3KcnponpHIlUHJlMH H peKBH3HD HJ1MH nOnbITKH HaBeCTH AHCI1 Hl1JlH­ BY nyTeM napTHHHoro KOHTponJi H8 l npoq COI03aMH 3KOHOMHKa oCa J Horo nOnO lKeHHJI nOA q narOM KOMMYHHCTH'leCKOH HAeOnOrHH lIaCTH'lHO OpraHR30BaHHblH xaoc HeBblCnaBlIlHeCJI KOMHccapbl B KO­ lK8HbIX KypTKaX KpyrnocyTo'lHo H OOcnnoAHo nblTalOmHeCJI YHHllTO­ AJleK Hoe I lfT CBo60 l HblH PblHOK H ToprOBnlO K Hallany 1920 r OOn Ie apMHH OO lK8nH Ha Bcex q poHTax H 6on lIleBHKH YCTaHOBHnH KOHTponb H8 l BeeH HCTomeHHoH CTpa­ HOH HaCTanO BpeMJI nO l yMaTb Ha KaKOH OCHOBe MO lKHO ocymecT­ BHTb peKOHCTPYKIJ HIO Omana B03MO JKHOCTb HnH Heo6XOAHMOCTI» HOBAJl3KOHOMH1IECKAB OOJIHTHKA Bee nOA'lHHJITb coo6pa lKeHHJIM Boopy lKeHHOH 6op 6bl 3a BbI lKHBa­ HUe Tenepb H8 l ne lKanO Hcnon 30BaTb Bee HMelOmHeCJI B H8nH'lHH H30 cpep CTBa IlJIJI 03p opoBneHHJI CTpaHbl C KOHna 'laCTb 1919 1918 r H 6onbIIIYlO r yp ep lKHBaeM8JI COBeTaMH TeppHTOpHJI POCCHH 6bWa oTpe3aHa OT npe lKHHx HCTO'lHHKOB CblPbJlIlJlJI TeKCTHnbHOH npoMbIIIl­ neHHOCTH TYPKeCTaH H npH6anTHKa OT Heq TH OT 'uoHeUKoro yronbHoro 6aceeiiHa OT nlIleHHUbl CeBepHoro KaBKa3a H YKpaHHbl OT 60nblIleH 'laCTH MeTannyprHlleCKHx H CT8nenHTeiiHbIx 3aBOP OB CyJQ oen BOeJIIIoro KOMMyBII3Ma Tenepb Bee 3TO CHOBa 6bInO B pyKax COBeTOB HO B nna'leBHOM COC­ MO JKHO BbJAenHTb cne 1UHe ocoOOHHOCTH BOCHHoro KOMMY­ HH3Ma 1 BeeH npoMbnuneHHoCTH rocYAapcTBeHHOC pacnpeAeneHHe nOqrH Beex MaTepu8nbHbIX pecypcOB H TOH HeMHorO'IHC'JIeHHOH npo­ AYKlJ HH KOTOpas TorAa npoH3BoromaCb B nepBYIO O'lepeAJ IlJIJI BoeHHblX HY'K l 2 3anpeT 'laCTHOH TOprOBJIH KOTOPblH He 6bIn OCOOOHHO 3CPq eKHaCHnbCTBeHHOe H31 JlTHe H3nHIIlKOB Y KpeCTbJIH npoApa3­ npouecc o6p yMbwaHRJI peKOHCTPYKIJ HH H3-3a npHHJITHJI 3KCTpeH· HbIX Mep Ho K KOHUY OKTJI6pJI 1920 r npeKpaTHnHc Cp8 lKeHHJI KnIO'leBOH npo6neMoH OCTaB8nHCb omOlIleHHJI C KpeCTbJIHCT' HOH MenKoH npoMblIIIneHHoCTH CTaHOBHnOCb Bee fianee O'leBH l HO qrO OpraHbI rOCYAapcTBa He B CHnax CnpaBHTbCJI C ynpaBneHHeM lIaCTH'lH8JI nHKBHAaD HJI AeHer BO B38HMOOTHOlIleHHJIX rocy­ AapCTBa C co6CTBeHHblMH OpraHR38D HJIMH H rpa I D 8HaMH nepexoA Ha OOcnnamoe cHa6 lKeHHe TaM r l e 6bWO 'leM cHa6 lKaTb 5 1920 r npolJ BH lKeHHe PYCCKHX K BapIIIaBe H 3aTeM TJlrOCTHoe oTcTynneHHe Ha BpeMJI npepBaJIH 3TOT BOM H BblTeKaBlIlHe OTCIOAa npo6neMbl CBo60p bI TOpmBnH H 'lacr· BepCTKa 4 3TOMy nonbCKoe BTop lKeHHe B Mae H C nonblIleH THBHblM HO nepHOAH'leCKH B0306HOBnMCJI 3 Bocnonb30BaTbCJI Hap o 6bInO npHHHMaTbCJI 3a peKOHCTpYKIJ HIO H napTHHHOe PYKOBOP CTBO Bee 60nblIle yp enMo BHHMaHHe HMeHHO OOnblTKa 3anpeTa 'lacmoro npoH3BOACTBa HaUHOHanH31lUHJI nOqrH TOJIHHH OAHaKO pecypcbl Bce·TaKH HMenHCb H HMH C'JIep OB8nO BceMH ceKTopaMH npoMbIIIIneHHOCTH C pa3MemeHHeM H pacnpep e­ neHReM peCYPCOB C ToprOBneH PeKBHlHlJ HH np0P pa3BepCTKa Bbl· 3bIB8nH OT'laJIHHOe conponmneHHe 60nblIlHHCTBa KpeCTbJIH Boccra­ Bee 3TH q aKTOPbl CO'leT8nHCb C TeppopoM H npOH3BonOM HOBneHHe cenbCKoro X03J1HCTBa 6bInO HeMblC'JIHMO 003 MaTepH8nb­ HOH 38HHTepeCOBaHHOCTH H XoTb KaKorO-TO qyBCTBa OO30nacHoCTH y Alec Nove An Economic Books Middesex 1982 38 History of OTPblBKH H3 KHHrH the USSR Penguin KpeCTbJlH fOCYAapCTBeHHble eenbCKHe X03JIHCTBa He 6bInH IlJIJI HHX npHeMneMblM pelIleHHeM KpeCTbJIHe pelIlHTenbHO npOTHBHnHCb 39 nepe r 3'1e 3THM x03Jdi cTBaM nOne3HOH 3eMnH KOTOPOH XOTenH nOnb30BaTbCH caMH TpOUKHH npe n CTaBnHeTCH KaK Kpaii HHH CTOPOH­ HHK lJ HC nnHHapHbIX Mep UHH TPY r 3 11 B 1920 r OH HaCTaHBan Ha MHnHTapH3a­ Bee Ke HMeHHO TpOUKHH 6bID nepBblM H3 6onbllie­ BHCTCKOro PYKOB0 n CTBa ny6nH'lHo npH3HaBlIIHM He06xo lJ HMOCTb nOKOWIHTb C npo n pa3BepCTKOH OTMeHHTb HanOr HaryPOH o6ner­ 'lHTb CB060 lJ HyIO TOprOBnIO HnH no KpaHHeH Mepe TOBapo06MeH nOXO Ke qTO eHHH 6b1n B paCTepJlHHOCTH 1920 KOHUa B npHH SlTblX n o r • n eKpeTaX HeT HH HaMeKa Ha cMJlrqeHHe Kpaii HOC­ rei BoeHHoro KOMMYHH3Ma 3TH n eKpeTbl 6b1nH 60nee KeCTKHMH qeM Kor r 3 61 1 TO HH 6b1no OC03HaBaH npoKnJITbIH 3aKOll n OBaHHbli Kpyr frO 6e3 npoMblmneHHoro npoH3Bo n CTBa He 6y n eT npo­ n OBonbCTBHJI B ropo r 3X a 6e3 npo n OBonbCTBHJI He 6y n eT npoMbIlli­ OH 06 3TOM rOBOpHn B q eBpane 1920 r Ha 310M Ke rHeBHO KpaCHO­ pe'IHBO HaCTaHBaJIH TOr r 3 elli e aKTHBHl le MeHbllieBHKH OC06eHHO neHHoro npoH3Bo n CTBa eHHH nbITanCJI npoPBaTb ero nyTeM elli e c I 11• naH CJI B npoMblUIDeHHbIX TOBapax a He B 6YMa I HbIX n eHbrax eHHH Ho 3TH npe ll 10 KeHHH Bbl3bmanH pelIIHTenbHoe COnpOTHB­ neHHe eHHHa KOTOPbIH no BeeH BH l HMOCTH B TOT nepHO n CKnO­ HeH 6b1n C'lHTaTb CBo60 lJ HyIO ToproBnIO no caMOH ee CyTH rocy r 3p­ CTBeHHbIM npeCTynneHHeM Ho r 3 Ke eHHH npH3HaBan frO peKBH3H l HH 6bIDH He06xo lJ HMOH BpeMeHHOH MepoH Bbl3BaHHOH lIpe3BbI­ 'IlI iiHbIM nOnO KeHHeM H 06lli eii HHlli eTOii CTpaHbl UH TO Ke He Ha n eJlnCH frO KpeCTbJlH y r 3CTCJI y6e lJ HTb H B lJ anbHeii meM n 06pOBonbHO 60nee 6eenOlli a J HbIX peK 3 OH 3Han frO KpeCTbJllfe Hy K A31OT­ n onycKan frO 60nbllieBHKH n ecnOmqeCKH OTHOCJlTCJI K KpeCTbJIHCT­ BY HO npH 3TOM HaCTaHBan frO OT r 3BaTb CBOH H3nHlliKH n onr KpeCTbJlH 27 n eKa6pJl 1920 3TO r BblCrynaH sa KOHq epeHUHH B MOCKBe eHHH npH3bman K HOBblM aTaKaM Ha KynaKOB He Ubl­ TaHCb onpe n enHTb 3ry KaTeropHIO Toquee nIOAH Ha MeCTe Mory onpe n enHTb KynaK nH qenOBeK KOTOPbIH CKa I eM KynHn nOnIaAb OT lJ aBaTb H3nHlliKH B 06MeH Ha TO frO caM Ke eHHH Ha3Ban B 06MeH Ha IDlTb ny n OB 3epHa Kor r 3 OAHH H3 n eneraTOB 3aHBM KnOllKaMH 6ecnone3Hoii UBeTHoii 6YMarH eHHH no Bceii BHAH­ frO B MOCTH Ml lcnHn 0 HeKoeM po n e OpraHH30BaHHOro npo n YKTo06MeHa ero o6naCTH Ha CTaBpononbe 06 f13aTenbHbie nOCTaBKH cne n yeT COKpaTHTb fr06b1 H36e KaTb KOHq HCK H H He no n op­ KOTOPbIH no-npe I HeMY HCKnIOtJaJI 61 1 'l8 CTHbIX ToproBueB OCTaD­ BaTb X030CTBO eHHH OTBeTHn IIocrynaii Te TaK Ke KaK H paHb­ nJlJl KpeCTbJllf B nonHoii 3aBHCHMOCTH OT rocy n apCTBeHHblx HCTOq­ llie nocTynanH HHKOB CHa6 KeHHH Pe'IH Toro BpeMeHH a TaK Ke TaKHe nHTeparyp­ BnaCTH H Bamei KOMMyHHCTuqeCKoii COBeCTbIO 3 CnpaBe ll 1HBOCTH B CTporOM COOTBeTCTBHH C n eKpeTOM COBeTCKOH Hble npoH3Be n eHHJI KaK JleMeHT fna lJ KOBa CBH n eTenbCTByroT co paAH cne n yeT O J HaKO CKa3aTb frO B TOT n eHb eHHH OKUanC fI Bceii O'leBH lJ HOCTbIO frO orpoMHoe 6onblliHHCTBo qneHOB napTHH B MeHblliHHCTBe Kor r 3 npe ll 10 l Hn BBeCTH npeMHH KpeCTbJllfaM 3a npo n on I aDH nOBbIllieHHe npoH3BOAHTenbHOcm HX X03J1HCTB Ero Konnem C'IH­ paccMaTpHBaTb npeAIIpHHHMaTenbCTBo KaK CBo60 lJ HyIO 3no TOprOBnIO n OnyIIJ eHHe H 'l8 CTHOe KOToporo 6bIDO TanH frO npeMHH n on I Hbl BbI r 3BaTbCJI pUHOro po n a cenbCKOXO' KanHryn eH nepe n BparoM H n0310MY qepHblii PbIHOK cne n yeT 3J1ii cTBeHHbIM 06be D HHeHHJlM a He e lJ HHOnHqUHKaM eHHH Ha 310 6eenolli a D Ho HCKOpeH SlTb n03AHee eHHH npH3HaBanCJI frO OH OKa­ OTBeqan Mbl HMeeM ABa n uaTb MHnnHOHOB x03 f1iCTB KOTopble 3anCJI 29 no n anpenJi aTMoc epbl X03JIHHH'I8 IOT oT n enbHo H He MOry HHaq X030HH'I8 Tb H BOT ecnH r OH CKa3an MbI rOBopHM frO KpeCTbJlHHH n on­ MbI HX He 6y n eM B03HarpaJl l aTb ll 1J1 nOAHJITHJI npoH3BO lJ HTenbHOC­ B03 n eHCTBHeM 1920 roeno n CTBYIOlli eii Tor r 3 KeH lJ aBaTb pa60'IHM CBOH H3nHlliKH xne6a noTOMY frO npo n aBaTb 3TH H3J1HlliKH B ycnOBHJlX HaCTOJllli erO BpeMeHH 6bIDO 61 1 npecryn­ neHHeM H nOToMY KaK TonbKO MI I BOCCTaHOBHM HallY npoMbllil­ neHHOCTb ynoTpe6HM Bee YCHnHJI qT06bl y n OBneTBOpHTb KpeCTbJlH B rOTOBbIX q a6pHKaTax ropo r 3 1 11 Bee Ke Beero 3a ABa AHJI n o 3Toro eHHH roBOpHn Mbl He 6y n eM KOPMHTb Tex KTO He pa60· TH 3TO 6y n eT B KopHe HenpaBHnbHo 4 Ho 8 q eBpanJi 060neHcKHH npe ll 1o l Hn UeHTpanbHoMY KOMHTeTY OTMeHHTb npo n pa3BepcTKY H eHHH 3TO npe ll 10 KeHHe JlBHO 0 n 06pHn 5 pe30nIO IO 11 On HatJaJI roTOBHTb no 3TOMY Bonpocy BCe-TaKH 24 q eBpanJi 1921 r OKa3aBlIIHCb nepe n nHUOM C06bITHii KOTopble OH oxapaKTepH30Ban KaK KymuU He BOCCTaHHJI TaeT Ha COBeTCKHX npeAIIpHJITH SIx H B COBeTCKHX yqpe l J eHHJlX'' 2 H KaTaCTpoq HqecKYIO CHTya IO eHHH o6'b flCHHn HX KaK HHenH­ pacueHHBaH TaKHM 06pa30M KaK npecrynneHHe caM q aKT o6ecne­ pHpyeMbIH H3-3a rpaHHUbI 3eepoBcKHH 3arOBOp nOCKonbKY soc­ qeHHH TaKHX nIO n eii e n oii CTaHHJI npOHCxO lJ jJT KaK pa3 B Tex paii OHaX H3 KOTOPblX MbI 6epeM 40 41 XJIe6 6 1I0 D OOOble a6CYP D Hble 3aJ1BJIeHIDI CBH D eTeJII CTBYIOT 'ITO 3a no6e D bI 6enon apMHH HapaCT3JIa HHTeHCHBHOCTb KpeCTbmtCKUX nemm JIH60 nepeYTOMH1lC II JIH60 Boo6me MaJIO Ha D 3THM D yMaJI BOCcraHHH TeM He MeHee H OH nOCTeneHHO npHXO D HJl K Bbmo D y 0 He06xo D H­ 6aH D bI MOCTH nepeMeH D HJIOCb BBO D IITb n enble apMHH CaMbIM KpynHl IM 6bIJlO BOCCTaHHe 1920 B D eKa6pe Ha 06umpHbIX TeppHTOpwrx 6po D HJlH B HeKOTopbIe paHOHbI pa360ii lnf1lhH D roI nO D aBJIeHIDI BOCCTaHIDI IIpUXD­ r 6bIDa C D eJIaJla nonbITKa B D HpeKTHBHOM DO D BO D HTenI CTBOM AHToHoBa B TaM60BIUHHe OKa3bIBaJIOCb no D 20 MIIH yrpo30H cHa6 1 eHHe ropo D OB npoAOBonbCTBHeM 1I0cneAHeii cono­ nop II D Ke nOCTaBHTI no D KOHTpoJIl noeeBbl H coop ypo KaJI B KpeCTb IIHCKUX X03 11nCTB Pa3YMeeTC II 3Ta nODbITKa 61 IDa 06pelleHa MHHKon OKa3aJIOCb BOCCTaHHe MaTPOCOB KpoHlllTa l ra OTpa3HBumX Ha Hey D aqy Ho Bee l e HaMepeHHe 6bIDO O'leBH D HbIM H C non n eJIblO B CBOHX n03yarax B 6HOCTb KpeCTbmtCTBa K nonHTHlIeCKoii OpraHH30BaJIH IlOeeBKOMbl TaKon l e 3KcrpeMH3M 06HapY I 8­ JIHHHH napTHH 3ro BOCcraHHe Hal 3JIOCb B3JIC II B nOAXo D e K npoMblumeHHOCTH 3 D eCb KaK H Ha XJIe6HOM Bepo llTHO e HJlH BO BC IIKOM cnyqae He n03AHee q poHTe neHHH MbICllHJI B KaTeropwrx OpraHH3an HOHHb1X Mepon­ 24 npH3HaJI HaJ OHen Hacymayro He06xo­ pwrnm YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX npHopHTeTOB nO D aBJIeHH II pblHKa IIpo­ D IIMOCTb peumTenbHblX DepeMeH peTI oTMeay npo D pa3BepcTKH 8 MbrumeHHOCTI D 0JI K1f3 HallaTl pa60TaTb npO D OBOJIbCTBHe D OJI l HO 6blTl o6ecne'leHO CBOH CHJIbl Be Ha q eBpaJIH 8 q eBpaJIH 1921 r neHHH OR 28 q eBpaJIH 1921 r Ho npoJIBHJI rOTOBHOCTI paccMoT­ 110 Bceii Bep0 llTHOCTH HMeHHO non 3a D a'le HaM Ha D O COCpe D OlOlIUTb Bee KPOHlllTa D TCKoe BOCCTaHHe IIOMOTJlO y6e D HTb D a l e caMbIX KpaHHHX Ha D O pelllHTb BOeHHblMH Cpe D CTBaMH C nOJIHOn 60JIbllleBHCTCKUX PYKOBO D HTeJIeii 'ITO pe3KHii DOBOPOT CT3JI Bonpo­ 6ecnOma D HOCTblO C nOJIHbIM nO D aBJIeHHeM Beex OCTaJIl HbIX HHIe­ COM l H3HH HJIH CMepTH KaK D JI II pe I HMa TaJ H D JI II HHX CaMHX peCOB 7 3TO rOBOpHJI nemm HCnOJIHHTenl HbIM OpraHaM COBeToB nH'lHO 2 q eBpaJI II IJ HTaTe - 1920 PO D HJlacl HOBaJI 3KOHOMHl eCKaJllloJIHTHKa r Bepo llTHO nOClle D HHe HeCKOJIbKO CllOB B non KJIIO'IeBbIe D J1 11 nOHHMaHH II nOnHTH'IeCKOn JIHHHH Ha npo­ T II l eHHH Toro ro D a Pacna D 6bIJI nOJIHbIM HeoTJIO I HocTh 3a D a1f peKOHCTPYKIJ HH nO D J1OJIbHbrH He nO D J1e I aJIa COMHeHHIO 0 D HaK0 orpoMHbrH KaK npoH30UIJIJI nepeMeHW PbIHOK He nO t J tUmaBIIIHiiC II KOHTPOJIIO BblcaCbIBaJI 3a Bce HMelOllUIeC II peCypCbI pa3JlaraJI H annapaT H npoJIeTapHeB OT­ 1921-1922 nepeMeHbI rr H HeCKOJIbKO Docne D ylOllUIx neT coBepum­ CIO D a D eJI3JIC II BbmO D 'ITO 1fepHbln pblHOK cne D yeT nO D aBHTI nOJI­ nHCb H3MeHHBume HOCTblO Beero JIHlllb 3a ro D D O noro ByxapHH H Ilpe06pa l eHcKHn waHC qaCTHbrH ceKTOP MeJIKaJI 6YP 3wr Hal 3JIH D eii CTBO­ BeCb COIJ HaJIbHO-3KOHOMH'leCKnH JIeBa1feCTBOM OTKPblro YTBep l D 3JIH BaTh B nonHOM npoTHBope'IHH C H D eOJIOrHeH H npaKTHKoii BpeMeH B A36YKe KOMMyHH3Ma 'ITO HaIJ HOHaJIH3aIJ H II Bcen MenKon BoeHHoro KOMMYHH3Ma Pe3KO IIOBbICHJIaCb poJIb phlllKa He TOJIbKO npoMblIlIDeHHOCTH a6COJIIOTHO HeMbICllHMa lIoJToMY M3JIOBepoHT­ B OTHOllleHUH C KpeCTbmtCTBOM HO D a I e B PaMKax npHHa D De l alUe­ H3BeCTHbIe TOr D a CBOHM HO 'ITO neHHH D enCTBOBaJI no D D aBJIeHHeM JIeBbIx 1920 29 HO ll6p ll ro rOCY D apCTBY 3KOHOMH'IeCKOrO eeKTOpa Ii Bce l e KOr D a HaKD­ r 6bID H3 D aH D eKpeT 0 HaIJ HOHaJIH3aIJ HH MeJIKon npoMbllll­ Hen rOPbKaJI norHKa 06CTOHTeJIbCTB BbIay D HJla neHHHa K 3THM ne­ JIeHHOCTH XOTJI Bce e 6bIJIO JIH60 HaIJ HOHaJIH3HPOBaHO nH60 peMeHaM OH JlBHO He D OOn eHHJl Beex B03MO l