanCJI B 8C­ 6Y J eM 3 J eCb aHal1H38pOBaTb npH'lHHbI H nOCJIe J CTB8J1 'lfepH06 I11bCKOii Tpare J HU B naHHOM cnytme cymeCTBeHHO J pyroe C06bITUJI npo830lIIe J lIIHe BeCHoii 1986 r Ha YKpaHHe 6bI1lU TOlIbKO qaCTblO B u enoH cepHH KaTacTpo P CJIe J OBaBWHX O J Ha 3a J pyroH B netmTl nonlJIO co06meHUe 0 ruOO1l8 B qepHoM MOpe napoXona A J MHpa1I HaXUMOB BMecre C KOTOpbIM nOlII1lH Ha J HO 'lfenOBeK 400 naccaJKHpoB H 'lJIeHOB 3K8naJKa O J HaKO MHHHCTepCTBO nYTeii co06meHUJI He npemlCTaBHllO 06IIIeCTBY CBe J eHUH 0 MHOrO'IfHcneH­ HbIX KpyweHHJlX nOe3mlB npHBe J lllHX K YJKaCHbIM qenOBeqeCKHM JKepTBaM C on03 ll' 1lHHeM u eHTpa1IbHbIe ra3eTbi H3BeCTH1IH HacelleHHe 8 TaHHH C HepB03HoCTblOH pacTepJlHHOCTblO ynpulleH'lfeCKOrO nepco­ Hana npHBeno K MHOJKeCTBY aBapHii 8 KaTaCTpo P' C06bITUJI Ha JKelle3HbiX J Oporax ll' IllOT HaM 06mylO MO J enb npOHCXO J HBlIIero HenpHJlTHOCTU 6bI11H Bbl3BaHbI BbIXO J OM Ha no­ BepXHOCTb 3aCTapenbIX npo6JIeM H Henpo oyMaHHbIMH nonblTKaMU HX pelIIeHHJI MOJKHO lIH C'lfHTaTb 3TO 3aKOHOMepHOH ueHOH nepe­ TOpHH 'lfenOBe'lfeCTBa He paooTHUKoB pe3KO yBe1IH'lfHTI HHTeHCUBHOCTb TPY ll' ll 3TO B co'lfe­ CTpoHKH OTBeT Ha naHHbIH Bonpoc He TaK yJK npoCT rHOO1lb 1I1O J eH J eHCTBHTenbHO qaCTO OKa3blBaeTCJI u eHOH o6meCTBeHHOrO nporpecca HO TOllbKO He Ha J O J ellaTl OTClO ll' Il B IBO J a 6Y J TO Kor­ ll' Il 1I1O J H rH6HyT nO J KonecaMH 31IeKTpoB03a a He nO J KOnbITaMU 1I0lIIa J H - nporpecc Hal1HU O npHHJlTble MepbI HMeHHO nOTOMY 8 BenH K pa3Horo po J a HenpHJlTHOCTJlM H JKepTBaM qTO He 0OOcne­ 'lfUBlJI8 nO I TlHHHOH nepeCTpoHK8 H 3TO TOJKe He CJIyUHO • OT1IU'lfHe nepeMeH B CCCP OT pe pOpM B BeHrpHH np8 Ka J a­ pe H1IH OT npaJKCKOH BeCHbl COCTOHT He B CTeneHU pa J HKlJIH3Ma B 3TOM OTHOlIIeHUH npou ecc rOp6a'lfeBCKOH nepeCTpoHK8 BbIrO J HO 9 OTnHqaeTC II OT Mep npOBO UfBlIlHXC II Ka l apoM B 1962-1968 rr Pa3­ HHna B TOM 'tITO H B BeHrpHH H B qeXOCJIOBaKHH HMenC II 60nee HnH MaHHpoBaHH fI AonycKalOIUero lIlHpOKoe yqacme HH30B HMeHHo TaK paCCy JK 1 aIOT H HaH60nee neBbIe COBeTCKHe aBTOpbI HanpHMep MeHee pa3BHTbIH peCPOPMHCTCKHH npoeKT BOKPyr Koroporo KOHCO­ AKa l - nHp HPOBaJIC fI lIlHPOKHH COUHaJIbHbrii 6JIOK qeXOCJIOB HH npoeKT KH nepecTpoHKH Bce CXO l llrc fI Ha He06xop HMOCm HcnOnb30BaHH fI 6bID pblHKa TO oHH paCXO l llTC fI B Bonpoce 0 TOM l 1I fI qero ero Hcnon ­ CcpOpMynHpoBaH n03 W1ee BeurepcKOrO H OKa3aJIC II pap HKaJIb­ Hee 'tITO H npe J onpe J