·• D£P RTM£N'T C STA TC JC l• - ' f ·· TO fflROt1Gl C b l l 67 -- Fat»t 1 ' - ' _CbHS · Thi s-•ca se ··re llains -bothersome • --'l'he c onnota uon s for the-·1 xec ut1ve are not 900d J n the Bill academic col ' i n nit y ·-··· • the press u d the Bo ma -i furily the intiutions ue of r egliqence on our p rt or worse complieity i Hon iAn' · death lvnile the focus o dlis memo is on Hor nan the se a applies to the case of F -a n lt 'l'eruggi •·•• l - · - •-• ·-•··- ·· ·' • • • • • ••• - 1 •• Ill _ •• o r _ • • • • •• • •• • • ' • •••• • categorically to -e ute s _u ch innuer r os in defa se o u s cf cials to p oce• against involved 1 - is is a z ec bJ ✓ if • Wi o t furt er tho cugh i vestigatior we a e in a position to o r either ± tne - c - do ·2 1ot ·bave ··a··coheren t account -of what happened see att ched •Gleaniny•• 'tba t--is why we believe we s l uld continue to prc e ·• Cb CS --· o s c icial• B sec or wr at we ha-e we ce persuaeed th t -- -he GOC SOt ght F O ' aJ I• ar d el t th atened · enough to order his immediate executi n 'rhe Gt C might h ve believed this Amez ic an could •be killed fl ut negative tall-out f c m 1 he JJSG -- ----- There is so e ci 'r6 r u tantial evic ence to • ggest lb CS o s · intell gence - ay··have_-playe an'··un fortunaee part in Horman• a 6 u th At best - ·-· u· '··· - s -· XGDS-4 - 1 _ -_ - ---- 4 '- ' -- - ·- ---- --- - - - · - - ' _ _- • ·- T t - 2 - it was li J lited to providing or con ir iing infor ation that helped otivate hi• mw der by I' the coc At worst o s intelligence was aware the COC saw Eoni n in a rat ' er seriows light and D S officials id nothing to discourage the logical outcome of GOC puanoia • • Our leads are - • · Rafael Conzalez Eis men al con ition is open to quest OQ Yet this my be selective since he can also be pretty lucid If he is unbal nced it is for Chilean intelligence to explaa why they kept bin on the payroll for so me ny years and used hi r i as contact with us on Bonnan Wa should question ha fu --ther alon9 • lines s ge5te in th• enclosure - 1·· p - l ' · ·- En - aue Sanc oval' s brothe Inquiry would have -· to E itade wi£h connr ere cl e discretion Approach H6i -· •- -ing _ he brother most likely' Colonel Guiller ao ·• ·• • ' S i coval Velasaue il to confirm Ho was shot ' the SUl U -would be terribly sensitive ii evelatic o his in isc •tion in 1973 ul eneanger e Colonel l poss ly oee 1 We L skeptical that anything positive cm be accOJ P- lished t ' rc h t li line of icguiry The GOC •-· ·Q · 5 - 'l'he Chil eans h e ve faile satisfacto rily to explain why Gonz l ez wu c lo5e to deal with our _Consulate in the search for Korman'• body _ _We could press them on this point Pre enbly a ter • e clari y few things with Gon l•z We _could I I also ask for•-c ocplete copy of the autopsy cf 1 or ia ' s b dy which we do not setm to have • I I b l flt' ··-- t IA1 The A eney's ccm er t • en its relatlo - a with · zale c o not explain Gonzalez ' kliowlec il _ of ft 3 ·•· _ The · Jnee d s f rlt er illuirna tion T 4' c c 1-a _ s l-••• f nd -4 o n at er c_A d __ Fur • _ it r' ' i i hard to believe that the Chileans did not check _ withf regarding two detained 1 nlericans whe 1 'the COC was checld cr wit Hoc an'• fri•n · I I I i - _ I and ne1 - rs regar61ng So ian'a • tivities L ack cf cando r with us o '1 other matters only he _ •ns our suspicions rrrgrr- it · - ' · •· •' • • • - iii · • ' _ I I I • - ·- -- ' - --- ·-·-- --- - - ' -- ---- --- --- ---- - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- I I I - I I I I J l MER Othe - Actors - -• 3 - Accounts by Mrs Bormzn Terry Si mo Frank Ma 'll tzas Ce ct Davis a nd others don• t al1 fit in place '1' are is room or further in1cuJ ry here But this should wait a bit ' · · 'I