Hl IX nocne D CTBHn napaJIH30BaHO CaMO co6010 pa3YMeeTC II a D MHHHCTpaTHBHble op­ raHbl 6bIDH COBepllleHHO Hecnoco6HbI cnpaBHTbC II MeJIKUX npoH3BO D CTBeHHbIX e D HH Xaoc HapaCT3JI C TbIC IIlIaMH Ha npoT II I e­ Mbl Y I e BH D enH 'ITO BnnOTh AO q eBpaJI II 1921 r nemm ynop­ HO npH D ep I HBaJIC II KYpca Ha DonHyro HaIJ HOH3JIH3an HIO n eHTpaJIH3a­ IlHIO JIHKBH D aIJ H1O D eHer H B nepByro Ollepe D b Ha coxpaaeHHe npoA­ Era HUH Bcero ro D a npe D DpHHHM3JIHCb YCHJIH II COXpaHHTh XOT II 6bI Ha pa3BepcTKH nepHO D peKOHCTPYKIJ HH THIIH'IeCKHe MeTO D bI BoeHHoro KOMMYHH3­ H3MeHHTb 3ty nOJIHTHKY Cpe D CTBOM y6e l D eHWI 6bIJl CKopee XOA Ma Ho 3TO OKa3aJIOCb HeB03MO I HbIM C06blTHH IIO D TaJIKHBaJIH 110 Mepe Toro KaK HC'le3aJIa yrpo­ 42 KOMerH He OKa3blBaJIH Ha Hero D aBJIeHIDI 'lT06bl C06blmH 'IeM HHHIJ HaTHBa UeHTpaJIl HOrO KOMHTeTa lIepBble ny6­ nH'lHbIe npo llBneHHH coMHeHHii 06Hapy l HJ1HCb Ha nneHapHOM lace­ 43 MOCKOBCKOrO COBem 28 1921 cpeBp81IJI r Kor n a neHHH llpH3H81I np3BOTy OAHoro H3 ne n eraTOB HaCTaHB3BWerO lITO KpeC­ 6o n a ToprOBnH - rOBOpHJl neHHH Ha X C'be3ne na l e eCJIH OHa ThJlHaM nOJDKHO 6hITh H3BeCTHO 3apaHee lITO HMeHHO H B KaKHX pa3­ B Ha1WIe He TaK CBJl3aHa C 6e n orBapneHn aMH KaK 6bm CBJ13aH KpoHIIITanT Bee-TaKH HeMHHyeMO npHBeneT K nOH 6enorBapneH­ Mepax OHH 06JI3aHbI utJDie K no6ene KanHT81Ia K nonHOH ero peCT3BPan HH 11 nOCTaBHTh rocy n apCTBY HHaqe rOBOpJl lITO H Bce l e peKBH3HUHJI H31IHIIIKOB non 1 Jf3 6bITh 3aMeHeHa HaTYP81IhHhIM H81IOrOM npo l H81IOrOM 9 Konh CKOpO na HneJl 6bma npHHJITa na CTonh O HHOH lITO KaK TonbKO B Mapre nyCTb He Gel conpoTHBneHHJI OHa BneKna 3a co601o nepeCMOTp 6bIna XOTh KaK-TO ner81IH30BaHa OHa Haqana paCTH KaK CHe l 8bIH Ha npaKTIIKe He06xo lI HMOCTb B CBo60AHOM 06MeHe TOBapaMH 6bl­ 1921 r TOprOBnJl Beex OCHOB 3KOHOMHKH BoeHHoro KOMM 'HH3Ma KaK Y l e OTMe'lll­ KOM CMeTaJI Ha CBoeM nYTH Bee nperpanbl • focy n apcmo noompJl­ nOCh nOCJIenHHe COMHeHHJI OCT3B3BIIIHeCJI y neHHHa Ha 3TOT cqeT nO pacceMHCh Kor n a HaqanHCh KpeCThJlHCKHe BOCCTaHHJl BO MHOrHX npH npo n a l e nOTpe6HTenbCKHX TOBapoB B nepeBHe KaK H TOBapoB paHOHaX CTpaHbI 3a KOTOPbIMH nOCJIenOB81IO BOCCTaHHe MOPJIKOB nlO60ro BH n a B ropo n ax HapJIAY C rocy n apcTBeHHOH P03HHqaOH KpoHIIITanm 3TO npoH30umo KaK pal BO BpeMJI X KoonepaTHBHYIO ToproBnlO OHa OKal81IaCh OC06eHHO ycuellIHa C'be3 n a napTHH ToprOBneH KOTOPaJI nOCTeneHHO nOnHHM81IaCb H3 pyaH BpeMeH Cpa3y nOCJIe BoeHHbIX Mep nO n aBneHHJl KpoHIIITanTCKOro BOCCTa­ BoeHHoro KOMMYHH3Ma Ho H qaCTHhle ToprOBn 1 qeM D aJlbWe TeM HHJl J1eHHH BhlCTyllHJl C npe l l10 l eHHeM 0 3aMeHe nponpalBepCTKH 60nbwe nonyqanH B03M0 l 80CTh ocymeCTBnJlTh ToprOBbIe onepaUHH npOAH81IOrOM n01iTH nlO60ro BH n a npo n a l a KpeCThJlHaM nOKynKa y KpeCTbJiH PeWeHHJI 06 3TOM 6bmH npHHJlTbI naprHeH a liTeM COBeTCKH­ MH opraHaMH Ha npoTJl I eHHH MapTa 1921 r BBeneHHbIH HaTYp81Ib­ HbIH H81Ior 6hm 3HaqaTenbHO MeHhwe peKBH3HUHH npeAWeCTBYIO­ mero ro n a ECJIH pa3BepCTKa B 1920-1921 CHaq81Ia Kor n a napTIIJl y6e lI HJIaCb B Heo6xo lI HMOCTH nepeMeH 6bIn paBeH 240 M1IH nynOB 'lrIJi KapTocpenJi COOTBeTCTBYIOmHe B 1924 60 rocy n apCTBeHHhlX npe n npHJITIIJlX npe l l10nar81IOCh lITO OTCTYDneHHe OrpaHHqaTCJI 3aMeHOH KOHCPHC­ MJIH nynoB xne6a TO npoAH81Ior Ha H Ha 1921-1922 rr 423 110 H3roTosneHHhlMH H B O l H8alOmeM 'IllcrnOM eeKTOpe rr 6hma YCTaHOBneHa no PCClICP B UHCPPbI 6hI1IH nynoB 10 KYDnJl-npo n a l a Ha rocy n apCTBeHHbIX npe l l1pHJITHJlX TOprOBnJl TO­ BapaMH M1IH nynoB a l I1J1 MJica - 2S 4 H 6 S MJIH KaUHH npBMhlM TOBapoo6MeHOM B OKTJl6pe npH3H81I 'ITO no 6bIno 1921 r neHHB oWH6KOH E lI HHCTBeHHbIM BbIXonOM 6bma TOprOBIIJI focy n apcmy H napTHH npenCTOJlIIO yqyThCJI TOprOBaTh r HaTYP81IhHhIH H81Ior 6bIn 3aMeHeH neHe l HhlM nHmb liTO Bbl rOBopHTe 0 rocynapCTBeHHOH TOprOBIIe B TIOpbMax Hac nOCJIe TOro KaK 3HaqaTenhHO npop sHaynacb cTa6HJlH3aUHJl B81IIOTbl TOprOBaTh He yqyIIH - lloCJIe ynnaTbI H81IOra KpecThJlHe MornH paCnopJl l aTbCJI cBoeH oc­ Hac B TlOpbMax yqyIIH TaBWeHCJI npoiJYKUHH KaK OHH CO ay l 8hlM MornH - KaK no yqyIIH yKal81I OnKH H3 neIIeraTOB - A BoeBaTb A rocy n apCTBOM ynpaBnJiTb B TlOphMax B03Pa l 81I neHHH 12 nOrHKa C06blTIIH CTHXHiiHbIe CHJlbI nonqepKHB81IOCb B nepBOHaqanhHOM neKpeTe npo n aBaTh ee TonbKO MenK06yp a3Horo oKpY l eHHJl CMeT81IH Bce nonbITKH HX orpaHH­ Ha MeCTHbIX PbIHKax Ho 3TO HMeno M81IO CMbICJIa eCJIH n e n blO qaTh 6bmo nOOmpJlTh ToproBnlO nponOBOnbCTBHeM HMeHHO B Tex paiio­ llapTHJl TBepnO ynep l H881Ia B pYKax rocy n apcTBa KOMaHn­ HaX rne HcnhITbIB81ICJI nponoBonbcTBeHHhlH necpHUHT TaK 'ITO 06 HbIe BbICOThl 3KOHOMHKH 6aHKH BHellIHI010 ToproBnlO KpynHylO nOM orpaHHqeHHH npHumoch 6bICTPO 3a6bITh npoMbIIIIneHHOcTb Ho B TO l e BpeMJi npH3H81Ia 'ITO nonbITKa nOlI­ Bbmo a6cypnoM npe l l1onaraTh 'ITO KpeCThJlHe CTasyT e3 lI HTh HOCTblO HaUHOH81IH3HpOBaTh npoMbIIIIneHHOCTh 6hma 01IIH60qaa B 3a COTHH KHllOMeTpoB ToprOBaTb CBOHM TOBapoM B D aJlbHHX npo­ YCJIOBHJIX MbIIIIneHHbIX roponax - BO 3TO Cnen81IO HeH36e l 80H ner81IH3aUHIO 1921 r npH TOT81IbHOM necpHUHTe OC06eHHO Ha TonnH­ MHOrHe ynp3BIIJleMbIe rocynapCTBOM npe n npHJITHJl npHIIl1IOCb qaCTHOH TOprOBnH KaKoe 6bI OTBpameHHe K HeH HH HCUbIThIB81IO 3aKpbITh a HeKoTophle KaK H MHO l eCTBO MenKHX MacTepCKHX 6onhIIIHHCTBo npaBOBepHbIX KOMM 'HHCTOB CHaqana OllJlTb-TaKH Han HOH81IH3HPOBaHHbIX B npeAbIA 'lUHe p sa ro l 8 C D aJlH B apeHAr HaneMHCh ynep l aTh 3TY ToprOBnlO non CTporHM KOHTponeM CBO­ 'IliCTHblM npe lJ IlpHHHMaTeIIBM HJlH pa3Horo THlla KoonepaTHBHhIM 44 4S TOBap eCTBaM 3a HaT 'PaJIbH '1O WIaT ' TOBapaMH WIH B C'IeT ynna­ npo l pa3BepCTKH npHBenH K ooKpameHHIO noceBOB K TOMY ICe BOC­ Tbl peHTl I l eHhraMH MenKHM npe UIpHHHMaTenHM H36eX aBllmM TOK H IOro-BOCTOK CTpaHbl nOCTHrJIa 3acyxa YpoX aH 3epHa COCTa­ OHaJIH3aQHH 6bInO n03BOneHO Bnpe lU AeHCTBOBaTb JIeraJIbHO BHJI B 17 Masr r l eKpeT 0 H OHaJIH3aUHH BceX MeJIKHX npe UIpHH­ 1921 mH 6bIn aHH 'nHpoBaH 7 HIOM 1921 r BceM rpax l aHaM 6bInO pa3­ peweHo CBo60 l Ho 3aHHMaTbCH KYCTapHblM npoH3BO l CTBOM a TaK­ Ire OpraHH30BbWaTb MeJIKHe npoMl WIneHHble npe UIpHHTHH He 60­ nee '1eM C 10-20 HaeMHblMH pa60'IHMH Cl1 lltIa B apeH l y npe UIpHH­ mH HaXO l HBllmXCH BO Bna l eHHH l eKpeToM OT 1922 5 HIOM 1921 BCHX 6bIna yperynHpoBaHa r H Ha npOTH lCeHHH r 6bInO C l aHO B apeH1J Y 60JIee 10 1922 r K HatIany UIC npe UIpHHTHH CPOKOM npH6hInH OKono r Bcero 54% MJIH T T e paHoHax 43% 1909-1913 rr 'ITO Y lCe 1921 r npHHec Bcero 37 6 cpe l Hero ypo KaH OT cpe l HerO l OBOrO l OBOeHHoro ypo KaH Ho B OXBa'leHHhIX 3acyxoH nOnO ICeHHe 6hInO HeCpaBHeHHO x MHJIJIHOHbl KpeCTbHH BhIMepnH OT rOJIOI1 ll TO'IHhle UH PPhi HeH3BeCTHbI BhInH npHHHTht MephI nOMOmH B nOCTpa1l aBllmX 06­ JIaCTHX 6hIn OTMeHeH HaTypanhHbIH HaJIor Ho HMeBWHXCH Y rocy­ J 8pCTBa 3anaOOB 6hInO He l OCTaTO'IHO 'lT06bI cnaCTH nonox eHHe BhIn opraHH30BaH KOMHTeT nOMomH rOJIOI1 llIOII UlM B KOTOPhIH 10-15% BOWJIH 06meCTBeHHhIe l eHTeJIH He KOMMYHHCThl H l a Ke aHTHKOM­ Cpe l H nHX npe UIpHHTHH npeo6nal1 llnH BeTpHHhle MeJIh­ MyHHCThl HanpHMep TIpoKonoBH'I H KYCKOB3 BnOCJIe l CTBHH OHH OT 1l BYX l 0 nHTH neT Ha YCJIOBHHX BblWIaThl rOCYl1 llpCTBY 3 800 6hInH HHUbI HO 1920 6h1JIo l OCTaTO'IHO cKBepHo 16 YpO ICaH 50% l OBOJIhHO KpynHhlMH - no 15-20 pa60THHKOB 'laCTHHKOB 6hIJIH MeJIKHMH npe UIpHHHMaTeJIHMH 13 6hInH apeCTOBaHhI BhIn3 npHHJITa nOMOllU H3 COe l HHeHHhIX IIIn­ TOB BhIJIH HCDOnh30BaHhl CKY l Hhle 3anaChi BaJIIOUI 'lT06h1 3aKY­ cpe l H HHX npe KHHe Bna l eJIhUhl l aHHhlX npe UIpHHmH K OKTH6plO DHTh 3epHO 33 rpaHHUeH Ho HeXBaTKa npo l OBOJIhCTBHH pa3pyxa 1923 Ha TpaucnOpre H 06masr Ae30praHH33UH 1 orpaHH'lHJIH 3 P peKTHB­ r 'lHCJIO C l aHHbiX B apeH1J Y npe UIpHHTHH B03POCJIO l 0 B cpe l HeM OHH 3aHHMaJIH l 0 16 pa60'IHx 1 770 npe UIpH iTHH 06pa6auWaJIH DHmeBhle npo l yKTbl 5 698 apeH l oBaHHbIX HOCTh 3THX Mep MHOrHX YHeCJIH 3DH l eMlflieCKHe 6one3HH 60nee 1 515 - Bcero TH p MWInHoHbI ronO l HhIX 6PO l HJIH B nOHCKax H B 60­ Mexa H KO fQ TIPHMaH l eH OHaJIH3aUHJI 6bIna O l HaKO cpaBHHTeJIhHO pe l I OH 66 AenhUaM nee 6naronpHHTHhIX paHOHax npe UIpHHmH 6bInH B03BpameHbI HX npe fQ HM BJIa­ npe3H l HYMOM BCHX H HeKoTOpoe HeYCTaHOBJIeHHOe 'lHCJIO - o6naCTHhIMU OpraHaMH 14 TpY l HOCTH B npoMhllWleHHoCTH HOBYIO 3KOHOMH1IeCKyro TIOJIHTHKY CTaJIH ooKpameHHo Halhl­ Bath H3TIOM H3TI npe l cTaBJIILTI 006010 P0PMY CMeWaHHOH 3KOHO­ TOWIHBHhlH KPH3HC KOrophIH nOBneK 3a 006010 3aKpbITHe 1921 MHKH C nOI1 llBJIHIOII UlM npeo6na l aHHeM 'laCTHoro CeJIbCKOrO XO­ MHOrHX pa6pHK H 3aBO l OB CTan B 3HHCTBa C l o6aBneHHeM neraJIH30BaHHOH 'laCTHOH ToproBnH H Men­ POI1 ll H J l1H npaBHTeJIhCTBa K KOUUY noro rO l a KaK H B Koro 'laCTHoro npoH3BO l CTBa BJIaCTH npeflHTCTBOBaJIH B03HHKHOBe­ B03HHKJIa HHoro pol1 ll Tpare l H l PYKOBO l CTBO pewuno OTMeHHTh 1924-1925 r KowMapOM H J l1H H3­ 1922 r rr TOJIhKO cuCTeMY ynpaBJIeHHH npoMhllWleHHocThlO KOTOpasr CJIO KHJIaCh K TO­ Ha BOCeMHa1l UaTH 6hIno 3aH 1TO B cpe l HeM OT 20 l 0 1000 '1eJIO­ BeK 1S BOJIhWHHCTBO 3aHJITbiX B npoMhIllIneHHOCTH npo l OD J 3JlO MY BpeMeHH TIpe K l e npe UIpHHTHH pa60TaJIH He 3a60THCb 06 H3­ p epX K3x nOKphlBasr Bce paCXO lU I cpep cTBaMH KOTophle npe l OCTaB­ TPY1l HTbCH Ha rocY l apCTBo nlLTIHCh roCYI1 llPCTBOM P33nH'lHhle npe UIpHHTHH HaXO l HJIHCb B nop ­ HHIO KpynHbIX 'laCTHhiX npe UIpHHTuH K 'lHHeHHH fnaBKOB BCHX OHH pa60TanH no 3aKalaM 3THX fnaB­ KOB nonytIanH OT HHX H chlphe H TOWIHBO eCJIH OHH Bo06me 'lT0­ fono l MOO nonY'laJIH 3apWIaTa nO'lTH nonHOCThlO yrpaTRJIa CMhlCJI naHKH H yCJIym npeP OCTaBJIILTIHCh 6ecWIamo B pe3ynbTaTe qyp o­ 3TOH Bce eme HeMomHOH 3KOHOMHKe npHIWIOCh nepe fQ Th Y KaCuyro 46 KaTaCTpo Py fOI1 llMH HaKaWIHBaBWHeCH nOCJIe l CTBHH BHmHo pa3poCCH 61OpoKpaTH'IIeCKuH aWI3paT C ero rpoM03 l I OH ueHTpanH3 eH paCTO'lHTenhHOCTblO H He3 p peKTHBHOCThlO MHorHe 47 npe IUIpHJlTHJI 3aKpbUIHCb H3-33 OTcyTCTBHJI TOIDlHBa H CblPbJl ITpeA­ THtleCKYlO CHCTeMY pacnpeAeneHHJI BpeMeH BoeHHoro KOMMYHH3Ma npHIUIMaIlHCb OTlWIlUlble YCHJlHJI qr06bl BOCCTaHOBHTb lKene3HOAo­ npeADOqreHHe OKa3bIBaJIOCb H3nMauy KOMMYHHCTbl no enOBaM PO lKHbIH ypaHCnoPT H TOIDlHBHYlO npoMbllIDleHHOCTb H HaAO CKa3aTb 1922-1923 rr xo­ 75% po3HHQHOn TOprOBJIH Y lKe HaXOAHllOCb B qaCTHblxpYKax YC1IOBHJI 1921-1922 rr K KOHIJ Y 1922 r A06HllHCb 33MeTHoro ynyqweHHJI OAHOBpeMeHHo nblTaIlHCb nepeCTpoHTb npoMbilIDleHHOCTb Ha KOMMep recKoii OCHo­ nelUlHa AOn lKHbl 6bIJIH yquTbCJI TOprOBaTb K asiicTBeHHbln roA 3aKawnmaJICJI TorAa B CeHTJl6pe Be H36aBHTbCJI OT H3J1HlllHerO nepCOHaJIa H A06HTbCJI 34 q eKTHBHOC' MaIlO 6rraronpHJITCTBOBaJIH KOMMepqeCKoH 6yxramepHH H ynopJlAo­ TH npoH3BOACTBa 06J13aB 3AMHIUICTPauulO npe IUIpHJlTHH OIDlaQHBaTb 'leHHOn ToprOBne BbIJI ronoA H 06w HiI oTlWIHHbln Aeq HUHT Y npeA­ Bce HX paCXOAbI 3apIDlaTa CHOBa BblIDlaQHBaIlaCb B AeHbrax a C HlO­ JIJI-aBryCTa 1921 r Bee ycnyrn onJlTb CTaJIH IDlaTHblMH 17 10 HOJl6pJl npHllTHH He 6bIJIO pe3epBOB a y TpeCTOB - 1921 r 6bIJIH OTMeHeHbl nanKH Pa3rOBOpbl 06 OTMeHe AeHer paAH AeHer QT06bl A06HTbCJI nonO I HTenbHoro CaJ1bAO 01Ul AOn lKHbI 6bIJIH ToproBaTb H TOprOBaTb aKTHBHO HO H3-3a 06w en HHw eTbl MaIlO KTO HMeJI cpeACTBa nOKy­ HeMeAJleHHoro CKa'llCa B COUHaJIH3M npeKpaTHllHcb 6YATO HX H He naTb KaK no lUI napaAOKCaJ1bHO HeMOllUlble yCHJlHJI npoMbllIDleH­ 6blJIo HanpoTHB MHoro rOBopHllOCb 0 He06xoAHMOCTH CTa6HllH3H­ Hoem npHBellH K 3aTOBapHBaHHlO IDlOXO opraHH30BaHHOro pblHJ a poBaTb eHe lKHOe 06paw eHHe Ha OCHOBe KOToporo HaAJIe lKaJIO TpeCTbl CTpeMJlCb Pa3A06bITb XOTb HeMHoro AeHer KOHKypHpoBaJIH BnpeAb npoH3BO HTb paCqeTbl H BbiIDlaTbl rOCYAapcrneHHaJJ npo· Me l Ay co60ii paCDPOAaBaJI Aa lKe Cblp e H o60pYAOBaHHe OTKPbl­ MbwmeHHoCTb H TOprOBJIJI AOJI lKHbl 6bUIH q YHKUHOlUlpoBaTb Ha oe­ Ball Ha ynHWlX C06CTBeHHbIe napbKH TaK Pa3BHllOCb JlBnelUle KO­ HOBe X03paCqeTa Cblpbe H TOIDlHBO Tenepb HaAJle lKaIlO npH06peTaTb TOpoe B Te BpeMeHa CTaJIH