OT MeHJI H nO-MOOMY HH'lJero He 3HaJI 0 Moeii n03HnHH Deno 6bIJIO BepoJITHO B TOM tfTO OH 3HaJI fOMYJIKY em e co IIIKOJIbI HM ileHH­ HOBbiE KHHI'H Ha npH KOMHHTepHe OH Tepe3a TOpaHCKaR JlKy6 EepMaH KHJI C HHM Tor u a B O ll HOH KOMHaTe TaK KTO f e I3ce np06eJl PaOKe6UQ - He ll yMalO tfT06bI TaKOe ll eJIO umo tfepe3 Pa ll KeBH'IJa - 3HaQUT EepYT HElABHCHMOCTh no coBETCKH llIlIACTh - RCHo liTO 3TOro He Momo 6bl npoH30HTH 003 comacuJl BepYTa Y BepYTa B OTHOWeHHH fOMynKH 6bIJ1 KaKOH-TO KOMDJIeKC tfTO KOHeIlHO HHKaK ero He onpaB ll bmaeT KOTOPbrH MOe 6bIJIO Tpy ll HO nOHJITb H OCTaJICJI Y Hero 3TOT KOMnneKC em e CO BpeMeH OKKynaUHH He TO tfTO fOMynKa - npe u aTeJIb B no BepYT HaBep­ MKa He BepHJI npoCTO He 6bIJIO Y Hero nOJIHOrO o OBepuJl K fo­ BepHO IIU 'ITO I3bl rOMYIIKY apeCTOl3artU nOTOMY 'ITO OH TO f e HaMepel3artCR 6e JICaTb MYJIKe OH Bce KOJIe6aJICJI He 3HaJI 'lITO C HHM ll eJIaTb UyMaIO 'lITO no nCUXOJIOrH'IeCKoe npe o pacnOJIO lCeHHe Bepyra HCnOJIb30BaJlH COBeTHHKH U3 CCCP H He HCKJIIO'lJaIO 'lITO caM CTaJlHH Henocpe o CTBeH­ - R cnbIWaJI TllKylO BepcHlO U u a Ke cnOpHJI C HeR CMbIcna B HO nOBJIHIDI Ha TO 'llT06bI Bepyr OT ll aJl npHKa3 06 apecre fOMYJIKH HeH He 6bIJIO Be o b He B TOM COCTOIDI KOHcpmn r C fOMYJIlCOH KOHeIlHO roBOPHJl 11 y Hac eCTb npeTeH3HH K fOMYJIKe HO OHH - A KaKoe 6blllO ifjopMartblfoe oClfo6alfue nOJIHTHlleCKOro a He yrOJIOBHOro CBOHCTBa H He B TOM OHH liTO OH XOlleT OO KJlTb - Ha fOMYJIKY naJIo no o 03peHHe - TaK 3a 'ITO f e ezo apeCTOl3artU - R KaK 6cezOa - 13 UmUOHQ f e - HHKaK He Mor nOBJIHJlTb Ha 3TO peweHHe TeM 6oJIee tfTO JI JIe KaJl B 6oJIbHH1 e A Kor u a 11 0 peweHHH Y3HaJI TO npoTeCTOBaJI 3a PYKY fOMynKY HHKTO He nOHMan H MbI B ero H3Meuy He BepHJIH HO ll BYWI ro u aMH paHee HWI fOMynKH npo3ByqaJIO Ha npoTHB Hero caMbIM pe3KHM 06pa30M XOTb U 6e3ycneWHO KOHe'IJ­ npou ecce PaRKa B By u aneWTe H KOHe'IHO no He 6bIJ10 cnyqaii · HO 11 He Tpe3BOHHJl no BceMY CBeTY 0 CBOOM HecomaCHH HO 6bIJI HOCTbIO npas u a no ynoMHHaHHe em e He BbIm ll ll eJIO no o 03peHHeM y MeHJI pe3KHH pa3rOBOp C BepyroM nOHJITHO C ma3Y Ha ma3 B H3MeHe KaK n03 ll Hee Ha npou ecce CnaacKoro B npare HO BbICKa­ TOJIbKO He u aBHO y3HaJI JI tfTO U POMKOBCKHH TO lCe npoTeCTOBaJI 3aHO 6bIJIO B 38ByanHPOBaHHOH nOKa cpopMe tfTO 6bIJIH Me K ll y H npHBO JWI CBOH o OBO ll bl o eRCTBOBaJI OH COBepweHliO He38BHCUMO HHMH KaKUe-TO KOHTllKTbI npe o CTaBHTeneH Hawero ' 1-13 TH KHHrH Tepe3h1 TopaHCKolt OHH 3TOT C60PHHK HHTepBbIO C 6h1BWHMH o aH B I H II 164 nonbCKHMH nom we KOMMYHHCTH'IeCKHMH o eJlTenJl MH 6h1n H3­ Przedswit 17 18 B Heno o I teH3ypHOM H3 o arenbCTBe 'faCTH HHTepBbIO CM B HOMepax 15·16 H YB Tor o a ICe B By u aneWT npurJIaCHJIH nOJIbCKHe opraHbI roc6e30naCHOC­ Pe o TllK KaK COBeTCKHe COBeTHHKH xorerm tfT06bl Mbl 06 11­ 38TenbHO BOcnOJIb30B8JIHCb ll eJIOM PaAK8 OHH ynOpHo H8craHBaJIH 'llT06bI MbI H Y ce6JI npoBeJIH TaKOH npou ecc 165 r i - Ka JICeTCR 3a iJee Heoe rtU 00 np014eCca Parae Ha oonpoce €I npUCYTCTeuu iJeyx eaw ux COTPYOHUK06 U3 YE OTKa3aJ1 CR or ceoux npeJICHux npU3HaHUU €I U3MeHe U w nUOHa JICe BO J HTe nH K8 KIJ hIH CJIY'II8H OTCyYnHH'IIeCTBa peHeraTcma Bbl3bmaeT Bonpoc oui prodest - paBp bmalO HO Hap o nOH IYI - 3TO M3JIOBepoJImO II Tat oro 4 aKTa He nOMHIO 3HalO M OCTO­ 11 BOBee ee He on­ KOMy no BbITOIJ HO pHlO C fOMyrIKOH C nOH TO'llKO 3peHH I Ou eHHBaJIO 3TOT nO KHbIH nop xop BbITeKaJI 03 npHHu una lITO npoTHBHHKa CJIep yeT P 06UBaTh PP KOHD a TonhKO lITO Ha npou ecc OT HaC nOeXIIJIH B 'lHCJIe P pyrHX 3aM6poBCo KHH KOTOPhIH pa60Tan Torp a B apMHH H POMKOBCKHH BepHYnHCh OHH nonHhle COMlleHHH H Kone6aHHH POMKOBCKHH CKalaJI MIle npou ecc He KneHJICB - BnrlOTb 00 e20 YHU'ITO KeHWf KaK 3TO 6w l 0 €I CoeeTCKOM Come €I 19382 He Bblrn Ip en Kene3HO P IP MOMeHTOB - npo6Y KIJ IIJl COMHeHH I BOT Bee IITO I 3anOMHHJI ilop yMaeM CHa'IIaJIa 3a'lleM CTIIJlHH Torp a lTO cp enaJI BelJ l He COlllen lKe OH C YMa HeT He COlllen OH nOlllen no 3TOMY nym - PauKa Ka3HUIlU IIOTOMY lITO B Kat oii-TO MOMeHT OTKpbI1I 'liTO 6bl1l0 6b1 Hey6e J H­ TenhHO Bbl IJ BOraTh IIpomB OnIIOHeHTOB KOTophIe HapyrualOT e J HHCT­ - J a HO B 1956 r BO 0 ero pea6HJIHmpoBIIJIH MelllalOT pa60TaYl 'lHCTO nOnOTH'l eCKOe o6BoHeHH I 'IIT06bI Ha HaC p aBHJIH BOBCIO p aBHJIH 1IT06bI nop 06Hb1ii npou ecc YCTpaHHTb OX HJIO nOKBO J HpoBaTb HY KHO yHH'IITO I UTb OX MOpllJI1 ­ 6hl1l npoBep eH npomB fOM 'llKH BbI lJ BHHYnH npeIJ 1IO lKeHHe 'IIT06hl HO Tat I 06'b ICHJIIO 3TO ee6e HO He06xo J HMO 1I0MHHTb Tat lKe HeCK01IhKO TOBapHlu eH nOeXaJ1H Ha O'l epeIJ HOH nponecc - 'lITO Bee lTO npoHCXOIJ HJIO Korp a Bee BhIllle nOp HHMIIJI ronOBY CnaHCKo­ yrP03a ro B ilpare ilOCJIaJIH Mbl TYp a napTHiiHYIO p eneraIUllO B COCTaBe fOTJIep 4-5 'l enOBeK B TOM 'lHCJIe ilID onKoBcKoro H BOHrpoBCKoro Ha CTaHOBHJIaCI Bee 60nee O'lleBHIJ lIOii a IIOTOMY CTaHOBHnOCb He06xo­ nOM npou ecce BCfi1Ib11l0 p eno BeCJIaBa B CB I3H C KOTOphlM y lKe J HMOCThIO H e J HHCmO p eHcmoH cnnO'lleHHOCTb pMOB ilop o6HaJI 003 06HH IKOB YKa3bmanOCb Ha CB I3H fOMYnKH co CnaHCKHM H COBeTCKOMY COlO3Y co CTOPOHbl fepMaHHH CHTYaIUlJI XOTJI H B MeHhllleH cTelIeHH IIOBTOpHJIaCh 0 B KOHu e 50-x roP OB H60 mpp nOMHHTb 'lITO Ka I J Oe ooocTpe­ OIJ HaKO HHKaKHX p OKa3aTenhCm BHHbI fOM 'llKH He 6bl1l0 npep ­ 4O-x - CTaBJIeHO - HHe Me KIJ YHapoIJ HOH 06CTaHOBKO Kat IIpaBHJIO CHa'IIaJIa Bep eT K HX H He 6h11l0 IiHKTO He Mor npep CTaBHTb npH3HaHHe Ha'IIaJIe B KOTOPOM HMenHCI 6b1 06BHHeHHJI fOMYnKe Ho pa3 BCTpe'IH 6bl­ 060CTpeHHIO J HCKYCCHO nH TeHb p ena CnaHcKoro fiaJ1a H Ha fOMyrIKY nHU OM Bpara a 3aTeM 'liTO MeruaeT KOHConHIJ 8IUIO CH1I lIepep 0 K OOOCTpeHHIO BHYTpeHHero nOnO lKeHH I Torp a TO Ke cymecTBOBaJIa peaJIbHaJI yrpo3a co CTOPOHbI AMepOKH - CmzHCK020 U oeCRTepblx 0PY2UX TOeapUll4eu Ka3HUIlU H lIepep nOH yrP030H BeCb COII larepb p On KeH 6bl1l om e J HHHThC I OTCIOp a - YCTpaHeHHe BOlJ HblX p e ITeneii BO MHorox rrapTH IX He - Ho nOTOM HX TO Ke pea6HJIHTHpoBMH OCKnIO'IIalO JI TaK lKe 0 no60'IIHbIX npH'IIHH no KOTOpblM OM IIpe ll h IB­ A Bbl-TO Kat p yMaeTe I 'IIero npoBOIJ HJIH Tat He nOKa3a­ n I1IHCb TJI KeneHume 0 6ecCMbIC3leHHbIe 06BOHeHHJI 3TO 6bl1l roph­ Tenl HhIe npou eCCbl B DonrapHH B BeHrpHH B lIeXOCJIOBat HH lITO­ KHH Mpa'IIHbIH nepHOP KOTOPblH HY KHO 6bl1l0 lIepe KlJ 3Th 0 JI IIpH­ 6bl Tat He p ena OXBaTHJIH BeCh cou narepl Ho Mbl He 3allDlH TaK H I1I l aJ1eKO KaK mum coee J H H He p onyCTHJlH cyp a HaP fOMyrIKoii BpeM I He p OIIYCKaTb BbIHeCeHH I npHrOBopoB 3aBepllleHH I Mbl Bee 06BHHeHH I npomB Hero OTpHUaJIH B 3TOM CMbICJIe Mbl - p O I J aThC I MOMeHTa Korp a MO KHO 6yp eT OCBo60 J HTh nlOp eH nO-MoeMY e J HHCTBeHHO IIpaBHnbHYIO TaKTHKY BbIUrpaTh p en HCKnlO'IIeHHe TonbKO Mbl 0p HH He l aJ1H BblpBaTb u eHTpaJII HbIX 4 H­ ryp H3 PYKOBop cma napnm - A O UI lIe20 CTaJ1 UH 3TO oe rtaJ1 166 - Ha c n eoYlOll4UU oeHb noc l e apeCTa rOMY l KU HaIlaJ1 CR npo­ 14eCC 2eHepaJ1 a Tampa U eOCbMU 0pY2UX orjiU14ep06 ApMUU Kpauo­ €Iou 3ro c l Y lauHOe coenaoeHue 167 _ HeT TlUCHX cnyqaHHOCTeH He 6bmaeT llaJteKo Hm'JiUIe mIa­ HbI npe oyCMllTpHBaJIH ome HeHHe 3THX o oyx J elI HaBepIDlKa no 6bDIO CBH38HO C nOHCKaMH OKa3aTelIbCTB H3MeHbI fOMYlIKH n06Y lK lJ eHHii KOHe'IHO mnOTe3Y cne CTBH II HeJlh3H 6bIJlO HCKJllO­ lIHTb nOlIHOCThlO HO MeH II OHa He y6eJ HlIa H yueIIHlIC II 3a 3TO H B 3aKJllOqeHHH no o6BHHHTelIhHOMY aKTy HaIIHcan lfIO He TOlIbKO Tarap HO H pYrHe o6BHIDleMble HH B KoeM cnyqae He OJlX HbI KOTOPbIX nOBTOpHIO He 6bIlIO 6bITb npHrOBopeHbI K CMepTHOH K83HH 3TO 6bIJlO Bee lITO H MOr _ lIpOl-Iecc TaTapa HailallCJI IlTo6b' 1 aBzycTa 31 UlO lJI 1951 z He OIlJl TOZO IlU B ceObMYlO ZOOOBU4UHY BapwaBcKozo BOCCTaHUJI c elIan H npe J llO lQfJl BbIHeeeM npHroBopbI a nOTOM BpeM II nOKa­ X eT H qepe3 CKOJlhKO-TO lIeT MbI YlHaeM npaBJJ Y H He OTpHIIaJI HX Bce Za3eTbl MOZIlU Ha nep8Nx nollOCax nucaTb 0 zepOJlX lIollbwu Bp8 K J e6HOH eHTelIhHOCTH H lJ 3 I e He Mor npHBOJ HTb TaKOro PO a ' apryMeHTbI HO CMeprHble npHrOBOPbI II ClIHTaJI KpaiiHe BpeJ HbIMR aHTUHapooH JJI waUKa fiaHouTOB XaIlKUe MOON npecryMeHUJI KapllUKu-nullcyOIlUKU U T n J ll ll 3Toro eJla OHO 6bIJlO 6bI 3aKPbITO ecnH JlIO 6bIJlH 6bI K83­ HeHbI 3TOro H He XOTelI Hao60poT• II XOTelI lIT06hI OHH MornH IIpH3HaIOCb H 3TH lJ 3 TbI He CBH3hIBaJI H TOHKOCTb 3TOH BepHYTbCH K aKTHBHoii l H3HH K CqaCThIO MHe y J aJ10Cb y6e Th B KOppemm HH OT MeIDl yCKOlIb3HYlIa Ho H KOHe'IHO 3HalI lfIO npH­ nOM Bepyra nOTOMY lfIO caM II He CMor 6bI OTCTO llTh ny CBOIO _ MllH uelIb npouecca lIOHAOHCKHM J eJITelI IIM H CHlIbHbm y lJ 3 p no ApMHH KpaHOBOH If ee TOlIKy 3peHHJl P83roBOP C BepyTOM 6bDI HelIerKHM H Tor lJ 3 KaK eMY lfIO CMepTHbIe npHrOBopbI HenelIecoo6pa3HbI H60 OHH He cny­ pa3 nepeHec Onepau H1O H noqTH om llCH IIJl He Mor pa60TaTb HO nepe rrpoueCCOM MllTepHalIbI HaIIpaBHlIH MHe l 8T HaweMY J eJly a rrpHHOCJIT eMY Bpe H HaCTaHBaJI Ha nOM YaK raK KaK 3TO elIO IIIlIO rrpHMO rro JIHHHH YB KaX eTCJI H H3yqaJI rop ll'lO H KaTeropH'lHO 'ITO Bepyr B KOHIIe KOHIIOB co MHoii coma­ MllTepHaJIbI BMeCTe C MHHIIeM MbI BHeCIDl napy norrpaBoK HO HHKa­ CHlIC II MOX eT 6hITh no 06UCH IIJlOCh H TeM lITO H TOJlhKO lfIO ne­ KHX qy ec COBepWHTb He MornH IIoKa3aHHH 6bIlIH H TaKHe H 3 lJ 3 ­ peHec 6oJle3Hb a K TOMY KHe HO H3 HHX CKlIaJ bmaJIaCb KapTHHa qpeBaTaH 06BHHeHH IIMH apeCT fOMYJlKH Bepyr BbI3BaJI POMKOBCKOro H npHKa3aJI eMY ICe 6bIJl HeMHOrO eep T Ha Bepyra 3a CMepTHbIX npHroBopoB He BbIHOCHTb TOT 6bDI OWeJlOMlIeH - KaK Jl xe _ 1la H Bee OHH 6bDIH oweJlOMlIeHbI - 3HaIlUT eU4e KTO-TO KTO qTO cymeCTBOBaJI 3arOBOp HaCHlIbCTBeHHoro H3MeHeHHH rOCY lJ 3 pCTBeHHoro CTpoH HapoJ Hoii IIolIbWH - - J CHO H OeUCTBUTet1 bHO TaKOU 3al080p UMet1 MeCTO COBeTHHKH H3 CCCP KOTopble nOT npouecc nOJ fOTaBlIH­ BaJIH B paC'leTe Ha eepbe3HbIe pe3yJIhTaTbI IIo-MoeMY OHH paCClIH­ ThIBaJIH Ha _ CymeCTBeHHo qro 3TO BbITeKaJIO H3 npe CTaBlIeHHbIX MHe 4-S BbIWeK 6bIJIH pa30qapoBaHbI a BeCh MHp 6bIJl H3YMlIeH 3TO 6bIJl nepBbIH TaKoii npouecc MllTepHaJIOB lJ 3 6bIlI 3aroBop TaM 6bIlIH rrpH3HaHHH 06BHHHeMbIX Hbm - rrOK83aHHH CBH eTelIeii - rOBopbI 6bDIH O'leHb CYPOBbIMH Bee lfIO HYX HO J llH OCY K J eHHH H Bee B IIolIbwe nOK83aTelIb­ H HH OJ Horo cMepTHoro npnrOBQpa XOTH BbIHeeeHHble npH­ 6bIlIO YaK JlOrH'lHO ysH3aHO qro npH paTbCJI 6bDIO He K qeMy qeTb'pe nOJICU3HeHHblx Y MeIDl BbI3BaJIO COMHeHH II TOJlbKO qro reHepan TaTap B03Bpa­ maHCb H3 3MHrpau HH CH IIJl C J err03HTa B aHmHHCKHX 6aHKaX H npH­ Be3 B IIOJlbIIIY 30JlOTO rrpHHa J lle K8BIIIee OBoeHHOMY rrOJlbCKOMY - CY J hH omawaH rrpHroBop c006IuHlI 0 BH3HTe POMKOBCKO­ rrpaBHTeJlbCTBY MHe He rrOKa3aJIOCb y6e TeJlbHbIM lfIO OH OCTa­ ro K Bepyry raK qro BC II cnaBa AQCTalIaCb eMY - BHlI 3TO 3OJlOTO C oypHbIMH HaMepeHHHMH lfI06bI HaC KyrrHTh CO l aJ1eHHIO npouecc TaTapa 6bIJl HCKlIIO'IeHHeM KaK rrbITaJIOCh OKa3aTb cne 'CTBHe a He H3 rraTpHOTHqeCKHX CTerreHHbIX npoueccax ApMHH 168 H npaBHlIhHO K B pyrnx BTOpo­ KpaHOBOii J aBJleHHe COBeTHHKOB 169 r 6bIJIO KpaiiHe BpelJ OHOCHbIM H HH'IerO He Mor ClJ en atb H CMept­ opraHbI OHH CMOrJIH y6e J Htb BepYTa KOtOPbIH 6YAYtJH 'Ien OBe­ HbIX npHrOBopoB 6bIJIO MHOro KOM yMHbIM H nOpAAO'IHbIM Bee-YaKH nonHoCtblO nOBepHD B BHHY BTopocreneHHble np0l4eCCbl 6b1 llU 3aKph1TblMU npo6oiJu­ IlUCb 6 TlOpeMHblX KaMepax KaK 6 J1e jopT060 UIlU Ha J1YWfHKe H CYlJ BelJ b Ha 3aeelJ aHHJtX CYlJ a Bee nOlJ CY J HMble qysCtBOBanH CnblxanbCKoro H ce6H rOMYJIKH 3HatJHT cnelJ CtBHe Morno y6elJ HTb CKOBaHHO H Hy H 6bIJI He06bl'laiiHo tBeplJ bIH xapaKtep 'lt06b1 npotHBOCtoJtth lJ aBneHHIO CYAa· B tlOPbMaX HO He B KaMepaX H B cneummbHblX 3anax YaK 'itO CPOpManbHble tpe60BaHHH 006nIOlJ anHCb 'itO no 06bHCHHnOCb lJ enaetCH J 1IJt 6e30naCHOCtH 3aKnlO'IeHHbIX 'lt06bl HX He _ tPellbiJop j MOqapCKUU KyponecKa J1ex06Uq COXpaHUIlU TaKOU xapaKTep H iJo KOHlta MornH Ot6Hth npH nepeB01Ke B llJ aHHe CYlJ a CaMS lHaete taKHe teKCtbl BeerlJ a taM BbIlJ alOt - 3toro Jt He 3HaIO 710 BelJ b cnyXH KOHe'IHO HaWH CYlJ bI 6bIJlH lJ aneKH OT coBepWeHCtBa Ife TaK IlU nozu6 nOllK06HUK IfUil noiJnollbHaR KIlUqKa 3MUIlJf f JellbiJop ja Jla H npo6neMa nO-MQeMY 6bIJIa He B tOM 'itO 3aeelJ aHHJt npoBO IJ IDIHCb B TIOpeMHbIX nOMeIlJ eHHJtx a B tOM tJTO cylJ bB 6bIJlH 3apasee HaCtpoeHbl npoTHB nOlJ CY J HMbIX H notOMY He BeerlJ a 06'beKtHBHbl TaKoro lJ ena Jt He npHDOMHHalO - TOllbKO TaKUX 6bl U Ha3HaqallU - HHTepeCHO qyTb IlU He KaJlCiJozo U3 6ac Jf 063TOM cnpaUlu­ 6alO U HUKTO 3TOU jaMUIlUU He 3HaeT A eeiJb 3TO 6b1 ll zepou MaCUlTa­ t5a OKYIlUItKOZO U FP0Ta -P06eItKozo • OH 6b1 ll KOMaHiJupoM iJu­ 6epcuoHHOZO oTiJella APMUU Kpau060u ZOT06U1l nOKYUleHue Ha Kyqepy U onepaltulO no oC6060JlCiJeHulO Y3HUK06 ApCeHtlIlbCKOU mpbMbl 6b1 ll KOMaHiJupoM opZaHu3altUU lfeT ' o aqalla ezo apeCT06a1l IfKBJ U noc lQ Il 6 Cu6upb a KoziJa OH 6epHYIlCJI ezo apecr06a1l0 YEo - He MI l - COBeTHHKH CYlJ eii 6panH H3 cnY lK6 6e30naCHOCtH KaK H B COBetCKOM COI03e OHH BelJ b CBOH MeTOlJ b1 CYlJ OnpoH3BOlJ ­ CtBa npHBHBanH H HaM II03TOMY CYlJ b1 CPOpMHPOBanHCb no COBeTe­ KHM 06pa3IJ aM - OHU U 6blHOCUllU npUZ060pbl _ IIpHroBopbl BbIHOCHJIHCb B COOtBeTCtBHH C yronoBHblM KO­ - ECJ1H OH npHHa J 1Ie lQUl K KOMaHlJ OBaHHlO ApMHH Kpaiio­ lJ eKCOM H laBHeenH OHH ot CteneHH H xapaKtepa BHHbl Mbl BMeWH­ BOH to KOHe'IHO ero JJ eno paCCMaTpHBanOCb He Ha HH3KOM ypoBHe BanHCb TOObKO B Ba lKHeHWHX KnIO'leBbIX cnyqaJtx B o CtanbHblX Ha· Ho MeHH OHO BepoJttHo o60llDIo Ka3aHHe onpelJ enHJIOCb HopManbHo - CMepTHblU npUZ060p KOTOPblU OH nOllyqUll 6blHOCUil Ta­ KOU 60T He3a6UCUMblU KaK 6bl CqUTaeTe cyiJ - EOJICe MOU _ CornaeeH no He 6bIJIH HOpManbHble CYlJ bI H cylJ bH He 6bl­ - Y MbIii Bac Bee O'leHb npoCTO CYlJ 3aBHCHMbIH HnH He3aBHCH­ JIH CJ1HWKOM npoHHIIaTenbHblMH HO BbI lJ On lKHbI nOHHth CYlJ bH pa60raet C MatepHanOM KOtOPblH lJ alOt eMY cnelJ CTBeHHble lKenanH 'IeCTHO BblnonHHtb CBOH napTHiiHble 06H3aHHOCtH BbIte­ KalOIlJ He H3 rOCYlJ apCTBeHHOH He06xolJ HMOCtH BbI lHaete KaK lto 6bIBaeT I IHorlJ a HHTepeCbI nHtJHOCTH npHXO J HTCH nolJ tJH­ • KOMSH lJ HPbl 170 ApMHH KpaAOBOH - llpHMeqaHHe IlepesO l'IHK HHth mnepecaM rOCYlJ apCtBa a KorJJ a rOCYJJ apCtBO nOlJ yrpo30H 171 nOA03pemUI pal aIOTCll 'lT06hI npH o aTb HM BHAJ MOCTb npaB ll O­ nOA06Hll H - To eCTb nOCllJICeHbl He OT alO 6hmH JIO Hhle npHrOBOpl I B03MO HO - JIa o a ecnH 6hI CY ll J H 6hmH ll pyrHMH MHorHX olIIH60K Y ll 3J10Ch 6101 H3OO­ lKaTb Ho TPY ll HO 6hmo HaHTH CY ll eii KOTopble CMorllH 6101 coxpa­ H 6hmH apeCTOBaHhl caM BaueK KOMap fle ll ep naTO Bee BpeM1l npHCMaTpHBaJlCll K HX ll eny 'lT06hI nOCTaBHTh no ll HHTb JI01lJ1bHOCTb H B OTHomeHHH K HaM H no OTHOmeHHlO K 0OOH­ COMHeHHe BbmO ll hI KOTophIe BenH K HX OCY I ll eHHlO Ho II He Mor H1leMhIM 'ITO He06xo ll HMO WIll BhlHeeeHHll cnpaae lJ llHBorO npH­ oCBo60 ll HTb HX• ilJI R 3TOro Y MeH R He 6bmo ll OCTaTO'lHhIX D aHHhIX rOBopa - He 6bl lo OoCTaTO'lHO ux HeBuHoBHOCTU - Kozoa R CJlblu Y U3 YCT BaM no006HbiX CJlOBa cnpaBeoIlU­ BOCTb ' paBeHCTBO ' COijUMU3M ' R OpOJlC l OT crpaxa HeBHHOBHOCTH 6hmo 6101 ll OCTaTO'IHO HO ee Ha ll O 6hmO CHa· 'lalla ll OKa3aTb yaK KaK HM npe D h RBn1lJ1H BnonHe KOHKpeTHhle - c yn1 l6KOii TaK y cnytlHJ10Cb K HeCtlaCTblO 'ITO H ll ell OKalaJlaCb ll HCKpeAJ THpoBaHHoii Ho npoH30IllJ10 3T0 He nOTOMY 'ITO ee HCKa3H11H a nOTOMY 'ITO npH ee ocymeCTBneHHH 6hmH HC­ 06BHHeHH1l CeH'IaC II He 6yAY 06CY I JJ 8 Tb - MHHMbie HJIH npaBHnb­ Hhle HO 06BHHeHH1l 610mB B XO ll e cne ll CTBH1l 3TO Ha ll O 6hmo Blome­ HHTb J1 Mbl nl lTaJlHCb no BhI RCHHTb nonb30BaHhI MeTO ll hI KOTophIe npHBenH K Henpe ll BH ll eHHhIM OTpH­ QaTenhHI IM pelYnbTaTaM Cl lrpallO ponb TaK e HaCTYDJIeHHe pa3­ - Bbl3HMU KOMapa lleoepa nH'lHhIX CIUI Bpa l ll e6HhIX COu HaJlH3MY - 0 H - KOHe'IHo KOHe'lHO Ho 1lY'lU e BepHeMCR K ¢aKTaM He xoqy 000nllTh ll eHCTBHTenbHO n030pHhle q aKThl YBhI - TaK 'lTO JlCe TYT 6bl lO BbIRCHRTb - BH ll HTe nH cxeMhI npaB o a - TaK nOT MexaHH3M pa60TaJl H TYT 11 HH'Iero nO ll enaTb He Mor Moe nonO l eHHe 6hmo OCOOOHHO TpY ll HhIM H60 H COBeTCKHe COBeTHHKH 610mB 60nee H1IH MeHee OCBe ll OMneHhI 0 TOM KaK CTaJlHH KO MHe OTHOCHTC1l EC1IH HM o a l e 06 3TOM npllMO He rOBOpHllH TO Bee e KaKHM-TO 06palOM HX HaCTpoHnH B TOM CMhIcne 'ITO co MHOH MO ­ HenpaB o a sHROBeH He- BHHOBeH yahl nerKO MeH1llOTC1l B CHTYaI I IH Kor o a aTMOCq epa HaChlIUeHa nO ll 03peHH RMH H IlO ll 03peHH R Bee 60nbme nO ll OrpeBaIOT­ C1l H He Mor anpHopHO yYBep l JJ 8 Th 'ITO Bee 06BHH1leMhle B 1 lIIIH0­ Ha l e HeBHHOBHhI Tor o a MHe npHnmocb 6101 npe ll I10nO I HTh 'ITO Bpa­ HO He C'lHTaThCll l eCKHe pa3Be ll KH nepecTaJlH 3aHHMaTbC R llOJIbmeH H JIHKBH ll HPO­ - 11 HOR6pR 1952 Z Bbl apeCTOBMU zeHepMa BaijllaBa Ko­ Mapa BaJlH CBOlO areHTYPY B CTpaHe a 3TO Ilpe ll I10nO l eHHe CMhlcnHua llpo6neMa CTaJlO 6hlTb COCT01lJ1a B TOM 'lT06hl BhmaB­ 