MOX HO O l H tUlTh BOHIlYT BeChMa YCMHTC II eC1lH fOpOOqeB pennlr­ CH Ha yCrynKH HHaKOMhIC1I IIIIlHM B TOH CHryaJJ HH B KOTOPOH HaXOIlH1IHCb 3TH nOC1lellHHe C'lHTan H OHH BOCnpHMYT 3TO nOJIO l 8­ reJIhHO no KpaHHeH Mepe cnepBa qro JIOrHqeCKH npHBeJJ eT K CY­ llUTep Peooae lU IIleCTBeHHOMY ocna6neHHIO KOHrpo1I II B o6naCTH KYJIbTyphI lleMO­ paJIH3YIOIIlaH yTe'IKa BhIllalOIIlHXCH TanaHrOB Ha 3anall - BC1IellcmHe 3MHrpaJlHH H no6eroB - cran a HaIJ HOHa1lbHOH npo6neMoH 0 1 8­ llalOIIleH Korna 3a Hee B03bMeTC II CMeJIbrH nOJIHTHK llO BmHCbrOPBAqEBA Y HhIHeumeH COBerCKOH CHryaJJ HH eCTb H OnaCHaH cropoHa llOJI l HOCTH o KHHI'e Shadows and Whispers Power MHOrHX BJIH IITeJIhHhIX tmeHOB npaBHIIlero KJIacca HOMeHKJIarypbl OKa3aJIHCb nOll yrpo30H nOCKOllhKY fop6aqeB Politics Inside the Kremlin from Brezhnev to Gorbachev by Dusko Doder Random House pp 339 3aXOqeT OTnaTh 3TH nOCThI CBOHM CTopoHHHKaM HJIH noroMY 'ITO pe$OpMhI 0 KOTOPhIX OH KOHe'IIHO Ke IlYMaer Moryr CKOPO npH­ BeCTH ero K MhIC1lH Bo06I1le OrMeHHTh HeKoTOpble 1l0JI l HOCTH MH y6paTh 3aHHMaIOIIlHx 3TH 1l01l I HOCTH CeHqaC KaK HecoomeTcmylO­ IIlHX HOBhIM 3anaqaM If 3ro 06CTOHrellbCTBO H paJl HKWlH3M PH­ TOpHKH rop6a1leBCKOH pe POPMhI npHBeJIH K C03 naHH1O o60poHH­ reJIbHOH KOaJIHII HH KOHcepBaTopoB H peaKIJ HOHepoB BCJIellCTBHe OceHblO 1985 rona II Ha 3THX CTpaHHllaX l BblCKa3aJI npenno- noro 6yJJ eT oqeHb TpYIlHO npHcrynHTh K oCYIIleCTBlIeHHIO onTH­ 1I0 KeHHe t1TO COBeTcKHH COI03 B03MOX H0 Ha'IIHeT MeHHTb CBOH MHCTH1IeCKOH nporpaMMbl 06PHCOBaHHOH MHOIO H ellle TpYllHee ee KYPC' BhmOJIHHTb HaH60JIee BepO llTHblM HCXOlloM oCTporo KOH pJIHKTa Ero pyKoBO IJ HTe1lH MorYT pennlTb qyBCTBoBan II tITO 3KOHOMH1IeCKHH nporpecc BaX Hee qeM yrplOMoe llennJIHHe 3a Ka­ Me l Jly CTOPOHaMH 6Yller KaK II nHcan HeKOToporo pona no6e· KYIO-lIH60 P0PMY n01lHlleHcKoro KOHTpon ll B TO BpeM ll KaK HX no­ na - lIHTH1IeCKaH lIemTHMHOCTb nOCTeneHHO y6hIBaeT H B03MO I HO 'laCTH'lHaH H HenoC1lelloBareJIbHaH - pe P0PMHCTC­ BblCKa3aJI KHX CHJ1 OllHaKO CTOPOHHHKH fOpOOqeBa Moryr H He npeycneTb npennOllO KeHHe 'ITO fop6aqeB 6YIleT npollOll l aTb yCH1IH II no YCTpaHeHHIO HaH60nee HenpHMHpHMhIX K ero KYPCY O pHJJ HllJlb­ B oCYIIleCTB1IeHHH CBOHX 3aMhIC1IoB H B HTore yrpaTHTh B1Iacrb B HblX lIHIl C KJIlOqeBblX 1lO1IX HOCTeH a 3aTeM C03 naB nnlpoKHH nOJIb3Y COnepHHqalOllleH ppaKII HH Qepe3 nOJIropa rolla C06hITH II noxo l e pa3Bopa'IHBaIOTC II KPyr CTOpoHHKKOB Ha'IIHeT nporpaMMY pe P0PM llOXO Ke OH OC03HaeT 'ITO 3KOHOMH1IeCKaH pecpopMa He CMO KeT 6hITh 3 P p eK - OlleHHTb HhIHe1IIH101O cHryauHlO H nOCTaBlfTh HOBbIe BonpoCbI MO l eT THBHOH 6e3 conyTcmYlOIIlHX eH 06I1leCTBeHHblX H nOllHTHqeCKHx pe pOPM ll03TOMY COBeTCKHe cneIJ HaJIHCThI MomH 6hI reneph 60JIee MH MeHee B HaMeqeHHOH MHOH TOrna nOC1leIlOBaTeJIbHOcTH nOMOIfb KHHra UyllIKo llOllepa H Ilpymx aBTOpoB OCBeIllalOlllHX pa3JIH'llHhIe yrOJIKH KpeM1leBCKOH cu eHhI B 80-e rollhI 2 HaJJ e llThCH Ha 601lee KOHCTpyKTHBHhIe OTHOllIeHHJt C rOp6aqeBCKHM CaMble HHTepeCHhIe H3 B03RHKnnlX renepb BonpoCOB raKOBbl pe l 8MQM KOaJIHIJ H II CTOpoHHKKOB pe P0PM B KOropYIO OHH KaK CYMeeT JIH fop6aqeB Oma I HhrH 1l000TbC1f ycnexa raM rile npoBa­ J1HJ1CH XpYIlleB HeYCTpallIHMbIH llocTaro'IIHo JIH CHJ1bHa KOWlHIJ HH fop6aqeBa t1T06hI pa3pa60Tarb BHellPHTh H npoBeCTH lleHCTBeHHble pe P0PMhI coomeTcTBYIOIIlHe BhIIlBHraeMblM renepb pallHKWlhHbIM fio-aHrnHil cKH CTaTlo1l I5lollla Haneq8TaH8 B lICypHane The York Review of Books 200 OT 28 Mall 1987 r New npe 1 IO KeHHHM llpoqHa JIH ero JIH'lHaH BJIaCTb llOJI KeH JIH 3anall KaK-TO nOMOqh eMY H eC1lH Ila TO KaK 201 Jlonep paCCMaTpHBaeT BCe 3TH BOnpoCbI KpoMe nOCJIe IJ Hero ern HH p0PMa u HH Jlonep 60JIee Beero omapameH TeM qro npeeM­ OR B CBOeH HHTepecHoH u eHHOH H caM06bITHOH KHHre TeHH H menOT HHKOM AHnponOBa CT3Jl lIepHeHKo no nOHRTHbIM npH'lHHaM MHorHe ero OTBeTbI aM6HB3JleHTHbI OH HOro annapaTa Ha MeCTaX KOTopbm npe IJ IIoqen 6e30llaCHOro lIep­ Henoo u eHHJ1 CHJ1y napmH­ HCKpeHHe eJIaeT ycnexa fop6aqeBY HO KOr ll a nOT Cepne'IHbm no­ HeHKO PHCKOBaHHOMY 6ynyw eMY npenCTaBJIeHHoMY fop6alJeBbIM pbm 3aBO IJ HT ero CJIHIDKOM naneKO pa3YM OMpaqaeT ero Ha IJ eJlC lJ bI npaBna Kor ll a Jlonep OTBa I HJIC Il ompaBHTbCJl B npoBHHIJ HKl TO COMHeHHRMH H KaK OH caM llHmeT orpoMHOCTb H CJIO I HOCTb CTpaHbl npoRCHHJIH 1981 1986 CKenTHUH3MOM TaK 0 nJlTHJ1eTHeM nepHOne C ron B OCHOBHOM npoBe lJ eHHOM HM B MOCKBe B Ka­ Moe npenCTaBJIeHHe 0 CJIO KHOCTH MHCCHH fop6aqeBa Ho u eHTpoM I Kpyr030pa Jlonepa no-npe l HeMY OCTaB3JlaCb MocKBa OH M3JlO 'ITO 6bIJI CBHneTeJIeM CMeHbI BJIaCTHTeJIeH 3aeeB1llHX B OKonax HOBbIM MO l eT CKa3aTb H 0 BOCTO'IHOH EBpone KpoMe TOro 'ITO B CB Il3H no qeCTBe PYKOBo IJ HTeJIJl 6KlPO BaIDHHrTOH nOCT OH llHmeT nOKOJIeHHeM eJIaKlW HM pe4l0pM fop6aqeB HaMepeBaeTCJl MOnep­ C HeH YCHJIHBaeTCJl nOJIHTHqeCKHH pHCK 3KOHOMHqeCKOH pe pOpMbI HH3HpoBaTb CTpauy H neCTaJIHHH3HpoBaTb ee nOJIHTHqeCKYKl H 3KO­ B CCCP HOMHqecKYKl CHCTeMY B nOM MeCTe KaK pa3 Korna y Hero npo­ EBpona 6yneT CKJIOHHa nOCJIenOBaTb 3a HHM KaK nOKa3bmaeT He­ pbmaeTCJl HOTKa 3H pOpHH Jlonep Bnpyr llHmeT BpeMJI nOKa eT naBHJl ll HCTOPH ll pe3ynbTaTbI Moryr 6bITb nOTeHIJ H3JlbHO pa3pyum­ cnOC06eH JIH OH nOn'IHHHTb CHCTeMY CBOHM u eJIJlM TeJIbHbIMH ECJIH pa IJ HK3JlbHO H3MeHHTC Il COBeTCKHH COKl3 BoCTO'IHaJI aM6HB3JleHTHOCTb Jlonep lJ aeT RpKHe nOpTpeTbI Beex qeTblpex COBeTCKHX JIHne­ YCHJ1HBaeTCJl HeCOMHeHHO npo u ecc