copeBHOBaHHH 1111 COXpaHeHRll 'IeJIOBe'leCTBa a He IJ ljI ero yHH'ITQ­ lKeHHH B copeBHOBaHHH KOTOpoe nOMO lKeT 06eHM CTpaHaM cnpa­ BHTbCH C HX BH 'TpeHHHMH npo6JIeMaMH a He YTPO lKaIOlUeM MHpy pa3pymeHHeM MbI H ' lKnaeMCH B npopOKax H Me'ITaTeJIHX He MeHb­ we 'IeM B reHepaJIaX H 6IOPOKPaTax HaM H ' lKH0 pa3pa60TaTb ro­ BOpH CJIOBaMH BaJIeHTHHa PacnyrHHa HHOR nJIaH BbInOJIHeHHe KO­ TOporo H3MepHeTCH He TOHHaMH H Ky60MeTpaMH a AYWaMH OTPbffiKH H3 HHTEPBblO nPE llOCTABREHHOro T H 3ACJlABCKOA l YPHAnHCTAM HA KOH DEPEHQHH B llATOKYA o B03MOXQIOCTH AeKOJIlleKTHBH31l1U1H Ha npoTH lKeHHH BceR MoeR lKH3HH H O'leHb MHOro 3aHHMaJIaCb KOJIXOlaMH H B TO BpeMH KOr1 a H Ha'lHHaJIa C HHMH pa60TaTb 3TO 6bIJI 1950 rOA KOJIX03bI KOHe'IHO npeACTaBJIHnH co60R AOCTaTO'l­ HO lKaJIKOe 3peJIHIUe nOCKOJIbKY 60JIbWaH 'IaCTb nponyKToB C03Aa­ BaeMbIX B HHX H3bIManaCb lIepe3 HH3KHe ll eHbI B 061UeM nO'lTH He nJIaTMH 3a TpyA JlIO rQi lI HJIH 3a ClIeT JlH'lHblX nOACOOHhlX X03HRCTB H T Jl Ho C Tex nop npOllIJIO MHoro B peMeHH H B lIaCTHOCTH B KOH­ ll e 50-x - Ha'laJIe 60-x rOAOB B nepHoA XpymeBa Kor1 a MHoro Ae­ JIaJIOCb IJ ljI CeJlbCKOrO X03HHcTBa nOCJIe npo1 a lKH MTC KOJ1X03aM H np KOJIX03hI Hal 3 lH nOKalblBaTb CBOIO O'leHh OOJIbIIIylO CHJIy H OrpOMHhIH nOTeHll HaJI KOTOPblH OHH B ce6e HeCYT MHe npeACTaB­ JlneTCH 'ITO KOJIX03HaH j opMa npOH3BOACTBa B CJIYllae eCJIH KOJIXO­ 3b1 He HBJlHIOTCR CJIHWKOM KpynHhIMH a OHH K CO lKaJIeHHlO y Hac R BJlnIOTCH CJIHWKOM KpynHbIMH OHa C O I HOR CTOPOHbl TaHT B ce6e 'Ipe3BhNaHHO 60JIbWym B03MO ll HOCTh pa3BHTHn H C APYTOH CTOPOHbI cooTBeTcTByeT cOBpeMeHHoMy OOlUecTBeHHoMY C03HaHHIO B CCCP• lleJIo B TOM ttrO 70 JIeT cOBeTcKoH BJIaCTH H Y lKe nOliTH 60 JleT cymeCTBOBaHHH oOlUeCTBeHHOrO CeJIbCKOrO x03nHcTBa npH­ BeJIH K TOMy liTO HeCKOJIbKO nOKOJIeHHH CMeHHJlOCb H Te JIIO rQi KOTopble CerO I HH pa60TaIOT B KOJIX03e HJIH COBX03e He TOJlbKO HHKorAa He 6hmH e rQiHOJIH'lHHKaMH HO y lKe HX PO rQiTeJIH He OhmH e rQiHOJIH'lHHKaMH BHRX HeT Ae lbl HX BCTynaJIH B KOJIX03hl B 3THX yCJIO­ nCHXOJlOrK'leCKHX npeAllOCblJIOK AJIR pocnYCKa KOJIXQ­ 30B ••• llonYCTHM MhI pacnycKaeM KOJIX03bl H nepeXOAHM Ha j ep­ MepcKHH THll X03HRCTBa HeT HH nCHXOJIOI'H'leCKHX HH COll HaJIbHbIX 236 237 npennOCbIJIOK AIm 3TOro H He 3HalO BO BCliKOM CJIyqae JIIO lJ eft KOTopble 6bIJIH 6bI B nOM 3aHHTepeCOBaHbI MHe MHoro npHXOAHT­ pocnYCK COBX030B H KOIIX030B MHe Ka f eTCJI OHa npoCTO He­ cnoc06Ha Ho AYMaeTCH 'ITO H IIIO lJ H noro He nOHHJIH 6bl Cli 6b1BaTh B KOJIX03ax C pa3HbIMH JIIOW MH pa3rOBapHBaTb H 1I yrBep llQlaIO JIIO lJ eH KOTopble Me'ITam 6bI B OAHHOqKY pa60TaTb HeT H o f OCIIJ1aHe TOT KOJIJIeKTHBH3M COBeTCKoro 06pa3a JKH3HH 0 KOTOPOM MbI JI106HM rOBopHTb H nHcaTb OH lJ eiiCTBHTeJIbHO cymecTByeT MbI OCHOBHaH H lJ ell 3aKIIIO'IaeTCH B TOM 'ITO focnnaH lJ OJI f eH H3HYTpH lJ IDKe He TaK XopOWO ero omymaeM KaK ero omymalOT HHOCTPaHIIbI KOTopble lKHByT B CCCP OHM rOBopHT y Bac COBep­ weHHO OCOGhIH 06pa3 JKH3HH • IIonoMY MHe Ka f eTClI 'ITO Ha IJ O HC­ KaTb KOMUPOMHCC Me f lJ y ABYMlI nO lJ XO IJ aMH C OAHoii CTOPOHbl KpaHHe B Tpy lJ e Heo6xoAHMa B MaTepHaJIbHaH KOHeqHOM 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTb JIIO lJ eii pe3yJIbTaTe CBoero co6cTBeHHoro Tpy lJ a ECJIH OH pa60TaeT B OpraHM3aIIHH r lJ e 60JIbwe TblCJIt H qeJIOBeK TO KOHe'IHbW pe3yJIhTaT JIHWb B MaJIoii CTeneHH OT Hero 3aBHCHT H B 06meM eMY no He TaK CHJIbHO Ha IJ O C lJ pyroii CTOPOHbl 1I nOJIa­ COCpe lJ OTO'lHTbCli Ha peweHHH cTpaTerHqeCKHX BonpocoB 3KOHOMH­ KH 'ITO BCH CHCTeMa nIIaHOBblX opraHOB lJ OJI lKHa OTpelUHTbCH OT npHBbI'lHblX y lKe lJ JI1i HHX Tpa l Hll HOHHbIX p0PM lJ eHTeIIhHOCTH OT MeJIo'IHoii oneKH KaK y Hac rOBopliT Ka f U Iii war npennpHH­ THH OTCJIe f HBaTb BOBpeMH IIH BbIBe3eu HaB03 Ha nonll H T lJ Bce no He lJ on lKHO 6b1Tb 3a60Toii nJIaHOBblX OpraHOB H B006­ me COBeTCKHX H napTHHHblX - 3TO Bonpoc caMoro KOJIJIeKTHBa l IeM f e TOr lJ a 3aHHMaThCH focnnaHY EMY Ha lJ O 3aHHMaThCH cTpaTerH­ ralO 'ITO y Hac npe lJ nOCbIJIOK WIH nepexo lJ a Bo06me K HH lJ HBH lJ yaJIh­ '1eCKHMH BonpocaMH lJ OIIrOCpO'IHhIMH BonpoCaMH pa3BHTHH 3KOHo­ HhIM pOpMaM X0311HCTBOBaHHH paKTH'leCKH cero lJ HH HeT IIOJTOMY MHKH 3 lJ eCh MHe KIDKeTCH eCTh ABe rpynnbI BonpocoB O lJ Ha CBH­ MHe npe lJ CTaBJIlIJICH 6bl OnTHMaJIhHbIM CJIe lJ yroIUHH nyTh Bo-nep­ BbIX 06paTHoro npeBpameHHH COBX030B B KOJIX03b1 Y Hac CaJIbHaH 'laCTh KOJIX030B 6bIJIa orocy n apCTBJIeHHa Ho KOJIOC­ no Bew laHa C opraHH3aIUieii H nnaHHpoBaHHeM Bo06me f e CqHTaeTCH 'ITO HMelOTCli TpH 3neMeHTa X0311iiCTBOBaHHlI - OpraHH3awm nJIaHHpO­ BaHHe H CTHMynHpoBaHHe TaK BOT B o6JIacTH OpraHHlaIJ HH H Ma­ no MePTBlimee BJIHHHHe 3TO 6lOpoKpaTH3aLUffi CeJIhCKOe x0311iicTBO HHpOBaHHH KaK HHKaKaH lJ pyrali OTpaCJIh He TepIIHT pernaMeHTaIUIH OHO OqeHb 3 lJ eCh Ha lJ OJIIO fOCMaHa OCTaeTCli pacnpe lJ eneHHe TOH qaCTH KaJlH­ Bce-TaKH ABH f eHHe cBepxy npliMoe ynpaBJIeHHe f HBOTHble paCTeHHH OHH Tpe6y1OT TaJIbHblX BJIO f eHHH KOTOPaH y Hero OCTaHeTCH CHCTeMa caMo PH­ npliMoro HenOcpe lJ CTBeHHoro KOHTaKTa C qenOBeKOM H qeJIOBeK HaHCHpoBaHHH npennonaraeT 'ITO onpe lJ eJIeHHali '1aCTb pOH lJ a Ha­ CaM lJ OJI f eH BH lJ eTb pe3yJIbTaThl CBoero Tpy n a OH lJ OJI f eH 6bITb KOMeHHH 6Y lJ eT OCTaBaThCH B pYKax npennpHHTHH H npennpHHTHH f HBoe TYT lKHBble cymeCTBa - X0311HHOM Ha 3eMJIe IIonoMY C MoeH TOqKH 3peHHlI OnTHMaJIbHbl­ caMH 6YAYT pewaTh 'ITO HM Ha IJ O pa3BHBaTh CTPOHTh peKoHcTpyH­ MH lIBJIJUOTCH He60JIhlUHe KOJIX03bI IIpHMepHo TaKHe KOTopbIe poBaTb H T lJ - COOTBeTCTByroT CHCTeMe paCceJIeHHlI - y Hac OqeHb pa3HaH CHCTeMa pHpOBaTb H T lJ 3TO KOHe'lHO OqeHb 60nbwoii CTHMyJI WUI yBMH­ eCTh MeJIKOceJIeHHhle paiiOHbI eCTh KpynHoceJIeHHble qeHHH lJ OXO lJ OB HO eCTeCTBeHHO rocy n apcTBO 6Y lJ eT aKKyMyJIHpO­ paCCeJIeHHH - Ho rpy60 rOBopll 0 lJ H0 xopowee ceJIO - no KOJIX03 a He orpoM­ Hhle TeppHTopHH Ha CaMOM lJ eJIe HeT HY IIQlbI B TaKHX X0311HCTBaX BaTb no-npe lKHeMY HJIH 60% He Mory CKa3aTb KaKyro qaCTb - H npOCTO He 3HalO - nonOBHHY HO cymeCTBeHHyro qaCTb 06mero ceJIbCKOM X03HHCTBe KOTopble ceiiqac cymeCTByroT pOH lJ a HaKonneHHH 6Y lJ eT aKKyMynHpOBaTb rocy n apcTBO H foc­ HeT HY IIQlbI B TOM qTOGhI OHH 6bIJIH rocy n apcTBeHHbIMH CHCTeMa nIIaH COOTBeTCTBeHHO lJ OII f eH pewaTb KY n a C TOqKH 3peHHH CTpa­ oco6eHHO B H MaIDHHbI nOKynaTb HIIH CKOT HJIH 3eMJIIO MeJlHO­ He60JIbwHx H n03ToMY lJ OCTaTOqHO rH6KHx KOJIX030B MHe KIDKeT­ CR OTBe'laJIa HY lKHyro 6bI o6meCTBeHHblM HHTepecaM H o6ecneqHJIa 6bl MaTepHaJIhHYIO 3aHHTepeCOBaHHoCTb JIIOAH nOHHJIH 6bl 'ITO 3TO Ba lKHO KCTaTH rOBopll H HaIDa 6IOPOKpaTH3HPOBaHHaH CHCTeMa ynpaBJIeHHH cnoco6Ha Ha TaKoii war noiiTH IIoHTH Ha 238 TerHqeCKHX HHTepeCOB 3KOHOMHKH Ha IJ O 3aTpa'IHBaTh 3TO CTPYK­ TYpHaH nOIIHTHKa npe f lJ e Bcero B f eIIe3HhIe lJ OpOrH HY lKHO Bno­ JKHTb HJIH B OCBoeHHe HOBbIX 3eMeIIb B CH6HpH HJIH B He pTe-ra30­ BbIe PaHOHbl H np r lJ e Y f HHKaK Henb3H paCCqHTbIBaTh Ha PbIHOq­ Hhle MeXaHH3Mbl H Ha lJ eHTeIIbHOCTb cymeCTBYIOmHX npennpHHTHii 239 3TO o ll a rpynna BOnpOCOB OTpacneBoH CTPYKryPl 1 - 06ecne'lHTh COBepWeHCTBOBlIHHe HapO ll OrO X03RHCTBa KOTOpa» ceiiqac RBMeTCR 'Ipe3BI JlmiiHo HeBblfOnHoH HeCOBepWeHHOH H Bbl3bIBaeT O'leHb 6olll Woe HeAOBOlll CTBO - OHa He C6allaHCHpOBlIHa Y Hee npOH30HAeT nepeMeHa Kap POB nOToMY 'ITO MHorHe pa60THHKH rOCMaHa H ApyrHX KOMHTeTOB npOCTO He CMoryr CnpaBHTbCR C HOBbIMH q YHKUHRMH Macca HeAOCTaTKOB BTOpa» l e rpynna BonpOCOB KOTOPI IMH rOCDllllH AOll l eH 3a­ o rpynnax 06'beAHHeHHbIX OOUUIMH llJlTePecaMH HHMaTbCR CBR3l1Ha C 3KOHOMH'IeCKHM CTHMYllHpOBaHHeM 3ro pa3­ pa60TKa H Kompolll 3a HcnOllb30BaHHeM 3KOHo eCKHX HopMa­ THBOB neRTellbHOCTh HH30BI IX 3BeHbeB npeAIIpWlTHii 6YAeT pery­ llHpOBaThCR CHCTeMOH 3KOHO ecKHX HOpMaTHBOB H KTO l e KpOMe rOCMaHa B CO'leTlIHHH KOHe'D O C ApyrHMH KOMHTeTaMH MO l eT 06ecne'lHTh rH6KOCTI nOH CHCTeMbl ee COOTBeTCTBHe MeCT­ HbIM YCllOBHRM H T A 3TO orpoMHu pa60Ta KOHe'IHo ynpaBJlj Tb 3KOHOMH'leCKHMH MeTop aMH Ha nOpR l OK cno I Hee 'IeM KOMaHAO­ BaTb ClleAOBaTellbHO rOCDJ1aHY eIUe npe l CTOHT OCBOHTb 3ry HaYKY BeAb K 'lHcny 3KOHOMH'leCKHX HOPMaTHBOB Mbl H neHbI AOll I Hbl OTHeCTH A 0 l Ha npo6J1eMa neHo06pa30BlIHHR - q aHTaCTH'IeCKH cnO I HU npo6J1eMa nellO B TOM 'ITO neHbI BH l U MO 6YAyr q 0PMH­ MHe Ka l eTCR OAHa H3 nepBblX 3ap a'l KOTOpa» nepeA HaMH CTOHT nOHRTb KaK Ha caMOM Aelle YCTpoeHO COBeTCKoe 06­ IUeCTBO nellO B TOM 'ITO q opMYlla KOropU Ha npoU I eHHH eCR­ THneTHii ny6J1HKOBallaCb BO Bcex yqe6HHKax BnepBbIe 6bma npOCTO 06bRBlleHa B TaK Ha3bIBaeMOH