We heve accepted without question g the r torg e record that a body• la ter identified -- oroner mo que as B o cme n • • wu Ulllped u the street and in the 111or ue at 1330 9 18 · @ was logc ed A death certifieat e was issued a week later and an autcpsy was perforuied October S putting the ti me of death as 09'5 9 l 8 his imi lies th•t Hori ia -i wa s killed no late·r than about 17 hours after being detained That is he was shot e u ly 9 18 _ l'his is in conflict with eports the Chilean intellic ence wu trying to get • l ine on H0n 1an throughout t e morning of 9 18 bl- S s it possible the re d• · are phor y to ccuce a i t le t it e o ea u · ncS why · · -w---- --- DIA FB I _ - ·· ·· -et l5 b SJ • - have askec 'INR tc ·question both t ' IA and Far a bout NlY records they lni ht h ve t n Borman and I rerugg-i L V ' _U f - SS v • u Q U - t t ' j - t --1 - h 11 q_ 5 1'-i '1c C Hl ' we JU Y be wrong This is an _ - - -_ avenue we have to c i ther follow or cl ose · • - -- · Te c eii Finally the Horman and n eres ing Bot l worked fo r FIN did eho es for ro esso E ein at and both were arrested d 2l no1t '1' eru - · · liri_ s are klipping service • the Ford Foundation i mr ec iataly shct ot 80 Azneriel 1'1s who re ui e4 the E -bassy's attentien b S only these t wo ep ec to have bee tortured ari 4 en ' shot In their October 30 JDeffi0 to Cclonel Bon th Chileans lucped them tc ether as radical a Goczelez' statement that Ho an was oor si ere as knowing too s c ' c 0n- es to u 'le ru e i 71 c- st tie e c irc tL lces of bot 'l de3 s • Attaclu tent • I Ir1 · •• • • I I _ __ _ _ • t • •·•· • • X' 'y• • r · i- 'fl' ' • j- I '- • ' ' - l t I • • • • • '• •·· · · L 4 r ·• a· 4' • · • I c ' C • • •• • '• • I C O f i 'vP '• • f ' · • t • ••- • • •• i IE - - C • •C - •t• • '• •' 11 • • - f 4 •fl' ••••£' S _• 4•'-'ff n l I jl D T ' 1 hl hc felt i' ' h I h ' - Gleanincs had l f k' hill — fh - activation to proceed acainst Ho r Qnc o Ilo sn's o d neighbozs was caLled about OOOO 9 1S 73 by a pezson identifying hiraalf as an of»icc foz Chilean nilitazy intelligence Sha was told that g ingo with a beaM had bean detained an unidsnti»isd and he had hsr name and phone'neer Sha explained Boznan wa a for neighbor wh L occasionally used hcz p'hone Shs was asked if she knew Boznan was an extzcnist and whether she knew he worked in filunaking Sha responded she had no knowledge of Ho„ cn's activities i udatcd xeno by husband I a io Carva al Arcya at d to 10 30 73 nano by Anderson Ques 'cn Hcw d'' ch%yd i t5 I C — e GOC -accused Sornan and szuagi of subve siva activities Cct 30 n fran Ch'lean Az y Zntelligenca ucctic hhcza did they gat the info wtion h7 ct was the aszs fo thai- conclusions Gan Lutr said they had knowledge that Tezuggi was in Ch'lc to sp aad false s to thc ou side wo ld ega ding Rile Col I on re- o of LO 15 73 I cr s ggi we ' valved in a nc s cl'pping czv' c pzk favor ' lc o aliunde - urdy zcsclcr Ho u was doing research cn GQC USG tie in Sc cider esca sina 'cn w Eoznan Bor- - wo ksd in Chile Piles fo Zd 'a do Pa cd s on -t' a lande Invest'cutie cs Director Hanitnas G C h 5 it IICR I - CASS s 4» sd co u savory th they tni ntsd Bo - an rs'ur Panacea as a soll ce fc — Bo knew tcc -- Goncalsn Ec--an is Was s'tu y o» tl e b 3» ccasional zefs crees a e na c to Te ugci since hs cacus a-e C c pro «I 5199900VVGI 1 Exon p ion s Deny Dcc ca b 5 2 0 Vhe «iliad Ho n - Chmm«oloqv« Fo rctuzns to Santiago 1730 Saturday with Capt Davis 9 15 73 He chechs into Riviera Petal night o 9 15 Steven Volk anderson mero of IO I 73 to his gus ere on 9 16 Mrs Eozaan Mrs returns Uozmau lash So on 9 17 Santiago 4715 9 29 73 Put reported to U S Pmhassy sl e had not seen he husbandshe afte 9 10 when he left fo Vina del Maz Santiago 