Page # 3 and 4 are redacted in full IAW bl and b3 exemptions Pages are not included C0 312127 I LH JIt'IGH I IUN Page 1 of 4 From Sent svcsmartmti 1 912010 7 42 19 AM To SMART Core Subject 10 PAKISTANI SCHOLAR PRAISES DRONE STRIKES AND OFFERS ANALTERNATIVE ANALYSIS ONTHE TRIBES U b 3 10 USC 424 b 3 10 USC 424 b 3 50 USC 3024 i Jan 09 2010 10912352 JAN 10 b 3 10 USC 424 b 3 50 USC 3024 i DIA WASHINGTON DCRounNE b 3 10 USC 424 PAKISTANI SCHOLAR PRAISES DRONE STRIKES AND OFFERS AN ALTERNATIVE ANALYSIS ON THE TRIBES U Date DTG From Action Subject QQQQ SERIAL U COUNTRY b 3 10 USC 424 U PAK PAKISTAN b 3 10 USC 424 b 3 50 USC 3024 i b 3 10 USC 424 SUBJ OFFERS AN ALTERNATIVE WARN--NG EVAWATED DO J U THIS PAKISTANI SCHOLAR PRAISES DRONE STR KES AND ANALYSIS ON THE TRIBES U11 - IS AN INFORMATION REPORT REPORT CLASS FTFD NOT FINA LY INTELLIGENCE 20100104 b 3 10 USC 424 1 U DESCRIPTION -- OPEN SOURCE OP-EN SCURCE DAILY TIMES b 3 10 USC 424 b 3 50 USC 3024 i LAHORE-BASED LIBERAL ENGLISH LANGUAGE DAT3 OF SOURCE 2014C104 b 1 1 4 c CLASSIFICATION 19-69 N19CC111-1 It Page 9 of 4 DAILY R%Jw DA L _'TIMES COM PK C05312127 ucrasslrwH I IuN Page 2 of 4 b 1 1 4 c SOURCE B 1 U DESCRIPTION -- OPEN SOURCE OPEN SOURCE THE NATION CENTER-RIGHT NATIO14AL ENGLISH DAILY WWW NATION CCM PK DATE OF SOURCE 20100108 2 U CONTEX _ STATEMENT -- A LONG-STANDING ENGLISH LANGUAGE DAILY INCREASINGLY KNOWN FOR A STRIDENT ANTI-US BIAS ERITES OFTEN SENSATIONALIST PIECES CRITICAL OF US FOREIGN POLICY AND THE US PRESENCE IN PAKISTAN ARTICLE WAS TAKEN FROM THE INTERNET VERSION OF THE PAPER SOURCE C b 3 10 USC 424 b 3 50 USC 3024 i P AG3 6 1 U DESCRIPTION -- OPEN SOURCE OPEN SOURCE DAILY TIMES LAHORE-BASED LIBERAL ENGLISH LANGUAGE DAILY %'FAn' VA LYTIMES COM PK DATE OF SOURCE 20091229 b 1 1 4 c b 3 10 USC 424 SUMMARY U ENCLOSURES TEXT SEE EXECUTIVE SUMN_ARY 1 4f b 3 10 USC 424 RESEARCH SCHOLAR BASED EXECUTIVE IN OSLO NORWAY SUMMARY RECENTLY 1 BELOW A PAKISTANI PEI4NED TWO THE CONVENTIONAL WISDOM IN PAKISTAN ABOUT DRONE STRIKES AND THE U14REST IN FATA THE FIRST PIECE TAKES APART THE NARRATIVE PROPAGATED BY THE PRESS AND OTHER ANTI-US ENTITIES THAT US COUNTERTERRORISM OPERATIONS VIOLATE PAKISTANI SOVEREIGNTY AND KII L COUNTLESS CIVILIANS IN THE SECOND PIECE THE AUTHOR OFFERS All ALTERNATIVE VIEW OF THE TRIBAL PEOPLE WHOM SHE VIEWS AS HISTORICALLY OPPRESSED BY A DOMINATING PUNJABI SECURITY PROVOCATIVE ELITE THE OP-ED PIECES TEXT PARAGRAPH STATE THAT CHALLENGE SHE CLAIMS HAS USED THE TR BAL AREAS AND IMPORTED b 3 10 USC 424 b 3 50 USC 3024 1 m r r 1 PAGE 7 JIHADIS INTO IT AGAINST THE WILI CF THE RISES AS A STRATEGIC BASE TO LAUNCH AT ACKS AGAINST AFGHAN STAN AND OTHERS RO NOTES THE AUTHOR'S VIE'r4S ARE HER OWN AND ARE DIFFICULT TO PROVE GIVEN THE LACK OF ACCESS INTO THE TRIBAL AREAS BUT HER VIEWS MAKE FOR COMPEL ING READING RC ADDS A THIRD PIECE AS A SAMPLE OF THE DRONES ARE EVIL MANTRA THAT APPEARS HERE REGULARLY ENCLOSURES b 3 10 USC 424 IN THE FIRST PIECE F ARHAT TAJ AN 2 1 ETHNIC PASHTUN CLAIMS THE STRIKES ENJOY HUGE SUPPORT AMONG TRIBAL PEOPLES TERRORIZED BY A14 OCCUPATION OF BRUTAL FOREIGNERS THE A UTHCR WRITES THAT THE PRECISION IS A CAUSE FUR JOY AMONG THE RIBALS AS THE COLLATERAL DAMAGE WHILE KILLING THEIR OPPRESSORS IN THE SECOND PIECE THE NATION RANTS ABOUT THE OUTRAGE OF PAKISTAN'S SOVERE GNTY BEING VTOLATED BY THE US IN THE THIRD FNCLOSF D PTECE TAJ AGAIN TAKES 014 THE PAKISTAN STATE WHICH SEE CLAIMS HAS CONSCIOUSLY SUBJUGATED TRIBAL SOCIETY AS PART OF A POLICY TO USE THE TERR TORIES AS A BASE FOR HOUSING AN JIHAADIS WITH AN EXPANSIONIST AGENDA SHE REFERS THESE ACTORS IN FATA AS INTERNATIONAL ARMED JIHADI GROUPS AND STATES THAT MA14Y ARE UNJA3_ BY ETENICITY ATTACKS MINIMIZE CLASSIFICATION Page 2 of 4