enHnO ero rH6enb - ycnex paAHKaJIbHblX T H 3aCJIaBCKa R B II KypaIIlBHnH H J p BenH CTOPOHHH­ 3QBaTb BYHHq BHp HT B pblHKe uenb 3aCJIaBCKa R cpe J CTBO Ha­ pecpopM Bbl3BaJI nO fIBneHHe COseTCKHX TaHKOB Ha ynHuax IIparH KOHeu uena R rpynna TexnoKpaTHqeCKHX 3KcnepToB Ha J eeTC fI HC­ TeM He MeHee H 'tIeXOCJIOB3UKHH H BeHrepCKHH BapHaHTbl peCPOPMbl nonb30BaTb PbIHOK KaK nononHHTenbHbIH KOMneHcaUHoHHbIH Me­ npH BceM HX pa3JIH'tIHH 6bmH OCHOBaHbI Ha 11eTKOH COUHaJIbHO-nO­ xaHH3M cymecTBYIOIUHH C HeMHoro ynop fl J O'tleHHbIM 6lOpOKpam­ nHmqeCKOH KOHuenUHH • IJ aneKo He Bee WJ10 rna J Ko IIpHXo J HJ1oCb qeCKHM nnaHHpoBaHHeM AraH6euH caM He npHHa l 1Ie JKaIIIHH K npeo J oneBaTh conpOmBJIeHHe KOHeepBaTopoB HO BallCHO 'tITO caMH TexnOKpaTaM OXOTHO C HHMH COTPyAHH'l3eT pecpopMHcrbI HMenH fICHyIO nporpaMMy KOTOPa R H npoBO J HJ1aCb B H3Hb KaK BHAHM eAHHOH KOHUeDUHH HeT y caMHX CTOpoHHHKOB nepeCTpoHKH paJyMeeTC fI pa3JIH'lHe MHeHHH cpep H yqeHbIx liH'tIero nO J 06Horo He 6bIDO B IIonbIIIe B 1980-1981 rr B l aH­ fIB­ neHHe HOpManbHoe O WIaKO 3a l a'la nonHmKOB B TOM H COCTOHT HOM CJIyqae HH napmHHa R BepXYllIKa HH COnH l apHOCTh H J pyme 'tIT06bI CHHTe3HpoBaTb pa3Ho06pa3HbIe Tpe60BaHH fI H npe l 1IO JKeHH fI onn03HUHOHHbie rpynnbl He HMenH cBoero peCPOPMHCTCKoro npoeK­ B ep HHbIH npoeKT nonb3YlOIUHHC fI nOMep JKKOH lIlHpoKoro COUHaJIb­ Ta IIpoBop HBlIlHec fI Mepbl OKa3bmanHCb He pe3ynbTaToM 6opb6bI Horo 6JI0Ka Ha npaKTHKe HHqerO nO J 06Horo He npoHCXOAHT Ka JK­ Ja J a fl rpynna 3KcnepTOB HMeeT CBOHX CTOPOHHHKOB cpeAH napmHHO­ peaJIH3aUHIO onpe J eneHHoro 3apauee pa3pa60TaHHoro nnaHa a nHlIIb OTpa JKeHHeM CJIO HBlIIeroC II B J aHHbrii MOMeHT cmxHHHO­ roCYAapCTBeHHOH BepXYlIIKH TO COOTHOlIIeHH fI CHn H HHTepeCOB CaM no ee6e npouecc 6bID HeKOH­ npoBOp HThC II 3KcnepHMeHTbI H MeponpH fIm fl OTpa JKaIOIUHe B033pe­ TpOllHpyeM B CTpaue He 6bIDO CHnbI cnoco6HOH K nonHmqeCKOH HHH pa3HblX rpynn H npomBOpe'IaIUHe J pyr APYry IIonblTKa peop­ B HTOre Ha'IHHaIOT O l HOBpeMeHHO rereMOHHH Bce 3TO npe J onpe J enHnO B KOHe'tIHOM C'tIeTe Hey l a'tly raHH3aUHH JKeJ1e3HbIX J opor B iJ Yxe H J eH BYHH'tIa H cI pH l MaHa npH peBonlOUHH· O WIOBpeMeHHOM IIepeMeHbI npoHCXO J fllUHe B HallIeR CTpaue Ha nepBbrii coxpaueHHH 61OpoKpam'tleCKOH CTPYKryPbI Ha ypoBHe MHHHCTepcTBa y JKe l aJla KaTaCTpo«PH'tIeCKHe pe3ynbTaTbI B30I II J 6JIH JKe K BeHrepcKOH HUH 11eXOCnOBa ttKOH MO J enH HHHuHa­ 3aKOHbl 0 HeTpYAOBblX