CTallHHCKOH KOHCTHTyUHH 'ITO 06­ IUeCTBO Hawe COCTOHT H3 pa60'lero Kllacca KonX03Horo KpeCTbRH­ CTBa H HHTe1IJlHreHUHH B TaKOM BHAe 3Ta q opMyna npo KHlIa MTI ­ AeCRT lleT H Aowna AO Hawero BpeMeHH pa60'lHii Kllacc H KpeCTbRHCTBO B COOTBeTCTBHH C HeH paCCMaTpHBallHCb KaK KllaCCl 1 H cneAoBaTellbHO KaK OCHOBHbIe 3neMeHTbI a HHTe1IJlHreHUWI ­ pOBaTbCR B 3Ha'lHTelll HOH CTeneHH Ha AorOBopHOH OCHOBe 3Ha'lHT He Kllacc 3AeCI y Ke BKlllO'IaeTCR MeXl HH3M PbIHO'IHbIX oTHoweHHii B TO l e He O'leHb nOHRTHO 'ITO 3TO 3Ha'IHT - BpeMR rocyp apcTBO AOll I HO Aep l aTl B CBOHX pyKax KOMlIHAHbIe 3TO 3a CTpyKTypa HHKTO 3Toro He pa3bRCHRll H BMeCTe C TeM Bce BblCOThI H He AonYCKaTb CTHxHUHOH Hrpbl neH ClleAOBaTellbHO HccneAoBaHWI no 6YAeT O'leBH ll O AellaTbCR 'Iepes yCTaHOBlleHHe neH Ha HeKOTO­ KOHKpeTHble pble KllIO'IeBble BHAbI npOAYKUHH Ho BceM nOHRTHO 'ITO He TaK Kat H3 p auHOCTH HCXOAHllH 'ITO OCHOBHble AelleHMR - llerKO corllaCOBaTb MaHOBblH MeXllHH3M neHo06pa30BaHHH 3Ha'lHT Kllacc KpeCTI RHCTBO H HHTe1IJlHreHUWI a Bce OCTalll Hoe - 3Aecl HaBepHRKa 6yAYT B03HHKaTI pa3JlH'lHble np06lleMbI H no Mepe KllaCCOBble pa3JlH'lWl Toro Kat OHH 6y l yT B03HHKaTb MbI AOll KHbI HayqHTI CR nOHHMaTl HX CYTh H HCKaTI nyrH yBR3KH 3AeCI 6y l yT O'leHb cnO KHl le Bonpo­ ChI CTORTh He neHTpalll HblX TOllbKO rOCMaH Kat BbIRCHReTCR HO H CHCTeMa 3KOHo eCKHX BeAOMCTB 6YAeT npH3BaHa pa3pe­ waTh 3TH TPYnHOCTH pOCTa 3aHHMallHCI AO CHX nop a6cOllIOTHO HenpHBbl'IHaR O'leHI J1IO l H AIDl HHX Tpe6ylO­ BblCOKOH KBallHq HKauHH TaM KBallHq HUHpOBlIHHl le HO OHM B onpeAelleHHoM Hac l e nOCTORHHO rOBOpHTCR 'ITO no npocnoHKa KOTOpbIe BenHCb HccneAoBaHWI A ABa Kllacca H npocnoiiKa 'ITO Ha npOTH I eHHH CTpyKryPbl eCRTH1IeTHH COBeTCKorO MO l eT WTb TaM 70 06IUeCTBa 3TO pa60'luii BHyTpH­ Kat HX-ro ApyrHX lJT06bI OnpeAeJ1HTh Kat He rpynnbl caMble KpynHble Hap O CHa'lalla OTpewHTbCR OT Toro 'ITO HX TpH H HccneAOBaTb BCIO COBO­ KynH0CTb Torp a 6YAeT RCHO KaKHe THnbl OHH 06pa3YIOT H T o Ta­ KHe HccneAoBaHHR no CYTH He npOBOAH1IHCb Ho MO KeT 6b1Tb ec­ llH 6bl H npOBellH H AllR ce6» npoaHallH3HpOBallH 3TOro 6bl HHKTO He KOHe'IHO 3TO COBceM APyru pa60Ta 'IeM ra KOTOPoii OHH IUa» rpynn Y CMblClle KBallHq HUHpoBaHHble Hane'laTall nOTOMY 'ITO no 6bl1Ia OnHa H3 AorM Ha KOTOpylO 3aMa­ XHBancR 6bIDO COBepweHHO HeB03MO I H0 A ceH'laC npHW1Io cOBep­ llIeHHO Apyroe BpeMH Bbl HaBepHOe 'IHTallH CTaTblO HKoBneBa B KOMMYHHcTe 3TO C06cTBeHHo 6bm ero AOKlIaA CnywaTb ero OHH XopOWO yMeIOT BbIDOllHRTb ry pa60ry KOTOpYlO cero ll R BbI­ WllO 0 ll 0 Hacna KAeHHe nOllHRIOT a 3aBTpa nOTpe6yeTcR BbIDOllHRTb COBceM p pyrylO pa60­ OH no cyrH Aella He CTaBH1I nepeA co60H nellH yTBepAHTI Kat He-TO ry 3ro norpe6yeT KOHe'IHO nepeyqHBaHHH Kap POB H HaBepHoe HOBbIe B3fJlR l bI OH npoCTO XOTell paC'IHCTHTI Aopory H nOKa3aTb 240 OH pa36HBall 0 l Hy AorMY 3a Apyroii 241 uaCKOllbKO MO l eT 6bITb peBOJ1IOII HOHHbIM MbIWlleHHe 'ITO ClleAYeT OTKa3aTbC II OT TOro 'ITO MeIIIaeT npo6HTbC II HCTHHe R KJ1aCCOBOH CTPYKTypo8 Mbi ee Ha3bIBaeM JKOHOMHKO-COII HOllOrU­ AYMalO 'ITO OJ Ha H3 HamHX nepBbIX 3a 'I 3aKlllO'IaeTC II B HenpeAB3 11TOM 06DeKTHBHOM aHaJ1H3e KpeTHa II CTpyKrypa no CpaBHeHHIO C KllaccOBoH MbI ee He Ha3bIBaeM COII HallbHOH CTpyKrypbI 'IeCKOH CTPYKrypoH 3TO rpynnbI KOTopble B3aHMOll eHCTBYlOT B JKOHOMHKe Mbi ee raK I e Ha3bIBaeM COlI HaJ1bH8 11 CTpyKTypa 'Ie­ COBpeMeHHoro 06XUeCTBa MbI AOJ1 lKHbI nOH IITb H3 KaKHX rpynn OHO llOBe'leCKOrO Q aKTopa B JKOHOMuKe TIpo 'IenOBe'leCKuH Q aKTOp COCTOHT Ha caMOM Aelle nOTOM nOH IITb HCClleAOBaTb HX peaJ1bHOe B JKOHOMHKe o'lem MHoro HanucaHO B COBpeMeHHOH HameH JIHTepa­ nOllO l eHHe nOTOMY 'ITO B nOllO l eHHH 3aJ10 l eHa OCHOBa HHTepeCOB H TorAa MbI Y l e CMO l eM H3yqaTb HX nOBeAeHHe H Barb COOTBeT­ CTBYIOXUue xapru repUCTHKH rype fOBOPUTCJI 'ITO OH urpaeT peIIIaIOXUYIO POllb 'ITO Bee laBUCUT OT 'IellOBeKa HO 'IenOBe'leCKUH Q aKrop CTPYKTypupOBaH OTAellb­ HbIe ero 3lleMeHTbI UMelOT CBOU co6CTBeHHbIe HHTepeCbI U cyxueCT­ BOT MbI eeHtlac nHIIIeM KHHry C MOHM coaBTopoM npo$ecco­ BylOT B3aHMOAeHCTBH II Me I J y HHMH 3 Ha'lUT Mbi AOll I HhI nOH IITb pOM PbIBKHHOH 3Ta KHHra CroUT B nllaHe H3 TenbCTBa 1987 r HO ero CTpyKTypy 3TO cnO I HO HO U JKOHOMUKa CllO I HOe AellO H ee OHa BbIHAeT HaBepHOe B nepBOM