'lHCTU OOe­ lIHBaTb IlOWIHHHhIX areHTOB 'lT06hl YB pa60TaJlO OO301IIH60'IH0 HaCTynHno BpeMll Kor o a B H3MeHe Ha'laJlH nO ll 03peBaTb A06poBOJIbUeB Cpa I aBlIIHXCll B J1cnaHHH B 6aTaJlbOHe HMeHH JlOM6­ Bepo RTHO 6h1BalIH TO'lHble IlOIla D aHH R HO 610mB H 01IIH6KH O ll HaKO Ka l ll Oe ll eno Ha ll O 6hmo BhmCHHTb ll 0 KOHUa· poBcKoro B03HHK UeJIhIH KOMImeKC nO ll 03peHHH npoTHB OT ll ena KOMapa KOTOPhIH B npe ll lIleCTByroIUHe ro ll hI 6hm Ha'laJlbHHKOM - ilocpeiJcTBoM nblToK IIITa6a BToporo OT ll ena BOHcKa llonbcKoro BoeHHoH palBe ll KH llpHMetlaHHe nepeBO ll 'lHKa OH YKOMImeKTOBaJl 3TOT OT ll en maB­ KOMapa He IlbITaJlH Pa3Be 'ITO B CMblcne nCHXH'IeCKOrO B03­ HhlM 06pa30M CBOHMH OOH3KHMH TOBapHIUaMH B OCHOBHOM ll OM­ ll eHCTBH R HO He q H3H'IeCKoro HanpHMep nyrallH 'ITO 6YAYT c ll e­ 6POBQaMH llo'ITH Bee OHH 610mB YCTpaHeHhI naHhI BhmO ll J 1 B OTHomeHHH eeMbH B o6i ueM TaKHe BeIUH KOTophle 172 173 llpaKTHKyroTCH B nHX eny'IaJIx 06 H36HeHHHx H He enbIIUaTI Aa H OH BnoeneACTBHH Ha no He 3J10BaJICJI penpecCHii 3HaIlUT OH AZflIl H OH U Heoep JJltlTO U zeHepflllbl Kypo­ neCKa TaTap Moccop Kupx Maii ep CKu6uHCKUU u HaKOHe14 Mo­ lIapcKuii HeMY KOTOPblU onucflIl 49 6U006 nbITOK COBeTHHKOS H Ha'IaJIbHHKOB HO no y6e f IJ eHHID B npaBHJIbHOCTH npUMeHeHHblX K - SOJICe no y6eJICoeHuIO 6blpbl6aTb HOZTU oT6u6aTb no'lKU oepxaTb 6 XOAOOHOii 60oe EenH 6b JI 3HaJI 06 3TOM TaKHe OC PHUepbl He 3aAep 3J1HCb H lIliTaJI 3TO H C PaKTOB 3THX He OTpHUaID MbI C03AaJIH KO­ MHCCHID l TIH npoBepKH - 6bI Y MeHJI H nJiTH MHHyT 6bIDT HJIH He 6bIDT EbIJlH 06HapY f eHbI C PaKTbI npeBbIWeHHJI BnaCTH H MbI npHHHJ1H MepbI no llHCUHImHHap­ Hoii nHHHH 3m CAenaJIH MbI TO eCTb EepYT H JI HecKonbKHx OC PH­ - TaK Haoo 6bl lO nouru 6 TIOPbMY KPmc npo6eOaTb C60UX opY3eu uepoB He noMHIO CKOJIbKHX HaKa3aJIH HXnpHBneKJIH K OTBeTCTBeH­ Hoem no llHCUHImHHapHOii nHHHH OHH nOJIytlHJIH BbIfOBOPbI HX OTCTpaHHJIH OT HCIlOJIHeHM CllY f e6HbIX 06J13aHHOCTeii Ha HeCKOJIb­ KO MeCJlueB a TO H Ha nonrOAa CornaceH HaKa3aHHe 6bIJlO 60nbwe - 3Toro JI lJ eiiCTBHTeJ1bHO He CAenaJI Bo-nepBbIX JI 6bIJI CBJl3aH B CBOHX nepeABH f eHHJlX SO-BTOPbIX JI He O'leHb-TO sepHJI CllyxaM l TIH BHAY tfeM no CYlUeCTBY nOAeiiCTBOBaJIO OHO JIHWb Ha KOPOT­ Koe BpeMJI CHCTeMbI He H3MeHHJIO H MaWHHa KpYTHJIaCb AaJIbwe IlpoH30IIDIO TaK nOToMy 'ITO Bo-nepBblx annapaT roc6e30nacHOC­ - Ho He 6yoeTe JlCe 6bl YT6epJICOaTb 'lTO 6bl He 3HaAU KaK 6ac HeHa6UOJlT TH CTaJI CTaBHTb ce6JI Hall napTHeii KaK H B COBeTCKOM COID3e OH Mor MaHHnynHpoBaTb BCeMH HCTO'IHHKaMH HHc popMaUHH H MbI'Iac­ TO 6bIJIH npoCTO 6eCCHJIbHbl nepeA HHMH BO-BTOPblX KOHTponb Hall - A Sb AYMaeTe liTO XOTb KTO-TO H3 HaC peWHJICJI Ha nepeBO­ poT S 06lUeCTBe TOJIbKO nOTOMy 'ITO ero He nID6 11T CTOJIb 3aMKHyTblM KnaHOM KaKHM CTanH opraHbI roc6e30naCHoc­ TH 6bIJ1 KpaiiHe 3aTpYAHeH HX COTPYAHHKH APyr Apyra nOKpbIBa­ - qTO 6bl UMeere 6 6UOy nH H AOKa3aTb lITo-nH60 MO f HO 6bIJ10 TonbKO eCllH Y Te6J1 6bIJlO Ha Koro onepeTbCH 3Ha'IHT KTo-TO AOn f eH 6bIJ1 OTKpbITb HX BHYTpeH­ HHe ceKpeTbI TO eCTb enY f e6HbIe TaiiHbI - KOHe'IHO M0 f 80 6bIJ10 6bI CKa3aTb noene Hac XOTb no- Ton HO KOMMYHHCT MblenHT He TaK KOMMYHHCT AOll f eH SHAeTb XOA MHposoro npouecca H nblTaTbCJI H3MeHHTb MHp OH AOn f eH OT­ - H 6-TperbUX 6 bl npeonOllUTflIlU He 3HaTb He npaeoa AU - BellaTb 3a CBOH nOC1 'III H H cnaem HaPOA OT KaTaCTpoC PbI HeT Mbl npocm He BepHJIH B TaKoe 3sepCTSO CornaceH - 3Ha'lUT KOMMYHUCTbl npUHOCJ T ce6J1 6 JlCepT6y pOOUHe - MbI He npHHOCHJIH ce6J1 B f epTBY a BblnonHHllH H BbmOJi­ BO3MO f H0 MbI 6b1J1H enenbI He SepHJIH CImeTlUIM C'lHTaJIH HX Bpa f eCKOii nponaraHAoii nOToMY 'ITO cnYXOB H Bpa f eCKHX H3­ MbIIIDIeHHii Ha Haw C'IeT 6bIJIO MHO f eCTBO HaAo AoporaJi naHH HJleM nepeA Heii CBoii Aonr IlpH'lHHa npocTa eCllH 6bI MbI He CTpaAa­ OTAaBaTb ce6e OTtfeT B KaKoii 06CTaHOBKe MbI f HJ1H a OHa 6b1J1a nH TO IlonbWY pa3AaBHJ1H 6b1 B neneWKY TaKOBa 'ITO Aa f e MHorHe H3 aIlnapaTa roc6e30naCHOCTH B OCO­ KOrAa 3Ta HCTHHa AoiiAeT AO rOJIOB 3THX MHJIllHOHOB HO KOrAa­ 6eHHOCTH nID llH HAeiiHbIe nOBepHJIH B HeKOTopbIe MHC Pbl H ne­ reHAb 0 HaBHCWeii yrpo3e H AeiicTBOBaJIH He npoCTO noll BJ1HJlHHeM 174 KpH1IHT He 3HaID HH6YAb AoiilJ eT H OHH nOCTeneHHO nOHMYT OT KaKoii onaCHOCTH MbI HX y6epernH 175 -Ma30XU3M - KTO ux Ha3Ha'l Jll - nOlJeMY Ma30XH3M - - A HaeT a Bhl Be l h nOHHMaeTe OHH MHe He o OKna l hIBanH Yllw6Ka 'ITO JfCe eUje lJaCTb HapOOa nmOeT Ha BaC OPYZt1Jl npoKIlU­ 90% - He XOTJlT Bac - Ho Bbl JfCe 6blllU - Hy-HY He 6y o eM ToprOBaThCB HaClJeT npou eHTOB CornaeeH eCllH 6hl He 6htJIO 3a HaMH npaBoThI HlIH eCJIH 6hl npaBOTa HallIa 6hl­ na MHHMoii Tor o a KOHe'IHO MO lQ O 6htJIO 6hl CKa3aTh OHH OO3YM­ I J h1 Ho 3a HaMH eCTh npaBOTa BnonHe palyMHaJI npasoTa H nepcneK­ THBa KOTOPyro B Y ICe He pa3 BaM paCKphman 6htJIa H eCTh peanhHaJI nepcneKTHBa C 3THM HHt ero He no o enaeWh a t TO Hac 6hmo H OCTa­ nOCh HeMHoro Ho HCTOPHJI yqHT t T0 Beer o a MeHhWHHCTBO cnacaeT 6onhWHHCTBO - ux Ha'l JllbCTBOM 3TO HeBa lQ O OHH co6HpanH HH$OPMaUHIO 060 MHe H 060 Bcex KTO 6hm no o HX oneKoii TO eCTh 060 Beex HaIlHHaJI C MHHHCT­ POB H Ky o a-TO ee nepe o aBanH Kor o a qenOBeK 6hmaer Ha pa60Te KTO ero nocewaeT On HaKO palrOBopoB OHH CJIhIllIaTh He MornH nOToMy t T0 CH o enH B KOpH o Ope B nepe lJ Heii a neTOM - nepe o o OMOM - Ho He B KBaprupe - He 3HaHJ 'ITO Ha 3TO OTBeTUTb••• MOJfCeT 6blTb nozoBopUM - HeT BHe o OMa HO B npe o enax o OCBraeMOCTH Mbl-TO palro­ o Bazueu IlU'IHOU JlCU3HU Dbl JICUIlU Ha KIleHOBOu Y llu 14 e BapHBanH TonbKO B 3aKphIThIX Ka6HHeTax - Jla nepBhlii 3Ta IC o OMa 3aHHMan B BTopoii - liepyr Tpe­ THii - KaKOe-TO BpeMB lIIBanhOO KoonepaTHBHhIH o eBTenh B03rna­ BHlI ry IJaCTh PYKOBo o CTBa rrnc - llOOCIlYZUUBaHUJl He 6blllO KOTOpaB KanHrynHpoBana nepe o KOMMYHHCTaMH H nomna Ha o6'he lJ HHeHHe C HHMH B nopn - npH­ - He l yMalO Me K o y TpeMJI H qeTblPbMJI B exan o oMoii 000­ MeIJaHHe nepeBo o 'lHKa Y MeHJI 6htJIO t eThlpe KOMHaThl H o OBonhHO o an C lCeHoii H o ot ephlO H B03BpawancB B UK I1Hor o a npHe3 Kan npHBTHaJI npHXo ICaJI B 1954 r MHe anH o aqy B KOHCTaHTHHe MOB o oMoii Y JCHHaTb HO t awe MHe B Ka6HHeT npHcbmanH 6YTep6po o hl o a1Ja CTOMa PJI l OM C o at eii Pa o KeBHIJa HanpoTHB o a1lK liepyra qYTh Ka6HHeT no cymecTBY l Ba O lJ HH B COBeTe MHHHCTpoB o pyroii - B o anhwe CTOM o OM MHHI J a KH3Hh B Ben cnoKoiiH 'lO BCTaBan B BO­ UK 6hDI Y MeHB 6onhWOii 60nhwe 3TOii KOMHaThI llBa Tene$oHa eeMh HHor o a B nonBochMoro 3asTpaKan BMecre C KeHoii H Mhl 000 0 l HH 06hlt Hhlii ropo o cKoii o pyroii - Bq cneUHanbHwH no KOTO­ exanH Ha pa60ry KeHa B I1HCTHTyr peBMaTonorHH Ha CnapTaHCKOii B - B UK HlIH B COBeT MHHHCTPOB Ha o eBBThlii 3Ta IC o OMaWHBJI pa60THHn a Y HaC 6hma POM ' MO ICHO 6htJIO 3aKa3hmaTh pa3roBophI C MOCKBOii npBMoro Tene$OHa He 6hmo OH 6hm He HY lCeH CBB3b qepe3 Bq o aBanaCh HeMe ll leHHO CTanHH BBen pe ICHM pa60ThI KOTOPhIH 6hDI 06B3a· TenhHhlM no BeeM ' COBeTCKOM ' COlO3Y H no BceM ' COIJ JIareplO - llpUCIlaHHtVl CH o enH B KOHTOpaX 0 0 n03 lJ Heii HO'IH CTanHH 06hI'lHO Ha'IHHan pa­ - HOlIK OH CBB3hmanCB CO BeeMH n03TOMY Bee KTO Mor eM ' noHa lJ O­ 60Tan B weCTb Beqepa Me K o y weCThlO H nOnHOt bIO a TO H t aCOM KOHe'IHo B MHHHCTepCTBe rocOO30DaCHOCTH 6hDI OT o en OXpaHhI 'llIeHOB npaBHTenhCTBa OH oneKan Beex Koro eM ' 6hDIO no­ 6HTbCB HnH OTBeTHTb Ha Bonpoc IC l anH ero 3BOHKa nOHHMaJI t T0 pyt eHO OXpaHJITh 3TOT OT o en OpraHH30Bhman HaW OT ru IX H CJIy­ OH MO ICeT n03BOHHTh B nlO6yro MHH 'ry lCe6HhIe nOe3 lJ KH npHchman o oMpa60THHu H HalHat an oXpaHy Y MeHJI 6hDIO 4-5 qenOBeK KOTophle CMeHBnH o pyr o pyra Kpyrnhle CYIKH Bee OHH HMenH onpe o eneHHhle 06B3aHHOCTH 176 - 3Ha'lUT cuoenu 6 OJfCUOaHUU 360HKa 177 Mhl He CH l enH 003 l ena BhmonIDllIH CBOIO paGoTY TOxre 3BOHHJIH pa3HhlM nIO l JIM B ysepeHHOCTH IJTO Ka lC lU lH CH l HT Ha Mec­ Te 3HaR 1fI0 H HM Moryr n03BOHHTb 33 l arb Bonpoc HllH nepe­ arb HH4 OPMa IO 60JICOR Ile tlOeelieCTea ' oceo60ouTetIR nOflbCK020 HtlpOoa' KOTOPblU O JJl HaM ceo60oy Oblll 'HaM eceM OT140M' ee lUK020 Cr JJlUHtl' - - U HaCT JJlO epeMR CaMblX TRJlCe tlbIX OflR HapoOa COObITUU Hal JJlocb epooe Obi He6UHHO CHaIl JJla 7 MapTa nepeUMeHOe JJlU - no eOCKpeCeHbRM TOJICe - HeT B BocKpeeeHhe Y 'IlIeHOB nonHToIOpo ohIBanH l pyxrec­ KHe BCTpeltH H B OCHOBHOM BCTpeltanCR C 'IlIeHaMH Haweii TpoiiKH - KaTOeU14e e CT JJlUH02PYO 3ro OhInO