AOXO J ax H 06 HHp HBHiJ YaJIbHOH TPY J OBOR mBa nepecrpoiiKH HCXOAHT CBepxy a He CHH3y KaK B IIonblIIe Ae flTenbHOcm BMeCTO Toro 'tIT06bl J ononHHTb J pyr J pyra npoTHBo­ fpynna HOBOCH6HPCKHX 3KOHOMHCTOB BO OIaBe C A AraH6erHHoM pe'laT Apyr J pyry MeCTHbIM BnaCT fIM npe J OCTaBneHO npaso HHTep­ c J enaBlIlHMC II nH'tIHbIM COBeTHHKOM fop6aqeBa He CKpbIBaeT CBoe­ npempoBaTb HeHCHbIe Mecra 3aKOHa 'tIT0 Be J eT K ro BeHrepCKHM OnbItOM H u eonorH fl pbIHO'tIHOrO pa3HblM nO J XOAaM B pa3Hbix 06nacT fIx H pecny6JIHKax lla JKe ca­ COUHanH3Ma npoB030IamaeTCH Ha CTpaHHUaX raleT H C 3KPaHOB re­ Mble onmMHCm'tIHbIe 3KcnepTbl npH3Ha1OT 'tiro 3a npe J enaMH Mo- BocxmueHWl neBHAeHH II Be OIaBHbIH nonyn flpH3aTOp II BYHH'tI BOCXBaJI fIeT coBeplIIeHHo CKBbl JIeHHHrpa l a H HeKoropbIx COlO3HblX pecny6JIHK JaKOH 06 HH­ BceCHUHe pbIHKa He MeHee BOCTOp JKeHHO 'tIeM no AeJ1aeT B 'hIKaro AHBH J y3J1bHOH TPYAOBOH J e flrenbHocm OCTaHeTCH Ha 6YMare Ec­ MBnTOH cI PH J MaH IIpaB l a 3 J eCb MbI y JKe JaMeqaeM pa3nH't He Me JK­ nH JKe KaKoe-TO cornaCOBaHHe KOHKypHpylOIUHx H J eH npoH3BOp HT­ iJ Y CCCP H BOCTO'tIHOH EBponoii 'tIeXOCJIOBa ttKHM H BeHrepCKHM C fI TO nyTeM 3KJ1eKm'tleCKorO coep HHeHH fI OAHHX npe l 1Io JKeHHii 3KOHOMHCTaM HAeanH3auM pbIHKa He 6bIDa CBOHCTBeHHa Teopem­ CApyrnMH KH npa JKCKOH BeCHbl XOTeJ1H Hcnonb30BaTh pbIHOK KaK HCTO'tIHHK KOHUeDUH fI J eMoKpam3aUHH x03HHcmeHHoH H COUHaJIbHOH HHcpopMaUHH 06 31PcpeKTHBHOCm npHHHMaeMblx pelIIeHHii a maB­ JKH3HH B3 f1Ta fl Ha BoopY JKeHHe rpynnoH 3aCJIaBCKOH H KYPaIIlBHnH HOH 3a60ToH cBoeii C'lHTaJIH C03 l aHHe J eMOKpamqeCKOrO MeXaHH3Ma Morna 6bl nOCJIy JKHTb OCHOBOH A1I fI KOHconH l aUHH pe«PopMHCrOB 10 11 He H8 IJ 0 AYMaTb 6YATO B pa60Tax 3THX aBTOPOB eCTb OTBeTbl Ha QemepTOH pecny6JIHKH BOPb6a pe«pOPMHCTOB H KOHeepBaTopOB Bee BonpoCbI Ho OHH npeAJIararoT nocneAoBareJIbHYIO nporpaMMY BeAeT He K TOp IKecmy MYApoH pe«pOpMbI KaK Y IbH CJiOnHHa B cnoco6HylO npHBJIe'lb Ha CBOIO CTOPOHY KaK KaTae a K nOJIHTHqeCKOMY xaocy BOJIHeHHH B Ka3axcraHe B03­ 3Ha'IIHTeJlbaylO qaCTb 1986 MeHeWKepoB TaK H WHpoKHe cnOH TpY wn QHXCH TeM He MeHee HHKWHe B AeKa6pe rOp6aqeBCKOe PYKOBOACTBO He peWHJ10Cb npHHHTb nOA06aylO KOH­ HcnblrbmaBWHe K OTCTpaHeHHOMY OT PYKoBOACTBa B pecny6J1HKe ueIIUHIO OTCYTCTBOBaJIH eAHHCTBO H nOJ1HTHqeCKaH BOJIH KyaaeBY 6onbWOH CHMnaTHH 6blJIH B03MYWeHbI KorAa Ha ero KOHcepBaTopbl nOTepneJIH B 1968 r pHA nopaxreHHH XXVII