Ha3bIBaTb pa36a3apHBaHHeM qepe3 ToprOBYlO eeTb a pa60QHM BblIDlaQHBaTb 3apIDlaTY ITpeKpaTH­ Bee no B3J1TOe BMeCTe nOBJIeJ JIO 3a co60n OTHOCHTenbHoe JIOeb KOpMJIeHHe C JIO lKeqKH - 6bUIH JIHKBHAHPOBaHbl JIerKHe HCTOll­ DaAelUle u eH Ha npoMbwmeHHble H3AenHJI no CpaBHeHHlO C u eHaMH HHKH KpeAHTa 3TO ropbKoe JIeKapCTBO 6blJIO npoDHcaHO AeKpeTOM OT 9 aBryCTa 1921 r QT06bl npoMbllIDleHHOCTb q YHKUHolUlpoBaIla B 3THX HOBblX ycnOBHJlX He06xoAHMO 6bIJIO nepeCTaTb paccMaTpH­ BaTb ee KaK ruraHTCKyro q HPMY B KOTopon BCHX HrpaII POJIb CO­ BeTa AHpeKTOPOB H pa3AenHTb ee Ha aBTOHOMHble eAHHHWd 3TH Ha npoAOBOJIbCTBHe ene oyeT no epKHYTb - OTHOCHTeJIhHoe H Te H ApyrHe u eHbl 6blCTpO POcnH H3-3a HHq nJlu HH BblpyqKa OT npoAa lKH qaCTO He nOKpblBaJIa paCXOAOB ITOcpeAH Bee06w ero e­ q HUHTa HaKanJIHBaJIHCb HenpoAaHHble TOBapbl TpeCTbl OKa3blBaJIHCb He B COCTOJIHHH OIDlaQHBaTb CBOH pa3 lJYTble WTaTbl 6e3pa60THWl BHOBb 06pa30BaHHble nOApa3AeneHHJI no 60JIbruen qaCTH CTaJIH CTpeMHTenbHO POC1Ia HeCMOTpJl Ha TO qrO 60nbrue nonOBHHbl npo­ HMeHOBaTbCJI TpecTaMH KYAa BOllUIH 3aBOAbl q a6pHKH MacTepc­ JIeTapHeB 6e lKaJIo H3 ropoAOB B AepeBHIO HBHaJJ lKH3HeHHO HaCYW ­ KHe H ruaxTbl HeCKOJIbKO HaH60JIee KpynHblX npe IUIpHJITHn 6bIJIO HaJJ nOTpe6HOCTb B YBenuqeHHH BbmYCKa npoJJ YKu HH COqeTaJIaCb C npHpaBHeHO K TaKHM TpeCTaM Bee 01Ul Aon lKHbl 6bIJIH pa60TaTb HeB03MO lKHOCTblO npoAa lKH non npo oyKu HH TaKOBbl 6bIJIH Henoe­ BnpeAb Ha KOMMepqeCKOn OCHOBe CHaqaJIa ew e COXpaHJIJIHCb HeKOTO­ pble OrpaHHqeHHJI CB060Abi B KyIDIe-npoAa lKe HO 3HaQHTeJIbHaJI qaCTb npoMbllIDleHHOCTH Y lKe Ha npoTJI lKeHHH 1921 r CTaJIa npoBoAHTb TOproBble onepau HH Ha co6CTBeHHblii CTpaX H PHCK HaqwaJJ C 1922 r TpeCTbI HllH KpynHble aBTOHOMHble npe IUIpHJITHJI CTaJIH nepe6HBaTbCJI caMH KaK MornH KpHTepHJIMH ycnexa CTaHOBHJIHCb npH6bIJIb H coKpaw elUle pacxoAoB KaK npaBHllO He 6bIJIO 60JIbrue peACTBeHHbie nOeneACTBHJI BHe3anHoro norpY lKeHHJI npoMbllIDleH­ HOCTH B JIeAliHYlO BaHHY KOMMepqeCKHX PpHHu HDOB Ho K 1923 r DOJIO lKeHHe HaqaJIO MeHJITbCJI JIelUlH rOTOB 6blJI HATH Ha Bee qr06bl BOCCTaHOBHTb X03JIHCT­ BO BnonHe nOIUlMaJI qro 3TO Heo6xoAHMO AIDI Bbl lKHBaHHJI pe lKHMa OH OHaJIHHO CTapanCJI y6e HTb COMHeBalOw HXClI TOBapHWen qrO llIl lKe HHOCTpaHHble KOHu ecCHH - npHeMJIeMbIH cnoco6 perueHHJI npHopHTeTa AIDI nOKynOK Y rOCYAapCTBa ecnH qaCTHHK npeAJla­ npo6rreM peKOHCTpYKu HH B CTaTbllX H peqax 3Toro nepuoAa OH B03· raJI JIycnuylO u eHY 6paIlH Y Hero EenH qaCTHble nOAPJlAQHKH HllH BpaW aIlClI K nocpeAHHKH o6ecneQHBaJIH nyqwee KaqeCTBO ycnyr qeM rOCYAapCT­ ITPOrHaJIH Mon CHOHX KanHTaJIHCTOB a Tenepb XOTlIT npu3BaTb BeHHble TOproBble opraHH au HH nOCTeneHHO 3aMeW aBIUHe 6lOpoKpa KanHTaIlHCTOB HHOCTpaHHbIX JIeIUlH OAHaKO HaCTaHBaIl Ha TOM 48 3Ton TeMe CHOBa H CHOBa HeKOTopble B03pa lKaJIH 49 'ITO n03BOJHUI HHOCTpaHHblM KaIIHT3JIHCTaM pa3pa6aTbIBaTb 3anaCbl HecpTH JIeCHble peCypCbl H T J COBeTCKOe rOCY J apCTBO nOJIyqHT HolKllllQbI ueH MaTepH3JIbl B KOTOPblX OHO HCnblTblBaeT OCTpyro HY I J y 'ITO HHOCT­ 1923 paHHble nO J pJl J 1JHKH o6ecne'laT ero COBpeMeHHbIM 060pY J OBaHHeM Cepbe3HblH C J BHr B 3TOM HaIIpaBJIeHHH MOrJIH 6bl J 3Tb B 6oJIbwe­ BHCTCKOH POCCHH npHHa JIe l 3 IUHe HHOCTpaHHOMY KaIIHT3JIY npo­ MbIIIIJIeHHble npe u n pHJlTHJI Ha J e l J b1 ileHHHa OKa3arrHCb npeyBeJIH­ 'IeHHblMH XOTJI OH CTaparrCJI KaK MO I HO WHpe peKJIaMHpOBaTb HeMHorHX aM6HIUf03HblX KaIIHT3JIHCTOB MOCKBY co CBOHMH npe JIO l eHHHMH - KOTopble npHe3 I 3JIH B TaKHX HaIIpHMep KaK aMepHKaHcKuH 6H3HeCMeH BaH J eprrHn O J HaKO B KOHetfHOM C'IeTe Bce 3TO npHHecrro He TaK Y I MHoro nrrO J OB BOCCTaHOBHTeJIbHOrO nepHo J a 'lHcrrHITOCb npHcTynHITH Hble Kouu eccHH I 8 B 3aHJ1TO Ha 31 1924-1925 K pa60Te TOJIbKO 13 npe J IIpWITHe ITpeOIlrr3 J 3JIH JIec­ rr TOJIbKO 4 260 pa60'IHx 6blJl0 60JIee HITH MeHee 3Ha'IHTeJIbHbIX KOHueCCHJlX ueccHH coxpaHHBWHXCJI 0 6% Bcero K KOHUY 42 KOHueCCHH HO pe3JIbHO 1928 K 68 HaUUOHarrbHoro npo J yKTa fJIaBHOH npH'lHHOH 6blJlO BepOJIT­ HO ynopHoe He J oBepHe 6oJIbweBHKoB K HHOCTpaHllblM KanHTarrHC­ TaM 'ITO e J Ba JIH Y J HBHTeJIbHO ecrrH yqeCTb XaOTH'IeCKOe COCTOJl­ HHe POCCHH B 3TOT nepHO J H OTKpblTO J eKJIapHpOBaBWYIOCJI 6oJIb­ WeBHKaMH Bpa l J e6HOCTb K KanHT3JIHCTH'IeCKHM nOpJl J KaM a TaK I e OTKa3 OT BbInJIaTbl CTapblX J OJIrOB POCCHH KOHCPHCKaIUlJI B 1921 TOprOBJIJI O J HaKO Ha'l3JIa nOCTeneHHO paCTH r OHa 06crry l HBarra 60JIee Beero HeMe J JIeHHble HY l JpI 3aKynarrH 3epHO H yrOJIb 'lT06bl cnpaBHTbCJI C KpHTH'IeCKHMH CHTYaUUJlMH Ho nOCTeneHHO H B nOH ollrracTH npoHcXO J HJIa CTa­ 6HJIH3aUHH B 1922 r 6blJl0 nO J llHcaHo ToproBoe corrraweHHe C AHrrrHeH a 3a HHM nocrre J OB3JIH H J pyrHe B 1922 r HeKoTopble TpecTbl e l arrOBarrHCb Ha KOHKypeHUUIO HMnOpTa HeKoTopble nOTpe6HTeJIbCKHe TOBapbl 3aKynarrHcb 'IT06bl CTHMYJIHpoBaTb Ma­ TepHarrbHYIO 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOCTh pa60'IHx Ho HMnopTHpoBaHHble JIOKOMOTHBbI H J pyroe cerrbCKOX03J1HCmeHHble 060PY J oBaHHe B peKoHcTpYK UIH 3KCllOPT B BeHb 3KCnOpTa 50 MawHHbl 3JIeK TpH'Ie CKoe 3Ha'IHTeJIbHOH Mepe cnOC06CTBOB3JIH 1924-1925 1921-1922 rr XOTJI 1913 r I 9 TpeTH OT 3KCnopTa MJI rOJIO J 3 J epeBHH He MOrJIa KOHetfHO nOJIb30BaTbCJI 3THMH npeH­ M 'IUeCTBaMH O J HaKO H3MeHHBWHeCJI ycrrOBHJI npHBeJIH K J pyrOH KPaHHOCTH - K TaKHM HellrraronpHJlTHblM nepeMeHaM ueH 'ITO Y KpeCTbJlH nponarra oxon ToprOBaTb H C03 J 3J1aCb nOJIHTH'IeCKaJl yr­ po3a pe I HMY nOCKOJIbKY ero nOJIHTH'IeCKaH CTa6HITbHOCTb J ep l a­ JIaCb Ha yCTyn'IHBOCTH KpeCTbJlH HX TepneHHH HerOTOBHOCTH 6yuTO­ BaTb ITPH'lHHbl Y J HBHTeJIbHO CTpeMHTeJIbHOH nepeMeHbl COCTOJIJIH B crre J ylOmeM Bo-nepBblX CeJIbCKOX03J1HCTBeHHoe npoH3BO J CTBO BOCCTaHaB­ JIHB3JI0Cb 6blCTpee 'IeM npoMblIWIeHHOCTb H3-3a rOJIO J 3 1921 r COKpaTHJIHCb noeeBllble nrrOm3 J H B ollrraCTJlX KOTopble OT Hero nOCTpa J 3JIH 3TO BH J HO H3 TaIlrrHUbl CM CTp 52 O J H3KO Y I e B crre J ylOmeM ro J y ypo l aH 6blJl o'lem xopow K 1923 r pa3Mep noceBHblX llJIOma J eH J OCTHr nO'ITH 90% J OBoeHHO­ ro ypoBHH H XOTJI ypO l aH Bce eme 6blJl 3Ha'IHTeJIbHO HH I e 'IeM B 1913 r J ecpHUUT npo J yKTOB nHTaHHJI Y I e He 6blJl KaTaCTpocpH'IeC­ KHM HanpoTHB pa3pyweHHaH CTpyKTYpa npoMblIWIeHHOCTH Tpe60­ co6CTBeHHOCTH HHoCTpauueB H T J BHeWUJlJl HeH OKa33JIHCb crrHWKOM llrraronpHJITHblMH J JIJI KpeCThJlH Bo Bpe­ KOH­ r npoH3BO J HJIH Bcero TOJIbKO rO J npHHec C co60H HOBblH KPH3HC Bbl3BaHHbIH TeM 'ITO HOBbIe ycrrOBHJI ToprOBblX oTHoweHHii Me l J y ropo J OM H J epeB­ rr npeBblCHIT B 9 pa3 ypo­ OH COCTaBJIJIJI HeMHorHM 60JIee B3JIa 60JIee J JIHTeJIbHbIX CPOKOB J JIJI BOCCTaHOBJIeHHH Ta l e TaIlrrH­ ua nOKa3blBaeT 'ITO B 1923 r npoMblIWIeHHOCTb 6blJla Ha 3Ha'IHTeJIb­ HO 60JIee HH3KOM ypoBHe no cpaBHeHHIO C 1913 r 'IeM cerrbCKOXO­ 3J1HCTBeHHoe npoH3BO J CTBO ITpoMblIWIeHHOCTb 6blJla Beepbe3 no­ J opBaHa pa3pyweHHeM OCHOBHoro KaIIHTarra J JIHBwerOCJI rO J 3MH npeHe6pe l eHHJI K peMOHTY o 6opY J oBaHHJI J ecpHUUToM 3anaCllblX 'laCTeH H KB3JIHcpHIJ HpOBaHHoro TpY J 3 KB3JIHCPHuupOBaHHOrO pyKo­ BO J CTBa TOllJlHBa CblPbJI H Cpe J CTB TpaHcnOpTa B 06meM xaoee npe J bl J yIQHX JIeT B eeJIbCKOM X03HH Cme npoH30WeJI eepbe311bIH C J BHr OT npoH3Bo J cTBa CblpbeBblX MaTepH3JI0B J JIJI npOMbllilJleH­ HOCTH K npoH3Bo J cmy npo J oBOJIbCTBHJI HanpHMep noceBbl XJIon­ Ka ynarrH C 688 TbIC ra B 1913 r J O 70 TbIC ra B 1922 r C J pyrOH CTOPOHbl He 6blJl0 BarrlOTbl J JIJI HMnOpTa CblpbR B MaCWTa6ax He06­ XO u HMbIX JIJI 6blCTporo BOCCTaHOBJIeHHH TeKCTHJIbHOH npOMblw­ rreHHOCTH B 1922 r ee npO J yKUUJl COCTaBJIJlJIa Beero 26% OT J O­ 51 ' ' D D r- ll ' D g l ' o BoeJUloro ypoBHH Tor n a KIlK cen bCKoe X03HHCTBO Aocnrrno l 75% BO-BroPblX xaoTWlecKHe YCHllHH roCYAlpCTBeHHbIX TpeCTOB D po c6bITY TOBapoB H CbIPbH H HX KOHKYpeHlUUl Me l Ay C060H AnD­ JIHCh He caHlliKOM Aonro PeopraHHlOBaHHaIl 6aHKOBCKaJI CHCTeMa ' 10 ' ' ' t ' 00 ' ' ' 00 8 ' o l o6ecaetJHJIa HM KpeAlfT BCHX pearHpoBan Ha OIIbIT ' 00 H8tW1 COlAaBaTb B o D ' D ' t D It It It a 0 ' l 0 0 It '' ' o ' D ' ' oo o ' ' ' ' o 00 It g g $ ' 00 00 ' ' g D ' 00 ' ' ' ' o ' tD ll t ' ' o ' D ' o ' t ' 00 o o II 8 j I i i ' » D I 3 il a 8 II 1 r o § a I I t u - a a J E­ Q aill ' I ­ I ­8 t ­ IIpoH3BOAHTeJIbHOCTb TpYAl OCTaBaJIaCh RaMBoro HH Ke AOBoeHHoro t HblMH HIlKJIaAHbIMH paCXO n aMH H nepepacxoAOM pa60lleii CHllbl ci • III D I ' • I j0 t - 5 • oc 0 ' ' -o05m M Q 'If - II o • ' ' e t 'i 8 s8 8il M t i i @- Iii 8 $ 0 eg g l e 0 i r II 8 l e R' 8 II lEi j 0 _ iii «iii t B-TpeTbHX rocy n apCTBeHRaH npoMbIumeHHocTb obma He3 p­ § 8e 2 ag E i i ill 81 ii3 E2 8 i_ j e_ t - u i J i HaS '­ II 6 t o o00 I -I'll 52 ' ' D • ­ - 0 ' 8 -' II 0 peKTHBHa pa60TaJIa HaMHoro HH lKe CBOHX B03MO KHOCTeH C orpoM­ j 1 c i t ' ¢'rI U noMHHHpoBan B npoH3BoAcrne AaHHOro BHAl TOBapa Ii s_ I ' t to 00 ' BbICOKHe eHbI ecaH rOCYAlpcrneHHbIH eeKTop npoMbIumeHHOCTH II II D HM TBepAYlO n03HI1 HIO H OHH 3aIIpalIIHBanH 3a CBOIO npoAYKn H1O tD I CI' is 9 ' ' a Ii I I WHeCH TIlKHM oopa30M ttrOObl o6JIer'lHT CObIT 3TO o6ecnetmno 00 o D Booome HCKnlOtJHJIH KOHKype 1O Me l Ay TpecTaMH omeAHHHB­ D I l 8 8 j 1921-1922 rr rr CHHAHKaTbI 3ro 6bInH ynpaB_ nHeMbIe npaBHTem CTBOM opraHH3lUUfH KOTOpble OrpaHHtmmI HJIH I 1922-1923 a 0 8 • I • 6 r j tQ ypoBHH Bee no nopo IKAaJIO BbICOKHe eHbI • B-qeTBepTblx CHCTeMa omoBoro H polHHlfHoro pacnpen eJIe­ HUH OCTaBanaCb TO IKe He3$ peKTHBHOH H 06XOAHl aCb qpelBbJllaHHO noporo pa3HH Me l Ay eHoH COCTaBJIMa B 1913 To 17 3% CornaCHO IIpeoopa KeHcKoMY CpeAHHH cet'ieCTOHMOCTblO H P03HHlfHOii Tenepb OHa nOAIDDIaCh npH6JIH3HTeJIbHO AO 60% 20 B-MTbIX npaBHTenbCTBO HeCMorpH Ha 3Ha'lHTeJIbHOCTb po_ JIH H3nMaHOB OCTaBanOCb pIlKTWleCKH rnaBHblM nOKynaTeJIeM xne­ 68 H CTpeMHllOCh npoHlBOAHTb 33KynKH no HH3KHM eHaM • HaKoHe KpeCTbIDIe npoHrpblBaJIH 83-la ranOnHp 'IOmeii HH­ cpmnUIH Kor n a n eHhm e IKeAHeBHO nan anH B eHe IIpH TIlKHX ycno­ BHHX Al IKe Hen enbHoe on03n aHHe C nOe3n K0ii KpeCTbHHHHa B ropoA 33 nOKynKaMH o60palfHBaJIOCb H Hero qyBCTBHTenbHbIMH nOTepH­ n eHhrn-qepBo bI eHbl Ha npoMbIUDIeHHbIe MH KpeCTbHHaM nocneAHHM BbIAaJIH HOBbIe HO bI eH B TOM CMbICJIe ttro TOBapbl OKalanHCb Bblwe a Ha eenbCKOXOl FIHCTBeHHbIe npoAYKTbl HH Ke eH 1913 r paCKpbmanHCb Bee IIIHpe EcaH HH eKC eH 1913 r B3HTb 3a 100% TO B OKTHOpe 1923 r HHAeKC eH Ha npo­ MbIlUJIeHHbIe TOBapbl COCTaBHll 276% a Ha cen bCKOX03HHCTBeHHble _ 89% TOT IKe HCTOlfHHK nOKa3bmaeT CTaAHH pa3BHTHH nora pa3pbl­ Ba B eRaX 53 H3MeHeHHe COOTHOmeHHR lleH Ha npoMblmneHHble H3AeJIHR K lleHaM Ha CeJIbCKOX03RHCTBeHH le npoAyKTbl nOKa3aTeJIh 3a 1913 r 100 HOfO npoH3BO ll CTBa MeJK J y TeM npo ll oJIJKaJIa BOCCTaHaBJIHBaTbCJl crpeMHTeJIbHhIMH TeMnaMH XOTJl OHa Bce eme OCTaBaJIaCh HHJKe ll OsoeHHoro ypoBHJl BClIX BOBpeMH CnOXBaTHBlUHCb HCnOJIh30­ SaJI CBOlO 3HallHTeJIhHylO pOPMaJIbHylO BJIaCTh Ha ll rOCY J 3 pCTBeHHbIM 1922 r 1922 r «PeBpanh 1923 r 1923 r MaH HloJIh 1923 r CeHTR6pb 1923 r OKTR6pb 1923 r OKTR6pb Il eKa6ph ceKTOpoM 3KOHOMHKH Bce 3TH 06CTOJlTeJIhCTBa BMeCTe B3JlTbIe cno· B omoBoH B ToproBJIe TOprOBJIe 131 141 169 215 202 294 310 P03HH'IHOH C06CTBOBaJIH IlaCTHIlHOMY cOOHJKeHHlO 06Pa30BaBlIIHXCJl HOJKHHIJ Ha npoTJlJKeHHH 1923-1924 rr TOpraBbIe u eHbl Ha npoMbmmeH­ 23 3% BbIJI yqpeJK J eH HapO I Hbnf KOMHCca­ J ble TOBapbI yoaJIH Ha 161 167 180 223 211 280 297 pHaT ToprOBJIH KOTOPbIH CTaJI ycnelllHo paCIUHpHTb c Pepy rocy o ap­ Cl'BeHHOH TOpraBJIH H npo J 3 BaTb npoH3BO ll CTBeHHble tOBapbl B ceJIb· CKOX03JlHCTBeHHbIX paHOHaX no u eHaM HHJKe npep rraraeMbIX H3nMa­ HaMH K anpeJIlO HJIJlCJl Ha 92% 1924 f HH J eKC ceJIbCKOX03HHCTBeHHhlx u eH no ll ' 100 u eHbI 1913 r a HHJJ eKC npo 131% B nepepacqeTe Ha HOBbIe cTa6H­ eC1lH CIlHTaTb 3a MbIIlIJleHHblX u eH CHH3HJICJl Ha JIH3HpoBaHHble J eHhfH Tor J 3 HeKOtOpbIM CTaJIO Ka3aTbCH 'ITO HOJKHHIJ hI COlllJIHCb C1lHlIIKOM OOH3KO HCTO'IHHK rJla D KOB COBeTCKoe HapoAHOe X03RHCTBO 1921-19251'1' MocKBa 1960 r CTp 413 lIn