KBapTaJ1e 1988-ro Oua Ha3bIBaeT­ C nOMOIUblO HeCKonhKHX rpynn HeB03MO I H0 onucaTb C II COII HOllOrH II 3KoHoMHlIecKoH IQl3HU UeHTpaJ1bH8 11 npo6neMa AelleHH II pa60THHKU napruHHoro KOTOpa ll TaM paCCMaTpHBaeTC II 3TO np06lleMa CTpyKryPbI HaIIIero MUKOH - 06xueCTBa Jln ll roro 'IT06bI He nyraTb ee C HCCllell OBaHH IIMH CO­ rpynn BTOpaH rpynna II HaJ1bHOH CTpyKryPbI - neHlleCKHX Q YHKII HH TbIC II'IU KHHr Ha ny TeMY HanUCaHbI - Mbi f Y Hac raKue COBeTCKoro ynpaBlleHUJI 3KOHO­ JTO BHeX03J1HCTBeHHbIH ypoBem uellaJi COBOKynHOCTb pa60THHKH YMCTBeHHOro TPY 003 ynpaB­ rpeTbJl pa60THHKU Q H3Hl1eCKOrO Tpy ­ CBOIO CTpyKTypy Ha3BaJ1U JKOMHKO-COII HOllOrHlleCKa ll Mbl nOCTa· pa60'lue H KpeCThHHe U 'IeTBepT8 11 - BUllU Bonpoc TaKUM 06pa30M KOTophle He MOryT 6hITb Ull eHTHQ UII HpOBaHhI no MeCTY pa60ThI - npeACTaBHM ceOO 'ITO Mbi XOTHM COBOKynHOCTb OC06hIX rpynn npOBeCTU AelloBylO urpy p83BHTH II COuUallHCTH'IeCKOH JKOHOMHKH AOnyCTHM eeMbH 6e3 pa60THHKoB eeMbH neHCHOHepOB CKa l eM HJ1U npOCTO COBeTCKOH JKOHOMHKH KaKHX urpOKOB HaM H8 J O 6bI­ CIO l e Mhi OTHeCJIH ManbIe HapOAbl CeBepa OHH BbIAeJ1JlIOTCH He llO 6bI HMeTb B Hrpe 'IT06bI HX B3aHMOAeHCTBHe ll eHCTBUTellbHO no MeCTY CBoeH pa60TbI a no uellOH COBOKynHOCTU npU3HaKOB 06'h 11CHJlllO peanbHbIe 3aKOHOMepHOCTU pa3BHTH II C0II HaJ1UCTHlIeC­ K08 JKOHOMHKH 1l0cTaro'lHO npeACTaBHTb ee6e Tpex urpOKOB CIOAa l e uaAO OTHeCTU ll eKnaCCupoBaHHbIe JneMeHTbI - XHnnU 6po lJ l'lr 6ecnacnopTHhIX KOTophIe BeAyr HeonpeAeneHHhIH 06pa3 pa60'lHH KPeCTbHHHH U HHTeJIllUreHT 'lT06bI nOH llTb 'ITO urpaTb IQl3HU U np CIO raK I e H8 J O OTHeCTU llHU Korophle uaxOIl llTCH HeB03MO I H0 Ha caMOM Aene B TOH Hrpe yqacTBYIOT Il pyrHe rpyn­ Ha U l J UBeHHH rocYll apcTBa U COAep l 3TCH B pa3J1H'1HhIX y'lpe I IJ e­ nbI TO eCTb peallbHa ll IQl3Hb npOTeKaeT COBepIIIeHHO nO-ll pyrOMY HH IIX AonYCTuM AeTH-CHpOTbI Koropble BOCnHTbmaIOTCH B ll eTCKHX Be J b B TOH Hrpe He 6billO 6bI HH pa60THHKOB focnllaHa HH pa60T­ IJ OMax HJ1H npecTapenhIe Mhl XOTHM 06'b llTh Bce HaceneHHe lleJIo HHKOB ToprOBllH 6bITOBOrO 06cJIY l HBaHH II U T A Mbl npOBellH B TOM 'ITO KorAa MhI rOBOpHM 0 'IeJIOBe'leCKOM Q aKTope 3KOHOMU­ 6ollbIIIylO aHaJ1UTH'IecKylO pa60TY rJIaBHblM 06P830M TeopeTHlIec­ KH TO Mbl Be J b HMeeM B BHAY 'IenOBeKa He TOJIbKO KaK pa60THHKa Koro nllaHa HO U KaK nOTpe6HTeJIJI OT Hero HCXOAHT onpeAeneHHhIH cnpoc Bce-TaKU OnHpa llCb Ha HMelOXUYIOC II JIHTeparypy H T J HO MbI CBoe 06xueCTBO 3HaeM B 06xueM MbI nOCTpOHJIH He'ITO TaKoe 'ITO MbI Ha3BaJ1U HayquaJl runoTe3a - JKOHOMHKO­ COII HOllOm'leCKa II CTpyKTypa COBeTCKoro 06xueCTBa TOllbKO noc­ 3TO TO l e BJIHHeT Ha JKOHOMUKY I10JTOMY Hepa60TalOIU8 11 rpynna uaeeJIeHHH Hac TaK l e UHTepecyeT KaK H pa60THHKH 3TO KpynHhIe AeneHH II MhI BhIll ellHJ1U TaK I e rpynnhI nO lle Toro KaK MbI H3yqHM peaJ1bHOe nOJIO l eHHe JTHX rpynn MbI CQ epaM Ae llTeJIbHOCTH Hy HanpHMep D HImoMaTHJI Me I J yuapOIl ­ CMO l er CKaJaTb Ha caMOM llU Aelle OHU pa3Hble UJIH B03MO l ­ Hble OTHOIIIeHH II 3TO He npoCTO c j epa AeJlTeJIbHOCTU JTO nlOAH KO­ HO BbI IICHHTC II reTeporeHHOCTb HeKOTopbIX rpynn BbI IIBJIeHHbIX Tophle 3aHUMalOT COBepIIIeHHO CneII HQ HlIeCKoe MeCTO B 3KOHOMH­ Ha nepBOM nane a Ha CaMOM Aelle MO l eT 6bITb UX U 60JIbIIIe 'IeCKOH IQl3HH nOTOMY 'ITO 31l eCb H AHImOMaTHH H BHeIIIHeTopro­ Y Bhle OTHOIIIeHHH HaC nOllyqHJ10Cb 75 TaKUX rpynn 3ro 3Ha'lUTellbHO 60llee KOH- 242 Y JTUX JIlO J eH O'leHb cneII HQ U'IeCKHH xapaKTep 243 nOAc06Horo xosJtii CTBa nOBCeMeCTHOe BHeApeHHe KYKYPYSLI H np nOYpe6neHH II cneIJ H pH'leCKHH 06pas l ft3HH ro eCTb 3ro COBeplJleH­ Ceifqac HH'lero TaKOrO npoHsoiiTH He MO l eT PyKOBOACTBO MO l ftO HO oco6aH rpynna KOTOp3JI Aa l e B COIJ HaJIhHOM OTHOlJleHHH JIBJIJIeT­ CKasaTh He TOJIbKO YMHoe HO H MYApoe 3TO BeAl HeMHO l KO pas­ CJI AOBOJIbHO 3aKPhITOH - 6paKH npOHCXOWIT BayTPH 3TO oco6aH CTpaTa 113 HHTeJIJIHreHIJ HH TaK Ke BblAeJIJIIOTCJI pasJIHllHhle rpyDnbI B Hhle BemH IIOJIHTlI'IeCKaH MYApoCTh nOSBomleT HCKaTb npaBRJIbHLIH nYTb IIO-MoeMy no O'leHL Ba l ftLIH saJIor ycnexa no CpaBHeHHIO C CBJI3H C ypOBHeM KBaJIH PHKauHH H c pepaMH npUJIO l eHH II TpYAa Ho TeM BpeMeHeM I1sMeHHJ1HCh TaK l e JIIO n H H3MeHRJIOCh 06meCTBO c l ephl onpeAeJIJIIOTCJI C TaKHM paC'IeTOM IIT06hl OHH HAeHTH pUUUPO­ IIpe l Ae Bcero Y Hac HAeT HenpepblBHhlH POCT ypOBH II 06pasoBaHHJI BaJIH COIJ HaJIbHO-3KOHOMH'IeCKOe nOJIO l eHHe JIIOAeH 3TH rpynnhl Bce06mee 06JISaTeJIhHOe cpeAHee 06paSOBaHHe npHBO n HT K TOMY jleaJIbfio cymecTBYIOT B03MO l ft0 eCJ1H MbI XOTRM nepecTpaHBan X03JIHCTBeHHLIH MeXaHH3M TO HaM He H O Y'lHThIBaTh AeTeH­ 'ITO Ka l AOe HOBoe nOKOJIeHHe JIBJIJIeTCJI 60JIee 06pasOBaHHhlM lIeM npeAhlAymee ECJ1H Bhl B03bMeTe MaTepHaJIhl nepenHCH OHH no Ae­ CHPOT HO eCJ1H Mhl XOTHM CAeJIan pe popMY pacnpeAeJIeHH II Poa n OB CJITh JIeT CTPYKTyPHPOBaHLl Bhl no YSH n HTe nOTpe6neHHJI TO TOrAa 3TO Y l e He06xo n HM0 'leT sa C060H H3MeHeHHe COIJ HaJIbHOrO THDa 'IeJIOBeKa - A 06pa30BaHHe BJIe­ ropasAo 60JIee IJlHPOKHii Kpyr030p ropasAo 60JIblJl3JI KPHTH'lHOCTh 3ro o p83JIH'DfH MelKJJ Y HLmennmMH H xpymeBCKHMH nOllblTKaMH pe90PM y l e He TeMHaH Macca KOroPOH MO l ftO 6hlJI0 ynpaBJIJITh H KOTOPOH MO l HO 6hlJI0 snpaBJIJITb M03rH no MhlCJIJIlIJ He JIIO n H Y HHX eCTh CBOH npeTeH3HH HX yqHnH TOMy 'ITO TaKOe COIJ HaJIH3M H Ka­ KHM OH AOJI KeH 6h1Th H OHH XOTJIT 'IT06hl OH 6bIJI TaKHM OHH MeHJI cnpalllHBalOT 'ITO 6YAeT ysepeaa JIH JI B TOM-TO B TOM'TO B TOM-TO H He JII06n1O OTBellaTh Ha TaKHe BonpOCbI 3ro nn pHH npeACKa3blBaJIH H KacCaHApa Bemana 'ITO 6YAeT a yqeHble rOBOpJIT eCJ1H np0H30HAeT TO-TO TO HaCTynHT TaKOe CJ1eACTBHe nora O KHAaJOT POCT 06pasOBaHHJI aKTHBH3HPOBaJI JIIOAeH 11 KO­ He'IHO IJ HH HaAO yqHTLIBaTh BJIliJIHHe PacnpOCTpaHeHHe cpeACTB TeJIeBHAeHHJI MaCCOBOH HH popMa­ CblrpaJIO orpoMHYlO POJIh nOTOMy 'ITO B Ka l AOH rnYXOH AepeBHe JIIO n H SHaJOT 0 TOM llro I TO 6YAeT KOHKpeTHO npeACKaSaTb AOBOJIbHO TPYAHO I TO l e Ka­ npOHCXO n HT He TOJIbKO B CCCP HO H B MHpe• caeTCJI KOHKpeTHOrO Bonpoca liTO H3MeHHJIOCb no cpaBHeHHIO C KOHe'IHO HaAO CKa3aTh 'ITO CHCTeMa 3KOHOMH'leCKHX OTHOlJleHHH xpymeBcKHM BpeMeHeM TO JI Mory CKa3an liTO H3MeHHJIOCh XOTJI MO l eT 6LlTb eme H HeAOCTaTO'lHO H3MeHHJIOCh eme BpeMJI nOKa l eT AOCTaTO'IHO JIH H3MeHHJIOCh IIpe l Ae Bcero JI HCKpeaHe C'IHTaIO 'ITO COBpeMeHHLIH ypOBeHb nOJIHTH'IeCKOrO PYKOBOACTBa CTPaHOH HeAOCJIraeMO 60JIee BblCOKHH 'IeM 6hlJI Mae npHXO n HJIOCh il nJI paBHOBeCH II cymeCTBOBaBlJl3JI Bce no BpeMJI H He TOJIhKO 3KOHOMH'leCKHX HO H HAeOJIOrH'leCKHX O'leHb CHnbHO pa60TaJIa B CTOpOHy naCCHBH3a­ IJ HH II03TOMy AOCTaTO'lHO paCnpOCTpaHeHHLIM JIBJIJIeTCJI THn BhICD­ KO 06pa30BaHHoro 'IeJIOBeKa KOTOPhlH B ro l e BpeMJI BHyTpeHHe oTqy l AeH OT 06meCTBeHHhIX ueHHOCTeH H He HHHuoaTHBeH 3TO paK­ JIH'lHO BCTpe'laThCJI C TOBapnw eM rop6a'leBblM He pas H 6eCeAOBaTb TOphi BJIHJIlOlIJ He B 06parnYIO CTOpoay Ho KTO H Ha KaKHX Becax C HHM IIepBhlH pa3 KorAa MbI BCTpe'laJIHCL OH 6hIJI eme ceKpeTa­ MO l eT B3BeCHTh 'ITO Ba l ftee HaCKOJIhKO YAaCTCJI C nOMOmhlO HO­ peM no ceJIbCKOMY X03JIHCTBY eme He 6hIJI reHceKOM H MbI HMe­ BhlX 3KOHOMH'leCKHX OTHOlJleHHH paClJleBeJIHTh HalJlerO 'IeJIOBeKa JIH AOJIrHii pasrOBOp H 6hlJIa He OAHa TaM 6hlJI0 lJleCTepo y'le­ 3KOHOMH'leCKH KOHeIlHO KaK B TeCTe 6h1BaIOT ApO K l H H Ha 3THX HLIX MhI HMeJIH AOJIrHii pa3rOBOp lIaca ABa HaBepHoe H STO 6hIJI APO K l aX Bee TeCTO nO D HHMaeTCJI TaK H Y HalJlerO HapoAa npH 06­ pasrOBOp npo peCCHOHaJIOB Pe'lb IIIJ1a 06 3KOHOMHKe CeJIhCKOrO meH Tea n eHUHH K XOSJIHCTBa H MhI Bce nOHHMaJIH Apyr APyra C nonyCJIOBa 3Toro APO K l H naCCHBHOCTH BHYTPH Hero 6e3YCJ10BHO eCTh JIIO n H 3HeprH'lHbIe KOTOPhIX CBJI3hIBana KOTOPblX TOMH­ KOHeIlHO He 6hIJIO C XpymeBblM XpymeB AeHCTBOBaJI peBOJIIOIJ HOH­ JIa BOT 3Ta npe l H llJI CHTyaUHJI MHorHe K HeH npHBhIKJIH HO 6blJIli HO HO BeAb OH O'leHh 'laCTO KaK MeABeAl JIOMHnCJI KYAa-ro npOCTO JIIO n H KOTophle XOTeJIH AeHCTBOBan HepaSYMHO HeJ1b3JI 6hlJI0 AenaTh TaKHe BemH KaK pOCnyCK JIH'lHOrO l RJIKa H OHH C'IHTaJIH 'ITO HX CHJIbl He peaJIH30BaHLl 11M paCKpbl­ 244 Y HHX npe n npHHHMaTeJIbCKaH 245 BaJOTCR ce if'laC nsePH HM n03BOmiJOT ll e ifCTBOBaTI H MO I HO Ha­ Hac 3THM He 3aHHMaeTCH H Mbl nOHRJIH liTO Mbl caMH ll 0JI f Hb C ll e­ ll eRTbCH liTO KaK ll PO f K f nOAHHMaJOT TeCTO TaK ll eHTeJIbHOCTb JIaTb Bce D JIH TOro lITo6b1 ceJIbCKOe X03HHCTBO CTaJIO pa3BHBaTbCH 3THX aKTHBHblX JIJO ll e if nOCTeneHiJO pa36Y ll HT ll peMJIJOl I yro B HaCTOH­ no lTOMY nYTH Mbl BbIHY f ll eHbl 6bIJIH nO JJUITb COl HaJIbHble BonpOo l I