MeCTO nOCTaBHJ1H r OQeHb nOKa3aTeJlbHbl 1la IKe Ka3axH He PYCCKOro Me KA reM HHKro He C06HP3J1CH Che3A ocna6HJ1 HX n03HUHH B BblCWHX 3WeJlOHaX napTHH IIpaBM OCKOp6JIJITb KOpeHHoe HaeeJIeHHe HJ1H npoBouapoBaTb OOcnOPHAKH CTOPOHHHKH 6pe I HeBH3Ma OqeHb 6blCTPO 06'beAHHHJ1HCb C qaCTblO IIepeA HaMH 06blKHOBeHHbIH npHMep nOJ1HTHlleCKOH HeKOMnereHT­ reXHoKpaToB paaee nO ll Il ep KHBaBWHX nepeMeHbl C TOqKH 3peHHH HOCTH BOPb6a BOKPyr JlHBapCKoro nneHYMa nocneAHHX nepeCTpoHKa 6JIaronoJIyqHo 3aBepWHJIaCb cMeHoH no­ 1987 r OT KOTOPOH KOJIeHHH HaBepxy H ynopHAOqeHHeM UeHTpaJIH30BaHHOH CHCTeMbI O KHAaJIH Ba lKHbIX C lJ BHrOB B nOJIHrHqeCKOH CHryaUHH He AaJIa HH ynpaBJIeHHH OAHOH H3 rpynnHpOBOK pe3J1bHOH no6e Abl fop6aqeB BblCTynHJ1 UanbHeHWHe 3KCnepHMeHTbl no AeueHTpaJIH3auHH H AeMoKpaTH3aUHH CHCTeMbl BOCnpHHHMaIOTCH HMH KaK H3Aep IK­ KH nepeMeH BblCIDaH TeXHoKpaTHH npeAaJIa XpYUleBa B 1964 r C pellblO nOJ1HoH npeKpacHblX 0OOlUaHHH HO B nocraHOBJIeHHH UK KIlCC orCYTCTBOBaJIH HaH60nee Ba lKHble nOJIoxreHHJI ero AOKJIaAa Tenepb A06HBWHCb YAOBJIeTBOpeHHH CBOHX Tpe60BaHHH OHa ox­ K JIaAeJIa H K fop6aqeBY 3TOT HeoKOHeepBaTHBHbIH 6JIOK CT3J1 maB­ OCTaHerCJI 6eccMblCJ1eHHbIM ecnH He 6YAeT npoBeAeHa WHpoKaH TOMY IKe pa3rOBop 0 BbI60pax PYKOBoAHTeJIeH npeADpHJITHH HOH yrpo30H l JlH pe«P0PMHCTOB IIocT npeAeeAaTeJIH COBeTa MH­ H KOMDJIeKCHaH pe«popMa Yxre B AHH nneayMa X03JIHCTBeHHble PY­ HHCTpoB nepeweAWHH OT craporo peTporpaAa H ThxOHoBa K MO­ KOBOAHTeJIH OTKpbITO 3aHBJIR J1H lITO HHKaKHX Bbl60poB He Aonyc­ JIOAoMY TeXHoKpaTY H PbI lKKOBY OCTaJICH 0pY lKHeM B PYKax TJIT EcnH He C03AalOTCJI pa60TalOlUHe HHCTHryTbI npOH3BOACTBeH­ aHTHpe«P0PMHCTCKHX CHJ1 MaHeBpHpoBaHHeM Ii Bee xre fop6aqeBY YAaJIOCb YMeJIblM YKpenHTb CBOH n03HUHH BOJIbWOH MaCTep 61OpoKpaTHQeCKHX KOM6HHauHH OH cYMeJI 0OOcne'IIHTb eeOO Hey­ HOH AeMOKpaTHH BbI60pbI JIH60 npeBpawaroTCJI B nYCTyro «Pop­ M3J1bHOCTb JIH60 Ae30praHH3YIOT npOH3BOAcrBO Pa60'IIHe KaK npaBHJ10 OTHeCJ1HCb K 06elUaHHHM JIHAepa AOBOJIbHO CKenTHqeCKH CTOHlIHBoe HO AOCTaTO'IIHOe AJIH npHHHTHH KOHKpeTHblX peweHHH OTcyrCTBHe aanaxreHHoH CHCTeMbI AeMOKpaTHqeCKOH HH«pOpMauHH 6oJIbWHHCTBO B PYKOBO wn QHX napTHHHblX opraaax CTOPOHHHKH Ha npeADpHJITHHX B JII060M cnyqae He AaeT HM B03MO KHOCTH nepeMeH nOCTOHHHO OKa3bm3J1HCb CHJ1bHee OAHaKO AJIH TOp IKeCTBa «PeKTHBHO B03AeHCTBOBaTb Ha npHHHTHe peweHHii He3aBHCHMO OT 34 ­ TOro 6YAYr HJ1H He 6yAYT npOBOAHTbCJI Bbl60pbl