aHHpoBaHHe H KOHTpom CJIe ll OBaTeJIbHO B OKTJl6pe 1923 r' t Kor J 3 HoxamU bl u eH ll OCTHfJIH HaHBblClIIeH TO'lKH npoMbmmeHHble u eHhI 6hIJIH B TpH' pa3li BhIllle ceJIbCKOX03HHCTBeHHbIX no CpaBHeHHlO C u eHaMH ll 0 BOHHbI He Y J HBHTeJIbHO 'ITO 3TO nopo J HJIo TPYAHOCTH B KaKOH-To Mepe 3TOT pa3phlB B u eHax caMOKOppeKTHPOBaJI­ CH KpeCTbJlHe 6hIJIH rJIaBHbIMH nOTpe6HTeJIJlMH npoH3BO ll CTBeH HhIX TOBapoB a rocy o apcTBeHHaH npoMhillIJIeHHOCTb HcnhlThlBaJIa 60JIblUHe TpYAHOCTH C npo ll 3 f eH JIHX TOBapoB CMeHa ceJIbCKOXo­ 3liHCTBeHHbIX ce30HOB CTBO ll eHCTBOBaJIO pelUHTeJIhHO 'lT06bl 03 ll OpoBHTb COOTHOllleHHe u eH TIblTaJIHCb nOHH3HTb u eHhI Ha npOMhmmeHHhle TOBapbI H3 J aBa­ JIHCb ll eKpeThl 0 KOHTpoJIe Ha ll u eHaMH HJIH 3anpeThi nOBblIUaTb u eHhl Ge3 pa3pellleHHJl npoBO J HJIHCb KaMDaHHH no coKpaw eHHlO H36hlTollHoro nepcoHaJIa B npoMhlllIJIeHHOCTH H B TOproBoH ceTH no paClUHpeHHlO H YJIyqmeHHlO CHCTeMhI nOTpe6HTeJIbCKHX Koonepa­ THBOB no OrpaHHqeHHlO Kpewna 'ITO nOHyJKA8JIO TpeCThl KaK MOJK­ HO 6bICTpee H36aBJIJlThCJl OT 3liTOBapHBaHHH EMKOCTb npoMbmmeH- H K 1924 r BOIlllla B 60JIee cnoKoHHble BO J bI 1924-1925 rr MOryT 6bITb oxapaKtepH30BaHbi KaK BeplllHHa H3TIa KaK 3Ta CHCTeMa BblrJIJl ll eJIa KaK OHa pa60TaJIa OcymeCTBJIJlJIOCb JIB Tor J 3 DJIaHHpoBaHHe H KTO era ocymeCTBJIHJI KaKOB 6hlJI OTHOCHTeJIh­ HhIH Bec IlaCTHOrO ceKTopa HaCKOJIbKO aBTOHOMHbIMH 6bIJIH TpeCTbl H KaKYlO BJIaCTb Ha ll HHMH coxpaHHJI BClIX qTO npoHcxo J HJIO C ceJIbCKHM X03HHCTBOM TOJKe BJIHJlJIa Ha u eHhl Ha npo ll OBOJIbCTBHe ­ OHH nOBbnuaJIHCb nOCJIe y60pKH oqepeAHOfo ypoJKaH Ho npaBHTem ­ 54 I1TaK CHCTeMa CMelllaHHOH 3KOHOMHKH H3TIa npollIJIa qepe3 Gypn HaIJHeM C IIJIaHHPOBaHHJI 1921·1922 rr CH lIITa60M B pe3YJIbTaTe TpeCTH pHKa u HH BClIX 6bIJI ll eu eHTpaJIH30BaH HO Bce eme OCTaBaJI· COBeTCKOH 4 YHK u HOHHPOBaBlUHX B racy o apCTBeHHOH npoMbIllIJIeHHOCTH 1922 430 r TpeCTOB 172 113 no J llHHHJIHCb BClIX npJlMO HJIH qepe3 nocpe ll CTBO MeCTHbIX OpraHOB npoM61O po a 258 HaxO J HJIHCh B Be ll eHHH MeCTHbIX coBHapxo30B TaK OCTaBaJIHCh B nO J lllfHeHHH BeHX 33 TpecTa MeTaJIJIo06pa6aTbIBalO­ meH npOMbmmeHHOCTH 3TH TpeCTbl KOHTPOJIHPOBaJIH C 218 344 pa60IlHMH C ll pyrOH CTOPOHhI PYKOBO I HJIH 95 npe J DpHHTHHMH C 12 701 24 316 3aBO ll OB 0OOacTHbIx TpeCTa pa60IlHM T e KaK npa­ 55 BIDIO 6bmH rop33AO MelIb'le no MaCIlITa6y HaA CBOHMH npeA­ D IlJl He HMe1Ja 3aKOHO J 3 Te1JbHbIX nocneACTBHH• Ila l e AeKpeThl no­ npHJITHJlMH TpeCTbl pacnOlIaraJIH nOlIHOH BlIaCTblO llpeAllpHR THJI He ra HMelIH pHHaHCOBOH aBTOHOMHH KOHHOCTH peAKO OTpa KaJIH pea1JbHYIO CHTYaUHlO He rOBOp1l Y I e C06CTBeHHbIX C'IeTOB paCXOAOB H npH6bmH He 1IBlIRlIHCb OHH H IOpHAH'IeCKHM lIHUOM Y HHX rpy60 BpeMeHH HallpaalIeHHble Ha YKpenneHHe peBOlIIOUHOHHOH 3a­ o TOM 'ITO OHH KaK npaBH1IO 6bI1IH CKBepHO COCTaBJIeHbI rOBOp1l 6bm TOT l e CTaTYC 'ITO H Y nOApa3AelIeHHH COBeTCKHX npeA­ MbI He 6YAeM 3AeCb AaBaTh nOJIHOrO 0630pa MHOrOlfHCJIeHHbIX npHJITHH B 60-e rO J h1 H1IH y nOApa3AelIeHHH ueHTpaJIH30BaHHhlX neKpeTOB onpeAeJI1IBIlIHX H H3MeHJIBIIlHX PYHKUHH H BHyTpeHHIOIO KopnopauaH Ha 3anaAe I aKTH'IeCKH A1I1I HX 0603Ha'leHH1I He ynOT­ opraHH3aUHIO BClIX B AeKpeTe OT 12 H01I6p1l 1923 r nOBTOpRlIHCb pe6JtRlIH Aa l e TepMHH npeAllPH1Ime Beg HX npo J yKua1l MaHH­ MHorKe nOlIO l eHH1I KOToPble Mbl TOlIbKO 'ITO UHmpoBaJIH HO B poBaJIaCb H npo J 3 Ba1JaCb TpeCTaMH KOTopble o6ecne'IHBaJIH HX MeHee AHpeKTHBHOM TOHe C 60JIbIlIHM Y J 3 peHHeM Ha TpeCThI H Ha HX II He06xoAHMbIMH pOHAaMH a TaKlKe OMa'IHBaJIH pa60qylO CH1IY OTHOWeHHH C ApyrHMH opraHH3aUHHMH TaK nyHKT r OTAe1Ja 1l0cTeneHHo 3TO nOlIO l eHHe MeHRlIOCb HO npaBa H 06113aHHOCm noro AeKpern npeAOCTaBJI1I J BCHX npaao pOPMYJIHpoBaTb npoH3­ AHpeKTOpoB npeAllPH1ITHH B HX OTHOWeHHHX C TpeCTaMH OCTaBa­ BOACTBeHHble llJIaHbI 61O J I eTa A1I1I npoMbIIlmeHHOCTH 06meC0103HO­ JIHCb HeonpeAe1JeHHbIMH BnnOTb AO 1927 r Bnpo'leM Aa Ke Tor J 3 ra 3Ha'leHH1I OHH He 6bmH npH3HaHbl IOpHAH'leCKHMH lIHUaMH PeaJIbHaJI BlIaCTb HbIe 61O J I eTbl COlO3HblX pecny6JtHK COCTaBJI1ITb 06mHH npOH3BOA­ npoBepR Tb npOH3BOACTBeHHbIe MaHbI H npOMbnIIneH­ AHpeKTOpa B 3HalfHTe1JbHOH CTeneHH BapbHpoBaJIaCb OT TpeCTa K cmeHHbIH MaH H 61O J I eT npoMbnuneHHocTH COBeTCKoro COlO3a TpeCTY B 3TOT nepHOA nO'ITH He npeAllpHHHMaJIHCb nonblTKH CTaH­ K npeACTaB1I1ITb ero 'Iepe3 fOCMaH Ha YTBep l J eHHe B COBeT Tpy­ J 3 pTH3alUlH ueH ComaCHO pe301IIOlUIH 29 HI01I1I 1922 r BCHX a MeTO J 3 MH 3KOHOMH'IeCKorO xapaKTepa pHHaHCHpoBaHHe 6 cymeCTBYIOIUHM 3aKOHoAaTe1JbCTBOM H KaK MO I HO npeAlloJIo­ pa60THHKOB KHTh 3TH yTOlJlleHH1I HMe1JH ueJIblO npeAOTB paTHTb H3JIHIllHee BMe­ OTBeTCTBeHHblX TpeCTOB H ApyrHX ToproBo-npoMblW1IeHHbIX eAHHHU nepeMemeHHe MaTepHa1JbHbIX pe­ CYPCOB H3 OAHOH OTpacnH npoMbIIlmeHHOCTH B Apyryro OT npeA­ npHJITHJI K npeAllpH1ITHIO H TaK J a1Jee B roCYAapcma I YHKUHH KOHTPOJI1I HaA nO J 'IHHeHHhIMH eMY e J HHH­ MeTO J 3 MH a J MHHHCTpaTHBHOro xapaKTepa H33Ha'leHHe YBOlIbHeHHe pa60TKa COlO3Hble pecny6JtHKH 6bI1IH 3AeCb ynOM1I­ uaMH HeCKOJIbKO p33 YTO'1H lIHCb CCbmKaMH Ha COOTBeTCTBHe C opraHH3aUH1I KpeAHTa nOlIHTHKa ueH H T A H J 3 K 060POHbI CTO MyTbI BcneACTBHe 06pa30BaHHJI B 1922 r CCCP KaK peAepaTHBHoro OCYIIIeCTBmm KOHTPOlIb HaA npoMblW1IeHHoCTblO B COOTBeTCTBHH C nnaHOM tnaTelIbCTBO B pa60TY TpeCTOB cBepxy BClIX B 1923-1926 rr BKJIlOlJaJI B ce611 cne J ylOmHe ceKUHH OT J enbI H nOApa3AeneHHH MeTO J aMH npoH3BOACTBeHHO-MaHOBOrO xapaKTepa pa3­ - npe3H J HyM BClIX BO maBe C npeAceAaTeneM MaHOB - BHYTpeHHee ynpaaneHHe npoH3BOACTBa H pacnpeAelIeHHH HHCneKUH1I H npoBepKa HX BbmOlIHeHH1I o6ecne'leHHe COOTBeTCTBH1I npoMbIIII­ liHa'le rOBop1l npeBpamBWHCb no cYIIIeCTBY B KOMHccapHaT npoMbnuneHHoCTH H TOprOBlIH BCHX CTa1J HaCT01lIUHM X0311HHOM HaXOAHBIlIHXC1I B ero IOPHCAHKlUIH - fnaBHoe 3KOHOMH'IeCKOe ynpaBneHHe f3Y C npH J aHHoii eMy npoMblIlI1IeHHOH llJIaHOBOH KOMHCCHeH IIPOMMaH lIeHHOro MaHa 06meMY MaHY H T A npeAllPHJImH Bce p33ro­ - UeHTpaJIbHOe ynpaBneHHe rOCYAapcTBeHHOH npoMbIllI1IeH­ HOCTH uyrnPOM - C MHorO'IHcneHHbIMH nOAOTAeJIaMH - maBHOe ynpaBneHHe o60poHHoH npoMbnuneHHocm BOPbl 0 CY I eHHH PYHKUHH BCHX H 'IaCTH'1HOH nepe J 3 'Ie HX PaKYlIb­ - HaYlfllo-TeXHH'IeCKHH OTAe1J TaTHBHbIM npoMbIIlmeHHbIM eAHHHuaM npeACTaB1I1IIOT C060H Bynb­ MeTaMyprHJI H 3JIeKTpo3HepreTHKa nepeIlI1IH B nOA'lKHeHHe rapHoe ppHTpeAepCTBO cBo60AHaB TOproB1I1I PeA 21 ••• Bo BeeM 3TOM qyBCTByeTC1I 03a60'leHHOCTb coxpaHeHHeM aB­ K Hacne J HHKaM npe I HHX maBKOB rnaBMeTaJIn H fJIaB3Hepro KOTopbIe no HeCKonbKKM cnyqaHHbIM npH'lKHaM OK33aJIHCb nOA TopHTern BCHX HO 6bI1I0 6bI BelIH'laHWeH oWH6KOH BocnpHHHMaTb np1lMbIM KOHTponeM npe3HAHYMa BClIX a He uyrnpoMa 3TH POpMYJlHpoBKH 6yKBaJIbHO He TOlIbKO ynoM1IHyTa1l pe OlIlO­ BAo6aBOK BClIX 6bmH npH J 3 Hbl H ApyrHe cneuaaJIH3HpoBaH­ Hble KOMHTeTbl 2 2 56 57 r ' BlillDI Y'lpe eHbI TaKX e peCIIytirIHKaHCKHe COBeTbI Hapo u aO lCHM 06pa30M COOTBeTCTBYIOm He OT o eJIbI BCHX ocym eCTBJIJl JIH Ha lJ ro X03J1HCTBa COBHapX03bI KOTOpbIe ynpaBJIJIlIH BTOpoCTeneH ' BBMH nonHbIH Ha l1 30p H KOHTpoJIb BO MHOI'HX OTHOWeHHJIX HanOMH­ HbIMH OTpaCJIJlMH npoMbIU1JleHHOCTH H nOJIyqH1IH npaBO COBema TeJIli JflVl HOro rOJIoca B cranJUlCKOH Mo o eJIH C o PyroH CTOPOHbI MHorne TpeCTbI - OC06eH­ OTHOWeHHJlX C BCHX COXpaHHJIHCh otirIaCTHbIe H paHOHHbIe COBHapX03bl BJIaCTb KOTOPbIX B pa3HbIX so BJIaCTb MHHHCTepCTB Ha lJ npe o nPHJITHJlMH B 60JIee n03 l1 HeH npoH3BO l1 HBWHe nOTpe6HTeJIbCKHe TOBapbI - caMH pa3pa6aTbI­ cymeCTBeHHO pa3JIHtJaJIaCb Koe-r o e OHH ynPaBJIJIlIH paCnOJIOX eHHbI saJDl npoH3Bo o CTBeHHbIe MaHbI C yqeToM pbmollHoH KOHJ IOHKTypbI MH Ha nO l1 KOHrpOJIbHOH HM TeppHTOpHH npoMbIWJIeHHbIMH II BCHX MaJIO B 3TO BMeWHBaJICJI HanpHMep B TeKCTHJIbHOH npo­ PHJITHJlMH 06m eC0103HOro 3Ha1leHHJI B o pyrnx MeCTaX - MbJilllIeHHoCTH COOTBeTcTBYIOm Hii OT o eJI B HX Be o e· HHH HaXO o HJIHCb JIHWb npe o npHJlTHJI MecrnoH npoMbWIJIeHHOCTH TaKHM 06Pa30M B paCCMaTpHBaeMbIH nepHO o rocYABpCTBeH­ 6hJJI BCHX fJIaBTeKCTHJIb nOIlTH nOJIHOCTblO 6e3BJIaCTeH a TpeCTbI HMeJIH o eJIO npe f l1 e seero C TeKCTHJIbHbIM CHH l1 HKaTOM - rocy o apCTBeHHoH OurOBOH HaJi npoMbIWJIeHHOCTh 06m eCOlO3Horo 3Ha1leHHJI 3a HCKJIlOlleHHeM opraHH3auHeii KOTOPaJI ocymeCTBJIJl JIa CHa6 f eHHe MeTaJIJIyprHH npe o npHHTHii H otirIa o ana TaKOH o oMHHHpyrom eii ponblO 1lTO B H 3JIeKTp03HepreTHKH OCTaBaJIaCb no o BJIaCThlO BCHX KOTOpblli ocym eCTBJIJm KOHTpom Ha lJ ynOMJIayTbIM BblWe 1927 r llyrnpoMoM Hero no o pa3 o eJIeHHJlMH - HHor o a Henocpe o CTBeHHO H3JIHWHHH OT o enbI H no o pa3 o eJIbI BCHX paccbIJIaJIH npHKa3bI no HHorAB llepe3 MeCTHbIe OpraHH3a o HH caMblM pa3HbIM BonpocaM 06m enOJIHTHlleCKHe PYHKrum UyrnpoMa B 3HallHTeJIbHOH Me­ pe u ytirIHPOBaJIHCb X03J1HCTBeHHbIM ynpaBJIeHHeM f3Y BCHX 6bIJIH fJIaBTeKCTHJIb TeKCTHJIbHbIX 6bIJI JIHKBH l1 HpoBaH KaK COBepweHHo C o pyrOH CTOpoHbI MHOrHe TpeCTbI no 60nbweH IlaCTH aBTOHOMHbI HHKaKOH o6m eH KapTHHbl He nonyllaeTCJI 3a HCKJIlOlleHHeM Toro 1lT0 Bo-nepBbIx KOHTPOJIb focnnaHoM BayTpH f3Y IIpOMMaH B CBOIO Ha o HOBblMH KaDHTaJIOBJIO f eHHJIMH 6bIJI ropa3 o o f eCTlle lleM 3a 0llepe l1 b o ytirIHpoBaJI HeKOTopbIe PYHKIlHH fOCMaHa KOTOPbIH He­ reKym HMH o eJIaMH a BO-BTOPbIX KOHTponb Beex BH o OB CTaJI MaHOBbIe PYHKrum - nocpe o CTBeHHO no o IlHHJIJ1CJ1 CTO a He BCHX 3Ta nYTaHaJi a o ­ MHHHCTpaTHBHaJI MawHHa 6blJIa nepeCTpoeHa Ha 60JIee JIOrHIlHOH CTpo f e K KOHUY 2Q-x ro o OB - Tenepb nOCMOTpHM KaK ocym eCTBJIJl JIOCh B 20-e rO l1 bI MaHH­ OCHOBe Kor o a H f3Y H llyrnpoM JIHKBH l1 HPOBaJIH a npOMbIWJIeH­ HbIM no o pa3 o eJIeHHJlM B03BpaTHJIH Ha3BaHHe H CTaTYC rnaBKOB no Mepe TOro KaK HapaCTaJIH TPY l1 HOCTH C pecypcaMH poBaHHe focnnaH KaK H3BeCTHO 6bIJI oo3 l1 8 H B nOMom b COBery TPY­ nOCTaBHB HX KaK H IIpoMnJIaH B npJlMoe nO l1 1lHHeHHe npe3H l1 HY­ o a H o60poHbI CTO 3TOT nOCJIe l1 HHii HOMHHaJIbHO 6bIJI KOMHC­ MY BCHX Ho Bee 3TH nepeMeHbI no 60JIbweH IlaCTH OTpa3HJIHCh JIHWb B Ta6nHllKax Ha o BepJlX Ka6HHeTOB IlHHOBHHKOB - KaK npaBHJIO eKeH COB eTa Hapo l1 HbIX KOMHCcapoB HO paKTHlleCKH npe o CTaBJIJIJI oo60H BoeHHO-X03J1HCTBeHHbIH Ka6HHeT 3aee o aBWHH nOKYAB ne­ Tex f e caMbIX OHH He ABIOT npe o CTaBJIeHHJI 0 o eHCTBHTeJIbHbIX HHH 6bIJI em e pa60Tocnoco6eH no o ero npe o ceABTeJIhCTBOM B CTO PyHKIJ HJlX BCHX 0 BXO o HJI npe o ee o aTeJIb BCHX HapKoMbI 060POHbI TPY o a Tpaacnop­ CTeneHH UeHTpaJIH3OBaHHoro KOHTPOJIJI Ha lJ TpeCTaMH co CTOPOHbI ero OT o eJIOB H no o OT o eJIOB HJIH 0 TOM B Ka­ Ta KOH Mepe B o eHCTBHTeJIhHOCTH npo peccHOHaJIhHbIX C01030B 24 leKpeTbI CTO HMenH CHJIY 3aKOHOB B 20-e rO l1 bI ocym eCTBJIJlJIOCb IUIa­ eeJIbCKOrO X03 IIHCTBa cHa6 f eHHJI a TaK f e npe o CTaBHTeJIH HHpoBaHHe 3TO He TaK Y f npoCTO YCTaHOBHTb H onHcaTb Haa60JIee nOJIHO 3TO c o eJIaJIH HeCOMHeHHO 3 Kapp H P l3BHC 23 OHH nOKa­ KaK eCJIH 6bI OHH H3 o aBaJIHCb npaBHTeJIbCTBoM focnnaa KOTOpbIH 3aJIH cym eCTBeHHbIe Pa3JIH1lHJI B ynpaBJIeHHH pa3HbIMH OTpaCJIJlMH MaHHPOBaHHJI 6bIJI C03 l1 8 H 22 peBpaJIJI 1921 r l1 l1J1 pa3pa60TKH CHallaJIa 6bIJI H3BeCTeH KaK KOMHCCHH o6m ero rocy o apCTBeHHoro npoMbIWJIeHHOCTH B pa3HbIe nepHO l1 bI HanpHMep HeKoTopbIe KJIIO­ eJI HHoro reHepaJIbHOrO rocy o apCTBeHHoro Maaa a TaK f e MeTo o OB lleBble OTpaCJIH TJI f eJIOH npoMbwmeHHocTH nOCTaBJIJlBWHe H3 o e· ero peaJIH3a o HH COTpY o HHKH focnnaaa Ha3HaIlaJIHCb COBeToM TPY­ JIHJI CTpaTerHlleCKOrO 3HalleHHJI o rUI Beero X03J1HCTBa nOJIYIlaJIH o a H 060poHbl Ero oM3aHHoCTH 6bIJIH onpe o eJIeHbI 3aROBO 21 aB­ npJlMbIe npHKa3bI - ryCTa 1923 r H HMeHHO C 3T0ro MOMeHTa nOJlBHJIOCb 3H8KOMoe HaM 58 1lT0 npOH3BO l1 HTb CKOJIbKO H l1 l1J1 Koro H Ta­ 59 Ha3BaHHe foCIlJIaH Ero 06I1Ufe 3aAa'IH q OPMynHPOB8JIHCb n01l­ HI lJ 3aK31I01JaJ1H KOHTPaKlhl 0 KpeARTe C 6aHKaMH H lJ pyr C lJ py­ B leX JlCe CJIOBaX lITO H 3aAa'IH KOMHCCHH nOM b B pa3pa­ roM PyKOBO lJ CIBYIlCb DpH 3IOM HHTepecaMH co6CIBeHHOH npH6hlJ1H m 6on e 6lOAJlCela H3yt1eHHe OCHOBHhIX