myno EepyroM H MwmeM XO l HnH l pyr K l PYry Ha y KHHhl Ha 0OO l h1 Ha IJaii JIeToM 0hD10 Gom we CBoGo ll Horo BpeMeHH H MhI MornH XO l HTh Ha nporynKH B KOHCTaHTHHe HO He u an eKO B npe l enax Ha­ weii 3aKPhlroii teppHTOpHH Ho H BO BpeMR nporynoK MhI 3aHHMa­ JIHCh ThlCRIJeii l en Ha l O npH3HaTh Hawa ltaCTHU KH3Hh OhIna OO l ­ HOBaTa H B03 l epXCanCR np ronOCOBaHHH - DbiflO 20flocoeaHue -EhInO - 3TO OblllO npeoflOJICeHUe DepYTa CnYI JJlOCb 6aM pan06apUeaTb OPY2 c 0PY20M 00 apecTO­ eaHHblX T06apU J fOX - H no nOWlTHhlM npHItHHaM Ha noxopoHhl He noexan Bce nOHHManH onaCHOCTb nonoxreHHR B l eKaope 1952 r npoI1llIH JJ Ba CTp3llIHhlX npouecca B MOCKBe 23 CMepTHbIX npHroBo­ pa 3a KOCMOnOnHTH3M 0 TaKOM npouecee HHIJero He H3BeCTHO B03­ MO KHO HMeeTCR B BHAY Ka3Hh eBpeiicKHX KynbtypHhIX H nOnHTH­ -He nOMHIO - A KTO Oblll 3a - ITpe u n oxceHHe nponmo OonhlIIKHCTBOM ronOCOB TaK IJTO CItHTaTh tyT Heqero B TaKHX cnYIJaJlx MoryT ChlrpaTh ponh cnyqaii o lJeCKHX l eRTeneii KOTOPYIO npHHRTO aTHpoBaTh 12 asryCTa 1952 r - ITpHMeIJaHHe nepeBO l 1JHKa B ITpare - 11 B TOM ItHcne CnaHCKOMY H KneMeHTHcy 14 mmapR 1953 r OhI1l0 ony6nHKoBaHo Hhle oocToRrenhcma HecymeCTBeHHhle He BhlTeKamIIIHe H306IIIeii H l eH Mory Bac Bee xre YTenmTh qro C Moeii nOMOIIIhIO y u an OCb coooIIIeHHe 0 paCKphITHH 3arOBOpa KpeMneBCKHX BpaIJeii 1fI0 npe l ­ llB0puoM KynbtyphI H HaYl H BeIIIano OIJepe ll HYIO GonhWYIO ItHcmy CHOBa HaJJ BHranaCh rpo3a Ko MHe npHwen 3HrMYHT MO l 3eneBCKHii BeTepau KOMnap­ THH HCTOPHK H l HnnOMaT 'IlIeH UK - ITpHMeltaHHe nepeBO l ItHKa 1tT00hI noroBopHTh 0 l ene rpynnhl KOMapa OCOOOHHO 0 JIe l epe KOToporo OH 3Han C l OBOeHHhIX BpeMeH H l PyxcHl1 C HHM eeMMIMH JIe l ep caM OhIn ChIHOM BH l HorO l eRTenR KITIT Crrywaii - CKa3an II eMY eeiiltac II HHIJerO C l enau He MOry TaKOe yxc nonoxceHHe Ho II reOO 0OOIIIam qro IJepe3 rO l -nonTOpa MHe y aCTCR HX KaK-TO BhlTaIIIHU Ii y u an OCb - Ho He TaK yJIC ObICTpo 5 MapTa nepecTaIlo OUTbCR cep014e 178 cnYCTHTh Ha ropM03ax coopyxreHHe naM ITJ HKa CTanHHY nepe l - nOTOM Ob flU YOUTbl 19 nOflbCKUX o¢u14epoe U3 91 npu20­ eopeHH020 K cMepmou Ka3HU 6 npeOblOY J fUe 200bl - H He xoqy 00 3TOM rOBopHTh 3TO ohma CKBepHaR HCTOPHR KOTOpIUI MOxreT npe l CTaBHTh B MOXOM CBeTe Eepyra OH OhIn onaro­ po ll HhIM IJenOBeKOM H TonhKO 6JIaroAaPll eMY BhI Boo6IIIe co MHoii ceiiqac pa3roBapHBaeTe TaK IJTO BbIlJepKHHTe TO IJTO II BaM ceiiqac paccKaxcy H OhIn B EenhBe l epe TOrAaWWlR pe3H l eHUHR EepyTa KaK npe3H l eHTa rocYAapcTBa - ITpHMeqaHHe nepeBo l 1JHKa wen no KOPH l OPY H TyT OH MeHlI ocraHOBHn Cnywaii - roBOPHT - II 179 TeOO l lM 3m o eJIa IIpollHTaH nOJJ yMaH H nOCOBeTYH 'lT0 MHe C HHMH AeJIaTI H eMY OTBeTHJI JI 3m JJ eJIa He B03bMY MHe H3BeCTHO KaK OHH cpa60TaHbl HHKaKOrO aHaJIH3a JI npoBecm He cMory Bee B ero KOMDereHUHH lleJIo lllJIO He 0 KaKoii-TO MeJIOllH a 0 npHMaee B KaTOJIH'IeCKOii CTpaHe Ho Ha o o nOHHMan 'ITO B nOM cnyqae HMenaCb B BHAY He JIH'lHOCTb npHMaca a caMa UepKOBb c o eJIaHO TaK 'lT0 BblllHTaTb H3 HHX H lero HeB03MO I H0 06 OJJ HOM TeM TOJIbKO npomy - He l lBaH CMepTHblX npHrOBopoB nOKa JJ eJIO - Rbi XOTetlU ee Pa3PYUlUTb He 3aKpblTO MO I HO erue 'lTO-TO BbIJICHHTb a 'lenOBeK Bee-TaKH EcnH l l Ke HeCKOJIbKO JIeT nOCTpa l leT y Hero eCTb maHc BbI­ IQIB Mbl l l l e H He nbITaJIHCb - Ha 3TO He 6blJI0 HHKaKHX maH­ 6onb­ HTb BepHyJICJI JI AOMOH H l l l e yrpbl3eHHJI coBecm nOttyBCTBOBaJI COB Ho Bcer l l 000 CTOpoHbl cTapalOTCJI nOOYllHTb KaK MO I HO MO lKeT 6blJI0 6b1 JIyqrne eCJIH 6bl IJ B3M 3m nanKH Ho c o eJIaTb -TO we K03blpeH KaTOJIH'IeCKaR UePKOBb pe3Ko paclllHpHJIa CBoe BJIHJI­ HH'lerO 6blJI0 HeJIb3J1 TaM BeAl 6hIJIH CBH o ereJIbCKHe nOKa3aHHJI HHe H HaM HaAO 6b1JIO TaK HJIH HHa'Ie Ha 3TO OTBeTHTb Ha peweHHe npH3HaHH II BHMbI Bee oTpa60TaHO H npHrHaHO He 3a 'lT0 6blJI0 6bl Bepyra nOBJIHJlJIa TaK lKe H 06ruaR CHTYanH IJ COBna o eHHe HeCKOOb­ 3auenHTbCJI H Mor 6b1 HanupaTI JIHmb Ha MOpaJIbHyIO cropoHy KHX He6naronpH lJTHbIX 06cr0 IJTeJIbCTB C OJJ HOH crOPOHbl erue npH o eJIa 'lT0 JIYlJIIle MOO Bpy6HTb 60nblllHe CPOKH HO He CMepTHbie H3HH CTaJIHHa 6b1JIH HaMeqeHbl aKlJ HH no AHCKpeAHTanHH UepKBH npHrOBopbl K CO l aJIeHHIO Bepyr MeH IJ He nocnymaJI Peroco cny­ C ApyrOH crOPOHbl B 1953 'JaJIOCb 'IT06bl OH He nocnyman Moero COBeTa HO BOT cnYllHJIOCb HHKOB-naTpHOTOB H IIaKC OH K CO KaJIeHHIO CJIHlllKOM BepHJI B 3m 6YMarH KOB HHcnHpHpoBaHHaJI npaBHreJIbCTBOM - r CTaJIO JlCHO 'lT0 tBH KeHHe CBJlrueH­ opraHH3au H IJ CBeTCKHX KaTOJIH­ IIpHMe laHHe nepeBO o ­ lIHKa He CMOryT c o ep lKaTb aKTHBHocm UepKBH - H H OKOH ell npUUl lO O'iepeOb llepK6u 23 ceH TJl6pJl 1953 z nOClle cepuu H anaOOK 6 ne'lOTU U npOlleCC06 C6JlUleH H UK06 6bl l opeCT060H npUMOC RbIUlUH CKUU - C6JlUleH H UK06-nOTpUOToe' TO eCTb Tex KOTopble XOTetlU p036uTb llepK06bU3H YTpU - H 3TOMY npOmBHJIC R HO He CMor nOBJIH R Tb HacrOJIbKO 'lT0­ - HeT OHH K 3TOMY He crpeMHJIHCb TaKoe o eno 6blJI0 06pe­ 6bl peweHHe 6b1JIO OTMeHeHO Bo06IUe-TO HaMe'laJICJI He apecr a HH­ 'leHO Ha Hey ll a'lY BMecre C JIaKCOM OHH nblTaJIHCb C03 ll aTb omIO­ repHHpoBaHHe B MOHaCTbIPb TO ecrb B JIY'lWHe ycnOBH R Ho o eIllJIH 3HD H1O BHYTPH UepKBH UeHTP KOTOPblH Mor 6bl 3aMeHHTb B cnyqae He HMeJIH 3Ha'leHH II - Bee no 6b1JIO OOccMblcneHHo Bbl Ke 3Haere Ha o 06Hocm UePKOBHblX JIHJJ ePOB Ha neperoBOpax C rocy ll ap­ B nOJIHm'leCKHX Hrpax JJ eJIaIOT pa3JIH'lHble XOJJ bI He Bcer ll a Y ll a'IHble CTBOM H B TO l e BpeM R orpaHH'lHTb MacwTa6b1 JJ e R TeJIbHOcm H YMHble Apecr npHMaca R OTHOWY K llBHO HeYMHbIM XO ll aM c o e­ UepKBH H ee arpeCCHBHOCTb H60 Mbl paCCMarpHBaJIH UePKOBb KaK JIaJIH H3 BbIWHHCKoro erue oJJ Horo MyqeHHKa H BMecro Toro 'lT0­ opraHH3anHlO nYCTb He llBCTBeHHO nOJIHm'leCKyro HO HaCTpoeH­ 6bl ocna6Hrb UePKOBb YKpelUUlH ee HyIO HeA06po KeJIaTeJIbHO no OTHOWeHHIO K CTpolO H K 00360 1 ­ HblM H o e R M KOTopble C HHM CBJl3aHbI OJJ HaKO Mbl o OJIroe BpeMJI - A n ' oUlu6KY KTO coeepUlUll OCOOOHHO AO 1947 r XOreJIH npHBJIe'lb uepKoBb Ha CBOIO CTOPOHY B nepsylO O'lepeAl - BepYlOlllHx - Bepyr roeOPJl nonpocTY nOO'lUH UTb Ee3 nOMOUlu opY3eu - Be3 ApecT npHMaca 6blJI0 HalllHX BJIacreii a KOHKpeTHO - 180 Her HeT Mbi CTOJlJIH Ha n03HUHJlX MHPOB033peH leCKO­ HalllHM peweHHeM pemeHHeM ro nJIlOpaJIH3Ma npH3HaHH IJ 3a rpa lKAaHaMH a6COJIIOTHOH CB060­ BepYTa raK KaK UePKOBb 6blJIa o bl COBe CTH MbI He co6HpanHCb MemaTb UepKBH B BblDOJIHeHHH 181 ee peJIHI'H03HblX $ 'HKUHH a no KaK BaM H3BeCTHO n03HUHH COBepweHHO npoTHBOnOJIOJKHaH TOH lITO npHH IlJlH HaWK coceIJ H MbI He XOTeJIH BOeBaTb C uepKOBblO He XOTeJIH coBepwaTb noCTyIl­ KOB HenpHHTHbIX H HeYMHblX BHa'IaJIe HaM 3TO y n aBaJIOCb focy n apcmeHHble AeHTeJIH yqaCTBOBaJIH B npoueCCHHX B npa3 IJ HHK TeJIa XpHCTOBa UePKOBHble Hepapxn - B UepeMOHHHX OTKpblTHH HOBbIX llIKOJI H 3aBOAOB OA­ HaKO C Te'JeHHeM BpeMeHH H C o60cTpeHHeM Me K l yHapoAHOH 06­ CTaHOBKH BbIJIHBWeHCH B XOJIOAHYIO Bonuy HaWK OTHOWeHHJI C KapTa EBponbI MO eT H3MeHUTbCJI npOH30IllJIa KOHCOJIH D aUHH H aKTHBH3auHH onn03HUHOHHbIX rpynn BepYT nbITaJICJI HX no n a­ BHIb - KTO eMY nOMozan - Ma3YP H nlOHa BpHCTHrep KOTOpaH co6Hpana J JUI Hero HH$OpMauHlO no JIHHHH MHHUCTepcma rocy n apcmeHHoH 6e30nac­ Hoem UepKOBblO H3MeHHJIHCb 'ITO npHBeJIO K HCKa eHHIO Hawux nepBO­ Ha'JaJIbHbIX nnaHOB Erue B 1950 r Mbl nbITaJIHCb npHHTH K coma­ weHHIO H nOAfiHCaJIH C BbIWKHCKHM OqeHb xopoWHii AOKYMeHT 'IacTH'lHo nOTOM H3MeHeHHbIii KOTOPblH CblrpaJI nOJIO HTeJIbHYIO - He OHa IlU Toeoa zOToeUila nOKa3QTeIlbHblU np014eCC enUCKO­ na Kelle14Koeo qeCllaea Ka'IMapeKll OCYxOeHHOzo KQK U MHozue CeJluteHHUKU 3a UmUOHa JIC POJIb npaB n a He HaAOJIro H60 ero He Bcer n a K CO aJIeHHIO C06nIO­ AaJIH - - rllaeHblM 06pa30M - ebl 'ITO OOK03bleaeT AHOJICeU MU14eec­ KUU e KHuze HaKC U 3HaK He JJ yMaIO XOTH BepoHTHO OHa 6bIJIa 3Ha KOMa C 3THM I e­ JIOM OHO 6bIJIO B ee KOMneTeHUHH B03MO H0 qTO OHa rOTOBHJIa HeKOTopble AOKYMeHTbl AJIH cneACTBeHHOrO OTAeJIa rAe KaK BbI 3HaeTe CHAeJI PY 8HCKHH 3AeCb ee HH$OpMauHJI B TOM llHcne H HenOJIHaJI H HeTO'lHaJI npoBepJlllaCb my6 e HHor n a MeTo n aMH - 3TO 06blllHO lITO Ka l aJl CTOpoHa HMeeT npereH3HH K APY­ ron AQKa3bffiaJI 'ITO OHa-TO BeJIa ce6H 6e3ynpe'lH0 Ho 3TO HeB03­ MO HO TaK KaK petIh HAeT 06 orpoMHbIX Maccax JIIOAeH 0 HBOM OpraHH3Me COCTOHrueM H3 MHo eCTBa JIHlIHOCTen C pa3JIH'lHbIMH TeMnepaMeHTaMH B3mH n aMH H HaCTpoeHHHMH 30H K HHM a Y HHX - Y Hac 