B nOCTaHOBJIe· pe«pOpMbl 3TOro HBHO HeAoCTaTOIIHO KOHeepBaTopbl 3HalOT Qero OHH XOTJIT IIpo AeJITeJleH nepe­ HHH He rOBOpHJ10Cb H 06 000lUaHHH fop6alleBa Bbl lJ BHraTb HeCKOJ1 ­ CTpoHKH noro He cKaxrewb OHH nOJIYIIHJ1H peaJIbHYlO XOTJI H He KO KaHAHAaTOB nOJIaylO BJIaCTb HO Y HHX Her HH CTparenm HH eAHHOA WHJI HbIH COBeT 3ra pe«PoPMa B cnyqae ycnexa Morna 6bI 03HallaTb MHeHHe 6YATO B HaWeH CTpaHe HMeeT MeCTO nOCTeneHHaH HeKoropoe Ha Ka lKAOe Mecro B COBerax BKJIIOIIaH H BePXOB­ ocna6JIeHHe CHCreMbI nOJIHTHqeCKOrO KOHTpOJIJI HO Pe«POPMa BCTpeQalOlUaH COnpOTHBJIeHHe HO Bee IKe nocneAoBa­ HHKOHM 06pa30M HH ee JIHKBHAaUHIO fOBopHrb 0 AeMOKpaTHH reJIbHO npoBOAHMaH B lKH3Hb - Bcepbe3 npH TaKOH nOCTaHOBKe Bonpoca He npHXOAHTCJI 1laxre cTpaTenm HH qHCTeHIDaJI HJIJ1103HH He HMeJI HH COuaaJIbHO-3KOHOMHlleCKoro npoeKTa npaBJIlUaH OTHOCHTeJIbHO CBo60AHbIH Bbl60p Me KA KaHAHAaTaMH He 3aMeHHer Ii rpynna BbIHY lKAeHa lKHTb rOJIbKO CerOAHJIWHHM AHeM npHOOraH AeifcTBeHHblX AeMOKpaTHqeCKHX HHCTHTyrOB qT06bl HOH H B nOJIHTHQeCKOH lKH3HH B03HHKaeT OAHa H Ta xre npo6JIeMa YAep IKaTbCJI Y BJIaCTH K BeeB03MO lKHbIM nOJIHTHqeCKHM B npoH3BOACTBeH­ KOM6HHauHJIM H COMHHTeJIbHblM KOMnpoMHccaM KaK npaBHTeJIb­ fop6aqeB npH3b1BaeT K npoBeAeHHIO AeMOKpaTHqeCKHX MeponpHH­ CTBa THH 003 C03AaHHJI AeMOKpaTHqeCKHX CTPYKTYp 12 MeHbWHHcma B xYAWHe rOAbI «PPaHUY3CKOH TpeTbeH HJ1H 13 B u eJIOM fop6a'leB BeJI ce6J1 KaK JIH J ep Onn03Hu HH npoH3HO­ nnaTY 3a TeJIeq OH B TO I e B peMJI OCHOB HaJl CTPYKrypa H MeTO J hI CHJI Pa J HKaJIhHhIe JI03yurH H 3aHHMaJICJI KPHTHKOH OH rOBopHJI J eHCTBHJI nponaraH u HCTCKOro npeKpaCHhIe CJIOBa 0 CBo60 J e npH'IeM HeT OCHOBaHHH COMHeBaThCJI B O J HOH H TOH l e ra3eTe nepe J OBHIJ a H OCHOBHaJI Macca cTaTeH annapara OCTaJIHCh HeH3MeHHhIMH B ero HCKpeHHOCTH fOpa3 J 0 60JIhwe COMHeHHH BhI3hIBaeT ero KOM­ cOBepweHHo npoTHBope'laT J pyr J pyry HOBaJI npaB J a cocYIIlecT­ UK ByeT co CTaPOH JIO l bIO Bce 3TO o60CTpJleT COu HaJIhHYIO HanpJl l eH­ neTeHTHOCTh YTBep K J aJI B 3aKJIIO'lHTeJIhHOM CJIOBe 'ITO B cYIIleCTByeT nOJIHOe e u HHCTBO OH O J HoBpeMeHHo npH3BaJI KOH'laTh u HCKYCCHIO 0 TOM Hy I Ha JIH Bo06me nepeCTpoHKa EcJIH B HOCTh H J ecTa6HJIH3HpyeT cHTyau HIO UK nOJI­ Hoe e u HHCTBO TO KTO C KeM u HCKYTHpoBaJI B OTKPhITOH ne'laTH lIOTeHu HaJI MaCCOBoro He J oBOJIhCTBa HaKonHBWerOCJI eme npH Ope I HeBe O'lem BeJIHK HO y peq OPMHCTOB He XBaTaeT CMe­ no KpaHHeH Mepe TaKaJI