npo6neM lJ eHeJICHorO 06paw e­ UpaBAa BpeMil OT BpeMeHH H3 ueHlpa lJ e31aJIHCb nOnhlTKH nOCIaBHTb HH1l Kpe ll Hla H 6a HKOB palM eHHe npoMbIlID1eHHocm craH l 8 p­ neHo06palOBaHHe no lJ KOHTPOJlb K KOauy 20-x rO lJ OB 3TH nonbIII H m3au HJl fOCIlJIaH OcymeCIBJ1 fUI KOOp lJ HHHposaHHe H nOJIycDUI npa­ yCHJ1HJ1HCh «lIe31HKC ll3ePJICHHCKHH npe lJ eeAaTem BCHX H maBa qK BO H3Y'Jalb Bee IlJIaHbI H npo lJ OBOJIbCIBeHHhIe nporpaMMbI npeAJIa­ raeMbIe HapO ll HhIMH KOMHccapHalaMH BK TIlOqag BCHX H BhICKa­ nucaJt 3bIBaIh CBoe MHeHHe 0 HHX B3 lJ YMaeTcll OHH caMH ce6e X0311eBa caMH ce6e H fOCIlJIaH H fJlaB­ TIPH nO lJ 06HOH ClpyKlype IJ y6nHpoBaHHe 6hmo HeH36e HbIM a no lJ 1Jac - H IpeHH fl C IlJIaHHpYlOmHMH nO lJ pa3 lJ eJleHH flMH BCHX B 1924 r Y HaC no'ITII Ka lJ bIH lpeCI lJ eJlaeI lITO eMy MelaJIJl H BCHX a eCJ1H lITO-HH6y lJ h He B nop1l lJ Ke nhllalOICIl CKpbIlb - no npHtleM npH nO lJ lJ ep l e MeCTHhlX opraaOB Z S• ll3ep­ TaK nO ll fOTOBKY KOHlPOJlbHbIX IJ Hq p Ha 1925·1926 rr ocymecT­ HHCKHH CTpeMHJlCIl YCHJlHTb KOHTPOJlb 3a tpeCIaMH HO ycnexu BJl flJl TOJlhKO fOCIlJIaH HO B03rnaB31I1BIIIHH ero TOrAa KP fGI JKaHOBC­ Ha 3TOM nym OClaBaJIHCh lJ OCTaTO'IHO CKPOMlIblMH KHH JKaJlOBanC1l co XY C C'he3 IJ y napmH Ha oTcyrCTBHe COlpY lJ HH'IeCTBa lJ pyrOH CIOPOHhl caMH COTpY ll HHKH tpeCIOB Ha'IHHaJlH oC03HaBalb lITO lpeCThl CJ1HlIIKOM Hem6KH CJIHlIIKOM rpoM03 lJ KH CIOPOllbI lJ pyrHX ytlpe lJ eHHH O ll HaKO CJIOBO IlJIaHHpOBaHHe B 1923-1926 rr HMeno co­ BeplIIeHHO HHOH CMIIICJI tleM BnOCJle lJ CIBHH He cymeCIBOBano n031­ 'iT06bI 3q q eKIHBHO ynpaB31I1Ib x03I1ii cmOM TaK Ha XU Che3 lJ e napIHH 1923 f pa3AaBanHCb npH3bIBbI K lpeCtaM npe lJ OCTaBHIb HOCIhIO pa3pa60IaHHl IX nporpaMM npoH3BO lJ CIBa H pa3MemeHHil pe­ 60JlblIIe caMoCIOIlIeJlbHOCTH BXOronuHM B HHX npeAJIpH1ITH1lM OC­ CYPCOB He IaBHB 6bUIO KOMa H ll HOH 3KOHOMHKH Cpe lJ H 3KcneprOB 3a co60H pacnpe lJ e31eHHe npeMHanbllblX B 3aBHCHMOCIH OI fOCIUIaHa MHome He COCI01lJlH B napIHH HJlH 6hIJlH npe f lJ e MeHblIIe­ npH6bmbHOCTH 3mx npeAJIPH flmH Ho H 3 lJ eCh 3aMemble H3MeHe­ BHKaMH Pa60ra HX Tpe60Bana IBOp'leCKOrO nO lJ XoAa AJII1 npeo lJ Oo HH fl npoH30lIIJ1H J1HlIIb n03 ll Hee JleHH fl lJ eq eKIOB TorAa1IIHeH ClaTHCIHKH OHH CIpeMHJ1HCb COlAaTh nepsbIH B HCTOPHH 6anaHc Hapo ll HOrO X031lHCIBa - nepBylO MOo lJ eJlb AJI1l IlJIaHHPOBaHHII poCla Ho BaJICHO nO lJ tlepKHyrb 'IIO pe3yn ­ QeHl I PJdIIOK H qaC'l'HLIe npeAJIpHH11IJI IalaMH HX YCHJlHH H paCtleTOB 6bIJlH He IlJIaHhI KaK npHKalbI lJ eHCT­ BOBaTh a KOHpOJlbHl Ie IJ Hq PhI 3TO 6hIJlH OT'JaCIH nporH03bI OT­ C HacrynneHHeM H3TIa 83-3a lJ eq HIJ Hta IOBapOB B CB1I3H C 'Jacm PyKoBO lJ CIBa AJII1 clpalem'leCKHH pelIIeHHii 0 KanHIanOBJlOo B0306HOBJIeHHeM BbIUJlaTbI 3apa60moH IlJIaTbI lJ eHbraMH H npeKpa­ JlCeHH flx 6a3HC AJII1 Il HCKYCcHH H onpe lJ eneHH fl npHopHleTOB HH fOCIlJIaH HH BCHX He MornH H He nhII8JIHCb o6ecne'IHTb rn eHHeM BhIAa'IH 6eCIlJIatHl IX naiiKOB H yCJIyr BClana npo6neMa ueH lleKperOM OI 5 OC06eHHO OClpO aBfYCIa 1921 r npH HaPKO­ IlJIa Hh1 BhmYCKa npo IJ yKIJ HH AJI1l Beex lpeCTOB H npeAJIpH1lTHH 3TO Male q HHaHCOB 6hm 06palOBaH KOMHler UeH nOJlytlHBlIIHH npaBo lJ eJlanOCh 31HlIIb AJII1 HeKOTophIX KJllOtleBhlX OTpaCJIeH BOJlblIIHHCT­ q HKCHpoBaIb onrOBble H po3HH'1Hhle UeHl I Ha IOBapbl H3fOIOB31l1e­ BO lpeCIOB npHHHManH pelIIeHHIl caMH JIHlIIh npH tlaCTH'lHOM Ha IJ 3Oo MIlle HJlH npoAaBaeMIIle fOCY lJ apCIBeHHbIMH npeAJIpH1lTH1lMH a raK­ pe CBepxy TpeCIhI cymeCIBeHHO pa3J1H1JaJ1HCb H no palMepaM H no JKe Ha TOBaphI nOKynaeMbIe rOCY lJ apCmeHllbIMH ytlpe lJ eHH1lMH HanpHMep HanpHMep Y KpeCT 1IH-e lJ HHOJlH'IHHKOB Ho Ha npaKIHKe YCIaHOB­ BaKHHcKail Heq IIIHaII o praHH3allHll KOIOpail HeCJIa omeTcmeH­ neHHhle csepxy ueHhl no 6031blIIeH 'Jacm HfHOpHPOB8JIHCh H B 1922 r HOCTb 3a COBeICKoe Heq IlIHoe npOH3BO lJ CIBO H 6hma IeCHO CBII3a­ OHH 6hIJlH 3aMeHeHhl TaK Ha3bIBaeMbIMH opHeHIHpOBO'IHhlMH ueHa­ MH KOlophle ClaJIH BOcnPHHHMaThCII KaK MHHHM8JIbHl Ie H 3TH n eHbI opraHH3aIJ HH pa60IhI CpeAR HHX 6hlJ1H orpoMHhIe Ha C coomelcIBYIOI1UfM nO lJ OI IJ e310M BCHX llpyrue lJ OCTaIO'IHO CBo60 ll HbIe OI KOHlPOJlIl co CIOPOHhl BCHX BCTynanH B C lJ eJlKH lpeCIbI no CBoeMY YCMOTpeHHIO MOfJIH nOBblIIIaIb HCKJllOtleHHe C lJ pymMH lpeclaMH C tlaCIHl IMH IoproBuaMH KoonepamBaMH npe lJ ClaB31 flJlH ueHhl Ha HeKOIopble MOHonOJlH3HpoBaHHl Ie rocy­ 60 61 n aPCTBOM TOBapbI - C01ll Ta6aK KepoCHH H CII1f1IKH UeHbI Ha 3TH TOBapbI p eiiCTBHTenbHO TBepp O q HKCHPOBaJIHCb XOTK 'laCTHble ToproBn bI eenH HM YJJ 3 BaJIOCh 3TH TOBapbI P OCTaTb npo n aBaJIH HX no CTOJIh BbICOKHM n eHaM KaKHe TonhKO Mor BhI ll epX aTb MeCTHblii pbIHOK KOMHCCHK no ToproBne yqpe l eHHlUl rrpH CTO B 1922 r o YCTaHOBHIla rrpKMbIe CBK3H Me l y rocy n apCTBeHHoii npOMbIIllJIeH­ HOCTbIO H nOTpe6HTenbCKHMH KoorrepaTHBaMH Ype3aB TaKHM 06­ paJOM c4 epy p eKTenhHOCTH 'laCTHbIX nocpe J HHKOB HO H eii Bee-Ta­ KH He y n anOCh KOHTponHpoBaTb n eHbI CKOJIhKO-HH6YAh 3q q eKTHB­ HbIM 06pa30M 26 COCYIIJ eCTBOBaHHe 'laCTHoro H rocy n apcTBeHHoro eeKTopOB p a eIIJ e Bp 06aBOK p OCTaTO'IHO aBTOHOMHbIX KoonepaTHBOB B yeno­ BHKX HHq nKIJ HH pa3BaJIa TpaHcnopTa H He3q q eKTHBHOCTH ap MHHH­ CTpaTHBHoro PYKOBop CTBa BneKnO 3a co60ii 3HatJHTenbHYIO TeKy­ qeCTh n eH MbI Y Ke ynOMHHaJIH 0 HO KHHIJ ax n eH KOTOpbIe oceHbIO 1923 r nopo J HIlH KPH3HC a TaK Ke 0 eepbe3HblX TPY J HOCTKX rocy­ n apcTBeHHblx npelUlpHKTHH C npo n a Keii CBOHX p oporocTOKIIJ H X TOBapoB 3TH TOBapbI OKa3blBaJIHCh eIIJ e p opo Ke Kor n a OHH HaKO­ OC06eHHO B eenbCKHX paiioHax Hen p OCTHraJIH nOTpe6HTenK npoii WJ qepe3 MHorHX 'laCTHbIX nocpe J HHKOB Bo MHornx cenhCKHX MeCTHOCTKX B 1923 r ToproBnIO BeJIH nO H HCKnIO'lHTeJIhHO H3rr­ MaHbI K TOMY BpeMeHH npu n a Koe-rp e 6bIJIH C03P aHbI eeJIhCKHe KoonepaTHBbI HO B 60nbWHHCTBe OHH OKa3aJIHCh qpe3BbIqaHHO He3q q eKTHBHbIMH Bce 3TO HIlJIIOCTpHpyeT Ta6rrHIJ a p aHHbIe KOTO­ poii OTHOCKTCK K OKTK6pIO 1923 r flpH TaKHX KOJIOCCaJIhHbIX pa3pbIBax B n eHax KoonepaTHBaM 6bIJI0 TPYIJ HO KOHKypHpoBaTb C H3nMaHaMH la Ke B MocKBe rp e B 1922 r rrop Oq HIJ HaJIbHbIM nOKpoBH­ TenhCTBOM 6hIJIa C03 n aHa ToBapHlUl 6HP Ka H3rrMaHbI KOHTpOnH­ poBarrH 14% OIlTOBOii TOprOBJIH 50% OIlTOBO-P03HH'IHoii TOprOBJIH H 83% P03HH'lH0ii TOproBJIH KoorrepaTHBaM rrpHHap JIe KaJIo TonhKO 10% a rocy n apcTBeHHoii TOprOBJIe 7% lJ 0 MapTa 1923 r rro Bceii crpaHe OIlTOBlUl ToproBnR TeKcmneM Ha 50% rrpHHap JIe KaJIa 'laCTHO MY KaIIHTaJIy qaCTHlUl TOprOBJIR B 1922-1923 rr COCTaBJIKJIa 78% Beeii po3HH'IHOn TOprOBJIH XOTR Bnocnep CTBHH 3Ta rrponOpIJ HK nOCTeneHHO coKpaIIJ arrach - 57 7% B 1923-1924 rr 42 5% B 1924­ 1925 rr 42 3% B 1925·1926 rr H 36 7% B 1926-1927 rr 27 O J HaKo 3TO rrpOn eHTHoe cOKpaIIJ eHHe Ha rrepBbIx rropax orr­ peWIJIOCb POCTOM a6COnIOTHOrO o61 eMa ToproBnH B paMKax CTpeMH­ TenhHO pacTyruero 06IIJ ero TOBapo060poTa B 1925-1926 rr H orrTO­ BaR H po3HH'IHlUl TOprOBJIR BbIpoenH Ha 50% IlHmh Ha cnep yIOIIJ Hii rop a6COJIIOTHbIH o61 eM JIon ToproBnH Ha'laJI COKpaIIJ aTbCK qacrHlUl TOproBJIK 3aIIOnHRJIa rryCTOThI KOTopbIe 06pa30BblBa­ nHCb B pe3ynbTaTe He3q q eKTHBHOCTH rocy n apCTBeHHoii H Koorrepa­ THBHOii TOproBOii ceTH KaK Y Ke 6bIJIO OTMeqeHO OHa orrepHpoBarra npop yKIJ Heii rocy n apCTBeHHbIX rrpelUlpHRTHii HO 3Ha'IHTenhHYIO ee ' aCTb cOCTasnHIlH TOBapbI 'laCTHOn rrpOMhlIIIJIeHHOCTH H peMecen C 1923 r npuHTenbCTBo BO Bee B03paCTaIOIIJ eii CTeneHH paCWHpHIlO rocyp apCTBeHHYIO H KOonepaTHBHYIO eeTb po060poTe He 'KJIOHHO poena Ha Hx p onK B 06IIJ eM TOBa­ rrepBbIX rropax 3TO p enarrOCb Ha OCHOBe KOHKypeHIJ HH H HaIIpuneHHR rocy n apCTBeHHon rrpoPYKIJ HH OAe rB03 llH KepoCHH Caxap ConI qepe3 oq HIJ HarrhHbIe KaHarrbI Ho Bnoenep CTBHH H3nMaHQB Ha'IaJIH BhITeCHKTb MeHee MHpHbIMH cpep CTBaMH UeHbI Ha npoAyK 1O TpecrOB B npOMbIIllJIeHHOM npOH3BOP CTBe K 1924-1925 rr CHryaIJ HR 100 100 100 100 100 174 136 100 162 107 UeHbI B ceJIbCKHX KoonepaTHBaX 243 177 128 222 121 HcrO'llIHK 62 KPynHlUl npoMhIIllJIeHHOCTb npOH3BOp CTBO B OTnH'lHe OT MacTepcKHx - UeHbI B o6nacrHbIx KoonepaTHBax MOCKB8 6hIJIa TaKOBa T e 4 a6pH'lHoe no rrOJIHOCTbIO OCTaBarraCb B pYKax rocyp apcTBa B 3TOM ceKTope TOJIbKO 1 82% rrpHHa l TIe KaJIH 'lacrHHKaM O J HaKO npoP 'KIJ HR MenKoii H peMeeneH­ Hoii npoMbIIIIJIeHHOCTH p enHIlaCb enep yIOlIJ HM 06pa30M Mana$eeB HcrOpHK eHoo6pa30BaHHft B CCCP 1964 crp 63 63 p 1'HBHOCTI ttaCTHHKOB '1pe3BbIlIIlHHO 3aBHceJIa OT CHa6 ICeHH II MaTe· 192319241'1' 192419251'1' 192519261'1' 1926­ 19271'1' pHaJIaMH npoH3BOAHMbIMH rocy u apCTBeHHOH npoMbIllDIeHHOCTI W J TOMY ICe 6oJII IlIHHCTBO ttaCTHbIX MaCTepCKHX apeH Il OBaJIOCI Y rocy u apCTBa Bee S % K 06UleMY nOOIlYKry 2 2 2 6 2 5 2 3 KoonepaTHShl 8 1 20 4 19 8 20 2 tlaCTHhle npen npHRTWI 89 7 77 0 77 7 77 5 rna lKOS CoSeTCKOe HapollHoe X03RHCTBO 3aHJlTOCTI B ttaCTHOM eeKTope npoMhllWleHHOCTH poena B% 1921­ 1925 IT MocKsa 1960 CTp 201 B 1925 no enOBaM COBeTCKoro HCTopHKa u aBaJIO npoH3BoACTBa n 2 8 rocyn apcTseHHble npellnpHRTHJI HCTO'DIHK no B pyKH rocy u apCTBa CHJIbHOe 0pYAHe perynHpoBaJm II MeJIKorO r 3aHRTOCTb B MeJIKOH npoMbIUDIeHHOCTH pacnpeAe­ lI llJIaCb TaK 13 20 2-5 1924-1925 rr 1925-1926 rr 1926-1927 rr 3aTeM nOeneAOBaJIO KaTaCTpotjJH'IeCKOe naAeHHe B paccMaT­ pHBaeMbIe rOAbI npoHcxoAHJI nOCTO llHHbIH pOCT OCHOBHblX tjJOH Il OB KanHTaJIa ttaCTHoro eeKTopa B neJIOM OAHaKO npaBHTeJIbCTBO 6bICTpo yKpenmlJlo CBoe AOMHHHpywInee nOJIO ICeHHe B 3KOHOMHKe tlHcneHHOCT pa60THHKos THn npen npiUlTHII a nOCJle pacnpoCTpaHeHH II rocy u apcTBeHHoH H OooOOHHO Koonepa­ THBHOH ToproBoH eeTH B eeJIbCKHX MeCTHOCT IIX OTKpbD1aCb B03­ MO KHOCTb iJYUlHTh 'laCTHbIH ceKTop COKPaIna ll nOCTaBKH eMY roo rOcyn apCTBeHH8JI MeJIK8J'I npoMbIWJIeHHoCT 30644 127162 1922­ 1923 rr ee AOJIB B P03HH'lHOM TOBapoo60poTe ooCTaBJI llJIa 10% a 75% P03HH'lHOH ToprOBJIH npHxoAHJIHCb Ha 'laCTHbIH ceKTop K 1926-1927 rr AOJIB KoonepaTHBHOH P03HH'lHOH ToprOBJIH BbIpoC­ na B 19 pal BoT KaK H3MeHHJIaCb npH nol f 06mu KapTHHa TOBa­ paTHBHa II TOprOBJI II poCJla CTpeMHTeJIbHbIMH TeMnaMH B 2285161 PeMecneHHHKH-'IllCTHHKH 270823 tlaCTHble npen npHJITHJI 2713790 Bcem po060pora BHA npen npiUlTHII Be3 HaHMa pa60QeH CHJIhl SHe eeM H rn8llKOB CoseTcKoe 1922-19231'1' 1926-19271'1' s MJIH py6neA C HaHMOM pa60QeH CHJIbI HCTO'DIHK Kor u a TOJIbKO nO KeJIaIDT TIoOInp lleMa II H nOMepxomaeMa II rocy u apCTBOM P03HH'1Ha ll Koone­ KoonepaTHBhl TOBbIX H3AeJIHH TOIDIHBa H CbIpl ll - uapollHoe X03RHCTBO 1921­ 19251'1' MOCKsa 1960 CTJ 204 3TH nutjJPbI nOKa3bmamT 'ITO B MeJIKOH npoMbllIIJIeHHOCTH rOCY n apCTBeHHhle KoonepaTHSHble qaCTHhle 512 368 2680 1817 6838 5063 Bcero 3560 13718 'laCTHbIH eeKTOp AOMHHHPOBaJI H JIbBHHa II AOJIJI npHxoAHJIaCb Ha MeJIKoe ceMeHHoe peMeeneHHoe npoH3BOACTBO TIPOH3BoACTBeHHa II 64 65 3TH UHcJ Pbl CTpeMllTeJIbHblX B nOCTO llHHbIX TeMIlaX neHaX 03p opoBJIeHH Il CBHp eTeJIbCIBYIOT 0 3KOHOMHKH B nepBhle rOAbl H3ITa HHe 3eMJIH npoBOAHJIOCb nop 311fP OH TPap HnHOHHOH KpeCTb llHCKOH Y 1906 06IUlfHbI Hee Tenepb 6bIlIO OOJIbllie BJIaCTH 'leM KOrAa-JIHOO nocne r nepep eJI IlTb KpeCTbJiHCKHe Hap eJIhI H HaB Il3h1BaTb r peCTb llHaM 'lepecoonocHny K IIpHHaAITe lKaJIO OOJIee CenbCKoe X03 IIACTBO H Kpec rLI1HCTBO lK l aTb 'lT0 B eeJIbCKOM x03JIiiCTBe 'laCTHbIH eeKTOp AOMHHHPOBaJI Ha npo­ 1918-1920 U lKeHHH Beero nepHOAa H3ITa B 350 90% 1925 r K AepeBeHCKHM 06mHHaM KpeCTb llH ECTb Bee OCHOBaHH Il yTBe TbIC TaI HX o6maa KOHTPOJIHPOBaJIH BCIO X03 1lHCT­ BeHHyro lKH3Hb AepeBHH 29 B 3TOM CMbIcne nocneAcTBH Il peBOnlOnHH rr KOJIJIeKTHBHhle MO lKHO C'lHTaTb peaKlJ HoHHbIMH 3eMJIIO Hape3aJIH Ha AeCIDKH a TO X03 1lHCTBa H KOMMyHbl 6bmH MaJIO'IHCJIeHHbI HO B nocJIeAyrornHe H COTHH nonoc KOTopble pa3p eJIJUIHCb HHOrAa 3Ha'lHTeJIbHbIM pac­ rOAbI HX CTaJIO eme MeHbllie B 1927 r noeeBHble nnoma l H pacnpe­ p eJIJiJIHCb cneAyromHM 06pa30M CTO llHHeM H nO l Jle lKaJIH nepHO l H'leCr OH nepeAa'le H3 OAHHX PYK B APyrHe ITpe06JIa l aJIa CHCTeMa TpoenOJIb