H3MeHeHHH••• 6yneT nponOJI­ poB npH KOTOPbIX OH 6blJ1 B MOCKBe EMY nOBe3JIO B3 1lTb HHTepBbKl Ha 3aKJIKl'IHTeJIbHbIX CTpaHH u aX KHHrn l 3TbCR B HanpaBJIeHHH onpeneJIeHHOM fop6aqeBbIM HeCOMHeH­ Y lIepHeHKo HO HaH60JIee nOJIHbIM H caM06bITHbiM H3 Beex lJeTbl­ HO Bee HOBbIe JIKl IJ H 6ynyr BbI J BHraTbCJl Ha nepe IJ HHH llJIaH eCJIH pex OKa33JlC Il nOpTpeT AHnponOBa - HMllyJIbC H3MeHeHHH He HCCJlKHeT Ha 45 BeCbMa 3anOMHHaKlW HXC Il CaMaJI u eHHaJI 'laCTb KHHrH cTpaHH u ax Jlonep npenCTaBHJI Ho npo6rreMbI Bee ew e orpoMHbl H B03MO KHO HenOnDeMHbl n u aTeJIbHO npoBeneHHbm H 'IeTKO HallHcaHHbm aH3JlH3 'ITO xapaK­ B 3TOH CTpaHe ••• He06bIKHOBeHHO KOHeepBaTHBHoe 06w eCTBO H H3­ repHO IJ JI Il BceH ero pa60Tbl OH 3aBOeB3Jl nOBepHe npY3eH H pon­ MeHHTb HallpaBJIeHHe ero lJ BH I eHHR HeJIerKO B npolWIOM OHO non­ CTBeHHHKOB HenaBHO yMep1llHX COBeTCKHX PYKoBo IJ HTeJIeH H co6p3Jl 'lHHRJIOCb B OCHOBHOM CHJ1e B 3TOM llJIaHe fop6aqeB npenCTaeT y HHX u eHHyKl HH POPMaUHKl C nOMOW bKl HHryHUHH H onbITa o u e­ no'ITH TparnqeCKOH pHrypoH ••• BbI30B 6pomeHHbIH HM MO l eT OKa­ HHJ1 TO'IHOCTb Tex lJ aHHblX KOTOpbIe OH He Mor npoBepHTb H 3aTeM 3aTbCJl qpe3MepHbIM H caMoHaneRHHblM fop6aqeB Ha'l3Jl KaK eepbe3­ ony6rrHKOB3Jl Hbm pe4l0PMaTOp HO OH MO eT CTaTb aBTOKpaTOM eCJIH yHaCJIenO­ HCTO'lHHKH TaK Jlonep HapHCOB3Jl 06pa3 AHnponoBa - CBOH H3bICKaHH Il He paCKpbma ll BaHHbIe HM npo6neMbI OKa I fTCR HenO ll aTJIHBblMH H eCJIH HCCJlKHeT HOH H npoTHBope'IHBOH JIH'lHOCTH COqeTaBmeH xpa6pocTb C po_ 3HeprnR ero CTOPOHHHKOB H OCJIa6eeT HX nO lJ lJ ep I Ka HbmelIIHeMY 6ocTbKl npocBew eHHOCTb KpeMJIeBCKOMY PYKOBonCTBY 6ecnow a IJ HocTb C Be l JlHBOCTbKl ynoPCTBO CJIHmKOM CBOH 3aranoq­ C 06CKYpaHTH3MOM H peaKUHOHHOCTbKl co CJIa60CTbKl 3TO Jlonep 6rreCTJlIIJ e BCKpbmaeT nOJIHTHqeCKHe KOH pJIHKTbI B nOpTpeT maBbI TaHHOH nOJIHIJ HH TpaBHBmero lJ HCCUneHTOB H llH­ napTHHHOM pYKOBOnCTBe OH BeJIHKOJIenHO tlyBCTByeT 'ITO npenCTaB­ CaBmero CTHXH CBoeH eHe H npY3b llM 0 IJ H0 H3 3THX CTHXOTBope­ JIRKlT co60H TaKHe KJIKlqeBbIe PHrypbl KaK AHnponOB y Hero CBOH HHH B3DIRn Ha npoHcxonm u ee B MOCKBe Ho OH yneJI IleT CJIHIDKOM MHO­ 'ITO AHnponOB 6bm He JIHmeH n03THqeCKOrO tlyBCTBa H HCKyeeH B paKCHMHJIe KOTOPOro npHBO IJ HT Jlonep CBH lJ eTeJIbCTByeT ro BHHMaHHR nOJIHTHKe B YIIJ ep6 npo6JIeMaM o6w ecTBa H KyJIbTy­ CTHXOCJIO l eHHH B HeCKOJIbKO CTapoMO IJ HOM CTHXOTBOpeHHH 0 He­ pbl JIH'IHOCT IlM - B YIIJ ep6 aH3JlH3Y CHCTeMbI H MOCKBe B03MO I HOCTH IJ JI Il Hero npHH llTb HneKl CMepTH AHnponOB numeT CTpaHe B u eJIOM He roBOp ll Y l e 0 BeeH COBeTCKOH HMllepHH B YIIJ ep6 nOCJIenCTBH Il TaKOrO non XO ll a HeO IJ H03Ha'IHbI non BJIH IlHHeM pa pHHHpoBaHHbiX MOCKBHqeH KOTopbIe 6bIJIH DIaBHbIMHCTO'lHHKOM 202 Ho B 'laC nO lOJfCeHHblU U Jl KaK Bce YMPY H nD MJlTb 000 MHe COTpeT ceiJaJl JIeTa 203 TOHKHe 3apHCOBKH xapaKTepoB C J enaHHble nO J epoM MorYT C03p aTh Y lIHrarenH Bne'lllmeHHe 'Iro nH'lHOCTb PYKOBO J HTenH cronb Ba lCl a B no COBeTCKOH nOnHTHKe KaK B HOBYIO npo J oBonbcTBeHHYIO nporpaMMY 'IT06bI 3aBepHTb Haeene­ HHe 'ITO npe lJ lIpHHHMaIOTCH IIIarH J l1H CMHr'leHHH npo6neMbI 3ana J HbIX J eMOKpaTHHX XOTH HHorp a nO J ep CCbIDaeTCH Ha HuKHTY XpymeBa HH OH He TaK KaK caM nO J ep nOCTOHHHO nO J 'lepKHBaeT 6Y J yIIIHH HH J PyrHe KOMMeHTaTopbI He OCTaHaBnHBalOTCH Ha 3HaMeHaTenbHbIX COBeTCKHH BO K l b He MO eT cnHIIIKOM paCKpbmaTh CBOH JIH'lHble napannenHX Me K J y XpymeBbIM H fop6a'leBbIM KOHe'IHO Me K J y Ka'leCTBa nOKa He J OCTHr caMOH BepllIHHbI fop6a'leB HanpHMep HHMH MHoro pa3JIHlIHH HO CXO J CTBO TeMDepaMemOB H 06CTOH­ Ho npoH3HOCHJI CKyqHble H HY J Hble pellH Korp a 6bID Mna u urnM 'DIe­ TenbCTB npH KOTOPbIX H TOT H J pyrOH npHIIIJIH K KOPMHJIY BnaCTH HOM IIonHT61Opo HO TeM He MeHee Bcero 'Iepe3 MeCH nocne CBoe­ a TaK Ke CTpaTerHH npHHHTOH HMH J l1H npeO J oneHHH yHacne J OBaH­ ro Ha3Ha'leHHH Ha nOCT reHeeKa OH 06HapY KH I nopa3HrenbHOe opa­ HOH HHepTHOCTH J eHCTBHTenbHO nopa KaeT KaKOBbI e ropcKoe MacTepcrno O'leBH J HO OH C03HaTenbHO CKpbman CBOH crryqae IIIaHCbI npHpo J HbIH J ap B Te'leHHe npe J llleCTBYIOI I UfX neT no KOH a 1985 cBeprHYTbIM 'Iepe3 HeCKonbKO rop a OH He Mor HanO lCl Tb Ome'lllTOK CBoeH nH'lHOCTH Ha KpeMneBC­ BopoTa Koe PYKOBO J CTBO enH OH He Mor nocne CBoero H36paHHH npHBeCTH C co60H HOBYIO a J MHHHCTp lO KaK no 6bIDO 6bI Ha 3ana J e a fop6a'leBa H36e KaTb neT B pe3ynbTaTe CTanH nH np06neMbI CCCP 30 neT B TaKOM cY J b6bI XpymeBa - 60nee 6bITb J BOp OBOro nepe­ HacymHbIMH eeH'IllC He­ Ha3a J ECTh nH CBH J eTenbCTBa 'ITO nOMep KKa rop6a­ 'IeBCKOH cMenoH HO PHCKOBaHHOH cTpaTerHH - MO J epHH3a H 'Ie­ J omKeH 6bID 6opoThCH 3a Ka K l Oe nOHH eHHe H nOBbllIIeHHe qro pe3 J eMoKpaTH3a 1O H rnaCHOCTb CHJIbHee 'IeM TIl KOTOPOH pacno­ KacaeTcH AH J ponOBa roT J on eH 6bID J eMOHCTpHpoBarb 6e3ycnOB­ naran J eHCTBOBaBIIIuH no CXO J HOH cTpaTerHH XpymeB Cnoco6eH HYIO nOAAbHOCTb Epe lCl eBY B Te'leHHe B 1982 15 neT a Korp a OH HaKOHe ro J y 3aHAA ero MeCTO H Mor paCKPbITbCH 6bIDO n03 J H0 nH fop6a'leB HaMHoro 06paJoBaHHbIH H MeHee nopbIBHCTbIH UenblO XpymeBa nocne Y J yIIIalOmeH Hen008UJlCHOCTU nocne J ­ OH YMHpan nO J ep 60nee npeB30HTH B ycnexax CBoero npe J IIIecrneHHHKa CTpeMHTCH K om eKTHBHOCTH B CBOHX nOnHTH'IeCKHX HHX neT lCl 3HH CTanHHa 6bIDO CHOBa XOTen npHBeCTH CTpaHY B J BH Ke­ aHanH3ax OH He Y J ep IQfBaeTCH OT npHMonHHeHHbIX KOMMeHTapHeB HHe OH onHCbIBaeMbIX C06bITHH OC06eHHO B Tex cnyqaHX Korp a nlO J H 3a­ BHHMaHHH MHPOBOH peBonlO H H 60nbIIIe nap a npoHBnHIOT HaHBHOCTb B EHJInH fp3Ma B MOCKBY B 1982 YKpenHTh 3KOHOMHKy H 06mecTBo MeHbIIIe - Y J enHTb coxpaHeHHIO MHpa o eHKe COBeTCKOH CHCTeMbI BH3HT ynyqIIIH1I OTHOIIIeHHH paKTH'IeCKH CO BeeMH HHOCTpaHHbIMH J ep Ka­ ro J y TaHHO OpraHH30BaHHbIH KfE BaMH TaKaH CTpaTerHH n03BonAAa KaK OH Ha J eAACH OXpaHHTb O J HH H3 TaKHX nO J p06HO OnHCaHHbIX HM 3nH30 J OB Bo BpeMH BnaCTb napTHH H cnY K6 fp3Ma epKBH 6bIJIH 3a6HTbI o p epaMH KfE - Korp a 3KOHOMHKa H 06meCTBO OKpeDHyr pacnpoCTpaHHTb KOMMY­ MonO J bI­ YKpeDHTb 060poHocnoco6HoCTb CCCP 'IT06bI MH rna u Ko BbI6pHTbIMH CTOHBIIIHMH cnoKoHHo H BbIITIH J eBIIIHMH HH3M 3a rpaHHIIeH CHJIOH npHMepa T e onHpa1 ICb Ha Ha60 lCl o fp3M c J enan cHTya 1O eme OHHble 3aHBHJI Ha npecc-KoH pepe H 'ITO 60nee He rpoTecKHoH Korp a BCTpernn orpaHH'IeHuH MeTO J bI 60nee qT06bI nerHTHMH3HpoBaTh HOBYIO Tpa J H­ CTpaTerHIO H M06HJIH30BaTb HaeeneHHe Ha ee ocymeCTBneHHe XpymeB nepe­ BH3HTa CMOTpen MapKCHCTCKo-neHHHCKYIO H J eonOrHlO nO J po6HO pacnHcaB MbI Bee 6bIDH B36eIIIeHbI 3THM ero JaMe'laHHeM TaK KaK COBeTbI no CTa J HHM nyrb K KOMMYHH3MY OH an HaeeneHHIO MHO KeCTBO CBo60 J bI penHrHH B Te'leHHe CBoero IIIeCTH J HeBHoro K penHrHH CTHMynOB yBenHlIHB 3apa60THylO unaTY npHHHB Bne'lamHlOmylO fp3M BbICKa3an npe lJ lIonO KeHHe 'ITO PYCCKHe nHTaIOTCH nporpaMMY KH IHIIJ HOrO CTpoHTenbCTBa YCOBepIIIeCTBOBaHHH 3 J pa­ COBepIIIeHHO OTKPbFrO roBOpHT 0 CBoeH onn03H H 3areM nY'lIIIe aMepHKa eB CKa3aB MHe J aBanH HKPY 3 J eCb nO'lTH K BooxpaHeHHH H 06pa30BaHHH Ka K l OMY 3aBTpaKY 06e J y H y KHHy nO J ep KOMMeHTHpyeT Hble 3a C'IeT YBenH'IeHHH npoH3BO J HTenbHOCTH TPYp a H COKpameHHH OnepaTHBHHKH KfE HaXO J HBIIIHeCH B aY J HTOpHH J on lCl o 6bITb 6bIDH nonbmeHbI B TO B peMH HeXBarKa npo J OBonbCTBHH CTana CTonb eepbe3HOH 'ITO KaK pa3 Torp a Epe lCl eB npe J l1o KH I 204 HanpaBHB TYp a cpe J CTBa nonyqeH­ BoeHHbIX paCXO J OB H 06emaH Bee06mee MarepHanbHoe H306HJIHe K 1980 r MopanbHble H nonHTH'IeCKHe acneKTbI ero J eHTenbHOC­ TH 6bIDH eme 60nee Bne'lamHlOmHMH IIpe K J e Beero OH nonO KH I 205 KOHeu npeClleAOBaHHJlM OCB060 lJ HB MHJIJIHOHbI nOJIHTH'IeCKHX H300paIOT PYKOBO lJ HTeJIeii H 3KcnepHMeHTHpoBaJI C BbI60paMH B B MeCTHbIe COBeTbI npH HaJIH'IHH HeCKOJIbKHX KaHAHAaTOB CMOTpeB 3aKOHO lJ llTeJIbCTBO BO-BTOPbIX OH 3HeprH'lH0 CnOC06CT­ OH npH6erHYJI K paAHKaJIbHbIM MepaM BHYTPH napTHH Tpe6YJI pe­ BOBaJI AeMOKpaTH3aUHH COBeTcKoro 06WeCTBa H OTMHPaHHIO ro­ ryJIJlpHoii CMeHJleMOCTH nocpeAcTBOM BbI60poB qyTb JIH HH Beex B cy rr apCTBa 'ITO B COBOKynHOCTH AOJDKHO 6bIJIO npHBeCTH K HaPOA­ 3BeHbeB napTHHHoro PYKoBOACTBa HOMY caMoynpaBJIeHHIO B TpeTbHX OH CTpeMHJICJI YCTaHOBHTb CO­ CKJIOHHOCTH - UHaJIbHyro cnpaBeAlIHBOCTb nyTeM orpaHH'IeHHJI npHBHJIerHH HO­ UHH - MeHKJIarypbI - MOHOnOJIHH napTHH Ha BJIaCTb B rOCYAapcrne HepapXHH AOJI lC fOCTHbIX JIHU - H nOBbIWeHHeM IlrIJI OCyweCTBJIeHHJI 3TOrO H COXpaHeHHJI OCHOBbI CBOeH BJIaC­ TO ICe BpeMJI OH He npoJlBJIJIJI HH B O ll HOM H3 CBOHX Ha'IHHaHHii no AeMOKpaTH3a­ K H3MeHeHHIO OCHOB COBeTCKoro npaBJIeHHJI npe l ll e Beero 11 CTaTYca 6ecnapTHHHbIX H l eHIUHH 1961 r 3aKJIIO'IeHHbIX pe3KO OrpaHH'lHB BJIaCTb TaHHOH nOJIHUHH H nepe­ HaKOHeu BO BHeWHeii nOJIHTHKe B UeJIH XpyweBa BXOAHJIa AorOBopeHHOCTb 0 Me l ll 'Hapo ll HOM KOTpoJIe HaA Boopf l eHHJlMH TH XpyweB CMeCTHJI MHOrHX 'lHHOBHHKOB - CTaJIHHHCTOB Ha HX MeC­ H 0 AOCTH lCeHHH paBHOBeCHJI CHJI Me l ll y CBepx o ep I aBaMH - Ta OH Bbl lJ BHraJI AeJlTeJIbHbIX caMoCTOJlTeJIbHO MbICllJlIllHX H BbICOKO H COeAHHeHHbIMH IIlTaTaMH O ll HOBpeMeHHO XpyweB peUDlTeJIbHO CCCP KBaJIH PHUHPOBaHHbIX 35-45-JIeTHHX CneUHaJIHCTOB O ll HHM H3 OC­ AeMOHCTpHPOBaJI 'ITO Y CCCP eCTb CBOH rOCYAapCTBeHHbIe HHTepe­ HOBHbIX HHCTpYMeHTOB OCYLQeCTBJIeHHJI 3aAYMaHHOH HM nporpaM­ CbI TO H npHBeJIO K 3HeprH'lHbIM aKll HJlM Ha Ky6e H B EeprrHHe MbI 6bIJIa Z UlCHOCTb CaM no ce6e nOT TepMHH He HcnOJIb30BaJICJI H CTpeMHJICJI K 'laCTbIM BCTpe'laM C npe3HAeHTOM CIIlA WHPOKO HO OCBe ICeHHe H 06HOBJIeHHe CpeACTB MaCCOBOH HH popMa­ He npaB rr a JIH Bee 3TO O'leHb noxo l e Ha nOJIHTHKY fopfia'leBa UHH XOTJI H OCTaBaBWHXCJI nOA KOHTpoJIeM pe I HMa H cnY l HBWHX lleiicTBHTeJIbHO HanpaBJIeHHe ropfia'leBCKoii CTpaTerHH Hero AeJl­ z lac­ TeJIbHOCTb B nepBbIe ABa ro rr a BeCbMa CXO ll HbI C TeM 'ITO nbITaJICJI HOCTb B nOClle ll HHH rOA KaK H fopfia'leBY XpyweBY Hy I Ha 6bIJIa CAeJIaTb XpyweB 30 JIeT Ha3aA B MaJIO OTJIH'laIOWHXCJI ycnOBHJlX Z iaCHOCTb 'lT06bI 3HaTb AeHCTBHTeJIbHOe nOJIO ICeHHe B pa3HbIX 06­ QT06bI npoHJIJIIOCTpHPOBaTb TO JI cnepBa paCCMOTpIO AeiicTBHJI ero nOJIHTHKe 6bIJIO no CBoeH npHpoAe TeM ICe caMbIM 'ITO JIaCTJlX CTHMYJIHpoBaTb AefiaTbI no BonpocaM 3KOHOMH'IeCKOH pe­ fopfia'leBa no CHIO nopy A pOPMbI nO lJ D ep I HBaTb O I HBJIeHHe B KYJIbTYpe npoBeCTH 'lHCTKY paAHKaJIH3M a nopoii H HeYMeJIOCTb xpyweBcKoii nOJIHTHKH noc­ 3aTeM naMJIryJl 'ITO '1aCTO HaHBHbIH CBOHX npoTHBHHKOB H Bne'laTJIHTb 3anaA TeMnaMH H pa3MaxoM TOJIHHO npHBoAHJIH K OTCTpaHeHHIO KJIIO'IeBbIX rpynn OT KOTOPbIX npe06pa30BaHHH IlrIJI BOcnHTaHHJI B AYxe Z iaCHOCTU OH npH3bmaJI 3aBHeeJIa ero co6crneHHaJl BJIaCTb H B HTore npHBeJIH K ero naAe­ K KpHTHKe H caMoKpHTHKe BO Beex o6rraCTJlx l H3HH HHIO XpyweB BepHll B CTHMYJIHpYIOLQee B03AeHCTBHe lJ HClJ HDJIHHbI B nOClle ll HHe CBOH rO ll bI Y BJIaCTH OH yCHJIHJI 6oPb6y C Koppyn­ 6YAYIlleM fopfia'leB KaK H XpyweB Ba I HeiiwyIO CBOIO ueJIb BH lJ HT B UHeH