u HCKYCCHJI J a l e He Ha'IHHaJIaCh lIpocTO JIOCTH ero HCnOJIh30BaTh OHH He nOHHMaIOT 'ITO 603MOJICHOCTU npoB03rnaCHJIH nporpecc H MhI Bce no6e I aJIH 3a HHM CJIe J OM ynYU4eHHble ceZOOHR MOZyT 06epHYTbCJI YZp03QMU 3a61p l HeKoTophIe J a l e Bnepe u H OTKphlTaJl H cephe3HaJI A Me K J Y TeM cTpaue O'leHh Hy l Ha nOJIHTH'IeCKaJI u HCKyCCHJI Ii BpeMeHH J J1J1 Hee OCTaeTCJI Bce MeHhwe CJIe J yeT yqeCTh 'ITO B OTJIH'lHe OT lIOJIhWH aBTopHTeT napmu B Maccax eme J OBOJIhHO BeJIHK HO HMeHHO n03TOMY K HeH npe J hJlB­ JIJlIOTCJI 3aBhIweHHhIe Tpe60BaHHJI 3a'laCTyro HeCOBMeCTHMhIe C ee HecMoTpJl Ha TO 'ITO OCHOBHaJl 60ph6a Be J eTCJI B npaBJlmHX peaJIhHOH 06meCTBeHHOH POJIhIO MnnI03HH Macc OTHOCHTeJIhHO Kpyrax a HHHu HaTHBa nepeMeH HCXO u HT cBepxy npou ecc COu HaJIh­ BJIaCTeH MoryT BeCTH K J eHCTBHJlM B KOHe'IHOM C'IeTe He6e30nac­ HhIX npe06pa30BaHHH KaK H B lIoJIhwe JlBJIJleTCJI HeKoHTpoJIH­ HhIM J J1J1 caMHX BJIaCTeH - pyeMhIM B pe3YJIhTaTe no Mepe J BH I eHHJI Bnepe J npoilrIeMhI He BeTCKOH HCTOpHH KaK y l e 6hIJIO He pa3 B PYCCKOH H co­ HeoKoHcepBaTophI co CBoeH CTOPO hI He c06HpaIOTCJI nac­ pa3pewaIOTCJI a 060CTPJlIOTCJI lIpoxo J JImaJI B cTpaue J eMOKpaTH3au HJI COBepweHHO peaJIh­ Ha lIpecca CTaJIa ropa3 J 0 CBo60 J Hee nOJIHOMO'IHJI u eH3yphI orpaHH­ CHBHO O I H J aTh nOCJIe J CTBHH J eMOKpaTH3au HH J OJIro Ouu yaepeHhI 'ITO TaK npo J OJI l aThCJI He MO l eT lIpH nepBOM l e KpynHOM '1eHhI B03HHKaIOT HOBhIe q OPMhI COu HaJIhHOH aKTHBHOCTH HeMhI­ 3KOHOMH'IeCKOM npoBaJIe peq opMH3Ma OHH nonhITaIOTCJI BepHyTh CJIHMhIe paHee MO I HO CKa3aTh ce6e HHHu HaTHBY H HOpManH30BaTh 06CTaHOBKY lIpa3 J HoBaHHe 'ITO J eMoKpaTH3au HJI y l e KOCHy­ JIaCh WHpoKHX Macc XOTJI H He nOBCIO J y 3TO nO I aJIYH rJIaBHOe 70-JIeTHJI OKTJl6pJl OHH nhITaIOTCJI HcnOJIh30BaTh KaK nOBO J J J1J1 3aBoeBaHHe fop6a'leBa lIapa J oKc B TOM 'ITO nepBOHa'IaJIhHO J e­ KOHCOJIH J au HH CBOHX CHJI H Ha'laJIa KOHTpHacTynneHHJI MOKpaTH3au HJI nnaHHpoBaJIaCh KaK J ecepT K OCHOBHOMY ilrIIO J Y - nOJIHTH'IeCKHH HeCOCTOJlTeJIhHOCTh peq OpMhI CBepxy 3aCTaBJIJleT J yMaTh 0 X03HHCTBeHHOH peq opMe fop6a­ CBoero po J a JIeBOH aJIhTepHaTHBe onupaIOmeHCJI Ha HH3hI H cpe J HHe CJIOH Ha '1eB Ha J eJIJIcJI 3aHJIThCJI nO J 06HhIMH npoilrIeMaMH nOCJIe Toro KaK J eJIe O J HaKO HhIHeWHJIJl CHryau HJI KpaHHe OCJIO l HJleT q OPMHPO­ Y J aCTCJI no ero BhIpa l eHHIO paCKa'laTh MaXOBHK CTPYKrypHOH BaHHe nepeCTpoHKH Ha npaKTHKe I e BhIWJIO