ll KOTOpa ll npenIDCTBO­ BaJIa BBeAeHHIO OOJIee COBpeMeHHOH npaI THKH eeBoooopoTa noe­ % KonbKY 3Ta nocneAH ll ll He B Il3aJIaCb C nop ll l KaMH KpeCTb llHCKOrO MHpa Eme B COBX03hl KonX03hl Bcex THnoB 1 1 0 6 EAHHonH'lHHKH 98 3 1928 r 5 5 MJIH X03 1lHCTB nOJIb30BaJIHCb COXOH a nOJIOBHHY ypo lKa ll 3epHa y6HpaJIH eepnoM HJlH KOCOH 40% ypo lKaJi MOJIOTHJlH nenaMH JlocTH I eHH ll Mop epHH3anHH CeJIbCKorO X03JlH­ CTBa Ha'laJIa CTOJIeTHH 6bIlIH YTpa'leHbI Bee 3TO BMeCTe nOCTaBHJIO HOBbIH pe lKHM nepeA eepbe3HbIMH npoOrIeMaMH HCTO'IHHK STaml 3KOHOMH'IeCKOH nOJlHTHKH CCCP peD n BaHc6epr MocKBa 1934 CTp 35 ITOJIO l eHHe ycyryOrIJlJIocb KnaCCOBbIM nop xoAoM Onpe­ l eJIeHH ll KynaI eepe l HHK HJIH OOAH llK C npHCOe l HHeHHeM K 3THM nocneAHHM 6e33eMem HbIx 6aTpaKOB 6bIlIH ynpomeHHJl­ 1 aI TH'leCKH nepepacnpe l eJIeHHe 3eMJIH a TaI lKe nocnep CTBHH KJIaCCOBOH ooPb6bI B 1920 1917-1918 rr AepeBHe B 1918­ r anae KpeCTbJiHCTBa CTaTHCTHKH H aHaJIHTHKH TPyAHJIHCb 'lT06bI B MH MHoro 6bIlIO HanHcaHO Herne OOJIbllie HarOBOpeHO 0 CTpaTHcJ H­ rr npHBeJIH K JIHKBHAanHH He TOJIbKO nOMetnH'lbHX HMeHHH nOAOrHaTb nOA MaPKCHCTCKO-JIeHHHHCKHe OnpeAeJIeHH ll AOCTaTOq­ HO H 3Ha'IHTeJIbHOH 'laCTH KpynHbIX KpeCTb llHCKHX X03 1lHCTB MHJI­ HO cno l Hble OTHOllIeHHH B l epeBHe npHBeCTH HX B COOTBeTCTBHe 00­ C 3apaaee 3arOTOBJIeHHbIMH JlpJIbIKaMH ITocKonbKY 06CTaHOBKa JIHOHbl OO33eMeJIbHbIX OOTpaKOB H 6bIBIIIHX KpeCTbHH KOTopble lKaJIH H3 ropoP OB Halap B AepeBHIO BO BpeMeHa BoeHHoro KOMMY­ 6bIlIa B3pbIBoonaCHa KaI l HHaMHT OObeKTHBHOe HccneAOBaHHe HH3Ma JIHOO C6paCbIBaJIOCb co C'leTa JIHOO npeACTaBJIJlJIOCb cnHIIIKOM PHe­ 'lHcno nony'iHJlH 3eMJIIO B HTore KpeCTb llHCKHX X03 1lHCTB TeppHTopHH rp e AO 1917 cymeCTBeHHO ITpHOrIH3HTeJIbHO Ha taKOH lKe r 6bmo 17-18 BaeMblX OAHOH KpeCTbJiHCKOH eeMbeH B p o 24 MJIH a B 1927 r - p o 25 yseJIH'lHJlOCb MJIH x03JIiiCTB o6cny I H­ 1924 r HX 'lHcno BbIpocnO KOBaHHbIM Kar nHcan Kapp He KJIaCCOBblH aHaJIH3 onpep eJIJlJI Tenepb nonHTHKY HanpoTHB KJIaCCOBbW aHaJIH3 p HKTOBaJICJl TeM 'lT0 60nbllie nop xoAHJIo npH AaHHOH CHTYanHH 30 MJIH Bonee TO'lHble CpaBHHTenb­ JleHCTBHTeJIbHaJi MeTOp OJIOrH'leCKaJi TPYAHOCTb 3aKJIIO'laJIaCb Hble l aHHble no BeeH BH l HMOCTH He cymeCTBYIOT Be33eMeJIbHbIX B TOM 'lT0 0 l Ha KaTerOpHJl HanaraJIaCb Ha APyrylO Be33eMenb­ H MaJI03eMenbHbIX KpeCTbJlH Hap eJIJlJIH 3eMJIeH 3a C'leT HX coceAeH HbW Mor HMeTb HeMHOrO 3eMJIH HO CTonb MaJIO 'lT0 OAHH HJlH ABa CpeAHHil pa3Mep 3eMeJIbHbIX BJIa l eHHH H pa3HHna Me lKAY 3 I H­ 'lJIeHa TO'lHbIMH H OO l HbIMH YMeHb1lIHJIHCb KpeCTbJiHHHY JIHOO paOOTaTb Ha MHP AonyCTHM naCTYXOM fOAbl peBonlOnHH YHH'lTO l HJlH nocnep CTBH Il CTonbIIIHHCKOH pecJ OPMhI B 66 MHOl1fe 1918 eeMbH BbIHY lKAeHbI 6bmH JIHOO HaHHMaTbC Il K ApyrOMY nOJIO lKHTeJIbHhle nHOO Bble3 1 aTb Ha OTXO lKHH npoMbleen•• BeAH llK no onpep ene­ r nepepacnpeAeJIe- HHIO HMen HeAOCTaTO'IHO 3eMJIH 'lT06bI npoKopMHTb CBOIO eeMblO 67 H OH TaK Ke Bbm yx o eH Obm K KOMY-TO HaHHMaTbCfl Ha 'laCTb rorot HX ce1lbCKOX03J1HCTBeHHblMH MawHHaMH KaKHe Torrot HMe1lHCb WIH ornYCKaTb BHaeM KorO-TO H3 'llIeHOB CBoeH ceMbH C1Iep yeT 6epR HX BHaeM KaK H 1I0maneH B01l0B H npyrux necpHUUTHbIX nOMHHTb 'ITO KpeCTbJIHCKHH u Bop KaK npaBHJIO BK1IIO'Ia1I B noMaWHHX l HBOTHbIX Y KY1IaKOB Obma HHHuuaTHBa H X03J1HCT­ ce6a HeCK01IbKO TpynocnocoOHblX H 3TO TaK Ke YCJIO' lQUlJlO 3a l 3 'IH BeHHaJI CMeKaJIKa OHH B030Y l J aJIH 3aBHCTb HO C npyroH CTOPOHbl CTpaTHCPHKau HH Cepe nH IIK HHorna TO Ke no 1I100bIM pa3YMHbIM BonnOlll aJIH B ceDe TO K KpeCTbJlHHH CTaH o apTaM Obm nOCTaTO'IHO DeneH H Ha HH3KHX ypoBH fIX Obm qHCJIeHHOCTb HeOT1IH'lHM OT De nH IIKa lfueHbI cepe nH IIIJ Koro X03 IIHCTBa TO­ Ke MornH HaHHMaTbC II Kyrot-HHOYAb B TO BpeM II KaK TO e X03 IIH­ 'ieMY' CTpeMH1lCfl Ka lKAbIH X03J1HCTBeHHbIH KynaKOB CY J Jl no HMelOllI HMCJI naHHbIM poCJIa CTBO B CBOIO oqepenb Morno HaHHMaTb paDoTHHKa MHorne TaK Ha3blBaeMbIe cepe J H SIKH He HMe1lH 1I0WaneH YKpaHHbl 48% - 40% 1922 r BceX KpeCTb IIH 1923 r 1924 r 1925 r B TaM60BCKoH ryDepmm H T n I1Horrot aHaJIH­ %K THKH HCn01lb30BaJIH TepMHH MaJIOMOlll HbIH KOTOPblM OXBaTbIBa­ S JlHCb H MeHee npeycneBaIOllI He cepe nH IIKH H De J H SIKH a HaxO­ X0311HCTS o6meMY 'lUcny nuBWHXCfI BbIWe noro ypoBH fI OTHOCHJIH K 3a I HTO'IHbIM H1IH KpenKHM KpeCTbJIHaM KYrot B coBepweHHo npoH3B01IbHOH npo­ nopIlHH 3a'IHCJIJIJIHCb H cepe J H SIKH H TaK Ha3blBaeMble KY1IaKH IlpeHAOBaBI1IHX 3eMJUO 2 8 3 3 4 2 6 1 HIlHHMaBI1IHX pa60THHKoB 1 0 1 0 1 7 1 9 Ho Koro e B TaKOM CJIyqae C'lHTaJIH KY1IaKOM 3TO noH II­ THe OnRTb-TaKH CTaTHCTHKH onpene1lJl1lH B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT n01lHTH­ licrO'IHHK rJIlI IlKos IJ HT pa60TIl crp 271 qeCKHX OOcTO IITe1lbCTB a n01lHTHKH 3aHOBO nepeHHallHBaJIH npHKa­ O U aKO 3blBaB CTaTHCTHKaM oDecne'IHTb HeooxonuMble UUCPPbI iJ TI II o60cHo­ BaHH II TOH WIH HHOH TOllKH 3peHH II I Y1IaKaMH npHH lITO Obl1l0 C'lHTaTb 5-7% HeKoTopbIe KpeCTbJlHe n01lb30BaJIHCb HaeMHbIM TpynoM Bcero JlHWb no HeCK01lbKO MeCJlu eB B rony Bcero KpeCTb IIHCTBa Ho H 3TH KpeCTb IIHe no KpaHHeH C caMoro Ha'la1la npaBHTe1lbCTBO OKa3aJIOCb nepen nWIeMMoH Mepe no 3afianHblM CTaHrotpTaM no 601lbweH 'laCTH Obl1lH nOCTa­ nopo lKAeHHOH TeM 'ITO y KpeCTbJlH Obmo KaK ObI nsa 1IHD a con­ TO'lHO De J Hbl JlBe 1I0manu H nse KOPOBbI H JeMe1lbHbIH Hane1l HOH CTOPOHbI OHH Obl1lH n01lynp01IeTapHJIMH HO C npyroH - nOCTaTO'lHbIH 'lTOObI ODecne'IHTb ceO II H ceMblO Ha BeCb ron CKpoM­ KHMH 0YP lKYa OHH K01leOanHCb H MornH ODecne'IHTb nOllBY iJ TIJI B03PO lKAeHHJI KanaTaJIH3Ma B TO e BpeM II COBeTCKHH COlO3 Obm HOH enOH H 'ITO-TO nponaTb comacHO T01lbKO rotHHblM 1% BOT Y lKe H KY1IaK Ho npH 3TOM COOPaHHblM npocpeccopOM Mowe neBHHOM OT oOlll ero 'lHCJIa KpeCTbJIHCKHX X03 IIHCTB HaHHMaJI 601Ibwe OnHoro paoOTHHKa HeKoTopbIe KY1IaKH MornH BbICTynaTb B p01lH poCTOBllI H­ KOB nepBOHa'la1lbHOe 3Ha'leHHe CJIOBa KY1IaK CB lI3aHO HMeHHO C Me1l­ oDuB1IeH pecny6n HKOH paDo'IHx H KpeCTbJlH H3II OCHOBbIBaJI­ CfI Ha cMblllKe Me lKny HHMH II03ToMY BCnOMHHaB YKa3aHHJI neHHHa npHxonWIH K BbIBOny 'ITO De U eHwee KpeCTbJlHCTBO MOo KeT ObITb COI03HHKOM cepe J H SIKH a KY1laKH no caMOH HX CYTH CBOHM BepoJlTHbIMH nonyrllHKaMH BparaMH ECJIH cepe nH IIKH 6n aro­ 3TOH CPyaKUUeH I1HOrna OHH HMeJIH B03MO KHOCTb ccynHTb CBOHM rotpR MeHee 6n aron01lY'IHblM COce J JlM HeMHoro lepHa Korrot Te KaK no HeH30e I H0 nepeHAYT B 1Iarepb BparOB COBeTcKoro pe I HMa 0YAYT X03JIHCTBeHHbIM ycnexaM CTaHyT Ky1laKaMH OHH 'laCTO CJIY'IaJIOCb OKa3bIBaJIHCb K BeCHe De3 nponHTaHH II OHH MornH YCTpaHBaTb npoTHB Hero 3aroBopbl CTpeM IICb B03POAHTb KanaTa­ TaK Ke COXpaH IITb 'laCTb ypo I 8 II B aM6apax 'lTOObl nporotTb ero no 1IH3M BCKapMJIHBa II n01lHTHqecKyIO onn03HD H1O Do1lee BbICOKOH u eHe Torrot KaK MeHee COCTO IITe1lbHble KpeCTb lIHe OnaaKO npH3HaHHe Ka I J oro npeycneBalOllI ero KpeCTbJIHH­ BbIHY lKAeHbI ObmH nponasaTb CBOH ypo KaH OblCTPO Korna u eHbl Ha BparOM 03HaQaJIO ObI npeBpalll eHHe HneH CMbllIKH B He1lenOCTb Ha pblHKe ObmH CaMbIMH HH3KHMH I1Horrot cocenu n01lb30BaJIHCb Ew e 601lbweH He1lenOCTblO C 3KOHOMHQeCKOH TOllKH 3peHHJI obmo 68 69 KapaTb Ka l J bIH x03JtiiCIBeHHblH ycnex B TO BpeMR KaK CTpaHa HY ­ AWlaCb B nOBbIllleHHH npoH3BOAHTeJIbHOCIH H pa3BHTHH pbIHKa Me TeM npou ecc BOCCTaHOBJIeHHR npOTeKaJI B nonycpe l ­ HeBeKOBbIX ycnOBIDIX KOr l a 6oJIblllHHCIBO MeJIK03eMeJIbHbIX KpeCTbJlH paCnOJIaraJIO BeCbMa MaJIhIMH B03MO HOCTRMH CTHMyJIa­ l aJleKO He BCerml· BeJIHKH 6bIJIH nOTepH H l PYrHX BH l OB CKOTa Pe3KO COKpaTHJIHCb noceBbI paCTeHHH l 1IR npoMbIlllJ1eHHoro HCnOJIb­ 30BaHHR - IIPO l OBOJIbCTBHeM caMHX ce6R MH H pecypcaMH 'IT06bl YJIY'llllaTb MeTO l h1 IIPOH3BO l CTBa HJIH npH­ MeIDITb MalllHHhI 11M OCIaBaJIOCb JIHllih paClllHpRTb CBOH 3eMeJIbHble BJIa l eHIDl yBeJIH'lHBaTh l OJIlO TOBapHOCTH B CBOeM npoH3BO l CIBe H Bo06ID e l BHraTbCR no TOMY nYTH KOTOPbIH HaMeTHJICR nOCJIe pe f JOPMbI CTOJIhlnHHa Ho HMeHHO 3TOT nyu C TO'IKH 3peHHR 6oJIbllleBHKOB BeJI K KanHTaJIH3MY B OAHOH H3 CBOHX nocne l HHx pa60T J eHHH npe l 1IaraJI BhIXO l OTY'lHTb KpeCTbJlH OT HH l HBH l YaJIH3Ma JleMoHCTpHPYJl KpeCTbRHaM npeHMymecTBa M3lllHHHOH o6pa60TKH 3eMJIH CHJIY TPaKTOpa MO ­ HO 6Y l eT B KOHe'IHOM C'IeTe CKJIOHHTb HX Ha CTOpOHy COu HaJIH3Ma no Pa60n pyccKorO COBeTCKHX 71 % Beero caMocHa6 eHHJI Cneu HaJIHCTOB Jlo xapaKTepHaH peBOJIlOu HH nOMeID HKH H ero HY HO y6e mlTb TaKOBa OC06eHHOCTb cornaCHO nO l C'IeTaM KYJIaKH nOCTaBJIRJIH TOBapHoro 3epHa Cepe l HJlKH H 6e l HJlKH HeCpaBHeHHO 29% CeJIbC­ 14 7% TOro 60JIee MHoro'IHCJIeHHhIe nOCIaBJIRJIH Ha PhIHOK TOJIbKO 'ITO OHH npoH3BO l HJIH PeBOJIlOu HR 3Ha'IHTeJIbHO yBeJIH'lHJIa 'lHCJleH­ HOCTh eepe l HftKOB H 6eAHJlKOB COKpaTHB 'lHcno KynaKoB I1ono­ My 06Pa30BaJICJI cymeCIBeHHhlii pa3phm Me 061u HM POCIOM eeJIbCKox03JtiiCIBeHHoro npOH3Bo l cTBa npoHcXO l HBlllHM ropa3 l o 6hICTpee 'IeM POCT CeJIbCKOX03J1HCIBeHHOH TOBapHOH npo J YKu HH yH l eT 3Ha'IHTeJIbHOe BpeMR anOKa KpeCTbJlHHHa HeJIb3J1 HaCHJIOBaTb l 1IJI KpeCTbRHCTBa KOX03ftiiCIBeHHoii TOBapHoii npo J YKu HH CIpaHhI T e Koonepau HJI H MexaHH3au uR I1ocTeneHHO KoonepaD HJI l OJI H3 6bIDa Ho COrJIaCHO J eHHHY Ha OT'laCTH H3-3a yna l Ka npOMbIlllJ1eHJIOCTH OT'IaCTH H3-33 Toro 'ITO KpeCTbRHe B nepBylO O'lepe l b CTpeMHJIHCb o6ecne'IHTb Pa3MepbI noceBHhIX nnOID a l eii H nOrOJIOBhe l OMalllHerO CKOTa yBeJIH'lHBaJIHCb nocne rOJIO l Horo 1921 r 6bICIPhIMH TeMIIaMH 6hIDa 06ID aJi nJIaT f J0pMa KOTOPYlO B nepBhIe rO l hI H3I1a npH3HaBa­ JIH Bce f JpaKUHH 6oJIbllleBH3Ma I100ID PJIJIHCb ceJIbCKHe nOTpeOOTeJIb­ KHe KoonepaTHBhI nOCKOJIhKY OHH npH3BaHbI 6bIJIH npHY'lHTb KpeCTbJlH K KoonepaUHH npeBpaID aJiCb TaKHM 06pa30M B OCHOB­ noceBHB II nnow a zu HOH pbI'Iar JIeHHHCKOro KOOnepaTHBHOrO nJIaHa qTO e KacaeT­ MJIH ra CJI npOH3BO l CTBeHHbIX KoonepaTHBOB TO 0 HHX nO'ITH He rOBOpHJIH Ypo» aif 3epHoBhIx MJIH T H eID e MeHbllle l 1IJI HHX l eJIaJIH THIIH'lHbIM l 1IR Toro nepHO l a 6bIDO BbICTynneHHe H MeID epJlKOBa Ha TOp eCTBeHHOM 33Ce l aHHH nOCBRID eHHOM naMJITH J eHHHa BCKOpe nOCJle ero cMepTH I10 cno­ 1913 r 1922 105 0 77 7 104 3 80 0 50 3 72 5 35 5 24 1 27 1 r MJIH rOJIOB CKOT MJIH rOJIOB 58 9 45 8 62 1 CBHHLH MJIH rOJIOB 20 3 12 0 21 8 B mlHHOM KOHTeKCTe He CTOJIb y CYID eCTBeHHO HaCKOJIbKO 3TH YTBep l eHIDI COOTBeTCTBOBaJIH TOMY l eJIaJIOCb no yKa3aHHJ1M J eHHHa B 'ITO B 1918-1921 r nowllAH BaM MeID epRKOBa J eHHH 6bID pelllHTeJIbHbIM npoTHBHHKOM HaCHJIb­ CIBeHHhIx MeTO l OB B o6nacTH CeJIbCKOrO X03RHCTBa H y'l HJI 'ITO TOJIbKO l YpaKH MorYT nOMbIIIIDJlTb 0 HaCHJIHH Ha l KpeCTbJlHCTBOM 31 1925 J aaHhIe sa 1916 r l eHCTBHTeJIbHOCTH rr Ba HO OAHaKO 'ITO HMeHHO TaK HCTOJIKOBbmaJIH ero B3rJIJI l hI B 1924 r 3TOro I1CTO'IHHK 1934 r CTp CO qlfSJIHC'I'H'IeCKOe CTpoHTeJILCTBO MocKBa 4 TOrml HHKTO He OCnapHBaJI KpeCTbJlHe CTpamlJIH He TOJIhKO OT YCTapeJIOH CHCTeMhI 3eMJIe­ nOJIb30BaHIDI I1epBaH MHpoBaH a 3aTeM rpa mlHCKaH BOHRbI YHec­ JIH C co60H MHo eCTBO JIOllla l eH H ml e CepeAHRKH HMeJIH ox 70 71 r B npoTHBononO I HOCTb poCTY CeJlbCKOXOlJlHCTBeHHoro 3IJBlIIHCb B 1924 r OT BlHMaHHJI Hanora HarypoH H 3aMeHHB ero BO lCTBa npoHlBO n CTBO TOBapHOrO lepHa He n OCTHrJIO n OBoeHHoro n eHe HbIM HaJIorOM rocy n apCTBo 60Jlbme 'IeM Kor n a 6bI TO HH 6bI' ypoBHJI OllHaKO CTaJIHH HaMepeHHO npeysemmIBaJI 3TOT pa3pbIB no OKa3aJIOCb 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIM B CHH eHHH eH Ha caMbIH OCHOB­ OH YTBepX JlWl lITO B 1927 r npoHlBo lCTBO TOBapHoro lepHa COe­ BOH Tosap eeJlbCKOrO x03J1ii CTBa - lepHO Bonbme Beero OT nOHU eHHJI ypoBHJI TOBapHOCTH lepRa CTpa· TaBJlJIJIO JlHWb nonoBHHY nOCTaBJIeHHoro Ha PbIHOK B 1913 r 3TH n aHHbIe nOBTopHJlH MHorHe aBTOPbI Ho coBeTcKHH aBTop 10 H COBeTCKHe H lana lHbIe MOIIIKOB KaK H aMepHKaHCKHH HCCJle n a­ BaTeJlb ll Kap no n qepKHBaJIH lITO CTaJIHH cy eCTBeHHO laHH3HJl 1JIl1l COBeTCKHH 3KcnopT 3TO HJlJIIOCTpHpyeTcJI CJle n yIO MH n aHHbI' MH B 1913 r KOTOPbIH OTJIHIlaJICJI