5667 saw husband ' - v Il 18 73 —Visits 'U S Massy afternoon of 9 17 Mania as —A z«liter patrol azz sts Pc an on 9 17 between 1630-1800 hours neighbors gifp th y lilt 111 Q — military return 'at 2200 and haul away several caztons 1 ' place neighbors Pzierd of Ro «s Mazwic «A t g gets secondhand messace morning o 9 18 to repo to the pclico statio to answer questions regard«ug aneamst friend who res San «ago 5667 11 I 73 from Hoznan's — f1 —Wa «ick w rcng i«nfo Cccaula around noon 9 18 that Pc -an was detained —Fili ary intelligence calls neighbors amund 0800 9 10 to ash about data' ed bee ed grege cazva al Araya Hzs Meric Jc is seen c side oen nut-«of ice Gonzalez s 'cn Sha t«««2 C — he Pc eign YMistzy confirms then denies Rcrman d taiucd at the stadium September 20 and zclea ed the follcwing day Poteign Kinistzy was was tN o f' cia said r«litary 1lc -an had been savagely mc o 10 18 73 sources reported that beaten and shot Anderson —Ch'lean vho asked not to be i unified clair d tha a relative an officer in Naval Zntclligancc said tha zican priscnet who the relative had personally inta ogatcd had later been ta cu out and shot Anderson nano 10 10 73 Sou cs at stadiu passos vozd to E assy through zn igu Sand ' 1 amund 9 30 that lloznan is dead Snzicue Sz do val state - ent to Kcssler Oiuguid PMzcs he Gon ales Connection — b 6 3 - Gon alex sezved fo- 20 years as intclligcnca with Sational Defense Staff Gcc ales —w's Gona ln s ' 31 had contacts with punic cent hin to pYck up oz o» icc -hcn dcl'ver natczial - On 9 11 'acc'ccoauiad b 6 1 troops that sterned La Bonada Bic 3cb vas to collect papers and to toke thezz to the s zy of oe ease Gon nice C stion Can ve vc i r this fran GOC moo - —Ec xvlnntee d his se riess to the nilitszy i ns czz d to PACB 5 15 74 as a civil'zn viEN rank Capt in the r sczvcs Gonzales Sav t' c 'guys' that brought Bozcnn back to Santiago b o talon of cation Sno ve thcv Be vz cnllod in to t Of ica of A 'lntnalicanco on twa lo an a st Gonzalez At th ti e Le v s working fcz the Estado v aoz de Oefensa Bacionzl zz V to O - zng Bureau's Spanish vas rather poo despite his n vy conchs in Chil„ Lt Col Ryan - 10 5 73 nano nut Gonzalez neve talked to Boznan Gcnralaz Ouestions %ho called Gonzales in i hat tine vas it2 low icng va he in the off'ca What el c vas said about Yozcan2 Can hc further describe the civilian in the o «ice Gr 1 - Ilk j X„ f i h Ch lean X aval counter intelligence off ce tolls Bilgzp 3 14 74 hc has autho v to effect tzansfa c X ocean's reruns Bibassy cable Co zalea contacts Anderson at thc U s Consulate Anderson Gonzales was sent 'ixxtelligcncc service' on March 214 1974 tc by assist Consulate in recognidtionh and ex tarnation of Bc he body Gcn alc Be would not' nam the superior officer giving hixx the order Erbassy cable ha intelligence ser ice' who sent hin zenenbered t' xat Gon alar had seen alive and coaaeguentiy could identify the body Gonzales O csticnsx trxc sent Conzalcs to the Ccn ulnta7 d ' ll hh I h hin Did he identify hinself as n PACB Lt Col as - i — Bo b 5 ' ed by Andarccn —'Scnabcdy fzcn CZA cane ove to tbe h inistzy nate nct recalled and togethc they went to the cmetezy to sea eh foz Boznan's body Gonzalez- 4snitzas tape stionsx was this Anderson as this a second O ' call allowing Ccnzalc 4 B- ide ti cn the Consult 7 cd Bornanhs body by the clothes blond h- — acd bc- d Gonzales r-Gassy cable Bcznan had a bcazd ban seen outsi 'e Lu ' off co Gon aloe cc Davis described Honcan as havina on 9 15 a and blac'r hair mw of 10 30 73 But shaved his beard on 9 15 c 9 17 'because of the cox 'p B m tzas Pu dy xxxcno of 11 30 73 However 3 Eo M sau hcr husbaxxd last ti oxl 9 16 and circulated pictu o of Human with beard Puzdy nc- -o o ll 30 73 'hen