Hao60poT npoBeCTH Kynh­ XX rypHyIO JIH6epaJIH3au HIO H paCWHpHTh npaBa rpa f l1 au OKa3aJIOCh q OPMHCTCKHM BepxaM TaKOH aJIhTepHaTHBhI MO I HO BcnOMHHTh KaK B Ha'IaJIe BeKa 3ana J HhIe COu HaJIHCThI CnOpHJIH 06 OTHOWeHHH K nOMep I HBaTh HX - pe­ 3Ha'IHT COMKHyTh­ ropa3 J 0 JIer'le He l eJIH H3MeHHTh cHcTeMY ynpaBJIeHHJI npOH3Bo J ­ CJI C O J HOH H3 q paKu HH npaBJIIlI ero KJIacca a BhICTynaTh npOTHB CTBOM B HTore HOBaJI CB060 J a BCTynHJIa B npoTHBope'IHe CO CTaPhI­ HJIH OTCTpaHJIThCJI OT 6oph6hI - MH 3KOHOMH'IeCKHMH OTHOWeHHJlMH AuaJIOrH'lHhIe CTPYKrypHhIe peaKu HH OOJIhWHHCTBO JIeBhIX B CCCP CeH'IaC Be J yT ce6J1 KaK npOTHBOpe'IHJI B03HHKJIH BnpO'leM H B caMoH KYJIhTypHO-H J eOJIo­ npe J CTaBHTeJIH Pa u HKaJIhHOro KphIJIa rop6a'leBCKOH nepecTpoHKH rH'IeCKOH c Pepe l YPHaJIHCThI nOJIY'IHJIH B03MO l HOCTh rOBopHTh o J eHcTBHTeJIhHhIX np06JIeMaX H KPHTHKOBaTh HeKoTophIe J eHcT­ 3TO 14 H pa3YMHO HO B CJIO I HBWeHCJI 06CTaHOBKe Toro Y l e He J OCTaTO'IHO 3KOHOMH'leCKaJI BHJI Oq Hu HaJIhHhIX KpyroB HanpHMep JlHTepaTypHaJl ra3eTa Ha­ '1aJIa 6oph6y npoTHB MHHHcTepcrna CBJl3H cTpeMJIIlI erOCJI nOBhICHTh 3aKOHOMepHo 3Ha'IHT JIHTh BO J y Ha MeJIhHHU y u HH Oq Hu HaJIhHOH CHryau HJI CTaTHCTHKH HeCMOTpJl Ha no6e J HhIe CKJIa J hIBaeTCJI penJl­ HeilrIaronpHJITHo IS r npoTHBOpellHBble H HenOClle ll OBaTenbHble Mepbl npeAOpHHHMae­ Mble W1J1 nepeCTpoHKH ynpaBneHHJI Ae30pHeHTHpYIOT AKpeKTOpoB npeAOpHJlTHH rnaBHaJI npo6TJeMa COBeTCKOK lKOHOMHKH - 3cJeHeK MnuHapr npo6­ neMa Ae pHUHTa peCYPCOB nOpo J tUleMOrO paCTOllHTenbHOCTbJO CHC­ reMbl - OCTaeTCJI Hepa3peWeHHOK COlUfaJIbHble nporpaMMhI rop6a­ qeBa nOBblWeHHe 3apnnaTbl HeKOTOpblM KaTerOpHJlM TpYAJ W HXCJI yaenHqeHHe CpoKa nOCllepoAOBOrO OmYCKa W1J1 l eHw HH H T n rOPBAlfEB B OB JlTHJIX BPEJ 8EBA 6e3YCllOBHO He06xoAHMbI HO Ha nepBblX nopax OHH nHJl Il 060­ CTPJIT Ae pHUHT pecypCOB B nOA06HblX YCllOBHJlX HeT OCHOBaHHK HlAeJITbCJI Ha W1HTenb­ HbIK 3KOHOMHqeCKHH nOgbeM He34 peKTHBHocTb npHHJITbIX Mep Aon l Ha BbIJIBHTbCJI BeCbMa 6blcrpo H 3TO HeCOMHeHHO 6YAeT HCo nOnb30BaTbCJI KOHeepBaTopaMH KaK nOBoA W1J1 KOHTpHacrynne­ HHJI TaKHM 06pa30M EAHHCmeHHblM pe POPMH3M OKa3bIBaeTCH B IIeKrHOTe BblXOAOM OCTaeTCJI paJ HKanH3alUfJl nOnHTHKH nepeCTpoHKH HO HMeHHO 3AeCb OC06eHHO CKalbIBaeTCJI OTcyrCTBHe paAKKanbHoro MbwmeHHJI HOBoro 06w ecmeHHoro npoeKTa UemoT pe popMH3Ma H oTCYTcmHe o popMneHHOH neBoH anbTepHaTHBbl Y MHOrHX Bbl3bIBaJOT