BBe ll Jl HanpHMep CMepTHYIO Ka3Hb 3a MHOrHe 3KOHOMH'IeC­ KHe 3JIoynoTpe6rreHHJI OH Ha'laJI TaK lCe KaMnaHHIO JI nOnbITaIOCb oueHHTb BJIHJlHHe ropfia'leBCKoii nOJIHTHKH Ha ero co6cTBeHHbIe nepcneKTHBbI YAep I aHHH BJIaCTH HbIHe H B npoTHB nbJlH­ 3KOHOMH'IeCKOM H COUHaJIbHOM pa3BHTHH COBeTcKoro COI03a Ho lleiicTBYJI a ll MHHHcTpaTHBHbIMH MeTOAaMH 3a'laCTYIO no DJIO­ nOJIaraJI 'ITO ycneXH CCCP npe06pa3yroT BeCb MHp B KOMMYHHCTH­ CTBa H OTJIblHHBaHHJI OT pa60TbI OH oueHHBaeT CBOH B03MO I HOCTH MeHee ODTHMHCTH'IeCKH XpyweB xo npoAYMaHHbIM DJIaHaM XpyweB nbITaJICJI TeM He MeHee nOBbI­ '1eCKHii CHTb 3 P peKTHBHOCTb ero nporpaMMbI nepecTpoiiKH B TOM 'lT06bI UeHTpaJIH30BaHHoro DJIaHHpoBaHHJI 3KOHOMH­ B fopfia'leB ICe Heo ll HoKpaTHO nOA'IepKHBaJI 'ITO CMbICll CCCP He OTKaTbl6Q1ZCJI KH COKpaIUllJI BJIHJlHHe Ha Hero Cpe ll HHX 3BeHheB BJIaCTH B pecny6­ Ha3aO JIHKaX H pailOHax OH nbITaJICJI oClla6HTb KOHTPOJIb H3 ueHTpa 3a HJI l H3HH H YAOBJIeTBopeHHJI nOTpe6HoCTeii 060POHbI TeMDbI pa3­ 1985 roAY OH CKa3aJI 'ITO TOJIbKO AlIJI nO lJ D ep I aHHJI ypoB­ 4% PYKoBo lJ HTeJIJlMH npoH3BoACTBa H noowpHTb yqaCTHe pa60'IHX B BHTHJI 3KOHOMHKH AOJI l HbI paBHHTbCJI npHHHTHH peweHHii no ynpaBJIeHHIO npe IJ IpHJlTHJlMH OH npoJlBJIJIJI 3% EOJIee TOro ecnH CCCP He CYMeeT 3Toro AO6HTbCJI OCTPbIH J1HJleT 206 HHTepec K IOrOCllaBCKOii CHCTeMe rAe pa60'IHe caMH B rOA a He TenepeWHHM no nOB­ Ha CYAb6bI COUHaJIH3Ma B MHpe II03 ll Hee OH CKa3aJI 207 eCJ1H 3aXJIe6HeTCJl nepecrpoHKa nOCJIe lJ CTBIDI 6y lJ T Ky lJ a 60nee cepLe3HLIMH lJ IUI 06mecTBa B u enOM H lJ JUI Ka l Jl Oro COBeTCKOrO trenoBeKa 3 OTcyrcTBHe Tpa lJ HD HOHHOro KOMMYHHCTHtrecKorO BOCXBalle­ HHH xapaKTepH3yeT HOB 'lO napTHHHyro nporpaMMY npHHHTylO B npoIWlOM ro lJ KaK OTMeqaeT nO lJ ep B CBOeH KHHre nOT Ba KHeH­ IIIHH lJ OKYMeHT 60nee He npoB03rnawaeT na lJ eHIDI HMnepHallH3Ma H BceMHPHOH no6e lJ LI KOMMYHH3Ma a rOBopHT ronLKo 'ITO lJ BH­ X eHHe 'IellOBe'leCTBa K COUHallH3MY H KOMMYHH3MY He06paTHMO TOHanLHOCTL pe'leH fopGa'leBa TaKOBa x e Hx O'leBH lJ HaR u ellL crHMYllHpoBaTL COBeTCKHH naTpHOTH3M TO eCTh 3a60ry 0 6narono­ lly'iHH crpaHLI 0 pacnpocrpaHeHHH KOMMYHH3Ma 3a npe lJ ellLI CCCP He ynoMHHaeTCJl lJ aX e MellLKOM MOXOlO KOHe'IHO HaCTaHBaTh 'ITO 3Ta HOBM n03HD IDI TOllLKO TaKTHKa H 06MaH KaKHMH 6LVlH lleHHHCKaR ROBaR lKOHOMH'IeC­ KaH nonHTHKa H xpYllleBCKOe MHpHOe COCYllleCTBOBaHHe H 'ITO lTO TOllLKO noc rre lJ HHH npHMep CTpaTerHH lJ Byx waroB Ha3a lJ ne­ pe lJ IllarOM Bnepe lJ B TeopeTH'IeCKOM nnaHe nOT apryMeHT B03­ MOXOlO BepeH MoXOlo npe lJ CIaBHTL ce6e 'ITO HMeHHO lTHM OObHC­ HHIOT He06xo lJ HMOCTh pe l 0PM B BLICIIIHX Kpyrax MOCKBhI ec rrH lJ aX e no TaK TO TaKaR TeopHH Bce-TaKH KaK-ro OTpa3HTCJl Ha co­ BeTCKoH MeX lJ YHapo lJ HOH nonHTHKe Ho II nOllaralO 'ITO pa3yMHee paCCMarpHBaTh CCCP no KpaHHeH Mepe B HacroHmee BpeMH KaK CBepx n epX aBY lJ eHCTByromyro B co6crBeHHLIx HHTepecax TO eCTh KOHD OB nOPJl lJ OK B lJ OMe MOX eT HaBeCTH llHIllL 'IellOBeK qyBCT­ BYIOI lJ HH ce6H ero X03HHHOM S Bce 3TO BMeCTe co MHOrHMH lJ pyrHMH KOMnOHeHTaMH crpoUKU K npoHCXO lJ HI lJ eMY - 30BaHHOe IVlaHHpoBaHHe H HOBeHIllaR TeXHOnOTHH O'leHh BaXOlhI HO HaHMeHee HCllonL30BaHHhIH pecypc no 'IeJlOBe'leCKHH l aK­ IloKa caMoe nepecrpoHKH 3TO no c rrOBaM fopGa'leBa Tpe6yeT cePJ e3HOH my60KoH lJ eMOKpaTH3au HH COBeTCKoro o6w ecTBa 'ITO n03BOllHT HaM BOBne'll B peKOHCTPYKUHIO pewalOmyro CHlly MOKpaTHH HaM HyXOla KaK B03 lJ X TH'leCKHMH H ECJIH MhI 3Toro He nOHMeM He06xo lJ HMO paCIIIHpHTL caMoynpaBlleHHe Hapo lJ a B KOHu e 208 pa60'IHe lJ onXOlhl caMH BhI6HpaTL PYKOBO lJ HTeneH npoH3BO lJ CTBa BnepBhIe napTHHHhIe BLI60phI 6Y lJ T lJ eHCTBHTenLHO TaHHLIMH H H36HpaTellH 6YAYT HMeTL lJ eHCTBHTellLHYIO B03MO IC­ HOCTh BLI6HpaTL H3 HeCKOllLKHX KaH lJ H lJ aTOB l eCTKHH OTKa3 UK nO lJ lJ epX aTL lTH npe lJ jIoX eHHH B HHBape O'leBH lJ HO He 06eCKYpa­ f lIJl fop6atreBa MeCHu eM n03X e OH Ha'lall HpoCTHOe HaCIynneHHe Ha CBOHX KpHTHKOB Hx pe'IH He 6LVlH ony6nHKoBaHhl 'ITO nOKa­ 3LmaeT npe lJ ellLl maCHOCTH B 06pameHHH K npo l colO3aM B KOHD e l eBp3l1H fOpGatreB no CYllleCTBY pa306pall H OTBepr ymepx ­ lJ eHHH O'leBH lJ HO HanpaBlleHHLle npoTHB Hero MbI H lJ eM He B CTO­ poHy OT COUHallH3Ma a 'Iepe3 nepeCTpoHKY pa3BepThmaeM nOTeH­ IJ Hall COUHallHCTH'IeCKoro CTpoH He B CTOPOHy OT lJ eMoKpaTHH HaM TaKHe CHllhHhle l OpMbl lJ eMoKpaTHH KaK Z UlCHOCrb KpHTHKa H caMoKpHTHKa HyXOlhI llIH ocymeCTBlleHHH pa lJ HKallbHhIX npeo6­ pa30BaHHH BO Bcex c I epax 06I lJ eCTBeHHOH XOI3HH Y Koro B03HHKalOT COMHeHHH B u eneC006palHOCTH lJ allbHeHilleif lJ eMOKpaTH3au HH HBHO cTpa lJ aeT O lJ HHM cePJ e3HbIM He lJ OCTaTKOM He BepHT B Haill Hapo lJ BH lJ HTe llH HK06Ll lJ eMOKpa­ THH 6y lJ eT HcnOllL30BaHa lJ jIH TOro 'lT06bJ lJ e30praHH30BaTL 06­ I lJ ecrBo H nO lJ OpBaTb lJ HCUIDlJ1HHY nO lJ opdaTL KpenOCTh CTpoH neMOKpaTHH He npoTHBOnOnOXOlOCTL nopH lJ Ka HanpoTHB ­ 3T0 nOpH lJ OK 60nee BhlCOKoro ypoBHH OCHOBaHHbIH He Ha 6e3 lJ M­ HOM noc rrYIllaHHH CJIenOH HCllOllHHTeJlbHOCTH a Ha nOllHonpaBHOM HHHUHaTHBHOM yqaCTHH 'DleHOB 06meCTBa BO Bcex lJ ellax neMOKpaTHH - HapO lJ ne­ ' TO laXJIe6HeTCH HaIlla nOllHTHKa 3a lJ OXHeTCH nepeCTpoHKa TOBa­ pHlllH 4 pa lJ HKallLHOe npe lJ jIOX eHHe fopGa'leBa BLI60pLI B naprHii HLIe H B COBeTCKHe opraHhI lJ OllXOlLI CTaTL 60llee lJ OMOKpa­ TOp IlapTHH lJ OllX Ha BLmeCTH MaCCLI COBeTCKoro Hapo lJ a H3 ana­ THH H y6e lJ HTh HX 'ITO Ka l Jl hIH rpaX lJ aHHH 