detain-d Bo an had a beazd 4 - t Bo 4 -rid lly 4 h 4 - -' dll 4 hlin e p cs 'h xat about thc bl cnd blacw hair disczcpanc Oz' be d no beard aspect h'-- 4 l' —Ccnzalcz ta ' cs acyl in Ztalian Bnbassy on Septenbcr 1075 Allegcs DISA threatened to kill hin because hc 3 knows too nu 'x and was critical of DZBA abuses Gonzalez —Gonzales b begins to spread stories of alleged cozy mlati cnc and nisdccds of nunezcus oPicidals accuses providix g hit woz ing 3 4 QOC lists to DZBA Bnbansy of Novenbcz l975 AP correspondent and talion so a atoly bring Gonzales' etonian to Enbassy's Charge attention Tiptcn Steven Zn —Enbassy checks xi bf ' as refacHK xtD -M prinz to 9 7 Gcnznle is desc-Red i dicates record able Gcn Av alen' legations denied r rtal stnbii™ry isCZAques icn- esse s zola 'on xith DZ A chief Is a w-length consistent xith agreed-u n gaidolincs tho fera unconcerned if Gonsn1ez ' a cnsations apoeaz I press assy apparently heads o f p ss sto ios on Gonzalez' allegations Gon aloz re cm to previous p ofoss al contact xith Gmo nl utz latter to Pinochet 4 27 76 ea ly June 1976 Ranch Onang and Nanit as held seve sl int revs xith Gonzalez Gonzalez is asbcd «he hcz hc k o«s any M g agarding «o load Africans e znfczs to Bo -an says he navar heard o 'Tcrucgi Be repeated his allegations that CZA got tdizod up — Zn to a's doa h nnd 'xns behind it sv interviaxs xi the press Qon o Zmde vcn as a CLL agent alas zafcrs Rani zac tape is z ccats thin to U S Consul June 22 cnd cini s he h ' bncsn Pzdcrvon socially since Iccv2 Be also rcfezn Zo snd dencziuos e ployoe - - -nvsy says he vast lztely refer ing to a cnployce xho xas zecnntly transferred ' -i — s e ' tor-icvs U S press eonfirns Con lc bona fii' ec as rot' zed civilian fzon FBCB This based on Zn i — d i' i ' i i i i i i fi Ji no 6 intezvicx xith 7 5 Consul Gon alos invi s Consul to send Bnbassy lltieal o fleer to ri-c i h'n oc hin noxledga ooperations Zn f p 5 P Hze 'tive — iv ed fot Tat oo withheld in w dCketa en loyoe af twose Ko werc stationed - Ho 111 - uw RZ onsx ' c he said oan t p azez 0 docs His sg'4 8 wl in also ticnad tho 1 c 1950's l na t G utiago vozxecg xn chile during Hp with details how 6 h I' - d dicclRLA Gon ales on July 6 shows Consul N letters from pay at ists 'attesting to his mental stahility dssy cable says Gonzales 'has shown she intelligcnco zutd lucidity in intemievs with Consu' Dues-dens Hov do va reconcile this lucidity and the zopo ted psychiatrists ohsezva 'cns with the annsticn of Gon alas' inntahili 2 — 5 5 tl is J H w 4 Di' th USC '1 olav a role in Hotman's a est of ho 1 zogis -ation card for Hc- Simon cht ' ad Ca t Davis - nemz 10 30 3 Copy o 5 dna oy enon Did the vncn was t lo c UZ Havel Nission l dcs G C-5-Ange teen i dc — -ed hy C' zc was cn hn vay w cw2 copy 'nt 'ripened Ho Ho m's zc um from Ualpdzniso vith Capt Davis Diuguid ' 'tzas based o Gcnzale intefvievs t waited outcid G nznlez inagined the civilian to hc with U 5 intalligeucc hy the vay h bo ' dvcd his cress shoes and everything Gener 1o '-si tzas tape acticrs Cnn hc but css his conclusion vi h rene n ow ' cn Can hc provide a description of this tho coup the number of V S intelligence agents in Chile Got zalea speculates in June 6 state ant that GOC would not dam shoot a V ci iran unless a 'go snead vas given fmm the U U side Juno 6 intervicvsy t ausczipt s z —g e ocher 30 oezornndun frou g Znte11igence sly have buon also based on indozrm ion prov'ded bv U intaIliganm tiuguid e Chicane vere seeking con ation that Boruan vas a radical Rzs Cazva al or other infomaticn on his fa trong Guesthouse gas U S ir telligenco q ez-ed abouBo f ouldn't the Chileans logically ask its U intelligence contacts about a U S citizen c sidepod dangozousg to Colcnel ' s Bon s