6bIJIH npeTeH­ K HaM H H He MOry 06BHIDtTb B 3TOM npHMa­ ca BbIWHHCKoro KOTOpbIii 6bIJI 'JeJIOBeKOM WKpoKHX B3mHAOB ueHHJI 3aKJIIO'JeHHoe C HaMH COrJIaWeHHe H MHe Ka eTCH Hennoxo OTHOCHJICH K Bepyry TaK qTO Bepyr Mor 6bI C HUM AorOBOpHTbCJI Ho H BbIWHHCKHH He Mor nOBJIHHTb Ha TO lITO rOBopHT TOT HJIH He cnHWKOM AOCTOHHbIMH H H3 Hee AeJIaJIHCb re HJIH HHble BbIBOAbl Mbl KaK Bbl 3HaeTe PY 8HCKOrO CHJlJIH - Hy oaneKO He cp03y - fOAOM n03 e nocne OKTH6pbCKoro nneHYMa - A TaKJlCe noclle 6ezcTea CeJlTIlO U eeo nepeOa'l no paouo Ceo60oHaJf Eepona ' He TaK IlU HHon CBmueHHHK HJIH ellHCKon - - 3a 'ITO ezo KOHKpemo apecToeanu - 3TH penpecCHH H ro C nOCTa comaceH lITO OHH 6bVlH HeYMHbIMH BbITeKaJIH H3 06rueH CHTyaUHH HX HaAO BHAeTb B nOJIHOM KOH­ TeKCTe C06b1THn Qepe3 HeCKOJIbKO MeCJlUeB nocne cMepTH CTaJIHHa B HIOHe npoH30IllJIH H3BeCTHbIe C06bITHH B f llP H BepnHHcKoe BOCCTaHHe Koe-KTo Y HaC TO e HatJaJI BepHTb B nepeMeHbI B TO qTO 182 PaHee Mbl He pacnOJIaraJIH npJlMblMH AOKYMeHTHpoBaHHbl­ MH YJIHKaMH KOTopbIe AaJIH 6bI OCHOBaHHe AJIJI CHJlTHJI Py aHCKO­ - Oa HY BeOb 0 eeo oellax 3Hana 'Iyn IlU He eCJl HOIlbUl a - nereH l b1 0 qbeM-TO ca1J H3Me MOfYT 6blTb npauAHBbIMH HO Moryr 6bITb H HeBepHbIMH H 3JIOHaMepeHHbIMH ECJIH 6bI H 06 3TOM 3HaJI flJITH MHHyT 6bI••• 183 - A PailKe6u'I '3TOT 6poiJe 6b' noPJlOO'lHb'U IU Il00eK••• He BCTpeTHillh Ha noxopoHax OH nop omen KO MHe H cnpoCHJl He ll ep y nH JI Ha Hero ma 38 ro 'ITO OH Ha3Ban 3TH HMeHa• - HeCOMHeHHO - nO'leMy OH '31UM He nOUHTepeC06Q1lCJI 06 H36HeHHJlX H yace roBOpHJl Mbl orKphDlH HeCKonhKO AHCWUUJHHapHhIX p en 113 cnep cmeHHoro annapara KOrophlM py­ KOBOAHJl Py J aHCKHH ro J e 6hDlH YAaneHM HeCKOJlhKO qenOBeK fI BOBce He ymep l J 8 IO 'ITO Bee npoHCXO D HBmee 6hDIO npeKpaC­ HMM HasepHoe He Ha ll O 6hDlO P O J HAaThCH nOKa HaKonHTCH CTOJlhKO MarepHana npoTHB Py J aHCKOro HaP O 6hDlO p eHCmOBaTh paHhme H peillHrenhHeH CHaqana MhI ero nepeBenH Ha nocr AHpeK­ TOpa fOCH3Aara Ho qepe3 HeCKOJlhKO MeC lIIeB KorAa HaKOIIHJlOCh CTonhKO o6BHHeHHii qro npHumoch ero apeCTOBaTh OH 6hDI npHBne· qeH K yronoBHOH omerCmeHHOCTH 3ro npoH30umo eme KorAa H 6hDI Ha nocry TorAa ace MhI HaqanH nepeCMarpHBarh Bee p ena B oco6eHHocm re KoropMe Bena BOeHHaH KOHTppa3Bep Ka raM Ha­ KOIIHJlaCh Macca qenyXH eme 6onhme qeM B YE I1taK Hacrano BpeM II 0 KOTOPOM II roBOPHJl MO ll 3eneBcKoMy H HMeHHO II Qepe3 Bepyra ycrpoHJl C031 IB cneIJ HanhHOH KOMHCCHH C yqaCTHeM OxaGa lJl ll nepeCMorpa n Korophle Bena BOeHHa ll KOHrppa3Bep Ka fI or­ BeTHJl eMy 'Iro My ll peUM rOBOp IIT XO'leillh Koro-ro ynpeKHYTh npep CtaBh ee6 11 Ha ero Mecre • fI ce6 11 B moeM nonO J eHHH npep cTa· BHTh He MOry n03ToMY II He Mory eepAHThCJI 3a ro 'ITO Thl p enan rnynoCTH Mory TonhKO CKa3aTh 'ITO Thl nan HX H K TOMy ace y J aCHhIe rpy ll HO 6hDlO npeABHp eTh K KaKHM nocnep CTBH IIM lJl ll Ha3BaHHhlX ro60H nIO H 3TO npHBep er Co CTOpoHM BaueKa o6BHHeHHe 'lneHOB nonHroIOpo B 1lllIH0­ Haace 6hDlO OT'IaHHHOH nOnhITKOH CBecm Bee cne ll CTBHe K a6cyp­ JJY OH Bepo llTHO xoren 'lT06M Ha ero ll eno B3rnJlHYnH no- ll py­ roMy Ho TaKHe paCqeThl p oBonhHO PHCKOBaHHhI H Moryr npHBecm nHillh K HOBhIM 6ep aM KOMHCCHIO Mhl C031J anH He3aBHCHMO or npH3HaHHH KOMapa noroMy 'ITO YMep CranHH H n03rOMY HaqanC II nepeCMOrp Bcex ll en - KOMUCCUJI 6bllla c030aHa 60npeKU POKOCC06CKOMY - KOHe'IHO BeAf OH 6hDI aenocpe ll CTBeHHMM Ha'lanhHHKOM BoeHHOH KOHTppa3Bep KH - OH COnp01U6IlMCJI - KOMUCCUIO 6b' C030a1lU nOTOMy 'ITO ZeHepQIl KOMap npu3­ HQIlCJI 60 ZIla6e umUOHCKOU ce1U 6 KOTOPOU OH pa60TfJll CTOJlIlU EepYT U Ma3YP o Bepyre He cnhIllan BO BCHKOM cnyqae HaM Toro He C006LUHJlH MO J er 6h1Th ytaHJlH Ho KOMap p eHcmHrenhHo J enaH BMropoAHTh ce6 ll cran rOBOpHTh rnynoCTH a 3areM o6BHH IITh Bcex no ll p IIA -H6ac - MeHJI Ka J erC II Her lo MeH II HH'lero He ll oumo MO J er 6hITh He xorena MeHJI rporaTh KOMap HalBan Ma3Ypa 3asa ll CKorO Mop 3eneBcKoro Beex nop p llp lJepe3 MHoro ner MbI BCTpemnHCh Ha Knap 6HLUe Koro ronhKo 184 - HaBepHOe OH He 6hW p oBOJleH Brop J eHHeM B ero p ena HO oH He npoTeCTOBan Yace HaCTanH ll pyrne BpeMeHa H MHOrHX COBeTC­ KHX COBerHHKOB Mhl HallanH orChwaTh ll OMOH TIepep 0n e3 ll OM OHH npHXOAHJlH KO MHe CpeAH HHX 6hDIH BoeHHhle lIlIeHhI Hamero Bep­ XOBHoro cyp a OHH npoCHJlH 'lT06hl JI He llHcan nnoxoro B HX xa· paKrepHCTHKax - 60MHch nOnyqHrh no mee nocne B03BpameHH II 11 HcmHrenhHO HeKOTophlX DOcaAHJIH HeCKonhKO ner nonyqHn CK 'JIh6ailleBcKHH a B03HeeeHCKHH - ll eC IITh ner K CO J aneIDfIO OH 6hDI 3 11reM KaponJi CBep'leBCKOrO - OH aceHHJlCH Ha ero ll OqepH tIneHhl KOMHCCHH OxaGa no6ecep oBanH C apeCTOBaHHMMH H MHOrHM 6hDI H3MeHeH pe J HM cop ep J aHH II 3ro OTpa3HJlOCh B BocnOMHHaHHn KorophIe OHH Bnocne ll CTBHH ony6JmKoBanH TaK KyponeCKa KOTOpMii KaX eTCJI CHAen p onhme Beex c'lHTan 6narOAeJIHHeM 'ITO ero nepeBenH H3 TIOphMhI KOHTppa3Bep KH B 185 TIOpbM ' YB napaAOKC 6bm B TOM 'ITO 3AeCb OH nOlJ 'BCTBOBan ee611 6e30nacHee TaK KaK 3AeCb He 6bmO H36HeHHii KOTOpbJe H3M ''IHJIH ero B BoeHHOH TIOpbMe KOMHCCHR Oxa6a nonyqHJ1a npHMOH JJ OCTyn B BapmaBe 3HaKOMbJe C 3aKynHCHOH nOnHTH'leCKOH HrPOH npa· BHnbHO O eHHnH ynaneHHe MeHR H3 eeKpeTapHaTa K o enaM H BbIBCHHna 'ITO 6bmo HeMano a6cYP o HhJX o6BHHeHHH o CO6eHHO B BoeHHOH pa3Be o I e lena paCCJJe o oBanH 3aROBO pac­ nYTbmanH pacKpyqHBanH H CTanH onpaB D bmaTb H BhmYCKaTb mo­ UK H BHIJ e· npeMbepCTBO He C'lHTanH npo o BH KeHHeM - CTape6UfI KaCMflH U CTaUle6C'KUU 1Jbl Ul OTCTpaHeHbl no TeM ICe npU'IUHaM AeH - He 3HaKl TeM 6peMeHeM 6ac nOHU3U1lU 8 - He ToponuTecb - HeT 11 TaK He D yMaKl H OOAJlCHOC1U no·npe KHeMY yqaCTBOBan BO Beex Jaee o aHHJIX nonHT6Klpo H BbmOnHJIn Bee npe KHIle 4lyHKU HH 06 OTCTpaHeHHH MO KHO 6bmo 6bJ rOBopHTb paHbWe Kor o a Ha o o MHOH BHeena yrp03a He o oBepHJI CTanHHa 'ITO orpaHH'lHBano B03MO KHOC' TH MoeH AeJiTenhHOCTH H y'laCTHJI BO Beex o enax - B 1954 Z 6bl nepeCTatlU OblTb ce'KperapeM TaK KaK - 3Ha'lUT MOAOT06 nOMOZatl6aM - H 00 'KOHijO 'laCTO C HIlM BCTpe'lanCJI OC06eHHO BHa'lane Kor o a pewa­ nOCb MHO Kecmo o en KacaKlwHXCJI IIonbJIlH H nOTOM Kor o a B03· HHKana KaKaJI-HH6y D b nonHTH'leCKaJI npo6neMa II npe K J e Bcero 06­ pawanCJl K HeM ' TaK 6bmo B 1948 r C KOHrpeccoM MHpa Kor o a 11 3BOHHn eMY H3 BpolJ laBa mua cnaeeHHJI H OH 3TO Aeno cnac OH aK CTan BH e·npeMbePOM TO eCTb npo o BHHynCJl BhJWe 6bm co MHOH Be lOUl8 Ho OHH Bce 6hmH Be lKnHBbJ - H KaraROBH'l H MHKOJIH Bee Be lKnHBOCTb BXO o HT B pHryan Ho CHMnaTHKl II no­ lJ 'BCTBOBan TonbKO co CTOPOHbJ ManeHKOBa Kor o a '1epe3 HeCKon ­ KO neT B 1954 r y lKe nOCJJe CMepTH CTanHHa 11 CHOBa npHexan B MOCKBY ManeHKoB no o an MHe PYlCY H CKa3an 3 o paBCTBYH HKOB - HeY ICetlu H 3Han 0 HeM ManO TonbKO TO 'ITO OH 6bm qneHOM nonHT­ 6Klpo OH yqacmoBan BO BCTpe'laX HHor o a Mhl CHAenH PR o OM 6e­ CornaeeH 3TO 6bm KaK 6hJ nHHOK HaBepx Koe-KoMY 6hmo Ba KHO 'lT06bJ II ywen H3 eeKpeTapHaTa U K KOHe'lH0 He BepYTY HO OH no o 'lHHHnCJI TaK II o yMaKl nOTOM ' 'ITO TO'lHbIX CBe­ AeHHH Y MeHR HeT o aBneHHKl XpyrueBa TOT npas o a He 6bm aRTH­ eeMHTOM B 06hI'lHOM CMbJCJJe CJJOBa HO KaKHe-TO KOMnJIeKCbJ Ta­ ee o OBanH HO npHHIJ HnHanbHbJX o HCKYCCHH II C HHM He Ben A ryT OH c o enan TaKOH o PY KeCKHH KeCT Bpo o e 6bJ HH'lerO oco6eHHoro HO Bee lKe no 6hmO CBH o erenbCTBOM CHMnaTHH C HHMH TaKoe pe o I O CJJYtJanOCb - KTO 6blUletl nepeblM U3 3a'KAIO'IeHUJl rOMYA'Ka Kora po o a Y Hero 6hmH OH YTBep K J an 'ITO B HaweM PYKOBo o CTBe CllHIllKOM MHoro eBpeeB Era CJJOBa Karow nonxaaThmanH H npHBo­ o HnH B Ka'leCTBe peKoMeH o a nHii XpyweBY Ka3anOCb 'ITO JlIJI 06­ wero ycnoKOeHHJI H oCJJa6neHHJI HanpJI lKeHH1I B CTpaHe 6YAeT no­ ne3HO MeHJI OTCTPaHHTb H CBanHTb Ha MeHJI OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a Bee npoHcwe o uree leno paCCMaTpHBanOCb B KpeM1le H pa3 D yMhma­ nH KaKOH nOCT MHe o aTb KaK MHe paCCKalhmanH B KaKOH-TO MOMeHT MonOTOB B nOHcKax npHnH'lHO BhJrnJIAeBWerO BhJXO­ o a npe JlIO KHJ1 a He c o enaTb nH ero BHIJ e-npeMbepoM 'lT06hl He B03­ HHKno o6BHHeHHJI B o HCKPHM1fHaIJ HH BepYT COrnaCHnCJl Ho nKl o H 186 - He 3HaKl 6bm nH OH nepBbJM HO 'lepe3 napy neT C Hero CHRnH Bee 06BHHeHHJI H OH BbDlIen B KOHUe MO KHO 6bmo BbmyCTHTb H paHbwe HO TaK 1954 ro o a Ero Y lK CJJyqHJ10Cb H o PyrHe HatJanH BbJXO o HTb OCBo60 o HJIH enyIO rpynuy nKlAeH MOJI AHKa llypa'l npHUYTaRHbJe K o eny l wIb o OB HaM nOMorno 'ITO B BeHrpHH o eno