ee B peMH MaCCY••• ChI pa3BHTHH lKOHOMHKH H HHOr ll a cpaBHHBaro CHTYauHJO KOTOPaR Y Hac CeH'laC CJIO K f­ B 1979 r Mbl npoBeJIH nepBYJO 3KCne ll H­ u Hro no lTHM BonpocaM 06'beXaJIH 26 panoHoB BCTPelJaJIHCb C PY­ JIaCh C lIeJIOBeKOM KOTOPbl if ll OJIroe BpeMH f HJI CO CBH3aHHblMH HO­ KOBO ll HTeJIHMH H BblHBJIHJIH caMble OCTpble npo6neMbI X03HHCTBeH­ raMH a nOTOM eMY Hom pa3BH3aJIH H rOBopHT 6erH A OH He MOo Horo MexaHH3Ma AHKeTbl KOTopble Mbl COCTaBMJIH Ha3bIBaJIHCb f eT nOTOMY liTO Y Hero 3aTeKJIH HorH llaH bor lIT06bl OH CHallaJIa KaK c ll eJIaTb lITOPbl JIJO ll H pa60TaJIH lI illIe nomeJI Me D JIeHHO Ho KaK TOJIbKO OH nOH ll eT OHeMeHHe HallHeT npo­ IIOJIyqHB nOT MaTepHaJI H npH lJ jf K BbIBOAY liTO nOJIO f eHHe XO ll HTb H HaCTaHCT MOMeHT Kor ll a OH CMO f eT 6 f aTb 113MeHeHHR B CeJIbCKOM XOlHHCTBe HBJIHeTCH KpHTHlIeCKHM H liTO HHKaKHX Ha­ B ll e f ll no CYl I eCTBY HeT lITO TaM lITO-TO H3MeHHTCH Mhl P 33pa60TaJIH 06l 1 eCTBe He MoryT npOHCXO ll HTb MrHOBeHHO no CTpaIDHO HHepl HOHHaR CHCTeMa Y Hac eCTb JIJO ll H KOTopble rOBopHT liTO Ha O'leHb MaJIO C ll eJIaHO 3a nsa C nOJIOBHHOH ro D a lITO CHH3Y peaJIbHO npoeKT no ll Ha3BaHHeM COu HaJIbHbIH MeXaHH3M pa3BHTHR 3KOHO­ CJIe ll YJOl I yro nRTHJIeTKY l980-1985 rr HCCJIe ll OBaTeUbCKHH JIHIDb Hasepxy MeHHeTCH ••• 3TO Ha caMOM MHKH Mbl nOHHMaJIH CBOJO 3a D aqy TaK eCJIH Mbl e ll eM Ha KaKOM­ ll eJIe TaK ••• Ho MHe Ka f eTCH lITO BCe-TaKH HCTOpHlJeCKH ABa C no­ TO JIaHHepe H OH meJI 6b1CTPO HO HallaJI 3aMe D JIjfTb XO ll a nOTOM JIOBHHOH ro D a - Ka f eTCH COBceM o CTaHOBHJICH TO HHlIero ll Pyroro He OCTaeTCH HHlIero He H3MeHHJIOCb - no Bce paDHO lITO O ll Ha MHHyTa KaK cnyCTHTbCH B MaIDHHHoe OT ll eJIeHHe H nOCMOTpeTb lITO npOHC­ XO ll HT C MamHHaMH IIpHMepHo TaKaH 3a D a'la 6bIJIa H Y Hac o HOBocu6HPCKOM ll OKYMeHTe ECJIH X03HHCTBO nepeCTaJIO pa3BHBaTbC Il ll aBanTe HCCJIe ll yeM COu HaJIbHbIH MexaHH3M nOlleMY He cpa6aTbIBaeT nO'leMY HeT 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOC­ H PYKOBO oT ll eJIOM COl HaJIbHbIX npo6neM I1HCTHTYTa 3KO­ TH Mbl B TelleHHe nsyx JIeT pa3pa60TaJIH TeOpeTHlJeCKHH npoeKT ­ H opraHH3aUHH npoMbllWIeHHoro npOH3BO ll CTBa CH6HPC­ OKOJIO ABYXCOT CTPaHHU 3TOT npoeKT 6bIJI npHHUHlIHaJIbHO HOBblM Koro OT ll eJIeHHH AKa ll eMHH HaYK IIpHMepHo Y f e B KOHue 70-x ro­ H peBOJIJOUHOHHblM Bo06l 1 e rOBopH D JIH TOro BpeMeHH nOCKOJIbKY ll OB Ham KOJIJIeKTHB - 3TO 6bIJIO npH fipe f HeBe Mbl peIDHJ1H lITO npe f D e lIeM MbI HalJHeM HOMHKH 50-60 lIeJIOBeK - OlleHb XOpOIIIHH ll PY f HblH KOJIJIeKTHB B 3aHHMaJICH CeJIbCKHM X03HHCTBOM arpapHbIMH 3MnHpHlJeCKHe HCCJIe ll OBaHHH H O o6cY ll HTb Ham npoeKT C Y Hac ll eJIa­ HaYllHOH 06l 1 eCTBeHHOCTbJO HaH60JIee TBoplleCKOH lIaCTbJO yqeHbIX JIH paClJeTbI pa3JIHlJHbIX BapHaHTOB pa3BHTH Il ceJIa H nOTpe6HOCTeH MbI C ll eJIaJIH 10 lK3eMUJIsrpoB npoeKTa H pa30CJIaJIH ero B 10 aKa D e­ 3Toro ceKTopa KOHelJHO MbI ynHpaJIHCb B 3KOHOMHKY Henocpe ll ­ MHlJeCKHX HHCTHTYTOB 3aHHTepeCOBaHHblX B lTOM Bonpoee 3TO ll eJIaMH H npe f D e Bcero COl HaJIbHbIM pa3BHTHeM ceJIa CTBeHHO nOTOMY liTO Cpe ll CTBa MO f HO B3HTb TOJIbKO H3 lKOHOMH­ 6bIJIO oceHbJO 1982 r Mbl npOCHJIH pyKOBO ll CTBO HHCTHTYTOB npOo KH BeCTH BHyTpH nHX HHCTHTyTOB o6cy f ll eHHe Mbl paCCMaTpHBaJIH BapHaHTbl pa3HOH CTeneHH onTHMH3Ma IIoJIytlaJIoCb liTO C6JIH f eHHe ropo D a H ll epeBHH MO f eT 6blTb ll OCTHr­ r BHyTpeHHHx o6cY f ll eHHH y B pe3YJIbTare 3THX JIJO ll eH B03HHK OrpOMHblH HHTepe'c T e npHMepHO 3a 20 JIeT HO JIHIDb npH YCJIOBmi lIM 3aXOTeJIOCb BCTpeTHTbCH H BMeCTe 06cY ll HTb 3TH BonpOCbl MbI KopeHHblx nepeMeH B CeJIbCKOM X03HHCTBe H pe3KoM YCKopeHHH Ha3HallHJIH ceMHHap Ha anpeJIb 1983 r K 3TOMY BpeMeHH fipe f HeB BYTO K 2000 pocTa npOH3BO ll HTeJIbHOCTH TpY ll a A npH HHepl HOHHOM BapHaHTe YMep Ha ceMHHap Mhl npHrJIaCHJIH Ha o6cy f D eHHe npOeKTa OKOJIO pa3BHTHH T e eCJIH Bee OCTaHeTCH TaK KaK 6b1JI0 TO D a f e paCXO f ­ U IlTH ll eCHTH KpynHblX yqeHblx pa3Horo npo$HJIH HMeBIIIHX OTHOo ll eHHH B03HHKBYT - ceJIO OTCTaeT OT ropo ll a Mbl HeCKOJIbKO pa3 ll e­ meHHe K 3TOH np06JIeMe H3 lTHX HHCTHTYTOB H He TOJIbKO OTTY ll a H JIaJIH TaKHe paC'leTbl HCXOM H3 Toro lITO 3KOHOMHCTbl 06ecnellaT IIpHexaJIo lIeJIOBeK 60 11 Hac 6bIJIO lIeJIOBeK 40 nO ll 'beM ceJIbCKOrO