3aHHTepeCOBaH B ycnexe lJ OllXOlOCTHhIX nHU Ha Bcex ypoBHHX O lJ flH llHIllb npH3LmLI He npHBe lJ yT K TaKHM HlMeHeHHHM TOT fop6a'leB roBOpHT 'ITO lJ jIH peallH3au HH 3THX nnaHOB HyXOlO He ronLKO 06hI'lHbIX nlO lJ eH HO KaK fop­ Ga'leB HeO lJ HoKpaTHO nO lJ 'IepKHBall npHHHTh 3aRBlleHHe fopGa'leBa 3a 'lHCT 'lO MOHeTY MOOOH30BaTh HeHC'IepnaeMLIe peCYPCLI COUHallH3Ma UeHTpanH­ nepe­ Tpe6yeT rny60KHx H3MeHeHHH nCHxonorHH H OTHOIlleHHH THB no He npoTHBOnOllOXOlOCTb lJ HCIJ HIV1HHhI Hanpo­ C03HaTellLHaH lJ HCIJ HIVlHHa H OpraHH30BaHHOCTb nlO lJ eif Tpy lJ a neMOKpaTHH He - He 6ecKOHTponbHOCTh H npoTHBOnOllOXOlOCTb OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH Bce lJ 03BOlleHHOCTb HanPOTHB no ­ 209 CaMOKOHTpo1Ib o6mecTBa OCHOBaHHbIH Ha AOBepHH K rpa l lJ aHCKoii aKTHBHOCTb 3peJIOCTH H nOHHMaHHH o6mecTBeHHOrO AOJIra COBeTCKHMH JIIOAbMH CCbmKH Ha BcenpoHHKaIOIIlYIO onn03HIJ HIO pe$OPMaM MOryT yTBep­ no e l HHCTBO npaB H 06S 3aHHOCTeii 11 'IeM 60JIbIIle Y HaC 6YAeT AeMOKpaTHH TeM 6bICTpee Ml l noii AeM BnepeA no nYTH nepeCTpoii TaK H anaTHIO nOCTOSIHHhle H BnOJIHe HCKpeHHHe l HTb KOHcepBaTopoB no Bceii cTpaHe lJTO OHH He O l HHOKH H 'ITO HM TOJIbKO cneAreT BbI KAaTb BpeMJIl4l1J1 KOHTpaTaKH KH COUHaJIHCTH'IeCKOrO 06HOBJIeHHSl TeM 60JIbwe 6YAeT nopSAKa Hao60poT oCBo60 KAeHHe nOJIHTHIJeCKHX 3aKJIIO'leHHbIX npH­ H l HCUHnnHHbI B HaWeM COIJ HaJIHCTH'IeCKOM AOMe TaK 'ITO Bonpoc Hecno no KpaHHeii Mepe Ha KopoTKoe BpeMJI 60JIee cywecTBeHHbIH cero l WI BblHrpbIW 'IeM npoCTo AOCTaBJIeHHe YAOBOJIbCTBHJI JIH6epanbHOii CTOHT TaK JIH60 AeMOKpaTH3aIJ HS JIH60 COUHaJIbHan HHepTHOCTb H KOHcepBaTH3M TpeTl ero TYT He AaHO TOBapHWH 6 OcHOBHoe HanpaBJIeHHe 3TH'IeCKHX HJIH 3MOIJ HOHlIJlbHbIX HHTeJIJIHreHIJ HH OA06pHTeJIbHble OTKJIHKH 3a py6e KOM MO KHOCTb AaJIH BOl­ AHApeIO CaxapoBY 6e3 ywep6a A1lJl ero y6e l lJ eHHH n06Y I lJ eHHii rOp6a'leBcKoii $paKIJ HH C HX onaCHblMH VIS KOHcep­ BblCTynHTb B nOMep KKY rop6alJeBcKoii reHepllJlbHOH JIHHHH H C BaTopoB aHapXOCHH l HKIIJlHCTCKHMH BeSIHHS MH Tenepb S CHbI qTO KpHTHKoii eIIle npel4l1araIOT OHH HaceJIeHHIO HOii HHHIJ HaTHBbI Ho zn aCHOCTU He XBamno lJT06bI MOCKOBCKOH KpOMe nOMeP'KKH COBeTCKoro naTpHOTH3Ma 60JIee BHHMa­ aMepHKaHCKOH nporpaMMbI CTpaTem'leCKOH o60poH­ llinepaTYpHOH ra3eTe 6bIJIO pa3peweHO ony6nHKoBaTb npoBeAeH­ TeJIbHbIM OTHOWeHHeM K KyJIbTypHOMY Hacne l HIO CTpaHbl 60nee Hoe eIO HHTepBbIO C CaxapoBbIM KpOMe Toro JIH6epanbHbIM nOAXOAoM K HapoAHoii KyJIbTYpe H nOnblTKH BOCllH­ HHJlMH npaB TaTh ropAOCTb 3a CBOii HapoA B PYKOBO l HTeJIJlX KOTopbIe Tenepb H JIH6ePIlJlH3M He AOcTHr ypoBHJI pa3peweHHoro pe KHMOM Me KAY Y Ke He APJlXJIbIe CTapH'IKH H YKpenneHHJI COBeTCKoro BJIHJlHHSI B 1974 H 1979 rr B CBJl3H C Hapywe· IJeJIOBeKa penyraIJ HJI KpeMJIJI H ceH'IaC lanJITHaHa KaMllaHHJlX 3a MHP oco6ble YCHJIHJI 6bIJIH npeAnpHHJlTbI 'IT06bI JleHCTBHTeJIbHO 60JIee COTHH umPOKO H3BeCTHbIX nOJIHT3aK­ MoijHJIH30BaTb Ha nOMep KKY rop6a'leBCKoii nporpaMMI I JIH6epanb­ JIIO'IeHHbIX oCBo60 KAeHbI pa3peweHbI MHOrHe nepCOHllJlbHble cny­ HyIO HHTeJIJIHreHIJ HIO H B ycnex fop6a'leBIIbI 3TOM 6bm BblcnYllIHBaJIH AOCTHrHyT 3Ha'IHTeJIbHbIH 'laB KaCaIOIIlHeCJI HHoCTpaHIIeB nepeAa'IH Pa l HOCTaHIJ HH EHEHCH HAeH He rnywaT B MOCKBe CTepneJIH HeCKOJIbKO HHTeJIJIeKTYIIJlOB 0 AeMOHCTpaIJ HH a co­ B03MO KHbIX nOJIHTH'IeCKHX pe$opMax H HX coo6meHHJI Ha caMl le BeTCKHM l HnJIOMaTaM no MeHbweH Mepe pa3peWHJIH 06CY KAaTb pa3Hhle BKJIIO'IaR paHee HaXOAHBumeCJI nOA lanpeTOM TeMbl Hap­ cnyqaH KacaIOIIlHeCJI npaB 'IeJIOBeKa KOTHKH a60pTbl caMoyooii cTBa 6e3AOMHbIe H TaK AlIJlee npHBJIeKJIH Ha CBOIO CTOpoHy Apyme OHH Ho CTOHT nOA'lepKHyTb 'ITO AO HaCTOJlIIlerO BpeMeHH oCBo60­ rpynnbI HHTeJIJIHreHIJ HH ARJIacb JIHWb He3Ha'IHTeJIbHaR 'faCTI H3 HeCKOJIbKHX TbICJI'I nOJIHTH­ nepeAaB B HX PYKH KOHTPOJIb B o6naCTH KyJIhTYPbl H pa3peumB 'IeCKHX H peJIHm03Hblx 3aKJIIOIJeHHbIX a HeKoTopbIM oCBo60 KAeH­ 60JIbwe waCHOCTU B o6naCTH WKOJIbHOro npenOAaBaHHJI B JIHTepa­ HbIM laKJIIO'IeHHbIM yrpo KaIOT apeCTOM eCJIH He 6yAYT BeCTH ce6J1 TYpe H B HCKYCCTBe 11 OHH CAeJIIIJlH Bne'laTJIJlIOIIlHH KeCT OCBo60­ l HB 60JIee COTHH JIIOAeii HMeBWHX TeCHbIe CBJllH C JIH6ePllJlbHOii HHTeJIJIHreHIJ Heii - 3a'laCTYIO ApY3eii H poACTBeHHHKOB - H3 rpYAO­ mxo ApeCTbl HHaKOMblcnSlIIlHX OC06eHHO 6anTHCTOB npoAOJI­ KaIOTCJI H npoAOJI KaIOTCJI norpe6eHHJI JIIOAeH B nCHXHaTpHlJeCKHX 6oJIbHHIIax XOTSI H Te H Apyme cnyqaH CTIIJlH 60JIee peAKHMH BbIX JIarepeii l4I1J1 nOJIHTH'leCKHX 3aKJIIO'IeHHbIX H 06eIIlaIOT OCB060· KpoMe EHEHCH Apyme 3apy6e KHbIe pa ll HOCTaHIJ HH npoAOJI KaIOT l HTh MHoro 60JIbwe rnywHTb O'leBHAHO 'ITO waCHOCTb - lTO o60IOAoocTpan nOJIHTHKa MO KHO HaAeJlTbCS Ha yseJIH'IeHHe AOBepHJI K PYKOBOACTBY H pacum­ Jla Ke B MOCKBe KOTOpaH 1lBJIS eTCJI BHTpHHOH JIH6ePIlJlH3aIJ HH HeKOTopble AeMOHCTpaIJ HH pa3roHJIJIHCb C npHMeHeHHeM HaCHJIHJI peHHe Kpyra CTOPOHHHKOB pe$OpM C nOMOIIlhIO rnaCHOCTH OTKpbI­ BaIOIIleii HaPOAr ma3a Ha He06xo l HMOCTb 3THX pe$OpM Ho 'leCT­ HaJl Mpa'IHaJl KapmHa COUH3JIbHbIX H 3KOHOMH'IeCKHX HeArroB C KOTOpyIO AaeT maCHOCTb Ha caMOM AeJIe MO KeT nopo l HTb KaK pHKH - 2lO KOHQ8 M8R 1987 r I1peKp8THJlH T8KlICe rnYIllHT ronoc AMe­ PeA 211 Kor MbI 06pam aeMCfI K TaKTHKe rop6a'leBCKOH $paKUHH TRiKeJIble YCJIOBHR CO u epXGlHHR B Mecrax 3aKJIlO'IeHH II He YJIY'lllIH­ JIHCb Ii - Ma - 3aKOHbl 06 3MHrpau HH BcrynHBllIHe B CHJIY B JIHBape 3TOro B03MO I HbIH HCrO'lHHK HanpRiKeHH II 3a rpaHHUeH H u