l wIb o OB TO Ke 06aRKPOTHnOCb H Bearpbl Ha'laJIH H3 Hero Bbl­ nYTbmaTbCJI BeCCMblCJJeHHaJI 6bma HCTOPH1I MHO Kecmo nKlAeH 6hl­ no 06H KeHO MHorne nOCTpananH a re OB o a Ke yMep 187 - A Ta1 Xe zeHepail FepMaH 1l01l1 013HU1 OOtJyJICUHC1 UU nOIl­ - CnbIXaIlbC1 UU - 00 XX C'Oe30a U cMepTU EepYTa a oou14013 1 013HU1 Bepyw -K013a1lbC1 UU A opyzue moou U3 APMUU Kpauo­ APMUU Kpau080u 13bmYCTUIl IlUWb OxatJ no fl MHUCTUU otJM8lleH­ 130U OCTa8a1lUCb 8 3a1 lllOlIeHUU Hoil 8 anpelle - OCBo60xmeHHe fibDlO npoueCCOM a He e u HHOBpeMeHHoH aK­ lJ HeH IIpoBepKa Aen H oCBo60iK t l eHHe Tpe60BaJIH BpeMeHH H npoHC­ XO u HnH nOCTeneHHO XY Ke Beero oficro llJ1O u eno C ofiBHHeHWlMH B lllllHOHa Ke IlBa u ena TJlHynHcb nO l 03pHTenbHO u onro MeIDl 3nHnO 1955 'ITO B r Kor u a nO'iTH Bce KOMMYHHCTbI Y'Ke BbIllDlH Ha CBo60­ u y npo u OJl llJ1H CH u eTb BaueK KOMap H MapHaH CnbIXaJIbCKHH Ho BepYT OTKJIa l blBaJI HX oCB060iK t l eHHe Y Hero CJlO KHJIC II ueJlbIH KOMIIJ1eKC no u 03peHHH paCee llTb KOTopbIe MHe He y u aBaJIOCb H OTHOwy 3TO Ha C' eT ero 3aKOCTeHeBIIIHX u OKTpHHepCKHX B3rn ll u OB OTCIO a - em Bepa BO Bee fiYMUCKH KOTOpbIe no u COBblBaJIa eMY - Ha 1956 z XX Chel u MbI noeXaJIH BTpoeM - BepYT E KH MopaBc­ KHH H II BepYT ' yBCTBOBaJI ee6 ll MOXO OH 6bIJl CJlafi nOCJle Tonb­ KO 'ITO nepeHeeeHHoro rpHnna C'bel u OKa3aJ1C II JlI II Hero T II KeJlbIM nepe KHBaHHeM Y Ke BbIcrynneHHe MHKO llHa B HaqaJIe Che3 u a npe u ­ BeIIIaJIO 'ITO-TO HOBoe MHKO llH KOHe'IHO HHKaKHX OTKPbITHH He c u enaJI HO paCCYaHOBKa aKueHTOB B ero pe'IH nOKa3blBaJIa 'ITO HacrynaeT HOBbIH 3Yan MeIDl laxsaTHnO pa u ocTHoe ' yBCTBO H no u ero BJlH IlHHeM II BbIDHn C MOpaBCKHM Ha fipYAePIllaq T XpymeB BbICTynHn B nOCJle l HHH u eHb Che3 a Ha 3aKPbITOM 3aee l aHHH TOJlbKO l 1I II Il eJleraTOB I1HocTpaHHbIe rOCTH He fibIJlH npHrnameHbI B 3aJ1 Ha CJle u yIOIIIHH AeHb JI u on KeH fibIJl B03B pamaTb­ YB OH HM BepHn O'leHb BepHn C Il B CTpaHY BepYT nony'IHll TeKCT u OKJIa l a XpymeBa H u an ero MHe Ha nOCJle l H101O HO'Ib KOHe'IHO u OKJla npOH3Ben Ha MeH II fionbilloe - A 13bl He 13epU lu Bne'lameHHe HO BH 1J HMO II BocnpHWln ero CDOKOHHee qeM BepYT - Y MeIDl 3TH no u 03peHH II Y Ke nonHOCTblO HC'Ie3JlH a Y Hero TaK KaK u OCTaTO'IHO KPHTH' eCKH OTHOCHJIC II K CTanHHY Hero u e ll­ Ila H BepYT u OJl KeH 6bIJl OTHOCHTbC ll YaK Ke Be l b CeMbJl eIIIe HeT lleno TYT B OTHOllleHHH K CJle u CTBeHHOMY MaTepHaJIY TeJlbHOCTH • O u HH 'lHTaeT ero C HaMepeHHeM 06enHTb no u 03peBaeMoro u pyrOH c t oPHaJIbCKOH KeHa BepYTa - 60nbille BepHT CJle l OBaTeJlIO BepYT no-npe KHeMY BepHn 06BHHe­ HO nOCTpa u ana BO BpeMJI 60nbWHx 'lHCTOK H BepYT Kor u a fiblBaJI HHIO n03TOMY B pa3rOBOpax C HHM II He CTaBHn Bonpoca BHHOBHbI B MOCKBe KaiK t l bm pal CDpaIllHBaJI 0 ee aBHO yfiHTbIX fipaTb llX B HnH HeBHHOBHbI CnbIXaJIbCKHH H KOMap H npe JllaraJI '1TofibI CJle u CTBHe no HX AeJlaM BeJlOCb OTKPbITO 'ITO npH u ano fibI eMY COBepllleHHO HHOH xapaKrep 0 KOMape rOBOpHn II C BepYToM HeO l HOKpaTHO 3TO He u aJIO HHKaKHX pe3yJIbTaTOB II03TOMY Bee­ HOH 1955 r • II nOCTaBHn Bonpoc 0 ero oCB060xmeHHH Ha nonHT­ firopo Ho II OKa3aJIC Il B O u HHO'leCTBe H 1955 r 3TOT pa3 - Ha u eiK t l e 'ITO KTO-TO Hl HHX MO KeT fibITb eIIIe KHB Hero MO KHO BbITaIIIHTb TaK 'ITO H Y BepYTa u on KHO fibDlO HMeTbC ll npoTHBOJl­ u He npoTHB nOTp llCeHH II Ho 0 l H0 u eno Kor u a lHaeIIlb OT u enbHbIe CJlY'IaH a u Pyroe Kor a npe u CTaeT nepe u rnaaaMH ofiIIIa ll KapTHHa BepYT 6bDl nOTp lleeH u a Ke 3a60nen H3-3a 3Toro nony'IHll MHKpoHHq apKT H HeCKonbKO He u enb npone KaJI B nOCTenH OceHblO IIpHMe'laHHe nepeBo u 'lHKa CTpam­ - ilOH lIl Ha1 OHe14 1 OMY OH C lyJlCU l II BHOBb no l H llJ1 Bonpoc 06 oCBo60xmeHHH Ha CnbIXaJIbCKoro Ho Moe npe JllO KeHHe CHOBa npoBa­ - He B TOM u eno 'ITO CJlY KHJI BepYT npocTO He Mor nOIDITb KaK Y CTaJIHHa l O noro u OIIInO TYT Y'K He HMeno 3Ha'leHWl QTO JlHnOCb pa306JIaQeHHe KeCTOKOCTeH yrPO llJ10 OcyiK t l eHHeM CTaJIHHa H reM A 1 a1 ZOIlOC013a1l MUH14 'ITO ero BbI'lepKHyY H3 HCTOpHH 3TOro c u enaTb He y u aCTC II OH no6e u Hn fHmepa H nOTOMY OH OCTaHeTC II B MHPOBOH HCTOPHH Hec­ - He nOMHIO PelllaJI BO BC IIKOM CJlY'lae BepYT H KaK Beer­ MOTP ll Ha Bee COBepllleHHble HM rnynocTH a B AeJlax rOCY apcTBeHHOH Ba KHOCTH ronoc IIepBoro nepeBeCHn 000 npocHAenH u o 1956 r 188 - He zllynoCTU a npecTynlleHUJI 189 If npeCTynneHH II KOHe'IHO Ho OH coBepwan HX B y6e lKAe­ MapKOB omeTHJI - HeT MbI 6oHMc II lITO pa3roBOp C BaMH enHIlIKOM HHH 'ITO 310 nOenY lKHT neny peBonIOJJ HH H3 HneHHhIX n06Y lKAe­ - B3BOJIayeT Bepyra a 3TO npoTHBOnOKa3aRO eMY OlKa3 BbIrJI IInen HHH••• O'leHb Hey6enHTeJIbHO BH lHMO OH nOJIY'IHJI TaKHe pacnop llx eHH II MHe olJem 6bmo 6oJII Ho II npHJIeren nonpomaTI C II a MeH II He no­ if rUTllep TOJICe npowy 3aMeTUTb OCTaBbTe Y nYCKaIOT MeH ll OXBaTHJIO OTIJa lIHHe IToene CMepTH BepYTa npHJIeTenH 3aBanCKHH H Ma3YP' 3aBanc­ CTanHHa 6bma Hne ll - BenHKa ll Hne ll - 3amH­ THTb peBOJIIOJJ HIO nI060H u eHoH KHH nOmKeH 6bID npoH3HeClH pe'll B loMe ooI030B H II nOMoraJI eMY rOTOBHTb pelJb II nY'lllle 3HaJI PYCCKHH rpo6nOClaBHJIH B lOMe COlO­ 3OB a Hac BbICTPOHJIH y rpo6a MHe omenH MeClO nOnaJIbllle a MeCTO - A y rUTllepa - 3alqUTUTb '1UCTOTY pacbl Ma3Ypa OKaJaJIOCb 6rIHX e R yaHnen B 3TOM om IICHeHHe nO'leMY Me­ H lI He nonyCTHJIH K BepYTY CTaJIO IICHO 'ITO 3TO KOHeu - HeT KPH'IHT HeT 310 BemH HecpaBHHMbIe Qepe3 nsa MeC lIIJ a II Yllien B OTCTaBKY IIT06bI o6ner'IHTb no­ nOX eHHe HOBoro PYKOBOnCma a lJepe3 'IeTbIpe MeC llu a npHllIeJI - Ho pe3YllbTaT TOT JtCe OKT II6pb 3Ha'leHHe ero 6bmo nsO llKHM HM 6ypHO 3aKOH'lHJIC II MeJJl eHHbIH npou ecc OTTeneJIH HalJaTbIH HaMH H B TO X e BpeM II - TaKoBbl napanOKCbI HCTOpHH OHH T IIx enhI 6one3HeHHbI HO BI ICB060nKJIHCh 3JIbIe CHJIbI TaHBIlIHeC II B MbIllIJIeHHH nOn llKOB yYT yx HH'Iero He nonenaellib ITOTOMY H CTan TaKHM nOTp lleeHHeM noKJIan XpYIUeBa He3aBHCHMO OT Toro npaBHJIbHO nH OCSeTHJI OH - geM 8ce 3TO Dbl lO 8b138aHO no 8aweMy MHeHUlo TOT HJIH HHOH Bonpoc CaMHM 4 aKTOM BhIClynneHH lI C U eJIbIM P ll­ nOM 06BHHeHHH npoTHB CTanHHa XpYIUeB 06HaPy I HJI 6oJIblllYIO CHJIY xapaKTepa Bepyr pacXBOpanC II HO II He nyMaJI 'ITO 3TO CMepTeJIbHO R BepayJIC lI C MOpaBCKHM B BaplllaBY Pa306JIaIJeHH lI XpYIUeBa nOlllJIH CIOna O'leHb 6hICTPO' OHH BbI3BaJIH paClep llHHOCTb - Tenepb CTaJIO MOnHhIM aHaJ1H3HpOBaTI KPH3HCHI Ie cHTya­ JJ HH H Ka KJJ bIH 6oJITaeT 'ITO B ronOBY B36peneT R CIJHTaIO lyY lHCKYCCHIO 6eCIDIOnHoH B HeH 6hD1 6bI CMbIen TonbKO eCJIH pelJb llIJIa 6bI 06 oIIIH6Kax B lKOHOMH'IeCKHX Bonpocax 6pox eHHe CHTYau H II eme 60nee oenOX HHJIaCb BbIJIO naX e HeCKOJIb­ KO caMoy6HHcm He Bee BbInepX aJIH TaKoe HepBHoe Hanp llx eHHe - KaKue JlCe owuDKu Dbl lU c08epUleHbl 8aMu OT3BYKH lTHX C06bITHH no pa3HbIM KaRarIaM nOXOnKJIH no Bepyra OH 'IaCTO 3BOHHJI H3 MOCKBbI B OCHOBHOM KOHJI xaoc B03HHKIIIHH B BaplllaBe R MHe Ero O'leHb 6ecno­ 'lYBClBOBan 'ITO OH HeMHoro x aneeT MeH ll nOHHMa ll 'ITO II He Mory OBJIaneTb nonox eHHeM R nblTaJIC II no B03MO lKHOCTH ycnOKOHTb ero rOBOpHJI 'ITO nonox e­ HHe neHcmHTenbHO HeJIefKOe HO MbI CnpaBHMC II nyClb He 6ecno­ KOHTC lI Bnpyr 3BOHHT MHe H3 MOCKBbI BaRna rypCKa lI ITo ee enOBaM BepYT 3360JIen BocnaneHHeM JIerKHX H 6hm npH CMepTH R Cpa3y x e BbmeTen B MOCKBY ITpHJIeTeJI II BO BTOpoM 'lacy AH lI H np llMO C a3ponopra noeXarI K BepyyY BaRna KOTOPa ll CHnena OKOJIO Hero Bce BpeM ll Bblllma KO MHe H3 ero KOMHaTbI R 06paTHJI­ C lI K npo4 ecoopy MapKoBY - Bpaqy Ha3HaIJeHHoMY JJl II nOCTO llH­ Horo Ha6nIOneHH II 3a BepyroM - 3a pa3pellleHHeM YBHneTb BepYTa 190 - OmeTHTb Ha lTOT Bonpoc TPYnHO Ben Ka lKAYlO CHyYau HIO cnenyeT paCCMaTpHBaTb BO BceH ee cnO lKHOCTH JIerKo 3annaHHpo­ BaTb IITO-JIH60 3a ClOJIOM B Ka6HHeTe H C'lHTaTb IJlO HaiineHo CaMoe MYnpoe pellleHHe TpYnHee OCYIUeClBJI IITb nnaRbI Benb Ha HX OCY­ meClBJIeHHe BJIH IIeT MHOX eClBO 4 aKroPOB B TOM IJHcne H Me f lJyHa­ ponHl IX HalllllleClHJIeTHHH nnaH B HalJarIe O'leHb YMepeHHbIH npHllI­ nOCb nepeCMOTpen He nOTOMY IJTO HaM TaK XOTenOCb XOJIOnHa lI BOH­ Ha npHHYnKJIa HaC pacIIIHpHTb nporpaMMY BoopYX eHHH H H3MeHHTb OOOTHOllleHHe MeX nY CTaTb lIMH pacxonoB 'ITO npHBeJIO K CHHX eHHIO lKH3HeHHoro ypoBH lI a BcnencmHe noro - K HenOBOJIbcmy If re­ peK Tox e Mor 6bI cnPaBHTbC II C lKOHOMHlJeCKHM KPH3HCOM eCJIH 6bI He Mex nyHapOnaa ll 06CTaROBKa KOHKpemee 06mHH KpH3HC 191 MHpoBoro x031lHcma