XOpolliHM ypo aeM 3epHo COCTaBHJlO 40% Beero 3KcnopTa ypoBeRb TOBapHoro eeJlbCKOXOlJlHCTBeHHoro npoHlBo n CTBa eepe n n­ RbI 2 x rO lOB H MJIH T MaIIIKoB H Kap nHcaJIH 'ITO B 1909-1913 rr npoH3BO lCTBO TOBapHoro lepHa n OCTHraJIO B cpellHeM 16 7 MJIH T 1913 r 1925·1926 rr 1926-1927 IT 1927-1928 rr OKOJlO 25% BeeH lepHoBoii npo n yK H a B 1926-1928 rr OKOJlO 16 MJIH Tt T e npHfirrH3HTeJlbHO 21% Beero npoHlBO lCTBeHHOro lepHa 32 CTaJIHH a BCJle n 3a HHM H lpyrHe yrsepX JlWlH lITO B Te e rO ll bI H3na TOBapHoe lepHO COCTaBJlJIJIO TOJlbKO 13% Bcero npoH3· 12 0 2 0 2 1 0 3 Be n eHHoro 3epHa O n HaKO eCJlH HCXO n HTh H3 60Jlee ylKoro onpe n e· KpeCTbJlHe pearupoBanH Ha HOByro cHrylllUlIO H OTKpbIBaeMbIe JleHHJI nOHJITHJI TOBapHoe lepHO CTanHH 6bIJl MeHee n aneK OT HCTHHbI Ho B mo60M CJlyqae PbIHOK eeJlbCKOXOlJlHCTBeHHOH npo n yK· eIO B03MO lQlOCTH HeollHolHallHO OHU KOHe'lHO npHBeTCTBoBanH COKpaTHJlCJI no cpasHeHHIO C n OBoeHHbIM Tor n a KaK nOTpe6- CBo60JlHYIO TOprOBJlIO H nocpe n HH'leCTBo llaCTHbIX ToprOB eB He· HOCTb B lepHe BOlPOCJIa a B YCJlOBHJIX CTpeMHTeJIbHOH HH n YCTpHa· KOTopbIe la HTOllHbIe KpeCTbJlHe CTpeMWIHCb pacmupHTb CBoe xa- JlHl n OJl Ha 6bIJla paCTH e e 6bICTpee 3JlHCTBO B YCJlOBHJlX Kor n a y 6o lee MeJlKHX KpeCTbJlH 6bIl10 He· fJlaBHyro npH'lHHY CHH cHHJI TOBapHOCTH eeJlbCKOro X03J1HCTBa n OCTaTOllHO leMJIH IITo6bI npoKopMHTb caMHX ee6s H OHH o«PHnHaJIb' MbI YKa3bmanH MeJIKoe KpeCTbJlHCTBO nepeIWIO Ha caMocHa6· HO HJlH Heo4 HI4HaJIbHO BbI eHbI 6bIJlH apeH n OBaTh n onOJlHUTeJlb­ eHHe B 1925 r K peCThJlHe JlytnlIe DHTaJIHCb H MeHbIlIe npo n asanH HYIO leMJIIO Y CBOHX 60nee 60raTbIX coee n eH HJlH llononHHTeJlbHOH npH'lHHOH 6hIJlH HefirraronpHJITHbIe YCJlOBHJI TOp­ BOlMO I HOCTeH OTKpbmanOCb MHO eCTBO Jln4 4 epeHI QI8 UHJI Kpee­ roBoro 06MeHa Me ll y ropo n OM H n epeBHeH B OCOOOHHOCTH BO CTbJlHCTBa YrJIyfirrJIJIaCb 4 OPMHPOBaJICJI KJlaCC 60raTbIX KpeCTbJlH H n TH K HUM BHaeM BpeMJI KPH3Hca CBRlaHHoro C HO MH eH a TaK e n03 n Hee 3TO pa3YMeeTCJI 6bIJl ecrecTBeHHhIii H HeH300 HbIH npo ecc Kor n a 3TH HO HH Il bI palOIWIHCb CHOU K 3TOMY CJle n yeT n 06a· HO OH-TO HMeHHO H TpeBO HJl npasHTeJIbCTBO OCOOOHHO nOTOMY lITO BHTh CTpeMJIeHHe KpeCTbJlH yseJlHllHTh nOrOJlOBbe CKOTa H lHallHT Tpa n H OHHbIH KpeCTbJlHCKHH cxo n Bee e e 6bIJl B n epeBHe ra­ He06xo n HMOCTb ero KOPMHTb pacmHpeHUe nOCJle 1923 r DJIo a­ pal n O n eH no n CeJlbCKOXOlJlHCTBeHHbIMH paCTeHHJIMH 1J JIJI npoMbIIWIeH­ CeJIbCKHe COBeTbI BJlHJIHHe naprHH B n epeBHe OCTaBanOCb CTIa· HOCTH H HaKOHe nOCJlellHee HO He MeHee Ba l Hoe - nOCJle n CT' 60nee peanbHOH BJlaCTbIO 'leM XHllJoIe H MaJI034 4 eKTHBHbIe 6bIM O n HaKO BDJIOTb n O 1926 r BKJIIOliHTeJIbHO nOKa rJIaBHOH BHR eJIeHanpaBJleHHbIX YCHJlHH npasHTeJlbCTBa KOHTpOJlHpoBaTh 3a n a'leH rocy n apCTBa OCTaBaJIOCb noo peHHe TOBapHoro npoH3Bo n ­ pbIHOllHbIe eHbI Ha lepHO TaK y e B 1924-1925 rr 6bIJlH npHHJlTbI CTBa H BbIBOla eeJlbCKOXOlJlHCmeHHbIX npo n yKToB Ha pbIBOK 60· MepbI no ynopJl ll OqeHHIO CHCTeMbI larOTOBKH lepHa no YCHJleHHIO DJIaHHpoBaHHJI H BbITeCHeHUIO llaCTHbIX ToprOB eB B 1925·1926 rr COKpaTHJlH llaCTHyro TOprOBJlIO 3epHoM 3aKY HKOM TOBapHoro lepHa 75% - Y C B 3TH rO ll bI rJlaBHbIM CTaJIO rocy n apCTBO OTKa· lee COCTOJlTeJlbHbIe CJlOH KpeCTbJlHCTBa nOJlb30B l1HCb nOMep ' KOH lITO C n pyrOH CTOpoHbI nopoX JlWlo He n OBO lbCTBO napTHiiHbIX aKTHBHCTOB H pa3OlIapoBaHHe OO n HOTbI KOTOpaR paCCllHTbIBaJIa Ra 60Jlee firrarO eJIaTeJlbHoe OTHomeHUe BJlaCTeH Bee no 0Tp83HJlOCl BO BHYTpunapTHii HbIx n e6aTax Toro BpeMeHH 72 73 pe I HMY TO ICe He 6hVlO 0 ll H0­ aapHaHT KOToporo 6hVl npHIDlT B 1929 r npeAYcMaTpHBaJl poCT 3Ha'IIHhIM KpeCTb IHe npaBAll n01lyqwIH 3eMJUO HO He 3a6hVIH ' TO OTHoweHHe KpeCTb IHCTBa K HaUHOHaJlbHOrO AoXona B ttaCTHOM eeKTOpe He MeHee lleM Ha 23 9% 3 3 q aKTlflIeCKH 3axBaTWIH ee caMH C ApyrOH CTOPOHl I ewe 6hV1a ese­ Ho HaCTynneHHe Ha H3nMaHa BHe CeJlbCKoro XOlJlHCTBa Y lCe IImO naMJlTh 0 peKBH31fIVOIX BpeMeH BoeHHoro KOMMYHH3Ma na H n01lHhIM Xo JJ OM a HaCTynneHHe sa KpeCTbJlHHHa-eAHHOJlH'llHHKa B ICa npHe3 Ka8WHe B AepeBHIO KOMMYHHCTHlleCKHe q YSKlf HOHePhI KaK AepeBHe npaBWIO ttacTHOro 3KOHOMHlleCKOro npeADpHHHMaTeJIbCTBa HJlJlIOCTpHpyerCJl - 3ammeHHJI ropo ICaHe He BI I3bmaJlH CHMnaTHH KpeCTb IHCTBa rraPTHiiHI Ix JlHAePOB 0 MeJIK06YP lCfa3HOH CTHXHH BOT-BOT AOJl ICHO 6hV1o HattaTbCJl YnaAOK JleraJlbHOrO CJleAYlOweH ratirIuueH KOTOPOH OHH OKpY lCeHl I HeH36e ICH0 BHywaJlH TpeBory KpeCTbJl­ HaM 'llHTaBllIHM 3TH 3aJlBJleHHJI DocneAOBaBllIHe C06bITHJl no­ Ka3aJlH lfI'O na TpeBora He 6hVla 6ecnO'lBeHHoH Bo BCJlKOM cnyttae eCTeCTBeHHhIM qacrHhlii TOBapo­ o60ooT MnH Dy6 rOAbl CTpeMJleHHeM KpeCTI JlHHHa 6hV1o npHKymrrb no­ a % no aeeii TODroBne 60Jlbwe 3eMJlH ewe OAHY JlOW ewe OAHY KOPOBY a 61 1Tb MO lCeT H HaHHIb pa60THHKa Ho npH nOM OH He Mor 3a6bIBaTb lfI'O ero OTHeCYT K KJlaccy KYJlaKOB CTaRy KJleHMHTb KaK 3JlOAeJl H KPOBOCOca otirIO ICaT 60Jlee BhICOKHMH HaJlOraMH KpeCTbJlHCTBO npeACTaBJlJlJlOel pe I HMY nPOKJlJlThIM BonpoCOM H JlerKO npeA­ CTaBHTI lfI'O OHO OTIUIa'IIHBaJlO pe I HMY TOH ICe MOHeToH DpH 3TOM nOCK01IhKY B03MO ICHOCTH 3aRfl TOCTH B ropoAaX 6hVlH BeCbMa CKpoMHhIMH Ha npoTJl lCeHHH Beex 20-x rOAQB J UlBaJlO 0 ee6e 3HaTb 1924-1925 1925-1926 1926-1927 1928 1929 1930 1931 42 5 42 3 36 9 22 5 13 5 5 6 3 300 4 963 5 063 3 406 2 273 1 043 ewe 0 ll H0 JlBJleHHe H 6e3 Toro 3Ha'lHTeJlbHOe no OTHoweHHIO K HMelO­ WHMCJl 3eMeJlhHhIM pecypcaM ceJlbCKOe nepeHaceneHHe ycyrytirIJl­ JlOel no Mepe eCTeCTBeHHoro POCTa HapoAOHaceJleHHJI BOCnOJlWJB­ wero TJl ICeJll le nOTepH BbI3BaHHI Ie BOHHOH rOJlOAOM H 3nHAeMHJl­ MH HcrOllHHK Mana t ees HcrOPHR ueHo06pa30aaHHR a CCCP MocKas 1964 r crp 134 ABTOP HanOMHHSeT 0 WHPOKOM 061aeMe HeneranhHoii H1IH He3a t HKCHpOaaHHOii roproanH COKpawaJlaCb H AOJlJl 'IaCTHOrO eeKTopa B HaUHOHaJlbHOM AOXO- KOHen H3Da Ae 1925- 1926- 1928 1929 1930 1931 1932 1926rr 1927rr H3D AOCTRr aDOreJl K 1925 r Ha DpoTJl ICeHHH 1926 r a6co­ JlIOTHhIH poCT ttaCTHoro ceKTOpa 6bVl OCTaRODJleH Ho q aKTH'IeCKH ero CpaBHRTeJIhHhIH YDaAOK Ha'laJlCJl paRbWe BO BCJlKOM cnyqae R B 1926 r ewe npH3H3 BaJlOel ' TO ttaCTHOMY npeADpHHHMaTeJlbCT­ By A01I lCHa OTBOAHTI CJI 3aKOHHaJI POJlb B paMKax COBeTCKOH CRCTe­ %% 0606w ecraneHHhlii ceKTop 45 9 48 7 52 7 61 0 72 2 81 5 90 7 qscrHhlii ceKTOP 51 1 47 3 39 0 MI I OTMeHY H3Da HeJlerKO AllTHpoBan B oco6eHHOCTH nOTOMY lfI'O oq HUHaJlbHhle 3aJlBJleHHJl 06 3TOM Cmm'lHBhI WIR HaMepeHHO HeBepHhI TaK B 1929 r CTaJlHH meBHO onpoBepraJl cnyxu ' TO 59 1 27 8 18 5 9 0 H3D 3aKOH'IeH na ICe B 1931 r •• B AeCJlTWIeTHeH3Da YTBep lC l aJlOcb 6y l T0 OH Bee ewe OCTaeTCJl B CWIe DJlTHJleTHHii MaH ODTHMaJlbHhIH 74 HcrOllHHK 1925-1926 1926-1927 Hapo llHoe X03RHCTBO CCCP 1932 1928-1932 E KBHpHHr ilpo6neMbl3KOHOMHKH NgN 10-12 1931r crp 5 75 II fOCYAaPCTBO pacnollarllJIO nOTeHrQfllJIhHO MOI1UlhlM phl'IarOM I1pHHJlTOe B 1926 r AOnOJIHeHHe K Yr01l0BHOMY KOAeKcy npe­ npoTHBoAeii CTBHJllJaCTHOMY eeKTOpy B TOprOB1le H Ha npoH3BOACTBe p yCMaTpHBIIJIO 1lHweHHe CB060 J hI no CYP y AO Tpex lleT C nOJIHOH nOCKOllhKY B 3Ha'IHTellhHoii Mepe nOA ero KOHTponeM OCTaallJIOCh H1JH 'laCTH'lHon KOH pHcKalO en HMYIUeCTBa llHn BHHOBHhIX B 31l0CT­ CHa6 KeHHe ChlpheM H ApyrHMH TOBapaMH I1pOCToe a u MHHHCTpa­ HOM nOBhIWeHHH neH Ha TOBaphI nyTeM CKynKH COKPhITHJl H1lH He­ THBHOe peweHHe TaKHM 06pa30M Mor1l0 CH1lhHO H3MeHHTh CHTya­ BhlnyCKa TaKOBhIX H3 PhIHOK 36 TaKOBa 6bma 3HaMeHHTaR CTaThJl lO lO H 6e3 3aKOHOAaTellhHhlX HIIJIOrOBhIX Mep CnelO lIJIhHO lleHHhlX npoTHB mnMaHOB BnnoTh AO 1930 HllJIpaa­ r lJaCTHaR TOprOBllJl 107 Yro1l0BHOrO KOAeKca B MOMeHT Korp a ee BBellH OHa no 60111 ­ cneKYllJllO JI wen 1JaCTH OCTaallJIaCh MepTBoii 6YKBOH CT3JIHH CT3JI lIlHPOKO npH­ MeMTb ee Qepe3 ABa rop a nocne ee npHHJlTHJl Op HaKO caM p aKT B 3TOM rop y HaeM TPYAa Il 1lJl 1JaCTHOrO npoH3BOACTBa 6bm o6l JIBlleH HellerllJIhHhIM 34 Ho TeHAeHlO H K 3TOMY npoJlBH1lHCb BBeAeHHJI TaKOn CTaThH B 3aKOHop aTellhCTBO 3HaMeHOB3JI co60ii on­ pOPMa1lhHO He paCCMaTpHBIIJIaCh KaK npeCTynHaR Ii TOllhKO 3Ha'IHTenl HO paHee HIIJIpHMep HaOOIO J anCJI HeYK1l0HHhm poCT neH H3 1JaCTHhIe Kene3HOAopo KHbIe nepeB03KH B 1926 K TapH paM no nepeB03Ke qaCTHhIX rpy30B AOCTHr1lH 1926 50-100% a B r 6hl1la npoBeAeHa nepBaR eepHJI H3JIOroBhlX Mep no COKpa­ IUeHHIO npH6bmhHoCTH 1JaCTHOn TOprOB1lH TaK J eKpeT OT 18 HIOM BBOp H1l BpeMeHHhIH rOCYAapCTBeHHhIn HllJIor Ha CBepxnpH6hl1lH H3nMaHOB 9 anpellJl Toro Ke rOAa nneHYM UeHTpa1IhHoro KOMHTeTa nOCTaHOBH1l 'lITO 'lHcno 3ePHOBhIX MellhHHU HaxOp HBWHXCJI B PYKax 1JaCTHHKOB AOll KHO 6hITh pelIlHTellbHO coKpa IUeHo TOH naprnii ­ HhIX AOKYMeHToB no OTHOWeHHIO K KynaKaM H H3DMaHaM CTaHOBH1l­ CJI Bee 601lee pe3KHM•• npeycneBalOIUHx KpeCTbJlH 1926·1927rr 1 83 HCTOPHJl napTHH CTpeMHTCJI npeYMeHbWHTh ero 3Ha'leHHe HaCTyn1le­ P YCMaTPHB3JIOCh caMon KOHneDUHeH H3I1a C caMoro ero Ha'lana 1 0­ cyp aPCTBO CTIIJIO CH1JhHee OKpenna ero cnoco6HOCTh PYKOBOp HTh npoMhIW1leHHOCThlO H TOprOBlleH o6ecne'IfHBaTh cellhCKoe X03J1HCT­ BO KanHT3JIhHhlM o60pYAoBaHHeM KOTopoe B KOHe'IHOM C'leTe npH3­ BaHO 6hmo peBOlllOUHOHH3HpoBaTh COUHIIJIhHo-npoH3BOACTBeHHhle OTHOWeHHJI B AepeBHe TaKoe HCT01lKOBaHHe He nOllHOCThlO 1l0 KH0 D nJl MHorHX 'If1leHOB napTHH H3I1 6bm Bblsy KAeHHhIM KOMnPOMHC­ Ba KaK TOllhKO Il 1lJl 3Toro C03peIOT ycnOBHJI npHMeHJIJI npH 3TOM 13 25 17 77 KynaKH 63 60 100 17 BOIIPOChl HCTOPHH 4 1967 cpeACTBa Korophle OKa KyTCJI B paCnopJI KeHHH napTHH Op HaKO npeACTaBllJlTh C06blTHJI TOllbKO B TaKOM CBeTe 3Ha'lfH1l0 6hl CYIUeCTBeHHO HeAOOneHHTh 3Ha'leHHe nepeMeH B naprniiHOH nOllHTH­ 0 9 Cepe wl ltKH r MOp ltXHH 3TOT CABHr B nOllHTHKe O pHrQfllJIhHaR HHe Ha lJaCTHbm ceKTOp comaCHO 3Ton O pHrQfllJIhHOH BepcHH npe­ 1l106hle 1925-1926rr HCTO'IHHK qeM o6l JlCMeTCJI COM C HeHaBHCTHhIM BparOM Ha KOToporo H3 Il 1le KanO HanaCTh CHO­ I1PHBO J HMaR HH Ke TaOOHua nOKa3hlBaeT yaellH'IeHHe HllJIOrOB Be wUtKH py6JIeH B ro l ceKTOpy r HaA6aaKH nocnep ylOIUHe rO J hI yaellH'IfH1lHCh no OTAenhHhlMrpY3aMAO 400% 35 B peAelleHHYIO 3BOlllOlO IO B OTHOWeHHH PYKOBOACTBa K 1JaCTHOMY Ke KOTophle Ha'IHHaR C MHHaUHH K weM 1926 r •• CTIIJIH HapaCTaTh H AOCTHrllH Kynh­ KOHUY AeCJlTH1leTHJI B aellHKOM CKa'IJKe 03Ha'IaB­ pa3pyweHHe nocnep Hero 6aCTHOHa lJaCTHOH C06CTBeHHOCTH nyreM nOBIIJIhHOH K01l1leKTHBH33UHH AepeBHH I1pH'lHHhl 3TOH nepeMeHhI B nOllHTHKe 6hl1lH MHOrO'IHcneHHhI CTp 27 cnO KHhI H B3aHMOCBJl33HhI Bo-nepBhIX HMeeTCJI TeCHaR B3aHMOCBJl3h Me Kp y OKOH'laHHeM H3I1a H aM6HUH03HhIMH nporpaMMaMH HOBhIX KanHTIIJIOBJIO KeHHii B 1925·1926 nepHop a rr 3HaMeHOBaBIIIHX OKOH1JaHHe BOCCTaHOBHTellhHoro YpoBeHb MeTa1l1lyprH'lfeCKoH npoMhIW1leHHOCTH Bee eIUe OCTaBIIJICJI HH Ke 1913 r HO ApyrHe OTpaC1lH B OC06eHHoCTH npoH3­ BOACTBO 31leKTpo3HeprHH yr01lbHaR npoMhIW1leHHoCTh H HeKoTophle 76 77 OTpaCJlH MaI IlHlIOCTpoeHHJI - nOT YpoBeHb yX«l npeB30lIll1H C no­ HX KynHTb 8 H36p8HHhlM KaTerOpHRM IlOKynaTeneii - ro MOMeHTa HapamHBaHHe YCHJum no YBeJIH'IeHHIO npoMbllIll1eHHorO HanpHMep 1IJleB8M Koonep8THBOB HJlH 1I1IeB8M npocPCOI030B ECJIH TOBapHhlH npoH3BOACTBa Tpe60BaJIO HanpJlX eHHJI Beex CHJI CTpaHbl B AeKa6pe AecPHUHT npoBHnReTCft B T8KHX OCTPhlX cPoPMU B 60nhwHX ropo­ 1925 A8X TO IlOnO KeHHe B AepeSHe e e HaMHOrO XY Ke TaKOB 6bIJI pe_ r pe30JIIOlI HJI XIV C'be3Aa BKII 6 npH3BaJIa K HHAYCTPHaJIH­ lalQlH H B KOHe'IHOM C'IeTe K no6eAe COlQlaJIHCTH'IeCKOrO ceKTopa 3YJIbTaT npoBOAHBweHCJI JIOJIHTHKH eH TOB8PHhlH AecPHUHT T8­ KOlw eHTpaII HJI peCYPCOB B PYKax rOCYAapCTBa npeACTaBJIJlJIaCb He­ KHM 06p830M HMeeT MecTO nHWh TaM rAe ueHhI nepeCT8IOT BhlnOn­ COBMeCTHMOH C Ae ll1'eJIbHOCTbIO H3nMaHOB KOHKypHpoBaBlIlHX C HftTh CBOIO rn8BHym cPYHKUHIO ypaBHHB8HHft cnpoca H npeWIOXCeBHft roCYAapCTBOM H OTBJIeKaB1IlHX peCYPCbI KOTopble He06xoAHMO 6b1­ rAe OHH HHepTHhl H He pearHpYIOT H8 H3MeBeBHR PhU O'lHOH KOH1 IOH­ JIO COCpeAOTO'lHTb Ha BbWOJIHeHHH nOCTaBJIeHHOH 3aAa'IH H3nMaHbI