o­ ro CTanH l ecr' e a He JIH6epani Hee 'IeM paRee OKono 11 TbIC II'I BHHX OTKa3HHKoB-eBpeeB B03MO I H0 6ynyr ornYllIeHbI B 3TOM rony pap H l eCTa B CTOpoHY 3ana Ho eCJIH 3areM 3aKOH 6y u eT npHMeHRTbCR CTPOro nHIIIb He60nbllIaJI 'IaCTi H3 60nee ' eM nooy­ MHJInHOHa eBpeeB HeMUeB H apM IIH BbIp33HBllIHX iKeJIaBHe 3MHr­ tITO MO I HO CKa3aTb 0 rop6a'leBCKOH nOnHTHKe MarepHani HbIX nOOlUpeHHii Bo-nepBblX OH nO lJ lJ ep I HBaeT Ha u e l ny Ha pellIHTenb­ Hoe YJIY'lllIeHHe l H3HeHHbIX YCJIOBHH npoB03rnalliWI OCYllIeCTBJIe· HHe MaHOB B o6naCTH lKOHOMHKH B03MO I H0 CJIHIIIKOM aM6H­ 2000 ro u y 3areM OH nOllien C K03blpeH pellIHB YBeJIH'lHTl pa3HHUY B 3apa60THOH MaTe Harpa l lJ aR cnoco6HbIX H TpY lJ OnI06HBbIX H CTporo nocTynaR B OTHOllIeHHH no u blpeH ni flHHU paCTpaT'lHKOB H B3RTO'lHHKOB Ii BHTC II 60nee pacnnbIB 'laTOH TeM He MeHee HeKOTopble o6mHe npHHIJ HnbI lICHbl llapTHHHaJI HepapXH II H llITaTbl MHHHcrepcTB HanpaBnJDOIlUlX orpoMHbIii rocy pCTBeHHbIii ceKTOP 3KOHOMHKH u omKHbl 6blTb COKpam eHbI He3Ha'IHTenbHble CeH'laC KoonepaTHBHbIH H 'laCTHbIH ceKTOpbI 3KOHOMHKH nO-BHp HMOMY 6ynyT paCTH XOTb H Me J IeHHO 3Ha'leHHe PbIHO'IHblX OTHOllIeHHH B03paCTeT a IJ MHHH­ CTpaUH II COKpaTHTCfI BnaCTb cpep Hero CB lI3yrolUero 3BeHa 3KOHO­ pHpoBaTi CMOryT nOOy'IHTl pa3pellIeHHe Ha BbIe3 1J UH03Hi IX K B o6nacrn nOnHTH'IeCKHX H COUHanbHblX npo6neM KapTHHa CTaRO­ HaKOHeu OH BCR'IeCKH no u 'IepKHBaeT Ba I HOCTb COUHanbHOH C PepbI H pellIHMOCTb KpeM­ MH' eCKoro ynpaBJIeHHfI B pecny6JIHKaX H panOHax - u on l Ha 6bITb pe3KO COKpaw eHa Hero $YHKUHH p33 u eneHbI Me l Jy ueHTpanbHOH a u MHHHCTpaUHeH C O IJ HOH CTOPOHbI H Henocpe u CTBeHHblM PYKO­ BO u CTBOM npe u npH lITHH C u pyroH Ha panOHHOM ypoBHe H BbIllIe 6bIJIH Ha3Ha'leHbI Ha MHorHe Ba I Hble nOCTbI 60nee MonOl1 ble B B03pacre 55-65 neT H 60nee p HHaMH'lHbIe PYKOBOp HTeJIH B cenbcKoM X03f1HCTBe fop6a'leB nOllien nyreM OTJIH'lHbIM or XpYllIe­ Ba H 60nee 6narop33YMHbIM BMeCTO nO lJ lJ ep HCKH TpaAHUHOHHbIX KonX030B H COBX030B OH XO'leT BHe u pHTb Ha npaKTHKe eCJIH He B TeopHH He6oni llIHe KoonepaTHBi I H llIHpe HcnOnl 30BaTb CBo60 u ­ JIR yny'lllIHTb Ka'leCTBO l H3HH 3 u eci B03HHKaeT cypoBaR p nneMMa Ha RHBapcKoM nneHyMe fop6a'leB nonbITanCR 3apY'IHTbcR nO J lJ ep I KOH CBoeH nOnHTHKH HbIii pbIHOK Ho Kor u eJIO u OXOp Hr ' JfJ peani HbIX nOOHTH'IeCKHX npo­ rpaMM Bi IpHCOBbIBaeTC II HeCKonbKO CMYIUalOlUaJI KapTHHa CTo­ c u enaB HeCKonbKO peaJIHCTH'IeCKH 3BYQaw HX 3aRBJIeHHH poHHHKH pa3Hi IX HanpaBneHHH pacxo J flrc II BO MHeHHflX no nOBony 0 HlUlIeH nOJUITHKe 0 nepeCTpoHKe mop H 6ynyT CYp HTb ­ H 'IeM na nbllIe reM CTpoiKe no OCfl3aeMbIM pe3ynbTaTaM B npaKTH'IeCKOM YJIY'IllIeHHH YCJIOBHH TPY H u3HH MHJIJIHO­ HOB HaCKOObKO CTana 'IeT'Ie opraHH3aUHfl npOH3Bo u CTBa cnpa­ Be l llHBee onnaTa YJIY'IllIHJIaCb TPY ToproBnfl YCKOPHJIOCb 6blTOBoe CTpoHTenbCTBO 06cnyX HBaHHe f H Ibfl pa60Ta ro­ po u CKoro TpaRCnOpTa nonHKnHHHK 6onbHHU HaCKOnbKO 'lHIUe CBeiKee HpaBCTBeHHbIii KJIHMaT B napTHiiHoH opraHH3au HH B TPY­ u OBOM KOJIJIeKTHBe 7 Ho HeCKOObKo n03p Hee OH nOBTOpHJI paHee c u eJIaBHoe npe u y­ npe l lJ eHHe 'ITO HHKaKOrO 3aMeTHOrO ynY'lllIeHHR l H3HeHHi IX CTaR­ pTOB He CJIenyeT 0 I H Tl paHee 1990 ro By u er JIH COBeTCKHH Hapo u pa60TaTb HallpRiKeHHee B re'leHHe nRTH neT no u BOp HTenbCr­ BOM fop6a' eBa eCJIH o6elUaHHOe B03Harpa l lJ eHHe CTOJIi orna neHHO TOro 'ITO Ha u o u enaTb H n03TOMY HHKaKHe 3Ha'iallUle pe$OPMi I ' JfJ CHX nop He Ha'iaTbl H He pa3pa60TaRbI cornaCOBaHHble npoeKTbI TaKHX pe$OpM Ka l lJ afl rpynna 3KClIeprOB HMeeT CBOHX CTOPOH­ HHKOB cpep H naprHHHo-rocy pCTBeHHOH BepxYJ IlKH - O IJ HH nO-BHp HMOMY OCBe u OMJIeHHbIH Ha6mo renb Ha'IHHaIOT O IJ HOBpeMeHHO CKa3an H 8 HTore npoBOp HrbC II 3KcnepHMeHTbI H Mepo­ npH lITHR OTpa KaIOIlUle B033peHHR pa3HbIX rpynn H npoTHBOpe'la­ lUHe u pyr u pyry••• llpaBRlUaJI rpynna BbIHY I IJ eHa uTb TOnbKO cerO lJ H lIllIHHM p HeM 8 Tor 'ITO ike RBnRerCR OCHOBOH Ha KOTOpoii fop6a'leB Hero cropoHHHKH XOTRT CMOTHTl nonHTH'leCKYIO KOaJIHUHIO fo­ BOpfi nonpOCTY OHH nblTalOTC II M06HJIH30BaTb HaH60nee p HHaMH'I­ HbIe 3J1eMeHTbI H B HOMeHKAaType H Boo6me B o6mecTBe HaH60­ nee 3aMerHoro ycnexa OHH u ocrHrnH nOKa B cpe u e HHTeJIJIHreH­ UHH B cpe u CTBax HH$OPMaUHH H annapare BHeIIIHeH nOJIHTHKH H Heonpe u eJIeHHO 212 213 MO l eT OCJla6HTb BnaCTb napTHH 6b1JIa oTBeprHyra Ha HHBapcKoM K 06WHPHbIM COUHaJIbHbIM rpynnaM HHTepeCbI KOTOPbIX HrHopH­ POBaJIHCb npH Bpe lKHeBe napTHHHbIM K l eHllIHHaM K MOJIOne lKH H K 6ec­ OHH 06pamaJIHCb C yqeTOM 3THX HOBbIX HHTepeCOB BHyTPH HOMeHKl1 aTypbl rOp6aqeB paCC TbIBaeT Ha TeX KTO XOTelI 6bI npo IJ BHHyTbC II Ha nOCTbI eme IaHHMaeMbIe 6pe lKHeBrQlMH H Ha TeX naTpHOTOB HCDblTbIBalOlUHX TpeBory H Pa lO'lapoBaHHe OTHOCHTelIbHO nOlIO eHH II nelI B CTpaHe HIIH ane1I1IHpyeT K 06eHM 3THM KaTerOpH IIM O IJ HOBpeMeHHO ClIenyeT OTMeTHTb qTO OTHOC II­ Iu Hec II K nepBOH KaTeropHH 6ynyT nO lJ lJ ep I HBaTb rop6aqeBa lIHWb nOKa BeTep nyeT B ero CTOPOHy HX aHTHCTaJIHHCKHe 3KBHBaJIeHTbI 50-x rO lJ OB nO lJ lJ ep I aHHbIe XpymeBbIM He KOlIe61I 1lCb nownH npoTHB Hero B HaqaJIe 6O-x rO l OB KorJJ a OH yrpaTH1I nOlIHTHqecKoe BlIH IIHHe CaM rop6aqeB - xopoWHii npHMep CHHTe la aMOHUHH H naT­ pHOTHqeCKOH 03a60qeHHoCTH OH B HaCTOHlUee BpeM ll He TOlIbKO OCHOBHoii Bblpa3HTelIb CBoeH co6CTBeHHOH nQ1IHTH'IeCKOH lIHHHH HO B03MO lKHO CHllbHeHIIIaJI H caMa Il xpq eKTHBHa Il ee CH1Ia Ero nopa3HTenbHa ll