x03srHCTBa Ho Mhl y6e ll HJIHCb lITO HHKTO KpOMe $eBpaJIe OT ll bIXaJIa B CaHaTopHH TaM H ll YMaJIa 0 BCrynHTeJIbHOM 246 B HHBape H B 247 nOKJIane Bee tfHTaJIH npoeKT B 200 cTpmmu Ho Koe-KTO npHeneT KTO He tfHTaJI KaK Ke MHe cneJIaTh TaKOH nOKJIan tfTofibl OH fibIJI HHTepeceH BceM - H TeM KTO tfHTaJI npoeKT H TeM KTO He tIHTaJI 3a ron HaKOnUJIHCb KaKHe-TO HOBble uneH H I B CaHaTOpHH Hanuca­ JIa nOT nOKJIan rtJI I ceMHHapa CorpYnHHKH BbIpa3HJIH MHeHHe tITO ero He HanO ny6JIHKOBaTh OTKPbITO tITO OH CJIHIIIKOM nyllIelIlHIIaTeJIb­ HDIH KaK rOBOpHTC I AraH6er IH pellIUJI ony6JIHKoBaTb ero rtJI I CJlY KefiHOrO nOJIb30BaHH I TOJIbKO nJI I yqacTHHKoB ceMHHapa tfTO­ fibl MO J HO fibIJIO ero 06cynuTb HO nwbllIe tfTOfibl OH HHKyna He llIeJI B nOM OH MeH I nOnnep KaJI B3rJI InDI Y Hac fiDIJIH ofilIUfe H OH npocTo nO J llHCaJI no MDI pa3MHO l HJIH 3TOT nOKJIan H Bee yqacTHHKH ceMHHapa ero nOJIyqHJIH EbIJIO HeofiDIKHOBeHHO HHTe­ peCHoe 06cy KneHHe KOTopoe npOnOJI KaJIOCb TpH lUUI fllOnu 6blJIH npOCTO CtfacrJIHBbl OHH rOBOpUJIH tfTO HHKorna B KJf3HH He yqaCT­ BOBaJIH B TaKOM TBOptfeCKOM ceMHHape Y Hac fibIJI YCTaHOBJIeH perJIaMeHT 7 MHHyr rtJI I BblcrynJIeHHil B npeHH IX HO MO KHO 6bIJIO CHOBa 3anHCblBarbC I B Otfepenb H BTOPOH pa3 HatIHHaTb C Toro Ke MeCTa rne OCTaHOBUJIC I OtfeHb 6oJIbllIOH nHHaMH3M 6JIaronap l 3To­ MY fibIJI Koe-KOMY H 7 MHIIYT XBaTUJIO HO 6blJIH JIlOnu KOTopbIe no HeCKOJIbKy pa3 BbICTynaJIH Bce BpeM I MeHDllIe 10-11 3anHcaB­ llIHXC I He fibIJIO Bce BpeM $l TaKa l aKTHBHaH OtfepenI H fibIJIa BDIC­ Ka3aHa Macca HneH R ou eHUJIa Torna tITO nOJIyqHJIa npHfiaBKY uneH 100 100 npyrHe monu B pe3YJIbTare 3Toro ceMHHapa npHMepHO BnBOe BOT eCJIH 3a B3 1Tb TO tfTO 6bIJIO 3aJIO KeHO B nOKJIane TO eIlle reKCT KOTOPblH Mbi netfaTaJIH a nepeCH ITblH C Hero reKCT IIOCKOJIb­ Ky MaTepHaJIbl rtJI I CJlY KefiHOrO nOJIb30BaHH I He nOJIaraeTC I nepe­ CHHMarb TO C Hero fibIJIa COpBaHa o6JIO KKa Ha 06JIo KKe 6bIJIO Ha­ H 3aCJlaBCKa l TaKOH-TO 3arOJIOBOK nOKJIana H HOBOw 1983 r BOT 3Toro HHtfero He fibIJIO Cpa3y Ha'tfHHaJIC I nHcaHO T CU6HpCK TeKcT KOTOPbIH npHllIeJI Ha 3anan fie3 aBTOpa fie3 HHtferO a cpa3y neTaJIbHOe HaHMeHOBaHHe nepBoro nYSKTa nOMHIO R R Y Ke eeHtIaC ero He na Ke 3HalO tfTO H3 cIIPf nepenaBaJIC I TeKCT noro nOKJIa­ na I He 3HalO no CB060ne UJIH no CBo60nuoH EBpone MHe paCCKa3blBaJIH tITO OHH rOBOpUJIH tfTO aBTOp HeH3BeCTeH Torna HeCKOJIbKO nepenatI nOCB ITUJIH 3TOMY IIOTOM B OnuOH nepenatIe rOBOp lT tITO Mbl B ofiIlleM HatfaJIH nOranDIBaTbC I KTO aBTOp BenI B BallIHHrroH nOCT fibIJIO HanHCaHO tITO 3Ta pa60Ta KaKOro­ TO KOJIJIeKTHBa H tITO B anpeJIe B KpeMJIe COCTO lJIOCb 06cY KneHHe KpeMJIb K 3TOMY He HMeJI HHKaKoro OTHOllIeHH I Bee no 6bIJIO npOCTO HameH TeKYIlleH pafiOTOH H 3TO yInnO Ha 3anan EJIaronap l 3TOMy I nyMaIO MOH nOKJIan CTaJI OtIeHb llIHPOKO H3BecreH B CCCP Hano Ke 6bIJIO pa306paThc I tfTO Ke 3Ta 3aCJIaBCKaH HanuCaJIa a n03TOMY ero npOtfHTaJIH Bce HallIH PYKoBonuTeJIH A fie3 noro BPM JIH CTaJIH fibl OHH ero tIHTaTb MaJIO JIH neJIaJIOCb nOKJIanOB Ua Ke eenH 6DI HM ero nOCJlaJIH cneU UaJIbHO Bce PaBHO taM TaKaH Macca npnxonuT HHl l0pMaUHH A TaK OH npHBJIeK BHHMaHHe K cefie npHfiaBHJIH OT nyllIH nOTOMY liTO 3TO 06cy KneHHe cnpOBOUHpoBaJIO o HalUIOHaJlJ HOM BOnpoce OTnaTb Bce HMH HaKonneHHoe fllOnu nyMaJIH Ka Kn r IH Ha CBoeM MeCTe a 3neCb BCTpeTUJIHCb AYnuTOPH l fibIJIa OlleHD BbiCOKoro ypoBH I Mbl KOHetfHO npurJIallIaJIH B OCHOBHOM enHHOMDUnneH­ HHKOB 3atfeM Mbi 6yneM npurJIallIaTb peaKU UOHepOB fllOnu Bnep­ Bble BCTpeTHJlHCb B 3TO BpeM I fibIJI Y Ke AHnponOB Y Hac OlleHb XOpOllIO H H Bee npoIDJIo Bnpyr Y Ke B aBrYCTe I Y3HaIO tfTO B Ba­ llIHHrrOH nOCT ony6JIHKoBaH TeKCT 3Toro nOKJIana KaK OH ryna ymeJI EcrecTBeHHo KTO-TO nepenw HO KaK KTO - I no ceH nopbI He 3HalO 3TOro Hy TOrna KOHetfHO HallaJIOCb BC IKoe IIoTOMY tITO OH BCe-TaKH He fibIJI npenHa3HatfeH rtJI I llIHpOKOH ny6JIHKH ECJlH fibl OH fibIJI ony6JIHKOBaH B CCCP rtJI I OTKPbITOH netfaTH TO KOHetfHO Bce fibIJIO fibl HOPMaJIbHO HO OH BenI He npenua3HallaJIC I nJI I 3TOH u eJIH • ilOBOJIbHO JIerKO fibIJIO noranaTbC I tITO ymeJI He caM nOKJIan ­ HaUHOHaJIbHbIH Bonpoc HaUHOHaJIbHble OTHOllIeHH I TpefiYIOT KOHetfHO orpoMHoro BHHMaHH I 3TO O lHa H3 HaH60JIee CJlO KHbIX OfiJIaCTeH