KTyphl 1I36b1TO'IHaa nOKynaTenbHaR cnoco6HOCTb nepeMemaJIaCb AeHCTBHTeJIbHO H3BJIeKaJIH 6bl npH6blJIb H3 TOBapHoro Aeq HIJ HTa eCTeCTBeHHO B TaKHe cq epbl rAe KOHTPOJIb HaA eHaMH He AeHCTBo­ KOTOPblH HeH36e f H0 AOJI lKeH 6bIJI HapaCTaTb no Mepe YBeJIH'IeHHJI BOBaJI a 'laCTHaR TOprOBJIJI 06peTaJIa cneKYJIJlTHBHbIH xapaKTep noc­ KanHTaJIOBJIO lKeHHH B HHAYCTpHaJIH3alQllO KOJIbKY CTaHOBHJIOCb BbIro D HO npH06peTaTb npoH3BOAHMbIe rocy­ BO-BTOPbIX O'leHb B8 f HbIM MOMeHTOM peAKO O eHHBaBllIHM­ AapcTBeHHbIMH npe D npHJITHJIMH TOBapbl lJ lJl nepenpoAa lKH q aKTH­ ca no AOCTOHHCTBY HCTOpHKaMH 3TOro nepHOAa 6blJIa npOBOAHB­ 'IeCKH nepeKa'IHBaR TaKHM 06pa30M peCYPCbl B 'laCTHbIH eeKTOp lIlaRca nOJIHTHKa eH CHTyaII HJI Bbl3BaHHaR HO aMH eH Eme 60JIee TJI lKeJIbIM nOCJIe D CTBHeM TaKOH nOJIHTHKH 6blJI0 06paT­ BblHY lKAaJIa rOCYAapcTBeHHble TpeCTbl CHH lKaTb npOH3BOACTBeHHbIe Hoe B03AeHCTBHe Ha nOKynaTeJIbHYIO cnOCOGHOCTb KpeCTbJIHCTBa 3aTpaTbl H eHbl aa CBOIO npo oyK 3Ta nOJIHTHKa npoAOJI lKaJIaCb ECJIH H B TpeCTaMH H rOCYAapcTBeHHOH TOprOBJIeH nepBOaa'IaJIbHO MOTHBH­ nOCJIe oylOmHe rOAbI XOTR ropoACKHe H eeJIbCKHe AOXOAbI Aa lKe COKpameHHe eH 3anpaWHBaeMblX rocYAapCTBeHHblMH POCJIH 6blCTpee 06mero om eMa BblnycKaeMoH npoAYK H TeMIlbI POBaJIOCb lKeJIaHHeM COKpaTHTb HO lKHHll bl H T e YJIY'IllIHTb poCTa npoH3BOACTBa B nOCJIe oylOIQHe rOAbI TO lKe aapaCTaJIH Hec­ YCJIOBHJI TOprOBJIH lJ lJl KpeCTbJlHCTBa Ha npaKTHKe pe3YJIbTaTbI MOTPJl Ha AaBJIeHHe pbIHKa KOTOPblH AHKTOBaJI nOBbIlIleHHe eH OKalbIBaJIHCb npoTHBOnOJIO f HbIMH IIOCKOJIbKY Oq aJIbHble eHbl eH npaBHTeJIbCTBO TeM He MeHee ynOpHO npHAep lKHBaJIOCb nOJIHTHKH 6b1JIH HHX«l HX nOHH lKeHHJI H paAH 3Toro pacnpoCTpaHJlJIO KOHTPOJIb HaA q a6pHKe nOJIY'IaJI TOBapbI Ha 60JIee Bblro D HblX YCJIOBHJIX rOpoAA eHa­ Ha CBo60 D HOM pblHKe TOT KTO HaXO IJ HJICJI 6nHX«l K MH Ha Bee 6oJIblIlYIO H 6oJIblIlYIO AOJIIO roCYAapCTBeHHOH npoMbIllI­ 6nHXCe K HCTO'lHHKaM npoMhlWJleHHhlX TOB8POS AepesHH OT HHX JIeHHOCTH rOCYAapcmeHHOH H KoonepaTHBHOH ToprOBJIH KaK MO lK­ 01leBh A8JleKH TaKHM 06pa30M ropo D 8 no Beeii BH D HMOCTH DOny­ HO 6b1JIO npeABHAeTb TaKaR nOJIHTHKa 6blCTPO npHBeJIa K TOBapHO­ 'I81OT 60nhwe npoMhlWJleHH IX TOBapoB 'IeM OHH MornH 6hl nony­ MY roJIO oy 'IHTh DO ueHaM COOTBeTCTBYIO HM 68J18Hcy cnpoca H npeWIOXCeHHR IIMeHHo 3TOT TepMHH CHOBa H CHOBa nOJIBJIJlJIcJI B Oq aJIbHbIX H Heoq aJIbHbIX 3aRBJIeHHJlX Ha'IHHaJI C 1926 r nonHTHK8 HH3KHX UeB He TonhKO He CMorna A06HT Cft nOHH KeHHhIX TaJIaHTJIHBblH MOJIOAOH 3KOHOMHCT B HOBO lKHJlOB KOTOpoMY eme UeB WIR AepeBHH HO H8npoTHB Bhl3B8Jl8 nOHHXCeHHe UeB D JlR ro­ npe D CTOJIJIO 'Iepe3 40 JIeT BHeCTH 6oJIbwOH BKJIaA B B03po lKAeHHe POAA 38 C'leT IlOBhlWeHHR HX D JlR AepeBHH - H B 86conIOTHhIX UHcP­ COBeTCKoro X03J1HCma OnHCbIBaJI TorAaWH101O CHTYaIJ H1O CJIe oylO­ pax H B npoueHTHOM OTHOWeBHH 37 06p nepeBOA C aHrJI _ mHM 06pa30M He TOBaphl H YT Pe D MOJIO D OH KpHTHK DOKynaTeneA a DOKynaTenH­ TepneJIHBO YKalbIBaJI aa a6CYP HocTb TOB8P I nepeA HeKoTophIMH Mar83HH8MH BhlCTp8HB8IOTCR WIHH­ 3TOH nOJIHTHKH KOTopaa CTaHeT eme 60JIee a6CYp D HoH npH nOBbIlIle­ HhIe 01lepeAH B 1I8CTHOR TOprOBJIe UeBhl Cy ecTBeBHO Bhlwe Topro­ HHH rOCYAapcTBeHHbIX KanHTaJIOBnO lKeHHH H60 OHa 6YAeT CTHMYJIH­ BhlX UeB Ha npoAYKUHIO rOCYAAPCTBeBHhIX TPecTOB - poBaTb POCT D OXOAOB 'ITO JIJI lKeT eme 60JIbweH TJI lKeCTbIO Ha cnpoc Ha TOBapbI H yCJIym HHU8 COCT8BJIReT 100-200% HHorAA pa3­ BBO D ftTCft orpaHH'leBHR H8 nOKynKH TOBaphl KOTophle nOJIh3ymTCft H8H60JUWHM cnpocoM roCYA8PCT­ BeHHhle H KoonepaTHBHhIe Mar83HH I npo D 8lOT He BeeM KTO X01leT 78 3THM COBeTOM O HaKO npeHe6pernH enaR eepHJI D eKpeTOB H AeKJIa BBO IJ HJIa Bee HOBbIe H HOBbIe orpaHH'IeHHJI eH 2 HIO­ 79 1UI 1926 j£lHO He COOTBeTCTBOBaBmaJI npHHUHnaM H3IIa YnopCTBO B npoBe­ r COBeT TPY nl H 060POHbI H3A11ll AeKpeT caMO Ha3BaHHe KOToporo YKa3bIBaJIO Ha ero oUIH60IlHOCTb nl Ke CTYll eHTy-nepBo­ KYpcHHKY 3KOHOMHlleCKoro q aKynbTeTa CHH lCeHHe po3HHIIHblX ueH Ha Aeq bIe TOBapbl roey nlpCTBeHHOro npoH3BOIl CTBa IIpe lJllonaraJIOCb npoBeCTH TaKOe CHH lCeHHe B pa3Mepe CHH lCeHHe BBO o H TIOCb ll eKpeToM OT 10% upyroe 16 q eBPaJIJI 1927 r MO C nOfHKoH H3IIa H HeMHHYeMO BneKJIO 3a oo60H aTaKY Ha 'IIllCT­ HbIX ToproBneB KOTopble npo nlBaJIH npoMbmmeHHble TOBapbI B ll epeBHJlX laRpaUIHBaJl 3a HHX BIl BOe HJIH elUe 60nbme no CpaBHe­ HHIO C neHaMH B roey nlpCTBeHHbIx H KoonepaTHBHbIX Mara3HHaX rll e O l HaKO 3THX TOBapoB npocTO He 6 IJIO IIoll 06HblM ICe 06pa­ 30M H3BneKaJIH IJ OnOJlHHTenbHYIO npH6bmb BJIall eIIbnbl Bee elUe OC­ TaBaBIIlHXCJI IIerBJIbHblMH 'IIllCTHbIX npOMbIlIIJleHHbIX npe o n pHJlTHH H peMeClleHHHKH 'ITO TaK Ke ell Ba 11H 6bIJIO no BKYey nOIIHTH'leCKHM H HaJIOrOBblM BJIaCTJlM TeIIbHO CeIIbCKOX03 IIHCTBeHHOrO npoH3BOll CTBa H 3arOTOBOK CTpeM­ npoll YK 1O CHH3HJIOCb H3-3a TO­ BapHoro rOJIo nl a TaK lCe H3-3a YCHJIHH npaBHTeIIbCTBa npoBO l HTb 3afOTOBKH no CHH I eHHbIM neHaM HcnOJlb3YJI 6JIarOnpHJITHble l IIJI laKynKH YCIlOBHJI nOClle CpaBHHTeIIbHO BblCOKHX Ypo I 3CB rOCY nlp­ CTBO CTpeMHJIOCb ClKOHOMHTb COKpama II paCXO l bI Ha 3arOTOBKY eeIIbCKOX03 IIHCTBeHHbIX npo lJ 'KTOB B 1926-1927 eeIIbCKOX03J1HCT­ BeHHOM ro lJ ' 06UIHii ypoBem roeyll apCTBeHHblx 3aroroBHTeIIbHblX neH no cpaBHeHHIO C npell meCTBYlOlUHM rOIl OM ynaJI npH6JIH3HTeIIb­ 60% q aKTOPOB HeooMHeHHO MHoroe OObJlCHJIeTCJI OO'leTaHHeM ynop­ HOH npe naaMepeHHoH CIlenOTbl C npHcYmeH 60IIbmeBHKaM 8HTHIIa­ THeH K CTHxHHHbIM CHJIaM pbIHKa Ho OT'l3CTH nOMY ynPJlMCTBY neHHHKH BbICyYOaJIH 33 nOBbIWeHHe ypoBRJI H3J onneHHii H KanHTa­ nOBIIO ICeHHii a J10rHKa 3TOH n03H Tpe60BaJIa nOBblWeHHJI a He nOHH KeHHJI neH Ra npoMbIWIIeHHbIe TOBapbl nOCKOJIbKY mKHM ny­ TCM roey nlpCTBO Morno YSeIIH'lHTb CBOH nOXO nbI TOIIbKO noro 6blII0 nOCTaTOIIHO Il IIJI CTaJIHHa 'lT06bI BOcnPOTHBHTbCJI no n06HbIM MepaM BHe COMHeHHii OH yCM3TPHBaJI nOJlHTH'leCKHe BbIr01l bl B Kypce Ha nOHH lCeHHe neH Tpe60BaHHe nOBbICHTb ueHbI Ha 3epHO He­ XO o H TIO C Il PyroH CTOPOHbl OT JiyxaPHHa Hero e ll HHOMbIlIIJleHHH­ KOB BnOCJIe nCTBHH ooCTaBHBWHX IlpaBYIO onn03HURIO TYT 0 IJITb­ TaKH CTaJIHH HaxO o H TI BeCKHe nOJlHTH'leCKHe npH'lHHbI l IIJI CBocro B-TpeTbHX TaKOH ICe rpy6blH npoC'leT 6bIJI 1l 0nymeH OTHOCH· HO Ha q IIHKTbI H eyMHTHUY nl Ke npH OTcyTCTBHH Il pymx HeraTHBHbIX MO KHO nlTb nOIIHTH'leCKOe OObJlCHeHHe TPOUKHH Hero e l HHOMbIW­ IIpoBell eHHe TaKOH nonHTHKH 6bIJ1o ooBepmeHHo HeCOBMeCTH­ IIeHHe KpeCTbSH npO UlBaTb CBOIO neHHH 3TOH nOJlHTHKH HeMHHYeMOBIIeKJIO 3a co60H TJI KKHe KOH­ TaKoe coKpaw eHHe OTHlO l b He Morno 6blTb onpaB nlHo PblHOIIHOH KOH'bIOHKTYPOH nl Ke xy Ke npaBHTeJIbCTBO KaK 6YIl TO 3arHnHOTH3HpoBaHHOe He KIIlOtleBOH poIIblO lepHa Cpe3aJIO 3aKY­ nO'lHble neHbl Ha Hero elUe 60IIee pemHTeIIbHO Ra 20-25% B pe­ 3YIIbTaTe KaK MO KHO 6bIJIO npell BHIl eTb HapaCTaJIO He ICeIIaHHe npo­ ynpJlMCTBa H no - He npoCTO 1l 0ra nKa Bee CHOBa H CHOBa CTaJIHH 06BHHJIII pa3J1H'lHbIX npell CTaBHTCJleH onn03H B HaMepeHHH no­ BbICHTb ueHbl IIapTHiiHbIH nneHYM npoxO nHBUlHH 1927 7-12 q eB panJl r 3aROBO nO nTBep o H TI He06xo nHMOCTb nOCJIe lJ OBaTeJlbHOrO CHH I eHHJI neH H nO l 'lepKHYJI 'ITO B Bonpoee neH COCpeIl OTO'lHnHCb Bee B3aHMOCBJl3aHHble 3KOHOMH'leCKHe H nOJIHTH'leCKHe npo6neMbl COBeTCKoro roey nlpCTBa 3m H36paHHaJI napTHeH nOJlHTHKa 6bIJIa B OCHOBe CBoeH Bpa KAe6Ha PblHOlIHbIM OTHOmeHHJIM H B npoMbmmeH­ HOCTH H B TOprOBJIe H B CeIIbCKOM X03J1HCTBe OCTaBaJIOCb J1H60 OT­ Ka3aTbCJI OT Hee J1H60 nOKOH'lHTb C PblHKOM H pbIHO'lHblMH OTHome­ HHJlMH CoxpaaeHHe H3IIa 6bmO MbICIlHMO J1HWb npH YCJIOBHH 'ITO nOJlHTHKa neH 6YAeT H3MeHeRa A nOCKOJIbKy oRa He 6b1IIa HlMeHe­ Ra H3II 6bIII 06pe'leH J1HIm nOCJIe peUIHTem Horo nOpa lKeHHJI 'IIllCT­ HHKa 6bIJIa H3MeHeHa nOJlHTHKa ueH - Ra eeH pa3 u lIJI Toro 'lT06bl q HRaHCHpoBaTb POCT rocY nlpCTBeHHOH HH lJ 'CTpHH UlBaTb 3epHo roeyll apCTBY B03HHKJla TeHll eH JI COCpeIl OTO'lHTbCJI Ra npoH3BOIl CTBe Il pyrHX BHIl OB eeIIbCKOX03 IIHCTBeHHbIX npo lJ 'K­ ilepeeoiJ E lI paeuHa TOB H Ha IQlBOTHOBOIl CTBe rll e ueHbI 6bIJ1H 60IIee 6JIaronpHJITHbl­ MH CymeCTBeHHO BbIpoC pa3pbIB Me lKAY' Oq HURBJIbHbIMH roeyll ap­ CTBeHHbIMH neRaMH H TeMH neHaMH KOTopble rOTOBbl 6bIJlH nnaTHTb Bee elUe IJ 03BOneHHbIe laKOHOM 'IIllCTHbIe roproBnbI-H3nMaHbI IIo'leMy ICe 6bma npHHJITa TaKaJI nOIIHTHKa B o6JIacm neH 80 81 14 1 B CaMoXBanoB COBem HapollHoro X03JIII'CTBa B 1917-1932 rr MocKBa 1964 cIp 121 nPHME'IAUHlI B H lIeHKIl CO' T 31 H lAo 4 CTp B H lIeHKIl Co' T 40 H lA 5 3 B H lIeHKIl Co' T 42 H lA 5 CTp 192 4 TaM lICe CTp 188 5 B H lIeHKIl Co' T 43 H3A 5 CTp 433434 6 B H lIeHKIl Co' T 42 H3A 5 CTp 349 7 B H lIeHKIl Co' T 30 H3A 4 8 B H lIeHKIl Co' T 32 H3A 4 cIp 111 9 CTp 308 TaM lICe CTp 317 17 B H JIcHKIl Co' T 44 H lA 5 CTp 544 18 H A fnaAKoB YKa3 CO' CTp 204 19 TaM lICe CTp 522 20 CM B eCTHHK COUHanHCTH' eCKoR AKaAeMHH NQN9 6-7 1923-1924 IT • CTp 316-317 21 CoBeThI HapollHoro XO lJIII'CTBa H lIl1aHOBhle opraH bI B ueHTpe Tax 1917-1932 IT MocKBa 1957 CTp 131-132 22 TaM lICe CIp 154 1 B CaMoXBanoB YKa3 CO CTp 153 23 E H Carr Ha Mec­ R W Davies Foundations of a Planned Eoonomy 1926­ 1929 Macmillan 1969 24 CM 1 B CaMOXBanOB YKa3 CO' CTp 97 25 CM TaM lICe CTp 159 B TeKCTe o6paTHhlR nepeBoA C aHrn 26 TaMlICe cTp 133 B H lIeHKIl Co' T 43 H3A 5 H PeAo CM A U ManaljleeB HCTOpU ueHoo6pa30BaHU B CCCP H3A-BO Mwcm MOCKBa 1964 rn I CM H A fna Ill OB COBeTCKoe HapOllHoe XO lJIII'CTBO 1921-1925 IT AU CCCP HHCTHTyr 3KOHOMHKH MocKBa 1960 CTp 239 f A Ko­ HlOXOB KnCC B 6opl 6e C xne6H bIMH 3aIpYIlHeHHJIMH B CTpaHe Cou ncrH3 MocKBa 1960 CTp 38 CTp 25 12 B H lIeHKIl Co' T 33 H3A 4 CTp 80 13 BeCTHHK CoUHanHCTH'leCKolI' AKaAeMKIl N9 2 1923 CTp 173 82 16 329 10 11 H A fnaAKOB YKa3 co' CTp 193-194 100 2 CTp 15 27 CM JI KPHUMaH npo6neMl llKOHOMHKH 28 H A fnaAKOB YKa3 CO' CTp 197 29 M Lewin La paysannerie et Ie pouvoir sovietique Monton Paris 1966 30 E H Carr A History of Soviet Russia 4-5 1930 CTp 17 Socialism in one Country Vol 1 p 99 31 BeCTHHK KOMMYHHCTH'lecKoR AKaAeMHH N9 8 1924 CTp 40 83 32 10 MOWl OB 3epHOBaJI npo6neMa B ro lbI CIIl1oWHoA J 0Ill1eJ THBH3a­ MOCJ Ba 113 D -BO MOCJ OBCJ HA yHHBepcHTeT 1966 CTp 23 J Karcz Soviet Studies April 1967 R W Davies Soviet Studies January 1970 pp 314-329 IJ HH 3azopKa FO ly608u'I 33 nllTKlIeTHHlt IIl18H HapoJJ HO-X03J1AcmeHHoro CTpOHTellloCTBa MoeJ Ba 34 1930 T 2 CTp CCCP 36 ABTOpy He y llllJIOC HaRTH nO lJ OOHbIX 3aJ OHOB KOTopble OblllH BBe lJ eHbl paHee 35 A H Manac peeB YKa3 CO'l CTp 36 r A KOHIOXOB YKaJ CO'l CTp 98-99 37 B HOBOll KlIOB BeCTHHK C PHHaHCOB N9 6bI IOfOCJlABCKOE OBtnECTBO H COQHAJ1H3M KPH3HC IOfOCJlABCKOR CHCTEMbI H B03MOlKHOCTH EE3BOJllOUHH 1932 r 133 2 1926 B JUo60M aHaJlH3e 1OrocnaBCl oro 06mecma H COUHaJlhHOH CHCTeMhl cnO I HBllIHXCB nocne BTOPOH MHPOBOH BOHHhl He06xoAH­ MO npHHBTh BO BHHM8HHe TOT cl aKT lITO nocneBOeHHaB CTp ' 1 'pa 1OrocnaBCI OrO 06meCTBa 6hma CMO ll enHpoBaHa no 06pa3 O ll HaI O IOrocnaBHB ooBeTCI OM ' e ll HHCTBeHHaB CTpaHa 1 0TOPaB paHO npHHJIJIa Mephl I TOM ' qT06b1 BblHTH H3 OOUHanHCTHqeCI Oro oo06mecma nHTHQeCI Oro OO103a CnO KHBllIerOCR B pe3ynbT8re HOB oro reono­ pa3 ll ena EBponbl n03TOM ' aHaJlH3 ll On KeH TaK Ke BbIRBHTh B l aKOH CTeneHH 'ITa CHCTeMa OTnHqaeTCR or peaJlhHoro OOUHailH3Ma H l al OBa my6HHa COUHaJlbHblX H3MeHeHHH npoHC­ llIe ll llIHX nocne 1948 r HToroM aHaJlH3a ll On KeH 6bITb orneT Ha cne D y1OmHe BonpoChI 1 IIpHHa l ne KHT nH no-npe KHeM ' 1OrocnaBCKoe o6meCTBo I l aTeropHH 06mecm ll eHCmHTelIbHO cymeCTByromero COUHa· nH3Ma I 2 qeM OHO OT1IHQaerCB OT ll pyrHx BOCTO'IJHOeBponeHCI HX 06meCTB H HOCRT nH 3TH OT1IHqHjf I neCTBeHHblH xapal Tep T e pacnPOCTPaHB1OTCB nH 3TH OT1IHQHB Ha BC10 CHCTeM ' OpraHH3aUHH 06meCTBa 3 IIpeMaraeT nH 1OrocnaBCI HH nyTb I ooUHanH3M ''' ll eHCTBHTenhHyro aJlhTepHaTHBY 06mecTBY COBeTCI OrO THna T e BhIXO lJ HT nH OH 3a paMKH OCHOBHblX npHHUHnoB Ha 1 0TOPbIX OHO 3H I Jl eTCR 84 85