CMenOCTb IIPKOCTb ero nHqflOCTH Mac­ repCTBO y6e l JJ 8Tb rH6KHH yM HeHCqepnaeMa ll 3Hepm ll OTcyrcTBHe rmeCJlaBH Il YMeHHe MaHeBpHpOBaTb H HeOCJla6eBalOlUHH Hanop Ha npoTHBHHKOB KOTOPbIX OH OTTeCHH1I Ha BTopbIe ponH xapaKrepH­ 3YlOT ero KaK BblJJ alOmeroC II nOlIHTHKa Ero OTHOIDeHHe K HaPOny Hero peJJ Ka Il IJ 1I II COBeTCKoro nOJIHTHKa cnoc06HOCTb HenpHHY I ­ l eHHO pa3rOBapHBaTb C npoCTblMH 1I1O l bMH TO e eMY Ha nonb3Y no KpaiiHeH Mepe nOKa CBoe OTHOWeHHe K Hapony OH Bblpa lHII He lJ llBHO B pennHKe O Jl tfoMy HHOCTpaHHOMy KOMMYHHCTHqeCKOMy nH l epy OHH XOT IIT C l eJIaTb H3 MeH II Bora HO II He Bor EC1IH Bor eCTb TO ITO - coBeTCKHH Hapon 9 OnaCHOCTb TaHTC II B TOM qyO eC1IH OH He CMO l eT o6eCDe Tb 3KOHOMHQeCKHe 6nara IJ 1I II HaPOJJ a ero COqyyT nepCOHaJIbHO 3a ITO OTBeTCTBeHHbIM B 3TOM CJlyqae ero HCKYCCTBO y6e l JJ 8Tb MO l eT npeBpaTHTbC ll B ysemeBaHH Il H qyO eme xY l e ero MaHeBpeH­ HOCTb MO l eT npHBecm ero K aBTOKpaTHQeCKHM MeTO l 8M ynp3 BJIe­ HH II CH1IbHOH PYKoii rop6aQeBa l 01I lKH0 TpeBO I HTb qyO ero KonnerH no nOlIHT­ 61OPO Ka l eTC II HepeJJ Ko npe lJ llOqaTalOT OCTaBaTbC II B CTopoHe KorJJ a OH BblCTynaeT npoTHB cymecTByromero nop llJJ Ka KaK Mbl BH l enH 214 ero nOnbITKa BBeCTH npHHUHD BbI60pHOCTH KOTOPbIH nneHYMe TorJJ a OH y IJ BoHII YCH1IH II H OpraHH30BaJI Bbl60pbI B HOBOM CTH1Ie B TaKHX MeCTax KaK KeMepoBo H naTBH Il Ero rnaB­ Hble copaTHHKH B nonHT61Opo KOB - Erop J1HraQeB H 1iHK000aii PbI I ­ coBepWH1IH TorJJ a l e Ba lKHble noe3 l KH no cTpaHe BO BpeM ll KOTOPbIX OHH nO lJ lJ ep I aJIH HeKoTopbIe nOnHTHQeCKHe aKu HH rop6a­ qeBa HO q aKTHqeCKH HrHopHpoBaJIH OCHOBHoe ero HaqJiHaHHe ­ nepexon K npHHInmy BbI60PHOCTH I 0 Hano YKa3aTb qyO HHKTO B HblHellIHeM nOnHT61Opo He 06H3aH CBoeii KapbepoH nHqflO rOp6aQeBY H Bee OHH 3aHHTepeCOBaHbi B TOM qy06bI rOp6aQeB He nOJI CJlHWKOM 60JIbWOH nHqflOH Bnacm rOp6aQeB n06H1IC II CH1IbHOH nO lJ lJ ep I KH B crep lKHeBOM Mec­ Te - B CeKperapHare UK HO cpe IJ H 307 qneHOB caMoro UK cHTya­ UH II COBeeM HHa ll OH nOCBHTHII 3HaqaTenbHYlO 'laCTb CBoeH 3aKnlO­ relIbHOH peqa Ha IlHBapCKOM nneHYMe OTBeTHOMy ynapy no reM qneHaM KOTopbIe Cnep I HBaJIH ero HIIH He corlIaCH1IHCb C HHM B Bonpoce 0 Bbl60pax H no HeKOT PbIM npymM KaK COO6I UalOT TaKHX 6bIJIO OKOJIO nOJIOBHHbI 11 KpOMe Toro 3aHBHB QTO Ha ITOM CJlenyeT 3aKO Tb lJ HCKYCCHIO 0 TOM Hy lKHa lIH Bo06lUe nepeCTpoHKa OH c l enaJI HCHblM qro JJ a l e ero CTpaTerH ll B lJ eJIOM eme HaXO IJ HTC II non orHeM B IJ HH nocne nneHYMa rop6aQeB qyBCTBOBaJI He06xo IJ HMOCTb npHrpo3HTb OTCTaBKOH TaK OH CKa3aJI QTO rny60Ko BepHT B Halla­ Toe HM H HHKor lJ a He corlIaCHTCH OCTaHOBHTb npO lJ eCC nepeCTpoHKH nOCKOJIbKY He l enaeT THKOH 12 6blTb CB II3aHHbIM HH C KaKOH npyroH nOlIH­ B 3TOM HeT HHqerO y IJ HBHTenbHoro eCJlH YQeCTb qyO BeJJ YmHe ra3eTbI H H3BeCTHbie nlO IJ H TaKHe KaK nOnHTHQeCKHH KOMMeHTa­ TOp AneKCaHnp BOBHH nO IT AH IJ peH Bo3HeeeHCKHH a TaK I e no­ nHTHQeCKHe ne llTenH BKJIlOqa Il caMoro rop6aQeBa He pa3 B relleHHe nOcne IJ Hero ro lJ a C TpeBorOH rOBOpH1IH 0 Bparax peq OPMbI 06pa­ 3YlOmHX OQeHb CHllbHyro peaKUHOHHYIO rpynny He nOTepHBWHX Ha l e l JJ bI Bbl I H lJ alOlUHX Y l 06HbIH MOMeHT 3TH 1I1O IJ H OKa3a­ nH nOllecm HOBHHKY oCY I lleHHoMy 3a KOPPynUHIO BHOBb 06HarlIenH H nblTalOTCH l10XOPOHHTb Bce HOBoe TaKOBa aTMOC­ q epa B KOTOPOH UHpKYnHpyeT nO lJ llOJIbHO H3rOTOBneHHa ll BH l eO­ neHTa C Hana l KaMH Ha eHy rOp6aQeBa 215 B03MO KH0 6bIJIH HaH60JIee BbICtyIIJIeHH I B KOHlIe MapTa - OTKpoBeHHbIM PyKOBO D HTeJIeH B COlO3a 3TOM omOIIIeHHH IIHcaTeJIeH PCcDCP no 6bIJIa enHIIIl enerKa 3aMaCKHpoBaHHa I opra­ HH30BaHHa l aTaKa Ha JIHHHIO fOpOOqeBa C n03HlUfH 6pe f HeBueB ropa3 0 60JIee CHJIbHyIO KOaJIHlUflO qeM Ta orpaHHqeHHa I H OBOJIb­ HO XpynKaH 6a3a BJIaCTH KOTOPOH ceHtIaC pacnOJIaraeT fop6aQeB EenH no TaK H ecnH 6bIBIIIHH cOBeTCKHH tnfHOBHHK JIeHCKHH npaD 'ITO MHXaHJI C J BHrH BO MHeHHH HOMeH1 lilrypbl 3a tIeM nOCJIe OBaJI npH3bm K KOHTpaTaKe BbICIIIeH TO'lKOH nOH C03 J 3 IOT HOBbrH 6aJIaHC CHJI HaDepxy 14 TO BH D HMO J eMOHCTpalUfH npH eTCH HJIH OTCTynHTl HJIH J aBHero 6bIJIO BbICTyrI1IeHHe IIHcaTeJI I IOpH I EOH J 3 peBa KOHCepBaTOpa YTBep K aBIIIerO 'ITO q OHaPb ZIIQCHOCTU Boc­ 6blCTPO fop6aQeBY nO J BeprRyTb ce6H pHCKy oTCTpaHe­ HH I OT OJI f HOCTH KaK no 6bIJIO C Xpym eBbIM B TeqeHHe Hec­ yKpa eH Y CnpaBe JllHBOCTH H npaB J bI JI Ke eMOKpaTaMH OT JIHTepa­ KOJIl KHX ene J yIOIIIHX JIeT flpH TeMnepaMeHTe fop6aqeBa Hero Bce TypbI flocJIe J HHe KaK OH CKa3aJI nOJIyttHJIH MOHOnOJIHIO Ha ZIIQC­ HapaCTaIOm eM pa J HKaJIH3Me BTOPOH nyrb 60JIee Bepo l TeH HOCTb OT HaIIIHX Cpe CTB HHq OPMalUfH H netIaTH 3Ta BCepa3py­ Ho nOKa nOJIO KeHHe ero Ka KeTC II J OCTaTOtJHO 6e30nacHbIM IIIalOm a l rpynna B3 1 JIa B oca J y PYCCKYIQ JIHTeparypy H KaK Ha­ KpoMe ero HCKYCHOCTH B nOJIHTH'feCKHX CXBaTKaX TpaBMa TpeX CMeH 1941 ro J y BbIHy J HJIa ee OTCTynHTl qT06bI BJIaCTH 3aq HKCHPOBaHHa ll 1l0 epoM em e CIIHllIKOM CBe Ka B naMHTH H36e KaTb nOJIHOrO pa3pYIIIeHH1f eCJIH 3TO oTCTynJIeHHe 6y eT npo­ HOMeH1 IIQTypbl 'lT06bI OCTaHaBJIHBaTb B03MO f HbIX 3arOBOPIIIHKOB lUfCTCKHe 3axBaTtIHKH B OJI KaTbC I H He HaCTYIIHT nopa CTaJIHHrpa J 3 - eJIO KOHqHTC I TeM floXOJKe fop6aqeB OCTOPO KHO OrpaHHtJHBaeT MaCTb CBoero nOJIHTH­ 'ITO palUfOHaJIbHble ueHHOCTH H Bce 'ITO HBJI I eTC I YXOBHOH rop­ qeCKoro OCTblO HapO J a 6y yr onpoKHHYTbI B nponaCTb 1 3 KaK Xpym eB 6y eT ynopCTBOBaTb B CBoeM pa J HKaJIH3Me