neCCHMH3M Pa3YMeeTCH B03BpaT K 6pe l HeBH3MY HeB03MOX eH CTapaJl nOnHTHKa HCqepnana nO'ITH H Beex COO6w eHHJIX 3anaAHbIX KoppecnOHAeHTOB fyeaK He 06HHManHCb H He n06b13aJIHCb Ho 3TO He coomeTCTBO­ BaJIO KcmHTenbHOCTH H co6crBeHHblMH rlla3aMH BH n Ha 3Kpa­ He reneBH30pa 'ITO lTOT pHTYaJI 6b1lI co6TJJO eH KaK 06bNHO B03­ MO l HO O tHaKO 'ITO npHCYTCTBOBaBlIIHe npH BCTpe'le HanHCTbI 3TOro He BHAenH nOCKonbKY 06HHMaBlIIHeCJI H u enOBaBllIHeCJI nH­ pbl 6b1lIH 3aCllOHeHbi TenaMa OXpaHHHKOB KOTOpblX Ha nOT pal 6b1l1o 60nbwe 'IeM 06bl'IH0 ee6 R nCHxonorHQeCKOe paBHOBeCHe 70-x rOAOB HapyweHO KOM­ npoMHCC Me AY BeeMH PpaKlUfJlMH BepXOB CMeHHnCJI npoTHBQ­ BO H3 nparH BO BpeMJI BH3HTa rOp6aQeBa OTMe'laJlOCb 'ITO rop6a'leB To'IHO TaK X e Bee CKa3aHHOe B npare 3aTeMHHnO H TOT PaKT 'ITO BO BpeMJI BH3HTa B t eXOCllOBaKHJO rop6a'leB 6blll 60nee 'IeM 6opcmoM pa3BHBaJOIIIHMCH nO CBoeii nOrHKe B CTpaHe npoCTO Kor -nH60 06peMeHeH 6pe I HeBCKHM HaClleAKeM He TonbKO ry­ HeT peCYPCOB W1J1 B03BpaTa K 6pe I HeBCKoii MOAenH TaKHM 06pa­ eaK 30M peanbHbrH Bbl60p CTOJlIIIHK nepeA HaMH He Me AY 6pe I He­ BH3MOM H rOp6aQeBIIIHHoK naTpHapXaJlbHblM KOHCepBaTH3MOM H YMepeHHoii pe popMoii a Me AY TOTanHTapHOii peaKlUfeH H Bbl­ HY l AeHHoii paAHKanH3auHeii nepecrpoHKH 'ITO B03BpaT K penpeCCHH KOHeepaaTH3MY TonKaeT BneBO yxce nOHHMaHHe TOro HeB03MOX eH 6e3 WHpoKHX 3HallHTenbHYIO qaCTb nH6ePaJIbHblX BepXOB H cpeAHHe CllOH TaKHM 06pa30M OObeKTHBHO noqaa W1J1 neBOH aJIbTepHaTHBbl B CTpaHe cyweCTByeT M Bce X e rop6a'leB HrpaeT HCKnJOllHTenbHO 1l0nO I HTenbHYJO H HCTOpH'IeCKH Ba HYJO ponb nOMep I Ka ero 1I0nHTHKH AQn KHa 6bITb 3a 'Ieii HOMep OAKH 1J JlJl Bcex 3aHHTepeCOBaHHblx B 1I0nO I H­ TenbHOM pa3BHTHH He COBpeMeHHoro MHpa H TonbKO COBeTCKoro COJ03a HO H Beero 6e30rOBOpo'IH0 1I0Mep I HBaJO rop6a'leBCo KYJO nHHHJO C caMoro Ha'laJIa H O CHX nop MMeHHO n03ToMy II He MOry H He HaMepeH MOnQaTb a YKa3bIBaJO Ha paMKH orpaHHllHBaJO­ JJ nJl naHHKH TaK Ke HeT OCHOBaHHH KaK H 1J JlJl 3if P0pHH B HO H MepTBbrH Bpe I HeB m'WHJIH ero B KpeDKHX OObJlTHJIX Bee 3THTpH nOAQ6HbIX YCllOBHJlX nJOAJ M HCKpeHHe crpeMJIW HMCJI K AeMO­ W He ero 1I0nHTHKY 'ITO OC06eHHO HarllJlAHO IIPOJlBHnOCb BO BpeMJI ero BH3HTa B npary KpaTHQeCKOMY H COlUfaJIHCTHQeCKOMY 06HOBneHHJO He OCTaeTCJI HH'IerO pyroro KpoMe KaK ClleAOBaTb n03YHry napH KCKHX KOM­ M 'HaPOB KOTOPbrH nocrOJlHHO lUfTHPOBaJI AHTOHHO rpaMlIIH neCCHMH3M pa3YMa OnTHMH3M BonH 16 17