IIonbcKHH KpHlHC 6bIll CJle CTBHeM MHpoBO­ roo no 1975 r Bce KaK-TO llDlO H llDlO 6101 lIJIbwe eCJ1H 6101 He MHe npRllDlO TOr a B r0J10BY CJl0Be 0 npo i HJI peBan Tor a IJ TO OHO TaK paCOPOCTpaHHTCJI R O K eHHe He TonbKO B R H He nO 03­ BH en 3aKOCreHe­ npoH30llDla KaTaCTpo i a Ha 3ana e Ho OHa npoH30llDla H repeK He HHe 6IOPOKpaTH3aIJ H1O Mor paCCttHnmaTb HH Ha nOMomb HH Ha Kpe l HTbI HO H B nOnHTUqeCKOH KH3HH 3TH JlBneHHJI B03HHKnH B nepRo 06I1J eCTBeHHoH xonOJ HOH BOHHbI H3-3a HenOHHMaHHJI npou eCCOB npoHCXO l HB­ - Ho 8bl YT8epJlC MU liTO KanUTMUCTUileCKue KPU3UCbl He IIIHX B MHpe KaK-TO BeqepoM B pa3rOBOpe C KeHOH JI nonbITanCJI HaHTH nO 'xO JlllJ ee onpe eneHHe lJ JUI 3THX JlBneHHH 8 lUR IOT Ha nn aH080e COijUMUCTUileCKoe X03RUCT80 MHH neperpeBa Mbl npHllDlH K aTpo i HH HOCTH - He MornH He nOBnHJlTb R OT mneprep­ norepe qyBCTBHTeJlb­ npoqen oKJIa Ha 3Ty TeMY Ha eJlCb nOMOqf eJly Be b HaCTYJ1HIla nopa nepeMeH BCTan Bonpoc 0 nOBblllleHHH KHlHeHHO­ ro ypoBHJI HaceneHHJI IJ TO CTanO B03MO KHblM B pe3ynbTare 0CJ1a6­ - Ho 8bl YT8epxoMu liTO He 8 lUR IOT nemul Me K o yHapoJ HoH HanpJl KeHHOCTH nOCJ1e OKOHqaHHJI BOHHbI B OHH He BJ1HMH 6bI eCJ1H 6bJ MbI He 6bDIH CBJl3aHbI C KanaTa­ Kopee H 3aKJ1lOtJeHHJI BeHCKoro 'oroBopa 3TH npo6neMbl Mor­ J1HCTH'leCKHM MHpoM 3KOHOMHlftlCKH Ho Mbl Bcer a 6bDIH CBJl3aHbl J1H 6bITb pemeHbI eCJ1H 6bI HaIIIa rpynna B PYKOBO 'CTBe He pacna­ H HaM 6bDIO Ba I HO paClllHPJlTb 3TO COTpY l HHqeCTBO a He CBepTbl­ naCb H eCDH 6101 He npoH30WJIH co6b1THJ1 B II03HaHH KOTopbIe He­ - Ban ero HameH U eJ1blO 6bDIO palBHTHe TOproBblX OTHomeHHH co BceMH CTpaHaMH - He TonbKO co CTpaHaMH COlJ HanHCTHlftlCKOrO COMHeHHO 3aTOPM03ID1H OTreneJ1b H nOMeIIIaJlH pa3BHTHIO no nym HaMeqeHHOMY HaMH 6noKa HO H co CTpaHaMH 3ana a H Tpenero MHpa Mbl CTapa­ rOMYJlKa 8 J1HCb COXpaHJlTb ToprOBblH o60poT C COBeTCKHM COlO30M B npe e­ nax 30% H60 npH 60nbmeH ero one HanpHMep OKono lIJIO 6bI OTPHIJ aTeJ1bHbIe nOCJ1e CTBHJI - 40% 1970 z TOJICe He npeycne n 3TO npHBeno 6bl K 3KOHOMH­ lftlCKOH 3aBHCHMOCTH a 3areM H K nOJ1HTHlftlCKoH Be b TaKHe BemH - CTpenJlTb OH npHKa3aJ1 003 BCJlKOH Hy K bI OT CTpaxa OH nO-CBoeMy 3a60THIlcJI 0 IIOJ1bme • no caMoro na eHHJI OH 6bIll onpe enJlIOT rpaHHu bI caMOCTOJlTenbHOCTH Tenepb Ke MO KHO 6bl­ yOO K eH IJ TO COBepIDHII BenHKoe eno H OH eHCTBHTenbHO COBep­ no paccttHnmaTb Ha nOMOlIJ b TOnbKO C coBeTcKoH CTOpoHbl 3TO IDHII ero laKJ1lOttHB cornameHHe C BpaH TOM nonyqHTb JIJI IIOJ1bIDH ycyry6Hno onaCHOCTb KOTOpyro nbrranOCb npe OTBpaTHTb Hame rapaHTHH Ha Bna eHHe 3anaJ HblMH 3eMJ1J1MH 6bDIO ero Meqmii OH PYKOBO 'CTBO BnO KHJl B 3TO BCIO l H3Hb HeCOMHeHHO 'orOBOp C ClIpr - ero HCTO­ npyroi npHttHHOH nOJ1bCKOrO KpR3Hca JlBMeTCJI o60CTpeHHe pHqeCKaJI laCJ1yra Ho OH ee nepeOu eHHlI OHa BCKpY KHJIa eMy rOJ1Q­ He pemeHHblX paHee npo6neM He npoBe eHHble BOB peMJI pe i OPMbI BY H OH peIDHII qm eMy Bce n03BoneHO Ho TYT npoH30WJIO BbICTyD­ H3-la lToro 6bDIO YTpatJeHO OBepHe K neHHe Ha IIo6epe Kbe OKalanOCb qTO nlO l H COBceM He B BOCXHIIJ e­ MeTO aM PYKOBO CTBa HeCOMHeHHO Y HaC 6bDIH e i eKTbI H a Ke 'e i opMaIJ HJI OC06eHHO B nepHO xonO l HOH BOHHbl B B 1953 1949-1953 ro ax 60J1ee Bcero r Cneil YeT nOHJITb O llaKO qTO penpeccHH JI cornaceH H l HOTCKHe KOTopble HaqanHCb nOCJ1e CMepTH CTanHHa OObJlCHJI­ HHH OT Hero 3TO cnoMHIlO rOMynKY K TOMy Ke OH 3BOHKa OTTy a OH pacCttHTbman IJ TO ero no e T Ho HHKTO He n03BO­ HHJI rOMynKa 6bDI B OTqaJlHHH A TaM nonpocTy peIDHIIH IJ TO ero KapTa 6HTa H yxsaTHIlHCb 3a repeKa Ho H TOT OKalanCJI He TaKHM Y K J1HCb COqeTaHHeM He6naronpHJITHbIX 06CTOJlrenbCTB· r J P oxsaTHnH OOnbIDHM K03blpeM B 3TOM CKalanaCb nonHTHtJeCKaJI mynoCTb opra­ BOnHeHHJI H la6aCTOBKH BcobIXHYno Bep1IHHCKOe BOCCTaHHe B HHlaTOPOB r aHbCKHX H melJ HHCKHX OOcnOpJlil KOB y30CTb HX B3mJl­ IIonbme aKTHBH3HpoBanHCb Bpa K e6HbIe OB H HeyMeHHe ou eHHTb Bpe KOTOpblii OHH HaHeCJIH nonbme CHIlbl B Ha e K e qm Kapu EBponbl MO KeT H3MeHHTbCJI 3TH HaCTpoeHHJI no ep KH8anH lana Hhle pa l r HOCTaHlJ HH B OCOOOHHOCTH 192 CB060J HaJI EBpona HeyJICe nu A KTO OUlUOanCJI 8 l103HaHu 193 KaJ He TaM CWlbl lJ eHCTBOBaJIU MHe CY l HTb Tpy lJ HO TaM COl lJ 3JJaCb HanpJI liCeHHaJI 06CTaHOBKa OTCIOJJ a MOX HO C IJ eJIaTb Bbl­ B03BpaT CTapoH lIonbIlIU KOTOPaJI 6YJJ eT npoTHBOCTOJITb COBeTC­ BOJJ 'ITO BU lJ HMO cymeCTBOBaJIU CHJIbI 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIe B Har­ KOMY COlOlY· 06 nOM He rOBopHJIH OTKPbITO HO sa IIo OBHHY HJIU HeTIIHHH HaJIpJI lICeHHOCTH XOTJI 6bI Ha qeTBepTb no 6bUIa Ha lJ e Ha KaKYIO-TO KOHcppoHTa­ UHIO lIOJIbIlIU U COBeTcKoro COI03a - Bbl UMeeTe B BUOy opzaHbl oesonaCHOCTU - Pe'lb lU la oOoceoooJKi enuu He JJ YMalO KaK pa3 OHH HHKaK B nOM He 6bUIU 3aHHTepe­ COBaHbI TaK xre KaK U COBeTCKUH COI03 Ha060poT n03HaHbCKUe C06bITH fI nO lJ pbmaJIU e l HHCTBO napTHU KOTopoe 6bUIO OqeHb BaX Ho R PJIJI COBeTCKoro PYKOBO lJ CTBa • TorJJ a HaJIUCaJI nUCbMO Oxa6y nOTOMY 'ITO BCTpeTHTbCJI C HHM JI yxre He Mor OT lJ en• R JI 6bUI OTerpaHeH He OTPHlI aJI 'ITO B lI03HaHH lJ eHCTBOBaJIU CHJIbI KOHTppe­ - Jla A BCH HCTOPHH B fJJ aHbCKe Ha Cbe3 1J e COJIUJJ aPHOcm C B033BaHHeM K HaPOJJ aM COBeTCKoro 6JIOKa Ha 'ITO OHa 6bUIa pac­ C'lHTaHa Ha 'ITO eCJ H He Ha pa3BaJI CoBeTCKoro COlOla MO lKHO JIU 6bUIO Ha lJ eHTbCH 'ITO no CTepnJ IT tho no npomoTHT ' ePTOM KOMY no 6bUIO HY lKHo A A 3a KaKHM A IIOTOM Be lJ b n01l1l1H Ha 3TO BOJIIOlJ HH HO B oueHKe C06bITHH JI npUHHMaJI BO BHHMaJIHe MaCIlITa­ eme KPUllaJIU 3TO 6Y IJ eT nOCJ1eJJ HHH U peIlIHTeJIbHhIH BCllOMU­ 6bI HaIlIUX OIlIH60K H He lJ OBonbCTBa pa60qero KJIacca u60 3TH cpaK­ HaJIU HHTepaalJ HoHaJI ynapHeT KynaKoM no CTOlly TOpbl 6bUIH TaM peIlIalOmHMU• R npU3bmaJI Oxa6a K yeraHOBneHHIO BlauMonOHHMaHHJI C pa60'IHM KJIaCCOM 3TO n03Bo HJIO 6b1 OTbIC­ KaTb BbIXO lJ He TOJIbKO B lI03HaJIH CeHqaC KOHequo MOX HO pal lJ y­ - IloJ CQ lyiicTa He lleeCKUU HepeHU'IaUTe 3TO Oblll KapOllb Moose­ MblBaTb lJ OCTaTOquo nH 6b1CTPO 1l1l1U MbI no nyTH 06HOBJIeHHJI Hy H 'ITO C TOro 'ITO 3TO Cbill 3urMyHTa Cbill 3UrMyHTa H60 MbI HallaJIU 06HOBJIeHHe nyCtb He B CTporOM CMbICJle CJlOBa HO TaKUM nyTeM Ha KaKOH MbI 6bUIH Clloco6HbI MoX HO cnpaIlIU­ BaTb BepHO JIU MbI lJ enaJIU Ha KHMaJI Ha TopM03a lJ eHCTBYJI Me lJ ­ neHHO nOCTeneHHO pa3 1J enJIJI npouecc nHOOpanu3aunu Ha 3TanbI IIo'leMy MbI TaK noerynaJIu lIoTOMY 'ITO 60MHCb ro 'ITO B3PbillaJIOCb B CJI eme B 1954 1956 r lIonbIlIa - U 1980 60MUCb TO­ rOJJ ax a Momo 6bI B30pBatb­ ueJIbIH YHH'lTO lKeHUe COBeTCKUX KJIa IJ OOm u naMHTHHKOB 0 qeM KOMllJIeKC OxaoYTBepJlC aeT 'ITO 3TO OellQ l - Oxa6 C'lHTaeT TaK a H UHaqe• B3pbm HeCJlbIXaHHOH HeHaBHCTH - KaKux 3 1 blX OYX06 3TO A no rOBopuT A Be lJ b HHKTO noro He OpraHH30BbmaJI YHHqTO lKaJIH UX CTHXHHHO U B MaCCOBOM MaCIlITaOO 3TO JIIUHK IIaH lJ OPbI 3 1J eCb nerKO Bbl­ nyCTHtb 3JIbIX JJ YXOB HO 3arHaTb ux 06paTHo TPY IJ HO - TOxre MO lKeT lJ enatb mynoCTH lIapeHh OH HHteJIJIUreHTHbIH HO BnaJI B pa lK H la6bUI 060 BceM lIO bIlIa BeJ1UKaJI lJ ep lKaBHaJI CBeTOq Hapo lJ OB nOJIJIKU - H36paHHbIH Hapo lJ 3TH MHCPbI no-npe lK­ Hnu YEo R YTBep lO 'ITO no 6bUI BOT MHXHHK lIoqeMy MuXHHK BhICtynaeT npoTHB Rntbl qTO 6bl MbI lJ eJIaJIH 003 Rntbl qeM 6hl Mbi 6bIJIH CaMoe 6onbIlIoe _ HeMy l HByt B pa3HbIX CJ10JIX 06meCTBa npu06peTaJI Bee HOBbIe KHJI lKeCTBOM BapIlIaBCKUM CPOPMbI 06JIH'lbJI orreHKU KaK BbI JJ YMaeTe nOqeMY fOMynKa B H KaTaerpoCPHqeCKUH xapaKTep Mbl1l1l1eHHH KpaHHHX OHH He OTJJ aIOT 1956 r npu06pen TaKYIO nonynJIpHOCTb KaKOH HHKTO B nOCJ1eBOeH­ TYT-TO MhI U BUJJ HM HeJIoruqHOCTh ceOO oneTa B TOM 'ITO UX lJ eHCTBHH yrpo lKaIOT ueJIOCTHoeru lIon ­ HOH lIOJIbIlIe He UMeJ1 U npuIlIeJ1 K Bnacm 3ry nonYJIJIpHOerb no­ IlIU Be lJ YT K npeBpameHHIO ee B KHJI lICeCTBO BapIlIaBCKoe f lJ e lICe poJJ HJIO HMeHHO TO qero MbI 60Mucb U 'ITO HaC CKOBbillaJIO OH Heo­ ryT CMbICJI H 3TO BbIJJ aIOT 3a my60Koe nOJIUTH'leCKoe MbWUIeHHe KHJJ aHHO PJIJI ee6JI caM Toro He xreJIaJI npo6YJJ HJI HaJJ e KJJ bI Ha ECJIH 3TO MbWUIeHHe TO Bpe lJ HOe HHKYJJ a He BeJJ yIUee CBH IJ eTeJIbCT­ BYlOmee 06 POCTH ropu30HTa COJIHJJ aPHOCTH A Ha'IaJIOCh Bee C 194 195 OOaropoAHblX nopbmOB H u ymHX H3 3 opoBoro HCTOllHHKa OT 3 u 0­ poBbIX KopHeH - C HCIIpasneHHR OlIlHOOK C yTBep HHR HOBbIX npHHUHnoB A K lIeMY npHBeno K pa3iJYBaHHlO e 6bInO npHTHX­ lIlHX Me'ITaHHH 0 He3aBHCHMOCTH q 3CKoro TonKa He33 BHCH­ MOCTH nonyae3aBHCHMOCTH