COu HaJIbHbiX OTHOllIeHHH Y Hal KCTaTH rOBOp l 6bIJI OnHH H3 BonpOCOB KOma MDI rOBOpUJIH ofi 3KOHOMHKO-COUHOJIO­ m'tfeCKOH CTpyKType nOJI KHbl JIH MDI yqHTbIBaTh B HeH KOHetfHO He HaU UOHaJIbHDIH acneKT 3TO npOCTO HeB03MO KH0 6bIJIO fibl HO COUHaJIbHO-HaU UOHaJIhHbIH Bee'TaKH y Hac eCTb rpyIUIbl pecnyfiJIHK KOTOpble pa3JlHtfaIOTC I no xapaKTepy X03 1HCTBeHHoro COU UaJIbHO­ ro MeXaHH3Ma CKa KeM CHCTeMa pOnOBblx oTHollIeHHH pono-nne­ MeHHDIX HCKa KaeT Bce Ha CBeTe Ho nOTOM npHIDJIH K BbIBony tfTO 3TO Bce-TaKH HeB03MO KH0 ECJlH B3 ITb IIpHGaJITHKY EeJIopyc­ CHIO YKpaHHY KaK onus paiOH a CK a KeM CpenHlOlO A3H1O KaK 248 249 gpyrOH TO BCe PaBHO CllHmKOM MHOrO nonyqaeTC II Ha caMOM ge­ ne KOHe'lHO npH npHCYanbHOM B3fJ1 IIge nerKO yBHgeTh OrpOMHble pa3J1H'IHlI B 3KOHOMHKe H II 6bI CKa3aJIa B COUHaJIbHOM MexaHH3­ Me pa3BHTHlI 3KOHOMHKH TaM pa3HbIe COUHaJIbHbIe MexaHH3MbI pa3Ha II COUHanbHa II CTpyKTypa MbI npHWJ1H B KOH e KOH OB K BbIBOgy 'ITO TaKoe MeTogonorH'IeCKoe 0pYgHe KaK 75 H3 lUHX rpynn MhI MO l eM npHllaraTb K pa3HbIM pecny6 rrHKaM BHgHMO OHO 6ygeT yaK HllH HHa'le TpaHc popMHpoBaTbC II HO gfi II nepBoro no lJ XO­ ga OHO rOgHTC II T II I eHHH gOllforo BpeMeHH H3 1aJIHCb O'leHb OgHOCTOpOHHe OHH H3 1aJIHCh nog 3agaHHbIH pe3ynbYaT TaK l e KaK COUHaJIbHa II CTPYK­ yYpa H3 1aJIaCb C n03HUHH C6nH I eHHlI Bcex rpynn Y I e 3apaHee 6hIllO H3BeCTHO 'ITO OHH c6nH I aIOTC II H BeCb Bonpoc YCTaHOBHTb KaK 6bICTPO H KTO C KeM 0 npo ecce gH p pepeHUHa 06meCTBa npaKTH'leCKH He rOBopHllH a nIOgH omymaJIH ny pacTymyro gH p pe­ peHUHaUHIO Bee TaKHe pa60TbI WJ1H MHMO C03HaHH II TO eCTb npOCTO XOTenOCh OTnO l HTh HX B CTOPOHy He 3aHHMaThC II 3THM OHH OhlnH paJIhIIIHBbIMH OT Ha'lana go KOH a 0 HaUHOHaJIbHhIX OTHOmeHH lIX JapaHee 3agaHHa II CHyYaUH II 'ITO OTHOmeHH II MH COBepmeHHO gpY l enIOOHble BaHHe y Hac 'IaCTO Beg Ha CaMOM gene 3HaMeHeM HaUHOHaJIHCTH'leCKHX HaCTpoeHHH B Ka I gOH pecny6 rrHKe IIBJl IIeTCH npe l ge Beero KyJIbTypa nI060Bb yBa l eHHe K CBoeH KyJIbyYpe CTpeMneHHe 'IT06bI OHa He nogaBJl II­ JIaCb 'lT06hI OHa pa3BHBanaCb B nOnHOH Mepe npOTHB pyCH pHK H T g Ho PYCCKa II KyJIbTypa KOHe'lHO KyJIbyYpa BenHKa II H npo­ THB Hee TO l e MHoro 'ITO geJIaJIOCb OTcIOga TaK3Jl l e peaK pYCCKoro HaceneHHH - Ho geno B TOM 'ITO HaUHOHaJIbHbIe OTHOmeHH II TO I e Ha npo­ TO I e - BpeM II cYaJIa npO IIBJl IITbC II H 3Ta TeHgeH KaK 6bI pYCCKoe Hace­ neHHe PYCCKa II HHTeMHreHUH II TO l e CKaJaJIa a 'IeM MbI X ' Ke J1 Me HaUH II­ 3a TO 'ITO Hy I HO nOgHHTb pyCCKyIO KyJIbTy­ py H TaKHe BOT HaI HOHaJIbHO OKpameHHble OTHOmeHH II Ooma II n03H y Hac CeH'IaC TaKa II K C'IaCTbIO 'ITO Hy I HO rOBopHTb 060 BceM 'ITO 6onHT IIpe l ge Bcero rOBopHTb nOTOMY 'ITO CHa'laJIa HaBepHOe HagO rOBOpHTh H o6CY l I aTl a nOTOM 'ITO­ HH6yg MO I HO genaTb HO BP IIg JIH Hago 'ITO-JIH60 Cpa3Y MeH IITb IIpe l ge Bcero Hy I Ho nOH IITh cHyYaUHIO MHe Ka l eTCH 'ITO MHOrHe BonpOCbI H MHorHe oone3HeHHbIe TO'IKH MOrnH ObI 6blYb npeogOJIeHbI ga l e Ha OCHOBe OgHoro TonbKO OTKpbIToro pa3rOBopa Hy l HO Hay'lHTbC II rOBOpHTh 00 3TOM 06 3TOM Beg He rOBopHllH Ha npOT II I eHHH gec lITHlleTHH H HaBepHOe Hy I HO eme Ha lHThC II rOBOpHTI OTKpbITO TaK KaK CllOBO ycoBepmeHCTBO­ ynoTpe6 rr IIeTC II npegnonaraJIOCb 'ITO OHH H yaK COBepmeHHble HO Ha lJ O cgenaTb HX oonee COBepmeHHbIMH MHe Ka l eTC II fJIy6HHa H OCTpon COUHaJIbHblX np06neM KOTopbIe B nOH oonaCTH HMeIOTC II He OTpa l eHbl B gOCTaTO'lHOH CTeneHH B HameM oOmecTBoBegeHHH OHH CKopee OTpa l aIOTC II Ha ypOBHe 06hIgeHHoro C03HaHH II nOCKonbKY Ka l gblH CTaJIKHBaeTC II B TOH HllH RHOH CTeneHH C nHMH OTHOmeHHlIMH KOHe'lHO B HHX O'leHb MHoro CllO I HOCTeH COBceM He npoCTbIMH IIBn IIIOTC II nH OTHome­ HH II HMeeT MeCTO H HaUHOHaJIH3M CHllbHO Bblpa l eHHbIH B COI03HbiX pecny6 rrHKax 'ho eCTeCTBeHHO B onpegeneHHOH CTeneHH BeCb Bonpoc B TOM KaK nOHHMaTb nOT HaUHOHaJIH3M KaKHe y Hero pOpMbI MHe Ka l eTC II 'ITO COBpeMeHHbIH MHPOBOH npo ecc O'leHb CHllbHO aKTHBH3HpyeT HaUHOHaJIbHOe C03HaHHe Jlonroe B peM II Y HaC He 6bmo aHaJIOrH'lHbIX IIBneHHii B POCCRH TO eCTb He Obmo Toro 'ITO paHbme Ha3bIBaJIOCb PYCCKHM BeJIHKogep l aBHbIM mOBH­ HH3MOM HO 'ITO MO I HO 6bIllO 6bl TaK I e Ha3BaTb PYCCKHM HaHHOHa­ nH3MOM BOT noro KaK-TO COBceM He omymaJIOCb B nOClle r Hee 250 251