H npH QT06bI OpraHH30BaTl TaKoe c06paHHe a nOTOM nO p06HO conepHHKa Eropa nHraqeBa 3TOM npoBaJIHTCH EenH 0 J HaK0 fop6aQeB C llJIaHaMH nOBbIlIIeHHH KH3HeHHOro ypoBHH OCBeTHTb ero B neqaTH Hy KHO HMeTl Morym eCTBeHHbIX nOJIHTH'fec­ TPY J HO nOBepHTb tJTO OH CMOJKeT Y J ep KaTbCH Y BJIaCTH Ha OJIro KHX nOKpoBHTeJIeH BepoHTHee Bcero 'ITO TaKHe HMelOTC I B flOJIHT­ HeJIb3 11 nOJIHOCTblO HCKJIlOtIHIb B03MO KHOCTb 'ITO rOpOOIJeBCKHe 61Opo HJIH OKOJIO Hero OHH OCBe OMJIeHbI 0 HYTPHHbIX qYBCTBax peq OPMbI BbI30Byr HMllYJIbC KOTOPbrH npHBe eT K 6ecnpeUe eHT­ KOHcepBaTHBHOH qaCTH HOMeH1 IIQryPbl BO BceX Be DylUHX yqpe ll' J e­ HbIM H3MeHeHH I M Ho COBeTCKaH CHCTeMa Ha MOH B3m l He 60JIee HHHX CTpaHbI H Bblpa3HJIH HX Ha JIHTepaTypHOM q 0PYMe AHapxo­ BocnpHHMtJHBa K npe06pa30BaHHIO CeHIJaC qeM CHH J HKaJIHCTCKHe 06ePTOHbI rOpOOqeBCKOH nporpaMMbI - MaIO npe ­ 'ITO eHCTBeHHbIMH cpe CTBaMH B 30 JIeT Ha3a R ny­ TaKOH CHTYalUfH Moryr CTaBJIeHHble HaH60JIee tIeTKO B ero q eBpam CKoH petnf H lUfTHpOBaH­ CTaTb JIHIIIb Bcer J 3 Tpe60BaBIIIHec II B PYCCKOH HCTOpHH Ha npoTH­ HbIe Bl IlIIe J OJI f HbI 6bIJIH BbI3BaTl TpeBory y JKeHHH noqTH J Byx CTOJIeTHH HJIH pacna 06m ecmeHHoro nop l ­ KOHCepBaTopoB OpmH eMOKpam3alUfH npe JllO KeHHaH HM 6bIJIa nOKYIIIeHHeM Ka HJIH BoeHHoe nOpaJKeHHe Ha npHBbIlIH '1O HM CHCTeMy H B enyqae OTCYTCTBHJI conpoTHMeHH I HaKOHeu nocne J HHH Bonpoc 'ITO 60JIee B HHTepecax 3a­ IIOJIHOCTblO 6bI ee pa3pYIIIHJIa C TOqKH 3peHHH KOHcePBaTOPOB na J 3 3 Pq eKT 6bIJI 6bI KaK pa3 TaKHM KOTopbIii fop6aqeB eMarorHqeC­ HO B JII060M cnyqae myno nyMaTb 'ITO MbI MO KeM cym ecmeHHo KH OTPHIIaJI T e eMOKpaTH3aIJ HH 6bIJIa 6bI HcnOJIb30BaHa Hapo­ nOBJIHHTb Ha CHryalUflO no KpaHHeH Mepe npe CKa3yeMbIMH HbIHe OM nYTHMH J l1H e30praHH3alUfH 06m eCTBa H nO pbma D HCIJ HnnHHbI BbI KHBaHHe fOpOOqeBa HJIH ero npoBaJI Tpy D HO CKa3aTb nO pbma OCHOB CHCTeMbI C TOqKH 3peHH I KOHcepBaTopoB fop6a­ MO f HO OTBa KHTbC II Ha npe J llOJIOJKeHHe qro fop6aqeBY ceH­ qeB JIHllIl no HaHBHOCTH CtnfTaeT 'ITO J eMOKpaTH3alUf l KOTOPaH 'lac cepbe3Ho Hy f HbI om YTHMble OCTH KeHHH H n03TOMy OH eHCT­ eHCTBHTeJIbHO BJIHJIa 6bI CBe KHe CHJIbI B HOMeH1 IIQTYPY Ha BceX BHTeJIbHO rOToB Ha OCTHJKeHHe OroBopeHHOCTH C COe J HHeHHbIMH ee ypoBHHX MO KeT npHBeCTH K e D HHCTBy a He K pa36po J y TaKHe OBO bI eCTecmeHHO npHXO J HJIH Ha YM Opro OK­ caM BceX qeTblpex onopHbIX CHJI COBeTCKOH CHCTeMbI - B napTHH B MHHHCTepcTBax B KfE H B apMHH OHH JIerKO MorYT C03 J 3 Tb 216 UITaTaMH no MHomM BonpocaM TeKym He neperOBopbI 0 KOHTpoJIe Ha BOOpYJKeHH I MH noxo Ke nO J KpellJI IIIOT 3TO MHeHHe B TaKOM enyqae orOBopeHHOCTl 6bIJIa 6bI BblrO J HOH H JllH fOpOOqeBa H JllH COe D HHeHHbIX UITaTOB 217 DPHME'IAHHJl 5 Pe'lh fopGa'leBa Ha OTKpblTHH nneHYMa llpaB Illl 28 HHBapH 1987 r 6 DpaB Illl 26 cpeBpaJIH 1987 7 DpaB Illl 30 HHBapH 1987 8 Waiting for Gorbachev B OlKH llllHHH fop6a'leBa The Nevv York 'laTIlHll B iKYPHane llpo6neMhl BOCTO'IHOit EBponw N'l 13-14 1985 r r CM CTaThlO H BeperoBa The Washington Post 19 anperur 1987 r CornaCHO ra3eTe BeperoB Review of Books 100KTH6pH 1985 r no-pyccKH CTaThH 6hllIa Halle­ r no nceBp OHHM AaBHero MOCKOBCKOro AHcCHp eHTa coWla1I-p eMOKpaTH'leCKoit opHeHTaIlHH 6nH3KOro K COBeTCKOit l1IHTe Llpyroit rny60KHit aHanH3 BeperoBa nOHBHJ1CH B TOit iKe ra3eTe 7 p e­ Ka6pJl 1986 r 06e CTaThH 6wnH npe lOCTaBneHhl ra3eTe Ba1WlHl'TOH DOCT pe laKUHeit iKypHaJIa Dpo6neMW BOCTO'IHOit EBponw DepBlIlI H3 HHX 6wna CTp 250-268 HlIne'laTaHa B N'l17-18 iKYPHaJIa BTOPaJI B 3TOM HOMepe Pep Comrade Chairman Soviet Succession and the Rise of Gorbachev 2 9 Arbor House 1987 Pwlapp OY3H MocKOBcKHit KoppeCnOHP eHT The Wash ington Post 10 MaPTa 1987 r TlIJ M C 1982 no 1986 IT OXBaThIBaeT TOT iKe nepHOP 'ITO H Llop ep HO npeABapHeT OnHCaRHe BaiKHWM pa3p enoM nOCBJIII eHHWM npeeMCTBeHHOCTH 10 B COBeTcKoit HCTOPHH OT neHHHlI AO BpeiKHeBa fny60KHit HCTOpH'lecKHit H nOnHTH'lecKHit aRaJIH3 CKnOHHeT aBTOpa K CKenTHUH3MY B OTHOWeHHH MOM ropGa'leBCKHX pe$0pM 'IecTePCKOit ra3eThl MaPTHH YOKep MOCKOBCKHit KoppecnoH leHT MaR­ fapUHaH C Ha'lana 1984 roAa HanpoTHB YTBepiKA aeT DpaB Illl 6 MapTa nHra'leB H 10 MapTa PhllKKOB 1987 r B anpene nHra'leB BhICHlI3aJICJl 0 npHHUHne Bw60pHOCTH C 60 hlIIHM 3HTY3Ha3­ B KHHre The Waking Giant Gorbachev's Russia H3 ll Pantheon 11 Challenges Grow to Gorbachev's Reform IThe Washington Post 10 MapTa 1987 r 1986 'ITO fop6a'leB A06heTcJI 'IaCTH'lHoro ycnexa OH YAenJleT MHOro MeCTa COBeTCKHM COUHaJIhlIhlM H 3KOHOMH'leCKHM npo6neMaM a TaKiKe nonHTHKe 12 PaAHo MocKBa 19 cpeBpaml 1987 r 13 Pe'lh IOPHH BOH IlllpeBa nHTepaTYPHaJI PoCCHH 27 MapTa 1987 r 14 CM Michael B KHHre Gorbachev's Challenge EconomiC Reform in the Age of High Tech­ nology H3A Norton 1987 Mapwann fon lMaH cocpeAOTa'lHBaeTCJI Ha 3KO­ HOMHKe H npHxOAHT K HeKoropwM ewe 60nee CKenTH'IeCKHM JaKmo'leHHJIM HanpoTHB THMOTH KonToH B pacwHpeHHoM H3 1lllHHH KHHrH The Dilemma Voslensky Nomenklatura lI3A Doubleday 19841 of Reform in the Soviet Union Council on Foreign Relations 19861 C'lHTaeT fop6a'leBa HCKYCl lhIM YMepeHHhlM pe$0pMaTopoM KOTOPWit BepOJlTHO 6YAeT HMeTh ycnex B npoBeAeHHH YMepeHHoit COWla1IhHo-3KOHOMH'leCKoit pecpoPMhl HO BPJlA nH 3aXO'leT MeHHTh MHoroe B nO HTH'leCKoit CHCTeMe 3 Pe'lh HI C'he3Ae COBeTCKHX npocpcoI030B DpaB Illl 26 $eBpaJI II 1987 r 4 1 13 3aKnIO'IHTenhHoit pe'lH fop6a'leBa Ha JlHBapcKOM nneHYMe UK DpaBAa 30 JlHBapJl 1987 r 2 1 8 ­ 219