lIemepTbHe33 BHCHMOCTH H 'IepT 3HaeT lIero eme B pa3DH'lHbIX Kpyrax lTO BbIrnR enO no-pa3HOMY HO Bce He OT u aBaR ee6e B TOM OT'leTa nOlIInH KaK CTa u O Bene 3a HHTennH­ reHUHeH BOT HX n03HUHR n03HUHJI lIlHpoKHX KpyroB nonbCKoH HHTennHreHUHH BOT 3TO Bbl3bmaeT BO MHe 6onb Be b lTO nlOnH pa3YMHbIe paUHoHanbHo MblenlllLl He A KY u a OHH cTpeMnCJI K lie­ 3m perueHHeM Bonpoca COll 1arepb linH I e COI033 Ii nOTepillU nOpa l eHHe I10nbwa CTaHeT KHJJ I eCTBOM BapWaBCKHM BcnblXHeT TpeTbR MH­ poBU BOHHa H 6yneT YHH'ITO l eHa BCR EBpona HnH ee lIaCTb Jlpyrnx nepcneKTHB R He BH H He nOHHMaIO nOlleMY He BHnHT noro nonbCKoe o6nrecmo nOnbCKaH HHTennHreHl J lUl H CTapalOCb npo­ HHKHYTb B HX nCHxonorHIO H nOHJJTb lIero OHH KHDRTRTCR 3alleM OHH BOpoUIaT npownoe Ii npHxo Bce BpeMR K OJJ HOMY BbmoJJ Y pa3HbIe HenpHRTHOCTH orpaHHlIeHHH H oonRlIKH TaK 3aenOHJJIOT OT BTopoCTeneHHblX Ho OHH Bee YSIUVIT u on l Hb1 6YJJYT YSH u eTb MO l eT 6bITb e noene MoeH CMepTH 'ITO nOKa ena 06CTORT TaK He3a6UCUMOC1U a He HHalle Mbl 06pelleHbl cymecmOBaTb B 3TOH CHCTeMe - nOnbeTCB HH lJ TUJ Koro He MO l eT 6bITb HX none 3peHHR liTO OHH He MoryT OTnenHTb OCHOBHbIX npoOOeM MY Be u yT - K nOTpe6YlOT BbIClIlHe HHTepeCbI COBeTCKOrO KPOBb HaPO H30HneT KpoBblO fnynocTb KPHqHT HnHOTH3M lIHcTeHlIlHH HJJ HOTHlM Be u b Mbl l HBeM B u pyrYIO 3IIoxy B u PyroM BeKe I10ene nepBoH MHPOBOH BOHHbl MO I HO 6bDlO eme HMeTb H1IJ1103HUHH CTpoHTb nnaHbl TO l e He enHWKOM y u a'IHbIe KaK lTO enan IlHnCY CKHH Ho noene BTOPOH MHPOBOH BOHHbl lTO e CTano a6cyp u OM qTO-TO B MHpe H3MeHHnOCb HeY l enH Bbl 3Toro He BHJJ HTe HeT Y l e cyse­ Be MO I HO ynYlIUIaTb HcnpaBnRTb CMJIrlIaTb HO OHa 6y u eT cymecmOBaTb BMeCTO YCHnHH CBaJIHTb ee Ha u O ysenHlIHTb YCHnHJI u ml CnaCeHHJI I10nbIIlH TaKOH KaKOH MbI ee C03JJ anH co BeeMH HalIlHMH He u oe­ raTKaMH H OlIlH6KaMH - CHnbHOH I1onblIlH Ha O H36aBHTbCJI OT a6CYPAHbIX MHq OB H HepeaJIbHbIX Ha u e l l HOO OHH HJJ yT npoTHB 3aKOHOB npHpo bI peHHblX roCy u apCTB eCTb TonbKO nonyae33 BHCHMble CreneHb 3a­ BHCHMOCTH MO l eT 6bITb 60nbllIeH HnH MeHbweH HO OHa eCTb Beer u a - IlpoTU6 3aKOH06 npupOObl Hbmeumee n0J10JICeHUe 6ezqeU - Hy BOT onRn fOMynKa TO l e B KOHlle KOHIIOB nOHRn I10cMOTpHTe liTO u enaeT ClJpaHl J lUl CHnbHaH ClJpaHUHH MaHeBpHpyeT Ew e J e fonnlO xsarano CHnbl BonH H X8paKrepa 'IT06bl BeCTH ca­ MocTORTenbaylO nonHTHlIeCK 'IO nHHHIO HO MHTTepaa e nneTeTCB B XBOCTe HOO TaKOB MHp H no ene u yeT BH u eTb Ii yKnOHHTbCH OT noro Henb3H Hellero Ha lTO paCClIHTblBaTb Mblenb 0 TOM 'ITO Mbl ce6e yCH eMCB B yronKe OAHHM ynbI6HeMCR u pyrHM YCMeXHeM­ CR - 31'0 rnynocTb KOTOpaR CBHneTenbcmyeT 0 He3HaHHH reorpa­ q HH H 3DeMeHTapHblX OCHOB nOnHTHKH I10nbUIa MO l eT 6bITb nHOO npoCOBeTCKOH nuoo npoaMepHKaHCKOH pyrnx B03MO I HOCTeH HeT HeT KPH1IHT I10nbllIY Henb3R BblpBaTb H3 COBeTCKoro 000­ Ka Be u b ecnu BblpBaTb TO r u e ee nOMeCTHTb Ha nyae I10nbUIa ne l lfT Me I JJY COBeTCKHM COI030M H 3anaAHOH EBponOH H nono­ l eHHe ee HCHO HnH - HnH HeT npoMe TO'IHbIX KpaCOK B B03 u y­ xe ee He nOBecHWb 061 eKTHBHaH peaJIbHOCTb TaKOBa liTO eenH AMepHKe y u aCTCR C03 u aTb 3 u eCb raKoe 6po l eHHe '1m HaC CBepr­ HyT TO TorJJ a eCTecmeHHO npoH30HneT HHTepBeHl J lUl H60 nora 196 'ITO TOJ1bKO H1IJ1I03HH cnnomnu nonHKOB BOKpyr Hero MO l eT 6blTb OH nOHJIJ1 lTO He cpa3y MO l eT 6blTb nonHoCTbIO lTO u owno O Hero nHWb B 1957 a TO H B 1958 r He 3HaIO Ho MHe Ka l eTCR 'ITO 'IaCTH'lHoe nOHHMaHHe npHwno K HeMY Y l e BO BpeMR MHTHHra Ha nnom IIapa u OB BeeHapoAHbIH MHTHHr B nOMep I KY HOBoro Kypca COCTORBWHHCH noene 1956 r VIII nneayMa UK I10PII B OKTH6pe I1pHMellaHHe nepeBO lIHKa BepoHTHo OH 6bIn nOTpJI­ ceH HOO nOHJIJ1 D BOHCmeHHocTb CBoero nonO l eHHR C OnHOH CTa­ poHbl OH OT u aBan ee6e OT'leT B TOM 'ITO KaKHe-TO 6aPbePbl PYXHY­ J1H Ho OH nOHHMan TaK I e 'ITO pa3pbm 6y eT paClIlHpnbCJI H OH­ neT u o TOro 'ITO no u yrP03y 6y u eT nOCTaBneHa BCH CHCTeMa eno­ l HBWaHCH noene BTOPOH MHPOBOH BOHHbl KOTOpaH 1tBnHeTCR OC­ HOBOH Hawero BnaneHHH 3aDaJJ HbIMH 3eMDHMH H Bcero Hawero ro­ cyJJ apcmeHHoro 6bITHH Be b 'ITO HallaJIOCb OJJ HH nuWb paCCy l u aJ1H 197 KTO XOpollIHH nmUIK a KTO - HeT HO lJ pyme CTaIIH lleHCTBOBan O IJ HH KpH'WlH lITO OHH XOTJIT BOCKpeCHTb HaD HOHanbHYIO lJ eMO­ KpaTHIO lJ pyme XOTeJIH BOCCTaHOBHTb napTHIO TpY lJ a TpeO manH TaKHX peipOPM H lTaKHX pecpOpM fOMynKa paCTepMCJI OH CTan nOnpaBJIJITb caMora eefiJI HHor D a npaBHJIbHO HHor lJ a HeT HOO Y Hero He XBaTanO t 'TbJI H nOHHMaHHJI KaK OT IJ eJIHTb O IJ HO OT lJ py­ roro A nOCKOJIbKY MbICJIHJI OH Y3KO TO OecnpepbmHO coBepwan OllIHOKH K TOMY lKe OH He o6JIa D aJI TanaHTOM OpraHHlaTOpa HMeJI MHO Kecmo He lJ OCTaTKOB ObD1 CJ1HWKOM caMOYBepeH H qpe3Mep­ HO BepHJI B apHq MeTHqeCKHe paCqeTbI OH OTTOJIKHYJI OT eeOJI HeCKOJIbKHX YMHbIX npe D aHHbIX napTHH nlO IJ eH no-rnynoMY OOM­ CJI CTapoH HHTeJIJIHreH lJ HH H WeJI Ha OOOCTpeHHe KYpca 3a e'leT peq OpM A noqeMY 1-13 OOJI3HH H3-3a onaceHHH H3'3a TOro qTO nOTepJDl rOJIOBY B KOHUe KOHUOB lJ 0 Hero lJ oumo OKOHtJ ayeJIbHO qTO nO lJ HJlJIaCb BOJIHa CTpeMlIeHHJI K He3aBHCHMOCTH KOTOPYJO HY l HO C IJ ep KaTb HOO eCllH He o lJ OJIeTb ee OHa ero 3aXJIeCTHeT KaK OKeaH KaKHe-TO nepeMeHbI HO Y HHX He ObIJIO TaKoro rnYOOKoro nOTpJI­ eeHIfJI KaK Y HaC BeHrpbI rrOTepHJIH nOClle BOHHbI TpaHCHJIbBaHHIO 3Ta 3aH03a CH lJ HT B HX D yWax BepoJITHO lJ 0 CHX rrop HO 3aTO OHH MHoro rrpHoopenH - HeKOTOpylO la KRTO'IHOCTb YCTOH'lHBOCTb I1c­ TOpllJI PYMbIHHH TO lKe He CTOJIb lJ paMaTHlJ Ha KaK Hawa MbIoopeqe­ HbI BJIa'IHTb Ha ITJIeqax orpoMHbIii rpY3 CBoero TblC IIlJ eJIeTHero orrbI­ Ta npouecc pa3pbma C Tpa D HUWlMH YCBoeHHe HOBblX q OPM He MO­ KeT OblTb JIerKHM He MO l eT H IJ TH rna IJ Ko H nOCTerreHHO HeH30e K­ HbI nOTp llCeHIfJI KOTopbIe B TOH HJIH HHOH q OPMe OY D yT BpeM II OT BpeMeHH BbIXO IJ HTb Hapy K ' nOBTOpHTbC II TeM ooJIee lITO lJ 0 CHX rrop KRBbl Bce 3TH JIreJIJIOHCKHe MellTaHHH 0 BeJIHKOH 3KcnaHCHH Ha BOCTOK KOTopble H3BeCTHbI HaM H3 POMaHOB CeHKeBHtJ a OHH l HBYT B C03HaHHH rrOJI IIKOB rrOTOMY lITO HX JIeJIeMH B pa3HbIX CIlO llX o6mecma Bee nOKOJIeHIfJI BocnHTaHbI Ha lTHX H lJ e llX H rrpo­ lJ OJI KaIOT BOCnHTbmaTbCH Ha HHX Ke HecMoTp ll Ha Bee YCHJIH II C HaweH CTOpoHbI nepeqepKHYTb lTO O lJ llHM MaXOM HeB03MO I H0 3Toro HeJIb3 11 HcnpaBHTb caMbIMH JIOBKO HanHCaHHbIMH yqeOHHKaMH HCTOPHH H CTaTb llMH npaB D a II H He ymep l D alO lITO HaITHcaHHoe - H 00 KaKUX nop ebl Hf1 M epeeaeTeCb C31UM 6oporbCJl ObIJIO lJ OCTaTO'IHO yMHO HaBepHHKa ene lJ OBano ObI MeHbwe lJ eHCT­ BHTeJIbHbIX q aKTOB laManlJ HBaTb Ho pacC'lHTbmaTb Ha TO lITO TOT - 1160 H 100 JIeT eCJ1H nOHa lJ OOHTCJI HO 3TO HY l HO o lJ OJIeTb 6heT KYJlaKOM no croJlY HJIH HHOH palrOBOp q HJIbM HJIH KHHra la 30-40 JIeT MOryT H3MeHHTb C03HaHHe CIlo I HBweec II BeKaMH ObDIO ObI HITJII03HeH KaKOH'HH' oy IJ b ytJ HTeJIb Mor BnaCTb B pa30qapoBaHHe eCllH ero YCHnH II He lJ a­ - Ho eeOb U 3a 150 He OOoJI IlU D yT l eJIaHHbIX pe3ynbTaTOB CIlytJ HTbCJI - Ho O lJ eJIeeM KPH'IHT Hapo lJ lJ OJI lKeH BJIHTbCJI B HOBble Ho Be lJ b Cpa3y TaKOro He MO KeT BeplO B MarHlJ eCKOe B03 1J eHCTBHe enOB - rrpOJIBHTbCH - q OpMbl KR3HH HeOOXO IJ HM nepenOM KaKOrO eme He 0bD10 B ero 150 JIeT pOCCHHCKoro ymeTeHIfJI H OOPbObl C POCCHeH HeJIerKO BbIlJ epKHyn H3 naMJITH 3TO OCTaBHJIO rnyooKHe CIle lJ bI B Hapo lJ llOM C03HaHHH HH Y O lJ llOH CTpaHbI HeT TaKOrO HC­ TOpHqeCKOrO onblTa KaK Y Hac B 3TOM OTHOIDeHHH HH qeXH HH BeHrpbI HH PYMblHbI He MorYT CpaBHHTbCJI C HaMH qeXH nepe I HJIH 198 1160 BbIrO lJ b1 HOBOH CHCTeMbI npoHBHTC II - EcJIH lJ OJI l HbI He YHHIlTO KRT Hac aTOMHaH BoiiHa H Mbl Bee He KaHeM B JIeTY TO HaCyYnHT HaKOHeu KOHe'IHO lITO ObI Hapo lJ npHHJDl HOBbIe ueHHOCTH HHbIe TbICJIlJ eJIeTHeH HCTOpHH I e II lJ eHCTBHH B KOHe'IHOM ClJ eTe rrpHHeeeT pelYJIbTaT H C03 D aCT HOBoe C03HaHHe Y nOJI IIKOB -Her 11 Bee YOe l lJ eH lITO COBOKynHOCTb noene lJ OBaTeJIbHO H YMeJIO rrpoBO IJ H­ MbIX HaMH 410 pMbI llOJI lKeH H He rrepeJIOM B HX MbWIJIeHHH lITO npll D aCT eMY HOBoe CO lJ ep KaHHe H KalJ eCmo 11 TOr D a MbI KOMMYHHCTbI CMO KeM npHBeCTH B lJ eHCTBHe Bee npHHIJ Hnbl lJ eMOKpaTHH qero Tenepb Mbl C IJ eJIaTb He MO l eM HOO lTO 3aKOHlJ HTCJI HallIHM nop eHHeM H YCTpaHeHHeM MO KeT ObITb no rrpoH30H IJ eT qepe3 50 JIeT MO l eT ObITb Qepe3 100 H He XOTeJI ObI npopoQeCmOBaTb HO H ysepeH lITO Kor D a-HHOY IJ b 3TO npoH30H D eT Hepeeoo BaOUMa MeHUKepa 199